Arista Records LLC et al v. Lime Wire LLC et al

Filing 186

FILING ERROR - DEFICIENT DOCKET ENTRY - DECLARATION of Katherine B. Forrest in Opposition re: 168 MOTION to Strike Plaintiffs' Exhibits Filed as Part of Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendants' MSJ and Defendants' Motion to Strike., 165 MOTION to Strike Plaintiffs' Exhibits Filed as Part of Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendants' MSJ and Defendants' Motion to Strike.. Document filed by Capitol Records, Inc., Elektra Entertainment Group, Inc., Interscope Records, Laface Records LLC, Motown Record Company, L.P., Arista Records LLC, Priority Records LLC, Sony BMG Music Entertainment, UMG Recordings, Inc., Virgin Records America, Inc., Warner Bros. Records Inc., Atlantic Recording Corporation, BMG Music. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 492 to Forrest December 5, 2008 Declaration, # 2 Exhibit 493 to Forrest December 5, 2008 Declaration, # 3 Exhibit 494 to Forrest December 5, 2008 Declaration, # 4 Exhibit 495 to Forrest December 5, 2008 Declaration, # 5 Exhibit 496 to Forrest December 5, 2008 Declaration, # 6 Exhibit 497 to Forrest December 5, 2008 Declaration, # 7 Declaration of Elizabeth Cuneo, # 8 Declaration of Siobhan Minarovich, # 9 Declaration of Andrew Kempe, # 10 Declaration of Thomas Sehested)(Forrest, Katherine) Modified on 12/8/2008 (jar).

Exhibit

494

UNITED SOUTHERN

STATES
DISTRICT

DISTRICT OF

COURT
NEW YORK

LLC; ATLANTIC BMG CORPORATION; MUSIC; CAPITOL RECORDS, INC.; ELEKTRA ENTERTAINMENT GROUP INC.; INTERSCOPE LAFACE RECORDS RECORDS; LLC; MOTOWN RECORD PRIORITY RECORDS COMPANY, L.P.; BMG MUSIC UMG LLC; SONY ENTERTAINMENT; RECORDS RECORDINGS, INC., VIRGIN BROS. RECORDS AMERICA, INC.; and WARNER INC., Plaintiffs,
RECORDING
V.

ARISTA

RECORDS

DEFENDANTS' SUPPLEMENTAL DISCLOSURES
FEDERAL RULE

FIRST
PURSUANT TO

OF

CIVIL

PROCEDURE

26(a)(1)

CIVIL

ACTION

NO.

06

CV

5936

(GEL)

LIME

WIRE

LLC;
GREG

LIME

GROUP

LLC;
M.J.G.

MARK LIME WIRE

GORTON;
FAMILY

LIMITED

and BILDSON; PARTNERSHIP,

Defendants. Defendants Lime Wire Lime Wire Limited

LLC, Lime

Group LLC,

Mark

Gorton,

Greg Bildson
make

and these

M.J.G.

Family
disclosures

Partnership
to

(collectively
Rule need of Civil each

"Defendants")
Procedure

first

supplemental
of the with

pursuant
and

Federal

26(a)(1) and the stipulation
the

parties that Plaintiffs
information:

Defendants

only disclose

identity of individuals

discoverable

Reservations Defendants time. Defendants make have these
not

disclosures

based

upon

information of this

reasonably
case

available

at

this

completed their

investigation

and

have

not

completed prejudice

preparation for trial.
to

Accordingly, these supplemental
to

disclosures
at

are

provided without
that is

Defendants'

right

introduce

at

a

hearing right
to

or

trial

any

evidence

subsequently
the

discovered.

Defendants

reserve

the

clarify,

amend,

modify,

or

supplement

information Civil

contained

in these

supplemental
of this Court.
with

disclosures

in accordance

with

the Federal

Rules

of

Procedure

and the rules

Individuals

Discoverable

Information

1.

Defendants and

identify the
numbers

following
those

individuals

(and

to

the

extent

known Defendants

their

addresses have

telephone
to

of the

individuals)
that

currently known
may
use

to

to

or

likely

have

discoverable

information

Defendants

to

support

its claims

and defenses: Unknown

Representatives of Altnet, 14011 Ventura Blvd., Suite 501 Sherman Oaks, CA 91423 Representatives
Avenue,
South

Inc.

Unknown 200
12
th

of Amazon.com,

Inc.

Seattle,

Washington 98144-2734

206-266-1000 Unknown
1 Infinite

Representatives Loop
CA 95014

of

Apple,

Inc.

Cupertino,
408-996-1010

Ikezoye Schrempp, Vice President Engineering Michael of Business McTeigue, Vice President Audible Magic 985 University Avenue, Suite 35
Vance

Jim

Development

Los

Gatos,

CA

95032

408-399-6405

Alex All

Rofman,

Vice

President,

Business

Development

Aydar Rusty Rueff
SNOCAP,
310-403-3809 Unknown 14011 Sherman
Fax Inc.

Ventura

Representatives of Brillant Blvd., Suite 501 Oaks, CA 91423

Digital Entertainment,

Inc.

818-386-2179

1270844vl

2

John
Hank

Hummer

Berry
Winblad
CA Venture Partners 300

Hummer One San

Lombard

Street, Suite
94111

Francisco,

415-979-9600

David
James

Goldberg
A.

Pitaro,
Fisher

Business

Affairs

Roberto
Ken Matt Rita

Tarmas

Compton, Media
Gardin Music
Avenue

Services

and

Strategic Partnerships

Yahoo
701

First

Sunnyvale, California Larry Linietsky
Senior
Alan

94089

Vice Cohen Kehoe

President

Global

Business

Development

Noel Andrea Giles Aileen Cliona

Davenow

Yassin Atkins

Murphy
Melrose
Avenue California West

Napster
9044

Hollywood,
Hasan

90069

Miah
R.

Keough, Managing Director Cams, Managing Director Dennis B. Levine, ADASAR Group Oris Capital Partners
Michael
445 New

Clarke

Park

Avenue New

York,

York

10022

Avi Nadar, WhenU
1 Penn New

CEO

Plaza, Suite 4532
York,
New

York

10119

1270844vi

3

Chris Zahavah Eric 2601

Maxcy
Levin
Inc.

Klein Elliott
Avenue 98121

RealNetworks,
Seattle,

Washington

Carey Sherman
Mitch
Steve Ken

Bainwol Marks Doroshow of America
300

Stanley Pierre Louis Recording Industry Association
1330

Connecticut
D.C.

Avenue,
20036

Suite

Washington,
202-857-9600 Nicholas
Janus

Zennstrom

Friis

2

Skype Technologies Stephen Street
W 1T 1 AN

London,

England
Michael StreamCast 20969
Ventura

Weiss Networks

Blvd.,
CA

Suite
91364

215

Woodland 818-998-8610 Unknown
702

Hills,

Representatives
8
th

of Walmart

S.W.

Street
72716

Bentonville, Arkansas
479-273-0280
Sam 45 New W.

Yagan
21
st

Street NY

#6D

York,

10010

646-216-8762

Representatives
c/o Katherine 825
New B. Avenue New

of Arista

Records

LLC

Forest,
York

Cravath, Swaine
10019-7475

& Moore,

L.L.P.

Eighth
York,

1270844vl

4

Representatives
c/o Katherine
825 B. Avenue New

of Atlantic

Recording Corporation Forest, Cravath, Swaine & Moore
York 10019-7475

L.L.P.

Eighth
York,

New

Representatives
c/o Katherine
825 New B. Avenue New

of BMG

Music

Forest,
York

Cravath,
10019-7475

Swaine

& Moore

L.L.P.

Eighth
York,

Representatives
c/o Katherine
825 New B. Avenue New

of

Capitol Records,
Cravath,
10019-7475

Inc.

Forest,
York

Swaine

& Moore

L.L.P.

Eighth
York,

Representatives
c/o Katherine
825 New B. Avenue New

of Elektra

Entertainment

Group
& Moore

Inc. L.L.P.

Forest,
York of

Cravath,
10019-7475

Swaine

Eighth
York,

Representatives
c/o Katherine 825
New B. Avenue New

Interscope Records
Cravath,
10019-7475

Forest,
York

Swaine

&

Moore,

L.L.P.

Eighth
York,

Representatives
c/o Katherine 825
New B.

of Laface

Records

LLC Swaine
&

Forest,
York

Cravath,
10019-7475 Record

Moore,

L.L.P.

Eighth Avenue
York,
New

Representatives
c/o Katherine 825
New B.

of Motown

Company,
Swaine
&

L.P. L.L.P.

Forest,
York of

Cravath,
10019-7475

Moore,

Eighth Avenue
York,
New

Representatives
c/o Katherine 825
New B. Avenue New

Priority Records
Cravath,
10019-7475

LLC

Forest,
York of

Swaine

&

Moore,

L.L.P.

Eighth
York,

Representatives
c/o Katherine 825
New

B.

Sony BMG Music Entertainment Forest, Cravath, Swaine & Moore,
10019-7475

L.L.P.

Eighth Avenue York, New York

1270844vl

5

Representatives
c/o Katherine 825
New B. Avenue New

of UMB

Recordings,
Cravath,
10019-7475

Inc. &

Forest,
York of

Swaine

Moore,

L.L.P.

Eighth York,

Representatives
c/o Katherine
825 New B. Avenue New

Forest,
York

Virgin Records America, Inc. Cravath, Swaine & Moore,
10019-7475
Bros.

L.L.P.

Eighth York,

Representatives
c/o Katherine
825 New B. Avenue New

of Warner

Records

Inc. &

Forest,
York

Cravath, Swaine
10019-7475 of Sharman of

Moore,

L.L.P.

Eighth
York,

Unknown Unknown
455

Representatives Representatives
Real

Networks

pressplay/Roxio

E1 Camino

Santa

Clara, California
Rosso D.

95050

Wayne
Allen Mike
216

Lenard

Bebel 58th
Street

Mashboxx

Apartment B Virginia Beach,
Talmon Ofer Robert iMesh
Marco

VA

23451

Shabti Summers

Jeffrey Kimmel Meister Seelig
708 Third
New

& Fein

LLP

Avenue,
NY

24th

Floor

York,

10017

Stephen
Gracenote

DuPont

2000

Powell

Street, Suite

1380

Emeryville, California
Mitchell Mitch

94608

Reichgut
Golden

1270844vl

6

Jun

Group,

Inc.

203-761-8744 Mimi
Scott AOL One New

Kim

Boyd
Music Time
Warner New Center

York,
Martin

York

10019-8016

Glenn
Intent 4470

MediaWorks Chamblee
310

Dunwoody Road, Suite Atlanta, Georgia 30338
Paul

Senior
845 New

Greenberg Vice President, Business
Avenue, York, New
rd

Development

MusicNet 3
11
th

Floor
10022

York

212-704-0280 Mark Senior
New

Eisenberg
Vice President
and

Business Business

Affairs/

Technology
Haussler Wiesenthal

Development

Christa Rob

Sir Howard

Stringer
Music
Avenue New

Sony
New

BMG

Entertainment York 10022-3211

550 Madison

York,

212-833-5392

Ken

Parks Vice
Munsen

Senior

President,

Strategy and Business
and Distribution

Development

Ralph Digital Development
EMI 150 New

Music Fifth
Avenue New York 10011

York,

212-786-8877 Elliott Vice Howie
Peters

President,

Senior

Counsel

and Head

of

George White, SVP Strategy and Product Singer, VP Strategic Technology

Digital Legal Affairs Development

1270844vl

7

Stephen M. Bryan, VP Strategic Planning and Business Counsel Amy Lauren, Associate Warner Music Group
75 New Rockefeller Plaza New

Development

York,

York

10019

212-275-2180

Larry Kenswil, President Christopher Bell Edgar Bronfman
Universal Universal 2220
Santa

eLabs Music

Group
Avenue 90404

Colorado

Monica, California

310-865-4094

Mark Lime
Porter 1000

Gorton Wire LLC S. Baker

c/o Charles
&

Hedges,
Street,
Texas

L.L.P. 36 77002
th

Main

Floor

Houston,

Greg Bildson
Lime
Porter 1000

Wire
&

LLC S. Baker

c/o Charles Main

Hedges, L.L.P.
Street, 36
Texas 77002
th

Floor

Houston,
Sam Lime
Porter

Berlin Wire &
LLC S. Baker

c/o Charles 1000 Main

Hedges,
Street,
Texas

L.L.P. 36 77002
th

Floor

Houston,
Zlatin Lime
Porter

Balevsky
Wire LLC S. Baker

c/o Charles
&

1000

Main

Hedges, L.L.P. th Street, 36 Floor
Texas

Houston,

77002

1270844vl

8

Tim Lime
c/o Porter 1000

Olsen Wire
Charles & Main LLC S. Baker

Hedges,
Street,
Texas

L.L.P. 36 77002
th

Floor

Houston,
Katie Lime
Porter 1000

Catillaz

Wire
&

LLC S. Baker

c/o Charles Main

Hedges,
Street,
Texas

L.L.P. 36
th

Floor

Houston,
Andrew Lime
Porter 1000

77002

Fischler Wire
& LLC S. Baker

c/o Charles Main

Hedges,
Street,
Texas

L.L.P. 36 77002
th

Floor

Houston,
Zenzele Lime
Porter

Bell

Wire
&

LLC

c/o Charles 1000 Main

S. Baker

Hedges,
Street,
Texas

L.L.P. 36 77002
th

Floor

Houston,
Krik Lime
Porter

Kahn
Wire LLC S. Baker

c/o Charles
&

Hedges,
Street,
Texas

L.L.P. 36 77002
th

1000

Main

Floor

Houston,
Felix Lime
Porter

Berger
Wire
& LLC S. Baker

c/o Charles 1000 Main

Hedges,
Street,
Texas

L.L.P. 36
th

Floor

Houston,

77002

1270844vl

9

Kevin Lime
Porter 1000

Faaborg
Wire
& LLC S. Baker

c/o Charles Main

Hedges,
Texas

L.L.P.
th

Street, 36

Floor

Houston,
Christine Lime
Porter 1000

77002

Cioffari
LLC S. Baker

Wire
&

c/o Charles Main

Hedges,
Street,
Texas

L.L.P. 36 77002
th

Floor

Houston,
Jesse

Rubenfeld Wire
& LLC S. Baker

Lime
Porter 1000

c/o Charles Main

Hedges,
Street,
Texas

L.L.P.

36

th

Floor

Houston,
Nathan Lime
Porter 1000

77002

Lovejoy
Wire
&

LLC
S. Baker L.L.P. 36 77002
th

c/o Charles Main

Hedges,
Street,
Texas
Kumar LLC

Floor

Houston,

Akshay
Lime
Porter 1000

Wire
&

c/o Charles Main

S. Baker

Hedges,
Texas

L.L.P.
th

Street, 36
77002

Floor

Houston,
David Lime
Porter 1000 Yeu

Wire
&

LLC S. Baker

c/o Charles Main

Hedges,
Street,
Texas

L.L.P. 36
tn

Floor

Houston,

77002

1270844vl

10

Michael Lime
Porter 1000

Nutt

Wire
& Main

LLC S. Baker

c/o Charles

Hedges, L.L.P.
Street,
Texas 36 77002
th

Floor

Houston,

Jorge Mancheno
Lime
Porter 1000 Wire LLC S. Baker

c/o Charles
&

Hedges,

L.L.P.
th

Main

Street, 36

Floor

Anthony Carlucci 81 Sycamore Street Massapequa, New York
Ron 449

11758

Vogl
Huron Avenue

Cambridge, Massachusetts
Jennifer-Kate 300 Mercer
New Barrett

Street, Apt.
New

1D 10003

York,

York

Roger Kapsi 137 Rivington Apt. #5
New

Street

York,

New

York

10002

Matthew
607

Kotzen

Lorimer

Street, Apt.

1

Brooklyn, New York
Mark 300 New

11211

Kornfilt
Mercer

Street, Apt. 22J
New

York,

York

10003

Benjamin Hunter
252
New

Seventh Soule

Avenue,

Apt.

81

York, New York

10001
4B

Robert

44 Columbia

Place, Apt.
New

Brooklyn,

York

11201

1270844v

1

11

Tarum 27 New West

Kapoor
82
nd

Street, Apt.
York

3B

York,

New

10024

7

Stephen Cho Stonebridge
New

Lane

Princeton,
Steffan
1855

Jersey 08540

Pingel
West 12
th

Avenue

Vancouver,
V6J 2E7

BC

Canada

Anurag Singla 30 Newport Parkway, Apt. 2409 Jersey City, New Jersey 07310 Christopher Rohrs
215 New East

84

th

Street, Apt.
York

1A

York,
Fisk
th

New

10028

Adam 95

S. 4

Street
New York 11211

Brooklyn,
Yusuke

Naito

11 Lefferts

Place, Apt.
York

2 11238

Brooklyn, New
Adam
138

Harris 11756

Stephen Street Levittown, New York
Sumeet 302 New Mott

Thadani

Street, Apt.
New

12 10012

York,

York

Aubrey Arago
15 Terhune

Avenue

Jersey City, New Jersey 07305
Susheel
2110

Daswani

Haste Street, Apt. 323 94704 Berkeley, California

1270844vl

12

Dave 1105

Nicponski
Summit

Ave., Apt
New

3 07307

Jersey City,
Christine
191

Jersey

Nicponski Congress Street, Floor 2 Jersey City, New Jersey 07307 Angel Leon
363

Stockholm
New

Street, Apt.
York 11237

2L

Brooklyn,
Karl
377 New

Magdsick Broadway,
York,
New

11

th

Floor
10013

York

Meghan Formel
310 New East 9
th

Street, Apt.
New York

3 10003

York,

Zaphaniah Grunschlag 560 Riverside Drive, Apt. 3P New New York 10027 York, Amy Hoy
Sean 3400 #312 Los

Clifford
Ben

Lomond
CA

Place 90027

Angeles,
Schmidt

Justin
New

245 Avenue

C, Apt. 5A
NY 10009

York,
Steme

Rachel
321 New East

Houston, Apt. York, NY 10002

1

1270844vl

13

Mike

Linksuayer
Commons

Vice-President Creative
San

171 Second and/or

Street, Suite
CA 94105

300

Francisco,

Gipsstrasse 12 10119 Berlin, Germany
Rick
P.O.

Prelinger Prelinger Archives
Box

590622
CA

San

Francisco,
C.

94159

Martin
DCIA

Lafferty
Neck

2838

Cox

Road, Suite 200
21619

Chester,
Unknown
201 San

Maryland

representatives
Street, Suite
CA 94105

of BitTorrent
900

Mission

Francisco,

Unknown

representatives 22/24 Boulevard Royal, Luxenbourg
Friis, Niklas
101 T Xc

of

Skype Technologies

S.A.

L-2449

Janus

Zennstrom

and other

unknown

representatives

of Joost

Schipholweg
2316 The Netherlands and 41 East
New 11
th

Leiden

Street,
New

11

ta

Floor
10003

York,

York

Valerio

Zingarelli and unknown Dublin, Ireland representatives
at Raw

individuals

at

Babel

Networks

Ltd.

Unknown

Flow

Sugih Jamin, Beat Knecht, Thomas
Patel, Dug Song and other
1327 Ann Jones

unknown

Billeter, Francesco Vass, Benoit at Zattoo representatives

Henry, Jignesh

Drive, Suite 106 Arbor, Michigan 48105

1270844vl

14

Unknown
New

representatives
New York

of Raketu

Communications

Inc.

York,

Unknown 487 East

representatives
Middlefield Road CA 94043

of

Verisign

Mountainview,
Unknown
1902 S.E.

of Abacast, reffresentatives 6 Avenue
t

Inc.

Camas,
Unknown
211 New

Washington

98607

representative
Avenue,
New

of 10016

Qtrax

Madison

#28B

York,

York

Mitgang, Dmitry Shapiro, Joshua Metzger, Bilger, Todd Dagres, Michael Eisner and unknown
Inc. San

Steve

Dr.

Dunning, Ted Meisel, Arthur representatives of Veoh Networks,

Ted

Diego,

CA

Alfie Contact
Steve

Zappacosta at [e-mail]
Winwood

Page Stuart Sleepwalker's Paradise Contact via [e-mail] Or realpolitik(·earthlink.net Brooklyn, New York Members of the group Soulcoughing
Members Members Contact
5225 Los

Krisfin

of the group of the group the above Blvd.
CA

New

Riders

of the

Purple Sage
Kufala Records

Slip through Brady Lahr

The

at

Wilshire

Angeles, Kayuba

90036

Pucka Members Alex Robert Contact

of the group
Devon

The

Quick Fix Kills
Rice of the group The Animators

Wong,
Roth

Copley, Phil Galitzine, Kevin

via [e-mail]

1270844v

I

15

Members Sushirobo Members Members Members Members
John

of the group

The

Worship Project

of the

group

The

Blam

of the group of the group of the group

American The The

Analog

Set

Appleseed Cast
Sick

Lipstick

Vanderslice

Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown
Dean

Representatives Representatives Representatives Representatives Representatives

of MGM
of

Studios

Disney Studios
Bros. Studios

of Warner of

Sony Entertainment
Studios

of Universal

Garfield Picture Association Nine of America
Inch

Motion Members Artist Artist

of the group

Nails

Jay-Z
Ne-Yo
LLC

Sparkart
P. O. Box

8639
CA

Emeryville,
510-420-0201 Rich

94662-0639

Egan Manager of the

group

Dashboard

Confessional

1270844vl

16

Unknown
1601

representatives c/o ARTISTdirect, Inc.
Cloverfield South
CA 90404

of MediaDefender

Blvd.

Ste. 400 Santa

Monica,

JeffTweedy
The band
The

Wilco of Furthumet.com

operators
Morris

Kevin General Wincraft
41

Manager
Music

Rodney Road Cheltenham, U.K.
044-1242-260066

Unknown Members Anders Unknown Unknown Jari Ahola
VTT

representatives
of the group

of

Capitol Records
Ros

Sigun

Weberg representatives representatives
Research
1

of

Interscope Records

of P2P-Next

Technical

Centre

of Finland

Tekniikankatu
FIN-33720 358 20 722

Tampere, Finland
3334

Luista Head

of the

Rodriguez-Rosell6 Europe Union's representatives
Avenue

Network of Swarmcast

Media

Unknown 615 First
Suite 330

Minneapolis,
651-340-8787

MN

55413

representatives Cambridge Center Cambridge, MA 02143
8 817-325-2624

Unknown

of Akamai

1270844vl

17

Unknown Unknown

representatives representatives

of Kontiki of

RayV

Operators of the following websites: http://bt.etree.org/ http://nugs.net/ http : / /www. wizards.co http://torrent.ibiblio.org/
Laura

m/

default.asp ?x=magic/magi conline/

do wnloadlinks

Tunberg
Norwich
Avenue CA 91411

5420

Sherman

Oaks,

1270844vl

18

Respectfully Submitted,
Of counsel:
Charles Lauren E. Handler /s/ S. Baker D. K.

Joseph
Susan
& PORTER 1000

SDNY

(LEH 6908)
BROMBERG

(CB1365) (JC3017) Hellinger (SH8148)
Cohen
&

PORZIO,

HEDGES,
th

LLP

NEWMAN, P.C. 100 Southgate Parkway
P.O. Box

Main

Street,
Texas

36

Floor

Houston,

77002

1997

Morristown, NJ 07962-1997 [phone] (Facsimile) [phone] (Telephone)
lehandler(5),pbn.com

[phone] [phone]

(Telephone) (Facsimile)

cbaker(·,porterhedqes.com icohen·,porterhed.qes.com shellinqer·,porterhed.qes.com
A

ttorneys for Defendants/ Counterplaintiff
SERVICE of the
on

CERTIFICATE

OF

The the

undersigned hereby certifies that a true and via electronic mail and/or following counsel
as

correct U.S.

copy

mail,

this

22nd

foregoing was served upon day of February, 2008,

addressed

follows:

/s/

Charles
TO:

S. Baker

Katherine Teena-Ann Worldwide
825 New

B. V.

Forrest Sankoorikal & Moore,
LLP

Cravath, Swaine
Plaza
Avenue NY

Eighth
York,

10019-7475

[phone] [phone]
Counsel

(fax)

Counterclaim

for Plaintiffs/ Defendants

1270844vl

19

Of Counsel: Kenneth
L. Doroshow

Karyn A. Temple Recording Industry Association
1025 F

of America

Street, NW, 10th Floor

Washington, DC 20004 [phone] [phone] (fax)

1270844vl

20