Arista Records LLC et al v. Lime Wire LLC et al

Filing 186

FILING ERROR - DEFICIENT DOCKET ENTRY - DECLARATION of Katherine B. Forrest in Opposition re: 168 MOTION to Strike Plaintiffs' Exhibits Filed as Part of Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendants' MSJ and Defendants' Motion to Strike., 165 MOTION to Strike Plaintiffs' Exhibits Filed as Part of Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendants' MSJ and Defendants' Motion to Strike.. Document filed by Capitol Records, Inc., Elektra Entertainment Group, Inc., Interscope Records, Laface Records LLC, Motown Record Company, L.P., Arista Records LLC, Priority Records LLC, Sony BMG Music Entertainment, UMG Recordings, Inc., Virgin Records America, Inc., Warner Bros. Records Inc., Atlantic Recording Corporation, BMG Music. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 492 to Forrest December 5, 2008 Declaration, # 2 Exhibit 493 to Forrest December 5, 2008 Declaration, # 3 Exhibit 494 to Forrest December 5, 2008 Declaration, # 4 Exhibit 495 to Forrest December 5, 2008 Declaration, # 5 Exhibit 496 to Forrest December 5, 2008 Declaration, # 6 Exhibit 497 to Forrest December 5, 2008 Declaration, # 7 Declaration of Elizabeth Cuneo, # 8 Declaration of Siobhan Minarovich, # 9 Declaration of Andrew Kempe, # 10 Declaration of Thomas Sehested)(Forrest, Katherine) Modified on 12/8/2008 (jar).

SEHESTED

DECLARATION

UNITED SOUTHERN

STATES

DISTRICT

COURT YORK

DISTRICT

OF NEW

ARISTA

RECORDS

CORPORATION;

RECORDING LLC; ATLANTIC BMG MUSIC; CAPITOL ENTERTAINMENT

.RECORDS, INC,; ELEKTRA GROUP INC.; INTERSCOPE RECORDS LLC; MOTOWN PRIORITY RECORDS L/P.; MUSIC ENTERTAINMENT;:
INC.;
VIRGIN RECORDS RECORDS
WARNER

RECORDS·
RECORD

LAFACE

COMPANY, LLC; SONY BMG UMG RECORDINGS, AMERICA, INC.; and
INC.,
ECF CASE

BROS.

Piaintiff·%

06 Civ. 05936

(GEL)

LLC; LIME GROUP LLC; MARK and M.J.G. LIME GORTON; GREGBIISDSON; WIRE FAMILY LIMITED PARTNERSH1P·
LIME WIRE

Defendants·

DECLARATION DEFENDANTS PLAINTIFFS FURTHER
·

OF

THOMAS
EXCLUDE

SEHESTED
1TIE

IN OPPOSITION

TO
OF TH.OMAS FOR AND IN SUMMARY

MOTION
·

TO

DECLARATIONS

SEHESTED,

ANDREW
FAILURE

KEMPE, AND
TO DISCLOSE
·

Ka·THERYN FACI'UAL FOR

COGGON WITNESSES
PAR2.·IAL

SUPPORT

OF PLAINTIFFS

MOTION

JUDGMENT

I, THOMAS
1· I
:am

SEHESTED,
the co-founder

h·by

declare

as

:fallows:

and Chief

Executive

O·icer

of DtecNet facts

Saftware
and

ApS ("DtecNef;). I have persomfl knowledge of thefoUowing
sworn as:a

and, if called

witness,

could

competently testii·

thereta. of America

2.

DtecNet

was

engaged by the Recording Industry As·eiafian plaintiffs in
this
case

("R:IAA')

an

behalfaf

the

at·er

July 1'8, 2008

to assist

ingathering

evidence

as

to

whether
Statement

copies of the thirty sound recordings ("files'3 listed in Attachment
of

A to Plaintift·'

Undisputed Material by LimeWire
to my

Facts, dated
users.

July 18, 2008

('·Attachment A'),
3·

are

being shared
as an

Attached

EXhibit which
at

September 9,
used

2008

declaration

was

a

spreadsheet showing tile dates

on

DtecNet

Phex, apeer-to-peer
and

client

publiclyavailable lbr download
client with

http:!/www.phex.org,
at

Beal·hare,
'to

a

peer-to-peer

publicly available
identical
·

for download of each

http:/iwww.bearshare.eom,
A from two

download

ex)pies

hashes
to
a

of the files in Attachment

different

LimeWire

us.ers.

Due

corrupted dam file, DtecNet

re-performed this "task° Exhibit A
the dates
on

to

tliis

declaration

is

an

updated s·tsheet
hash· of each.of

presenting
the files

which

Dte·Net

downloaded. different

copies with identical
LimeWire
users·

in Attachment is aCD

A fi,om two

:Exhibit each

B to this declaration

eontaining.a opy
A.

ofa ·und

recording:matching
4· download
at

hash provided in Attachment used Wimshark,
a

DieNet

packet capture ciienI publicly avmlable
the transfer

for the

http://www.wireshatk,org,
to the

to doctunent

ofthosefiles
was

t·om dowdoaded

LimeWire
froma

user

DteeNet

computer,
transfer

thus· confirming that the file
ofe·acli file in Attachment between
''

LimeWire Wiresliark

user·

Dttring the

A, DtecNet
DtecNeffs

utilized computer

to

"capture" :all tim data -packetstransferral
user.

and theP2P

These'·paeket capture" or"..pcap

files eontain

all the data

As I slated,

they

are

identical

having the same (See http://www.rsa.com/rsalabs/node:asp?id=2927 ; ihtlp://blogs.zdnet.com/Ou/?p·09.) user's file is a copy a file with identical liashes, one users q'laus, if two LimeWire possess of the othen Seh·ted 09t09/08 DecL '[i 5,) (See

declaration, if two files have die same hash, files, not directly copi·l from one another, SHA-I hash (the kind of hash used by Lira(Wire and DteeNet)is 2^63.
in my The

September 9,

2008
two

probabilityof

2

about the transfer,
i·le

including the
P2P client.

user's In

IP address

and

proof that

the

user

transtbrred information

the about

·rsirtg a LimeWire
file name,
to

addition, the ".pcap" files contain
the file
was

the:audio

th:e file hash

and the date and rime ·reen·shot

&·wnload·,xt.
At

E·bit.C request

·is

declea'ation

contains review·xl

a

example ofa %ly·ap" file.

the

I ofptaimifl·,·, have that
files

each of the %pcap" files and I eonfil·

that

those
hashes
to

files indicate
each office

each

of the files download¢·l

by DtecNet
fi-om
two

(files witl ! identical
diftbrent
LimeWire

in Atl·ehrnent

A)

were

transferred

use·.

t

declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is

true

.and cotter.

Deeember·,

2008

Thomas

Sehested

3

SEHESTED

DECLARATION
A

Exhibit

11_24_2008 11_22_2008 11_28_2008 11_21_2008 11_20_2008 11_20_2008 11_22_2008 11_21_2008 12_01_2008
11 25 22 2008 2008

Only Wanna
Match Keith Third Green Linkin Box 20 Sweat
-

Be With
-

You.mp3
CY7357BOPPF6XTL3R7EWQINFJCDCCX7 4ECZUHPSAOMPT2A3VJU7D2FJQMCY4DQI

Long Day.mp3

Games.rap3
-

Eye Blind Day
Park-

Semi
-

Charmed 06
-

Life.rap3

DDGJQANTFRN2JGBILHEGRTBHFIDPKGVF
XCYDL67EVYKCOO2QTGZNSWU5P7XXP611 RHCKC2E47LDJ2SM52Q2LPODQ42QDDEGO 78NDNBK26QRLC4QVHE61KORHX3GOPLY7 ZVD5BQOAA2WNN3RY5XJHO6YNKSH2SCRJ HNBWI3AWZOH2BB64SH7LK2PG723U2LCY

Dookie

Pulling Teeth.mp3

Papercut.mp3
I Got A Woman.rap3

Ray Charles

Light My Fire.rap3
14
-

No

Doubt

-

Dark
-

Blue.mp3
Breach
-

02. The

Wallflowers
-

Hand

Me Down.rap3

PD6OXL7OVY7DIG7RZDO,

VC77FZH4AAJCO F7UQ

98 Degrees Brian

Invisible
-

Man.rap3 dance.rap3

4DUVAK4M4ZC4XQCKK2Si3Z5ZIQO5 VFPH DT22CG

12_01._2008

Mcknight
Crows

last
-

N742ZL6PMWWRJVOCSESAKJ H5SN76DL24ZYW7 LWTO U6C7

11_21_2008
11_24_2008 12_01_2008 11_21_2008 11_21_2008 12_01_2008 12_01_2008 11_21_2008 11_24_2008 11_22_2008 11_24_2008 12_01_2008 11_25_2008 11_21_2008 11_25_2008 11_21_2008 11_21_2008 11_24_2008

Counting

A Long December.rap3 On.MP3
a

NIJJRWZ6PS4BFW2GTN

George StraitMarvin EverclearMaze

Lead
-

IEY2WDICYCBU5MIMT2A71GAG One

Gaye

You're

Wonderful

(1964).mp3

XYVWJZT67NWEIHB2XNJJ3ASCIBM7VFDW 7DN3TCV4NLN3M3AMPSLG4WNCXSE7GBA

l=ather

of mine.rap3

featuring
-

Frankie,Beverly
Da

-

Joy And Pain.rap3
Not Told
-

TSD2FJKUS4J77EJAPQBSFU67LRNIPZ2N

Snoop Dogg
06
-

Game

Is To Be Sold

02.

DSUCEUCVXV6QQJYVSU U PWH BTKDU UOHQI
G BVU H66 K4JX2GJ CKQWOI3WZGDVAARVWH

Kelis

-

Game
-

show.rap3
Hearted Little Surfer

Paula The

Abdul Beach

Cold
-

Snake.mp3 Girl.mp3

KQDNWZUVUHZCZAVDRTKFM TBOE4W7EKZM RDRWZ3YAU

D3H5322FKI PRRO K60,AP71=H

Boys
-

Alan jackson Brooks He Talks SWV
-

someday.rap3
-

CINAM B3ZN LC6U4S3PZFT5OJATWKNYRB5 Found
in A

& Dunn

Lost And

Border

Town.rap3

WB4XHZI2HN

NV36QUJHN5KKETODDXDDK
PCLIIJ3DJ4UGU5 DCZY2BXN5WZ EPZLZ LTS

To Me.rap3

IXDH PZ7FP5XPXVZHA3H LKFQ6SVOYSTAJZ5DK71:4M IS3 H4YLI20

I'm So Into
-

You.mp3
-

Outkast UsherMariah Nas
-

ATLiens

10

-

Mainstream.rap3

FU U DVT7ZBSWAYCFHS

Final

Goodbye.rap3
-

4FC3YVH NWPQPWBE4M A l=riend.mp3

E31V51M4QKVN

Carey
IIImatic
-

Anytime You Need
07
-

KKOWB MYG5V6PKXCKHZDLNGZVC33POIWY LIAE DGJ KU U MGQD6WVD4OZ6EVFTSDU6EX

One Born

Love.rap3
to

The Byrds

Wasn't

Follow

-

Easy Rider.mp3

2G EYHOX3WO,

AVTFH7RM3LG

EEG6UV303

KL

SEHESTED

DECLARATION
B

Exhibit

Sehested 12/03/08 Declaration

SEHESTED

DECLARATION C

Exhibit

®