Schoolcraft v. The City Of New York et al

Filing 598

DECLARATION of Alan H. Scheiner in Opposition re: 566 FINAL MOTION for Attorney Fees for Levine & Gilbert and Peter J. Gleason, Esq.., 559 MOTION for Attorney Fees , Costs and Disbursements.. Document filed by The City Of New York. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit, # 2 Exhibit, # 3 Exhibit, # 4 Exhibit, # 5 Exhibit, # 6 Exhibit, # 7 Exhibit, # 8 Exhibit, # 9 Exhibit, # 10 Exhibit, # 11 Exhibit, # 12 Exhibit, # 13 Exhibit, # 14 Exhibit, # 15 Exhibit, # 16 Exhibit, # 17 Exhibit, # 18 Exhibit, # 19 Exhibit, # 20 Exhibit, # 21 Exhibit, # 22 Exhibit, # 23 Exhibit, # 24 Exhibit, # 25 Exhibit, # 26 Exhibit, # 27 Exhibit, # 28 Exhibit, # 29 Exhibit)(Scheiner, Alan)

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

.

1

No.
1.0

B

Date
11/26/12

2

2.0

12/02/12

3

3.0

12/07/12

4

4.0

12/09/12

5

5.0

12/12/12

6

6.0

12/14/12

7

7.0

12/15/12

8

8.0

12/16/12

9

9.0

12/21/12

10

10.0

12/27/12

11

11.0

01/12/13

12

12.0

01/13/13

13

13.0

01/15/13

14
14.0

01/17/13

15

15.0

01/22/13

16

16.0

01/23/13

17

17.0

01/23/13

18

18.0

01/30/13

19

19.0

02/04/13

D

C

Timekeepe Description
Meeting with RG regarding obtaining and
Peter J.
scheduling picking up Schoolcraft file from prior
Gleason
counsel.
Phone cony. with AS regarding status of
Peter J.
investigations.
Gleason
Phone cony. with AS re: NYPD employment issues
Peter J.
Gleason
Phone cony. with FS, re: his overview of the matter
Peter J.
and scheduling a time to meet to discuss same in
Gleason
person
Meeting with FS's attorney to discuss FS
Peter J.
Gleason involvement in the Schoolcraft matter.
E-mail to NYPD Asst. Comm. Kearns, re:
Peter J.
Schoolcraft NYPD employment issues.
Gleason
Legal research, re: prosecutorial misconduct as a
Peter J.
bar to overcome immunity.
Gleason
E-mail from FS's atty.
Peter J.
Gleason
Organize and review case files.
Peter J.
Gleason
Review of part of Schoolcraft file: Partial review of
Peter J.
"Attorney's eyes only" File.
Gleason
Phone cony. with NS re: updating him on veracity
Peter J.
Gleason of matter.
Multiple e -mails from AS and follow up phone
Peter J.
Gleason cony. with AS. Re: PBA, NYPD, employment
status and investigation.
Phone cony, with AS re: Queens DA.
Peter J.
Gleason
Meeting with VP, re: "Home Invasion,"
Peter J.
participants.
Gleason
Phone cony. with AS, re, NYPD issues, sheduling
Peter J.
Gleason his travel to meet with counsel in NYC, update on
progress of investigation.
Phone cony. with RG, Re: NYPD letter
Peter J.
Gleason
E-mail to NYPD Asst. Comm. Kearns, re:
Peter J.
Schoolcraft position on employment matter.
Gleason
Phone conc. with AS, update.
Peter J.
Gleason
Phone cony. with AS, re: travel to NYC on 2/7/13,
Peter J.
e-mail AS, round trip Amtrak tickeets for AS & LS.
Gleason

Hours

0.250
0.500
0.750

0.250

4.000
0.125

2.250
0.125

2.500
3.500
0.750

3.250
0.500
0.750

2.250
0.125

0.125

0.250

0.500

20

20.0
21

E

02/07/13

Peter J.
Gleason

Meeting with AS, NS, & JL, re: adding lawyers to
the legal team.
Page 1

2.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

21.0

Date
02/09/13

22.0

02/10/13

23.0

02/18/13

24.0

02/20/13

25.0

02/21/13

26.0

02/22/13

27.0

02/24/13

28.0

02/26/13

29.0

02/27/13

30.0

02/28/13

31.0

03/04/13

32.0

03/05/13

33.0

03/07/13

34.0

03/13/13

35.0

03/14/13

36.0

03/16/13

37.0

03/18/13

38.0

03/19/13

39.0

03/20/13

40.0

03/21/13

41.0

1

03/23/13

No.

22
23

24
25

26

C

D

E

Timekeepe Description
--Peter J.
E-mail and phone cony. with AS re: upcoming
Gleason
deposition on 2/12/13, purchase train ticket
Peter J.
E-mail to NS, re: deposition
Gleason
Peter J.
E-mail from JL, re: internet posting pertaining to
Gleason AS, review of same.
Peter J.
Meeting with NS, JL. Re: Queens DA subpoena
Gleason
Peter J.
E-mail from RG, re: evidence preservation.
Gleason
Peter J.
Review of e -mails from JL & NS, re: DOJ. E-mail
Gleason
to NS & JL re: Agenda for Sunday's meeting.

27

1.000

0.125

0.500
0.750
0.250

0.750

28
29

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

30
31
32
33

34
35

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

meeting in Saugerties NY with NS, JL, AS, LS.
Travel to and from Saugerties
E-mail from Magdalena Bauza (MB), re: resume
and her interest in working on matter.
Phone cony. with NS, re: service upon 5
defendants. Travel to 1PP to serve summonses after
law dept. refuses to accept.
Queens DA's office to serve subpoena. (travel)

3.500
0.125

2.250

2.000

E-mail from Brian Lee, Esq., re: scheduling order.
0.250

E -mails to and from AS re: trip to city, purchase
train ticket.
Meeting with AS & NS

0.500

3.500

ECF notice and review of same. (letter to judge
from City.)
(3) ECF notices and review of same. (Defendant's
motion to Quash) and follow up discussion with NS

36

0.500

1.250

37

38
39

40
41
42

Hours

-

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

E-mail from JL, re: Letter to DOJ and strategy.
0.500

E-mail from JL, re: Schoolcraft media report.
0.250

E-mail from NS, re: Home invasion recording.
0.125

ECF notice, re: amended answer.
0.500

E-mail from JL, re: Schoolcraft tapes in WSJ.
0.125

E-mail from AS, re: recording of Lt. Mascol.
0.500
Page 2

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

42.0

B

Date
03/26/13

43

43.0

03/27/13

44
44.0

03/27/13

45

45.0

03/28/13

46

46.0

03/28/13

47

47.0

04/01/13

48
48.0

04/02/13

49

49.0

04/02/13

50

50.0

04/04/13

51

51.0

04/05/13

52

52.0

04/13/13

53

53.0

04/08/13

54

54.0

11/20/12

C

D

1

Timekeepe Description
Phone cony. with NS, re: motion.
Peter J.
Gleason
ECF notice, re: Schoolcraft declaration
Peter J.
Gleason
Meeting with NS, MB, re: demonstrative evidence
Peter J.
to be used at trial.
Gleason
E-mail from JL, re: next meeting upstate.
Peter J.
Gleason
E-mail from JL, re: confirming meeting with AS
Peter J.
Gleason
E-mail from sound engineer containing filtered
Peter J.
Gleason home invasion tape, review of same.
ECF notice, re: Hospital letter to judge.
Peter J.
Gleason
Monitor Floyd trial, re: Mauriello testimony.
Peter J.
Gleason
(2) ECF notices, re: City's motion to quash
Peter J.
Gleason
ECF notice, re: motion to quash.
Peter J.
Gleason
Phone cony. with NS, re: status.
Peter J.
Gleason
Meeting with AS & NS, re: trial prep.
Peter J.
Gleason
Meeting with investigator Vincent Parco (VP)
Peter J.
regarding working on this matter. Gave VP an
Gleason
over -view of the matter and the scope of work of
which he would perform at a rate of $150 per hr.

Hours

0.500
0.125

3.500
0.125
0.125

0.750
0.125

3.500
0.250
0.125

0.500
1.500

2.000

55

55.0

11/23/12

56

56.0

11/27/12

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

Travel
8.000

E-mail from RG and follow up phone conversation
with RG regarding the Schoolcraft file.
0.250

57

57.0

11/28/12

Peter J.
Gleason

Phone cony. with AS regarding Nov. 12, 2012 news
report and possible sources of media leaks.
1.500

58

58.0

12/03/12

59

59.0

12/09/12

60
60.0
61

E

12/22/12

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

Phone cony. with RG regarding e-mail from AS's
previous counsel.
Phone cony. with VP, re: update on investigation of
named defendants.
E-mail to RG, re, amended complaint

0.250
0.125
0.125

Page 3

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

i No.

A

B

C

D

Date

Timekeepe Description

61.0

12/24/12

Peter J.
Gleason

12/31/12

Peter J.
Gleason

63.0

01/02/13

64.0

01/20/13

65.0

01/29/13

66.0

02/05/13

67.0

02/14/13

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

E-mail from and follow up conversation with JL,
Re: his potential involvement in the Schoolcraft
matter, Queens DA's investigation, scheduling a
time we can meet.
Phone cony. with LS, re: Update on matter.

68.0

02/15/13

69.0

02/21/13

70.0

02/28/13

71.0

03/01/13

72.0

03/01/13

73.0

03/04/13

74.0

03/04/13

75.0

03/05/13

76.0

03/06/13

77.0

03/09/13

78.0

03/18/13

79.0

03/18/13

62

Hours

2.000

63

64
65

66
67

1.500

0.250

Continued review of Schoolcraft recordings, notes
to file.
Meeting with RG, FS atty.

4.500
1.500

E-mail to NYPD Asst. Comm. Kearns.
0.125

Transport file from Levin & Gilbert to Law office
of Nat Smith. Meeting with NS to discuss how file
is formatted. Meeting with AS and legal team.

68

3.500

69

70
71
72
73

74
75

76
77

78
79
80

E

Draft and hand deliver a notice of appearance that
NYPD Asst. Comm. Kearns demanded before she
would communicate with my office regarding AS.

62.0

1

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

Phone cony. with NS, re: NYS CPL & file
0.250

E-mail from AS, re: Sunday's meeting.
0.125

Review ECF notice.
0.125

ECF notices.
0.125

E-mail from and to Brian Lee, Esq.
0.250

E -mails back and forth with MB, to set up meeting
later that day.
E-mail with enclosed letter from Suzanna
Publicker, Esq., review of same.
Review e-mail from Suzanna Publicker, Esq.

0.250
0.250
0.125

E-mail from JL, re: DOJ
0.125

Meeting with NS at his office, re; strategy/status.
3.000

ECF notice, re: Order setting date for hearing.
0.125

E-mail form NS, re: edits to letter to DOJ.
0.250

Page 4

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

B

A

D

C

No.

Date

Timekeep Description

80.0

1

03/20/13

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

81
81.0

03/20/13

82
82.0

03/21/13

83
83.0

03/24/13

84
84.0

03/27/13

85
85.0

04/03/13

86
86.0

04/04/13

87
87.0

04/07/13

Hours

E-mail from NS, re: final draft of DOJ letter.
0.125

Phone cony. with NS, re: correspondence.
0.250

E-mail form JL, re: status update.
0.125

E-mail from NS, re: recording of Lt. Masco!
0.125

ECF notice, re: Plaintiffs Memo of Law.
0.125

E-mail from AS, re: NYPD employment issues.
0.125

E-mail to and from Rae Koshetz, Esq., re: NYPD
employment issues.
Meeting in Saugerties with AS, LS and legal team.
(Travel at 1/2 hr. rate)

0.250

6.000

88
88.0

04/09/13

89
89.0

04/09/13

90

90.0

11/19/12

91

91.0

11/30/12

92.0

12/01/12

92

93

93.0

12/02/12

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

Review Google alert, Re: AS
0.125

E-mail with invoice form sound engineer.
0.250

Meeting with RG to discuss news articles and our
strategy to follow up with AS and LS.
Meeting with D2, to discuss Schoolcraft matter and
backgrounds of named defendants.
Phone cony. with AS regarding update of the
investigations.
Phone cony. with RG regarding correspondence to
and conversation with AS's previous counsel.

1.500

2.500
0.750

0.500

94
94.0

12/03/12

Peter J.
Gleason

95
95.0

12/04/12

96
96.0

12/10/12

97.0

12/13/12

97

98
97.5

12/13/12

99
98.0

12/14/12

100

99.0
101

E

12/17/12

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

Phone cony. with AS regarding e-mail from his
previous counsel, investigation and setting up
another meeting.
Phone cony. with AS regarding all aspects of his
representation.
E-mail and follow up phone cony. with RG, re:
follow up with AS's prior counsel.
Follow up e-mail to FS's attorney

0.500

0.750
0.500
0.125

Meeting with VP, RE; Investigation
1.500

E-mail to NYPD Asst. Comm. Kearns, re:
Schoolcraft NYPD employment issues.
E-mail to NYPD Asst. Comm. Kearns, re:
Schoolcraft NYPD employment issues.
Page 5

0.125

0.125

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

,

C

D

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

100.0

12/22/12

101.0

12/26/12

102.0

01/03/13

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

103.0

05/05/13

104.0

01/11/13

105.0

01/14/13

106.0

01/18/13

107.0

01/25/13

108.0

01/25/13

109.0

01/28/13

110.0

02/03/13

111.0

02/08/13

112.0

02/11/13

113.0

02/17/13

114.0

03/05/13

115.0

03/11/13

116.0

03/15/13

117.0

03/20/13

118.0

03/22/13

119.0

03/25/13

120.0

03/28/13

1

102
103

Phone cony. with FS, re: complaint

0.250

E-mail to and from NYPD Asst. Comm. Kearns.
0.250

Meeting with JL, Re: Queens DA, the amended
complaint, and aspects of the Schoolcraft file.

104

2.500

105
106

107
108

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

E-mail to and from Rae Koshetz, Esq. re:
scheduling meeting.
Meeting with VP, re: individuals preset at, "Hone
invasion."
Meeting with RG, re: Queens DA.

0.125

0.750

0.750

E-mail to PBA, re: their assistance in the matter.
0.125

E-mail from NYPD Asst. Comm. Kearns, outlining
her position/demand that she will not accept e-mail
correspondence regarding this matter.

109

0.125

110
111

112
113

114
115

116
117

118

119

120
121
122

E

_ Hours
.._

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

Meeting with RG to discuss NYPD's refusal to
acknowledge e-mail communications.
Edit and hand deliver letter to NYPD Asst. Comm.
Kearns.
Phone cony. with NS, re: decision.

0.500
2.000

0.750

E-mail from, Elisha B. Barron Law Clerk to the
Hon. Shira A. Scheindlin, re: Deposition.
E-mail from RG, re: deposition/conf.

0.125
0.125

E-mail correspondence between NS & JL, re:
Queens DA.
E-mail from AS, with attachment outlining
examples of NYPD retaliation.
E-mail from AS, review attachment (transcription)
forward same to NS.
ECF notice, re: Plaintiff letter to judge.

0.250
0.250
0.750
0.125

Phone cony. with NS,
0.250

Monitor Floyd trial, re: named defendant's
testimony.
E-mail from JL, re: Schoolscraft Google alert,
review of links.
ECF notice. re: Memo of Law.

4.000
0.750
0.125

Page 6

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

B

I

I

D

C

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

121.0

1

03/28/13

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

E-mail from NS, re: Photos of Plaintiffs residence,
print and review of same.
Phone cony. with NS, re: gag order.

Peter J.
Gleason

Multiple phone conversation with RG, AS, and LS
regarding setting up a meeting the following day.

123
122.0

03/29/13

124

123.0

03/30/13

0.500
0.500

Meeting with legal team at NS office, re: update
investigation, Deft. Ans. To amended complaint.
1.250

125

124.0

11/22/12

0.750

126

125.0

11/29/12

Peter J.
Gleason

127

126.0

12/01/12

128

127.0

12/03/12

129

128.0

12/05/12

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

Phone cony. with AS regarding status of obtatining
his file from previous counsel and strategy moving
forward.
Phone cony. with VP regarding meeting of previous
night.
Phone cony. with VP regarding investigation.

0.750
0.500
0.125

E-mail and phone conversation with AS regarding
Frank Serpico (FS) and his assistance through
support and institutional knowledge of the NYPD.
0.750

130

129.0

12/05/12

131

130.0

12/06/12

132

131.0

12/14/12

133

132.0

01/09/13

134

133.0

12/19/12

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

E-mail from AS regarding previous counsel, phone
cony. with RG and AS
Legal research, re: Civil Service Law, NYPD
employment rights.
9 Metro Tech re: FDNY EMS report for AS and
(Travel at 'A hr. rate)
Meeting with RG Re: inveistgation strategy.

1.250

2.250

0.750
0.750

Albany meeting with D2 and AS.
Updated AS as to status of his claims. Discussed
with AS means for providing AS and LS the ability
to communicate with his attorneys.
(Travel at 1/2 hr. rate)

7.00

8.00

135

134.0

12/20/12

Peter J.
Gleason

Phone cony. with John Lenoir, Esq. (JL) discussing
his potention involvement in the Schoolcraft matter
0.750

136

135.0

12/23/12

137

136.0

01/02/13

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

Phone cony. with AS, re update on Queens DA
0.500

Meeting at law office of Levine & Gilbert and
continued review of "Attorney's eyes Only," file.
3.250

138

137.0
139

E

Hours

01/07/13

Peter J.
Gleason

Meeting with VP, Re: update on investigation.
1.500

Page 7

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A
1

B

Date
01/09/13

No.
138.0

140
139.0

01/10/13

140.0

01/11/13

141.0

01/12/13

142.0

01/14/13

141
142
143

144
143.0

01/16/13

144.0

01/21/13

145.0

01/21/13

146.0

02/01/13

147.0

02/01/13

148.0

02/02/13

149.0

02/20/13

150.0

02/22/13

151.0

03/10/13

152.0

03/25/13

153.0

04/01/13

154.0

04/05/13

155.0

11/29/12

156.0

12/07/12

157.0

02/08/13

145
146

147

148
149

150
151
152
153

154
155

156
157
158
159

.

158.0

12/05/12

159.0

12/06/12

160
161

C

D

Timekeepe Description
Peter J.
Phone cony. with LS, Re: status of case.
Gleason
Peter J.
Multiple phone cony. and e -mails back and forth
Gleason
with AS, re: PBA and AS's recordings.
Peter J.
Meeting with RG, re: PBA matter.
Gleason
Peter J.
Phone cony. with JL, re: viability of DOJ
Gleason
involvement.
Peter J.
E-mail from JL, Re: Schoolcraft matter.
Gleason
Peter J.
Phone cony. with VP re: update, meeting to follow.
Gleason
Peter J.
E-mail to and from RG, re: NYPD letter.
Gleason
Peter J.
Phone cony. with FS, re: the status of Schoolcraft
Gleason
matter.
Peter J.
E-mail from RG, re: e-mail from CCR. scheduling a
Gleason
phone cony. this date.
Peter J.
Phone cony. with CCR, re: Schoolcraft affidavit.
Gleason
Peter J.
E-mail from AS and review of documents attached,
Gleason re: NYPD mediation.
Peter J.
E-mail to legal team, re: Sunday's meeting.
Gleason
Peter J.
E-mail to Pub. Advocate, re: follow up meeting.
Gleason
Peter J.
E-mail to Council Member Williams
Gleason
Peter J.
E-mail from NS, re: Letter from Dept. Advocates
Gleason Office dated April 5, 2011.
Peter J.
E -mails between City, Hosp. & Plaintiff, re:
Gleason
discovery issues.
Peter J.
E-mail from/to City/Hospital re: scheduled
Gleason
conference 4/10/13.
Peter J.
Phone cony. with RG for update on obtaining file.
Gleason
Peter J.
Meeting with RG, re: strategy NYPD employment
Gleason
issue, disciplinary charges.
Peter J.
Phone cony. with NS, re: joining legal team.
Gleason
_
Peter J.
Phone cony. with VP with an update on one of the
Gleason targets of the investigation.
Peter J.
Phone cony. with RG with update regarding VP
Gleason
investigation, memo to file.

Page 8

I

E

Hours

0.500
2.500

0.750
0.500
0.125
0.125

0.250
0.750
0.125

0.750
0.750
0.125
0.125

0.250
0.250
0.500
0.125

0.250
1.000

0.500

0.500
1.250

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

I

1

j. No.

160.0

B

Date

12/10/12

162
161.0

12/17/12

163
162.0

12/20/12

164
163.0

01/08/13

TimekeepPeter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

165
164.0

01/21/13

166
165.0

01/29/13

167
166.0

02/27/13

168
167.0

03/14/13

169
168.0

03/29/13

170
169.0

11/19/12

D

C

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

I_

E

Description

Hours

Phone cony. with FS to set up the following days
meeting with FS, AS, LS.
Phone cony. with FS, follow up on cony. 12/15/12

0.125

0.500

E-mail and phone cony. with Professor from John
Jay College.
Meeting with RG to review and discuss the review
of the parts of the file reviewed by Levine &
Gilbert and by PG.
Phone cony. with NS, re: NYPD's handling of
Schoolcraft matter.
E-mail from Center for Constitutional Rights
(CCR) review of enclosed affidavit.
E-mail form MB, re: scheduling a meeting

1.250

3.500

0.750
0.500
0.125

E-mail from NS, re: Queens DA
0.125

Meeting with VP, re: photos and update.
1.500

Meeting with RG, and follow phone conversation
with AS to discuss strategy of case, drafting of the
retainer and setting up next meeting with AS.
1.500

171
170.0

11/19/12

172
171.0

11/27/12

173
172.0

11/27/12

174
173.0

12/11/12

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

Phone cony. with Nathaniel Smith, Esq. (NS) to
discuss potentially working on this matter.
E-mail from AS regarding the preferred method of
communications.
Meeting with VP regarding update on his
investigation
Meeting in Albany with AS, LS, FS. Re: Status of
investigations, NYPD employment issues, concerns
regarding Queens DA, concerns regarding Jamaica
Hospital and concerns regarding FDNY EMS
Follow up cony. with RG upon return to NYC
office, memo to file. (Travel at 1/2 hr. rate)

0.500
0.125
1.500

6.000

175
174.0

12/13/12

Peter J.
Gleason

E-mail from AS containing review/discussion of
12/4/12 Press Release from QCDA with the
conclusion that there was no criminality in the
manner that Plaintiff was taken from his home and
placed in a psychiatric facility. Extensive Follow
up phone cony. with AS and RG.
4.500

176

Page 9

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

175.0

Date
12/14/12

176.0

12/21/12

177.0

12/23/12

Peter J.
Gleason

178.0

12/28/12

179.0

01/06/13

180.0

01/29/13

181.0

02/28/13

182.0

03/29/13

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

183.0

04/08/13

184.0

12/17/12

185.0

11/20/12

186.0

12/17/12

187.0

12/23/12

188.0

01/26/13

189.0

02/11/13

190.0

02/28/13

191.0

12/06/12

192.0

12/15/12

193.0

1

01/22/13

No.

177

D

E

Timekeepe Description
..__
Peter J.
Phone cony. With RG, re: 1PP's position on AS.
Gleason
Peter J.
Phone cony. with AS regarding status, strategy,
Gleason
contents of file and investigation status.
_

178

0.500

0.750

179

180
181
182
183

184
185

186
187
188
189

190
191
192
193

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

E-mail correspondence and phone cony. with JL
Re: Queens DA's investigation of the Schoolcraft
matter.
Phone call from D2, re: Information on Schoolcraft
matter.
Completion of review of file from prevous counsel,
Memo to file.
Meeting with VP, re: update on investigation.

0.750
0.125

6.500
1.250

Prepared and file notice of appearance.
0.250

E-mail from NS, re: enclosed letter from Hosp.
Defendant to Judge concerning press, review of
same
ECF notice, re: Hospital filing re motion to quash
and letter motion re media.
Meeting with VP re: investigation update.

0.500
0.250
1.250

Phone cony. with D2, regarding his insight into one
of the named defendants.
Legal research, re: NYS PL kidnapping.

0.250
1.750

Review of amended complaint, memo to file.
1.500

Phone cony. with LS, re: status update.
0.500

Phone cony. with NS, re: Floyd case.
0.500

Review Deposition.
1.500

Phone cony. with AS regarding investigation
0.750

Phone cony. With FS, re, his conversation with first
hand witnesses to the manner in which the NY PD
maintains crime stats and subsequent memo to file.

194
195

Hours

1.500

Peter J.
Gleason

Meeting with RG, Re: NYPD letter.
1.250

Page 10

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

B

No.

Date

194.0

1

02/27/13

Timekeepe Description
Review of e-mail from Corp. Counsel containing
Peter J.

Gleason
196
195.0

11/30/12

D

C

Peter J.
Gleason

additional "Attorney's eyes only" documents and
discussion with RG & NS.
Phone cony. with RG discussing strategy and focus
on the investigation of the named defendants

E

Hours

1.250

1.000

197

196.0

12/21/12

198

197.0

01/03/13

199

198.0

01/10/13

200
199.0

02/05/13

201

200.0

03/08/13

202

201.0

01/02/13

203

202.0

01/13/13

204

203.0

12/26/12

205

204.0

01/08/13

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

Meeting with VP regarding investigation on one of
the named defendants.
Several phone calls with LS, Re: update

1.500

0.750

E-mail, fax and phone cony. with PBA legal
counsel.
E-mail from AS re: Authorization, print out and
distribute same.
ECF notice, re: Court order.

1.250

0.250
0.125

E -mails back and forth to JL re: meeting.
0.250

E-mail to Pat Lynch, PBA President.
0.125

E-mail and follow up phone conversation with Prof.
from John Jay College.
Phone cony. with AS, Re; update as to complete
review of file (excluding review of recordings) and
discussion on need for investigator to verify
identity of certain individuals who were present at
the, "home invation."

0.500

0.750

206

205.0

02/13/13

207

206.0

02/23/13

208

207.0

03/06/13

209

208.0

03/27/13

209.0

04/02/13

210
211

210.0

04/10/13

212

211.0

11/23/12

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

Meetings with AS, meeting with RG and NS.
Meeting with VP, review of file with AS.
E -mails to JL & NS, re: update from JL.

7.500
0.125

Reivew fax from Suzanna Publicker, Esq.
0.250

E-mail from NS, re: final draft of reply.
0.250

Press inquiry, re: AS
0.125

Letter from NYPD Department Advocates Office,
review of same.
Meeting with AS, LS, RG in Albany to discuss
strategy scope of work, investigations needed.
Travel to and from NYC. (Travel at 1/2 hr. rate)

0.250

4.000

213

Page 11

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
,

A

B

No.

Date

212.0

12/12/12

213.0

03/22/13

214.0

01/04/13

215.0

12/13/12

216.0

01/04/13

217.0

01/19/13

218.0

01/19/13

219.0

11/18/12

220.0

11/16/12

221.0

12/10/12

222.0

12/17/12

223.0

01/05/13

224.0

02/12/13

225.0

12/14/12

226.0

11/16/12

227.0

04/10/13

1

214
215
216

217
218
219

220
221

C

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

222
223

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

224
225

D

Timekeepe Description

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

1 Police Plaza, to discuss Schoolcraft matter with
NYPD Department Advocate's Office.
E-mail from NS & JL, re: Notice to Produce.

E

Hours

1.500

0.250

E-mail and phone cony. with PBA counsel, Re:
Union's position on Schoolcraft matter.
Phone cony. with FS re: Queens DA press release.

0.500

0.500

Meeting with RG and continued review of File.
4.250

Review of Schoolcraft audio regardings, notes to
file.

4.750

Several e -mails back and forth with RG, re: draft
letter to NYPD.
Internet review of news articles relating to AS.

0.500
5.500

Meeting with my colleague Richard Gilbert, Esq.
(RG), Retired NYPD 2" grade Detective (D2) and
Larry Schoolcraft (LS) to discuss Adrian
Schoolcraft's (AS) claim against the City of New
York.
Meeting with VP, re: update on named defendant's
investigation.
Meeting with RG, Re: procuring file from previous
counsel, NYPD employment issues, status of
investigation.
Continued review of the file

6.000
1.250

2.000
4.500

Meetings throughout day with AS in NYC, brought
him up to speed regarding aspects of his claims.
Defended his deposition in the Floyd matter before
MJ Freeman. Attended public meeting, to discuss
matter with Public Advocate DeBlasio.
Follow up meeting with AS. Review amended
discovery plan.

226

12.000

227

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

Travel
0.750

Travel to and from NYC Office to Catskill, NY.
Upon Return to NYC Office review of documents
provided by LS. (Travel at 1/2 hr. rate)

228
229

I

8.000

Peter J.
Gleason

Court Apearance, and subsq. Meeting with legal
team.

Page 12

3.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

B

I-

I

D

C

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

228.0

1

12/11/12

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

230
229.0

02/11/13

231
230.0

2/24/2013

232
231.0

02/11/13

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

233
232.0

04/05/13

234
233.0

12/18/12

Peter J.
Gleason
Peter J.
Gleason

E

Hours

Travel to Albany
8.000

Meeting with AS, review of case, discussion of
strategy and updated AS in investigation, Purchase
of business attire for AS.
meeting in Saugerties NY with NS, JL, AS, LS.
Travel to and from Saugerties
Conf. call with Elisha B. Barron Law Clerk to the
Hon. Shira A. Scheindlin re: ground -rules for
tomorrow's deposition and follow up call with NS,
& RG
Review Plaintiffs Opposition to City's motion to
Quash, e -mails between NS. JL re, edits.
Meeting with RG to facilitate picking up file from
previous counsel, picked up file (6+ banker boxes)
from previous counsel with RG and initial cursory
review of once secured in office.

4.500
8.500

2.000
0.750

6.000

235
234.0

04/11/13

Peter J.
Gleason

Consultation with AS, Meeting with legal team and
Rae Kosheck, Esq., Follow up e-mail to Rae
Kosheck, Esq., re: issues discussed at meeting.
Draft response letter to NYPD re: letter received on
4/10/13. Discussed strategy with AS.
8.000

236
235.0

04/12/13

Peter J.
Gleason

Consultation with AS discussing matter purchased
return ticket to Albany, meeting with VP.
4.500

237

Peter J.
Gleason

237.0

Expenses:
Provided AS with Apple laptop, printer/scanner
and two iPhones. Set up Verizon cell phone service
for two iphones for 12 month contract at $144.97
per line per month.

Vincent
Parco, PI

Meeting with Peter Gleason (Atty.) regarding being
hired as investigator on the Schoolcraft case.
Discussed scope of investigation which included
Investigating named defendants and determining
Identity of individuals at the Schoolcraft home the
night he was removed to Jamaica Hospital.

238
238.0

11/20/12

2.000

239

Page 13

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

I

C

D

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

239.0

11/21/12

Vincent
Parco, PI

Reviewed Civil Complaint, Reviewed NY
Magazine article, "Captain Midnight," and
numerous other media reports on subject of NY
Magazine article as well media reports on
Schoolcraft. Contact with ret. NYPD Lieutenant
who has knowledge of individuals present at the
Schoolcraft home.

240.0

1/23/12

Vincent
Parco, PI

11/27/12

242.0

12/1/12

243.0

12/2/12

Vincent
Parco, PI
Vincent
Parco, PI
Vincent
Parco, PI

244.0

12/3/12

Vincent
Parco, PI

245.0

12/5/12

246.0

12/5/12

247.0

12/9/12

248.0

12/10/12

Vincent
Parco, PI
Vincent
Parco, PI
Vincent
Parco, PI
Vincent
Parco, PI

249.0

12/13/12

Vincent
Parco, PI

250.0

12/16/12

Vincent
Parco, PI

240

241

Hours

2.500

1.500

242

243

244

Meeting with Atty., provided update as to
information obtained from a contact.
Phone call with Atty., update and strategy.

1.500

0.500

Conversation with contact, discussed NYPD,
Emergency Service Unit involvement in
Schoolcraft incident.
Phone call with Atty., informed him I was awaiting
a call back from individual with knowledge.

245

0.500

0.125

246
247

248

249

250
251

E

Called a number of contacts that might have direct,
secondary or tertiary knowledge of the subject
matter of this investigation. I find this method
conserves resources by "throwing out a net," to my
various contacts and wait to set what it yields. This
passive method of investigation is reactionary
waiting for my, "contacts," to reach out to me
should they encounter anything that might be
relevant. Given the publicity of this matter there
should be no problem initiating this type of
investigation.

241.0

1

Spoke to contact with useful knowledge.
0.500

Phone call with Atty., update as to intel obtained.
0.500

Phone call with Atty., update.
0.125

Meeting with Atty., update on individuals present
at Schoolcraft incident. Atty. Satisfied of mulitiple
sources confirming identity of individual(s) at
scene.
Meeting with Atty., provided Press Release from
Queens DA's office, discussed same and follow up
On other aspects of investigation.
Spoke to contact discussed new information.

1.250

1.500

0.500

Page 14

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

1

No.

251.0

B

Date
12/17/12

D

C

Timekeepe Description
Meeting with atty., updated as to new information
Vincent
Parco, PI on both Queens DA and steroid issue.

I
1

E

Hours

1.250

252

252.0

12/21/12

253

253.0

12/28/12

254

254.0

1/7/13

255

255.0

1/11/13

256

256.0

1/14/13

257

257.0

1/16/13

258

258.0

1/17/13

259

259.0

1/29/13

Vincent
Parco, PI
Vincent
Parco, PI
Vincent
Parco, PI
Vincent
Parco, PI
Vincent
Parco, PI
Vincent
Parco, PI
Vincent
Parco, PI
Vincent
Parco, PI

Meeting with atty. Given instructions on issues to
follow up on.
Conversation with contact with source confirming
outstanding issue.
Meeting with atty. discussed investigation strategy
moving forward.
Meeting with atty. discussed credibility of potential
witnesses.
Interview of potential witness.

1.500

0.500
1.500

0.750
0.750

Phone call with atty. update set up meeting
0.125

Meeting with atty. Regarding Schoolcraft
residence.
Meeting with att., discussed entire investigation,
home invasion, named defendants, Queens DA.

0.750

1.250

260

260.0

2/13/13

261

261.0

3/29/13

Vincent
Parco, PI
Vincent
Parco, PI

262

261.5

4/12/13

263

262.0

06/06/10

Vincent
Parco, PI
JLN

264

263.0
265
266 264.0
265.0
267
266.0
268
267.0
269
268.0
270
269.0
271
272 270.0
273 271.0

06/18/10
06/20/10
06/21/10
06/22/10
06/23/10
06/24/10

06/24/10
06/24/10
06/24/10

JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN

Meeting with atty. Update on new development.
0.500

Meeting with atty. Reviewed photographs from
Schoolcraft apartment. Discussed possible use of a
rebuttal witness, strategy.
Meeting with atty. and Plaintiff, discussed overall
investigation.
Discussions with Joshua Fitch ("JF") re Schoolcraft
case
Meeting w/ Gerald Cohen ("GC") and JF re:
Schoolcraft coming to our office for interview
Read Voice articles on Schoolcraft
Read articles sent by Schoolcraft on Gerald Nelson

Discussion with GC and JF re Schoolcraft case &
causes of action
Meeting w/ GC and JF re: GC's upcoming meeting
w/ Schoolcraft
Initial client meeting & interview with AS in
Johnstown
Traveled to Johnstown to meet prospective Client
Adrian Schoolcraft (3.6)
Travel back to NYC (3.2)
TC with GC re: meeting w/Schoolcraft

Page 15

1.500

0.500
0.800
0.800
2.100

0.800
0.800
0.750
7.400
1.800
1.600

0.400

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

D

272.0

Date
06/25/10

Timekeepe Description
JLN
Meeting w/ GC and JF re: scope of Schoolcraft
materials that need to be reviewed for complaint,
overall strategy & next steps for moving forward

273.0

06/25/10

JLN

274.0

06/25/10

JLN

275.0

06/25/10

JLN

276.0

1

06/25/10

JLN

No.

274

Hours

3.250

275

276
277

278

Read Schoolcraft's PBA contract; took notes re:
same
Meeting with GC & JF re: possible discovery
demands after suit is filed and general strategy
Reviewed transcript of Polanco tapes; took notes
re: same
Sent GC information for retainer; forwarded
retainer to AS; forwarded signed retainer back to
GC

277.0

06/26/10

JLN

278.0

06/28/10

JLN

279.0

06/28/10

JLN

280.0

06/28/10

JLN

06/28/10
06/28/10

JLN
JLN

279

280
281
282
283 281.0

282.0
284

06/29/10

JLN

284.0

06/29/10

JLN

06/29/10
06/29/10

JLN
JLN

06/29/10
06/29/10

JLN
JLN

06/29/10

JLN

06/29/10
06/29/10

JLN
JLN

06/29/10
06/29/10
06/30/10

JLN
JLN
JLN

285

286
287 285.0
286.0
288
289 287.0
288.0
290
289.0
291
292 290.0
291.0
293
294 292.0
295 293.0
294.0

2.500
1.400

0.400

0.100

Reviewed Schoolcraft's records from Jamaica
Hospital Medical Center; took notes re: same
Discussion with JF and GC re retainer & meeting
with Schoolcrafts
Discussion with JF re meeting with P.O. Velasquez
re policy of quotas
Discussion with JF & Adrian Schoolcraft (AS) re
prior counsel Jonathan Moore
Memo re: Eddie Velasquez
Review of correspondence w/Jonathan Moore re:
AS

283.0

296

E

3.250
1.250

0.900
0.300
0.300
0.100

Listened to "home invasion" recording from Oct.
31 multiple times; took notes re: same
Meeting w/ GC and JF re: PBA materials for use in
Schoolcraft
Review of 75th Pct arbitration decision
Discussion with JF & GC re decision on PBA
arbitration case
Drafted correspondence to Jonathan Moore
Correspondence w/ GC re: Jonathan Moore
substitution
Discussion with JF & GC re substitution of counsel
Moore
E-mail exchange GC re: Schoolcraft matter
E-mail exchange with AS re: 911 calls and getting
copies of same
E-mail from GC re: Stop and Frisk case
E-mail to GC re: Stop and Frisk case
Listened multiple times to call from LS to Capt.
Lauterborne re: "City wide" search for AS; took
down best quotes from same for possible inclusion
in complaint.
Page 16

2.600
1.250

0.900

0.400
0.300
0.200
0.200
0.200
0.100
0.100
0.100

1.400

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

295.0

B

Date
06/30/10

297

296.0

06/30/10

298

297.0

06/30/10

299

298.0
300
301 299.0
300.0
302
301.0
303
302.0

06/30/10
06/30/10
07/01/10
07/01/10
07/01/10

304

303.0

07/01/10

305

304.0

07/01/10

306

305.0

07/02/10

307

306.0

07/02/10

308

307.0

07/02/10

309

308.0

07/04/10

310

309.0

07/05/10

C

D

'

Timekeepe Description
Listened to call from AS to IAB on Oct. 31; took
JLN
notes re: same
Reviewed composite file of materials on Cmr. Julie
JLN
Schwartz complied by AS
Discussion with JF & GC re FOIL requests for 911
JLN
calls & how to proceed
Reviewed FOIL requests for 911 calls made by AS
JLN
to NYPD and discussed with JF
Reviewed PBA quota affidavit
JLN
Started listening to day tour recording by AS made
JLN
on Oct. 31, 09; took notes on same.
T/c w/AS re: specific details of events alleged in
JLN
Aug. 20, 2009 UF 49 re: Caughey/Weiss
Listened to recording of cony. w/ PAA Monique
JLN
Carter from Aug. 16, 09, (re: removal of personnel)
files from office by Caughey/Weiss); took notes re:
same
Reviewed UF 49 dated Aug. 20, 2009 from AS to
JLN
C. Campisi (Chief IAB)
Reviewed UF 49 from AS to Campisi dated Jan.
JLN
12, 2009 re: allegation of sexual misconduct by
prisoner
Finished listening to day tour recording made by
JLN
AS of Oct. 31, 2009; made notes re: same
Reviewed media stories & news articles provided
JLN
by AS; notes re: same
Discussion with JF re AS' ability to pursue claim
JLN
under Labor Law 215-a
Read e -mails from A. Schoolcraft re: articles on
JLN
Mauriello and Palestro
Reviewed composite file on Paul Browne, incl.
JLN
prior testimony in another action, as put together by
AS; took notes re: same

Hours

0.700

0.600
0.500
0.300
0.100

3.400
1.300

0.700

0.200

0.200

4.200

4.200
0.600
0.250

2.400

311

310.0

07/05/10

JLN

312

311.0

07/05/10

JLN

313

312.0

07/05/10

JLN

Reviewed composite file on Ray Kelly prepared by
AS; took notes re:same
T/c AS re: Palesto, Daily News Contact, trip to
NYC and news interviews '
Reviewed memo showing contact between Lt.
Caughey & Lt. R. Lee at Early Intervention Unit

1.600
1.200

("HU")

314

313.0
315

E

07/06/10

JLN

0.100

Meeting with JF/GC re: progress/developments on
the case, meeting in NYC on Wednesday and filing
of lawsuit;

1.750

Page 17

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

314.0

Date
07/06/10

315.0

07/06/10

317
318 316.0
317.0

07/06/10
07/07/10

No.

C

D

318.0

07/07/10

319.0

07/07/10

320.0

07/07/10

Timekeepe Description
JLN
Meeting w/ GC and JF re: new whistleblower who
contacted GC re: Schoolcraft
JLN
T/c Len Levit re: his knowledge of NYPD &
thoughts about case
JLN
T/c R.P. (Daily News reporter) re: AS case;
JLN
Listened multiple times to recording between AS &
Capt. Lauterborne re: "devil you know", "Mr.
Community" etc.; took notes re: same
JLN
Reviewed Schoolcraft documents, evals, memos,
letters to PBA, letters to Mauriello
JLN
Meeting w/ AS, LS re: Rae Koshetz (Attorney for
charges and specifications) and options for fighting
NYPD
JLN
Meeting w/ AS prior to group meeting later today

07/07/10
07/07/10
07/07/10

JLN
JLN
JLN

07/07/10

JLN

07/08/10

JLN

07/08/10

JLN

327.0

07/08/10

JLN

328.0

07/08/10

JLN

329.0

07/08/10

JLN

330.0

1

07/09/10

JLN

07/09/10
07/09/10

JLN
JLN

07/09/10

JLN

07/09/10

JLN

316

319

320

321
322
323 321.0
324 322.0
323.0
325
324.0
326
325.0
327
326.0
328

Discussion with JF re Labor Law research
Meeting with AS, LS, JF & GC
Meeting with JF and GC re Schoolcraft Meeting
and tapes;
T/c AS/LS and Hampton Inn re: authorization for
cc; fax letter re same
Started review of CD Recordings (2008 roll calls)
provided by AS; took notes re: same
Listened to Oct. 28, 2009 recording of cony. b/w
AS and Sgt. Devino at PBBN regarding status of
plaintiffs appeal; notes re: same
T/c with LS regarding status of move and
discussions with landlord Stretmoyers (witnesses)

329

Hours
1.300

0.500
0.500

3.400

2.700

2.000
1.500
0.800
0.750

0.500
0.250

3.700

1.200

0.250

330
331

332
333 331.0
332.0
334
333.0

Read tribute to Mauriello praising effectiveness in
crime reduction
Reviewed OF 49 from AS to DI Brower (former
CO 81) re: forced overtime
Continued listening to 2008 Roll Call recordings;
notes re: same.

0.100
0.100

6.400

Discussion with JF re timeline
Drafted bullet pt time line summarizing criT/cal
events in Schoolcraft case
T/c AS re status of move, discussions with landlord
(eyewitness) and additional does located at apt.

335

1.100
1.000

0.750

334.0
336

E

Reviewed PG Guide 314-11- re: appeals of
evaluation; took notes re: same
Page 18

0.400

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

1

No.

335.0

I

Date
07/12/10

Timekeepe Description
Listened to recording of appeal meeting on Feb. 25,
JLN
2009; replayed and took notes re: same

-

Hours

3.400

337
JLN

336.0

07/12/10

337.0

07/12/10

338.0

07/13/10

JLN

339.0

07/13/10

JLN

338
JLN

339

340

T/c AS re QAD interviews and PBA letter re:
illegal quotas
Reviewed memo from Lt. Mascol re: TS operators
not to speak with complainants
Review of additional Schoolcraft recordings; took
notes re: same
Reviewed recording of cony. blw AS & Lt. Mascol
on Feb. 20, 20September ; took notes re: same

0.750
0.100
4.200

0.600

341

340.0

07/13/10

341.0

07/13/10

342.0

07/13/10

JLN

Reviewed FDNY PCR for AS; took notes re: same

342

JLN

343
344
345 343.0

344.0

07/13/10
07/14/10

JLN
JLN
JLN

346

345.0

07/14/10

346.0

07/14/10

JLN

347

JLN

348

347.0

07/14/10

JLN

349

348.0

07/15/10

JLN

350
351 349.0
350.0

07/15/10
07/15/10

JLN
JLN

352

351.0

07/15/10

JLN

353

352.0

354

E

D

C

B

07/15/10

JLN

T/c Rae Koshets re: status of Schoolcraft matter &
pending charges & speed
Listened to recording b/w AS & Det. Peterson on
Sept. 13, 2009
T/c RP re: Frank Palestro
Reviewed multiple NYPD performance evalaution
guides provided by pltf, including guides for
Detectives & P.O.'s, for P.O. Det. Specialists; took
notes re: same
Meeting w/ GC and JF re: Schoolcraft complaint &
next steps for moving forward
T/c Eric Sanders, Esq., re: Frank Palestro & PO
Minaya & possible joint participation in each
others cases
Reviewed document re: conversation b/w Lt.
Masco! & Schoolcraft on Jan. 14, 2009 re: need for
more "activity"
Review of Schoolcraft recordings (2008 roll calls)
Discussion with GC and JF re tapes
Reviewed AS's evaluation for Sept. 2009 (by Sgt.
Stukes & Mauriello) re: Pltfs' "poor activity" &
how he was "counseled" re improvement; took
notes re: same
Reviewed AS evaluation for April 2009 noting
"poor activity" & AS's unwillingness to meet
"performance standards" of NYPD
Reviewed Brown & Gropper letter to Mauriello re:
appealing evaluation & numerical calculations of
performance vs. actual rating, etc; took notes re:
same
Page 19

0.500

0.500
0.400
0.250

3.800
1.250

0.250

0.200
3.100
1.100

0.500

0.400

0.400

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

1

No.

353.0

B

Date
07/15/10

C

D

Timekeepe Description
JLN
Reviewed PG 205-56 and PG 205-57 re: P.O.s'
monthly/quaraterly perfmmance reviews; took
notes re: same
JLN
Reviewed AS Meritorious Police Duty Medal
JLN
Reviewed Itr from AS to Senator Hugh Farley
requesting assistance
JLN
Reviewed UF 49 from AS to Mauriello dated
9/2/09 re: appeal of his evaluation
JLN
Continued listening to recordings (appeal meeting;
Mascot conversation; Lauterborn Duty Captain
incident); took notes re same.
JLN
Continued review of Schoolcraft recordings (2008
roll calls)
JLN
Meeting with GC re: Schoolcraft issues and status
of complaint & overall strategy
JLN
Reviewed composite file on Brandon Del Pozzo
(former CO of 50 Pct);
JLN
T/c AS re: Eric Sanders conversation and status of
hard drive retrieval
JLN
Rev'd Admin. Guide procedure 303-20 re: steps to
be followed for an appeal; notes on same.

355
356 354.0
355.0
357

07/15/10
07/15/10

356.0

07/15/10

357.0

07/16/10

358.0

07/16/10

359.0

07/16/10

360.0

07/16/10

361.0

07/16/10

362.0

07/16/10

363.0

07/16/10

JLN

364.0

07/16/10

JLN

365.0

07/17/10

JLN

07/17/10

JLN

Reviewed 81st Pct Chart regarding monthly selfinspections for 20September ; notes re: same

367.0

07/17/10

JLN

Reviewed photos of 81st precinct as provided by
AS; flagged photos most relevant for case &
created list of same.

07/17/10
07/19/10

JLN
JLN

07/19/10

JLN

E-mail exchange with AS re: UF 250's
Review of Schoolcraft roll calls (2009 roll calls);
notes re: same
Listened to recording b/w LS & FBI Special agent
on Nov. 9, 2009 requesting fed. Investigaiton into
what happened to AS

07/20/10

JLN

Hours

Listened to 3 different recordings of interviews by
Lamstein (NYPD Psych); took notes re same:

366.0

E

358

359
360
361
362

363

364

0.100

0.100

5.400

3.400
1.250
1.200

0.750

0.200

365

Rev'd pltfs Itr on July 31, 20September to PBA
gen. counsel & summarizing events to date &
seeking PBA representation
Reviewed PBA letter (Aug. 17, 09) in response to
AS's request for legal representation from PBA

366

0.200

0.100

367

3.400

368

0.300

369
370 368.0
369.0
371
370.0
372

371.0
373

0.300
0.100

Continued review of Schoolcraft roll calls (2009):
took notes on same
Page 20

0.300
0.100

4.200

0.300
3.900

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

1

No.

374 372.0
373.0

C

B

D

1

Date

Timekeepe Description

07/20/10
07/21/10

JLN
JLN

T/c with AS regarding case status
T/c call b/w AS, JN&LS re: GR information and
Del Pozzo "offer" & new officer fired b/c if quotas

E

Hours

0.500

2.100

375

374.0

07/21/10

JLN

376

375.0

07/21/10

376.0

07/22/10

JLN

377

JLN

378
377.0
379
380 378.0
379.0
381
380.0
382
381.0
383
382.0
384

383.0
385
386 384.0
385.0
387
388 386.0
387.0
389
390 388.0
389.0
391
390.0
392
391.0
393
392.0
394
393.0
395
394.0
396

07/22/10

07/22/10
07/22/10
07/26/10
07/26/10

JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN

JLN

Conference call b/w Graham Raymond ("GR") GR
& AS & LS re call by NYPD to GR
T/c GR re NYPD contact by Brandon Del Pozzo re
Schoolcraft employment issues
Continued review of Schoolcraft recordings (2009
roll calls)
T/c AS re Del Pozzo, GR & letters to Stuart
London
T/c JFIGC re updates on Schoolcraft
E-mail exchange with AS re: council speaker wants
CCRB to try its own cases
Meeting with JF & GC re case & updates on
Brendan Del Pozo
Meeting JF/GC reissues for Schoolcraft complaint

1.200

0.250
3.100
1.100
0.500

0.100
2.100
1.000

07/26/10
07/26/10
07/26/10
07/26/10

07/26/10
07/27/10
07/27/10
07/27/10
07/28/10
07/28/10

07/28/10
07/28/10

07/28/10

JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

JLN
JLN

JLN
JLN

JLN

Discussion with GC & JF re complaint draft next
steps moving forward
T/c Larry Schoolcraft re: Del Pozzo e-mail GR &
PBA letter to Stuart London
Discussion w/ GC re Brandon del Pozo
T/c w/ GR re: new rookie (PO Chris Bienz) fired
b/c of quota
Sent E-mail to GC re: Del Pozo
Meeting w/AS, GC, JF to prep for discussion with
US attorneys office EDNY
Meeting w GC and JF to discuss complaint
Mtg GC re draft of complaint and proposed
revisions
Discussion with JF and GC re: Adhyl Polanco and
other whistlblowers
Discussion with JF re complaint (proposed areas
for improvement)
E-mail to JF re meeting with Polanco, Raymond &
Rocco
Reviewed AS Certificate of Completion of Police
Academy
Reviewed OF 49 from Sgt. Meyer (81) re: shooting
in confines of 81 Sept. 2009

Page 21

0.600

0.600
0.300
0.300
0.100

3.250
1.250

0.750
0.500
0.400

0.100
0.100
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

D

E

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

395.0

07/29/10

JLN

Reviewed NY AG's investigation into NYPD's Stop
& Frisk Practices & Statistical Review of NYPD's
UF 250 data, as provided by AS; took notes re:
same

2.800

396.0

07/29/10

JLN

Meeting with JF and Rocco P - Daily News re
Schoolcraft and evidence of quotas for Monell
claim

1.500

397.0

07/30/10

JLN

07/30/10
07/30/10

JLN
JLN

07/30/10

JLN

07/30/10

JLN

07/30/10
07/31/10

JLN
JLN

07/31/10
07/31/10
08/01/10

JLN
JLN
JLN

Meeting with JF, GC, Polanco & Raymond re:
Schoolcraft & Monell claim
Continued edits and revisions to complaint
Meeting with JF and GC re: changes & additions to
complaint
Read Judge Beinstock's decision in PBA Velez
arbitration; took notes re: same; extracted language
for use in complaint
Reviewed docs re: NYC Safety Restraint
Enforcement Program, from Sept. 11-14, 2009 for
increased summons activity
Reviewed Boro Daily Impact OT Form
Cont'd review of Schoolcraft tapes and timeline
chart
Continued edits/revisions of complaint
E-mail from JF re edited complaint
T/c w/AS & LS re: Fulton Cty decision & current
status of public benefits & continued processing of
Dec. 9, 2009 application for benefits

407.0

08/01/10

JLN

409
410 408.0
411 409.0
412 410.0
411.0

Reviewed Fulton County Decision after Hearing (69-10) reversing agency's decision that AS
voluntarily ended NYPD employment; took notes
re: same

08/02/10
08/02/10
08/03/10
08/03/10

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

08/03/10

JLN

414.0

08/03/10
08/03/10

JLN
JLN

Further edits revisions & additions to complaint
Reviewed original Notice of Claim filed by AS
Edited complaint and sent to JF for review
Meeting w/ GC re: Schoolcraft complaint and other
whistleblower police officers to possibly include in
complaint
Compose E-mail to JF with detailed edits for the
revised Complaint
Discussion with JF re corrections
Reviewed memo from Lt. Ragnello (81Cdr. 3rd
Platoon) re: creating Crime Reduction Unit at 81

415.0

08/03/10

JLN

1

397

398
399
400 398.0
399.0
401
400.0

402

401.0
403
404 402.0
403.0
405
406 404.0
407 405.0
406.0

408

3.250
3.200
1.200

0.600

0.300
0.100
3.100
2.800
0.100

1.100

413

412.0

414
415 413.0

416
417

Hours

0.800
3.200
0.100
1.600

0.500
0.400
0.300

0.300

Reviewed Schoolcraft OF 49 re: Lt Jones (filed in
June 07)
Page 22

0.300

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

418 416.0
419 417.0
418.0
420
421 419.0
422 420.0
423 421.0
422.0

Date
08/03/10
08/03/10
08/04/10
08/04/10
08/04/10
08/04/10
08/05/10

424
423.0

08/05/10

425

424.0

08/06/10

426

425.0

08/06/10

427

426.0
428
429 427.0
430 428.0
429.0
431
430.0
432
431.0
433
434 432.0
433.0
435
434.0
436
437 435.0
436.0
438
437.0
439
438.0
440
439.0
441
442 440.0
441.0
443

08/06/10

D

C

B

Timekeep Description
Discussion with JF re corrections to complaint
JLN
E-mail exchange with JF re Revised complaint
JLN
Review of AS chronology for complaint;
JLN
incorporated same
Further edits and revisions to complaint
JLN
Read AS memo re: Brandon Del Pozo
JLN
E-mail exchange JF re complaint edits
JLN
Review of AS's August and March September
JLN
recordings transcribed from Legal Language; took
notes re: same
E-mail exchange with JF re: clarification of some
JLN
factual issues in the complaint
Reviewed June 2009 roll calls, Halloween night
JLN
and visits to Johnstown recording transcripts and
discussed same with JF
Review of revised complaint from JF: made edits
JLN
and revisions to same
Continued review transcriptions of August 2009
JLN
logs

08/06/10
08/06/10
08/07/10
08/07/10
08/08/10

08/08/10
08/08/10
08/08/10
08/09/10
08/09/10
08/09/10
08/09/10

JLN
JLN
JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

E-mail exchange with JF re community visits
E-mail from JF re: complaint revisions
Continued review transcriptions of March 2009
logs
E-mail exchange JF re explanation of community
visits
Reviewed transcription of December 2008 logs of
roll calls; notes re: same
Discussion with JF re: edits to complaint
E-mail to JF with additional allegations for
complaint
Review of E-mail re: revision of Schoolcraft
complaint
Meeting with AS to finalize complaint
Meeting w/GC and JF re: Schoolcraft website to
support Monell theory
E-mail from JF re final draft of complaint;
reviewed same
Review of final draft of AS complaint to be filed

E

Hours
0.250
0.100
1.400
1.200

0.200
0.100

3.500
0.200

3.800

2.100
1.400
0.200
0.100
1.800

0.250
3.600
0.400
0.100
0.100
2.700
1.500
1.250

0.500

08/09/10
08/09/10
08/09/10

JLN
JLN
JLN

Discussion with GC and JF re Adrian interview
E-mail to JF re negligent ret. claim
Review of legal issues re: Negligent hiring claim

0.300
0.300
0.300

Page 23

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

C

B

D

442.0

Date
08/09/10

443.0

08/10/10

444.0

08/10/10

445.0

08/10/10

446.0

08/10/10

Timekeepe Description
JLN
Reviewed fax from anonymous PO re: Marino's
quota system
JLN
Began review of new CD from Client w/ numerous
additional recordings and does
JLN
Listened to Brian Lehrer show (podcast) re:
Schoolcraft allegations
JLN
Reviewed transcript of exceprts that refer to
"Mauriello Specials", as provided by AS
JLN
Review of Articles about Schoolcraft complaint

447.0

08/10/10

JLN

448.0

08/10/10

JLN

449.0

08/11/10

JLN

08/11/10

JLN

451.0

08/11/10

JLN

452.0

08/12/10

JLN

08/12/10
08/12/10

JLN
JLN

08/12/10

JLN

08/13/10

JLN

457.0

08/13/10

JLN

458.0

08/14/10

JLN

Discussion with GC re anonymous P.O. re:
quota/retaliation
Review post of anonymous P.O. who contacted
website re recording Mauriello
Reviewed transcription of Jan 2009 logs; notes re:
same
Reviewed PBA by-laws and const.
Meeting w/JF and GC re: legal strategies on Monet]
and whistleblower cop contacts
Meeting w/GC and JF re: legal strategies & next
steps for moving forward
Read Eterno & Silverman's article on Compstat
("Compare Statistics or Compose Statistics"); took
notes re same
Discussion with GC & JF re Jonathan Moore Cease
& Desist letter
Tc w/AS & LS re: Eterno & Silverman as possible
expert wtinesses and re: specific issues raised in
their Compstat article

459.0

08/15/10

JLN

460.0

08/15/10

JLN

08/16/10
08/16/10

JLN
JLN

08/16/10

JLN

08/16/10

JLN

E

Meeting with PO Kevin Rodriguez 52nd Precinct

450.0

1

No.

444
445
446
447

448

Hours

0.100

3.700
0.500

0.500
0.400

449

Discussion with JF & GC re articles and possible
typo in complaint
Reviewed GC draft of Schoolcraft website content

450

0.200
0.200

451

2.750

452

453

454
455 453.0
454.0
456
455.0
457
456.0
458
459

460
461
462
463 461.0
462.0
464
463.0
465
466 464.0

Internet research on Eterno/Silverman studies &
articles & on Compstat
Meeting with JF and GC re NY Times story about
quotas & Schoolcraft
Continued review of new CD from client
Interview of J. Ferrrera (former Lt. at 81st Pct.)

0.300
0.200
2.900
0.900
0.800
0.500

0.700
0.400

1.200

2.200
0.600
4.100

3.400

Read CCRB Report on 75th & 81st Pcts, as
provided by AS; took notes re: same
Travel back to NYC (1.40)
Page 24

1.200

0.700

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

467 465.0
466.0
468
469 467.0
468.0

Date
08/16/10
08/16/10
08/17/10
08/17/10

D

C

B

Timekeepe Description
Travel to Long Island to meet Ferrara (1.2)
JLN
Read articles about NYPD's gun buy-back program
JLN
provided by AS
Meeting with Eterno & Silverman
JLN
T/c w/AS & LS re: charges & specs, underlying
JLN
facts relating to each charge, & best way to
challenge charges in the NYPD trial room

0.300
2.300

1.400

470
469.0
471
472 470.0
471.0
473
472.0
474
473.0

08/17/10
08/17/10
08/17/10
08/17/10
08/18/10

JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

475

474.0

08/18/10

JLN

Discussion with GC and JF re anonymous e -mails
that we got as a result of the website
Travel back downtown (.80)
Travel uptown to meet Eterno & Silverman in
midtown (.80)
Reviewed NYPD Charges & Specis against AS;
created bullet point summary of same
Reviewed Relevant PG Sections for Charges &
Specs (PG 203-03,203-10, 203-18, 205-47); took
notes re: same
Reviewed AS Quarterly Performance report from
08; took notes re: same

0.400
0.400
0.400

0.200

1.750

1.600

476

475.0

08/18/10

JLN

477
476.0

08/18/10

JLN

T/c w/AS & LS re: my reivew of PG sections
relating to charges & specs, & best args. for
challenging same
Discussion with JF re Rocco's story in Daily News

0.900

0.250

478

477.0

08/19/10

JLN

479
478.0

08/19/10

JLN

480
479.0

08/19/10

JLN

481

480.0

08/19/10

JLN

482

481.0

08/19/10

JLN

483

482.0

08/20/10

JLN

484

483.0

08/20/10

JLN

485

484.0
486

E

Hours
0.600

08/22/10

JLN

Finished review of new CD recordings and
documents from client; took notes re: same
Discussion with JF and GC re: new recordings and
documents provided by AS
T/c w/AS and LS re: chronology of events &
questions relating to specific entries
Reviewed AS's chonology of chain of events
leading up to Halloween night, starting with
discussion w/Lt. Delafuente on Jan. 29, 2009 (AS
should "work for ASPCA")
E-mail from P.O. Chris Whitehead worked under
Marino in 75th Pct.
T/c w/Chris Whitehead re: quotas at 75th Pct. &
retaliation
Interviewed Marc Johnson, Ph.D., re: possible use
as expert for psych claims
Meeting with JF & GC re whistleblowers reaching
out through the website

Page 25

2.900
1.250
1.100

0.700
0.100
0.900
0.600
0.800

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

D

485.0

Date
08/22/10

486.0

08/22/10

487.0

08/22/10

JLN

488.0

08/23/10

JLN

489.0

08/23/10

JLN

491
492 490.0
491.0

08/24/10
08/24/10

JLN
JLN

08/24/10

JLN

T/c w/AS & LS re: harassment by NYPD &
Johnstown PD, interactions with NYPD during
visits, and specific questions relating to what is
shown on videos

08/24/10
08/24/10

JLN
JLN

08/25/10

JLN

08/25/10

JLN

Travel to L.I. to meet Chris Whitehead (1.20)
Travel back to NYC from meeting with C.
Whitehead (1.40)
Meeting w/GC and JF re: ACC assigned,
Schoolcraft Initial Disclosures
Reviewed Rand Report provided by AS re:
"Analysis of Disparities" of NYPD's Stop, Question
& Frisk practices; took ntoes re: same

497.0

08/25/10

JLN

498.0

08/25/10

JLN

08/25/10
08/26/10

JLN
JLN

08/26/10
08/27/10

JLN
JLN

08/27/10

JLN

1

No.

487

Timekeepe Description
JLN
Reviewed notes from AS activity log from Jan.
September to March September
JLN
Reviewed memorandum "Your Right to Know"
provided by AS and released by NY State re:
Public Officer Law & FOIL requests.

488

E

Hours
0.700

0.400

E-mail exchange with AS re: Internet search results
on Dr. Lamstein and previous Cheroff case

489

0.200

490

Reviewed NYPD "Critical Objectives" & statistics
re: index crimes, as
Reviewed Investigations Unit comment sheet
provided by AS re: Sgt. Defabizio & contacts with
Schoolcraft
Mtg. w/Chris Whitehead (P.O. 75 Pct.)
Reviewed AS videos & audio recordings & photos
re: "Harassment &Stalking" by NYPD &
Johnstown PD in upstate NY; took notes re: same

493

1.200

0.200
2.400

2.400

492.0

494
495 493.0
494.0
496
495.0
497
496.0

498

1.300

0.600
0.400
1.750

1.200

499

500
501 499.0
500.0
502
503 501.0
502.0
504
503.0
505

Meeting with JF & GC re more whistleblower
email & meeting with P.O. Fioranelli
Reviewed NYC Bar Ass'n Statement on NYC Stop
& Frisk Practices; took notes re: same
Meeting with JF & GC re: Whitehead mtg.
Meeting with JF and GC re: interview of PO from
81st precinct "PF" re: corruption
Correspondence w/GC re: Frank Serpico
Read arT/cles by Eterno & Silverman re: Compstat

0.900
0.800
0.750
1.500

0.200
1.500

Discussion with GC & JF re having Eterno &
Silverman as experts

Page 26

0.600

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

504.0

Date
08/29/10

D

C

B

Timekeepe Description
Discussion with GC re: Walter Lipscomb interview
JLN

E

Hours
0.500

506

505.0

08/30/10

JLN

507

506.0

08/30/10

JLN

508

507.0
509
510 508.0
509.0

08/30/10
08/30/10
08/30/10

JLN

JLN
JLN

511

510.0

08/31/10

JLN

Meeting with JF & GC re Garcia (cop from 81 who
knows Schoolcraft & has info on quotas)
Meeting with JF & GC re Labor & Employment
case & 12(b)(6) motion
E-mail correspondence w/GC re: MG (PO in 81st
precinct)
E-mail w/ GC re: ACC Donna Canfield
Reviewed Notice of Appearance by Donna
Canfield ("DC") on behalf of The City Of New
York
Conversation with GC and JF re: topics to be
discussed/disclosed with Mark Toor in Chief article

1.250

0.500
0.100
0.100

0.100

0.250

512

511.0

09/01/10

JLN

513

512.0

09/03/10

JLN

514

513.0

09/03/10

JLN

515

514.0
516
517 515.0
516.0
518
517.0
519
518.0
520
521 519.0
520.0
522
521.0

09/03/10
09/03/10
09/03/10

JLN
JLN
JLN

524
525 523.0
524.0
526

1.800

1.400

0.500
0.400
0.200

0.100
09/04/10

09/05/10
09/06/10
09/06/10
09/07/10

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

JLN

523

522.0

Meeting w/GC and JF re: discuss anonymous POs
contacting us and how they can help Schoolcraft w/
Monell claim
Meeting with JF and GC to discuss infromation
provided by DH, MG, EB (whistleblower cops) in
furtherance of the Monell claim
Meeting w/ GC re: THEE RANT post to get
officers to contact us on Schoolcraftjustice.com to
support Monell claim
Discussion with JF re AS interview with This
American Life
E-mail w/GC re: THEE RANT post
E-mail w/ GC re: This American Life Radio show

09/07/10
09/07/10
09/07/10

JLN

JLN
JLN

Reviewed PG section 216-05 (EDPS), notes re:
same
Reviewed indictment of Sgt. Stukes (AS
Supervisor) filed in Kings County
Discussion with JF re amended complaint
E-mail exchanges with Joseph Ferrara (former Lt.
81 pct)
Listened to recording of mtg b/w AS and Stuart
London PBA Attorney re: appealing evaluation &
options available
Reviewed Defendant Isakov's answer to complaint
E-mail exchange with Joseph Ferrara
Reviewed Aff of Service by defendants Jamaica
Hospital Medical Center.

Page 27

0.400
0.100
0.400
0.200

0.500
0.300
0.100

0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

C

B

525.0

Date
09/07/10

526.0

09/07/10

527.0

09/10/10

JLN

528.0

09/12/10

JLN

529.0

09/12/10

JLN

530.0

09/12/10

JLN

531.0

09/13/10

JLN

532.0

09/13/10

JLN

533.0

09/13/10

JLN

534.0

09/15/10

JLN

535.0

09/15/10

JLN

536.0

09/16/10

JLN

537.0

09/17/10

JLN

538.0

09/17/10

JLN

539.0

09/18/10

JLN

540.0

1

09/18/10

JLN

No.

527
528

529

530
531

532
533

534
535

536
537

538

539

540
541

542

Reviewed letter addressed to Judge Sweet from DC
dated 9/1/2010 Requesting a sixty day extension
Reviewed "Crime, Police & the Community" report
by Citizens Crime Commision, as provided by AS

Reviewed "Poilice & Public Safety in NYC" report
from Citizens Crime
Reviewed Opinion/Order of Joan Lobis (JSC NY
County) re: Ray Kelly under Article 78, as
provided by AS
T/c w/AS re: salary with NYPD, benefits, and
overall lost earnings claim
Reviewed NYC pay statements for AS from Nov.
13, 09; Oct. 30, 09; Feb. 5, 2010; June 4, 2010 (for
"prior to separation" work)
Reviewed Notices of Claim filed by AS for
"Property Loss" and "Salary Loss"
Reviewed Dep. of Eddie Valasquez (P.O. punished
for not meeting quota); took notes re: same
Reviewed defendant Bernier's endorsed stipulation
extending time to answer
Reviewed Floyd deps from Floyd Proceedings,
including Mauriello Dep., Donald McHugh Dep.;
Angel Herran Dep, and Paul Browne dep.; took
notes re same.
Meeting with JF and GC regarding information
obtained from Floyd litigation and its impact on
Schoolcrafts Monell and Retaliation claims
Started review of transcript from Velez
proceedings; took notes re: same
Reviewed NYPD Admin guuide provided by AS;
took notes re: same
Conversation with GC & JF re new whistleblower
cop

541.0

09/18/10

JLN

543

E

Hours
0.100
0.100

0.100

0.800
0.700

0.400
0.900

0.300
0.200

1.200

0.100

4.250

1.300

0.600
1.200

0.300

Correspondence w/ GC re: anonymous Schoolcraft
post

542.0
544

D

I

Timekeep Description
JLN
Reviewed defendant JHMC's corporate disclosure
statement
JLN
Reviewed defendants answer to complaint filed by
Jamaica Hospital Medical Center

09/19/10

JLN

0.200

E-mail exchange w/ J. Ferrara re: Browne's reaction
to Quota Tapes

0.100

Page 28

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

B

L

D

C

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

543.0

09/20/10

JLN

544.0

09/20/10

545.0

1

09/21/10

l

545

JLN

546

547
548 546.0
547.0
549
548.0
550
551 549.0
550.0

JLN

Discussion with JF re meeting with DOJ on AS
case
Discussion with GC & JF re media upload to
website
Meeting with DOJ EDNY regarding potential civil
rights enforcement action and setting up meeting w/
AS

09/22/10
09/23/10
09/23/10

09/23/10
09/24/10

JLN
JLN

JLN

JLN
JLN

Meeting with JF to prepare for EDNY DOJ
Meeting with GC, JF and Center for Constitutional
Rights (CCR) re Schoolcraft

Discussion with JF re new post for THEE Ranrt for
more whistleblower Pos to support Monell claim
Reviewed insurance coverage for Def. Isakov
Discussion with JF and GC re: first meeting with
the DOJ and upcoming meeting with the DOJ and

0.400

0.200

3.100
1.100
2.250

0.300
0.100

AS

552

551.0

09/25/10

JLN

553

552.0

09/25/10

553.0

09/27/10

JLN

1.750

Meeting with GC & JF re: upcoming AS interview
with feds
E-mail from JF re: upcoming fed meeting with AS

0.500

0.100

554

JLN

555

554.0

09/27/10

JLN

556

555.0
557
558 556.0
559 557.0
558.0
560
559.0
561
560.0
562
561.0
563
564 562.0
565 563.0
564.0

09/28/10
09/28/10
09/29/10
09/30/10
09/30/10
09/30/10

JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

565.0

Meeting with AS and Feds re: potential fed civil
rights violations
Discussion with JF re: location of witnesses from
This American Life interview
Continued review of transcript of PBA (Velez)
hearing re: quotas
E-mail from JF re article in Russian news
Finished review of PBA transcript
Meeting with GC and JF re: anonymous cop
interviews (VM and EF)
Reviewed answer to complaint filed by Lillian
Aldana-Bernier
Reviewed Bernier's corporate disclosure statement

2.300
0.500
1.700

0.100
2.800
1.100

0.500
0.100

10/02/10

10/02/10
10/02/10
10/04/10

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

566
567

E

Hours

10/06/10

JLN

E-mail exchanges w/ GC re: whistleblower cops
E-mail from JF re whistleblower cop
E-mail re whistleblower cop from JF
Meeting w/ GC and JF to discuss information from
"JR" retired police officer re: quotas, downgrading,
NYPD corruption
Reviewed answer to amended complaint filed by
Jamaica Hospital

Page 29

0.300
0.100
0.100

0.750
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

No.

Date

566.0

1

10/07/10

568
569 567.0
568.0
570
571 569.0
572 570.0
571.0

10/08/10
10/10/10
10/11/10
10/11/10
10/11/10

573

572.0

10/12/10

573.0

10/12/10

575
576 574.0
575.0

10/12/10
10/12/10

574

C

I

D

Timekeep Description
JLN
T/c w/ Colleen Long (AP wire) re: doing story on
Schoolcraft
JLN
Review of AP story re: Schoolcraft case
JLN
Meeting with GC and JF re: infromatoin provided
by MV, NB, EB whistleblower cops
JLN
E-mail from JF re Lewis whistleblower cop
JLN
E-mail correspondence w/ GC re: Posts
JLN
E-mail exchange with Chris Whitehead :re
Compstat videos and possibly obtaining copies of
same
JLN
Reviewed memo of law in Support of defendants
JHMC motion to Dismiss; ; took notes re: same;
researched case law cited
JLN
Meeting w/GC re: Schoolcraftjustice.com calls
from Pos
JLN
Discussion with JF re motion to Dismiss sched.
JLN
Reviewed Declaration of Gregory J. Radomisli in
Supportof defendant JHMC motion to Dismiss

577

E

Hours

0.600
0.200
1.400
0.900

0.200

0.100

2.800
1.000
0.300

0.300

576.0

10/13/10

JLN

577.0

10/13/10

JLN

578.0

10/14/10

JLN

579.0

10/15/10

JLN

580.0

10/30/10

JLN

581.0

11/01/10

JLN

582.0

11/01/10

JLN

583.0

11/08/10

JLN

584.0

11/08/10

JLN

585.0

11/08/10

JLN

586.0

11/09/10

JLN

578
579

580
581

Discussion with JF re: arguments to make in
response to JHMC motion
Discussion with JF re agreement on briefing sched.
w/ defendant Jamaica Hosp.
Meeting with GC re: information provided by PL
and RL (whistleblower cops) to support Monell
claim
Reviewed order re: defendant JHMC's motion to
Dismiss
Meeting with GC & JF re: information provided by
MR, MG RC (whistleblower cops) and movie and
book publicist contacting AS for information

582

1.250

0.100

0.750
0.100

2.250

583

584

Meeting with GC and JF re: updating Schoolcraft
website
Reviewed letter addressed to Judge Sweet from DC
requesting ext. of time to answer
Read 1st Set of Rogs for plaintiff sent by Isakov

585

0.300
0.100

0.100

586
587

Reviewed defendant Isakov's dep notice for
plaintiff Adrian Schoolcraft
Reviewed Defendant Isakov's request for
Production of Documents
Meeting with GC about interviews with CW and
MC whistleblower cops regarding Monell claim

588

0.100
0.100

0.600

Page 30

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

[No.
..-._
1_

587.0

589
590 588.0
589.0
591
590.0
592
591.0
593
592.0

B

Date
11/09/10
11/09/10
11/11/10
11/11/10
11/11/10
11/12/10

594

593.0
595
596 594.0
595.0
597
596.0
598
597.0
599
600 598.0
599.0
601
602 600.0
601.0
603
602.0
604
603.0
605
606 604.0
605.0
607
606.0
608
609 607.0
608.0
610
609.0
611
612 610.0
613 611.0
614 612.0

11/14/10

11/15/10
11/16/10

11/16/10
11/16/10
11/29/10
12/01/10
12/02/10
12/02/10
12/04/10
12/05/10
12/06/10
12/08/10
12/09/10

12/10/10
12/11/10
12/14/10
12/16/10
12/17/10
01/01/11

D

C

Timekeepe Description
Drafted letter to Judge Sweet requesting extension
JLN
JHMC's motion to dismiss
Reviewed Dep notice for plaintiff from B. Lee
JLN
Reviewed defendant Bernier's 1st Set of
JLN
Interrogatories
Reviewed defendant Bernier's answer to Second
JLN
amended complaint
Reviewed defendant Isakov's corporate disclosure
JLN
statement
Meeting with JF and GC re: issues on our
JLN
opposition and GC's meeting with JW anonymous
cop
Reviewed AS recordings w/ Kings County DA and
JLN
Queens County Michelle Cort
Review AS application to NYPD
JLN
Review of affidavit Darius Charney wants
JLN
Schoolcraft to sign Aff for Floyd
E -mailed GC re: changes to Schoolcraft Floyd
JLN
affidavit
Reviewed memo from Lt. Brower (April 10, 2006)
JLN
re: forced O.T.
Reviewed draft CCR Affidavit by AS
JLN
Discussion with GC & JF re affidavit from
JLN
Schoolcraft
Reviewed AS proposed changes to Affidavit
JLN
Reviewed Defendant City of New York's answer to
JLN
amended complaint
E-mail exchange w/ AS re: Detective accused of
JLN
falsifying records and making bogus arrests
Reviewed JF's draft Opp to MTD; made edits to
JLN
same
Discussion with GC & JF re final corrections
JLN
Reviewed NYPD memos regarding anti quota
JLN
legislation
Discussion w/ JF & GC re discovery responses &
JLN
timing
E-mail w/ GC re: HIPAAs for AS meds
JLN
E-mail exchange re: posting on Thee Rant relating
JLN
to Mauriello
Reviewed Darius Charney correspondence re
JLN
affidavit for AS
Reviewed final AS Affidavit for CCR
JLN
E-mail from JF re AS benefits
JLN
E-mail to JF re WSJ article about case
JLN

Page 31

!

E

Hours

0.300
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.300
0.400
0.300
0.400
0.100

0.100
0.100
0.400
0.200
0.100

0.100
0.700
0.800
1.200

0.500
0.100

0.100
0.200
0.100
0.100
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

[

A

B

I

C

613.0

Date
01/10/11

614.0

01/20/11

615.0

01/20/11

616.0

01/26/11

JLN

617.0

01/31/11

JLN

618.0

1

01/31/11

JLN

No.

615

616

D

Timekeep Description
JLN
Meeting with GC & JF re interrogatories and
demands & misc. discovery & strategy issues
JLN
Meeting with GC, JF to discuss JHMC's reply
memo of law
JLN
Reviewed Defendant JHMC's reply memo of law in
Supportof their motion to Dismiss; additional
research regardng issues raised in same

617

Hours
1.500

0.400

0.300

618
619

620
619.0

01/31/11

JLN

620.0

02/08/11

JLN

621.0

02/11/11

JLN

622.0

02/11/11

JLN

623.0

02/12/11

JLN

625
626 624.0
625.0

02/13/11
02/19/11

JLN
JLN

626.0

02/19/11

JLN

627.0

02/23/11

JLN

628.0

02/25/11

JLN

629.0

03/01/11

JLN

630.0

03/01/11

JLN

631.0

03/03/11

.11,N

632.0

04/12/11

JLN

621
622

Discussion with GC & JF re oral arguments on
MTP
Discussion w/ GC re: requesting Queens DA to
investigate Halloween night
Meeting with JF & GC re sending documents &
authorizations to Queens DA office
Review ofmaterials sent to Queens DA to start
investigation
Discussion w/ JF & GC re letter to court to
schedule discovery
Researched issue of stay while MTD is pending

623

0.600
0.400
0.400
0.200
0.300

2.400

624

627
628

629

630
631
632

633

634

E

Reviewed JHMC request for stay while MTD is
pending
Discussion with JF re; motion to stay and
arguments in opposition
Drafted letter brief opposing stay
E-mail exchange the trial in Kings County
involving quota allegations and testimony from
Captain Perez (81)
E-mail correspondence w/ GC re: Seth Harris
verdict finding quota in Carolyn Samuels case
E-mail exchange with Chris Whitehead :re Anti Quota Bill and his failure to get promoted based on
numbers
E-mail exchange with C. Whitehead re: Marino,
Carolyn Samuels case and Capt. Alex Perez's
testimony in that case
Meeting with anonymous cops from T34 w/ GC
and JF- recordings of Lt. Janice Williams
Reviewed recordings of Sgt. Hans, and Lt.
Williams provided by PO "Angel" Rosa
E-mail exchange with C. Whitehead re: Daily News
article on quotas and pressure.
Cony w/ JF re AS suspension & our position with
NYPD on same

Page 32

0.100
0.900
3.200

0.200

0.100

0.100

0.100
1.250

0.300
0.100
0.300

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

1

No.

633.0

B

Date
04/13/11

635

634.0

04/13/11

636

635.0

04/18/11

637

636.0

05/06/11

638

637.0

639
640 638.0
639.0
641
642 640.0
641.0
643
644 642.0
643.0
645
646
647
648
649
650
651
652
653

644.0
645.0
646.0
647.0
648.0
649.0
650.0
651.0
652.0

654
655 653.0
654.0
656
655.0
657
658 656.0
659 657.0
658.0
660
659.0
661

05/06/11
05/09/11
05/09/11
05/09/11
05/10/11

05/10/11
05/10/11

05/12/11
05/14/11
05/15/11
05/15/11
05/16/11
05/17/11
05/18/11
05/19/11
05/19/11
05/19/11
05/19/11
05/19/11
05/19/11
05/20/11
05/20/11

D

C

Timekeepe Description
E-mail exchange with C. Whitehead re: Marino
JLN
steroids findings & punishment
E-mail exchange with C.Whiteheaad re: LAPD
JLN
Officers Quota lawsuit and possible implications
for quota claims in this case
Discussion w/ JF & GC re prep of letter re NYPD
JLN
hearing & PBA representation
Read Judge Sweet's decision on defendants' MTD;
JLN
notes re: same
E-mail exchange w/ GC and JF re: motion to
JLN
dismiss decision
Drafted 1st Set of Rogs to Isakov
JLN
Meeting with GC and JF re: neccesary disclosures
JLN
under Rule 26 for plaintiff
Started drafting R.26 Initial Disclosures
JLN
Started drafting Requests For Admission ("RFA")
JLN
from City
Finished Initial Disclsoures.
JLN
Meeting with GC and JF re: edits to Intial
JLN
disclosures and discussion regarding requests to
admit
Discussion w/ GC & JF re agency agreement
JLN
Continued drafting RFA for City
JLN
Finished drafting RFA for City
JLN
Meeting with GC and JF re: edits to RFA's
JLN
Started drafting Rogs for City
JLN
Cont'd drafting Rogs cor City
JLN
Started drafting 1st Doc Demands City
JLN
Continued drafting document demands for City
JLN
Discuss w/ JF & GC edits & topic areas that should
JLN
be explored on interrogatories
Drafted Schoolcraft deposition notices.
JLN
Review of GC's draft document demands to include
JLN
in our demands
E-mail from GC re: additional dep noT/ces to be
JLN
served
Sent draft document demands to GC
JLN
Finished drafting Rogs for City
JLN
Finished drafting 1st Document Demands for City
JLN

E

Hours
0.100

0.100
0.300

0.300
0.200
2.100
1.750

0.400
2.500
1.400

1.400
0.400
2.200
2.400
1.000
1.900

2.400
1.600
2.100
1.250
0.400

0.300
0.100
0.100
2.800

2.700
05/20/11

JLN

Discussion w/ GC & JF re request to admit
corrections/additions .

Page 33

1.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

D

660.0

Date
05/20/11

Timekeepe Description
JLN
T/c AS & LS re: discovery demands/admissions &
adding many more demands that they feel are
important (vs. overbroad/irrelevant concerns)

661.0

05/20/11

JLN

No.

1

662

E

Hours

1.400

663

Finalize interrogatories & discuss EBTs w/ JF &
GC

662.0

05/20/11

JLN

663.0

05/20/11

JLN

05/20/11
05/20/11

JLN
JLN

05/21/11

JLN

05/22/11
05/22/11

JLN
JLN

05/23/11

JLN

05/23/11
05/23/11

JLN
JLN

05/23/11
05/24/11

JLN
JLN

05/24/11

JLN

05/25/11
06/01/11
06/03/11
06/10/11

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

679.0

06/11/11

JLN

680.0

06/13/11

JLN

681.0

06/16/11

JLN

682.0

06/16/11

JLN

1.300

E-mail exchange AS re: 1st Set of Interrogatories

664

0.200

665
666 664.0
665.0
667
666.0
668
669 667.0
668.0
670
669.0

671
672 670.0
671.0
673
674 672.0
673.0
675
674.0
676
677 675.0
678 676.0
679 677.0
678.0

680
681

682

683
684

I

E-mail exchange re: Plaintiffs' First Request for
Admissions
Sent GC request for admissions for review
Sent GC revised draft document demands for
review
Started drafting 1st Set of Document Demands for
JHMC
Finished 1st Set of Doc Demands Jamaica
Started drafting Schoolcraft document demands for
other defendants
Continued drafting Schoolcraft discovery demands
and interrogatories against medical defendants
Drafted 1st Set of Rogs for JHMC
E-mail correspondence w/Brian Lee re: dep notices
for Caughey & Weiss
Reviewed Notice of Deps for Isakov/Bemier
Finished drafting discovery demands/rogs for med
defendants
Review of E-mail and correspondence w/ GC re
anonymous P.O. from 81st precinct
Drafted NoT/ce of Inspection for JHMC
Reviewed initial disclosure from JHMC
Reviewed JHMC's Initial Disclosures
T/c w/Donna Canfield re: extending City
defendants' time to answer from June/20 to July 20;
e-mail f/u regarding same.
Ltr from B. Lee re: discovery responses and order
of priority

E-mail exchange w/Jim Leander (Queens DA
Office) re: setting up a meeting to discuss
Schoolcraft investigation
E-mail exchange upcoming meeting with Queens
DA & plaintiff desire to postpone meeting until we
have discovery responses
E-mail exchange w/ team re: another NY PD
Detective caught giving false testimony
Page 34

0.200
0.100
0.100
2.300
2.900
1.700

3.600
2.300
0.100
0.100

3.700
0.300
2.300
0.100
0.100

0.100
0.100

0.100

0.200
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

1

No.

683.0
685
686 684.0
685.0
687
686.0
688
687.0
689
688.0
690
689.0
691
692 690.0
691.0
693
694 692.0
693.0
695
694.0
696
697 695.0
696.0

Date
07/17/11
06/17/11
06/21/11
06/21/11
06/23/11

D

C

B

Timekeepe Description
Reviewed Isakov response to Document Demands
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

Reviewed Isakov response to Rogs
E-mail exchange re: 3 cases in EDNY with
Mauriello as one of defendants
E-mail exchange re: Queens DA meeting &
avoiding any contact w/ press/media
Review of answers to interrogatories by Isakov

E

Hours
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.100
0.900

06/23/11

06/23/11
06/23/11
06/23/11
06/24/11
06/27/11

06/27/11
06/30/11
06/30/11

JLN
JLN

JLN
JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

Review of response to doc demands by Isakov;
notes re: same
Discussion with GC & JF re responses & requests
from lsakov
Review of requests for discovery from lsakov
Letter to Jim Leander re: authorizing release of
med records to Queens DA
Reviewed Def. Isakov's 2nd Request for Docs
Discussion with JF and GC re City's failure to
respond to discovery requests
E-mail exchanges with all counsel re: setting up R.
26 Conf. for scheduling of discovery
Rule 26 Conf. w/all counsel present
Reviewed Brian Lee's Proposed Discovery Plan in
advance of mtg later today; notes re: same

0.700
0.600
0.300
0.100
0.100
0.300

0.200
0.900

0.200

698

697.0

07/01/11

JLN

E-mail from B.Brady re: need to modify plan re:
setting deps only after receipt of records from City
0.100

699

698.0
700
701 699.0
700.0
702
701.0
703
702.0
704
705 703.0
706 704.0
707 705.0
708 706.0
707.0
709
710 708.0

07/01/11

07/05/11
07/06/11
07/06/11
07/08/11

07/08/11
07/09/11
07/09/11
07/11/11
07/15/11
07/15/11

JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

Reviewed Brian Lee's Proposed Discovery Plan as
agreed upon at yesterday's conference.
Review discovery plan w/ JF & GC
Mtg. w/ Jim Leander & AS re: Schoolcraft
investigation
Discussion w/ JF & GC re changing case
management plan
Discussion with GC and JF re: meeting with Jim
Leander and AS about investigation
Reviewed Judge Sweet's order re: Oct. 5 conf
E-mail from City on relevancy redaction issue
E-mail to City re: redaction issue
Final review of discovery plan w/ JF & GC
Meeting with JF an GC re: discovery plan and
issues to raise with defense counsel
sent GC E-mail re: objections to discovery plan
Page 35

0.100
0.300

2.400
0.400
1.750

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.250
0.500
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

1

No.

709.0

711
712 710.0
711.0
713
712.0

B

Date
07/18/11

C

D

Timekeepe Description
JLN
Review of changes to discovery plan made by B.
Lee

07/18/11
07/23/11

JLN
JLN

08/05/11

JLN

713.0

08/10/11

JLN

714.0

08/11/11

JLN

715.0

08/14/11

JLN

716.0

08/15/11

JLN

717.0

08/15/11

JLN

08/16/11
08/17/11

JLN
JLN

08/26/11

JLN

09/01/11

JLN

722.0

09/12/11

JLN

723.0

09/20/11

JLN

724.0

09/26/11

JLN

725.0

09/28/11

JLN

09/28/11
09/28/11

JLN
JLN

09/28/11
09/28/11
09/30/11

JLN
JLN
JLN

10/05/11

JLN

714
715

Sent draft E-mail to DC re changes for review
E-mail w/Greg Radomisil re: extending time for
inspection of JHMC
Reviewed JHMC guidelines re: Involuntary
commitment, Psych ER guidelines and use of
handcuffs
Review of GC comments to JHMC discovery
responses
Review of responses to Isakov discovery demands

716

E

Hours

0.200
0.100
0.100

0.900
0.200
0.400

717
718

719
720 718.0
719.0
721
720.0
722
721.0
723

724
725

726
727
728 726.0
727.0
729
730 728.0
731 729.0
730.0
732
731.0
733

Review GC's draft responses to all discovery
demands for medical defendants
Review of our responses to Bernier & Jamaica
discovery demands; edits/revisions
Reviewed Rule 26 (a) Discovery plan filed by
Isakov
Reviewed confidentialty stip from City
Discuss confidentiality stip w/ GC & JF b/c of
plaintiffs objections
Read letter from B. Lee re: request for Suppl
responses
Review of E-mail from Darius Charney enclosing
Floyd decision; read SJ decision; took notes re:
same

Drafted letter motion to compel City defendants to
produce discovery
Reviewed Judge Sweet's order re: motion to compel
and setting oral argument date
T/c w JHMC def. counsel re: extending time for
hospital to respond and/or object to visiting JHMC
and/or taking pies.
Discussion w/ JF re law enforcement privilege &
motion to compel
Attend oral argument on motion to compel
Prepare for hearing before Judge Sweet regarding
Plaintiffs letter motion to Compel
Travel to SDNY- motion to compel (.5)
E-mail from JF re law enforcement privilege
E-mail from all parties re: executed amended
discovery plan
Reviewed Rule 26 Discovery Plan filed by B. Lee

0.400
0.800
0.100
0.300
1.250

0.400

0.500
0.700

0.100

0.300
1.250
1.000

0.700
0.250
0.100

0.200
0.100

Page 36

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

1

INo.

732.0

Date
10/07/11

734
733.0
735
736 734.0
735.0
737
738 736.0
737.0

10/08/11

10/08/11
10/17/11
11/01/11
11/17/11

739

738.0

11/18/11

D

C

B

f

Timekeepe Description
Started Review of first set of docs exhanged by
JLN
City, including Interim IAB Report, QAD Report,
Personell folders, memobook entries etc.; took
notes re: same
Cont'd review of City's 1st response to doc.
JLN
Demands. Took notes re same
Review of operations order sent from client
JLN
order from Judge Sweet directing parties to appear
JLN
for PTC
Reviewed Isakov 3rd request for does
JLN
E-mail from D. Chantey re: Polanco Recordings for
JLN
use in Schoolcraft action; GC to pick up recording,
later today.
Listened to Polanco recordings, including Heran,
JLN
McHugh, Sgt. Bennett; took notes re: same.

E

Hours

4.250
4.700
0.400

0.100
0.100

0.100

1.400

740
739.0

11/18/11

JLN

741

740.0

11/29/11

JLN

742

741.0

12/05/11

JLN

Reviewed mise recordings re: "4 collars" Jones,
Guillermo and Kamper
E-mail from B. Lee re: upcoming discovery
conference and status of case
Started review disclosures from D. Canfield,
including BNIU file and multiple CD Recordings

0.400
0.100

1.800

743

742.0

12/05/11

JLN

744

743.0

12/06/11

JLN

745

744.0

12/13/11

JLN

746

745.0

12/19/11

JLN

747

746.0

12/23/11

JLN

748

747.0

01/05/12

JLN

749

748.0
750
751 749.0
752 750.0
753 751.0
752.0
754

01/10/12

01/20/12
01/24/12
02/07/12
02/07/12

JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

Reviewed City's first set of doc demands, City's
response to Plaintiffs request for admissions, &
City's Rule 26 disclosures
Con'td review of BNIU file and recordings; took
notes re same
Drafted letter re: supplemental discovery responses
for med. Defendants
Discussion w/ GC & JF re plaintiffs thoughts on
discovery & next steps for moving forward
Reviewed recordings and documents from Frank
Palestro
Reviewed ltr from def. counsel re: request for IRS
releases
Meeting with AS, JF and GC re: multiples issues in
use & general strategy for moving forward
Phone call with Adrian and Larry
Spoke to GC re: AS salary
Email from GC re: supplemental demands
Review Notice of Appearance for City Defendants

0.600
3.750
0.100

0.500
2.400
0.100

4.900
0.700
0.200
0.100
0.100

Page 37

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
t
A

B

No.

Date

753.0

02/07/12

C

D

02/10/12

Timekeep; Description
JLN
Reviewed Notice of Apperance by Max Leighton
on behalf of City
JLN
Pre-trial conference before Judge Sweet
JLN
Discussion with JF and GC re: conference and
discovery and strategy for moving forward
JLN
Started drafting Second Set of Document Demands
for City
JLN
Reviewed Judge Sweet's order setting motion
schedule and discovery deadlines
JLN
Started drafting 2nd Request for Docs from City

02/10/12

JLN

760.0

02/10/12

JLN

761.0

02/10/12

JLN

762.0

02/10/12

JLN

763.0

02/10/12

JLN

764.0

02/10/12

JLN

765.0

02/10/12

JLN

766.0

02/10/12

JLN

767.0

02/10/12

JLN

768.0

02/13/12

JLN

769.0

02/24/12

JLN

770.0

1

02/26/12

JLN

755
756 754.0
755.0
757
756.0
758
757.0
759
758.0
760
759.0

02/08/12
02/08/12

02/09/12
02/09/12

E

Hours

0.100
1.000

0.750

2.600
0.100
3.400

761
762

763
764
765
766

767
768

Revised, edited and finalized Second Set of
Document Demands for City. Also drafted list of
items needed for subpoenas and for supplemental
disclosure from City.
Discussion w/ JF & GC re additional items of
discovery
T/c with Adrian and Larry regarding update on
correspondence and update on new discovery
demands
Reviewed proposed supplemental demands for the
City
Telephone Conversation with GC regarding
discovery demands and additional demands
E-mail to GC re discovery we need to follow up
with city
E-mail to JF re additional items of discovery from
City & subpoenas for Johnstown records
E-mail to GC re: Cancellation of Adrian and Larry
trip to NYC
Review of E-mail to Jeremy Steven (investigator)
re: subpoena of Schoolcraft records

769

2.200
1.600

0.700
0.400
0.300
0.200

0.200
0.100

0.100

770
771

772

Review of final supplemental discovery demands
for NYC
Review of E-mail correspondence w/Chris Dunn
(NYCLU)
Reviewed Fulton County Records re: AS Produced
pursuant to subpoena; took notes re: same.

771.0

02/26/12

JLN

02/27/12

JLN

0.200

2.400

Reviewed records from Fulton Ciounty Volume -1

772.0

0.300

Review of subpoena response from Johstown PD

773

0.700

774

1.000

Page 38

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

No.

Date

773.0

1

02/27/12

D

C

B

Timekeepe Description
JLN

Reviewed records from Fulton County Volume - II

775

774.0

02/27/12

E

Hours

0.900

Meeting with JF and GC re: documents received
from Johnstown PD for plaintiffs subpoena

JLN

0.750

776

775.0

02/28/12

JLN

E-mail exchange re: number of actual visits by
Johnstown PD & dates times (vs. their dates/times)

777

776.0

03/06/12

JLN

778

777.0

03/07/12

JLN

779

778.0

03/07/12

JLN

780

779.0

03/08/12

JLN

781

780.0

03/09/12

JLN

782
781.0

03/09/12

JLN

783

782.0

03/09/12

JLN

784
783.0

03/12/12

785
786 784.0
785.0
787

03/12/12
03/12/12

786.0

03/12/12

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

788

787.0

03/12/12

788.0

03/14/12

JLN

"

Reviewed article re: Etemo/Silverman analyzie
flaws in NYPD terror effort
Discussed adding 1st Amendment claim with JF
and GC
Reviewed Notice of Appearance by Suzanna
Publicker on behalf of City
Discussion with JF & GC re Voice article and the
confidential report
Began drafting responses to City's Documents
Demands
Discussion with JF & GC re reinstating 1st
Amendment claims in this case based on Garcetti &
actions after the fact
Drafted letter to Lt. Gilbo Johnstown PD re:
missing documents on visits to Schoolcraft
Continued drafting reponses to City Documents
Demands
Meeting with JF & GC re letter from City
Revised & edited response to City's letter re
protective order
Read/review of letter from defendant City on
breach of confidentiality stip
E-mail to JF re corrections to motion to reinstate

792.0

794
795 793.0
794.0

796
797 795.0

0.100
0.250

0.100
0.750
1.700

1.250

0.900

2.800
0.600
0.250
0.200
0.100

789

790
791 789.0
790.0
792
793 791.0

0.200

03/14/12
03/15/12
03/19/12
03/21/12

03/22/12
03/25/12

03/26/12

JLN
JLN
JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

JLN

E-mail from JF with proposed amended complaint

Review of NY Times article on Schoolcraft
Meeting with JF and GC re proposed amended
complaint
Discussions w/ JF re amended complaint
Read Itr motion from NYT seeking disclosure of
Schoolcraft Materials.
Final edits on amended complaint w/ JF
Finished responses to City's document demands;
forward same to GC & JF for review
City's response to NYT Ltr motion
Page 39

0.100
0.100
0.600
0.500

0.200
0.250

2.400
0.200

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

D

796.0

Date
03/26/12

797.0

03/26/12

Timekeepe Description
JLN
E-mail exchange re Whistblowing Sgt. had role in
crime spike in Queens Pct.
JLN
Reviewed order of Judge Sweet re: NYT motion

799
800 798.0
799.0

03/28/12
03/28/12

JLN
JLN

800.0

03/28/12

JLN

801.0

03/28/12

JLN

802.0

03/29/12

JLN

03/29/12
03/30/12

JLN
JLN

03/30/12
03/30/12
03/30/12

JLN
JLN
JLN

03/30/12

JLN

03/30/12
04/02/12
04/02/12
04/04/12

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

04/05/12

JLN

04/05/12

JLN

04/05/12

JLN

04/08/12

JLN

817.0

04/09/12

JLN

818.0

04/10/12

JLN

04/10/12
04/13/12

JLN
JLN

04/13/12

JLN

1

No.

798

802
803

Meeting w/ JF & GC prior to upcoming conference
to prep
Ltr from S. Publicker re: plaintifs outstanding
discovery
Revised and help draft proposed AEO stip w/ GC
and JF for City
Review of AEO; Notes regarding same
Discussion with GC and JF re: filing motion to
amend and discovery issues
Meeting w/ JF & GC re AEO changes
Final review ofproposed AEO stip
E-mail from Eli Silverman re: ABC news story on
under reoprted crime rates; watched same
E-mail from City re: IAB docs and extending time
to produce
E -mailed proposed AEO stip to the City
E-mail from Bernier consenting to amendment
E-mail from Isakov consenting to amendment
E-mail from JHMC regarding change in amended
language
Drafted response to Defendants 1st Set of
Document Demands
Review & discuss w/ JF & GC plaintiffs responses
to City demands
E-mail from City stating reasons why they oppose
amendment to complaint
T/c w/Kevin Rodriguez (PBA Delegate & PO in
52) re quotas in his precinct; sending materials for
our review

.,,

818
819

820
821 819.0
820.0
822
823 821.0

Hours
0.100
0.100

Oral Argument on City motion
Discussion with JF and GC re: court's order on
City's motion for breach of confidentiality
agreement

801

804
805 803.0
804.0
806
807 805.0
808 806.0
807.0
809
808.0
810
811 809.0
812 810.0
813 811.0
812.0
814
813.0
815
814.0
816
815.0
817
816.0

E

E-mail correspondence w/GC re: discovery
responses
Meeting w/ AS re: case status general strategy next
steps for moving forward
E-mail re: Schoolcraft arrival to NYC
Discussion with GC and JF re: Matthews decision
Read Matthews decision; took notes re: same
Page 40

1.000

0.500
0.400

0.100
0.800
0.600
0.600
0.600
0.300

0.200
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

2.800
0.800
0.100

0.700

0.100

4.600
0.100
0.600
0.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

824 822.0
823.0

C

B

Date

04/13/12
04/23/12

D

I

Timekeep Description
E-mail from plaintiff re 1st Amendment claim
JLN
Reviewed draft letter from JF regarding motion to
JLN
amend complaint; made edits to same

E

Hours

0.100

0.400

825

824.0

04/25/12

JLN

826

825.0

04/25/12

JLN

827

826.0

04/30/12

JLN

828

827.0

04/30/12

JLN

829

828.0

05/01/12

JLN

Discussion with re: edits/changes to 1st
Amendment letter
Reviewed JF letter to Court requesting leave to
amend to add Lt. Hanlon
Discussion w/ JF re NY Times alteration to
protective order
E-mail from JF to City re additions to protective
order
Discussions w/ JF re City's request for affidavits &
deposition for confidentiality breach

0.750

0.100
0.300
0.100

0.400

830

829.0

05/02/12

JLN

831

830.0

05/03/12

JLN

832

831.0

05/08/12

JLN

833

832.0
834
835 833.0
834.0
836
835.0
837
836.0

838
839 837.0
840 838.0
839.0
841
840.0
842
841.0
843
842.0
844
843.0
845

05/08/12
05/09/12
05/11/12

05/12/12
05/13/12

05/16/12
05/16/12
05/16/12
05/17/12

JLN
JLN
JLN

JLN
JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

E-mail to JF to City re confidentiality and
discovery issues
Discussion w/ GC & JF re Affidavits and Conf.
Stip AEO
Discussion w/ JF and GC re argument on 1st
Amendment claim
Reviewed Notice of Appearance by William
Fraenkel on behalf of City
Attended Argument on 1st Amendment claim
Read defendant's motion to quash and discussion
w/ GC & JF re: same
Reviewed letter by S. Publicker regarding quashing
Vallone subpoena
Reviewed docs from another quota case (Robinson
v. City, 05cv9545) Reviewed dep transcripts from
Robinson, Including Emmanuel Bowser, Michael
Ryan J. Robinson); took notes re: same
Legal research regarding City motion to Quash
Began drafting letter opposing City motion
Discussion w/ JF and GC re opp to defendant's
motion to quash
Finished drafting Opposition to motion to Quash

0.100
0.750
0.600

0.100
1.000

2.100
0.100

3.400
3.400
1.600

0.600
3.200

05/17/12

JLN

Discussion w/GC and JF re: AS breach affidavit
0.700

05/17/12
05/22/12

JLN

JLN

Review and discuss City New York Times opp
letter w/ JF & GC
Discussion w/ JF & GC re defendant's letter re
Vallone subpoena
Page 41

0.400

0.600

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

1 JNo.

C

B

Date

846 844.0
845.0
847

05/23/12
05/24/12

JLN

846.0

05/24/12

JLN

847.0

05/30/12

JLN

06/02/12
06/05/12

JLN
JLN

06/06/12

JLN

06/06/12

JLN

848

r

849
850 848.0
849.0
851
850.0

852

851.0
853
854 852.0
853.0
855
854.0
856
855.0
857
856.0
858
857.0

D

Timekeepe Description
JLN
Prep for argument w/ JF & GC

Notice of Appearance by Walter Kretz, behalf of
Mauriello; Google search re: Kretz
E-mail from S. Publicker re: proposed changes to
Confidentiality Stip
E-mail exchange w/GC and JF re City stips and
revisions
Reviewed discovery demands from JHMC
Review of E-mail correspondence between SP and
Times
Reviewed Confidentiality stip and proposed
changes made by GC; made additional
edits/suggestions
Review of E-mail correspondence between SP and
Times
Reviewed final AEO Stip
E-mail exchange w/GC re: changes to AEO stip

06/07/12
06/07/12

JLN
JLN

06/08/12

JLN

06/08/12

JLN

06/14/12

JLN

06/14/12

JLN

858.0

06/14/12

JLN

06/18/12

JLN

06/19/12
06/19/12
06/19/12
06/21/12

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

Reviewed JF draft motion for reconsideration;
made edits to same
Meeting with Schoolcraft in Johnstown
Travel back to NYC from Johnstown (3.5)
Travel to Johnstown (3.5)
E-mail correspondence w/GC and JF re Schoolcraft

06/26/12

JLN
JLN

07/12/12

JLN

07/13/12

JLN

Reviewed Frankel letter opposing plaintiff motion
for reconsideration of 1st Amend Claim
Review of Schoolcraft's recordings; prepared
comprehensive timeline; sent to JF
E-mail from City regarding tax return
authorizations

1.000

0.200
0.100
0.300
0.200
0.100

0.300

0.100
0.300

Read Judge Sweet's order re: motion to reconsider

07/05/12

Hours

Read Judge Sweet's Opinion on Plaintiffs motion
to amend Councilman Vallone's motion to quash

859.0

E

0.100

E-mail from GC to SP re: redlined changes to
proposed Stip.
Read ltr from NYT counsel re: inventory of
confidential materials for
Meet with GC and JF to discuss motion for
reconsideration on 1st amendment claim
Reviewed background search by Warren
Investigators of Marino, Lauterborn and Mauriello

859

0.100
0.100
0.750

0.300

860

0.200

861
862 860.0
863 861.0
864 862.0
863.0
865
864.0
866
865.0
867
866.0
868
867.0
869

0.400
4.800
1.750
1.750
0.200
0.100

Page 42

0.100

3.800
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

j
1 INo.

A

868.0

Date
07/17/12

870

869.0

07/20/12

871

870.0

07/23/12

872

871.0

07/23/12

873

872.0

07/24/12

D

C

B

Timekeepe Description
E-mail w/GC re: upcoming meeting in Albany with
JLN
Schoolcrafts
Read Opinion of Judge Sweet denying Plaintiffs
JLN
motion to reconsider
Discussion w/ GC & JF re: upcoming meeting w/
JLN
Schoolcrafts in Albany
E-mail exchange w/JF & GC re: visit to
JLN
Schoolcrafts in Albany
E-mail from JF re Albany meeting w/ Schoolcrafts
JLN

E

Hours
0.100
0.100
0.300
0.100

0.100

874

873.0

07/28/12

JLN

875

874.0

07/31/12

JLN

876

875.0
877
878 876.0
877.0
879
880 878.0
881 879.0
882 880.0
883 881.0
884 882.0
885 883.0
884.0
886
887 885.0
888 886.0
889 887.0
890 888.0
889.0
891
890.0

08/03/12

08/07/12
08/08/12
08/08/12
08/08/12
08/09/12
08/09/12
08/09/12
08/09/12
08/10/12
08/10/12
08/10/12
08/10/12
08/10/12
08/10/12

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

893
894 892.0
893.0
895
894.0
896
895.0
897

E-mail from JF re extension of discovery
E-mail to JF re extension of discovery
E-mail to JF re plaintiffs dep
E-mail w/GC re Schoolcraft breach affidavit
Response E-mail regarding deposition from Greg

08/13/12

JLN

08/13/12

08/13/12
08/13/12

JLN

JLN
JLN

0.600
0.200

0.100
0.100
1.300

0.500
0.200
5.750
5.500
1.500
1.500

0.200
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

R.

892

891.0

Discussion w/ JF & GC re motion to amend to add
prior restraint
Reviewed JF draft of letter seeking leave to amend;
edits to same
E-mail from S. Publicker re: format of document
production once stip is finalized
Read order re: plaintiffs motion to amend
Meeting w/ JF & GC re: upcoming meeting w/ AS
in Albany for prep
Review of final stips
Printed out docs to go over with Adrian
Meeting w/AS in Albany
Meeting with Client in Albany with GC & JF
Traveled from Albany back to NYC (3.0)
Traveled to Albany to meet Client (3.0)
E-mail correspondence re: extension of discovery

Reviewed City's supplemental disclosure of does
(non -confidential records from JAB file); took
notes re: same
Continued review of discovery produced by NYC
E-mail from Brian Lee regarding deposition
Review of E-mail from SP re: scheduling AS depo

3.400
2.800
0.100
0.100

08/14/12
08/14/12

JLN
JLN

Continued review of doc production by city;
highlighted & took notes re: same
Drafted letter to defense counsel re: Schoolcraft tax
returns
Page 43

3.600
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

898 896.0
897.0
899
900 898.0
901 899.0
902 900.0
901.0
903
904 902.0
905 903.0
906 904.0
905.0
907
908 906.0
909 907.0
908.0
910
911 909.0
912 910.0
911.0
913
914 912.0
915 913.0
916 914.0
915.0
917
918 916.0
919 917.0
918.0
920
921 919.0
920.0
922
923 921.0
922.0
924
923.0

B

Date

08/14/12
08/14/12
08/14/12
08/14/12
08/14/12
08/15/12

C

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

08/15/12
08/15/12
08/15/12
08/16/12

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

08/16/12
08/16/12
08/20/12

JLN
JLN
JLN

08/20/12
08/20/12
08/20/12

JLN
JLN
JLN

08/21/12
08/21/12
08/21/12
08/22/12

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

08/22/12
08/22/12
08/23/12

JLN
JLN
JLN

08/27/12
08/28/12

JLN
JLN

08/28/12
08/28/12

JLN
JLN

08/29/12

JLN

08/29/12

JLN

925

924.0

926

D

Timekeepe Description
JLN
E-mail from Brady re deps

E-mail from JF re letter to City w/ tax
authorizations
E-mail from JF re plaintiffs dep
E-mail to JF re plaintiffs dep
Review of correspondence re Tax returns
Continued review of doc production by city; took
notes re: most impt. Docs.
E-mail from B Brady re plaintiffs dep
E-mail from B. Lee re plaintiffs dep
E-mail from Brian Lee re subpoenaed does
Discussion w/ JF & GC re City's suggestion on
multiple deps of AS & best way to oppose same.

E-mail from City re plaintiffs dep
E-mail to JF re plaintiffs dep
Discussion w/ JF & GC re amendment of the
complaint to add Lt. Hanlon
Discussion w/ JF re AS dep prep
Reviewed City's Second Request for Docs.
Review of E-mail from JF to City re amendment
adding Lt. Hanlon
E-mail from Brady consenting to Amendment
E-mail from Brady re scheduling AS dep
E-mail from City requesting copy of complaint
Meeting w/ GC & JF re Kretz's request to have an
additional day to depose plaintiff
E-mail from City re AS dep date
E-mail from GC re dep dates
Reviewed correspondence between Al Vann and
Ray Kelly
Reviewed Supplemental Disclosures from City
Drafted letter to Court re: extension of discovery
deadline
E-mail from GC re Chief article
E-mail from JF to defendants enclosing responses
to discovery
Mtg. w/ JF & GC re: City's Suppl. Disclosure & the
need for us to depose at least 5 of the 9 new
witnesses identified by City & other gen.strategy
issues for advancing discovery
Reviewed City's Suppl. R. 26 disclosures re: P.O.
Rodriguez, P.O. Rudy (both at 81 when Pl. left) &
P.O. Sadowski & EMT Villaverde & Det Yeager,
etc

E

Hours

0.100

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
4.200
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.700
0.100
0.100
0.600
0.400
0.200
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.400
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.400
0.100

0.100

0.800

0.100
Page 44

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

925.0
927
928 926.0
927.0

C

B

Date
09/01/12

09/06/12
09/07/12

Timekeepe Description
Multiple e -mails and attachments from PO Kevin
JLN
Rodriguez re: quota activity at the 52 pct.
JLN
JLN

929

928.0

09/10/12

JLN

930
929.0

09/10/12

JLN

931

930.0

09/10/12

JLN

932

931.0

09/10/12

JLN

933

932.0

09/10/12

JLN

934
933.0

09/11/12

JLN

935

934.0

09/12/12

D

I

JLN

Reviewed grievance filed by Kevin Rodriguez
E-mail exchange w/K.Rodriguez re: monthly
performance evaluations & evidence of
quotas/pressure
Read Opinion & order from Judge Sweet on
plaintiffs motion to amend
E-mail from GC re 120 day extension of discovery
deadline
E-mail from JF re 120 extension of discovery
deadline

E-mail to JF re 120 extension of discovery deadline
Response from City on Hanlon amend; notes re:
same
Drafted letter seeking extension of discovery
deadline until January 2013
Reviewed ltr and enclosures from ACC Publicker,
including multiple CD's with recorded interviews
made by IAB (non -confidential); began listening to
CD interviews (3742-3748)

Hours

0.300
0.200

0.200
0.700
0.100
0.100

0.100
0.100
0.400

3.400

936

935.0

09/13/12

JLN

937

936.0

09/14/12

JLN

938

937.0

939
940 938.0
939.0

09/14/12

09/14/12
09/15/12

JLN

JLN
JLN

941

940.0

09/16/12

JLN

942

941.0

09/17/12

JLN

943

942.0
944

E

09/18/12

JLN

Cont'd listening to CD interviews from IAB (non confidential) investigation
Cont'd listening to CD interviews from IAB (non confidential) investigation
Reviewed materials sent by Kevin Rodriguez,
including Sgt Summa statements re: "activity",
various recordings; perfomance
evaluations;numerous memoranda, posts and
photos

Reviewed production by City
Listened to recordsings of Capt. Thoms J. Kemper
at Transit District 4; recording of Deputy Insp.
Donna Jones (Employee Management Division);
took notes re same.
Reviewed records from Councilman Vallone as
provided by City on 9-12
Reviewed JF draft letter to Court regarding adding
Lt. Hanlon as deft
Reviewed JF's proposed Itr to Court re: Request to
Amend

Page 45

3.700

4.600

3.700
0.400

1.200

0.300
0.100

0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

I

943.0

Date
09/18/12

944.0

1

09/24/12

No.

945
946
947 945.0
948 946.0
949 947.0
948.0
950
951 949.0
952 950.0
953 951.0
952.0
954
955 953.0
956 954.0
957 955.0
958 956.0
959 957.0
960 958.0
961 959.0
960.0

09/24/12
09/24/12
09/24/12
09/24/12
09/25/12
09/25/12
09/25/12
09/26/12
09/26/12
09/26/12
09/26/12
09/26/12
09/26/12
09/26/12
09/26/12
09/28/12

C

D

Timekeepe Description
JLN
Reviewed Judge Sweet's order granting plaintiffs
request for an extension of discovery deadline until
January 12, 2013
JLN
Meeting w/GC and JF to discuss City deficiency
letter and AS dep prep
JLN
E-mail from City re: amended complaint
JLN
E-mail response from Kretz
JLN
E-mail response to Kretz & City
JLN
E-mail to defendants re service of amended
complaint
JLN
Prep AS for his dep
JLN
Meeting w/ AS & GC & JF re dep prep
JLN
E-mail from Greg R re Lauterborn dep
JLN
Meeting w/ JF & GC & AS re adjorning dep due to
father's medical emergency
JLN
Brady E-mail re: service of process
JLN
E-mail from JF adjourning dep of AS
JLN
E-mail from Kretz re Lauterborn dep
JLN
E-mail to JF adjourning dep of AS
JLN
Response from B Lee re: adj.
JLN
Response from Kretz re: adj.
JLN
Review of E-mail from GC adjourning AS dep
JLN
Drafted letter to all counsel re: responses from nonparties, including Albert Vann, Fulton County and
Johnstown PD; reviewed enclosures

962

E

Hours

0.100
1.750

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
3.500
2.900
0.100
0.600
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.200
961.0

963
964 962.0
963.0
965
964.0

09/29/12

JLN

10/02/12
10/04/12

JLN
JLN

10/05/12

JLN

Reviewed revised amended complaint by JF; edits
and revisions to same
Listened to entire QAD interview of AS
Reviewed stipulation and Protective order for
Attorneys Eyes Only Signed by Judge Sweet
Replayed 2d hour of QAD interview of AS (re:
downgrading based on index scrime stats); took
notes re sme.
Prepared AS for depostion
Continued prepping AS for upcoming dep on Oct.

966
967 965.0
966.0
968
969 967.0
970 968.0
971 969.0
970.0

10/08/12
10/09/12

JLN
JLN

10/09/12
10/10/12
10/11/12
10/11/12

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

Reviewed cover Jetter w/disclosures from City
Continued prepping AS for dep tomorrow
Defended AS at his deposition
Mtg. w/client to discuss his performance at today's
deposition, and next steps for moving forward

972
973 971.0

10/11/12

JLN

Meeting with JF, GC, AS before depo

11

.

Page 46

0.700
3.300
0.100

1.800

6.400
7.200
0.100
6.700
7.100

1.800

0.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

972.0

974
975 973.0
974.0

Date
10/12/12

10/12/12
10/12/12

D

C

B

Timekeep Description
Reviewed Citys' disclosure of plaintiffs NYS Tax
JLN
Returns 2004-2009; compared same w/tax records
in file.
E-mail to JF re photos used at AS dep
Email to JF to City re allowing AS access to QAD
report

0.400
0.100

JLN
JLN

0.100

976
975.0

10/13/12

JLN

Began listening to IAB interviews (Sgt. Duncan/Lt.
Gough); took notes re same; created summary of
most important points re: Halloween nt.
3.800

977

976.0

10/14/12

JLN

978

977.0

10/15/12

JLN

979

978.0

10/16/12

JLN

980

979.0

10/16/12

JLN

981
980.0

10/16/12

JLN

982

981.0

10/16/12

JLN

983

982.0

10/17/12

JLN

984

983.0

10/17/12

JLN

Listened to Chief Marino IAB interview; Side A
and Side B; took notes re: same; prepared summary
of most important points
Mtg w/GC & JF re: Marino's IAB interview &
inconsistencies w/claims in OF 49 & Halloween
Night recording
Created chart summarizing differencs b/w Marino
& Lauterbome in IAB interviews.
Listened to Caughey interview (Sides A & B); took
notes re: same
Reviewed City's. Priv. log (27 pgs); highlighted all
claims that need to be challenged & the basis for
doing so
Listened to IAB interview of Capt. Lauterbom;
took notes re: same
Mtg w/JF & GC re: City's privilege claims and
possible arguments/motions to defeat such claims
highlights of Lauterbom interview &
inconsistencies w/Marino & home invasion
recording
Research re: City's "Deliberative Process" Privilege
claim and best cases for defeating such a claim

3.200

1.200

2.100
1.600

1.600
1.400

3.300

3.200

985

984.0

10/17/12

JLN

986

985.0

10/17/12

JLN

987

986.0

10/17/12

JLN

988

987.0

10/17/12

JLN

989

988.0

990

E

Hours

10/18/12

JLN

Drafted letter re: opposing Mauriello's request for
an additional 7 hrs to depose plaintiff.
Listened to interview w/Sgt. Hawkins; took notes
re: same; compared & contrasted with Gough &
Duncan.
Compiled list of all CD's from City Production Still missing 3801/08
Dicussion w/ GC & JF re City's refusal to allow AS
to see QAD file
Drafted letter to Judge to modify AEO to allow AS
access to confidential materials
Page 47

2.400

2.100
0.400
0.400

3.200

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

D

No.
989.0

Date

10/18/12

Timekeepe Description __...
JLN
Listened to interviews of Det. Yeager, Lt.

990.0

10/18/12

JLN

991.0

10/18/12

JLN

992.0

10/18/12

JLN

993.0

10/18/12

JLN

995
996 994.0
995.0

10/18/12
10/19/12

JLN
JLN

996.0

10/19/12

JLN

997.0

10/19/12

JLN

10/19/12
10/19/12
10/20/12

JLN
JLN
JLN

T/c w/ GC/JF re: Nelson, Caughey interviews
Read answer filed by Isak Isakov
T/c w/GC & JF re: P.O. Nowacki acknowledging
quota (15 c's per month) at 81 & possibly serving
non-party subpoeana on her for dep and
discovering other possible w's at 81 re summons
quota

1001.0

10/21/12

JLN

1002.0

10/22/12

JLN

1003.0

10/22/12

JLN

1004.0

10/22/12

JLN

1005.0

10/22/12

JLN

1006.0

10/23/12

JLN

1007.0

10/23/12

JLN

listened to IAB interviews for Sgt. Scanlar, Lt.
Crawford & Det. Barbara; took notes re same
Listened to IAB interview of Sgt. Glaudino (ESU),
P.O. Sadowski and PAA Thomspon; took took
notes re same
Listened to IAB CD of EMT V illaverde, Sgt.
Conwell & P.O. Hurly; took notes re same
Listend to IAB interviews of DI Green (CO 104) &
P.O. Deck; took notes re same.
Compared DI Green statements w/Mauriello's
statements re: interaction with DI Green at scene
and statements re: suspension
Listened to IAB CD interviews of Sgt Weber, P.O.
Lewis and P.O. Reyes
Listened to IAB interviews of P.O.'s Astor &
Santana; took notes re:

1

991

992

993

994

Delafuente & Sgt. James; took notes re same.
Research re: City's Grand Jury privilege claim
regarding ADA Jim Liander & Quuens DA
investigation into Schoolcraft matter
Mtg w/JF & GC re: City's Deliberative Process and
Grand Jury privilege claims and best strategy for
defeating same.
Listened to interview w/Assistant Chief Gerald
Nelson; took notes re:same
Reviewed and edited motion permitting AS to
review QAD material and opposing 3 days of
depositions for AS
Read amended answer by City
Listened to IAB interviews for PO Mohabir, P.O.
Gaspari, and P.O. Nowacki; took notes re same

997

Hours

3.200

2.600

1.200

0.700

0.500
0.100

2.900

998

999
1000 998.0
1001 999.0
1000.0

1002

1003

1004
1005

1006

1007
1008
1009

E

Listened to IAB interviews of P.O. Reyes, P.O.
Visconi; notes re same
Created chart summarizing differences b/w James
& Yeager accounts of events at JHMC Med. ER.

Page 48

1.800

1.700
0.300
0.100

0.900
1.800

2.800
1.800

1.600

0.400
2.300
1.700

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

1008.0

Date
10/23/12

D

C

B

Timekeep Description
Reviewed Ltr from S. Publ icker responding to our
JLN
letter to modify AEO to allow access by Plaintiff

Hours

0.100

1010
1009.0

10/24/12

JLN

Listened to IAB interview of E. Marshall, P.O.
Louis, P.O. Miller and P.O. Itwaru;took notes re
2.600

same

1011

1010.0

10/24/12

JLN

1012

1011.0

1013
1014 1012.0
1013.0
1015
1014.0
1016
1015.0
1017
1016.0
1018
1017.0
1019
1018.0
1020
1019.0
1021
1020.0
1022
1023 1021.0
1022.0

10/24/12

JLN

1023.0

Listened to IAB interviews of Misty Schoolcraft
(AS Sister); took notes re: same.
T/c w/AS & LS re their relationships with Misty
Schoolcraft, her present location, last time of any
contact; also gen. discussions about status of
discovery and moving forward w/NYPD deps.

2.100

1.200

10/25/12
10/25/12
10/26/12
10/26/12
10/27/12

JLN
JLN
JLN

JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN

Motion to compel heard
Ltr from GC re: Plaintiffs Response to City's 2d
Request for does
Started review of IAB does exchanged by City in
latest production
Reviewed Judge Sweet's endorsement of letter filed
Kretz, Jr
Continued reviewing IAB does from latest City
exchange; notes re same
Continued review of IAB documents; took notes of

0.500

same.

10/24/12
10/24/12

3.800

0.100
1.700

0.100

4.250

Continued reviewing IAB does exchanged by City
3.700

10/27/12
10/28/12
10/29/12
10/29/12

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

1024
10/29/12

JLN

E-mail & follow up T/c w/ Eli Silverman re: case
status and specific items for discovery
Further review of IAB docs; highlighted and took
notes re: same
Finished review of IAB files; notes re same
Reviewed multiple Patrol Guide Procedures
provided by City; highlighted and flagged most
important provisions; took notes re: same
Reviewed City's production re: Vallone does &
correspondence from third parties, notes on same.

0.400

4.800
4.400

3.200

0.900

1025

1024.0

10/30/12

JLN

1026

1025.0

10/30/12

JLN

1027

1026.0
1028

E

10/30/12

JLN

Reviewed Audio CDISprint Reports re:
transmission made by NYPD on Oct. 31, 2009 -104 Pct; notes re same.
Reviewed Add! Sprint Reports/Radio
Transmissions from Nov. 1, 2009 from 104th Pct;
notes re: same.
Reviewed Prop. Clerk Invoices & NYSPIN
response message.
Page 49

2.600

1.400

0.200

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

No.

Date

1027.0

10/31/12

1028.0

10/31/12

1029.0

11/02/12

JLN

11/02/12
11/07/12

JLN
JLN

11/11/12

JLN

1033.0

11/12/12

JLN

1034.0

11/12/12

JLN

11/14/12
01/22/15

JLN

JLN

01/23/15

JLN

01/23/15

JLN

01/23/15

JLN

01/23/15
01/24/15

JLN
JLN

01/26/15

JLN

1043.0

01/27/15

JLN

1044.0

01/27/15

JLN

1045.0

01/27/15

JLN

1046.0

01/27/15

JLN

1047.0

01/28/15

JLN

1

1029

D

Timekeepe Description
JLN
Reviewed CD's re service attempts upstate; took
notes re: same
JLN
T//c w/ AS re: CD's showing attempted service &
radio transmissions & AS's guidance as to what
info should be focused on in transmissions

1030

Hours
1.800

1.200

1031
1032 1030.0
1031.0
1033
1032.0

Review of case law sent by Lee re: medical
defendants' liability
E-mail to GC re: Schoolcraft phone numbers
E-mail w/ GC re: service of newly named
defendants
Reviewed redacted responses to Schoolcraft justice
website for inclusion in discovery responses

1034

0.400
0.100

0.100

1.100

1035

1036
1037 1035.0
1036.0
1038
1037.0
1039
1038.0
1040
1039.0
1041
1042 1040.0
1041.0
1043
1042.0

Drafted response to City 2nd request for documents
Phone call with LS and AS re: continuing atty
client relationaship
Tennination letter from AS
Call from LS re: reentering case as lead counsel

1.200

0.750
0.100
0.750

T/c with Adrian re: potentially taking over as lead
counsel for trial
F/u call w/GC and JF about taking over case again

1.200

0.800

1044

1045

Tic w/GC re: potentially re-entering case & taking
over for trial
Reviewed R. 68 from Oct. 2014
T/c w/AS and LS re: wilingness to take over again
and inclusion of C &F on our trial team
Discussion with AS & LS re my initial review of
materials they sent me and the R. 68 offer, and the
next steps for moving forwad
Researched case law cited in City's Memo re:
Unlawful entry section, 1st Amendment section and
conspiracy section.
Researched case law re: MHL 9.39; 9.40; 9.41

1046

0.700
0.200
0.900

1.400

3.400
2.800

1048

Reviewed Plaintiffs Memo of law for Partial SJ;
notes on same
Reviewed City Memo of Law for SJ; took notes re

0.750

same

1047

1049

E

0.700

Legal research re: JHMC arg. for exclusion of
emergency med. expert Dr. Halpren Ruder

1.600

Page 50

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

1

No.

1048.0
1050
1051 1049.0
1052 1050.0
1051.0
1053
1052.0
1054
1053.0
1055
1054.0
1056
1055.0

Date
01/28/15

Timekeepe Description
Reveiwed all SMF ("Statement of Material Facts")
JLN
exhibits in support of Mauriello's motion.

01/28/15
01/28/15
01/28/15
01/29/15
01/29/15
01/30/15
01/30/15

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

JLN
JLN

JLN

01/31/15

JLN

Reviewed JHMC motion for SJ
Reviewed Mauriello's motion for SJ
Reviewed plaintiffs motion to Amend Second
complaint & Reply Mem. re: same
Reviewed Dr. Bernier's motion for summary
judgment; notes on same.
Reviewed Isakov's motion for summary judgment;
notes on same
Reviewed Callan Declaration & Exhibits in
Support of Motion
Telecon w/ plaintiff and Larry Schoolcraft re: case
status, summary of w/ deposition testimony and
taking over for Nat Smith
Reviewed City's Revised Memo of Law for Partial
SJ; reviewed City's Local R. 56.1 Statement

0.800
0.600
0.400
0.600
0.500
1.600

0.750

1.100

1058
1057.0

01/31/15

JLN

1059

1058.0

1060
1061 1059.0
1060.0
1062
1063 1061.0
1062.0
1064
1065 1063.0
1064.0
1066
1065.0
1067
1068 1066.0
1067.0
1069
1068.0

02/01/15
02/01/15
02/01/15

02/01/15
02/01/15
02/02/15
02/02/15
02/02/15
02/02/15
02/04/15
02/04/15

JLN
JLN
JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN

Reviewed revised Suppl Decl. of RS adding add'!
docs in support of City SJ motion
Rev'd Plaintiffs exhibits in support of SJ motion;
notes re: same
Reviewed Dep. of Sgt. James
Reviewed Dep. of Lt. Broschart.; notes on same
Read Curtis Boston Dep.; notes on same

Read Rasheena Huffman Dep.; took notes re: same
Reviewed Dep. of Sgt. Sawyer; notes on same
Further discussion w/ GC & JF rejoining team to
represent AS for trial
Reviewed Dep. of Lt. Hanlon; cross-referecenced
PX 67 (IAB interview)
Reviewed Dep. of Dr. Halpren Rudit
Reviewed 1st 112 of Mauriello's dep; took notes re:
same
T/c AS & LS re: case status, Si motions and trial
strategy and next steps for moving forward

0.200

2.400
1.900

1.200
0.600

0.500
1.700
1.300

0.900
0.600
1.700

1.100

1070
1069.0

02/04/15

JLN

1071

1070.0
1072

E

Hours

1.400

1057

1056.0

D

C

B

02/04/15

JLN

T/c GC & JF re: pending trial strategy and
misc.evidentiary issues, and setting up meetng to
discuss same in greater detail
Review of E-mail from AS re: QAD memo from
Sgt. Scott
Page 51

0.900

0.400

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

.._

No.
1073 1071.0
1072.0
1

B

Date

02/04/15
02/04/15

C

D

Timekeepe Description
JLN
Reviewed docket sheet

JLN

1074

Hours

0.300

Discussion w/ JF & GC re scheduling a meeting w/
Nat Smith ("NS") to discuss case status and trial
prep

0.250

E-mail from AS to NS and entire team re: formally
stating that we have been reinstated as lead trial
counsel

0.100

1073.0

02/04/15

JLN

1074.0

02/04/15

JLN

1075.0

02/05/15

JLN

1076.0

02/06/15

JLN

1077.0

02/06/15

JLN

1078.0

02/07/15

JLN

Reviewed all remaining Rule 56.1 Statements and
Declarations; took notes re: same and prepared list
of all potential exhibits all witnesses, all possible
motions in limine based on said review

1079.0

02/08/15

JLN

1080.0

02/08/15

JLN

1081.0

02/09/15

JLN

1082.0

02/09/15

JLN

Cont'd review of 56.1 statements and supporting
docs
Reviewed Silvennan's deposition; took notes re
same
T/c AS & LS regarding negative articles in Daily
News regarding AS last week and steps moving
forward
T/c GC re: issues that came up in Adrian's Dep and
Larry's Dep and possible motions in !Milne

1083.0

02/09/15

JLN

1084.0

02/10/15

JLN

1085.0

02/10/15

JLN

1086.0

02/10/15

JLN

1075

1076

1077

E-mail from NS acknowledging Adrian Schoolcraft
e-mail and suggesting mtg of entire team

T/c w. GC re: updates on discussion with Nat
Smith, records and transcripts provided by Adrian
and goal to streamline case for trial
Reviewed Eterno's deposition; took notes re: same

1078

0.100

0.500

2.800

1079

Reviewed 2nd amended complaint for refreshing
mem. regarding core factual allegations, notes re:
same

0.700

1080

3.400

1081
1082

1083

1084

3.700
3.200

0.500

0.400

1085

E-mail exchange with NS regarding setting up
meeting and getting Broschart Dep and Exhibits
from Maurielloi Marino Dep
Meeting w/ GC & JF regarding global trial strategy,
witnesses to be called (or not called), exhibits to
use, Rule 68 offer and next steps for moving
forward.

1086

0.100

3.500

1087
1088

E

E-mail correspondence w/AS, GC re: Defendants
request to adjourn trial
E-mail correspondence w/AS, GC re: Defendants
request to adjourn trial
Page 52

0.200

0.200

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

1089 1087.0
1088.0

D

C

B

Date

Timekeep :. Description

02/11/15
02/11/15

JLN
JLN

Started review of deposition exhibits
T/c AS and LS regarding trial adjournment request
by City, strategy for dealing with multiple issues
raised by defendants in dep of plaintiff and overall
approach to the case against NYPD

E

Hours

3.400

1.400

1090
1089.0

1091
1092 1090.0
1093 1091.0
1094 1092.0
1093.0

02/11/15
02/11/15
02/11/15
02/12/15
02/12/15

JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

1095
1094.0

02/12/15

JLN

1096
1095.0

02/12/15

JLN

1097
1096.0

1098
1099 1097.0
1098.0

02/13/15

02/13/15
02/13/15

JLN

JLN
JLN

1100
1099.0

02/13/15

JLN

Review of witness/exhibit list from JF and discuss
with GC
Reviewed JHMC memo in opp to SJ
Review of E-mail from AS regarding trial
Continued review of deposition exhibits
T/c NS and JL regarding scheduling motion
practice, procedural history, and setting up meeting
for next week to discuss exhibits, docs, and trial
strategy
E-mail exchange with NS regarding schedule
change for trial and clients consent.
T/c client regarding update on schedule, new
materials he sent me, overall trial strategy
Meeting w/GC to discuss which witnesses I would
be responsible for at trial; general trial strategy
Reviewed Bernier Opp to PH. SJ motion
Reviewed City Memo of Law in opp to Pl. Mot;
took notes re same
Reviewd Mauriello Aff. In Opp; notes on same

1.300
0.300
0.100
3.750

0.500
0.100
0.100

1.300
0.500

0.400
0.300

1101
1100.0

02/13/15

JLN

1102
1101.0

02/13/15

JLN

Reviewed JHMC Mem. of Law in opp to Pl. mot
for SJ
T/c NS regarding missing evidence (Appeal file,
EIU file, locker contents & Digital recorder)

0.300

0.300

1103
1102.0

02/13/15

JLN

Review of letter by Ryan Shaffer requesting more
time for reply and 2 week adjournment of trial
0.100

1104
1103.0

02/13/15

JLN

Review of order setting trial date to April 20, 2015
0.100

1105
1104.0

02/14/15

JLN

1106
1105.0

02/14/15

JLN

Reviewed exhibit books volumes 1-3; read and
highlight Dept. Adv. Interviews or Marino and
Mauriello
Began review of Pl. Combined Opposition memo
to City's motion, Mauriello's motion; made bullet
point summary of salient points/issues

4.900

2.600

1107

Page 53

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

D

No.

Date

02/14/15

JLN

1108.0

02/15/15
02/15/15

JLN
JLN

1109.0

02/15/15

JLN

1110.0

02/15/15

JLN

E

Timekeepe Description

1106.0

1

1108
1109 1107.0
1110
1111
1112

-

--

Finished review of Plaintiff omnibus response to all
motions
Cont'd review of deposition exhibits
Reviewed and highlight Dr. Lamstein Dep; took
notes re: same
Reviewed handwritten notes of Dr. Lamstein; took
notes re: same
Reviewed Mauriello's Mein. in Opp. To Pl. Mot.
For SJ
Began drafting case summary of all relevant and
important facts for use at trial; began developing
outline with bullet points for opening and closings,
added citations for proof at trial
Finished review of deposition exhibits
T/c AS & LS regarding list or witnesses, JPTO,
filing deadlines, meeting w/ NS this Friday and
gen. trial strategy
E-mail AS regarding adjourned trial date and
proposed meeting with NS and rest of trial than this
Friday
E-mail GC & JF regarding new MIL for Queens
DA findings and meeting with NS this Friday

Hours
,

1.800

3.200
3.100
2.900
0.500

02/16/15

JLN

1113.0

02/17/15
02/17/15

JLN
JLN

1114.0

02/17/15

JLN

1115.0

02/17/15

JLN

1116.0

02/18/15

JLN

1117.0

02/18/15

JLN

1118.0

02/19/15

JLN

Reviewed and tabbed wl notes Mauriello Dep pp.

02/19/15

JLN

4/06/71
Reviewed 1AB summary of witness statements;

2.700

1119.0

02/19/15

JLN

1121.0

02/19/15

JLN

took notes regarding same
Reviewed Lt. Caughey's Dept Advocate testimony;
took notes regarding same
T/c GC regarding best and worst pts from Huffman,
Adrian's handling of downgrading issue at his
deposition, fit for duty reports, and general issues
that might come up at tomorrow's meeting

1.800

1120.0

1122.0

02/19/15

JLN

E -mailed GC summary of deposition section and

1123.0

02/19/15

JLN

noted it for prep of AS at trial
E-mail exchange with GC regarding points in
Mauriello's motion papers

1111.0

1113
1114 1112.0

1115

1116

1117

0.800

0.100

0.100

1118

Continued working on outline, inserting specific
facts with citations to the record
T/c GC regarding meeting for Friday, important
testimony from PAA Boston and issues to cover in
the plaintiffs direct (re: downgrading and MIL
regarding Johnstown Social Services)

1119

2.100

0.600

1120
1121
1122

1123

1.400

0.500

1124
1125

7.600
1.800

Page 54

0.300
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

B

No.

Date

1124.0

1

02/20/15

f

Timekeepe Description

JLN

1126
1125.0

02/20/15

JLN

1127

1126.0

02/20/15

JLN

1128

1127.0
1129
1130 1128.0
1129.0
1131
1130.0

02/20/15
02/20/15
02/20/15
02/21/15

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

1132

1131.0

02/21/15

JLN

E

D

C

I

I

Meeting w/ NS and JL regarding overall trial
strategy and specific evidentiary issues and motions
in limine , verdict sheet and Monell theories against
JHMC and the City and allocution of trial
responsibilities
Further revised and edited proposed list of exhibits
and witnesses; E -mailed same to NS for todays
meeting
Meeting with GC & JF prior to today's meeting
with NS to go over legal issues to discuss
T/c with AS & LS re: overview of today's meeting
and strategic issues that came up
T/c GC regarding summary of todays meeting
Read E-mail from AS regarding indemnification for
Mauriello's counterclaim
Continued working on developing case summary of
all most impt facts for the case; incorporated facts
into opening outline
Started outline of crosses for Lauterbom, Marino
and Mauriello; moved relevant case facts into each
cross outline; started adding relevant facts from
recordings of home invasion and IAB interviews.

Hours

3.500

1.600
1.000

0.750
0.200
0.100

3.700

3.600

1133

1132.0

02/22/15

JLN

1134

1133.0

02/22/15

JLN

1135

1134.0

02/22/15

JLN

1136

1135.0

02/22/15

JLN

1137

1136.0

02/23/15

JLN

1138
1137.0

02/23/15

JLN

1139

1138.0

02/23/15

JLN

1140
1139.0

02/23/15

JLN

Started to develop specific points using documents
for Lauterborn cross; continued cross reference
Dept. Adv. tx and Dep tx
Continued developing opeing outline and global
case summary
Read and highlighted transcript of Lt. Joe Ferrara;
took notes regarding same
E-mail exchange AS regarding clients request for
indemnification from city for Mauriello's
counterclaim
Continued working on global case summary;
focused on client's background in Navy and
employment with NYPD, then arrival of Mauriello
and pressure for numbers
Reviewed second set of filings by all defendants
(responses); took notes re: same
Follow up t/c with AS & LS re: summary of
meeting with NS, points of agreement and
disagreemen, overall trial strategy
T/c GC regarding transcription of IAB tapes and
obtaining remaining tapes from Smith today

3.900
2.600
1.600

0.200

1.700
1.300

1.100

0.100

1141

Page 55

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

C

B

D

I

No.

Date

1140.0

02/24/15

Timekeep Description
JLN
Continued adding critical facts to case summary

1141.0

02/24/15

JLN

1142.0

02/24/15

JLN

1143.0

02/24/15

JLN

1144.0

02/24/15

JLN

1145.0

02/24/15

JLN

1146.0

02/24/15

JLN

1147.0

02/24/15

JLN

1148.0

02/25/15

JLN

1149.0

02/25/15

JLN

1150.0

02/25/15

JLN

1151.0

02/25/15

JLN

1152.0

02/25/15

JLN

1153.0

02/25/15

JLN

1154.0

02/25/15

JLN

1155.0

02/25/15

JLN

1156.0

02/25/15

JLN

1157.0

02/26/15

JLN

1158.0

02/26/15

JLN

1

1142

Hours

and opening statement

1143

1144
1145

2.700

Continued drafting preliminary stages of Mauriello
cross, focusing on false statements in 1st and
second affidavits

1.800

Review of Eterno's dep; took notes regarding same
Reviewed Mauriello's EBT tx in Floyd; took notes
re: same
Continued working on opening and case summary,
continued adding critical facts to case summary

1146

1.600
1.400

1.100

1147

1148
1149

E-mail to JF re motion in liming issues to be
covered
E-mail exchange with GC & JF regarding MIL
issues presented by Eterno's testimony (and hypos
asked by City)
E-mail exchange with NS regarding additional
discipl. Records for Mauriellio and Marino
Reviewed Marino's Dept. Adv. Trial Tx; highlight
same for extraction of excerpts onto my outline

1150

0.200

0.100

0.100

1.100

1151
1152
1153

1154
1155

1156
1157
1158
1159

1160

E

Highlighted Mauriello's Dept Adv. testimony for
incorporation into cross x outline
Reviewed dep of 30 (b) (6) witness Valenti,
highlighted same
Reviewed Lauterborn excerpts from Dept. Adv.
transcript; added to cross x outline
Reviewed timeline of events prepared by AS; crossreferenced with our own time line; made
adjustments accordingly.
E-mail correspondence re: major points for Valenti
w/GC
Reviewed AEO & confidentiality order, signed
same for NS office
E-mail exchange with client regarding his
mauriello/kress timeline
E-mail exchange with GC regarding highlights
from Valenti dep
Worked on developing additonal points for Marino
cross
Meeting w/GC and JF re: outstanding items we
need from trial from NS

Page 56

0.700
0.600
0.400

0.400

0.300
0.200
0.100
0.100
1.300

1.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

D

C

B

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

1159.0

1

02/26/15

JLN

I

1161
1160.0

02/26/15

JLN

1162
1161.0

02/26/15

JLN

1163
1162.0

02/26/15

JLN

1164
1163.0

02/26/15

JLN

1165
1164.0

02/26/15

JLN

1166
1165.0

02/26/15

JLN

1167
1166.0

02/27/15

JLN

1168
1167.0

02/27/15

JLN

1169
1168.0

02/27/15

JLN

1170
1169.0

02/27/15

JLN

1171
1170.0

02/27/15

JLN

1172
1171.0

02/28/15

JLN

Read e-mail from NS regarding new 2d Cir. 1st
Amend. Decision (Matthews); read & highlighted
decision
T/c GC regarding plaintiffs conversation with
Huffman, recording of same and making transcripts
of other recordings.
Phone call w/GC and Merry Soeto re: lAB and
DAO recording
E-mail conespondence w/NS and GC re: IAB
recorded interviews
Sent client summary of new Matthews decision and
its impact on our case
Sent GC Summary of most important pts in
Matthews to ensure that those points are included
in Adrian's direct
T/c with Meny (NS office) and follow up E-mail
exchange regarding obtaining cd's from Sgt. Scott's
1AB interview
T/c with JF regarding following up with NS, 1AB v.
DAT transcripts, calling additional witnesses like
Nelson and Valenti and Yeager
E-mail conespondence with NS and GC re: dep
summaries, index of all exhibits, potential trial
exhibits
E-mail exchange toNS requesting review of our
exhibit list (as compiled by JN & GC) re global
"universe" of all exhibits needed for trial, and made
additional requests for items that will facilitate trial
prep.
Reviewed preliminary list of exhibits and Indexes
provided by NS
E-mail exchange with NS regarding following up
on Exhibit lists, Index of CD's, Index of exhibits
and EBT summaries
Revised cross -x for Mauriello adding sections from
Dept. Adv. Transcript

Hours

0.600

0.400
0.300
0.200
0.200

0.200

0.200

0.600

0.400

0.200
0.200

0.100

2.800

1173
1172.0

02/28/15

JLN

1174
1173.0

02/28/15

JLN

1175
1174.0

03/01/15

JLN

1176
1175.0

1177

E

03/01/15

JLN

Revised Marino cross -x draft incorporating in
testimony from Dept. Adv. Transcript
Revised Lauterbom cross -x draft, adding all
sections and points from Dept. Adv. Transcript
Continued working on global case summary and
opening statement outline
Reviewed and highlighted Mauriello EBT Volume
I; took notes re: same
Page 57

2.750

2.600
4.200
2.900

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A
1

1No.
1176.0

B

C

Date

D

Timekeep- Description
JLN
Reviewed AS dep transcript Vol. I, took notes re:

03/01/15

1178

same

E

Hours

2.900

1177.0

03/01/15

JLN

Reviewed and highlighted EBT of Captain Trainor;
Cross referenced E -mails refered to in deposition

1178.0

03/01/15

JLN

Reviewed NYPD patrol guidelines for AWOL
procedures and EDP's; took notes regarding same

1179.0

03/02/15

JLN

Reviewed AS dep Vol. II, took notes and prepared
summary of most important issues raised

1180.0

03/02/15

JLN

1181.0

03/03/15

JLN

1182.0

03/03/15

JLN

1183.0

03/03/15

JLN

Continued adding to case summary and opening
outline
Reviewed final volume of AS transcript; notes and
bullet point summary of same
Worked on Mauriello cross -x incorporting sections
from Volume 11 of deposition
T/c GC regarding IAB tapes, strategy for plaintiff
direct and for use of home invasion audio in
opening

1184.0

03/04/15

JLN

1185.0

03/04/15

JLN

1186.0

03/04/15

JLN

1188
1189 1187.0
1188.0

03/04/15
03/04/15

JLN
JLN

1190
1191 1189.0
1190.0

03/04/15
03/04/15

JLN
JLN

1191.0

03/04/15

JLN

1192.0

03/04/15

JLN

1193.0

03/04/15
03/05/15
03/05/15
03/05/15

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

1179

2.200

1180

0.700

1181

3.400

1182
1183

1184

1185

1186

_

1187

1192
1193

1194
1195
1196
1197
1198

1194.0

1195.0
1196.0

Finished review of Bernier's dep; notes and
prepared summary of most important points for use
in opening.
Started reviewed of Bernier's dep. highlighted and
took notes re same
Worked on adding deposition testimony into
Lauterborn cross
Reviewed dep. of Dr. Patel
T/c with GC regarding Huffman cross -x points, and
using Valenti deposition testimony to refute same
and reassigning Sgt. James cross and obtaining a
draft of direct for plaintiff from NS
Phone and E-mail w/GC re: witness list
E-mail to Scott Korenbaun ("SK") regarding jury
charges, including 1 st amended complaint; subst.
due process, malpractice and MH 9.39
E-mail exchange GC regarding Velez PBA
transcript, copy of same
E-mail exchange with GC regarding identity of
other 1AB investigator
E-mail to GC with revised witness list
Continued working on cross of Lauterborn
Continued working on Lauerborn cross -x
Continued working on Lauterborn cross
Page 58

3.200
2.800
1.100

0.500

3.200

2.100
1.600
0.900

0.500
0.300

0.200
0.100

0.100
0.100
3.750
3.600
2.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

B

D

C

I

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

1197.0

03/05/15

JLN

1198.0

1

03/06/15

JLN

Continued working on Marino cross; all relevent
text from deposition incorporated into cross

03/06/15
03/06/15
03/06/15
03/06/15

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

Continued working on Marino cross
Continued working on Marino cross
Discussion w/ JF & GC re proposed witnesses
E-mail exchange with client and LS regarding
witness list and case update
Contined working on case summary and opening
outline, incorporated all important facts for same

1199

1200
1201 1199.0
1202 1200.0
1203 1201.0
1202.0
1204
1203.0

03/07/15

JLN

Reviewed veritext transcript for Lauterborn and LS

0.300

4.200
3.700
1.600

0.600
0.100

3.250

1205

1204.0

03/07/15

JLN

Reviewed veritext transcriptions of home invasion,
Lauterborn call, IAB interview of Carter, Huffman
and Det. Yeager; took notes re: same
2.600

1206

1205.0

03/08/15

JLN

1207

1206.0

03/08/15

JLN

1208

1207.0
1209
1210 1208.0
1209.0

03/08/15

03/09/15
03/09/15

JLN

JLN
JLN

1211

1210.0

03/09/15

JLN

Started review of Dr. Isakov's deposition; crossreferenced with his notes in the chart; made
summary of salient points
Continued reviewing Dr. Isakov's dep and
extracting important points for use in opening
statement.
Reviewed transcripts of Dr. Dhar and Dr. Lwin;
took notes re: same
Review of plaintiffs consolidated 56.1
T/c client regarding case strategy, witnesses who
will be called, Queens DA findings and
investigation, overall strategy for trial and next
steps for moving forward
E -mails to NS regarding missing IAB tapes, Marino
confidentiality section of deposition; adding
exhibits to global trial list, and revising list of trial
assignments for each member of team

2.900

2.400

1.900
1.000

0.900

0.400

1212

1211.0

03/09/15

JLN

1213

1212.0
1214

E

Hours

03/09/15

JLN

T/c NS regarding R. 56 admissions; impressions of
Lamstein; striking Lamstein affidavit; IAB
recordings on MarinoiLautemom, and meeting on
Thursday
Compiled List of NYPD witnesses for trial and
assigned all witnesses to team for trial; e -mailed
copy of same to team

Page 59

0.400

0.300

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

C

B

No.

Date

1213.0

1

03/09/15

D

Timekeepe Description
JLN
T/c w. GC regarding E -mails sent to Smith and

E

Hours

setting up meeting with him and his trial team
1215
1216 1214.0
1215.0

03/10/15
03/10/15

JLN
JLN

Continued working on Mauriello cross -x
Reviewed NS' Rule 56.1 Statement global summary
of all facts admitted; took notes re: same

1217

0.300
1.800

1.400

1216.0

03/10/15

JLN

T/c with AS and LS regarding Lamstein, Seroquil,
Velez PBA hearing and admissibility, ESU
appearance and actions, Sawyer and James actions
in ER

1217.0

03/10/15

JLN

T/c LS follow up on call and issues that arose in
Larry's deposition
Continued working on Mauriello cross -x
Continued working on Mauriello cross -x
E-mail exchange with NS regarding Mauriello
meds & Marino steroid trial
E-mail w/NS and GC re: exhibits and meeting
Mauriello cross -x continued
Meeting w/ GC, JF, NS, and JL re trial, motions

1218

1219
1220 1218.0
1221 1219.0
1220.0
1222
1223 1221.0
1224 1222.0
1223.0
1225
1224.0
1226
1225.0
1227
1228 1226.0
1229 1227.0
1228.0

03/11/15
03/11/15
03/11/15

JLN
JLN
JLN

03/11/15
03/12/15
03/12/15

JLN
JLN
JLN

0.750
0.400
3.700
2.600
0.100
0.100
3.500

2.400
03/12/15

JLN

03/13/15

JLN

03/13/15
03/13/15
03/14/15

JLN
JLN
JLN

1230
1229.0

03/14/15

JLN

1230.0

03/14/15

JLN

1231.0

03/15/15

JLN

1232.0

03/15/15

Meeting w/ GC to follow up with specific issues
discussed at today's meeting
Reviewed Marino Disc. file, Comp stat docs
regarding Mauriello and Marino, amnesty program
docs, crime reporting handbook
Review of proposed jury instructions from SK
E-mail to GC re: case theory
Added all relevant parts of home invasion into
Lauterborn cross -x also added appeal meeting and
March 2009 conversation into cross
Continued revising and editing Lauterborn cross

1231

0.750

3.750
0.500
0.200

2.750

2.750

1232

Added relevant quotes from home invasion into
Marino cross -x; continued revising & editing
Marino cross
Continued Revising and editing Lauterborn cross

1233

2.400
3.900

1234
1235 1233.0
1234.0
1236
1237 1235.0
1238 1236.0

03/16/15
03/17/15
03/17/15
03/17/15

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

Continued revising and editing Lauterborn cross

Continued revising and editing Mauriello cross
Reviewed appeal meeting and also 1AB interview
of Gough, Sawyer and Dunch
Continued working on Lauterborn cross
Review of interview memo of Stretmoyers
Page 60

3.750
3.100
1.900
1.600

0.200

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

1239 1237.0
1238.0
1240
1241 1239.0
1240.0
1242
1241.0

B

Date

Timekeepe Description

03/18/15
03/18/15

JLN
JLN

03/18/15
03/18/15
03/19/15

JLN
JLN
JLN

1243

1242.0
1244
1245 1243.0
1244.0
1246
1245.0
1247
1248 1246.0
1249 1247.0
1250 1248.0
1249.0
1251
1252 1250.0
1253 1251.0
1254 1252.0
1253.0
1255
1256 1254.0
1255.0
1257
1256.0
1258
1257.0
1259
1260 1258.0
1259.0

03/19/15

JLN

Continued working on Lauterborn cross
Reviewed facts in SJ motions for use in opening
outline; took notes regarding same
E-mail w/GC re Schoolcraft direct
E-mail exchange with NS regarding subpoenas and
points for Lamstein cross
Continued reviewing PES records; reviewed file
and handwritten notes of Dr. Lamstein; took notes
re: same
Started review of NYPD Psychological Evaluation
Section ("PES") file for AS; notes on same.

E

Hours
1.700

1.400
0.200

0.100

3.700

2.100
03/19/15
03/19/15
03/19/15
03/19/15
03/20/15
03/20/15
03/20/15

03/22/15
03/22/15
03/22/15
03/22/15

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

03/23/15
03/23/15

JLN
JLN

03/23/15

JLN

03/23/15
03/23/15
03/23/15

JLN

JLN
JLN

1261

1260.0

03/23/15

1261.0

03/23/15

JLN

1262

1263

D

C

I

JLN

Continued work on Mauriello cross
Review of NS verdict sheet; made edits revisions to
same
E-mail comments and feedback re: verdict sheet
E-mail exchange with GC regarding Jamaica
Continued working on Mauriello cross -x
Continued working on Mauriello cross
E-mail exchange with rest of team regarding city's
proposed adjournment of trial and other misc issues
Continued working on Mauriello cross
Continued working on Mauriello cross
Mauriello cross -x continued
Review of NS letter re Lamstein and E -mailed
comments
Continued working on Mauriello cross
Meeting with GC regarding important points of
Sgt/ James and Sgt. Sawyer's testimony
Phone call w/GC re: James call to Lauterborn from
hospital
Phone correspondence w/ GC re: AS discussion of
Home Invasion
E-mail correspondence re: Schoolcraft film
E-mail exchange with NS regarding trial exhibit list
and verdict sheet (uncluding JL's marshalling of
facts)
Locate and send portions of AS deposition
testimony to help with GC crosses
Review of Kretz supplemental interrogatories re
Schoolcraft movie

Page 61

1.700

0.400
0.300
0.100
4.600
2.900

0.200
3.700
2.600
2.100
0.400
3.900
0.400

0.400
0.300
0.200

0.200
0.200
0.200

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

C

B

D

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

1262.0

03/23/15

JLN

1263.0

03/23/15

JLN

1265
1266 1264.0
1267 1265.0
1266.0

03/24/15
03/24/15
03/24/15

JLN
JLN
JLN

03/24/15

JLN

1

1264

E-mail exchange with NS with NS regarding
Kretz's new interogatories for Adrian regarding
Schoolcraft movie
E-mail to GC portion ofLauterbom cross re: Sgt.
James
Continued working on Mauriello cross
Continued work on Mauriello cross
Meeting w/ GC discussing role of Sadowsky,
Miller and Sawyer; Also, QAD Huffman interview
and relation to Mauriello and general trial strategy

1268

E

Hours

0.100

0.100
3.900
1.700

0.600
1267.0

1269

1268.0

03/24/15

JLN

1269.0

03/25/15

JLN

1270.0

03/25/15

JLN

1270
1271
1272
1273 1271.0
1272.0
1274
1273.0
1275
1274.0
1276
1275.0
1277
1278 1276.0
1277.0

03/25/15
03/25/15

JLN
JLN

03/25/15

JLN

03/25/15

JLN

03/26/15

JLN

03/26/15
03/26/15

JLN
JLN

03/26/15
03/26/15
03/26/15
03/26/15

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

1282.0

03/27/15

JLN

1284
1285 1283.0

03/27/15

JLN

1279
1280 1278.0
1281 1279.0
1282 1280.0
1281.0
1283

E-mail exchange with rest of team regarding
exhibit list and concerns over 1AB file and
impeachment documents
E-mail exchange with SK regarding issues
requiring special jury charges
Continued working on Mauriello cross -x (attack
counterclaim)
Continued working on Mauriello cross -x (attack
counterclaim)
Continued working on Mauriello cross -x
T/c with clients regarding strategy for trial and next
steps for moving forward
E-mail correspondence w/GC and NS regarding
regular meetings
E-mail exchange with team regarding Yeager
(retired) and setting up meeting for Fridays
Finished cross -x outline of Mauriello
(counterclaim)
Continued cross -x of Mauriello
Reviewed Forest Hill Hospital records and records
from Dr. Sure; took notes regarding same;
forwarded same to GC
E-mail correspondence w/AS re Kretz letter
E-mail to GC re: medical records
Review of Kretz letter re film
Reviewed letter from Kress regarding
Supplemental Interrogatories on Schoolcraft movie
and e-mail exchange regarding same
T/c with NS, JL and GC regarding multiple issues
related to prepping for trial, including exhibits,
experts, jury charges, voir dire, speaking to
landlord, prepping client and comp stat clips
Reviewed and edited opening statements
Page 62

0.200
0.200

3.750
2.900
2.100
0.900
0.200
0.100

4.600
3.900

1.400
0.100
0.100

0.100

0.100

1.900
1.700

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

1

No.

1286 1284.0
1285.0
1287
1288 1286.0
1287.0
1289
1288.0
1290
1289.0
1291
1290.0
1292
1293 1291.0
1292.0

1

B

Date
03/27/15
03/27/15
03/27/15
03/27/15
03/27/15

03/27/15
03/28/15

03/28/15
03/28/15

1294

1293.0

03/28/15

1295

1294.0

03/29/15

1296

1295.0

03/29/15

D

C

Timekeepe Description
Phone conference with GC, NS, JL
JLN
Various E-mail correspondence GC and NS re:
JLN
meeting and missing IAB Lauterborn recording
Review of Sgt. Chu and Scott memo
JLN
E-mail correspondence between GC and Merry
JLN
Soete re: AS Audio Clips
E-mail to GC regarding conference call for assorted
JLN
trial issues today
T/c GC regarding preparing for conference call
JLN
with NS today and using Veritext software
Reviewed highlighted sections from Lamstein
JLN
Dep.; cross-referenced with PES file and Lamstein
notes on Schoolcraft
Reviewed GC's rough draft of AS direct
JLN
Reviewed narrative report and records of Dr.
JLN
Steven Luell; cross referenced with JHMC findings
re: mental health of AS.
Reviewed IAB Summary on Dr. Lamstein's
JLN
interview; took notes re: same
Reviewed narrative reports of defense experts Dr.
JLN
Levy, Dr. Tancredi, Dr. Dolger, & Dr. Dowling;
prepared bullet point summary of key points from
each report; cross-referenced with plaintiff expert,
Dr. Lubit's report.
Reviewed Veritext transcripts and recordings from
JLN
Home Invasion, began creating audio clips for trial

E

Hours
1.000

0.400
0.300
0.100
0.100

0.100

3.200
1.400

0.600
0.400

4.200

1.750

1297

1296.0

03/29/15

JLN

Further reviewed Dr. Sure's records and records
from Forest Hills Hospital; cross referenced with
notes in PESLamstein file.
Reviewed Dr. Halpren's Ruder's report; highlighted

JLN

same
Reviewed, revised and edited Lauterbom cross -x

JLN

1298
1297.0

03/29/15

1299

1298.0
1300
1301 1299.0
1302 1300.0
1301.0

03/30/15
03/30/15
03/30/15
03/30/15

JLN
JLN
JLN

Added sections to opening statement
Phone call w/GC re: Citys request to adjourn
T/c GC & JF regarding admissibility of tape
recorded statements of persons interviewed by IAB

1.400

0.300
3.700
1.900
0.300

0.300

1303

1302.0
1304
1305 1303.0
1306 1304.0

03/30/15

03/30/15
03/30/15

JLN

JLN
JLN

T/c JF regarding motion in limine issues and recent
filings by NS regarding striking affidavit and
request for conference
E-mail from city re amendment opposition
E-mail from GC w/AB report

Page 63

0.300
0.100
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

D

No.

Date

1305.0

03/31/15

Timekeepe Description
JLN
Continued working on various new sections on

1306.0

03/31/15

JLN

1307.0

03/31/15

JLN

1308.0

03/31/15

JLN

1310
1311 1309.0
1310.0

04/01/15
04/01/15

JLN
JLN

1311.0

04/01/15

JLN

1312.0
1313.0
1314.0
1315.0
1316.0
1317.0

04/01/15
04/02/15
04/02/15
04/02/15
04/02/15
04/02/15

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

1318.0

04/02/15

JLN

1319.0

04/02/15

JLN

1320.0

04/02/15

JLN

1321.0

04/02/15

JLN

1322.0

04/02/15

JLN

1324
1325 1323.0
1326 1324.0
1325.0
1327

04/03/15
04/03/15
04/03/15

JLN
JLN
JLN

1

1307

1308
1309

1312
1313
1314
1315
1316
1317
1318

1319

1320

1321

1322

opening statement outline
Continued highlighting, revising and editing
Lauterborn cross, integrated newly found info from
2nd IAB interview

E-mail correspondence w/NS and GC re trial
witnesses and exhibits
E-mail exchanges with GC and NS regarding list of
trial exhibits, list of trial assignments, verdict sheet
from Marshall and handling Valenti
Continued working on opening statement
T/c with GC regarding important points from
Valenti and Broschart and additional grounds for
impeaching Huffman and difference between
"administrative leave" and "lost time"

E

Hours

3.400

2.800
0.200

0.200
2.500

0.500

E-mail exchange regarding setting up meeting for
tomorrow with trial team
E-mail re: meeting w/GC, and NS team
Working on revising and edits Marino's cross -x
Resumed working on Marino cross -x
Meeting with GC and NS team
Comtinued work on opening statement
Drafted and sent follow up E -mails w/NS team and
GC after meeting re: exhibits
T/c with JF regarding several issues in motion in
limine and admissibility of Marino's steroid
investigation under R. 608 (b)
Follow up t/c with JF locating does relevant for
motion in limine, including plaintiff IAB/CCRB
transcripts, Affidavits for spoilation, and Eterno
deposition testimony

0.300

Reviewed proposed exhibit list from NS in prep for
today's meeting. Also compiled own list of subject
for discussing

0.300

0.100
0.100
3.700
2.600
1.900
1.700

0.500

0.500

T/c with GC regarding Lauterborn's second PG in
September 2010 and getting recordings of same

1323

0.100

T/c with JF regarding area of expertise and scope
of testimoy for Eterno
E-mail rough draft from JF and reviewed
Continued working on Marino's cross -x outline
Worked on several more sections of opening
statement

Page 64

0.100
4.400
4.250
3.700

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

No.

Date

1326.0

1

C

B

04/03/15

D

1

Timekeepe Description
Reviewed Final IAB report; took notes re: same
JLN

E

Hours

2.400

1328
1327.0

04/03/15

JLN

1329

1328.0

04/03/15

JLN

1330

1329.0

1331
1332 1330.0
1331.0
1333
1334 1332.0
1333.0
1335
1336 1334.0
1335.0
1337
1338 1336.0
1339 1337.0
1340 1338.0
1339.0
1341
1342 1340.0
1341.0

04/03/15

04/03/15
04/03/15
04/03/15
04/04/15
04/05/15
04/05/15

04/05/15
04/05/15
04/06/15
04/06/15

04/06/15
04/06/15

JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

JLN
JLN

1343

1342.0

1344
1345 1343.0
1344.0
1346
1347 1345.0
1346.0
1348
1347.0
1349
1348.0
1350

04/06/15

04/06/15
04/06/15

04/06/15
04/06/15
04/06/15

JLN

JLN
JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN

Worked on opening statement; adding new section
on QAD findings
Reviewed plaintiffs monthly activity reports and
created chart summarizing annual totals for all
catergories for use at trial
T/c GC regarding important point from Broschart
testimony and real reason for entering apartment
(illegal search and destroy evidence)
Review of revised SK jury instructions
T/c with JF regarding progress on motion in limine
and clarification of certain factual issues
E-mail to GC including AS performance report
Reviewed revised verdict sheet and revised exhibit
list sent by NS
Continued working on Marino cross
E-mail correspondence w/GC and NS re revised
exhibit list
E-mail to JF re edits to motion
E-mail to GC including AS W2's
Continued working on Marino cross -x outline
Continued working on opening statement, trying to
master parts of 1st A. Claim and AS stay in hospital
Reviewed JF MIL; edits to same
T/c with NS & GC regarding exhibit list, verdict
sheet, important points for opening regarding
Bernier and Isakov and failure of med departments
to speak with IAB
Researched on Internet additional stories about
Marino for potential use in cross -x (patrol o/s
house and NYM Mag story); took notes re: same
Phone call w/GC and NS re: trial exhibits
Reviewed GC's draft direct of plaintiff, made notes
on same
Read NS edits to MIL
E-mail to rest of team regarding specific comments
and suggestions on verdict sheet
E-mail from JF re: draft Motion in Limine ("MIL")

1.750

0.700

0.300
0.200
0.200
0.100
0.400
4.400

0.200
0.200
0.100
3.800

1.750
1.600

1.000

0.700
0.500
0.500
0.300

0.200
0.100

04/06/15

JLN

E-mail to rest of team regarding additional exhibits
that should be added to list
Page 65

0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

D

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

1349.0

04/06/15

JLN

1350.0

04/06/15

JLN

1351.0

04/06/15

JLN

1353
1354 1352.0
1353.0

04/07/15
04/07/15

JLN
JLN

Finished cross -x outline of Chief Marino
Review and discuss NS's letter to court re: delay of
trial and announcing our rehiring w/GC

1354.0

04/07/15

JLN

1355.0

04/07/15

JLN

1356.0

04/07/15

JLN

04/07/15
04/07/15

JLN
JLN

04/07/15

JLN

04/07/15
04/07/15
04/07/15

JLN
JLN
JLN

04/07/15

JLN

04/08/15

JLN

1365.0

04/08/15

JLN

Reviewed changes to verdict sheet; additional edits
and revisions to same
T/c GC & NS regarding best strategy for handling
City's request for adjournment
E-mail from JF re: receiving everyone's imput on
MIL and incorporating changes
E-mail from JF to NS re: edits to letter
E-mail from JL re: Halpren's dep testimony re: his
daughter and need to add this to MIL
E-mail from SK detailing comments on JF's draft
MIL
Read City reply letter regarding adjournment
Review of SK comments on JF MIL draft
Reviewed letter to Court opposing City application;
t/c with GC regarding same
Reviewed NS draft letter to Court re: adjourning
trial at City's request
Continued adding sections to opening, focusing on
Mental Health Law & 9.39, as well as med mal
claims against hospital
T/c with GC and JF regarding trial adjournment,
proposed filings, various strategies for trying to
make sure trial goes on April 20

1366.0

04/08/15

JLN

T/c GC regarding points from Duncan deposition
regarding ESU, meat cleaver and travelling to
Johnstown

1367.0

04/08/15

JLN

1368.0

04/08/15

JLN

Court regarding trial date issues
E-mail exchangs amongst counsel re: availability
for Comt conf. on 4/13

1369.0

04/08/15

JLN

E

T/c NS and GC rewriting a supplemental letter to

1

1351
1352

E-mail with C.Whitehead re: obtaining copy of Sgt.
Lurch memo for use at upcoming trial.
Read e-mail and letter from defense counsel
regarding application for adjournment
Reviewed e-mail exchange between GC and NS
regarding PBA letter from AS to Stu London

1355

0.100
0.100

0.100
4.250

0.300

1356
1357
1358
1359 1357.0
1358.0
1360
1359.0
1361
1362 1360.0
1363 1361.0
1362.0
1364
1363.0
1365
1364.0
1366

1367

0.200
0.200
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.100
0.100

1.300

0.750

1368
1369

1370

1371

Hours

E-mail from GC to NS stressing need to ensure trial
goes forward as planned & does not get delayed

Page 66

0.200
0.200
0.100

0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

No.

Date

1370.0

1

C

B

04/08/15

Timekeepe Description
JLN

E-mail from GC to NS stressing need to ensure trial
goes forward as planned and does not get delayed

1372
1371.0

04/08/15

JLN

1373

1372.0

04/08/15

JLN

1374
1373.0

04/08/15

JLN

1375

1374.0

04/08/15

JLN

1376

1375.0

04/09/15

D

I

JLN

E-mail from NS re: proposing team meeting for this
Friday
E-mail from NS stressing importance of Duncan as
a witness & his testimony re: trying to get AS to
resign
E-mail NS Confitming Court conference for 4/13
and advising of his new address
E-mail response suggesting meeting take place after
conference on Monday
Reviewed Dep. of William Gough; notes on same

E

Hours

0.100
0.100

0.100
0.100
0.100
2.100

1377

1376.0

04/09/15

JLN

Reviewed Dep. of Kurt Duncan; took notes re:
1.800

same

1378

1377.0

04/09/15

JLN

Reviewed Dep. of Joe Ferrara; cross-referenced w/e
mail exchanges b/w JLN and JF.
0.900

1379

1378.0

04/10/15

JLN

1380
1379.0

04/10/15

JLN

1381

1380.0

04/10/15

JLN

1382

1381.0

04/10/15

JLN

1383

1382.0
1384
1385 1383.0
1384.0

04/10/15

04/10/15
04/11/15

JLN

JLN
JLN

1386

1385.0
1387
1388 1386.0
1387.0
1389
1390 1388.0

04/11/15
04/11/15
04/11/15
04/11/15

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

Reviewed Schoolcraft Graham Raymond materials
made summary of most important ponts from
clients' e-mail correspondence and chronological
summary
E-mail exchange w/ NS and rest of team regarding
developments on trial schedule (criminal trial
adjourned to Fall)
E-mail from NS to GC re: mistakes in home
invasion transcript that need to be fixed
E-mail NS to GC re: 2 other changes to transcript
for home invasions
Reviewed e-mail exchange b/w NS & Court re:
purpose of conf. on Monday is for scheduling &
not for substantive issues
T/c w/ client regarding updates on trial status
Finished review of QAD Repmt; made summaries
of most egregious examples of downgrading; made
separate summary of two specific instances of
misconduct of Mauriello re: manipulation of crime
stats
Started to review final QAD Report and
attachments; took notes re same
Continued to review final QAD Report
E-mail correspondence w/ GC and NS re: trial date
and schedule
E-mail w/NS re Home Invasion Transcript
Page 67

1.400

0.100

0.100
0.100

0.100
0.100

4.250
2.400
2.100
0.200
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

Date
04/12/15

1390.0

04/13/15

1391.0

04/13/15

No.

1391

1392

1393
1394 1392.0
1393.0
1395
1394.0
1396
1395.0
1397
1396.0
1398
1397.0

1399
1400 1398.0
1399.0
1401
1400.0
1402
1401.0
1403
1402.0

C

B

1389.0

1

04/13/15
04/13/15
04/13/15
04/14/15
04/14/15
04/15/15

04/15/15
04/15/15

JLN
JLN

04/15/15

JLN

04/15/15

JLN

04/15/15

JLN

1403.0

04/15/15

JLN

1404.0

04/15/15

JLN

04/15/15
04/15/15

JLN
JLN

04/17/15

JLN

1408.0

04/17/15

JLN

1409.0

04/17/15

JLN

1404
1405
1406
1407 1405.0
1406.0
1408
1407.0
1409

1410
1411

D

Timekeep Description
JLN
Compiled list of all trial exhibits to be used on my
section of trial.
JLN
T/c with plaintiff regarding today's conference and
Judge's proposed dates and impact this will have
and variety of trial issues
JLN
Conference before Judge Sweet regarding
adjournment of trial and next steps for moving
forward
JLN
Meeting w/ GC and JF re new trial date
JLN
E-mail w/ veritext re: changes to Home Invasion
transcript
JLN
E-mail from NS to RS re: Lauterborn's PG &
missing half of interview
JLN
Reviewed e -mails and attachments from SK
regarding latest versions of jury charges
JLN
T/c w/ SK regarding adjournment of trial and status
of jury charges
JLN
Reviewed Lamstein's new "draft" type written notes
& compared w/ old type written notes; prepared list
summarizing differences between them
Review of newly produced Lamstein notes
E-mail & attached letter re: illness to PO Boston &
unavailability for trial
E-mail from NS relaying another call from Scheiner
re: city agreeing to pay for mediator
E-mail from NS to team forwarding Lamstein's
"newly discovered" draft notes
E-mail from NS to team recapping his call with
Scheiner requesting adjournment to November date
E -mailed wiGC and NS re mediation offer from the
City
Letter from Scheiner to NS re: draft document from
Lamstein
Phone call w/ GC re Boston unavailability
Reviewed E-mail and letter regarding PAA
Boston's medical condition
Telecon w/ rest of trial team regarding City's
proposal for mediation and best strategy for
responding to same
Conference call with team re: best strategy for
responding to City latest "offer"
T/c with GC & JF following up on telecon and
discussing settlement position vs. going to trial
Page 68

E

Hours
0.700

1.250

1.000

0.500
0.200
0.100
0.200
0.200

0.400
0.200

0.100
0.100
0.100

0.100
0.100

0.100
0.100
0.100

0.600

0.500
0.400

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

1410.0

C

B

Date
04/17/15

-

D

Timekeepe Description
E-mail form NS explaining Scheiner's view that we
JLN
cannot prepare for trial & negotiate at same time

E

Hours

0.100

1412
1411.0

04/17/15

1412.0

04/17/15

1413.0

04/17/15

1414.0

04/17/15

1415.0

04/20/15

JLN

1413

JLN

1414
JLN

1415

JLN

1416

JLN

1417

1416.0

04/21/15

1417.0

04/21/15

JLN

E-mail from NS relating exact terms of last
settlement demand
E-mail from Scheiner to NS re: locating complete
copy of Lauterborn type
E-mail to NS responding to City's "offer" re:
mediation & adjusting adjourning trial
Reviewed e-mail from NS describing City's "offer"
to mediate and response to same
E-mail exchange with team regarding City's
settlement position and request for mediation with
out any counter offer
E-mail from NS to team re: City's letter to Court

0.100
0.100

0.100

0.300
0.100

1418

JLN

Review of letter from City requesting more time for
0.100

MIL

1419

1418.0

0.100

04/21/15

JLN

Reviewed City's letter to Judge Sweet seeking to
ensure that trial does not go forth on May 4, 2015
0.100

1420
1419.0

04/22/15

JLN

1421

1420.0

1422
1423 1421.0
1422.0

04/23/15

04/27/15
04/28/15

JLN

JLN
JLN

1424

1423.0

04/29/15

JLN

E-mail exchanges re: NS letter response to City
latest request to adjourn trial
T/c LS regarding status of case, Judge Sweet's
decision on SJ and likely impact on case once it
comes down & City's multiple setlement overtures
in the past two weeks
E-mail from Scheiner re: City latest disclosures
Letter to NS from Scheiner re: AS employee
evaluation & complete recording of Lauterborns
2nd Go - 15 Interview
E-mail exchanges with NS and GC regarding mock
trial and bringing AS down to NYS to prepare

1425

1424.0
1426
1427 1425.0
1426.0
1428
1427.0
1429
1428.0
1430
1431 1429.0

05/05/15

05/05/15
05/05/15
05/08/15

JLN

JLN
JLN

JLN

05/10/15

JLN

05/12/15

JLN

Read and review Ct's Opinion on SJ; took noes re:
same; prepared list of claims which still must be
tried & fact issues to be decided
Discussion w/GC and JF re SJ decision
E-mail w/GC re Judge Sweet's Summary Judgment
opinion
Discussion w/ GC & JF re SJ decision and impact
on trial and motion in limine
Listened to Lauterborn's 2nd GO interview; notes
re: same
Meeting w/NS team GC and JF pre-conf
Page 69

0.100

0.750
0.100

0.100

0.100

1.600

0.500
0.100
0.800

0.900
1.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

1

No.

1432 1430.0
1431.0

B

Date

C

D

Timekeepe Description
JLN
Team meeting following conf.

05/12/15
05/12/15

JLN

05/13/15

JLN

05/13/15
05/14/15

JLN
JLN

05/14/15

JLN

05/14/15
05/15/15

JLN
JLN

05/18/15

JLN

05/21/15
05/22/15
05/28/15
05/29/15

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

05/29/15

JLN

06/01/15
06/01/15

JLN
JLN

06/02/15

JLN

06/02/15

JLN

06/02/15
06/03/15

JLN
JLN

06/03/15

JLN

06/04/15

JLN

06/05/15
06/06/15

JLN
JLN

06/09/15
06/10/15

JLN
JLN

06/16/15

JLN

E

Hours
1.250

Conference before Judge Sweet regarding setting
new trial date and schedule for pre-trial filings

1433

1.000

1432.0
1434
1435 1433.0
1434.0
1436
1435.0
1437
1438 1436.0
1437.0
1439
1438.0
1440
1441 1439.0
1442 1440.0
1443 1441.0
1442.0
1444
1443.0
1445
1446 1444.0
1445.0
1447
1446.0
1448
1447.0
1449
1450 1448.0
1449.0
1451
1450.0
1452
1451.0
1453
1454 1452.0
1453.0
1455
1456 1454.0
1455.0
1457
1456.0
1458

T/c client regarding updates on yesterday's
status/pretrial conference with Judge Sweet
E-mail correspondence w/SK re conference
E-mail correspondence amongst all parties re:
pretrial submissions schedule
E-mail from Alan Sheiner re: proposed briefing
schedule for motions in limine
E-mail re: pretrial submissions schedule
Further e-mail w/ all parties re: pretrial
submissions schedule
Review of letter motion filed by City re: JPTO
dates
E-mail from NS re settlement offer from City
T/c with clients re: update on settlement
E-mail GC re Veritext bill
E-mail w/GC and NS re: City bifurcation request

1.200
0.100

0.100
0.100
0.100

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.750
0.100
0.200

E-mail exchange w/ all parties re: pretrial
submissions schedule
Reviewed NS draft reconsideration
Reviewed draft of Plaintiffs motion for
Reconsideration
Read City's motion to reconsider bifucation on
Monell claim
Read memo of law in Support of defendant
Mauriello's motion for Reconsideration
Review of citys motion to bifurcate
Review of E-mail correspondence w/court re
motions
Reviewed plaintiffs motion for reconsideration as
filed

0.100
0.400
0.200

0.300
0.300
0.200

0.200
0.200

Reviewed Mauriello's motion for reconsideration
Reviewed Request for Extension
T/c with AS & LS re: case update, next Court
filings & general strategy going forward
Order granting extension of time
Phone call with Schoolcrafts and GC re: Mauriello
recon. and bifurcation
E-mail from NS requesting assistance in responding
to City's reconsideration motion
Page 70

0.500
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.800
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

D

C

B

I

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

1457.0

1

06/22/15

JLN

1459

1458.0

06/22/15

JLN

1460
1459.0

06/22/15

JLN

1461

1460.0

06/22/15

JLN

1462
1461.0

06/23/15

JLN

1463
1462.0

06/23/15

JLN

1464
1463.0

06/24/15

JLN

1465
1464.0

06/24/15

JLN

1466

1465.0

06/25/15

JLN

1467

1466.0
1468
1469 1467.0
1468.0

06/25/15
06/29/15
06/29/15

JLN

JLN
JLN

1470

1469.0

06/29/15

JLN

1471

1470.0

07/02/15

JLN

1472

1471.0

07/02/15

JLN

1473

1472.0

07/02/15

JLN

T/c w/ AS & LS re: case status, pending motion for
reconsideration & impact on case if we cannot call
Dr. Halpren as witness
Another e-mail from NS re: responding to City's
Motion for Reconsideration
E-mail exchange between NS & W. Kretz re:
respective dates to respond to motions
E-mail from NS to defense counsel seeking an
additional week for opposition to reconsider
E-mail from NS to team regarding Scheiner's e-mail
on bifurcation reconsideration
E-mail from Scheiner to NS re: putting Monell
bifurcation & motions for reconsideration on two
different tracks
E-mail & attached letter to Judge Sweet re:
adjusting briefing schedule
Review of E-mail correspondence w SK re: motion
schedules
E-mail exchanges w/ all counsel re: adjustment to
briefing schedule
E-mail from NS enclosing letter to Court w/ agreed
upon dates
E-mail & draft memo of law on bifurcation
E-mail from JF to team adding case law to oppose
bifurcation
E-mail to NS /JL adding case law for opposing
bifurcation
E-mail from Scheiner to all counsel re: City's latest
doc production
Letter from Scheiner to NS re: latest City
productions
Request to NS to put City's new materials on disc.

Hours

0.900
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.100

0.100
0.100

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.200

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

1474

1473.0

07/03/15

JLN

1475
1474.0

07/03/15

JLN

1476
1475.0

07/06/15

JLN

1477

1476.0

07/06/15

JLN

1478
1477.0
1479

E

07/06/15

JLN

E-mail from NS forwarding City's latest production
E-mail to Scheiner from NS confirming that City
new production consists of 511 pages
Review of opposition to defendants'
reconsideration motions
E-mail exchange between JL & A. Scheiner re:
providing City with all of the data expert relied on
by Etemo & Silverman
E-mail exchanges re: writing to Court & clarifying
correct due date

Page 71

0.100
0.100

0.700

0.100
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

1

B

C

D

1

1478.0

Date
07/06/15

Timekeepe Description
JLN
E-mail from NS to Scheiner requesting explanation
as to where new City docs came from

1479.0

07/06/15

JLN

1481
1482 1480.0
1481.0

07/07/15
07/07/15

JLN
JLN

E-mail from Scheiner re: ECF filing errors
E-mail request from Scheiner seeking to adjourn
City's Reply on Monell

1482.0

07/07/15

JLN

1483.0

07/08/15

JLN

Reviewed City's latest disclosure of Schoolcraft
med records, screening tests to become NYPD
officer; LOD reports for AS & other docs related to
AS's prior LOD claims; took notes re same.

1484.0

07/10/15

JLN

1485.0

07/11/15

JLN

Read Reply in Further Support of motion for
Bifurcation filed by City
T/c wl AS & LS re: NS opp to reconsider motions
& summary of arguments re: same & likely
outcome, as well as overall status of case and trial
prep

E

Review of E-mail correspondence between NS
team re Eterno & Silvennan

1

No.

1480

0.100

Letter from Scheiner re: correcting typo in previous
Bates number correspondence

1483

0.100
0.100

0.100

1484

0.100

1485

1.800

1486

1487
1488 1486.0
1487.0
1489
1488.0
1490
1489.0

1490.0

0.100

1.100

07/13/15
07/13/15

JLN
JLN

07/13/15

JLN

07/15/15

JLN

07/15/15

JLN

1491
1492

1491.0

07/16/15

JLN

1492.0

07/17/15

JLN

1493.0

07/17/15

JLN

1494.0

07/17/15

1493

1494
1495
1496

Hours

JLN

Review of JHMC to NS motion for recoil
Read opposition brief to Plaintiffs motion for
Reconsideration filed by JHMC
Reviewed NS letter so ordered by Judge Sweet re: a
modification to briefing schedule
Reviewed Dep of K. Finnegan (30(b)(6) --Topic C
and reviewed primary dep exhibit (old performance
guide); took notes re same
E-mail response from NS to all counsel re: adjourn
filing dates but keep JPTO date
Read City's letter motion for more time on motions
for Reconsideration
E-mail exchange between JL and NS re: John
Eterno
Sent GC E-mail correspondence between nyself
and NS re: John Eterno
Reviewed Judge Sweet's order granting the City's
motion

Page 72

0.300
0.100

0.100

2.400
0.100
0.100
0.200

0.100
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

1

No.

1495.0

D

C

B

Date
07/18/15

Timekeepe Description
T/c w/ AS & LS re: JHMC opp & City's bifurcation
JLN
argument & anticipated reply arguments

E

Hours

1.200

1497

1496.0

07/18/15

JLN

1498

1497.0

07/20/15

JLN

07/21/15

JLN

1499
1498.0
1500
1499.0

07/21/15

JLN

1501
1500.0
1502
1503 1501.0
1502.0
1504
1505 1503.0
1504.0
1506
1505.0
1507
1506.0
1508
1507.0
1509
1508.0

07/22/15
07/22/15
07/23/15
07/23/15
07/23/15
07/23/15
07/23/15
07/23/15

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN

Reviewed NS prior letter motion re: Weiss EIU
file, Sgt. Purpi and cont'd dep of Dr. Patel
Sent GC E-mail correspondence between Myself
and NS re: John Eterno
Started reading "NYPD Tapes" (book on Scholcraft
case) for additional facts & evidence & themes to
use at trial.
E-mail exchanges amongst team re: setting up next
meeting for trial team
Watched new Schoolcraft documentary (Eterno
appears)
E-mail re: new Schoolcraft "documentary"
Cont'd reading NYPD Tapes; took notes re: same
Review of reply memo for AS
Review of City Defendants' reply affirmations
recon motions
Read City's Reply Memo of Law in Support of
motion for Reconsideration
Read Kretz' reply affirmation for Reconsideration
of Judge Sweet's Order
Reviewed AS letter requesting Extension of time

0.200
0.100

2.400
0.100
0.300
0.100
3.250
0.700
0.500
0.200
0.100

0.100
07/24/15

JLN

Meeting with rest of trial team regarding various
strategic issues and timeline for pre-trial filings
2.900

1510
1509.0

07/24/15

JLN

1511

1510.0
1512
1513 1511.0
1512.0
1514
1513.0
1515
1514.0
1516
1517 1515.0

07/24/15
07/24/15
07/24/15
07/24/15
07/24/15
07/24/15

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

JLN

T/c with JF & GC regarding issues to discuss at
meeting today with rest of trial team
Reviewed reply memorandum from Mauriello; took
notes re: same
Follow up e-mail to trial team retrial docs
Reviewed reply memorandum from City in further
support SJ; took notes re: same
Post meeting discussion with JF and GC regarding
issues raised during today's meeting
Reviewed NS reply memo of law in Support of
motion for Reconsideration
E-mail exchanges re: JPTO deadliine

Page 73

0.500
0.400
0.300
0.300

0.250

0.200
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

j

C

B

D

1516.0

Date
07/25/15

Timekeepe Description
JLN
T/c with AS & LS re: City's reply & Mauriello's
reply & NS reply & overall sense of which
arguments are strongest & most likely to prevail;
updated them re: team's meeting yesterday

1517.0

1

07/25/15

JLN

No.

1518

1518.0
1520
1521 1519.0
1522 1520.0
1523 1521.0
1522.0
1524
1523.0
1525
1526 1524.0
1525.0
1527
1528 1526.0
1527.0
1529
1528.0
1530
1531 1529.0
1532 1530.0
1531.0
1533
1532.0

07/26/15

JLN

07/27/15
07/27/15
07/27/15
07/28/15

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

07/28/15

JLN

07/29/15
07/30/15

JLN
JLN

07/30/15
07/30/15

JLN
JLN

07/30/15

JLN

07/30/15
07/31/15
07/31/15

JLN
JLN
JLN

08/01/15

JLN

1533.0

08/01/15

JLN

1534.0

08/04/15

JLN

1535.0
1536.0
1537.0
1538.0
1539.0
1540.0

08/04/15
08/04/15
08/04/15
08/04/15
08/04/15
08/05/15

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

1534

E-mail exchange from NS re: adding Polanco to
JPTO
Cont'd reading NYPD Tapes; took notes re: same
E-mail w/ MS re: master exhibit list
E-mail GC re Polanco as witness
Read NS letter motion for extension on JPTO
Reviewed revised Jury Charges from SK; made
notes re: same
Reviewed revised witness list; made edits/revisions
to same
E -mails with Schoolcraft team re: settlement
Reviewed and highlighed first volume of Lt.
Caughey's deposition for extraction and use in
cross x outline; took notes re: same
Phone call w/GC and NS re settlement
T/c GC regarding settlement position & response to
City's settlement overtures
Read City's joint letter to Coml re: striking
plaintiffs reply memo of law
Read letter motion to strike reply by City
T/c conference with defense counsel
Reviewed Notice of Appearance by Kavin Thadani
on behalf of City
Finished NYPD Tapes; incorporated notes of
additional facts & salient themes into case
summary
T/c w/ AS re: meeting together on Tuesday &
preparing list of issues to discuss at our meeting

1535

1542

Hours

0.700

1519

1536
1537
1538
1539
1540
1541

E

0.100
2.100
1.750
1.700
0.100
0.600
0.200
0.100

2.300
0.400
0.400

0.100
0.100
0.500
0.100

1.800

0.300

Meeting with AS to discuss case & best strategy for
moving forward & preparing for trial
4.750

Travel back to NYC from Johnstown 3.40
Traveled to Jolmstown to meet client 3.50
Phone call w/GC re: witness list and exhibit list
Review of NS revised witness and exhibit list
T/c GC regarding discussion with NS
Continued conversations with NS regarding
exhibits & witnesses
Page 74

1.750
1.700

0.400
0.300
0.200
1.000

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

1541.0

B

Date
08/05/15

1543

1542.0

08/05/15

1544
1543.0

08/05/15

1544.0

08/06/15

1545

1546
1545.0

08/07/15

1547

1546.0

08/07/15

1548
1547.0

08/07/15

1548.0

08/07/15

1549

1550
1551 1549.0
1550.0
1552
1551.0
1553
1552.0
1554
1555 1553.0
1554.0
1556
1555.0

08/07/15
08/07/15
08/07/15
08/07/15
08/08/15
08/08/15

JLN
JLN
JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN

08/08/15

JLN

08/09/15

JLN

08/10/15

JLN

1559
1558.0

08/10/15

JLN

1560
1559.0

08/10/15

JLN

1561

1560.0

08/10/15

JLN

1562

1561.0

08/10/15

JLN

1563

1562.0
1564

E-mail toNS seeking confirmation of exact terms of
City's new offer
NS e-mail explaining City's "new" back pay offer
(extending it to Dec. 2015)

,

Hours

0.900
0.300

0.100
0.600
1.000

0.700
0.300

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.900
0.600

1558
1557.0

"offer"
E-mail from NS re: Bernier & Isakov JPTO
E-mail from NS re: getting a response to City latest
"offer"

"offer"
Reviewed Mauriello's production; notes re: same

E

I

Timekeepe Description
JLN
Multiple phone calls w/ GC & NS regarding JPTO
exhibits and witnesses
Preliminary review of City's JPTO and hospital
JLN
JPTO
E-mail from NS re: reaching him when he is out of
JLN
town next week
JLN
Continued review of JPTO submissions by all
parties; took notes re: same
JLN
T/c with GC, JL & NS regarding multiple issues in
defendants' respective JPTO's
JLN
E-mail from NS enclosing Mauriello's production
(Docs# 61-362); reviewed same
T/c w/ GC in which GC recapped latest settlement
JLN
offer as relayed by Scheiner to NS
JLN
E-mail exchange with NS regarding City's latest

1557

1556.0

D

C

08/10/15

JLN

T/c w/ AS & LS re: City latest "offer" and what
conditions would need to be met (monetary &
otherwise) for case to settle
E-mail correspondence re: JPTO and motion
deadlines
Highlighted and made edits and notes on Trainor's
deposition outline for purposes of building cross -x
outline
Reviewed cross -x outlines of Captain Lauterborn,
DI Mauriello and Marino to make sure all
documents on JPTO are accounted for
Continued highlighting Trainor's Dep for cross -x
excerpts
E-mail correspondence re: JPTO and motion
deadlines
E-mail response from NS re: my recap of
conversation with AS
E-mail to NS recapping discussion w/ AS this past
weekend
Page 75

0.100
0.100

3.400

2.800
1.200

0.100
0.100

0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

D

C

B

1563.0
1565
1566 1564.0
1567 1565.0
1566.0
1568
1567.0
1569
1568.0

Date
_._

E

08/11/15
08/11/15
08/11/15
08/11/15
08/11/15
08/12/15

Timekeepe Description
JLN
Made revisions and edits to base cross -x outline for

Hours

Sgt. Weiss
Review of City defendants JPTO
Review of new discovery served by City
E-mail from NS to all counsel w/ consolidated shell
of JPTO; reviewed same
E-mail from Scheiner with two additional docs
inadvertently omitted from previous disclosures
Reviewed portion of opening outline regarding
treatment in ER & interactions with James &
Sawyer and Yeager
Reviewed NYPD memo re: Amnendment to Quota

2.100
0.600
0.200

bill

No.

0.300

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

1570
1569.0

08/12/15

JLN

1571

1570.0

08/13/15

JLN

08/13/15

JLN

Reviewed NS letter to Court seeking 1 extra week
for JPTO; also reviewed opposition e -mails by
defense counsel to same; reviewed Mauriello's
response to plaintiffs JPTO

0.100

0.700

Reviewed portion of opening outline regarding
MHL 9.39 and Bernier decision to involuntary
commit; reviewed section relating to QAD;
reviewed section regarding harrassment upstate

1571.0

0.100

1572

1.400

1573

1572.0

08/13/15

JLN

1573.0

08/13/15

JLN

08/13/15
08/13/15

JLN
JLN

08/13/15

JLN

08/14/15

JLN

08/14/15

JLN

1579.0

08/14/15

JLN

1580.0

08/14/15

1574
1575
1576 1574.0
1575.0
1577
1576.0
1578
1577.0
1579
1578.0

E-mail from Scheiner w/ spreadsheet re: City JPTO
objections
Read order of Judge Sweet granting plaintiffs
extgension parties
Review of correspondence all parties re: JPTO
Reviewed Judge Sweet's order Defendants' motion
to strike Plaintiffs reply
Reviewed NS letter motion to Court for extension

0.400
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.100
0.100

Reviewed consolidated JPTO; made notes re: same

0.700

Review of Lauterborn's transcribed audio
interview; 2nd IAB interview took notes re: same

1580

0.600

1581
JLN

1582

1583 1581.0
1584 1582.0

08/14/15
08/14/15

JLN
JLN

Reviewed multiple E-mail exchanges between NS
and counsel regarding JPTO and best way to
proceed
E-mail from NS asking team for input in
responding to Scheiner's letter JPTO
E-mail re: City filing JPTO without our input
E -mails among team re: MIL due date

Page 76

0.300

0.100
0.100
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

D

C

B

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

1583.0

1

08/14/15

JLN

E

Hours

Read City's letter reply to Court in further support
of the City's motion to strike plaintiffs reply
0.100

1585

1584.0

08/14/15

JLN

Read City's letter to Court re: Defendants' JPTO
0.100

1586

1585.0

08/14/15

JLN

1587

1586.0

08/15/15

JLN

1588
1587.0
1589
1590 1588.0
1589.0
1591
1590.0
1592
1593 1591.0
1592.0
1594
1593.0

08/15/15

08/16/15
08/16/15

JLN

JLN
JLN

Review of letter to Court filed by Scheiner re:
Defendants' JPTO (wlo plaintiffs portion)
Reviewed City's latest disclosures, incl. certified
docs from Hertzel Sure, M.D., multiple photos and
info relating to rifle found in Schoolcraft's
apartment; LS's prior lawsuit against Montgom.
Cty; QAD investigations that resulted in discipline
for officers; additional PG guidelines and IAB
Guidelines; forensic manual for Mental Hygiene
Law
T/c w/ AS & LS re: City's JPTO filing & attorney's
motion to strike reply & several updates on trial
prep
Started work on Sgt. Weiss cross -x outline
Internet research re: rifle identified by City (9 MM

08/17/15
08/17/15

JLN
JLN
JLN

same
Continued Weiss cross -x outlne
Continued working on Sgt. Weiss cross -x outline

08/17/15

JLN

08/17/15

08/18/15
08/18/15

JLN

JLN
JLN

1598

1597.0

08/18/15

JLN

1599

1598.0

0.600
5.600

4.250

Reviewed additional Patrol Guide sections
disclosed by City (15147-15170); took notes re:
1.400

same

1596
1597 1595.0
1596.0

0.900
4.600

Reviewed defendants JPTO filing; took notes re:

1595

1594.0

3.400

1.900

Canines).

08/16/15

0.100

08/18/15

JLN

Read City's letter to Court re: Opposition to
Plaintiffs August 13th Request to Modify the JPTO
Filing Deadline
Phone call and e-mail w/ GC re Huffman
T/c w/ Alan Sheiner & Cheryl Shammas regarding
City's latest settlement offer and plaintiffs position
regarding same
Read City's letter to Court re: opposition to
plaintiffs request to modify the deadline of the
filing of the JPTO
Read City's letter to Court re: requiring the plaintiff
to identify a single police practices expert

0.100
0.300

0.200

0.100

0.100

1600

1599.0
1601
1602 1600.0

08/18/15
08/18/15

JLN
JLN

Reviewed NS letter reply to motions for extension
of time
Reviewed NS reply to City's letter JPTO
Page 77

0.100
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

1601.0

Date__.
08/19/15

1602.0

08/20/15

JLN

1603.0

08/20/15

JLN

08/20/15
08/20/15
08/20/15

.ILN

08/21/15

JLN

08/21/15

JLN

08/21/15
08/21/15

JLN
JLN

08/21/15

JLN

08/21/15

JLN

08/21/15

JLN

08/22/15

JLN

1615.0

08/24/15

JLN

1616.0

08/24/15

JLN

1618
1619 1617.0
1618.0

08/24/15
08/24/15

JLN

1620
1621 1619.0
1622 1620.0

08/24/15
08/25/15

1

No.

D

I

Timekeepe Description
JLN
Tic with plaintiff regarding City latest settlement
offer and City's message that window to settle will
close this week and will not re -open

1603

E

Hours

0.400

1604
1605
1606 1604.0
1607 1605.0
1606.0
1608
1607.0

JLN
JLN

1609
1608.0
1610
1611 1609.0
1610.0
1612
1611.0
1613
1612.0
1614
1613.0
1615
1614.0

1616
1617

JLN

JLN

JLN

Reviewed City's latest disclosure (Office of Mgt
Analysis & Planning Reference Guide); took notes
re same.
1.800
Read NS e-mail to Scheiner re: his misleading
submission to Court
0.100
Reviewed NS letter to Court re:
JPTO
0.100
Scheiner e-mail rejecting service by fax
0.100
Scheiner re: e-mail responding to NS "misleading
submission"
0.100
Tic with NS regarding Larry's serious medical
condition, discussion wl Alan Sheiner & CS
regarding City's latest settlement and regarding
status of cross -x outlines and JPTO issues
0.800
T/c NS re: several trial prep issues & outstanding
work that still needs to be done & update on LS
medical condition
0.700
E-mail all parties re MIL due date
0.100
Read Alan Sheiner's letter to Court regarding
striking plaintiffs JPTO
0.100
Read various e -mails amongst counsel regarding
motion in limine schedule
0.100
Scheiner letter to Court attaching City's response to
August 20th letter by NS
0.100
Sent NS summary exhibit that we created regarding
Schoolcrafts performance in 2008
0.100
T/c w/ AS & LS re: City's letter seeking to limit us
to one police expert & city opp. to our request to
modify JPTO deadlines & general updates on status
of cross examinations
0.700
Reviewed GC's cross -x outline on Gough; took
notes re: same
0.700
Reviewed GS's cross outline on Yeager; took notes
re: same
0.400
Review of NS e-mail re upstate visits to AS
0.200
NS e-mail re: receipt of my crosses & dates when
he will exchange Bernier & Isakov crosses
0.100
Sent GC cross outlines for review
0.100
Reviewed JPTO; edits and revisions to same
0.600

Page 78

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

D

C

B

No.

Date

Timekeeper Description

1621.0

1

08/25/15

JLN

1623

1622.0

JLN

08/25/15

1624

1623.0

JLN

08/26/15

1625

1624.0

JLN

08/26/15

1626

1625.0
1627
1628 1626.0
1629 1627.0
1630 1628.0
1629.0

JLN

08/26/15

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

08/26/15
08/27/15
08/27/15
08/28/15

NS e-mail & letter to Court respond to Scheiner
August 18 & August 21 letters re: # of police
experts
Reviewed filing by NS responding to various
arguments by defendants on JPTO exhibits and
witnesses
Began work on Trainor Cross -x outline using JM
preliminary outline
Reviewed GC draft cross of Det. Yeager & Boston;
higlighted & made edits to same
Drafted points to discuss w/GC re: trial strategy
Sent GC more cross outlines for review
Continued working on Trainor cross -x
Continued working on Trainor cross -x
Reviewed GC draft cross x of Sgt. Huffman;
extracted section re: Mauriello ordering Pl. back
after Huffman approved (worked into Mauriello
cross -x as new section); made edits/revisions.

E

Hours

0.100

0.100

2.700
1.400

0.700
0.100
6.400
4.800

1.800

1631

_

1630.0

08/28/15

JLN

1632

1631.0
1633
1634 1632.0
1633.0
1635
1634.0
1636
1635.0

1637
1638 1636.0
1637.0
1639
1640 1638.0
1639.0
1641
1642 1640.0
1641.0
1643
1644 1642.0
1645 1643.0
1646 1644.0

08/28/15
08/28/15
08/29/15
08/29/15

08/30/15

08/30/15
08/30/15
08/31/15
08/31/15

08/31/15
08/31/15

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

JLN

JLN
JLN

JLN
JLN

JLN
JLN

.._

09/01/15
09/01/15
09/02/15

JLN
JLN
JLN

Reviewed GC draft of Duncan cross; edits &
revisions to same
Reviewed GC draft cross of Sgt. Sawyer;
highlights, edits, revisions to same
Sent GC cross outlines for review
Reviewed GC draft cross of Lt. Broschart;
edits/revisions to same
Reviewed GC's draft Valenti cross; edits/revisions
to same
Contined working on cross -x of Capt. Trainor;
cross-referenced BNIU file for several additional
points
Started working on Lt. Caughey cross -x
Reviewed GC draft of Gough cross; edits/revisions
to same
Contined working on cross -x of Lt. Caughey
Reviewed GC draft of Sgt. James cross; edits to
same & extracted relevant points for opening
statement
F/u telecon with NS re: schedule
Conference call w/ all counsel to clerk re: pending
motions
Continued working on Caughey cross -x
Sent GC cross outlines for review
Cross outline of Lt. Caughey
Page 79

1.800

1.300
0.100
1.900

0.600

6.750
4.250
1.900

6.400

2.400
0.400
0.300
8.200
0.100
7.600

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A
1

No.

1647 1645.0
1648 1646.0
1647.0
1649
1648.0
1650
1651 1649.0
1652 1650.0
1651.0

I

B

C

D

Date
09/02/15
09/03/15
09/03/15

Timekeepe Description
__.
JLN
Continued working on Trainor cross -x
JLN
Review of City letter re: JPTO schedule
JLN
NS response to Scheiner re: request for telecon

09/03/15

JLN

09/04/15
09/04/15
09/04/15

JLN
JLN
JLN

E

Hours
1.400
0.200
0.100

1653

Request from Scheiner to have telecon re: settlemt

Continued working on Caughey cross -x
Continued working on Trainor cross -x
T/c w/ NS regarding his conversation with Alan
Scheiner regarding City's latest settlement offer;
spoke to GC regarding same
E-mail from NS re: City letter to Court treating 917-15 as new date for MIL's
Reviewed City letter to Court re: Court's failure to
decide pending motions
t/c with AS and LS regarding City's latest
settlement offer
Finished Trainor cross -x
T/c w/ LS regarding City's settlement offer and
requirements for resolving matter
Continued working on Caughey cross -x
T/c with JF & GC recapping discussion with
defense counsel and clients over the weekend
T/c with NS, GC and JF regarding best strategy for
handing settlement discussions with the City

1652.0

09/04/15

JLN

1653.0

09/04/15

JLN

1654.0

09/05/15

JLN

09/06/15
09/06/15

JLN
JLN

09/07/15
09/08/15

JLN
JLN

09/08/15

JLN

1660.0

09/08/15

JLN

09/08/15

JLN

1663
1664 1662.0
1663.0

09/08/15
09/08/15

JLN
JLN

1664.0

09/08/15

JLN

1665.0

09/08/15

JLN

09/09/15
09/09/15

JLN
JLN

09/10/15

JLN

T/c with NS & Alan Sheiner following up on City's
offer and discussions earlier today
Phone call w/GC re Schoolcrafts
Flu conversation with NS to discuss last
conversation with defense counsel regarding City's
3/4 disability analysis
E-mail from Scheiner re: getting back to him on
City's settlement proposal
E-mail from Scheiner seeking plaintiffs response to
latest City offer
Started work on cross -x Lamstein
E-mail from Scheiner to NS & JN re: following up
on settlement
Reviewed Lamstein's PES file & her handwritten
notes for incorporation into cross

0.600

T/c with AS and NS regarding City's latest
settlement offer and plaintiffs response to same

1661.0

0.100
4.600
4.600

1654
1655
1656
1657 1655.0
1656.0
1658
1659 1657.0
1658.0
1660
1659.0
1661

0.100
0.100

0.700
7.100
0.750
6.250
0.600

0.600

1662

0.400

1665

1666

1667
1668 1666.0
1667.0
1669
1668.0
1670

Page 80

0.400
0.300

0.200
0.100
0.100
1.700

0.100
2.600

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

B

C

D

1669.0

Date
09/10/15

Timekeepe Description
JLN
Reviewed Lamstein Declaration Lamstein dep
corrections & Lamstein original typed notes vs.
"draft" notes exchanged this summer compared
with dep testimony for use in cross -x

1670.0

1

09/10/15

JLN

No.

1671

E

J

Hours

2.400

1672

1671.0

09/10/15

JLN

1672.0

09/10/15

JLN

1674
1675 1673.0
1676 1674.0
1675.0

09/10/15
09/10/15
09/10/15

JLN
JLN
JLN

09/11/15
09/11/15

JLN
JLN

09/11/15

JLN

09/11/15

JLN

1673

1677
1678 1676.0
1677.0
1679
1678.0
1680
1679.0
1681
1680.0
1682
1681.0
1683
1684 1682.0
1685 1683.0
1684.0

1686
1687 1685.0
1686.0
1688
1687.0
1689
1690 1688.0
1691 1689.0
1692 1690.0
1691.0
1693

09/11/15

JLN

09/11/15

JLN

09/11/15
09/12/15
09/12/15

JLN
JLN
JLN

Reviewed Lamstein's IAB interview compared w/
dep testimony for developing grounds to explore in
cross

Reviewed Lamstein VM to AS on 10-31-09 to
incorporate into cross
E-mail from GC recapping his conversation with
AS yesterday re: clients position re: lack of 3/4
pension
NS e-mail describing disability options
NS response to GC's e-mail re: summary plan
Reviewed Court's endorsement of plaintiffs letters
dated August 18, 2015 and August 21, 2015
Continued working on Lamstein cross -x
T/c w/ AS & LS re: City latest offer & pros and
cons of same
Phone calls with NS and GC re City settlement
offer
Telecon with NS & Scheiner City is willing to
increase offer for P&S
E-mail from NS & Scheiner re: our availability to
speak later this a.m.
E-mail from NS to Scheiner re: conference call for
today at 11:00 am
E-mail to GC re Schoolcraft timeline
Continued working on Lamstein cross -x
T/c w/ AS & LS re: pros and cons of settlement,
risks of verdict, impact on disability pension &
ability to still have trial against medical defendants

1.800

0.300

0.100
0.100
0.100

0.100
3.200

0.900
0.800
0.800
0.100
0.100
0.100
4.250

1.400

09/13/15
09/14/15
09/14/15
09/15/15
09/15/15
09/15/15
09/15/15

JLN
JLN

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

Continued working on Lamstein cross -x
E-mail from Scheiner cannot speak today - but can
tomrorow
E-mail to Scheiner from NS re: setting up time to
speak
Continued working on Lamstein cross -x
T/c with NS re: conversation w/ Scheiner
Reviewed NS settlement memo to client
E-mail from NS re: Draft version of JPTO &
extending dates to respond to MIL's
Page 81

2.800
0.100
0.100
3.200
0.400
0.200
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

No.

Date

1692.0

1

09/15/15

1694
1695 1693.0
1694.0
1696
1697 1695.0
1698 1696.0
1697.0
1699
1700 1698.0
1699.0
1701
1700.0
1702
1701.0
1703
1704 1702.0
1703.0
1705
1704.0
1706
1705.0
1707
1706.0
1708
1707.0
1709
1710 1708.0
1709.0
1711
1712 1710.0
1711.0
1713
1712.0
1714
1713.0
1715
1714.0
1716
1715.0
1717
1718 1716.0
1717.0
1719

09/15/15
09/16/15

D

C

B

Timekeepe Description
E-mail from Scheiner to NS & JN re: setting time
JLN

JLN
JLN

to speak re: settlement
Sent GC more cross outlines for review
Review of NS cross examination outlines; notes re:

E

Hours

0.100
0.100

same

09/16/15
09/16/15
09/16/15

09/16/15
09/16/15

JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN
JLN

1.400

T/c with GC & NS re: settlement status
Review of new Rule 68 offer
Review of NS memo to Schoolcraft re settlement

0.700
0.500

E-mail w/ NS re memo and settlement
Review of NS e-mail to Schoolcraft resettlement

0.300
0.200
0.100

08/03/15

JJM

08/03/15

JJM

08/03/15
08/04/15

JJM
JJM

Mtg. w/ Jon L. Norinsberg re: new role in
schoolcraft case
Watch documentary on Schoolcraft case to get feel
for case & issues
Begin prelim cross outline of Sgt. Weiss
Continue prelim cross outline of Sgt. Weiss (part 1)

0.500
0.300
1.400

3.200
08/04/15

JJM

Continue prelim cross outline of Sgt. Weiss (part 2)
3.400

08/05/15

JJM

Continue prelim cross outline of Sgt. Weiss (part 3)
5.600

08/06/15

JJM

Continue prelim cross outline of Sgt. Weiss (part 4)

JJM

Continue prelim cross outline of Sgt. Weiss (part 5)

2.600
08/06/15

4.800
08/10/15
08/10/15

JJM
JJM

08/10/15
08/11/15

JJM
JJM

Start Caughey prelim cross outline
Start MS OneNote Tab - reorganize dep highlights
on Caughey prelim cross outline
Continue reorganizing dep nighlights
continue prelim cross outline of Caughey (Pt. 2)

1.600

3.500
1.100
1.400

08/11/15

JJM

Add allegations to prelim cross outline of Caughey
4.300

08/12/15

JJM

Continue prelim cross outline of Caughey (Pt. 3)
3.300

08/12/15

JJM

Meeting with Jln re: Caughey signing memobooks

08/12/15

JJM

08/12/15
08/13/15

JJM
JJM

Add memobook impeachment to Caughey prelim
cross outline
Conlinue prelim cross outline of Caughey
Reviewed additional transcript for Caughey;
highlighted same

0.500

Page 82

1.250

2.100
1.200

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

1 JNo.
1718.0

Date
08/13/15

1720
1719.0

08/13/15

1721

1720.0
1722
1723 1721.0
1724 1722.0
1723.0

08/13/15

08/14/15
08/14/15
08/17/15

D

C

B

Timekeepe Description
Add new dep highlights into existing prelim cross
JJM
outline
Re -organize prelim cross outline to account for
JJM
additional transcript
Continue to add new deposition highlights into
JJM
existing prelim cross outline
Continue Caughey prelim cross outline (Pt 5)
JJM
Continue Caughey prelim cross outline (Pt 6)
JJM
Continue Caughey prelim cross outline (incorporate
JIM
part 1 of IAB transcript into cross) (Pt 7)

Hours
2.900
2.250

2.700
3.200
3.100

2.400

1725

1724.0

08/17/15

JJM

Continue Caughey prelim cross outline (incorporate
part 2 of IAB transcript into cross) (Pt 8)

JJM

Continue Caughey prelim cross outline (incorporate
part 3 of IAB transcript into cross) (Pt 9)

1.800

1726
1725.0

08/17/15

2.300

1727

1726.0

08/17/15

JJM

Continue Caughey prelim cross outline (incorporate
part 4 of IAB transcript into cross) (Pt 10)
2.100

1728
1727.0

08/18/15

JJM

1729

1728.0
1730
1731
1732
1733
1734
1735
1736
1737
1738
1739
1740

E

1729.0
1730.0
1731.0
1732.0
1733.0
1734.0
1735.0
1736.0
1737.0
1738.0
1739.0

08/18/15
08/18/15
08/19/15
08/19/15
08/19/15
08/20/15
08/20/15
08/21/15
08/21/15
08/24/15
08/24/15
08/25/15

JJM
JJM
JJM
JJM
JJM
JJM
JJM
JJM
JJM
JJM
JJM
JJM

1741

1740.0
1742
1743 1741.0
1742.0
1744
1743.0
1745
1744.0

08/25/15
08/25/15
08/26/15

JJM
JJM
JJM

Finished Caughey prelim cross outline, reorganized
and edited same
Added part headings to Caughey prelim cross
outline
Finish Caughey prelim cross outline
Begin Trainor prelim cross outline (part 1)
Continue Trainor prelim cross outline (part 2)
Continue Trainor prelim cross outline (part 3)
Continue Trainor prelim cross outline (part 4)
Finish Trainor prelim cross outline (part 4)
Continue Trainor prelim cross outline (part 5)
Continue Trainor prelim cross outline (part 6)
Continue Trainor prelim cross outline (part 7)
Continue Trainor prelim cross outline (part 8)
Add part hearings to parts 1 - 4 and reorganize
Trainor prelim cross outline
Add part hearings to parts 5 - 8 and reorganize
Trainor prelim cross outline
Begin prelim cross outline of Lamstein (Part I)
Continue prelim cross outline of Lamstein (Part 2)

2.700
2.400
0.900
2.900
2.300
1.700
3.700
2.600
3.300
4.700
3.100
3.700

2.600
3.100
3.700
3.200

08/26/15

JJM

Continue prelim cross outline of Lamstein (Part 3)

JJM

Continue prelim cross outline of Lamstein (Part 4)

3.400
08/27/15

2.800

1746

Page 83

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

C

B

D

1745.0

Date
08/27/15

Timekeepe Description
JJM
' Continue prelim cross outline of Lamstein (Part 5)

1746.0

08/28/15

JJM

1747.0

09/02/15

JJM

1748.0

09/02/15

JJM

09/08/15

JJM

Continue lambstein prelim cross outline (Part 8)

1750.0

09/08/15

JJM

Continue lambstein prelim cross outline (Part 9)

1751.0

09/09/15

JJM

E

Continue lambstein prelim cross outline (Part 7)

1749.0

1

No.

1747

Hours
2.200

1748

Discussion with JLN about fomat of prelim cross
outline of Lamstein
Continue lambstein prelim cross outline (Part 6)

1749

0.300

3.700

1750

2.300

1751

2.900

1752

2.300

1753

1752.0
1754
1755 1753.0
1754.0
1756
1755.0
1757
1756.0
1758
1757.0
1759
1758.0
1760
1759.0
1761
1760.0
1762
1761.0

09/09/15

JJM

06/25/10
06/25/10

NB
NB

06/28/10

NB

06/28/10

NB

06/28/10

NB

06/28/10

NB

06/28/10

NB

07/01/10

NB

07/12/10

NB

1762.0

07/13/10

NB

1763.0

07/13/10

NB

1764.0

07/13/10

NB

1765.0

07/13/10

NB

Add part headings and reorganize Lamstein prelim
cross outline
Continued to reorganize lamstein prelim cross
outline
Saved retainer signed by client to file
Prepared Substition of Attorney for taking case
over from JM
Downloaded documents from new client Adrian
Schoolcraft from CD to compuler file
Faxed Substitution of Attorney to Jonathon Moore;
mailed same via regular mail
Saved Witness Summary of Eddie Valasquez to
client file
E -mailed Substitution of Attorney and Signed
retainer Agreement to J LN
Saved additional witness information to client file

3.700
2.800
0.100
0.200
0.200
0.200

0.100
0.100

0.100

1763

Calendared JLN meeting with Justice Dept. re:
Schoolcraft
Went through documents from CD Schoolcraft's
provided; watched videos & recordings & prepared
digest of same
Listened to recording b/w AS & Det. Peterson on
Sept. 13, 2009 and made notes regarding same

1764

0.100

4.100

0.400

1765
1766

Continued review of Schoolcraft recordings;
prepared digest of same
Examined FDNY PCR for AS; prepared summary
of same
Reviewed recording of conversations b/w AS & Lt.
Mascol on Feb. 20, 2009; prepared digest of

1767

4.200
0.500

0.600

Page 84

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

1766.0

B

Date
07/14/10

1768

1767.0

07/15/10

1769

1768.0
1770
1771 1769.0
1770.0
1772
1773 1771.0
1772.0
1774
1773.0
1775
1774.0
1776
1775.0
1777
1776.0
1778
1777.0
1779
1780 1778.0
1779.0
1781
1780.0
1782
1783 1781.0
1782.0
1784
1785 1783.0
1786 1784.0
1785.0
1787
1786.0
1788
1787.0
1789
1788.0
1790
1791 1789.0
1790.0
1792
1791.0
1793

08/10/10
08/11/10
08/11/10
08/18/10
08/19/10

I

D

C

Timekeepe Description
Continued reviewing CD recordings (2008 roll
NB
calls) and prepared digest of same
Continued reviewngSchoolcraft roll calls (2009 roll
NB
calls); prepared digest of same
Filed Summons and Complaint; sent s&c to as
NB
Aetna Judicial for service
Saved witness information to client file
NB
Began review of new CD from Client w/ numerous
NB
additional recordings and docs
E -mailed JLN schoolcraft audio files
NB
Filed Affidavit of Service as to Frederick Sawyer
NB

E

Hours
3.600

3.100
0.600
0.100

3.900
0.100
0.100

08/30/10
08/30/10

NB
NB

Filed Affidavit of Service as to Jamaica Hospital
Medical Center
Filed Affidavit of Service as to Steven Mauriello

0.100
0.100

08/30/10
08/30/10

NB
NB

Filed Affidavit of Service as to Christopher
Broschart
Filed Affidavit of Service as to Timothy Caughey

0.100
0.100

08/30/10
08/30/10
08/30/10
08/30/10
08/30/10
08/30/10
08/31/10
09/13/10
09/16/10

09/17/10
09/18/10
10/08/10

10/12/10
10/20/10
10/27/10

NB

Filed Affidavit of Service as to Michael Marino

NB
NB

Filed Affidavit of Service as to Shantel James
Filed Affidavit of Service as to Theodore
Lauterborn
Filed Affidavit of Service as to Lillian AldanaBernier
Filed Affidavit of Service as to Isak Isakov
Filed Affidavit of Service as to defendant Gerald
Nelson
Saved AS personal information to file
Filed Amended Complaint
Reviewed AS hospital records to locate discharge
summary; sent JLN snme
Printed Judge Weinslock opinion re: Velez
proceedings for JLN review
Printed NYPD Admin Guide provided by AS for
JLN review
Email correspondence w/ GC re: more recordings

NB
NB
NB
NB
NB
NB

NB
NB

NB
NB
NB

NB

Printed JHMC MTD for JLN: bound same
Viewed AS hospital records to find ER notes for
JLN: sent JLN same
Filed Affidavit of Service as to defendant The City
of New York
Page 85

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.100
0.100
0.300

0.200
0.100
0.150
0.100
0.150
0.200

0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

D

1792.0

Date
10/27/10

1793.0

10/27/10

1794.0

10/27/10

1795.0

10/27/10

1796.0

10/27/10

1797.0

10/27/10

Timekeepe Description
NB
Filed Affidavit of Service as to defendant Theodore
Lauterborn
NB
Filed Affidavit of Service as to defendant
Christopher Broschart
NB
Filed Affidavit of Service as to defendant Steven
Mauriello
NB
Filed Affidavit of Service as to defendant Timothy
Caughey
NB
printed and saved answer into computer file and
hard file
NB
Filed Affidavit of Service as to defendant lsakov

1798.0

10/27/10

NB

1800
1801 1799.0
1800.0

11/16/10
11/17/10

NB
NB

1801.0

12/09/10

NB

1802.0

12/10/10

NB

1803.0

12/10/10

NB

1804.0

12/10/10

NB

1805.0

12/15/10

NB

1806.0

02/09/11

NB

1807.0

03/04/11

NB

1808.0

05/06/11

NB

1810
1811 1809.0
1812 1810.0
1811.0

05/09/11
05/10/11
05/10/11

NB
NB
NB

No.

1

1794
1795

1796
1797

1798
1799

E

Hours
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.100
0.100

Filed Affidavit of Service as to defendant Jamaica
Hospital Medical Center
Sent AS e-mail enclosing Affidavit
Formatted First Request for Admissions, request
for discovery demands, request for interrogatories
and sent same to J LN for review

1802

0.100
0.100

1.200

1803

1804

Drafted letter to all counsel enclosing, opposition
to MTD
Prevared AS authorizaitons for Jamaica Hospital
and sent same to all counsel
Filed Affidavit of Service for Gough and Duncan

1805

0.250

0.700

0.100

1806

1807

1808
1809

Prepared attorney list of all defense counsel in case
and saved to file
Filed Affidavit of Service as to defendant Kurt
Duncan
Formatted Ltr. Opposing Defendants' Request Stay
pending MTD; made multiple edits and filed same
with Court
Prepared authorizatiou and letter enclosing
authorization to ACC
Printed Judge Sweet's decision on defendants' MTD
for JLN review
Drafted Deposition notices for all defendants
E -mailed JLN Opinion of Judge Sweet
Formatted initial disclsoures for City of New York;
created litigation backs; prepared documents to sent
with disclosures; copied same to for all parties;
prepared letter enclosing said documents; sent to all
parties via regular mail

1813

0.200
0.100

0.600
0.250

0.200
0.100
0.100

1.400

Page 86

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

1812.0

C

B

Date
05/13/11

D

I

Timekeepe Description
Prepared and sent authorization for NYC
NB
employment records to Martin Clearwater and Bell

Hours

0.500

1814
1813.0

05/15/11

NB

1815

1814.0

05/20/11

NB

1815.0

05/20/11

NB

Formatted final draft RFA for City of New York;
copied same for courtesy copy to all parties;
prepared letter enclosing, said documents; sent to
all parties via regular mail
Formatted final draft of 1st Document Demands for
City; copied same for courtesy copy to all parties;
prepared letter enclosing said document sent to all
parties via regular mail

1.200

0.800

1816

1817

1816.0

05/20/11

NB

Formatted final draft of Rog,s for City; copied
same for courtesy copy to all parties; prepared
letter enclosing said documents; sent to all parties
via regular mail
Formatted final draft of Deposition Notices for City
Defendants; copied same for courtesy copy to all
parties; prepared letter enclosing said documents;
sent to all parties via regular mail

0.700

0.400

1818
1817.0

05/24/11

NB

Formatted final draft of discovery demands/ Rogs
for JHMC; copied same for courtesy copy to all
parties; prepared letter enclosing said documents;
sent to all parties via regular mail
1.700

1819

1818.0

1820
1821 1819.0
1820.0
1822
1821.0

05/25/11

NB

06/16/11
06/23/11

NB
NB

07/08/11

NB

Formatted final draft of Deposition JHMC
Defendants; copied same for courtesy copy to all
parties; preared letter enclosing said documents;
sent to all parties via regular mail
Sent AS authorizaiton to Queens DA
Prepared authorization and letter enclosing
autorization to Queens DA
Drafted letter to all counsel notifying them of pretrial conference; made edits and sent out same

0.500
0.200
0.250

0.250

1823

1822.0

08/08/11

NB

Downloaded and printed research received from
0.100

JLN

1824

1823.0

12/13/11

NB

Sent AS Authorization to James Liander (Queens
0.200

DA)

1825

1824.0

12/13/11

NB

1826
1825.0
1827

E

12/13/11

NB

Letter to defense counsel enclosing responses to
discovery requests (authorizations)
Letter to Callon enclosing Luell and IRS
Authorization

Page 87

0.200
0.200

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

Date
01/05/12

1827.0

01/11/12

No.

1828
1829

1828.0

C

B

1826.0

1

01/23/12

D

Timekeepe Description
NB
Made reservation for Schoolcrafts for
Cosmopolitan Hotel
NB
Sent Callan kletter and AS authorization via regular
mail and e-mail
NB
Letter to Greg Radomisli enclsoing auths for

Hours

0.100
0.100

1829.0

02/10/12

NB

1831

1830.0

03/09/12

NB

medicaid records and disclosing lost earnings
E-mail exchange to Jeremy Stephens regarding
serving subpoenas on Johnstown PD, FCSD and

0.250

FCDSS

1830

0.200

Formatted to Lt. Gilbo regarding the documents
that were sent in response to subpoena and sent
same

1832
1831.0

03/13/12

NB

1832.0

03/14/12

NB

1833.0

04/16/12

NB

1834.0

04/23/12

NB

1835.0

05/11/12

NB

1837
1838 1836.0
1837.0

05/17/12
08/14/12

NB
NB

1833
1834

0.250

Formatted letter and made edits to letter to Court
re: leaks to media
Pulled and email GC various documents from
Schoolcraft file
E-mail exchange to Jeremy Stephens (investigator)
regarding serving subpoenas on Vallone and Kelly

1835

0.300
0.200

0.200

1836

1839

Sent package to all counsel enclosing transcripts of
Browne, Pichardo, McHugh, Polanco, Mauriello,
Herran, Gianelli, Esposito
Prepared follow up letter to Gilbo subpoening
records for JPD; sent same via regular mail
Sent Schoolcraft Affidavit of GS as per JLN
Prepared letter and authorization for the release of
tax records to Publicker; sent same via mail and email

08/28/12

1839.0

08/28/12

NB

Copied, sorted and catalogued various non party
subpoenas (County of Fulton, Johnstown PD for
each defendant); drafted and sent letter to all
counsel enclosing same via mail

1840.0

09/11/12

NB

1841.0

10/01/12

NB

Formatted and made edits to JLN letter to Court
requesting 120 day extension of time; filed same
with Court
Multiple phone calls to Hotel Albany regarding
setting up confercnce room for rreeting with AS

1843
1844 1842.0
1843.0

10/02/12
10/12/12

NB
NB

NB

0.800
0.250
0.100

0.250

1838.0

Email to all counsel enclsoing documents received
in response to various non-party subpoenas

1840

0.150

1841

1842

1845

E

Forwarded schoolcraft justice website to JJM
Drafted and sent letter to City requesting color
copies of photographs shown at plaintiffs
deposition
Page 88

0.450

0.600

0.600
0.100

0.300

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

1844.0

Date
10/12/12

1846
1847 1845.0
1846.0

10/16/12
10/18/12

1

No.

1848
1849 1847.0
1848.0
1850
1849.0

10/21/12
11/13/12

11/14/12

D

C

B

Timekeepe Description
email exchange with S. Publicker regarding City's
NB
consent
Emailed Mauriello letter to Judge to JLN
NB
Drafted letter regarding additional day of testimony
NB
for AS deposition and sent to GC and JF for review
NB
NB

NB

Filed Second Amended Complaint
newly identified defendants; emailed JLN
regarding same
Scanned and e -mailed AS Letter of Termination in
file; filed same in computer file and hard file

1

E

Hours
0.200
0.100

0.200
0.600
0.200

0.250

1851

1850.0

11/15/12

NB

1852

1851.0

01/29/15

NB

1853

1852.0

02/03/15

NB

1854
1853.0

02/03/15

NB

1855

1854.0

02/05/15

NB

Made changes and formating edits to letter to Judge
Sweet regarding being relieved as counsel and filed
same with Court
Read deposition transcript of Mauriello; digested
same
Printed Amended Compaint and Docket sheet for
JLN review
Downloaded and printed all memorandums of law
filed by defendants
Read deposition transcript of Bernier; digested

1855.0

02/06/15

NB

1856.0

02/09/15

NB

1858

1857.0

02/11/15

NB

1859

1858.0

02/12/15

1859.0

02/13/15

1860.0

02/18/15

1861.0

02/19/15

NB

1860
NB

0.600

1.300

Read deposition transcript of Finnegan; digested
same
Read deposition transcript of Caughey; digested
same
Read deposition transcript of Duncan; digested
same
Printed various exhibits from Plaintiffs deposition

1.100

1.700

0.600
0.200

1861
NB

Printed and bound deps of Mauriello and Valenti
0.200

1862
1863
1864 1862.0
1863.0
1865
1864.0
1866
1867 1865.0
1866.0
1868

0.100

Read deposition transcript of Cooper; digested
same

1857

2.400

1.900

same

1856

0.600

NB

Read deposition transcript of Dhar; digested same
0.600

02/19/15
02/19/15
02/25/15

02/25/15
02/25/15

NB
NB
NB

NB
NB

same
Printed various exhbits from deps of Mauriello
Lauterborn and Floyd
Read deposition transcript of Ferrara; digested
same
same
Reade deposition transcript of Hanlon; digested
same
Page 89

1.600

0.200
1.200

0.400
0.400

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

No.

B

Date

C

D

03/11/15
03/12/15

Timekeepe Description
NB
E-mail Marino deposition to JLN
NB
Printed Plaintiffs Rule 56.1 Statement for JLN to
review
NB
same
NB
Read deposition transcript of James; digested same

03/12/15

NB

1872.0

03/18/15

NB

1873.0

03/20/15

NB

1874.0

1

03/23/15

NB

03/23/15
03/25/15

NB
NB

1869 1867.0
1868.0
1870
1871 1869.0
1870.0
1872
1871.0

03/03/15
03/09/15

E

Hours

0.100
0.100
1.800

0.750

1873

1874
1875

Printed and bound documents from City of New
York from City of New York and Mauriello
medical documents
Read deposition transcript of Lamstein; digested
same
Read deposition transcript of Lauterborn; digested

0.200
1.600

same

1876
1877 1875.0
1876.0
1878
1877.0

NB

1879

0.400
0.100

same

03/25/15

2.100

Downloaded, printed and bound second set of
filings by all defendants for JLN to review
Printed Huffman QAD for JLN
Read deposition transcript of Silverman; digested

0.600

Printed, reviewed and signed confidentiality
agreement for myself; had JLN review and sign
same

0.200

E -mailed Confidentiality agreement to Merry
Soelanto signed by JLN and myself
Converted Schoolcraft opening statement to MS
Word

0.100

Printed IAB Documents for JLN; bound & collated
same
Printed and bound Caughey and Weiss Interviews

0.400

1878.0

03/25/15

NB

1879.0

03/27/15

NB

1880.0

03/30/15

NB

1881.0

03/31/15

NB

1882.0

04/01/15

NB

1883.0

04/01/15

NB

1884.0

04/01/15

NB

04/02/15
04/08/15

NB
NB

Compiled, sorted, copied and collated multiple trial
exhibits
Printed, collated and bound AS direct outline
Read deposition transcript of Lwin; digested same

04/09/15

NB

Read deposition transcript of Marino; digested

04/13/15
04/14/15

NB
NB

1880
1881

1882
1883

0.100

0.200

1884

1885

1886
1887 1885.0
1886.0
1888
1887.0
1889
1890 1888.0
1889.0
1891

Printed and bound exhibit list and witness list for
Court
Printed deps of Huffman, James, Hanlon, Halpren,
Gough, Ferrara, Duncan, Caughey, Broschart,
Bernier and bound

0.200

0.700
0.600
0.200
1.600

same

Printed crime reporting review documents
Read deposition transcript of Patel; digested same

1.800
0.200
1.100

Page 90

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

D

C

B

E

Date
04/15/15

Timekeepe Description
Read deposition transcript of Sangenti; digested
NB

Hours

04/16/15

same
Read deposition transcript of AS; digested same

0.600

1891.0

1892.0

04/16/15

1893.0

04/16/15

1894.0

04/17/15

1895.0

04/27/15

1896.0

1

04/27/15

No.

1890.0
1892

NB

3.100

1893

NB

1894
NB

1895

NB

Read deposition transcript of AS (Volume 11);
digested same
Read deposition transcript of AS (Volume III);
digested same
Read deposition transcript of LS; digested same

2.900

2.500
1.400

1896
1897
NB

1898

1897.0

04/28/15

NB

Read deposition transcript of Trainor; digested
same
Read deposition transcript of Valenti; digested

0.400

same

NB

1.100

Read deposition transcript of Weiss; digested same
1.300

1899

1898.0

05/01/15

NB

1900
1899.0

05/04/15

NB

1901

1900.0

05/05/15

NB

1902

1901.0

05/06/15

NB

1903

1902.0

05/13/15

NB

Read deposition transcript of Broschart; digested
same
Read deposition transcript of Duncan; digested
same
Read deposition transcript of Sawyer; digested
same
Read deposition transcript of Marquez; digested
same
Read deposition transcript of Purpi; digested same

2.100

0.700
0.800

0.600
0.750

1904

1903.0

05/13/15

NB

1905

1904.0

06/02/15

NB

1906
1905.0
1907
1908 1906.0
1907.0
1909
1908.0
1910
1909.0
1911
1910.0
1912
1913 1911.0
1914 1912.0

06/02/15

06/04/15
06/05/15
06/05/15

NB
NB
NB
NB

Calendared dates for JPTO, MIL, Jury Charge,
Voir Dire,
Read deposition transcript of Milone; digested
same
Read deposition transcript of Carrasco; digested
same
same
Read deposition transcript of Halpren-Ruder;
digested same
Read deposition transcript of Lubit; digested same

0.100

0.750
0.900
0.600
0.800
1.100

06/17/15

06/17/15
08/05/15
08/06/15

NB

NB
NB
NB

Printed and emailed defendants memoranda of law
for reconsideration for JLN
emailed defendants memoranda of law for
reconsideration of AS
Printed City's draft JPTO
JPTO

Page 91

0.200
0.100
0.100
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

I

C

D

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

1913.0

08/10/15

NB

1914.0

08/11/15

NB

1915.0

08/13/15

NB

1917.0

08/25/15
08/25/15

NB
NB

1918.0

08/25/15

NB

Printed, collated and stapled multiple discovery
documents from City sent to JLN via email
Printed spreadsheet from A. Scheiner with City's
objections to plaintiffs JPTO
Printed JPTO for JLN review
Printed filing by NS responding to various
arguments by defendants on JPTO exhibits and
witnesses for JLN Review
Printed, bound, sorted and tabbed Lauterborn Cross

1919.0

08/25/15

NB

08/25/15
08/25/15
08/25/15

NB
NB
NB

Printed, bound, sorted and tabbed Carter Cross
Printed, bound, sorted and tabbed Weiss Cross
Printed, bound, sorted and tabbed Mauriello Cross

1923.0

08/31/15

NB

Printed Amended Compaint and emailed to JLN

1924.0

09/03/15

NB

1926.0

09/05/15
09/05/15

NB
NB

1928.0

02/03/13

NBS

Printed City letter re: JPTO schedule for JLN
review
Prepared Schoolcraft Trial Folder
Gathered and Prepared Folder of Supplies for
Schoolcraft Trial
Telephone conference with Peter Gleason; review
of docket complaint and decision by J. Sweet.

1929.0

02/07/13

NBS

1930.0

02/08/13

Hours

Made multiple formatting changes to final S&C;
prepared civil cover sheet and summons for same

1915

0.700

1916
1917
1918 1916.0

1919

1920

0.200

0.100
0.100

0.100

0.600

1921
1922 1920.0
1923 1921.0

1924

0.800
0.500
0.600

0.800

1925

0.100

1926
1927 1925.0
1928

1929

0.100
0.200
0.250

2.500

Meeting with Adrian Schoolcraft; Peter Gleason
and John Lenoir re possible representation.

1930

2.500

1931
1931.0

2/11/2013

NBS
NBS

1932.0

2/12/2013

NBS

1933.0

2/13/2013

NBS

1934.0

2/14/2013

NBS

1932

1933

1934
1935

E

Printed, bound, sorted and tabbed Marino Cross

1922.0

1

TElephone conference with Peter Gleason re taking
on new case
Telephone conference with co -counsel; review of
Floyd case.

0.300

Appear for examination before trial of client in
Floyd case and defend same (3.5) (before MJ
Freeman); meeting with co -counsel and client in re
going forward; review of emails re status.
Telephone conference with Peter Gleason;
telephone to Richard Guilbert re status.
Telephone conference with client; review of Floyd
decision; meeting with client and team.

5.500

Page 92

0.500

0.500
3.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

B

D

C

No.

Date

1935.0

1

2/15/2013

Timekeepe Description
Review of files from counsel; review of pleadings;
NBS

2/17/2013
2/18/2013

telephone call to co -counsel twice; review of penal
code.
Review of boxes from client and Guilbert.
Review of decisions of file; review of production.

1936
1937 1936.0
1937.0
1938
1939 1938.0
1939.0
1940
1940.0

2/20/2013
2/22/2013
2/24/2013

NBS
NBS

Meeting with co -counsel; prepare subpoenas
Review of emails; telephone call to co -counsel;
telephone Graham Raymond (Village Voice).
Travel with Peter Gleason to meet defendant and
his father in Saugerties, NY.
Review of file; prepare summons fo amended
cmplt; file Summons with SDNY clerk; tc attempt
service of same on Law Dept; telephone call to
Peter Gleason re status of serving 5 remaining
defendants.

NBS
NBS
NBS

1941
1941.0

2/27/2013

NBS

1942
1942.0

2/28/2013

Review of examination before trial; prepare
subpoena; prepare Notice of Appearance.
Telephone conference with potential medical
expert (.5); review of discovery; file Affirmation of
Service; review of medical and hospital records.

NBS

1943
1943.0

3/1/2013

NBS

2.200
2.500
3.500
0.800
0.700
5.200

2.800
3.500

3.200

1944
1944.0

1945

3/2/2013

Review of Section 1983 and 242 issues and jury
instructions for various theories of the case.

NBS

5.000

_

1945.0

3/3/2013

Review of discovery; review of discovery plan;
review of draft letter to Justice Department.

NBS

2.500

1946
1946.0

3/5/2013

NBS

1947

.

1947.0

3/6/2013

NBS

1948
1948.0

3/7/2013

NBS

1949
1949.0

3/9/2013

NBS

1950
1950.0

3/14/2013

NBS

1951
1951.0

1952

E

Hours

3/20/2013

NBS

Telephone conference with client re Justice letter
and Chris Dunn three times; review of discovery
record.
Review of discovery records; telephone call to
Chris Dunn (NYCLU); meeting with City CM
Williams; Peter Gleason and Adrian Schoolcraft
(2.1).
Review of file; meeting with client and Peter
Gleason; review of new matter.
Meeting with co -counsel and intern in reference to
status.
Emails to opposing counsel; letter to Judge Sweet
in reference to motion schedule.
Review of Magistrate Judge letter; telephone call to
Peter Gleason; letter to court re two motions;
review of discovery file.

Page 93

2.500

3.500
3.800
2.500

0.700

2.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

No.

B

C

1952.0

Date
3/22/2013

1953.0

3/23/2013

1954.0

3/25/2013

1955.0

3/26/2013

NBS

1956.0

3/27/2013

NBS

1957
1958 1957.0
1958.0

3/28/2013
3/29/2013

NBS
NBS

3/30/2013

NBS

3/31/2013
4/1/2013

NBS
NBS

1

1953

1954

D

'Tirnekeepe Description
NBS
Appearance in court on Floyd case to see Marino
testify (2.5); telephone call to client (.3); call to
Peter Gleason(.4); prepare Rule 34 demand for
property.
NBS
Review of motion and motion letter; research on
taking high-level government employee's
deposition.
NBS
Working on opp to motions to guash and compel;
telephone call with client and review of materials
with client (1.5); telephone conference with Jon
Norinsberg re Queens DA; suit and sharing
information (0.5).

1955

1

E

Hours

4.200

3.500

8.500

1956

1959
1959.0

1960
1961 1960.0
1961.0
1962
1962.0
1963
1963.0
1964
1965 1964.0
1966 1965.0
1967 1966.0
1967.0
1968
1968.0

1969
1970 1969.0
1970.0
1971

Telephone conference with client (.5); call to Peter
Gleason (.3); drafting memo of law in opposition to
motion.
Revising Memo of Law in Opposition (4.5);
telephone call to client; meeting with Peter
Gleason; mag and artist re demonstratives.
Draft supplemental memo of law.
Review of discovery; review of letter re gag order;
telephone call to client; email team; call to Peter
Gleason; telephone G. Rayma.
Review of gag order cases (1.5); conference with
team (1.0).
Review of cases on gag order.
Review of discovery; email reference discovery
plea.

4/2/2013

NBS

4/3/2013

NBS

4/4/2013
4/5/2013
4/7/2013
4/8/2013

NBS
NBS
NBS
NBS

4/9/2013

NBS

6.500

5.800
1.500

7.500

2.500
3.500

3.500

Appearance at Floyd trial to hear Mauriello testify.
3.500

Appearance at Floyd trial to hear part of Dr. Fagan
direct.
Drafting memo of law on prior restraint.
Revise memo of law on prior restraint.
Meeting at upstate with' team.
Meeting with client all day re prep for case and ebt

2.500
7.500
3.800
8.600
7.500

Continued review of discovery)(4.0); MHL on
emergency hospitalization; meeting with potential
expert re: medical malpractice issues (1.5); meeting
with John re: motion; telephone call to Walker re:
same.

4/10/2013
4/11/2013

NBS
NBS

6.500

Meeting with team after court appearance.
Meeting with team and Rae Kosheck re: NYPD re
adm trial issues.

1.500

Page 94

2.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.
1971.0

1972
1973 1972.0
1974 1973.0
1975 1974.0
1975.0
1976
1977 1976.0
1977.0

Timekeepe Description
Telephone conference with Peter Gleason re:
NBS

Hours

4/15/2013
4/16/2013
4/22/2013
4/23/2013

status.
Review of production.
Review of production
Review of testimony in discovery
Review of PG on Marino, Mauriello,and
Lauterborn; review of reports of PG by IAB.

0.500
2.000
2.500
3.000

4/24/2013
4/25/2013

NBS
NBS
NBS
NBS

NBS
NBS

4/26/2013

NBS

1979
1979.0

4/27/2013

NBS

1980

1980.0

4/28/2013

NBS

1981

1981.0

4/29/2013

NBS

1982

1982.0

4/30/2013

NBS

1983

1983.0

5/1/2013

NBS

1984
1984.0

5/2/2013

NBS

1985
1985.0

5/3/2013

NBS

Review of AEO files.
Appearance at 1 Police Plaza for conference;
telephone call to client re: status; review of
interviews by QAD.
Meeting with client re: background and
chronological with John Lenoir.
Meeting with client re: background with John
Lenoir.
Telephone conference with John Lenoir re:
upcoming trial with NYPD.
Telephone conference with with client (1.0) re:
trial; research on collateral estoppel issue.
Telephone conference with client; research on
collateral estoppel issue.
Telephone conference with Peter Gleason re:
status; emails with clients re: same.
Draft letter to Publicker re: collateral estoppel
issue; email all counsel re: discovery deadlines;
email court re: same.
Review of cases; email letter to opposing counsel
re: collateral examination before trial issue.

4.500
3.500

2.500

6.500
7.500
0.200

2.800
2.800
0.500

1.500

0.700

1986

1986.0

5/7/2013

NBS

1987
1987.0

5/8/2013

NBS

Listening to day -long recording of 10/31/09; taking
notes thereof (7.0); review of discovery requests;
prepare same.
Review of recordings; prepare discovery responses.

9.500
5.500

1988

1988.0
1989
1990 1989.0
1990.0
1991
1991.0
1992
1992.0
1993

E

Date
4/14/2013

1978

1978.0

D

C

B

5/9/2013

5/10/2013
5/13/2013

5/14/2013
5/15/2013

NBS

NBS
NBS

NBS
NBS

Meeting with J. Lenoir re: case and status; review
of internal memos by IAB; review of recordings.
Continued review of discovery.
Meeting with John and Melissa re: NYPP;
telephone call with client.
Telephone conference with client re: status; review
of discovery files; outline of production.
Continued review of production; email opposing
counsel re: status of IPP trial and Queens DA
document.
Page 95

3.200
3.500
2.500
3.800

2.200

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

D

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

1993.0

5/16/2013

NBS

1994.0

5/17/2013

NBS

1995.0

5/18/2013

NBS

1996.0

5/20/2013

NBS

5/21/2013

NBS

Meeting with Jon Lenoir; telephone conference
with co -counsel and Jim McCutheon; telephone
conference office of Lisa Bland; review of civil
commitment articles and decision on dangerousness
predictions; review of discovery record; prepare
responses to objections to City Defendants
demands; listening to recording of lAB interview.

1998.0

5/22/2013

NBS

Telephone conference re: status; telephone call
Lisa Bland re: possible deal (demand of back pay in
consideration of resignation);
review and revised responses to discovery
demands.

E

Review of personal file on defendants; sick report
and duty status at 10/31/09; research on Judge
Sweet letter; telephone call to John Lenoir re:
Jimmy McCutkin re: telephone to Lisa Bland.

1997.0

1

1994

Hours

Review of files; telephone call to co -counsel;
telephone client; call to Lisa Bland.
Continued review of discovery; telephone call to
client (2 times); call to John Lenoir; email re: same.

1995

5.500

3.500

Telephone conference with client and co -counsel.

1996

1.200

1997

3.500

1998

5.800

1999
1999.0

2000

5/23/2013

NBS

Telephone conference with client; call to co counsel; review of decisions; email re: status.

1.800

0.800

2000.0

5/24/2013

NBS

2001
2001.0

2002

5/30/2013

NBS

2002.0

6/3/2013

NBS

2003
2003.0

6/4/2013

NBS

2004
2004.0

6/5/2013
2005

NBS

Telephone conference with client re: status; review
of emails from co -counsel re Eli Silverman.
Telephone conference with client; telephone call to
Lisa Bland's office.
Telephone conference with co -counsel; letter to
Judge Sweet on discovery; telephone call to Lisa
Bland re: now want demand from us and will not
agree to stay.
Telephone conference with client; telephone call co counsel; draft letters to Judge Sweet re: stay and re:
alleged discovery deficiencies.
Appearance in court at conference before Judge
Sweet handled by John Lenoir; conference with
John re: same.

Page 96

0.400
0.500

3.500

3.500

1.800

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

,

A

No.

1

B

6/12/2013
6/13/2013

NBS

Review of Younger et al decisions on stay motion.

6/14/2013

NBS

Email regarding press contracts; telephone call to
client; further research on Younger issue.

6/18/2013

NBS

Drafting reply on stay; research on issues re: same.

6/19/2013

NBS

Drafting reply; telephone call to client re: reply
transcript of 10/31/09; call from Village Voice;
telephone G. Rayman re: status of case.
Telephone conference with co -counsel; review of
Floyd submissions.
Telephone conference with client; telephone co counsel re: travel to upstate; review of issuses
regardig: litigation with indigent client; prepare for

6/6/2013

2006
2006.0
6/7/2013
2007

2007.0

6/9/2013

2008.0
6/10/2013

2009
2009.0

2010
2011 2010.0
2011.0
2012
2012.0
2013
2013.0
2014
2014.0

6/11/2013

2015

2015.0

6/20/2013

NBS

2016

2016.0

6/25/2013

NBS

2017.0

6/26/2013

2018.0

6/27/2013

NBS

2018

2019
2020 2019.0
2020.0

6/29/2013
6/30/2013

NBS

NBS
NBS

E

Hours

1.800

4.500

3.500

5.500
5.500
1.500

3.500
3.500
8.500

5.500

2.500

2.800

same.

2017

2021

D

C

Timekeepe Description
Review of emails; review of proposed order;
review of notes on defendant's examination before
NBS
trial; email co -counsel; prepare for meeting with
experts.
Review of Queens D.A. files (20); meeting with
John Lenoir and potential experts on NYPD and
NBS
dangerousness (2.0); telephone client re: motion for
stay of NYPD
Preparing proposed Order to Show Cause on stay
NBS
of adm proceedings
Revised Order to Show Cause; filed same; emails
with counsel; telephone call to co -counsel;
NBS
telephone call to client re: status; 2nd appearance at
court.
Research on Younger abstention issues for stay
NBS
motion.
Review of Younger case law.
NBS

Date

2005.0

2008

I

Travel to Johnstown for meeting with client [8
hours of travel].
Review of tapes for the purpose of responsing to
discovery demands by the City for requests for
admissions and providing additional information to
the defendants about the recordings.
Review of stay decision on NYPD trial.
Review of tapes and drafting response to Court
Order re: complication of Plaintiffs deposition
testimony and requests to admit.

Page 97

9.000

7.500
0.500

5.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

D

E

No.

Date

2021.0

7/1/2013

2022.0

7/10/2013

NBS

2023.0

7/11/2013

NBS

2024.0

7/18/2013

NBS

Telephone conference with client re Judge Sweet
and re: discovery status; email opposing counsel re:
same and schedule of examination before trial.

2025.0

7/22/2013

NBS

2026.0

7/23/2013

NBS

Telephone conference with client; re: status; review
of to do list; memo to file.
Telephone conference with co -counsel re: status.

2027.0

7/24/2013

NBS

Telephone conference with Magdelena re: status

2028.0

7/25/2013

NBS

2029
2030 2029.0
2031 2030.0
2031.0

7/26/2013
7/27/2013
7/30/2013

NBS
NBS
NBS

Prepare for all counsel conference call; telephone
co -counsel; telephone call client.
Preparing documents for client.
Meeting with T. Skinner re: case.
Revising documents (sub of counsel; memo of
understanding; discovery demands) (1.5); telephone
call H. Suckle re: possible involvement; telephone
co -counsel re: status; review of Section 1983 case
law (1.5).

3.500

2032.0

7/31/2013

NBS

Meeting with H. Suckle re: hospital; draft memo to
client; revise sub of counsel; memo of goals;
document demand; emails re: discovery plan with
co -counsel and opposing counsel; telephone call to
client re: status.

6.500

2033.0

8/1/2013

NBS

2034.0

8/6/2013

NBS

2035.0

8/13/2013

NBS

2036.0

8/14/2013

NBS

2037.0

8/15/2013

NBS

1

Timekeepe Description
NBS
Telephone conference with client twice (1.5);
review of various tapes; review of transcripts;
prepare Response to the Court Order re: discovery.

2022

3.800

2023

2024

Travel to Albany and meet with the client at John
Garber's office (194 Washington Avenue); return to
NYC ( 8 hours travel time)
Telephone conference with R. Gilbert; telephone
conference with client re decision; telephone call to
client; telephone Gilbert

2025

8.500

0.900

0.700

2026
2027

1.500

0.400

2028

0.300

2032

2033

2034

2035
2036
2037
2038

Hours

Meeting with Magdalen re: status and case; review
of case law in jury instructions.
Telephone conference with co -counsel; review of
emails and press coverage; call from G. Rayman re:
book out.
Read recent book by G. Raymond called NYPD
Tapes
Travel to Mayfield, NY (4.5); review of recent
decision in Floyd case
Meeting with client re: examination before trial
preparation
Page 98

3.500
0.900
0.800

2.800

0.800
4.500

4.750
6.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

B

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

2038.0

1

8/16/2013

NBS

2039
2039.0

8/20/2013

NBS

2040
2040.0

8/21/2013

NBS

2041

2041.0

8/22/2013

NBS

E

D

C

1

!

Meeting with client to discuss case and deposition
(7.5); travel back to NY (4.5).
Telephone conference with client; revised letter to
court.
Telephone conference with co -counsel; emails with
opposing counsel re: discovery schedule.
Telephone conference with Jon Lenoir re: status;
telephone Greg Radomisle re: hospital inspection;
review of emails re: schedule; conference with all
counsel re: schedule; draft objections (2.5);
conference with Adrian Schoolcraft re: same.

Hours

9.750
1.500
1.200

4.200

2042

2042.0

8/23/2013

NBS

Meeting with Magdalena re legal research on state
action; telephone call with Jon Lenoir re: status.
1.500

2043

2043.0

8/24/2013

NBS

Meeting with investigator (1.0); telephone
conference with Jon Lenoir re: Paul Brown (0.3).
1.300

2044
2044.0
2045
2046 2045.0
2046.0
2047
2047.0

8/25/2013

8/26/2013
8/27/2013
8/28/2013

NBS

NBS
NBS

NBS

2048
2048.0
2049
2050 2049.0
2051 2050.0
2051.0
2052
2052.0
2053
2054
2055
2056
2057

2053.0
2054.0
2055.0
2056.0
2057.0

8/29/2013

8/30/2013
9/3/2013
9/4/2013
9/6/2013

9/8/2013
9/9/2013
9/10/2013
9/16/2013
9/18/2013

NBS

NBS
NBS
NBS
NBS

NBS
NBS
NBS
NBS
NBS

Review of production for AEO issue (5.0);
telephone call to J. Smith (photography of
inspection).
Continued review of production.
Travel to Saugerties to meet client (4.5); meeting
with client re: status (3.5).
Review of decision on jury order; telephone Pete
Gleason re: suits and apartment; review of counsel;
review of conference orders;
review of production.
Review of productions; telephone call, to client
(0.5)
Continued review of production
Telephone conference with client re: status.
Email to client re: status; review of status report;
review of letter motion by city.
Review of correspondence on discovery; drafting
AEO letter motion; telephone call to client re:
status and AEO letter issues (1.0)
Drafting letter motion on AEO.
Revising letter motion; emails on same.
Telephone conference with client.
Email regarding status; telephone call to client.
Telephone call and emails reference 81 inspection

5.500
3.500
5.750

3.500

3.800
3.500
1.500

0.700

3.500
2.500
0.800
0.200
0.500
0.500

2058

Page 99

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

D

Date
9/19/2013

Timekeepe Description
NBS
Inspection at 81 with defendants, cleint, and Mag.

9/21/2013
9/22/2013

NBS
NBS

9/23/2013

NBS

2062.0

9/25/2013

NBS

2063.0

9/26/2013

NBS

2064.0

9/27/2013

NBS

9/29/2013
9/30/2013

NBS
NBS

10/1/2013

NBS

10/2/2013

NBS

2069.0

10/4/2013

NBS

Appearance for client; examination before trial and
prepare for same.
Appearance for examination before trial of
defendant and prepare for same.
Meeting with client re: case and next Steps.
Telephone conference with co -counsel; review of
emails; review of productions.
Meeting with client re: examination before trial and
inspection preparation.
Inspection at Jamaica Hospital; visit Queen's
location; Meeting with client; reviewing tapes re:
examination before, trial.
Preparing for Marino and Mauriello examination
before trial (5.0); telephone conference with co counsel; emails with opposing counsel re:
adjournment for Mauriello; review of PG & Floyd
trial transcripts.

2070.0

10/7/2013

NBS

10/8/2013

NBS

Preparing for and taking Marino's examination
before trial; calls to Court on status of various
motions.

2072.0

10/9/2013

NBS

E

Prepared for examination before trial; conference
call with co -counsel; conference with client.

2071.0

I

Appearance in court on motions (2.0); meeting with
team re: case and examination before trial (2.0);
prepare for examinations before trial of plaintiff

Telephone conference with John Lenoir re: status.

No.

1

2058.0
2059
2060 2059.0
2060.0
2061
2061.0

Meeting with client.
Review of motion letter re: AEO and personal
property motion.
Draft reply letter on AEO and personal property
motion telephone conference with client; telephone
call with Mag; telephone call to John Lenoir re:
status; review of 81 inspection photos; review of
AEO designations.

2062

Hours
5.500
3.500

2.500

2.500

2063

7.500

2064
2065
2066 2065.0
2066.0
2067
2067.0
2068
2068.0
2069

2070

9.000
9.000
1.500
2.500
3.500

7.500

5.500

2071

5.500

2072
2073

9.500
0.500

Page 100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

NBS

2073.0
10/9/2013

2074
2074.0

10/10/2013

NBS

2075
2075.0

10/11/2013

2076.0

10/13/2013

NBS

2076

NBS

2077

2077.0

10/14/2013

NBS

E

D

C

B

Hours
1

Meeting with co -counsel; review and revise status
report; review of motions and filing on case re:
discovery; telephone conference with G. Raymond
re: Mauriello counterclaims (will comment in
opposing papers).
Review of email; conference with co -counsel;
review of law on tortuous interference claim; email
opposing counsel re: emotion to amend Mauriello
answer.
Drafting letter to Court; research on motion to
amend.
Telephone conference with client re: status re:
NYCLU and Dunn and going forward; telephone
call to John Lenoir re: same
Telephone conference with L. Dunn; telephone call
to John Lenoir re: case; drafting and research on
motion to strike Mauriello answer; discovery
matters (AEO personal property) and opposing to
motion to amend pleadings (7.5).

1.800

3.500

2.300

8.500

2078

2078.0

10/15/2013

NBS

Revised motion and memo; emails re: same; letter
to court; conference with client're: status.
3.500

2079

2079.0

10/16/2013

NBS

Prepare for court appearance; appear before Judge
Sweet on various motions (3.2); conference with
trial team; telephone call with Howard Suckle re:
status and medical defendant's examination before
trial; email to client.
4.500

2080

2080.0

10/17/2013

NBS

Telephone conference with client; emails re: status;
email prior counsel re: discovery matters.
0.800

2081
2081.0

10/18/2013

NBS

2082
2082.0
2083

4.500

10/22/2013

NBS

Telephone conference with client; review of
medical documents responses; email opposing
counsel re: status of production.
Meeting with H. Suckle re: medical examination
before trial preparation.

Page 101

1.800

2.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

No.

1

2083.0

B

C

D

Date
_Timekeepe Description
10/23/2013
NBS
Telephone conference with court re: oral argument
date; telephone call with Walter Kretz re: same;
conference with co -counsel; telephone call and
email to client; telephone J. Eterno re: status and
Monell issues (alleged conflict of interest issue
raised by Law Dept in the past); review of Jamaica
Hospital records; email with prior counsel re:
substitution and document search.

2084

E

Hours

3.500

2084.0

10/24/2013

NBS

Prepared for examination before trial of Dr. Bernier

2085.0

10/25/2013

NBS

10/27/2013
10/28/2013

NBS
NBS

10/29/2013

NBS

Appearance for Bernier examination before trial;
wait for response from Court on video objection;
meeting with team.
Research on dangerous assessment.
Telephone conference with client re: status; emails
re: schedule and video objections.
Preparation for examination before trial of
Mauriello; review of research on video use
conference with 10-10.

2089.0

10/30/2013

NBS

2090.0

11/1/2013

NBS

2091.0

11/3/2013

NBS

11/4/2013
11/5/2013

NBS
NBS

11/7/2013

NBS

2095.0

11/8/2013

NBS

Meeting with investigator (1.0); telephone call
same and Mag (0.5); review of research and emails.

2096.0

11/14/2013

NBS

2097
2098 2097.0

11/15/2013

NBS

Email in reference to Daily News Article;
telephone call to Mag Bauza re: interview with
Carol Street.
Prepare for Mauriello.

2085

2086
2087 2086.0
2087.0
2088
2088.0

5.500

2089

0.800

5.800

Telephone conference with client (1.0); email
opposing counsel re: adjournment on Mauriello;
review of ernails; review of Mauriello
testimony in Floyd case; review of AS personnel
file records for examination before trial (2.0)

2090

4.500

2091

2092
2093 2092.0
2093.0
2094
2094.0

3.200
3.000

2095

Telephone conference with client; telephone call to
John Lenoir re: Stop and Frisk; status.
Review of Lauterborn recordings and preparation
for his examination before trial.
Prepare for examination before trial.
Review of record; prepare for Lauterborn
examination before trial
Prepare for and take examination before trial of
Lauterborn; conference with team; telephone call
with client re: status.

2096

0.500

4.200
2.500
4.500

9.500

3.500

Page 102

1.200

2.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

1

No.

2098.0

2099
2100 2099.0
2101 2100.0
2101.0
2102
2102.0
2103
2103.0

B

Date
11/19/2013

11/20/2013
11/21/2013
11/22/2013
11/26/2013

D

C

L
Timekeepe Description
Telephone conference with B. Shaffer re: Larry
NBS
Schoolcraft examination before trial re:
examination before trial of Larry Schoolcraft; prep
for ebts of polce defendants
Prepare for Marino examination before trial.
NBS
Prepare for Marino examination before trial.
NBS
Prepare for and appear at Mauriello examination
NBS
before trial (busted by defendant).
Drafting notices for depositions ; review of email.
NBS

E

Hours

2.200
2.500
2.500
3.500
1.000

12/1/2013

NBS

Review of Caughey, Weiss and Hanlon recordings;
prepare for Caughey examination before trial;
telephone conference, re: status (left message).
2.800

2104
2104.0

12/2/2013

NBS

2105
NBS

2105.0

12/4/2013

2106.0

12/6/2013

NBS

2107.0

12/7/2013

NBS

2106
2107

2108
2109 2108.0
2110 2109.0
2110.0
2111
2111.0
2112
2113 2112.0
2114 2113.0
2114.0
2115
2115.0
2116
2116.0
2117
2118 2117.0
2119 2118.0

12/8/2013
12/9/2013
12/17/2013

NBS
NBS
NBS

12/18/2013

NBS

12/19/2013
12/20/2013
12/24/2013

NBS
NBS
NBS

12/29/2013

NBS

12/30/2013

NBS

12/31/2013
1/1/2014

NBS
NBS

Telephone conference with W. Kretz re: Mauriello;
telephone
emails with counsel re: status and discovery
deadline.
Letter to opposing counsel; email to opposing
counsel re numerous discovery disputes.
Emails re: status; prepare opposition to motion for
reconsideration.
Telephone conference with client and John Lenoir;
prepare for Caughey examination before trial;
prepare for opposition to Mauriello
reconsideration.
Prepare for Caughey examination before trial.
Take examination before trial of Caughey.
Prepare for examination before trial of Mauriello;
review of recent correspondence.
Prepare for Mauriello; conference with co -counsel,
telephone call to client re: status.
Prepare for Mauriello.
Take examination before trial of Mauriello.
Meeting with client and John Lenoir re: status and
possible settlement demand.
Meeting with client to review various tape
recording.
Meeting with client and review various tape
recordings (4.3); obtain tape recorder from NYPD
and send to specialist for enhancement
Review of production; research on compstat.
Review of Silverman and Eterno book

Page 103

2.500
1.500

3.500

2.800
2.500
7.500
3.500

4.500
3.500
8.500
3.200
4.500

4.500
1.800

4.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

2119.0

2120.0

1/3/2014

2121.0

1/5/2014

2122.0

1/6/2014

2120
2121

2122

2123
2124 2123.0
2125 2124.0
2125.0

C

B

Date
1/2/2014

No.

1

1/8/2014
1/12/2014
1/13/2014

2126

D

Timekeepe Description
_______
NBS
Meeting with client re: review of tapes; telephone
conference with co -counsel; emails re: schedule;
letter to Court re: schedule
NBS
Prepare for Boston and Huffman examination
before trial
NBS
Prepare for Boston and Huffman examination
before trial.
NBS
Prepare for and take examination before trial of
Boston and Huffman; meeting with team re: status
and going forward
NBS
Letter to Court; email re: scheduling
NBS
Prepare for Hanlon examination before trial
NBS
Prepare for and take Hanlon examination before
trial; conference with team re: examination before
trial and case
NBS
Appearance in court; conference with co -counsel;
email re: status
NBS
Review of production; review of report on crime
reporting; emails re: status of examination before
trial
NBS
Review of documents produced; review of report of
crime reporting; review of prior discovery demands

2126.0

1/15/2014

2127.0

1/16/2014

2128.0

1/17/2014

2129.0

1/23/2014

NBS

1/24/2014
1/27/2014

NBS
NBS

1/28/2014
1/29/2014
1/30/2014

NBS
NBS
NBS

Produce documents
Revising letter to website responders; sending Out
same; letter to City Defendants re: examination
before trial
Prepare for Dr. Lamstein
Prepare for Dr. Lamstein
Prep for and take Dr. Lamstein examination before
trial

2/3/2014

NBS

2/5/2014

NBS

2/7/2014

NBS

1.800

4.500

3.700

10.500
0.200
3.500

8.500

Prepare documents for supplemental production;
long status conference with client re: need for AEO
production and status of case (1.3)

2130
2131 2130.0
2131.0

E

Hours

2127

2128

2129

2132
2133 2132.0
2134 2133.0
2134.0
2135
2135.0
2136
2136.0

2138

3.500

3.500

1.900

Telephone conference with co -counsel; email
reference examination before trial.
Telephone conference with client; emails reference
examination before trial; and letter to Judge Sweet.

2137

2137.0

2.300

0.400

1.200

3.500
2.300
9.500
0.500

0.800

Email regarding status with client; meeting with
Mag in reference to redaction issues; letter to Law
Department reference redaction; drafting and
revising discovery demands.

Page 104

3.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

D

C

B

A

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

2138.0

1

2/10/2014

NBS

2139
2139.0

2/11/2014

2140.0

2/12/2014

NBS

2140
NBS

2141
2141.0

2/16/2014

NBS

Telephone conference with the court clerk
reference submission on February 10, 2014; letter
to court; prepare for doctor's examination before
trial (2.8)
Prepare for and attend Dr. Bernier examination
before trial.
Prepare for and attend Dr. lsakov examination
before trial.
Telephone conference with John Lenoir and client
reference status; review of privilege issues.

E

Hours

3.800
8.500

9.500

1.700

2142
2142.0

2/18/2014

NBS

Review of examination before trial for discovery
letter; emails reference defendant's examination
before trial and Norinsberg termination letter;
request JHMC provide and produce the two EMT's.
3.800

2143

2143.0

2/19/2014

NBS

2144
2144.0

2145
2146 2145.0
2146.0

2/20/2014

2/21/2014
2/23/2014

NBS

NBS
NBS

2147
2147.0

2/24/2014

NBS

2148
2148.0

2/25/2014

NBS

2149
2149.0

2150
2151 2150.0
2152 2151.0
2152.0

2/27/2014

2/28/2014
3/3/2014
3/4/2014

NBS

NBS
NBS
NBS

2153
2153.0

3/8/2014

NBS

2154
2154.0

3/11/2014

2155
2156 2155.0

3/24/2014

NBS

NBS

Telephone conference with co -counsel (HS)
reference medical case; state action; pro and sub
due process; review of emails reference discovery
status; telephone call to John Lenoir reference
same.
Email co -counsel; client review of examination
before trial for motion.
Review of cited psychiatric journals.
Review of examination before trial; telephone co counsel; telephone conference with client reference
status.
Review of examination before trial; email reference
recording.
Review of examination before trial; transcripts for
discovery issues; telephone call to Walter Kretz
(two times) regarding possible work out.
Drafting letters to court re outstanding disocvery
disputes by plaintiff and by defendants

Letter motion regarding discovery issue.
Review of emails and letters
Prepare for and attend meeting to confer; emails
reference status same.
Review of letters on discovery motions; email to
team reference response.
Meeting with team John Lenoir and Mag Bauza;
drafting letter to court.
Meeting with team: telephone call with client.

Page 105

2.500
2.800
2.500

3.500
0.400

5.000

3.500
6.500
0.500
1.500
1.200

2.300
3.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

No.

Date

2156.0

1

3/26/2014

C

D

E

Timekeepe Description
NBS
Review of drafts 30(b)(6); appear in court on

discovery status (2.2); telephone call client; review
of document demands; meet and confer with
opposing counsel (1.0).

2157
2157.0

3/27/2014

Hours

-

NBS

2158

3.800

Telephone conference with client (twice) re subject
matters of numerous 30(b)(6) notices; revising
same.

3.500

2158.0

3/28/2014

NBS

Meeting with Mag reference jury instructions;
telephone call with client reference 30(b)(6);
revising same and serving same.

2159.0

4.500

3/31/2014

NBS

Telephone conference with client; review of
discovery; emails reference settlement.

2160.0

1.800

4/1/2014

NBS

Telephone conference with City re: settlement;

2159
2160

2161

telephone conference with client; conference with
team re: same.
Review of medical expert decisions and affidavit;
prepare for Trainor examination before trial.

1.500

2161.0

4/4/2014

NBS

2162.0

4/7/2014

NBS

Prepare motion to strike paragraph six of
Mauriello's counterclaim (1.3); prepare outline of
discovery issues; telephone call to D. Beekman
(Daily News); telephone conference Graham
Raymond; telephone MJ Freeman's chambers;
email all counsel.

2164.0

4/8/2014
4/9/2014

NBS
NBS

Prepare for Trainor examination before trial.
Preparing for hearing on Raymond motion to
compel; appearance in court on motion (2.2);
prepare for Trainor and Gough examination before
trial.

2165.0

4/10/2014

NBS

2166.0

4/11/2014

8.900

NBS

Prepare for and take deposition of Trainor; prepare
for Gough examination before trial.
Prepare for and take Gough examination before
trial

7.800

4.500

2162

2.500

2163
2164 2163.0

2165

2166
2167

2167.0

4/13/2014

NBS

Prepare for and meet with potential expert (Roy
Lubit).

2168.0

4/14/2014

NBS

Telephone conference with co -counsel re: status;
conference with client; emails with opposing
counsel re': new dates for settlement
demands/offers/conference; draft letter to MJ
Freeman re: same; email Hearn.

2169.0

4/15/2014

NBS

Telephone conference with H. Suckle re: status and
settlement.

2168

2169
2170

Page 106

2.500
2.800

2.800

1.800

0.300

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

D

C

B

No.

Date

Timekeep Description

2170.0

1

4/16/2014

NBS

E

Hours

Telephone conference with team (1.0); conference
with client re: settlement demands (1.2); research
on commitment cases; state action and Section
1983; review of Plaintiffs demands.
5.800

2171
2171.0

4/17/2014

NBS

2172

2172.0
2173
2174 2173.0
2174.0

4/18/2014

4/22/2014
4/23/2014

NBS

NBS
NBS

2175
2175.0
2176
2177 2176.0
2178 2177.0
2178.0

4/24/2014

4/25/2014
4/27/2014
4/28/2014

NBS

NBS
NBS
NBS

2179

2179.0

4/29/2014

2180.0

4/30/2014

NBS

2180
NBS

2181
2181.0

5/2/2014

NBS

2182

2182.0

5/5/2014

NBS

Telephone conference with team; review of
decisions; telephone Mag; telephone Howard;
telephone John; letter to all defendants counsel re:
Norinsberg termination letter; telephone call to S.
Mettham re: settlement.
Various telephone calls with John Lenoir;
telephone client; review of decisions on involuntary
hospital and damages.
Telephone conference with Joe Ferrero.
Drafting opposition to Jamaica Hospital motion for
protective order; prepare for and attend
examination before trial of Bernier
Prepare for Sawyer examination before trial (3.0);
revise opposition to Jamaica Hospital protective
order motion.
Prepare for and take deposition of Sawyer.
Preparing reply to Mauriello opposition
Prepare for and take Duncan examination before
trial and conference with all counsel and MJ
Freeman re: settlement discussion.
Review of state motion cases; meeting with co counsel; call to client.
Appearance in court on JHMC motion for
protective order and Adrian's motion to strife
Mauriello counterclaims reference (2.2); prepare
for same; lunch meeting with team and colleague of
John's re: case.
Telephone conference with Gregory Radomsile
reference examination before trial; emails to
opposing counsel' re: same.
Telephone conference with Sheri; telephone call to
John Lenoir; prepare letter to Judge Sweet re:
Plaintiffs motion to compel; telephone to John
Cohen re: fees; review of Gleason fees.

2.900

3.500
0.500

8.500

3.500
6.500
2.800

7.800

2.500

3.800

0.800

2.200

2183

Page 107

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

No.

Date

2183.0

1

5/8/2014

2184
2185 2184.0

C

D

Timekeepe Description
NBS
Prepare for conference; attend tc conference with
Magistrate Freeman re: settlement: hospital
defendant have no pay status and City willing to
continue discussions, email client re: status;
revising letter to Judge; review of opinion on
Mauriello counterclaim/motion to strike Plaintiff
(0.5); research on law enforcement privileged (1.0).

2185.0

5/11/2014
5/12/2014

NBS
NBS

2186.0

5/13/2014

NBS

2186
2187

Prepare for James examination before trial.
Prepare for and take James examination before
trial.
Travel to Holbrook and meet with Ferrara and his
wife.

E

Hours

4.500
3.500
6.800

4.500

2187.0

5/14/2014

NBS

2188.0

5/15/2014

NBS

2189.0

5/19/2014

NBS

Review of production; prepare for meeting with
client; telephone call with co -counsel; research on
discovery issues (law enforcement privilege).

2190.0

5/20/2014

NBS

Travel to and from Johnstown, NY meeting with
client; conference with Magistrate Freeman; exparte conference with Magistrate Freeman.

2191.0

5/22/2014

NBS

Drafting opposition to City motion for protective
order and cross -motion for documents, research on

2188

2189

Prepare and take examination before trial of
Marquez.
Prepare for and take examination before trial of
Sangetti (4.5); emails with client re: status and
settlement (0.5).

2190

8.400

5.000

3.800

2191

8.250

2192

same.

8.500

2192.0

5/23/2014

NBS

Research on blue wall silence (2.5); telephone call
to potential witness (Stephen Lerner); telephone to
Lubit; email team; email client; review of
document production; telephone conference with
Jon Norinsberg re: 81 locker photos.

2193.0

5/28/2014

NBS

Prepare for conference of motion; appear on motion
before Judge Sweet (2.8); telephone call to Dr.
Lubit; telephone call to the office of Eterno;
conference with all counsel re: schedule and need
30-45 days; prepare for Weiss examination before
trial; conference with team re: Weiss; telephone
Jon Norinsberg re: locker photos.

2194.0

5/29/2014

NBS

Prepare for Weiss: take Weiss examination before
trial: prepare for JHMC.

2193

4.500

2194
2195

j

8.500

Page 108

9.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

B

D

C

1

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

2195.0

5/30/2014

NBS

2196.0

1

6/2/2014

2196
NBS

2197
2197.0

6/3/2014

NBS

Prepare for and take examination before trial of
Jamaica Hospital (Maffia)
Telephone conference with client; emails with
opposing counsel re: discovery; reviewing
production for index.
Email regarding plan for discovery; production of
Aetna documents and dOcket photos; telephone call
to J. Ferrara re: examination before trial for 6/5/14.

E

Hours

4.500

1.800

1.500

2198
2198.0

6/4/2014

NBS

Prepare for Ferrara examination before trial;
telephone conference with co -counsel re: same.
3.200

2199

2199.0

6/5/2014

NBS

2200
2200.0

6/6/2014

NBS

Meeting with team and J. Ferrara; attend deposition
of J. Ferrara at Law Department; drafting discovery
demands for Mauriello.
Prepare discovery demands re: Mauriello (1.5);
conference call with John Eterno; Eli Silverman
and team re: expert issues (compstat, blue wall, and
digital recorder); review of New York City conflict
of interest issue, law, decision (1.2)

9.500

3.200

2201

2201.0

6/8/2014

NBS

2202

2202.0

6/9/2014

NBS

Revising discovery demand for Mauriello
counterclaim.
Telephone conference with client re: status of case.

1.200

2.000

2203

2203.0

6/10/2014

NBS

2204
2204.0

6/11/2014

NBS

2205

2205.0

6/12/2014

NBS

2206

2206.0

6/13/2014

NBS

2207

2207.0
2208
2209 2208.0
2209.0
2210

6/16/2014
6/17/2014
6/18/2014

NBS
NBS
NBS

Drafting demands on Mauriello; drafting letter to
court re: amended discovery schedules.
Travel to Rhode Island and meet with Dr. Dan re:
ER expert.
Continue meeting with Dr. Dan re: ER expert;
review parts of PX69 and home invasion recording
with expert; revised and drafted discovery demand;
travel back to New York.
Telephone conference with Eli Silverman and John
Eterno re: expert discovery schedule (1.0); review
of conflict laws; telephone call to Mag Bauza;
telephone to John Lenoir; memo to file on ER
expert (.5)
Review of city letter re: supplemental discovery;
conference with co -counsel.
Prepare for Broschart.
Prepare for and take Broschart re: examination
before trial.

Page 109

0.800
6.500

5.500

4.500
0.800
3.500
7.800

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

No.

B

C

D

2210.0

Date
6/19/2014

2211.0

6/20/2014

NBS

Draft opposition to reconsider; review of Duncan
examination before trial; prepare for Duncan.

2212.0

6/23/2014

NBS

Telephone conference with client (log) re: status;
prepare for and take examination of Duncan; emails
with opposing counsel re: schedule; telephone call
to'Dr, Patel.

2213.0

6/26/2014

NBS

2214.0

6/27/2014

NBS

2215.0

6/28/2014

NBS

2216.0

6/29/2014

NBS

Entails with opposing counsel re: schedule;
conference with co -counsel re: same.
Review of Mauriello examination before trial;
telephone call to Dr. Roy Lubit; and prepare for
Mauriello examination before trial.
Review of Mauriello examination before trial;
review of Lubit affirmation in Monaco.
Review of Mauriello examination before trial;
prepare for continued examination before trial of
Mauriello (4.5); conference with client re: status;
email Dr. Lubit; email John Lenoir.

2217.0

7/1/2014

NBS

E

Timekeepe Description
NBS
Review of scheduling order; email with team re:
schedule; email Dr Lubit; review of Patrol Guide;
prepare for Duncan examination before trial (3.0)

1

Hours

2211

4.500

2212

4.500

2213

2214

2215
2216

2217
2218

0.500

3.500
4.500

7.500

Prepare and take Mauriello examination before
trial.

2218.0

7/3/2014

NBS

2219.0

7/6/2014

NBS

2219
2220

9.500

Prepare and take Dr. Lwin examination before trial;
meeting with team re: expert report; lunch with
team.
Prepare for Jamaica Hospital ebt (Dhar) on policy

3.800

issue.

2220.0
2221
2222 2221.0
2222.0
2223
2223.0

2224

7.500

7/7/2014

NBS

7/9/2014
7/14/2014

NBS
NBS

7/15/2014

NBS

7/16/2014

NBS

,

2224.0

3.800

Take and prepare for Jamaica Hospital examination
before trial.
Telephone conference with police experts.
Prepare for examination before trial of City
30(b)(6) witnesses.
Prepare for 30(b)(6) of witnesses on appeal; review
and quatoa issues; prepare for City examination
before trial on training; disciplines and crime
reporting.

7.500
0.800
1.500

.

3.200

Take deposition 30(b)(6) witnesses of City in the
morning and afternoon; prepare for same;
conference with co -counsel; conference with court
clerk; prepare for examination before trial next day.

2225

9.500

Page 110

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

D

C

B

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

2225.0

7/17/2014

NBS

1

1

E

Hours

Prepare for and take examination before trial of
City 30(b)(6) witnesses on performance evaluation
of supervisors and of police officers.
6.500

2226

2226.0

7/18/2014

NBS

2227

2227.0

7/21/2014

NBS

Review of prior arguments and submissions
discussions outstanding; conference with Dr.
Halpern and team.
Drafting letter to Court; review of transcript of
prior hearing; research on legal issues raised by
objections and Purpi examination before trial.

3.400

2228
2228.0

7/22/2014

NBS

Telephone conference with client and team; prepare
2.500

letter.

2229

2229.0

7/23/2014

NBS

Prepare for examination before trial on Thursday;
review of recent City production, emails with
opposing counsel re: examination before trial.
4.500

2230

2230.0

7/24/2014

NBS

2231

2231.0

7/25/2014

NBS

Prepare for and attend City 30(b)(6) (cooper);
prepare for examination before trial for Dr. Patel;
conference with client.
Prepare and take examination of trial of Dr. Patel;
draft letter to Court on application re: Dr. Patel.

7.500

3.500

2232

2232.0

7/28/2014

NBS

2233

2233.0

7/29/2014

NBS

2234

2234.0

7/30/2014

NBS

2235

2235.0

7/31/2014

NBS

2236

2236.0

8/1/2014

NBS

Review of Dr. Lwin examination before trial;
review letter from Jamaica Hospital.
Emails and telephone conference with client and re:
experts; review of letters to Court.
Telephone conference with John and Eli re: expert
report.
Review of earlier Silverman book on NYPD (2.8);
drafting letter to Judge Sweet; review of letter re:
outstanding; telephone conference with trial team
and Dr. Lubit and Dr. Halpern.
Review of letters on numerous discovery disputes;
review of videos of Dr. Patel's examination before
trial; drafting letter on three motion letter.

1.200
1.200

0.800

5.500

7.500

2237

2237.0

8/3/2014

NBS

2238
2238.0

2239

3.500

8/4/2014

NBS

Review and revise letter to Court; research on
deposition conduct re: definition of harassment.
Drafting letter re: 3 discovery motions; long
conference call with experts Silverman and Eterno
(1.5); preparing letter for experts on
police issues and transmitting documents to experts
(2.5)

Page 111

5.800

7.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

No.

Date

2239.0

1

8/5/2014

C

D

I

Timekeepe Description
NBS
Revise letter to Court on 3 motions; draft second

2240
2240.0

8/6/2014

NBS

2241.0

8/7/2014

NBS

2241
2242

letter re: video objection.
Telephone conference with Mag Bauza to do list;
meeting with John Lenoir re: same; revise letter to
Court re: video objection.

8/8/2014

NBS

2243.0

9/2/2014

NBS

2244.0

9/3/2014

NBS

2245.0

9/5/2014

NBS

9/10/2014
9/11/2014

NBS
NBS

2248.0

9/12/2014

NBS

2249.0

9/12/2014

NBS

2250.0

9/13/2014

NBS

2251
2252 2251.0
2252.0

9/14/2014
9/16/2014

NBS
NBS

2253.0

9/17/2014

NBS

2254.0

9/18/2014

2243

3.200

1.500

Review of report; telephone call to John Eterno re:
same

2242.0

E

Hours

1.200

Review of reports of experts (police and ER);
review of record from psychiatric experts.
Meeting with co -counsel; review of decisions on
discovery; emails re: scheduling with experts;
telephone call with Roy Lubit re: same.

2244

3.500

1.500

2245

2246
2247 2246.0
2247.0
2248
2249

2250

2253

Email to all counsel re: schedule; telephone call
with Eli Silverman.
Review of time limitation issues for examination
before trials.
Telephone conference with all counsel.
Reply to Defendants' letter motion on experts; letter
to all counsel re: expert fees to be paid; review of
cases on same.
Travel to Upstate, NY to meet with client; meeting
with clientc
Prepare for meeting with client; outline summary
judgment motions; causes of action.
Meeting all day with client, John Lenoir and
Magdalena Bauza re summary jugdment motions;
motion to amend; wages/damages issues; trial
plans; expert discovery and reports
Meeting with client; return travel to New York
Telephone conference with experts; conference
with co -counsel; emails re: schedule with all
counsel.
Prepare for and take Purpi examination before trial.

2254

0.700
1.500
0.500

3.500

4.500
2.500

7.500
5.500

1.800

3.500

2255
2256 2255.0
2256.0
2257
2257.0

NBS

Prepare for examination before trial; telephone call
with Walter Kretz; telephone conference with Roy
Lubit; review of expert reports served today and
with co -counsel.

9/19/2014
9/20/2014

NBS
NBS

9/21/2014

NBS

Prepare for and attaend Carrasco ebt
Review of medical expert reports by Jamaica
Hospital Medical Center; Bernier and lsakov.
Meeting with John Lenoir and Mag Bauza; meeting
with Lubit re: examination before trial preparation.

2258

3.500
5.500
2.200

3.500
Page 112

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

B

2258.0

Date
9/22/2014

2259.0

1

9/23/2014

No.

2259

2260
2260.0
2261
2262 2261.0
2262.0

9/24/2014

9/25/2014
9/26/2014

2263
2263.0

9/29/2014

2264
2264.0

9/30/2014

2265

2265.0

10/2/2014

2266

2266.0

10/3/2014

2267

2267.0

2268
2269 2268.0
2269.0

10/6/2014

10/7/2014
10/8/2014

D

C

Timekeepe Description
Email regarding schedule; telephone call with John
NBS
Eterno.
Prep for and attend examination before trial of Roy
NBS
Lubit; call to court re: schedule.
Telephone conference with Roy Lubit; telephone
NBS
call with John Lenoir; review of emails; letter to
court re: motion by city.
Drafting opposition to discover motion.
NBS
Review of production for motion to compel;
NBS
telephone call with co -counsel; message from Dr.
Lubit.
Meeting with Dr. Halpern Ruder and John Lenoir;
NBS
prepare for examination before trial; review of
CompSTAT notes.
Appear for and defendant Ruder examination
NBS
before trial; prepare for conference the following
day; review of CompSTAT notes.
Email re: scheduling Silverman and Lubit;
NBS
conference call with John Lenoir and Mag Bauza
re: trial prep review of CompStat notes.
Legal research on Monell issues (1.8) meeting with
NBS
Mag and John Lenoir; emails re: trial date;
conference with client re: status and trial date;
review of Nelson discover records (1.5); review of
Patrol Guide; review of CompStat notes (2.0); prep
motion for discovery.
NBS

NBS
NBS

Drafting motion for discovery; drafting letter re:
opposition to adjourn for trial date; emails with
opposing counsel; scheduling Patel examination
before trial; telephone call to the clerk for Patel's
attorney.
Draft motion on discovery.
Review of Floyd record; research on witness list
issues; telephone call with Dr. Dan Halpern; email
correspondences Silverman and Eterno.

0.400
8.000

1.700
3.500

2.200

5.800

8.900

4.500

6.500

5.500
4.500

7.500

2270

2270.0
2271
2272 2271.0
2272.0
2273

E

Hours

10/9/2014

10/10/2014
10/14/2014

NBS

NBS
NBS

Telephone conference with client; review of Eterno
production; email re: same; review of Floyd trial.
Review of Floyd transcripts and decision.
Meeting with Eterno (2.5); travel to Hempstead
(2.0); review of Rule 68 offer (.5); review of Floyd
trial transripts and decision

Page 113

4.500
4.500

7.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

INo.

Date

2273.0

1

10/15/2014

C

D

Timekeepe Description
NBS
Telephone conference with Walter Kretz re:

Hours

Mauriello; wants a small compensation from
Adrian to settle (.3); telephone call to Suzanna
Mettham and Ryan Shaffer re: Rule 68 offer (.4);
drafting reply letter on discovery motion (3.8);
briefing schedule and witness lists.

2274

5.500

6.500

2274.0

10/16/2014

NBS

Telephone conference with John Lenoir; drafting
letter to court on discovery motions/issue (2.8);
research on Rule 68 issues (2.5); email re:
discovery schedule.

2275.0

10/17/2014

NBS

2276.0

10/18/2014

NBS

2277.0

10/19/2014

NBS

Appear for and defend Eterno examination before
trial; revise and file letter with court re: outstanding
discovery issues.
Research on Rule 68; draft and send memo to client
re: Rule 68 offer; telephone client re: same;
telephone call to John Lenoir re: same.
Review of 2nd Amended Complaint for purpose of
motion to amend; conference call with team re:
Rule 68 offer; email exchange with Howard Suckle
re: same.

2278.0

10/20/2014

NBS

Telephone conference with with John Eterno (1.5)
re: examination before trial and case; telephone call
with chambers re: next conference; emails re: same;
revising pleading for purpose of motion; review of
case law on right to refuse, medical treatment (1.5).

2279.0

10/21/2014

NBS

2280.0

10/22/2014

NBS

2281.0

10/23/2014

NBS

Review of right to refuse medical treatment cases;
emails re: schedule; telephone to Eli Silverman re:
his examination before trial.
Meeting with Eli Silverman to prepare for
examination before trial.
Prepare for Silverman; telephone call to Silverman
(2 times); review of report; draft letter rejecting
Rule 68 offer.

10/24/2014
10/25/2014

NBS
NBS

10/26/2014
10/27/2014

NBS
NBS

2275

2276

2277

2278

2279

9.500

3.500

4.500

3.800

2280
2281

2282
2283 2282.0
2283.0
2284
2285 2284.0
2285.0

2286

E

Defend Silverman's examination before trial.
Research on criminal standard for exigent
circumstances.
Revise letter re: rejection of Rule 68 offer.
Meeting with John Lenoir re: amended complaint;
review of emails; telephone call to Investigator
Skinner; email with Silverman review of discovery
record on complaint; review of tapes re: Amended
Complaint.

Page 114

3.700
3.500

6.500
7.500
3.000
1.000

5.800

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

1

No.

2286.0

B

Date
10/28/2014

C

I-

Timekeep Description
NBS

2287

2287.0

10/29/2014

NBS

2288.0

10/30/2014

NBS

2289.0

10/31/2014

2288
2289

2290
2291 2290.0
2291.0

11/1/2014
11/3/2014

NBS

NBS
NBS

2292

2292.0
2293
2294 2293.0
2294.0
2295
2295.0
2296
2296.0

11/4/2014

11/5/2014
11/6/2014
11/7/2014
11/10/2014

NBS

NBS
NBS
NBS

NBS

2297
2297.0

11/11/2014

2298.0

11/13/2014

2299.0

11/14/2014

2300
2301 2300.0
2301.0

11/16/2014
11/19/2014

NBS

2298
NBS

2299

2302
2303
2304
2305
2306
2307

2302.0
2303.0
2304.0
2305.0
2306.0

11/20/2014
11/21/2014
12/1/2014
12/2/2014
12/3/2014

D

I

NBS

NBS
NBS

NBS
NBS
NBS
NBS
NBS

Prepare revisions to 2nd Amended Complaint for
motion to arrest; research on issues relating to
motion to amend.
Prepare for court; appear in court; conference with
client and John Lenoir re: status.
Prepare for Patel examination before trial; research
warrantless entry and search.
Prepare for and take 2nd examination before trial of
Dr. Patel (3.2); research on causes of action for
motions to amend and summary judgment.
Research on exigent circumstances case law.
Research an existing cir. case law (3.0); telephone
conference with Roy Lubit; emails with opposing
counsel; revised 2nd Amended Complaint for
motion to amend.
Drafting motion to amend; letter to court re: page
limit; email client re: status.
Drafting motion to amend.
Telephone conference with client re: amending
complaint.
Meeting with S. Korenbaum; emails re: status;
telephone call with Dr. Lubit.
Telephone conference with Dr. Lubit; attend and
defend examination before trial of Dr. Lubit at
Martin Clearwater; review of draft Amended
Complaint; research, on 4th Amendment
warrantless entry (1.5)
Telephone conference with paralegal (JS) re: case;
review of ebt summaries.
Appear and defend Dr. Lubit; conference re:
examination before trial with witness.
Review of examination before trial summaries and
indexes.
Revise complaint; email re: same.
Review of examination before trial of Lauterborn
and Mauriello on questions about evaluations;
email client re: same.
Review of file in Azira case on Blue Wall.
Emails re: Lubit; review of Azira files
Revising motion to amend
Revise memo re: motion to amend.
Revising 3rd Amended Complaint and Memo Of
Law In Support Of Motion To Amend.

Page 115

E

Hours

6.800

4.500
3.500

5.500
3.500

3.800
3.500
3.500

2.500
2.200

5.200
1.500

5.500
1.500
1.000

0.800
1.500
2.500
2.500
3.500
3.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

I

B

No.

Date

2307.0

1

12/4/2014

C

D

Timekeepe Description
NBS
Revising Amended Complaint and Memo on

2308

motion to amend; began review of depositions for
summary judgment motion.
Review of letters; review of Duncan transcripts,
emails with team re: status.
Review of examination before trial record.
Drafting letter to Court re: motion to amend;
review of examinations before trial for motion for
summary judgment.
Drafting letter to Court re: defendants' motion to
adjourn trial and summary judgment; review of
examinations before trial for summary judgment
motion; review of Compstat video.

2308.0

12/5/2014

NBS

2309
2310 2309.0
2310.0

12/7/2014
12/8/2014

NBS
NBS

2311.0

12/9/2014

NBS

2312.0

12/10/2014

NBS

12/11/2014

NBS

2314.0

12/12/2014

NBS

Review of examination before trial for summary
judgment motion; conference with M. Bauza re:
JHMC claims; review of cases.
Review of record for summary judgment motion.

2315
2316 2315.0
2316.0

12/13/2014
12/14/2014

NBS
NBS

2317.0
2318.0
2319.0
2320.0
2321.0
2322.0
2323.0
2324.0

12/15/2014
12/16/2014
12/17/2014
12/18/2014
12/19/2014
12/20/2014
12/21/2014
12/22/2014

NBS
NBS
NBS
NBS
NBS
NBS
NBS
NBS

2325.0
2326.0
2327.0
2328.0
2329.0

12/23/2014
12/24/2014
12/29/2014
12/30/2014

NBS
NBS
NBS
NBS
NBS

li

Hours

4.500

Review of examination before trial for preparation
of motions meeting with John Lenoir re: motions.

2313.0

E

2311

2312

2313

2325
2326
2327
2328
2329

3.500

5.500

8.500

2314

2317
2318
2319
2320
2321
2322
2323
2324

1.800
5.500

12/30/2014
2330
2331 2330.0
2332 2331.0
2333 2332.0

12/31/2014
1/1/2015
1/3/2015

NBS
NBS
NBS

Research on exig. cir. exception.
Review of examination for summary judgment
facts; review of exig. cir. cases; review of prima
facie tort and tortuous interference case.
Research on Mauriello counterclaims.
Drafting summary judgment motion.
Drafting summary judgment motion.
Drafting summary judgment motion.
Drafting motion for summary judgment.
Drafting summary judgment memo.
Drafting summary judgment motion.
Draft motions; memo; Rule 56.1 Statement;
conference with client re: sealing and objection to
it; letters (2x) Court.

Revising and filing paper; review of paper.
Preparing motion papers
Drafting Reply Memo on motion to amend.
Researching motion for summary judgment.
Telephone conference with John Lenoir; telephone
call to client re: Norinsberg; drafting summary
judgment; review of new material.
Draft opposition to summary judgment.
Review of motions by defendants.
Reading City motion and case law.
Page 116

5.500

3.500
3.500

5.500
3.800
7.500
10.500
12.000
10.500
9.500
7.500

12.500
7.500
3.500
5.500
2.500

9.500
7.500
5.500
5.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

2333.0

1/4/2015

NBS

1

E

D

C

B

A

___. _____

_

Reading Mauriello and JHMC motions and case
8.200

law.

2334
2334.0

1/5/2015

NBS

Hours

Review of motions; review of recent production by
City (videos and EIU file); conference with John
Lenoir and Mag Bauza re: motions.
5.500

2335
2335.0

1/7/2015

2336.0

1/8/2015

NBS

2336

NBS

2337

2337.0

1/9/2015

2338.0

1/10/2015

2339.0

1/11/2015

NBS

2338

NBS

2339

2340
2341 2340.0
2341.0
2342
2342.0

1/13/2015
1/14/2015
1/15/2015

NBS

NBS
NBS

NBS

2343

NBS

2343.0

1/16/2015

2344.0

1/17/2015

NBS

2345.0

1/18/2015

NBS

2344
2345

Reviewing motions; meeting with John Lenoir; J.
Mck; J.S re: Compstat videos.
Telephone conference with Howard Suckle (.3);
meeting with Mag (.1.5); telephone call to Ryan
Shaffer; Paul Callan; Gregory Radmosili re:
summary judgment schedule; review of Lauterborn
examination before trial (4:5)

Emails re: status; conference with team; conference
call with client.
Review of examinations before trial and Compstat
videos.
Review of examination before trial and Compstat
videos; conference with group on Commpstat
videos.
Compstat vide review
Conference with client and John Lenoir; review of
examination before trial and motions.
Review of Hanlon examination before trial; review
of Marino examination before trial; review of cases
in summary judgment motion discussion re:
Compstat videos.
Review of Hanlon examination before trial; review
of cases; review of Compstat video.
Review of examination before trial; prepare
summary judgment oppositions.
Prepare summary judgment opposition; review of
Hanlon, Sangianetti, and Marquez examination
before trial; review of Compstat videos.

7.800
1.500

7.500

7.500
5.500
7.500

4.500
7.500
7.500

8.500

2346

2346.0

1/19/2015

NBS

2347

2347.0
2348

4.500

1/20/2015

NBS

Review of Compstat videos; review of cases cited
in various motions; research on standard of
objective/subjective good faith and qualified
immunity.
Review of decision on motion to amend; review of
cases on conspiracy; review of examination before
trial for motion.

Page 117

7.500

5.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

I

C

D

No.
2348.0

Date

Timekeepe Description

1/21/2015

NBS

Drafting summary judgment motion papers (memo
of law; rule 56.1 statement); telephone Ryan
Shaffer; call Norinsberg re: wants co -counsel to get
access to Adrian Schoolcraft's records (medical) in
IAB file.

2349.0

1/22/2015

NBS

2350.0

1/23/2015

NBS

2351.0

1/24/2015

NBS

2352.0

1/25/2015

NBS

2353.0

1/26/2015

NBS

2354.0

1/27/2015

NBS

2/1/2015
2/2/2015

NBS
NBS

Drafting memo in opposition; telephone call to
Walter Kretz; emails re: schedule.
Research and draft Response to Mauriello summary
judgment motion.
Review of record; research on cases cited by
defendants summary judgment motion.
Review of record for summary judgment motion
opposition.
Drafting opposition papers; research on probable
cause.
Meeting with John and Mag re: summary judgment
motion; draft opposition; research on St
amendment issues.
Drafting opposition to motions.
Telephone conference with Jon Norinsberg (.5);
meeting with John Lenoir re to do list for trial(1.2);
conference with client and John Lenoir re: trial
team; drafting opposition to motion (5.0);
telephone call to client re: same; letter to court re:
schedule adjustment.

2357.0

2/3/2015

NBS

2358.0

2/4/2015

NBS

2/5/2015
2/6/2015
2/7/2015

NBS
NBS
NBS

Drafting opposition brief.
Drafting opposition papers.
Drafting opposition to Jamaica Hospital and doctor
motion.

2/8/2015

NBS

Drafting opposition to Dr. Bernier and Dr. lsakov's
motions; conference with John Lenoir; telephone
call with Mag Bauza.

2363.0

2/9/2015

NBS

2364.0

2/10/2015

NBS

Opposition motion ; telephone conference with
Ryan Shaffer: telephone call with Jon Norinsberg,
email client.

2349
2350
2351
2352
2353

2354

2355
2356 2355.0
2356.0

2357

2358

2359
2360 2359.0
2361 2360.0
2361.0
2362
2362.0
2363

Review of Monell case law for motion; review of
supplemental papers filed by all defendants.
Email with client; review of cases on Monell
liability; review of record (ebt's) on Monell issues.

2364

2365

E

Drafting opposition motion; conference with John
Lenoir (.5) telephone call with Mag Bauza; drafting
56.1 opposition; telephone conference with Brian
Lee re: Isakov claims (0.2).

1

Hours

8.500

7.500

9.000
6.500
7.500

7.500

9.500
5.500

7.800

3.500

1.800
7.500

9.500
7.800

9.500

10.500

Page 118

12.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.
2365.0

B

Date
2/12/2015

2366

2366.0

2367
2368 2367.0
2368.0

2/13/2015

2/17/2015
2/20/2015

Timekeepe Description
Telephone conference with client; call with Jon
NBS
Norinsberg and John Lenoir; emails; telephone call
with new city lawyer; review of files under seal;
review of opposition motion.
Review of 5 oppositions to summary judgment
NBS
motion & meeting with John Lenoir and Mag
Bauza re: issues to address (3.5), telephone call to
client (2 times); emails re: trial date; telephone to
Jon Norinsberf re: meeting and status.
NBS
NBS

2369

2369.0

2370
2371
2372
2373
2374
2375

2/23/2015

NBS

2370.0
2371.0
2372.0
2373.0
2374.0
2375.0

2/27/2015
3/3/2015
3/4/2015
3/5/2015
3/6/2015
3/9/2015

NBS
NBS
NBS
NBS
NBS
NBS

2376

2376.0

3/10/2015

2377.0

3/12/2015

2378.0

3/13/2015

D

C

NBS

Review of files on summary judgment papers.
Meeting with John Lenoir and Mag Bauza; meeting
with Jon Norinsberg and his group (Gerald Cohen
and Joshua Fitch).
Meeting with John Lenoir re: reply to Mauriello.
Preparing reply papers.
Drafting reply.
Drafting reply.
Drafting reply.
Drafting reply.
Research on new evidence issue; telephone
conference with team; revising letter to Court on
Matthews.
Review of cases on s/i; review of reply submission.

NBS

2378
NBS

3/15/2015
3/16/2015
3/17/2015

NBS
NBS
NBS

3/18/2015

NBS

Research on new evidece and new arguments on
reply; meeting with team.
Meeting with team re: trial preparation; drafting
letter to Court.
Research on motion to strike.
Drafting motion to strike.
Drafting motion to strike Lamstein Declaration.

7.500

4.500
2.500

4.800
2.500
5.500
7.500
10.500
10.500
9.500

4.500

6.500
2.800
4.500
7.500
5.500

Review of JPTO reqirement; telephone to Walter
Kretz re: status; drafting verdict sheet; prepare for
trial; review of subpoenas; meeting witj John
Lenoir re: trial lists of witnesses and exhibits.

6.500

2383

2383.0

3/20/2015

NBS

Telephone conference with Walter Kretz re:
Kickstarter movie; email with trial team re; inquiry.
0.500

2384

2384.0
2385

Hours

3.500

2377

2379
2380 2379.0
2381 2380.0
2381.0
2382
2382.0

E

3/21/2015

NBS

Drafting letter re: Lamstein; Q/F issue and
adjournment request: review of exhibit lists for
JPTO.
Page 119

3.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

No.

B

C

D

2385.0

Date
3/22/2015

Timekeepe Description
NBS
Review of exhibits for JPTO; revise letter to Court.

2386.0

3/23/2015

NBS

2387.0

3/25/2015

NBS

2388.0

3/26/2015

NBS

2389.0

3/27/2015

NBS

2390.0

3/29/2015

NBS

2391.0

3/30/2015

NBS

2392.0

3/31/2015

2393.0

1

2386

E

Hours

3.500

2387

2388
2389

Prepare witness and exhibit list; rewrite letter to
Court.
Emails re: status; conference with Scott
Korenbaum re: instructions; telephone conference
with John Lenoir and Mag Bauza re: instructions
and to do.

Review of production (discs & cd's) for plaintiffs
trial exhibit.
Review of production for JPTO; emails to opposing
counsel; emails to co -counsel re: status.

2390

4.500

3.500
5.500

5.500

Review of discovery record for JPTO and witness
cross.
Review of discovery record for JPTO - exhibits and
witness; telephone call to John Lenoir re: witness
responsibilities; telephone to Mag Bauza re: jury
instructions and diagram.

7.500

NBS

Review of discovery for witness list, exhibit list,
and JPTO; emails with opposing counsel re: service
of subpoenas.

5.500

4/1/2015

NBS

Email team; telephone call Brown (Daily News) re:
status; study of hospital chart; review of Bernier
examination of trial and prepare cross.

2394.0

4/2/2015

NBS

Meeting with team; review of trial exhibits;
conference call with John Lenoir re: Compstat; call
with Mag re: jury instruction; prepare for cross of
Bernier.

2395.0

4/3/2015

NBS

2396.0

4/4/2015

NBS

2397.0

4/5/2015

NBS

2398.0

4/6/2015

NBS

2399.0

4/7/2015

NBS

2400.0

4/8/2015

NBS

2391

2392

2393

2394

6.500

2395

2396
2397

2398
2399

2400
2401

7.500

Prepare for cross of Bernier; review of chart and
examination before trial.
Prepare cross of Bernier; review of trial exhibits;
review of draft jury instructions.
Prepare of Isakov cross; review of examination
before trial and chart.
Email team; telephone call to Scott Korenbaum re:
jury change; prepare Isakov cross.
Review of and revise motion in limine; review of
and revise jury instructions (medical); draft leter to
Court re: extension; continued preparation on
Isakov cross.
Drafting cross - outlines; letter to court; conference
with trial team.

Page 120

8.500
5.500
6.500

4.500
2.500

4.500
5.800

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

C

B

D

I

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

2401.0

1

4/9/2015

NBS

2402
2402.0

4/10/2015

NBS

2403
2403.0

4/12/2015

NBS

2404
2404.0

4/13/2015

NBS

2405
2405.0

4/15/2015

NBS

2406
2406.0

4/17/2015

NBS

2407
2407.0

4/29/2015

NBS

2408
2408.0

5/5/2015

NBS

2409
2409.0

5/7/2015

NBS

2410
2410.0

2411
2412 2411.0
2412.0

5/8/2015

05/08/15
5/11/2015

NBS

NBS
NBS

2413
2413.0

5/12/2015

NBS

2414
2414.0

5/13/2015

NBS

2415
2415.0

5/15/2015

NBS

2416
2416.0

2417
2418 2417.0
2418.0

2419
2420 2419.0

5/21/2015
5/22/2015
5/28/2015

NBS
NBS
NBS

Prepare for trial - jury verdict sheets and cross
examination outlines of witnesses
Prepare for Harlon cross; emails re: status;
telephone call to Mag Bauza re: to do; telephone
conference with John Lenoir re: witnesses; review
of witness list.
Prepare for Harlon cross (3.0); review of
Lauterborn transcript.
Prepare for oral argument; appear in court for
conference with court (2.0); conference with team
thereafter; email opposing counsel re: Lauterborn
CD and Boston illness.
Telephone conference with Alan Scheiner re:
settlement and trial date; emails re: discovery and
Boston.
Telephone conference with Alan Scheiner and team
re: settlement demand email.
Review of new recording from City on Lauterborn
PG; email trial team restatus; telephone call G.
Radomisli re: status of trial.
Review of review of decision on summary
judgment motion.
Review of decision; telephone call with opposing
counsel (Brian Lee) re: state medical malpractice
sliding scale issues and status.
Telephone conference with trial team re: status.
Review of decision; email team
Review of decision on summary judgment; prepare
for conference with court.
Prepare for conference meeting with team;
conference with court on case re: schedule for trial
and pre-trial.
Telephone conference with Dr. Lubit re: status and
trial date; telephone call to Dr. Eterno re: status and
trial date.
Emails re: schedule on motions in limine; review of
recent EDP decision.
Telephone conference with A. Schiener; email team
re: settlement.
Review of recent EDP decision.
Review of memo re: reconsideration; telephone call
with John Lenoir and email with MG re: same.

E

Hours

7.500

7.500

4.000

3.200

1.500
1.200

1.800

0.700

1.300

0.300
1.800
1.500

3.500

0.700
0.700

0.800
0.500

0.500
5/29/2015

NBS

Prepare reconsideration letter.
Page 121

1.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

D

Date
6/1/2015

Timekeepe Description
NBS
Drafting letter to court on reconsideration motion.

6/2/2015
6/15/2015

NBS
NBS

6/19/2015
6/22/2015

NBS
NBS

2425.0

6/23/2015

NBS

2426.0

6/24/2015

NBS

2427.0

6/25/2015

NBS

2428.0

6/26/2015

NBS

2429
2430 2429.0
2430.0

6/28/2015
6/29/2015

NBS
NBS

6/30/2015

NBS

7/1/2015
7/3/2015

NBS
NBS

7/4/2015
7/5/2015
7/6/2015

NBS
NBS
NBS

7/7/2015
7/8/2015

NBS
NBS

7/15/2015

NBS

Review of emails; telephone call to John Lenoir re:
expert discovery; review of opposition to
reconsideratio motions; review of prior record for
reply; review of motion in limine and schedule for
trial preparation.

7/17/2015

NBS

Telephone conference with John Lenoir: review of
CompStat clips; review of emails.

No.

1

2420.0
2421
2422 2421.0
2422.0
2423
2424 2423.0
2424.0

Hours
3.500

2425

2426

Revising and drafting reconsideration motion.
Review of calendar; telephone call to John Lenoir
re: status.
Review of motion by City and authorities.
Emails re: motions; review of City memo;
telephone conference with City; call to W. Kretz;
review of Mauriello memo; emails with team re:
schedule.
Email team re: schedule; telephone call to city
counsel re: same; email all counsel re: same.
Telephone conference with John Lenoir; telephone
S.K. re: opposition to bifurcation; emails to counsel
re: schedule; letter to Judge Sweet re: schedule;
review of motion on bifurcation.

2427

3.000

0.300
1.500

3.200
0.600

1.300

2428

2431
2431.0
2432
2433 2432.0
2433.0
2434
2435 2434.0
2436 2435.0
2436.0
2437
2438 2437.0
2438.0
2439
2439.0

2440.0

Emails with counsel re: status; letter to court re:
schedule; review of trial exhibit folder.
Review of draft portion of opposition to bifurcation
Review of draft memo; revise same.
Review memo in opposition to bifurcation motion;
telephone call to Scott Korenbaum; call to John
Lenoir re: same.
Review of motions, memo, and case law on
reconsideration motions by City and Mauriello.
Review of reconsideration motion.
Review of recent production from City Defendants;
review of reconsideration motions.

Drafting opposition to reconsideration motions.
Drafting opposition to reconsideration motions.
Revising opposition papers; email co -counsel;
emails to opposing counsel.
Review of schedule; review of emails.
Review of recent and prior productions by the City

0.300
0.500
1.200

2.800
3.500
1.800

3.500
3.800
4.000
2.500
0.500
7.500

2440
2441

E

Page 122

3.500
1.200

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

2442 2441.0
2442.0

C

B

Date
7/21/2015
7/22/2015

D

I

Timekeepe Description
Preparing memo in reply on reconsideration.
NBS
Drafting reply on reconsideration; review of
NBS
documentary on Schoolcraft; emails with team;
review of tape and transcript of the home invasion;
review of witness list and trial exhibits.

E

Hours
1.500

5.500

2443

2443.0

2444
2445 2444.0
2445.0
2446
2446.0

7/23/2015
8/4/2015
8/5/2015
8/7/2015

NBS

NBS
NBS
NBS

Drafting reply; review of witness list and exhibit
trial list for JPTO
Preparing JPTO draft section.
Preparing JPTO section; telephone call with team
re: same.
Review of JPTO sections from defendants;
telephone call with Brian Osterman; conference
call with Plaintiff's team re: JPTO objections; letter
to Judge Sweet oposing motion to strike reply.

5.500
4.500
5.500

3.200

2447

2447.0

8/9/2015

NBS

Review of JPTO submissions and interrogation of
sections; email team; email opposing counsel re:
schedule; review of trial assignments.
3.500

2448

2448.0

8/10/2015

NBS

2449

2449.0

8/11/2015

NBS

2450
2450.0

8/13/2015

NBS

2451

2451.0

8/14/2015

NBS

Revised JPTO; letter to court re: schedule; emails
with co -counsel; emails with opposing counsel re:
JPTO.
Revising JPTO; review defendant's depositions;
objections to exhibits.
Prepare letter motion to court re: JPTO deadlines;
review of recent production and emails re: status
with defense counsel.
Revising section of JPTO; review and inclusion in
sections from defendants; emails with opposing
counsel and co -counsel re: JPTO; conference with
John Lenoir re: rifle issues for trial.

3.500
3.500

2.800

3.500

2452

2452.0

8/16/2015

2453.0

8/17/2015

2454
2455 2454.0
2455.0

8/18/2015
8/19/2015

NBS

2453

NBS
NBS
NBS

2456

2456.0

8/20/2015

NBS

Review of Plaintiffs Trial Exhibits; review of
objections.
Review of JPTO; telephone call with Kretz; review
of letter to court from city.
Letter to court in reply on JPTO adjournment.
Preparing JPTO; review of emails; preparing
witness focus sheets; review of all defendants
exhibits for purposes of asserting objections.
Review of exhibits and serve photos on defendants
by email and fax; letter to court re: filing JPTO;
revise and file plaintiffs draft of pre-trial order.

2.800
2.500
1.500

8.500

3.800

2457

Page 123

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

No.

I

B

2457.0

Date
8/21/2015

2458.0

8/24/2015

2459.0

8/25/2015

2460.0

1

8/31/2015

2458

2459
2460

2461
2462 2461.0
2462.0

9/2/2015
9/4/2015

2463

C

D

Timekeepe Description
NBS
Preparing witness focus sheets; email opposing
counsel re status and moiton in limine deadline;
and to do (Larry Schoolcraft very sick and in
hospital).
NBS
Preparing focus sheets; email co -counsel re: mental
patient gun rights.
NBS
Review of various recordings listed on JPTO; letter
to court in opposition to motions.
NBS
Telephone conference with clerk and parties;
telephone call with John Norinsberg re status;
review of draft motion.
NBS
Telephone conference with W. Kretz re status
NBS
Review of and drafting JPTO; long tc with A
Scheinder (3x) with J Norinsberg re settlement; tc
JL re settlement; email team re same

E

Hours

4.300
1.300

5.000

1.300

0.300

4.500

2463.0

9/6/2015

NBS

Review of caselaw and statutory provisions for
obtaining disability pension; review of summary
plan description for pension benefits

3.800

2464.0

9/7/2015

NBS

Preparing for trial; preparing cross examinaiton
outlines and focus sheets for witnesses set to testify
or likely to testify for various witness assignements
fro trial team

4.500

2465.0

9/8/2015

NBS

Telephone conference with JN; tc A Schiener
(several times) re settlement; email all counsel re
JPTO and new exhibits added; tc B Osterman re
request to discontinue against JHMC (less than 6
figures)

3.500

2466.0

9/9/2015

NBS

Telephone conference with A Schiener and with co counsel re settlement (JN: PG; Harvey Levine;
Rick Guilbert) re issues pertaining to additional
pension benefits.; review of caselaw cited by the
City on pension issues

2467.0

3.200

9/11/2015

NBS

Telephone conference with A Schiener and JN re
settlement and willing to increase offer of cash
some

2468.0

0.700

9/12/2015

NBS

Preparing for trial; drafting cross outlines and
witness focus sheets for trial witnesses and their
key points

5.500

2469.0

9/15/2015

NBS

2464

2465

2466

2467

2468

2469

2470

Telephone conference with A Scheirer re no deal
w/o pension benefit; tc JN re status; drafting
detailed settlement memo to cleint on settlement

Page 124

3.800

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

D

C

B

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

2470.0

1

9/16/2015

NBS

2471
2472 2471.0
2473 2472.0
2474 2473.0
2474.0
2475
2476 2475.0
2477 2476.0
2477.0
2478
2478.0
2479
2480 2479.0
2481 2480.0
2482 2481.0
2482.0
2483
2483.0
2484
2485 2484.0
2486 2485.0
2487 2486.0
2488 2487.0
2489 2488.0
2490 2489.0
2491 2490.0
2492 2491.0
2493 2492.0
2493.0
2494
2494.0
2495
2496 2495.0
2497 2496.0
2497.0

12/31/2014
1/10/2015
1/11/2015
1/11/2015
1/14/2015
1/16/2015
1/19/2015

1/31/2015

2/1/2015
2/3/2015
2/5/2015
2/6/2015

JM
JM
JM
JM
JM
JM
JM

JM
JM
JM
JM
JM

2499
2500 2499.0

Review of CompStat videos.
Review of CompStat videos.
Telephone conference discussing Schoolcraft and
CompStat.
Email communication of summary judgment City
response.
Email of summary judgment City response.
Email correspondence of City response
Email of summary judgment on City reponse
Email regarding summary judgment to City reponse

2.800
1.500

4.000
2.000
0.750
3.000
11.000

0.590
0.090
0.090
0.090
0.090

0.090
2/12/2015
9/7/2014
9/8/2014
9/9/2014
9/10/2014
9/16/2014
9/17/2014
9/23/2014
9/24/2014
9/25/2014
9/30/2014
9/30/2014
10/1/2014
10/1/2014
10/2/2014

JM
JLL
JLL
JLL
JLL
JLL
JLL
JLL
JLL
JLL
JS

JS
JS
JS
JS

2498
2498.0

Telephone conference with A Scheiner; conf call
with JN and GC re settlement; revised detailed
memo to client re settlement; tc JL re same; email
cleint re settlement
Office meeting
Review of CompStat videos
Review of CompStat videos
Discussions of Compstat and Schoolcraft materials.

E

Hours

10/2/2014

10/3/2014

JS

Is

Email exchange for summary judgment for City
response.
Read Schoolcraft deposition.
Read Schoolcraft deposition
Read Schoolcraft deposition
Read Schoolcraft deposition.
Ferrara summary deposition
Ferrara summary deposition.
Ferrara summary deposition
Ferrara and Broschart summary deposition.
Broschart summary deposition
Reading, taking notes and discussing the
Schoolcraft depositions
Reading, taking notes and discussing the
Schoolcraft depositions.
Reading and taking notes on "NYPD Tapes."
Reading and taking notes on NYPD tapes
Reading and taking notes on Schoolcraft
Depositions; listening to and discussing Schoolcraft
tapes from October 31, 2009.
Reading and taking notes on the Schoolcraft
depositions; listening to and discussing the
Schoolcraft tapes from October 31. 2009.
Trainor summary deposition.

Page 125

0.090
2.000
2.000
2.000
2.000
2.000
2.000
8.000
8.000
8.000
5.500

5.500
1.500
3.500

4.430

5.000
5.000

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

No.

2500.0

Date
10/6/2014

2501.0

1

10/7/2014

2501
2502
2503 2502.0
2503.0
2504
2504.0
2505
2505.0
2506
2507 2506.0
2507.0
2508
2508.0
2509
2510 2509.0
2511 2510.0
2511.0
2512
2512.0
2513
2513.0
2514
2514.0
2515
2516 2515.0
2517 2516.0
2518 2517.0
2519 2518.0
2520 2519.0
2521 2520.0
2521.0
2522
2523 2522.0
2524 2523.0
2525 2524.0
2525.0

2526
2527
2528
2529
2530

2526.0
2527.0
2528.0
2529.0

C

B

10/8/2014
10/8/2014
10/9/2014

10/9/2014
10/8/2014
10/9/2014

10/10/2014

JS

10/9/2014
10/14/2014
10/14/2014

LS
JS
JS

10/15/2014

JS

10/16/2014

JLL

10/17/2014

JLL

10/19/2014
10/20/2014
10/21/2014
10/22/2014
10/21/2014
10/23/2014
10/23/2014

JLL
JLL
LS
JLL

10/24/2014
10/27/2014
10/28/2014
10/29/2014

10/30/2014
10/31/2014
11/3/2014
11/7/2014

D

Timekeepe Description
JS
Reading, taking notes, and discussing the
Schoolcraft depositions.
JS
Reading and taking notes and discussing the
Schoolcraft depositions.
LS
Trainor summary deposition
JLL
Mauriello deposition summary - session 2 with
errata sheet.
JS
Reading, taking notes and discussing the
Schoolcraft depositions.
JS
Reading, taking notes, and discussing the
Schoolcraft depositions
LS
Trainor summary deposition.
JLL
Drafting deposition summary - session 2 with errata
I

LS

JLL
JS
LS
LS

LS
JS

LS
LS
LS
LS

sheet.
Reading, taking notes and discussing the
Schoolcraft depositions
Trainor summary deposition.
Reading and taking notes.
Reading and taking notes on the Schoolcraft
depositions.
Reading and discussing the Schoolcraft
depositions.
Mauriello deposition summary - session 2 with
errata sheet.
Mauriello deposition summary - session 2 with
errata sheet.
Shantel James deposition summary.
Shantel James deposition summary.
Gough deposition summary.
Kurt Duncan deposition summary.
Gough deposition summary.
Kurt Duncan deposition summary.
Listening to radio police calls on disc 10, 22 and
Schoolcraft surveillance videos.
Sawyer deposition summary
Sawyer deposition summary.
Sawyer deposition summary.
Reviewing surveillance videos of Adrian's house
and writing summaries of these videos along with
other documents on the CD's
from the Schoolcraft file.

Sawyer deposition summary.
Gough deposition summary
Summarize Gough deposition transcript.
Summarize Marquez deposition transcript.
Page 126

E

Hours
1.000

2.500
5.000
3.000

2.000
1.750
5.000

2.000
1.000

2.000
3.000
3.000
2.000
8.000

4.000
3.000
2.000
4.000
5.000
4.000
3.000
4.000
4.000
4.000
4.000

2.000
3.000
4.000
3.000
4.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

1

B

E

D

C

Timekeepe Description
Summarize Marquez deposition transcript.
LS
11/10/2014
Summarize Marquez deposition transcript.
LS
11/12/2014
Summarize deposition of Sangetti.
LS
11/13/2014
Summarized deposition of Larry Schoolcraft.
LS
11/14/2014
Summarize deposition of Sangetti
11/14/2014 LS
Summarize deposition of Sangetti
LS
11/16/2014
Summarize deposition of Sangetti
LS
11/17/2014

Date

.

2531 2530.0
2532 2531.0
2533 2532.0
2534 2533.0
2535 2534.0
2536 2535.0
2537 2536.0
2538 2537.0
2539 2538.0
2540 2539.0
2541 2540.0
2542 2541.0
2543 2542.0
2544 2543.0
2545 2544.0
2546 2545.0
2547 2546.0
2548 2547.0
2549 2548.0
2550 2549.0

2551 2550.0
2552 2551.0
2553 2552.0
2554 2553.0
2555 2554.0
2556 2555.0
2557 2556.0
2558 2557.0
2559 2558.0
2560 2559.0
2561 2560.0
2562 2561.0
2563 2562.0
2564 2563.0
2565 2564.0
2566 2565.0
2567 2566.0
2568 2567.0
2569 2568.0
2570 2569.0
2571 2570.0
2572 2571.0
2573 2572.0
2574 2573.0
2575 2574.0

JLL
11/20/2014
JLL
11/23/2014
LS
11/24/2014
JLL
11/25/2014
11/24/2014 LS
JLL
11/26/2014
LS
11/28/2014
11/28/2014 JLL
JLL
11/29/2014
JLL
11/30/2014
11/28/2014 LS
LS
12/1/2014
12/1/2014 LS
12/1/2014 JLL
JLL
12/2/2014
JLL
12/4/2014
LS
12/5/2014
LS
12/6/2014
12/6/2014 LS
LS
12/8/2014
LS
12/9/2014
12/9/2014 JLL
LS
12/10/2014
12/10/2014 JLL
LS
12/11/2014
JLL
12/11/2014
JLL
12/12/2014
JLL
12/13/2014
LS
12/15/2014
LS
12/16/2014
LS
12/17/2014
LS
12/18/2014
LS
12/21/2014
LS
12/22/2014
LS
12/24/2014
LS
12/26/2014
LS
12/27/2014
LS
12/28/2014

Summarized deposition of Larry Schoolcraft.
Summarize deposition of Larry Schoolcraft.
Summarize deposition of Dr. Patel
Summarize deposition of Larry Schoolcraft.
Summarize deposition of Dr. Patel.
Summarize deposition of Larry Schoolcraft.
Summarize deposition of Purpi
Summarize deposition of Steven Mauriello.
Summarize deposition Steven Mauriello
Summarize deposition of Steven Mauriello.
Summarize deposition of Purpi.
Summarize deposition of Dr. Patel
Summarize deposition of Purpi.
Summarize deposition of Steven Mauriello,
Summarize deposition of Steven Mauriello.
Summarize deposition of Steven Mauriello.
Summarize deposition of Dr. Lwin.
Summarize deposition of Dhar.
Summarize deposition of Dr. Lwin.
Summarize deposition of Dhar.
Summarize deposition of Dhar.
Summarize deposition of Dominick Valenti.
Summarize deposition of Carrasco.
Summarize deposition of Dominick Valenti
Summarize deposition of Dhar.
Summarize deposition of Kevin Finnegan.
Summarize deposition of Kevin Finnegan.
Summarize deposition of Bernard Whalen.
Summarize deposition of Cooper.
Summarize deposition of Cooper
Summarize deposition of Cooper.
Summarize deposition of Cooper
Summarize deposition of Maffia.
Summarize deposition of Maffia.
Summarized Lubit deposition.
Summarized Lubit deposition.
Summarized Lubit deposition
Summarized Lubit deposition
Page 127

Hours

4.500
5.000
4.000
2.000
4.000
2.000
4.000
5.000
5.000
4.000
5.000
3.000
5.000
3.500
2.000
1.000

2.000
3.500
2.000
1.000

4.000
6.000
4.000
3.000
4.000
1.000

4.000
4.000
1.000

4.000
8.000
2.000
3.000
3.000
2.500
3.000
4.000
3.000
2.000
3.000
3.000
4.000
3.000
4.000
4.000

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A
1

No.

2576 2575.0
2577 2576.0
2578 2577.0
2579 2578.0
2580 2579.0
2581 2580.0
2582 2581.0
2583 2582.0
2584 2583.0
2585 2584.0
2586 2585.0
2587 2586.0
2588 2587.0
2589 2588.0
2589.0
2590
2590.0
2591
2591.0
2592
2592.0
2593
2593.0
2594
2594.0
2595
2595.0
2596
2596.0
2597
2597.0
2598
2598.0
2599
2599.0
2600
2600.0
2601
2601.0
2602
2603 2602.0
2604 2603.0
2604.0
2605

B

Date

C

D

12/29/2014
12/30/2014
1/1/2015
1/2/2015
1/3/2015
1/3/2015
1/5/2015
1/7/2015
1/8/2015
1/9/2015
1/12/2015
1/13/2015
1/14/2015
1/22/2015
1/29/2015

Timekeepe Description
LS
Summarized Lubit deposition.
LS
Summarize Halpren-Ruder deposition.
LS
Summarize Halpren-Ruder deposition.
LS
Summarize Halpren-Ruder deposition.
LS
Summarize Lauterborn deposition.
LS
Summarize Halpren-Ruder deposition
LS
Summarize Lauterborn deposition.
LS
Summarize Marino deposition transcript.
LS
Summarize Marino deposition transcript.
LS
Summarize Marino deposition transcript.
LS
Summarized Lubit deposition
LS
Summarized Lubit deposition
LS
Summarized Lubit deposition
LS
Summarized Lubit deposition.
LS
Silverman deposition summary for expert witness.

1/29/2015

JS

1/30/2015

LS

2/2/2015

LS

2/3/2015

JS

2/2/2015

LS

Reviewing and taking notes on CompStat meeting
videos.
Silverman deposition summary for expert witness.

2/4/2015

LS

Silverman deposition summary for expert witness.

2/4/2015

JS

2/5/2015

JS

2/5/2015

LS

2/6/2015

LS

2/9/2015

LS

2/10/2015

LS

2/10/2015
2/11/2015
2/11/2015

JLL
JLL

Reviewing and taking notes on CompStat meeting
videos
Reviewing and taking notes on CompStat meeting
videos
Summarized Adrian Schoolcraft deposition
transript.
Summarize Adrian Schoolcraft deposition
transcript.
Summarize Adrian Schoolcraft deposition
transcript.
Summarize Adrian Schoolcraft deposition
transcript.
Summary of Whittman deposition transcript.
Summarize Whittman deposition transcript.
Summarize Adrian Schoolcraft deposition
transcript.

E

Hours

4.000
3.500
3.500
4.000
3.000
1.000

3.000
3.000
3.000
2.000
4.000
4.000
2.000
1.000
5.000

Reviewing and taking notes on CompStat meeting
videos.
Silverman deposition summary for expert witness.

6.000
4.000

Silverman deposition summary for expert witness.
4.000
6.000
5.000

2.000

LS

Page 128

2.000
6.000

4.000

4.000

4.000
4.000
1.000

2.000
4.000

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

2605.0

Date
2/12/2015

2606
2606.0

2/13/2015

2607

2607.0
2608
2609 2608.0
2610 2609.0
2610.0
2611
2612 2611.0
2613 2612.0
2614 2613.0
2614.0
2615
2615.0
2616
2617 2616.0
2618 2617.0
2618.0
2619
2620 2619.0
2621 2620.0
2622 2621.0
2623 2622.0
2623.0
2624
2625 2624.0
2626 2625.0
2627 2626.0
2628 2627.0
2628.0
2629
2630 2629.0
2630.0
2631
2632 2631.0
2633 2632.0
2633.0

2634
2635 2634.0
2636 2635.0
2637 2636.0

2/16/2015
2/16/2015
2/17/2015
2/17/2015
03/08/15
08/09/12
11/23/10
02/21/15

D

C

B

E

_

Timekeepe Description
Summarize Adrian Schoolcraft deposition
LS
transcript.
Summarize Adrian Schoolcraft deposition
LS
transcript.
Summarize Adrian Schoolcraft deposition
LS
transcript.
Summarize Milone deposition transcript.
JLL
Summarize Milone deposition transcript.
JLL
Summarize Adrian Schoolcraft in Floyd deposition
LS
transcript.
Review of Deposition of AS with Exhibits
JPF
Meeting w/ AS in Albany
JPF
Draft of Argument
JPF
Review of Schoolcraft discovery/deps - Caughey
JPF

Hours

_____ _.

4.000

4.000
3.000
1.500

3.500
3.000
6.250
5.750
5.600
5.600

03/01/15
04/02/15
12/05/10
02/19/15
11/18/10
01/10/12
06/19/12
12/06/10
02/16/15

02/22/15
11/22/10
12/03/10
04/24/12
03/04/15

07/21/10
09/15/12

03/27/15
04/10/12
02/18/15

03/30/15
11/26/10
12/04/10

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF

Review of Schoolcraft discovery/deps Broschart/Sawyer
Draft motion in lim
Edit and Incorporate changes on argument
Review of deposition exhibits & depositions Lauderborn
Draft of argument
Meeting with AS, IN and GC
Meeting w/ Schoolcraft in Johnstown
Review and edit argument
Review of deposition exhibits &
depositions
Review of Schoolcraft discovery/deps - Gough
Draft of Argument
Draft of argument
Research on 1st Amendment claims for motion
Review of Schoolcraft discovery/deps - Duncan
Review of Schoolcraft documents & tapes
Reviewed/listened to IAB recordings provided by
the City re: investigation into Schoolcraft matter
Draft motion in lim
Meeting w/ AS
Review of deposition exhibits & depositions -.
Marino
Draft motion in lim
Draft of Argument
Review and edit argument for brief
Page 129

5.500
5.250
5.250
5.250
4.900
4.900
4.800
4.800
4.800
4.800
4.750
4.750
4.750
4.750
4.750

4.750
4.600
4.600

4.500
4.400
4.400
4.400

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A
1

No.

2638 2637.0
2639 2638.0
2639.0
2640
2641 2640.0
2641.0
2642
2642.0
2643
2644 2643.0
2645 2644.0
2646 2645.0
2646.0
2647
2647.0
2648
2649 2648.0
2650 2649.0
2651 2650.0
2652 2651.0
2652.0
2653
2654 2653.0
2655 2654.0
2656 2655.0
2656.0
2657
2657.0
2658
2659 2658.0
2659.0
2660
2660.0
2661
2661.0
2662
2662.0
2663
2663.0
2664
2664.0
2665
2666 2665.0
2667 2666.0

B

Date

04/03/15
07/12/10
02/25/15

C

D

Timekeepe Description
JPF
Review and edit motion in lim

JPF
JPF

03/17/15
11/10/10

JPF
JPF

02/24/15

JPF

07/03/10
07/17/10
03/14/15
11/18/10

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

11/20/10

JPF

03/11/15
10/10/12
03/31/15
12/04/10
11/19/10

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

02/15/15
07/18/10
11/24/10
11/21/10

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

02/23/15

JPF

04/01/15
07/02/10

JPF
JPF

11/11/10

JPF

02/17/15

JPF

08/01/10

JPF

Review of Schoolcraft tapes
Review of Schoolcraft discovery/deps Lamstein/Sanganetti/Marquez
Draft motion in lim
Research on hospitaf confinement constituting state
action under any of the three tests
Review of Schoolcraft discovery/deps - Huffman
Review of Schoolcraft recordings
Review of Schoolcraft tapes
Draft motion in lira
Research on joint action w/ private parties and
police in the context of false arrest claims
Research on state action - use of private facilities to
imprison
Review of Discovery and Dpeositions - Weiss
Review of IAB recordings
Draft motion in lim
Draft of argument
Research on joint action w/ private parties and
police in the context of false arrest claims
Review of deposition exhibits & depositions
Review of Schoofcraft tapes
Draft of Argument
Research on joint action where state coerces private
action
Review of Schoolcraft discovery/deps - Larry
Schoolcraft
Draft motion in lim
Research of Labor Law 215-a for potential claim

E

Hours

4.400
4.400
4.300
4.250

4.250

4.250
4.250
4.250
4.200
4.100

4.100
4.100
4.100
3.900
3.900
3.900
3.900
3.900
3.800

3.800
3.800
3.750

3.750

Research on state action standard for private parties
- joint action test
Review of deposition exhibits & depositions Mauriello
Review of new documents and recording CD from
AS

3.750
3.750
3.750

02/28/15

JPF

Review of Schoolcraft discovery/deps - Boston

03/02/15

JPF

03/14/15
04/22/12

JPF
JPF

Review of Schoolcraft discovery/deps Sawyer/Duncan
Draft motion in lim
Research on 1st Amendment claim

3.750

Page 130

3.750
3.600
3.600

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

B

No.

Date

2667.0

11/08/10

2668.0

03/09/15

2669
2670 2669.0
2671 2670.0
2671.0

07/14/10
06/17/12
02/10/15

1

2668

2672

2672.0

02/20/15

2673.0

11/15/10

2673

2674
2675 2674.0
2675.0
2676
2676.0
2677
2678 2677.0
2679 2678.0
2680 2679.0
2681 2680.0
2681.0

11/19/10
02/07/12
11/20/10

02/26/15
07/15/10
08/01/10
03/19/15
10/17/12

2682

2682.0
2683
2684 2683.0
2684.0
2685
2685.0
2686
2687 2686.0
2687.0
2688
2688.0

03/27/15

04/04/15
09/20/10

Timekeepe Description
Research on involuntary confinement & state
JPF
action
Review of reply memo & supporting docs filed by
JPF
all defendants
Review of Schoolcraft tapes
JPF
Draft motion for reconsideration
JPF
Meeting w/ GC & JN regarding global trial
JPF
strategy, witnesses to be called (or not called),
exhibits to use, Rule 68 offer and next steps for
moving forward.
Meeting w/ TEAM to discuss trial strategy,
JPF
division of labor, motions
Research on conspiracy under §1983 versus state
JPF
action
Draft argument
JPF
Read and review of JHMC medicals (full set from
JPF
hospital)
Research on joint action where state coerces private
JPF
action
Review of Schoolcraft discovery/deps - James
JPF
Review of Schoolcraft tapes
JPF
Review of Schoolcraft tapes & timeline
JPF
Draft motion in lim
JPF
Meeting w/JN & GC re: City's privilege claims and
JPF
possible arguments/motions to defeat such claims
highlights of Lauterborn interview &
inconsistencies w/ Marino & home invasion
recording
Research on motion in lim re IAB doc admission &
JPF
opinions in them
Review and edit motion in lim
JPF
Review of deposition of Mauriello from Floyd case
JPF

E

Hours

3.600
3.600
3.600
3.500

3.500
3.500

3.500
3.400
3.400

3.400
3.400
3.400
3.400
3.300

3.300

3.300
3.300
3.300

02/12/15

03/28/15
04/24/12

Review of Memo of Law in Opp to plaintiffs
motion for SJ
Draft motion in lim
Draft of motion to Amend 1st Amendment claim

JPF

JPF
JPF

3.300
3.250
3.250

J

08/31/10

JPF

2689

2689.0

D

C

08/27/10

JPF

Interview with GC of "DH" and "EB" former
NYPD, reviewed materials, recordings re: quotas,
downgrading
Interview with GC of Walter Cipscomb, former PO
confirms quotas - wants to help Schoolcraft

3.250

3.250

2690

Page 131

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

I

D

2690.0

Date
09/27/10

2691.0

06/25/10

2692.0

07/30/10

JPF

05/05/15
11/15/10

JPF
JPF

Meeting with JN, GC, Polanco & Raymond re:
Schoolcraft & Monell claim
Read and review Ct's Opinion on SJ
Research on close nexus test and private parties

03/07/15

JPF

07/23/12

JPF

Research on prior restrain, retaliation, and
protected speech/law enforcement under Tachler

2697.0

03/10/15

JPF

2698.0

02/25/15

JPF

Research on ultimate issue, bolstering w/ prior
litigation for Bernier
Review of Schoolcraft discovery/deps - Valenti

2699.0

07/31/10

JPF

2700
2701 2700.0
2701.0

09/22/10
10/26/10

JPF
JPF

2702.0

06/14/12

JPF

2703.0

11/21/10

JPF

2704
2705 2704.0
2705.0

03/05/15
06/18/12

JPF
JPF

2706.0
2707.0
2708.0
2709.0
2710.0
2711.0

12/05/10
12/02/10
07/22/10
07/31/10
06/26/10
09/27/10

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

2712
2713 2712.0
2714 2713.0
2715 2714.0
2716 2715.0
2717 2716.0

04/23/12
09/25/12
10/08/12
07/06/10
07/24/15

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

E

Research on press & statements made by counsel

No.

1

2691

Timekeepe Description
JPF
Meeting w/AS witkr JN, GC to prep for discussion
with US attorneys office EDNY
JPF
Meeting w/JN and GC re: scope of Schoolcraft
materials that need to be reviewed for complaint

2692

3.250

3.250

2693
2694 2693.0
2694.0
2695
2695.0
2696
2696.0

3.250
3.250
3.250
3.250

2697

3.250

2698
2699

3.250
3.250

Meeting with Polanco, Raymond, JN, GC re:
quotas and Monell Claim
Meeting with DOJ EDNY
Meeting with GC and "RC" to discuss experience
with quotas in a Brooklyn North precinct

2702

3.200
3.100

3.100

2703

2706
2707
2708
2709
2710
2711

Hours

Research on 1st Amendment cases cited in Judge's
opinion
Research on hospital state action where EDPs are
involved
Research on prior litigiousness exclusion
Review and edit and incorporate additions
suggested by JN and GC on Motion for
Reconsideration
Review of argument
Review of Memo of Law argument
Review of Schoolcraft documents & tapes
Review of Schoolcraft tapes & timeline
Review of Schoolcraft's medical records
Schoolcraft interview with Civil Rights Division
JN, GC, DOJ
Draft of letter on 1st Amendment claims
Meeting w/ AS & GC & JN re dep prep
Prep w/ AS for dep
Research Labor Law issue
Schoolcraft team meeting
Page 132

3.100

3.100
3.100

3.100
3.100
3.100
3.100
3.100
3.100

3.100
2.900
2.900
2.900
2.900
2.900

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

2718
2719
2720
2721
2722
2723

D

C

B

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

2717.0

06/18/12
07/28/12
06/17/12
07/31/10
06/15/12
07/09/12
05/14/11

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

2718.0

2719.0
2720.0
2721.0
2722.0
2723.0

2724
2724.0

09/03/10

JPF

2725
2725.0
2726
2727 2726.0
2728 2727.0
2728.0
2729
2729.0
2730
2730.0
2731
2731.0
2732
2732.0
2733
2734 2733.0
2735 2734.0
2736 2735.0
2736.0
2737
2738 2737.0
2738.0
2739
2739.0
2740
2740.0

08/25/10
03/09/15
07/22/12
07/20/12

JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF

Draft motion for reconsideration
Draft of motion to amend
Research on prior restraint
Revision of Complaint
Draft motion for reconsideration
Draft reply motion for reconsideration
Meeting with GC reviewing Requests For
Admission's (RFA's)
Meeting with GC with PO from 81st precinct "MG"
re: corruption
Meeting with GC, PO from 81st precinct "PF" re:
corruption
Research on lAB conclusions & admissibility
Research on prior restrain
Research on retaliation and protected speech issue

E

Hours

2.800
2.800
2.800
2.800
2.750
2.750
2.750

2.750
2.750
2.750
2.750

2.750
11/11/10

08/23/12

JPF

JPF

Research on traditional function state action test
"hospital used as jail"
Review of disocvery provided by City defendants

2.750
2.750

08/05/10
08/06/10

09/27/11
04/06/15
07/30/12
05/08/12

07/30/10
09/20/10
06/25/10
08/28/15

JPF

JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

Review of transcribed tape recording from August
& March 2009 from Legal Language
Review of transcripts from Legal Language re June
2009 roll calls, Halloween Night, & visits to
Johnston
Research re law enforcement privilege
Review and edit motion in lim
Review and edit motion to amend
Review and prep response to defendant's 1st
Amendment letter
Revision of Complaint
Meeting with GC with PO "JB" re: NYPD quotas
and downgrading
Review of Schoolcraft 's Patrolmens Benevolent
Associtation ("PBA") contract
Draft additional sections to motions in lim re rifle
pictues, Queens DA & prior complaints made by

2.750

2.750
2.600
2.600
2.600
2.600
2.600

2.500
2.500

AS

2741
2741.0
2742
2743 2742.0
2743.0
2744
2744.0
2745

03/12/15
10/07/12
06/15/12

JPF

JPF
JPF

2.400

Meting w/ GC, JN, NS, and Jon Lenoir ("JL") re
trial, motions
QAD interview review
Research on prior restraint and Carcetti progeny

2.400
2.400

2.400
05/23/11

JPF

Review and Edit discovery demands and rogs
against all defendants
Page 133

2.400

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

2745.0
2746.0

09/17/10

2746
2747
2748 2747.0
2748.0
2749
2750 2749.0
2751 2750.0
2751.0
2752
2753 2752.0
2753.0
2754
2755 2754.0
2756 2755.0
2757 2756.0
2757.0

C

B

Date
08/17/11

No.

1

04/25/12
11/04/10

09/24/12
01/26/11
03/04/15
03/09/12
02/12/15

09/21/10
08/03/10
11/20/10
10/30/10

D

Timekeepe Description
JPF
Review of responses to requests & discovery
demands from hospital defendants
JPF
Reviewed documents and depositions from the
Floyd litigation for purposes of Monell claim
JPF
Final review & edit 1st Amendment letter
JPF
Meeting with GC and police officer "BP" re:
quotas, downgrading, and NYPD corruption
JPF
Prep AS fro his dep
JPF
Prep for oral argument
JPF
Research of racial comments & exclusion for
motion in lira
JPF
Research on 1st Amendment claims
JPF
Review of 56.1 counter statements from JHMC,
City, Mauriello, & Isacov
JPF
Review of Angel Heran depo from Floyd
JPF
Review of Complaint edits by JN
JPF
Draft of Argument
JPF
Meeting with GC & JN re: information provided by
MR, MG RC whistleblower cops and movie and
book publicist contacting AS for information

2758

E

Hours

2.400
2.400
2.300
2.300
2.300
2.300
2.300
2.300
2.300
2.300
2.300
2.250

2.250

2758.0

09/23/10

JPF

2759.0

06/14/12

JPF

06/16/12
02/13/11
03/27/15

JPF
JPF
JPF

2759

2760
2761 2760.0
2762 2761.0
2762.0
2763
2763.0
2764
2765 2764.0
2766 2765.0
2767 2766.0
2767.0
2768
2768.0
2769
2769.0
2770
2770.0
2771
2771.0
2772

Meeting with GC, JN and Center for Constitutional
Rights (CCR) re Schoolcraft
Read and review Opinion and Order on 1st
Amendment and Motion to Quash and notes on
same
Research on prior restraint
Review and Edit letter brief opposing stay
Review of Draft Direct Examination of AS from
GC

08/15/11

JPF

07/09/10
07/23/12
07/29/12
07/26/10

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

05/11/12

JPF

06/20/10

JPF

07/08/12

JPF

03/06/15

JPF

2.250

2.250
2.250
2.250
2.250

Review of responses to Bernier & Jamaica
discovery demands
Review of Schoolcraft timeline prepared by JN
Draft motion to amend
Draft of motion to amend
Meeting with JN & GC re case & updates on
Brendan Delpozo
Read and review of defendant's letter to quash and
discussion w/ GC & JN
Reading Village Voice articles on; Schoolcraft and
Halloween night
Research cases cited in defendant's brief in opp in
preparation of reply
Research on limitations of witness examinations

2.250
2.250
2.100
2.100

2.100
2.100
2.100
2.100
2.100

Page 134

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

D

C

B

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

2772.0

1

03/28/15

JPF

2773
2774 2773.0
2774.0
2775
2776 2775.0
2777 2776.0
2778 2777.0
2779 2778.0
2780 2779.0
2780.0
2781
2781.0

05/08/12
08/05/10
03/19/15
08/31/10
04/02/15
11/21/10
09/21/10
10/04/10

09/01/10

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

Research on motion in lim conclusions re
credibility admissibility
Review caselaw in defendant's letter
Review of Complaint with client's chain of events
& correction
Review of James Cross outline
Drafting Amended Complaint
Meeting with JN and NS team
Research on joint action
Review of Donald McHugh depo from Floyd
Meeting w/ GC and "JR" retired police officer re:
quotas, downgrading, NYPD corruption
Meeting w/JN and GC re: discuss anonymous POs
contacting and how they can help Schoolcraft

E

Hours

2.100
2.100
2.100
2.100
1.900
1.900
1.900
1.900

1.800

1.800

2782

2782.0
2783
2784 2783.0
2784.0
2785
2786 2785.0
2786.0
2787
2787.0
2788
2789 2788.0
2790 2789.0
2790.0
2791
2791.0
2792
2792.0
2793
2793.0
2794
2795 2794.0
2796 2795.0
2797 2796.0
2798 2797.0
2799 2798.0
2799.0
2800
2801 2800.0

10/07/10

05/09/12
08/04/10

08/03/10
07/08/11
09/24/10

JPF

JPF
JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF

Meeting with GC and "EB" retired police officer
re: quotas, downgrading, NYPD corruption
Review of cases & letter in prep of argument
Review of client's chain of events for Complaint

Revise and edit of Complaint
Discussion with GC and JN re: meeting with Jim
Leander and AS about investigation
Discussion with JN and GC re: first meeting with
the DOJ and upcoming meeting with the DOJ and
AS

12/01/10
06/16/12
08/25/10

09/24/12
05/09/11

07/06/10
12/06/10
06/18/12
03/16/15
06/19/12
06/19/12
02/10/12

08/09/10

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

JPF
JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

Draft factual section of opp
Draft motion for reconsideration
Meeting w/JN and GC re: ACC assigned,
Schoolcraft initial disclosures
Meeting w/JN and GC to discuss City deficiency
letter and AS dep prep
Meeting with JN and GC re: neccesary disclosures
under Rule 26 for plaitniff
Meeting w/JN and JF re: new whistleblower
contacted JN re: Schoolcraft
Review and edit brief
Review and edit Motion for Reconsideration
Review of Direct Examinaiton Outline for AS
Travel back to NYC from Johnstown (3.5)
Travel to Johnstown (3.5)
Discussion w/ JN & GC re additional items of
discovery
Edit/Revise Complaint
Page 135

1.800
1.800
1.800
1.800
1.750

1.750
1.750
1.750

1.750
1.750
1.750

1.300
1.750
1.750
1.750
1.750
1.750
1.600
1.600

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A
1

No.

2801.0
2802
2803 2802.0
2803.0
2804
2804.0
2805
2806 2805.0
2806.0
2807
2807.0
2808
2809 2808.0
2809.0
2810
2811 2810.0
2811.0
2812
2812.0
2813
2813.0

B

Date
03/14/12
08/08/10
11/11/10
01/20/12

C

D

Timekeepe Description
JPF
Editing Amended Complaint to add 1st
Amendment facts & law
JPF
Editing Complaint with additional allegations
JPF
Meeting with GC and "JW" cop to discuss
quotas/retaliation
JPF
Phone call with Larry Schoolcraft re discovery &
EBTs

05/19/11
05/20/11

JPF
JPF

03/10/15

JPF

07/07/10
08/09/10

JPF
JPF

05/12/15
01/10/11

JPF
JPF

08/26/10

JPF

07/29/10

JPF

2814.0

10/12/10

JPF

08/09/12
08/09/12
07/22/10
09/04/10
06/25/10

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

2820.0

10/27/10

JPF

2821.0

05/10/11

JPF

Traveled from Albany back to NYC (3.0)
Traveled to Albany to meet Client (3.0)
Discussed causes of action w/GC
Drafting Amended Complaint
Meeting with GC & JN re: possible discovery
demands after suit is filed
Meeting with GC and David Velez re: arbitration,
quotas, Michael Marino
Meeting with JN and GC re: edits to Intial
disclosures and discussion regarding requests to
admit

2822.0

10/10/10

JPF

2823.0

09/03/10

JPF

Meeting with JN and GC re: infromatoin provided
by MV, NB, EB whistleblower cops
Meeting with JN and GC to discuss infromation
provided by DH, MG, EB whistleblower cops in
furtherance of the Monell claim

2824
2825 2824.0
2826 2825.0

11/21/10
04/05/12

JPF
JPF

Research on supplement jurisdiction
Review & edit response to City's interogs

Hours
1.600
1.600
1.600
1.600
1.600

Review of Motion to Dismiss by Jamaica Hosp.

2815.0
2816.0
2817.0
2818.0
2819.0

E

2814
2815
2816
2817
2818
2819

2820
2821

2822

2823

Review & edit demands & interrogatories
Discussion w/ GC & JN re request to admit
corrections/additions
Discussion with GC to help outline AS direct
exmaination
Meeting w/ only with AS
Meeting w/JN and GC re: Schoolcraft website to
support Monell threory
Meeting w/NS team JN and GC pre-conf
Meeting with GC & JN re interrogatories and
demands
Meeting with GC and JN re: interview of PO from
81st precinct "PF" re: corruption
Meeting with JN and Rocco P - Daily News re
Schoolcraft and evidence of quotas for Monell
claim

Page 136

1.500
1.500
1.500
1.500
1.500
1.500

1.500

1.500
1.500
1.500
1.500
1.400
1.400
1.400
1.400

1.400

1.400

1.400
1.400
1.400

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

2826.0

Date
06/23/11

D

C

B

Timekeepe Description
Review of answers to interrogatories by lsacov
JPF

E

Hours
1.400

2827

2827.0
2828
2829 2828.0
2830 2829.0
2831 2830.0
2831.0
2832
2832.0
2833
2833.0
2834
2835 2834.0
2836 2835.0
2836.0
2837
2837.0
2838
2838.0
2839
2839.0

02/11/15

07/26/10
03/23/15
08/04/10
02/02/15
03/16/15

05/10/12
07/09/12
12/07/10
05/20/11

07/06/10
08/08/12
09/17/10

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF

2840

2840.0

07/05/12

JPF

2841

2841.0
2842
2843 2842.0
2843.0
2844
2844.0
2845
2845.0
2846
2846.0
2847
2847.0
2848
2848.0
2849
2849.0
2850

07/22/12
12/01/10
12/08/10

JPF

JPF
JPF

Review of declarations from City, Berniers, Isacov,
& JHMC w/ accompanying exhibits
Review of draft of Complaint prepared by GC
Review of Sawyer cross examaintion outline
Revise and edit Complaint
Discussion w/ GC & JN re representing AS again
for trial
Discussion with GC re: AS direct examination and
points to cover, strategy
Draft letter providing supplemental authority in
response to defendant's opp
Edit reply
Final review & edit of brief
Finalize interrogatories & discuss EBTs w/ JN &
GC
Meeting w/JN and GC re: new whistleblower
contacted JN re: Schoolcraft
Meeting w/ JN & GC re meeting w/ AS in Albany
for prep
Meeting with JN and GC regarding infromation
obtained from Floyd litigation and its impact on
Schoolcrafts Monell and Retaliation claims
Read and review of defendant's opp to plaintiffs
motion for reconsideration
Review of complaint for allegations conforming to
plaintiffs 2nd motion to amend
Review of Complaint for facts
Review of NYPD Memos re anti quota legislation

1.400
1.400
1.400
1.400

1.300
1.300
1.300
1.300
1.300

1.300
1.300
1.300

1.300
1.300
1.300
1.300
1.300

02/11/15
08/17/11
05/19/11

09/28/11

04/23/12
08/19/10

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

JPF
JPF

Review of witness/exhibit list from JN and discuss
with GC
Discuss confidentiality stip w/ GC & JN b/c of
plaintiffs objections
Discuss w/ JN & GC edits & topic areas that should
be explored on interrogatories
Discussion w/ JN and GC re law enforcement
privilege & motion to compel
Discussion w/ Larry Schoolcraft re amendments to
complaint
Discussion with GC and JN re: new recordings and
documents provided by AS

Page 137

1.300

1.250

1.250
1.250
1.250

1.250

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

C

B

1

D

Date

Timekeepe Description

2850.0

03/09/12

JPF

2851.0

06/28/10

JPF

2852.0

10/13/10

JPF

12/04/10
07/10/12
06/20/12

JPF
JPF
JPF

04/08/15
07/30/10

JPF
JPF

07/14/10

JPF

07/27/10
03/01/11

JPF
JPF

2861.0

08/30/10

JPF

2862.0

1

07/22/12

JPF

09/10/15
03/08/12

JPF
JPF

04/11/11

JPF

01/25/11
07/20/12

JPF
JPF

09/10/12

JPF

06/29/10

JPF

03/20/12

JPF

08/06/10
12/02/10
12/03/10
08/16/11
02/24/15
06/26/10

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

JNo.

2851
2852
2853
2854 2853.0
2855 2854.0
2855.0
2856
2857 2856.0
2857.0
2858
2858.0
2859
2860 2859.0
2860.0

Discussion with JN & GC re reinstating 1st
Amendment claims in this case based on Carcetti &
actions after the fact
Discussion with JN and GC re retainer & meeting
with Schoolcrafts
Discussion with JN re: arguments to make in
response to JHMC motion
Draft section on supplement jurisdiction
Edit reply final
Final edit and review of Motion for
Reconsideration
Final edits and corrections to motion in Lim
Meet with GC and JN re: changes and additions to
complaint
Meeting w/JN and GC re: Schoolcraft complaint
Meeting w/JN and GC to discuss Complaint
Meeting with anonymous cops from T34 w/ GC
and JN - provided recordings of Lt. Janice Williams

2861

E

Hours

1.250
1.250

1.250
1.250
1.250
1.250
1.250

1.250
1.250
1.250

1.250

2862

2863
2864 2863.0
2864.0
2865
2865.0
2866
2867 2866.0
2867.0
2868
2868.0
2869
2869.0
2870
2870.0
2871
2872 2871.0
2873 2872.0
2874 2873.0
2875 2874.0
2876 2875.0
2877 2876.0

Meeting with JN & GC re Garcia cop from 81 who
knows Schoolcraft & has info on quotas
Phone call w/ Larry Schoolcraft re meeting and
outstanding discovery issues and depositions
Phone Call with AS re: settlement
Phone call with client re article and whether
confidential info had been disclosed
Phone convo w/ AS, re representation on his
suspension & internal hearing
Prep for oral argument on JHMC motion
Read and review judge's decision denying
reconsideration
Read and review Opinion & Order from Sweet on
plaintiffs motion to amend
Receipt & review of Weinstein arbitration decision
in PBA case
Research on 1st Amendment Second Circuit
decisions following Carcetti
Review and edit Complaint after clarification
Review of Amended Answer filed by City
Review of argument
Review of confidentiality stip from City
Review of Huffman cross examination outline
Review of PBA contract
Page 138

1.250

1.250
1.250
1.250

1.250
1.250
1.250

1.250
1.250
1.250

1.250
1.250
1.250
1.250
1.250
1.250

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

1

No.

2878 2877.0
2879 2878.0
2880 2879.0
2880.0

I

C

D

Timekeepe
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

Description
___.
Review of revised Complaint from JN
Review of Valenti exmanination
Team meeting following conf.
Meeting w/JN & GC re: City's Deliberative Process
and Grand Jury privilege claims and best strategy
for defeating same.
Meeting w/JN & GC re: Marino's lAB interview &
inconsitencies w/claims in OF 49 & Halloween
Night recording
Discussion with GC and JN re tapes
Discussion with JN re timeline
Meeting w/JN and GC re: outstanding items we
need from trial from NS
Meeting with GC and JN re: anonymous cop
interviews VM and EF
Meeting with GC to discuss documents that must
be requested in our demands
Meeting with JN to prepare for EDNY DOJ
Prep w/ AS for AS dep
Review & edits request for admissions
Review and edit motion in lim
Review and edit revised demands for City
Review jury instructions from NS team
Review motion in lim based on comments
Review of draft witness list from NS: notes taken

B

Date
08/06/10
02/26/15
05/12/15
10/18/12

2881

2881.0
2882
2883 2882.0
2884 2883.0
2884.0
2885
2885.0
2886
2886.0
2887
2888 2887.0
2889 2888.0
2890 2889.0
2891 2890.0
2892 2891.0
2893 2892.0
2894 2893.0
2894.0
2895
2896 2895.0
2896.0
2897
2898 2897.0
2899 2898.0
2900 2899.0
2901 2900.0
2902 2901.0
2903 2902.0
2903.0
2904
2904.0
2905
2905.0
2906
2907 2906.0

10/15/12

07/15/10
07/09/10
02/26/15

09/30/10
05/18/11

09/22/10
10/09/12
05/20/11
08/30/15
02/13/12
03/13/15
04/07/15
07/24/15
04/06/15
01/26/11
03/28/12
09/28/11
05/09/12
04/13/15
05/12/15
09/05/10
07/26/10
10/12/10

02/20/15

05/15/11

JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

JPF
JPF

JPF

Review of NS comments
Appearance for motion to dismiss in Schoolcraft
Attend oral Argument on City motion
Attend oral argumqnt on motion to compel
Attended Argument on 1st Amendment claim
Conf. on trial date - case adj ourned
Conf. trial adjourned to Oct. 19
Editing Amended Complaint
Meeting GC and JN re issues for Schoolcraft
complaint
Meeting w/ GC and IN re: Schoolcraftjustice.com
calls from Pos
Meeting w/ JN and GC before meeting with Nat
Smith to dicuss how we are going to proceed at
meeting
Meeting with JN and GC re: edits to RFA's

Page 139

E

Hours
1.250
1.250
1.250

1.200

1.200
1.100
1.100
1.100

1.100
1.100
1.100

1.100
1.100
1.100
1.100
1.100
1.100

1.100
1.100
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000

1.000
1.000

1.000
1.000

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A
1

No.

2907.0
2908
2909 2908.0
2910 2909.0
2911 2910.0
2912 2911.0
2912.0
2913
2913.0
2914
2914.0
2915
2915.0
2916
2917 2916.0
2918 2917.0
2918.0
2919
2919.0

2920
2921 2920.0
2921.0
2922
2922.0
2923
2924 2923.0
2925 2924.0
2925.0
2926
2926.0
2927
2927.0
2928
2928.0
2929
2929.0
2930
2931 2930.0
2931.0
2932
2933 2932.0

B

C

D

Date
11/12/10

Timekeepe Description
JPF
Meeting with JN and GC re: issues on our motion
opposition and GC's meeting with JW anonymous
cop

03/27/15
05/23/12
02/08/12
06/23/11

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

09/12/15

JPF

12/19/11

JPF

06/28/10

JPF

02/12/11

JPF

08/01/12
05/31/12
08/25/10

JPF
JPF
JPF

02/04/15

JPF

10/06/10
09/11/11

JPF
JPF

08/11/11

JPF

Review of responses to Isacov discovery demands

04/06/15
02/11/15
01/23/15

JPF
JPF
JPF

Review of revised SK jury instructions
Berniers counter 56.1 statement
Call w/GC and JN about taking over case again

03/28/12

JPF

Conf. re confidentiality stip & Village Voice article

04/04/12

JPF

07/02/12

JPF

05/08/15

JPF

12/06/10
06/22/10

JPF
JPF

07/07/10

JPF

Conf. re NY Times letter to undo the
confidentiality stip
Discussion w/ AS and Larry Schoolcraft re
financial issues and possibly locating donors
Discussion w/ GC & JN re decision and impact on
trial and motion in lim
Discussion with GC & JN re final corrections
Discussion with Gerald Cohen (GC) and JN re
Schoolcraft case & causes of action
Discussion with JN re Labor Law research

E

Phone conference with JN, GC, NS, JL
Prep for argument w/ GC & JN
Pre-trial conference before Judge Sweet
Review of response to doc demands Isacov
Adding a new section on Bernier's naval yard
disaster testimony
Convo w/ Larry Schoolcraft re discovery issues,
avenues to pursue with defendants
Discussion with JN re meeting with P.O. Velasquez
re policy of quotas
Discussion with JN re; motion to stay and
arguments in opposition
Final review of motion to amend
Meeting w/JN and GC re: City conf. Stips
Meeting with JN & GC re more whistleblower
email & meeting with P.O Fioranelli
Phone call w JN and GC re: pending trial strategy
and misc. evidentiary issues, and setting up meetng
to discuss same in greater detail
Review of Answer to Complaint by Jamaica
Review of plaintiffs motion to compel discovery

1

Hours

1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000

0.900
0.900

0.900
0.900
0.900
0.900
0.900

0.900
0.900
0.900
0.900
0.900
0.800

0.800
0.800

Page 140

0.800
0.800

0.800
0.800
0.800
0.800

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

No.

Timekeepe Description
Meeting w/ Gerald Cohen ("GC") and JN re:
JPF

Date

2933.0

1

06/06/10

2934

2934.0

06/20/10

t

JPF

2935

2935.0

11/18/10

JPF

2936
2936.0

09/20/10

JPF

2937
2937.0

06/18/10

JPF

2938

2938.0

08/12/10

JPF

2939

2939.0

08/22/10

JPF

2940

2940.0

08/29/12

D

C

B

JPF

Schoolcraft coming to our office for interview
Discussions with Jon Norinsberg (JN) re
Schoolcraft case
Draft of prelim statement in opp to Motion to
Dimiss
Listening to This American Life interview with
client
Meeting w/JN and Gerald Cohen ("GC") re:
Schoolcraft coming to our office and retaining for
lawsuit
Meeting w/JN and GC re: legal strategies on
Monell and whistleblower cop contacts
Meeting with JN & GC re whistleblowers reaching
out through the website
Meeting. w/ JN & GC re: City's Suppl. Disclosure
& the need for us to depose at least 5 of the 9 new
witnesses identified by City & other gen.strategy
issues for advancing discovery

E

Hours

0.800
0.800

0.800
0.800

0.800
0.800
0.800

0.800

2941
2941.0

2942
2943 2942.0
2943.0
2944
2944.0
2945
2945.0
2946
2947 2946.0
2947.0
2948
2948.0
2949
2950 2949.0
2950.0
2951
2951.0
2952
2953 2952.0
2953.0
2954
2954.0
2955

11/08/10

07/25/12
05/22/12

08/27/10
04/05/12
09/30/10
11/08/10

JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

Met with GC and police officer "MC" re: quotas
Phone call w/ Larry Schoolcraft
Phone call w/ Larry Schoolcraft re Vallone and 1st
Amendment
Reading articles written by Eterno & Silverman re
Compstat & numbers game
Review and discuss w/ IN & GC plaintiffs
responses to City demands
Review of Answer to Complaint by Bernier
Review of Doc Demands/Interrogatories by Isacov

0.800
0.800

0.800
0.800

0.800
0.800
0.800

03/06/15
11/11/10
06/30/10

03/29/12
02/12/15
05/03/12

08/16/12

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF

Review of email from AS w/ witness suggestions
Review of Interrogatoiies & Demands Bernier
Review of PBA website internal access for P.O.s
with AS
Revised and help draft prqposed AEO stip w/JN
and GC for City
Affidavit of Mauriello
Discussion w/ GC & JN re Affidavits and conf. stip
AEO
Discussion w/ JN & GC re City's suggestion on
multiple dates for deps

Page 141

0.800
0.800
0.800
0.800
0.750

0.750
0.750

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

C

B

D

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

2955.0

05/17/12

JPF

02/08/12

JPF

02/24/15
03/19/15

JPF
JPF

Discussion with GC and JN re: conference and
discovery and stratedgy moving forward
Discussion with GC re: Huffman cross
Discussion with GC re: James cross examinaiton

03/08/12

JPF

04/25/12

JPF

E

Discussion w/JN and GC re: AS breach affidavit

2956.0

1

2956

Hours

0.750

2957
2958 2957.0
2958.0
2959
2959.0
2960
2960.0
2961
2961.0
2962
2962.0

0.750

06/14/12

JPF

10/04/10

JPF

2963

2963.0
2964
2965 2964.0
2965.0

0.750
0.750

06/23/10

JPF

07/07/10
02/27/12

JPF
JPF

08/25/10

JPF

Discussion with JN & GC re VV article and the
confidential report
Discussion with JN re: edits/changes to 1st
Amendment letter
Meet with JN and GC to discuss motion for
reconsideration on 1st amendment claim
Meeting w GC and JN to discuss infromation from
"JR" retired police officer re: quotas, downgrading,
NYPD corruption
Meeting w/JN and GC re: JN's upcoming meeting
w/ district attorney
Meeting with AS, LS, GC & JN
Meeting with GC and JN re: documents received
from Johnstown PD for plaintiffs subpoena

2966

0.750
0.750

0.750

0.750

0.750
0.750

0.750
2966.0

Meeting with JN & GC re: Whitehead Meeting.

2967

0.750

2967.0

04/08/15

JPF

Phone call with GC and JN regarding trial
adjournment, proposed filings, various strategies
for trying to make sure trial goes on April 20

2968.0

01/23/12

JPF

04/20/12
05/03/12

JPF
JPF

10/18/12

JPF

10/19/12

JPF

09/07/10

JPF

Phone call with Larry Schoolcraft re plaintiff salary
and benefits and work suspension status
Phone discussion w/ AS
Receipt and review of email from City re: revised
confidentiality AEO and Affidavits
Review and edit letter to Ct. re ASO issue & AS
ability to see the QAD report
Review of Answer to Amended Complaint from
lsacov
Review of Answer to Complaint from Jamaica

2968

0.750

2969
2970 2969.0
2970.0
2971
2971.0
2972
2972.0
2973
2973.0
2974
2974.0
2975
2975.0
2976
2977 2976.0
2978 2977.0

Hosp.
05/10/11

JPF

10/28/11

JPF

0.750
0.750
0.750
0.750
0.750
0.750

Review of Intial disclosures and discussion with
GC

08/13/10
06/23/11

JPF
JPF

0.750

Review of operations order 10/17/11 sent from
client
Review of PBA regulations
Review of requests for discovery from Isacov

0.750
0.750
0.750

Page 142

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

2979 2978.0
2980 2979.0
2980.0
2981
2981.0
2982
2982.0

C

B

Date

Timekeepe Description

07/28/15
09/28/10
08/20/12

JPF
JPF
JPF

05/23/12
05/22/12

JPF
JPF

2983

2983.0

07/28/12

JPF

2984

2984.0

D

1

03/06/15

JPF

Review of updated jury instructions
"Rich" anonymous cop discussion with GC
Discussion w/ JN & GC re additional amendment
of the complaint to add Hanlon
Discussion w/ JN & GC re: defendant's letter re
subpoena
Discussion w/ JN & GC re defendant's letter re
Vallone subpoena
Discussion w/ JN & GC re motion to amend to add
prior restraint
Discussion w/ JN & GC re proposed witnesses

E

Hours

0.750
0.600
0.600

0.600
0.600
0.600
0.600

2985

2985.0

05/08/12

JPF

2986
2986.0

05/16/12

JPF

2987

2987.0

07/26/10

JPF

2988
2988.0
2989
2990 2989.0
2990.0
2991
2991.0
2992
2992.0
2993
2993.0
2994
2994.0
2995
2995.0
2996
2996.0
2997
2998 2997.0
2998.0
2999
3000 2999.0
3000.0
3001
3001.0
3002

08/27/10
01/26/11
06/23/11

03/23/15

04/13/12

JPF
JPF
JPF

JPF
JPF

Discussion w/ JN and GC re argument on 1st
Amendment claim
Discussion w/ JN and GC re opp to defendant's
motion to quash
Discussion with GC & JN re Complaint & drafts
going forward
Discussion with GC & JN re having Eterno &
Silverman as experts
Discussion with GC & JN re oral arguments
Discussion with GC & JN re responses & requests
from Isacov
Discussion with GC re: Sawyer points for cross
examination
Discussion with JN and GC re: Matthews decision

0.600
0.600
0.600
0.600
0.600
0.600
0.600
0.600

07/02/10
03/16/12
03/20/12

JPF
JPF

JPF

Discussion with JN re AS' ability to pursue claim
under Labor Law 215-a
Draft of opp that defendants request plaintiff be
ordered to appear @ 3 /28/12 conf.
Incorporating language into Amended Complaint

0.600
0.600

0.600
09/26/12
03/30/12
02/19/11
03/12/12
08/15/10
03/15/12

JPF
JPF
JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF

Meeting w/ JN & GC & AS re adjorning dep due to
father's medical emergency
Meeting w/ JN & GC re AEO changes
Meeting with GC re: getting transcript for Bryant v.
City verdict finding quotas existed
Meeting with JN & GC re letter from City
Meeting with JN and GC re NYTimes story about
quotas & Schoolcraft
Meeting with JN and GC re proposed Amended
Complaint

Page 143

0.600
0.600

0.600
0.600
0.600

0.600

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

1

B

C

D

3002.0

Date
04/17/15

3003.0

09/08/15

3004.0

02/27/15

JPF

3005.0

09/08/15

JPF

3006.0

05/06/11

JPF

3007.0

10/18/12

JPF

3008.0

05/17/12

JPF

3009.0

05/12/11

JPF

10/22/12
10/27/10

JPF
JPF

Phone call with NS, GC and JN regarding best
strategy for handling settlement discussions with
the City
Read & review the decision & order written
disposing of the motion to dismiss
Review and edit letter to Ct opposing an additional
day for AS dep for Mauriello lawyer
Review and edit plaintiffs opp to defendant's
motion to quash
Review of agency agreement for client on
book/movie deals he does
Review of Amended Complaint by Bernier
Review of Answer to Amended Complaint Isacov

06/21/10

JPF

09/01/11

JPF

04/13/12

JPF

01/20/11
05/10/12
04/17/15

JPF
JPF
JPF

12/19/11

JPF

12/09/10

JPF

03/25/15
05/05/15
07/28/10

JPF
JPF
JPF

02/26/15

JPF

E

Phone call with JN regarding following up with
Smith, IAB v. DAT transcripts, calling additional
witness's like Nelson and Valenti and Yeager

No.

1

3003

Timekeepe Description
JPF
Phone call w/ rest of trial team regarding City'
proposal for mediation and best strategy for
responding
JPF
Phone call with JN & GC recapping discussion
with defense counsel and clients over the weekend

3004

Hours

0.600

0.600

3005

0.600

3006

3007
3008
3009

3010
3011 3010.0
3011.0
3012
3012.0
3013
3013.0

3015
3016 3015.0
3017 3016.0
3017.0
3018
3018.0
3019
3019.0
3020
3021 3020.0
3022 3021.0
3022.0
3023
3024 3023.0

0.600

0.600
0.600

0.600
0.600
0.600

3014
3014.0

0.600

Review of articles sent by Schoolcraft on Gerald
Nelson
Review of decision in Floyd on summary judgment
& its relevance to Schoolcraft tapes and Monell
claim
Review of Decision in Matthews 1st Amendment
case from Judge Jones
Review of defendants' reply memo of law
Review, edit & submit supplemental letter
Conference call with team re: best strategy for
responding to City latest "offer"
Discussion w/ GC & JN re plaintiffs thoughts on
discovery
Discussion wi JN & GC re discovery responses &
timing
Discussion w/ SK re motions in lim
Discussion WJN and GC re SMJ
Discussion with GC and JN re: Adhyl Polanco and
other whist' blowers
Discussion with GC re: Valenti examination

Page 144

0.600

0.600
0.600
0.600
0.600
0.500

0.500
0.500
0.500
0.500
0.500
0.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

1

No.

3024.0

Date
06/30/10

3025

3025.0

03/28/12

3026
3026.0

03/30/12

3027
3027.0

09/27/10

3028
3028.0
3029
3030 3029.0
3030.0
3031
3032 3031.0
3032.0

03/19/12
08/21/12
09/17/12
03/12/15
09/24/12

D

C

B

Timekeepe Description
Discussion with JN & GC re FOIL requests for
JPF
911's & how to proceed
Discussion with JN and GC re: court's order on
JPF
City's motion for breach of confidentiality
agreement
Discussion with JN and GC re: filing motion to
JPF
amend and discovery issues
Discussion with JN re location & witnesses from
JPF
This American Life interview
JPF
Disucssion w/ JN re corrections Amended
Complaint
Draft Amended Complaint adding Hanlon
JPF
Draft of letter to amend to add Hanlon to complaint
JPF
JPF
JPF

Email from AS re additional witnesses for trial
Email from City re service of amended complaint,
Lauderborn dep, & discovery deficiencies

E

Hours
0.500

0.500

0.500
0.500
0.500
0.500

0.500
0.500

0.500

3033
3033.0

3034
3035 3034.0
3035.0
3036
3036.0
3037
3038 3037.0
3038.0
3039
3039.0

3040
3041 3040.0
3041.0
3042
3043 3042.0
3043.0
3044
3044.0
3045
3045.0
3046
3047 3046.0
3047.0
3048

08/12/10
04/13/15
09/25/10

JPF
JPF
JPF

Meeting w/GC and JN re: legal strategies + next
steps for moving forward
Meeting w/JN and GC re new trial date
Meeting with GC & JN re AS interview with feds

0.500
0.500
0.500

07/15/11

10/11/12
07/24/15

04/02/15

09/25/12
05/22/12

03/29/12
07/19/11

JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

Meeting with GC an JN re: discovery plan and
issues to raise
Meeting with JN, GC, AS before depo
Phone call with JN & GC regarding issues to
discuss at meeting today with rest of trial team
Phone call with JN regarding several issues in
motion in limine and admissibility of Marino's
steroid
investigation under R. 608 (b)
Phone call with Larry Schoolcraft re AS dep
Read and review of defendant's letter re Vallone
subpoena
Review of AEO
Review of agency agreement for AS book deals

0.500
0.500
0.500

0.500
0.500

0.500
0.500
0.500

11/11/10

JPF

Review of Answer to Amended Complaint Bernier
0.500

02/27/12
10/12/10
10/17/12

JPF
JPF
JPF

Review of does from Johnstown PD re plaintiffs
subpoena
Review ofJHMC Dec. for motion to dismiss
Dicussion w/ GC & JN re City's refusal to allow
AS to see QAD file
Page 145

0.500
0.500

0.400

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

No.

B

C

D

E

Date

Timekeepe Description

Hours

05/12/11
07/06/11

JPF
JPF

0.400

08/20/12
12/01/10

JPF
JPF

08/13/10

JPF

08/17/10

JPF

08/09/10
06/29/10

JPF
JPF

09/06/10
09/03/10

JPF
JPF

07/28/10
08/08/10
09/20/10

JPF
JPF
JPF

09/07/10

JPF

08/03/10

JPF

05/01/12

JPF

3064.0

08/06/10

JPF

3065.0

1

03/12/12

JPF

02/25/15
08/03/10
03/15/12

JPF
JPF
JPF

08/22/12

JPF

03/28/12

JPF

08/30/10

JPF

01/31/11

JPF

01/20/11

JPF

3049 3048.0
3049.0
3050
3051 3050.0
3051.0
3052
3052.0
3053
3053.0
3054
3055 3054.0
3055.0
3056
3057 3056.0
3057.0
3058
3059 3058.0
3060 3059.0
3060.0
3061
3061.0
3062
3062.0
3063
3063.0

Discussion w/ GC & JN re agency agreement
Discussion w/ JN & GC re changing to case
management plan
Discussion w/ JN re AS dep prep
Discussion with GC & JN re affidavit from
Schoolcraft
Discussion with GC & JN re Jonathan Moore issue
cease & desist letter
Discussion with GC and JN re anonymous e -mails
that we got as a result of the email
Discussion with GC re website content
Disussion with JN & GC re decision on PBA
arbitration case
Discussion with JN re Amended Complaint
Discussion with JN re AS interview with This
American Life
Discussion with JN re Complaint
Discussion with JN re edits to Complaint
Discussion with JN re meeting with Department of
Justice ("DOJ") on AS case
Discussion with Mark Toor re article in Chief
about Amended Complaint
Discussion with Rocco re Schoolcraft recordings

0.400
0.400
0.400
-

0.400
0.400
0.400

0.400
0.400
0.400
0.400
0.400
0.400

0.400

0.400

Discussions w/ JN and GC re City's request for
affidavits & deposition for confidentiality breach

3064

0.400

3065

3066
3067 3066.0
3068 3067.0
3068.0
3069
3069.0
3070
3070.0
3071
3071.0
3072
3072.0
3073
3073.0
3074

Discussions with JN about quotes to add to
complaint from trnascribed recordings
Diaft Response to defendants letter re: breach of
protective order
Email from AS re counterclaim
E-mail from JN re Revised Complaint
Incorporating corrections from JN to Amended
Complaint
Meeting w/ GC & JN re Kretz's request to have an
additional day to depose plaintiff
Meeting w/ JN & GC prior to conference to prep

0.400
0.400
0.400
0.400

0.400
0.400
0.400

Meeting with JN & GC re Labor & Employment
case & 12(6)(6) motion
Meeting with JN & GC re send documents &
authorizations to Queens DA office
Meeting with JN, GC to discuss JHMC's reply
memo of law
Page 146

0.400
0.400
0.400

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

1
1

A

No.

3074.0

Date
04/07/15

Timekeepe Description
Phone call w/ SK re final corrections to motion in
JPF

3075

3075.0

04/17/15

D

C

B

JPF

limine
Phone call with GC & JN following up on phone

E

Hours
0.400

call and discussing settlement position vs. going to
3076
3077 3076.0
3077.0
3078
3078.0
3079
3079.0
3080
3080.0
3081
3081.0
3082
3083 3082.0
3083.0
3084
3085 3084.0
3085.0
3086
3086.0
3087
3087.0
3088
3088.0
3089
3089.0
3090
3090.0
3091
3091.0
3092
3092.0
3093
3093.0
3094
3095 3094.0
3095.0
3096
3097 3096.0
3097.0
3098

03/23/15
04/07/15

03/12/12
05/17/12
04/07/15
03/21/12
04/07/15
09/03/10
11/13/12

09/18/10

JPF
JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

0.400
0.400

breach of confidentiality stip
Reciept and review of Kretz's demands re: the
student "movie" about AS
Response email to team re comments on motion in

0.400

lim

03/08/12
03/12/12

trial
Read Voice article on QAD report
Read/review of letter from defendant City on

0.400

Review & edit response to City's letter re protective
order
Review and discuss City New York Times opp
letter w/ JN & GC
Review of JL's comments
Review of NY Times letter to court re
confidentiality
Review of SK's comments
Composing post to get more cops to talk to us about
Schoolcraft & Monell claim
Confirming with GC w/ AS on the phone that he is
terminating representation
Conversation with GC & JN re new whistleblower

07/23/12
02/08/11
04/18/11

04/30/12
08/09/10
08/11/10
06/27/11
08/03/10
10/12/10

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

0.400
0.400
0.400
0.400
0.400
0.300
0.300
0.300

cop

04/06/12

0.400

Corresponderice w/ NY Times about amendments
to Schoolcraft protective order
Discussion w/ GC & JN re meeting w/ Schoolcrafts
in Albany
Discussion w/ JN & GC re letter to court to
schedule discovery
Discussion w/ JN & GC re prep of letter re NYPD
hearing & PBA representation
Discussion w/ JN and GC re NY Times alteration
to protective order
Discussion with GC and JN re Adrian interview
Discussion with GC re JN re anonymous P.O.
Discussion with JN and GC re City's failure to
response to discovery requests
Discussion with JN re corrections to complaint
Discussion with JN re Motion to Dismiss schedule

0.300

0.300
0.300
0.300
0.300
0.300
0.300

0.300
0.300
0.300

Page 147

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

'

D

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

3098.0

09/23/10

JPF

3099.0

06/28/10

JPF

3100.0

03/11/12

JPF

3101.0

08/16/10

JPF

3102.0

1

05/29/12

JPF

3099

3100
3101

Discussion with JN re new post for RANT for more
whistleblower Pos
Discussion with JN, GC & Adrian Schoolcraft
("AS") re: prior counsel Jonathan Moore
Draft email to defendants re amending complaint to
add 1st Amendment claims
E-mail article from "Gman" re downgrading stats &
PBA admission about quotas from 1994

3102

1

E

Hours

0.300
0.300
0.300

0.300

3103
3104 3103.0
3104.0
3105
3105.0
3106
3107 3106.0
3107.0

08/09/10
08/08/10

JPF
JPF

07/06/12

JPF

09/12/11
04/02/15

JPF
JPF

3108.0

04/30/12

JPF

3109.0

03/03/15

JPF

04/07/15
11/01/10

JPF
JPF

06/25/12

JPF

03/30/15

JPF

03/30/15

JPF

08/11/10
08/31/10
04/12/11

JPF
JPF
JPF

10/18/12

JPF

3108
3109

3110
3111 3110.0
3111.0
3112
3112.0
3113
3113.0
3114
3114.0
3115
3116 3115.0
3117 3116.0
3117.0
3118
3118.0
3119
3119.0
3120

_

05/11/12

JPF

Email, from GC w/ proposed confidentiality stips
E-mail from JN re negligent ret. claim
E-mail from JN with additional allegations for
Complaint
Email to City re relevancy redaction portion of
AEO & stip
Final review & edit motion to compel
Follow up phone call with JN locating does
relevant for motion in Limine, including plaintiff
IAB/CCRB transcripts, Affidavits for spoilation,
and Eterno deposition testimony
Letter from City requesting affidavits & dep of
client re confidentiality breach
Letter to Ct. from Kretz correcting 56.1 statement
errors
Making corrections to motion in lim
Meeting with JN and GC re: updating Schoolcraft
website
Phone call w/ Frank Serpico re meeting w/
Schoolcrafts
Phone call with JN & GC regarding admissibility
of tape recorded statements of persons interviewed
by lAB
Phone call with JN regarding motion limine issues
and recent filings by NS regarding striking affidavit
and request for conference
Phone call with Mark Toor re article in Chief
Phone call with Mark Toor re new article
Phone convo w/JN re suspension issue & our
response to the NYPD
Read and review Answer to Amended Complaint
from City
Read and review NY Times letter re confidentiality
stip

0.300
0.300
0.300
0.300
0.300

0.300
0.300
0.300
0.300
0.300
0.300

0.300

0.300
0.300
0.300

0.300
0.300
0.300

Page 148

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

1

No.

3120.0

Date
05/11/12

3121

3121.0
3122
3123 3122.0
3124 3123.0
3124.0
3125
3126 3125.0
3126.0
3127
3127.0
3128
3128.0
3129
3129.0

02/09/11

09/18/12
07/05/11
05/24/12
11/16/10
12/11/10

08/10/10

D

C

B

I_

Timekeepe Description
Read and review of defendant's response to
JPF
plaintiffs supplemental letter
Review & edit letter to court re discover schedule
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

JPF

Review and edit amended complaint
Review discovery plan w/ JN & GC
Review letter by GC in response to Vallone
subpoena issue
Review of affidavit for AS for CCR case
Review of article from Eterno & Silverman re
manipulation of crime stats
Review of articles about Schoolcraft Complaint

06/30/10
03/22/15

JPF
JPF

Review of FOIL requests for 911 calls made by AS
to NYPD and discuss with JN
Review of plaintiffs response letter to defendants
opp to plainitff s motion to strike & re adjourning

09/06/11

JPF

3131

08/17/10

JPF

3132

3132.0
3133
3134 3133.0
3134.0
3135
3135.0
3136
3136.0
3137
3137.0
3138
3138.0
3139
3139.0

08/31/10

09/02/15
09/01/10
12/14/10

JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF

03/07/12

09/20/10
07/15/11

02/04/15

JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF

08/10/10

JPF

3141

3141.0
3142
3143 3142.0

Review, edit, discuss confidentiality stip language
re related matters
Conversation with Adhyl Polanco re article,
website, status of the case
Conversation with JN and GC re: topics to be
discussed/disclosed with Mark Toor in Chief article
Corrections from SK
Correspondence from Donna Canfield re extension
of time to response
Correspondence with Darius Charney affidavit for

0.300
0.300
0.300

0.300
0.300
0.300

06/29/10
08/03/10

JPF
JPF

0.300

0.300
0.250

0.250
0.250

0.250

0.250

AS

3140

3140.0

0.300

0.300

trial

3131.0

Hours

0.300

3130

3130.0

E

Discussed adding 1st amendment claim with JN
and GC
Discussion & review with GC & JN re media to
upload to website
Discussion of time limit for plaintiffs EBT as part
of discovery plan
Discussion w/ JN & GC re scheduling a meeting w/
Nat Smith ("NS") to discuss case status and trial
prep
Discussion with JN & GC re articles and possible
typo in Complaint
Discussion with JN & GC re substitution of counsel
Moore
Discussion with JN re corrections

Page 149

0.250

0.250
0.250

0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

D

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

3143.0

08/18/10

JPF

02/20/15

JPF

3145.0

01/03/11

JPF

3146.0

03/30/12

JPF

3147.0

04/05/12

JPF

3148.0

05/20/11

JPF

Email from AS re indemnification issue w/
Mauriello
E-mail from Chris Whitehead re Compstate DVDs
& NYPD summons quota
Email from City re IAB does & extending time to
produce
Email from City stating reasons why they oppose
amendment to Complaint
Email from client re article on "Collars for Dollars"

E

Discussion with JN re Rocco's story in Daily News

3144.0

1

3144

Hours

0.250

3145
3146
3147
3148
3149
3150 3149.0
3150.0
3151
3151.0
3152
3152.0
3153
3153.0
3154
3154.0

3155
3156 3155.0
3156.0
3157
3158 3157.0
3159 3158.0
3160 3159.0
3160.0
3161
3161.0
3162
3162.0
3163
3164 3163.0
3164.0
3165
3166 3165.0
3166.0
3167
3167.0
3168
3169 3168.0

12/15/10
01/05/11

JPF
JPF

08/04/11

JPF

07/09/12

JPF

E-mail from GC re article involving Marino
E-mail from GC re NBC news coverage on
Schoolcraft
Email from GC re Polanco charges and specs for
retaliation for whistleblowing
Email from GC w/ draft for Schoolcraft donation
page

03/20/12

JPF

02/10/12

JPF

04/05/15
02/24/15

JPF
JPF

03/07/12
02/07/12
08/17/10
05/21/15

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

09/16/10

JPF

06/08/12

JPF

09/22/10
04/24/12

JPF
JPF

JPF
JPF

08/05/10

JPF

09/28/11

JPF

0.250

0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250

Email from hospital defendant & City re proposed
Amended Complaint
E-mail from JN re additional items of discovery
from City & subpoenas for Johnstown records
Email from JN re edits to motion
Email from JN re motion in lim issues to be
covered
Email from John Eterno re QAD report
Email from Lee re outstanding authorizations
E-mail from Mark Toor re Chief article
Email from NS re City's overture on discussing
settlement
E-mail from other hospital defendant re Amended
Complaint
Email to AS re discovery VV affidavit and 1st
Amendment issues
E-mail to DOJ with medical records
Email, to hospital defendants re amendment Gough
issue

08/06/10
08/07/10

0.250

E-mail to JN & from JN re community visits
E-mail to JN & from re explanation of community
visits
E-mail to JN re clarification of some factual issues
in the Complaint
Email to JN re law enforcement privilege
Page 150

0.250

0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250

0.250
0.250

0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

1

No.

3170 3169.0
3171 3170.0
3172 3171.0
3172.0
3173
3173.0
3174
3174.0
3175
3175.0
3176
3176.0
3177
3178 3177.0
3179 3178.0
3179.0
3180
3180.0
3181
3181.0
3182
3183 3182.0
3184 3183.0
3185 3184.0
3185.0
3186
3187 3186.0
3187.0
3188
3189 3188.0
3190 3189.0
3190.0
3191
3191.0
3192
3193 3192.0
3193.0
3194
3194.0
3195
3196 3195.0
3197 3196.0
3197.0
3198

D

C

B

Date

Timekeepe Description

12/07/10
03/22/12
07/11/11
07/18/11

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

File final brief
Final edits on Amended Complaint w/ JN
Final review of discovery plan w/ JN & GC
Final/final review of discovery plan w/ time limits

E

Hours

0.250
0.250
0.250

0.250
02/10/12

05/17/12
05/25/12
03/20/15

04/25/12
05/22/12
04/07/15
10/08/10
09/28/11

09/07/10
10/18/10
06/25/10
03/12/12
09/10/10
08/11/10
09/28/11
02/08/12
01/26/11

05/09/12
09/12/15
04/13/15

JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

Phone call with client cancelling meeting because
of eviction issues
Read and review letter from City re NY Times
response
Read and review NY Times response to Pubichas
letter
Research on the "movie" project referenced in
Kretz's email
Response emails
Review and sign Affidavit re VV article
Review edit NS to Ct. re our opp to defendant's
letter
Review of article from Associate Press on
Schoolcraft
Review of changes to confidentiality stip & disc.
plan
Review of Chief article on AS
Review of letter to court re briefing sched.
Review of Schoolcraft retainer
Review of So Ordered Protective Order re doc
produced by City
Review of Times article points with GC
Review post of anonymous P.O. who contacted
website re recording Mauriello
Travel from SDNY - motion to compel (.5)
Travel from SDNY - motion to compel (.5)
Travel from SDNY for appearance for motion to
dismiss in Schoolcraft (.5)
Travel from SDNY for Argument on 1st
Amendment claim (.5)
Travel from SDNY for conf. (.5)
Travel from SDNY for conference re: trial date (.5)

0.250

0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250

0.250
0.250
0.250

03/28/12
09/28/11
02/08/12
01/26/11

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

Travel from SDNY for Oral Argument on City
motion (.5)
Travel to SDNY - motion to compel (.5)
Travel to SDNY - motion to compel (.5)
Travel to SDNY for appearance for motion to
dismiss in Schoolcraft (.5)

Page 151

0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A
1

No.

3198.0
3199
3200 3199.0
3200.0
3201
3201.0
3202
3202.0

C

B

Date
05/09/12

D

05/12/15
04/13/15

Timekeepe Description
JPF
Travel to SDNY for Argument on 1st Amendment
claim (.5)
JPF
Travel to SDNY for conf. (.5)
JPF
Travel to SDNY for conference re: trial date (.5)

03/28/12

JPF

04/03/15

JPF

02/11/15

JPF

2nd confirmation email fiom AS that we have been
officially retained again to represent AS in this case

10/24/10
04/30/12

JPF
JPF

Article from the "L" re Schoolcraft
City e-mail request to adjourn amendment conf.

05/07/12
12/01/10
11/13/12
01/10/12

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

04/04/12

JPF

City's response keeping the 5/9 date
Correspondence from CCR re affidavit
Correspondence from City re rep of AS
Correspondence mail from medical defendant
Isacov re plaintiff EBT
Correspondence to JHMC re Amended Complaint

06/19/12
10/13/10

JPF
JPF

08/29/12

JPF

E

Hours
0.250
0.250
0.250

Travel to SDNY for Oral Argument on City motion
(.5)
Phone call with JN regarding progress on motion in
limine and clarification of certain factual issues

3203

0.250

0.200
3203.0

3204
3205 3204.0
3205.0
3206
3207 3206.0
3208 3207.0
3209 3208.0
3209.0
3210
3210.0
3211
3212 3211.0
3212.0
3213
3213.0
3214
3215 3214.0
3215.0
3216
3216.0
3217
3217.0
3218
3219 3218.0
3220 3219.0
3221 3220.0
3222 3221.0
3222.0
3223
3224 3223.0
3225 3224.0
3226 3225.0
3227 3226.0

04/11/12
12/29/10

JPF
JPF

02/04/15

JPF

04/19/12

JPF

08/31/15
11/29/10
02/10/15
08/15/12
12/09/10

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

08/15/12
04/02/12
08/21/12
08/14/12

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

Correspondence w/ Adhyl Folanco
Discussion with JN re agreement on briefing sched.
w/ defendant Jamaica Hosp
Email 2 & 3 froin JN re discovery to defendants
Email Amended Complaint to defendants
E-mail article from GC by Len Levitt re AS case

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.100
0.100
0.100

0.100
0.100
0.100

0.100

Email AS confirming our rep w/ current counsel
0.100

Email correspondence to City correcting Lt. Gough
for Amended complaint
Email final motion to team
E-mail from AS re CCR affidavit
Email from AS re thoughts on adjournment
Email from B Brady re plaintiffs dep
E-mail from B. Lee defendants re late responses to
interrogatories
Email from B: Lee re plaintiffs dep
Email from Bernier consenting to amendment
Email from Brady consenting to Amendment
Email from Brady re deps
Page 152

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

3228
3229
3230
3231
3232
3233

D

C

B

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

3227.0
3228.0
3229.0
3230.0
3231.0
3232.0
3233.0

08/23/12
08/21/12
08/13/12
08/15/12
04/20/12
09/24/12
02/10/15

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

3234
3235 3234.0
3235.0
3236
3237 3236.0
3238 3237.0
3239 3238.0
3240 3239.0
3241 3240.0
3242 3241.0
3243 3242.0
3243.0
3244
3245 3244.0
3245.0
3246
3246.0
3247
3248 3247.0
3248.0
3249
3250 3249.0
3251 3250.0
3251.0
3252
3252.0
3253
3254 3253.0
3255 3254.0
3255.0
3256
3257 3256.0
3257.0
3258
3259 3258.0
3260 3259.0

07/09/12
04/25/12
03/30/12
08/22/12
08/03/12
09/13/12
08/01/12
05/18/12
08/16/12
07/13/12

08/21/12
06/05/12

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

._

E

...

Email from Brady re plaintiffs dep date
Email from Brady re scheduling AS dep
Email from Brian Lee re deposition
Email from Brian Lee re subpoenaed docs
Email from City
Email from City
Email from City defendants re moving the trial date
back two weeks
Email from City on relevancy redaction issue
Email from City on Vallone subpoena extension
Email from City re: Amendment opposition
Email from City re AS dep date
Email from City re confidentiality stip
Email from City re fax # confirmation
Email from City re motion to amend
Email from City re moving argument
Email from City re plaintiffs dep
Email from City regarding tax return authorizations
Email from City requesting copy of complaint
Email from Ct. re inventory on NY Times issue

Hours

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

11/16/10

06/06/12
11/19/10

02/23/15
05/06/11
05/24/11

02/10/12
10/20/12
09/28/10
02/24/11

12/16/10
02/19/11

08/28/12
03/08/11

JPF
JPF
JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

E-mail from Darius Charney re Schoolcraft
affidavit
Email from defendants re inventory
E-mail from French journalist Marie Brunerie re
documentary on whistle blowing and Schoolcraft
case
Email from GC & NS re IAB file
E-mail from GC on Cts decision on motion
E-mail from GC on new cop whistleblower from
the 75th precinct
E-mail from GC re additional discovery items to
seek
E-mail from GC re another article AMNY
E-mail from GC re article on AS

0.100
0.100

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.100
0.100
0.100

Email from GC re article re Marino misconduct
E-mail from GC re AS affidavit
E-mail from GC re Bryant v. City verdict finding
quotas existed
Email from GC re Chief article
Email from GC re medical defendants' article

Page 153

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A
1

No.

3260.0
3261
3262 3261.0
3262.0
3263
3263.0
3264
3264.0
3265
3266 3265.0
3266.0
3267
3268 3267.0
3269 3268.0
3270 3269.0
3270.0
3271
3272 3271.0
3272.0
3273
3274 3273.0
3275 3274.0
3275.0
3276
3277 3276.0
3278 3277.0
3278.0
3279
3280 3279.0
3281 3280.0
3281.0
3282
3282.0
3283
3283.0
3284
3285 3284.0
3286 3285.0
3287 3286.0
3288 3287.0
3289 3288.0
3290 3289.0
3290.0
3291
3292 3291.0

C

B

Date
12/02/10

D

08/15/10

Timekeepe Description
JPF
E-mail from GC re new whistleblower cop on the
website
JPF
E-mail from GC re NY Times article
JPF
E-mail from GC re NYCLU lawsuit for POs faced
with quotas
JPF
E-mail from GC re NYPD blog picking up case

05/03/11

JPF

Email from GC re P.O. Hicks, Bronx quota cop

11/03/10
01/25/11

JPF
JPF

09/24/10
08/10/12
11/21/10
08/16/10

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

Email from GC re plaintiffs financials
Email from GC re statements from Jamaica
Hospital to Village Voice
E-mail from GC re The RANT
Email from GC re VV affidavit
Email from GC re Wall Street Times article
E-mail from GC re website update for articles on

E

10/22/10
02/23/12

Hours
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

11/15/10
03/07/12

JPF
JPF

09/25/12
08/22/12
12/08/10

JPF
JPF
JPF

03/03/11
04/02/12
09/15/10

JPF
JPF
JPF

04/04/12
04/04/12
04/04/12

JPF
JPF
JPF

01/10/12

JPF

09/26/12

JPF

09/10/12
09/28/10
03/12/12
08/22/12
08/10/12
09/25/10
08/14/12

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

10/11/10

JPF

case
E-mail from GC re whistleblower cop
Email from GC re: conversation with Larry and
Adrian
Email from Greg R re Lauderborn dep
Email from Greg Rad re AS dep
E-mail from Hospital defendants re docketing error
on ECF
Email from HV re article re Lt. Williams
Email from Isacov consenting to amendment
E-mail from Isacov's attorney re Amended
Complaint
Email from JHMC
Email from JHMC
Email from JHMC re change in amended language

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

Email from JMH re outstanding discovery from
plaintiff
Email from JN adjourning dep of AS re: medical
issues he was having
Email from JN re 120 extension of discovery
E-mail from JN re article in Russian news
Email from JN re corrections
Email from JN re dep dates
Email from JN re extension of discovery
E-mail from JN re fed meeting
Email from JN re letter to City w/ tax
authorizations
E-mail from JN re Lewis whistleblower cop
Page 154

0.100

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

3292.0
3293
3294
3295
3296
3297

3293.0
3294.0
3295.0
3296.0
3297.0

3298
3299 3298.0
3299.0
3300
3300.0
3301
3301.0
3302
3302.0
3303
3304 3303.0
3305 3304.0
3306 3305.0
3307 3306.0
3308 3307.0
3308.0
3309
3310 3309.0
3311 3310.0
3311.0
3312
3312.0
3313
3313.0
3314
3314.0
3315
3315.0
3316
3317 3316.0
3318 3317.0
3318.0
3319
3320 3319.0
3321 3320.0
3321.0
3322
3323 3322.0

Date
07/28/10
10/12/12
08/10/12
08/14/12
08/16/12
01/01/11

10/02/10
04/30/12
10/12/12

08/29/12

D

C

B

Timekeepe Description
E-mail from JN re meeting with Polanco/Graham
JPF
Raymond & Rocco P.
Email from JN re photos used @ AS dep
JPF
Email from JN re plaintiffs dep
JPF
Email from JN re plaintiffs dep
JPF
Email from JN re plaintiffs dep
JPF
E-mail from JN re Wall Street Journal article about
JPF
case
E-mail from JN re whistleblower cop
JPF
Email from JN to City re additions to protective
JPF
order
Email from JN to City re allowing AS access to
JPF
QAD report
Email from JN to defendants enclosing discovery
JPF

E

Hours

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.100

0.100
0.100

08/28/12

08/22/12
09/26/12
08/21/12
08/23/12
08/22/12
06/08/12
08/21/12
08/23/12
02/04/15

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

Email from JN to defendants enclosing responses to
discovery
Email from Kretz re AS dep date
Email from Kretz re Launderborn dep
Email from Lee consenting
Email from Lee on plaintiffs dep dates
Email from Lee re AS dep datr
Email from Lee re docs in response to subpoenas
outstanding
Email from Lee re scheduling AS dep
Email from Lee re second day for AS dep
Email from Nat Smith re logistics of representation

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

03/14/12
09/04/15
03/20/15
05/08/15

06/05/12
06/07/12
03/13/12

04/13/12
05/17/12
02/23/15
07/31/10

JPF
JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

JPF

Email from Nic re doc in connection w/ Schoolcraft
meeting
Email from NS adjusting motion in lim filing
deadline to 9/21/15 motion
Email from NS re a movie about AS that Kretz
wants discovery on
Email from NS wanting to schedule team meeting
prior to 5/12/15 conf.
Email from NY Times in response
Email from NY Times re inventory
Email from PBS producer Weinrich on
documentary of Schoolcraft
Email from plaintiff re 1st Amendment claim
Email from Publichas re Schoolcraft Aff.
Email from Scott Korenbaum ("SK") re motion in
lim prep
E-mail JN & GC re edited Complaint
Page 155

0.100
0.100

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

1

No.

3324 3323.0
3325 3324.0
3326 3325.0
3327 3326.0
3328 3327.0
3329 3328.0
3330 3329.0
3331 3330.0
3332 3331.0
3333 3332.0
3333.0
3334
3335 3334.0
3335.0
3336
3337 3336.0
3338 3337.0
3339 3338.0
3340 3339.0
3340.0
3341
3341.0
3342
3343 3342.0
3344 3343.0
3344.0
3345
3346 3345.0
3346.0
3347
3348 3347.0
3349 3348.0
3350 3349.0
3351 3350.0
3352 3351.0
3353 3352.0
3354 3353.0
3354.0
3355
3355.0
3356
3356.0
3357
3358 3357.0
3359 3358.0

B

C

D

Date
03/12/12
04/06/15
03/23/12
10/02/10
09/10/12
09/10/12
09/10/12
09/10/12
09/10/12
07/13/12
01/25/11

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

09/24/12
04/03/15

JPF
JPF

04/07/15
12/17/10
09/10/12
07/09/12
04/04/12

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

03/31/12

JPF

08/21/12
06/05/12
09/24/12

JPF
JPF
JPF

04/04/12
07/24/12

JPF
JPF

Email team w/ revisions to motion in lim
E-mail to AS with opp to Jamaica's motion
Email to City re Hanlon amend
Email to City re redaction issue
Email to City re updated version of proposed
Amended Complaint
Email to City requesting clarification on reason for
refusal
Email to City w/ Amended Complaint
Email to Ct. re proposed amended complaint
Email to defendants re service of amended
complaint
Email to JHMC
Email to JN re Albany meeting w/ Schoolcrafts

12/17/10
08/04/10
08/06/10
08/09/10
07/07/10
02/12/15
08/03/10
08/08/10

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

E-mail to JN re AS benefits
E-mail to JN re Complaint
E-mail to JN re Complaint revised
E-mail to JN re Final version of Complaint
E-mail to JN re Labor Law research
Email to JN re proposed email
E-mail to JN re Reviped Complaint
Email to JN re: revision of Schoolcraft complaint

03/14/12

JPF

04/25/12

JPF

04/08/15
06/18/12

JPF
JPF

Email to plaintiff re letter to amend on 1st
Amendment claim
Email to team final motion
Email w/ draft to GC & JN

E

Email to JN with proposed Amended Complaint

Timekeepe Description

Email letter to City re amendment
Email motion to team for review
Email of Amended Complaint to City
E-mail re whistleblower cop from JN
Email response from Brady
Email response from City
Email response from Greg Rad
Email response from Kretz
Email response from Lee
Email response re tax authorizations
Email Response to GC re statements from Jamaica
Hospital to Village Voice
Email response to Kretz & City
Email rough draft of Mot. In Lim. to JN for review

Hours
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.100

0.100

Page 156

0.100
0.100
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

3360 3359.0
3361 3360.0
3362 3361.0
3363 3362.0
3364 3363.0
3364.0
3365
3366 3365.0
3366.0
3367
3367.0
3368
3369 3368.0
3369.0
3370
3371 3370.0
3372 3371.0
3373 3372.0
3374 3373.0
3375 3374.0
3376 3375.0
3377 3376.0
3378 3377.0
3379 3378.0
3380 3379.0
3381 3380.0
3382 3381.0
3383 3382.0
3384 3383.0
3385 3384.0
3386 3385.0
3387 3386.0
3387.0

Date

08/11/10
08/11/10
08/11/10
08/11/10
08/11/10
05/02/12
06/04/12
04/02/15
12/17/10

06/08/12
09/26/12

08/10/12
08/01/12
03/20/15
04/24/12
09/24/12
09/26/12
04/25/12
09/27/12
09/10/12
09/27/12
09/24/12
09/24/12
09/24/12
09/26/12
04/30/12
04/05/15
09/28/10
10/18/12

D

C

B

Timekeepe Description
E-mail with Mark Toor - Chief
JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF
JPF

E-mail with Mark Toor - Chief
E-mail with Mark Toor - Chief
E-mail with Mark Toor - Chief
E-mail with Mark Toor - Chief
Email from JN to City re confidentiality and
discovery issues
Letter from Kretz re discovery
Phone call with JN regarding area of expertise and
scope of testimoy for Eterno
Phone convo with Lany Schoolcraft re NYPD
benefits & suspension status
Read and review of Times letter re inventory
Response email from B Brady re service of
amended complaint
Response email re deposition from Greg R.
Response email to City re motion to amend
Response email to NS
Response emails
Response from B Lee
Response from B Lee
Response from City
Response from City
Response from City on Hanlon amend
Response from Greg R
Response from Greg R
Response from Kretz
Response from Kretz
Response from Kretz
Response to email
Response to email
Review of article from Rocco & Daily News
Review of email from B Lee asking that plaintiff
withdraw opp to extra day of dep for AS

E

Hours

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.100

3388

3388.0

08/20/12

JPF

Review of email from JN to City re amendment
adding Hanlon
Review of letter front City extending Answer time
for Amended Complaint
Review of letter re Bernier's extension to answer
Amended Complaint
Review of letter to Sweet extending motion time

JPF

Review order adjourning conf.

JPF

3389

3389.0

10/29/10

JPF

3390

3390.0

11/04/10

JPF

3391

3391.0
3392
3393 3392.0

11/08/10
12/07/11

Page 157

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

D

No.

Date

06/18/10

GMC

3394.0

06/20/10

GMC

06/21/10
06/23/10

GMC
GMC

06/24/10
06/25/10

GMC
GMC

E

Timekeepe Description

3393.0

1

3394
3395
3396 3395.0
3396.0
3397
3398 3397.0
3398.0

Hours

Meeting w/Jon Norinsberg (JN) and Joshua Fitch
(JF) re: Schoolcraft coming to our office and
retaining for lawsuit
Email from Adrian Schoolcraft (AS) re: meeting
with JN
Email from AS re: Gerald Nelson
Meeting w/JN and JF re: JN's upcoming meeting w/
district attorney
PC with JN re: meeting w/Schoolcraft
Meeting w/JN and JF re: scope of Schoolcraft
materials that need to be reviewed for complaint

0.800

0.100
0.250
0.750
0.400

.

3399
3400 3399.0
3400.0
3401
3402 3401.0
3403 3402.0
3403.0

06/25/10
06/25/10

GMC
GMC

06/25/10
06/26/10
06/28/10

GMC
GMC
GMC

3404.0

06/28/10

GMC

3405.0

06/28/10

GMC

3406.0

06/28/10

GMC

Discussion with JN and JF re retainer & meeting
with Schoolcrafts
Discussion with JN, JF & Adrian Schoolcraft (AS)
re: prior counsel Jonathan Moore
Review of interview memo re: Eddie Velasquez

3407.0

06/28/10

GMC

3.250
1.750

Review of correspondence w/Jonathan Moore re:

Review of AS medical records
Meeting with JF & JN re: possible discovery
demands after suit is filed
Drafted retainer for Schoolcraft
Reviewed transcript of Polanco tapes
Online search of PBA Arbitration decision and
phone call w/Bonnie Siber Weinstock (arbitrator)

3404

1.400
0.600
0.750

2.100

3405

3406
3407

1.250

0.300
0.300

3408

AS

3408.0
3409
3410 3409.0
3410.0
3411
3412 3411.0
3412.0
3413
3414 3413.0
3415 3414.0
3415.0
3416
3417 3416.0
3417.0
3418
3419 3418.0

06/29/10

GMC

06/29/10
06/29/10

GMC
GMC

06/29/10
06/29/10

GMC
GMC

06/29/10
06/29/10
06/29/10

GMC
GMC
GMC

06/29/10
06/30/10

GMC
GMC

06/30/10

GMC

0.100

Meeting w/JN and JF re: PBA matters and how
they can be used in Schoolcraft
Review of David Velez arbitration decision
Discussion with JN & JF re decision on PBA
arbitration case
Correspondence w/JN re: Jonathan Moore
Discussion with JN & JF re substitution of counsel
Moore
Email from JN re: Stop and Frisk case
Email to JN re: Stop and Frisk case
Review of email from JN re: Schoolcraft matter
Sent email to JN re: Schoolcraft matter
Discussion with JN & JF re FOIL requests for
91 1's & how to proceed
Review of email from AS

Page 158

1.250
0.500

0.400
0.250
0.250
0.100
0.100

0.100
0.100
0.500
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

3419.0

B

Date

07/02/10

Timekeepe Description

GMC

3420

3420.0

07/06/10

GMC

3421

3421.0

07/06/10

GMC

3422

3422.0
3423
3424 3423.0
3425 3424.0
3425.0
3426
3427 3426.0
3428 3427.0
3428.0

07/07/10

07/07/10
07/07/10
07/07/10

GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC

3430
3431 3430.0
3432 3431.0
3432.0

07/09/10
07/12/10
07/13/10

GMC
GMC
GMC

07/14/10

GMC

07/15/10
07/15/10
07/16/10

GMC
GMC
GMC

07/17/10

GMC

3434
3434.0

E

Hours

0.300
1.300

1.750

2.900
1.800
1.500

Reviewed AS timeline of events
Draft Schoolcraft complaint
Reviewed Schoolcraft materials, listened to
recording, made notes for further drafting of
complaint
Meeting w/JN and JF re: Schoolcraft complaint

1.400

2.300

1.750
1.250

3433
3433.0

Phone call w/Eric Schneiderman staff re:
Schoolcraft
Meeting w/JN and JF re: new whistleblower
contacted JN re: Schoolcraft
Meeting with JN/JF re: progress/developments on
the case, meeting in NYC on Wednesday and filing
of lawsuit
Reviewed of Schoolcraft documents, evals, photos,
memos, UF49s, letters to PBA, letters to
Mauriello...
Listened to Schoolcraft recordings
Meeting w/only Schoolcraft
Meeting with AS, Larry Schoolcraft (LS), JF & JN

L

0.750

3429
3429.0

D

C

07/19/10

GMC

Draft Schoolcraft complaint
Discussion with JF and JN re tapes
Meeting with JN re: Schoolcraft issues and
complaint
Reviewed of Schoolcraft documents, evals, photos,
memos, UF49s, letters to PBA, letters to
Mauriello...
Review of Village Voice Articles re: Schoolcraft

2.100
1.100

1.250

2.100
1.250

3435

3435.0
3436
3437 3436.0
3438 3437.0
3439.0
3439
3439.0
3440
3441 3440.0

3441.0

07/20/10
07/21/10
07/22/10
07/26/10
07/26/10
07/23/10
07/26/10

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC

3442

3442.0
3443
3444 3443.0
3445 3444.0

07/26/10
07/26/10
07/26/10

GMC
GMC
GMC

Researched case law for complaint and continued
drafting complaint
Drafted complaint
Discussed causes of action w/JF
Review and revised Schoolcraft materials and
complaint
Meeting with JN & JF re case & updates on
Brendan Delpozo
Drafted and revised complaint
Meeting JF and JN re issues for Schoolcraft
complaint
Discussion with JF & JN re Complaint & drafts
going forward
Discussion w/JN re Brandon del Pozo
Review of email from JN re: Del Pozo
Page 159

2.100
1.500
1.400
3.100
2.100
1.250
1.000

0.600
0.300
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

1

No.

3446 3445.0
3447 3446.0
3447.0
3448
3448.0
3449
3450 3449.0
3450.0
3451
3452 3451.0
3453 3452.0
3453.0
3454
3454.0
3455
3455.0
3456
3456.0
3457
3458 3457.0
3459 3458.0
3460 3459.0
3461 3460.0
3461.0
3462
3462.0
3463
3463.0
3464
3464.0
3465
3465.0
3466
3467 3466.0
3467.0
3468
3469 3468.0
3470 3469.0
3470.0
3471
3471.0
3472
3472.0
3473

B

Date
07/27/10
07/27/10
07/27/10
07/28/10
07/28/10
07/28/10
07/28/10
07/29/10
07/30/10

07/30/10
07/30/10
07/31/10
07/31/10
08/02/10
08/03/10
08/03/10
08/03/10
08/03/10
08/03/10
08/03/10
08/05/10
08/05/10
08/06/10

08/06/10
08/06/10
08/08/10
08/09/10

08/09/10

C

D

Timekeepe Description
GMC
Review and revise Complaint
GMC
Meeting w/JN and JF to discuss Complaint
GMC
Mtg JN re draft of complaint and proposed
revisions
GMC
Listen to AS recordings, locate quotes, add to
complaint
GMC
Review of David Velez Arbitration Decision
GMC
Discussion with JF and JN re: Adhyl Polanco and
other whistlblowers
GMC
Review of email re: meeting with press
GMC
Review and Revise AS complaint
GMC
Meeting with IN, JF, Polanco & Graham Raymond
(GR) re: Schoolcraft & Monell claim
GMC
Review and revise complaint, transcribed partial
recordings, research case law
GMC
Meet with JF and JN re: changes and additions to
complaint
GMC
Meeting with Polanco + GR, JN, JF re: quotas and
Monell Claim
GMC
E-mail from JF re edited Complaint
GMC
Review and revise AS complaint
GMC
Review of 1st amendment case law
GMC
Review of JN's revised Schoolcraft complaint
GMC
Read and reviewed certain transcribed AS
recordings
GMC
Meeting w/JN re: Schoolcraft complaint and other
whistleblower police officers
GMC
Phone call with Jim Hoffer (ABC News) re:
Schoolcraft
GMC
Email correspondence re: media coverage of filing
Schoolcraft complaint
GMC
Read and reviewed certain transcribed AS
recordings
GMC
Review and revise AS complaint
GMC
Read and reviewed certain transcribed AS
recordings
GMC
Review of Schoolcraft complaint for typos
GMC
Review of transcribed call from LS to FBI
GMC
Review of email re: revision of Schoolcraft
complaint
GMC
Meeting w/JN and JF re: Schoolcraft website to
support Monell theory
GMC
Read and reviewed certain transcribed AS
recordings

Page 160

E

Hours
2.000
1.250

0.750
3.800
0.750

0.500
0.100
3.100
3.250

2.400
1.250

3.200
0.100
1.250
1.100
1.000

0.800

0.500
0.300
0.250
2.400
0.800

2.750
1.100

0.250

0.100
1.500
1.400

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

B

D

C

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

3473.0

1

08/09/10

GMC

3474
3475 3474.0
3476 3475.0
3476.0
3477
3477.0
3478
3479 3478.0
3479.0
3480
3480.0

08/09/10
08/09/10
08/09/10

GMC
GMC
GMC

08/10/10
08/10/10
08/10/10

08/10/10

GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC

08/10/10

GMC

3482

3482.0
3483
3484 3483.0
3484.0
3485
3486 3485.0
3487 3486.0
3487.0
3488
3489 3488.0
3489.0
3490
3490.0
3491
3491.0
3492
3492.0
3493
3493.0
3494
3494.0
3495
3495.0
3496
3497 3496.0
3498 3497.0
3498.0
3499
3500 3499.0

Hours

Review of final draft of AS complaint to be filed

Discussion with JF re website content
Discussion with JF and JN re Adrian interview
Review of legal issues re: Negligent hiring claim

0.500
0.400
0.300
0.300

3481

3481.0

E

08/10/10
08/10/10
08/10/10
08/11/10
08/11/10
08/11/10
08/11/10
08/12/10

08/12/10

GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC

Meeting with AS to finalize for complaint filing,
news coverage, and prep for website launch
Draft Schoolcraft website content
Compiled news articles, stories, and formatted for
website
Phone and email correspondence with Off the Page
Creations to discuss deign of Schoolcraft Justice
website
Discussion with JN & JF re articles and possible
typo in Complaint
Reviewed and signed contract for website hosting
Schoolcraft complaint prepared for filing
Emailed draft of Schoolcraft website content to JF
and JN for review
Review and revise Schoolcraft website content
Discussion with JF re JN re anonymous P.O.
Review of email from whistleblower "JF" from 81st
precinct - info on Mauriello
Review of San Francisco Chronicle coverage
Meeting w/JN and JF re: legal strategies on Monell
and whistleblower cop contacts
Email of does from potential whistleblower PO

08/13/10
08/13/10

GMC
GMC
GMC

2.100

1.250

0.250
0.250
0.250

0.100
1.400
0.300

0.250
0.100
0.800

0.750

"KR"

08/12/10

2.750
2.250

Meeting w/JF and JN re: legal strategies + next
steps for moving forward
Discussion with JF & JN re Jonathan Moore issue cease & desist letter
Review of Bloomberg coverage of AS complaint

0.500
0.400
0.250

08/15/10
08/15/10
08/15/10
08/16/10
08/17/10
08/17/10

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

Meeting with JN and JF re NYTimes story about
quotas & Schoolcraft
Email w/JN re: NY Times to run Schoolcraft story
E-mail to JF re NYPD blog picking up case
Email re: updates to Schoolcraftjustice.com
Discussion with JF and JN re anonymous e -mails
that we got as a result of the e-mail
Review of Mark Toor article - JF interview
Page 161

0.600
0.250
0.100
0.100

0.400
0.250

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

I

1

No.

3501 3500.0
3501.0
3502
3502.0
3503
3503.0
3504
3504.0
3505
3506 3505.0
3507 3506.0
3508 3507.0
3508.0
3509
3509.0
3510
3511 3510.0
3511.0
3512
3512.0
3513
3514 3513.0
3514.0
3515
3515.0
3516
3516.0
3517
3517.0
3518
3519 3518.0
3520 3519.0
3520.0
3521
3522 3521.0
3522.0
3523
3523.0
3524
3524.0
3525
3526 3525.0
3527 3526.0
3528 3527.0

B

Date
08/17/10
08/18/10

I

C

D

I

08/25/10

Timekeepe Description
GMC
Updated AS website added new articles
GMC
Email correspondence w/website designer re:
Schoolcraftjustice.com
GMC
Discussion with JF and JN re: new recordings and
documents provided by AS
GMC
Meeting with JN & JF re whistleblowers reaching
out through the website
GMC
Phone call w/ "DM" former police officer re:
Schoolcraft
GMC
Review of Schoolcraftjustice posts
GMC
Phone call with Isakoff Attorney - Brian Lee
GMC
Review of Schoolcraftjustice posts
GMC
Email correspondence w/JN re: Schoolcraftjustice
posts
GMC
Meeting with JF, PO from 81st precinct "PF" re:
corruption
GMC
Drafted interview memo of "PF"
GMC
Meeting w/JN and JF re: ACC assigned,
Schoolcraft initial disclosures
GMC
Meeting with JN & JF re more whistleblower email
& meeting with P.O. "PF"
GMC
Meeting with JN & JF re: Whitehead
GMC
Review of email correspondence w/ Len Levitt re:
WSJ police correspondence
GMC
Review of email correspondence w/"DM" (former
PO) re: Schoolcraft
GMC
Emailed former anonymous PO re: Schoolcraft post

08/26/10

GMC

08/26/10
08/26/10
08/27/10

GMC
GMC
GMC

08/27/10
08/27/10

GMC
GMC

08/27/10

GMC

08/27/10

GMC

08/27/10
08/29/10
08/29/10

GMC
GMC
GMC

08/19/10
08/22/10
08/22/10
08/22/10
08/23/10
08/23/10
08/23/10
08/25/10

08/25/10
08/25/10
08/25/10

08/25/10
08/25/10
08/25/10

I

E

Hours
0.250

0.250
1.250

0.800

0.300
0.300
0.800
0.400
0.250

2.750
2.100
1.750

0.900
0.750

0.250
0.250
0.100

Meeting with JF and JN re: interview of PO from
81st precinct "PF" re: corruption
Correspondence w/JN re: Frank Serpico
Email correspondence with Frank Serpico
Interview with JF of Walter Lipscomb, former PO
confirms quotas - wants to help Schoolcraft
Drafted interview memo of Walter Lipscomb
Discussion with JF & JN re having Eterno &
Silverman as experts
Discussion w/Jim Hoffer re: story on 81st precinct

1.500

0.250
0.100

3.250
2.000
0.600

0.500

Email to website designer with updates for
Schoolcrafjustice website
Review of Schoolcraftjustice posts
Discussion with JN re: Lipscomb interview
Phone call w/former PO re: Schoolcraft
Page 162

0.300
0.250
0.500
0.400

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

3528.0

B

Date
08/30/10

3529

3529.0

08/30/10

3530
3530.0
3531
3532 3531.0
3532.0
3533
3534 3533.0
3534.0

08/30/10

08/30/10
08/30/10
08/30/10
08/31/10

3535

3535.0

08/31/10

3536

3536.0

08/31/10

D

C

Timekeepe Description
Meeting with JN & JF re "MG" cop from 81 who
GMC
knows Schoolcraft & has info on quotas
Meeting with JN & JF re IAB Labor &
GMC
Employment case & 12(b)(6) motion
Email correspondence w/JN re: "MG" (PO in 81st
GMC
precinct)
Email w/JN re: ACC Donna Cannfield (DC)
GMC
Review of Donna Canfield (DC) Notice of
GMC
Appearance
Review of AOS prior to filing
GMC
Interview with JF of "DH" and "EB" former
GMC
NYPD, reviewed materials, recordings re: quotas,
downgrading
Interview of "ER" NYPD officer re: quotas,
GMC
downgrading
Email of does from potential whistleblower PO
GMC

3537.0

08/31/10

GMC

1.250

0.400
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

3.250
1.800

Conversation with JN and JF re: topics to be
discussed/disclosed with Mark Toor in Chief article
0.250

3538
3538.0

08/31/10

GMC

Email correspondence w/Jim Hoffer re: Schoolcraft
0.100

3539

3539.0

3540
3541
3542
3543
3544

Hours

0.900

"KR"

3537

E

3540.0
3541.0
3542.0
3543.0
3544.0

09/01/10

09/01/10
09/01/10
09/02/10
09/02/10
09/03/10

GMC

Meeting w/JN and JF re: discuss anonymous POs
contacting and how they can help Schoolcraft

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

Drafted interview memo of "ER" meeting
Review of DC extension letter
Drafted interview memo of "EB" meeting
Drafted interview memo of "DH" meeting
Meeting with PO from 81st precinct "MG" re:
corruption
Meeting with JN and JF to discuss infromation
provided by DH, MG, EB whistleblower cops in
furtherance of the Monell claim
Review and revised JF draft of Rant post
Meeting w/JN re: THEE RANT post to get officers
to contact us on Schoolcraftjustice.com

3545

3545.0
3546
3547 3546.0
3547.0

09/03/10

09/03/10
09/03/10

GMC

GMC
GMC

1.800
1.500

0.100
2.400
1.100

2.750

1.400
0.600

0.500

3548

3548.0

09/03/10

GMC

Email correspondence w/JN re: THEE RANT post
0.250

3549

3549.0
3550
3551 3550.0
3552 3551.0
3553 3552.0

09/03/10
09/07/10
09/07/10
09/07/10

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

Email correspondence w/JN re: This American Life
Radio show
Review of JHMC Answer
Review of Media coverage NYTimes
Review of JHMC corporate disclosure
Page 163

0.100
0.300
0.250
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

3554 3553.0
3555 3554.0
3555.0
3556
3557 3556.0
3558 3557.0
3558.0
3559
3560 3559.0
3560.0
3561
3561.0
3562
3562.0
3563
3563.0

C

B

Date

Timekeepe Description

09/10/10
09/10/10
09/10/10

GMC
GMC
GMC

Listened to AS NPR radio show
Review of Times article points with JF
Review of Judge Sweet's endorsement of extension

09/13/10
09/13/10
09/13/10

GMC
GMC
GMC

Drafted interview memo of "MG" meeting
Review of Amended complaint
Email correspondence w/ "WJC" former NYPD

09/15/10
09/15/10

GMC
GMC

09/15/10

GMC

Review of Eddie Velasquez depo from Floyd
Email correspondence re: Amended Complaint
with medical defendants
Review of stip extending time for Benier answer

E

Hours
1.000

0.250
0.100
2.100
0.500
0.250
1.100

0.100
0.100

09/17/10

GMC

09/17/10

GMC

3564.0

09/18/10

GMC

3565.0

09/18/10

GMC

3566.0

09/20/10

GMC

3564
3565
3566
3567
3568 3567.0
3569 3568.0
3570 3569.0
3570.0
3571
3571.0
3572
3573 3572.0
3573.0
3574
3575 3574.0
3575.0

D

09/20/10
09/20/10
09/20/10
09/20/10

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

09/20/10

GMC

09/21/10
09/23/10

GMC
GMC

09/23/10
09/24/10

GMC
GMC

3576

Reviewed and cataloged Schoolcraftjustice.com
posts
Meeting with JN and JF regarding infromation
obtained from Floyd litigation and its impact on
Schoolcrafts Monell and Retaliation claims
Conversation with JF & JN re new whistleblower
cop
Correspondence w/JN re: anonymous Schoolcraft
post
Meeting with JF with PO "JB" re: NYPD quotas
and downgrading
Review of Angel Heran depo from Floyd
Review of Steve Mauriello depo from Floyd
Review of Donald McHugh depo from Floyd
Updated Schoolcraft Justice media page with Radio
interview
Discussion & review with JF & JN re media to
upload to website
Drafted interview memo of "JB" meeting
Meeting with JF, JN and Center for Constitutional
Rights (CCR) re Schoolcraft
Reviewed and finalized THEE RANT post
Discussion with JN and JF re: first meeting with
the DOJ and upcoming meeting with the DOJ and

2.800

1.300

0.300
0.250
2.500
1.750
1.500
1.100

0.500
0.250
1.500

2.250
0.250

AS

3576.0

09/24/10

GMC

3577.0

09/25/10

GMC

3578.0

09/25/10

GMC

3579
3580 3579.0

09/25/10

GMC

3577

1.750

Drafted email and sent post to anonymous PO to
post on THEE RANT
Meeting with JF & JN re AS interview with feds

0.250

3578

0.500

Email re: Schoolcraft visit to meet with Feds. NY
Times, ABC news
Email to Jim Hoffer re: Schoolcraft visit
Page 164

0.250
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

B

No.
3580.0

Date
09/27/10

3581.0

1

09/27/10

3581
3582
3583 3582.0
3584 3583.0
3585 3584.0
3585.0
3586
3586.0
3587
3588 3587.0
3588.0
3589
3590 3589.0
3591 3590.0
3591.0
3592
3593 3592.0
3593.0
3594
3594.0
3595
3595.0

09/28/10
09/28/10
09/28/10
09/29/10

09/29/10
09/29/10
09/30/10
09/30/10
10/01/10
10/02/10
10/02/10
10/04/10
10/04/10
10/04/10

Timekeepe Description
Schoolcraft interview with Civil Rights Division
GMC
DOJ (pre and post), NY Times, ABC news
Meeting w/AS with JN, JF to prep for discussion
GMC
with US attorneys office EDNY
"Rich" anonymous cop discussion with JF
GMC
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
GMC
Review of Daily News article re: Schoolcraft
GMC
Phone interview of PO "VM" re quotas and
GMC
downgrading
Phone interview of PO "EF" re quotas and
GMC
downgrading
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
GMC
Meeting with JF and JN re: anonymous cop
GMC
interviews VM and EF
Review of Bernier answer
GMC
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
GMC
Email correspondence w/JN re: whistleblower cops
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC

3596
3596.0
3597
3598 3597.0
3598.0
3599
3600 3599.0
3600.0
3601
3601.0
3602
3603 3602.0
3603.0
3604
3604.0
3605
3606 3605.0
3606.0
3607

10/04/10

10/05/10
10/05/10
10/05/10
10/06/10

D

C

GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

Phone call with former PO "BS"
Meeting w/ JF and "JR" retired police officer re:
quotas, downgrading, NYPD corruption
Met with potential whistleblower PO "MF" re:
Schoolcraft, quotas, corruption
Meeting w/ JF and JN to discuss infromation from
"JR" retired police officer re: quotas, downgrading,
NYPD corruption
Emailed w/anonymous NYPD Captain re:
Schoolcraft allegations
Drafted interview memo of "MF" meeting
Reviewed Schoolcraftjustice posts, made calls,
returned emails and set up appointments
Drafted interview memo of "JR" meeting
Phone interview w/"PR" former 81st precinct PO

E

Hours
5.250

3.250
0.600
0.250
0.100
1.300

0.800
0.300
1.100
0.300
0.100

0.400
0.300
1.800

1.100

0.750
0.400
1.250
1.250

0.800
0.400

10/07/10
10/08/10
10/08/10
10/08/10
10/08/10
10/09/10

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC

Meeting with JF and "EB" retired police officer re:
quotas, downgrading, NYPD corruption
Drafted interview memo of "EB" meeting
Phone interview with "MV" retired PO re: quotas,
retaliation, downgrading
Email correspondence w "NB" re: more recordings
Review of AP story re: Schoolcraft case
Review of Schoolcraft post from former PO "WN"

1.800
1.500
1.300

0.250
0.250

0.100

Page 165

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

3607.0

Date
10/10/10

3608.0
3609.0
3610.0
3611.0
3612.0

10/10/10
10/11/10
10/11/10
10/11/10
10/12/10

3613.0

10/12/10

3614.0

10/12/10

No.

1

3608
3609
3610
3611
3612
3613

3614
3615
3616 3615.0
3616.0
3617
3618 3617.0
3618.0
3619
3619.0

10/12/10
10/12/10
10/12/10
10/13/10

10/14/10

C

D

Timekeepe Description
GMC
Meeting with JN and JF re: information provided
by MV, NB, EB whistleblower cops
GMC
Review of Schoolcraft posts
GMC
Review of Schoolcraft posts
GMC
Email correspondence w/JN re: Posts
GMC
Review of email from a police practices expert
GMC
Phone interview police officer "RL" re: quotas,
retal iation, downgrading
GMC
Meeting w/ JF and JN re: Schoolcraftjustice.com
calls from POs
GMC
Phone interview police officer "PL" re: quotas,
retaliation, downgrading
GMC
Review ofJF1MC motion to dismiss
GMC
Phone call and email w/ CUNY professor who has
info re: Schoolcraft
GMC
Review of Schoolcraft posts
GMC
Spoke to police officer "PL" re: quotas, retaliation,
downgrading
GMC
Meeting with JN re: information provided by PL
and RL whistleblower cops to support Monell

3620

claim

3620.0

10/14/10

GMC

3621.0

10/15/10

GMC

10/16/10
10/18/10
10/18/10

GMC
GMC
GMC

10/19/10
10/20/10

GMC
GMC

10/22/10

GMC

3621
3622
3623 3622.0
3624 3623.0
3624.0
3625
3626 3625.0
3626.0
3627
3627.0
3628
3629 3628.0
3630 3629.0
3631 3630.0
3631.0
3632
3633 3632.0
3633.0

10/23/10
10/24/10
10/24/10
10/25/10

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

10/25/10
10/26/10

GMC
GMC

3634
3635 3634.0

10/27/10

GMC

E

Hours
1.400

0.400
0.300
0.250
0.250
1.100
1.000

0.750
0.750

0.250
0.250
0.400

0.750

Email to web designer updating
Schoolcraftjustice.com
Review of order setting deadlines for Motion to
Dismiss
Review of Schoolcraft posts
Phone call w/ "MG" re: quotas at 81st precinct
Review of letter requesting additional time to
respond to Motion to Dismiss
Review of Schoolcraft posts
Meeting with technician to reduce size of
Schoolcraft audio files
Phone call with police officer "MR" re: NYPD
quotas, downgrading, corruption
Left VM for JN re: Schoolcraft
Phone call with David Velez
Review of Schoolcraft posts
Phone call with retired PO "RC" re: meeting to
discuss quotas provide evidence
Phone call with DC re: City Answer
Meeting with JF and "RC" to discuss experience
with quotas in a Brooklyn North precinct

0.400
0.100
0.250
0.750
0.250
0.250

0.400
1.250

0.100
0.300
0.250
0.600
0.250

3.100

Drafted interview memo of meeting w/"RC"

Page 166

1.750

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

B

D

C

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

3635.0

1

10/27/10

GMC

3636
3636.0
3637
3638 3637.0
3638.0
3639
3639.0

3640
3641 3640.0
3641.0

10/27/10

10/28/10
10/29/10

10/30/10

10/30/10
10/30/10

GMC

GMC
GMC

GMC

GMC
GMC

3642

3642.0

11/01/10

GMC

3643

3643.0

3644
3645 3644.0
3645.0
3646
3646.0
3647
3647.0
3648
3648.0
3649
3649.0
3650
3651 3650.0
3652 3651.0
3652.0
3653
3653.0
3654
3654.0
3655
3655.0

11/01/10
11/01/10
11/01/10
11/02/10

11/03/10
11/04/10
11/04/10

11/05/10
11/08/10
11/08/10
11/08/10

11/09/10

11/09/10

GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC

Meeting with JF and David Velez re: arbitration,
quotas, Michael Marino
Review of Isakov Answer to Amended complaint
Interview memo for meeting with David Velez
Review of City's request for an extension of time to
Answer to amended complaint
Meeting with JF & JN re: information provided by
MR, MG RC whistleblower cops and movie and
book publicist contacting AS for information

Phone call with entertainment lawyer
Email correspondence re: selling Schoolcraft life
rights for movie or book so that Adrian can support
himself while case proceeds
Reviewed Schoolcraftjustice posts made calls,
returned emails and set up appointments
Meeting with JN and JF re: updating Schoolcraft
website
Drafted content to update website
Review of Judge Sweet's order granting City more
time to file Answer
Email and phone correspondence with web
designer re: updates to Schoolcraftjustice.com
Review of mark ups from entertainment lawyer re:
Schoolcraft entertainment contracts
Meeting with JF and police officer "BP" re: quotas,
downgrading, and NYPD corruption
Review of letter and stipulation re: extension of
time to Answer Amended Complaint
Interview memo for "BP"
Met with JF and police officer "MC" re: quotas
Review of Document Demands and Interrogatories
filed by Isakov
Review of letter requesting additional time to
oppose motion to dismiss
Spoke to anonymous police officer CW re: quotas
in the 81st precinct
Meeting with JN about interviews with CW and
MC whistleblower cops regarding Monell claim

E

Hours

1.400

0.250
1.400
0.250

2.250
0.400

0.300
1.750

0.300
0.250
0.100
0.750

0.300

2.300
0.250
1.400
0.800
0.500

0.250
0.750

0.600

3656
3656.0
3657
3658 3657.0

11/10/10
11/10/10

GMC
GMC

Phone call w/ police officer "JW" re: quotas and
retaliation in a Brooklyn precinct
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts

Page 167

0.500
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

1

No.

3658.0
3659
3660 3659.0
3660.0
3661
3662 3661.0
3663 3662.0
3663.0

3664
3665 3664.0
3665.0
3666
3666.0
3667
3667.0
3668
3669 3668.0
3670 3669.0
3670.0
3671
3672 3671.0
3672.0
3673
3674 3673.0
3675 3674.0
3676 3675.0
3677 3676.0
3678 3677.0
3678.0
3679
3679.0
3680
3680.0
3681
3681.0
3682
3683 3682.0
3683.0
3684
3685 3684.0
3685.0
3686
3687 3686.0

C

B

Date
11/11/10

D

11/13/10
11/16/10

Timekeepe Description
GMC
Meeting with JF and "JW" cop to discuss
quotas/retaliation
GMC
Review of discovery demands from Bernier
GMC
Review of draft of plaintiffs first set of
interrogatories
GMC
Review of amended answer from Bernier
GMC
Interview memo for meeting with "JW"
GMC
Meeting with JN and JF re: issues on our motion
opposition and about information provided by JW
anonymous cop
GMC
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
GMC
Phone call with Charney re: Schoolcraft affidavit

11/16/10

GMC

11/16/10

GMC

11/16/10
11/16/10
11/17/10

GMC
GMC
GMC

11/18/10
11/19/10

GMC
GMC

Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Email correspondence with French documentarian

11/19/10
11/20/10
11/21/10
11/29/10
11/29/10
11/30/10

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

12/01/10

GMC

12/01/10

GMC

12/02/10

GMC

12/02/10
12/06/10

GMC
GMC

12/06/10
12/06/10

GMC
GMC

12/08/10

GMC

Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Review of WSJ article re: Schoolcraft case
Review of AS's changes to Floyd affidavit
Phone call w/AS re: Floyd affidavit
Implemented AS's changes to Floyd affidavit for
final review by Charney
Email and phone correspondence w/Charney re
Floyd affidavit
Discussion with JF & JN re affidavit from
Schoolcraft
Review of City Defendants answer to Amended
Complaint
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Revise and review opposition to JHMC motion to
dismiss
Discussion with JF & JN re final corrections
Drafted letter response to premature discovery
demands for Bernier and Isakov
Review of NYPD re: new quota bill

11/11/10
11/11/10
11/11/10
11/12/10
11/12/10

E

Hours
1.600

0.400
0.300
0.250
1.100

1.000
0.100

0.400

Review of affidavit Darius Charney wants
Schoolcraft to sign for Floyd case
Emailed JN re: changes to Schoolcraft Floyd
affidavit
Left voice message for Charney re: affidavit
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Reviewed and revised Discovery Demands and
Requests to Admit to be served on City Defendants

Page 168

0.400

0.100
0.100
0.100

3.800
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.250
0.500
0.300
3.400
0.800
0.400
0.400
0.100
1.250

0.800
0.400
0.400

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

3687.0

B

Date

12/08/10

D

C

Timekeepe Description

GMC

E

Hours

Email correspondence from Lee re: Docket sheet
0.100

3688

3688.0
3689
3690 3689.0
3690.0
3691
3692 3691.0
3693 3692.0
3694 3693.0
3694.0
3695
3695.0
3696
3697 3696.0
3698 3697.0
3698.0
3699
3699.0
3700
3700.0
3701
3701.0
3702
3702.0
3703
3704 3703.0
3704.0
3705
3705.0
3706
3706.0
3707
3707.0
3708
3708.0
3709
3709.0
3710
3711 3710.0
3712 3711.0
3713 3712.0
3714 3713.0
3714.0
3715

12/08/10
12/08/10
12/09/10
12/09/10
12/09/10
12/10/10
12/12/10
12/14/10

12/24/10
12/26/10
01/03/11
01/10/11
01/20/11
01/20/11
01/26/11
01/26/11
01/26/11
01/26/11
01/31/11
01/31/11
01/31/11
02/08/11
02/10/11
02/11/11
02/14/11
02/17/11
02/19/11

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

Review of email correspondence w/Graham
Raymond
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Discussion w/ JN & JF re discovery responses &
timing
Review of email re: Discovery from Isakov
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Email w/JN re: HIPAAs
Review of Daily News article w/memo showing
proof of quota
Correspondence w/Charney and Schoolcraft re:
Floyd affidavit
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Review of email correspondence from police
officer "CW" re: Marino and quotas
Meeting with JF & JN re interrogatories and
demands
Review of JHMC reply memo in support of motion
to dismiss
Meeting with JN, JF to discuss JHMC's reply
memo of law
Appearance for motion to dismiss in Schoolcraft

Discussion with JF & JN re oral arguments
Travel from SDNY for appearance for motion to
dismiss in Schoolcraft (.5)
Travel to SDNY for appearance for motion to
dismiss in Schoolcraft (.5)
Discussion w/JN re: requesting Queens DA to
investigate Halloween night
Meeting with JN & JF re send documents &
authorizations to Queens DA office
Review of materials sent to Queens DA to start
investigation
Discussion w/ JN & JF re letter to court to schedule
discovery
Review ofJHMC motion to stay discovery
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Meeting with JF re: getting transcript for Bryant v.
City verdict finding quotas existed
Page 169

0.100
0.100
0.500
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.250
0.400
0.100
0.100
0.250
1.500

0.500
0.400
1.000
0.600

0.250
0.250
0.400

0.400
0.250

0.300
0.250
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.600

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

No.

1

3716 3715.0
3716.0
3717
3718 3717.0
3718.0

B

Date

02/19/11
02/19/11

C

D

Timekeepe Description
GMC
Phone call with former NYPD officer "SS"

GMC

Email correspondence w/JN re: Seth Harris verdict
finding quota
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Meeting with anonymous cops from T34 w/ JF and
JN - provided recordings of Lt. Janice Williams

02/19/11
03/01/11

GMC
GMC

03/03/11

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

04/12/11
04/14/11

GMC
GMC

04/15/11

GMC

04/18/11

GMC

04/20/11
04/26/11
05/06/11

GMC
GMC
GMC

05/06/11

GMC

05/09/11

GMC

05/10/11

GMC

05/10/11

GMC

Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Phone call with Adrian and Larry Schoolcraft re:
Letter from NYPD charges and specs
Review of email re: Adrian charges
Review of email from WME re: Schoolcraft life
rights
Meeting w/Harry Levine Queens College re:
Schoolcraft, quota study
Discussion w/ JN & JF re prep of letter re NYPD
hearing & PBA representation
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Review of Judge Sweet's opinion re: JHMC motion
to dismiss
Email correspondence w/JN and JF re: motion to
dismiss decision
Meeting with JN and JF re: neccesary disclosures
under Rule 26 for plaitniff
Meeting with JN and JF re: edits to intial
disclosures and discussion regarding requests to
admit
Review of Initial disclosures and discussion with

0.300

0.100
0.100

Email correspondence with former NYPD PO PK

03/03/11
03/13/11
03/16/11
04/11/11

E

Hours

3719

1.250

3719.0
3720
3721 3720.0
3722 3721.0
3723 3722.0
3723.0
3724
3725 3724.0
3725.0
3726
3726.0
3727
3727.0
3728
3729 3728.0
3730 3729.0
3730.0
3731
3731.0
3732
3732.0
3733
3733.0
3734

3734.0
3735
3736 3735.0
3737 3736.0
3737.0
3738
3739 3738.0
3740 3739.0
3741 3740.0
3741.0
3742
3742.0
3743

JF
05/10/11
05/12/11
05/12/11

GMC
GMC
GMC

05/13/11
05/14/11
05/15/11
05/18/11

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

05/18/11

GMC

Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Discussion w/ JF & JN re agency agreement
Review of Book deal agreement for Adrian
Schoolcraft
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Meeting with JF reviewing RFA's
Meeting with JN and JF re: edits to RFA's
Drafted outline and notes for neccesary discovery
demands for JN
Meeting with JF to discuss documents that must he
requested in our demands
Page 170

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.750
0.250
0.100
0.500
0.300
0.100
0.100
0.600
0.250
1.750

1.400

0.750
0.100
0.400
0.250
0.100
2.750
1.000
1.300
1.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

3743.0
3744
3745 3744.0
3746 3745.0
3746.0
3747
3747.0
3748
3749 3748.0
3749.0
3750
3751 3750.0
3751.0
3752
3753 3752.0
3753.0
3754
3755 3754.0
3755.0
3756
3756.0
3757
3758 3757.0
3758.0
3759
3760 3759.0
3760.0
3761
3761.0
3762
3762.0
3763
3764 3763.0
3765 3764.0
3765.0
3766
3767 3766.0
3767.0
3768
3768.0
3769
3770 3769.0
3770.0
3771

B

Date
05/19/11
05/19/11
05/19/11
05/20/11
05/20/11

C

j

D

Timekeepe Description
Discuss w/ JN & JF edits & topic areas that should
GMC
be explored on interrogatories
Review of JN's draft document demands
GMC
Email from JN re: dep notices to be served
GMC
Discussion w/ JF & JN re request to admit
GMC
corrections/additions
Discuss interrogatories & discuss EBTs w/ JN & JF
GMC

E

Hours
1.250

0.750
0.100
1.500
1.300

05/20/11
05/20/11
05/20/11
05/24/11
05/30/11
06/13/11
06/19/11
06/23/11
06/23/11

GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC

Review of JN's request for admission
Review of JN's revised draft document demands

Email from Adrian Schoolcraft
Review of email and correspondence w/JN re
anonymous PO from 81st precinct
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Email correspondence with anonymous PO re:
Schoolcraft matter
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Discussion with JF & JN re responses & requests
from lsacov
Review of Isakov response to Discovery Demands

07/08/11
07/11/11
07/15/11

GMC
GMC
GMC

07/15/11
07/15/11

GMC
GMC

Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Discussion with JN and JF re City's failure to
response to discovery requests
Review of email correspondence with DC
Review of Discovery plan and correspondence
regarding same
Discussion w/ JN & JF re changing to case
management plan
Discussion with JF and JN re: meeting with Jim
Leander and AS about investigation
Review of pretrial order for conference
Final review of discovery plan w/ JN & JF
Meeting with JF an JN re: discovery plan and
issues to raise
Review revised discovery plan
Review of JN email re: objections to discovery plan

GMC

0.300
0.300
0.100

0.400
0.100
0.250
0.100
0.600

0.600
0.100

Review of changes to discovery plan made by Lee

06/23/11
06/27/11
06/27/11
07/05/11
07/06/11
07/08/11

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC

0.300
0.300
0.750
0.400
1.750

0.100
0.250
0.500
0.400
0.100

07/18/11
07/18/11
07/19/11

GMC
GMC

Review of email by JN to DC re changes
Review of Literary Agency agreement for
Schoolcraft

Page 171

0.250
0.100
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

B

C

D

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

3771.0

07/25/11

GMC

3772.0

1

07/26/11

GMC

07/27/11
08/04/11
08/08/11

GMC
GMC
GMC

08/09/11

GMC

08/09/11
08/10/11
08/11/11
08/14/11

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

08/15/11

GMC

3772
3773
3774 3773.0
3775 3774.0
3775.0
3776
3776.0
3777
3778 3777.0
3779 3778.0
3780 3779.0
3780.0

3781

3781.0
3782
3783 3782.0
3783.0
3784
3784.0
3785
3785.0

08/16/11
08/17/11

GMC
GMC

08/17/11

GMC

08/18/11

GMC

3786

3786.0

08/23/11

GMC

3787

3787.0
3788
3789 3788.0
3789.0
3790
3791 3790.0
3791.0
3792
3792.0
3793
3794 3793.0
3795 3794.0
3796 3795.0
3796.0
3797
3797.0
3798

08/30/11

GMC

08/31/11
09/01/11

GMC
GMC

09/02/11
09/12/11

GMC
GMC

09/28/11

GMC

09/28/11
09/28/11
09/28/11
09/29/11

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

Review of email from Brian Lee re: Discovery plan
dispute
Review of email correspondence between parties
finalizing language of discovery plan
Executed discovery plan email
Fully executed discovery plan
Review and revised responses to Bernier Discovery
demands
Drafted responses to JHMC discovery demands
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Review of JN comments to JHMC responses
Review of Isakov demands
Drafted responses to all discovery demands for
medical defendants and emailed to JN for his
review
Review of email correspondence re: delay in
discovery production
Review of City protective order stipulation
Discuss confidentiality stip w/ JF & JN b/c of
plaintiffs objections
Review of Brian Lee objections to protective order
stip
Drafted letters accompanying responses to
Discovery Demands and prepared thumb drives that
included responsive documents
Review of email from Gregory Radmosli re:
Protective order stip
Review of email correspondence from Brian Lee
re: protective order stip changes
Email response from DC re stip
Review of email from Darius Charney enclosing
Floyd decision
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Review and revise motion to compel City to
produce discovery
Discussion w/ JN and TF re law enforcement
privilege & motion to compel
Attend oral argument on motion to compel
Travel from SDNY- motion to compel (.5)
Travel to SDNY- motion to compel (.5)
Review, revised, and executed amended discovery

E

Hours

0.250
0.400
0.100
0.250
0.500
1.800
0.100

0.250
0.250

4.750
0.250
0.400
1.250

0.250

1.100

0.100
0.300
0.100
0.500
0.100
0.400
1.250
1.000

0.250
0.250

plan

09/30/11

GMC

0.300

Email from all parties re: executed amended
discovery plan

0.250

Page 172

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

1

No.

3798.0
3799
3800 3799.0
3801 3800.0
3802 3801.0
3803 3802.0
3804 3803.0
3805 3804.0
3806 3805.0
3807 3806.0
3808 3807.0
3809 3808.0
3810 3809.0
3811 3810.0
3812 3811.0
3813 3812.0
3814 3813.0
3815 3814.0
3816 3815.0
3817 3816.0
3818 3817.0
3819 3818.0
3820 3819.0
3821 3820.0
3822 3821.0
3823 3822.0
3824 3823.0
3824.0
3825
3826 3825.0
3827 3826.0
3827.0
3828
3829 3828.0
3830 3829.0
3831 3830.0
3831.0
3832
3833 3832.0
3834 3833.0
3834.0
3835
3836 3835.0
3836.0
3837

B

Date
10/12/11
10/12/11
10/17/11
10/21/11
10/22/11
10/23/11
10/24/11
10/25/11
10/26/11
10/27/11
10/28/11
10/29/11
11/02/11
11/03/11
11/04/11
11/05/11
11/12/11
11/13/11
11/17/11
11/29/11
11/29/11
12/06/11
12/07/11
12/13/11
12/13/11
12/15/11
12/19/11

01/05/12
01/10/12
01/12/12
01/20/12
01/24/12
01/24/12
02/07/12

02/07/12
02/07/12
02/07/12
02/08/12
02/08/12

C

D

I

Timekeepe Description
Receipt and review defendants first discovery
GMC
responses
Review of motion to approve protective order
GMC
Review of pre-trial order
GMC
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
GMC
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
GMC
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
GMC
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
GMC
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
GMC
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
GMC
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
GMC
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
GMC
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
GMC
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
GMC
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
GMC
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
GMC
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
GMC
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
GMC
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
GMC
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
GMC
Review of email re: discovery from Brian Lee
GMC
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
GMC
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
GMC
Review of order re: pretrial conference
GMC
Phone call with Larry and Adrian Schoolcraft
GMC
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
GMC
Review of Schoolcraft.justice.com posts
GMC
Discussion w/ JF & JN re plaintiffs thoughts on
GMC
discovery
Review of letter from Bernier's attorneys
GMC
Meeting with AS, JN and JF
GMC
Review of City Defendants first Discovery
GMC
Demands
Phone call with Adrian and Larry
GMC
Spoke to JN re: AS salary
GMC
Email copy of NOC with salary included
GMC
Review of email demanding authorizations from
GMC
Brian Lee
Email from JN re: supplemental demands
GMC
Email correspondence re: pretrial conference
GMC
Review notice of appearance for City Defendants
GMC
GMC
GMC

Pre-trial conference before Judge Sweet
Discussion with JF and JN re: conference and
discovery and strategy moving forward
Page 173

E

Hours
2.000
0.250
0.100
0.100
0.300
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.800
0.100
0.100
0.500
0.250
4.900

0.500
0.750
0.250
0.100
0.250
0.100
0.100
0.100
1.000
0.750

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

3838 3837.0
3839 3838.0
3839.0
3840
3840.0
3841
3841.0
3842
3842.0
3843
3843.0

C

B

D

Date

Timekeepe Description

02/08/12
02/08/12
02/10/12

GMC
GMC
GMC

02/10/12

GMC

02/10/12

GMC

02/10/12

GMC

02/10/12

GMC

3844.0

02/13/12

GMC

3845.0

02/24/12

GMC

Travel from SDNY- motion to compel (.5)
Travel to SONY- motion to compel (.5)
Drafted proposed supplemental demands for the
City and emailed to JN for review
Discussion w/ JN & JF re additional items of
discovery
Review of email from JN re discovery we need to
follow up with city
Email from JN re: Cancellation of Adrian and
Larry trip to NYC
Review of email to Jeremy (Meridian
Investigations) re: subpoena of Schoolcraft records

3844

0.250
0.250
1.800
1.600

0.250
0.100

0.100

3845

Review of final supplemental discovery demands
for NYC
Review of email correspondence w/Chris Dunn

3846

0.300

0.250

3846.0

02/27/12

3847.0

02/27/12

GMC

Review of subpoena response from Johstown PD

3848.0
3849.0
3850.0
3851.0
3852.0
3853.0

02/28/12
02/29/12
02/29/12
02/29/12
03/01/12
03/06/12

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

3854.0

03/07/12

GMC

03/07/12
03/07/12

GMC
GMC

03/07/12
03/07/12
03/08/12

GMC
GMC
GMC

03/08/12
03/08/12
03/08/12
03/09/12

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

03/09/12

GMC

Review of email from AS's former partner
Phone call with AS's formaer partner
Phone call w/Adrian reformer partner
Email to AS's former partner
Phone call with AS re: former partner
Review of Village Voice Article re QAD
investigation
Discussed adding 1st amendment claim with JN
and JF
Phone call with Larry and Adrian Schoolcraft
Email to JN an JF re: conversation with Larry and
Adrian
Review of NOA by Suzanna Publicker ("SP")
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Discussion with JN & JF re VV article and the
confidential report
Email from Jim Hoffer
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Review of Schoolcraf iustice.com posts
Discussion with JN & JF re reinstating 1st
Amendment claims in this case based on Garcetti &
actions after the fact
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts

GMC

Meeting with JF and JN re: documents received
from Johnstown PD for plaintiffs subpoena

3847
3848
3849
3850
3851
3852
3853

E

Hours

0.750

3854
3855
3856 3855.0
3856.0
3857
3858 3857.0
3859 3858.0
3859.0
3860
3861 3860.0
3862 3861.0
3863 3862.0
3863.0

3864
3865 3864.0

Page 174

0.750
0.100
0.750
0.400
0.100
0.300

0.300
0.250
0.250
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.750
0.100
0.100
0.100

1.250

0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

B

Date

3868.0

03/10/12
03/12/12
03/12/12
03/12/12

3869.0

03/12/12

3866 3865.0
3867 3866.0
3868 3867.0

Timekeepe Description
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
GMC
Meeting with JN & JF re letter from City
GMC

GMC
GMC

3869

3870
3871 3870.0
3872 3871.0
3873 3872.0
3873.0
3874
3875 3874.0
3875.0
3876
3876.0
3877
3878 3877.0
3879 3878.0
3879.0
3880
3880.0
3881
3882 3881.0
3883 3882.0
3883.0
3884
3884.0
3885
3886 3885.0
3886.0
3887
3888 3887.0
3888.0

03/12/12
03/12/12
03/13/12
03/13/12
03/13/12
03/14/12
03/14/12
03/14/12
03/14/12
03/15/12

03/15/12
03/16/12
03/20/12
03/21/12

03/21/12
03/22/12
03/24/12
03/28/12
03/28/12

GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

3889

3889.0

03/28/12

GMC

3890
3890.0

03/28/12

D

C

GMC

Review of SP letter re "leaked" QAD report
Email correspondence with defendants re
Amendment
Review & edit response to City's letter re protective
order
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Review of signed protective order
Email correspondence with Mark Toor
Email from PBS producer Weinrich on
documentary of Schoolcraft
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Review and revise of amended complaint adding
1st amendment claim
Email correspondence w/Nic re does in connection
w/ Schoolcraft meeting
Review of NY Times article on Schoolcraft
Review order on City motion re QAD
Meeting with JN and JF re proposed Amended
Complaint
Email correspondence from anonymous "MD" PO
re: 81st precinct
Radio interview re: Schoolcraft
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Review of NY Times motion to unseal Schoolcraft
records
Email correspondence w/JN re: NY Times motion

Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Email correspondence w/Defendants re Amended
complaint
Oral Argument on City motion
Discussion with JN and JF re: court's order on
City's motion for breach of confidentiality
agreement
Legal research: review of Garcetti and progeny to
discuss Amendment issues
Meeting w/ JN & JF prior to conference to prep

0.100
0.600
0.400
0.250
0.250
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.100
0.100
0.500

0.250
0.100
0.100
0.600
0.100
0.400
0.100
0.400

0.100
0.100
0.250
1.000

0.500
0.400

0.400

3891

3891.0

03/28/12

GMC

3892

3892.0
3893

E

Hours

03/28/12

GMC

Travel from SDNY for Oral Argument on City
motion (.5)
Travel to SDNY for Oral Argument on City motion

0.250

(.5)

0.250

Page 175

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

B

C

D

I

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

3893.0

03/29/12

GMC

3894.0

1

03/30/12

GMC

03/30/12
03/30/12

GMC
GMC

03/30/12
03/30/12
04/05/12

GMC
GMC
GMC

3894

3895
3896 3895.0
3896.0
3897
3898 3897.0
3899 3898.0
3899.0
3900
3900.0
3901
3901.0
3902
3902.0
3903
3903.0
3904
3905 3904.0
3905.0
3906
3907 3906.0
3907.0
3908
3909 3908.0
3910 3909.0
3910.0
3911
3911.0
3912
3912.0
3913
3913.0

04/05/12

GMC

04/05/12

GMC

04/06/12

GMC

04/09/12

GMC

04/10/12
04/10/12

GMC
GMC

04/10/12
04/13/12

GMC
GMC

04/13/12
04/13/12
04/24/12

GMC
GMC
GMC

04/24/12

GMC

04/25/12

GMC

04/30/12

GMC

3914.0

04/30/12

GMC

3915.0

04/30/12

GMC

3916.0

05/01/12

GMC

Revised and help draft proposed AEO stip w/JN
and JF for City
Email correspondence w/SP re Discovery extension
and opposition to amendment of Complaint
Meeting w/ JN & JF re AEO changes
Discussion with JN and JF re: filing motion to
amend and discovery issues
Final review of proposed AEO stip
Emailed proposed AEO stip to the City
Reviewed and revised responses to City defendants
discovery requests
Review & discuss w/ JN & JF plaintiffs responses
to City demands
Review of basis for City's opposition to
Amendment
Correspondence w/ NY Times counsel re:
protective order
Email correspondence w/JN re: discovery
responses
Meeting w/ AS
Email enclosing discovery responses to City
demands
Email re: Schoolcraft arrival to NYC
Discussion with JN and JF re: Matthews decision
Review of Matthews decision
Email from plaintiff re 1st Amendment claim
Review and revise JF motion to Amend 1st
Amendment claim
Email correspondence to City correcting Lt. Gough
for Amended Complaint
Email from City re: Vallone and Vans subpoenas

E

Hours

0.800

0.600
0.600
0.500
0.300
0.100
1.800

0.800
0.250
0.300
0.100
4.600
0.100
0.100

0.600
0.600
0.100
0.750

0.100
0.100

Review NY Times proposed language to protective
order and email sent to City Defendants

3914

0.400

3915
3916

Discussion w/ JN and JF re NY Times alteration to
protective order
Review of correspondence with SP re: adjourning
oral argument on Amendment
Discussions w/ JN and JF re City's request for
affidavits & deposition for confidentiality breach

3917

0.300
0.250

0.400

Page 176

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

3917.0

B

Date
05/02/12

3918

3918.0

05/03/12

3919

3919.0

05/03/12

3920
3920.0

05/03/12

3921
3921.0
3922
3923 3922.0
3923.0
3924
3924.0
3925
3925.0
3926
3926.0
3927
3927.0
3928
3928.0
3929
3930 3929.0
3930.0

05/08/12
05/08/12
05/09/12

D

C

Timekeepe Description
Email to City re: failure to provide discovery or
GMC
respond to proposed AEO
Review of defendants proposed AEO stip and
GMC
declaration re: "leak"
Discussion w/ JF & JN re Affidavits and conf. stip
GMC
AEO
Review of correspondence with SP re: adjourning
GMC
oral argument on Amendment again
Discussion w/ JN and JF re argument on 1st
GMC
Amendment claim
Review of NOA William Fraenkel
GMC
Attended Oral Argument on 1st Amendment claim
GMC

E

Hours
0.250
1.250

0.750
0.100
0.600
0.100
1.000

05/09/12
05/09/12
05/11/12
05/15/12

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

Travel from SDNY for Argument on 1st
Amendment claim (.5)
Travel to SDNY for Argument on 1st Amendment
claim (.5)
Read and review of defendant's letter to quash and
discussion w/ JF & JN
Email correspondence w/SP re: Breach Affidavit

0.250
0.250
2.100
0.100

05/16/12
05/16/12
05/17/12

GMC
GMC
GMC

Discussion w/ JN and JF re opp to defendant's
motion to quash
Email correspondence w/Darius Charney
Review and edit plaintiffs opp to defendant's
motion to quash Vallone and Vans motion to quash

0.600
0.250

0.800

3931

3931.0

05/17/12

GMC

Discussion w/JN and JF re: AS breach affidavit
0.750

3932

3932.0

05/17/12

GMC

3933

3933.0
3934
3935 3934.0
3936 3935.0
3936.0
3937
3937.0
3938
3939 3938.0
3940 3939.0
3940.0
3941
3942 3941.0
3943 3942.0

05/17/12
05/17/12
05/18/12
05/18/12
05/22/12
05/23/12
05/23/12
05/23/12
05/23/12
05/23/12

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

Review and discuss City New York Times opp
Jetter w/ JN & JF
Phone call with NY Times counsel re: Stip
language
Email re: AS breach affidavit
Meet and confer w/SP re: Stips
Email correspondence w/SP re: scheduling oral
argument on motion to quash
Discussion w/ JN & JF re defendant's letter re
Vallone subpoena
Attend and argue against motion to quash
Prep for argument w/ JF & JN
Discussion w/ JN & JF re defendant's letter re
subpoena
Travel from SDNY for motion to quash (.5)
Travel to SDNY for motion to quash (.5)
Page 177

0.400

0.300
0.100
0.600
0.100
0.600
1.000
1.000

0.600
0.250
0.250

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A
1

No.

3943.0
3944
3945 3944.0
3945.0
3946
3946.0
3947
3947.0
3948
3949 3948.0
3950 3949.0
3950.0
3951
3951.0
3952
3952.0
3953
3953.0
3954
3955 3954.0
3955.0
3956
3956.0
3957
3957.0
3958
3958.0
3959
3960 3959.0
3961 3960.0
3961.0
3962
3963 3962.0
3964 3963.0
3965 3964.0
3965.0
3966
3966.0
3967
3968 3967.0
3968.0
3969
3970 3969.0

B

Date
05/24/12

05/24/12
05/25/12

C

D

Timekeepe Description
GMC
Drafted and submitted supplemental evidence to
support our opposition to quash Vans and Vallone
subpoena
GMC
Review of NOA-Walter Kretz ("WK")
GMC
Read and review NY Times response to SP letter

E

Hours

0.500
0.100

0.250
05/29/12

GMC

05/30/12

GMC

05/31/12
06/04/12
06/05/12

GMC
GMC
GMC

06/06/12

GMC

06/07/12

GMC

06/07/12

GMC

06/08/12
06/08/12

GMC
GMC

06/08/12

GMC

06/14/12

GMC

06/14/12

GMC

06/14/12
06/14/12
06/18/12

GMC
GMC
GMC

06/19/12
06/19/12
06/19/12
06/19/12

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

06/20/12

GMC

06/20/12
06/21/12

GMC
GMC

Revised City proposed AEO and Conf Stips
incorporating NY Times requests
Email correspondence w/JN re City stips and
revisions
Meeting w/JN and JF re: City conf. Stips
Review of WK correspondence re: discovery
Review of email correspondence between SP and
Times
Review of email correspondence between SP and
Times
Revised AEO and Conf stips to send back to the
City and emailed to JN for final review
Review of email correspondence between SP and
Times
Email re: subpoenaed does
Emailed stip to SP with revisions in track changes

0.500

0.300
0.900
0.100
0.100

0.100
1.400

0.100
0.100
0.100

Review of correspondence with NY Times and SP
re: Schoolcraft materials
Meet with JN and JF to discuss motion for
reconsideration on 1st amendment claim
Review of Judge Sweet re: motion to amend and
motion quash subpoena
Phone call with Adrian and Larry re; decision
Email correspondence with JN re: decision
Review of JF motion for reconsideration on motion
to amend
Meeting w/ Schoolcraft in Johnstown
Travel back to NYC from Johnstown (3.5)
Travel to Johnstown (3.5)
Email and phone correspondence with Adhyl
Polanco re: Schoolcraft issues
Final edit and review of Motion for
Reconsideration
Reviewed SP response to Stip proposal
Email correspondence w/JN and JF re Schoolcraft
issues

06/30/12

GMC

Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts

Page 178

0.100

0.750
0.600
0.500
0.250

0.750
4.800
1.750
1.750

0.100
0.300
0.300
0.250
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

3970.0
3971
3972 3971.0
3973 3972.0
3973.0
3974
3975 3974.0
3975.0
3976
3976.0
3977
3977.0
3978
3978.0
3979
3980 3979.0
3980.0
3981
3982 3981.0
3982.0
3983
3984 3983.0
3985 3984.0
3986 3985.0
3986.0
3987
3988 3987.0
3989 3988.0
3990 3989.0
3991 3990.0
3992 3991.0
3993 3992.0
3993.0
3994
3995 3994.0
3996 3995.0
3996.0
3997
3997.0
3998
3999 3998.0
3999.0
4000
4000.0
4001

B

Date
07/02/12
07/06/12
07/09/12
07/09/12
07/10/12
07/17/12
07/20/12

07/23/12
07/23/12
07/26/12
07/28/12
08/01/12
08/03/12

08/04/12
08/06/12
08/07/12
08/08/12
08/08/12
08/08/12
08/09/12
08/09/12
08/09/12
08/10/12
08/10/12

08/10/12
08/12/12
08/13/12

D

C

Timekeepe Description
Discussion w/ AS and Larry Schoolcraft re
GMC
financial issues
Review of email from JF re Stips
GMC
Researched donations to individuals
GMC
Drafted proposed language for Donate button on
GMC
website
Review of City response re Stips
GMC
Email w/JN re: meeting in Albany with
GMC
Schoolcrafts
Review of opinion on Plaintiffs motion to
GMC
reconsider
Discussion w/ JF & JN re meeting w/ Schoolcrafts
GMC
in Albany
Correspondence re: visiting Schoolcrafts in Albany
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC

Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Discussion w/ JN & JF re motion to amend to add
prior restraint
Review and revise motion to amend
Email correspondence w/SP re: document
production
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Email re: meeting with Schoolcrafts
Email correspondence re: authorizations
Meeting w/ JN & JF re meeting w/ AS in Albany
for prep
Review of final stips
Printed out docs to go over with Adrian
Meeting w/AS in Albany
Traveled from Albany back to NYC (3.0)
Traveled to Albany to meet Client (3.0)
Email correspondence re: extension of disco
Email correspondence re: Schoolcraft deposition
Email w/JN re Schoolcraft breach affidavit
Review of Schoolcraftjustice.com posts
Review of email from SP re: scheduling AS depo

E

Hours

0.400
0.100
0.500
0.400
0.100
0.100

0.300
0.300
0.250
0.100

0.600
0.400
0.250
0.100
0.100
0.250
1.300

0.500
0.250
5.750
1.500
1.500
0.250

0.250
0.100
0.100
0.100

08/14/12

08/14/12
08/15/12
08/15/12

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

Email web designers re: donation for Schoolcrafts
button on website
Review of correspondence re Tax returns
Email correspondence with all defendants re:
subpoenaed docs
Email correspondence re: Schoolcraft deposition

0.250
0.100

0.250
0.100

Page 179

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

C

B

D

4001.0

Date
08/16/12

4002.0

08/16/12

Timekeepe Description
GMC
Discussion w/ JN & JF re City's suggestion on
multiple dates for deps
GMC
Email correspondence re: Schoolcraft deposition

4003.0

1

08/20/12

GMC

4004.0
4005.0
4006.0
4007.0
4008.0
4009.0
4010.0
4011.0

08/21/12
08/21/12
08/21/12
08/21/12
08/21/12
08/21/12
08/21/12
08/22/12

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

4012.0
4013.0
4014.0
4015.0
4016.0
4017.0

08/22/12
08/22/12
08/22/12
08/22/12
08/22/12
08/23/12

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

No.

4002
4003

4004
4005
4006
4007
4008
4009
4010
4011
4012
4013
4014
4015
4016
4017

E

Hours
0.750
0.100

4018
4019 4018.0
4020 4019.0
4021 4020.0
4021.0
4022
4023 4022.0
4023.0
4024
4024.0

08/23/12
08/23/12
08/23/12
08/28/12

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

08/28/12
08/28/12

GMC
GMC

08/29/12

GMC

Discussion w/ JN & JF re additional amendment of
the complaint to add Hanlon
Review of Amended Complaint adding Hanlon
Email from Brady consenting to Amendment
Email from Brady re scheduling AS dep
Email from City requesting copy of complaint
Email from Lee consenting
Email from Lee re scheduling AS dep
Email to City w/ Amended Complaint
Meeting w/ JF & JN re Kretz's request to have an
additional day to depose plaintiff
Email from City re AS dep date
Email from Greg Rad re AS dep
Email from JN re dep dates
Email from Kretz re AS dep date
Email from Lee re AS dep date
Review of discovery provided by City defendants
Email from Brady re plaintiffs dep date
Email from Lee on plaintiffs dep dates
Email from Lee re second day for AS dep
Email from JN to defendants enclosing responses to
discovery
Email JN and JF re Chief article
Review of correspondence sending out Fulton
County records
Meeting w/ JF & JN re: City's Suppl. Disclosure &
the need for us to depose at least 5 of the 9 new
witnesses identified by City & other gen. strategy
issues for advancing discovery

4025

0.600
0.500
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.400
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
3.500
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.800
4025.0

08/29/12

GMC

Email 2 & 3 from JN re discovery to defendants

4026.0

08/29/12

GMC

Email from JN to defendants enclosing discovery

4027.0

09/10/12

GMC

4028
4029 4028.0
4030 4029.0
4030.0
4031

09/10/12
09/10/12
09/10/12

GMC
GMC
GMC

4026

0.100

4027

0.100

Read and review Opinion & Order from Sweet on
plaintiffs motion to amend
Phone call with PO "FP" re Schoolcraft
Email from City re fax# confirmation
Email from JN re 120 day extension of discovery

0.750
0.400
0.100
0.100

Page 180

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

4032
4033
4034
4035
4036
4037
4038
4039

B

No.

Date

4031.0
4032.0
4033.0
4034.0
4035.0
4036.0
4037.0
4038.0
4039.0

09/10/12
09/10/12
09/10/12
09/10/12
09/10/12
09/10/12
09/10/12
09/15/12
09/17/12

4040
4041 4040.0
4042 4041.0
4042.0
4043
4043.0
4044
4044.0

09/18/12
09/19/12
09/21/12

D

C

Timekeepe Description
Email response from Brady
GMC
Email response from City
GMC
Email response from Greg Rad
GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

Email response from Kretz
Email response from Lee
Email to City re Hanlon amend
Response from City on Hanlon amend
Reviewed IAB recordings provided by the City
Review of draft letter to amend to add Hanlon to
complaint
Review of order granting ext. of disco deadline
Received final Stips
Email correspondence w/Darius Charney re: Floyd

E

Hours

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100
3.800

0.250
0.100
0.100
0.250

09/24/12
09/24/12

GMC
GMC

Meeting w/JN and JF to discuss City deficiency
letter and AS dep prep
Email from City re service of amended complaint,
Lauderborn dep, & discovery deficiencies

1.750

0.500

4045
4045.0

09/24/12

GMC

Email correspondence w/Darius Charney re: Floyd
0.250

4046
4046.0

4047
4048 4047.0
4049 4048.0
4049.0
4050
4051 4050.0
4052 4051.0
4053 4052.0
4054 4053.0
4055 4054.0
4056 4055.0
4057 4056.0
4057.0
4058
4058.0
4059
4060 4059.0
4061 4060.0
4061.0
4062
4063 4062.0
4063.0
4064

09/24/12

09/25/12
09/25/12
09/26/12
09/26/12
09/26/12
09/27/12
09/28/12
10/02/12
10/03/12
10/04/12
10/04/12
10/04/12
10/10/12
10/10/12
10/11/12
10/11/12
10/12/12

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

Email correspondence re service of amended
complaint
Prep AS for his dep
Meeting w/ AS & JF & JN re dep prep
Meeting w/ JN & JF & AS re adjorning dep due to
father's medical emergency
Brady email re: service of process
Review of email from JN adjourning AS dep
Reviewed and signed stips
Reviewed and resigned stips
Review of QAD interview of AS
Received AS new email address
Review of IAB recordings
Phone call and email correspondence w/Darius
Charney
Review of plaintiffs responses to defendants
interrogatories
Prep Adrian for deposition
Review amended complaint
Attended AS deposition and meeting afterwards
Meeting with JN, JF, AS before depo
Correspondence to SP re: color photos and QAD
file review by AS
Page 181

0.100
3.500
2.900
0.600
0.100
0.100
0.250
0.100
2.250
0.100
2.750

0.750
0.400
4.600
0.750
8.900
0.500

0.250

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

1

No.

4064.0

Date
10/15/12

4065
4065.0

C

B

10/15/12

4066

D

Timekeepe Description
GMC
Meeting w/JN & JF re: Marino's IAB interview &
inconsitencies w/claims in OF 49 & Halloween
Night recording
GMC
Read and reviewed Kretz motion to have extra day
to depose AS
GMC
Meeting w/JN & JF re: City's privilege claims and
possible arguments/motions to defeat such claims
highlights of Lauterborn interview &
inconsistencies w/Marino & home invasion
recording

4066.0

10/17/12

4067.0

10/17/12

GMC

4068
4069 4068.0
4069.0

10/17/12
10/18/12

GMC
GMC

4070.0

10/18/12

GMC

4071.0

10/18/12

GMC

4072.0

10/18/12

GMC

4073.0

10/18/12

GMC

4074.0

10/20/12

GMC

Phone call w/JN & JF re: P.O. Nowacki
acknowledging quota (15 c's per month) at 81 &
possibly serving non-party subpoeana on her for
dep and discovering other possible w's at 81 re
summons quota

4075.0

10/22/12

GMC

4076.0

10/23/12

GMC

Review of City request to enlarge Hanlon time to
respond
Drafted responses and compiled responsive docs
for City defendants second request for discovery
sent to JN for review

10/24/12
10/24/12

GMC
GMC

10/24/12

GMC
GMC

11/02/12

GMC

Review of case law sent by Lee re: medical
defendants liability
Email from JN re: Schoolcraft phone numbers

1.200

0.300

Travel from SDNY for conference re: trial date (.5)

11/02/12

E

Hours

4067

4070
4071

4072
4073

Dicussion w/ JF & JN re City's refusal to allow AS
to see QAD file
Email from SP re: QAD file
Meeting w/JF & JN re: City's Deliberative Process
and Grand Jury privilege claims and best strategy
for defeating same.
Read and review Answer to Amended Complaint
from City
Review and revised of JN Motion permitting AS to
review QAD material and opposing 3 days of
depositions for AS
Email from SP re: service of newly named City
defendants
Review of email from B Lee asking that plaintiff
withdraw opp to extra day of dep for AS

4074

3.300
0.400
0.100

1.200

0.750

0.500
0.100

0.100

4075
4076

4077
4078 4077.0
4078.0
4079
4079.0
4080
4080.0
4081
4082 4081.0

Hearing on issue of extra dep time for AS
Travel from SDNY for conference re: trial date (.5)

0.900
0.100

3.400
0.800

0.250
0.250

Page 182

0.400
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

4082.0

B

Date

11/07/12

D

C

Timekeepe Description

GMC

E

Hours

Hearing on issue of AS able to review QAD file
0.800

4083

4083.0

11/07/12

GMC

4084
4084.0

11/07/12

GMC

Review of letter by SP relieving City as counsel for
Mauriello
Travel from SDNY for conference re: trial date (.5)

0.300

0.250

4085

4085.0

11/07/12

GMC

Travel from SDNY for conference re: trial date (.5)
0.250

4086
4086.0

11/07/12

GMC

Email w/JN re: service of newly named defendants
0.100

4087

4087.0

11/13/12

GMC

4088
4088.0
4089
4090 4089.0
4090.0
4091
4091.0
4092
4092.0
4093
4093.0
4094
4095 4094.0
4095.0
4096
4096.0
4097
4097.0

11/13/12
11/13/12
11/14/12
11/15/12
11/19/12

11/26/12

01/23/15
02/02/15
02/02/15

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC

Confirming with JF w/AS on the phone that he is
terminating representation
Various correspondence confirming termination of
representation with the parties
Correspondence from City re rep of AS
Receipt and review of letter terminating our
representation of AS
Review and signed letter to court informing we no
longer represent AS
Review of court order prohibiting providing AS
AEO material
Review of correspondence to AS enclosing files
Call w/JN and JF about taking over case again
Discussion w/ JF & JN re representing AS again
for trial
Phone conversation w/JN re AS wants to rehire us

0.300
0.250
0.100
0.100
0.250

0.100
0.250
0.800
1.300

0.300
02/04/15

GMC

Phone call w JN and JF re: pending trial strategy
and misc.evidentiary issues, and setting up meetng
to discuss same in greater detail

GMC

Review of email from AS re: QAD memo from Sgt.
Scott
Read and reviewed email from AS re: rehiring us

0.900

4098
4098.0

02/04/15

4099

4099.0

02/04/15

GMC

0.400
0.300

4100
4100.0

02/04/15

GMC

Discussion w/ JN & JF re scheduling a meeting w/
NS to discuss case status and trial prep
0.250

4101

4101.0
4102
4103 4102.0

02/04/15
02/05/15

GMC
GMC

Review of email from Nat Smith ("NS")
acknowledging and logistics of represetation
Read and reviewed AS deposition

Page 183

0.100
2.250

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

C

B

D

Date
02/05/15

Timekeepe Description
GMC
Phone call w. JN re: updates on discussion with Nat
Smith, records and transcripts provided by Adrian
and goal to streamline case for trial

02/08/15
02/08/15
02/09/15

GMC
GMC
GMC

Read and reviewed AS deposition
Email correspondence re: videos of deps
Read and reviewed Larry Schoolcraft Deposition

02/09/15

GMC

4108.0

02/10/15

GMC

Phone call JN re: issues that came up in Adrian's
Dep and Larry's Dep and possible Miotions in
Limine
Meeting w/ JN & JF regarding global trial strategy,
witnesses to be called (or not called), exhibits to
use, Rule 68 offer and next steps for moving
forward.

4109.0

1

02/10/15

GMC

No.

4103.0

4104
4105 4104.0
4106 4105.0
4106.0
4107
4107.0

0.500
3.250
0.250

2.750

4108

4109

4110
4111 4110.0
4111.0
4112
4112.0
4113
4114 4113.0
4115 4114.0
4116 4115.0
4116.0

E

Hours

02/11/15
02/11/15

GMC
GMC

02/11/15

GMC

Email correspondence w/AS, JN re: Defendants
request to adjourn trial
Review of deposition exhibits
Review of summary judgment motions and exhibits

0.400

3.500
0.250
3.100

2.500

Review of witness/exhibit list from JN and discuss
with JF
Review of email from AS
Review of deposition exhibits
Review of NOA for Howard Scheirer
Review of all evidence we have and what we are
missing, drafted a list for JN to discuss, prepared
items to put in binder, organized critical evidence
for trial prep

02/11/15
02/12/15
02/12/15
02/13/15

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

4117.0

02/13/15

GMC

4118.0

02/13/15

GMC

4119.0

02/13/15

GMC

Review of order setting trial date to April 20, 2015

02/15/15
02/16/15

GMC
GMC

Review of deposition exhibits
Review of summary judgment motions and exhibits

02/17/15
02/17/15

GMC
GMC

02/18/15
02/18/15

GMC
GMC

1.300

4117

4118

Meeting w/JN to discuss which witnesses I would
be responsible for at trial
Review of letter by Ryan Shaffer requesting more
time for reply and 2 week adjournment of trial

4119

0.100
4.400
0.100

5.250
1.300

0.100

4120
4121 4120.0
4121.0
4122
4123 4122.0
4123.0
4124
4125 4124.0
4125.0
4126

Review of deposition exhibits
Listened and took notes of PAA Boston IAB
interviews and reviewed Scott inteview memos
Began cross examination draft of PAA Boston
Read, reviewed and took notes of PAA Boston
deposition
Page 184

0.100
4.800

3.100
3.750
1.600

2.300
2.250

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

B

D

C

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

4126.0

02/18/15

GMC

4127
4128 4127.0
4128.0
4129
4130 4129.0
4130.0

02/19/15
02/19/15
02/19/15
02/19/15

GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC

E

Hours

Phone call JN regarding meeting for Friday,
important testimony from PAA Boston and issues
to cover in the plaintiffs direct (re: downgrading
and MIL regarding Johnstown Social Services
Drafted Boston Cross outline
Reviewed Mauriello's motion for SMJ and
opposition to plaintiffs motion for SMJ
Retrieved a portion of AS deposition for JN
Phone call JN regarding best and worst PTS from
Huffman, Adrian's handling of downgrading issue
at his deposition, fit for duty reports, and general
issues that might come up at tomorrows meeting

0.600
2.300
1.400
1.250

0.500

4131
4131.0

02/19/15

GMC

4132

4132.0
4133
4134 4133.0
4134.0

02/20/15
02/20/15
02/20/15

GMC
GMC
GMC

4135
4135.0

02/20/15

GMC

4136
4136.0

02/20/15

GMC

4137
4137.0

4138
4139 4138.0
4140 4139.0
4141 4140.0
4141.0
4142
4142.0
4143
4144 4143.0
4145 4144.0
4145.0
4146
4147 4146.0
4148 4147.0
4149 4148.0
4149.0
4150
4151 4150.0

02/23/15
02/23/15
02/24/15
02/24/15
02/24/15
02/24/15
02/24/15
02/24/15
02/24/15
02/25/15
02/25/15
02/25/15
02/25/15
02/25/15

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

Emailed JN summary of deposition section and
noted it for prep of AS at trial
Meeting w/ TEAM to discuss trial strategy,
division of Labor, motions
Drafted Boston cross outline
Meeting w/ JN and JF before meeting with Nat
Smith to discuss how we are going to proceed at
meeting
Phone call JN regarding summary of todays
meeting
Review of letter AS wishes to send to Zachary
Carter re indemnification from Mauriello claim
Read, reviewed and took notes on Huffman
deposition
Follow-up email with NS re: meeting
Drafted Huffman cross examination outline
Review of John Eterno Deposition
Listened and isolated points of 10/31 day tour
recording from cross outline
Listened to Huffman IAB interviews and reviewed
Scott memo re same
Discussion with JF re: Huffman cross
Email correspondence w/NS re confidentiality
Review of email from JN to NS re missing docs
needed for crosses
Drafted Huffman cross examination outline
Drafted Valenti examination outline
Review of Valenti deposition
Review of patrol guide procedures re sick leave and
AWOL
Review of email from AS re timeline
Page 185

0.300
3.500
1.500

1.000

0.200
0.100
3.000
0.250
3.400
1.900
1.250
1.100

0.750
0.250
0.250
3.400
2.400
1.500

0.900
0.400

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

4151.0
4152
4153 4152.0
4153.0
4154
4154.0
4155
4156 4155.0
4157 4156.0
4157.0

C

B

Date

02/25/15

02/26/15
02/26/15
02/26/15

GMC

02/26/15
02/26/15
02/26/15

GMC
GMC
GMC

4158
4158.0

02/26/15

GMC

4159.0

02/26/15

GMC

02/27/15
02/27/15

GMC
GMC

02/27/15

GMC

02/27/15

GMC

03/02/15
03/03/15

GMC
GMC

03/03/15

GMC

4167.0

03/04/15

GMC

4168.0

03/04/15

GMC

03/04/15
03/04/15

GMC
GMC

03/04/15

GMC

03/04/15
03/05/15

GMC
GMC

4159

4160
4161 4160.0
4161.0
4162
4162.0
4163
4163.0

4164
4165 4164.0
4165.0
4166
4166.0
4167

4168

4169
4170 4169.0
4170.0
4171
4171.0
4172
4173 4172.0
4173.0
4174

D

i
;Tmekeepe Description
!
GMC
Email correspondence re: major points to hit with
Valenti
GMC
Drafted Valenti examination
GMC
Review of all recordings inventory and identifying

recordings that are missing
Meeting w/JN and JF re: outstanding items we need
from trial from NS
Discussion with JF re: Valenti exmanination
Email w/NS team re: missing recordings
Phone call with JN regarding plaintiffs
conversation with Huffman, recording of same and
making transcripts of other recordings.
Phone call w/JN and Merry Soeto re: IAB and
DAO recording
Email correspondence w/NS and JN re: IAB
recorded interviews
Review of deposition summaries by NS team
Email and phone correspondence w/Veritext re:
transcribing IAB recordings
Email correspondence with NS and JN re: dep
summaries, index of all exhibits, potential trial
exhibits
Emailed confidentiality stip to Veritext for
transcribers to sign
Review of deposition summaries by NS team
Review and revise Huffman cross examination
outline
Phone call JN regarding lAB tapes, strategy for
plaintiff direct and for use of home invasion audio
in opening
Review and revise Huffman cross examination
outline
Phone call with JN regarding Huffman cross -x
points, and using Valenti deposition testimony to
refute same and reassigning Sgt. James cross and
obtaining a draft of direct for plaintiff from NS
Phone and email call w/JN re: witness list
E-mail exchange JN regarding Velez PBA
transcript, copy of same
E-mail exchange with JN regarding identity of
other IAB investigator
E-mail froim JN with revised witness list
Received and reviewed (for accuracy) transcribed
IAB recordings from Veritext
Page 186

E

Hours

0.300
3.400
1.800

1.100

0.500
0.400

0.400
0.300
0.250
3.800
1.250

0.400
0.250
1.400
1.800

0.500
2.300

0.500
0.300
0.100
0.100
0.100

2.750

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

4174.0
4175
4176
4177
4178
4179
4180

B

Date
03/06/15

D

C

Timekeepe Description
Review of defendants Reply memorandums for
GMC
SMJ

4175.0
4176.0
4177.0
4178.0
4179.0
4180.0

4181
4182 4181.0
4183 4182.0
4183.0
4184
4184.0
4185
4185.0
4186
4187 4186.0
4187.0
4188
4188.0
4189
4190 4189.0
4190.0
4191
4191.0
4192
4193 4192.0
4193.0
4194
4194.0

03/06/15
03/06/15
03/09/15
03/09/15
03/09/15
03/09/15

03/09/15
03/10/15
03/10/15
03/10/15
03/11/15
03/11/15
03/12/15

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC

Review of Lamstein depostion errata sheet
Began drafting AS direct examination
Discussion with JF to help outline AS direct
examination
Email and phone correspondence w/NS team re
Schoolcraft recordings of 10/31
Draft AS direct examination, review deps, audios

GMC
GMC

Email w/NS and JN re: exhibits and meeting
Meeting w/ JF, JN, NS, and Jon L re trial, motions

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

03/12/15
03/12/15
03/13/15

GMC

Email from AS re: witness list
Draft AS direct examination, review deps, audios

GMC

Review of proposed jury instructions drafted by NS
team
Review of email from JN re:
Draft AS direct examination, spoke to AS on
phone, developed ideas re points to cover
Review of production index and evidence to assess
documents still missing and needed for review and
incorporation into examinations
Discussion with JF re: AS direct examination and
points to cover, strategy
Drafted and sent email to NS team re: missing
documents
Draft AS direct examination, reviewed docs,
memos, recordings
Review of interview memo of Stretmoyers
Began Draft James cross examination, reviewed
docs, memos, hospital records
Drafted and entailed subpoenas of City defendants
to NS

4198
4199 4198.0
4199.0
4200
4200.0
4201

1.000

0.800
0.400

0.300
0.300
4.800
1.500

0.600
5.500
0.100

2.250
0.100

4.300
03/13/15
03/13/15
03/16/15

03/16/15

GMC
GMC
GMC

03/16/15

GMC

03/16/15

GMC

4197

4197.0

2.250
0.600
0.300

Draft AS direct examination, review deps, audios

GMC
GMC

4196
4196.0

Hours

2.400

4195
4195.0

Discussion w/JN & JF re proposed witnesses
Review of AS proposed witness list
Review of plaintiffs consolidated 56.1
Review of Marino deposition
Phone call w/NS re consolidated 56.1
Phone call w. JN regarding E -mails sent to Smith
and setting up meeting with him and his trial team

E

03/17/15
03/17/15
03/18/15
03/18/15

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

Page 187

0.400
0.250
3.400

1.400
1.300

0.300
6.250
0.300
5.400

0.750

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

4202 4201.0
4203 4202.0
4203.0
4204
4204.0
4205
4206 4205.0
4206.0
4207
4208 4207.0
4208.0
4209
4209.0
4210
4210.0
4211
4211.0

B

C

D

Timekeepe Description

Hours

03/18/15
03/18/15
03/19/15

GMC
GMC
GMC

0.250
0.250

03/19/15

GMC

03/19/15
03/20/15

GMC
GMC

03/20/15
03/22/15

GMC
GMC

03/23/15

GMC

03/23/15

GMC

03/23/15

GMC

03/23/15

GMC

03/23/15
03/23/15

GMC
GMC

03/23/15

GMC

03/23/15
03/23/15

GMC
GMC

03/23/15

GMC

03/23/15

GMC

03/23/15
03/24/15

GMC
GMC

03/24/15

GMC

4223.0

03/24/15

GMC

4224.0

03/25/15

GMC

Email w/JN re Schoolcraft direct
Review of NS striking Lamstein report
Draft James cross examination, reviewed docs,
memos, hospital records
Discussion with JF re: James cross examinaiton
Review of NS verdict sheet
Began Draft Sawyer cross examination, reviewed
docs, memos, hospital records, audio
Email re Kretz finding Schoolcraft
Review of NS letter re Lamstein and emailed
comments
Draft Sawyer cross examination, reviewed does,
memos, hospital records, audio
Discussion with JF re: Sawyer points for cross
examination
Various email correspondence w/NS re: verdict
sheet, Lamstein letter and exhibit list/chart

4212

3.900
0.750
0.250

4.800
0.250
0.400

2.750
0.600

0.500
4212.0

4213
4214 4213.0
4214.0
4215
4215.0
4216
4217 4216.0
4217.0
4218
4218.0
4219
4219.0
4220
4221 4220.0
4221.0
4222
4222.0

Meeting with JN regarding important points of Sgt/
James and Sgt. Sawyer's testimony
Phone call w/JN re: James call to Lauterborn
Phone correspondence w/ JN re: AS discussion of
Home Invasion
Email correspondence re: Schoolcraft short film
Email to NS team re: PO Miller IAB tape
Locate and send AS deposition testimony to help
with JN crosses
Review of Kretz supplemental interrogatories re
Schoolcraft movie
Email from JN w/portion of Lauterborn cross re
James
Email to NS re: Sawyer memo book
Updated Huffman cross examination w/roll call
recordings, QAD findings
Meeting w/JN discussing role of Sadowsky, Miller
and Sawyer; Also, QAD Huffman interview and
relation to Mauriello and general trial strategy

4223

0.400
0.400

0.300
0.250
0.250
0.250
0.250
0.100
0.100
1.750

0.600

4224
4225

E

Date

Email and phone correspondence w/JN re:
Huffman QAD connection
Drafted email to NS team re: locating points of AS
Audio recordings

Page 188

0.300

0.250

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

4225.0
4226
4227 4226.0
4227.0
4228
4229 4228.0
4230 4229.0
4231 4230.0
4231.0

B

Date
03/25/15
03/26/15
03/26/15
03/26/15
03/26/15
03/26/15
03/27/15

C

D

I

Timekeepel Description
Email correspondence w/JN and NS regarding
GMC
regular meetings
Updated AS direct examination
GMC
Review of AS medical records from JHMC, Sure,
GMC
Luell, Forrest Hills
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

Email correspondence w/AS re Kretz fetter
Email from JN re: medical records
Review of Kretz letter re film
Phone call with NS, JL and JN regarding multiple
issues related to prepping for trial, including
exhibits, experts, jury charges, voir dire, speaking
to landlord, prepping client and comp stat clips

E

Hours
0.250
3.250

2.300
0.100
0.100
0.100

1.900

4232
4232.0

03/27/15

GMC

4233

4233.0

03/27/15

GMC

4234
4234.0

4235
4236 4235.0
4237 4236.0
4237.0
4238
4238.0
4239
4240 4239.0
4241 4240.0
4241.0
4242
4242.0
4243
4244 4243.0
4245 4244.0
4246 4245.0
4246.0
4247
4247.0
4248
4248.0
4249

03/27/15
03/27/15
03/27/15
03/27/15
03/27/15

03/28/15
03/29/15
03/30/15
03/30/15

03/30/15
03/30/15
03/30/15
03/31/15
03/31/15
04/01/15

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC

Phone conference with JN, NS, JF, John Lenoir
("JL")
Review of documents produced by Graham
Raymond
Various email correspondence JN and NS re:
Meeting missing IA13 Lauterborn recording
Review of Sgt. Chu and Scott memo
Review of emails w/City re subpoenas
Email correspondence w/Merry Soetano re: AS
audio clips
Phone call JN regarding preparing for conference
call with NS today and using Veritext software
Emailed JN and NS rough draft of AS direct
Review of AS email, timeline, records
Began Draft Broschart cross examination, reviewed
does, memos, audio
Phone call JN & JF regarding admissibility of tape
recorded statements of persons interviewed by IAB
Phone call w/JN re: Citys request to adjourn
Review of AS letter requesting conference
Email from JN w/IAB report
Draft Broschart cross examination, reviewed does,
memos, audio
Email correspondence w/NS and JN re trial
witnesses and exhibits
Reviewed and revised Broschart cross examination

1.000

0.500
0.400
0.300
0.250
0.100

0.100
0.100
0.400
4.500

0.300
0.300
0.250
0.100
3.500

0.250
3.900

Page 189

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

1

C

B

D

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

4249.0

1

04/01/15

GMC

Phone Call with JN regarding important points
from Valenti and Broschart and additional grounds
for impeaching Huffman and difference between
Administrative leave and lost time

04/01/15
04/02/15
04/02/15

GMC
GMC
GMC

Email re: meeting w/JN, and NS team
Meeting with JN and NS team
Drafted and sent follow up emails w/NS team and
JN after meeting re: exhibits
Review of SK jury instructions along with email re:
same
Email and phone correspondence with veritext re:
Lauterborn audio
Phone call w/NS re IAB transcripts
Phone call with JN regarding Lauterborn's second
PG in September 2010 and getting recordings of
same

E

4250
4251 4250.0
4252 4251.0
4252.0
4253
4253.0
4254
4254.0
4255
4256 4255.0
4256.0

04/02/15

GMC

04/02/15

GMC

04/02/15
04/02/15

GMC
GMC

4257.0

04/03/15

GMC

4258.0

04/03/15

GMC

4259.0

04/03/15

GMC

4260.0

04/03/15

GMC

04/04/15
04/04/15
04/05/15

GMC
GMC
GMC

04/05/15
04/06/15
04/06/15

GMC
GMC
GMC

04/06/15
04/06/15
04/06/15

GMC
GMC
GMC

04/06/15
04/06/15

GMC
GMC

4257
4258

Updated revised and drafted Broschart cross
examination outline
Phone call JN regarding important point from
Broschart testimony and defendants' of obsession to
suspend and real reason for entering apartment
(illegal search and destroy evidence)

4259

Hours

0.500
0.100
1.900
0.500
0.300
0.250
0.250

0.100

5.500

0.300

4260
4261
4262 4261.0
4263 4262.0
4263.0
4264
4265 4264.0
4266 4265.0
4266.0

4267
4268 4267.0
4269 4268.0
4269.0
4270
4271 4270.0
4272 4271.0

Review of revised Scott Korenbaum ("SK") jury
instructions along with email re: same
Review email from JN including AS performance
report
Email from NS re: revised exhibit list
Review of revised verdict sheet from NS
Email correspondence w/JN and NS re revised
exhibit list
Review email from JN including AS W2s
Review and revised JF MIL
Phone call with NS & JN regarding exhibit list,
verdict sheet, important points for opening
regarding Bernier and lsakov and failure of med
departments to speak with 1AB
Phone call w/JN and NS re: trial exhibits
Review of audio clips from NS
Review of revised SK jury instructions along with
email re: same
Email from NS re Audio clips
Review of City letter request for extension

Page 190

0.250
0.100
0.250
0.100
0.250
0.100
1.250

1.000

0.500
0.400
0.250
0.100
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

B

A

C

D

I

No.

Date

Time keep Description

4272.0

1

04/06/15

GMC

4273
4273.0

4274
4275 4274.0
4275.0
4276
4276.0
4277
4277.0
4278
4278.0
4279
4280 4279.0
4280.0
4281
4281.0

04/07/15
04/07/15
04/07/15
04/07/15
04/07/15
04/07/15
04/07/15
04/08/15
04/08/15

GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC

Review of email correspondence re Alan Scheirer
("AS") request for adjournment
Began Draft Duncan cross examination, reviewed
does, memos, audio
Review of revised JF MIL
Review and discuss NS letter to court re: delay of
trial and announcing our rehiring w/JN
Review of Jury Instructions from Magdelena Bauza
("MB")
Phone call JN & NS regarding best strategy for
handling City's request for adjournment
Phone call with JN regarding City's application for
adjournment
Review of SK comments on JF MIL draft
Draft Duncan cross examination, reviewed does,
memos, audio
Phone call with JN and JF regarding trial
adjournment, proposed filings, various strategies
for trying to make sure trial goes on April 20

E

Hours

0.100

3.500
0.500
0.300
0.300
0.200
0.100
0.100

3.800

0.750

4282
4282.0

4283
4284 4283.0
4284.0

04/08/15

04/08/15
04/08/15

GMC

GMC
GMC

4285
4285.0

04/08/15

GMC

Email and phone correspondence re: pushing trial
back a week to avoid delay of trial post summer
Final review of MIL
Phone call JN regarding points from Duncan
deposition regarding ESU, meat cleaver and
travelling to Johnstown
Phone call NS and JN re writing a supplemental
letter to Court regarding trial date issues

0.600
0.300

0.200

0.200

4286
4286.0

4287
4288 4287.0
4288.0
4289
4289.0
4290
4291 4290.0
4292 4291.0
4293 4292.0
4294 4293.0
4294.0
4295
4295.0
4296

04/09/15
04/09/15
04/09/15
04/11/15
04/11/15
04/13/15
04/13/15
04/13/15
04/13/15
04/13/15

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

Draft Duncan cross examination, reviewed does,
memos, audio
Emailed JN a portion of Duncan cross
Emailed NS for BNIU exhibits for inclusion on
JPTO
Email correspondence w/JN and NS re: trial date
and schedule
Email w/NS re Home Invasion Transcript
Update and revise Duncan cross examination,
Conf. on trial date- case adjourned
Meeting w/JN and JF re new trial date
Email w/veritext re: changes to Home Invasion
transcript
Travel from SDNY for conference re: trial date (.5)

4.100
0.100
0.100
0.250
0.100
2.100
1.000

0.500
0.250
0.250

Page 191

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

B

i

C

D

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

4296.0

04/13/15

GMC

04/13/15

GMC

4298.0

04/14/15

GMC

Email correspondence w/RS and NS re: Lauterborn
interview
Email correspondence with SK re: Jury instructions

4299.0

04/15/15

GMC

04/15/15
04/15/15

GMC
GMC

04/15/15
04/15/15
04/17/15

GMC
GMC
GMC

4305.0

04/17/15

GMC

4306.0

04/17/15

GMC

04/17/15
04/21/15

GMC
GMC

04/27/15

GMC

04/29/15
05/05/15
05/05/15
05/05/15
05/08/15

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

05/12/15
05/12/15
05/12/15
05/12/15
05/12/15
05/13/15
05/14/15

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

05/15/15

GMC

05/18/15

GMC

05/21/15

GMC

E

Travel to SDNY for conference re: trial date (.5)

4297.0

1

4297

Hours

0.250

4298
4299

0.100
0.100

4300
4301 4300.0
4301.0
4302
4303 4302.0
4304 4303.0
4304.0
4305
4306

4307
4308 4307.0
4308.0
4309
4309.0
4310
4311 4310.0
4312 4311.0
4313 4312.0
4314 4313.0
4314.0
4315
4316 4315.0
4317 4316.0
4318 4317.0
4319 4318.0
4320 4319.0
4321 4320.0
4321.0
4322
4322.0
4323
4323.0
4324
4325 4324.0

Reviewed and revised Boston outline for deposition
read ins
Review of newly produced Lamstein notes
Emailed w/JN and NS re mediation offer from the
City
Phone call w/JN re Boston unavailability
Review of correspondence re: PAA Boston
Phone call w/ rest of trial team regarding City'
proposal for mediation and best strategy for
responding
Conference call with team re: best strategy for
responding to City latest "offer"
Phone call with JN & JF following up on phone
call and discussing settlement position vs. going to
trial
Email from RS re Lauterborn audios
Review of letter from City requesting more time for
MIL

2.250
0.250
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.600
0.500

0.400
0.100
0.250

Email correspondence with City re: Lauterborn
Audio
Email with NS re trial issues and AS
Read and review Ct's Opinion on SJ
Discussion w/JN and JF re SMJ
Email w/JN re SMJ opinion
Discussion w/ JF & JN re decision and impact on
trial and motion in lim
Meeting w/NS team JN and JF pre-conf
Team meeting following conf.
Conf. trial adjourned to Oct. 19
Travel from SDNY for conf. (.5)
Travel to SDNY for conf. (.5)
Email correspondence w/SK re conference
Email correspondence all parties re: pretrial
submissions schedule
Email correspondence all parties re: pretrial
submissions schedule
Review of letter motion titled by City re JPTO
dates
Email NS resettlement offer from City
Page 192

0.250
0.250
1.400
0.500
0.100
0.800
1.500
1.250
1.000
0.250
0.250
0.100

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.100

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

4326 4325.0
4326.0
4327
4327.0
4328
4328.0
4329
4330 4329.0
4330.0
4331
4331.0
4332
4333 4332.0
4333.0
4334
4334.0
4335
4335.0
4336
4336.0
4337
4337.0
4338
4339 4338.0
4339.0
4340
4340.0
4341
4341.0
4342
4342.0
4343
4343.0
4344
4345 4344.0
4345.0
4346
4346.0
4347
4347.0
4348
4349 4348.0
4349.0
4350
4351 4350.0

B

D

C

Date

Timekeep Description

05/28/15
05/29/15

GMC
GMC

Email JN re Veritext bill
Email w/JN and NS re: City bifurcation request

E

Hours

0.100

0.250
05/29/15
06/01/15
06/02/15
06/03/15
06/04/15
06/10/15
06/22/15
06/23/15
06/23/15
06/24/15
06/24/15
06/29/15
07/06/15
07/06/15
07/07/15

07/07/15
07/08/15

07/13/15
07/15/15
07/17/15
07/20/15
07/23/15
07/23/15
07/24/15

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

Email correspondence all parties re: pretrial
submissions schedule
Review and comment on NS draft reconsideration
Review of citys motion to bifurcate
Review of email correspondence w/court re
motions
Review of Mauriello's motion for reconsideration
Phone call with Schoolcrafts and JN
Review of email correspondence re: opposition to
reconsideration motions
Review of email correspondence re: opposition to
reconsideration motions
Review of email correspondence re: opposition to
reconsideration motions
Review of email correspondence re: opposition to
reconsideration motions
Review of email correspondence w SK re: motion
schedules
Review of NS motion opposing bifurcation
Review of opposition motions to defendants
reconsideration motions
Review of email correspondence between all
parties
Review of email correspondence between NS team
re Eterno
Review of email correspondence re: opposition to
reconsideration motions
Review of email correspondence between all
parties
Review of JHMC to NS motion for recon
Review of email correspondence between all
parties
Review of Email correspondence between JL and
NS re: John Eterno
Review of Email correspondence between JN and
NS re: John Eterno
Review of reply memo for AS
Review of City Defendants reply affirmations
recoil motions
Schoolcraft team meeting
Page 193

0.100
0.400
0.250

0.250
0.500
0.800
0.250
0.100

0.100
0.100
0.100
0.250

0.750
0.100
0.100
0.100

0.100
0.300
0.100
0.250
0.100
0.750
0.500
2.900

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

4351.0

Date
07/24/15

4352.0
4353.0
4354.0
4355.0
4356.0
4357.0

07/24/15
07/27/15
07/27/15
07/28/15
07/29/15
07/30/15

No.

1

4352
4353
4354
4355
4356
4357

4358
4359 4358.0
4360 4359.0
4361 4360.0
4362 4361.0
4363 4362.0
4364 4363.0
4365 4364.0
4366 4365.0
4366.0
4367
4367.0

07/30/15
07/30/15
07/31/15
08/03/15
08/03/15
08/03/15
08/04/15
08/04/15
08/05/15

C

D

Timekeepe Description
GMC
Phone call with JN & JF regarding issues to discuss
at meeting today with rest of trial team
GMC
Follow up email Schoolcraft team re trial docs
GMC
Email JN re Polanco as witness
GMC
Email w MS re: master exhibit list
GMC
Review of updated jury instructions
GMC
Emails with Schoolcraft team re: settlement
GMC
Phone call JN regarding settlement position &
response to City's settlement position and response
to City's settlement overtures
GMC
Phone call w/JN and NS re settlement
GMC
Emails with Schoolcraft team re: settlement
GMC
Emails with Schoolcraft team re: settlement
GMC
Review and revise Gough cross
GMC
Review and revise Duncan cross
GMC
Email w/NS re Gough deposition
GMC
Phone call w/JN re: witness list and exhibit list
GMC
Review of NS revised witness and exhibit list
GMC
Phone calls with JN and NS re: exhibit and witness
list

08/07/15

GMC

4368.0

08/07/15

GMC

4369.0

08/09/15

GMC

4370.0

08/10/15

GMC

4371.0

08/11/15

GMC

08/11/15
08/11/15
08/12/15
08/12/15
08/13/15
08/13/15
08/13/15
08/14/15

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

08/14/15

GMC

08/14/15
08/14/15
08/18/15

GMC
GMC
GMC

E

Hours
0.500
0.300
0.100
0.100
0.400
0.100

0.400
0.400
0.100
0.100
3.300
2.750
0.100
0.400
0.300
1.000

Phone call with JN, JL & NS regarding multiple
issues in defendants' respective JPTO's

4368

1.000

4369
4370
4371
4372
4373 4372.0
4374 4373.0
4375 4374.0
4376 4375.0
4377 4376.0
4378 4377.0
4379 4378.0
4379.0
4380
4380.0
4381
4382 4381.0
4383 4382.0
4384 4383.0

Review of Bernier and Jsakov proposed JPTO
sections
Review of email correspondence re: JPTO and
motion deadlines
Review of email correspondence re: JPTO and
motion deadlines
Draft Yeager examination - review records, listen
to audio and work of transcription
Review of City defendants JPTO
Review of new discovery served by City
Add to and revise Yeager examination
Update and revise Gough examination
Reviewed and updated Sawyer examination
Update and revise James cross examination
Review of correspondence all parties re: JPTO
Review and update cross examination drafts to date
and emailed all to team
Review of Lauterborn transcribed audio interview
and emailed to team
Review of City's email re JPTO
Email re: City filing JPTO without our input
Phone call and email w/JN re Huffman
Page 194

0.500
0.100

0.100

2.400
0.750
0.250
3.400
2.500
3.750
2.900
0.100
4.800
0.600
0.250
0.100
0.300

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

4385 4384.0
4386 4385.0
4387 4386.0
4387.0
4388
4389 4388.0
4390 4389.0
4391 4390.0
4391.0
4392
4393 4392.0
4393.0
4394
4395 4394.0
4395.0
4396
4397 4396.0
4398 4397.0
4398.0
4399
4400 4399.0
4400.0

D1

C

B

Date

Timekeepe Description

08/21/15
08/21/15
08/22/15
08/24/15

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
,

08/24/15
08/24/15
08/24/15
08/26/15
08/26/15
08/27/15
08/31/15
09/01/15
09/02/15
09/03/15
09/08/15

09/08/15
09/08/15

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC

Sent updated crosses to team
Email all parties re MIL due date
Updated AS examination and sent to team
Reviewed JN cross outlines and updated witness
examinations
Drafted points to discuss w/JN
Review of NS email re upstate visits to AS
Received JN cross examinations
Reviewed JN cross outlines and updated my own
witness examinations
Drafted points to discuss w/JN
Reviewed JN cross outlines and updated my own
witness examinations
Review of JF MIL with additional points
Reviewed JN cross outlines and updated my own
witness examinations
Drafted points to discuss w/JN
Review of City letter re: JPTO schedule
Update and revise Schoolraft direct examination

Phone call with Adrian Schoolcraft re: trial
Phone call with JN & JF recapping discussion with
defense counsel and clients over the weekend

Hours

0.250
0.100
2.900
1.750

0.400
0.250
0.100
3.300
0.750

2.500
0.500

2.800
1.400
0.250

3.400
0.750

0.600

4401
4401.0
4402
4403
4404
4405
4406

E

4402.0
4403.0
4404.0
4405.0
4406.0

4407
4408 4407.0
4408.0
4409
4410 4409.0
4411 4410.0
4412 4411.0
4412.0
4413
4414 4413.0
4414.0
4415

09/08/15,.

09/08/15
09/09/15
09/10/15
09/11/15
09/11/15
09/11/15
09/15/15
09/16/15
09/16/15
09/16/15
09/16/15
09/16/15
09/16/15

GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC
GMC

Phone call with NS, JF and JN regarding best
strategy for handling settlement discussions with
the City
Phone call w/JN re Schoolcrafts
Review and update Valenti deposition
Update Huffman cross examination
Review of email time line from Schoolcraft
Phone calls with NS and JN re City settlement offer
Email w/JN re Schoolcraft timeline
Reviewed JN cross outlines and updated my own
witness examinations
Review of NS cross examination outlines
Phone call w/Schoolcraft re settlement
Review of new Rule 68 offer
Review of NS memo to Schoolcraft re settlement
Email w NS re memo and settlement
Review of NS email to Schoolcraft resettlement

0.600
0.300
1.250

2.750
0.900
0.800
0.100

2.300
3.600
0.800
0.500
0.300
0.250
0.100

Page 195

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

D

4415.0

Date
02/16/13

Timekeep Description
JL
Review of case history and complaint; document

4416.0

02/17/13

JL

4417.0

02/18/13

JL

4418.0

02/19/13

JL

4419.0

02/20/13

JL

4420.0

02/21/13

No.

1

4416

4417

preparation for presentation to DOJ
Review of case files and and audio recordings;
document preparation to formally request DOJ
intervention
Review of case timeline and document preparation
for Main Justice and US Attorney presentation

4418

Hours
3.500

3.250

4.000

4419
4420
JL

4421
4421.0

03/20/13

JL

4422.0

04/01/13

JL

4423.0

04/09/13

JL

4424.0

04/10/13

JL

4425.0

04/11/13

JL

4426.0

04/25/13

JL

4427.0

04/26/13

JL

4428.0

04/27/13

JL

4429.0

05/09/13

JL

4430.0

05/12/13

JL

4431.0

05/13/13

JL

4432.0

05/16/13

JL

4422

Telephone conference with EDNY Civil Rts Chief
Pam Chen; document preparation.
Prepare draft letters to DOJ--Main Justcie and
USAO, EDNY
Telephone conference with Peter Gleason and
client Schoolcraft in reference to case preparation
for trial (DOJ letter review).
Final Draft, review and mail of letters to Main
Justice and US Attorney
Meeting with Peter Gleason to prepare for client
meeting April 7 and court appearance April 10

4423

0.750
1.500

1.250

1.500

1.000

4424

Meeting with Nat Smith to prepare for Hearing
April 10, 2013
Court: Hearing re discovery before Judge Sweet SDNY, 500 Pearl Street, NYC. Meeting w/Smith to
review hearing and discovery plan.

4425

2.500

3.250

4426

Meeting with R. Koshets; Nat Smith; Peter
Gleason; Gilbert to review NYPD pending internal
charges v. client
Meeting with Adrian Schoolcraft and Nat Smith to
prepare client for depositions; review status of case

4427

2.750

1.250

4428
4429

4430
4431
4432

4433

E

Meeting with Adrian Schoolcraft and Nat Smith to
prepare for depositions
Meeting with Schoolcraft and Nat Smith to prepare
for depositions.
Meeting with Nat Smith to review and prepare
discovery, engage investigator and prepare
depositions
Review of audio recordings made by client; sort
and prepare summaries.
Meet investigator Helena Melisi; review case re
engagement as investigator
Telephone call with Nat Smith and Helena Melisi
re: NYPD reinstatement options for AS.
Page 196

5.750
5.500

3.250

4.500
2.750
0.750

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

4433.0

Date
05/16/13

4434
4434.0

05/17/13

4435
4435.0

05/17/13

4436
4436.0

05/18/13

4437
4437.0

05/21/13

4438
4438.0

06/05/13

Timekeepe Description
Review of IAB reports of interviews with
JL
individual officers
Telephone call with Nat Smith 3:30-4:15 and draft
JL
email re: strategy for NYPD departmental hearing
June 17-18, 2013.
Review of IAB interviews of individual defendants
JL
and others; prepare notes
Review of IAB interviews; telephone call with Nat
JL
Smith and AS re: strategy for NYPD departmental
hearing
Meeting with Nat Smith and telephone call with
JL
James McCutcheon re: NYPD departmental trial
strategy
Appearance in court; Sweet, J. redpositions and
JL
discovery status; post hearing conf w/Smith

1

Hours

2.750

1.500

4.250

3.500

2.250

1.750

4439
4439.0

06/07/13

JL

4440
4440.0

06/09/13

JL

4441
4441.0

06/26/13

JL

4442

4442.0

07/10/13

JL

4443
4442.0

07/10/13

JL

4444
4443.0

06/26/13

JL

4445
4445.0

08/06/13

JL

4446
4446.0

08/07/13

JL

4447
4447.0

08/24/13

JL

4448
4448.0

08/27/13

JL

4449
4449.0

08/27/13

JL

4450
4450.0
4451

E

D

C

B

09/04/13

JL

Meeting with potential expert witnesses, Dr. Tom
Litwack, Dr. Eli Silverman and Dr. John Eterno;
introduction of Nat Smith to experts
Review and edit of Memorandum and proposed
Order for filing with Court
Meeting with client and Nat Smith - Johnston New
York Holiday Inn. 7 hours are travel time billed
separately
Travel for meeting with client and Nat Smith -Albany
Meeting with client and co -counsel Smith in
Albany NY. Full review of discovery and trial
posture. (7 hr travel)
Travel for meeting with client and Nat Smith Johnston New York Holiday Inn.
Confirm with Tom Litwack meeting re: Expert
Witness participation
Meeting with trial illustrator (11am-1pm). Meeting
with potential expert witness, Dr. Tom Litwack (3pm-5pm).
Telephone conference with Smith re invest report
on DCPI Brown
Client meeting at, Saugerties, NY. with Nat Smith;
Review case status and strategy with client. [7 hr
travel]
Travel from NYC to Saugerties and return for
client meeting
Prepare biweekly status report for client;; review
motion status and prepare case report.
Page 197

2.500
1.000

5.500
3.500

5.000

3.500
0.750

3.500
0.500

5.500
3.500
1.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

4451.0

Date
09/10/13

4452
4453 4452.0
4453.0

09/13/13
09/25/13

No.

1

4454

I

C

D

Timekeepe Description
JL
Review of documents in preparation for client's
examination before trial
JL
Prepare status report for client
JL
Prepare for hearing on discovery (1.0); Oral
Argument re: discovery - USDC SDNY Sweet, J
(.75).; consultation with client and Smith in
preparation for depositions (4.75)
JL
Representation of client along with co -counsel
Smith in examination before trial by defendant
Mauriello and NYC - Walter Kretz law office 444
Madison Avenue, NY.

4454.0

09/26/13

4455.0

09/27/13

JL

09/30/13

JL

4457.0

10/04/13

JL

4458.0

10/07/13

JL

4459.0

10/08/13

JL

4460.0

10/09/13

JL

4461.0

10/10/13

JL

Review of Mauriello examination before trial
notes.
Preparing dots and audio recordings for Marino
deposition; Tel Conf with Smith
Meeting with client and Smith re depositions of
Mauriello and Marino
co -counsel w/Smith in deposition of Marino; post
depo confer /Smith and client
Telephone conference with Smith and client re case
status after Marino depo
Telephone conference with Smith re depositions

4462.0

10/13/13

JL

4463.0

10/14/13

JL

4464.0

10/16/13

JL

4465.0

10/16/13

JL

4466.0

10/23/13

JL

10/25/13

JL

Appearance in court re attorney video of deposition -Bernier

4455

4456

6.500

9.000

9.000

4457
4458
4459
4460
4461

4462

0.750
2.750
3.500

9.000
0.500
0.500

4463

4464
4465

4466

Telephone conference with Smith and NYACLU re
assistance in case
Telephone conference with Smith re status of case
and share of responsibilities
co -counsel at deposition Dfnt Bernier - 111
Broadway- by H. Suckle
Prepare deposition of defendant Lauterborn (1.25).
Hearing re: Discovery and Defendant Mauriello
counterclaim - USDC, SDNY, Judge Sweet (.75).
Review of hearing results (.50); prepare report for
client (2.75)

4467
4468

4.500
0.500

Telephone conference with Smith re PD expert
report and testimony; Tel Conf w/Eterno

4467.0

Hours

Co -counsel with Smith in representation of client at
deposition of client by defendant Mauriello and
Jamaica Hospital defendants - Callan, Koster,
Brady & Brennan, LLP - One Whitehall Street,
10th Floor New York, NY 10004.

4456.0

E

0.750
0.750
1.750

5.250

1.500

Page 198

0.750

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

1 INo.
4468.0

D

C

B

Date

Timekeepe Description

11/01/13

JL

E

Hours

Review does and audio for Lauterborn deposition
2.750

4469
4469.0

11/07/13

JL

Prepare and take w/Smith examination before trial
of defendant Lauterborn. Review documents and
audio recordings; prepare exhibits.
9.500

4470
4470.0

11/13/13

JL

4471
4471.0

11/14/13

JL

4472
4472.0

11/17/13

JL

4473
4473.0

11/18/13

JL

Motion hearing at Judge Sweet Courtroom; review
of hearing outcome w/co-counsel; draft report to
client.
Review of hospital and NYPD files and audio
recordings in preparation for examination before
trial of Bernier and Mauriello.
Review of client Schoolcraft examination before
trial.
Consultation with non-party witnesses, audio
recordings of IAB interviews and document review.

3.750

5.500

2.250

2.500

4474
4474.0

11/21/13

JL

4475
4475.0

11/22/13

JL

4476
4476.0

11/24/13

JL

4477
4477.0

11/26/13

JL

4478
4478.0

11/27/13

JL

Review and produce Marino and Lauterborn video
depositions; reconcile Plaintiff depositions
transcript with video.
Mauriello terminated examination before trial
preparation; review of Court's decision and
additional City discovery documents provided.
Review of Plaintiffs depositions (1.00); review
defendant Mauriello and Lauterborn depositions
and produce videos (2.25); prepare
status report (.75).
Review of depositions; prepare challenge to City
Defendant obstructions; prepare for Lt. Caughey
examination before trial.
Review of examination before trial transcripts with
video; prepare for Defendant Caughey examination.

2.750

2.750

4.000

5.500

2.750

4479
4479.0

11/29/13

JL

4480
4480.0

11/30/13

JL

4481
4481.0

12/01/13

JL

Review of Marino and Lauterborn depositions re
response City's Refusal to Allow Witness to
Respond and otherwise interferes with
the examination before trial.
Review of dfnt Marino and Lauterborn examination
before trial research for motion to compel and
additional requests for production.
Review of Marino and Lauterborn examinations
before trial to identify areas for motion to compel]
and additional requests for production.

2.000

2.500

1.750

4482

Page 199

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

No.

Date

4482.0

12/02/13

4483.0

12/07/13

4484.0

12/09/13

4485.0

12/11/13

JL

4486.0

12/11/13

JL

4487.0

12/18/13

JL

4488
4489 4488.0
4489.0

12/19/13
12/20/13

JL
JL

4490.0

12/24/13

JL

4491.0

12/26/13

JL

4492.0

12/29/13

JL

4493.0

12/30/13

JL

4494.0

01/02/14

JL

4495.0

01/03/14

JL

4496.0

01/06/14

JL

4497.0

01/10/14

JL

4498.0

01/12/14

JL

01/13/14
01/15/14

JL
JL

01/29/14

JL

1

4483

4484

D

I

Timekeepe Description
JL
Telephone conference with Smith and client re case
status of depositions
JL
Telephone conference with Smith re Mauriello
counterclaim
JL
Prepare and 2d seat with Smith examination before
trial for dfnt Caughey; meeting with Peter Kelley re
potential assistance in trial prep.

4485

E

Hours
1.500

0.500

7.750

4486
4487

4490
4491

Represent client (w/Bauza) at depo of Larry
Schoolcraft--Albany [8:30 travel time]
Amtrak NYC - Albany - NYC for Larry Schoolcraft
deposition (w/Bauza)
Prepare for defendant Mauriello examination
before trial; review of motion for reconsideration.
Prepare for Mauriello examination before trial.
Represent client with Smith at Mauriello
examination before trial at Scoppetta Seiff Kretz &
Abercrombie.
Telephone conference with Smith and client re case
status and possible settlement range
Meeting with Smith, Bauza and client to review
Mauriello EBT; review settlement perameters

4492

6.500

4.250

3.250
2.750

9.500
0.750

2.000

4493

4494
4495
4496

Meeting with client, Smith and Bauza re status and
go -forward; review audio recordings
Confer with John Curran re Stroz Friedberg
analysis of recording device and audio
enhancement
Telephone conference with Smith re status and
schedule of depositions
Preparing docs and audio for Sgt Huffman and
PAA Boston depositions
co -counsel w/Smith depositions of Huffman and
Boston; post EBT review w/Smith and Bauza

4497

2.500

1.250

0.750

2.500

9.500

4498
4499
4500 4499.0
4500.0
4501
4502 4501.0

Prepare case files and review audio records for
future depositions
Prepare for Hanlon deposition; review docs and
audio files
co -counsel w/Smith at Hanlon deposition
Appearance in court, Sweet, J. re discovery; confer
with Smith and Bauza re status
Preparing for Lamstein deposition

Page 200

2.000
1.750

8.500
1.500
2.000

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

4502.0

Date
01/30/14

4503
4503.0

4504
4505 4504.0
4506 4505.0
4507 4506.0
4507.0
4508
4508.0
4509
4509.0
4510
4510.0
4511
4511.0
4512
4512.0
4513
4513.0

4514
4515 4514.0
4515.0
4516
4516.0
4517
4517.0
4518
4519 4518.0
4520 4519.0
4520.0
4521
4521.0
4522
4522.0
4523
4523.0
4524
4524.0
4525
4525.0
4526
4527 4526.0

02/03/14
02/04/14
02/05/14
02/06/14
02/10/14

02/11/14
02/12/14
02/13/14
02/16/14

02/18/14

02/19/14

D

C

B

Timekeepe Description
conduct as co -counsel w/Smith Lamstein
JL
depositiion
Telephone conference with Smith re deposition
JL
schedules
Prepare and review discovery demands.
JL
Conference with Smith re: discovery demands.
JL
Conference call with client re: discovery.
JL
Preparing depositions of Bernier and Isakof; review
JL
NYS 9.39
Deposition of defendant Dr. Bernier.111 B'Way--co.
JL
counsel with Smith and Suckel
co -counsel with Smith and Suckle at deposition of
JL
Defendant Dr. Isakov.
Review with Smith notes and exhibits of
JL
depositions of Bernier and Isakov.
Telephone conference with client and Smith re case
JL
status and way ahead
Review of discovery demands with counsel and
JL
client.
Review of correspondence re: discovery demands.
JL
tel conf client and Smith re discovery

E

Hours
8.500

0.500
1.500
1.750
1.000

2.500
8.500
7.500
1.000
1.250
1.500

1.750

02/23/14
02/24/14
02/25/14
02/26/14
02/27/14
02/27/14
02/28/14
03/03/14
03/04/14
03/05/14
03/05/14

03/07/14
03/07/14

JL
JL
JL
JL

JL
JL
JL
JL
JL
JL

JL

JL
JL

Telephone conference. Smith re depositions
Review file to prepare examination before trial
material for Gough.
Prepare examination before trial materials for
Weiss.
Prepare examination before trial materials for
Duncan.
Prepare examination before trial Marquez.
Prepare for Sangianetti.
Prepare examination before trial docs for Sergeant
James.
Prepare examination before trial materials for
Broschart.
Counsel conference call. Smith re status and
strategy. Needs for trial preparation.
Review discovery and depositions; update case
status report for client
Prepare examination before trial materials for
Timothy Trainor.
Draft, review and edit correspondence re:
discovery.
Research re: NYS CPL 190.25(4).

Page 201

0.750
1.500

0.750
0.500
0.500
0.500
0.750
0.750
1.500

1.250

0.500
1.250

0.750

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

No.
4527.0

Date
03/09/14

4528.0

03/10/14

4529.0

1

03/11/14

4528
4529

C

'

D

I

Time keep Description
JL
Review research re: response to City Defendants
non -production.
JL
Schoolcraft research for response to discovery and
deposition issues and hearing.
JL
Schoolcraft research and draft letter to court re:

discovery and deposition issues (4.00); confer w/cocounsel (1.00)

4530
4530.0

03/12/14

JL

03/13/14

JL

4532.0

03/13/14

JL

Hearing and conference. SDNY Sweet, J., re
discovery status
Schoolcraft preparation fr Hearing re: discovery.

4533.0

03/14/14

JL

03/16/14

JL

03/17/14

JL

4536.0

03/18/14

JL

Review schedule of examination before trial w
Smith and opposing counsel.
Review and consultation with Mauriello counsel re:
scheduling of inspection in Johnstown, New York;
related discovery review and
research.

4537.0

03/19/14

JL

4538.0

03/21/14

JL

4539.0

03/24/14

JL

4540.0

03/25/14

JL

4541.0

03/26/14

JL

4542.0

03/27/14

JL

4543.0

03/28/14

JL

4544
4545 4544.0
4545.0
4546

03/30/14
03/31/14

JL
JL

5.000

Update case status report; Prep plaintiff demands in
discovery and re -schedule depositions.

4535.0

3.500

Review scheduling for examination before trial.

4534.0

1.000

Schoolcraft preparation for Hearing re: discovery.

4531.0

E

Hours

4531

2.500

4532
4533

0.750

2.500

4534

0.750

4535

2.000

4536

4537

1.500

1.250

4538

4539

4540
4541

4542
4543

Review City Defendants production requests;
research and prepare response and plaintiff
production demands. Tel conf with client.
Review City Defendants' correspondence re:
discovery demands.
Prepare deposition schedules in consult with Smith
and defendants counsel. Review discovery and prep
motion draft.
Review City Defendants' supplemental discovery
demands.
Appearance in court for hearing re discovery status
and issues (.75); prep plaintiff discovery production
(2.75).
Prepare, review, and edit correspondence re
30(b)(6) examination before trial.
Finalize Plaintiff 30(b)(6) notices. Prepare
examination of City 30(b)(6) witnesses
Review jury instructions with Magdelena.
Consultation re: settlement context strategy and
demands. (Smith and client)
Page 202

4.500
0.750

3.750
0.750

3.500
1.500

3.250
1.000

1.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

1

No.

4546.0

4547
4548 4547.0
4548.0
4549
4549.0
4550
4550.0
4551
4551.0
4552
4552.0
4553
4553.0
4554
4554.0

C

B

Date
04/01/14

04/02/14
04/03/14
04/04/14

04/07/14

D

I

_ Timekeepe Description memorandum/ telephone call to City
Prepare trial
JL

JL
JL
JL

JL

re: settlement/ and prepare for Trainor and Gough
examination before trial.
Prepare draft trial memorandum.
Review terms and strategy re: settlement
negotiations. Smith and client.
Review correspondence to Court re: referral to
Magistrate; consult re: settlement strategy.
Review filings (ECF posts) and correspondence.

2.750
1.500
1.500
1.000
1.500

04/09/14

JL

Review settlement strategy with client; Hearing .
2.250

04/10/14

04/11/14
04/13/14

JL

JL
JL

Prepare/conduct w co -counsel Smith examination
before trial of Trainor.
Prepare/conduct as co -counsel w/ Smith
examination before trial of Gough.
Meet possible Psychiatric expert Dr. Lubit; review
case and discuss Dr. Lubit's participation.

8.250

7.500

2.750

4555
4555.0

4556
4557 4556.0
4557.0

04/14/14

04/15/14
04/16/14

JL

JL
JL

Telephone conference with client, Smith and MJ
Freeman re: settlement demands and discovery
issues.
Review ECF filing by JHC defendant.
Meeting with Smith (1.25); research on jury
verdicts/awards (2.25); telephone conference with
client to discuss settlement and trial issues (1.00).

1.500
0.500

4.500

4558
4558.0

04/17/14

JL

4559
4559.0

04/18/14

JL

4560
4560.0

04/25/14

JL

4561
4561.0

04/26/14

JL

4562

4562.0

04/27/14

JL

Schoolcraft settlement research (1.00); consultation
with Smith (2.00); telephone conf with Schoolcraft
re: settlement issues (1.25).
Research on detention verdicts (.75), discussion
and planning re: settlement (1.00); telephone call
with defense counsel (.50). Tel conf with client and
Smith (.75)
Prepare/conduct w/Smith examination before trial
for Sawyer.
Telephone conference with client and Smith re:
settlement.
Telephone conference with client re: settlement and
trial strategy re: medical! defendants and PTS.

3.250

3.000
6.250
1.000

1.500

4563
4563.0

04/28/14

JL

4564
4564.0
4565

E

Hours

04/29/14

JL

Prepare/conduct w/Smith examination before trial:
Duncan.
Schoolcraft meeting (client and Smith) re:
settlement strategy and discovery schedule.
Page 203

7.500
1.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

No.

Date

4565.0

1

04/30/14

C

D

Timekeepe Description
JL
Schoolcraft hearing with Judge Sweet re: discovery

'

E

Hours

(.75); post hearing consultation with Smith and
Henry Steinglass re: trial strategy (2.75).
4566

3.500
4566.0

05/01/14

JL

Conference with Smith re: prior counsel
fees/expenses; brief client on settlement issues;
research re: use/abuse of psychiatry for poitical
intimidation and retaliation.

4567.0

05/02/14

JL

Review and conf (all counsel) with re: deposition
schedules; review case law re: settlement (range of
awards of involuntary confinement, false arrest..).

4568.0

05/05/14

JL

4569.0

05/06/14

JL

Telephone conference with Smith re proposed mtn
to compel
Research and confer with Nat Smith re: settlement
issues (1.00); discussion with client re: settlement
(1.25); preparation of status report (.75).

4570.0

05/07/14

JL

4571.0

05/08/14

JL

4572.0

05/09/14

JL

4573.0

05/10/14

JL

4574.0

05/11/14

JL

4575.0

05/12/14

JL

Preparation/conduct w/Smith EBT of Sgt Shantel
James; EBT Sgt James 10am-3:30pm; review of
EBT; follow up with Dr. Halpern -Ruder; EMT/ER
expert.

4576.0

05/13/14

JL

meet (w/Smith) with potential witness for plaintiff;
NYPD Lt (Ret) Joseph Ferrara; telephone
conference with Chris Dunne re: possible
settlement issues; prepare EBTs of the EMTs.
[POV travel to -from Holbrook NY --3:00]

4567

4568

1.750

1.750

4569

4570

0.500

3.000

4571

4572
4573

4574

Prepare and review response to City Motion re:
30(b)(6) EBT.
Prepare for settlement conference (1.25);
conference call with Magistrate Freeman re:
settlement (.75); review settlement negotiations
(2.00); research and outreach to proposed ER
Medicine expert (1:00).
Review hospital records; City production re: 081
lockers; prepare status report.
Consultation and correspondence with Nat Smith
re: City defendants' discovery production re: 081
lockers; prepare EBT of Sgt James.
Consultation by telephone with Dr. Halpern -Ruder
re: EMT and ER procedures as potential expert
witness; review correspondence with client.

4575

1.000

4.500
1.250

2.500

2.000

4576

4577

7.000

4.500

Page 204

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

I

A

1 1No.
4577.0

1

B

Date
05/13/14

C

I

D

I

Timekeepe Description
Drive (Lenoir's POV) from 111 Broadway, NY, NY
JL
to Long Island to meet with Lt Ferrara (ret)

Hours

1.500

4578
4578.0

05/14/14

JL

4579
4579.0

05/15/14

JL

4580
4580.0

05/15/14

JL

4581
4581.0

05/16/14

JL

4582

4582.0

05/19/14

JL

EBT (w/Smith) of Marquez, EMT/JHC; prepare
status report.
Preparation/conduct w/Smith EBT of Sangetti;
EMT/JHC; preparation - conduct post depo-review
with Smith.
Review of EBT; review case and settlement
strategy with client and Smith
Prepare EBT for Broschart - review City motion to
strike 30(b)(6) issues.
Prepare for meeting with client and full status
review of discovery; settlement and trial strategy.

7.500

5.250
1.750

2.500

2.250

4583
4583.0

05/20/14

JL

4584
4584.0

05/20/14

JL

4585
4585.0

05/27/14

JL

4586
4586.0

05/28/14

JL

4587
4587.0

05/30/14

JL

4588
4588.0

05/31/14

JL

Consultation with client re: discovery; settlement
and trial strategy; settlement conference call with
Magistrate Freeman and client; Verizon "Hot Spot"
interne connectivity device for client
communication.
POV (Lenoir) 111 Broadway; NYC to Johnston, N
Y and return for consultation with client re:
discovery; settlement and trial strategy; and
settlement
Research and outreach re: potential Law
Enforcement expert(s) research re: damages and
settlement issues.
Preparation for hearing (1.50); hearing re: EBT
City 30(b)(6) issues (.75); review court holdings
(.75); prepare Weiss EBT (4.50).
Review w/co-counsel EBT Jamaica Hospital
30(b)(6); Skype conference with client (:30).
Skype conference with client to review discovery,

4589.0

06/02/14

JL

5.500

3.500

2.000

7.500
1.500
1.000

etc.

4589

Telephone conference with client (1.25); prepare
additional discovery requests (1.25); review status
of discovery received from defendants (2.00).
4.500

4590
4590.0

06/04/14

JL

4591
4591.0
4592

E

06/04/14

JL

Represent (with Smith) Ferrara at City deposition,
100 Church St
Meeting with Smith and Ferrara to prepare for
examination before trial; review EBT materials:
dcuments and audio.

Page 205

4.500

3.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

No.

Date

4592.0

1

06/06/14

1

C

D

Timekeepe Description
JL
Telephone conference with law enforcement

experts; call with John Eterno and Eli Silverman;
review and discuss law enforcement expert report
and testimony; prepare status report for client and
trial team.

4593
4593.0

06/09/14

JL

4594.0

06/11/14

JL

4595.0

06/11/14

JL

4596.0

06/12/14

JL

4597.0

06/13/14

JL

06/16/14

JL

Prepare status report for client; draft trial memo

4599.0

06/18/14

JL

Prepare for and conduct (with Smith) Broschart
examination before trial; review notes.

4600.0

06/19/14

JL

4601.0

06/20/14

JL

Status update on discovery schedule for client and
trial team.
Telephone conference with co -counsel re: law
enforcement experts; draft retainer agreements.

4602.0

06/21/14

JL

4603.0

06/23/14

JL

4604.0

06/25/14

JL

4605.0

06/26/14

JL

4606.0

06/27/14

JL

4594

4595

4596

Telephone conference with client; preparation and
review discovery and settlement issues.
(with Smith) Prepare and meet with Dr. Dan
Halpern -Ruder in Providence RI re proposed EMT
and ER expert.
Drive POV (Lenoir's) from 111 Broadway to
Providence, RI to meet with Dr. Dan Halpern
proposed EMT and ER expert
Return drive POV (Lenoir's) to 111 Broadway
NYC from Providence, RI for meeting with Dr.
Dan Halpern proposed EMT and ER expert.

4597

2.000

4.000

2.250

2.000

4598

2.000

4599

1.750

4600

7.500

4601

4602

1.000

2.000

4603

4604
4605

4606

4607

2.750

Telephone conference with Eterno and Silverman
re: law enforcement expert research and testimony;
review and preparation of retainer agreements.

4598.0

E

Hours

Draft and review law enforcement expert retainer
agreement.
Prepare for, and conduct with Smith dfnt Duncan
examination before trial; review Duncan
examination before trial.
Telephone conference with party counsel and co counsel re:discovery scheduling.
Telephone conference with client, co -counsel and
psychiatric expert re: meeting with client; call with
co -counsel re: examination before
trial scheduling.

2.000

Meeting (telephone conference) with client; cocounsel and expert re: evaluation by psychiatric
expert.

2.500

Page 206

0.500

7.500
1.000

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

8

A

No.

Date

4607.0

1

06/29/14

E

D

C

Hours

Timekeepe Description
Telephone conference with client; co -counsel and
JL

expert (Lubit) re: scheduling of evaluation meeting.
1.000

4608
4608.0

06/30/14

JL

4609
4609.0

07/01/14

JL

Meeting with client (2.00); arrange meeting with
psychiatric expert (2.00); conference with Dr.
Lubit; call with client re: evaluation (1.25).
Prepare and conduct w/Smith examination before
trial for Mauriello. Review w/client and Smith.

5.250

8.500

4610
4610.0

07/02/14

JL

4611
4611.0

07/03/14

JL

4612
4612.0

07/04/14

JL

4613
4613.0

07/07/14

JL

Telephone conference with client re: deposition
review and trial preparation; Adrian departs NYC
via Amtrak
Prepare and review w/Smith re: Dr. Lwin's
examination before trial.
Prepare for 30(b)(6) depositions and other JHC
witnesses.
Prepare for and attend deposition as co -counsel;
and review; 30(b)(6) witness to testify about
JHMC's policy on involuntary hospitalization.

1.000

3.500
3.750

4.500

4614
4614.0

07/08/14

JL

Schedule and plan remaining depositions (2.00);
review final discovery productions (2.50).
4.500

4615
4615.0

07/09/14

JL

Negotiate expert agreements with Dr. Silverman
and Dr. Eterno; draft retainer contracts; conference
call to resolve issues, finalize expert agreement and
schedule meetings and reports; and prepare for City
30(b)(6) examination before trial.

1.750

4616
4616.0

07/10/14

JL

Consultation and negotiation with psych and law
enforcement experts; revise retainer agreements.
2.250

4617
4617.0

07/11/14

JL

Arrange and negotiate terms for ER MD expert
witness; prepare for City examination before trial.
1.750

4618
4618.0

07/14/14

JL

Prepare for City 30(b)(6) examination before trial.
2.250

4619
4619.0

07/15/14

JL

4620
4620.0

07/16/14

JL

4621
4621.0

07/17/14

JL

4622
4622.0

4623

I

07/18/14

JL

Conduct two City 30(b)(6) examinations before
trial.
Conduct two City 30(b)(6) examination before
trial.
Conduct two City 30(b)(6) examination before
trial.
Prepare, do, and review telephone call with MD
expert; client and co -counsel.
Page 207

7.500
7.000
7.000

2.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

D

Date
07/21/14
07/22/14
07/30/14

Timekeepe
JL
JL
JL

07/31/14

J1,

08/01/14

JL

08/04/14

JL

08/05/14

JL

08/06/14

JL

08/07/14

JL

4632.0

08/08/14

JL

4633.0

08/09/14

JL

4634.0

08/10/14

JL

4635.0

08/11/14

JL

4636.0

1

08/14/14

JL

08/15/14
08/16/14

JL

08/18/14

JL

08/19/14

JL

08/20/14

J1,

No.

4624 4623.0
4625 4624.0
4625.0
4626
4626.0
4627
4627.0
4628
4628.0
4629
4629.0
4630
4630.0
4631
4631.0

E

Description
.

Review of discovery and depositions.
Status conference with Smith and client.
Telephone conference with Smith and LE experts
re repost
Preparing letter to Court; tel conf w/Smith and LE
experts
Draft case status report; update Trial
Memorandum.
Telephone conference with LE experts; Eterno and
Silverman with Nat Smith.
Discovery review; review letter to Court re:
outstanding issues; finalize status report.
Review and summarize depositions; confer
w/Smith re: expert reports.
Review depositions; prepare index and summaries;
confer re: expert testimony and reports.

4632

1.250

0.750
1.500

1.500
1.000

2.500
1.750

2.500

4633

4634
4635

4636
4637
4638 4637.0
4638.0
4639
4639.0
4640
4640.0
4641
4641.0

4642

Hours
1.500

.11

Review depositions; index and summarize; plan
expert report submission and prepare for
depositions.
Confer w/Smith re: expert reports; conference call
with LE experts.
Review expert reports; conference calls with
psychiatric expert.
Plaintiffs expert disclosure due; prepare packages
and send.
Research and review existing material re: expert
depositions and dispositive motions.
Prepare for depositions of plaintiffs experts.
Telephone conference with Nat Smith re: expert
report follow up and deposition.
Respond to City Defendant letter re: expert reports;
review and index depositions.
Review deposition summaries; draft
correspondence re: discovery issues.
Draft response to City Defendants letter re:
30(b)(6) witness; also renew demands for
production of Marino and other discovery
documents.

Page 208

2.250
2.000
2.500
4.250
1.500
1.500
1.000

2.500
2.500

4.750

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

No.

Date

4642.0

1

08/21/14

D

C

B

!

Timekeep Description
Telephone conference with Smith re: case
JL
scheduling with Larry Schoolcraft (.75); draft
response to medical defendants re: depositions of
Dr. Patel and Dr. Lwin and City Defendants re:
discovery issues (1.25); complete Adrian
Schoolcraft 2nd deposition summary (2.50).

E

Hours

4.500

4643

4643.0

08/22/14

JL

4644
4644.0

08/26/14

JL

4645
4645.0

08/29/14

JL

4646
4646.0

09/02/14

JL

4647
4647.0

09/04/14

JL

4648
4648.0

09/05/14

JL

Confer with all expert witnesses re: schedule
availability for depositions.
Confer with experts re: additional information on
reports; and schedule availability; review defendant
Mauriello letter to dismiss charges.
Review Court Order re: discovery; confer with
Smith.
Confer with co -counsel on expert discovery
response, schedule of depositions.
Schedule of expert depositions (.75); review
defendants letter motion re: expert reports and
depositions (1.25); prepare for expert depositions
(1.50).
Confer with co -counsel re: expert reports and
depositions; prepare response to defendants' letter
motion re: expert reports and deposition schedules;
organize further deposition summaries.

1.250

1.750

1.500
1.500

4.500

3.500

4649
4649.0

4650
4651 4650.0
4651.0

09/06/14

09/07/14
09/08/14

JL

JL
JL

4652

4652.0

09/10/14

JL

Review process of summmarizing deposition
transcripts; confidentiality agreement, billing
procedures,
Review PD expert Silverman prior research.
Confer with co -counsel re: expert discovery;
schedule and deposition strategy; review Monel
law and facts..
Review with all counsel expert witness deposition
schedule and outstanding discovery production;
review research material for depositions.

3.500
1.500

2.750

2.500

4653
4653.0

09/12/14

JL

4654
4654.0

09/12/14

JL

4655
4655.0

09/13/14

JL

Meeting with client and trial team in Mayfield NY
(Smith, Bauza and legal asst) in preparation for
trial.
POV from 111 Broadway NYC to 467 Bunker Hill
Road, Mayfield, NY for trial planning session with
client.
Meeting with client at Bunker Hill, Mayfield, NY.

4.000

2.000
7.500

4656

Page 209

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

C

B

No.

Date

4656.0

1

09/14/14

D

Timekeepe Description
JL
POV (Smith) from 467 Bunker Hill Road,

Mayfielld, NY (trial planning session with client
and trial team) to NYC.

4657
4657.0

09/14/14

JL

4658.0

09/15/14

JL

4660.0

09/16/14
09/17/14

JL
JL

4661.0

09/18/14

JL

4662.0

09/19/14

JL

4663.0

09/21/14

JL

4664.0

09/22/14

JL

4665.0

09/23/14

JL

4666.0

09/24/14

JL

4667.0

09/25/14

JL

4668.0

09/29/14

JL

Discuss and prepare documentation for LE Expert
depositions.
Prepare (w/Smith) Dr. Halpern-Rudger for
examination before trial at 330 East 42nd Street,
NYC.

4669.0

09/30/14

JL

10/01/14

JL

Hours

2.000

Expert deposition with Dr. Halpern -Ruder at MCB.

4670.0

E

Prepare for hearing on defendants' motion (1.25);
hearing on city and hospital defendants' motion
(.75); review of rulings from hearing (.25); prep
production of LE expert resource materials (.75).

4658

4659
4660 4659.0
4661

Meeting with client in Mayfield, NY. for trial prep
with trial team.
Review discovery materials produced by City
Defendants; conferred with LE expert Eterno by
telephone; and conference call with LE experts.
Reivew and consult re: expert discovery.
Prepare for Hearing; hearing with Judge Sweet
courtroom at 500 Pearl Street, NYC.
Prepare for City 30(b)(6) examination before trial
on Friday; prepare for motion for summary
judgment; defendants expert disclosure due.

4662

4.000

2.500
2.500
3.000

2.500

4663

4664

With Smith: City 30(b)(6) deposition with Sgt
Purpi; and City 30(b)(6) witness on gun amnesty
program.
Prepare ER expert for examination before trial;
confer w/Smith re med experts.
ER and Psych Expert deposition preparation (2.00);
review defendants' expert reports (2.00).

4665

2.750
2.750

4.500

4666

Expert deposition with Dr. Lubit at MCB 220 East
42nd Street, NYC.
Expert deposition: Review Lubit deposition; review
defendants' expert reports; prepare for LE experts.

4667

7.500

1.500

4668

4669

4670

2.000

2.000
7.500

4671

3.000

Page 210

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

4671.0

I

C

B

Date
10/02/14

Timekeeper Description

JL

4672
4672.0

10/03/14

D

I

JL

Prepare for summary judgment motion (1.25);
summarize examination before trial (1.00); review
LE expert resource materials for production (1.50);
prepare and schedule legal assistants (Jeanette and
Lysia) for examination before trial summaries
(2.50).

E

Hours

6.250

Case conference with client and Smith; preparation
for summary judgment motions; prepare research
for mtion to amend complaint.
3.750

4673
4673.0

10/06/14

JL

4674
4674.0

10/10/14

JL

4675
4675.0

10/14/14

JL

Review of discovery correspondence and
scheduling of remaining depositions.
Tel Conference with Lubit and Silverman re:
schedule and prepare for deposition.
Meet Nat Smith for meeting with LE expert Eterno;
drive to and from Molloy College from NYC to
discuss expert report and prepare dor Dr. Eterno for
examination before trial. [mtg:2:30] [travel: 2:00]

1.500
1.000

2.500

4676
4676.0

10/14/14

JL

4677
4677.0

10/15/14

JL

4678
4678.0

10/16/14

JL

4679

4679.0

10/17/14

JL

4680
4680.0

10/20/14

JL

4681

4681.0

10/22/14

JL

4682
4682.0

10/23/14

JL

4683
4683.0

10/24/14

JL

4684
4684.0
4685
4686 4685.0
4686.0
4687
4687.0
4688

10/28/14

10/29/14
11/03/14
11/06/14

JS

JL
JL
JL

POV (Nat Smith) to and from Molloy College from
NYC for meeting with LE expert Eterno; to discuss
expert report and prepare for Dr. Eterno for
examination before trial.
Conference w/Smith re: City Defendants settlement
proposal; prepare counter proposal.
Conference with client and Smith re: settlement
options and trial strategy.
Examination before trial of Dr. Eterno (with
Smith).
Meeting (conference call) with client and Smith re
City settlement possibilities
Review of 2nd Amended Complaint; research for
proposed 3rd Amendment.
Prepare and review summaries of deposition
transcripts; schedule remaining depositions with
counsel; prepare Silverman for deposition.
Defend with Smith City's examination before trial
of Silverman.
Review discovery issues outstanding and
preparation for hearing 10/29/2014.
Hearing before Judge Sweet.
Telephone conference with Smith re: 3rd Amended
Complaint.
Case conference with client and Smith; update re:
strategy and outstanding discovery matters.
Page 211

1.000

2.000
1.500

8.500

0.750
1.500

3.500
7.500

2.000
1.000
0.750

2.250

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

I

D

No.

Date

4688.0

11/10/14

Timekeepe Description
JL
Defend with Smith Lubit examination before trial

4689.0

11/13/14

JL

4691.0

11/16/14
11/18/14

JL
JL

4692.0

11/20/14

JL

4693.0

12/03/14

JL

4694.0

12/04/14

JL

4695.0

12/08/14

JL

4696.0

12/09/14

JL

4697.0

12/21/14

JL

4699.0

12/22/14
01/03/15

JL
JL

Draft and Review plaintiff motion summary
judgment.
Review plaintiff motion for summary judgment.
Meeting with Nat Smith re: Summary Judgment

4700.0

01/05/15

JL

4701.0

01/07/15

JL

4702.0

01/08/15

JL

4703.0

01/09/15

JL

01/10/15
01/11/15

JL
JL

4708.0

01/12/15
01/13/15
01/14/15

JL
JL
JL

4709
4710 4709.0

01/15/15

JL

E

Research review for motion for summary judgment
and opposition to Mauriello counterclaim.

1

4689

Hours

4.000

4690
4691 4690.0
4692
4693

4694
4695

4696

Lubit deposition continued (defend plaintiff psych
expert with Smith).
Review draft of 3rd Amended Complaint.
Review of legal assistant's work in summarizing
deposition transcripts.
Follow up re: Lubit deposition and prep materials
for trial testimony.
Review draft of 3rd Amended Complaint; review
plaintiff motion for Summary Judgment and
dismiss Mauriello counterclaim.
Review draft of 3rd Amended Complaint and
motion v. Mauriello.
Review deposition summaries; research on motions
for summary judgment; confer with Smith re
preparation for opposition.

4697

5.500
1.750
1.000
1.000

3.000
1.500

3.000

2.000

4698
4699 4698.0

4700

motion.

4701
4702

Review of summary judgment motion; prepare
response.
Meeting with Nat Smith and James McCutcheon re:
review of Compstat DVD's.
Review and index CompStat DVD's (4.50); prepare
response to summary judgment motion (4.00).

4703

2.000
1.500
1.750

4.500
1.500

8.500

4704
4705 4704.0
4705.0

4706
4707 4706.0
4708 4707.0

Review of Compstat DVD's (2.50); prep index.
Meeting with Nat Smith re: summary judgment
motion (2.00).
Review CompStat DVD's; prep index.
Review CompStat DVD's; telephone call re:
CompStat DVD's; review CompStat DVD's.
CompStat DVD review.
Review and index CompStat DVD's.
Meeting re: summary judgment motion (2.00);
CompStat DVD review (4.50).
Review and index CompStat DVD's.

Page 212

4.500
7.500
8.250
6.500
6.000

6.500
6.750

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

No.

1

4710.0

Date
01/19/15

4711
4711.0

01/20/15

Timekeepe Description
Draft Response to Mauriello summary judgment
JL
motion (4.50); telephone call (Smith and
McCutcheon)re: CompStat DVD review (.75);
research for Response to Mauriello (1.50); meeting
for summary judgment (1.25).
JL

4712
4712.0

01/21/15

JL

4713
4713.0

01/22/15

JL

4714
4714.0

01/23/15

D

C

B

JL

Review defendants Order re: TAC; prepare
Summary Judgment Response Mauriello.
Research, review and drafting portions of plaintiff
SJ mtn
Draft and research for Responses to Mauriello
Summary Judgment motion.
Review CompStat DVD's; prepare Summany
Judgment Response Statement of motion and facts.

E

Hours

8.000

3.500
7.000

7.500

3.000

4715
4715.0

01/24/15

JL

4716
4716.0

01/25/15

JL

4717
4717.0

01/26/15

JL

Research and draft Responses to defendant
Mauriello Summary Judgment motion.
Research and Drafting in collab with Smith plaint
SJ mtn
Client conference call (1.50); research and drafting
re: summary judgment defendant Mauriello (7.00).

3.500

4.000

8.500

4718
4718.0

01/27/15

JL

4719
4719.0

01/28/15

JL

4720
4720.0

01/29/15

JL

Meeting / consult with Smith re: summary
judgment responses (2.00); research re: summary
judgment response Mauriello (4.00).
Research and draft; prepare for summary judgment
response Mauriello.
Mauriello response and research, record, and draft.

10.500

4.750

4721
4721.0

01/30/15

JL

Summary Judgment response, research, and draft.
2.000

4722
4722.0

01/31/15

JL

4723

4723.0

02/01/15

JL

4724
4724.0

02/02/15

JL

4725
4725.0

02/03/15

JL

4726
4726.0

02/04/15

JL

Prepare, research, write draft for response to
Mauriello summary judgment.
Confer with Smith in final draft: Mauriello
Summary Judgment Response and review.
Telephone conference withSmith and client;
meeting re: summary judgment motions and trial.
Trial Memo review. [client to reinstate Norinsberg
et al to trial team]
Meeting with Nat re: summary judgment motion;
summary judgment Mauriello research.
Meeting with Nat re: summary judgment motions.

8.500

4.500

4.500
3.500
1.000

4727
4727.0
4728

6.000

02/05/15

JL

Research and draft response to defendant Mauriello
motion for summary judgment; Mauriello summary
judgment motion reponse.
Page 213

7.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

D

4728.0

Date
02/06/15

Timekeepe Description
JL
Research and draft Summary judgment motion.

4729.0

02/07/15

JL

4730.0

02/08/15

JL

4731.0

02/09/15

.11

Preparation in opposition to defendants summary
judgment motion.
Summary Judgment motions; confer w/Smith re
prepare in opposition to motions and response to
Rule 56.1 Statement.

4732.0

02/10/15

JL

4733.0

02/11/15

JL

4734.0

02/12/15

JL

4735.0

02/13/15

JL

4736.0

02/17/15

JL

4737.0

02/18/15

JL

4738
4739 4738.0
4739.0

02/19/15
02/20/15

JL
JL

E

Review and draft Summary Judgment Motions.

No.

1

4729

7.500

4730

6.500

4731

4732

4733

4734
4735

4736
4737

Prepare memorandum in opposition to defendant's
motions for summary judgment and Rule 56.1
Statement.
Review and edit of opposition to defendant's
summary judgment motion.
Telephone conference with co -counsel; review of
summary judgment motions by defendants.
Review of defendant's motions in opposition to
plaintiffs motion summary judgment; review of
defendant's motions and prepare for plaintiffs reply
re: Schoolcraft discovery.
Review of defendant Mauriello's motion and
prepare plaintiff reply.
Review and research on plaintiff reply
memorandum to defendant Mauriello's response
motion.

8.500

9.500

8.500
6.500

2.500

2.000
2.500

3.000

4740.0

02/23/15

JL

4741.0

02/24/15

JL

4742.0

02/25/15

JL

02/26/15
02/28/15
03/02/15

JL
JL
JL

03/03/15

JL

03/04/15

JL

4741
4742
4743
4744 4743.0
4745 4744.0
4745.0
4746
4746.0

4747
4747.0

Review of examination before trial summaries.
Prepare for meeting with new trial team; meet with
Norinsberg trial team; and review draft of trial

1.000

memo.

4740

4748

Hours

4.500

Review of Mauriello summary judgment motion
response; research and review documents for
summary judgment reply.
Review discovery to draft response to Mauriello
motion opposition.
Draft and research for reply to Mauriello summary
judgment response motion.
Review of Rule 56.1 Mauriello.
Review of Mauriello Rule 56.1.
Review and draft summary judgment motion; reply
to defendant's motion.
Research and review of defendants motions and
summary judgment statements re: re -preparation
w/Smith of reply brief.
Review of case file and research for smmary
judgment motion reply brief.
Page 214

3.000

2.500
2.000
2.500
1.500

2.250

6.500
7.250

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

1

No.

4748.0
4749
4750 4749.0
4750.0
4751
4752 4751.0
4752.0
4753
4753.0

B

Date
03/05/15
03/06/15
03/09/15
03/10/15
03/11/15
03/12/15

I
I

Timekeepe Description
Draft, discuss and review summary judgment
JL
motion.
Review and edit of summary judgment reply.
JL
Research and draft letter to Court re: Matthews.
JL
JL
JL
JL

4754
4754.0

03/13/15

D

C

JL

Telephone conference with Nat.
Meeting with Nat Smith re: Matthews letter and
response; trial strategy.
Review motions; prepare letter to court. re;
Matthews and quantified immunity. Meeting with
Norinsberg team at 225 Bway
Smith meeting at 111 Broadway for review of trial
strategy and rewponsibilities with new team.

E

Hours
8.500
3.500

2.500
0.500
2.500

4.500

2.500

4755
4755.0

4756
4757 4756.0
4758 4757.0
4758.0
4759
4759.0

03/16/15
03/18/15
03/22/15
03/23/15
03/24/15

JL
JL
JL
JL
JL

Review motion response re: Lamstein Affidavit and
reply to attorney motion.
Review of trial; prepare exhibits.
Trial exhibits preparation.
Meeting with Nat MSith at 100 Wall Street;
prepare trial exhibits and witness list.
Draft/prepare jury verdict sheet template. Research
re jury instruction re elements of complaint.

2.500
0.500
1.500

4.500

4.500

4760
4760.0

03/25/15

JL

4761
4761.0

4762
4763 4762.0
4763.0
4764
4764.0
4765
4765.0
4766
4766.0
4767
4767.0

03/27/15

03/28/15
03/29/15
03/30/15
03/31/15

04/01/15
04/02/15

JL

JL
JL
JL

JL
JL
JL

Review of of trial preparation - especially Lubit
Direct Outline.
Telephone conference with new trial team; assign
witness; complete jury questions round up;
compstat video by Wednesday.
Update Trial Memo
Prepare expert witness direct; draft jury instruction
round up.
Trial preparation; expect witness direct - Eterno,
Lubit, Halpren-Ruder.
Prepare trial examination - Eterno, Lubit, and
Halpren-Ruder.
Prepare expert witness testimony and trial
notebook.
Meeting with trial team; research expert testimony
for direct testimony and prep for cross.

2.500

2.000
1.500

4.750
6.000
6.500

6.500

5.000

4768
4768.0
4769
4770 4769.0
4770.0
4771

04/03/15

04/04/15
04/06/15

JL

JL
JL

Research and prepare expert witness; direct and
cross
Trial memo preparation.
Prepare expert trial testimony for Eterno; review
examination before trial for Eterno.
Page 215

4.500
2.000
3.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

4771.0

Date
04/07/15

4772.0

04/08/15

4773.0

04/09/15

4774.0

04/10/15

4775
4776 4775.0
4776.0

04/11/15
04/13/15

No.

1

4772

4773

4774

4777

C

4777.0

04/15/15

4778.0

04/17/15

4779.0

04/24/15

JL

4780.0

04/28/15

JL

4781.0

05/01/15

JL

4782.0

05/05/15

JL

4783.0

05/06/15

JL

4784.0

05/11/15

JL

4785.0

05/12/15

JL

4786.0

06/01/15

JL

4787.0

06/02/15

JL

4788.0

06/22/15

JL

4789.0

06/23/15

JL

4790
4791 4790.0
4792 4791.0

06/24/15
06/25/15

JL
JL

4778

D

Timekeepe Description
JL
Prepare trial testimony for Halpren-Ruder; review
jury instructions and motion.
JL
Review of trial exhibits for expert witnesses Eterno
and Halpren-Ruder; prepare expert testimony for
Halpren-Ruder.
JL
Expert trial preparation for Eterno; outline direct
and prepare exhibits.
JL
Prepare expert trial testimony for Halpre-Ruder;
expert witness preparation for Lubit.
JL
Prepare Eterno direct, with exhibits
JL
Prepare for hearing before Judge Sweet re: trial
schedule; meeting with trial team re: trial schedule
and strategy.
JL
Review of additional discovery by City Defendants
re: Lamstein.
JL
Review of City Proposal for settlement; telephone
call to Schoolcraft re: City Settlement offer.

4779

E

Hours

4.250

3.000

4.500
4.250
2.500

3.500
1.500

1.500

4780
4781
4782
4783

4784
4785
4786

Telephone conference with Nat Smith re possible
settlement strategy
Telephone conference with Nat Smith; call to Roy
Lubit re: trial schedule.
Telephone conference with Nat Smith re trial
responsibilities, tactics and overall strategy
Review / discussion of court's 200 page Opinion re:
Summary Judgment Motions.
Review and discuss with Smith plaintiff response
re court's Opinion.
Prepare for hearing re: Court's Opinion/Order re:
dispositive motions.
Meeting with full trial team re: hearing; status
conference with Judge Sweet.
Research and draft letter motion re: reconsideration
of order re: modified complaint.

4787

0.500
1.250

0.750
3.000

2.500
2.500
1.750

5.750

4788
4789

Review of draft and additional research re: court
motion to reconsider re: Dr HR; review draft of
reconsideration letter and motion.
Discussion re: opposition to city & summary
motions to reconsideration (Nat Smith).
Discussion with Nat Smith re: opposition to
consideration motions.
Prepare opposition response re bifurcation.
Draft and research re: bifurcation issue.

Page 216

2.000
0.750
0.500
1.500
7.500

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

13

4792.0

Date
06/26/15

4793.0

1

06/27/15

No.

4793

4794
4794.0

07/06/15

4795
4795.0

07/08/15

4796
4796.0

07/09/15

4797
4797.0

07/13/15

4798

D

C

1

Timekeepe Description
Research and draft plaintiff opposition to
JL
bifurcation of Monet! claim.
Further research and draft of plaintiff opposition to
JL
bifurcation motion; finalize draft of opposition to
bifurcation.
Review draft of opposition memo for
JL
reconsideration.
Research re: production of plaintiff PD expert to
JL
city defendants.
Confer with expert; Draft response to city re:
JL
plaintiff expert resource material; review police
expert disclosure requirements.
Response to city defendants request for additional
JL
discovery re: PD experts.
Review / research of JHMC Opposition Memo re:
JL
Halpren-Ruder.
Prepare response to defendant JHMC Memo in
JL
Opposition to motion for resonsideration re: expert
Halpren-Ruder.
Discussion and review re: Compstat Records; PD
JL
expert disclosure.
Draft opposition to JHMC Memrandum re Medical
JL
Expert Halpren-Ruder.
Prepare Response to JHMC Opposition to Plaintiff
JL
Medical Expert.
Research and draft Memo In Response to JHMC
JL
opposition memo;
Meeting with trial team re JPTO etc. at 100 Wall
JL
Street.
Review documentary film on client with Eterno.
JL
.

4798.0

07/14/15

4799
4799.0

07/15/15

4800
4800.0

07/17/15

4801
4801.0

07/20/15

4802

4802.0

07/22/15

4803

4803.0

07/23/15

4804
4804.0

07/24/15

4805
4805.0

07/27/15

4806.0

08/07/15

4811
4812 4811.0
4812.0
4813

4.500

4.000
0.750

2.500

5.750
2.500

0.200

5.500
1.250

5.000
4.250
7.500

2.250
0.750

4806

4807
4808 4807.0
4809 4808.0
4809.0
4810
4810.0

E

Hours

08/14/15
08/21/15
08/24/15
08/25/15

08/26/15
09/16/15

JL

JL
JL
JL
JL

JL
JL

Review JPTO's filed by defendants; telephone
conference with counsel team re: JPTO; conference
with co -counsel re: Trial Draft.
Meeting with Smith re JPTO
Draft letter to court re experts at trial.
Review of trial exhibits, expert rpts and EBTs;
prepare expert trial witness outlines.
Review and edit letter to court re: opposition to city
defendants 2 letters; witness trial outlines: Eterno.
Prepare witness trial outlines.
Confer with trial team re City R 68 offer of jmt;

3.500
1.000
1.000

6.500

2.000
3.500
2.500

Page 217

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

C

D

4813.0

1

4814
4815
4816
4817
4818
4819

Date
7/31/2013

Timekeepe Description
HS
meeting with Nat Smith to review role and case

4814.0
4815.0
4816.0
4817.0
4818.0
4819.0

8/1/2013
8/2/2013
8/6/2013
8/7/2013
8/13/2013
8/22/2013

HS
HS
HS
HS
HS
HS

9/4/2013
9/13/2013

HS
HS

10/1/2013

HS

10/2/2013

HS

emails from and/or to Nat Smith
reviewed amended complaint
reviewed Jamaica Hospital's doc exchange
read Plaintiffs depo
emails to and/or from Nat Smith
reviewed availability, called and emailed Nat Smith
re: my availability for depos
reviewed status report
reviewed departmental action affect on case by city
and emailed to group
prep for inspection of Schoolcraft home and Hosp:
reviewed records & depo of pit
home and hosp inspection and Scene inspection

10/7/2013
10/15/2013
10/15/2013
10/17/2013

HS
HS
HS
HS

read Kretz transcript
read John L status report
reviewed motion papers for motions of 10/16
started review of dots from drop box invasion tape

10/18/2013
10/21/2013

HS
HS

10/22/2013
10/24/2013
10/25/2013

HS
HS
HS

10/25/2013
10/28/2013

HS

10/28/2013
10/29/2013

HS
HS

prep for Aldana-Bernier depo
reviewed Aldana-Bernier interrogatories and
further prep for depo
meeting with Nat Smith to review case
prep deposition binder for Aldana-Bernier depo
appeared for Aldana-Bernier depo and strategized
with John Meg and Nat Smit
reviewed Nat Smith email re: discovery
reviewed motion by medical deft re; video depo/6
emails
performed research on video tape depositions
emails to team re: motion for video dep/ research

No.

4820
4821 4820.0
4821.0
4822
4822.0
4823
4823.0
4824
4825 4824.0
4826 4825.0
4827 4826.0

4827.0

4828
4829 4828.0
4829.0
4830
4831 4830.0
4832 4831.0
4832.0
4833
4834 4833.0
4834.0
4835
4836 4835.0
4836.0
4837
4837.0
4838
4839 4838.0
4839.0
4840
4841 4840.0
4841.0
4842
4843 4842.0
4844 4843.0
4845 4844.0

11S

1_

E

Hours

2.500
0.250
1.000
1.500
1.500

0.200
0.250
0.200
1.750

4.000
6.250
0.500
0.200
1.500

6.000
4.000
3.250
2.500
10.000
5.000
0.100

3.500
2.500
1.000

11/13/2013

HS

Appeared for SDNY motion: re video depositions

11/4/2013
11/18/2013

HS
HS

1/8/2014
2/9/2014

HS
HS

2/11/2014
2/10/2014
2/11/2014

HS

emails to team
telephone call with John Lenoir and emails re:
Larry Schoolcraft deposition
email to John Lenoir
call and email re: Deposition of hospital with deft
counsel
reviewed client's deposition questions
deposition preparation
prep lsakov deposition

1.250

HS
HS

Page 218

0.100
1.250

0.100
0.200
0.500
5.200
9.000

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

4846 4845.0
4847 4846.0

4848 4847.0
4849 4848.0
4850 4849.0
4850.0

Date

Timekeepe Description

2/12/2014
2/14/2014
4/20/2014
4/22/2014
4/23/2014
8/10/2014

HS
HS
HS
HS
HS
HS

4851
4851.0

4852
4853 4852.0
4853.0

12/8/2014

3/25/2015
02/21/13

HS

HS
MB

4854
4854.0

03/05/13

MB

4855
4855.0

D

C

B

03/09/13

MB

prep and conducted Isakov deposition
researched statutory duty
preparation Aldana-Bernier deposition
preparation Aldana-Bernier deposition
prep and conducted Aldana-Bernier deposition
reviewed expert report and emailed team re: expert
report
researched statutory standard and emailed team
with research
prepared request to charge
Initial meeting with Peter Gleason and Jeremy
Skehan
Meeting with Peter Gleason re: coming on board
the Schoolcraft team.
Meeting with Peter and Nat re briefing of the case.

Hours

7.250
2.100
4.500

3.000
8.000
1.500

4.250
1.250
2.000
3.000
3.000

4856
4856.0

03/15/13

MB

4857
4857.0

03/27/13

MB

4858
4858.0

04/01/13

MB

4859
4859.0

04/07/13

MB

4860
4859.5

4861
4862 4860.0
4861.0

04/07/13

08/01/13
08/02/13

Peter J.
Gleason
MB
MB

4863
4862.0

4864
4865 4863.0
4864.0

4866
4867
4868
4869
4870

E

4865.0

4866.0
4867.0
4868.0

4871 4869.0

4872 4870.0

08/05/13

08/06/13
08/07/13

08/12/13
08/13/13
08/14/13
08/19/13
08/20/13
08/21/13

MB

MB
MB

MB
MB
MB
MB
MB
MB

Started research on admissibility of demonstrative
evidence story board project.
Conference with Peter, Nat, and Artist re Story
Board project.
Memo to counsel re: research on prior restraint in
response to motion for gag order.
Meeting with Adrian and team in Saugerties (travel
to and from meeting 4 hours).
Meeting in Saugerties with AS, LS and legal team.
(Travel at 1/2 hr. rate)
Meeting with Nat re: jury instructions project.
Review Complaint, record, and prior case
decisions.
Jury instructions project: research fundamentals of
1983 litigation and federal causes of action; review
commentary Bender and Schwartz; causation by
multiple defendants; collect cases for authority.
Jury instructions project.
Prep for meeting with illustrator re demonstrative
project; meeting with potential "dangerousness
expert," Tom Litwack.
Jury instructions project.
Meeting with Nat at 3pm re update on projects
Jury instructions project.
Jury instructions project.
Jury instructions project.
Jury instructions project.
Page 219

6.000
3.000
6.000
6.000

8.000
3.000

7.000

5.000
5.000

7.000
5.000
3.000
5.000
5.000
5.000
5.000

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

1

No.

4871.0

4873
4874 4872.0
4873.0
4875
4876 4874.0
4875.0
4877
4878 4876.0
4877.0
4879
4880 4878.0
4881 4879.0
4882 4880.0
4883 4881.0
4882.0
4884
4885 4883.0
4886 4884.0
4885.0
4887
4888 4886.0
4889 4889.0
4890.0

4890
4891 4891.0
4892 4892.0
4893 4893.0
4894.0
4894
4895.0
4895
4896.0

B

Date
08/23/13

C

08/29/13
09/01/13

09/03/13
09/05/13

MB
MB

09/06/13
09/09/13
09/11/13
09/12/13
09/13/13

MB
MB
MB
MB
MB

09/18/13
09/19/13
09/24/13

MB
MB
MB

09/25/13
10/02/13
10/03/13

MB
MB
MB

10/04/13
10/07/13
10/08/13
10/10/13

MB
MB
MB
MB

10/11/13

MB

10/14/13

MB

Prepare medical defendants examination before
trial; review medical chart and record; review
depostions of City defendants; review hospital
policy and procedure; review MHL 9.39; draft
deposition questions.

10/15/13

MB

4897
4898 4898.0
4899.0
4899

E

Prepare medical defendants examination before

08/26/13
08/27/13

Jury instructions project.
Preparing detailed timelines for case on plaintiffs
entire work history; NYPD work history; hosptial
events and events of 10-31-09.
Timeline Project.
Timeline Project.
Timeline Project.
Timeline Project.
Meeting with Nat 4:30pm re update of current
projects
Meeting with Nat and Adrian
Inspection of 81st Precinct
Meeting with Adrian to work on layout of Glendale
apt
Oral Argument; team meeting
Jamaica Hospital inspection.
Prepare Marino examination before trial; compile
relevant discovery docs into searchable PDF;
review record and prepare questions

Prepare Marino exination before trial.
Prepare Marino examination before trial.
Deposition of Deputy Chief Michael Marino.
Research caselaw on involuntary commitments
involving private hospitals
Research involuntary commitments and MHL 9.39.

Hours

3.000
5.000
7.750
5.000

3.000
5.000

5.000
5.000
5.000
5.000
5.000
3.000
2.000
6.000

3.000
4.000
6.000

5.000
5.000
5.000
0.000
5.000
5.000

4896
4897.0

D

1

Timekeepe Description
MB
Meeting with Nat at 5pm re state action research
project
MB
Jury instructions project.
MB
Te meeting with Adrian in Saugerties. (Travel time
4.5 hours)
MB
Jury instructions project.
MB
Nat's office, listen to audios and review production.

trial.
10/16/13
10/17/13

MB
MB

Judge Sweet's courtroom hearing.
Prepare medical defendants examination before
trial
Page 220

5.000
5.000
3.000

3.000

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

No.

Date

4900.0

1

10/18/13

Timekeepe Description
Research involuntary commitments and due
MB

4900
4901.0

10/21/13

D

C

B

MB

process violations; brief cases.
Prepare medical defendants exination before trial

Hours

5.000

6.000

4901
4902.0

10/22/13

MB

Prepare medical defendants exination before trial
5.000

4902
4903.0

4903
4904 4904.0
4905 4905.0
4906.0

4906
4907 4907.0
4908 4908.0
4909.0

10/23/13
10/24/13
10/25/13
10/28/13

10/29/13
10/30/13
10/31/13

MB
MB
MB
MB

MB
MB
MB

4909
4910.0

4910
4911
4912
4913
4914

E

4911.0
4912.0
4913.0
4914.0

4915.0

11/01/13

11/04/13
11/05/13
11/06/13
11/07/13
11/08/13

MB

MB
MB
MB
MB
MB

4915
4916.0

11/09/13

MB

4916
4917.0

11/11/13

MB

4917
4918.0

4918
4919 4919.0
4920.0

4920
4921 4921.0
4922.0

11/12/13

11/13/13
11/14/13

11/15/13
11/18/13

MB

MB
MB

MB
MB

4922
4923.0

4923
4924 4924.0

11/20/13
11/21/13

MB
MB

Prepare medical defendants exination before trial.
Meeting with Nat re status on projects
Dr. Aldana-Berner; deposition was cancelled.
Research re:defendant's objection to plaintiffs use
of video at deposition; research Rule 30, Rule
28(c), CPLR 3313 (b).
Research video deposition Rule 30.
Research video deposition Rule 30.
Memo to counsel re; research video deposition
Rule 30.
Prepare Lauterborn examination before trial;
review record; listen to audios; compile discovery
docs into searchable PDF; draft deposition
questions.
Prepare Lauterborn examination before trial.
Prepare Lauterborn examination before trial
Prepare Lauterborn examination before trial
Lauterborn deposition.
Review discovery, catalog, and convert to
searchable PDF files.
Review discovery, organize, and convert to
searchable files.
Review discovery, catalog, and convert to
searchable PDF files.
Canvas Glendale neighborhood with Terry;
interview Adrian's next door neighbor and current
resident of Glendale apt.; take photos.
Judge Sweet's courtroom hearing.
Prepare Mauriello exination before trial; review
record; listen to audios;compile discovery docs into
searchable PDF; draft deposition questions.
Prepare Mauriello exination before trial.
Interview with Carol Stretmoyer at Midtown
location (w/TerrySkinner).
Interview with Ted Stretmoyer at Glendale apt.
(with Terry Skinner).
Prepare Mauriello examination before trial
Page 221

5.000
3.000
2.500

5.000
5.000
5.000
5.000

5.000
5.000
5.000
5.000
0.000

5.000
5.000
5.000

5.000
5.000

5.000
5.000

3.000
3.000
5.000

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

No.

Date

4925.0

11/22/13

4926.0

1

11/24/13

4925

4926
4927 4927.0
4928.0
4928
4929.0

11/25/13
11/26/13
11/29/13

4929
4930.0

4930
4931 4931.0
4932.0
4932
4933.0
4933
4934 4934.0
4935 4935.0
4936.0
4936
4937.0
4937
4938.0
4938
4939.0
4939
4940.0
4940
4941 4941.0
4942 4942.0
4943 4943.0
4944 4944.0
4945.0
4945
4946 4946.0
4947.0
4947
4948.0
4948

C

D

Timekeepe Description
MB
Mauriello deposition cancelled; begin Prof Rule 4.2
no contact research.
MB
Prof Rule 4.2 no contact research; issues include:
when gov. employees are considered "parties"
under Rule 4.2 and when employees are considered
"represented."
MB
Prof Rule 4.2 no contact research.
MB
Draft memo to counsel re: Prof Rule 4.2 no contact
research.
MB
Rule 30(c)(2) research; issues include: Rule 612;
the production of documents relied on during
deposition; attorney -client privilege; relevancy
under Rule 26.

11/30/13

MB

12/02/13
12/03/13

MB
MB

Rule 30(c)(2) research re: discoverable disciplinary
records; convictions; sanctions; applying state law
privileges.
Rule 30(c)(2) research.
Draft memo to counsel re: Rule 30(c)(2) research

12/04/13

MB
MB
MB
MB

Write up on all deposition objection issues.
Write up on all deposition objection issues.
Prepare Larry Schoolcraft examination before trial.

12/11/13

MB

12/12/13

MB

12/13/13

MB

12/16/13

MB

12/17/13
12/18/13
12/19/13
12/20/13
12/22/13

MB
MB
MB
MB
MB

12/24/13
12/26/13

MB
MB

12/27/13

MB

Larry Schoolcraft deposition in Albany, NY. (travel
6.5 hours).
Review discovery, organize, and convert to
searchable files.
Review discovery, organize, and convert to
searchable files; listen to audio.
Prepare Mauriello examination before trial; review
documents; create searchable PDF; review
depositions and record; listen to audio.
Prepare Mauriello examination before trial.
Prepare Mauriello examination before trial.
Prepare Mauriello examination before trial.
Mauriello deposition.
Meeting with Adrian Schoolcraft re: demontrative
evidence project.
Meeting with Team and Adrian Schoolcraft.
Meeting with Adrian re demonstrative evidence
project; joined by John Lenoir.
Meeting with Adrian Schoolcraft re demontrative
evidence project.

Hours

4.500

3.000
6.000
6.000

5.000

Draft memo to counsel re: Rule 30(c)(2) research

12/05/13
12/06/13
12/10/13

E

5.000
5.000
5.000

5.000
5.000
5.000
5.000

Page 222

12.750
5.000

5.000

5.000
5.000
5.000
5.000
0.000

3.000
3.000

3.000
3.000

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

4949.0

Date
12/29/13

4949
4950.0

12/30/13

4950
4951.0
4951
4952 4952.0
4955.0
4953
4956.0
4954
4957.0
4955
4958.0

01/03/14
01/05/14
01/06/14
01/10/14

01/12/14
01/12/14

D

C

B

Timekeepe Description
Meeting at Nat's office w/ Adrian; review audio
MB
and record.
Meeting at Nat's office w/ Adrian; review audio
MB
and record.
Prepare for Huffman and Boston Deposition;
MB
review discovery docs; draft questions.
Prepare for Boston and Huffman Deposition.
MB
Team meeting re review of Boston and Huffman
MB
depositions.
Review and catalog discovery production at Nat's
MB
office; listen to Hanlon audio.
Analyze NYPD emergency protocol; review NYPD
MB
Patrol guide.
Prepare for Hanlon's deposition; review EMT
MB
emergency procedure and discovery documents.

E

Hours

4.000
3.000

4.500
6.020
1.750

7.000

2.200

4.130

4956
4960.0

01/15/14

MB

4957
4961.0

01/28/14

MB

4958
4962.0

4959
4960 4963.0
4964.0

01/29/14

01/30/14
02/03/14

MB
MB
MB

4961
4965.0

02/04/14

MB

4962
4966.0

02/05/14

MB

4963
4967.0

02/07/14

MB

4964
4968.0

02/08/14

MB

Hearing with Judge Sweet re discovery issues; team
meeting re status of case.
Prepare for Lamstein deposition; review
handwritten notes in discovery docs; draft
questions.
Meeting Nat's Office re: review and prep for
Lamstein EBT.
Lamstein Deposition.
Research inadvertent production and ethics on
production obligation; search files and remove
discovery documents in question.
Research inadvertent production and ethics on
production obligation; research Rule 502, Fed. R.
Civ. P. 26(b)(5)(B) and caselaw.
Draft memo to counsel re: inadvertent production
research.
Meeting with Nat re: inadvertent production
redaction issues; begin prep for Medical
Defendants EBTs.
Prepare for Medical Defendant's EBTs; review
medical chart,record, and deposition summaries;
review Beiner's prior litigation testimony.

2.000

3.750
4.000
10.000

6.080

6.500
6.050

5.000

5.750

4965
4969.0

4966
4967 4970.0
4968 4971.0

02/10/14
02/11/14
02/12/14

MB
MB
MB

Conference with Howard Suckle re deposition
prep; prep for Medical Defendants depositions.
Bernier Deposition
lsakov Deposition.

Page 223

6.250
0.000
0.000

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

No.

Date

4972.0

1

02/20/14

4969
4970 4973.0

C

D

;Tirnekeepe Description

MB

E

Hours

Research state action under § 1983; draft memo to
counsel arguing Dr. lsakov's liability in response to
opposing counsel's request to release Isakov from
case.

4974.0

02/20/14
03/04/14

MB
MB

4975.0

03/07/14

MB

4976.0

03/08/14

MB

Research issues City Defendants' March 7, 2014
letter; ten-year limitation issue;
unsubstantiated claims issue; objections at
depositions generally; time to depose plaintiff
(Rule 30(d)(1).

4977.0

03/09/14

MB

4978.0

03/10/14

MB

4979.0

03/11/14

MB

4980.0

03/12/14

MB

Draft Memo to counsel re: City Defendants
deposition objection issues.
Research defendants assertion of privilege for
grand jury subpoenas.
Review and comment Letter to Judge Sweet; team
meeting re discovery issues.
Catalogue and review new discovery at Nat's office.

4981.0

03/12/14

MB

Letter to counsel re: search for missing discovery

4982.0

03/14/14

MB

Draft subject matter for NYPD 30(b)(6) notices.

4983.0

03/14/14

MB

Revise proposed jury instructions for City
defendants; research Monell custom and policy
municipal liability; analyze Monell jury
instructions from other jurisdictions; draft alternate
instructions; review and collect cases for authority.

4984.0

03/15/14

MB

Continue with research and drafting NYPD
proposed jury instructions; draft charges for
supervisor liability, First Amendment retaliation
and prior restraint.

4985.0

03/16/14

MB

4986.0

03/19/14

MB

Research and draft NYPD proposed jury
instructions; draft conspiracy and state action
charges.
Draft NYPD proposed jury instructions; continue
state action research re: Medical Defendants.

6.220
2.000

4971

Draft memo to counsel re: Dr. Isakov.
Conference call with City defendants; team
conference re trial prep status.
Research issues re: City Defendants' March 7, 2014
letter; attorney -client privilege issue; research Fed.
R. Evid. 612(b) and Fed. R. Civ Pro 26(b)(3).

4972

1.500

5.700

4973
4974

4975
4976
4977

4.650
6.660
5.230
3.360

6.500

4978

files.

1.000

4979

5.670

4980

5.470

4981

4982

4983

6.000

5.880

6.430

Page 224

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

03/21/14

7.800

03/27/14

1983 conspiracy liability.
Draft subject matter for JHMC 30(b)(6) notices.

4984
MB

5.250

4985
4989.0

4986
4987 4990.0
4991.0

03/28/14

04/02/14
04/03/14

MB

MB
MB

4988
4992.0

04/04/14

MB

4989
4993.0

04/11/14

MB

4990
4994.0

4991
4992 4995.0
4996.0

04/12/14

04/13/14
04/14/14

MB

MB
MB

4993
4997.0

04/14/14

MB

4994
4998.0

04/16/14

MB

4995
4999.0

4996
4997 5000.0
5001.0

04/17/14
04/24/14
04/24/14

MB
MB
MB

4998
5002.0

04/26/14

MB

Meeting with Nat re: NYPD proposed jury
instructions draft.
Research re: possible medical experts.
Memo to counsel re: possible medical expert Dr.
Peter Stastny, MD.
Research medical experts; review Roy Lubit's
filings.
Draft proposed Jury Instructions Medical
Defendants; research due process causes of action;
dangerousness standard re: emergency civil
commitment; statutory and common law procedural
protections re: restraints; legal privilege under
MHL 9.39.
Continue proposed jury instructions for case
against Medical Defendants; draft neg per say
charges.
Team meeting with potential expert, Roy Lubit.
Team conference call with Adrian re status and
settlement.
Continue drafting proposed jury instructions
Medical Defendants; draft medical malpractice and
other state claims.
Conference call with Adrian re trial issues and
settlement; team conference to confer.
Team conference call re progress on settlement
issues.
Research re: jury awards of damages.
Research the various state action tests in the
context of a private hospital; collect and analyze
Second Circuit case law.
Draft memo to counsel re: state action research.

6.250
6.500
5.530

6.850

3.650

5.000
4.250

0.660

4.550
2.500
1.250
4.170

4.000
5.230

4999
5003.0

5000
5001 5004.0
5005.0

05/13/14

05/14/14
05/20/14

MB

MB
MB

5002
5006.0

5003

E

Hours

Date

4988.0

D

I

Timekeepe Description
Research state action re: City defendants section
MB

No.

4987.0

1

C

B

05/21/14

MB

Prepare EMT Jessica Marquez's deposition;
research right to refuse medical attention; right to
choice of hospital.
EMT Jessica Marquez Deposition.
Trip to Johnstown to meet with Adrian (6.5 hours
of travel time).
Research re: blue wall of silence police retaliation
cases: the deliberative process privilege; the law
enforcement privilege.
Page 225

4.000
0.000
8.250

5.270

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

5007.0

Date
05/23/14

5004
5005 5008.0
5009.0

05/24/14
05/25/14

1

No.

5006
5007 5010.0
5011.0
5008
5012.0
5009
5013.0
5010
5015.0

5011
5012 5017.0
5019.0

C

B

05/26/14
05/27/14
05/28/14

05/28/14
05/29/14

06/04/14
06/06/14

5013

D

Timekeepe Description
__ ____
MB
Blue wall of silence research; analyze and review
prior testimony of possible police procedures
expert, Dr. Leinen.
MB
Review and catalog new discovery production.
MB
Analyze case law granting summary judgment on
plaintiffs Monell claims connected to practices in
Molten report.
MB
Draft writeup on blue wall of silence research.
MB
Create Medical defendants evaluation timeline in
the ER, psyche ER, and psyche ward.
MB
Hearing with Judge Sweet oral arguments on
motion.
MB
Prepare Weiss deposition; team conference call re
Weiss deposition.
MB
Draft summary of Weiss deposition send to
counsel; prepare for JHMC 30(b)6 depositions on
policy; review Beiner's depo transcript; draft
questions.
MB
Prepare for Ferrara Deposition.
MB
Draft summary of notes from Ferrara deposition
send to counsel; team conference call with police
practices experts, Eterno and Silverman re: expert
report and testimony.

5020.0

06/09/14

MB

5021.0

06/13/14

MB

5022.0

06/27/14

MB

07/01/14
07/02/14

MB
MB

5014

5015

5016
5017 5023.0
5024.0
5018
5027.0

j

Team conference call w/ Adrain re trial prep and
update.
Team conference call w/ Silverman and Eterno re
expert testimony; conference with Nat re conflict of
interest issue.
Prep for Mauriello's deposition; review prior
deposition; review City defendants depo
summaries.
Mauriello Deposition.
Prep for Lwin deposition; review Reiner deposition
notes and hospital chart.
Prep for City 30(b)(6) deposition topics; research
anti -quota law, New York Labor Law § 215-a, and
Operations Order No. 52.
Team conference call with expert Dr. Halpren.

07/13/14

MB

5030.0

07/18/14

MB

5031.0

07/22/14

MB

07/24/14
07/24/14
07/25/14

MB

City 30(b)(6) witness deposition, Cooper.
Prep for Patel deposition.
Patel deposition.

___

Hours

6.610
3.980

4.000
6.230
5.980

2.000
4.100

6.700
3.000

2.500
1.500

2.500

4.000
0.000
1.500

Research re City's application of subsequent
remedial measure; team conference call re status.

5021
5022 5032.0
5023 5033.0
5024 5034.0

E

5019

5020

6.000
2.000

MB
MB

Page 226

3.650
0.000
1.000

0.000

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

5025 5035.0
5036.0
5026
5037.0

Date
07/31/14
07/31/14
08/04/14

E

D

C

B

Timekeepe Description
.....
Analyze potential withdrawal of claims.
MB
Team conference call with experts, Halpern -Ruder
MB
and Dr. Lubit.
Research re: 8/4/14 letter to Judge Sweet; analyze
MB
defendants' instruction to witness not to answer
questions beyond scope of 30 (b)(6) subject matter
.

1.500

issue.

5027
5038.0
5028
5029 5039.0
5040.0
5030
5041.0
5031
5042.0
5032
5043.0
5033
5034 5044.0
5045.0
5035
5046.0

08/06/14
08/09/14
08/10/14

MB
MB
MB

3.100

Conference call with Nat re: defendant's objection
to video; new assignments.
Review and analyze Dr. Lubit's expert report.
Team conference call with Dr. Lubit re testimony.

0.500
3.130
1.250

08/14/14

09/04/14
09/12/14
09/13/14
09/14/14
09/20/14

MB
MB

MB
MB
MB
MB

Draft response addressing 8.5.14 Letter re: Purpi's
30(b)(6) issues.
Search for missing case citations for Dr. Lubit's
prior expert testimony.
Team Meeting weekend in Mayfield, NY
(including travel time of 4 hours).
Team Meeting weekend in Mayfield, NY.
Team Meeting weekend in Mayfield, NY
(including travel time of 4 hours).
Review Medical defendants expert reports; review
expert Tancredo's deposition transcripts.

4.900
2.320
6.000
7.500
6.000

4.620

5036

5047.0
5037
5038 5048.0
5049.0
5039
5050.0
5040
5041 5051.0
5052.0
5042
5053.0
5043
5054.0
5044
5055.0

5045

Hours
2.150

09/21/14
10/02/14
10/03/14
10/18/14

10/19/14
10/23/14

10/23/14
12/01/14
12/02/14

MB

MB
MB
MB

MB
MB
MB
MB
MB

Team meeting with Dr. Lubit re: deposition prep.
Team conference call re: trial prep.
Team meeting Nat's office re upcoming motion
papers; conference w/Adrian.
Research Rule 68; review letter to Adrian re
settlement offer.
Conference call w/ team re Rule 68 Offer.
Create claims "cheat sheet" from proposed jury
instructions.
Review/comment re: Letter Rejecting Rule 68
Offer.
Review 2nd Amended Complaint track proposed
changes.
Review Third Amended Complaint; draft proposed
addition of malicious abuse of process claim and
violation of substantive and procedural due process
claims.

Page 227

4.000
0.750
3.000

4.000
2.250
5.890
1.000

4.700

4.660

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

No.

Date

5056.0

1

C

B

12/02/14

D

Timekeepe Description
MB
Memo of law in support of Motion to Amend;

E

Hours

examine and analyze developing caselaw re:
respondent superior liability for private
corporations under § 1983 (Shields).

5046

7.920

6.500

5057.0

12/03/14

MB

Review final draft memo of law in support of
Motion to Amend; Begin research for summary
judgment arguments; analyze Second Circuit
summary judgment decisions re due process and
dangerousness in context of civil commitment;
false imprisonment claims.

5058.0

12/03/14

MB

5059.0

12/11/14

MB

5060.0

12/16/14

MB

5061.0

12/18/14

MB

5062.0

12/19/14

MB

5063.0

12/20/14

MB

Review final draft Third Amended Complaint;
review final draft Memo in Support.
Meeting Nat's office re:NYPD and Medical
Defendants summary judgment claims.
Draft summary judgment issues; analyze Fourth
Amendment search and seizure Second Circuit
summary judgment decisions.
Mauriello's Counterclaim issue; analyze tortious
interference w/prospective advantage summary
judgment decisions.
Summary judgment Memo in Support; research and
analyze Second Circuit decisions determining
exigent circumstances; review NYPD Patrol Guide
emergency protocol.
Summary judgment motion; review MHL statute
provisions, JHMC hospital chart and record.

5064.0

12/21/14

MB

5065.0

12/22/14

MB

5066.0

12/22/14

MB

5067.0

01/04/15

MB

5068.0

01/05/15

MB

5069.0

01/07/15

MB

5047

5048

5049

5050

5051

5052

5053

5.250

5.250

7.600

8.800

5.200

5.400

5054
5055

5056
5057

5058

Summary judgment memo in support draft; track
comments and caselaw support.
Review Summary judgment memo in support draft;
track comments and changes.
Review final draft Summary judgment Memo in
Support.
Review City defendants summary judgment
motions; research caselaw cited.
Review Medical defendants summary judgment
motions; research cited caselaw; conference with
Nat re: motions.

7.400
6.500
3.700

4.000

6.000

Prepare for opposition papers; draft Medical
Defendants' summary judgment issues; analyze
cited caselaw.

5059

6.500

Page 228

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

No.

Date

5070.0

1

01/08/15

D

C

B

Timekeepe Description
Meeting with Nat re: Medical Defendants summary
MB

E

Hours

judgment issues; conduct research on
issues.
5.500

5060
5071.0

01/09/15

MB

Research City Defendants summary judgment
issues; 4th amendment unlawful search and seizure;
legal standard for exigent circumstances; objective
reasonableness doctrine; research caselaw deciding
summary judgment on qualified immunity grounds;
team conference re motions.

MB

Research City Defendants summary judgment
issues; probable cause; exculpatory evidence;
review EMT emergency protocol ; review caselaw
and statutory right to refuse medical treatment;
right to hospital preference.

6.100

5061

5072.0

01/11/15

5062

5073.0

01/12/15

MB

5063

5074.0

01/14/15

MB

5075.0

01/15/15

MB

5076.0

01/16/15

MB

5077.0

01/21/15

MB

5064

5065

Research Medical Defendants summary judgment
issues; draft the state action issue; analyze
McGugan v. Aldana-Bernier and Doe.
Research Medical Defendant's summary judgment
motion issues; respondeat superior, vicarious
liability; apparent authority.
Research Medical Defendant's summary judgment
issues; review Dr. Lubit's Report for establishing
the standard of care.
Continue research on Medical Defendants summary
judgment issues; research applicable standard of
care; analyze "substantially below" legal standard;
review defendants deposition summaries.

5.550

5.400

7.100

6.700

5066

5067

5078.0

01/22/15

MB

5079.0

01/26/15

MB

Continue research on defendants summary
judgment issues; conspiracy/joint activity state
action liability.
Research re: intracorporate conspiracy doctrine.

7.000
6.750

5068
5069

5080.0

01/27/15

MB

Research re: intracorporate doctrine; draft memo to
counsel re: intra-Corporate doctrine.
Draft memo to counsel re: intracorporate doctrine.

6.420
4.500

5070
5081.0

01/27/15

MB

5071

5082.0
5072

4.000

01/28/15

MB

Meeting with Nat re: opposition issues; 1st
amendment issue.
Research First Amendment issues; analyze recent
development in the law limiting Garcetti (Lane,
Griffin, Hagan).

Page 229

4.500

7.000

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A
1

No.

5083.0

B

Date
01/29/15

C

D

Timekeepe Description
MB
Research intentional infliction of emotional distress
claim.

5073

5084.0

5074
5075 5085.0
5086.0
5076
5087.0

5077
5078 5088.0
5089.0

01/29/15

MB

02/01/15
02/02/15

MB
MB

02/03/15

MB

02/04/15
02/05/15

MB
MB

5079

5090.0

02/06/15

MB

5091.0

02/07/15

MB

5092.0

02/08/15

MB

5093.0

02/09/15

MB

5094.0

02/10/15

MB

5095.0

02/10/15

MB

5096.0

02/11/15

MB

5097.0

02/11/15

MB

5098.0

02/13/15

5080
5081
5082
5083

5084
5085
5086

Hours

4.700

Continue LIED research; IIED claim not duplicative
of the other claims issue.
Memo to counsel re: IIED research.
Research First Amendment issues; Monell
research.
Monell research; review and brief cases on police
retaliation to establish policy under Monell; review
and brief case law re establishing deliberate
indifference under Monell.

Memo to counsel re: Monell research.
Continue to research Medical Defendants Memo in
Opposition issues; research defendant's argument
of legal justification to confine plaintiff under
EMTALA.
Draft opposition to Medical Defendants summary
judgment arguments.
Draft opposition to Medical Defendants summary
judgment arguments.
Call with Nat discuss current status on JHMC
opposition issues.
Call with Nat re: progress on research Medical
defendants issues.
Draft opposition to JHMC summary judgment
arguments.
Draft opposition to JHMC summary judgment
motions.
Review and track proposed changes on first draft of
Motion in Opposition.
Review/edit second draft of Motion in Opposition.

5087

3.400
6.830
8.000

6.000
6.100

6.500
5.600
7.500
0.500

0.500
4.600

2.800
5.650
3.750

MB

5088
5100.0

02/14/15

MB

5101.0

02/15/15

MB

5102.0

02/16/15

MB

5089

5090
5091

E

Review all defendants motions in opposition
submissions; Meeting with Nat to discuss
submissions.
Draft issues re: reply to Mauriello opposition
motion.
Reply to Mauriello opp; research tortious
interference with prospective relations claim;
wrongful means constituting tortious conduct;
malice intent as the "sole motivation" for plaintiffs
alleged interference.

6.000

Reply to Mauriello opposition motion; research
defamation and damages.

4.300

Page 230

6.000
5.230

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

5103.0
5092
5093 5104.0
5105.0
5094
5095 5106.0
5096 5106.0
5107.0
5097
5108.0
5098
5109.0
5099
5110.0
5100
5101 5111.0
5112.0
5102
5113.0
5103
5104 5114.0
5115.0
5105
5116.0
5106
5117.0
5107
5108 5118.0
5109 5119.0
5110 5120.0
5111 5121.0
5122.0
5112
5123.0
5113
5114 5124.0
5125.0
5115
5126.0
5116
5127.0
5117
5128.0
5118

Date
02/17/15
02/19/15
02/20/15
02/24/15
02/25/15
02/23/15
02/26/15
02/27/15

02/28/15
03/02/15
03/03/15
03/05/15
03/06/15
03/07/15
03/08/15

03/09/15
03/10/15
03/11/15
03/12/15
03/12/15
03/12/15

03/13/15
03/16/15
03/16/15

D

C

B

E

Timekeepe Description
Draft portion of reply to Mauriello opposition
MB
MB
MB

MB
MB
MB
MB
MB
MB
MB
MB
MB
MB
MB
MB
MB

MB
MB
MB
MB
MB
MB
MB
MB

motion.
Draft reply to Mauriello opposition motion.
Team meeting; meet with Norinsberg and new
team.
reply to Medical defendants memo in opp.
Research sham affidavit doctrine.
Draft issues re: reply to Medical defendants memo
in opp.
Memo to counsel re; sham affidavit doctrine
research.
Research re: inadmissibility of hearsay on summary
judgment motions.
Draft issues re: reply to City memo in opposition.

Research re: collective knowledge doctrine.
Memo to counsel re: collective knowledge doctrine
research.
Review and track proposed changes to Reply
motion draft.
Final review/edit of Reply papers.
Prepare police expert Prof. Eterno deposition
summary.
Prepare police expert Prof. Eterno's deposition
summary.
Draft Eterno Deposition Summary; team
conference call.
Draft Prof. Eterno deposition summary.
Prepare Prof. Eterno deposition summary.
Prepare Prof. Eterno deposition summary.
Meeting with Team re new issues on reply.
Revise NYPD jury instructions; distribute revised
charges to counsel.
Meeting Nat's office with new team re division of
upcoming work.
Review Defendants Reply memos.
Draft Prof. Eterno's direct examination for trial.
'

Hours
6.220
4.230

4.500
7.200
3.820
7.000

4.300
4.700
6.080
4.000
5.160
5.500
4.000

5.050
7.050

6.900
5.920
6.100
4.830
3.000
1.700

4.000
3.000
2.100

03/17/15

MB

Review/comment March 17 Letter to the court.
1.200

03/18/15

MB

Draft Prof. Eterno's direct examination for trial.
6.500

03/19/15

MB

Draft Prof. Eterno's direct examination for trial.
4.300

Page 231

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

B

D

C

5129.0

Date
03/20/15

Timekeepe Description
MB
Draft Prof. Eterno's direct examination for trial.

5130.0

03/25/15

MB

5131.0

1

03/26/15

MB

No.

5119

3.600

5120
5121

Conference call w/ Nat re: status and assignments
moving forward.
Team meeting at Nat's new office; review Prof.
Eterno's direct examination outline.
Draft proposed jury instructions for claims against
Medical Defendants; draft charges for medical
malpractice and other state claims.
Draft proposed jury instructions for Medical
Defendants; draft state false imprisonment charge.

5132.0

03/28/15

MB

5133.0

03/29/15

MB

03/29/15
03/30/15

MB
MB

Make changes to diagram of the Glendale apt.
Call with Nat re: Glendale diagram/jury charges.

03/31/15

MB

5137.0

04/01/15

MB

Draft proposed jury instructions for claims against
Medical Defendants; draft charge re: the stigma of
an involuntary commitment; charge instructing
requirement of a sufficient investigation of
dangerousness; damages

5138.0

04/02/15

MB

04/03/15

MB

5.000

Trial Team meeting re trial prep, jury instructions.

5139.0

0.500

Draft proposed jury instructions Medical
Defendants; draft corporate negligence charge.

5122

5123
5124 5134.0
5135.0
5125
5136.0

6.600

5.700
1.700
0.500

5126

5.500

5127

5128

5.700

0.100

5129
5140.0

04/06/15

MB

5141.0

04/08/15

MB

04/10/15
04/13/15

MB
MB

05/05/15

MB

05/12/15

MB

5130
5131
5132 5142.0
5143.0
5133
5144.0
5134
5145.0
5135
5146.0

Combine NYPD and Medical Defendants Jury
Instructions.
Combine NYPD and Medical Defendants Jury
Instructions.
Revise jury instructions Medical Defendants
incorporating Nat's edits; conference w/ team.
Call with Nat re: progress on current projects.
Conference with Judge Sweet; team conference.

3.950
6.330
5.800
0.750

2.500

05/27/15

MB

05/28/15

MB

Review of Court's Opinion re: summary judgment
motions.
Conference with Judge Sweet; Trial team meeting
re status.
Draft motion for reconsideration issues; research
post -suspension First Amendment claim; review
cross examination outlines for defendants.

5136

1.000

3.500

6.150

5147.0
5137

E

Hours

Analyze Second Circuit freedom -of -speech cases
(Jackler, Gacetti, Walsh): conference call w/ Nat re
reconsideration motion.
Page 232

4.330

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

1

No.

5148.0

Date
05/31/15

Timekeepe Description
.
Memo to counsel re: post -suspension retaliation
MB

5138

5149.0

D

C

B

06/01/15

MB

06/02/15

claim.
Review letter to Judge for reconsideration draft;
track changes; research issue of qualified immunity
in a First Amendment retaliation case.

E

Hours

4.780

MB

6.900

5139

5150.0
5140

5151.0

09/15/15

5141

5152.0

09/16/15

5142

5171.0

11/18/12

Memo to counsel re: qualified immunity and
"clearly established" law doctrine.
Review cross examination of defendants outlines;
MB
review/comment on client memo.
Research Rule 68 issue; research offset issue;
MB
general obligations law 15-108.
Harvey A. Review of Larry Schoolcraft (LS) documents re:
son's case; confer with RG re: evaluation potential
Levine
strategies for Adrian Schoolcraft (AS) litigation

4.250
4.500
2.250

3.500

5143

5172.0

11/19/12

5144

5173.0

11/22/12

5145

5174.0

11/23/12

Harvey A. Further review of LS documents, ECF filings
including pleadings & internet materials Meeting
Levine
with RG to discuss case & strategy relative to
further AS and LS contact

Harvey A. Conf. with RG & PG regarding meeting with AS &
LS on moving forward, litigaiton strategies and
Levine
client managemnt issues.
Harvey A. TC's with RG re: issues arising during meeting with
Adrian Schoolcraft (AS).
Levine

4.5

1.000

0.500

5146

5175.0

11/26/12

Harvey A. Conf with RG re: meeting with AS; review of
documents from AS smart drive, ECF entries &
Levine
documents; discuss discharge of outgoing counsel

11/28/12

Harvey A. Conf. with RG re: prior cc oushnel discharge "for
cause" issues dispute over disbursements
Levine

4.500

5147

5176.0

0.450

5148

5177.0

11/30/12

Harvey A. Conf. with RG re: TC with co -counsel re: AS email
and discharge of PC "for cause"
Levine
1.500

5149

5178.0

12/3/12

Harvey A. Conf. with RG re: discharge/email from outgoing
attorney & TC from PG and TC with AS
Levine
0.500

5150

5179.0

12/7/12

5151

5180.0

12/11/12

Harvey A. Conf. with RG, re: AS dsicipllinary charges with
NYPD/employment issues/potential damages
Levine
reinstatement/retirement
Harvey A. TCs with RG re: meeting with AS, etc. Isssues &
strategies moving forward
Levine

5152

Page 233

1.5

.8

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)
A

No.

1

5181.0

B

Date
12/14/12

5153
5182.0

12/17/12

5154
5183.0

12/18/12

C

D

E

Timekeepe Description
J
Harvey A. Conf. with RG; review Queens D.A. press release
Levine
Multiple, TC's with PG and AS; alternate responses
discussed.
Harvey A. Conf. RG & PG re: discharge for cause. vs.
Levine
alternatives; review of correspondence to outgoing
attorney
Harvey A. Conf. RG & PG re: AS file transfer Begin
Levine
Inventory of files

i

5155

Hours

1.500

1.500

1.500

5184.0

12/22/12

5185.0

12/23/12

5186.0

12/26/12

Harvey A. Begin comprehensive review of transferred files &
Levine
notes; pleadings & discovery

5187.0

12/27/12

Harvey A. Continued review of AS files w/notes discovery
Levine
materials

5188.0

12/28/12

Harvey A. Continued review of AS files w/notes discvoery
Levine
materials

5189.0

1/2/13

Harvey A. Continued review of AS files w/notes Conf. with
Levine
PG & RG at office re: update on file review &
discussion of "eyes only" file. continued review of
file.

5190.0

1/4/13

Harvey A. Continued review of file; meeting with PG
Levine

5191.0

1/5/13

Harvey A. Memo summarizing and analyzing contents
Levine

5192.0

1/8/13

Harvey A. Conf. with PG & RG reviewing analysis and
Levine
Strategy going forward

5193.0

1/11/12

Harvey A. Conf. with RG re: Union's failure to represent AS
Levine
in trial room and/or return to full duty strategy

5194.0

1/12/12

Harvey A. Review of research on Union's representation and
Levine
failure to advocate for AS 2.0

Harvey A. Cont. inventory of contents of file conf. w/ RG re:
Levine
amended complaint

5156

2.500

Harvey A. Complete inventfory of AS files
Levine

5157

3.500

5158

6.000

5159

5.000

5160

6.000

5161

5162

6.250

6.000

5163

3.500

5164

3.500

5165

1.000

5166

0.700

Page 234

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

D

C

B

No.

Date

Timekeepe Description

5195.0

1/14/12

E

Hours

Harvey A. Conf. with RG re: Union rep. research & strategy
Levine

0.750

5167
5196.0

1/19/12

Harvey A. Conf. RG re: correspondence to Queens D.A. &
Levine
redrafts
0.250

5168
5197.0

1/21/12

Harvey A. Review of PG correspondence
Confer with RG letter
Levine

1/23/12

Harvey A. Review of PG correspondence to NYPD
Levine

0.200

5169
5198.0

0.125

5170
5199.0

1/29/12

Harvey A. Review of proposed AS affidavit for Center for
Constitutional Rights (CCR)
Levine
0.500

5171

5200.0

1/30/12

Harvey A. Conf. with RG re: dinner meeting w/ PG with PG.
Levine
0.250

5172

5201.0

01/31/12

Harvey A. Review of RG cease & desist letter re: website
Levine
0.250

5173
5202.0

2/6/13

5174
5203.0

2/12/13

Harvey A. Conf. RG re: expansion of legal team; and transfer
of banker boxes & files to PG & Nat Smith (NS)
Levine
for scanning; organizing files
Harvey A. Conf. with RG re: deposition of AS
Levine

1.000

0.500

5175

5204.0

11/16/12

Richard
A.

Gilbert

Meeting with my Peter Gleason, Esq. (PG), Retired
NYPD 2nd grade Detective (D2) and Larry
Schoolcraft (LS) to confer on merits of claim Filed
by Adrian Schoolcraft (AS) against NYC, Jamaica
Hospital & other medical defendants Review of
documents provided by LS.

14

5176
5205.0

11/18/12

Richard
A.

Gilbert
5177

5206.0

11/19/12

Richard
A.

Gilbert

Further review of documents provided and tc's with
PG relating to AS. Conferred with Harvey Levine
(HL) re: merits of claim and potential strategies for
litigation
Meeting with PG to discuss case parameters &
strategy relative to further AS and LS contact. &
impact of LS documents provided. Confer with
Confer with HL re: PG discussion & strategy

5.500

2.500

5178

Page 235

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A
1

No.

5207.0

B

Date

11/22/12

Timekeepe Description

Richard
A.

5179
5208.0

11/23/12

D

C

Gilbert
Richard
A.

Multiple phone conversation with PG regarding a
meeting the following day with AS/LS. Confer
with HL regarding potential strategies.
Meeting with PG, AS, LS, in Albany to meet client
Discussed scope of work, strategy, investigation.

E

,

Hours

1.500

Gilbert
5180

10.500
5209.0

11/26/12

Richard
A.

Gilbert

Confer with HL re: first AS meeting; Meeting with
PG regarding obtaining Schoolcraft file from prior
counsel (PC); review of client's smart drive, court
notes and documents filed in USDC; TC with
outgoing counsel; draft of correspondence to PC

5181

3.400

5210.0

11/27/12

Richard
A.

Gilbert

Obtained phone for client; further review of smart
drive and filed documents; follow up phone
conversation with PG on PC file with PG regarding
the Schoolcraft file. TC with PC & follow up
correspondence Forwarding Consent

5182

2.450
5211.0

11/28/12

Richard
A.

Gilbert

Review of PC case disbursements claimed as
prereq. for transfer of file; research on atty.
discharge for cause and excessive disbursements

5183

4.200
5212.0

11/29/12

Richard
A.

5184
5213.0

11/30/12

Gilbert
Richard
A.

Gilbert

Research on "cause" continued; TC & email with
AS re: facts underlying "cause" forward. TC with
PG on "cause"
TC with PC re: transfer of file vs. allowable disb.
Multiple TCs with PG on strategy and focus of
investigation, discharge of PC "for cause" &
Review of AS email and attachments; confer with
HL regarding course of action

5185

1.500

5214.0

12/2/12

Richard
A.

5186
5215.0

12/3/12

Gilbert
Richard
A.

5187
5216.0

12/3/12

Gilbert
Richard
A.

5188
5217.0

12/5/12

Gilbert
Richard
A.

5189

3.000

TC's. with PG regarding correspondence to and
conversation with PC.
0.500

Review of email from PC; confer with HL re: same
TC with PG regarding e-mail from PC.
0.500

Phone cony. with AS regarding e-mail from his
previous counsel, investigation and setting up
another meeting.
Review of e-mail from AS & TC with PG re:
transfer of file from PC

Gilbert

0.500

0.800

Page 236

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

B

No.

Date

5218.0

1

12/6/12

5190
5219.0

12/7/12

C

D

E

Timekeep Description
Richard
Phone cony. with PG re: VP investigation update
A.

Hours

Gilbert
Richard

0.250

A.

Gilbert

Meeting with PG, re: NYPD disciplinary charges
NYPD employment issues: confer with HL re: legal
position on disciplinary charges & return to duty
potential v. retirement

5191

1.500

5220.0

12/10/12

Richard
A.

5192

5221.0

12/11/12

Gilbert
Richard
A.

5193

5222.0

12/13/12

Gilbert
Richard
A.

5194

5223.0

12/14/12

Gilbert
Richard
A.

5195
5224.0

12/14/12

Gilbert
Richard
A.

5196
5225.0

12/17/12

Gilbert
Richard
A.

5197
5226.0

12/17/12

Gilbert
Richard
A.

5198
5227.0

12/17/12

Gilbert
Richard
A.

Gilbert

E-mail and TC with PG, re: file
transfer/termination for cuase of PC.
0.500

TC with PG regarding Albany meeting with AS &
others; confer with HL re: same
0.500

review of E-mail from AS with Queens D.A. Press
Release re: no criminality: multiple TC's with PG
and AS & confer with HL re: same
Confer with HL re: press release; TC with PG, re:
1PP's position on AS.

3.000

1.000

review of PG E-mail to NYPD Asst. Comm.
Kearns, re: Schoolcraft; confer with HL re: same
0.125

Review of E-mail to Kearns (NYPD) re:
Schoolcraft NYPD employment issues; confer with
HL

0.200

Meeting with PG, update on securing file from PC,
NYPD employment issues, investigation
2.000

Additional research on discharge for cause.
Conferred with HL re: merits of moving v. merits
of negotiated transfer; conferred with PC reaching
agreement on file transfer; draft letter

5199

2.250

5228.0

12/18/12

Richard

Gilbert

Confer with PG prior to file transfer; travel to PC
Office to effectuate transfer of 6 banker boxes of
files; brief review of files at PC office.

Richard

TC with AS & LS update & strategy discussed.

A.

6

5200
5229.0

12/19/12

A.

5201

5230.0

12/22/12

Gilbert
Richard
A.

5202

0.700

Review of PG E-mail re, amended complaint
Discuss with HL

Gilbert

0.200

Page 237

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

No.

Date

5231.0

1

1/2/13

5203

5232.0

1/4/13

D

C

B

Timekeepe Description
Meeting with HL & PG at office re: update on file
Richard
review & discussion of "eyes only" file. continued
A.
review of file.
Gilbert
Continued review of file; meeting with PG
Richard

E

Hours

4.500

A.

5204
5233.0

1/5/13

Gilbert
Richard
A.

5205
5234.0

1/8/13

Gilbert
Richard

6.000

Continued review of file
Memo to file.
3.500

Meeting with PG, HL re: file contents strategy.

A.

5206
5235.0

1/9/12

Gilbert
Richard

3.500

Meeting with PG RE: investigation strategy.

A.

5207
5236.0

1/11/12

Gilbert
Richard
A.

5208
5237.0

1/12/12

Gilbert
Richard

0.750

Meeting with PG, re: Union's failure to represent
Confer with HL on failure/strategy
1.000

Research on Union's failure to advocate for A.S

A.

5209
5238.0

1/14/12

Gilbert
Richard
A.

Gilbert
5210
5239.0

1/16/12

Richard

2.000

Meeting with PG, re: Queens DA. Research
Discovery of D.A.'s investigative file: email PG
Confer with HL regarding research outcome &
strategy with regard to same
Phone cony. with VP re: update, meeting to follow.

4.750

A.

5211

Gilbert
Richard

0.125

A.

1/19/12

5212

5241.0

1/21/12

5213

Multiple e -mails to /from PG, re: draft letter to
NYPD & redrafts

Gilbert
Richard

Review of PG, re: NYPD letter.

A.

5240.0

Confer with HL regarding letter

Gilbert
Richard

1.500

0.200

A.

5242.0

1/22/12

5214
5243.0

1/23/12

Multiple emails to PG re: 1 PP letter
Meeting with PG, Re: NYPD letter; review letter

Gilbert
Richard

Phone cony. with PG, Re: NYPD letter

1.800

A.

5215
5244.0

1/25/12

Gilbert
Richard
A.

5216

0.125

Meeting with PG to discuss NYPD's response to e mail communications.
0.500

Gilbert

Page 238

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

B

5245.0

Date
1/29/12

5246.0

1/29/12

5247.0

1/30/12

5248.0

1/31/12

5249.0

2/1/12

5250.0

1

2/2/13

No.

5217

5218

5219

5220

5221

5222

5251.0

2/5/13

C

D

Timekeeper Description

Richard 7 Review of PG E-mail & affidavit from Center for
A.
Constitutional Rights (CCR)
Gilbert
Richard
Dinner meeting with PG, FS atty.
A.
Discuss potential expert consulting
Gilbert
Richard
Confer with HL re: dinner meeting; multiple TC's
A.
with PG.
Gilbert
Richard
Per cony. PG draft cease & desist to PC
A.
Regarding website
Gilbert
Richard
E-mail to PG, re: e-mail from CCR. Final draft
A.
cease & desist to PC re: website
Gilbert
Richard
Draft memo on warrantless search by NYPD TC's
A.
with AS & LS re: progress / strategy
Gilbert
Richard
Research memo & draft subpoena to Queens D.A.

E

Hours

0.500

1.500

0.700

0.400

0.125

2.500

A.

5223

5252.0

2/6/13

Gilbert
Richard

2.500

Organize file for transfer to PG & Nat Smith (NS)

A.

5224
5253.0

2/7/13

Gilbert
Richard
A.

5225

5254.0

2/10/13

Gilbert
Richard

1.000

Draft receipt to PG for transfer of hard copy of files
For scanning for the legal team.
0.500

Review of file for deposition

A.

5226
5255.0

2/11/13

Gilbert
Richard

3.000

Emails to/from PG, re: deposition.

A.

5227

5256.0

2/11/13

Gilbert
Richard
A.

5228
5257.0

2/12/13

Gilbert
Richard

0.200

Conf. call Chambers of Judge Scheindlin and
conferred with AS, PG & NS
NS, AS & RG.
Prep and defense of deposition of AS

2.000

A.

5229

5258.0

2/13/13

Gilbert
Richard

6.000

Phone cony. with PG & NS, re: case status.

A.

5230

Gilbert

0.500

Page 239

EXHIBIT A -- SCHOOLCRAFT TIME CHARGES (LISTED IN "NO." ORDER IN COLUMN A)

A

D

C

B

No.

Date

Timekeeper Description

5259.0

1

2/14/13

Richard
A.

Gilbert

__
_ __
Meeting with PG & NS at office & file transfer of
Nat Smith. Meeting with NS to discuss how file is
formatted. Meeting with AS and legal team.

E

Hours

0.500

5231

5260.0

2/21/13

Richard

Email to PG re: file preservation

A.

5232
5261.0

2/27/13

Gilbert
Richard
A.

5233
5262.0

3/1/13

Gilbert
Richard

0.250

Review of e-mail from Corp. Counsel containing
additional "Attorney's eyes only" documents and
discussion with PG & NS.
Review of A.S. deposition transcript

1.250

A.

5234

5263.0

3/5/13

Gilbert
Richard

1.300

TC's with PG updating status

A.

5235

5264.0

3/21/13

Gilbert
Richard

0.200

TC's with PG updating status

A.

5236
5265.0

3/25/13

Gilbert
Richard

0.300

TC's with PG updating status

A.

5237

5266.0

4/2/13

Gilbert
Richard

0.200

TC's with PG updating status

A.

5238
5267.0

4/8/13

Gilbert
Richard
A.

5239
5267.1

4/8/13

Gilbert
Richard
A.

5240
5268.0

4/11/13

Gilbert
Richard

0.200

TC's with PG regarding appearance SDNY re: gag
order & other relief; review of papers in support
and opposition to relief
TC's with PG regarding appearance SDNY re: gag
order & other relief; review of papers in support
and opposition to relief
Appearance SDNY oral argument

2.5

0.300

A.

5241
5242

Gilbert

TOTAL

Page 240

2.000
9279.09