Dish Network L.L.C. v. ABC, Inc. et al

Filing 12

DECLARATION of Elyse D. Echtman in Support re: 3 Order to Show Cause,,,,,,,,. Document filed by Dish Network L.L.C.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit 5, # 6 Exhibit 6, # 7 Exhibit 7, # 8 Exhibit 8, # 9 Exhibit 9, # 10 Exhibit 10, # 11 Exhibit 11, # 12 Exhibit 12, # 13 Exhibit 13, # 14 Exhibit 14, # 15 Exhibit 15, # 16 Exhibit 16, # 17 Exhibit 17)(Echtman, Elyse)

EXHIBIT 8

Fox, NBC and CBS battle Dish network over AutoHop ad-skipping technology - latimes....

Like

Sign In or Sign Up

234k

Membership Services

Jobs

Cars

Real Estate

Subscribe

Rentals

Classifieds

Page 1 of 4

Custom Publishing Place Ad

ENTERTAINMENT
LOCAL

U.S.

BREAKING

WORLD
PHOTOS

BUSINESS
VIDEO

IN THE NEWS: AMERICAN IDOL

SPORTS

ENTERTAINMENT

CRIME

DOC WATSON

OBITUARIES
ELTON JOHN

HEALTH

WEATHER

LIVING

TRAFFIC

'MEN IN BLACK 3'

TRAVEL

OPINION

CROSSWORDS

DEALS

GAMES

HOROSCOPES

CANNES 2012

APPS

y
r
e
Q
t
i
m
b
u
S

Search

Connect
Recommended on Facebook

Networks' fight with Dish over ad-skipping has
huge implications
Comments

3

Email

Share

0

26

Recommend

Like

234k

You need to be logged into
Facebook to see your friends'
recommendations.

Login

15

ad vert i seme nt

Menu for Dish's AutoHop feature (Associated Press / May 25, 2012)

By Meg James and Dawn C. Chmielewski
May 25, 2012 , 6:06 p.m.

The major broadcast networks’ legal skirmish with satellite television service Dish Network over its
new ad-skipping device is shaping up to be a titanic struggle with enormous implications.
The outcome of their high-profile dispute could influence what features will be available to
consumers on their TV devices, as well as the price they pay for their monthly service.
Three of the major networks — Fox, CBS and NBC — sued Dish Network on Thursday over its
controversial AutoHop feature, which allows consumers to bypass all commercials in their primetime programming block with a single click of their remote control.
Dish simultaneously filed its own lawsuit against the three networks as well as Walt Disney Co.’s
ABC, asking a federal court judge to rule on whether its ad-skipping feature was in violation of
copyright laws.
“This is the biggest copyright case since Napster,” said prominent entertainment attorney Bonnie
Eskenazi, a partner at Greenberg Glusker in Los Angeles. “The entire financial model of the television
industry is at risk.”

Gold: Ración is a
revelation in Pasadena

http://www.latimes.com/entertainment/envelope/cotown/la-et-ct-broadcast-networks-fight-... 5/28/2012

Fox, NBC and CBS battle Dish network over AutoHop ad-skipping technology - latimes....

The networks argue that AutoHop, the latest technological enhancement to zap commercials, will
seriously erode the foundation of their business, similar to how the free file-sharing service Napster
fractured long-established music business fundamentals more than a decade ago.
The U.S. broadcast television model is built on advertising revenue. The networks rake in more than
$19 billion a year in advertising, money that pays for the high cost of programming. Without
advertising, network executives say, media companies would have to charge distributors three times
the current rate for their signals. The added costs would be passed on to consumers.
Dish said that it believes that the AutoHop feature, which rolled out May 10, does not violate the
networks’ copyright. Instead, the Englewood, Colo., company said AutoHop is simply an
enhancement of existing ad-zapping technologies, and ultimately a matter of consumer choice.

Ads by Google

Comcast® - Official Site
Photos: Memorial Day in
Sign Up For Comcast L.A., 1911-29 Learn
Digital Cable
More About Local Offers
www.comcast.com/move

Verizon FiOS Triple Play or untippable
2-wheel car,
motorcycle?
FiOS 3X Play: TV, Phone + Internet Best
Price Online. View Offers Now

Verizon.com/FiOS

The key question is whether the networks can copyright entire chunks of programming — including
the commercials — or just individual programs.

Opinion: 30 isn't the new
20

“It’s not very clear that the networks have the copyright for the entire programming block,” said
Eskenazi, who is not involved in the case. “The question is whether this ad-skipping feature is any
different from handing a person a remote control.”
Pay TV subscribers with digital video recorders for years have had the ability to fast-forward through
commercials of shows they record. But the AutoHop feature goes further.

Page 2 of 4

Ads by Google

Dish customers with the device can record all of the prime-time TV programming on ABC, CBS, Fox
and NBC for later viewing. Then when a commercial break appears, the screen goes black, and a few
seconds later the program returns — minus the ads. The feature becomes available the day after the
programming first airs.
“Consumers have the right to control their TVs,” said Art Brodsky, communications chief for the
Washington, D.C., consumer group Public Knowledge. “People have been skipping commercials for
years. You can already skip them without the help of a Hopper.” The Hopper is a Dish DVR service.
The dispute is reminiscent of a legal battle in 2001 that pitted TV networks against makers of one of
the first digital video recorders, called ReplayTV. That device allowed consumers to record programs
and automatically skip over ads. It also contained a feature that let users send a recorded show to
other device owners over the Internet. The networks accused the maker of ReplayTV with
contributing to copyright infringement.
That matter was never resolved in the courts because Sonicblue Inc., maker of ReplayTV, filed for
bankruptcy protection and the technology was acquired by a Japanese company. New versions of the
device were sold without the ad-skipping feature.

$59 for an iPhone/iPod/iPad
Controlled Mini Helicopter &
Free Shipping (reg. $100)

The stakes in the Dish case are enormous given the fast pace of technological advancements.
Mitch Stoltz, a staff attorney for the Electronic Frontier Foundation, a nonprofit group that advocates
for digital rights, said he found similarities in the ReplayTV and Dish cases. Both hinge on the notion
that the device enables consumers to engage in copyright infringement when they bypass a
commercial.
“It depends on convincing a judge that an individual TV watcher who skips commercials is violating
copyright,” Stoltz said, a legal theory which suggests that the viewer would be guilty of an act of
infringement “by getting up to make a sandwich during a commercial.”
RELATED:

Most Viewed

Latest News

Military members receive golf discount, free
replay from Marriott 05/28/2012, 6:00 a.m.
College transcripts replace birth certificate for
Obama detractors 05/28/2012, 6:00 a.m.

Dish says Hulu is an issue too

San Antonio schools to use scanner technology in
student IDs 05/28/2012, 6:00 a.m.

Dish's AutoHop feature sparks lawsuits

Chen Guangcheng is gone, but his village stays
locked down 05/28/2012, 5:00 a.m.

Dish's AutoHop feature irks network executives

Epithet that divides Mexicans is banned by
Oxnard school district 05/28/2012, 5:00 a.m.

Copyright © 2012, Los Angeles Times
Comments

3

Email

Share

0

26

Recommend

MORE FROM THE TIMES

FROM AROUND THE WEB

President, to president, to president

When is the Best Time to Retire?

15

Men's swimsuits: Bye-bye, baggy
Strong currents in women's swimwear
Nighttime fasting may foster weight loss
Four witnesses in Trayvon Martin case change
their stories

| Day One

Stories

Anna Nicole's Daughter, Dannielynn Birkhead, is
Growing Up Fast (Pictures) | Zimbio
How to Use HDMI to Stream HDTV from Your
PC | Intel

Videos

Only Heidi Klum Looks Like This After Losing
Her Luggage | Elle

http://www.latimes.com/entertainment/envelope/cotown/la-et-ct-broadcast-networks-fight-... 5/28/2012