Gentry v. Carnival Corporation et al

Filing 53

ORDER granting in part and denying in part 39 Motion to Compel; granting in part and denying in part 40 Motion to Compel. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jonathan Goodman on 5/8/2012. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B) (eg)

UN I
TED STA TES D I
STR I C O U R T
CT
SO U TH ER N DI
STR I T O F FLO RI A
C
D
M I M I D I SI N
A
VI O
CA SE N O .11 21
- 580- V - O O D M A N
CI G

I
CONSENT CASEI
APR I G EN TR Y ,
L
Pl ntif
ai f ,
V.

CA R NI L CO RP,e aI,
VA
t .
Def
endant .
s
/

ORDER ON M O TI
ONS TO COM PEL
Thi m a t r i be or t Cour on Pl i if A pr l G e r s M oton t Com pel
s te s f e he
t
a ntf
i nty'
i o

Bet r Re pons s t Pl i ifs I e r a ores a Reque t f Pr ton fom
te
s
e o antf' nt rog t i nd
s or oduc i r

De e d n M y tcMo n anLi td ( 3 )a M oin t Co e BetrRe p n e t
fn a t si u t i mie DE 9 nd to o mp l te s o s s o
Pli ifs I e r t res a Re t f Pm duc i fo Def nda Ca ni l
antf
nt roga o i
nd
ques or
ton r m
e nt r va

Cor ai ( 40)
porton DE .

By wa o g nea b c g o n Ge ty alg s ta s e wa ij rd wh l
y f e rl a k r u d, n r l e h t h
e
s nue
ie
pa tc pa i i an e ur i i J m a c a s he ed por- - l on one of Ca ni l s
r i i tng n
xc s on n a i a, c dul
tof ca l
r va '

c
omm e c a c u s . The e tr i wa a bobsed rde ope a e by M ysi Ge r
r i l r ies
xclson s
l i
rtd
tc. nty

iiil alg d t ts e wa ij rd d e t sa betf i r b ti n w as e plrn
ntal le e ha h s nu e u o e t l al e u s o lo x o ig
y
u
oh rpoe ta c u ain te re f rh rij r ,s c a b a e fiu e o te wen s o
te tn il a sto h o is o e n u y u h s rk alr r h te s f
t t ack.
he r

l a pr vi or ,t Cour di m i s d Genty' br c ofc r c c a m a ns
n
e ous der he
t s se
r s ea h
ont a t l i gai t
Ca ni butpe m it d t c e t pr e o G e r s r m a ni c a m s See Ge r v
r val
r te he as o oc ed n nt y' e i ng l i .
nty .

Ca nv lCop,No 1 - 5 0 2 1U. Dit LEXI 1 48 ( D. a Oc .5 2 1.
r ia r
. 121 8 , 01 S. s.
S 1 41 S. Fl. t , 01 )

Th s camsicu ean g ie c a dj itv nu ecam a an tb t d fn a t a da
e e li n l d e lg n e n o n e t r li g is o h ee d n s n n
age y cl i a ns Ca ni l
nc a m gai t r va .

The Cour ca e uly r vi d and consde ed t m otons t def nda s
t r f l e ewe
i r he
i , he
e nt '
r pons s a t pe tne po tonsoft r or i l ng va i s em e a flngs
es
e , nd he ri nt r i
he ec d, nc udi
r ous uppl nt l i i

a notc . The Cour a s he d or la gum e on Aprl23,201 The m o i a e
nd ies
t lo l a r
nt
i
2.
tons r
he e GR AN TED I PA RT a DEN I
r by
N
nd
ED I PA RT as o lne bel . A I
N
uti d
ow
I
s
uppl e al ans er and pr
em nt
w s
oduc i
tons or r he i s l be m ade w i hi
de ed re n hal
t n

f ee (4)days
ourt n 1
.

l
a

Dic v Reatd t Esabls ne Profttos Shari ( tc
s over
l e o t ihi
i/z s
nt Mysi

l e r t y 1 & Reque t f Pr
nt r oga or 4
s or oduc i 7, 8, 22, 23; Ca ni l
ton
r va

l er t y 1 & Re s f Pr ton7,8, 23)
ntrogaor 4
quet or oduci
22, .
Ge r fr tr quesst tM ysi and Ca ni lpr de i onnai on t a ot
nty is e t ha
tc
r va ovi nf
ton
he m mt
c r ed pe pa s r f e ch s r exczson and t a oun t t Ca nva pays
ha g
r s enge or a ho e
lr i
he m t ha
ri l

M y tc Ge tya g sta t sif r t n i rlv n t he j i t nu ecam.Mysi
si. n r r ue h t hi n o mai s ee a t o r o n ve tr li
o
tc
a Cam i pr de t Pli ift co r ctt tgove nst i r ltons p butr c e
nd
val ovi d o antf he nta ha
r her ea i hi
eda t d

te a u t p i b Cania t M y tcp rpa s n e . M y tca d Cn nv lo j c t a
h mo n s ad y r v l o si e s e g r
si n r ia be t h t
ti if r to i no rlv n b c u ete c n rc is l e tbihe t e lc o aj it
h s n o main s t ee a t e a s h o ta t tef sa ls s h a k f on
ve ur and be us t prci of t e ur i
nt e
ca e he i ng
he xc s ons i a t a s r t a c tt es
s r de ec e nd ons iut
s ns tve pr i a y i onna i t ti c os l g r i t i t y.
e ii
opret r nf
ton ha s l e y ua ded n he ndusr
i
hat he i
Dee d ns r lv n y o j ci ni o e ze The Courtfndst t prcesare
fn a t ' ee a c be to s v m ld.
wihi t br d s pe of di c r SeeFe R.Ci P.26( ( ) Dee
t n he oa co
s ove y.
d.
v.
b)1 . fndant s d
s houl

s v t sag me tf ras mma yj d me tmo in.
a e hi r u n o u r u g n to

De e d n s ta es ce o j cini as o e z d t pat s e igt s il is
fn a t' rd e rt be to s lo v m l . 1 ry e kn o hed t
e A
ta s r t orot r c
r de ec e s
he omm e c a i or ai m us esabls t tt i or i n t be
r i l nf m ton
t t ih ha he nf mato o
pr e t d i ata s r t t ti i c i nta ,a t tisdic os e mi htbeha mf l'
ot c e s r de ec e , ha t s onfde i l nd ha t s l ur g
r u.
'

Esrd v.Tar tCor ,No.1161 201 U. Dit LEXI 21 a #1 ( D.Fl.
tige
ge p.
- 490, 2 S. s.
S 593, t 9 S. a
Fe 1 201 . il bur n t n s fst t pa t s ki dicos et etbls t t
b. 6, 2) ç-he de he hit o he ry ee ng s l ur o sa ih ha
t tade s c e or c i nta i or ai s
he r
ert
ontde il nf m ton ought i r l va a ne s a y t t
s e e nt nd ce s r o he
a ton.
ci '
'

The De enda s ha notm a a s fc e s
f nt ve
de ufi i nt howi t tt i or i
ng ha he nf maton

s d bepr eced asa ta s cr t Butt a ly De e nt 'c
houl
ot t
r de e e .
o la
f nda s once n,t si or to
r hi nf mai n
s l be pr vi d pur ua t a confde i iy or rt tpr vi f û tor ys e
ha l
o de
s nt o
i ntalt de ha o des or s t ne ' yes
a
Onj :
y.
9
M ys i shal ans er i errogat y 14 and provi t unredact cont s
tc
l w
nt
or
de he
ed
ract

i r s ns t re t 7 and 8. AI of t s i or i wilbe s e t a
n e po e o quess
I hi nf maton l
ubj ct o
c i i iy or r w ih an Rat or ys e s onl ' pr vi i
onf dent alt
de
t
t ne ' ye
y' o s on. T he par i s s l
te hal
subm i an appropri e propos confdentalt order w i hi se davs
t
at
ed
i i iy
t n ven
.

G e r al o r que t t t Def nda s pr de a a al r or r t e tng t
nty s e s s ha
e nt ovi ny nd l ec ds e l c i he
c l c i ofm one f om Ca ni lpa s nge s f e ur i n tc t a w e la a a a1
ole ton
y r
r va s e r or xc s o i ke s s l s ny nd 1

rc r sr fe tn p y n fo Canv lt M y t .Dee d n so j c t a t i r q e t
e o d elcig a me t r m r ia o si
c f n a t be t h t h s e u s
i undul btr ns e Ge r c arfed t t s i onl i e e t i t dolaram ount
s
y lde om . nt y l ii ha he s y nt r s ed n he l
s

a wha ha ns i a exc so i ca le But t Cour ha ar dy or e
nd
t ppe f n
ur i n s ncel d.
he
t s lea
der d
Def nda s t pr vi t dolar am ount a G e r w il be abl t f nd out wha
e nt o o de he l
s nd nt y l
e o i
t

ha nswhen a e uri i c nc le durng a a opraeRul 30( ( de ii
ppe
n xc son s a eld i n ppr it e b)6) poston.
Defndant'obj ci t re t 22and23 ar s t ne
e
s e tons o quess
e usai d.

1

I i ntRe rs W ine sSt tme t a Po tAc i e tEmal
ncde
po t. t s a e n s nd s- cd n
i
s
( ysi Re tf Pr ton 1 1 1 24;Cani Requetf
M tc ques or oduci 3, 4, 5,
r val
s or
Pr ton 1 1 24)
oduci 3, 5, .

Gen r ne s e pr
t y xt e ks oduc i of a i de r
ton
ny nci nt epors w ines s a e e s a
t, t s t t m nt , nd

c r ponde bet e Ca ni la M ysi a
ores
nce we n r va nd
tc boutt i i . M ysi ha i ii d
he ncdent
tc s dentte

t redo u nsta aers n i et t i rq e tb to j cst t erdicoszeb s do
h e c me t h t r epo sv o h s e u s u be t o h i s l l a e n
r
t wo k pr
he r oductprviege Ca ni a s a s rst wor pr tpr ec i a wel a
i l . r val lo s e t he
k oduc ot ton s l s

t ej itd fn ed crn , e a s M y tcp o ie terlv n d cl n st Cania i
h on ee s o tie b c u e si r vd d h ee a t o t t o r v l n
me
a tcp to o ltg to a d De e d n sh v a c mmo itr s i t j itd fns o
niiain f iiain n f n a t a e o n n ee t n he o n ee e f
t sca e. G e r c e t t a i a lt of t w or pr
hi s
nty ont s s he pplc biiy he
k oduc prviege a guest tt
t i l ,r
ha he

j it d fn e d crn i a p ia e o y t t atr e -le tp iie e a d f rh r
on ee s o tie s p lc bl nl o he to n y cin rv lg , n u te
as e t t t s c n ove c e t qua ii pr vie f w or pr
s r s ha he a
r om he
lfed i l ge or
k- oduc , i ne es a y.
t f c sr

M ysi fl d t t eedoc nt a i s unde s alt pe m i an i c
tc ie he hr
ume s t s ue
r e o r t n amer r vi w. The
a e e
Cour r vi d t doc ent i came a.
t e ewe he um s n
r

Fe r lRul ofCi lPr dur 26( pr des i r e ntpat
de a e
vi oce e b) ovi ,n elva r,
( TralPrpar i M atral.
3) i e aton: e i s
( Doc nt and Tan bl Thigs. Or na iy, a pa t ma not
A) ume s
gi e n
di rl
ry y

di co rdoc e sand t bl t ngst ta e pr par d i a i pa i of
s ve
um nt
angi e hi ha r e e n ntci ton

ltgai orf tilby o f a he pat orisrprs nttve(ncl ng
ii ton or ra
r or not r ry t e e e ai i udi
t ot r pa t s a t ne c ula , s le y, i
he he
r y' tor y, ons t nt tr t ndem nior i ur , or
t , ns er

a e t. t s b e tt Ru e2 ( )4 ,ho emaeil ma b d s o ee i:
g n) Bu , u j c o l 6 b ( ) t s tras y e ic v r d f
()t ya eot r s dic r bl unde Rul 26( ( ) a
i he r he wie sove a e
r e b)1 ; nd
(i t pa t s
i) he ry hows t i has s tnta nee f t maeil t
hat t
ubsa il d or he tras o

pr pa e is c e a ca
e r t as nd nnot w ihou undue ha ds p, obt i t i
, t t
r hi
a n he r
s t nta e val ntby o he m e ns
ubs a i l qui e
t r a .
çl w or pr
d-he
k oduc doc rne i di tnc fom a br der t n t a t ne clen
t t i s si t r
nd oa
ha he tor y- i t
prvie and i pr t c s m a e i s pr pa ed by t a t ne w he he or not di c os t
i l ge,
t oe t
t ral e r
he tor y, t r
s l ed o

t clen,a wela maei sprpae by a s f t at ne ' Fo a ek v NCL
he i t s l s tral e rd
gent or he tor y. jts .
'

(
Bahamas Lt ,262 F. D.650,653 ( D.Fl 2009) tlhe pa t ase tng wor
) d
R.
S. a.
. ç- ry s ri
k
pr
oduc pr viege ha t bur n of s i t a i a lt of t doc rne. G r
t i l
s he de
how ng he pplc biiy
he
ti '
' and

Jur Pr e n v Unie St e ,1 F.d 1
y oce digs . td ats 56 3 038,1 42 ( 0t Ci.1 . The btr n
0 1 h r 998)
lde
t n s f s t t pr
he hi t o he opone oft di c
nt he s over w ho S us s
y,
t t how bot s t ntalne d a
m
h ubs a i
e nd

undueha ds p.'Casl v.San
r hi ' te
gamo We t I . 7 F. 1 1 ( 1h Ci.1 .
son, nc, 44 2d 464, 467 1 t r 984)
Thecrtc c i a i i evauatng ac am f wor pr
ii al onsder ton n l i
l i or
k oduc m aerali whe he lhe
t t i s t rd
t
prma y motva i pur e be nd t c e i oft doc e wa t a d i pos i e
i r
i tng pos hi he r aton
he um nt s o i n
sbl

ft eltgai ' Unie St e v Davs, F. 1 1 40( hCi.1 1 .
uur ii ton.' td ats . i 636 2d 028, 0 5t r 98 )
M ysi s ge r lc
tc' ne a ouns M ihae Dr kulc pr de a deca a i i s
el c l a i h ovi d
lr ton n uppor of
t
M ysi ' wor pr
tc s k oduc c am . Dr kulc sa e t t athi di e ton,wine ssa e e s
t li
a ih t t s ha ,
s r ci
t s tt m nt

a d i ie t rp rs ae c mpie a tr a y icd n iv l n pes na ij r t ad
n ncd n e o t r o ld fe n n ie t n ovig ro l n u y o i
M ys i i t e tofltg i n'
tc n he ven
ii ato .
Bas d on $ knowl
e
he
edgc a expe i
nd
rence 1have a
ccum ul e asa at e a a
atd n tonly nd s

t Gener M anager and Oener Couns of M ysi a busnes t c r ct wih s vc al
he
al
al
cl
tc,
i s hat onta s t e r

e te ta i ld cus ln s gu ss ta alge ij r whl viiig t p e s s oftur
mii, h t ncu e r ie ie , et h t l n u y ie stn he r mie
s
c
o
op rt s patcta l cuicpa sng r,i tae camss e ng c mpe ain fr>i ij rc ,
eaor. rit ry r s s e e s niit li e ki o ns to b d nu is
l
Ohcn tm es t ecl m sdevel i o lws t.
i , hes ai
op nt a uis
7.

Accor ngl l de oped a polcy t t M ysi i t i tga c al alegai
di y,
vel
i ha
tc s o nvesi t 1 l tons

i oli g es ij isi or rt p e r f cai a d/rltg tonta ma e s a ars t
nv vng u t nure n dc o rpae or l ms n o iia i h t y n ue s e ul.
Aspa toft s polc l ys i r r t pr r i ofi dentr 's and t ng ofw ines
r
hi iy,M tc equies he epa aton
nci
epol
t
aki
t s

gae ns f l ng a y i i n iv vi p ron l ij y.Th prmay pu p e oft ee
ttme t olowi n ncde t n ol ng e s a nuf e i r r os
hs
i tga i doc ent i t ai i t eventofa cl m and/ ltgaton.M ysi e pl
nvesi tve um s s o d n he
ai
or ii i
tc m oyeesar
e

isrce t icu e itr iwswih t ij c g s,win s e .e o e wi kn e geo
n tu td o n ld ne ve
t he nurd uet te s s mplye s t owld f
h
t i dent and t t ext appleabl a dicus on oft caus oft i de and wayst
he nci ,
o he ent i e, s si * he
c he nci nt
o
pr ntf ur i de s A1 i dc r porsar pr par atmy diecton and f m y r viw and
eve ut e nci nt. 1 nci nt e t e e ed
r i
or
e e
c l ton as Gener Cou el Upon r ew of ea i dentr ',l l y conti e t t
vaua i
al ns .
evi
ch nci
epol na
t
rbut o he
s i f t anct f t pr aton ofM ysi sdef es i t c
ame n urher
or he cpar i
tc' ens n he vcnt0fa cl m orlws t
' ai
a ui.

8.

M ysi pr csi dentr porsr dls ofwhehe t gues/ entalcli
tc epar nci
e t egar c s
t r he
tpot i amanti
:

apa s
s cngerofany oft s alc uie lne M ysi contac swih ora gaes t tpur e tcke s
hc ever r s i s
tc
rt t
t ha chas d i t
diec l &om M ysi.
r ty
tc

9.

I t c c tt ij r d gu s i a Ca nva pa s n r Mysi p o de icd n
n he v n he n u e e t s r i l se gc , tc r vi s n ie t

t pors t Car val Cor aton. whih r
' t o
e
ni
por i
c eques s c es of i dent r t f l ng cvcr
t opi
nci
epors olowi
y

icd n iv vnga g e tij y. n i br to a dbeif Canialma e ' s rqn ssa
n ie t n oli
u s n ur Upo nf main n le. r v
k st e e e t s
he
pm4oîisi tgaton i antci i and pr l ton ofltgaton.
t nvcsi i n i paton
epa- i
a
ii i
Bas d on m y expc i c and knowldgeconcer ng t s e excur i i ty,
e
renc
c
ni he hor
son ndusr

cuiepasn est tiiit camsa do lws t f l n p ron lij y g n rlyd s
r s se g r ha ntae li n /r a uis ol g es a nur e eal o o
owi
a i tbot t t opcr orand c s lnc.Accor ngl M ys i wilexchangecores
gans h be our
at
ruic i
di y, tc l
r pondence

N t Cani lr g r ng icde si ovi p son lij y i a c c re e f tt prp r f r
vi r va e a di n i nt nv l ng el a nur n on e td for o e a e b
h
t e ualt ofa cl m and/ l
he vent iy
ai
or awsui.
t

Bas on t sde l r ton a t i c
ed
hi c a a i nd he n amer r vi t Cour fnds t tM ysi
a e ew, he
ti
ha
tc
hasm e isbur n t s w t tt fr tt doc en s a i s c tt e w o k- od tl
tt
de o ho ha he i s wo
um t t s ue ons iut r pr uc .
The e doc e s w e e pr pa ed by a nt of M ys i s c
s
um nt r e r
ge s
tc' ouns prm a iy i a i i ton
el i r l n ntc pa i
ofltgaton.2
ii i
W ih r pe t t t fnal doc e , whi h co i t of s ve em ais t Cour
t es c o he i
um nt
c
ns s s
e n
l , he
t
fndst tonl t fr te a l whi h w ass nton J y 26,201 a 9: a. . i c
i ha
y he i s m i, c
e
ul
0 t 58 m , s over d by
e

1
The e t doc e s a e i ntfed as dl i t Re t' a û nc de
s wo
um nt r de ii
tncden
por' nd i i nt
l
Re tst t m ent' M ys i sprvie l
por / a e
' on
tc' i l ge og.
2

Br dgewat r v Ca nialCor , 1 22241 201 W L 438 2 ( D. a. pt
i
e . r v
p. No 0, 1
331 S. Fl Se .

20,2011,andJone v Car valCor ,No.04)
s . ni
p.
20407,( D.Fl.Sept 27,2005)( de
S. a
.
or r
o e zigo j ci nt M a itae,h t c s st a Ge typ i rl r le o t a tc
v m ln be to o g srt) te wo a e h t nr rma i eis n o ta k
y
M ys i s w o k pr
tc' r oduc c ai ,do notf e os t x s the e. The a fdaviss i t i
tlm
or cl e he ul r
fi t ubm ted n
t e c es w e e s t nta l w e ke t n t s i t t M ys i ha m a o t s
hos as
r ubs a i ly a r ha he how ng ha
tc s de n hi
m oton. U nlke he e Ca ni l di not s i a a fda t f om couns i e t r
i
i
r , r va d
ubm t n f i vi r
el n ihe
Br dge e orJone s a i t tt r l ntdoc en s w e e pr r a hi diec i n t
i wat r
s t tng ha he e eva
um t r epa ed t s r to o
a d i a i pa i of ltga i
i n ntci ton
ii ton. I Jone , J
n
s udge J da s cii ly not d t t
or n pe fca l
e hat he
a ci nt r por was not pr pa e a t diec i of an a t ne o i ur . And i
c de e t
e r d t he r ton
tor y r ns er
n
Br dge e ,t def nda di not s i a a fdavi f om a a t r y i ca i t t
i wat r he e nt d
ubm t n f i t r
n to ne ndi tng ha
t i de r pors we epr pa ed asa r ul ofpr e esi pl nt d a hi die ton
he nci nt e t r e r
es t
oc dur m eme e t s r c i
i a i pa i ofpos i e ltga i
n ntci ton
s bl ii ton.

t wor pr tprvieg The r m ani e l we e notpr pa e prm a iy t a d i
he
k oduc i l e.
e i ng mais r
e r d i rl o i n
pos i e f ur ltgai a m us bepr
sbl ut e ii ton nd
t
oduce
d.
Tur ng t wheherGe r c n over om e t qualfe wor pr uc pr t cto
ni o
t
nty a
c
he
ii d
k od t o e i n,
t Cour c l st ts ca t a las on t r c d pr en ed t t Cour. Fis ,
he
t oncude ha he nno , t e t he e or es t o he
t rt
di co r i ongoi a G e r ha ye t t ke s ve al ke de ii i t s c e.
s ve y s
ng nd nt y s t o a e r
y pos tons n hi as

Ac or ngl a t s tm e Ge r ha f ie t c r he bur t s
c di y, t hi i
nty s al d o ary r den o how und ha ds p.
ue r hi
M or ove ,Ge r c nno s
e r nty a t how a s t ta ne f t e doc
ubsan i l ed or hes
ument . Couns l
s
e
ofe a s
tn s ume t twhen opponent wihhol doc nt upon a cai of prvie t t
ha
s t d
ume s
lm
i lge, ha
t y do s bec e t y a e i f c sti on a s
he
o aus he r n a t itng
moki g
ng un. Cons que l co el
e nty, uns
pr po m di di c
o t ng s over of e s pe a om a i aly t t t oppone i a s ri t
y t n us ct ut tc l ha he
nt s s e tng he

wor pr t docrne bec us t a r a y i tyi t hi sgnii nt a s
k oduc
ti
a e he dve s r s r ng o de i fca , dvere
e de e.3
vi nc
But ba e o is i c e a r vi w ,t Cour c n r por t t t s i no t c e
s d n t n am r e e he
t a e t ha hi s t he as

he e. I f c ,des t a1 t ar um e on t sis ,t e doc e sa e notpa tculry
r n a t pie l he g nt hi s ue hes
um nt r
ri a l
hel u t pr ng Genty' alegai ns To t co r r t t i de r porsa one
pf l o ovi
r s l to .
he nta y, he wo nci nt e t nd
e a lar com par tve y i
m i e
a i l nnocuous doc e sw hi h s m pl r por t ba i i or a i n
um nt
c i y e t he s c nf m to
a ut t i i nt - i or a i n w hi h G e r e t r a r a know s or w il lkel s
bo he nc de - nf m t o
c
nty ihe l e dy
l i y oon
know ba e on depost o t tm ony obt i durng di c r
sd
ii n es i
a ned i
s ove y.

3
For a m us c lr f r nc t t s a tt , s çsus ci M i ,'a s
i a e e e e o hi t iude ee û pi ous nds ' ong s by
ung
El s Pr ly. Rec ded a Am e i n Sound St os i M e
vi ese
or
t
rca
udi n mphi,t s waswrte
s he ong
itn
by M a k J m es a r a d t /1 pos ton on t U . m us c c r s on N ove ber 1
r a
nd e che he /
ii
he S.
i ha t
m
,

1
969. hlp:/ di . tc od/l s e lyhit is pii mi . m (a tviie
/ol esabou .oe evipr se sog/ us cous ndsht ls std
M a 2,201 . The s c anst f l ng l i ç e c n' go on t t rwih
y
2)
ong onti he olowi yrc: ç a t
W
ogehe t

s pi i
us c ous m i , and w e c n' buid otr dr am s on s pi i
nds
a t
l
l
e
us c ous m i .'
nds '

hlp:/ .l isne e /l spr ly-y iss pi ousmi -yrcsht
/- eyrc . vraieevi- ese lrc /us ci - ndsl i . ml
viie May2,201 .
std
2)

(at
ls

Asf rCania' d s lszeo lg to s t eCo r s ti Cania' o j cin
o r v ls ico l b iain , h u t usans r v ls be to s
r
b sd o t j itd fns d crn . Asac d f n a twi M y tc Can v li ce ry
a e n he on ee e o tie
o ee d n t si, r i a s la l
h
e il d t r l on t s w e le t bls d doc r ne w hi i s e i e know n a t
ntte o e y
hi
l- s a i he
ti ,
ch s om tm s
s he

c mmo itr s d crn .S eFo ts k 2 2F. D. t65 Ctej n dee ete t ..
o n nee t o tie e ja e , 6 R. a 6 t oit fns h o' .
h
y
e tn s wo k p o u tp oe to t d c me t s rd b t e e ttis wh h v a
x e d r r d c r tcin o o u n s hae ewe n n ile l o a e
c
ommon i ees i t outome ofltgai ). Att he rng and i he pr - arng
ntr t n he c
ii ton'
he ai
n r ehe i

me rn u Ge tyt ktep sto t a tej itd fns d crnea piso l t t e
mo a d m, n r oo h o iin h t h on ee e o ti p l ny o h
e
a t ne dint prviege nott at e wor pr uc . Ge r has now m odii d he
tor y- e
i l ,
o tom y
k- od t
nty
fe r

p st n, ttn ise dt a tej n d fns d crn d e n ts edd s o ey a s n a
o io saig n ta h t h oit ee e o tie o s o hil ic v r b e t
i
fndi ofwor pr t Se DE 50) Thi r i me i ac r c sae ntoflw,t
i ng
k oduc.( e
. s efne nt s ore t ttme
a o
be s e,bu does no a d G e r gi t Cour ' fndi t t e e i t s x e a l
ur
t
t i
nty ven he
ts i ng ha , xc ptng he i m is
me i d a
ntone bove, t de e n s ha dul i
he f nda t
ve
y nvoke t wor pr
d he
k oduc pr e ton.
t ot c i

Ac o dn l Cania ma rl o M y tcs wo k p o uc a s rin b s d o aj it
c r igy, r v l y ey n si ' r r d t se t a e n on
o
def e t r
ens heo y.

I s M y tca Ca ni lso j ci nst r que t 1 ,1 1 a d 2 a e
n um, si nd r va' b e to o e ss 3 4, 5 n 4 r
s t ne as t t f r t t doc e s Is ed i M ys i s pr vie I and t lr t
us ai d
o he i s wo
um nt i t n
t c' i l ge og
he s

oft sve emais i t t r doc
he e n
l n he hid ument M ysi and Carni ' obj ci ar
.
tc
vals e tons e
overrul as t t I ter si em ais w hi t shal produce.
ed
o he at
x
l , ch hey
4
l

=
3

Re sofProrI de s( ysi l er t i 1 21& Re tf
port
i nci nt M tc ntrogaores 9,
ques or
Pr ton48;Cani I er tr 1 & Req s f rPr in48 .
oduci
r val ntrogao y 8
ue t o oducto )

Ge r ne s eksi or ton r ga di prori i nt ofc ie s p pas e r
nty xt e
nf ma i e r ng i nc de s nls hi
s nge s

ij r d o e c rinst M y tc srd . M y tc a vie ta i h s25 i ie trp rs
n ue n x u so o si' i e
si d s d h t t a
ncd n e o t
4

Th sr ln i wi u p eu c . S ul Plitf ltrc ncu t a s e h sa
i ui g s t t rj die ho d anif ae o lde h t h a
ho

s t t a nee f t m a era s a ca
ubsan i l d or he t i l nd nnot obt i t f tona e va e w ihou
a n he unc i l qui l nt t t

undue hads p,t n s ma sek rle (fe c yi wih Loca Rul 7. sprr hi he he y e eif a tr ompl ng t
l e 1' e
flngc er rquie nt.
ii onfral e rme )
8

dai fo t begimi oft bobse ope ai i 2008 untlt dae ofGe r s
tng r m he
r ng
he
ld
r ton n
i he t
nty'

i de on J 21 201 ( bi A,M ysi s e i t t Co ton 05/ 201 .
nci nt une , 0. Exhi t
tc' mal o he ur
02/ 2)
Gen r s ks t s
ty ee he ame i o m ai fo Ca i lr ga di a of ispa s nge s who
nf r ton r m
m va e r ng ny
t se r

weeijle o teb b ldrd d rngt esmetmep ro .
r nt d n h o se i e u i h a i ei d
r
Am ong ot a gum e s ysi a Ca ni lhave i er ed a wor pr t
her r
nt ,M tc nd r va
nt pos
k oduc

o j cin a an tds l u eo t e erp rs Fo t era o sae a ve t i o jcin
be to g is icos r f h s e o t. r h e s ns ttd bo , h s be t
o
i s ti
s us a ned. M ys i nee not pr
tc
d
oduce a i i nt r por s bas d on i s w or
ny nc de
e t
e
t
k
pr
oduc cl m . Si iarl Carni i not r qui d t produce any i i nt r
t ai
m l y,
val s
e re o
nc de eport
s

bas d on t j ntdeens docri .
e
he oi f e t ne
H o e , C ar val s l i or G e r of t num be of r port i is
w ver
ni
hal nf m
nt y
he
r
e
s n t

pos e son ( M ysi hasale done and e Defndants lls ()t ge ral
s si as tc
r ady
)
ach e
hal it i he ne
nat eofeac i i ntand (i how many pe ewe i ur d. Thi s lbei t
ur
h ncde
i)
opl re nj e
s hal n he
f m of a s or s m ar
or
w n um
y.
A ddi i l D ef
tonaly, endant s lans er t i errogat es butm ay lm i t r
s hal
w
he nt
ori
i t hei

r s ns st pro i i n s da i ba k t e y a sb f r Ge r si j y whih
epo e o ir ncde t, tng c hr e e r e o e nty' n ur , c
rel e t s bel use or faiure,t bum pi s oft track,t w et s oft t
at o: eat t
l
he
nes
he
he nes
he rack,

j ni ofcar ,hol ngont handl ,deeci br sornotutlzngbr s
oi ng
s di
o
ebars f tve ake
iii
ake.
=
4

M ai e eRe sand Re ords( tcI er at is1 20&
ntnanc port
c
Mysi ntrog ore 9,
Requetf Pr ton53,55,56 .
s or oduci
)

G e r a s s eks i or a i f om M ys i r r ng m ai ena e r pors a
nty l o e
nf m ton r
tc ega di
nt nc e t nd
r c ds r l tng t t bobs e rde. M ys i a gue t tt s r ques i ove br bec us
e or e a i o he
ld i
tc r s ha hi e
t s r oad a e
t r de i i pec ed on a daiy bas s a t e a e t m a r or .
he i s ns t
l
i nd her r oo ny ec ds
M ystc shal provi report and i orm at on goi back t
i
l
de
s
nf
i
ng
hree years f
rom

t s ec i de ,butmay Im i ispr ton t r t and r ordsconc r ng
he ubj t nci nt
i t t oduci o epors
ec
e ni

m ai m ai e
or
nt nanc r pl m e or re r t i, m ai e
e, e ace nt
pais; hat s
nt nanc r pais and
e, e r
i
nspectons t are notconduct on a daiy or routne basi
i
hat
ed
l
i
s.

lz

Adve ii M atri s( ysi Reque tf Pr ton 1 .
rtsnz e al M tc
s or oduci 9)

M ys i s lpr
tc hal oduc any adve i i or prom otonal m at i s t i m ade
e
rts ng
i
er al hat t

a l et Car valwihi oneye prort Ge r si ur
vaiabl o ni
t n
ar i o nty' nj y.
éz

Cor es
r pondencePrort I de ( tcReque tf Pr ton25;
i o nci nt Mysi
s or oduci
Cmni Req s f Pr ton25)
val uet or oduci
.

Ge r r ss pror c r pondenc bewee Ca ni l and M ysi Ge r
nty eque t i ores
e t n r va
tc.
nty
cl i st tt c r s
a m ha he or e ponde e w ile de t c l s ofbusne sbe w e Ca n va a
nc l vi nce he otr e
i s t en r i l nd

M y tca i t e eo erlv n t he j itv n u ecam.Dee d n scam t i wo d
si nd s h r f r ee a t o r on e t r li
f n a t li h s ul
be undul bur ns e bec us of t f e nc of c m uni ton on m a tr l ge y
y
de om
a e
he r que y
om
ca i
te s ar l

ir lva t Ge r scli (uc a ho ma pase er wilbea tndi e h da s
ree nt o nty' ams s h s w ny sng s l te ng ac y'

e c rin)
x u so .
Deendant s lpr
f
s hal oduceaI c e pondencer l i t t ()fnancng,(i
I orr s
eatng o he i i i i)

de i and (i)consr ton oft bobse rde Car vals lalo pr e any
sgn,
ii
tuci
he
ld i .
ni hal s oduc
perf ance eval i ofM ys c,w hi C ar valpr par is l .
orm
uatons
ti
ch
ni
e ed t e f5

zz

l pe tonsand Ce iiat soft Bobse Ri ( ysi Reque tf
ns c i
rtfc e he
ld de M tc
s or
Pr ton28,29)
oduci
.

M ystc s l produce any i pect on report or cert fcat by governm ent
i hal
ns i
s
i i es
enttesand regul ors t rel e t t bobs ed ri
ii
at
hat at o he
l
de.

K

Pe s n lFie ( y tcRe u s f rPr d ci n3 )
r o ne ls M si q e t o o u to 3 .

M ys c shal produce t personnelf l of t i vi s w ho w ere w orki
ti
l
he
ies he ndi dual
ng
on t excursi on the day of t i dent6 M yst c w il redact t i vi s'
he
on
he nci .
i l
he ndi dual

5
Ca ni ag e d t pr
r val r e o oduce M ysi s a i ton t be om e a of i a Ca ni l
tc' pplca i o c
n fci l r va
exc ts on ope a orw ihi 1 da oft he i
tr i
rt
t n 0 ys he arng.
l
0

s als c iy number ( t i Jam aian equi ent and any healh or medial
oci e urt
s or her
c
val )
t
c
i or aton unl s i re at t al oholor s t e abus
nf m i
e s t l es o c
ubs anc
e.
=
9

M anual.Gui sand Pr dure ( tcReques f Pr i 42)
s de
oce s Mysi
t or oducton .

M ys i s l pr
t c hal oduc any m anual , gui , pr e es r es or s andar
e
s
des oc dur , ul
t
ds

f ()t rdemanuf t r (i t c
rom i he i
acure , i) he ompany t i t l t ri ,or (i)t
hat nsaled he de
ii he
i
ndus i general
try n
.

1
0.

Compl nt Re
ai s zardi M vsi ( ni I erogaor 21& Reques f
nz tc Car val nt r t y
t or
Pr ton47)
oduci
.

Ca ni ls o j ci s a e o r uld Ho v r Ca nia ' a we t t
r va' b e ton r ve r e . we e , r v ls ns r o he
i e ogat y and re
nt rr
or
ques f produc i s l be Im i e t c pl nt r
t or
t on ha l
i t d o om ai s egar ng
di

s eyis sandreatngt t bobse rdeis l.( Exhi tB,Cnr valse lt
aft sue
l i o he
ld i tef See bi
ni ' mai o
t Cour on04/0/ 2)
he
t
3 201 .
11
.

Ot Re
her ques s
t

De e nt ha a s d t t t y ha no doc nt r ponsve t M ysi
f nda s ve dvi e ha he
ve
ume s es i o
tc
Re s f Pr
que t or oduc i 1 30,44 a Ca ni lRe
ton 2,
nd r va ques f Pr uc i 31 32.
t or od ton ,
D O N E A N D O RD ER ED i Cha be s n M i m i F or da M a
n
m r ,i
n , i , y

t 201
h, 2.

J t
ona
oodma
n
Unie St t M agita eJ
t
aes
sr t udge
Copi s f r s d t
e u nihe o:
A 1 Cou elofRec d
1 ns
or

6

M ystc a s d t ti be i ved t r w e e sx ors n s h i vi l .
i dvi e ha t le
he e r i
eve uc ndi dua s