Eolas Technologies Incorporated v. Adobe Systems Incorporated et al

Filing 875

***FILED IN ERROR. SEE DOCUMENT 877 FOR CORRECT PLEADING*** MOTION to Seal Document [DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OF INVALIDITY FOR LACK OF WRITTEN DESCRIPTION by Adobe Systems Incorporated, Amazon.com Inc., CDW Corporation, Citigroup Inc., Google Inc., J.C. Penney Company, Inc., Staples, Inc., The Go Daddy Group, Inc., Yahoo! Inc., YouTube, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Affidavit, # 2 Exhibit A, # 3 Exhibit B, # 4 Exhibit C, # 5 Exhibit D, # 6 Exhibit E, # 7 Exhibit F, # 8 Exhibit G, # 9 Exhibit H, # 10 Exhibit I, # 11 Exhibit J, # 12 Exhibit K, # 13 Exhibit L, # 14 Exhibit M, # 15 Text of Proposed Order)(Reines, Edward) Modified on 8/18/2011 (mll, ).

EXHIBIT M

STATES PATENT AND

Th

In

re

application

DOYLE

et

No

Application

Filed

of

TRADEMARK

Examiner

aL

Art

10/217955

OFFICE

Caidwell

Unit

2154

Response

2002

August

For DISTRIBUTED

HYPERMEDIA

METHOD AND SYSTEM FOR
AUTOMATICALLY INVOKING
EXTERNAL
APPLICATION
PROVIDING INTERACTION AND
DISPLAY OF EMBEDDED OBJECTS
WITHIN
HYPERMEDIA

DOCUMENT

Commissioner for Patents
Alexandria

VA

223 13-1450

Sir
In response
following

to

Amendments
10

the Office

Action mailed 09/09/2004

please

remarks

to the

Remarks/Conclusion

Claims begin
begin

on page

on page

of

this

of

this

paper

paper

consider

the

PATENT
Attorney

Docket

Client Reference

AMENDMENTS

No

006-4-1
94-108-3

TO THE CLAIMS

Please

This

the application

No

cancel

listing

claim

of the claims replaces

all

prior versions

and

listings

of claims

in

PATENT

No

Docket

Attorney

Original
and

workstation

client

network

environment
browser

utilizes

document

to

received

one network

located

at

location

directly

or indirectly

first

10

external

said

11

associated

12

first

13

browser

to

14

product

first

the location

at

least

hypermedia

of said

that

document

hypermedia
first

said

client

an embed

includes

of said object

portion

first

window on

document

workstation

client

of

portion

text

format

either

specifies

wherein said portion

wherein said object

one

least

at

is

comprising

to

with

first

it

distributed

distributed

of

least

wherein the portion

hypermedia

distributed

first

at

browser-controlled

first

distributed

said

in

wherein said

from said server

within

displayed

is

wherein said

workstation

network

said

over

environment

94-108-3

wherein said

environment

workstation

client

system having

network

to

coupled

hypermedia

on said

display

use in

for

product

program

server

distributed

is

document

hypermedia

computer

006-4-1

No

Client Reference

utilized

to

15

16

said

locate

and

document

invoke

automatically

and

identify

hypermedia

physically

17

embodied

readable

computer

18

19

object

20

location

21

first

invoked

automatically

and

enable

within

said

therein

wherein said embed
readable

computer

by the browser application

interactive

the portion

of the

cause

to

of said object

processing

first

code

distributed

is

the

external

computer

program

program

comprising

by said type information
the

within

workstation

client

the display

area

document

being

hypermedia

the

to

by said

parsed

readable

further

product

identified

code

code

format

text

program

program

has type information

program

medium having computer

usable

program

readable

computer

computer

computer
code

document

hypermedia

to

for

being

display

created

at

displayed

an

said

in

first

the

window

browser controlled

Cancelled
Original
client

and one network

workstation

network

computer

environment

is

program

server

distributed

for use

product

to

coupled

network

said

environment

hypermedia

in

environment

the

at

system having

computer

least

one

wherein said

product

program

comprising
usable

computer
code

physically

embodied

computer
browser application
included

10

to

initiate

in

to

readable

parse

said distributed

computer

said

therein

computer

program

first

code

distributed

hypermedia

instruction sequences

medium having computer
program
for

product

causing

specified

and

to

respond

by said

text

to

to

identify

predetermined

formats

program

comprising

workstation

client

document

hypermedia

document

said

further

readable

text

to

execute

formats

text

formats

PATENT
Docket

Attorney

No

Client Reference

readable

computer

11

12

browser

13

received

14

document

15

wherein said

16

first

17

indirectly

18

hypermedia

19

said

20

instructions

21

format

22

to

23

processing

24

said

25

window

to

on said

display

over

is

location

said

first

in

distributed

said

first

the location

document

execute

first

external

parsed

to

first

at

least

the

first

on said

client

of said object
distributed

to

workstation

within

hypermedia

hypermedia
first

said

client

that

specifies

identify

and locate

invoke

being

said

at

said

displayed

in

located

at

or

distributed

with

utilized

it

by

sequence of computer
said

sequence of computer

said object

to display

area created

workstation

document and wherein

hypermedia

document

either directly

first

said

utilize

hypermedia

an embed text format

includes

associated

order

document

of said

window on

document

first

has type information

to

display

of

portion

006-4-1
94-108-3

workstatiomto

to the

automatically

in

client

of an object external

portion

distributed

said

wherein the portion

hypermedia

program

by said browser

least

document

wherein said object
other

at

browser-controlled

hypermedia

distributed

of

browser or by some

is

from said server

within

displayed

workstation

client

network

code for causing

program

No

first

said

and

enable

location

first

embed

text

instructions

interactive

within

the portion

browser-controlled

of

PATENT

No

Attorney Docket

No

Reference

Client

006-4-1
94-108-3

REMARKS
Claims 1-3 have

now pending

in

and objections

and claims

canceled

is

and reconsideration

of

all

and

are

outstanding

rejections

requested

the admitted

Berners-Lee

claim

reexamined

Reexamination

the application

is

Claims
over

been

prior

art

and

Raggett

U.S

the

in

Raggett

No

Patent

as being

906

patent

teaching

of

5838906

and the newly

II

103a

under 35 U.S.C

are rejected

through

cited

unpatentable

of

the teachings

Toye

10

Claim
and

Claims

tenninal
15

patenting

rejection

canceled

attached

is

to

hereto

of claims

101

the judicially created

under

been

has

disclaimer

under 35 U.S.C

rejected

are rejected

Claim

patenting

is

obviate

to

obviate

the double
the

same invention

for

patenting
invention

same

double

patenting

of obviousness-type

doctrine

rejection

double

of claim

and

double

obviousness-type

and

Introduction
with

Included
Professor

20

traversing

this

of Computer

submitted

Although
with

25

these

with

issues

in the
present

raised

in the present

It

publication
this

is

according
is

and

this

U.S

in

those

Actions

office action

position
to

35

that

U.S.C

being treated

as

to

if

be made

is

identical

referred

However

prior art

to

declarations

in the following

the reference

102
it

are

for the

to

patent based

by Professor

May

2004

mailed

in

now

A/N 08/324443

these

Felten

2004

October

the 906

signed

to Office

Actions

Edward

132 Declaration

Felten

Office

will

5838906

10 2004

References

Action

II signed

in response

were prepared

raised

Office

No

Patent

Action and the Rule

May

filed

by Professor

Felten

University

of

Office

Declaration

of the parent patent application

Applicants

reference

in

declarations

raised

30

cited

the response

the reexamination

the obviousness

Princeton

at

of claims

the rejections

on the same references
Felten

Science

Rule 132

are

response

the

connection

906 patent
issues

the obviousness
relevant

to

identical

issues

arguments

below

purposes

as

Raggett

II

is

of the following

not

arguments

PATENT

No

Attorney Docket

No

Client Reference

Outline of the Non-Obviousness

The

Argument

Claims

for

006-4-1
94-108-3

and

Claimed Invention

Description

of the References
Admitted Prior Art

Applicants

Mosaic

Bemers-Lee

and

Raggett

Raggett

II

Toye

The

Examiners

Reasoning

Traverse

PART
that

The establishment
the claim

all

limitations

of obviousness

case

ofaprimafacie

must be taught or suggested

requires

MPEP

by the prior art

2143.03
None of

or collectively

individually

invention

Applicants
been

teach

is

Mosaic
external

parsed

the

or suggest

considered

either

claimed features of the
of obviousness

prima fade case

Accordingly

no suggestion

to

display

is

Mosaic
first

has not

the

in

processing

window on

Raggett

hypermedia

document

the

limitations

of claims

of

primary reference

or render the reference

MPEP 2143.01

The proposed
Raggett

combination and render
prima facie

The

case

it

of operation
that

images

and

the

II

inoperable

combination proposed

requiring

at

format

the

first

by the cited

would

has

inoperable

in

would
for

not

rendered

change
intended

its

been

the Office

of the Mosaic

images

case

not include

the

its

with

requires

of operation
intended
the

purpose

combination of

the operation

purpose

of the

of the

latter

Accordingly

established

Action contradicts

Bemers-Lee

when

of obviousness

for

Raggett

the Raggett

embed

fundamental
and

II

tag

is

at

and enabling

the object

created

art

text

being displayed

the principle

combination of Toye

of obviousness

principle

being

prior

an embed

or suggested

prima facie
change

is

in

and

combination cannot

Mosaic Berners-Lee

document

the rejection

in

server

the admitted

area

display

are not taught

The establishment

II

the claimed

Toye

format

computer

and displaying

of the hypermedia

combination proposed

references

display

client

an

text

window

network

of parsing

II

of the object within

limitations

in

from

the

either

in

or Raggett

the portion

the claim

an object

art

prior

invoking

when an embed

computer

network

over

the admitted

of automatically

II

control

or teaching

Bemers-Lee

Because

PART

received

no suggestion

within

location

client

browser-controlled

location

interactive

on

interactively

document
in

displayed

There

and

execute

Toye

either

or Raggett

Raggett

to

application

in

or teaching

Bemers-Lee

hypermedia

static

when

combination

established

There

that

of the proposed

the references

combination
parsed be

PATENT

No

Docket

Attorney

The

combination proposed

Bemers-Lee
basic

is

and

Raggett
of

principle

its

Berners-Lee
document

author

causes

the

PART

Ill

reaches

The

does

There

Mosaic

PART
combine

user

to

rejection

IV

There

is

the references

in

distributed
interactively

in

bye

of

and

no motivation
to

Toye

make

It

is

the

and therefore

premise

required

to

Manufacturing

object

consider
argue

Company

II

invention

which

in

that

would

227

dynamic

in

and

hypermedia

within

make obvious

that

the cited

system

art

references

to

obvious

would

teach

prior

image

cited

flexibility

by the Mosaic

make

the claims

Berners-Lee

away

by the

from

obvious

Raggett

and

combination

obvious

the references

against

into

openness

combination

the claimed

would

system

an object embedded

or teaching

and the Toye

browser

make

that

false

claimed invention

the

regarding

away from

HTML

hypermedia

dynamic

The fundamental problems solved

portions

based on

is

process

and Raggett

Bemers-Lee

would

give

system which

to

image taught by the combination of the admitted

static

The language

that

to

document

no teaching

the

examiner teaches

systems

system intended

browsing experience

Mosaic

the

change

lose that control

obviousness

hypermedia

is

modifying

to

not disclose

browser allows
distributed

author

purpose

combination from
the users

over

Mosaic

system which

distributed

Action would

the Office

in

II

an intended

the

change

94-108-3

conclusion

false

Toye

control

document

and

operation

and

Raggett

combination from being

II

The combination proposed

Action would

the Office

in

006-4-1

No

Client Reference

in

their

obviousness

USPQ 337

345

entireties

i.e including

Panduit Corp

CAFC 1985

Dennison

those

II

PATENT

No

Docket

Attorney

006-4-1

No

Client Reference

94-108-3

ARGUMENT

DETAILED

The Claimed Invention

The invention

where
that

the

from the network

of

location
associated

at

least

processing

first

distributed

When
instructions

an

of

portion

is

is

to

on the

document

the

document
The

client

workstation
to

responds

the

network

the

over

includes

document

specifies

the

The object

has

that

document

and locate

one

least

and where

received

document

hypermedia

identify

at

environment

and

hypermedia

hypermedia

the

to

by the browser

format

text

the

hypermedia

by the text formats

window
in

an object external

sequence of computer

document

hypermedia

by the browser

parsed

invoked

as

medium

automatically

formats

specified

location

first

utilized

the

embed

at

system having

in

executed
in

hypermedia

browser-controlled

located

to

identify

initiate

type information

instructions external

text

to

in

server

format

text

to

of

portion

for use

is

distributed

to

coupled

browser application

utilizes

text formats

browser displays

in claim

example
server

document

hypermedia

predetermined

for

one network

workstation

client

parses

an embed

as recited

and

workstation

client

has

sequence of computer

the

of the parsing

result

on the

execute

to

client

workstation

readable

computer

and enable

object

The

invention

claim

document

formats

The

to

to

identify

processing

browser displays

network

document

initiate

includes

The

object

of

has associated

text
at

When
instructions

an
is

embed

of
in

format

least

embodied

therein

workstation

client

within
being

to

the

text format

is

invoked

in the

displayed

to

window

display

automatically

for use

is

in

to

distributed

executed

on the

the

in

by the

for being

created

first

an

display

the

at

first

browser

document

system having

client

workstation

and responds

browser-controlled

window

at

parsed

to

that parses

predetermined

document

received

over

The hypermedia

location

in

hypermedia

document

to the

hypermedia

document

and

locate

an sequence of

identify

the

document

by the browser

result

to

external

first

of an object

utilized

one

least

formats

text

hypermedia

located

at

environment

hypermedia

distributed

first

hypermedia

as

claim

coupled

portion

type information

instructions external

computer

in

formats

specified

server

an embed

the location

specifies

text

portion

from the network

that

example
server

browser application

recites

document

hypermedia

for

as recited

and one network

workstation

The

the

of the hypermedia

the

cause

to

of the object

processing

code

program

window

controlled

text

interactive

of the portion

location

client

by the browser application

invoke

automatically

computer

of the

the

parsing

to

sequence of computer
execute

on the

client

workstation

When
is

displayed

location

the automatically

and

interactive

of the portion

invoked

processing

of the

application

executes

of the object within

hypermedia

document

Description

being

of the

on the
display

displayed

References

client

workstation

window
is

created

enabled

at

the object
the

first

PATENT

No

Docket

Attorney

l.a

The

e.g Mosaic

are several

ways

to

interaction

with

the

tJRL

HTML

of the 906 patent Applicants

specification

browser application

browser

as

document

HTML

an

retrieve

from

in

document

source

The browser application
renders the

the

step

document

such

static

the

then

browser may

and

images

the

There

is

no further interactionwith

causes

server

again

its

the browser application
local

store

HTML document
HTML document with

window

to

of

first

to

to

retrieve information

hypermedia

document

hypermedia

to

static

document

images referenced

For data

users

or non-native

specification

element

that

Many
the

the

Mosaic

to

1MG

that

format

in

files

for

local

copy

user believes

browser GUT

the

from the network

retrieved

newly

local

copy of

of the retrieved

version

the browser-controlled

in

were

links

from

of

list

price

changed

data

objects

The

link

by

in

retrieved

display

or picture

other

of allowing
that

types

by

information

window

separate

file

text

user may browse

has the capability
to

or the
If

document

document

such

mechanism

or

as

.TIF

for

exist

that

invoke

to

than

the user

the
to

be

cannot

handle

source

the rendered
in

the

URL

location

inline

in

document

an

of the source

of the document

format

HTML

certain

in

images

may be placed

images

All

must be retrieved

document

by the browser application

Mosaic

view

specifying

an object address

to

in

tags specified

HTML

window

These

specifies

displayed

FIG

of rendering

the capability

can not be rendered

separate

includes

viewers

document

had

displayed

format

element which

the

rendering

in

browser program

is

Mosaic

include

native

as

1MG

by

formats

command

as

by the browser and

by the browser prior

or

new window

open

designated

using the

be rendered

foreign

document

helper applications

GIF

as

to

application

by Mosaic

Some browsers such

file

HTML

the prices

passively

document

formats such

HTML

HTML

from the retrieved

displays

if

identified

the

the

version

other external

to

first

displayed

copy of the

button

HTML

HTML

determine

the

an external

refresh

retrieved
the source

displaying

replaces

invoke

document

hypermedia

links

selecting

window

the

During the

and displayed

of the previous

if

document

the

HTML

render again

Although the browser application

either

of the

copy

document

211

images

of the

page

the source

and

the subsequently

For example

goods the user might refresh

actively

user

locator

and displays

paragraph

the

rendered

can click

and replace the display

window

or another

elements

HTML

the local

to

render

Web

being

retrieve

copy again parse

the source
source

local

temporary

Web page

external
tags

the source

HTML document subsequent to
HTML document has changed she

which

uniform resource

of the

copy

into

at

into the

images

require

user

of thc source
the source

document

1MG

by

There

selected

retrieves

utilizing

stores

the local

parses

information

retrieve

insert

by

and

window

referenced

files

server

of which

all

server

describes

Art

documents

workstation

HTML

of the

copy

client

browser-controlled

as source

graphic
to

display

in

page

rendering

as

local

temporary

Web

rendered

network

on the network

on the

cache

network

Prior

HTML

The browser then

paragraph

locates

Admitted

viewer to view

functions

that

HTML document from
the HTML document

source

that

94-108-3

Admitted Prior Art

Applicants

published

006-4-1

No

Client Reference

launches

certain

types

and locating

in

the format

various

file

viewer program

helper

applications

of

types

file

linked

of Uniform

formats

helper

itself

object

is

As

such as TIF

application

in

Locator

When

typically

in
to

response

described

HTML

an

Resource

i.e data

user

the

in

anchor

URL
commands

by clicking

on an

PATENT

No

Docket

Attorney

No

Client Reference

anchor

with

displays
This

means

there

viewer program

As

has been

the

was

authors

There
interactive

user

the

tool

or

environment

while

browser

on

being invoked

and

The

active

is

by the browser so

browser program

the

screen

separate

viewer program

the

after

viewer program

to

continues

provide

made

that

data

of automatically
in

WWW

the

the

after

browser program
execution

access

to

viewing of

WWW

on the

an external

application

hypermedia

area of

Web

and gave

easily accessible

anywhere

objects

invoking

display

the

after

viewer programs

user-activated

simplified

and related external

run even

to

stops the

explicitly

advance

of an object

processing

windowing

of the

The viewer program

program

launched

no disclosure

is

in

the

viewer program

powerful

separate

no longer active

is

between

significant

documents

hypermedia

as

independent

unless

stopped

Mosaic
page

separate

completely

result
is

launched

is

window

browser program

the
is

viewer

no communication

is

execution

in

image
that

viewer program
that

the

mouse

the

006-4-1
94-108-3

document

network

to enable
being

displayed

by the browser

.B

Berners-Lee

Berners-Lee

al

et

HTML

Markup Language

Hypertext

Internet

Draft

IETF pages 1-40 June 1993

The

HTML
their

is

reference

Web

used by

language

browser parses

pages

the specified

items

Web

as

rendered

describes

distributed

Web

by

page

or enters

There

works
to

nor

enable

by

there

across

to

Web

departs

rendering

hints

to

display

HTMLHypertext

document

clicks

the

in

hyperlink

or

browser or how

building

area

browser

an external

application

invoking
of

document

hypermedia

page

authors

to

give

HTML

the

presentation

Web

page

static

display

authors

format

delivery

In pertinent

being

it

is

Web

by allowing
over

for

and

Document Format

greater control

23 1993

the

final

proposed

browsing and querying
generally

part Raggett

of equations

images

independence

July

Markup Language

Hypertext

independent

added
to

describing

from pure

Markup Language

HTML

entitled

the internet

At page

slightly

of automatically

weight presentation

light

information
allowing

relating

the reference

in

then

author

page

displayed

page

page and

the reference

of an object

of

displays

view

to

page

Web

as

in

processing

is

Raggett

Web page

another

Web

pages are written by

in

disclosure

Raggett

for

Web

which

The user views

user

select

and then

browser window

page within

in

structure

its

language

browser

the

Raggett

standard

to

text

to determine

browser and viewed

server to

no disclosure

is

is

interactive

displayed

lc

some

document

markup

and desired contents

the structure

describe

to

HTML

for the

specification

authors

model

browser window by the browsers
button

is

HTML

an

reference

This
then

Berners-Lee

simple
stated

page

relates

drawings

in

that

HTML

authors

appearance

to

specify

of

documents

At pages
are

treated

like

and

characters

Inlined
in

the

Graphics
text

or Icons

and an example

10

are

discussed

of the

1MG

it

tag

is

is

stated

given

that

these

elements

No

Docket

Attorney

No

Client Reference

This

img

line

It

and

that

editor

HTML

Raggetts

EMBED

such as TeX and

Raggetts

external

would
It

1MG

to

pixmap

example

of Raggetts

this

the

example

In

applicationleqn
render

static

embedded
this

data

reference

applications

It

EMBED
simple

is

also

for creating

also stated

element can

at

be

page

etc defined

graphs

At page

13 the

revising

in

ismap

of the figure can be designated

There
works
to

nor

enable

displayed

.d

is

that

data

data

as

is

embedded

the

embedded

content

or

library

data

is

is

by the eqn application

to

form

external

to

editor

data

the

using

FIG tag

instead

of using

FIG tag

the

following

and

src

that

attribute

this

useful

is

of the FIG tag

described

is

It

is

stated

that

the reference

relating

the reference

of automatically

II

Raggett

in

object

The

102

position

Posting

of

W-WWW-TALK
of the Applicants

However

in

the following

is

for

arbitrary areas

links

to

display

browser or how

building

browser

an external

application

invoking
of

area

hypermedia

document

being

by the browser

Raggett

an

fonnat

as hypertext

of an

shared

image

browsers can link

sophisticated

MIME

specify

tkit

in

processing

drawings

familiar

and the type information

processed

in

interactive

simple
use

to

follows

in the following

sinlw

immediately

attribute

tdt

mt sinomega

when

given

is

no disclosure

is

form of

tdt/embed

embedded

an external

tag

to

static

holding

there disclosure

[e-mail]

U.S.C

12

included

FIG tag

the

drawings are better

such as

of rendering

example

EMBED

pi

the

that

states

and

continue

attribute

type

structure

2ir

The

an

using

simple

and

complex

application

mt sinomega

is

example

An

data
data

is

pi

utilize

image of the embedded

graphic

with

provides

equations
to

and

images

that

rendering

propOsed

embed typeapplicationleqn2
In

would

tag

identify

which

that

authors

page

modify images

data

elements

EMBED

browser

Web

to

be specified

should

described

is

of the graphics

the source

authors

page

images

tag

also stated

is

name

to

Web

for mathematical

allow

used to render embedded

filter

as returning

An

EMBED

convenient

very

tag

used

is

allow

larger inlined

that

eqn

proposed

be used by

to

is

by using the FIG or

specified

notation

proposed

that

embedding

proposed

standards

URL

editors should

also stated

Raggett

page

level

given

ankh.tiff

src

is

It

94-108-3

end of the

the

at

hieroglyph

further stated that the

is

At

type

egyptian

sophisticated

external

object

has

line

PATENT
004-

Dave

Raggett

public

that

it

mailing

Raggett

will

II

list

is

be assumed

11

to

dsrhplb.hpt.hp.com
Posted

not
that

June 14

publication
Raggett

II

www
993i

complying
is

prior art

with

35

PATENT

No

Docket

Attorney

the subject

having

an

II is

Raggett

email

This reference

wants

an email

The email

an

number

large

that

then

is

It

MIME

content

stated

It

to

API

common

driven

programs

also stated

is

It

names

the function

that

these

requests

source

that

document

then

identifies

the

in

building

formats

support

browsers and

for

programs

foreign

by

possible

The

he

also quotes

documents

his

browser

the

that

It

e.g

as rendering

pixmap

those

to

formats

and

via piies

new

display

and

formats

by binding

that the functions

file

separate

be

could

stdinlstdout or as dynamically

can be put in

data

foreign

in

very large

for rendering

of documents

quite

also stated

is

be upgraded

for

Janssen

Bill

difficult

HTML

states

attribute

browsers can then

that

to

types

DLLs

libraries

tag and

lots

Postscript

both

the

in

of leading

has the danger

by using

as separate

implemented

type

makes

inline

EMBED

is

it

encapsulated

sequence of bytes and return

take

that

foreign

from the

data

can be avoided

this

functions

data

proposed

of formats

send

to

he has

that

stating

for equations

support
like

and

Nielsen

Torben

94-108-3

Postscript

eqn

HTML DTD

the

that

of Raggetts

example

would

embed

to

of the embedded

format
for

states

the capability

providing
gives

then

he

to

Raggett

from Nielsen

without

that

stating

from Janssen

and

for

support

email

an

quotes

Web

put on the

to

from David

message

HTML

line

006-4-1

No

Client Reference

linked

referenced

by

URL
There

works
to

nor

enable

interactive

bye

is

design

teams gather

information

paper

also presents

realization

of

Wide

at

services

Internet

39
of

application

invoking

of

document

hypermedia

being

SHARE

both

of the design

to

SHARE

of the

information

to apply

and communicate

undertaken

Infrastructure

for

build

technologies

and formal

informal

and design

The

process

an infrastructure toward the

environment are NoteMail

and

DIS

an application-oriented

depicts

link
over

is

of services

set

view

and constraint

managers

the Internet

as can

of the

other

SHARE

over

communicating

The

managers
information

The

architecture

Some of

the Internet

diagram

services

such

illustrates

as the

that

World

that

email

is

the

NoteMail

enables

them

to

primary medium

messages
be

for

both

are formatted

in

sent as ordinary

e-mail

human communication

MIME
and

Multi-purpose

read

using

any

reader

tear

One

seeks

that

project

Product

22 1993

April

understanding

components

architecture

mail

shaded

of tools

shared

For example

Mail Extension

The

on Enabling Technologies

re-access

strategies

for Collaborative

Catalogs and Libraries

Databases

integration

Environment

33-47

SHARE

SHARE

DIS

include

MIME-compliant

classes

browser

an external

Services

communicate

can

Web

tool

Two

page

architecture

In the

and

area

display

Workshop

organize

and

research

SHARE

Fig

SiARE

of automatically

and

IEEE pp

to establish

Information

Distributed

Second

paper describing

design

these

browser or how

relating to building

in

methodology

1993

Enterprises

Toye
helping

SHARE

Proceedings

Collaborative

level

of an object

processing

al

et

DevelojDment

top

the reference

in

in the reference

by the browser

displayed

in

no disclosure

is

there disclosure

is

drop

class

is

in

Fig

NoteMail

shows

that

and DIS

the

SHARE

which

12

environment consists

helps engineers

capture

of three

and manage

file

PATENT
Docket

Attorney

Reference

Client

NoteMail

information

team of engineering

NoteMail
Internet

standard

for

It

Unlike

that

This
inclusion

notebook

the

Subsequently

application
that

that

so
this

It

is

allow

then

stated

Because
to

Instead

everyone

as

DIS

There
used in claims
disclosure
processing

in

set
for

is

this

other

that

of

is

and preserves

architecture

open

viewer

its

any

video or graphics

audio

output

of

environments

data

with

file
that

will

the

selected

user for

by

for display

in

the

the original

restart

network

Macintosh

using

is

application

mouse
leaving

file

or

object

environment

It

is

and automatically

finder

file

notebooks

lack

this

openness and

and

flexibility

to

be sent by email

efficient

to

store

the

NoteMail

pointers

full

copies

components

uses

of the

messages are not

of the message

an object-oriented

in

one place
base

knowledge

repository

of

the reference

of an object

captures

of input formats

more

of reference

the

authoring

its

without

for processing

messages are
it

data

opening

engineering

handful

no disclosure
and

to

that

page

the appropriate

or updated

similar

insert

after

First
invoke

the displayed

application

NoteMail

and just transmit

known

is

functionality

processing

system

will

can be edited

data

the appropriate

invoking

steps

selecting

is

and read by using any

e-mail

type

the

dynamic window

two

in

the

of NoteMail

and multimedia

through

page

data

Mail Extension

Internet

Multi-purpose

Format

can

006-4-1
94-108-3

by several members of

editing

on each NoteMail

an X-server

No

team

can be sent as ordinary

items

notebooks

through

notebook

MIME

uses

an interesting feature

accomplished

is

in

notebook

sent

of information

displays

into

dynamically

only

NoteMail

reader

most other engineering

application

stated

that

stated

is

in

i.e

editing

an engineering

multimedia mail and

mail

arrangement

spatial

collaborative

within

messages are formatted

MIME-compliant
the

tool for

is

documents

No

in

in

the reference

modifying

that

applications

of automatically
display

of building

area

of

invoking

an external

hypermedia

browser

13

hypermedia

edit or
update

browser as

files

being

nor

or objects

application

document

that

to

enable

displayed

term
is

is

there

interactive

by the

Docket

Attorney

No

Client Reference

THE EXAMINERS

The examiner
Bemers-Lee

opposed

Raggett

to

It

is

then

stated

complete

the

Bemers-Lee
be

that

The

II

does

not

explicitly

combination teaches

within

distributed

Toye on

the other

document

user

citing

to

admitted

method

teach

method

that

discloses

interactively

prior

embeds

art in

view

enables

that

static

of

interactive
as

objects

documents

hypermedia

hand

94-108-3

REASONING

combination of Applicants

the

browser allows

hypermedia

distributed

process

byes description

an object

of NoteMail

system in

hypermedia

within

embedded

40

particularly

col

paragraph

It

modify

objects

hypermedia

distributed
first

dynamic

that

and Raggett

of said object

processing

which

states

PATENT
00641

No

is

then

method

discussed

Raggett

dynamic

object

to

would

be apparent

concluded

that

it

would

above combining

and Raggett
embedded

II

have been
the teachings

by further modifying

object

as taught

based on Toyes teaching

that

by Toye
its

flexibility

14

to

readily apparent
of the admitted
the
It

architecture

is

prior

combinations
stated that
provides

skilled

artisan

art

static

in

view

embedded

the modification

openness and

to

of

PATENT

No

Docket

Attorney

No

Client Reference

006-4-1

94-1083

TRAVERSE

This

The

Felten

entire

rejection

of claims

in Felten

II with

in

Felten

II

The

respectfully traversed

is

rejection

II

declaration

and

The

citations

to

Further the argument

basic

argument

of

requirements

includes

as

Case

traverse

an independent

presents

citations

Prima Facie

reasons

recapitulates

and

thereof

parts

also

herein

incorporated

is

following

relevant

the following

for

parts

of the traverse

arguments

addiponal

establish

prima facie

of Obviousness

of obviousness

case

are

three basic

must be met First there must be some suggestion
either

the references

in

available
or

to

combine

reasonable

or

themselves

one of ordinary

to

reference

skill

or

the

set

forth

of success

teach

criteria

motivation
generally

modify

the reference

must be

there

the prior

Finally

when combined must

or

knowledge
to

Second

teachings

expectation

references

in

the art

in

art

or suggest

reference

all

the claim

limitations

The teaching

or suggestion

20

The

level

USPQ2d

of

skill

in

PHOSA
science
just

of success

must both

disclosure

In re

Fed

1991

1438

equivalent

do things
level

for
person
at

who

conventional

having
is

in

or

ordinary

university

the industry

ways

skill

but

This

15

but

gained

knows how

15

as

computer

student

does not exhibit an unusual
paragraph

thinking

488

art

good

has

the

declaration

star

not

person

in

F.2d

in the

from

person who

or

found

be

Vaeck 947

the Felten

just graduating

student
in

forth

is set

college

average

of innovative

art

person

knowledge
in

Cir

the relevant

program
typical

claimed combination and

applicants

in

The benchmark
is

the

expectation

the reasonable
prior art not

make

to

forth

not present

Felten

to

2143
To

of the
set

to

in

MPEP

PATENT

No

Docket

Attorney

No

Client Reference

PART

The establishment
claim limitations

of

case

aprimafacie

obviousness

of

be taught or suggested

must

by

that

requires

the

all

MPEP

art

the prior

006-4-1
94-108-3

2143.03
None

of the references

invention

Applicants
been

of the

claimed features

the

or suggest

Accordingly

when considered

combination

proposed

teach

or collectively

individually

of obviousness

case

aprimafacie

either

of the

has not

established

There

Mosaic

Berners-Lee

external

window
server

in

on

and

to display

parsed

is

Raggett

over

received

an embed
in

object

network

browser-controlled window

in

being displayed

an

control

interactively

art

prior

an

automatically invoking

computer when

client

document

hypermedia

of

admitted

the

Toye

or Raggett

to execute

application

format

or teaching in either

no suggestion

is

display

from

on

text

network

the client

computer

As
document
that

described

are subsequently

II browsers have
into

the

of

set

static

document

is

as

feature

control

interactively

Further as
Berners-Lee
the

inserts

formats
being

and

an object

that

are

interactive

set

forth

Raggeu

an external

Felten

the

in

static

static

and
inline

by the browser

invoked

by the browser

by the browser itself and

to

form of the

presentation

window

display

image and

on the

in the

and

Berners-Lee Raggett

non-interactive
to execute

application

client

the claimed
to

computer
document

hypennedia

by

Thus

when Raggetts

invoked

of

beinglisplayed

the

applications

application

not

is

EMBED

is

tag

within

display

window

terminate

before

of

set

The browser

static
to

prior

applications

area

created

as required

the

allows

user

document

by Raggett

of providing
the

in

hypermedia

by claim

document

hypermedia

presentation
the

taught

are not capable

parsed

browser controlled

the

into

Mosaic

the

in

terminate

document

of rendering
types

an object displayed
in

image and

form of the hypermedia
the

invoked

applications
static

by the rendering

browser

the

the rendering

combination return

II

returned

image

rendering

in

can be inserted

that

application

handled

by the examiner the Mosaic

displayed

in

and

processing

document

inline

not

formats

and Raggett

Berners-Lee

displayed

rendering

format

browser displays

the

images

hypermedia

presentation

by the browser

displayed

comprising the presentation

displayed
II

inserts

invoking

Raggett

static

into

be subsequently

to

browser

acknowledged
that

in

static

system

II

static

described

files

graphics

formats

of ordered

by that combination of references

or suggested

taught

render

and

Raggett

set

As

by the browser

foreign

the

of automatically

into

format

subsequently

combination teaches

rendered

is

of an external

filein

Accordingly
II

Mosaic Berners-Lee

the use

teach

II

that

image

that

to

ability

and

static

the

presentation

graphics

process

return

in

displayed

the

Raggett
to

above

by the browser

retrieved

is

Instead

displayed

the

by the

browser

discloses

Toye
page

The

first full

NoteMail viewer

paragraph

on page

that

40 of

bye

describes

to

view

static

an authoring

image of

notebook

environment and

viewing environment

When
included

page

in

authoring

the

NoteMail

II

at

NoteMail page
page

paragraphs

and then

33-35

the author
static

The

may

image displayed

16

data

actively

image of the

file

is

in

the

displayed

page

file
in

must be

or object

the

to

be

NoteMail

static

because

PATENT
Client

Toye
so

states

that

subsequently

to

its

the displayed

that

selection

the application
at

40

page

selection

first full

is

the

processes

file

in

an

document

parsed

Thus

like

NoteMail

mouse

is

page

page
prior

an application

teaches

that

Finder
result

of the users

of user

interactive

the application

launched

of an external

application

of the object

and

bye

is

invoking
result

invocation

an application

Raggett

will

36

paragraph

II

by the viewer

launches

that

was possible

Macintosh

using

where

Finder

processing

invoke

to

displayed

page

at

the

that

automatic

interactive

Mosaic Berners-Lee

NoteMail

in the

displayed

II

enable

by

of the

format

Macintosh

using

the data

page Further
file

automatic

that

and

and

away from

teaches
to

the

by

fact

NoteMail

in

by the user the system

opening

teaches

claims

with

NoteMail

in

similar to

is

own window

Toye

selected

is

for display

file

must be selected

object

file

The

paragraph

35

paragraph

Thus Toye

opening

its

is

or

functionality

as required

Accordingly

when

object

paragraph

similar to

at

II

no interaction

that

94-108-3

the original application

restart

first full

006-4-1

No

Reference

with the data displayed

interact

and

static

the application

launching

not parsing

selection

was

when an

that

invoke

automatically

data

40

page

at
to

mouse will

with

updated

mouse

with

states

Toye

or

must be restarted

the original application
teaches

the data

selecting

can be edited

the data

that

No

Docket

Attorney

but instead

enable

to

interactive

combination

Subsequently
that

static

user

to

that

processing

presentation

image

static

selecting

allows

teaches

or update

edit

the

data

There

is

Mosaic
format

Berners-Lee

at

created

at the

in the

II

Raggett

of

the

of the

portion

text
the

displaying

within

art

prior

parsing an embed

processing of the object

within

admitted

the

document and

hypermedia

interactive

location

first

or

Raggett

location

first

and enabling

object

or teaching in either Toye

no suggestion

area

display

document

hypermedia

being displayed

In the admitted
selected
set

of

by the user

static

The

modification

invoked

rendering
inserted

terminated

the

retrieved

browser suggested

at

combination

hypermedia

by the browser

rendered

displayed

before

fundamentally
area

the

is

set

incapable

of

first

then

of

is

in

displayed

the

that
set

into

document
an ordered

browser

in

document

at

first

static

formats

interactive
being

17

returned

Since
is

the ordered

into

document

set

In

document

and terminates

formats

the

static

and the presentation
application

by the browser

of an object
the

this

by external

hypermedia

the rendering

displayed

in

in the

image

presentation

processing

displayed

does not change

by the browser

location
static

returns

of

II

images

form of the hypermedia

by the browser

presentation

of providing

hypermedia

tag located

static

in line

the displayable

invoked

location

static

the

system are inserted

comprising

and

by Raggett

above

described

EMBED

application

the

As

the Raggett

fonnats

form of the document

display

to

and II the Raggett

parsed

image

in

presentation

Raggett

is

and Berners-Lee

by the browser and subsequently

viewing paradigm

applications

is

Mosaic

on the Internet

formats

presentation

fundamental

static

art

window

controlled

of

prior

located

is

being

it

has

is

displayed

browser controlled

window

in

the

PATENT

No

Docket

Attorney

Turning next
purpose
to

and preserve

capture

Format

to

data

There

311

initiate

is

NoteMail
those

the

elsewhere by the

the

can be

server

mouse

restarted

so

application

to

an X-server

through

would
Toye

editing application
provide

this

of being
out

at

II

under
which

elements
in

display

file

using

would

area

in

Macintosh

Toye
being

teaches

with

an

of

interactive

at

40

is

specified

page

controlled

be created

As

run

own

interface
interaction

similar to

area

display

at

II
in

is

opening

Macintosh

In

paragraph

window

in

since existing

in their

provide

to

so as

functionality

launching

separate

be run

capable
points

displayed

first full

interaction

if

to

is

Felten

and other graphical

useable

being

Professor

to

by the

which

combination

were designed

being

able to display

should

purpose

bats

an

document

window

in

with

page

hypermedia

any application

file

an

through

modifying

any existing application

menu

in

application

of

of

applications

this

invention

the editors being

displays

NoteMail

in

from the proposed

away

the application

that

from enabling

away

for

of the document

location

of

that

and contained

Finder

launches

file

teaches

this

that

new

that

suitable

is

that

data

area

display

and updating

no teaching

control

teaches

intended

NoteMail

in

of information

no teaching

is

teaches

Toye

of the claimed

interfere
first

Further Toye

opening

38

own

their

There

Rather he teaches

the time

at

paragraph

text

no teaching

enabling

application

the displayed

within

editing

an X-server

paragraph

editor applications

windows

allow

that

or edited

window

provides

through

and

document

MIME

The

page
at

the
is

the location

NoteMail

teaches

processing

editing capability

displayed

displaying

and

in

selecting

can be updated

interactive

Further

there

because

reference

Toye

formats within

Multi

NoteMail

for

type

browser controlled

in

displayed

allow

data

text

location

first

NoteMail

on

formats

text

type

94-108-3

MIME

in

defined

is

of the document

portions

of using

by subsequently

the data

that

at

location

first

Format

Additionally

by

format

text

within

processing

in

text

data

of information

arrangement

from the

specified

processes

messages are formatted

new Format MIME

and

spatial

separate

no teaching

NoteMail

reference

Toye

the

stored

is

an embed

parsing

the

to

Mail Extension

Internet

006-4-1

No

Client Reference

34

paragraph

of

location

first

Finder

Thus

document

displayed

Because

the

combination

limitations

set

claim limitations

references

As

the

of claims

forth

below

the rejection

and such

Bemers-Lee

Raggett

possible

it

would

not include

Web

not include

the

through

the references

II

would

in the rejection

proposed

no motivation

provide

combination would
and

by the cited

are not taught or suggested

change

the basic

browser technology

combination proposed

the

by

principles of the Mosaic

operating

even

However

of the pending

the limitations

for

if

claims

the
II

combination were
at

46-

paragraphs

51
Such
interactive

combination would

processing

within

not automatically
area

display

of

Berners-Lee Raggett

data

map and

is

rendered
data

application

is

in

Instead
creating

static

to

static

displayed
separate

the

bit

as

static

bit

then

combination

bitmap within

displayed

map

window

it

could

at

II

by the browser

paragraph

be constructed

browser window

18

in

such

being

combination

must be selected by

that

II

if

and

application

document

hypermedia

browser because the Mosaic

external

an external

invoke

bye

mouse

enable

displayed

teaches

and

to

to

by the

external

that

teaches
launch

that

an

editor

47
would

way

include

that

the Raggett

user clicking

method

on that

of

static

PATENT
Client

bitmap would

launch an editor program

an external

in

window

as in

combination would

not

show

automatic

invocation

hypermedia

document

or enable

interactive

processing

hypermedia

document

This

the external

Instead
additional

manual
to

processing
II

at

Even
first

Reference

No

006-4-1
94-108-3

Toyc

at

50

paragraph

not

No

Docket

Attorney

is

being

of selecting

action

in an

automatic

as required

by claims

Thus
combination

at

least

the

external

static

would

within

if

only

on

the external

by claims

the user took

the

first

and
the

interactive

causing

it

application

when

of the

portion

as required

be invoked

image by clicking

window when

combination were

Toyc

hypemiedia document

show

browser window

of Toye

of the editor program

was

restarted

48-50

paragraphs

the

the

in

displayed

editor application

be enabled

if

parsed

being

invocation

displayed

to
in

show
the

interactive

browser window

of the editor program

when

the

within

processing
the

portion

combination would

hypermedia

document

is

and

two elements
II

at

of claims

paragraph

and

51

19

would

be missing

from the proposed

of the
still

parsed

PATENT

No

Docket

Attorney

PART

The establishment

II

of

cannot

The proposed

2143.01
Mosaic

Berners-Lee

combination

Accordingly

and

render

proposed

of

of the

principle

operation

teaches

Raggett

be

EMBED

proposed
the

At page

static

FIG element

document
image

static

return

file

The
reinforced

image

is

the

intended

its

Action

purpose
established

fundamental

contradicts

and

Raggett

images rendered when

of
of the

operation

has not been

Berners-Lee

EMBED

proposed

the

embed

Raggett

tag that require

EMBED

not qualified
cause

the displayed

in

images

FIG

tag

known

is

of

substitute

function

the

in

image

art that

HTML

the

src-deflned

for

EMBED

proposed
to

It

version

tag as

Raggetts

the

the returned

of using the src element Raggetts

instead

an element of the FIG tag

as

proposed

would

it

for

Office

stated that

is

static

display

or

selected

using

the figure

and

displayed

were

is

tag

to

required
at

incorrectly

of the Mosaic

EMBED-tag

application

to

II

system

is

be compatible

various

Since

areas

the

back

to

the

be
feature

ismap

utilized

explicitly stated intended
the

image

returned

to

purpose

by the Raggett

of the FIG tag

attribute

ismap

as

of

If the figure

would

can not be

click

mouse

to allow

with

figure

between areas

correspondence

Thus an

static

further

is

19

the

use

to

ability

would

Raggett

the

Raggetts

that

tag requires

image

require

returned

special

the

EMBED

proposed

and non-interactive

static

within

attribute

tag as an
that

and

Raggett

these

function

the

on

correspondence

over

single

the server

to

areas

semantic

this

can have only
clicks

is/nap

image

attribute

of the figure can be designated

semantic

by clicking

then

changed

page

static

only

13 The

browser to send mouse clicks

Arbitraiy

and the image must be

image

Berners-Lee

FIG

then

EMBED

mouse

paragraph

Thus
the

send

to

rendering

at

II

the case

mouse

Further

the

click

tag return

at

areas

thus creates

can be retrieved

that

pages

scheme

author

page

the

tag causes

be interactively

to

browser

with

interact

Web

of active

Raggett

FIG

EMBED

proposed

coordinate

Web

The

links

destroyed

Raggett
in

the

to

respect

hypertext

the

that

the discussion

with

the server

teaches

it

Raggetts

context

in this

requirement

by

described

within

to

the use of

MPEP

44

paragraph

causes

of Raggett

uses

primary

purpose

images

element can be used

static

only

static

of Raggett

12

is utilized

Since

be

parsed

is

tag

in the

the

the

of the

operation

would change

obviousness

of

that

requires

intended

its

94-108-3

of Toye with the combination
II

Mosaic

requiring that

combination

for

inoperable

it

case

prima facie

The combination

to

and

of

principle

inoperable

combination

Raggett

obviousness

of

the

change

or render the reference

reference

latter

case

aprimafacie

claimed combination

006-4-1

No

Client Reference

discussion

by Raggetts

be returned

image

on

such discussion

proposed

EMBED

is

tag

proposed
and thus Raggett

included

must be

were not

If this

of Raggetts

the use

No

FIG tag

of the src attribute

tag instead

and non-

static

interactive

the reasoning

Accordingly
image

static

object

taught

by Toye

as taught

the principle
inoperable

is

of operation

for

one
and

Lee

Raggett

then

the intended

compatible

by the Mosaic

with

of
II

its

intended

Bemers-Lee

purposes

ismap

attribute

the
of the

it

would
and

to

returned

FIG tag would

20

of Raggett
and

static

be dynamic

been

obvious

combination

Raggett

If the displayed

image

have

II

of the teaching

combination were modified
of allowing

that

Raggett

direct contradiction

of the Mosaic

purpose
the

of the rejection
Bcmers-Lee

II

image

be rendered

to

be

modify the
dynamic

and would

combination

change

and render

of the Mosaic

as suggested

by the Raggett

to

it

Berners

by the rejection

rendering

inoperable

function

to

be

PATENT

No

Attorney Docket

No

Client Reference

The combination
Berners-Lee
which

The admitted
to

view

document

text

document

hypertext

the

in

phrases
line

6-7

able

to

other

In

document

document

or data

distributed

imbedded

referenced

object

Internet

at

of

Thus
Since

the objects

may be

located

the

document

Thus
static

The

another

to
is

the

Accordingly
as

operate
retrieved

by

is

of various

is

media

documents

the

browser

on

displayed

display

or

page

the user

that

updated

hypermedia

that

objects

connected

to

are
to

the

its

by

of the location

specifies
the

HTML

of

distributed

system

the Internet

document

source

author

defined

combination teaches

connected

and displays

from

server location

its

document

the

The original source

browser user

by

and

on

combination teaches

II

server

and edited by

by

systems

FIG

or

and has control

for

copy of

by anyone

created

computer

combination the Web-page

and Berners-Lee

by

its

in

anywhere

are

that

author

readers using

browser

access

another

Toye

teaches

an engineering

Toye
workgroups

teaches

BernersLee

the

world

used only

using

to

separate

model

which

in

and read by anyone
from one

navigate

editing application

browser application

separate

team

the use

using

of

document

and

Raggett

objects

browser application

utilizing
to

Mosaic

system where

distributed

In contrast
within

words
at

except

to

the

II

at

12

paragraph

the

II

responsible

Mosaic

modified

and

anchor 1MG

Berners-Lee Raggett

is

in

certain

or select

system because data

of the

by simple unidirectional links

page
but not

viewed

or

published

pages are connected

page
and

can

pages

Mosaic

be

and

such as

on any computer

be edited

the

on many

form of the document

presentation
cannot

is

browser retrieves

the

Further

the

and

or phrases

or hypertext

document

link to retrieve

distributed

is

Raggett
in tags

the author

objects

users computer

user

27-29

line

page

referenced

allows

that

other objects

to

hypermedia

hypermedia

of

may be located

linked-to object

standard

renders

system

Mosaic Bemers-Lee

In the
the location

link

purpose

objects

document

that

system

by the link

hypermedia

document

within

the

the selection

to

or data

or

text

distributed

words

on

may click

hypertext

icons etc

to the

hypertext

Mosaic

the

change

document

as

to

documents

video

When

22-25

lines

page

are linked

would

intended

an

connected

device

similar to

is

graphics sound

browser responds

document

the user

other

to

sound icons video

at

mark-up

link

and

operation

that

document

hypertext

on images

the

its

display

objects

as additional

click

types such

from being

hypertext

on

data

that specify

text

hypermedia

program

describes

art

Action

combination

II

of

principle

displayed

and view

retrieve

access

prior

and

Raggett

basic

is

in the Office

proposed

006-4-1

94-1083

may be

by simply
located

stored

clicking

anywhere

system for collaborative
single

centralized

object-oriented

object-oriented

documents

21

II

combination was designed

anywhere
on

on the Internet

link

in

to

and

document

displayed

on the Internet

editing
database

of engineering

DIS

database

to

store

for storage

documents
documents

of the

PATENT

No

Docket

Attorney

Multimedia

be costly
full

to

copies

NoteMail

known

DIS

for

uses

service

files e-mail

DIS

serve

to

support

of

use

centralized

collaboration

page

41

page

The rejection
by

taught

the

at

the

states

Mosaic

it

emphasis

would

it

and

results

so

under the control

physically

persistent

CAD

is

object

created

in

handle

or

makes

database

sense

workgroup
in

II

the centralized

given

at

of Toye

to

21-24

paragraphs

and not

database

the goal

the

in

NoteMail

paragraph

first partial

that

simulation

and

design

with

added

engineering
are created

storage

information

associated

pointer

object-oriented

an

between objects

links

Further

within

created

reference

base

knowledge

centralized
the data

all

specifications

that

as

40-41

at

for

components

of reference

set

function

most data remains

In practice

of the application

object-oriented

the

store

and just transmit

an

of transferring

Instead
to

Sending
team can

design

large

efficient

repository

messages

forth

more

is

provides

management

The

it

this

DIS

Conceptually

on

everyone

one place

in

pointers
as

can get quite large

of both time and storage

everyone

of the message

to

94-108-3

encoded

raw text

containing

etc

clips

via email

terms

in

video

clips

documents

such

documents

engineering

audio

images

006-4-1

No

Client Reference

have

been obvious
and

Berners-Lee Raggett

II

modifS the

to

combination

to

be

combination

static

dynamic

object

as taught

by Toye

However

bye

with

the

and an intended
distributed

Mosaic

turn

under which

system operate
fundamentally

and

the

II

to

the

database

system and

II

and

PHOSA

referencing

and incompatible

22

by

taught

the basic

combination

II

is

to

provide

combination with

system thereby

destroying

its

away from any combination of the

Berners-Lee Raggett
and
storage

objects

change

on the Internet

anywhere

and

the

and

Raggelt

teaches

Raggett

of referenced

fundamental principle of operation

centralized

change

to

storage

combination would

modified

distributed

obvious

Mosaic

II

stored

system into

andlor

regard

different

be

to

Mosaic Berners-Lee

with

and

Bemers-Lee

fundamental

Raggett

combination of claims
principles

the centralized

Raggett

objects

distributed

Such

Berners-Lee

the

allows

that

that

nature

Thus

combine

of the Mosaic

purpose

system

would

distributed

to

of the combination being

of operation

principle

Toye

any attempt

Mosaic Berners-Lee

the

bye

Toye

centralized

references

would

because the differences
and

II

system

not

combination and the

of objects

from

make

the

in the basic

displayed

bye
page

are

PATENT
Client

The combination
Berners-Lee

Raggett

document author

the

Web

system which
author
data

able

is

Web

document
render

will

file

display

for

the user

Action would

the Office

in

proposed

document

locations

precise
that

page

model

In that

specifies
the

in

control

combination teaches

II

paradigm

which

experience to

browsing

and

Mosaic

the

system intended to give

to lose that

Berners-Lee Raggett

The combination

model

document

document

the

that

author

This

systems

documents

as accurate

This notion
principle of data

for the various

sees

at

II

be contrary

to

objects

An

this

21

paragraph

and

analyses

example

simulations

than

parameters

the original

document
document

in

document

the

reflecting

by any and

Since

document

sum

all

users

modified

Berners-Lee

system where

the author

intended

to

and

where

II

40

any user can

second

column

with

be displayed

to

she

but rather

different
in

the

the rendered

and the rendered
since

document

rely

would

therefore

the

Web

for

unsuitable

its

on the

of the

be

document
to

data

creation

its

system no user can

no resemblance

the

full

sees not the original

document

Toye

redo

can

recipients

unavoidable consequence

bear

That

at

first

by the published

render

form of

Web model

such an analysis
object

that

Toye

with

would

it

would

This

publish

page

the

An

communicated

the point

to

the

vision

of the

document

of the

modified

in

objects

Raggett

the information

time

by users over

the data

system

document

document

both

to

and

accessed

of the original authos

reflection

as

publishing

who have

any user can change

combination of Mosaic

of changes made

by the
since

on the published

for example

at

by the original creator

total

the

in

states

the

edited

last

environment where

recipient redoes

views

user

combination with the teachings

proposed

the resultant data

user

the

that

every

vision

editing

for display

Once

subsequent

form specified
the

in the

where Toye

specified

rely

fundamental principle

is

rendered
seen

was

it

publishing

to

users

own parameters

their

author

When

changes

which

is

since

intended

collaborative

under the Notemail heading

paragraph

objects

with

this

end

allow

to

for

end user on the other hand can be

any document

in

destroyed

is

are then

of

changed

of the authors

teaches

which

The

been

integrity

assurance

reference

viewing

can be assured

author

appear the same

to

going

for

important

data

document

has not

intended

representations

integrity

modify the data

extremely

of assuring

The Toye

Toye

is

viewed

are by nature

publishing

The

document

that

being

is

integrity

originally created

she

that

retrieves

subsequently

assured

document

insures

document

fully-rendered

of

author

94-108-3

principle

The

who

an

over the users

control

publish-once/view-many

HTML

browser

the

13-14

paragraphs

of the Mosaic

create

to

that

objects

basic

model

based upon

is

from

combination

causes the document

system which

The

and

006-4-1

No

Reference

would change

Action

in the Office

proposed

No

Docket

Attorney

could

be

document
intended

purpose

Another important
and

Raggett

document
the

II

author

browser

will

used
links

in

oniy

the
to

retrieve

of the
of

HTML

by the document

document

navigate

that

text

In the

from document
and acted

Web

model

referential

the specific

new

and they are resolved

paragraph

is

can specify

are easily specified
fonnats

principle

combination

integrity

locations

documents
author

directly

15

23

by the Mosaic

In the
in

these

The

Bemers-Lee

Web model

the

hypertext links

users click

since they

document

upon

contained

when

Web model
to

taught

are directly
are simple

document

upon

those

specified

These

links

embed

through
links

explicitly

by the browser application

from which

links

unidirectional
author

HTML

text

which

defines
II

are
these

at

PATENT

No

Docket

Attorney

This

both

document

to

document

text

or the data

is

it

Mosaic

be defined

only

out

of the document

HTML

Since

information

large

become

both

The

happen

workgroup
by

different

page

that

link

style

change
in

Web

Instead

functionality

CNN

browser with

This

documents

one

collaborator

instantly reflected

for

would

Furthermore
embedded
viewing
enabled

graphic
could

by Toyes

originally defined

So

it

and

is

TI

would

lose

their

by the

clear

the

been

presentation
over

to

at

to

to

to

in

which

only

teaches

away

the

that

documents

the

collaborative

editing

of

vital

to

of

series

through

propagate

Mosaic

so

Toye

home page

changes made by any

have

changes

is

can create

30

team-based

with

written

create

CNNs

always be what

to

that

integrity

Web

me

can no longer be assured

for

combination of Toye

referential

page

will

those

for

on
for

model

two

engineering

documents

difference

can

to

change

an

link

link

explains

the

goals
This

paragraph

naturally desire

see and

often

changes on

Webs

author

document

by
changes

connect

that

within

appropriate

cause

Felten

corresponding

be appropriate

their

TI

Professor

For example

for the

model

be managed

constraints

hyperlinks

system designed

discussed

be

as various
editing

rendered

semantic

HTML

users

Bemers-Lee

Raggett

the usefulness

of the

that

would

unusable

that

it

would

be

Toye

static

at

would
the

As

result

the

the various

and therefore

ismap

Web

data

links

referential

in

combination with

Toye

would

destroy both

fundamental principles behind the design

24

as

object
of the

defined

by

integrity as

author

are

an

of

functionality

intra-image
their

result

time

modify the corresponding

since

correspondence

such

combination with

while

environment

documents

integrity

the

above

of data that

format

time

therefore

referential

my page

document

would

formal

is

not

Web

destroyed

collaborative

FIG tag would

integrity

as has

change

FIG tag of Raggett
the

of

be unavoidably

would

can modify

the

all

proposed

the assurance

and II however
model

In the

it

As

causes

each other

Toye

in

sense

inter-linked

documents

trust

an authored

makes

Web

where

they create

of inter-linked distributed

system the definition of

represent

model

design

system can communicate

author

This

paths

systems

Toye

two documents

but

fundamental

and that they should

the

which

This provides

integrity the

referential

the Share

in

more appropriate

of any link within

intended

or

by changing

system therefore

Toye

within

example

on the

know

where

linked

for

document

only

this

information

that

is

either of the

follow

of

Webs

of multitudes

system taught

links

of the documents

integrity

of the document

home page

me

allow

Web

from the use of

referential

Web

of the navigational

vision

of the

the

either

unidirectional

can retrieve

users

principle

of such

this

can

not

CNN

hyperlinks

In the

of

the other

my own page and

can modify

creator

the

to

would

that

in

who may

people
links

of Toye

that

via collections

that links

doesnt make sense

it

basic

is

of the control

out

automatically
but

teaches

system the

the authors

only

document

of

23

paragraph

retrieval

be bi-directional

should

links

links

that

that

on the

rely

consequence

by agents

so

can

Toye

bi-directional

documents

final

for the creation

that

directions

insure

at

comprising
from

the user

location

combination employs

Without the enforcement

applications

be changed

to

can be created

unsuitable

teaches

Toye
separate
in

authors

systems

infonnation

II

in the

system which

the

documents

hypermedia
would

and

distributed

efficient

by

navigation

by the physical
II

94-108-3

viewing of documents

for rapid

imposed

and

publishing

reflected

to

integrity

also allows

of

for the design

for the

be displayed

to

objects

allows

optimized

limitations

by the author
is

are
It

Berners-Lee Raggett

can

referential

objects

primarily

model

linking

which

without

document

Since

by

lightweight

and distributed data

text

the

and

simple

browser applications

hypermedia

006-4-1

No

Client Reference

the data

of the

Attorney
Client

prior

art

unsuitable

Web
for

system and
its

intended

that

the

proposed

combination would

purposes

25

Docket

Reference

therefore

No
No

render the

PATENT
00641
94-108-3

Web

model

PATENT

No

Docket

Attorney

PART

The obviousness

lU

Toyc does

embedded

hypermedia

system

embedded

object

in

Raggett

and

view

access

phrases
line

3-6

able

to

the

types such

and

text

In

that

document

defined

by

objects

second paragraphs

located

in

suggest
with

the

at

of

different

for the
as

term

storage

is

words
at

documents

or hypertext

document

is

browser

on

displayed

and display

is

media

of various

objects

or

page

the user

that

except

other

link to retrieve

be

to

the

hypermedia

system because data objects

of the computer

system where

an open

to

the

not

distributed

use

Toye

DIS

page

and

does not teach

objects

requirements

is

of

25

26

at

II

the admitted

Toye

the use

prior

crucial

art

to

system

does
is

distributed

and used

in

the intended

distributed

and

hypennedia

objects
not teach

or

incompatible

24

paragraph

of

all

first

for referenced

reference

to

of operation

principle

its

documents

in

the

that

column

repository

document

Thus

locations

40

is

DIS

Service

as the central

hypermedia

is

meaning

system but requires

DIS

called

documents

Toye

universal

have

is

protocol

document

that

base

standard

of the

structure

of characters

geographic

of referenced

are

that

connected

systems

The

that

data

in

defined

the basic

in the

certain

objects

to

user

and to

or phrases

or select

the internet

distributed

hypermedia

same reasons

that

on

hypermedia

Distributed Information

heading

ability

allows

that

words

hypertext

distributed

to

system
single

described

pages
the

to

system and contradicts
paragraph

Berners-Lee

users computer

the

document

hypermedia

on many

sets

particular

in

to

or data

or

text

of

the Internet

of distributed hypermedia

of the centralized

at

statement

Mosaic

is

27-29

connected

teaches

Toye

using distributed

Also

an

process

by the link

lines

allows

be stored

the

system is

page

computer

computers

environment

II

at

below

contrast

the use

in

document

may click

hypertext

video

may be located

utilizing

The NoteMail
in

the

icons etc that link

When

referenced

HTML

each

In contrast

objects

interactively
this

as

to

documents

the selection

to

hypermedia

by the author

referenced

distributed

However

connected

the user

similar to

is

22-26

document

use of

implemented

to

defined

document

are linked

that

document

graphics sound

object

LApplication

The

user

terms

device

display

sound icons video

page

within

on

document

browser responds

or data

Internet

discloses

Toye

that

an object

process

document

document

hypertext

link to other

specify

line

distributed

imbedded

describes

hypertext

as additional
at

program

states

which

in

system

interactively

of the various

view other data objects

on images

the

to

hypermedia

hypermedia

meaning

displayed

hypermedia

click

hypermedia

browser allows

hypermedia

art

prior

document
in

user

4-7

lines

distributed

document

retrieve

hypertext

reaches

therefore

combination

II

text

premise and

false

on

distributed

distributed

page

of the precise

The admitted
to

at

which

within

view

incorrect

within

Action
in

disclose

not

browser allows

hypermedia

Office

based

is

94-108-3

conclusion

false

The

rejection

006-4-1

No

Client Reference

claims

purpose

hypermedia
and
of the

environment

The

bye

use

PATENT

No

Docket

Attorney

not teach

does

Toye
admitted

was

application

and Raggett

filed and as used

distributed

parses

documents

hypermedia

elements

of the pending

documents

browser

identifying

predetermined

text

to

responding

browser

utilizing

to

Further the Toye
between

where

objects

41 col

first partial

admitted

in

that

the

is

paragraph

Felten

click

mouse

teaches

Toye

at

there

is

second column
an object

process

physically

must be processed

give

arrangement

the

to

structure

mark

as

document

data

40

page

bye

Accordingly

Berners-Lee
document

of information

type defined

column

first

does not teach
and

Raggett

NoteMail

in

by the Toyc
last

the use of

combination

II

pages are therefore

or

not

documents

of interactively processing

Toye
that

data

in
that

any application
There

paragraph
in

order

of the application
for

object

page

and

update

displays

document

hypermedia

normal interface

to

edit

of modifying

in

must be selected via
data

such

The

type

the application

II

at

page

that
that

suggesting

it

of

an application

teaches

Further Toye
created

that

embedded

an X-server

through

no teaching

is

an

NoteMail

in

displayed

an application

under the control
using the

31

hypermedia

teaches

embedded

hypermedia

are interpreted

spatial

i.e

of the Mosaic

restart

frill

of

the use

text

tags

described

in

is

by the author

14

the structure

such

to

first

the

system being

Toyc

in

within

The mark-up

paragraph

Toye

by the user

by

MIME Format

the sense
in

links are defined

combination teaches

II

page
the

in

browser application

the

non-standard

no teaching

described

application

at

II

in

and

DIS database

in the

combination

II

links

by adding

system because

and resolved

paragraph

that

by

NoteMail

Felten

document

hypermedia

remains

in

II

hypermedia

some characters

standard
at

not

and

Raggett

where

Web-style hypermedia

to

Also

to

document

can be organized

stored

objects
is

Raggett

document

II

preserved

of an object

embedding

and

HTML

document

analogous

40

is

are

document

the

for the specific

hypermedia
the

and

formats

document

such

in

those

by

specified

hypermedia

format

text

information

Thus Toye

Bemers-Lee

In contrast

NoteMail page

partial

an embed

other

documents

hypermedia

processing
distributed

that

hypermedia

page

authors

distributed

of

portion

themselves

the links

text

by

tags specified

up

in

application

does not teach

it

the

that

of distributed hypermedia

as parsing

initiate

teaches

paragraph

The Mosaic
document

reference

Bemers-Lee

prior art

fonnats

text

to

the

in

the time

at

26-27

paragraphs

as

such

formats

text

and

94-108-3

defined

is

PHOSA

software

no

formats

text

term

the

by

teaches

Toye
uses

that

claims

and parsing

window

browser-controlled

or

formats
least

at

display

and

that

as

and II understood

claims

in

browser-related

by

browser application

hypermedia

Bemers-Lee

prior art

006-4-1

No

Client Reference

most data
the data
36-

paragraphs

37

There

is

modifying
art

In

proposed

view
in

distributed
other

no teaching in Toye

the

Mosaic

of the above

static

there

the rejection apparent

hypermedia

image

Berners-Lee

system

and

is

the

skilled

the

in

bye

artisan

of an analogous

architecture

27

that

object

combination
and

Raggett

no teaching

in

dynamic

taught by

to

or the use

fundamental incompatibilities

of

that

The

II

into

would
failure

hyperrnedia

described

above

would

of the

dynamic

make
of Toye

prior

image

the modification
to

suggest

document
would

make obvious

admitted

teach

or teach

as well

as the

away from

PATENT
Attorney

to

combine

Toye

any features of the Mosaic

The rejection implies
forth
as

in

set

forth

by clicking
object
the

and

claims

on

and

static

an

NoteMail

not automatically
interactive

dynamic object
image
to

application

of

process

in

the

is

format

an object displayed

in

is

the

link

within

the

only
the

an external
the

be activated

dynamic
database

is

parsed

hypermedia

nor

Accordingly
Raggett

there

and

is
II

no teaching
system

to

or suggestion

make

claims

28

in

and

Toye

of modifying

obvious

the

is

document

enabled

Berners-Lee

set

However

dynamic object

document

window of

display

that can

between

in

for processing

claims

pending

an object

stored

combination

II

meets the limitations

that
in

The

page

application
text

used

Toye

dynamic object

the external

Raggett

object

not

is

NoteMail

when an embed

invoked

processing

dynamic

described
in

displayed

Thus

itself

page

teaches

Toye

The term dynamic object

the

above

that

Bemers-Lee

and

006-4-1
94-108-3

system

attempting
the

No

Reference

Client

with

No

Docket

Mosaic

not
is

PATENT

IV

There

no motivation or teaching in the cited

is

references

make

to

The language

in

examiner teaches

claimed invention

the

Toye regarding
from

away

references

006-4-1

No

94-108-3

combine

the

cited

by the

Reference

Client

PART

No

Docket

Attorney

to

obvious

and

openness

combination

flexibility

would make

that

the claims

obvious

The
Raggett

the

However
NoteMail
to

referring

As

the

described

at

II

quoted

file

NoteMail

editor since

skill

in

references

the

not related

It

commonly used
the

skill

is

to

the strong

and

Raggett

from

be solved
Toye

MPEP

II

2143.01

Here

list

Beniers-Lee

of some

of the

Raggett

and

Toye

the

that

editing

by

centralized

documents

to

the

set

author

regarding

system over
if

editors

to

among

rely

problems

make

combine

the

different

by the Mosaic

solved

browser and

reference

the

bye

references

is

Raggett

nature

and have

away

obvious

the nature

and

Berners-Lee

system teach

claimed invention

object-oriented

can be retrieved

bye

between

of the

problem

combination and

II

structures

and

is

given

by an author
teaches

database

in

29

Felten

Bemers-Lee
and read

storage

Bemers-Lee

from anywhere

of the Mosaic

the teachings

of documents

editing

are created

of readers

on

these

incompatible

bye

at

II
other

find

oniy

to

1161

openness

were proper

it

the

projects

Inc 50 USPQ2d

would

be

or should

combinable

Mosaic Berners-Lee

collaborative

documents

insert

the references

even

PHOSA

combine

HTML

completely

and

In fact

systems

page

can

the suggestion

provide

language

of the NoteMail

fundamental differences

II

teaches

teaches

Toye

combine

would

to

VS/Intl

Corp

could

notebook

engineering

be relied upon

to

an X-server

away from modifying

teaches

known

specifically

NoteMail

into

NoteMail

that

the benefits

by the NoteMail

selected

motivation

different

that

is

there

cannot

they are not

systems

file

projects

using

and nebulous

to

are fundamentally

that

architecture

its

describing

formats

displays

language

advantages

motivation

for

that

Al-Site

quoting

that

system solve problems of

implementations

that

teaching

notebook

different

in

the other

art

collaboration

combination

source

the

motivation

suggestion

data

quoted
to

the general

The fundamentally

possible

Mosaic Berners-Lee

more than

nothing

no suggestion

the

any possible

engineering

to provide

doing

insert

is

merely highlighting

for

art

is

page when the

in

2143.01

is

411

the

in

object

other engineering

superior

In the rejection

and flexibility
paragraph

of

level

bye

any application

Thus

already

MPEP

references

apparent

to

There

system
is

the

Additionally

1999

it

that

NoteMail

40-41

other

any

static

based on Toyes

to

ability

teaches

into

paragraphs

with

FedCir

in

language

editors

Toye

combined

combine

been

flexibility

NoteMail

image of

static

have

system editor compared

above

of the

the modification

that

system would

II

openness and

provides

of the

states

rejection

and

without

of documents
teaches

and everywhere

in

that

on the

to

the

PATENT

bye

separate
teaches

that

within

unidirectional

The
need

the

to

To
which

solve

static

using

connection

are used

that

the

to the
to

only

Mosaic Berners-Lee

The

The pages
to

editing of engineering

viewed

at

II

II

in

is

can be

or operating
line

page

the

system

that

references

II

anywhere

another

16-30

model

teach

and read by

world

by simple unidirectional
is

page

modified

by

edited

by

its

author

readers using

its

12

paragraph

by the Toye

documents

and

connected

but not

of the problem solved

nature

server
are

from one page
is

at

Raggett

and

navigate

browser application

collaborative

on

by anyone

and

documents

of hardware

the types

to

42

Raggett

the Internet

to

by

know URLs

the Internet

on

widely

simple

paragraph

at

Bemers-Lee

regard

Ihtemet

links

implemented

users

that

II

distribute

connected

editor application

separate

separate

teaches

users without

by end

commands

know where

not

by the Mosaic

and

to publish

problem

users need

information

be published
pages can

anyone with
links

this

only

that

using

Berners-Lee teaches
and

94-108-3

Berners-Lee

bi-directional

rich

navigation

Berners-Lee

location

by the computers

utilized

systems

in

authors

and easily viewed

retrieved

providing

specified

by markup

specified

teaches

is

document

text

applications

teaches

are located

contain

is

Toye

of the problem solved

nature
allow

links

Toye

documents

outside

type

by separate

structure

display

structure

document

text

implemented

which

data

display

browser

that

teaches

Format

006-4-1

No

Reference

Client

Internet

No

Docket

Attorney

reference

within

is

need

the

create

to

team

an engineering

system for
at

36

page

toie5
To

solve

documents
includes

Because

the use

of the collaborative

publish-and-view
II

philosophy

combination

structured

Lee

and

II

It

those

design but

Toye

for Collaborative
design

is

information

to

teaches

email

portions

at

39

page

Powerbook
page

when

would

the disparate

other

be contrary

of Toyc

technique

the

in

to

For
the

Mosaic Berners-Lee

the

in

the distributed

to

nature

works
of the

well

Raggett

for highly

Mosaic

information

227

USPQ 337

in

entirety

teaches

its

for

apply

Bemers

is

in

depicted
to

be shared

Fig

File Server
in

the collaborative

30

and Environment
to

and formal

design

Abstract

process
and

tool

38 and

provides

group

1985

technologies

infonnal

on page
that

Corp

CAFC

345

Method

communication

i.e including

Panduit

information

both

of the design

both human

by email
to

to

Title

and communicate

understanding

environment

connected

obviousness

Company

considered

in their entireties

against

argue

Management

shared

SHARE
The

would

primary medium

computers

38

that

organize re-access

establish

The

storage

contrary

Manufacturing

Product

as the

embodied

as

or useful

of Toye

required to consider the references

reference

teams gather

is

by the references

combination

Dennison

The

of the Internet

store the

to

where the data base

paragraph 29-30

at

problems solved

editing techniques

24

paragraph

system are not relevant

Further the centralized

engineering

Raggett

different

one

in

at

II
II

database

object-oriented

single

objects

of the fundamentally
utilized

using

workgroup

between

links

and structures

example

teaches

Toye

by an engineering

bi-directional

techniques

and

problem

this

needed

is

Toye

integration

number

depicts

shared

help

access

stored

in

to

of

files

central

PATENT

No

Docket

Attorney

No

Client Reference

data

base

DIS

called

capture organize
such

modify and

formats

details

as

file

combination existed

chose not
goal

SHARE

of the

management
the

Mosaic

Berners-Lee

massive

the

hypermedia

skill

of

level

first

by

Mosaic

The benchmark

PHOSA
science
just

typical

PHOSA

at

professors

NoteMail

browser paradigm
architecture

46

the
II

is

last

project

because the

sense

data

highly-structured

who

engineers

model

taught

by

and

Raggett

that

recognized

would

did not attempt

paragraph

II

to

be
modify or

combination

not distributed

centralized

in

used

or

and

which

does

and

or

in the

good

but

of

way

Berners-Lee
with

Raggett

32

31

how

to

paragraph 151

The

entire

undertaking

As

is

and organization

Raggett
the

but

gained

person knows

paragraph

sharing

computer

student

star

has

art

does not exhibit an unusual

massive

last

not

who

This

at

column

incompatible

skill

from

person

conventional

of information

claims

university

the industry

the result

first

paragraph

and

Raggett

SHARE

the

world of engineering

just graduating

ways

Mosaic Bemers-Lee
at

centralized

Bemers-Lee

thinking

in
is

of the Mosaic

fundamentally

from modifying
rejection

page

model

teaches

in

conventional

does things

is

student

average

environment that

column

is

college

knowledge
in

and

having ordinary

person

at

of innovative

level

The

for

program

do things

to

know

is

person who

is

equivalent

collaborative

art

term

that

of

made

decision

innovative

system which

as

in the

Such

circumscribed

the

documents

Bemers-Lee

but the designers

editing

project

46

taught

The

not use

SHARE

NoteMail

the

to

combination

II

page

at

web browser

they designed

team

as

having

of the open distributed hypermedia

in the relatively

even

vision

bye

of

collaborative

and

of the

by the Mosaic

taught

paragraph 26-281

the goals

Raggett

undertaking

redesign
Instead

with

the designers

their

at

allow

to

project

the type

of publication

II

inconsistent

is

Thus
realizing

them

use

to

knowledge

design

their

without

and locations

the time

at

work

Services that helps engineers

share

web browsers of

Significantly
II

Information

Distributed

retrieve

006-4-1
94-108-3

Web
and

and
Thus
II

II

Toye

reference

that

Toye

combination

does

and

above

not use the

Web

but instead

uses

reference
as

engineers

extensively

discussed

combination

the

teaches

by innovative

teaches

proposed

an

away

by the

PATENT
Attorney Docket
Client Reference

No
No

006-4-1
94-108-3

CONCLUSION
In

early date

view

is

Examiner

Application please

Applicants

allowance

for

believe

The issuance

all

of

believes

telephone

telephone

the undersigned

conference
at

925

Reg
OFFICE OF CHARLES

P.O.Box
Walnut
Tel

KRUEGER

5607
Creek

925

CA

944-3320

now pending
Notice

94596

Fax

925

944-3363

32

would

of

expedite

944-3320

Charles

LAW

claims
fonnal

in this

Allowance

at

an

requested

respectfully

If the
this

of the foregoing

are in condition

Application

No

Krueger

30077

prosecution

of