Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al

Filing 312

BRIEF by Amgen Inc. CLAIMS CONSTRUCTION BRIEF. (Attachments: #1 Appendix A#2 Appendix B(part 1 of 4)#3 Appendix B (Part 2 of 4)#4 Appendix B (part 3 of 4)#5 Appendix B (Part 4 of 4)#6 Exhibit 1#7 Exhibit 2#8 Exhibit 3#9 Exhibit 4#10 Exhibit 5#11 Exhibit 6 (Part 1 of 2)#12 Exhibit 6 (Part 2 of 2)#13 Exhibit 7#14 Exhibit 8#15 Exhibit 9 (Part 1 of 2)#16 Exhibit 9 (Part 2 of 2)#17 Exhibit 10#18 Exhibit 11 (Part 1 of 2)#19 Exhibit 11 (Part 2 of 2)#20 Exhibit 12#21 Exhibit 13#22 Exhibit 14 (Part 1 of 2)#23 Exhibit 14 (Part 2 of 2)#24 Exhibit 15#25 Exhibit 16#26 Exhibit 17#27 Exhibit 18#28 Exhibit 19 (Part 1 of 2)#29 Exhibit 19 (Part 2 of 2)#30 Exhibit 20#31 Exhibit 21#32 Exhibit 22#33 Exhibit 23#34 Exhibit 24#35 Exhibit 25#36 Exhibit 26)(Gottfried, Michael)

Download PDF

Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al Doc. 312 Att. 10 Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 Page 1 of 25 EXHIBIT 5 Dockets.Justia.com 37025900 CTI-� 604761076MA YGW-4180q79 152 �bihxE lairT ��OC 1TZB�HXE .T�UOC oT T�J�US LA� eil r �U � �EP FO ER�A�G,S � nif 61 �I DE�N o�'acihC 73606 sionillI ,ogaci� teartS ht85 tsaE 029 fo ytisrevinU ehT YLL�FER�C SHOITCURTSHI WOLLOF HOIT�CI.L�FPA THARG 5ECIVKE5 �/UH DNA HTL.�H ro THE�/�IA'IED Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 Page 2 of 25 47025900 CTI-MA 704761076MA REDE6[ViTCETORP T�O�OT TCEJBUS LAiTiiEGiFiiOG 913691 A � �AP � .st�bbar "�a" wtwts ,st� ,ec�m ,se� ,� fI �1/�Hnm,dI .DEVLOVNI SLAMINA YROTAROBAL .depoleved �res n� n� metsys a rof hcraes ot eunttno� llt� �H .denimreted eb 1� gn�ru dna .�no� o� dnuof n�te�oporht3re fo stnemgarf fo seitreporp lacigoloib dna ,.lacimehc ehT 3duts treht etardyhobrac dna nietorp eht fo htob ,erutcurts 3ramirp ni�e�oporht2re fo sa eunitnoc ]l�w e� ,sniamod tnereffid tsniaga de:cer�d seidobitna gnidnif �o snaemehta no samod��byh tne�efftd'.erape�p ot nalp eH .ydobitna ,�anolconom depoleved y�we� desab yhparqotmorhc ,ytiniffa fo esu eht hti� devorp�t eb ]]iw sdoh,smp noitacif .n�te�opo�ht�re ,enomroh n|etorpocylg eht fo yduts eunitnoc ot esopor eH devorpm.l eb osla nA �iw ,ydobitna �ano]conom eh� �o esu eht nO desab ,yassaonummioida� fo� eht yduts ot hcihw .noitaluger stI dna n�tetopo�h�yre -iruP 73606 sionillI �ogacihC �eunevA stllE .S 1085 ,ogacihC fo yttscevinU ehT J| ��p .01 awh ,�$( NOITAZIHAGRO TNACILPPA FO SSERDDA DHA E�kAN NALP HCRAESER FO TCARTSBA REBMUN TCEJORP KNALB EVAEL SECIVRES NAMUH DNA HTLAEH FO TNEMTRAPED Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 Page 3 of 25 57025900 CTI-MA 804761076MA LAIT�iDIFNOC �3�IA REDRO EVITOETORf ffigOC OT TGEN11$ LAITNEDIFNOC dekcehc si ,1 egap ,4 metI fi 695 SHH mroF 0383 SHP �rof ,droceR tpieceR noitacilppA :)tsil( rebmuN :s�ita=ilbup �ti �htO le e�muN )xi�e� rof �ossec� gnir�n egap aH( )s�es xiS( xtd�pA .3 NOITCES ........................................................................ tsilkce� .......................................................... �fiC erutaretiL .I st�meer� e�ter�=ll� �zii�oF ro stnemegnarrA mui�os� .H ......................................................... st�lusn� .G .......................................................... �lominA yro�er�aL .F ................................ ataD ro sioiret� �vireD ,stcejbuS namuH .E .................................................... danoM .D )segap thgie d�cxe ot �( seidNS �animiler�tfopeR sserg�P -C ..................... eerht deecxe ot toN( ecnacifingiS .B �ecxe ot toH( smiA cif;cop� .A -21. .... . ................................. )seg� )egap �o nalP hcraeseR .2 NOITCES )snoifaci|ppa �atnemelppus dna desiver ;s.egap s�ec:�( noitcudortnI _�1'-_" .�-.7_ 4 ....................... tnemnorivnE �cna secruoseR ..................................................................... .opp.s :otto rehtO ......................... )hcae rof segap owt deecxe ot taN( sehctekS l"cihporgoiB }seg�p owt deecxe ot toN( rotceriD mergorP",rotagitsevnI lopicnirP.hctukS lacihpargoiB ............................................ troppuS fo sraeY llA r�f setamitsE tegduB htnoM 21 tsriF rof tegduB deliateD stnetnoC fo elbaT ,tcartsbA ,egaP ecaF ................................... doireP ................................. �egduB egap sa .I NOITCES SREBUUN EGAP ..egap noffounitnoc hcae dna o eman eht epyT..%- ,05 ni l detnirp hcae fo p�lf eht ta rotceriD margorP/rotagitsevmottobapdentirtPa eyhltevfitucesnoc segap rebmuN h hcus sexiffus esu ton oD .noi|acilppa eht tuohguorht STNETNOC FO ELBAT elrSq.U'� :ROTCERID MARGORP/ROTAGI'I'$EvNI LAPICNIRP Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 Page 4 of 25 67025900 CTI-MA 904761076MA LAITNEDIFNOC LAIr�IBDql�OC 123691 A � �EG*p �)B �I ,| "9*� �:n� 04L �1I �Af STSOC TCER;D .lATOT 0051$ ,stcartnoc ecn�no�n�I �/r�'lkez/�m� SESNEPXE REHTO $T10� YTRAPORIHT LAUI'CARTHOC 0. Jqe�etec ,�i *�/n�l( SNOITAVONER TNEITAPTUO DKA SHOITARETLA LEVART -sid ;008$ .003$ ,C-G rof sag ytirup p elire erutl $ hgih ;3(05$ ,A nietorp dna sei�bltnaald;�0n041erut,leurcaw ;00S1$ uc,),1521 ts,H3elb,aCso( 41 ,n�kres flac latef ;007$ , sepotosI ;004$ ,stnegaer edarg la"ttceps ;0�3$ ,namrab dna snmuloc CLPH STSOc ['NATLU�I�OC TROFFE/EUIT )sne�cuwsn/le$'I )y/no n�/�n=in�* tnee//�.A( LEHNOSREP YLHO STSOC TCERID DOIREP TEGDUB HTN)�/21 TSRIF ROF TEGDUB DELIATED Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 Page 5 of 25 77025900 CTI-MA 014761076MA IUDR)I EYIi�.FIOSF Ttlg0� OT-TCEJBJlS mA!T En_!FH _nC � �3�1 A .sno�cirts� on ni tn�ehni ytilibixelf eht evah o� elbaref ,ere� taht e -erp dluo� t� �ub ,yroget� detcirtser a n� ,est�eh�o .etauqedani eslb�sl�vo� eldm � u � b� ere� sdnuf esuaceb ss�gorp �g ek�o� degan�evah eH er�c t�erg h[� neve taht rae�c et�uq Lnuoma eht ,serutidnepxe gnitaluger n� sag dn� yhp�rg � sekm sraey o� tsap eht revo ecneire�e ruO .yhp�rg�t�rhc esu ot elba gnieb ton yb -ot�hc ytiniffa ,CLPH sa hcus sd�m �a-eh�-fo-et�s o� eht dna a dede�t �]alretm eb dluo� ytivitca s� �o �cepsao �r c�n�lch dna s �golop b n o � n�te�oporhtyre ro seitreporp larutcurts eh� �nnu� Kr]� tnuOlppuscraef ertse�rer methToc �o uq s� ro a� �soc desa�cnt yltaerg eht W elb�f�su� s� .ssergorp n� hcraeser e� ot l�t�v �eb s� hcus,secruos ]a�cr�c �rf elbaliava ev,h hc�hw,sutarapp� s�serohpor�celeorcim �b derevoc �on me� yrot�r�l �o noitcurtsnoc )� dn� stcartnoc ecnane�n�m eht esuaceb ecna�tn�m dna ri�p� )a n� devlovn� s� �hs en�hcm nt dedulcn� era �t s'rengised tns�rtsn� n� �o sruoh 5.Z ehT �on t�e�p s�h� �n�p�uqe �o !1� roF .�;�ne� d� len�.ep *� � s�c�| eilic� e� �A.e� ylfe�G :�ra�e��fi $�ap nOlmu�tnm esU( NOITACIF �SUJ 978,83 s 1> DOIREP TCEJORP DESOPORP ERITatE ROF LATOT' 697,41$ �IR_ 1 i54,31 � STSOC TCERID LATOT SESNEPXE REHTO DRIHT RO STSOC YTRAP L�UTCARINOC DNA SHOITAR ETLA SNOITAVONER TNEITAPTUO TNEITAPNI NGIEROF STSOC ERAC TN..F ITAP LEVAR�' CITSEMOD 604�01 06419 006,8 $EILPPU� TNEMPIUQE 5T50� THAT.IUSHOC 575;2 ,, IDETSEUQER TROPPUS SRAEY LANOITIDDA 143,2 $ 235 $ no;mzina9,o �i�Af yre�a$� LENNOSREP SLATOT DOIREP TEGDUB ts YROGETAC TEGDUB D'(�EUQER �na�n.-� YLHO STSOC TCERID TROPPUS FO SRAEY LLA ROF SETAMITSE TEGDUB 'ROTCERID �1z�':� MARGORP:ROTAGITSEVNI .,IAPaHIRP Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 Page 6 of 25 87025900 CTI-MA 114761076MA �4LTNZI�I'n�OC 323691 A EIIIOE"iORP TRUOC OT TCEJBUS LAITNEDIFNOC 0 .ksir detaluclac a sI siht ;CLPH eht ro hpargot=rhc sag eht no stcartnoc ecnanet evah ton od ew esnepx� evissecxe eht fo esuaceB .gniog noitarepo eht peek "pleh s�d hci�acnBnetnim evitneverp edulcni )tnarg rehtona yb rof diap osla{ stcartnoc ese� .kro� r� edepmi dI�w emitn�d dna esu tnatsnoc ni tne�iuB fo "stI era esehT .seguflrtnec deeps-hgih eht dna retnuoc noitallitnics diuqil e� ,sretnuoc �'eht rof �a stcartnoc ecnanetni� lacitirc tsom ehT .noltar�po ni stn�rtsnI detacitsihpos gnipeek ot detti=c yda�la taht tnalppus ot dednetni si.hci�stcartnoc e�anetnim rof )0OS1$( tnu�a tsedum a dedulcpi evah I .dev]ovn� �.�.P .r�e� re� �0] �bdes�ercn� er� tsoC .desu fe troffe tnecre� n� e�n�hc o� s� raey �uf eht �t retfA .r�e� ts] eht n� 389� enu� o� 389� lirpA 1 eht rof detaluclac era rengised tnemurtsni eht rof segaw ehT * �shtnom3 eneguE ,ressaxdloG Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 Page 7 of 25 97025900 CTI-MA 214761076MA 423691 A EGAP �;',0I .metI |�sHr LAITHEDiFNGG .syend� �on �z� �Ce�opo:�e �o n�cca� .E ,�essavdloG dna ,.5.3 ,�o�S lsb .)7791( �37 :�91 ec�cS .sllec �rra: �b � roCca� �Cudnu�c.� yCnloc �V nlCelo�:�e fo s�cz� su�clu�s � .E ,ressav�loG a , , aZ dna .)7791( I�2 :09 .1olsyhP 11� .3 .�1zc S�o�-ynoloc .nolCs:cnere�1d decud�-�e�oporhc�e .co�..de� .�1ec �olb �o �1�hc� eht � .� ,�ess�dloC dna ,.L.D ,d�adeD .E � �o �a�cne:e[� eht d� �C�opo�hc�E ,ressawdloG .)A791( 993 :�5 .n�-.s� .�hpo�3 .�hco� .s�ec �: enob ce: no n�eco�p � .s�sehc� or�v n� � �aelcun decudnI S=�Ca� �eCo:p ci�alpocyc ,ressa�o� A .'�T� dna ,.S,C ,C� �c �Cs c�C�o�a �o ecnegs�s�ep e� .B )�e�sa�dZoG � ,.R .sc�e� :)76�1 ec�s sapap �0Z �:� de�ce�S� :sno�CacLlbu� cnese�p 3691 � 26�" 36� o�c� �o yC�srev�nY o�c� fo yC$s�evinU ,��o� fo ros�foz� :�c�hcot� �o rosse�or� �aScos� wts�mehcoi� 0591 ,�acihC ,ognclhC fo vr�simehco�B YDUTS FO DLEIF 36�I DERREFHOC RAEY .D.hP .B.S LZ LI �osaclhC,o�ac�hC NOITACOL DNA fo �c�..scev�nU ehT 7c�srevlnU eh� HOITUTITSHI �o :�sse�rP � si� �ocotohP .reteiD detsil mar�r�0gitsevni lennOsr�p !�no�sse�mp yek rof HCTEKS LACIKPARGOIB Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 Page 8 of 25 Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 Page 9 of 25 08025900 CTI-MA 314761076MA 18025900 CTI-MA 414761076MA 62369] �oloiB lleC elkciS no tcejorp �rg�P :dennalp noitacilppA .3 .�/03/60 ot �/10170 launna ,sisenegoiB oc ,troppus fo doirep ,320,461$ ,38/03/60 ot 28/10/70 2 CsLH'Htcerid :gnidnep noitacilppA .2 IN ,seitreporP ,noitacifiruP ,niteioporht�E ,60-6761 .seneg nibolg esu� fo noisserpxe cificeps ot ,niteiopor�e yb d�udnt noit e� ot dna si�htnys �h fo noitaluger eht .rD rof si Lnu�a -pircsnart fo ydu�s.ot detoved st tcejorp si� .)bal4 ossorG t n s tsoc tcerid B$ siht fo flah-eno yletmix�ppa{ 427,9en ,38/13/P 0,,orti28/1t0/50 lseiop�yre E ss l launna ,ssorG .H & )%01( re:nawdB oG .E.eguI.P .I,.38/13/30v ot 47/10/40 doirep J. �o fo seiduts ;tcejorpbuS �narG :HIN tceJ�p ,�raes� lleC elkciS ro� retneC evisn�er�C ,50061 � .sllec eht o� neelab spihsnoitaler eht dna ntteiop�h�re fo �olotb llec,�1,57$ oppu fo doirep 87/1 7 detoved st t�orp sihT .38/03/50 d ot launna 01,0 %0tr('res sa�loG eneguE .I.P )2 s �/03/� ot 18/10/70 stsoc tceri ,�ttattnereffiD decudnI dna slleC metS ctteiopomeH 57381 AC �narG :HIN �op er tnadnet .6761� LH ot �it reh �o %�1 seto�ed ehS ot .77/1pus 0 hcraesus fo doirep 0/7 tropp .58/�/60 -ni yna evah ton s�d gnaW .F .F .rD /70 tso � ,n Ia nn p ,)% re 7612 en�uE .I.P ,157,351$ ,28J�/60-18110,noitascifc ruPerid iteuioa �yrE 51(50-s6sa�loGLH tnarG :HIN .l i ,sisenegoiB ,seitreporP :RO�ERID mets tn�opirulp dna sllec evisnops�-nttelop :TROPPUS EVITCA )1( �R�OTAGITSEVHI �PICHIRP d� � dna Ciflt�ics e� {o t� dna erutan yenhat et�nlJed �i .sei�n� m s�lr�o fI �tsil ma ro ,ylrevo ese� fo ei yfitsuj �itacllppa teserp e� yb detne�ipp�strsoac �a]p� lgni� e� �ige�d� lp�ej�bus e� �no tnarg tnm� e� � tc �id ou�a �i�s� ylfeirB ).� r� eritne dna ,�s� �id i�na ,deman lanoisseforp � fo seltit e� �mp ,�j� r�ra) � fo �ap fI( ,n�p� fo doiw o eman t tceimp ,rebmun 9 ni�itnedi tce�p e� � �e fo tnecMp ro �it ,�id �gmP/rotogifsovni lop�n;� f� �eltitg i�noit�ifsni d� ,la�deF �Po � ,�us ta ecr�s e� �ig m�i � raF ".EH�" �s ,e�n {I .�s n� � gn]� ro den�ip snoifacilp� )3[ ;gnldn� r� weiv� gnid�F edulcnI .no�sslmbus r� � �s evitca )1( :s� �es � ni ,tsli ,2 � � de=n sla�isse�mp � fo )Y�ECEH FI SEGAP HOITAUHITH� E�U( TROPPUS RE�O Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 Page 10 of 25 28025900 CTI-MA 514761076MA LAITNEDRI'ROC 723�91 A 1'1 E�AP B93-SH�I L%111 tEDI.FilOC .noitaclfitsu� tegdub deton sa �cnujda tna�o�i yfitnali ��ulmp na st pohs enthcm eht ;bal gn�|rcsed nolfam�ni �o eht nihtiw ecivres yna udlv�P eht ni lairaterceS seti�es troppus e� r� tnemnorivne u� :NOITAMROFNI LANOITIDDA .bal eht nihtiw lla sretnuoc ,srotinom tnentlrep dne era sretemotohpor�ceps saG dna ,segufirtnec ,srotabucni ,sdooh erutluc ,hpargotamorhc tsom ,CLPH �noltncoI u� gniton ,tcejorp sl� r� u|believe ydoerlo smeti tnempiuqe tnetopmi ,hr tsiL �cae |n $eiti|ibc�c �TNEMPIUQE ROJAM re�ItO I--[ .. .-yraterces eht dna .I.P eht rof seciffo'etarapes era erehT :retupmoC ]:I .sesoprup niatniam ot dna slamina bal lla esuoh ot desu si latnemirepxe rof etats yhtlaeh a ni meht ytilicaF hcraeseR laminA noslraC homi.A ][ :�oc�,�c .gnitset lacinilc rehtruf nac tI .elbaliava edam eb nac yna rof desu eb retneC hcraeseR lacinilc eht,dedeen neh�I ][ ][ dedeen dna ,sbal erutluc gnidulcnilgnitarepo /�11Uf :�f .qs 005] .XO�ppA� eht n; tnempiuqe :yrotOrob�..[ .,NALP HCRAESER lfnil�n; ee�u� ed;v�p dna snoittz;na�ra TNEMNORIVHE DNA SECRUOSER ,ressewdloG �l�egUE Page 11 of 25 �RO ,T'CERID MAROORP/ROTAOITSE',HI LAPICtIIRP Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 38025900 CTI-MA 614761076MA .noitaraperp nI .ytivitca rof FSC �raniru �97gl( na�h fo yteiom etardyhobrac eht fo ecnavelerrI .E ressa�loG dna CFF gnaW .5 .)noitaraperp ni( FSC �antru n�H fo noitacifiruP .E ressawdloG dna CFF gnaW .4 .evitavired deta]ysocylged yIevisn�xe na dna es�elcunobi�nicrop ni �itarti� noi + H enidttsIH fo � ,H� stiH dna ,CFF gna� .3 zHM 022 �b nosirapac A .OgOl ,452 �hC �ofB J .nietorp eht fo �tilibats dna noit�ofnoc eht no�elcunobir citaercnap enicrop ni sedirahccas -oreteH eht fo ecn�u�n�,8538 ,252 mehC loiB J )7791( ,WHC sreH dna ,CFF gnaW .� loca�ahP meh�B )6791( .FF trehC dna R ,okasurteiP .1 :snottacHbuP .1272 ,52 .tsitneicS hcraes� roinuO :)87-7791( retneC lacideM lanoitaN �oH ytiC rotcaf gnitalumits �noloc yraniru larotcod tsoP :)�9�-g791( ogacihC fo ytisreyinU n�h fo noitacift�p nitcenorbif fo setats ecneu�s nietorP .2 nitcenorbif h�iw stnegreted �o noitcaretnI .� tsitneicS hcraeseR roinuJ ,)8791-77g�( retneC lacideM epoH fo �tiC rotcaf gnitalumits ynoloc �aniru nmuh fo noitacifiruP eeniarT larotcoD tsoP ,)0891-9791( ogacihC fo .vinU niteioporhtyre fo seiduts larutcurtS .2 rotcaf gnItal�its ynoloC fo sei�tS lanoitcnuF dna �arutcurtS .1 etaicossA hcraeseR ,)tneserP-lB9]( ogacihC fo .vinU :ecneirepxE lanoisseforP ,eeniart 77.3791 vrf��m�hroiB .m�hC n.hP � R anaidnI 37�]791 "0791 �*� sreatuR larutlucirqA �F yti�e�inU vt isrwinU ),v�n�( naw�aT ]anoi�aN �s �o 84/50/50 etaicossA h�aeseR �e rof egap sik� gnaW ,gnaF-gnuF ypoc�ohP .ro�;O margorP/rotagitsevnI lopicnlrP HCTEKS L�CIHPARGO!B ressawdloG enequE :ROTCERID MARGORP/RO']�GITSEvNI LAPICNIRP Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 Page 12 of 25 48025900 CTI -MA 714761076MA �LTNE�/FN� esae]cunobtr--�nicrop ,�c .� � .�c :,'.. .noitaraperp nI .ytivitca rof FSC yraniru namuh fo ytei.om etardyhobrac eht fo ecnavelerr� .E ressawdloE dna CFF gna� ressawdl d F W .)noitaraperp ni( FSC yrdntru namuH fo noitacifiruP ..Eevitavired o�detnaalysCoFcylggnead ni noitartit noi H enidYtsIH fq R�t 3levtsnetxe na dna zHMOZ2 �b nosirapmoc A .0901 ,452 meht loiB J )gTgI{ ,HHC�srtH dna ,CF� gna� .nietorp eht fo ytilibats dna noitamrofnoc e�t no�-aelcunobir citaercnap enicrop ni sedirahccas -otereH eht fo ecndulfnI ,8538 ,252 mehC1oiB � )7791( ,WHC stiH dna ,CFF gna� .FF nehC dna R ,okasur�eiP .1272 ,52 loc�rahP mehcofB )6791( :sno�taci]buP retneC ]acldeM �anoltaN �o� .�sltnei�S hcraes� roinuO ;)87-7791( �;iC rot�f gnital�its ynoloc �aniru ogaci fo noitacifirup ,eeniart larotcod tsoP :)08gl-g791(ecneuqes hC fo �ttsreTinB ". nitcen�bif fo seiduts n�et�P .Z ni��enorbif htiw stnegreted Fo noitcaretnI- .I tsitneicS �raeseR roinuJ ,)8791-779i( retneC lacid� epoH fo �tiC rotcaf.gnital�its �noloc �aniru n�uh fo noitaclfir�P eeniarT larotcoD tsoP ,}0B91-9791( ogacihC fo .vin� nlteloporht�re fo seiduts ]arut��tS .� rotcaf gnI�al�i�s ynoloC fo sei�tS lanoitcnuF dna larutcurtS .I hcraeseR ,)�neserP-IBg]( ogacihC fo .vin� :ecneirepxE. lanois�f�P etaicossA _muhC larutlucirqA 0791 DERREFNOC RAEY SR EERGED ),vinU( nawiaT lanoitaN YDU�S FQ DLESF HOII'AGOL DNA NOITUTITSNI 84/50/50 .n�rep etai�ssA hcraes� � rof egap siht egap no gnaU ,gnaF-gnuF e�t �iG gni�;gcb ,2 de�si[ ypoc�t�P .rotc�;D �=rgorP/r�agifscvnI lap;tnirP le�sr� lano;ssefmp �ek ro( no�a�o[ni gn�wol�o( Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 Page 13 of 25 58025900 CTI-MA 814761076MA .LAITNE.DLFNOC 21 tnednepedni 0 0 obr c -orp eht fo �us eht yb dnuof taht h�l� tnemeerga ri.stneitnohcihetardyh3-� ac dna niet af S � 0004 ni stluser sihT .detaluclac eb nac 76.0+ fo eulav a tnetnoc etardyhobrac eht rof eulav. evitatnet" a gnisu dna emulov clficeps laitrap eht no tnedneped si n dna s�04 fo devired � fo eulav ehT .K 93 fo eulav eht detpecca yllanoisivorp e- )egnar morf wor -ran rehtar a revo{ noitartnecnoc leg fo eb ot demees siserohportcele yb �ulav eht ecniS .lonahteotpacrem dna etafluslycedod �o ecneserp eht ni slserohport -cele leg yb dnuof taht htiw deerga M rof eulav sihT .A �.23 fo )�( suidar 'sekotS a dna S 3 fo )s(tneiclffeoc noitatnemides a no desab saw ,00Og3 ,eulav detroper yl -suoiverp ehT .epa fo thgiew ralucelom eht detagitsevnier e� ,seuqinhcet yb dnuof nietorp dna etardyhobrac fo stnuoma eht ni seicnapercsid fo esulaacceiBtylana .tuo delur neeb tey ton evah noit -adi�a no desab secnereffid hguohtla ,lacitnedi eb yam owt eht fo snoitrop nietorp eht taht stseggus sihT .smrof. owt eht rof lacitnedi era seudiser 72 txen eht fo secneuqes eht taht dna ,�nlnala ,eudiser lanimret N elgnis a evah epa � dna : htob taht dnif e� �ereht.depoleved dohtem gnicneuqes etats-dilos-orcim eht gnisu epa smrof � dna � eht htob fo ecneuqes dica onima eht fo yduts eht detrats evah e� )ygol -onhceT fd etutitsnI ainrofilaC{ dooH yoreL .rD htiw noitaroballoc nI .eno dilav a sa, ,siserohportcele leg dna yhpargotamorhc no desab ,ytirup fo noitpmussa eht taht wonk won ew epa fo yrtsimehc eht ottcepser hti� .laitnatsbus ,weiv ym ni ,neeb sah ssergorp deweiver tsal saw tcejorp siht ecnis sraey eerht eht ni :troper ssergorP erehT .)23{ evitca yllacigo�olb s� taht epa htiw xal),noc a dennaf ,epa-itna gnizilartuen a morf devired a na taht dewohs yeloohcS .)13,03( sllec romut gnicudorp epa no otwnemgnarf-))'ba(F td deraeppa evah etats edurc eht ni epa fo seitreporp lacimehc mnos no srepap tr,o)h9s2-8o2�( T .)7�,32{ detroper epa gniyfirup rof seuqinhcet ot snoitidda tnatropmi lareves neeb evah erehT .)22{ gnitnaw eb ot rettal eht dewohs dohtem noltibihni-noitanitulggameh eht dna yassaoib eht neewteb noslrapmoc'A .)12-71{ sdohtem'yassaoib �nisu trap tsom eht rof ,setats �saesld ni ope gnitalucric fo seiduts lareves neeb osla evah 36gI ni bal siht ni ed� snoitavresbo lanigiro eht no desab yllareneg derutluc yb epa rof syassa fo stroper lareves neeb evah erehT ,)�l-Ol( sllec .)61( .gnizilartuen eb bt raeppa srehto eht ,gnI(ila�tuen-non si seidobitna eseht fo enO .)9,8{ seirotarobal owt morf detroper saw ope-ltna lanolconom a smrof taht amodirbyh a gnipoleved ni sseccuS .)7,3{ seirotarobal owt ni nwohs neeb sah esaesid laner cinorhc htiw stneitap fo eres ni ,ytivitca lacigoloib tuohti, ylbamuserp ,epa fo stnemgarf evltcaeronunTnI fo ecnetsixe ehT .)6{ aimehtycylop yradnoces dna yramirp nee,teb gnihsiugnitsid'fo snaem a edivorp ot nwohs neeb sah dna )S{ epa fo retit mures l�on eht fo noitanimreted eht dettimrep sah AIR eht yllanoitiddA .)4,2{ .syassaoib evitisnes ssel dna emosrebmuc eroc yb denimrete� sa epa fo )goloisyhp cisab eht dennif -noc ylegral evah AIR eht htiw stluser ehT .snoltutitsni rehto eerht ni sisab enituor ylriaf a no gnitarepo �on si dna )3,2{ elbissop edam saw )AIR( yassaonummioidar ,yrot deilppu� ).l( ,epa erup fo esu eht htI� .dleif siht ni ni ssergorp laitnatsbus neeb sah e'ieht tnarg siht fo lawener evitite�oc tsal eht ecniS :,eiveR :erohal siht morf .seitivitca lacigolonunnI dna lacigoloib fo seiduts lanoitidda rof ,llew sa ,�eht esu dna etats erup ni �eht etalosi ot elbissop ti sekam eniru dna �ures ni epa fo stnemgarf evltcaeronunel gnirrucco yllarutan fo ecnetsixe ehT .detcerid eb y� seidobitna eht hcihw tsniaga sniamod tnereffid gniyduts fo tnetni eK-� htiw epa ot seidobitna lanolconom lanoitidda poleved ot yrt lliw ew ,noitidda nI .aviv ni seitreporp lacigoloisyhp dna ycaciffe lacinilc sti fo yduts eht eunitnoc )d dna'ope fo ytivitca lacigoloib eht rof stnemeriuqer larutcurts eht yduts )c ,noitarapes rieht rof sdohte� evah e� ecno sniahc edtrahccasogtlo eht ni sragus eht fo ecneuqes eht gninimreted fo dohtem cimyzne na no trats )b ,niahc editpepylop eht fo erutcurts yramirp eht fo noitanimreted eht )ope( niteioporhtyre namuh erup hguone eraperp ot nalp eH :evitcejbO hsinif )a :ot �G�-41-eq4 eneguE ,ressaw�loG Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 Page 14 of 25 68025900 CTI-MA 914761076MA ecim edun diulf seticsa ton seod y�bltna etal�cca ot nugeb evah-eM .ytivitca lacigoloib eht ezilartuen olc s hT ib gnitluser e� ;ope-lSZ� gnisu yassa gnidn� a yb enod saw genMine�cpe-ietna .ean�1c .o l elbats.eno dnuof � erofeb sadirgbnyihpolesu�-tnar dedeecctuusobaevadheneeewr"c,sdetacidni tsuj sA eved i -on� s�of taht �dirbyh .nidive dele�a]-niecserou� dna �e-itna lano1�n� del�al-nltoib gnisu si tI sa evitavir� ope n�nknu eht gnisu �as eht s�,%4.1 tuoba )�r� ni sllec eseht fo �cn�qerf � ,raelc 11a ta ton si �utan ehT .sll� evis�pser ope ydu�s ot tI desu evah ope e �on i lacime� sti hguo� neve dna ,d�ssa �srlf �rehteoiaht dna tnhtcseroulsf stIcudtorp aht e sh eht taht tcaf eht etipseD .ytivitca lacigoloib lluf n ,oc-4-o ,s a ht hT evitavired a etareneg ot �e htiw stca� edlmiel�-)lynair�reve�h nimawlyere�id-�( .tnegaer HS tnecserou� ehT .delaev�r xodarap gnitseretni .elituf erew ruo tah tnerappa ekm sgni e seudiser enletsy� eht �iv ls� htiw lebal ot owst�ta��a gnitseggt s ,ytivitcati laci�loib t u ht -dnif esehT .de�iu�r era s�ob ediflusid stcae� ti snoitidnoc fo dioved si ope detalykla-S ehT .)el�/sel� 4( �N htiw ot elbissecca ton era hcus r�nU .decuder dna dRutaned si ope sselnu tnegaer eht saw spuo�g HS eht taht wohs �lraelc �n atad tnecer Rom r� .dn�b yltnelavoc ton eht ;lautcafitra saw ,sra�pa �n tI ,noitavres� sihT .ytivitca lacigoloib ot ope htiw stcaR )MEH( edimiel�lyhte-N fo ssol tuohtiw el�/selom 3 fo dnetxe eht gnidnib rof esu ot ytivit .)seid taht gnidnif ruo saw stnmirepxe ruo rof sisab ehTna sdleiy uts � elblsaef s� etardyhobrac d -ca cificeps �1 �t fo tub evitavired evitca .tnega� elbatanidoi na htiw noitalalykla rof ytila eht � ope fo noitaitirt ehT( eh esu ot gniritta neeb evah ew ,ytivitca -noitcnuf a sa ope fo spuorg lyrdyhflusspuot g � onima eerf e� no seudis� enisoryt eht lacigoloib sti fo noitavitcani desuac htiw ope gnilebal La� dnuof ew ecnis ,�aey weefnegtsaop e eht t �evO P eh gni�olc .e� elbisaef a sllec lairetcab yb sisehtnys sti gnisserpxe dna ovlv nI rof deriGqer eb �hg� la fo laog egnar regnol ruo ekm osla yehThtlw".opevivrus" oitcareCnI fo n eh��d�iuqe� ton hgooht neve ,sllec te�at s�i etard�obrac eht taht�o�s ,tseggus sgnidnif es�T .'yassa ovlv ni eht enod sa ,opeocylga e� yb deniater saw tey ton evah eW .doht� ortiv ni eh� yb d�usa� e ot dehcatt� eni�soculg ol . e �08 �uo�a fo tnetxe eht ot ,ytivitca leacig;deoiB.r nisato�ptarhtyhobrac eht fo %OB yletm we d vome -lyteca-� gnieb ragus gnini�r ylno ht dexim fo --ixorppa ,sesac htob nI .)lliH .R .rO yb dedivorp ylsuorene�( sesadisocylg i i y noitarap�p a fo esu yb dna FH suordo hnas�nhtenodirydpesuhtiewvahsisylo,vnlooistidd:nineItorpoc � a �� etardyhobrac gniv�er f fo laenotirep eht �rf GgI ope-ltna la�lcon� deifir� -ylg eht �rf 0 � :�.. 8.51 8.II 7.0 8.6 0 5.11 I.B 7.0 1.7 1.01 8.3 eni�sotcalaglyteca-N dicA cllaiS enimasoculglyteca-� 7.II 3.T FO �ITISOP�C EDIRAHCCASONOM esoculG esonn� esotcalaG esocuF )el�/seudiser{NI�IOP�H�RE tceps .eni�soculglyteca-� dna dica �cileais foot noitiser op ht htiw yltnereffid yltnacifingis eb ot�ht dnuof dna �of B dna evitatitnauq -�c etardyho�ac eht denimeted evah ew ,elo� ] tuoba fo noitanimeted rof noita fi vir ti�ep ot ,sedirahccason� eht fo sevitan�d edgnillytecaoBroul.snritahcfo edirahcnciacared o fo sogil acs y �ht� cihpargorihc diuqil-sag eht evah tub ,ope fo f esu � ,te re�n eht dehsilbatse ,lairetam fo htraed eht �o e�o�acelbamoy aet�on ea� erab eW � etardyhobrac eh� fo Y�:� ruo n� $ �.��5 loico5 �ml�i !s� ,llOL( �odiJ;moC � rolo�id'�oC motgo�/DP/� � Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 Page 15 of 25 78025900 CTI-MA 024761076MA 23)�91� E�iO�lORP TBU� OT T�US 41 -�e �res n�h ressawdloG evitcaeron�i fo ytienegoreteh ehT ressawdloG E a fo noitaziretcarahC .noitcudorp niteioporhtyre su.otua E dna doo�ehS BJ .niteioporh�re detelbuS yd�ftna lanolconom gnirud �dA WJ dna ressawdl� E ,renga� � ,t�ohletsiD� tnani�d l�sotuA decudni ni�eioporhtyre J .no it eff 27621-66621 .� �hC lolB noit�ofitahT nerresid �loG E dna gnoT DB sa e � -nttetoporhtyre n�h ot dna yksnivaK JC .ssieW LI ot eud sisotycorht�e lailimaf s�)�p enar�etycorh�re ,res.�loG ralulleC fo lortnoC nI noltai+n�=,,,, ,nostaW D pp E ,mah gninnuC D .sdE 494-784 ..u� d� dna niteioporntyrE �,))SgI� l)-21)�a �ehc�iB .sstL RAf ,xoF FC 1891 �n�olev� dna noiisviD ressa�loG E .nlteloporh � re .'� noitartnecnoc nI .ope �._� h w stneitap n�h eerf-nixotodne fo sei+ )1891( ,74-44 ,� daM tnI rn�sAsawdlaoiGmehE �dcnylop eltfife�H ar e gnitaulave ni �assanumioidar niteioporhtyrE Oll1-60ll ,65 doolB no niteioporhtyre dna )APB( ytivitca gnitarp .�utluc ni sisehtnysoib nibo1�h edloG WD ,re�oP NP ,awa� M ,awasareT T -t�ub fo tceffE ressawdloG E dna A ressawdloG E dna doo�ehS BJ doolB .nitelopor�Qe rof yassaon�ioidar )gTgI( g14-5B04 .,a6icrsalGleCFJ doolB do�ehS J :snoitacilbuP .niteiop�htyre f6 Yassaonu�ioidaR ress�loG � dna ,stinu uqi 71 f .noitubirtsid rof ,stineuht �stropo usstosla ladnani "I�JU 01 po na�h fo h�r9 066,503 d�ivorp evah eH .stsrubWOtibthni-non si t� .ytivitca 9nito�rp-t�ub ot pu s�utluc tsrub esu�rof fo deerf neeb sah tub nietorp fo �/7U a ybdetacolla eb ot laiv/U 5 dna ntxotodne ,rotcaf 9nital�its-ynoloc c eh .eetti�ocbus �11 ylno si noitaraperp � dnoa esnietT rp �/stinu 0�,07 ta mof o erup si ,seso�up o ot �ilppus evah slaiv 59 nevig evah .opedn fo sehctab �t ,noi�ubirLs�d rof HIsNuaceb ,yltsaL e AIR rof ,tsrif ehT �aes� rof la�retam rof deen t�er9 eht fo ew ,dleif siht nt .ai�na citsalpa eviLceeron�i llms rof ecnedive dnuof osla g htiw stneitap �f eniru ni stn�k arf desael� si tcudorp nwodkaerb eht dna deraelc evah e� .noitalucric .eht otni ae cab laner cinorhc htiw stneitap ni ,ope taht etac ti retfa n�d nekorb si ,es57 siddna evitan %52 tuoba saw ereht evruc eht fo �ap -idni atad esehT .stn�er� �g%a�f llms sa �52 dna ope dezis-evitan �57 tuoba s�k esir yradnoces e� nI ;stn ecnaraeppasid dipar eht n� taht deohs lairet e�uc ecnaraelc eht fo esahp eht fo sisylanA .de�duts stneitap eeht -m evttcaeron�i eht fo. ezis ralucelm ol ,noitalu�ic eht �rf rettt A�R fo9nss,llodipanr i ri lla ni ,esir yradnoces ayb de�llof otni detcejni ope fo ecnaraelc e�evitcaeronu�i si erehT .sisylaid no stneitap naht rella� "stn�garf" ycnap�cstd eht noitautis ralimisa dnif eE .C-�rhcotyc eh a AIR eh� ,eewteb retlt ope ni �o ecneserp eht si yassaoib eht t ,dnsaesid laner cinorhc htiw stneitap �rf aras ni e u rof neitanalpxe elbaborp �s� noitae�ep leg dna AIR eehth for�ensU eh.TOOZ fo se ,taht �hs ot su dettim� yhpargo�rhc .�1 si dlei Y �t ,snoitidnocgnidda t Y b d evor� saw enelyhte no pets ci�argot lanlf a ot ,reff�b gnltule ot locylg n x�ahpeslyporpbflus ylno fo dleiy a dah ylrmof e� hcisbe�vori �i taht dohtm dehsilbup eht ni egnahc p -�r� ehT .ylbaredI)noc dleiy eht t i ope rehto ot drag� eda� evah ew seuqinhcet noiotacifa rup dirbyh eht gni�ac dn � na polev� ,llams fi ,tnacifingis a yfirup ot do�ytiniffaonu�i )l�e� �G ,1$oLI elodidnoC � roeon�ooC �nor�orP/DPliP � enr�N Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 Page 16 of 25 88025900 CTI-MA 124761076MA A I T E:O JE.N 0 C % 51 �-m� .noitazln�i ortiv ni yb ro lufsseccus neeb ydaer nac ydobitna gnizllar�uen-non ehT sah taht doht� dlr�h e�-tar eht yb rehtie ,decu�rp eb lliw seidobitna ehT itna .elbissop sa elucel� ope eht fo snia�d tnereffid yB� sa ta detncaerirde seideorbapRp e etalu�cca ot "dna ,sezilartueD taht eno rof hcraos coe� ni ,lseidobitltnese hto l lliw eW .gnlzilar�en-non si yd�itna ]aneehtn�reelba� iadva 3eiceps rpo�ehTeht'ni hte na s lacI�loib BI devlovnI epa erutaef eb t cn r serutaef larutcurts suo�l�h era ereht ,opehte� enlmeted .o�e redro m nidnadspeeeu�shtob esuo hs e iidar RuP n ll�w ,ytlmeg�h �i fo d�n�peoc ew ecno �h-itna tibbar a detset evah ew ecnis dnif ot tluc tcaer o� ti dnuof dna o nosa� si erehT .tca� -iffid oo� � ton lliw noltcae� ssorc hcus taht eveileb ot ew ssorc s�d ta� eno dnif ew litnu sel�bitna ralimis ecu�rp ot eunitnoc lliw ruo .�ht� )detset te� ton( ope tibbar htiw tcaer ton s�d ydobitna ]�nolcon� y�mfI detal�c siht rof gnitiaw ,nezorf derots era taht �res tibbar evitca fo sretil .ope tibbar fo noitacifirup eht rof doht� �loc -ca evah � �aey tsap eht revO �� ytinif�a eht esu II� ew ,ope' n�uh fo Rutcurts �t yduts ot eunitnoc .�aey lareves txen e�. nihtiw ecudorp nac ew naht ope R� hc� eriuqer dluow dloc esu -�soro �o� desu euqin�e� RMN e� sa�ehw ,elbisaef �1lts si tub pets hcihw ta eht rof ot esadlso�1g hci� "gniss�g" sevlovni dohtm sihT .seiduts noltisop�c dirahcca -g b af depoleved ydaerla euqinhcet yhpargotsa�rhczndiuqile saretfyA ,y.nseidi ts ,eerutc�tssorno� f u desaeler eht enimeted lliw � desu i � e hca si , si i s sesadisoc�lg cific�s yebsansoirspylorrdyh esnii�aehts eedslurahlclcw so�i!o dehht,lCpL�ccayb s.i ,etaht siecnoOt lo e PH ag c etfa , .ope fo noits�id era eW ,sdica cilais lanimet eht ni H) htiw delebal ope. erup esu ot gniog osla .yawa �it �s llits si tcepsa tsal sihT .denolc na sa ANRm ope eht gnitalosi eb nac taht �)Dc eht gniraperp ot etisiuq�erp laitnesse fo esoprup lautneve eht rof ",la�agA fo dohtem eht gniwollof ,eborp editoelcun Woedogilo c(teht�s a eraperp ot desu � osla lliw noit�ofni ecneuqes ehT � r h .senletsyc eht ta nek�b stne�wgarf eht fo etrutcuh ts lliewt ta�hnk �b t litnu tiaw o eva os "�dltpepyl� elohw eht fo ecneuqes eht �vah yam fT of ,seidobitna h�iw noltcardetni fo yticifi�pslbfo eryaduts nIr�et lNufeesu eebcnis tustn�garn�aehf r b ,�t ht l .gnicneuqes rof �h� su tonnac. � dek� esac tsal siht nI .enietsyc spahrep hcus eraperp nac � taht dnuof ydaerla evah ew c dna nahpotpyrt ,enlnoht� sa hcus ,seudiser cificeps ta s�ht� eg.avaelycrevlataimenhc is yb ro )esaetorp 8V ,erutarep�t �l dna �it trohs ,noitartnecnoc �l rap -PWt�hc .dna nispyrt .g.e( sisyloetorp detimil yb �utcurts �onk fo stn�garf ief -erp o� ,spihsnoitaler noltcnuf-erutcurts fo seiduts rof :h�aeser fo sepyt e�tnu�s e sa �ita� -fid lareves ni desu eb neht lliw ecneu�s sihT .elbissopruo �nitnocofniiw eW ll hcu� sa teg ot redro ni dooH .forP ht� noitaroballoc .ecruos yradnoc -es a eb y� �sa�p.�o s,eCi] �o sdnasuo� yn� eht ",stnuo�a llams eseht gnirevoce�r eht o fo dohCe� e��s � dn�f n�c e� �I .ded�acs�d e�s s� s�hT .sso�C e� nt tnu� ]]ms ,�naclf�ng�s � eb ym ereht-taht nott�c�dn� c d�R ehC yb d�ap�p �sa]p To s�tca�T n� ope eht eCa��necnoc o� n�]oruo yn��n�fa I e� esu �]� e� �ope n�h fo secruos ev�ta�et]a �of hcraes deunitnoc .pets xed�hpeS �wo�pof�us eht �a d�e� eht gn�vo� n� sseccus yb ded�a s� eCats s�hT .��cracs yb dere�ah eb eoh ]]�w e� os ,woleb dessuc no �n ]a�etam ehC �ahC -s�d hc�aese� e� fo s�ey 6-5 �uoba �oT �ne�c�T�us s� dnah e�up �o d]e�y eH .e�u ev��ca fo ecruos � sed�vo�p �ahC ba� a o� ope � egnarra o� dalg eb eht fo flah-eno �uter.e� hc�h� �b ms�n�hc� ev�ta�ep�c e� t taht t� d�uo� e� ,e]bai]� ton st napaJ �rf ylppus eheraperp �N .k�w �npetseva�hehto ot nalp e p latretm gntni�r eht �rf elbissop sa ope erup hcum sa y� �t ro eno �na ,detset ydaerla ,�uloc ytiniffa ydobitna lanolcon� eht gnisu ssel ni eb dlu� naht lived .tnarg llu.f a rof si siht esuaceB :sdohteH eb lliw lasoporp "�N eht fo noitces siht ,tnalppus esac eht a rof tseuq� a �lf�-41-� eneguE )ressa�loG J�i� tsri[ ,I�L{ elod� ro �i� 1� roloni�czooC morgozP/O'�UP � ema� Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 Page 17 of 25 98025900 CTI-MA 224761076MA T"�ikIIS REBRO EVlT,�ETtf�I fflUOC OT "llaftrohs.� �t O _� --i --i .=f 0 � �-� --I -�" �/t � :. � U 0 Z siht trap nI .raey tegdub eht fo shtnom 3-2 tsal sesaercni ot eud si nee eht rof etirw dna daer tub gnihton od ot elba gnieb fo noitisorp o ehttuo niyrrac b otevah u su dluow ew sdnuf esoht tuohtiW .raey lluf eht rof noitatnemirepxe o cruos dettimrep noit6trtser fo gnitfil laiceps sihT .niatrecnu yrev won sisu opoe fe.lbaeliava t esenapaJ eht esuaceb ,sesoprup lareneg rof sraey owt tsap eht gnirud S .krow edam erew esahcrQp ope rof ;noitces yduts eht yb ,detcirtser sdnuf eht tfo em,osraey .owt ah ruo rof sdnuf hguone edivorp ton seod ylpmis tegdub lennosrep-non eht ruo t n e tsal eht ni ,dnuof evah ew ,rurutidnepxe hcae fo gnirotic omrof luferac dna dna c detimil era lamina aidem o etipseD .gnirutluc lle era sdnuf taht noitazilaer ,slamina evisnepxe ,stnevlos dna stnegaer erup artlu ,snmuloc CLPH yltsoc evlovni yeht si ecnis evisnepxe era gniyduts eno ew smelborp fo sdnik ehT .tnarg eeht t yb diap gnieb rh ,stismeh�oib ton era ohw stneduts etaudarg owt dna repleh bal a ,snaicinhcet lanoisseforp owt fo stsisnoc ffats yrotarobal ehT :sdnuf latnemelppus rof noitacifitsuJ ew elbissop nehw dna slairt .snoitutitsni rehto ni seiduts evitaroballoc etaitini lliw ni eseht eunitnoc.lliw ew dnah ta si lairetam hguone nehW .stneitap esaesid lanerotam lufesu eb llew yam ope taht etacidni ,stnemirepxe yranimilerP .sesaesid yr eh me -alfni fo ylbissop d)�a ,esaesid laner cinorhc fo aipe naerup t fo noitcerroc eht ni hguone fo noitalmucca tceffe sti fo lairt lacinilc tnacifingis a od ot o ni eht si ,smia latnemirepxe ruo fo tnuocca feirb siht ope denoitnems ebsa ot tsaL nac desu eb fo secruo .evoba detacidni sa ANRm ,tnuoma egral a niatnoc ro" ortiv ni ope ecudorp rehtie ot nwohs eb nac yeht fi ,sllec .meht fo snoitanibmoc.dna enoretsotset ,nidnalgatsorp ,PmA cilcyc romut esehT nwo e fo es n ,tlabloc ,aixopyh edulcni eseht ;oviv ni noitcudorp naopetahaerclli c otesoht nkrofsdohta m gni ,dn tse stceffe eht yduts ot erutluc ni dehsilbatse eb c .sisotycorhtyre htiw tneitap a morf saw asromut -neercs siht eunitnoc ot dnetni eW ope fo noitcudorp tneisnart wohs eht fo enoN .syad wef a nihtiw desaerced hcihw eno dnuof tey did thgie eht fo owt ;stnuoma tnacifingis ni ops seterces ylbats taht ew l ton evah ew raey tsap eht Bi sromut laner namuh thgie deneercs evah eht nhguohth A �aerg i ple .slamina yrotarobal ni setar ecnaraelc fo yduts fo eb lliw yassa evitisnes erom a ylralimiS .setats esaesid niatrec ot detcirtos t -er ro ,nonemonehp ,lacigolohtap-non ,lareneg a si noitatnemgarf rehtehw enlmr"eted ,yassa )dipar erom. a .ekil dna mures ni dnuof ope fo ,stnemgarf eht yduts ot redro ni erom l erom esu a dluow dna( evitisnes erom a deen eW .delebal eb ot tnegaera no eb dnlliwleb)al=Z=( lebal suht nac eW ,A nietorp ,tnegaer elba.liava yllaicr�noc erom x 5-4 eb dluoc ,detsuj eht ecnis yllaiceps.e ,AIR gnitsixe eht naht evitisnes ,erar llits ,eht no -da eb nac stnuoma dna semulov eht fi ,dohtem sihT .negitna naht rehtar tnuoma egral ni "nworg" eb nac hcihw ,ydobitnaeht fo yticificeps eht no desab ANR etats-dilos a poleved ot desu eb osla lliw ope-itna lanolconom ehT .gnidnib ope rof LEH dna ,Z65K ,CLF sa hcus senil llec hguo ekil-diorh�re foyteirav a tset ot'nalp osla eW .gnitnuoc tsrub yb tenreCetneserr p ) a ot detamitse �I ,esruoc fo ,nac rettal eht ;[-JIFB gnidulcni ,E-UFC naem eht eni�ieted nac � beF -er dluohs esehT .llec rep setis gnidnib fo r�n -ope delebal fo seiduts gnidnib tcerid yb dna noitalupop a hcus ni sllec delebal fo m )ycneuqerf( rebmun eht gnitnuoc yB .degnahc yllalcerppa ton si E-UFB fo repbo un eht ;�nit emos rof cirohtelp �lm gnipeek yb E-UFC fo dioved ts�rla snoitaluac p llec sllec worram eraperp nac ew tub ,tnetxe taerg yna ot deifirup eb ,tey ,tonn rettal esehT ?�E-UFB rep rebmun eht htiw erapmoc taht seod woh )b 7srotinegorpa diorhtlre etal es'eht no ope rof srotpecer fo rebmun eht si tahw ,tnetxe taerg ot deifirup eb nac EzUFC ecnis )a :era sdohtem eseht yb noitarolpxe deen taht u o snoitseuq eht gnomA .erutouf etaide�i ehetht ni ,ytroffoercirm o ybfo ,traiptnetdnatrt pmriedrnoa n�ib pocs yf io lliw sihT .srotpecer pe htiw sllec sn slle ba desu eb osla lliw enimadohr ro/dna ntecseroulf htiw gnilets L ot .taht c esevidnaopsxer-ope u elpmoc yllaitnetop rehto dna v(orram yb gnidnib evitatitnauq ydu o ope,baF eht ekam ,I=zz htiw ti lebal ,srotpecer cF htiw smelbe rp diovaot otdesruedreo b ,tnemgarf beF eht eraperp lliw eH .seiduts gnidnib rof op lebal ni eneguE ,ressawdlo6 Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 Page 18 of 25 09025900 CTI-MA 324761076MA 5336�1 A .71*- I� )03 92 8� 7Z �c �c .--- 54� ,4� doolB �- )0891( 038 ,8 lota�eH pxE .CJ yeloohc$ S45 .41 ortiV n� .,CD nnu� dna � egnaL .�J elgO )�791( .Y amayeU dna N lkoamaT--�n, ,PT neh� ,H ikjzuS ,N amai�u� �K amayoT )089]( 341 �69 nummoC �eR �yhpoiB mehcoiB .JA lks�oktyS )08gl( 453 ,39 nul�,oC seR sybpoiB meh�iB .JA ikswoktyS )0891( 0�6 ,65 doolB .LS gnauH ))-791( 641 ,694 atcA syhpoiB mehcoiB .F rebeiS IIam� ,Lla Ravip� )7791( 3364 ,47 SANP .DM grebnellotl dna U 162 )52 Z .. ")B791( 392 ,)TT )nilreB( deM prE seR .Y meY dna W ,nr_ohT ,M_ �879]( 871] ,� doolB .DM grebnelloH dna HJ repahS ,D .llamS n..nam.hcsuP. )42 559 ,55 doolB .R timsduoG dna P netragnesoR ,R teV ,G,LJkreklaKvtpeS )32 d )22 )9791( 41Ol ,44 recnaC .W deirF dna L iloloP ,SM )9791( 342 ,_6._6 deM � mA .E sbboC dna 0 relliM ,E usnaaKlor,ahCora,CA ,uSoAtsonlgsa�nA )12 a ve -E )979|( 778 ,45 i02 doolB .MK hcoK dna W e--ppeohc$ ,HE nnamreuehc$ ,MP sebrE ,A r , ektdaR -T9791( 163 ,22 norhpeN .MK hcoK dna E sreppihcS ,NePnsssueablC ,wWHH ektdaR rE )3691( 5804 ,.83�_� �ehC loiB � .� ressawdloG �a 0 eugit�a�-neillaG ,85 ztnarK )761 1 )97�I( �Tll ,35 doolB .B F P )8791( 065 ,25 do�18 .R ti�sduo8 dna C k�iwsiur�eKg,a.klatraHd,n��.relK�9ad� 51 A e )8791( 39-�,6 �otameH px� .R o�B tin�sjD dd � | )0891( 602 ,36 lotameX tcA .M ittedladuoG"nana ,A�i-enloN ,G,H kreell�sseeB ))�3l �t r )9791( 915 ,7 lotameH pxE ..BJ senoJ ,DR gnaL ,RDC nnuD )ll )7790 9�2 )OT )9 )8 141 )0891( 63 ,361 lotB ,171 )nilreB( deM pxE seR ..W nuapaK dna FC nnamua�--,W nrohT ,M nnamhcsuP )2891( 025 ,14 corP d sserp ni �P .E ressa,dloG dna � yksni eF .LS gnauH ss $ )1891{ � .l) lotamell J � .AI .sediruoK �a JB .namffoH va.KGC .LsTiluoirea/Z .[ ressawdloG dna PH rel-ff�K .DJ doowrehS dna E ressa�loG FJ atcraG ,EM relliM ,G aiccol) )9791( )lBgI( � .49 laeM tnI n� >lBgI( 953 ,89 lot�nea, J tirB pxE coS corP .PE etiknorC dna )9791( 588 ,45 doolB ,� s�C doo]B 504 .E .E ressawdloG dna BJ doowrehS dna KC �e I) I� )3 .E ressewdloG dna BJ do�,�ehS ,FJ aicraG )2 gnuK ,T ekayiM )l :secneref�R tessa'dloG .�lenit�r esu � hci� sutarappa �isero�portcele leg �cfm �a �us elba]iava yIIaicr�c ton era �aht smeti tcurtsnoc dna tcartnoc ecn�e�niam r�nu ton tn�iuqe ecivres o� pohs enihcam eht f cv -res eht fo e� elbaredisnoc ekm od eW .pohs.enihc� eht gniniatni�fo tnoemseeid � eht ot tsoc e� fo �ap stneserp� sihT .keew/sruoh 5.Z rof fo taht �yrogetac 1�nosr� eht ot noi$idda llams a ,tseuqer rengised tn�rtsni �t siht ot dedda si erehT .stsoc lennosrep rof desu si )�87( sdnuf eht fo klu eb ot gniog ton si ezis �ht tub ',tnarg e�al a ydaerb a eht ecnis degnahc yllairet� I si siht taht ezilaer I .CLPH sa tub ,wen tna�o�i o� tfihs eht ot dna stsoc erac ]�h�s seuqinhcet n ,evisn�xe ina s �dro ot ,lennosrep lanoisseforp-non eht rof sesiar �otanin�seo�aercd i ��ranese� a d ias�orp lanigiro eh� nehw e]baluclac ton erew taht eeuutidnepxe ni r ,dettimbus -art�e saw eneguE ,ressa�1oG Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 Page 19 of 25 19025900 CTI-MA 424761076MA A GNITS�O�R OT TI 'AR� �O �SOPO�P �IIT l177� �OF SllIT ESOLCNE .v*l( G95 -V ,KI -81 LALTHEDIFN REBMUN ENO�ELET t.IAICIFFO .LANOITUTITSNI FO ERUTANGIS �AICIFFO �NOITUTITSNI FO �LTI � 73606 ston,llI ,ogaCihC � ,sillE htuoS 1�5 ,ogacihC fo ytisrevinU ehT �W ST�[�USNAHUlf RO ;KSIR TA EB TON LlIW �C[JBUS N�H� R�H�E :TAHT LANOI�TI�i EHT DNA .DENI�E�D �H DRAO8 WEIVER LANOITUTI�NI EHT .]�OF �HT FO EDIS E�ER E[� DESU EB OT O�P sEqu�ECORP GNitNEMElPMI FO NO,TACIFITREC/SUTATS EC;�,ARU�.A FO NOITAR'ALCZ/D .4 .SRONIM -O�P D4'A �OB SiHT KC�H� .DEVLOVNI EB OLU� STCEJB� NAMUH ON FI( .YT�ITCA DESOPORP EHT NI DEVL�NI E� .SEUSSIT .SNAGRO �NW �ORF �SOH� GNIDULCNI ,$TCE�US IIAMUH DEREDISNOC THGIM OHW SLAU3�]VIDNI ON DEVLOVNI EB TOR DLUOW RO DLUOW REHTIE STCEJBUS NAMUH TAHT NOITARA.tCED .� r�ssa�loG" eneguE WO''EF/�OTCE.ID VT=VITCA/�OTAOITSEV.'LAP,CHISP .� sisenegoiB ,seitreporP ,noitacifiruP :niteioporhtyr� YTIVITCA RO .lASOPORP FO ELTIT �nui e� �of �EltD ot clbotn�ee� si �iec� � ne�rm ,tsn, � �o y�il,bls�s�t cm �l�:msrp si W�IID �rl �lc� REBMUN NOITACIFITNEDI HOITACI-ip.PA HOIT ARA.ICED/HOITACIFITREC/.FCHARUSSA STCEJBUS HAMUH FO HOITCETORP ,NOITACUDE oHT.IAEH FO THE4/TRA'FED ERAFLEW DNA Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 Page 20 of 25 29025900 CTI-MA 524761076MA ,Zt,33]�e9D1l'meOC � 7 A htiw detailogen gnieb i.emeergA 5HHD ][ ln�ilppa ekl ff .eci� l�oi� SHHD eto�por�o eht �lf� d�ilbot� etar. tsoc dm�nl tne�r tsom s'noitazinagro tnacilppa eht etacidnI :STSOC TCERIDNI ""'B ""'� ""'B :rotc�iD "''� 8 NOITCENNOC NI �of fo �"� B :HTI/I SECHARUSSA �rgmP/rmagitsevnI loplcnlrP e� )�lfcp �ej� l�ig�o sti � t�g dm�e ot sJ �ilppa sl�( :rebmunr�rg fo NOITAUNITNOC GNITEPMOC � EPYT �NOITACILPPA FO .detseuqer noitamrofni eht edivorp dna sexob etairporppa eht kcehC �no|taci|pp� eif1 fo ,ROTCERID eg�I tsal deriuqer eht si slh'i" TSILKCEHC �ARGORP/ROTAGITSEVNt LAPICNIRP Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 Page 21 of 25 39025900 CTI-MA 624761076MA �DIFNOC �33691 A 2891 ,8 ec�D lirpA 77/9 desiv. .sreetnulov tnetta�-non ro sreetmtloV tneitap era s%cej ).eet�i�oC noita�itsevnI lacinilC hcaer ton -bus eseh� rehtehw etacidni esaelP seod e�ap tegdub( sliated eht su evig esaelp ,diap eb ot era stcejbus hcraeser �I____. .tnemetats a esolcne esaelp ,sey si rewsna e�r fI dednetni eht go ypoc ?mro� X tnesnoc oN demro�ni eht fI seY-----" laiceps a esived uoy lliw ,�nittrw ni deniatbo si oN___.z__seY ?�nitir� ni tnesnoc demrofni .dettimbus eb tsum ,erofereht dna ton sah tub ,stcejbus niatbo ot dnetni uoy lliw eht yb lavorppa deviecer sihT( ).eciffO s*naeD eht yb deldnah eb ,eetti�oC noitagitsevnI lacinilC na�uth sedulcni noitacilppa sihT__ locotorP :uoilacilppA ot :deweiver e�&D fo eltiT :ycnega rehto yficepS .4 deilppa sa� I :�nidnu� rog ycnega rehtona noitagitsevnI lacinilC ruo yb devorppa dna 9932 dna de��eiver neeb sah # �eweiver locotorp emi� eht ta eettimmoC �raeser si�T locotorP .eettimmoC ehT locotorp ]8/|/�1 :deweiver etaD noitagitsevnI lacinilC ruo yb d#vor�.pa .noitacilppa siht ni devlovn� er� stcejbus namuH esr�oc x )tnemtaert. fo desoporp )( )( )( ( eht dnatsrednu tonnac( delbasiD yllatneM dedrate� vlla�ne� srenosirP ne�of' tn�n�er� sesutrobA sesuteF )( )( )( )x( sroni� gnlwollo� eht qo eno�----" :devlovnI stcejbuS mreuH X era ,noitacilppa :noitacilppa "erofeb sih� ni dedulcni ton stcejbus namuH .l ruoy ot niatrep taht stnemetats gniwollo� eht kcohC ).weiver ro� stcejbuS nanmH gnivlovni locotorp yna gn�ttiLnbus neh',, CIC eht dettimbus eb tsum�rof sih� �o ypoc eno ,yllanoitiddA .eci�O s'nae� eht ni �nissecorp tcartnoc dna tnar� lla htiw dettimbus d�,a deceip.oc eb TtJP� �rof sihT( ,snoi�cilp�a ,rehtO ,latnemtrapeD .lanretxE( HIN :ycnegA gnirosnopS sisenegoiB ,seitreporP ,noitecifiruP :niteioporhtyrE :uoitacLlpp� fo eltiT yrtsimehcoiB :tnemtrapeD :rotagitsevnI lapicnirP ressewd]oG eneguE $T�EI�))S �W�tH FO �'OI�CE�cRP Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 Page 22 of 25 49025900 CTI-MA 724761076MA )3(. :)s,rotagitsevnI lapicnirP yb dengiS .tnemeriuqer t�e�Tgissa dna !- e�solcsi� tnet�p s.�l won stnc�ap no etutatS taht erusne ot seerga )$[rotag�tsev�I lapicnirP � -.tcc�fc � ytisrevinU eht htiw ecnadrocca n� dessecorp dna .de�$� eb llahs sthg�r d� t�m�od �a� �cartnoc ytisrevinU eht �o s�et e� o� tcej�s si uoltacilppa s�t yb dr�a ro des�p6ocue �it�vit�a fo ro esruoc eht ni ��ats ro�o yna taht ro )s(�6tagitsevnI 28 l�picnirP �h*" ehT yb dvrevocs�d ei�m ,noftnev�t d�tsred6u )s[rotagitscvnI lapicnirP ] 7l "4_. :�l'.�.P" )2( ressawdloG eneguE es�lP[ )I(_ .. }$(.R�A�ITS�qXNI :n ,IAPIC�IRP s�senego iB ,seitreporP ",noitacif i#uP ro ite ioporhtyrE :ELTIT LASOP)�P) )aoixazinagrO ycnegA gnirosnops(� )IRA�IA RO "Q'�'�IG .�TC�'bIT�OC Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 Page 23 of 25 59025900 CTI-MA 824761076MA ,8 Y� UOY � lirpA �o weiver =o� senLle�uG .eecc� eht yb �avorp�a �a � � �Ci�us � 089%_ y�na� �r �of � � � Mb g�occa �o� n� C� e� �ra � tsum � � na �s� e� � � � .4 A� ).�neumcod noltartslgez der'-�uqer eht sa sev�es noi.tamotuA detseu�cx eht 9 �AnAatnoc n�of denqis s�ht taht etoN( �nolc gniwollof eht eb � ecneuqes A�D fo e=u�aU e�iVOr�I AJW na ,esac sb ton deen hguohtla eh� si siht fX senilediuG eht :no/tamrcfni .3 �e�tlm�us Fb denrevoG .)msinagro( �lc � � AND f.o ecruoS secudes � fo e�aN ro eno o� l�f �mi� �s� �0891 yraunaJ fo se�le� �H e� .no�ac�ppa �o� � �p tn� �a�s g�%ollof � .nolta�lppa. �o� � tsum �of s� fo � eno ,yl�noitid� erofeb ,sn�a�lppa n�oc �na t�g lla hSAw dettimbus dna .eciffo s'� e� � g�sseco� detelpmoc eb TSUM mrof HIN :Z'cn�g.� Scni:�o=�xi� fo e%t�T �i'�enegoiB ,seitrepo;�P ,noit�cifiru� :niteio'po�htyrE ressawdloG eneguE HCRA.FS:I,,� AND TNAHZBM,OCZR :no�zacilppA ;rotagitsevnI yrtSimehcoiB ;t.e�tz�I Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 Page 24 of 25 69025900 CTI -MA 924761076MA .sisehtnys lautneve sti rof �isiuq�erp a sa ,Wivltca lacigoloib �i rof stn'�iuqR larutcurts eht gnldnat�ednu fo noitnetni eht �iw� niteioporht�e fo seitreporp lacimehc eht fo noitagitsevni eht eunitnoc lliw ,ylsuoenatI�itS .seitrep�p laci9oloisyhp fo ydtus eht rof lairetm delebal hcus esu ot dna ,�iv.itca lacigoloib fo noitneter htiw niteioporhtyre fo noitanidoioidar rofdoht�a gnidnif � krow ot eunitnoc ll� eW .Oiduts eb osla lliw wssaonu�ioidar eht fo yticificeps eht nI tn�evor�I .noitaluger dna siEenegoib sti fo yduts timep osla yam �utluc llec nI noitcudorp niteioporhtyre lufsseccuS .gnin�rcs rof yassaonuBnioidar depoleved ylwen eht esu 11� e� .sdoht�p erutluc llec dna noitcartxe ,yendlk sa hcus ,niteioporhtyre fo sesuos elacs e�al evita�etla elbiss� yd�os)a lliw� .yhpargota�rhc diuqil hgih sa ll� sa ,niteloporh�re stn�evor�i esehT n�te�opo�ht�e ltna lanol�nom ro/dna snltcel gnlsu yhpargot�rh� �tinlff� edu]cnI �am .s�ht� noitanottcarf n� stn�evorpmi elbissop yduts ot dna namuh e�up etubirtsid dna erape�p ot eunitnoc ot esoporp e� 73606 .1I ,oBacihC ,eunevA sillE .S10BS.....�.oFacihC fo ytisrevinU ehT .NO|TUT| TSNI TN,�G|.IPP.P FO �r�IDOA DNA rosseforP hcraeseR ,yrtsimehcoiB fo tnmtrapeD ,gnaW gnuF rosseforP yrtsimehcoiB fo tnemtrapeD ,ressa�k(loG eneguE R�HTO �LA DNA SIF OT�ER|D r�-�EJORP RO SROTA;�TCrVNI LAPICNIRP FO $rLTIT LAICIFFO ONA .$T4rEMITRAPE� .SEMAN EVIG sisenegoiB ,seitreporP ,noitacifiruP :n�tefoporh�yrE TCEJORP FO �TI'T TCEJORP HCR�SER FO �iTON ECIVRES HTL�H CILBUP �r�ps SiHT [SU TON OD( ,ON r'GEJORP � .OM .B.M.O O�rO�m* �OF n� nott�p � mN SECIVRES NAMUH DNA HTLAEH fo tnemtrapeD .S .U .ypoc tsal fo esrever no snoitcurMni eeS :ECITON r Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 312-11 Filed 03/05/2007 Page 25 of 25

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.

Why Is My Information Online?