Cambridge University Press et al v. Patton et al

Filing 384

RESPONSE to 361 Plaintiffs' Revised List of Works at Issue filed by J. L. Albert, Mark P. Becker, Kenneth R. Bernard, Jr, Larry R. Ellis, Rutledge A. Griffin, Jr, Robert F. Hatcher, C. Thomas Hopkins, Jr, W. Mansfield Jennings, Jr, James R. Jolly, Donald M. Leebern, Jr, William NeSmith, Jr, Risa Palm, Doreen Stiles Poitevint, Willis J. Potts, Jr, Neil L. Pruitt, Jr, Wanda Yancey Rodwell, Nancy Seamans, Kessel Stelling, Jr, Benjamin J. Tarbutton, III, Richard L. Tucker, Larry Walker, Philip A. Wilheit, Sr. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B, # 3 Exhibit C)(Bates, Mary) Modified on 6/8/2011 in order to update docket text (ank).

Exhibit C: Plaintiff Works Alleged to be Infringed at GSU
Fall 2009

Course Title

Instructor

Title of Work

Publisher
Plaintiff

Total # of Pages and
Chapters in Work

Oxford

8 chapters, 432 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 382 pages)

(Books
Required for
Purchase)
The Slave Community

AAS3000 AfricanAmerican
Family

African American Single Mothers:
Understanding Their Lives and
Families
Dixon

SAGE

Black Children

SAGE

1

249-283

1

117-145

Percent
Used

Class Size

Hit Count
Defendants' Other Challenges
(including
(in addition to Fair Use)
library staff
and counsel)

35

8.1%

59

66

29

(Plaintiffs
contend 9.2%)
12.5%

59

15

59

13

(Plaintiffs
contend 15.9%)

(6 books
required for
purchase)

23 chapters, 256 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 235 pages)

1

73-96

24

9.4%
(Plaintiffs
contend 10.2%)

Black Families (1997)

Ancient Egyptian Materials and
Technology
AH4900 Materiality of
Egyptian
Painting

10 chapters, 232 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 192 pages)

# of
Page Range
# of
Chapters of Alleged Pages Used
Allegedly
Use
Used

Hartwig

SAGE

21 chapters, 380 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 363 pages)

Cambridge 25 chapters, 732 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 672 pages)

1

214-233

1
(plus part
of
additional
chapter)

44-54
104-120

(1 book
required for
purchase)

Page 1 of 8

20

5.3%

59

9

28

(Plaintiffs
contend 5.5%)
3.8%

13

25

(Plaintiffs
contend 4.2%)

• No statutory presumption
(registration >5 years after
publication)

Exhibit C: Plaintiff Works Alleged to be Infringed at GSU
Fall 2009

Course Title

Instructor

Title of Work

Publisher
Plaintiff

Total # of Pages and
Chapters in Work

(Books
Required for
Purchase)
Criterion-Referenced Language
Testing

Cambridge 7 chapters, 336 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 291 pages)

# of
Page Range
# of
Chapters of Alleged Pages Used
Allegedly
Use
Used
1

101-148

48

Percent
Used

Class Size

Hit Count
Defendants' Other Challenges
(including
(in addition to Fair Use)
library staff
and counsel)

14.3%

16

1

• No statutory presumption
(registration >5 years after
publication)

16

1

• 33 pages not protectable as
citing and using others' works;
use without permission at most
47 pages (14.8%)
• No evidence license available
• No statutory presumption
(registration >5 years after
publication)

16

N/A

• 55 pages not protectable as
citing and using others' works;
use without permission at most
14 pages (3.4%)
• No statutory presumption
(registration >5 years after
publication)

16

N/A

• 25 pages not protectable as
citing and using others' works;
use without permission at most 5
pages (1.2%)
• Inadequate assignment to
Plaintiff Publisher
• No evidence license available
• No statutory presumption
(registration >5 years after
publication)

16

N/A

16

N/A

• Inadequate assignment to
Plaintiff Publisher
• No statutory presumption
(registration >5 years after
publication)
• 20 pages not protectable as
citing and using others' works;
use without permission at most
18 pages (6.3%)
• No evidence license available
• No statutory presumption
(registration >5 years after
publication)

(Plaintiffs
contend 16.5%)
Assessing Grammar

Assessing Reading

AL8550 Second
Language
Evaluation and
Assessment

Kim

Cambridge 9 chapters, 317 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 274 pages)

Cambridge 9 chapters, 413 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 357 pages)

2

1

49-82
100-145

202-270

80
(33 of these
not
protectable)

69
(55 of these
not
protectable)

Oxford

8 sections, 420 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 360 pages)

1

81-110

Language Testing in Practice

Oxford

12 chapters (plus additional
section with projects), 383
pages
(Plaintiffs contend 365 pages)

3

17-42
43-60
85-94

54

Cambridge 9 chapters, 287 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 257 pages)

1

116-153

38
(20 of these
not
protectable)

Assessing Listening

Page 2 of 8

(Plaintiffs
contend
29.2%)**

16.7%**
(Plaintiffs
contend
19.3%)**

7.1%**
30
(25 of these
not
(Plaintiffs
protectable) contend 8.3%)**

Fundamental Considerations in
Language Testing

(1 book
required for
purchase)

25.2%**

14.1%
(Plaintiffs
contend 14.8%)
13.2%**
Plaintiffs
contend
14.8%)**

Exhibit C: Plaintiff Works Alleged to be Infringed at GSU
Fall 2009

Course Title

Instructor

Title of Work

Publisher
Plaintiff

Total # of Pages and
Chapters in Work

(Books
Required for
Purchase)
Assessing Language for Specific
Purposes

Assessing Speaking

Cambridge 8 chapters, 330 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 282 pages)

Cambridge 8 chapters, 228 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 191 pages)

# of
Page Range
# of
Chapters of Alleged Pages Used
Allegedly
Use
Used
1

2

24-40

59-95
139-169

17
(10 of these
not
protectable)

68
(50 of these
not
protectable)

Percent
Used

Class Size

Hit Count
Defendants' Other Challenges
(including
(in addition to Fair Use)
library staff
and counsel)

5.2%**

16

N/A

• 10 pages not protectable as
citing and using others' works;
use without permission at most 7
pages (2.1%)
• No statutory presumption
(foreign work)

16

N/A

• 50 pages not protectable as
citing and using others' works;
use without permission at most
18 pages (7.9%)
• No statutory presumption
(registration >5 years after
publication)

(Plaintiffs
contend 6%)**

29.8%**
(Plaintiffs
contend
35.6%)**

Learning Vocabulary in Another
Language
AL8550 Second
Language
Evaluation and
Assessment
(continued)

Cambridge 11 sections, 491 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 431 pages)

1

344-379

36
7.3%**
(25 of these
not
( Plaintiffs
protectable) contend 8.4%)**

16

N/A

• 25 pages not protectable as
citing and using others' works;
use without permission at most
11 pages (2.2%)
• No statutory presumption
(registration >5 years after
publication)

Assessing Vocabulary

Cambridge 8 chapters, 293 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 251 pages)

1

150-187

38
(16 of these
not
protectable)

16

N/A

• 16 pages not protectable as
citing and using others' works;
use without permission at most
22 pages (7.5%)
• No statutory presumption
(registration >5 years after
publication)

16

N/A

• 47 pages not protectable as
citing and using others' works;
use without permission at most
16 pages (5.7%)
• No evidence license available
• No statutory presumption
(registration >5 years after
publication)

Kim

Assessing Writing

Cambridge 10 chapters, 282 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 244 pages)

2

77-139

Page 3 of 8

63
(47 of these
not
protectable)

13.0%**
(Plaintiffs
contend
15.1%)**

22.3%**
(Plaintiffs
contend
25.8%)**

Exhibit C: Plaintiff Works Alleged to be Infringed at GSU
Fall 2009

Course Title

Instructor

Title of Work

Publisher
Plaintiff

Total # of Pages and
Chapters in Work

(Books
Required for
Purchase)

ANTH4440 Epidemiology
and
Anthropology

International Health Organisations
and Movements, 1918-1939

1

222-43

Percent
Used

Class Size

6.2%

29

29

20
6.6%
(for all 20, no
assignment to
(Plaintiffs
Publisher)
contend 9.3%)

29

64

14
(for all 14, no
contributing
author
agreement)

30

25

22

Hit Count
Defendants' Other Challenges
(including
(in addition to Fair Use)
library staff
and counsel)

(Plaintiffs
contend 6.8%)
McCombie

Evolution of Infectious Disease

(2 books
required for
purchase)
ENGL4200 Cyborgs in
American
Culture

Cambridge 5 chapters, 355 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 325 pages)

# of
Page Range
# of
Chapters of Alleged Pages Used
Allegedly
Use
Used

Gabler-Hover A History of Feminist Literary
Criticism

Oxford

11 chapters, 305 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 216 pages)

1

15-34

Cambridge 17 chapters, 364 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 335 pages)

1

322-335

(4 books
required for
purchase)

Page 4 of 8

3.9%
(Plaintiffs
contend 4.2%)

• Contributing author agreement
/ assignment
• No statutory presumption
(registration >5 years after
publication)
• No assignment to Plaintiff
Publisher; use without these
pages zero (0.0%)

• No contributing author
agreement; use without these
pages zero (0.0%)
• No statutory presumption
(foreign work)

Exhibit C: Plaintiff Works Alleged to be Infringed at GSU
Fall 2009

Course Title

Instructor

Title of Work

Publisher
Plaintiff

Total # of Pages and
Chapters in Work

Oxford

8 chapters, 185 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 134 pages)

(Books
Required for
Purchase)
The Craft of Inquiry: Theories,
Methods, Evidence

Approaches to Qualitative
Research: A Reader on Theory
and Practice
Handbook of Feminist Research:
Theory and Praxis

Handbook of Narrative Inquiry:
Mapping a Methodology
EPRS8500 Qualitative/
Interpretive
Research in
Education I
(3 books
required for
purchase)

# of
Page Range
# of
Chapters of Alleged Pages Used
Allegedly
Use
Used
1

21-31

Percent
Used

Class Size

11

6.0%

21

26

(Plaintiffs
contend 8.2%)
4.6
(Plaintiffs
contend 4.6%)
9.6%

21

16

Oxford

25 chapters, 564 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 546 pages)

1

447-472

26

SAGE

43 chapters, 767 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 712 pages)

1

71-106; 155172; 515534

74
(for 36 of
these no
contributing
author
agreement)

35-75

41
(for all 41 of
these, only 1
of 2
contributing
author
agreements)

(Plaintiffs
contend 6.3%)

1-32
109-138
357-373
443-465
547-557
915-932
959-978

151

12.3%

733-768

36
(for all 36 of
these, no
contributing
author
agreement)
12
(for all 12 of
these, only 1
of 3
contributing
author
agreements)

Hit Count
Defendants' Other Challenges
(including
(in addition to Fair Use)
library staff
and counsel)

SAGE

24 chapters, 710 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 650 pages)

1

21

(Plaintiffs
contend 10.4%)

5.8%

• No registration certificate
provided
• No statutory presumption
46; 28; 40 • No contributing author
(114 total for agreement for 36 pages (pp 71all excerpts) 106); use without those pages at
most 38 pages (5.0%)

21

84

• No contributing author
agreement for one of two
authors; use without these
pages zero (0.0%) (PX 259)
• No statutory presumption

21

48; 55; 100; 2;
42; 13; 34
(294 total for
all excerpts)

21

77

• No contributing author
agreement

21

54

• No contributing author
agreements for two of three
authors; use without those
pages is zero (0.0%)
• Insufficient evidence foreign
work (trial testimony)
• No statutory presumption
(foreign work)

Kaufmann
The SAGE Handbook of
Qualitative Research
(3rd edition)

SAGE

The SAGE Handbook of
Qualitative Research
(2nd edition)

SAGE

Handbook of Social Theory
(2001)

SAGE

44 chapters, 1229 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 1126
pages)

7

36 chapters, 1142 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 1065
pages)

1

39 chapters, 564 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 537 pages)

1

217-228

Page 5 of 8

(Plaintiffs
contend 13.4%)

3.2%
(Plaintiffs
contend 3.4%)

2.1%
(Plaintiffs
contend 2.2%)

Exhibit C: Plaintiff Works Alleged to be Infringed at GSU
Fall 2009

Course Title

Instructor

Title of Work

Publisher
Plaintiff

Total # of Pages and
Chapters in Work

SAGE

10 chapters, 237 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 188 pages)

(Books
Required for
Purchase)
EPRS8520 Qualitative
Research in
Education III

Esposito

Theoretical Frameworks in
Qualitative Research

# of
Page Range
# of
Chapters of Alleged Pages Used
Allegedly
Use
Used
2

xii-xxx
189-196

27

Percent
Used

Class Size

Hit Count
Defendants' Other Challenges
(including
(in addition to Fair Use)
library staff
and counsel)

11.4%

14

1; 3
• Plaintiffs count pages xii-xxx as
(4 total for used, but do not include these or
both excerpts) any Roman numeral pages in
their total page count; excluding
those pages from both the total
page count and total number of
pages, Plaintiffs would allege
13.3% used

(Plaintiffs
contend 14.4%)

(2 books
required for
purchase)
EPY7090 Learning and
the Learner

Kruger

EPY8220 Advanced
Developmental
Psychology:
Personality and
Socialization

Kruger

EPY8960 Seminar in
Educational
Psychology

Anggoro

Awakening Children's Minds

Oxford

7 chapters, 320 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 250 pages)

1

181-199
200-219

Understanding Trauma:
Integrating Biological, Clinical and
Cultural Perspectives

Cambridge Interdisciplinary analysis of the
individual and collective
response to trauma.

1

224-241

(14 books
required for
purchase)

19

40

19

3

3.8%

9

14

(Plaintiffs
contend 3.9%)
14.5%

18

• No statutory presumption
(registration >5 years after
publication)

22

16

• No author assignment to either
Oxford or foreign publisher; use
wihtout these pages zero (0.0%)

2.4%

1

1

• No statutory presumption
(registration >5 years after
publication)

3.3%
(Plaintiffs
contend 3.7%)

21 chapters, 547 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 490 pages)

Language Acquisition and
Conceptual Development

Film Language: A Semiotics of the
Cinema (1974)

Cambridge 19 chapters, 614 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 588 pages)

Oxford

1

566-588

10 chapters, 282 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 252 pages)

1

108-148

Cambridge 15 chapters, 1231 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 986 pages)

1

272-300

Barker

HIST7010 Issues and
Interpretations
in American
History

12.2%
(Plaintiffs
contend 15.6%)

FILM4750 Film Theory
and Criticism
(1 book
required for
purchase)
HIST4820 Cross-Cultural
Encounters in
World History

39

Gainty

The Cambridge History of China,
Volume 8, Part 2

23

41
(for all 41of
these, no
(Plaintiffs
assignment) contend 16.2%)

29

(Plaintiffs
contend 2.9%)
Region, Race and Reconstruction

Davis

The Unpredictable Past:
Explorations in American Cultural
History

Oxford

Oxford

15 chapters, 500 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 450 pages)

14 chapters, 394 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 320 pages)

1

1

143-177

35-58

35

7.0%

17

12

24

(Plaintiffs
contend 7.8%)
6.1%

17

15

(Plaintiffs
contend 7.5%)

Page 6 of 8

Exhibit C: Plaintiff Works Alleged to be Infringed at GSU
Fall 2009

Course Title

Instructor

Title of Work

Publisher
Plaintiff

Total # of Pages and
Chapters in Work

(Books
Required for
Purchase)
JOUR4800 Media Ethics &
Society

Freeman

# of
Page Range
# of
Chapters of Alleged Pages Used
Allegedly
Use
Used

Living Ethics: Across Media
Platforms

Oxford

10 chapters, 365 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 305)

2

116-121
299-305

The Organ As a Mirror of Its Time:
North European Reflections 16102000

Oxford

25 chapters, 392 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 346 pages)

1

78-91

North German Church Music in the
Age of Buxtehude 1996

Oxford

Percent
Used

Class Size

Hit Count
Defendants' Other Challenges
(including
(in addition to Fair Use)
library staff
and counsel)

13
3.6%**
(6 of these
not
(Plaintiffs
protectable) contend 4.3%)**

19

5

• 6 pages not protectable as
containing images from
another's work; use without
permission at most 7 pages
(1.9%)

14
(5 of these
not
protectable)
18

3.6%**

18

12

(Plaintiffs
contend 4%)**
7.3%

18

10

• 5 pages not protectable as
statorily exempt material; use
without permission at most 9
pages (2.3%)
• Insufficient evidence foreign
work (no date)
• No statutory presumption
(foreign work)

(1 book
required for
purchase)

MUS8840 Baroque Music

Orr

9 chapters, 248 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 224 pages)

1

9-26

(Plaintiffs
contend 8%)
Handbook of Mixed Methods in
Social & Behavioral Research

SAGE

26 chapters, 784 pages (2002
edition)

1

541-556

16

2.0%

14

27

Crabgrass Frontier: The
Suburbanization of the United
States

NURS8035 Theoretical and
Philosophical
Foundations for
Nursing

Oxford

16 chapters, 405 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 306 pages)

1

246-271

26

6.4%

114

194

The Politics of Public Housing:
Black Women's Struggles Against
Urban Inequality

Oxford

33

(Plaintiffs
contend 8.5%)
10.8%

114

238

Contemporary Cases in U. S.
Foreign Policy: From Terrorism to
Trade

SAGE

U.S. Foreign Policy: The Paradox
of World Power

SAGE

Moloney

(3 books
required for
purchase)

PERS2001 Comparative
Culture

Lasner

POLS3450 U.S. Foreign
Policy
Hankla
(2 books
required for
purchase)

6 chapters, 306 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 244 pages)

1

21-53

(Plaintiffs
contend 13.5%)
15 chapters, 512 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 456 pages)

12 chapters, 564 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 400 pages)

1

1

89-121

153-188

33

6.4%

48

16

• No evidence license available

36

(Plaintiffs
contend 7.2%)
6.4%

48

18

• No evidence license available

(Plaintiffs
contend 9%)

Page 7 of 8

Exhibit C: Plaintiff Works Alleged to be Infringed at GSU
Fall 2009

Course Title

Instructor

Title of Work

Publisher
Plaintiff

Total # of Pages and
Chapters in Work

Oxford

9 chapters, 299 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 246 pages)

(Books
Required for
Purchase)
Regimes and Democracy in Latin
America: Theories and Methods

# of
Page Range
# of
Chapters of Alleged Pages Used
Allegedly
Use
Used
3

Percent
Used

Class Size

16.7%

12

20

• No contributing author
agreement for 12 pages (pp 3950); use without those pages at
most 38 pages (12.7%)
• Inadequate assignment to
Plaintiff Publisher
• No evidence license available
• No statutory presumption
(foreign work)

14

14

13

20

• No contributing author
agreement; use without those
pages zero (0.0%)
• No editor agreement
• No contributing author
agreement
• No contributing author
agreement for one of two
authors for page 27; use without
this page at most 22 pages
(7.5%)
• No statutory presumption
(registration >5 years after
publication)

16

14

1-24
25-38
39-50

38
(for 12 of
these, no
contributing
author
agreement)

1 (partial)

8-15
19-48

1

27
91-112

38
9.2%
(for all 38 of
these, no
(Plaintiffs
contributing contend 10.7%)
author
agreement)
23
7.8%
(for 1 of
these, only 1
(Plaintiffs
of 2
contend 10.5%)
contributing
author
agreements)

2

269-297
298-324

POLS8250 Latin American
Politics
McCoy

Hit Count
Defendants' Other Challenges
(including
(in addition to Fair Use)
library staff
and counsel)

(Plaintiffs
contend 20.4%)

(7 books
required to
purchase)

POLS8470 Military Conflict
and
International
Security

PSYC4030 Cross-Cultural
Psychology

Duffield

Behavior, Society, and Nuclear
War, Vol. 1

Whitten

A World of Babies: Imagined
Childcare Guides for Seven
Societies

Oxford

5 chapters, 413 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 354 pages)

Cambridge 8 chapters, 293 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 220 pages)

(1 book
required for
purchase)
The Power Elite

SOCI8030 Social Theory I
(2 books
required for
purchase)

Oxford

15 chapters, 448 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 362 pages)

56

(Plaintiffs
contend 15.5%)

Harvey

The SAGE Handbook of
Qualitative Research (2nd edition)

SW8200 Evaluation and
Technology

SAGE

36 chapters, 1142 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 1065
pages)

1

15 chapters, 447 pages
(Plaintiffs contend 386 pages)

2

803-820

18

1.6%

42

45

38

(Plaintiffs
contend 1.7%)
8.5
(Plaintiffs
contend 9.8%)

42

90

Ohmer
(2 books
required for
purchase)

12.5%

Utilization-Focused Evaluation:
The New Century Text
(3rd edition)

SAGE

1-38

** Pages alleged contain material clearly not protectable. See further explanation under Defendants' Other Challenges

Page 8 of 8

• No evidence license available
• No statutory presumption
(registration >5 years after
publication)