Gentry v. Carnival Corporation et al

Filing 53

ORDER granting in part and denying in part 39 Motion to Compel; granting in part and denying in part 40 Motion to Compel. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jonathan Goodman on 5/8/2012. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B) (eg)

W I J.Char
CaFOS
don/

'4.

<c h do @ h mion l r
c ar n a l mie l
t la

To < o d @f d.s o rsg v
g o man l u c ut.o >
s
cc

05/ / 2 1 52 PM
02201 0:

bcc

Subec Aprl r v. ni & Mysi Mount n,CaseNo.
j t iGenty Car val
tc
ai
:
1: 1 cv 21 - G
1 - - 580 J
Hit y:
s or

* Timsaeabefwrd j
h esghseno ae.
s
rd

Dear Magi r e Goodm an,
st at

W e ar t at orneys f Mysti Mountai Li ied i t above r er
e he t
or
c
n m t n he
ef enced m at er.At the
t
heari on Pl ntifs Moton t Com pelBet er Responses t Di
ng
ai f '
i o
t
o scover on Monday,Aprl 23,
y
i

2012,Your Honor i tuct t wihi t ( da we pr de t Cour a bre r t
ns r ed hat t n en 10) ys
ovi he
t
if epor
i cati the num ber of i dent r
ndi ng
nci
epor s i Mysti s possessi docum entng i dent wer
t n
c'
on
i nci s
e

ij i wer r t i connec i wih t e sub ec bob e rde,r dl s oft al
n ures e epored n
ton t h
j t sld i egar es
he l
eged
Catse.
l

F l ng an i tgaton, Mys i det mi t e ar t y fve ( suc i i s
ol
owi
nves i i
tc er ned her e went i 25) h ncdent

r
eport f om the begi ng of t bobsl oper i
ed r
nni
he
ed
atons i 2008 untl t dat of Pl ntf '
n
i he
e
ai ifs
aleged i dent i June 21,2010. Out ofabundance ofcauton, i det m i ng the am ount
l
nci
n
i
n er ni
,

we i uded r t r dlss ofs iy oft c
ncl
epors egar e
evert
he ompl nt (. r ors oft
ai ie. ep t
empor y pai
ar
n,
m us e spas ,et )
cl
m c.
Respect uly,
f l

Carl J.Chardon, Esq.
os
Ham i on,Mier & Bit s L P
l
t
l
l
r hiel L
150 Sout eas Sec Avenue
h t ond
Suie 1
t 200
Mi i Fl rda 33131
am , o i

(
305)3793686 Ofie
fc
(
305)3793690 F si l
ac mi
e

www. i onm iera .om
ham l
t
l lw c
l
c ar
ch don@ ham i onm ieraw.om
l
t
l l c
l
M i i F Lauder e.Tam pa .O rando
am . t.
dal
l
Ki
ngst Vi gi I ands
on. r n sl

H
z/pr>(l$z/l l.
l/ ?tl 1 zll
,
'
*#* CONF DENTI I NOTI *** Thi c m uniaton,al wih any doc
I
AL R
CE
s om
c i
ong t
ument fl soratac ent ,i
s, i
e
t hm s s
it
n ended onl f t e us oft addr s and m a c t n prvi ged and c fden i i or i n.The i t ded
y or h e he
es ee
y on ai i l
e
on i tal nf mato
n en
r pi s lnotf t dit i e t e i f m a i t ansmit d i t s Emai unl s au horz by Iw ort e
eci ent hal
ur her s rbut h n or ton r
t e n hi
l es t ied
a
h

su ec oft i or i tans ted.I you ar nott i ended r pi ,you ar her notfed t atany
bj t he nf maton r mit f
e
he nt
eci ent
e eby ii h

dis iaton,dit i ton orc yig ofany i or i con ai i oratach t t s c m uniaton i s rc l
s em n i
s rbu i
op n
nf maton t ned n
t ed o hi om
c i s t ity
pr bied.I y h r ei t s mes
ohi t f ou ave ec ved hi
sage i eror pl e n iy t senderi m edi el an de r t
n r , eas otf he
m
at y d stoy he
orgi com m unia i and is atachment wih t r ng,prn i orsa ng i any mann
i nal
c ton
t t
s t ou eadi
itng
vi n
er