Motorola Mobility, Inc. v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 95

AFFIDAVIT signed by : Christine Saunders Haskett. Supplemental Declaration in Support of Apple Inc's Responsive Claim Construction Brief (Brief Filed Under Seal) by Apple, Inc. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 21, # 2 Exhibit 22, # 3 Exhibit 23, # 4 Exhibit 24, # 5 Exhibit 25, # 6 Exhibit 26, # 7 Exhibit 29, # 8 Exhibit 30)(Pace, Christopher)

EXHIBIT 25

.#5/17~
.()_

~3' ~-

/O/lfJb/

?y

IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
APPLICANTS:

Paulick, Thomas E.

EXAMINER:

Pham, C.

SERIAL NO.:

08/023,234

GROUP:

2611

FILED:

February 25,1993

CASE NO.:

CEOO802R

ENTITLED:

Receiver Having Concealed External Antenna
Motorola, Inc.
Corporate Offices
1303 E. Algonquin Road
Schaumburg, IL 60196
August 26,1994
AMENDMENT under 37 C.F,R. 1,115

Honorable Commissioner of
Patents and Trademarks
Washington, D.C. 20231
Dear Sir:
In response to the Office Action dated May 26, 1994, please amend .the
as follows:

~laims

In The Specification:

~e~ert'

On page
reference number "210".
On

-to produce integral contacts 308 and 310-- after the

page.s:Cy~e<'..

integm'-, before the wo,d "contacts",

On page

?~f':~ute

"FIG. 1" with number --FIG. 2--.

pag~

On
line 1{subStitute "......" with -1293A--; and on line 16 substitute
"model number ......" with --named "Bravo"--.

1\

I"

-1-

-------_

..

t1

..... ..... -"_.._....._-----.- -....j
987FH058

In The Claims:

1.
(Amended) A combination radiotelephone/pa er unit including .a....user
nterface, comprising:
a housing enclosing radiotelephone andp gel' circuitry;
a radiotelephone ailtenna coupled to the adiotelephone circuitry; and
a pager antenna coupled to the pager c· cuitry and [forming a loop
substantially surrounding the user interfac disposed between the housing a..n..d....at.
~. portion of the user interface.
(Amended) A combination radiotelephone/pager unit according to cl",n,-,""urther comprising [means, coupled to the housing,]
hi 1
Ie ding at least
one of the radiotelephone and pager circuitry.
3.
(Amended) A co
IOn radiotelephone/pager unit according to claim 1
wherein t~ mterface [element] further comprises at least one of the
following: an acoustic, a visu~~l...!ea~n~d~a..l:t""a:>:.ct""i~le.......
. in...,t""e","rfa""c""e.:...
...

~

radiotelepllone/pag~~

.;- A combination
unit according to claim
-acoustic, visual and tactile interface further comprises
y.
l'dU,,"" a di,pJay and a 'witch, "'.

6.

~

_

wherein the
us IC

mbination radiotelephone/pager unit according to claim 1 wherein the
antenna is integrally formed with at least a portion of the user interface.

~(Amended) A combination radiotelep
to

fd-. /

~

f\

one/pager unit comprising:
a housing enclosing radiotelephone d pager circuitry;
a radiotelephone antenna coupled t the radiotelephone circuitry;
a pager antenna coupled to the pa ercircuitry and [disposed on] ~led to
an outside surface of the housing; and
a cover for concealing the pager antenna such that the pager antenna is
unnoticeable to a user of the unit.

-2-

987FH059

· ... ...
~

8.
A combination radiotelephone/pager unit accor
0 claim 7 wherein the
cover further comprises at least one of the
mg: a hand grip, a keypad, a
lens, an escutcheon, a keypad
cap.
9. ,.,-f
ended) A combination r
further comprising [means, couple
on~_?f the radiotelephone and pa

e/pager unit according to claim 7
ing,] a shield for shielding at least

7

,/

10.
A combination radiotelephone/pager unit according to claim 7 wh III the
pager antenna is disposed between the outside surface of the housin nd the
cover.
11.
A combination radiotelephone/pager unit accord' g to claim 7 wherein the
pager antenna is integrally formed with the cover
12.
A combination radiotelephone/page nit according to claim 7 wherein the
pager antenna further comprises a I
antenna.
13.
A combination radiote hone/pager UI~it according to claim 12 further
comprises user interface
stimtially surrounded by the loop antenna.
14.
A combina ' n radiotelephone/pager unit according to claim 13 wherein the
user interfac urther comprises at least one of the following: an acoustic, a
tactile interface.

a housing;
receiver circuitry disposed in the hous' g;
[user interface coupled to the receiver circuitry;] and
an antenna coupled to the receiver 'rcuitry and [forming a loop
substantially surrounding the user inter!: ce] disposed between the housing and at
I
16.
A receiver according to claim 15 wherein the use
a~e further
comprises at least ~.t:-t:lnrfuj~,mtw.--a:rr1ffiioiUustic, visual and a tactile
a

interfa/'

/

-3-

·-------"-l
!

987FH060

\

17.
A receiver according to claim 15 wherei n the
ustie, visual and tactile
interfa ce further compri ses an electroacou
ransdu cer, a display and a switch,
respect ively.

\

~lease

1

i

\

I

cancel,

19.
eiver according to claim 15 wherei n the antenn a is integra lly formed
with a least a portion of the user interface.

I
i ~))[I (Amen~e~)' A receiver compris' g:

;

Cc{

fJ

~
i

i

.I

a housmg ;
receive r circuitr y disposed in he housing;
an antenn a coupled to the r eiver circuitr y and [disposed on] attache
<U2
an outside surface of the housin , and
a cover for concealing th antenn a such that the antenn a is ~nnotic
eable to
a user of the unit.

D ~ [21~]".e
I.
?~'.
rv..
1"2--0

\1
A receive r according to claim.2 6 wherei n the cover further compri
ses
at least one of the following: a hand grip, a keypad, a lens, an escutch
eon, a

cJ 'lu.~eypad and a cap.

~\"
I

r;

h.t;·

t'l-

21]~.

bet; ;

A rec-'·--.-~a<r.ccording to claim 20 wherei n the antenn a is disposed
utside surface of the housing \~d the cover.

d~];M'.
A receive r according to
formed with the cover.

claim~whereinthe antenn a is integra lly

Q.".e¥

(\

.

[23] ~.'
A receive r according to claim i6 wherei n the antenn a further
compri ses a loop antenn a.
[24]~.
(Amended) A receive r according to claim [23]
further comprises
user interfac e substan tially surroun ded by the loop antenn a.

a

r-\
\
I

J

i

i

-4-

1

!
;

. _._. , . .
.

L_5~ _ .

,j

. ._. . .

.1

....-.--..-..

,._".~,. :-1

1

987FH061

~

~.

~7

(Amended) A receiver according to claim [20] ~wherein the user
[25J·
c, a visual and
interfac e further comprises at least one of the following: an acousti
a tactile interface.

REMARKS

All claims origina lly filed have been reprodu ced for the examin er's
conven ience during examin ation.
ered
Respon sive to the examin er's point 2, the claims have been renumb
using the examin er's number ing system.
d to
Respon sive to the examin er's point 3, claim 26 has been amende
overcom e the examin er's rejection.
amende d
Respon sive to the examin er's points 4-5, claims 1 and 15 have been
d,
cancelle
to overcom e the examin er's rejection. Claims 5 and 18 have been
withou t prejudi ce.
the
Respon sive to the examin er's point 6, the applian t submits that
t. Specifically, the examin er
examin er's charact erizatio n of Kawam oto is incorrec
the abstrac t of
states that the ferrite case 2 is a "housing". Howev er, as stated in
. The applica nt
Kawam oto, the ferrite case 2 functio ns as the core of the antenna
re, the
submits that a part of an antenna is not the same as a housing . Therefo
applica nt submit s that claims 20-26 are allowab le over Kawam oto.
the
Respon sive to the examin er's points 7-8, the applica nt submits that
of the claimed
examin er's combin ation of referen ces does not meet the limitati ons
nt submits that the
inventi on as now claimed in claim 7. Specifically, the applica
prior claim
present claim languag e "attach ed to" is distingu ishable over the
been amende d in the same way.
languag e "dispos ed on". Note that claim 20 has
Krenz et a1. in
Therefo re, the applica nt submit s that claims 7-14 are allowab le over
view of Metrok a.

-5-

/{
'..
-··'l·.
.

,;;
'.

987FH062

Accordingly, Applicants respectfully request reconsideration of the claims and
passage to allowance at the earliest possible date.
Respectfully submitted,
PAULICK, THOMAS E.

by:

~)Q.K~

Kevin D. Kaschke
Agent for Applicants
Registration No. 35,767
Phone: [phone]
Fax: [phone]

I hereby certify that this correspondence is being
deposited with the United States Postal Service as
first class mail in an envelope addressed to:
Commissioner of Patents and Trademarks
Washington, D.C. 20231

by

on

d~8,rt/~

~

L"

Kevin D. Kaschke

?--..::2t{

-9

Date

-6-

987FH063