Cambridge University Press et al v. Patton et al

Filing 384

RESPONSE to 361 Plaintiffs' Revised List of Works at Issue filed by J. L. Albert, Mark P. Becker, Kenneth R. Bernard, Jr, Larry R. Ellis, Rutledge A. Griffin, Jr, Robert F. Hatcher, C. Thomas Hopkins, Jr, W. Mansfield Jennings, Jr, James R. Jolly, Donald M. Leebern, Jr, William NeSmith, Jr, Risa Palm, Doreen Stiles Poitevint, Willis J. Potts, Jr, Neil L. Pruitt, Jr, Wanda Yancey Rodwell, Nancy Seamans, Kessel Stelling, Jr, Benjamin J. Tarbutton, III, Richard L. Tucker, Larry Walker, Philip A. Wilheit, Sr. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B, # 3 Exhibit C)(Bates, Mary) Modified on 6/8/2011 in order to update docket text (ank).

Exhibit A: Plaintiff Works Alleged to be Infringed at GSU
2009 Maymester

Course Title
(Books
Required for
Purchase)

Instructor

Title of Work

Pronunciation Games

Publisher
Plaintiff

Total # of Pages and
Chapters in Work

Cambridge 7 chapters, 112 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 108 pages)

# of
Page
# of
Chapters
Range of
Pages
Allegedly Used Alleged Allegedly Used
Use
Selections

Keep Talking:
Communicative Fluency
Activities for Language
Teaching

1 (partial)

More Grammar Games:
Cognitive, Affective and
Drama Activities for EFL
Students
AL8480 Classroom
Practices in
Teaching
ESL/EFL

Cambridge 4 chapters with additional
worksheets and activities, 208
pages
(Plaintiffs contend 193 pages)
Cambridge 9 chapters, 192 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 174 pages)

Selections

8-27

58-98

Percent
Allegedly
Used

Class Size

8.0%**

10

3

• Work not used in class
• Work not listed on syllabus
• 11 of 20 pages expressly
photocopiable (9, 11, 13-14, 1718, 20-21, 23, and 25-26); use
without permission at most 9
pages (8.0%)
• No statutory presumption
(foreign work)

10

2

• Students required to purchase
book
• No statutory presumption
(foreign work)

10

5

• Work not used in class
• Work not listed on syllabus
• No evidence license available
• 10 pages not protectable (63,
67-68, 74, 77, 80-82, & 87-88);
use without permission at most
26 pages (13.5%)
• No statutory presumption
(registration filed >5 years after
first publication)

10

2

• Students required to purchase
book
• 37 pages not protectable (4546, 49-51, 56-61, 65-67, 69-71,
73-74, 76-77, 81, 83-88, 91-93,
95-97 and 100-102); use without
permission at most 22 pages
(7.4%)
• No statutory presumption
(foreign work)

10

3

• Work not used in class
• Work not listed on syllabus
• No evidence license available
• Assignment document lacks
signature
• No statutory presumption
(registration filed >5 years after
first publication)

20
(11 of these
expressly
photocopiable)

(Plaintiffs
contend: 8.3%)**

41

19.7%

Hit Count
Defendants' Other Challenges
(including
(in addition to Fair Use)
library staff
and counsel)

(Plaintiffs
contend 21.2%)
58-93

36
(10 of these not
protectable)

18.8%**
(Plaintiffs
contend 20.7%)**

Murphy

(4 books
required for
purchase)
Grammar Practice Activities Cambridge 4 chapters, with additional
(1st edition)
activities, 296 Pages
(Plaintiffs contend 282 pages)

Five-Minute Activities: A
Resource Book of Short
Activities

Cambridge Activities and advice for
language teaching.

Selections

Selections

44-102

1-23

117 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 101 pages)

59
(37 of these not
protectable)

23

19.9%**
(Plaintiffs
contend 20.9%)**

19.7%

(Plaintiffs
contend 22.8%)

Page 1 of 3

Exhibit A: Plaintiff Works Alleged to be Infringed at GSU
2009 Maymester

Course Title
(Books
Required for
Purchase)

Instructor

Title of Work

Newspapers

Publisher
Plaintiff

Oxford

Total # of Pages and
Chapters in Work

6 chapters, 144 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 129 pages)

# of
Page
# of
Chapters
Range of
Pages
Allegedly Used Alleged Allegedly Used
Use
1

30-58

29

Percent
Allegedly
Used

Class Size

Hit Count
Defendants' Other Challenges
(including
(in addition to Fair Use)
library staff
and counsel)

20.1%**

10

3

• Work not used in class
• Work not listed on syllabus
• No evidence license available
• Inadequate assignment to
Plaintiff Publisher
• 2 pages not protectable (45758); use without permission at
most 27 pages (18.8%)
• No statutory presumption
(foreign work)

10

3

• Work not used in class
• Work not listed on syllabus
• No evidence license available
• Inadequate assignment to
Plaintiff Publisher
• 9 pages not protectable (40, 4244, 46-47, 53-54, and 62); use
without permission at most 30
pages (15.7%)
• No statutory presumption
(foreign work)

(Plaintiffs
contend 22.5%)**

AL8480 Classroom
Practices in
Teaching
ESL/EFL

Murphy
Role Play: Resource Books
for Teachers

Oxford

191 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 182 pages)

Selections

24-62

(continued)

Page 2 of 3

39
(9 of these not
protectable)

20.4%**
(Plaintiffs
contend 21.4%)**

Exhibit A: Plaintiff Works Alleged to be Infringed at GSU
2009 Maymester

Course Title
(Books
Required for
Purchase)

Instructor

Title of Work

Publisher
Plaintiff

The Craft of Inquiry:
Theories, Methods,
Evidence

Oxford

Handbook of Feminist
Research: Theory and
Praxis

SAGE

Handbook of Social Theory

SAGE

The SAGE Handbook of
Qualitative Research (3rd
edition)
EPRS8500 Qualitative/
Interpretive
Research in
Education I

SAGE

The SAGE Handbook of
Qualitative Research (2nd
edition)

SAGE

Total # of Pages and
Chapters in Work

# of
Page
# of
Chapters
Range of
Pages
Allegedly Used Alleged Allegedly Used
Use

8 chapters, 185 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 134 pages)

43 chapters, 767 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 712 pages)

39 chapters, 564 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 537 pages)

44 chapters, 1229 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 1126 pages)

Original research and analysis
concerning the theory and
practice of qualitative inquiry.

1

1

1

4

3

36 chapters, 1142 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 1065 pages)

Kaufmann

(3 books
required for
purchase)

Handbook of Critical and
Indigenous Methodologies

Qualitative Research
Practice

Handbook of Narrative
Inquiry

SAGE

SAGE

SAGE

30 chapters, 619 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 570 pages)

38 chapters, 639 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 608 pages)

24 chapters, 710 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 650 pages)

2

1

1

217-228

5.9%

13

1

20

515-534

Class Size

11

21-31

Percent
Allegedly
Used

(Plaintiffs
contend 8.2%)
2.6%

13

56

(Plaintiffs
contend 2.8%)
2.1%

13

26

8.4%

13

(Plaintiffs
contend 9.1%)
3.15%**

31; 21; 34; 71
(157 total for
all excerpts)

13

2; 45; 1
• Plaintiffs' claim that the
(48 total for all chapters at pages 717-732 &
excerpts)
923-948 were used in
Maymester is contrary to the
evidence; these portions were
used in Summer 2009; actual
use is at most 36 pages (3.15%)
• No contributing author
agreement for excerpt at pp. 733768

6.1%

13

(Plaintiffs
contend 6.5%)
0.0%**

25; 35
(60 total for
both excerpts)

13

2

13

17

12
(for all 12 of
these, only 1 of
3 contributing
author
agreements)

1-32
357-375
443-465
651-679
717-732
733-768
923-948

103

85-99
135-156

37

78
(16; 36; 26)
(42 of these not
actually posted
(only 1
to EReserves;
chapter, pp for the remaining
733-768,
36, no
actually
contributing
used)
author
agreement)

391-406

16
(none placed on
EReserves)

3-34

32

(Plaintiffs
contend 2.2%)

(Plaintiffs
contend 7.3%,
but includes 2
chapters not
used)**

(Plaintiffs
contend 2.6%,
but includes
chapter not used)

4.5%
(Plaintiffs
contend 4.9%)

** Pages alleged contain material clearly not protectable. See further explanation under Defendants' Other Challenges

Page 3 of 3

Hit Count
Defendants' Other Challenges
(including
(in addition to Fair Use)
library staff
and counsel)

• Excerpt has three authors;
assignment from only one
provided; use without these
pages zero (0.0%)
• No statutory presumption
(foreign work)

• Work not placed on EReserves
(DX 534); Defendants calculate
pages 391-406 as 2.2% of work
• Work not assigned to class
(DX 534)
• No statutory presumption
(foreign work)