Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al

Filing 567

DECLARATION of Linda A. Sasaki-Baxley in Support of Amgen Inc.'s Opposition to Roche's Motion for Summary Judgment That Claim 1 of the '422 Patent is Invalid Under 35 U.S.C. Sec. 112 by Amgen Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit Ex. A#2 Exhibit Ex. B#3 Exhibit Ex. C)(Rich, Patricia)

Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-2

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 1 of 15

Dockets.Justia.com

211 .S CSU 53 rednU dilavnI si tnetaP 224' fO 1 mialC taht tnemgduJ yrammuS rof noitoM s'ehcoR oT noitisoppO s'negmA fo troppuS ni .lceD yelxaB

A TIBIHXE

Doc. 567 Att. 1

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

8077

.ON

.R.S.C

,retlaP

nalA

yrraH

:yb detropeR

).redro

evitcetorp eht htiw ecnadrocca ni tpircsnart eritne eht taert .redrO evitcetorP dednemA esaelP eht fo )c(5 noitceS rep sa laitnedifnoc detangised ynomitset sniatnoc tpircsnart sihT(
7002 AINROFILAC
I .D.HP

,82

HCRAM EKALTSEW

,EGALLIV
EMULOV
FO

,NIL

NEUK-UF

NOITISOPED

DEPATOEDIV

.stnadnefeD

,noitaroproC

,.DTL
YGW-73221-VC-50
.oN

yesreJ weN a ,.CNI ,EHCOR AL-NNAMFFOH dna ,ynapmoC namreG a ,HbmG SCITSONGAID ,ynapmoC ssiwS a EHCOR ,EHCOR AL-NNAMFFOH .F
oV

noitcA

liviC

,ffitnialP
,.CNI ,NEGMA

yp oC deifitreC
7002/8213

STTESUHCASSAM TRUOC TCIRTSID

FO

TCIRTSID DETINU

SETATS

LAITNEDIFNOC emuloV- .D.hP ,niL neuK-uF fo noitisopeD

)6()b(03

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-2

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 2 of 15

2

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

52
42

32
22 12

02 91
:liam-E

moc.relohcseyak@nanoond moc.relohcseyak@kinehcepg moc.relohcseyak@imanebI
9868.638.212 8953-22001
xaF

3027.638.212
weN 524

81 71 61

.qsE

,nanooN

kroY weN ,kroY eunevA kraP elleinaD
maharG
aroeL

.qsE ,kinehceP .qsE ,imA-neB
PLL

relohcS

:yB eyaK
:stnadnefeD
roF

51
41 31

moconegma@ydnew
0001.744.508

:liam-E 21
II 0i

9971-02319

.qsE

ainrofilaC ,skaO dnasuohT evirD retneC negmA enO :yB ,drofetihW ydneW negmA

moc.reebesacyad@namdlogb moc.reebesacyad@mddirdam
:liam-E
0220.378.804 xaF 0110.378.804 41059 ainrofilaC ,onitrepuC

9
8
7

6 5
4
roF

004 etiuS draveluoB keerC snevetS 00302 .qsE ,namdloG .R eirreB .qsE ,dirdaM .M divaD :yB PLL redlehctaB
&

dirdaM

reebesaC

yaD
:sffitnialP

3 2

:secnaraeppA
LAITNEDIFNOC 7002/82/3
emuloV- .D.hP

1

,niL neuK-uF fo noitisopeD )6()b(03
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 567-2

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 3 of 15

3

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

.ainrofilaC
eht rof dna

fo

etatS

52 42 32
22 12

ni

,8077

.oN

retropeR dnahtrohS
,.m.p
71:5

deifitreC
ot
.m.a
no

,retlaP nalA yrraH erofeb
61:9

morf

,7002

,82

hcraM

,yadsendeW
,evirD
nekat

,ainrofilaC
owT

,egalliV
snosaeS

ekaltseW eht
ta

eloD

,letoH

ruoF

02 91 81
71

,.D.HP

,NIL

NEUK-UF

FO

NOITISOPED

DEPATOEDIV

61
51 41 31

21
ii 0i

9 8
7

6 5

rehpargoediV

,ortsaC

enairdA
:tneserP

4
oslA

3
2

:secnaraeppA

1

7002/8213

LAITNEDIFNOC emuloV- .D.hP ,niL neuK-uF fo noitisopeD

)6()b(03

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-2

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 4 of 15

4

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

52
42

32 22 12

02 91
81
71

61
51

41
31 21

ii
0i

9
8
9
EGAP

IMA-NEB

.SM

YB

7

NOITANIMAXE

6
5

I

emuloV
neuK-uF :SSENTIW

4

.D.hP

,niL

3
2

XEDNI

1

LAITNEDIFNOC 7002/82/3
emuloV- .D.hP

,niL neuK-uF fo noitisopeD )6()b(03
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 567-2

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 5 of 15

5

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

52 42 32
21

hguorht
.son

CTI-MA CTI-MA
te 571 98.11.8

06031100 90031100 setaB ,.la

,.cte ,lacituecamrahP iaguhC
detad

.sv negmA ni tprecxe lairT

TIBIHXE

22
651

teehsdaerps
)21-1 .SON(

roloc

nodoC

ii

TIBIHXE

12

seirotagorretnI
fo
teS

tsriF
0i TIBIHXE

02
91

'stnadnefeD
721

ot

esnopseR
.S.U
.S.U .S.U
.S.U .S.U .S.U

latnemelppuS s'ffitnialP
224,559,5
080,126,5 943,657,5 896,816,5 339,745,5
868,144,5
.oN
.oN .oN .oN .oN
.oN

13
13 13

tnetaP tnetaP tnetaP tnetaP
tnetaP tnetaP

9
8 7

TIBIHXE TIBIHXE
TIBIHXE TIBIHXE TIBIHXE TIBIHXE

81
71

61 51
41 31

13
13 13

6
5
4

ffodzorD morf samohT
0I

rimidalV
3 TIBIHXE

21
ii 0i 9
2

ot edeaG .G mailliW 70.31.3 detad retteL

gniMelF
morf dna nosraC aicirtaP ot edeaG .G mailliW 70.6.3 detad retteL
ot

TIBIHXE

8

)6( )b(03 eluR negmA ot
0i

tnausruP

noitisopeD
'stnadnefeD
1 TIBIHXE

7 6

fo

ecitoN

tsriF

EGAP

NOITPIRCSED STIBIHXE
OT XEDNI

#

HXE

5 4

3
8077
.oN RSC

,retlaP
.sv

.A

yrraH
2 1

7002 ,82 hcraM ehcoRaL-namffoH
I

,yadsendeW
negmA
NEUK-UF

EMULOV

,.D.HP

,NIL

7002/82/3

LAITNEDIFNOC emuloV- .D.hP ,niL neuK-uF fo noitisopeD

)6()b(03

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-2

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 6 of 15

6

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

52
42
32

22 12 02

91
81 71
61

51
41

31
21 ii 0i
CTI-MA CTI-MA
te

78631100 hguorht 20631100 .son setaB ,.la

9
8
51

,.cte
detad

,lacituecamrahP
TIBIHXE

212

98.12.8

iaguhC .sv negmA ni tprecxe lairT hguorht
60631100 20631100

7 6 5 4

CTI-MA CTI-MA
te

,.cte
detad

.son setaB ,.la ,lacituecamrahP .sv negmA ni tprecxe lairT

iaguhC
881

98.12.8

41

TIBIHXE

3
2
31
.son

681

morf

28617100 CTI-MA ot 08617100 CTI-MA setaB ,niL neuK-uF 28.22.11 detad omeM

TIBIHXE

1

LAITNEDIFNOC
7002/82/3
emuloV- .D.hP

,niL neuK-uF fo noitisopeD )6()b(03
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 567-2

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 7 of 15

7

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

03:81:90
72:81:90 22:81:90 12:81:90 81:81:90 61:81:90 01:81:90 70:81:90 30:81:90 20:81:90 85:71:90 75:71:90
35:71:90 15:71:90 54:71:90
24:71:90

ta
no

ecalp gnikat si
nekat

dna

tnadnefed

eht

fo

flaheb

52
42

gnieb

si

noitisoped s'yadoT
.ecivreS flaheb
no

32 22

dlroW

etoNeviL

fo dna

gnitroper
nosluaP
ehT
truoc

,secivreS
fo

noitagitiL
yrraH si

gnitropeR

retlaP

12 02

yadot retroper

.0032-123

)514(
naS

91
81 71
61

rebmun

enohP

.50149

ainrofilaC

,ocsicnarF
ta

,0521

etiuS

,teertS niaM 122

detacol

,ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
enairdA

gnitneserper
ehT

,ortsaC

si

yadot rotarepo oediv

51
.M.A 61:9

41 31 21 ii 0i 9 8
7

si

rotinom

oediv
.82

eht

no

emit
etad

eht

dnA

hcraM
VC

si

s'yadoT
.,sttesuhcassaM
.S.U

.YGW

73221

50

rebmun

esac

fo ni

tcirtsiD

,truoC

tcirtsiD

eht eht

93:71:90 43:71:90 33:71:90 10:71:90 10:71:90

,ehcoRaL-namffoH
,I
emulov

susrev

negmA fo

rettam

ni

,i

epat

,.D.hP
eht

,niL

neuK-uF
ereH
EHT

.rD

fo

noitisoped depatoediv
.drocer
no

snigeb

er'eW

:REHPARGOEDIV

6 5
4

.M.A

61:9

3
2 1

7002

,82

HCRAM

,YADSENDEW
EKALTSEW

AINROFILAC

,EGALLIV

LAITNEDIFNOC 7002/82/3
emuloV- .D.hP

,niL neuK-uF fo noitisopeD )6()b(03
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 567-2

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 8 of 15

8

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

52
42
62:91:90 81:91:90

32
.ssentiw
truoc

eht

ni

raews

esaelp retroper
EHT

22
12

71:91:90
31:91:90 11:91:90
90:91:90

eht

dluoW

:REHPARGOEDIV

.cnI

,negmA

02

rof

drofetihW

ydneW
ym

:DROFETIHW

.SM

91
.namdloG

81 71

70:91:90 50:91:90 30:91:90
00:91:90 85:81:90 65:81:90 55:81:90 25:81:90 15:81:90

eirreB

,eugaelloc

htiw .niL

ereh

m'I .rD
no

neuK-uF

,ssentiw
reebesaC

61 51
41

eht

dna

,.cnI

,negmA fo

flaheb

yaD fo dirdaM divaD

:DIRDAM

.RM

.stnadnefed

rof
.SM

relohcS

31 21

eyaK fo

nanooN

elleinaD .stnadnefed

:NANOON

rof

relohcS
.RM

eyaK fo

ii 0i

osla

,kinehceP maharG

:KINEHCEP

.sevlesmeht
ohw

ecudortni
dnA

lliw

9

94:81:90
94:81:90 64:81:90

seugaelloc

owt

era

em

htiw
.ehcoR

8
7

gnitneserper
m'I .SM

,relohcS

eyaK morf

imA-neB
.seY

aroeL

6
5
etats

54:81:90

:IM·-NEB

34:81:90
14:81:90 73:81:90

.tneserper

uoy

ohw

dna

4

sevlesruoy
.26319

ecudortni

esaelp

,lesnuoC
ekaltseW
snosaeS

3

ainrofilaC ,mooR
ekaltseW

,egalliV
,letoH

,evirD
eht

2
1

23:81:90

eloD 2

ruoF

7002/82/3

LAITNEDIFNOC emuloV- .D.hP ,niL neuK-uF fo noitisopeD

)6()b(03

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-2

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 9 of 15

9

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008 ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

64:91:90 64:91:90 54:91:90 34:91:90
14:91:90

?erofeb

desoped

neeb

ev'uoY

52

.yakO
.od I
?kaerb taht
evah
a

Q
A

42 32 22

,seY
fi

ekat taht

ot

deen

uoy

,ytinutroppo
dnA fO

uoy

dnatsrednu

uoy

12

04:91:90 04:91:90
83:91:90

.esruoc

Q
ot

02
emit 91 81

.sey morf

,emit
tuB

,skaerb ekat

ot

deen

dluow I

63:91:90 43:91:90
33:91:90 33:91:90 13:91:90
03:91:90 tonnac

.oN

A

71 61
51

?ssenderitrevo

on

;nosaer

lacidem

oN .oN

Q
A

?yadot yfitset
uoy taht
nosaer

41
31

yna

ereht

sI

.rotcoD

,gninrom

dooG
:IMA-NEB

Q
.SM YB

21 II 0I

92:91:90
92:91:90 92:91:90 82:91:90 82:91:90 72:91:90 NOITANIMAXE

9
.uoy knahT
:IMA-NEB
.SM
EHT

8 7 6
:swollof

.nigeb

esaelP

:REHPARGOEDIV

5
4

sa

deifitset
erudecorP ni htao
na

dna

denimaxe
fo

saw

,4902

noitceS

liviC

edoC

htiw

ecnadrocca
neeb

3
2 1

deretsinimda

ylud

gnivah

,.D.HP

,NIL

NEIIK-UF

LAITNEDIFNOC 7002/82/3
emuloV- .D.hP ,niL neuK-uF fo

noitisopeD )6()b(03
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-2

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 10 of 15

77

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008 ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

44:95:01
34:95:01
24:95:01

.noitcejbO
.tcerroc

:DIRDAM

.RM

52
A

syawla
uoy

s'ti

,oN

42 32 22 12

?tcerrocni
saw

04:95:01 73:95:01
63:95:01

taht .sey

taht
,eneg

enimreted
eht morf

did

nehW

Q

decuded

s'tahT s'tahT
661
A

.thgir
?sdica ni
ecneuqes

02 91 81
71 61 51

23:95:01 92:95:01
62:95:01

onima
eht

si 6

erugif
uoy

dica

onima

taht
uoy

desolcsid Q

,stnetap eht ni

taht

llacer

,lleW

62:95:01 22:95:01 02:95:01
71:95:01 71:95:01 41:95:01 ·.1:95:0i 70:95:01 30:95:01 65:85:01
saw

.wonk
taht nehw

t'nod I t'nod I
uoy
tuB

.denimreted
A

wonk

?taht

denimreted

dah

,4891

41 31

,03

rebmevoN

yb

,saw

noitseuq

ym

.yakO
.sey

Q

21 ii

,561

sa ew

stsixe

ti

tuB
neve

.denimreted

ton

evah

hguoht

,eneg

eht

0i 9 8
7

yb

,sllec eht yb desserpxe
sa

s'ti

nehw

,flesti
eht
A

tcudorp

eht
ew

ni
nehw

stsixe
wonk

ecneuqes

tub

,taht

denimreted

t'nod I

55:85:01
05:85:01 64:85:01 54:85:01 44:85:01 44:85:01 ?snaem

?sdica onima
eht taht
561

6 5 4 3 2

si

OPE

namuh

fo

erutcurts oS .seY

yramirp

enimreted

negmA did nehw

taht

tahw

taht

sI
A

.tcerroc

s'tahT

1

7002/82/3

LAITNEDIFNOC emuloV- .D.hP ,niL neuK-uF fo noitisopeD

)6()b(03

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-2

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 11 of 15

87

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008 ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

12:00:11 91:00:11

?4891

,03
oS

rebmevoN

52 42

retfa

denrael

ylno

taht

saw

61:00:11
61:00:11 31:00:11 0I:00:iI 70:00:11 40:00:11 40:00:11
30:00:11

.yakO
.sey

Q

32
sa

,561

22 12
02

sllec
ew

eht

yb

edam

saw

ti

wenk
ew

eW

.ti

ecneuqes ecneuqes

,nietorp hguone
ew

evah

nehw
,no

evah

,nietorp
onima

eht .evah eht

ew

retal
A

,nehw

91 81
71

sdica

lautca

ehT

?ti

si

tahW .decuded

61 51

10:00:ii 10:00:iI
85:95:01

ton

,si ti tahw uoy gniksa

m'I

tuB

.yakO
.eneg

Q
A

41 31
OPE

eht

morf

decuded

sA 661

65:95:01
35:95:01 25:95:01 25:95:01

?sdica
namuh

onima
eht
oS

si

21 iI

fo

ecneuqes

dica

onima

Q
.SM
YB

:IMA-NEB
.tcerroc .tcerroc

0I 9

si

661
EHT I

15:95:01
05:95:01 05:95:01 74:95:01

s'tI

.seY

:SSENTIW

8
7
.ecneuqes

.raelc

eb

ot

tnaw

6 5 4

dica

onima

eht

tuoba
.oN

gniklat
:IMA-NEB

m'I .SM
.tcerroc

74:95:01 64:95:01 54:95:01
54:95:01

3 2 1

syawla

si

eneg

ehT

:SSENTIW

EHT

.noitcejbO

7002/82/3

LAITNEDIFNOC emuloV- .D.hP ,niL neuK-uF fo noitisopeD

)6()b(03

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-2

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 12 of 15

322

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

60:92:51 40:92:51 20:92:51 85:82:51 55:82:51 35:82:51 94:82:51
94:82:51 s'tI

?thgir
esuaceb
.661

;ecneuqes

redael
s'tI

eht

sah

ti

52 42 32 22
12

,tahtnaht reggib
s'tI

neve

Q

.eneg
s'tI

eht

yb deificeps
si

:eneg

eht

yb
eht

edam
sa

.561

etalosi

uoy

tcudorp

yb

edam

sA A

.tcerroc

s'taht

,haeY

02
91 81
71

?thgir
;sdica onima
ni debircsed si
taht
561

sah

ylno noitacificeps
ni
deterces eht
oS

eht

64:82:51 14:82:51
63:82:51

ssecorp
OPE

eht

yllautca
Q
ssecorp

tnanibmocer

61
51 41 31 21 ii

.gniterces
eht ni devomer
tub eht

fo

33:82:51 92:82:51
52:82:51 22:82:51 12:82:51 31:82:51 90:82:51 50:82:51 20:82:51 00:82:51 95:72:51 85:72:51

si

dica
si

onima

tsal

eht

,wohemos
onima
otni

,661

osla
eno

ylbaborp
s'ti
,eneg .eneg

dica

gnikam

gnikam
nehw

,sllec eht
eht
eht
oS

detcefsnart

s'ti

morf ni

decuded detats
A

0i 9
8

sa
sa

dica

onima
OPE

661

si

,6

erugif
ehT

,ecneuqes
?tcerroc 561

namuh

erutam

;seudiser dica onima deificeps
sedulcni
onima
OPE

7 6 5

ylno
dica

namuh

erutam

eht

fo

ecneuqes

eht

,tcaf

nI

Q
.SM
YB

:IMA-NEB

4

.yaw

tnereffid

a

ti

ksa

ll'I
.SM

3 2 1

75:72:51
65:72:51

.yakO

:IMA-NEB

.suougibma

dna

eugaV

7002/82/3

LAITNEDIFNOC emuloV- .D.hP ,niL neuK-uF fo noitisopeD

)6()b(03

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-2

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 13 of 15

282

egaP
1 .txE

8663·845·008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

52 42 32

12

02
91

81
71
.D.hP

,niL

neuK-uF

61
51 41 31

.ainrofilaC
ta

21 ii 0i

02

fo
.tcerroc

yad
dna
eurt

siht

DETAD
sa

si
ym

,detcerroc
taht
raeppa
;em
sa

,niereh

9 8
7 6 5
4

deniatnoc

sa

ynomitset
,niereh
evah I
fo

yb delaitini
snoitcerroc
hcraM eht nekat
daer

,kni ni
hcus edam

deton

taht

;7002

,82

noitisoped
evah I

ym

tpircsnart gniogerof
fo

taht

yrujrep
,.D.hP

ytlanep
neuK-uF

rednu

yfitrec

ybereh

od

,niL

,I

3

2
YRUJREP
FO

YTLANEP

REDNU

NOITARALCED

1

LAITNEDIFNOC
7002/82/3 emuloV- .D.hP ,niL neuK-uF fo

noitisopeD )6()b(03
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-2

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 14 of 15

52

42
8077

".oN

RSC

,retlaP nalA yrraH

32 22
12

02
91

ym

debircsbus

evah I

,FOEREHW SSENTIW NI

·

·

·

siht

eman

81
71

61 .emit
dna taht taht
eurt

ta-nekat
a

sgnideecorp
eht

51
41

ynomitset

eht

fo

drocer

si

gniogerof

;noitcerid ym rednu
otni
debircsnart

noitpircsnart dedia-retupmoc
dna
em

31
21 11
01 9

retal
erew

yb yllacihpargonets
dna

detroper
eht taht

sgnideecorp

ynomitset
edoC

;4902

noitceS
htao

erudecorP

liviC fo

htiw

ecnadrocca ni eht fo

na deretsinimda ylud
eht

,noitisoped noitisoped

tnemeclremmoc

erofeb

,saw

8
7

gniogerof

eht

ni

deman

ssentiw eht

tahT

6

:yfitrec ybereh
od

5

,ainrofilaC

fo

etatS

eht

rof

dna ni

,retropeR
3
2

dnahtrohS

deifitreC

,retlaP nalA yrraH ,I

NOITACIFITREC

S'RETROPER

I

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-2

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 15 of 15