Cambridge University Press et al v. Patton et al

Filing 384

RESPONSE to 361 Plaintiffs' Revised List of Works at Issue filed by J. L. Albert, Mark P. Becker, Kenneth R. Bernard, Jr, Larry R. Ellis, Rutledge A. Griffin, Jr, Robert F. Hatcher, C. Thomas Hopkins, Jr, W. Mansfield Jennings, Jr, James R. Jolly, Donald M. Leebern, Jr, William NeSmith, Jr, Risa Palm, Doreen Stiles Poitevint, Willis J. Potts, Jr, Neil L. Pruitt, Jr, Wanda Yancey Rodwell, Nancy Seamans, Kessel Stelling, Jr, Benjamin J. Tarbutton, III, Richard L. Tucker, Larry Walker, Philip A. Wilheit, Sr. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B, # 3 Exhibit C)(Bates, Mary) Modified on 6/8/2011 in order to update docket text (ank).

Exhibit B: Plaintiff Works Alleged to be Infringed at GSU
Summer 2009

Course Title

Instructor

Title of Work

Publisher
Plaintiff

Total # of Pages and
Chapters in Work

# of
Chapters
Allegedly
Used

Page
Range of
Alleged
Use

# of
Pages Used

Percent
Used

Class Size

36 chapters, 1229 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 1065
pages)

2

717-732
923-943

37

3.0%

9

19; 14 (33)

24 chapters, 564 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 506
pages)

1

14

(Plaintiffs
contend 3.5%)
2.5%

9

31

• No contributing author
agreement

33 chapters, 525 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 492
pages)

1

16

(Plaintiffs
contend 2.8%)
3.0%

22

62

• No contributing author
agreements
• No statutory presumption
(foreign work)

43 chapters, 767 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 712
pages)

1

36 chapters, 1229 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 1065
pages)

1

36 chapters, 653 pages.
(Plaintiffs contend 586
pages)

1

7 chapters, 320 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 250
pages)

1

(Books Required for
Purchase)

EPRS8510 Qualitative Research
in Education II

The SAGE Handbook of Qualitative
Research
(2nd edition)
Kaufmann

(3 books required for
purchase)

SAGE

Inside Interviewing: New Lenses, New
Concerns

SAGE

Handbook of Ethnography

EPSF8280 Anthropology of
Education

Handbook of Feminist Research:
Theory and Praxis

SAGE

SAGE

Esposito

(5 books required for
purchase)

SAGE

Awakening Children's Minds
Kruger***

SAGE

The SAGE Handbook of Qualitative
Research
(1st edition)

EPY7090 - Learning
and the Learner

The SAGE Handbook of Qualitative
Research
(2nd edition)

Oxford

415-428

188-203

Hit Count
Defendants' Other Challenges
(including
library staff
and counsel
attempts)

(Plaintiffs
contend 3.3%)

155-172

455-486

70-82

181-199

18

2.4%

22

22

32

(Plaintiffs
contend 2.5%)
2.6%

22

98

13

(Plaintiffs
contend 3%)
2.0%

22

25

19

(Plaintiffs
contend 2.2%)
5.9%

17

1

(Plaintiffs
contend 7.6%)

Page 1 of 2

Exhibit B: Plaintiff Works Alleged to be Infringed at GSU
Summer 2009

Course Title

Instructor

Title of Work

Publisher
Plaintiff

Total # of Pages and
Chapters in Work

(Books Required for
Purchase)

Liszt: Sonata in B Minor

Cambridge 5 chapters, 101 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 82 pages)

# of
Chapters
Allegedly
Used

Page
Range of
Alleged
Use

# of
Pages Used

Percent
Used

Class Size

Hit Count
Defendants' Other Challenges
(including
library staff
and counsel
attempts)

1

28-48

21
(6 of these
not
protectable)

20.8%**

10

8

• 6 pages not protectable; use
without permission at most 15
pages (14.9%)
• No evidence license available
• No statutory presumption
(registration >5 years after
publication)
• 2 pages not protectable; use
without permission at most 14
pages (4.2%)
• No statutory presumption
(foreign work)
• 3 pages not protectable; use
without permission at most 12
pages (3.7%)
• No statutory presumption
(foreign work)
• 5 pages not protectable; use
without permission at most 16
pages (4.1%)
• No statutory presumption
(registration >5 years after
publication)
• 2 pages not protectable; use
without permission at most 16
pages (4.2%)
• Inadequate assignment to
Plaintiff Publisher
• No statutory presumption
(foreign work)

(Plaintiffs
contend
25.6%)**

The Cambridge Companion to
Mendelssohn

1 (partial)

96-111

16
4.8%**
(2 of these
not
(Plaintiffs
protectable) contend 5.6%)**

10

10

The Cambridge Companion to
Schumann

Cambridge 13 chapters, 324 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 291
pages)

1 (partial)

105-119

15
4.6%**
(3 of these
not
(Plaintiffs
protectable) contend 5.1%)**

10

5

The Cambridge Companion to
Beethoven

MUS8860 - Romantic
Period 1800-1900

Cambridge 14 chapters, 331 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 268
pages)

Cambridge 14 chapters, 387 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 305
pages)

1

165-185

21
5.4%**
(5 of these
not
(Plaintiffs
protectable) contend 6.9%)**

10

2

1 (partial)

250-267

18
(2 of these
not
protectable

10

16

Orr
(2 books required for
purchase)

The Music of Berlioz

Oxford

10 chapters, 379 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 347
pages)

** Pages alleged contain material clearly not protectable. See further explanation under Defendants' Other Challenges

Page 2 of 2

4.8%**
(Plaintiffs
contend 5.2%)**