Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al

Filing 567

DECLARATION of Linda A. Sasaki-Baxley in Support of Amgen Inc.'s Opposition to Roche's Motion for Summary Judgment That Claim 1 of the '422 Patent is Invalid Under 35 U.S.C. Sec. 112 by Amgen Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit Ex. A#2 Exhibit Ex. B#3 Exhibit Ex. C)(Rich, Patricia)

Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-3

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 1 of 15

Dockets.Justia.com

211 .S CSU 53 rednU dilavnI si tnetaP 224' fO 1 mialC taht tnemgduJ yrammuS rof noitoM s'ehcoR oT noitisoppO s'negmA fo troppuS ni .lceD yelxaB

B TIBIHXE

Doc. 567 Att. 2

1egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

19621

:rebmuN

boJ

retropeR dnahtrohS
NAMTLEZ

lanoisseforP
.R

A·PABRAB

:YB

DETROPER

7002

,6

enuJ weN

,yadsendeW
,kroY
weN FO NOITISOPED

kroY

,.D.hP

,IZZOTREB

NYLORAC

LAITNEDIFNOC

X.

.stnadnefeD

dna

,.CNI ,EHCOR AL-NNAMFFOH ,HbmG SCITSONGAID EHCOR ,.DTL EHCOR AL-NNAMFFOH .F
.V

YGW 73221 .viC 50 .oN noitcA liviC

,ffitnialP
,.CNI
X

,NEGMA

STTESUHCASSAM FO TCIRTSID TRUOC TCIRTSID SETATS DETINU

700216/6

LAITNEDIFNOC .D.hP ,nyloraC ,izzotreB

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-3

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 2 of 15

2

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

52 42 32
22

12 02 91

81
71 61 51 41 31 21
.kroY
weN

fo

etatS

eht

rof

dna

nihtiw

ii
0i

cilbuP
a

yratoN dna
.R

retropeR

dnahtrohS

lanoisseforP
weN

,NAMTLEZ

ARABRAB 083
ot

erofeb
SIRROM

,kroY

,kroY
fo

weN

9 8
7

,eunevA
eht .D.hP

notgnixeL
ta

,PLL

ENAUD

seciffo

,ecitoN
,IZZOTREB

tnausrup
fo

,ffitnialP yb nekat

NYLORAC

noitisopeD

6 5

.m.a

01:9
enuJ

4 3 2 1

7002

,6

700216/6

LAITNEDIFNOC .D.hP ,nyloraC ,izzotreB

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-3

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 3 of 15

3

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008 ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

52 42 32

rehpargoediV lagelaraP

,areviR
,htimS

olecraM

22
:TNESERP OSLA

salguoD

12 02

moc.relohcseyak@lekcehh
8478.638.212

91 81 71
61 51

.QSE

,LEKCEH
kroY

.H

DERFLA

:YB weN

22001

weN

,kroY
kraP rof

eunevA

524

stnadnefeD

eht
PLL

syenrottA
EYAK

41 31
21

,RELOHCS

moc.reebesacyad@beolj
0110.378.804
.D.hP

ii 0I 9 8
7

,BEOL

NAHTANOJ

:YB

41059

ainrofilaC
keerC

,onitrepuC
00302

draveluoB

snevetS

ffitnialP
PLL

eht

rof

syenrottA
YAD

6 5
4

,REDLEHCTAB

&

DIRDAM

REEBESAC

3
:S
E

C

N

AR

AE

P

P

A

2
1

70021616

LAITNEDIFNOC .D.hP ,nyloraC ,izzotreB

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-3

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 4 of 15

4

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

52
42

32
22
6 tibihxE
491

fo

troper
fo

trepxe
ehT

ilairepmI .rD tibihxE
ot

C

12

yrtsimehC lacigoloiB
281 lanruoJ morf

elcitrA

5

tibihxE

02 91 81 71

slleC yravO retsmaH esenihC tnanibmoceR fo muideM erutluC eht dna enirU morf deifiruP sniteioporhtyrE namuH fo sniahC

raguS
961 021 eht

fo

dekniL-enigarapsA ydutS evitarapmoC gniwarD
izzotreB

4 3

tibihxE
tibihxE

61
51 41

17

nyloraC

.rD

fo

troper
,C

trepxE
srebmuN tibihxE

2

tibihxE

31
56 evitartsnomeD
1

tibihxE

21

ii
EGAP NOITPIRCSED
STIBIHXE IZZOTREB

0I 9 8
7

6
772 9
EGAP XEDNI

lekceH beoL

.rM

yb yb

noitanimaxE noitanimaxE

5 4

.rM

3
2

1

70021616

LAITNEDIFNOC .D.hP ,nyloraC ,izzotreB

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-3

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 5 of 15

5

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

52
42

32
22 12 02 91 81 71 61 51
ii 972
.rD

fo

tropeR

izzotreB nyloraC latnemelppuS

tibihxE

41
slaminA

31
0i

252

gniviL ni noitalysocylG dekniL O epyt-nicuM gniborP deltitne elcitrA
sisehtnyS

tibihxE

21
II

942

scitemiM editpepocylG fo eht ni snoitceriD deltitne tnemucoD
weN

9

tibihxE

0I

9
8
8 tibihxE

642

morf

snietorpocylG tnanibmoceR fo noitazilanoitcnuF cilobateM deltitne 4002 tuoba repaP
yrtsimehc
enirU

7
ni fo 122

niteioporhtyrE fo snrettaP gnisucoF cirtcelceosI eht ytilibatsnI eht gnissessA
,razacaleB yb
elcitrA
7 tibihxE

6 5
4

EGAP

NOITPIRCSED
STIBIHXE

IZZOTREB

3
2 1

70021616

LAITNEDIFNOC .D.hP ,nyloraC ,izzotreB

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-3

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 6 of 15

49egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

tsuj niteioporhtyre
64:51:11
54:51:ii 34:51:11 04:51:11 53:51:11

uoy

rof

oS
A

52 42 32
sti

.yakO
?uoy
ot

elbatpecca
.etats

taht

sI

noitalysocylg

22 12 02

fo
eht

evitcepserri nietorp niteioporhtyre
ot

gnirrefer
I

ma

I

"niteioporhtyre"
ew

33:51:11
13:51:11 03:51:11 52:51:11

yas

fi
em na

taht

eerga
ot

naC

91

.taht

rof

evigrof
naht

evah
a sa esu

ll'uoy
erom

oS

81 71 61 51 41
31 21

.evitcejda
ro

nuon

"OPE"

"niteioporhtyre"
fo
eno ma a

ohw

elpoep
Q

32:51:11
12:51:11 51:51:11 31:51:11 21:51:11

esoht
.eman
a

I

ssefnoc I
erutcurts

etercsid
s'tI yna

dna

etercsid

.serutmurts
ebircsa

ralucelom
uoY

esoht

ot

eman

dluoc

.serutcurts

ralucelom eht ni
dna

II

90:51:11
50:51:11 20:51:11 10:51:11 35:41:11 25:41:11 05:41:11 94:41:11 74:41:11 54:41:11

evah

eseht

fo

lla
eht

tub
dnA

erutaretil

0i
9

si

ygolonimret
era

.serutcurts

selucelom

eseht

dnim ym nI

8
eht

.erutaretil ni
yaw taht
ot

7 6

derrefer

s'tI

A
a

?nietorpocylg
ton

5 4 3 2

si

hcihw ,sey

nietorp niteioporhtyre
eb dluow taht
oS

si

ereht

Q

.taht
LAITNEDIFNOC

nees

evah I
NYLORAC

.D.hP

,IZZOTREB

1

700216/6

LAITNEDIFNOC .D.hP ,nyloraC ,izzotreB

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-3

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 7 of 15

59

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

.seY
84:61:11
54:61:11

Q

52 42 32

?nietorp niteioporhtyre ?nietorp niteioporhtyrE
?naem

tnanibmoceR
A

34:61:11
14:61:11 63:61:11 53:61:11

ot

"nietorp
esarhp

22
12 02

niteioporhtyre
eht

tnanibmocer" uoy
od tahW

dnatsrednu dna
neht
em a

.ereht dna t'nod

thgir
tel

ti

yfiralc

s'tel

91 81 71

92:61:11
62:61:11 42:61:11 32:61:11 32:61:11

wonk yaw

esaelp
esu

,dnatsrednu
fI

uoy

ni

ti

I

.yakO
.ot
era

Q

61
51 41

gnirrefer
sa

uoy

tahw

wonk

I

sa

gnol yeht

tub

12:61:11
91:61:11 41:61:11 31:61:11 21:61:11 01:61:11 90:61:11 20:61:11

,selucelom tnereffid

era

esuaceB
A

31 21

.gnisufnoc

s'ti

,lleW

?uoy
htiw

II 0I

yako
?mret

taht
emas

sI

.thgiR gnisu
uoy
ro

Q
serutcurts
A

eht
era

9
8
7

ynam

ot

gnirrefer

oS

?detalysocylg-non
eb

detalysocylg
oS

dluoc

niteioporhtyre
.ton
ro

6 5 4
ruoy

00:61:11
85:51:11 75:51:11 55:51:11 05:51:11

detalysocylg
Q

s'ti

rehtehw

evitcepserrI
?noitinifed

3
2 1

s'tahT

?sdica

onima .D.hP

fo

segaknil slauqe
NYLORAC

LAITNEDIFNOC

,IZZOTREB

70021616

LAITNEDIFNOC .D.hP ,nyloraC ,izzotreB

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-3

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 8 of 15

69

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

.thgiR
22:81:11 81:81:11 71:81:11 11:81:11

Q
eht
lla

52 42 32
22

.smrof

detalysocylg
uoy
nehw

tnereffid

edulcni
yas
a

"nietorp niteioporhtyre"
esuaceB

uoy

.eniru ni
wonk t'nod I

gniht
dna

hcus

si

ereht

taht

12 O2

01:81:11
70:81:11 10:81:11 75:71:11 65:71:11

,nietorp niteioporhtyre niagA

A

?naem

ot

91 81

"nietorp niteioporhtyre yraniru" esarhp
eht

dnatsrednu

uoy

od

tahW .llec taht dah

Q
otni taht

71
61 51 41 31 21

25:71:11
64:71:11
34:71:11 93:71:11 63:71:11 23:71:11 13:71:11 52:71:11 02:71:11 51:71:11 11:71:11 70:71:11 95:61:11 35:61:11 05:61:11

detresni llec
a

AND

tnanibmocer
saw

siht
taht

yb decudorp
eht

nietorp nietorp

niteioporhtyre niteioporhtyre

eb

dluow
oS

tnanibmocer .llec taht

fo

yrenihcam

II 0i 9

lanoitalsnart
ro

dna

lanoitpircsnart
eht eb evird neht

yrenihcam
tsoh
a

lanoitalsnart otni
a

ot
nac

llec taht dna
,ecruos

decudortni otni morf ti ti

8
7

dimsalp
ecruos
emos

gnitargetni gniyfilpma
AND

eht

6 5 4 3 2 1

morf

ecneuqes

gnikat gnikam
mret A

,elpmaxe

rof

;sAND
ot

laicifitra
desu

yllacisab ebircsed
eht

s'taht

si

"tnanibmocer"
.D.hP

,lleW

LAITNEDIFNOC

,IZZOTREB

NYLORAC

70021616

LAITNEDIFNOC .D.hP ,nyloraC ,izzotreB

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-3

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 9 of 15

79

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

yllanigiro
00:02:11 65:91:11 55:91:11 05:91:11 94:91:11 93:91:11 13:91:11 92:91:11 12:91:11 51:91:11 31:91:11 80:91:11 50:91:11 10:91:11 85:81:11 75:81:11 75:81:11 55:81:11 94:81:11 54:81:11 43:81:11 03:81:11 92:81:11 42:81:11
esac

si

niteioporhtyre
erutaretil
ym

namuh

52 42 32

lla
morf

taht

si

eht
tuB

gnidaer
ecaferp
A

gnidnatsrednu

.taht

htiw
I
.RM

22 12 02 91 81 71 61 51
41

;tsigoloisyhp
.noitcejbO

a

ton

ma

:LEKCEH

?dezisehtnys niteioporhtyre yraniru
namuh

si

ydob

eht

ni

erehW

Q
namuh dluow dluow
eht
fo

.semosomorhc
eht
tI

ni

stsixe
.eneg

ti

sa

eneg
a

eht
eb

eb
ton

tnanibmocer

niteioporhtyre yraniru
eht

namuh fo

ni

hcihw

eneg

eht

ecneuqes

31
21
ii

eht fo

yb deificeps
eht

s'taht

sdica
nI

onima

egaknil
.eneg

,sdrow rehto

niteioporhtyre

ehT

A

0i

?eneg

9
8
7

niteioporhtyre
taht
evah fo

eht
.AND

yb
eht fo

dedocnE

Q

yb

dedocne

gnieb
a

sdica

onima

egaknil
eht ni

nommoc

6

taht

eniru

namuh
eht

selucelom
ralucanrev

5
4

noitcelloc
ruoy ni

eb

dluow

nietorp niteioporhtyre
namuh
oS
A

3
2 1

yraniru
LAITNEDIFNOC .D.hP

,IZZOTREB

NYLORAC

70021616

LAITNEDIFNOC .D.hP ,nyloraC ,izzotreB

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-3

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 10 of 15

89

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS ddoW etoNeviL

tpurretni
05:12:11 54:12:11 83:12:11 03:12:11 12:12:11 71:12:11 51:12:11 21:12:11 11:12:11 90:12:11 80:12:11 30:12:11 20:12:11 00:12:11 45:02:11
05:02:11 54:02:11

ot

yrroS
rehto
ot

:BEOL

.RM

52

.snagro

yendik
hcihw
eht

,wonk uoy

42
32 22

,morf

ciffart

selucelom

yb

stneve

lacigoloisyhp
hcihw
eht ,yas ni

fo

tros

sebircsed

dluohs I

,scimanyd-ocamrahp
ton
ma

12
O2 91

trepxe

na

I .RM

A

.noitcejbO
trepxe
na

:LEKCEH

?niteioporhtyre
ni
ton
era

fo

ygoloisyhp
oS

eht

81

uoy

Q

71
61 51 41
31
morf

.ygoloisyhp
eht eht fo s'taht

fo

gnidnatsrednu
.desoporp
s'taht

ym

fo

tnetxe stneve

dnA

s'taht

redro

eht

eveileb I

.yendik
taht
ot

21
ii

roirp
taht ni

dna
ot

doolb

morf evah

detanigiro
dluow

roirp

eniru

0i

eht taht

snietorpocylg niteioporhtyre
gnidnatsrednu
ym
oS

9
8

si

24:02:11 24:02:11

.eniru sraeppa tesbus
emos

eht

ni rof

7

oS

.noitercxe eht

6 5

13:02:11 72:02:11
02:02:11 51:02:11

dessecorp
neht dna
,mures

si

lairetam

yllautneve

,doolb eht fo amsalp eht otni
eht

4 3 2
1

otni
dna

desaeler
eht

si
ni

lairetam

taht

fo

emos

yendik
.D.hP

decudorp

70:02:11

LAITNEDIFNOC

,IZZOTREB NYLORAC

70021616

LAITNEDIFNOC .D.hP ,nyloraC ,izzotreB

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-3

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 11 of 15

99

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

erus

ekam ot
ym

tnaw

tsuJ

?snoitinifed
naC sI
A

52
42

50:03:11
50:03:11

kcab

daer

uoy

?yako
.snoitinifed
m'I

taht

32 22
12

30:03:11 10:03:11 75:92:11

ruoy esoht
nac

gnitpoda tsuj
esu

sesarhp

owt

I

fi

taht

drawrof

gniog

emussa

uoY

02
91

65:92:11
45:92:11 35:92:11 25:92:11 74:92:11
64:92:11 34:92:11 14:92:11
a

.niteioporhtyre
tnanibmocer uoy
evag fo
a

fo

noitinifed

81 71 61
51 41

uoy

dna

niteioporhtyre
a em

yraniru
oga

noitinifed

evag

uoy

tnemom

,izzotreB
.rD

.rD

Q

.izzotreB

nyloraC

fo

noitisoped
eht

depatoediv
1 emuloV

deunitnoc sihT
.m.a

fo

31
21

,2 epaT si

62:11

73:92:11 73:92:11 63:92:11 63:92:11 00:22:11 85:12:11 65:12:11 55:12:11 55:12:11 25:12:11

si

emiT

:REHPARGOEDIV

EHT

ii

).nekat
saw ssecer

0i

feirb A(
.rD

9
fo

.izzotreB

nyloraC

noitisoped
fo 1
.m.a

8
7

depatoediv
,i epaT
si

eht

emuloV
81:11

setelpmoc sihT
:REHPARGOEDIV

6
5

emiT

EHT

.esaelp
,drocer eht ffo og .epat eht egnahc
LAITNEDIFNOC
.D.hP
ot
nac ew

4

fi

oS

3
2 1

deen

eW

.uoy
NYLORAC

05:12:11

,IZZOTREB

70021616

LAITNEDIFNOC .D.hP ,nyloraC ,izzotreB

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-3

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 12 of 15

982

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008 ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

52 42 32 22

12 02 91 81
cilbuP

yratoN

71 61 51

7002

fo

yad
41
erofeb
ot

siht
nrows

em

31
dna debircsbuS

21
.D.hP

,IZZOTREB

NYLORAC

iI

0I

).m.p
dedulcnoc
saw

93:5

ta

9
8
7

noitisoped ehT(

.izzotreB
62:34:50 42:34:50 02:34:50 91:34:50 81:34:50

nyloraC
depatoediv

.rD

fo

noitisoped
fo 1 emuloV .m.p
EHT

6 5 4

eht

,4 epaT
si

setelpmoc

sihT

93:5

emiT

:REHPARGOEDIV

3
2

LAITNEDIFNOC

.D.hP

,IZZOTREB NYLORAC

1

70021616

LAITNEDIFNOC .D.hP ,nyloraC ,izzotreB

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-3

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 13 of 15

092

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

52

42
32
etaD

erutangis

s'ssentiW

22 12

:NOSAER :EGNAHC
:NOSAER

02
91

81
71

:EGNAHC :NOSAER :EGNAHC :NOSAER :EGNAHC :NOSAER :EGNAHC :NOSAER :EGNAHC :NOSAER

61 51 41 31 21 ii 0i 9 8 7
ENIL EGAP

:EGNAHC

6

:snosaer

gniwollof
ot

eht

rof

,segnahc
4

gniwollof

eht

ekam

hsiw I
KROY
WEN WEN

FO
FO

YTNUOC ETATS

3
2

:SS

fo

EGAP

KROY

1

70021616

LAITNEDIFNOC .D.hP ,nyloraC ,izzotreB

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-3

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 14 of 15

52 cilbuP

yratoN dna

NAMTLEZ

retropeR truoC ARABRAB
.R

42 32
22

.7002
fo

,enuJ

12

yad ht8 siht dnah
evah I

ym

tes

otnuereh

02
91

,FOEREHW

SSENTIW NI
emoctuo
ma

.rettam

siht fo
on

eht

ni
dna
ot
ton

81
71

detseretni yaw

ni

I

taht

,egairram

ro

doolb fo

yb noitca siht
ot

61 51 41
31

seitrap
ma

eht

yna

detaler
I

I

taht

yfitrec rehtruf

.ssentiw eht yb nevig

ynomitset
noitisoped
ylud
si

eht

fo
taht

drocer
dna
tes
em

eurt

a

si

21 II 01

hcus

yb

nrows

saw

,htrof

erofebniereh

noitisoped esohw ssentiw eht
,IZZOTREB NYLORAC tahT

9 8

,.D.hP

:yfitrec ybereh
fo
etatS

od

,kroY

weN

7

eht

rof

dna

nihtiw

,cilbuP

6
5

yratoN dna retropeR dnahtrohS
,NAMTLEZ
.ss

.R

ARABRAB ,I KROY WEN

FO FO

YTNUOC

3

)

KROY

WEN

ETATS

ETACIFITREC

2

1 192

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 567-3

Filed 06/29/2007

Page 15 of 15