Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al

Filing 567

DECLARATION of Linda A. Sasaki-Baxley in Support of Amgen Inc.'s Opposition to Roche's Motion for Summary Judgment That Claim 1 of the '422 Patent is Invalid Under 35 U.S.C. Sec. 112 by Amgen Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit Ex. A#2 Exhibit Ex. B#3 Exhibit Ex. C)(Rich, Patricia)

Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-4

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 1 of 10

Dockets.Justia.com

211 .S CSU 53 rednU dilavnI si tnetaP 224' fO 1 mialC

taht tnemgduJ yrammuS rof noitoM s'ehcoR oT noitisoppO s'negmA fo troppuS ni .lceD yelxaB

C TIBIHXE

Doc. 567 Att. 3

81847900

CTI-MA

151091076MA

YGW-,·180 I-79 EVA tibihxE lairT

.D.hP

,ENWORB

.K YERFFEJ FO

NOITARALCED

LAES REDNU DELIF

REDRO EVITCETORP OT TCEJBUS LAITNEDIFNOC

) ) ) )

.stnadnefeD

,.CNI ,SEIPAREHT CITOYRAKSNART dna .CNI ,LESSUOR NOIRAM TSHCEOH
.SV

YGW-41801-79 :.oN noitcA liviC

,ffitnialP

STTESUHCASSAM FO TCIRTSID TRUOC TCIRTSID SETATS DETINU

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-4

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 2 of 10

91847900

CTI-MA

251091076MA

ecneuqes AND eht fo noisserpxe tnanibmocer eht sA .tnetap eht fo 6 erugiF ni htrof tes yb niteioporhtyre namuh gnicudorp fo sdohtem sebircsed tnetap 080' eht fo 01 elpmaxE ma .)"tnetap 080" eht"( 080,126,5 .oN tnetaP setatS detinU fo tnetnoc eht htiw railimaf

.snoitacilppa
yrotaluger
fo

esnecil eht fo

noitaraperp

dna ,tnempoleved ssecorp

gnirutcafunam ,hcraeser lacinilc

,hcraeser yrotarobal gnidulcni stcudorp niteioporhtyre s'negmA fo tnempoleved stcepsa lla ni devlovni saw I ,elor taht nI .7991 fo yluJ litnu yticapac taht ni deunitnoc redael eht emaceb I dna negmA ta maet tnempoleved tcudorp niteioporhtyre eht rof noisserpxe ,4891 rebmevoN nI .sllec nailammam morf niteioporhtyre fo noitcudorp dna
eht rof

elbisnopser

saw

I

,yllacificepS .ygolonhcet

AND tnanibmocer fo

esu

hguorht

fo

negmA ta niteioporhtyre namuh fo noitcudorp dna tnempoleved eht htiw devlovni .tnempoleveD tcudorP neeb dah dna no dekrow I ,7991 yluJ hguorht 3891 morF lleC raluceloM fo daeH fo rotceriD dna ,tnempoleveD tcudorP fo reganaM ,ygoloiB yrotarobaL sa emit emos rof gnivres retfa tnempoleveD tcudorP fo rotceriD roineS yraunaJ

noitisop

eht dleh I

,emit taht

tA .8991

ylsuounitnoc
-oc

saw

dna tsitneicS hcraeseR

a sa

ni deriter I litnu negmA yb deyolpme 1891 ,21 rebotcO no negmA denioj I
ot

.niteioporhtyre

tnanibmocer

etaler hcihw fo ynam ,derohtua

ygoloiB raluceloM

a sedulcni hcihw eativ mulucirruc ro derohtua evah I taht snoitacilbup eht fo tsil saw ym si 1-BKJ RbihxE dekram dna otereh dexennA .2891 ylrae ni dedrawa ym detelpmoc .D.hP ym dna 1891 rebotcO ni krow siseht

ni

eerged

ygoloiB raluceloM ta I .5791 ni selegnA soL ,ainrofilaC fo ytisrevinU eht etutitsnI AND gnitalosi eht ta margorp .D.hP eht deretne I ,gnippam noitcirtser dna ANR dna
sa a

ni

ogeiD

yrotarobaL hcus krow ygoloib ralucelom lareneg fo sepyt suoirav gniod naicinhcet eht sa etutitsnI klaS eht ta raey a gnikrow retfA .4791 ni aciremA fo setatS detinU ym deviecer I ainrofilaC fo ytisrevinU eht morf ygoloiB ni eerged .A.B
naS ta
:tcerroc dna eurt eb ot deveileb
era

feileb

ro

noitamrofni

no

edam stnemetats
taht aciremA

lla taht dna ,tcerroc dna

eurt era

fo-setatS detinU eht fo swal eht rednu

,egdelwonk nwo ym fo niereh edam stnemetats lla yrujrep fo ytlanep rednu eralced ,enworB

.K

yerffeJ ,l

.D.hP ENWORB .K YERFFEJ FO NOITARALCED

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-4

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 3 of 10

02847900

CTI-MA

351091076MA

2

100.$U.Iccdrmh enworb

.D.hP ,enworB .K

·ffe:J

/

'·

.ainrofilaC ,ytnuoC arutneV ni 9991 ,82

rebmetpeS

no

detucexE

.tnetap 080' eht fo 6 erugiF ni 561 ot 1+ sa htrof tes ecneuqes dica onima editpepylop eht si tcudorp niteioporhtyre siht fo ecneuqes dica onima ehT .enobkcab ecneuqes dica onima 561 a htiw nietorpocylg a si tcudorp niteioporhtyre sihT .elpmaxE taht ni debircsed dna detaerc sllec fo noitalupop lanigiro eht morf detceles ,neeb ot enil llec OHC a gnisu ,tnetap 080' eht fo 01 elpmaxE gnidrocca decudorp sah syawla dna ,si ediw-dlrow seesnecil sti dna negmA yb dlos dna edam niteioporhtyre negmA ta niteioporhtyre ehT .5891 ni noitcudorp elacs egral sti nageb negmA ecnis noitcudorp eht htiw railimaf osla ma I ,redael maet niteioporhtyre remrof
namuh fo

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-4

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 4 of 10

12847900

CTI-MA

451091076MA

tnempoleveD

tcudorP lacituecamrahP :tnatlusnoC

tnednepednI

:tneserp 89/1
:89/1-59/11
:59/11-98/2

.cnI

negmA ,tnempoleveD tcudorP ,rotceriD roineS
.cnI
.cnI

negmA ;tnempoleveD tcudorP ,rotceriD negmA ;tnempoleveD tcudorP ,reganaM

:98/1-78/21 :78/21-6891
:6891-1891/01

.cnI

negmA ;ygoloiB lleC raluceloM ,daeH tnemtrapeD
.cnI

negmA ;tsitneicS hcraeseR

:ecneirepxE lanoisseforP
7791-5791 ,tnarG gniniarT ygoloiB raluceloM .H.I.N 0891 7791 ,tnarG gniniarT sciteneG .H.I.N

:spihsralohcS
."sronoH htiW"

hgiH

,ainrofilaC ,alloJ

aL

,ogeiD naS

ta

ainrofilaC fo

ytisrevinU ,ygoloiB

4791 .A.B

yb ydutS
ta

".slaminA gniviL otni refsnarT eneG detacideM-AND riehT dna seneG nailammaM denolC fo secneuqeS" ,eltiT sisehT .D.hP

.ainrofilaC ,selegnA soL ,selegnA soL ainrofilaC fo ytisrevinU ,etutitsnI ygoloiB raluceloM ,ygoloiB raluceloM1891 .D.hP
:noitacudE

:pihsnezitiC
:sutatS latiraM

setatS detinU nerdlihc eerht ,deirraM 2591 ,92 yraunaJ ainrofilaC ,selegnA soL

:yadhtriB :ecalphtriB

:lacihpargoiB

0238-484 )508( 01039 AC ,olliramaC aroruA ellaC 4421

:sserddA

enworB

gniK yerffeJ

EATIV MULUCIRRUC
I-BKJ tibihxE

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-4

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 5 of 10

22847900

CTI-MA

551091076MA

2

eht fo

noisserpxE
xoF

dna

,F nitraM ,MG
dna

.4857-0857 ,28 .ASU .icS .dacA ltaN .corP .eneG niteioporhtyrE namuH gninolC .)5891( E ressawdloG dna HP iaL ,MS iwardaB ,Z yksnibatS ,KK trehC ,CJ eifgE ,R gnillamS ,KJ enworB ,H-C niL ,S sgguS ,K-F niL
fo noitaziretcarahC

yeknoM tnanibmoceR

.053-933,191 .seR .loiB dna .nilC .gorP .OPE namuH .)589 !( K-F niL dna P iaL ,KJ enworB ,CJ eirgE

591pg

.28 -36 ,581 .loiB .deM .pxE .vdA .tnanibmoceR suriV eniccaV-EGT a yb dna iloc.E ni desserpxE nietorP ekipS VEGT fo seidutS .)5891( KJ enworB dna R gnillamS ,J ikswezsurB ,S uH

.kroY weN ,robraH gnirpS dloC .052-542 ,)A.R remeL dna MR kconahC .de( .Y.N ,robraH gnirpS dloC ,muisopmyS ;yticinegonumml dna ecneluriV suriV fo sisaB lacimehC dna raluceloM :seniccaV ot sehcaorppA medoM nI .seniccaV tnanibmoceR fo noitcudorP .)4891( AG rettiB dna D notneF ,KJ enworB ,B lamaS ,NW ettemuB

B-sititapeH

desrepsretnI
selepiL ,M

eneG .emoneG eht ni erehweslE namuH .)189 I( W reslaS dna J

.681-771 ,51 dnuoF era secneuqeS ecapS eneG ANR lamosobiR touH ,OM nitraM ,KJ enworB ,DH gnatS ,R ihcugiH

eneG

.Y.N kroY weN .cnI ,ssiL .R nalA .433-313 ,)siuhneiN .A dna soluoponnayotamatS .G .de( II .loV ,seneG nibolG fo noisserpxE dna noitazinagrO nI .eciM gniviL fo slleC worram-enoB otni seneG nibolG namuH tresnI ot slaminA tcatnI ni snoitceleS ecnatsiseR gurD fo esU :seuqinhcet ypareht .)1891( JM enilC dna M ilE-raB ,K alocreM ,KJ enworB ,DH gnatS ,DB gnoT ,W reslaS

fo eneG weN eneG

a

.5301-3301 ,802 ecneicS .eciM fo slleC vxorraM enoB otni fo noitresnI .)0891( JM enilC dna W reslaS ,KJ enworB ,DH gnatS
W reslaS dna J enworB

nigirO lariV ,CK alocreM

.)0891(

.524-224 ,482 erutaN .slaminA tcatnI ni refsnarT ,R thcerpuR ,L esroM ,.K alocreM ,H gnatS ,JM enilC

.6481-2481 ,77 .A.S.U ecneicS .dacA ,ltaN .corP .emoneG suriV sititapeH kcuhcdooW dna B sititapeH namuH eht morf devireD sAND tnanibmoceR fo nosirapmoC dna noitaziretcarahC ,noitalosI .)0891( J sremmuS dna MJ celomS ,LR redynS ,VG relyT ,AW reslaS ,KJ enworB ,WI sgnimmuC .193-983

,591 ecneicS .sdimsalP iloe aihcirehcsE
editoelcuN

.)7791(

otni detresnI eneG nibolG ateB tibbaR morf secneuqeS W reslaS dna CH llednieH ,P ekralC ,A uiL ,VG kcoddaP ,KJ enworB

.402-771,91 .seR sdicA .leuN .gorP .sdimsalP lairetcaB otni noitalosI rieht dna secneuqeS ANRm nibolG fo noitanimreteD .)6791( P rakaZ dna G akcindutS ,J streboR ,G kcoddaP ,R ihcugiH ,H llednieH ,P ekralC ,KJ enworB ,W reslaS
:SNOITACILBUP

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-4

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 6 of 10

32847900

CTI-MA

651091076MA

.963-563 SG ssoM dna LH
a

,401 yregruS .noitanoD doolB suogolotuA dna niteioporhtyrE namuH tnanibmoceR .)8891( lagheS ,KJ enworB ,CJ eirgE ,RL lagheS ,AS dluoG ,LA nesoR ,AE eniveL

:92

.29-881 ,38# .ttiM .tsnI gnirheB .troper ssergorp :esaesid laner egats-dne fo aimena eht tcerroc ot )OPE( niteioporhtyrE namuH tnanibmoceR fo esU ehT .)8891( W hcabhcsE dna RM gninwoD ,KJ enworB ,CJ eirgE ,W nosmadA .652-142 pp .yrotarobaL robraH gnirpS dloC .seigolonhceT weN eht gnissessA :snietorP dna seditpeP citueparehT tropeR yrubnaB .niteioporhtyrE namuH tnanibmoceR dna larutaN fo seidutS evitarapmoC .)8891( WT dnalkcirtS dna ,.T ,awakarA ,.F ,niL ,P iaL ,KJ enworB ,CJ eirgE ,.D ,kenpaV

.sserP namuH fo

ytisrevinU

drofxO ,ygolonircodnE raluceloM ni scipoT detceleS nI .seneG niteioporhtyrE yeknoM dna noisserpxE dna gninolC .)7891( S sgguS dna CJ eirgE ,KJ enworB ,HP iaL ,K-F niL

a fo stluseR eht fo noitcerroC

:niteioporhtyrE namuH .)6891( WJ nosmadA

.87-37 ,613 enicideM fo lanruoJ dnalgnE weN .lairt lacinilc II-I esahP tnanibmoceR htiw esaesiD laneR egats-dnE fo aimenA dna KJ enworB ,RM gninwoD ,CJ eirgE ,WJ heabhcsE

yendiK .)DRSE(
tnanibmoceR dloC
N

.)6891(

esaesiD laneR egats-dnE ni tceffE WJ nosmadA dna KJ enworB ,RM

.tnemelppuS lanoitanretnI :)OPEuHr( niteioporhtyrE namuH gninwoD ,CJ eirgE ,WJ hcabhcsE

.seitreporP lacigoloiB
E nostaW

gnibbetS dna

.207-396,15 ygoloiB evitatitnauQ no aisopmyS robraH gnirpS dna ,erutcurtS nietorP ,gninolC eneG :niteioporhtyrE .)6891( ,T dnalkcirtS ,K-F niL ,HP iaL ,CJ eirgE ,MA nehoC ,KJ enworB

,KJ enworB ,K-F niL ,G liarT ,R gnillamS ,MA nehoC ,K ikoA ,J

namuH tnanibmoceR fo stceffE

lacigoloiB

.422-312 ,271 ,ygoloibonummI .niteioporhtyrE dna noitaziretcarahC .)6891( KD seniH dna enaL ,WT dnalkcirtS ,CJ eirgE

.902-102 ,44 ,eneG .eneG niteioporhtyrE namuH eht htiw nosirapmoC dna noisserpxE ,gninolC :eneg niteioporhtyre yeknoM .)6891( S sgguS dna M ortsaC ,KK nehC ,MG xoF ,R gnillamS ,CJ eirgE ,KJ enworB ,HP iaL ,H-C niL ,K-F niL
.021-311

,95 .dnatS .loiB .veD .negitnA

ecafruS B

evitaleR dna

sititapeH devired-AND tnanibmoceR fo snoitaraperP suoiraV fo ytieinegonummI seitreporP .)5891( AG rettiB dna KJ enworB ,B lamaS ,NW ettenruB

.3827-0827 ,28 .ASU .icS .dacA ltaN .corP .slleC yravO retsmaH esenihC ni enomroH gnizinietuL enivoB evitcA yllacigoloiB fo noisserpxE .)5891( .H.J ,nosliN dna RA nosamohT ,MT tteN ,F drofsidnoW ,KJ enworB ,MD lezteaK
dna .nilC no .gorP .niteioporhtyrE yeknoM dna ynoloC etycoyrakageM .)5891( K-F niL dna KJ

.911-501 ,512 .seR .loiB namuH tnanibmoceR fo ytivitcA gnitalumitS enworB ,WT ,dnalkcirtS ,CJ eirgE ,PP sekuD

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-4

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 7 of 10

42847900

CTI-MA

751091076MA

4

.328-318:21 ,lanruoJ
ot aresitna fo

.utis ni noitzazilausiv sti dna V esarefsnartlynimasoculglyteca-N elbulos ,tnanibmocer noitaraperP .)5991( M ecreiP ,N negierF ,J enworB ,B reldA ,N gnahZ ,L nehC

etagujnococylG

.58351-18351 ,862 ,.mehC .loiB fo .J .V-esarefsnartlynimasoculglytecA-N gnidocnE ANDe a fo noisserpxE dna ,noitaziretcarahC ,noitalosI .)3991( M ecreiP ,N neigerF ,P stlahkcuB ,R selppuC ,R usaB ,J nietsnieW ,B reldA ,SG gmeP ,M habierohS

,KJ enworB ,ZD

neW

.lesaB

,regraK
tcudorP

.511-501 .pp ,67 .loV .noitazidradnatS

lacigoloiB

fo

tnempoleveD .ycnetsisnoC

no noitatnemreF fo stceffE .)1991( J enworB ,ebeiW ,R kcinraG ,S redliuB ,R noohtarA ,D eiksdbaZ ,G namressaW ,B atikO ,M akO ,J neilatI'L ,J yawallaC ,K alumunA ,SA ikceinibuL

.dnalreztiwS ,regraK ,lesaB .08-27:88 ,)L kerozeieW ,P allagicS ,W nebeltmaS ,J naroM ,J H dnaduG .de( ygolorhpeN ot snoitubirtnoC .saimenA laneR-noN dna laneR ni niteioporhtyrE :nI .setatS detinU eht ni slairT lacinilC fo stluseR :ahplA-niteopE .)1991( WI. ,nosmadA ,KJ enworB ,RM gninwoD ,CJ eirgE ,WJ hcabhesE
fo

ytefaS

ehT

snikpoH

nhoJ ehT

,)slraeniW

GC dna hcabhcsE

WJ

.nodnoL dna eromitlaB ,sserP .vinU WJ

,nosmadA
:nI

:niteioporhtyrE
:otnoroT
N

,niteioporhtyrE

,velsrE DA .sde( 04-12 .pp ,ygoloiB lacinilC dna ralulleC ,raluceloM fo ygoloiB raluceloM ehT .)1991( KJ ,enworB ,CJ ,eifgE
.21-1 ,secivreS noitacudE lacideM SEM dna erutcurtS nietorP ,gninolC eneG :niteioporhtyrE nI .)0991( dnalkcirtS ,K-F gniL ,HP iaL ,CJ eirgE ,MA nehoC ,KJ enworB

.seitreporP lacigoloiB gnibbetS ,E nostaW ,T

.038-528 ,362 .A.M.AL .niteioporhtyrE namuH tnanibmoceR htiw detaerT stneitaP sisylaidomeH fo efiL fo ytilauQ ehT .)0990 )WJ nosmadA dna K namrekcuZ ,BD kcyW naV ,CJ enotS naV ,P nahcseT ,J W enotS ,J namdvitS ,AE ,ykstuR ,PE ininagaP ,AD nedgO ,RA nosnessiN,PA nidnuL ,KS ztnarK ,MS tebroK ,RN yelaH ,AE nami·eirF ,W deirF ,CJ eirgE ,RM gninwoD ,GB onaleD ,KJ enworB ,WJ hcabhcsE( .puorG lairT lacinilC OPE retnecitluM evitarepooC eht dna LD neinnaM ,L enaiD ,B redaR ,WR snavE lacinilC retnecitluM III esahP
a

.0001-299,1 .enicideM lanretnI fo slannA .lairT fo stluseR :esaesiD laneR egatS- dnE htiw stneitaP cimenA

ni niteioporhtyrE namuH tnanibmoceR .)9890 WJ nosmadA dna K namrekcuZ ,BD kcyW naV ,CJ enotS naV ,P nahcseT ,JW enotS ,J namlevitS ,AE ykstuR ,B redaR ,PE ininagaP ,AD nedgO ,RA nosnessiN ,PA nidnuL ,BS ztnarK ,S tebroK ,RN yelaH ,ES rcbarG ,AE namdeirF ,WR snavE ,CJ edgE ,RM gninwoD ,GB onadD ,KJ enworB ,HM idahludbA ,WJ hcabhcsE .22671-91671 ,462 .mehC .loiB .J .editpeP langiS a htiw rohcnA langiS lanimreT-2HN eht fo tnemecalpeR yb nietorP yroterceS a ot esarcfsnartlylaiS sutarappA igloG a fo noisrevnoC .)9891( CJ nosluaP dna KJ enworB ,B reldA ,UE eeL ,J K yelloC
561-061 ,67 .lorhpeN .rtnoC .stneitaP sisylaidomeH ni stluseR :)negmA( niteioporhtyrE namuH tnanibmoceR htiw lairT lacinilC retnecitluM ASU .)9891( WJ nosmadA dna KJ enworB ,CJ edgE ,RM gninwoD ,/VI. hcabhcsE

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-4

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 8 of 10

52847900

CTI-MA

851091076MA

eht fo noitcerroC lanoitanretnI ht5

niteioporhtyrE namuH tnanibmoceR htiw )DRSE( esaesiD laneR egats-dnE fo aimenA .)6891( WJ heabhcsE dna KJ enworB ,RM gninwoD ,CJ eirgE ,WJ nosmadA
.6891 ,02-71 .tpeS ,aimerU no ecnerefnoC irpaC esaesiD laneR egats-dnE ni tceffE :)OPEuHr( niteioporhtyrE namuH WJ nosmadA dna RM gninwoD ,KJ enworB ,CJ eirgE ,WJ hcabhcsE .361 ,301 .loiB lleC .J .slleC OHC detcefsnarT ylbatS ni enomroH fo noitcudorP setalumitS eneG tinubuS-ahplA eht fo noitacifilpmA HJ nosliN dna RA nosamohT ,KJ enworB ,MT tteN ,MD dzteaK

.)DRSE( .tnanibmoceR .)6891(

gnizinietuL enivoB
evitceleS
.964 ,41 .lotameH oviv nI & ortiv nI
A nehoC dna D seniH

.)6891(

.pxE .niteioporhtyrE tnanibmoceR fo stceffE citeiopotyeoyrakageM .)689 I( K-F niL dna KJ enworB ,WT dnalkcirtS ,CJ eirgE ,PP sekuD

.854,31 .lotameH .pxE .niteioporhtyrE tnanibmoceR namuH eruP fo noitaziretcarahC .)5891( ,KJ enworB ,G liarT ,R gnillamS ,K ikoA ,J enaL ,T dnalkciftS ,CJ eirgE
.notsoB ,ygoloisyhP lleC metS no muisopmyS lairomeM namlhotS keifderF launnA ht0 .niteioporhtyrE yeknoM dna namuH tnanibmoceR fo noitaziretcarahC .)4891( PP sekuD dna C yeldarB ,R gnillamS ,KJ enworB ,K-F niL ,J enaL ,J eirgE .753

,21

.lotameH .pxE .eneG niteioporhtyrE namuH dna ressawdloG dna FF gnaW ,J eirgE ,KJ enworB ,R

yeknoM fo noisserpxe dna gninolC .)4891( E gnillamS ,HP iaL ,S sgguS ,H-C niL ,K-F niL
.552,3 .hcsR enikohpmyL

.eneG niteioporhtyrE yeknoM dna namuH eht fo noisserpxE lanoitcnuF .)4891( K obesZ dna S ttoillE ,M sreteP ,E uaL ,A sknaB ,S sgguS ,KJ enworB ,H-C niL ,J eirgE ,R gnillamS ,K-F niL

:STCARTSBA

dna

.sserp nI .ygolorhpeN .coS .remA .J .stneitaP sisylaiD ni )OPEuHr( afla niteopE )PSEN( nietorP gnitalumitS siseioporhtyrE levoN fo scitenikocamrahP eht fo nosirapmoC .)9991( J ,eirgE ,J ,enworB ,B ,snikneJ ,C ,neerB ,O ,yovEeM ,J S ,yarG ,CI ,llaguodcaM .sserp nI .enicideM yranireteV fo J .sgoD lamroN ni niteioporhtyrE ytieinegitnA .)7991( CJ eirgE ,A relliM ,KJ enworB ,AL laeN ,DL ,lligwoC
no

tnanibmoceR fo

,J S ,bawhcS ,MD ,otomakO ,RA ,nosnessiN ,CJ ,eirgE ,KJ ,enworB ,KW ,notloB ,A ,baraseB
dna 825-125 ,212 .cossA enicideM yranireteV .remA .J .eruliaF laneR htiw staC sgoD ni aimenA fo tnemeganaM rof niteioporhtyrE namuH tnanibmoceR fo esU .)899 I( ,CJ ,eifgE dna ,TR ,reigniboL ,A ,relliM ,BJ ,enworB ,KJ ,yveL ,MK ,semaJ ,DL ,lligwoC

sisylaidomeH

.095-485 ,933 .deM .J .lgnE .N .esaesiD caidraC htiw stneitaP tircotameH cimenA susreV lamroN fo stceffE ehT .)8991( AD ,nikdooG

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-4

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 9 of 10

62847900

CTI-MA

951091076MA

.AC ,ocsicnarF naS ,4991 enuJ ,muroF enicideM yranireteV launnA ht21 .enicideM lanretnI yraniretev fo egelloC naciremA .sgoD lamroN ni )OPEuH-r( niteioporhtyre namuH tnanibmoceR fo yticinegitnA .)4991( A ,relliM ,J ,enworB ,J ,eirgE ,L ,laeN ,DL ,lligwoC

.ecitcarP

latipsoH

.J

.slacigoloibfo

lacinilc dna ygolonhcetoiB .)3991( D

,notneF

esu lacinilC :owt trap enicidem dna ,J ,enworB ,AC ,olleraniD ,PR ,snevE

eht fo noitcerroC
naS

niteioporhtyrE namuH tnanibmoceR htiw )DRSE( esaesiD laneR egats-dnE fo aimenA .)6891( WJ nosmadA dna KJ enworB ,RM gninwoD ,CJ edgE ,WJ hcabhcsE
.doolB .AC ,ocsicnarF ,6891 .ceD ,ygolotameH .coS .remA .lairt lacinilc fI-I esahP a fo stluseR :)OPEuHr(

.891,13 lanoitanretnI yendiK .lairT lacinilC

II-I esahP

a

fo stluseR

:)OPEuHr(

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-4

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 10 of 10