Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al
Filing
312
BRIEF by Amgen Inc. CLAIMS CONSTRUCTION BRIEF. (Attachments: #1 Appendix A#2 Appendix B(part 1 of 4)#3 Appendix B (Part 2 of 4)#4 Appendix B (part 3 of 4)#5 Appendix B (Part 4 of 4)#6 Exhibit 1#7 Exhibit 2#8 Exhibit 3#9 Exhibit 4#10 Exhibit 5#11 Exhibit 6 (Part 1 of 2)#12 Exhibit 6 (Part 2 of 2)#13 Exhibit 7#14 Exhibit 8#15 Exhibit 9 (Part 1 of 2)#16 Exhibit 9 (Part 2 of 2)#17 Exhibit 10#18 Exhibit 11 (Part 1 of 2)#19 Exhibit 11 (Part 2 of 2)#20 Exhibit 12#21 Exhibit 13#22 Exhibit 14 (Part 1 of 2)#23 Exhibit 14 (Part 2 of 2)#24 Exhibit 15#25 Exhibit 16#26 Exhibit 17#27 Exhibit 18#28 Exhibit 19 (Part 1 of 2)#29 Exhibit 19 (Part 2 of 2)#30 Exhibit 20#31 Exhibit 21#32 Exhibit 22#33 Exhibit 23#34 Exhibit 24#35 Exhibit 25#36 Exhibit 26)(Gottfried, Michael)
Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al
Doc. 312 Att. 13
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 312-14
Filed 03/05/2007
Page 1 of 22
EXHIBIT 7
Dockets.Justia.com
50235900
CTI -MA
835861076MA
832
-naba
won
,4891
,12
a
yraurbeF delif
dna
,581,285
won
.oN
laireS fo
zebmeceD
trap-ni-noitaunitnoc
delif
-oc
,denodnaba
,3891
tnetaP
,31
.S.U
,420,165
.oN
laireS
noltacilppA
a saw
gnidnep
rebotcO
ym fo
no
trap-ni-noitaunitno9
800,307,4
.oN
hcihw .S.U
,7891
sa
,72
tnetaP
sretteL
.oN
deussi
dna
4891
,03
rebmeuo1·
delif
ym
,892,576
fo
laireS
a
noitacilppA
si sihT--
tnetaP
".-...S.U
·nidnep-oc
noitaunitnoc
:foereht
ni txet
ecalp
sa
gniwollof eht tresni dna 7891 ,32
·i egap fo
txet
rebotcO
dednema
6-3
senil
eritne eht
eteled
esaelP
NI
NOITACIFICEPS EHT
:swollof
sa
noitacilppa
.P.E.P.M
deifitnedi-evoba
eht
dnema
esaelp ,20.807·
tnetsisnoC
fo.snoisivorp
eh· .dna
laiceps
ekaM oT
noititeP nO noisiceD
elbarovaf 8891
,81
yraurbeF eht htiw
:riS
stnetaP
13202 .C.D ,notgnihsaW skramedarT dna fo renoissimmoC..noH
TNEMDNEMA
YRANIMILR·p D·_n_P._e· S'TNACILPPA )7891 ,72 rebotcO no 800,307,4 .S.U sa deussi ,4891 ,03 rebmevoN delif ,892,576 .N.S no desaB(
:)detcepxE(
721
ztlohnenaT .A renimaxE
trA
7891
,32
rebotcO
:oN
:deliF laireS
tin0
puorG
97L,311
"nite·opo·htyrE
-·'·''-·
NEUK-UF :fo
·o
noitcudorpECIFFO KRAMEDART DNA SETATS DETIHIL EHT NI
noitacilppA
TNETAP
/
'·19tOBGI[EVIEGEI';
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 312-14
Filed 03/05/2007
Page 2 of 22
60235900
CTI -MA
935861076MA
932
.--IHmag-- eb
dluohs
dluohs
dluohs
"lHmaB" "lHmaS"
"IROcE"
,51 enil
,31 en·1
,55 egaP ,55 ,45
..--IHmaB-.--lRocE--
eb
eh
egaP egaP
egaP
,63 enil
//+eb
dna
dluohs
IV
elbaT"
,92 enil
,84
.--dica
cimatulg-esaelp ,51
foereht
enil
ecalp egaP
ni
tresni
"enimatulg"
ammoc
eteled
,84
"+-.
°'.),(
eht
."sgni[pS"
retfa
eteled
esaelp ,53 enil ,23 egaP
--selpmaxE--
eb
/.eb
dluohs
"elpmaxE" ,42
,22
enil
,72 egaP
dluohs "IV elbaT"
enil
,22
egaP
dna 5
/:.--6
eb
serugiF-tagapocp"
."stceffe"
dluohs
"IV dna V
selbaT"
,4
enil
,22 egaP
."noi
"/retfa --}-- tresni
esaelp ,12-02
senil
,31
egaP
retfa
--"--
tres·i
a
esaelp ,31 enil
enil
,31
egaP
"2381"
/
erofeb
ecaps
eb
tresni
esaelp ,6
,ii ,iI
egaP
//.--
;)0891(-eb
dluohs
"·0891|"
,4
enil
egaP
.--.lotameB.pxE-dluohs
".lotameH.tpxE"
eteled
,3
enil
,II eg·P
eht"
/." dnoces eht
fo
ecnerrucco
esaelp ,22 enil ,8 egaP
/
..--rebmem-23--
dluohs
"reb·em 23"
,72 enil ,7 egaP
--.4891
,82
rebmetpeS
a
delif
,148,556
.oN.·ireS
fo
trap-ni-noitaunitnoc
dna
,denod
./
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 312-14
Filed 03/05/2007
Page 3 of 22
70235900
CTI-MA
045861076MA
O42
ni
,wolla
ot
elbatius
snoitidnoc
tneirtun
se
·£oereht
ynego·p.
-eh t·re-r@lL ee-d·olb-de r-tc·a
· sa e r
·cneuqss rednu tyc·uc-i·e·--·o.-noi tcudorp
rp
c·i -ot--s·-lec- ·m-en
ob..gnisuatfo-r!Crepo
na
-lacigoloib
-a.=.
ro
gnidocne
si
ecn_euqes·gdetaloli
hcihw
tsoh
a
btlw
detcefsnart
demrofsnart
fo
noitalysocylg
si hcihw
llec
fo
)a(
dna·eh·-des·erpxe seditpepylop lanoitisnart-tsop gnitceffe elbapac Jailammam gniworg /
:fo
spets
eht
oviv
gnisirpmoc
ni
na
editp·iop
noitar·erp
.96-55
ro
detalysocylg
rof
evitca
yllacigoloib
·o
eht
ssecorp A
.56--
smialc
wen
retne
esaelP
a
ni
ot
epocs
ralimis
emas
.noitacilppa gniunitnoc delif-ylud tnacilppA
eht fo
smialc
eusrup
ot
ecidujerp
tuohtiw
46-16
smialc
lecnac
esaelP
SMIALC
EHT NI
.--senarbmem-eb
dluohs
"secnarbmem"
,01 enil
,59
egaP
egaP
.....
/eb
J
eb
dluohs
."a"
"IV
elbaT"
,0I enll
enil
,29
eteled
esaelp ,92
,63
,19
egaP
egaP
dluohs
"dellbal"
enil
,88
"/..--suoenegomoh-,52
enil
'/eb
dluohs
"suoenegomeh"
,16
egaP
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 312-14
Filed 03/05/2007
Page 4 of 22
80235900
CTI -MA
145861076MA
142
4
dias
·iere·w
..56
mialc ot
i
italosi
nierehw
56·
·ia·c ot
.decudorp
os
editpepylop
dna
fo enob
detaf,
;sllec
setyc
sllec
-olucite·
worram
noitcudorp gnisuac fo
eht
acigol
-oib
ov£v
ni
fo
tcudor
deta·ysocyl· detalsna·t eht nlteioporhtyre
wolla ot
noissessop
fo
yllarutan fo noital.
eht
gnirrucco nrettap
fo
evi·acllpud yltnei:
·euqes
a
dna
editpep
onima
-ylop detalsna·t dias fo
eht
dica
yb detcerid
llec .tsoh
nret
dias fo
dias
ihtiw
ni editpepylop noitalysocylg
·
debircsnart
eht fo dias
;ANR·
ecneuqes
snoitcaer
d·
/o
editoelcun noltalsnart
a
eht
editpepylop
nihtiw
;AND dias
fo
Ot
ANRm
yb detceri7 ecneuqe· · ts·
fo llec
dias
noitalsnart
ecneuqes
/
eht
yb detcerid snoitcaer
ANRm
noitpircsnar·
dias
fo
ecneuqes eht ni dias
nihtkw
ot
AND
editoel·n /o llec/tsoh
noitpircsnart
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 312-14
Filed 03/05/2007
Page 5 of 22
90235900
CTI-MA
245861076MA
242
5
sah
-sid
eht
eusrup ot
tnacilppA ,noitacificeps tneserp eht fo serusolc yb detroppus era sa smialc ssecorp rehtruf hcus thgir s'tnacilppA ot ecidujerp tuohtiW tcejbuS demialC 71tneserP ehT .C
rettaM
.smialc
deussi 13 eht
snmuloc
sedulcni
a
hcihw
"&"
tnetaP
800"
sa
eht
fO 24 ot
93
fo ypoc ,niereh
otereh
tibihxE
eht fo
sehcatta
·nacilppA
gnitaler
.oN
detneserp
smialc
noitaredisnoc etatil
levon ot
-icaf smialc
tnetaP .oN
oT
.secneuqes AND
niteioporhty·e
eht" ,72
rebotcO
won
htiw
,)"tnetaP B00'
.S.U
sa
retfaniereh(
no
800,307,4
deussi
sretteL
7891
892,578
laireS delif
noitacilppA
,420,165
,581
.oN
.)denodnaba
laireS dna
.oN
,3891
,31 rebmeceD
won
.oN
,denodnaba
,4891
,4891
,12
yraurbeF delif
delif
,285
laireS dna
,82
a
rebmetpeS
sa{
4891 tnetaP
,148,556
rebmevoN
laireS fo
trap-ni-noitaunitnoc
.oN
,03
delif
a
,892,576
laireS
noitacllppA
ehT
fo
noitaunitnoc
si noitacilppa tneserp snoitacilppA detaleR oT
ecnerefeR
.B
.delif
sa
noitacificeps
ot
eht
ni
tneserp
rebotcO
srorre
lacihparg
tnemdnemA
-opyt lla etanlmlle
7891
,32
detad
yranimilerP s'tnacilppA ni detseuqer esoht htiw enibmoc noit -acificeps eht ot stnemdnema detseuqer-evoba ehT
noitacificepS
SKRAMER
ehT
oT
stnemdnemA
.&
si
nierehw 56
·.D
dias
mialc ot g
ca
·secorp
ehT
.96
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 312-14
Filed 03/05/2007
Page 6 of 22
01235900
CTI-MA
345861076MA
6
ni
deificeps
sa
sa
AND
oimoneg
dna
ANDe
.96 dna 86 smialc ,.g.e ,gnidulcnI
sllec OHC
dna SOC
.76 dna 66 smialc n· deificeps sa sllec yendik-non ,namuh-non hcus
gnidulcnI
snoitidnoc
ssecorp
sa
era
rednu
ehT
erutluc n·
htworg
eht
llec
42
tsoh
rof
sllac
56
mialc sliec
).tnetaP eht fo
mialc ni
deticer
800'
tsoh
gnitluser
·na
dna 7 eht
mialc
flesti
tnetaP
fo
rettam
tcejbus suoivbonu
levon
si
ssecorp
eht ni
ti
noitce·snart/noitamrofsnart .ytivitca lacigoloib oviv ,yfilauq ot
dica onima
ot
wolla
ni deyolpme tnegaer &RD ehT( laitnetop cof ,e·iw-ecneuqes ot niteiopochtyre namuh
larutan
eno
ygolomoh ecneuqes dica onima tneiciffus gnivah
,.e.i
2
,edltpepylop detaeniled yllacificeps
AND
a
a
gnidocne
tsrif
I llec
a
ecneuqes
htiw
eht
detcefsnact
ro
·emrofsnart
·o
si
seditpepylop desserpxe
tsoh
gnitalysocylg
elbapsc
nailammam 56
a
niereh·
spets ssecorp fo seires levon
ot
setaler
mialc
tnednepedni
namuh
rof
a
yrassecen fo
seititnauq
eht
na
,dezirammus ylfeirB .ypareht citeiopotameh tcudorp nlteioporhtyce
ni
namuh nrut
noisi?orp
hcihw
tneve
,emit
tsrif
eht
rof namuh
,dewolla
ni
sah
,nietorpocylq
na
etagilbo
tsrif
evitca
eht
fo
eno
71lacigoloib
fo
uviv ni
fo
noitcudorp
fi(
secnatsni
tnanibmocer
eht
)ecnatsni tsrif e·__ht
eht
ton
etutitsnoc ot
etal ni
deveileb si
demialc
niereh
sessecorp
tes
fo
sA
3891
ecitcarp
dna
,retfaereh liated ni tuo
oviv ni
eht
.ytivitca lacigoloib n·teloporhtyre
cof
htob
dedeen ssessop
noitalysocylg
ot
reve
ecneuqes
namuh
dica
onima
erutcafunam
fo
elcitra
tsrif
eht
nietorp
nailammam ni noitnevni
namuh fo levon ot
sllec
tsoh
-ocylg niteioporhtyre noitcudorpeht rof sdohtem
sih fo
setaler
hcihw
wen
tcepsa taht
ot
niereh 96-56
smialc
dettimbus
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 312-14
Filed 03/05/2007
Page 7 of 22
11235900
CTI-MA
445861076MA
-7
gnitrats
si
la
erom
eno
taht
deredisnoc
sa
-pepylop gnitalosi dna gnisserpxe yl·nanib
fo
t·
erehw
eht fo nevE
revo
.niereh
demialc
sedit
301
-mocer
ssecorp
cisab eht
era
esolcsid ohw dna
sa
te
egdamlaT
rednu
elbatnetapnu gnieb
27-96
.C.S.U 53
detcejer
smialC
eht
no
:sdnuorg gniwollo·
)noitacilppa eht gnildnah srenimaxE eerht fo eno( ztlohnenaT renimaxE yb ot detcejbo erew )ecidujerp tuohtiw nwardhtiw retal{ smialc dohtem noitcudorp niteioporhtyre niatrec ot pu gnidael 892,576 .oN
,tnetaP
800* eht fo ecnaussi
laireS
noitacilppA
fo
noitucesorp
tnetaP
fo
esruoc
eht
nI
noitucesorP
800'
·niruD
dohteM
gnidrageR
noitisoP
smialC dohteM s'renimaxE ehT
.D
.ytivitca lacigoloib o·_._.viv n·_i rof deriuqer osla
si fo
eht
nrettap eht evah lliw
,noitalosi
detalsnart
ta
nopu
hcihw noitalysocylg ,tcudorp gnitluser
eht fo sdica
onima fo
eht
redro eht
fo
taht os editpepylop yb detcerid setis
editpep
-ylop detalsnart
gnissecorp noitalysocylg eht si 56
mialc yb deriuqer rehtruF ).noitamrofnoc larutcurts yramirp htgnel lluf eht gnitutitsnoc sdica onima eht ,redro ni ,knil ot devlovni era snoitamrof dnob editpep 291 dna ANRm eht ot s'ANRt fo stnemngila cificeps 391 ·o muminim a ,niagA( .noitamrof edltpepylop ot esir gnivig stneve lanoitalsnart fo ecneuqes cificeps a fo ecnamrofrep si 56 mialc yb ·etaeniled oslA )oremylop ANRm ehtfo noitamrof eht rof snoitidda editoelcun deredro yllacificeps 285 naht ssel ,on sevlovni yliranidro ANDc niteioporhtyre fo tpircsnart noiger gnidoc htgnel lluf a fo noitamrof eht ,ylevitartsu11·( .ecneuqes AND deticer eht yb dedivorp snoitcerid euqinu es ·ep eht ot gnidrocca noitamrof tpircsnart ANRm .srucco gnissecorp rof sllac mialceht ,ylralucitrap eroM ,noitpircsnart nierehw
noitalysocylg
dna
noitalsnart
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 312-14
Filed 03/05/2007
Page 8 of 22
21235900
CTI-MA
545861076MA
542
8
ytlvitcs lacigoloib o·__.viv ·_i
delaever ot
eht
fo
taht
noitnevni
tneserp
rekrow delliks eht ot
eht
ta
eht
emat
eht
tcepser htiw
niteioporhtyre
egdelwonk
"tra
fo
etatS?
.i
niteioporhtnietoropocscitsiretcarOhC a D yrE f ylG eta·llba ehsTA
noitcudorp tnanibmocer
.snietorpocylg
dna fo
fo
ot fo
yltnecer
eht
yllareneg 9nitaler
tra
deniatrecsa kcal
tra
roirp
800'
ytilibatnetap
eht fo
ot
)4(
dna go
;tnetaP
eht eht
ecnaveler
noitucesorp
roirp
er
ytilibatnetap
noisicea
na
gnirud
detic
ot
nI
ni
ni
ytilibatnetap
etagilbo"
)i(
53
on
ecnaveler fo kcal eht )3( ;ned·_·.ruD eesserdda seussi ·orf niereh seussi
eht
fo
fo
ssentcnitsid
fo
)2{
sa
niteioporhtyre namuh
skramer
;.nietorpocylg
eht
:ot
gnitaler
scitsiretcarahc
eht
seires
fo
tnacilppA ,noitisop
rednu taht
gniwolloE
sedivorp
siht
troppus
smialc eht fo
dna
elbatnetap
taht
ht
ylraelc
tcejbus
eht
nI .301$ .C.S.U noitcejer rof stsixe sisab reporp smialc fo rettam si
96-56
stimbus
smialC
fo
ytilibatnetaP
ylluftcepser tnacilpp& troppuS nI skrame_R
fO
.rorre
.E
etutitsnoc osla
dluow
fo
rettam tcejbus demialc yltneserp eht ot snoitcurtsnoc hcus noitacilppa taht dna suoenorre yllagel erew esac nedruD
eht
fo
noisiced
evoba eht taht
eht gniurtsnoc renimaxE eht fo stnemetats stimbus ylluftcepser tnacilppA
e
ro
eu
·__:·._·2··
d·o
·b decudorp tcudorp e ton ro rehteh· .)4691( 037 "0.p.S.U ,nedruD er nI ;301 141 ,nesraL er nI ;arpus nihtiw suoivbo eb llit.C.S.U ow53 fo gninaem eht S dlu eht ecudorp ot slairetam tluser detcepxe ssecorp noitacilppa eht ,levohcussi otslairetam n
na
fo
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 312-14
Filed 03/05/2007
Page 9 of 22
31235900
CTI-MA
645861076MA
642
9
lacigoloib oviv
htiw dezidixo taht nwohs
.ytivitca oviv ni lanigiro atad esehT eht fo %54 tuoba dah detaert ylralimis ope detalaised yletelpmoc taht nwohs evah .derotser ytivitca ew ,yrotarobal siht nI ni sti dah ,esadlxo esotcalag ,ope detalaised yllaitrap' retniap dna ykswokuL
nehw
evah
.doirep
lamron
snietorpocylg
dluow i ylraen a rof noitalucric eht ni nhtamerdevomer , olaisa deifidom e ro dezidixo.erew snietorpocylg olaisa fo seud -iser esotcalag lanimret eht fi ,taht dewohs .nietorpocylg olaisa osla srohtua esehT tset ralucitrap a rof etar ecnaraelc lamron lla ylraen a timrep dna setis gnidnib ehethtofo taht r ypucco dluoc ,eno os elbatarutas a eb ot nwohs saw metsys .noLtalaised yb desopxe seudiser revil ehT esotcalag lanimret ylwen eht htiw detcaretni yllaclficeps taht sllec citapeh yb detceffe .mrof evitan saw ecnaraelc dipar sihT a ta noitalucric eht naht etar retaerg hcum eht morf deraelc erew
snietorpocylgolaisa
,lareneg ni seiduts eht
fo
a
morf
,taht dewohs ohw devired saw
ro
snietorpocylg olaisa .la te lleroW fo xodarap tnerappa
.dohtem
tub
siht
noitan·--e·'·T
,lluf
erutluc
nehw
llec
worram
yb ]ortiv ni[ deyassa
dah
ytivitca
on sah ope olalsa ni yb deyassa nehw ytivitca a rof deraeppa ecnis lacixodarap eb ot emit ytivitca ope ni dica cilais fo eZor ehT
,desaercni
,sdohtem oviv
"C"
:taht 8822 egap ta stroper rehtruf ]otereh tibihxE[ )5791[ 2922-5822 ,·4___43 ,·corP.de· ,ressawdloG
.noitalucric eht morf snietorpocyl· -olaisa ·o lavo·r citapeh eht yb denialpxe .enomroh eb nac ytivitca fo ssol ehT tuoba evitan eht naht evitca er· semit eerht fo slevel wol ta deyassa nehw lluf sah nlteioporhtyreol·-a .oviv enod si yassa eht nehW
ro.,or-t·t6-n· · iv i
ni
taht
s·
sen·roh
sah
deyassa si ti nehw ytivitca lacigoloib fo ssol etelpmoc ni stluser noitalaiseD .elom rep seudiser dica cilais 81 ot 61 #tuempoleved etycorhtyre lamron secudni a
nietorpocylg
,niteioporhtyrE
egap
ta
:taht
2034
troper
]"otereh
tibihxE[ ]4791( 6034-2034
,.la te sti
sti osla
no
ressawdloG
,suhT
,· ,.mehC.loiB.J .noitalysocylg fo yarra
namuh
tub
ton
,noitamrofnoc ecneuqes d£ca onima cificeps
ylno
tnedneped
saw
nietorpocylg
siht
fo
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 312-14
Filed 03/05/2007
Page 10 of 22
41235900
CTI-MA
745861076MA
742
01
.ot eb
dednetta ecneuqes
a
dluoc
noltalysocylg
fo tnanibmocer detsixe
lla
deriuqer
fo
·__na
·llufsseccus editpepylop
,sselnu sllec
deriuqer
tsoh
seussi eht htob
·orf
ts
,muminim
evitca
dna
saw on
ta
lairetam
oviv nI
gnitalosi
rof
na
epoh
eb ot
nwonk
ylsuoucipsnoc
nletorpocylg etaqilb· n·teioporhtyre namuh
dluow
,2-nikuelretnI dna snorefretni eht sa hcus snieto·pocylg namuh rehto ekilnU .nlteioporht·re ot ygolomoh ecneuqes dica onima etisiuqer htiw editpepylop a )b( no dedivorp eb ,ylbissop ,dna seudiser
seudis·r
esotcalag etamitlunep
dica
lanimret
o·lais
·nidulcni noitalysocylg
ot
fo
yar·a
etairporppa
a
na
)a(
yberehw desived eb
evah dluow dohtem
,snaem
erew
eb ot fo
tnanibmocer yb seititnauq cituepareht ni dedivorp niteioporhtyre namuh evitca yllacigoloib oviv ni
eht Eo
snoitaraperp Ei taht dootsrednu evah suht dluow noitnevni
tneserp
emit eht
ta
rekrow
delliks ehT
yb
eht
decuder si enomroh eht no egrahc evitagen nehw srotpecer llec evisnopser-OPe eht ot
)dettln·. snoitatiC(
.noitala·sed
erom
fo esae retaerg ot eud eb yam sihT .mrof evitan eht naht ,)stinu -illim 4-1( evruc esnopser-esod eht fo dne rewol eht ta ortiv nI deyassa nehw ,ytivitca semit eerht tuoba .mrof evitan eht si
dna
noitsegid citpyrt
olaisa taht
dnuof
sah en·oh olaisa ehT naht noitavitcani taeh ot elbitpecsus erom osla evah eW
ro
eerht
-moc a
sa
tca
)evitan( lanigiro eht fo %03 tuoba gnittimrep ,slamina yassa ni srotitepmoc sa tca luoc eso·hca·s edirahccasartet eht dna d£o·umodeoro
-olaisa
rof
,esotcaL
.ope
.ruot rehtie eb ·su· deriuqer edirahccas fo ezis laminim eht os ,rotitep ton seod ,dnah rehto eht no olaisa ni dnuof eb ot ytivitca
etamitlunep
der·u·er
,noitidda nI .y·vitca lacigolo·b ton s· tub eudiser eta·yhobra· eht s· esotcalag taht tseggus
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 312-14
Filed 03/05/2007
Page 11 of 22
51235900
CTI-MA
845861076MA
·2
11
ton ,seussi de·psid ·o stcaf eht ot nettirw sa 301$ ,esac hcae ni ,ylppa ot si noit .esac -cnuf ruO s'worromot ni detterger eb ylekil dluow elur s'yadoT .od ot gniht teerc -sidni na eb dluow ti taht s·rof tnereffid hcus ni dna syaw fo yteirav elbatciderpnu na hcus ni sesira 301$ rednu ssensuoivbo fo noitseuq eht tuB .ti yrt ot detpmet eb thgim segduj emoS .dediced eb dluoc erutan siht fo sesac lla hcihw yb elur lareneg raelc emos etats su evah ot ekil dluow ohw esoht era ereht taht erus era eW
ot
dewollof
·c·lppa lasrevinu gnivah sa nekat eb ot tcn si snoitautis tcaf tnereffid gnissucsid ni dias evah yam srossecederp ruo ro ew tahW .noitautis tcaf ralucitrap nwo sti fo sisab eht no esac hcae ediced si hcihw ,sesac eussi ssensuoivbo ni elpicnlrp rehtona etaretier eW
.noltaredisnoc
levon
rednu si
a
lairetam
gnitrats
dohtem
gnirutcafunam
sesac
rof
a
levon a gnisu tcudorp ytilibatnetap eht fo "elur
.C.F.A.C
nierehw
11a
ot
noitacilppa
rof
larene·"
eht
yna
edivorp
ot
denilced
eht
ta
yllacificeps
dellacer eb
taht
,revewoh
,testuo
ot
lliw tI
.stcudorp elbatnetap
esu
niatbo
slairetam
eht
fo
gnitrats
ecitcarp
elbatnetap fo
dna
sevlovni
dohtem
dohtem
demialc
sa
eussi ni
era
smialc
,nedruD ni
.niereh
,ereH noitnevni
esac saw
demialc
eht
ot
tcepser htiw
eht
tnatxe
taht
·orf
tcnitsid
eht fo
yllohw si
sucof .301
eht
nedruD hcihw
ni
snoitarebiled
eht
s'truoC
os
txetnoc
lautcaf
esuaceb
si
sihT fo
noitceS
rednu
96-56
smialc fo
ssensuoivbonon
ni
ton
noitanimreted
taht
eht
no
gnillortnoc yaw yna
si
noisiced eht
stimbus ylluftcepser tnacilppA .892,576 .oN laireS tnerap ni detneserp yllanigiro smialc fo ytilibatnetap ot tnaveler
yllaitnetop
622
sa
er
renimaxE
nI
eht
yb
deton
eht
saw
}6891(
263-953
ehT .2
QPSU
,nedruD
nedruD
ni
.C.F.A.C
·o
noisiced
er
nI
·o
esoht
ytilibatnetaP
fo
·orf n·ereh seussI ssentcnitsiD lautcaF
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 312-14
Filed 03/05/2007
Page 12 of 22
61235900
CTI-MA
945861076MA
942
).txet nA sisahpme ,063 egap ta di( .euoiv -honu dna levon era ,deniatbo tcudorp eht dna deyolpme T·'·--retam gnitrats ciflc·--·-ethtob ro rehtie esuaceb elbatnetap si ,suoivbO esiwrehto ,ssecorp l·cimehc a rehtehw..
:saw
qedruD
ni
eht
deta·s
-ylesicnoc
erew
.C.F.A.C eht yb dediced eussi lagel ,dnuorgkcab lautcaf siht neviG
.draoB
ssecorp
eht hcus
fo
on
stluser
eht ro renimaxE eht ot dedivorp detcepxenu yllaitnetop yna
gninrecnoc s·caf
eb
-nosaer
,.C.F.A.C eht yb deton sA
etamabrac
a wen
.demrof
ot
tcudorp
rekrow
retse
derised eht
no
tcepxe ylba
dluoc
delliks
rehtehw
eht
ecneulfni yna evah tcnitsid eht
thgim lairetam gnitrats
,tra
fo
serutaef
sseccus
eht fo weiv ni
,rehtehw
slairetam
roirp eht ni deveihca ot sa tnacilppa eht gnitrats s'tra
larutcurts eht
sa
secnereffid
.laire·am
morf tupni lautcaf detseuqer dna roirp eht dne s'tnacilppa neewteb ylreporp renimaxE ehT
owt
deton
gnitrats
na
dnuopmoc gnir
retse
,derebmem-5
a
detut
-itsbus-emlxo dewohs
gnisu noitamrof
etamabrec
sa
lufsseccus
tra
roirp
ehT
.lalretam gnitrats
levon
a
dnuopmoc
dellac
na
gnir derebmem-6
,detutitshus-emixo
eroM nwonk
fo
esu
a
rof
ot ot
mialg
fo
eht
,yllaclflceps
lacimehc
.retse llew
a
etamabrac
emix0
noisrevnoc
saw
gnimrofrep
detcerid
noitaredisnoc rednu mialc eht
.ereh
,n__edruD
tceffe
nI
on
gnillortnoc
sah
esac
taht ni
eht
emoctuo ni
a
lanif
eht
taht
wohs ot
dna
yrassecen si
laeppa nedruD
stcaf eht fo noit
-animaxe yrosruc
seussi detalupits ylno ,dnuorgkcab
siht
tsniagA
ot
sa
-emos
sesac
."wal" eht .eerga yam dediced fo yaw eht s· hcus tuB deriuqer esoht fo lla ton ,swohs esac siht dna ,;tluciffid semitemos dna ysae eb semit yam ksat ehT .elbaeeserofnu era hcihw rehto rof selur ekam Fo ezilareneg ot
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 312-14
Filed 03/05/2007
Page 13 of 22
71235900
CTI -MA
055861076MA
O52
31
.serudeco·p
yb ecnetsixe
dluoc
evlovni
AND
deticer
neeb
eht evah
otni
emoc
ot
detcepxe
eht
fo ecitcarp ylbanosaer
detalosi
tcudorp
rehtehw n·
fo
noitaredisnoc ecneuqes
t·___sum
fo
osla dna
erutan
ssecorp eht
deyolpme
eht
levon eht fo
noitaredisnoc
.tluser
na
evlovni
na
noitarebileD fo seires
detcepxe
smialc
ot
esir
·of
fo
t·___sum eussi siht no gnivig sessecorp
dellac si
suoivbo
si
eht
yb
ecitcarp
eht
esohw
sessecorp fo seires eht ereh eussi
ehT
rehtehw
eussi
dlohserht
si
detneserp
.elbatnetap
eb tonnac detcepxe eht gniveihca ylerem ,noitinifed yb ,esuaceb evitagen ylbairavni si ytilibatnetap laitnetop no noitarebiled fo emoctuo eht ,esac a hcus nI .tcudorp wen a fo noitamrof ot deilppa eb ot ti gnisuac yb ro lairetam gnitrats wen a ot noitacilppa sti rof gnillac yb zlerem rettam tcejbus elbatnetap fo erutats eht ot deppartstoob eb detcepxe yleritne sti gnidivorp ,ssecorp suoivbo
nac
,tluser
·ldedecnqc
taht
ton
a
rehtehw
:truoC
nedruD
eht
erofeb
saw
hcihw
si
,erofereht
,ereh detneserp eussi ehT
.llec tsoh
eht
fo
ueilim
lacimehcoib
xelpmoc yletinifni eht nihtiw lla ,ecneuqes
editpepylop detalsnart eht yb Z llanif dna ,AND eht fo tpircsnart &NRm eht yb neht ,ecneuqes AND levon eht yb tsrif cificeps a ni snoitcaer ralullec laudivid·i
detcerid
redro
xelpmoc
s'llec
fo
sdnasuoht
sah
yllaretil demrofrep
ro neve
eb ot
niamer
ereht
,deveihca neeb
tsoh
noitcefsnart retfa
noitamrofsnart
detacidni
sA
lacigoloib
.ssecorp
eht
,reilrae
lacimehc elgnis a naht rehtar sessecorp lacigoloib dairym sevlovni ylsuoucipsnoc smialc tneserp eht fo rettam tcejbus yletelpmoc era esac tneserp eht ni ssen
ehT
.tnereffid
-suoivbo
fo
noitanimreted
a
ot
tnaveler
stcaf
ehT
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 312-14
Filed 03/05/2007
Page 14 of 22
81235900
CTI-MA
155861076MA
t52
41
.ssensuoivbonon
fo
eussi
eht
no
evitaborp ylhgih si
eht
a
deeccus ot
a
ti
gnitcepxe
taht
rof
tra
ni
sisab
laitnatsbus
ni
fo
ecnesba eht ni
a
tluser
eht
derised
gnidivorp
ot
sdeeccus
ssecorp
tcaf
a
tub
,htiw nigeb
ot
suoivbo
tonnac
¥ldedecnoc
tluser
a
si
hcihw
ssecorp
sucivbonon
mrofsnart
,detats yletanretlA
dna tnaveler
.snoitaredisnoc
ssensuoivbo ot
laireta·
ylniatrec si noitnevni demialc s'tnacllppA fo ecitcarp eht ,metsys tnanibmocer yna ni
fo tluser lufsseccus eht edam eb
tra
dluoc
lairetam evitca laitnatsbus
oviv ni
on saw
eht
eht
ni
sisab
ereht
taht gniveileb rof dna y·ob namuh eht namuh detalysocylg saw gnihton
nwonk
ni ecnetsixe otni semoc nlteioporhtyre gnirrucco-yllarutan woh ylesicerp tuo·a yllautriv ,ereh sa ,erehW .etairporppa
eb
yam
eht
ssensuoivbo
dael
wen
fo
tra
esu
gnidnif
eht eutriv
a
,tcepxe
taht
ot
nasitra
delliks
dluow
a
roirp
fo
hcihw
ylno si
eht
)lairetam gnitrats
tluser
eht
fo
yb "wen" revewoh(
fo
erutan
erehW tuohtiw
a
.deveihca
edam eb
tluser. eht
reve nac
no
gniredisnoc
Eo
sessecorp
evitalupinam
on
seires
fo
ssensuoivbo
eht eht
noitarebiled
,elbatnetap ti
yam
redner 7 lirassecen ton
eht
tcudorp
eht
a
gnikam rof ssecor· )ytilibatnetap
fo
.eurt
ton
,deedni(
y·levon
elihW
ylpmis
si
sihT
.ssecorp eht fo
ssensuoivbo
gninimreted
fo
sesoprup
demialc
.C.F.A.C
rof ytilairetan·i fo paeh knuj eht ot tcudorp s'ssecorp ·eitreporp qnidrager ecnedive detageler sah
a
fo
eht
taht .oN
etacidni ot
laireS ni
noisiced
nedruD eht
seurtsnoc
892,576
noitisop
s'renimaxE ehT
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 312-14
Filed 03/05/2007
Page 15 of 22
91235900
CTI-MA
255861076MA
252
51
nihtiw
ni
,...reenigne ,...citeneg ,tnanibmocer ecarbme ot denifed saw )"tnanibmoceR"( i .oN tpecnoC .sesab atad owt eht etisopmoc tupni edivorp ot syaw suoirav
smret
hcraes
denibmoc
erew
stpecnoc ehT
hcihw fo eht Eo
hcae
.smret
hcraes
evitanretla ruof
fo tnem
cificeps detaroprocni
-poleved devlovni
,"stpecnoC"
hcraes
tamrof
lareneg ehT
.mrof evitca yllacf·oloib oviv ni nf snletorpocylg etagilbo namuh ·o noitaraperp tnanibmocer eht ot ecnav -eler evah yam hcihw snoitacilbup rof sesa· atad "stcartsbA laclmehC'° dna "enlldeM" ni demrofrep eb ot hcraes detsissa tnacilppA ,seussi ytilibatnetap lla
-retupmoc
a
desuac
sah
fo
noitaredisnoc
ylrae etatilicaf
ot
tpmetta
na
nI
noitcudorP
trA
nietorpocyiG
fo
gnisolcsiD secnerefeR
ecnaveleR
tnanibmoceR fo
kcaL
.4
roirP
.tcudorp evitca yllaci·oloibo·____viv nq._i na gnidivorp ni deeccus dluow sessecorp hcus fo ecitcarp eht taht noitatcepxe elbanosaer yna ron ,96-56 smialc fo sessecorp eht ecitcarp ot noitseggus on edivorp suht yehT .snietorpocylg fo'noitcudorp tnanibmocer gninrecnoc tnelis yleritne era serusolcsid eht ,snietorp noisuf detropsnart ni gnitluser dna seneg noisuf otni detaroprocni langis "yroterces" suonegoxe dna suonegodne
secneuqes fo dootsrednu
niereh
era
gnissecorpf·_____loc.E gninrecnoc
evah
ecnerefer
revetahW
eht
morf
thgim nasitra delllks
eht
a
.demialc;
800'
eht
rettam.tcejbus
siht
fo
morf
tcnitsid
ehT
ylsuoucipsnoc
ssecorp ot
te
ecnerefer
serusolcsid
.tnetaP
fo
tnenitrep
eht
noitucesorp gnirud detneserp yllaitini smialc sa eht yb ecnerefer .la
renimaxE
a
·etic
sa
egdamlaT
fO
ypoc
si
"D"
tibihxE
otereh
dehcattA
ehT
.3
e·damlaT
kcaL
eht
ecnerefeR .La te fo ecnaveleR fo
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 312-14
Filed 03/05/2007
Page 16 of 22
02235900
CTI-MA
355861076MA
352
61
namuh
fo
fo
noisserpxe
tnanibmocer
ro
,snietorpoc¥lg
namuh-non
noisserpxe tnanibmocer htiw tlae· yllareneg secnerefer
eht
,yltnenimmi
eht
dettimbus eb ot
deludeho·tnemetatS
tuo
ot
tes
9441-OTP
ni
liated
·etaerg
dekram
ni
SA
.tnaveler eb
ecnerefer
eht
deraeppa hcihw
"X"
der
a
htiw
sah
"E"
eht
lesnuoc
s'tnacilppA
sa
,stroper
era
eseht nO stroper
.otereh
hcraes
tibihxE
fo
dehcatta
detareneg
seipoC
nrut X
ni
dna
stcartsba
94
evoba
"tnanibmocer" dna )stcartsba
94
.)stcartsba 56 gnidivorp eht gnidulcxe( "snietorp" gnidivorp( "nailammam"
-/"senil llec"
eht
no
X
desab
erew
4891-3691
"nietorp" X "tnanibmocer" setisopmoc doirep eht rof sehcraes tcartsbA
871
X
lacimehC
,ylralimiS
X
.)stcartsba
"snietorp"
"senil llec" X
sulp "nailammam"
26
-tnanibmocer" dna
gnllaever( "noisserpxe" )stcartsba
X
qnilaever(
eht
"snietorp"
-tnanibtaocer"erew
stpecnoc
fo
etisopmoc eht rof detcudnoc
sehcraes
saw
4891-6691 ecarbme
doirep eht rof
ot
enildeM
.lammam dna
namuh
denifed
,ICSB
saw
,1VC
,...ravo 3
)"seniL lleC"{
.oN
)"nailammaM"| 4 .oN tpecnoC .SOC ,KHB retsmah esenihc ,OHC ecarbme ot denifed tpecnoC .noitamrofnoc etardyhobrac
,erutcurtsetardyhobrac ,...talysocylg ,nilubolgoyrht
,niteiopobmorht ,snacylgoetorp ,c nietorp ,nibol·otpah ,nacylgoditpep ,snicum ,nletorpocum ,nirre·otcal
enarbmem ecarbme ot
,nibihni ,nixepomeh ,fsc ,nidiva ,snietorpocylgolaisa· ,dio1¥ma ,snietorpocy19 ,ninimal ,nitcenorbif ,nirhtalc ,emosonapyrt ,}s{rotpecer ,snietorp ecafrus ,snietorp tpecnoC
denifed
saw
)"snietorP"(
2
.oN
AND
.)s{nietorp tnanibmocer ,)ylno enildeM[ sisehtnysoib ,)ylno enildeM( ANRm ,...golonhce·oib ,niteioporhtyrEr ,denolc/gninolc ,gninolc ralucelom
.,ANDc ,ANDr
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 312-14
Filed 03/05/2007
Page 17 of 22
12235900
CTI -MA
455861076MA
452
71
fo
noitseggus
ro
erusolcsid
on
sniatnoc
rof
.late
acinneP
suhT
.stcudorp devired-lloc.E
eht
ytivitca laci·ololb
oviv
gnitseggus atsdo.n sedulcni ,esruoc ·o ·dna )022 egap no hpargarap etamitlune· ees( stcudo·p noisserpxe iloc.E deta1¥socylg-non htiw ylevisulcxe slaed ecnerefer .late acinneP 3891 eht ,revewoh ,APt fo noisserpxe llec nailammam fo noitpircsed a gnidivorp sa .late nelloC ni noita·i etipseD .otereh "G" tibihxE sa dehcatta
-retcarahc ecnerefer
sdohteM
sti
si
dna
.late
egap
aclnneP
detic ehT
siht
).2 enil
ro·
,slaireta·
·22-412
,741
eeS(
..esoprup
)3891[
tub
,103
saw
,erutaN
,.late
seinneP ot
·lec
setic
tsoh
ehT
rehtar
deraperp
namu·
tcudorp noisserpxe
ton
nallammam tnanibmocer
eht
woh
ebircsed
na
seod
ecnerefer
etagilbo
erahs
gnieb Eo citsiretcarahc
eht
.nietorpocylq nlteioporht·re
htiw
ot
rotavitca
rof
tnacilppa yb deveileb si &Pt gnirrucco yllarutaN negonimsalp epyt-eussit na·h tnanibmocer
slsob·orht niev
raluguj
tibbar
susrev
ytivitca
dna
lacigoloib
42·,165
.soN
oviv
laireS
n· citylobmorht sebircsel· )581,285 noitacilppa tnerap nI
lacigololb ovlv ni dna noisserpxe llec SOC s'tnacilppA retfa llew dehsilbup
laitini ro·
detroper ytivitca fo noitpircsed noitacllbup
dna
detpecca(
elcitra
.late
nelloC ehT
sa
tibihxE
otereh
dehcatta si
noitacilbup eht fo ypoc A .rotavitca negonimsalp eussi· ot gnitaler }4891( 251-641 ,I!._.32 ,scitueparehT .tpxE & .mrahP.J ,.late nelloC saw nletorpocylg namuh etagilbo evitca noitcudorp tnanibmocer ot etaler
oviv ni
na
fo
ot
deraeppa hcihw detacol ecnerefer ylno ehT .snietorpooylg etagilbo namuh fo stnemgarf fo noisserpxe tnanlbmocer
ro
,ytivitca
oviv n·
rof
ton
od dna
snietorpocylg etagilbo
noitalysocylg eriuqer ton hcihw.snletorpocylg
era
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 312-14
Filed 03/05/2007
Page 18 of 22
22235900
CTI -MA
555861076MA
81
etagilbo na fo noitcudorp eht fo noi·artsnomed?n edivo·p snoitacilppa tnetap dehsilbup.hcetneneG eht ,suhT .ytivitca
lacigoloib oviv
niatnoc eht
ni
fo
syassa
lufsseccus
ot
yna ot
ron on
stcudorp tnanibmocer eht fo noitalysocylg yeht
tub si·ec tsoh
ecnereger
fo
nailammam ni
esehT .4891
APt
noitcudorp
sserdda
dna
060
snoitacilbup
.S.O
fo
tsuguA etal ni
dehsilbup
erew
sgnilif
711 0
3891 711 0
dna
950
,yraunaJ no desab yldetrsssa snoitacilppA OPE
)deilppus sisahpmE( .lairetam evitan eht htiw derapmoc tnetxe ressel EO reraer9 a ot noital·soc·1g detaicossa niatnoc yam fo·-he rotavitca negonimsalp eussit namuh eht ,llec tsoh eht ·opu gnidne·ed ,noitidda nI
egap ta sraeppa dna
raelc llec
"noitnevnI
saw
eht .fo
yrammuS"
hcus
eht
ni
evitaluceps yleritne ylno
tsoh
smetsys
fo
noitnem
ehT
.noitcudorp
esu
APt
nailammam fo ek·1
fo
rof smetsys noisserpxe noitpircsed o__n sniatnoc
,.ta te
kcab
acinne·
,tnemucod
sihT
no
.)2891 ,yaM hguorht
desab
390 0
sa
gnitad snoitacilppA .tnetaP
3891
.S.U
saw
yletamitlu
OPE otereh
saw
dna|
,rebmevoN ni dehsilbup
dna "I"
916
,"H'!
stibihxE
dehcatta
era dna detacol ere· hcetneneG yb delif snoitacilppA tnetaP naeporuE dehsilbup eerhT .esab atad xednI stnetaP dlroW tnewreD eht ni snoitacilppa hcus rof detcudnoc saw hcraes a ,&Pt nam·h tnanibmocer fo noitcudorp ·lec nailammam thgim snoitacilppa tnetap dehsilbup
gninrecnoc
tsixe
rehtehw
enimreted ot
tpmetta tneuqesbus
.95-56 smialc ni
a
nI
tuo
tes
taht
ot
suogolana lla ta eb thgim hcihw nietorpocylg namuh etagi1bo noitcudorp rof ssecorp a fo ecitcarp lufsseccus
na
fo
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 312-14
Filed 03/05/2007
Page 19 of 22
32235900
CTI -MA
655861076MA
652
91
ynomrah lagel etelpmoc ni si smialc
.C.S.U 53
reporp
on
eht
fo
ecnawollA
.301$
sisab
rednu taht
smialc
eht
fo
noitcejer rof stsixe
on
,ylgnldrQcca ,dna tnacilppA .yb decitcarp
suoivbo yaw
ni
erew
yllanigiro
sessecorp eht
nehw
demlalc
niereh
taht
stimbus
ylluftcepser tnacilppA
.ytivitca lacigoloib oviv ni rof dedeen noltalysocylg dna ecneuqes dica onima eht gnivah tcudorp niteioporhtyre namuh a gnidlely ni deeccus ot detcepxe neeb evah ylbanosaer dluoc smialc tneserp eht yb debircsed sa noitalosi dna noltalysocylg ,noitalsnart ,noitpircsnart ,noitcefsnart/nolt·rofsnart eht taht gnidivorp ,esac nedruD eht ni gnitsixe
gnitressa
rof
sisab
a
taht ot
suogolana
lla
ts ton
eb
dluow
hcihw
taht
ton
tra
eht ni
noitam
-rofni fo
eb
tsum
ydob
yna
tsixe
did
ereht
raelc
yltnadnuba
.evoba
ti
,revewoh-,esac eht si siht
ro
rehtehW
debircsed sehcraes eht ni noitceted depacse ylpmis troper eht taht dna krow s'tnacilppA ot roirp e·it a ta detroper thgim nietorp evitca na hcus fo noisserpxe
neeb
evah
llec
nallammam
lufsseccu·.fo
ecnatsni
na
taht
elbissop si
tI
.smialc
-tuo ton
tneserp eht fo
si
ytilibatnetap
ot
fo
evitanimreted
emoc
tcepser siht ni deeccus
tsrif eht
yletulosba
tcaf ni saw tnacilpp& rehtehw ,esruoc fO .nietorp -ocylg namuh etagilbo evitca yllaclgoloib oviv ni na fo
noit
-cudorp
eht
lufsseccus
erew
eht
fo
secnatsni
,tsrif e·.__ht
ton
fi
,tsrif
gnoma
3891
a
noitacidni
-evoba eht
raelc £o
ni decitcarp sa sdohtem demialc eht taht edivorp sisylana dna sehcraes debircsed
eht taht
stluser
stimbus smialc
tnacilppA
tneserp fO sdohtem
.96-56
eht
ot
fo ecitcarp eht ni sseccus fo noitatcepxe elbanosaer yna ,ygolana yb ,esir evig thgim sa hcus nietorpocylg nmauh
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 312-14
Filed 03/05/2007
Page 20 of 22
42235900
CTI-MA
755861076MA
7'b2
02
sionillI
30605 azalP
,ogacihC
stnacilppA rof syenrottA
mriF eht
fo r
sionlllI ,ogacihC lanoitaN tsriF owT
rebmeM A
lea c·M
0575-643
)213(
)744,52
.oN
geR·
nuroB
,NIETSREG ,ELOOT'O ,LLAHSRAM
LLENKCIB
&
yARRUM
,dettimbus ylluftcepseR
.deticllos si foereht eciton ylrae
-wolla rof
eca
na
dna
ecn·
noitidnoc ni
skramer
era
96-56
smialc
taht
hsilbatse ot ehT
develleb
dna
stnemdnema
NOISULCNOC
gniogerof
.deniatta tcudorp elbaulav eht
ot
edivorp
sseco=p
detcepxe neeb evah ton
er
dluoc
eht
demialc
niereh
esuaceb nedruD
n_I ni
.C.P.&.C eht fo gnilu· eht htlw
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 312-14
Filed 03/05/2007
Page 21 of 22
52235900
CTI -MA
855861076MA
·2
6891
,42 yaM
sionillI
,ogacihC
)744,52 .oN .qeR{
0575-543 )213( sioni11I ,ogacihC 306·6 azalP lanoitaN tsriF owT stnacilppA rof syenrottA eht fo rebmeM A nutoB .F leahcI·
mriF
,NIETSREG
LLENKCIB & YARRUM ,ELOOT'O ,LLAHSRAM
,dettimbus yllufncepseR
.8891
,42 yaM
fo
no
,13202
.C.D
:ot
,motqnihsaW ,skramedarT
desserdda
setatS taht
dna
stnetaP
renoissimmoC
sa
epolevne
na
n· htiw
I
liam ssalc
-£srif
ecivreS
latsoP
detinU eht
detisoped
:riS
gnieb
si
ecnednopserroc
s·ht
yfitreo ybereh
stnetaP
.C.D ,notgnihsaW 13202 skramedarT dna fo renoissimmoC .noH
·l·ILI,· FO ETACIFITREC
)7891 ,72 rebot·/no 800,307,4 .S.U sa deussi ,4891 ,03 rebmevoR delif ,892,576 .N.S no desaB{
ztlohnenaT
.A
**)detcepxE(
"·'·"
renimaxE
trA
7891
,32
rebotcO
.oN
:deliF
laireS
puorG
971,311
·IL
··"__
·y
n
it
eiopor htyrE
noitcudorP#
NEUK-UF
fO
fo
noitaci
lpp·'·
"["
TNETAP
SETATS
DETINU
EH, NI
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 312-14
Filed 03/05/2007
Page 22 of 22
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?