Eolas Technologies Incorporated v. Adobe Systems Incorporated et al

Filing 875

***FILED IN ERROR. SEE DOCUMENT 877 FOR CORRECT PLEADING*** MOTION to Seal Document [DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OF INVALIDITY FOR LACK OF WRITTEN DESCRIPTION by Adobe Systems Incorporated, Amazon.com Inc., CDW Corporation, Citigroup Inc., Google Inc., J.C. Penney Company, Inc., Staples, Inc., The Go Daddy Group, Inc., Yahoo! Inc., YouTube, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Affidavit, # 2 Exhibit A, # 3 Exhibit B, # 4 Exhibit C, # 5 Exhibit D, # 6 Exhibit E, # 7 Exhibit F, # 8 Exhibit G, # 9 Exhibit H, # 10 Exhibit I, # 11 Exhibit J, # 12 Exhibit K, # 13 Exhibit L, # 14 Exhibit M, # 15 Text of Proposed Order)(Reines, Edward) Modified on 8/18/2011 (mll, ).

EXHIBIT G

Application

of Doyle

Application

Num

Filed December

For

90/007858

22

Distributed

2005

Method

Hypermedia

for Automatically

External

Invoking

Within

and Display of Embedded Objects

Interaction

Providing

Application

al

et

Document

Hypermedia

Examiner Pokrzywa J.R
Art unit

3992

Declaration

Edward

Felten declare

and the Regents

in the field

Curriculum Vitae which

Edward

Felten

follows

as

have been retained by Eolas
serve as an expert

of

of computer

of the University

science

my technical

recites

of California to

My

and Internet software

expertise

attached

is

hereto

to

as

Exhibit

Qualifications

B.S

am

in

degree

Ph.D

in

Honors

with

graduated

Science

University where

Affairs

am

Professor

Professor

Science

in

was

Computer Science

Computer
appointed

or co-author

have been asked

Office

in

1993

in

as Professor

to

1991 and

in

Princeton

at

Princeton

at

promoted

Professor

of Computer

1985 with

of Washington

was

1999 and

States

Patent

are unpatentable

Patent

Cohen issued
respectfully

disagree

believe

that

patentability over
to

to

publications

These publications

of

Science

Action

in connection

as being anticipated

Cohen

relating
listed

are

the arguments presented

No 5838906 the 906

United

described

Science

of numerous

address

to

the

2007

instead

Science

Computer

in

of

and Internet software

30

M.S

1993 both from the University

in

in

as

to

Computer

and Public

2006

the author

science

July

of

of

2003

in

an

of Technology

Institute

Computer Science and Public Affairs
have taught since 1993
was originally hired

Professor

currently

Associate

received

Physics

Computer

an Assistant

from the California

For the reasons

the claims

of the

the cited references

906

in

computer

my CV
Action mailed

the reexamination of
that

U.S

the claims

Patent

described

with the arguments presented

to

in the Office

with

Patent
by

in

in

this

No

of the

906

5367621

declaration

the Office

Action and

meet the requirements

for

as those patentability arguments have

been

Patent

fully

me

ATTACHMENT

To

familiarize myself with

documents

have reviewed numerous
its

the documents

history

file

referenced

or cited

My discussion
and teacher

the issues involved

also based

Web

and as

and

Action

my

on

Patent

and

other documents

all

user and network

software

From

developer
of

researcher

science

computer

as

experience

have gained an independent understanding

experience

906

the

the following

including

cited in the Office

declaration

in this

is

of the claims

in the rejection

how

this

the browser

art

developed
II

Response

the

to

have been told by patent
be obtained

told

forth in the claim

prior

art

reference

is

about

silent

may

be

present

by

the claims

Microsoft

level

knows how

how

what

but just an average

do things

to

Web

the Mosaic

forms and

skill

ordinary

in

matter
it

is

the

in

such

that

necessarily

would be so recognized

the claim construction

using

Circuit in the Eolas

in the art

in the

skill

One of

browsers

in

ways

but

were

just

art

ordinary

browser worked

helper

person who

is

college

or

is

just

university

person who has gained an

or

experience

conventional

at

program

student

through

means

the industry

This

person

does not exhibit an unusual

thinking

those of ordinary

and

that

and

Art

of knowledge

of innovative

1994

am

Patent

good computer science

student

equivalent

Web

for

from

star

In

906

of the

single

when

the art

in

of Skill in the

My benchmark
graduating

11

skill

the missing descriptive

and

in

such gap

characteristic

extrinsic evidence

the reference

in

described

litigation

The Level

level

inherent
to

element as

serve as an anticipation

to

by Judge Zagel and upheld by the Federal

established

not

clear that

of ordinary

In reading

10

it

prior art reference

or inherently

that

may not

patent

each and every

if

only

Action

Office

that

by

anticipated

either expressly

the asserted

the thing described

persons

is

anticipated

with recourse

filled

evidence must make
in

is

have further been told

reference

reference

found

is

matter

claim

that

in the

and the Regents

for Eolas

counsel

the patents subject

if

have further been
set

Arguments Raised

Unpatentability

skill

becoming

familiar with

would have had

general

the

idea of

and would have been familiar with hyperlinks

applications

The 906 Patent
12 The
to

claims

of the

include

within

briefly
that

stated

provides

information

on

the client

by providing

embed

text

906

Patent

describe

the boundaries
in

by including

to identify

computer

and locate
to

display

web browser
format how

to

that

use

that allows

web page

authors

web page interactive objects
This is done
web pages HTML text an embed text format

of
the

about where

information

technology

to

get the objects

an executable
the data and to

knows how

type

to

information

provide
parse the
to

with

data along

application

that

will be invoked
with

interactivity

HTML

to

it and

extract the

identify and locate

the

executable
the client
allow

13

how

application

and how

computer

the executable

interface

to

with

the user to interact

My analysis

invoke

to

it

within

on Claim

of patentability will focus

similar to Claim

the only material

computer program product

and Claim

very

Accordingly

of

all

my

from the patentability of the underlying

Prior Art Browsers

14 The

Action

Office

discussion

Actions

most advanced

15

1994

In

offered

form

to

be

only

file

very

known

as helper

the browser

For example

i.e

and

have reviewed

file

The

history

on the Mosaic

all

Office

was

which

browser

relatively

view another

to

submit

the

new technology
page could

contain

page could

page

which when

result

would

be

button

be

the browser

encountered

in

MPEG

the

that

on

format

MPEG

to link to

file

program and pass

clicked

was implemented

applications

the user clicked

if

movie

an external MPEG-viewer

The

Patents

allowed

technology

where

in .mpeg format

program

Action follows

page

This

cases

click

by

did not understand

launch

product

as well

limited form of interactivity

see another

to

browser
in

906

the

the user with

out

16 Another technology

program

covers

such

the Office

prior art

young and browsers were

was

filled

caused the user

Mosaic

admitted

of this prior art focuses

on which the user could

hyperlinks

in

is

prior art browser

Web

the

Browsers

in

discussed

Claim

using

Claim

to

Claim

Mosaic

Including

referenced

prior art references

for

independent Claims

the applicants

cites

window

Patent

that

being

applies

claims

906

method

covers

so as to

application

of the browser

of the

difference

analysis of Claim

of the other dependent

Patentability

the executable

to

the boundaries

on

to execute

application

whose format

file to

in

to

pointed

the browser

.mpeg
ran

program

the

the browser

that

hyperlink

then

the

in

an external

would

that

separate

window

from the browser

17 Helper

could

program

application

within

19 These methods

to

link to an external
the browser

within

interactivity

Web

allowed

the confines
are

all

ran on the

that

of

Web page
Web pages

implemented

program but that
The helper

window

same computer

in

author

to

place

fully interactive

display

in todays

browsers

and they are

all

in

use

today

906 Claim
20

the browser

was just an external program

of these methods

objects

the

not provide

window

separate

18 None

allowed

applications

Mosaic

lacked

Among

the required

automatic

at least

Elements

Lacking

in

Mosaic

three elements required

elements lacking

in

Mosaic

invocation and display of the object

by

the claims

of the

were an embed
within

906

text

the browser

Patent

format

window

on

Mosaic Lacked

21

Mosaic

lacked

Mosaic

used an ordinary

with

22

helper

Claim

document
Patent

23

said

906

claims

link to

to

that

distributed

first

format located

text

Text

format of the

text

hyperlink

Embed

any data

Format
Instead

was

to be displayed

document

includes

that

application

requires that

embed

embed

the required

Required

the

location

first

at

the location

specifies

hypermedia
in

said

of at least

distributed

first

hypermedia

906

of an object

portion

an

1814-18

at

were specified

HTML

the

example

Mosaic

in

Hyperlinks

using

an

short

for

Anchor

For

tag

element

hrefhttpI/example.com/page.htmllink.czla
would cause
the user

link

the text

and navigate

Similarly

the

HTML

URL

the

to

link

word

on the underlined

clicked

hyperlink

24

be displayed typically in underlined

to

blue

the browser would

type

follow

If

the

httpllexample.com/page.html

element

hrefhttp//example.com/video.mpgvideoIa
would

cause

on the underlined

clicked
the

URL

format

lacked

906

underlined

the browser

blue

If

type

would download

and launch

helper

text

immediately

the user

the file at
to

application

Examiner

references

..

that

states

Mosaic

that

are not seen

to

hypermedia document
object

external

Action

at

teach

the

that

paragraph

27

Mosaic

as

text

format

embed

Mosaic

was

significant

allowed the browser

it

was

28

Claim

includes

browser

to

present

to

and special

in

Mosaic Lacked
the required

automatically

which requires
that

invoke
that

is without

location

NCSA Mosaic

of limitations requiring

workstation

having an embed
the

format the

text

combination

specifies

the limitation

embed

said client

at

14 emphasis

further lacked

automatically

the

that

parses

text format

first

included

in the

portion of an

of at least

hypermedia document..

to the first distributed

ii

1823-25

lacks

hypermedia document

distributed

embed

browser

an embedded object

browser application

executing

of an

use

special tag the

should be included

needed

was

processing

The

format

the prior art Mosaic

over

used

an embedded object

that

specify

embed

the

recognize

user

in

the browser instead

system

to

improvement

26 The

photo

word

http//example.com/video.mpg

In the claimed
text

be displayed

to

it

display

25

video

the text

Office

original
the

automatic

wherein

invocation

said

embed

said executable

the executable
requiring

Automatic

Required

any

text

of the
format

application

application
action

Invocation

906

claims

is

parsed

906

Patent

by said
at

be invoked

such as

mouse

click

from the

29

In

Mosaic

All hyperlinks

hyperlink
launch

helper

the launching

30

Automatic

to

helping

31

Mosaic
within

32

over

906

of the

interactive

30

This

object

33

Mosaic

application

allowed

web page
web page

of the

part

claim element of displaying

to

the limitation
within

the

thus

Window

the object

interactive

at

1826-

of the

processing

window

displayed

separate

new window

launched

Patent

window

in

said

at

document

hypermedia

window 906

be displayed and

to

area created

display

of said first distributed

and

said object

display

an area in the browser

within

new window

this

906

906

invocation

Display within the Browser

browser-controlled

first

applications

was

Therefore

the enclosing

be an integral

of said object

the portion
said

in

helper

Automatic

the user visited

includes

requires the object

application

used

Patent

be enabled

to

click

the claimed

in

improvement

Required

the required

processing

within

being displayed

the

mouse

such

window

the browser

location

first

appear

To

by the user to be activated

click

make

browser

to

via an ordinary

not automatic

an important

Mosaic Lacked

Claim

was

applications

the object

further lacked

enable

the user had to

immediately when

make

iii

mouse

required

was

was launched

application

the prior art Mosaic

appear
to

helper

application

of helper

invocation

technology
object

above

stated

as

was created and

The new window

exclusively

was entirely separate from any window

When

helper

the helper

application

used by the helper

used or controlled

by the

browser

34 The

ability

within

processing

Mosaic
allowed
display
in

906 technology
browser window was

of the claimed

browser

the

Enabling

the object
This

more

natural model

of any descriptive

text

integral

part of the

for users allowing

appearing

over the prior

art

window

the browser

within

interactivity

interactive

advance

significant

appear seamlessly as an

to

was

the context

display and

display and enable

to

web pages

the object

to

be placed

on the web page

The Cohen Reference

35 Cohen

describes

system

that

allows

specific multimedia presentations

the author

accompanying

Cohen Does Not Anticipate

36 The
by

Examiner

Cohen

argues

that the claims

respectfully

disagree

of

the

906

this

of the

to

specify

book

Claims

1-3 and 6-8 of the

with

book

softcopy

the text

906

Patent

are anticipated

the reasons

conclusion

for

on Claim

of the

given

below

37 As

discussed

above

analysis of Claim

Claims
Claims

and
and

my

analysis will focus

also applies to
follows

Claim

Non-anticipation

from non-anticipation

906

Patent

My

of the dependent

of the underlying

independent

38

Several

of Claim

elements

elements of

interactive

browser

identify

and locate

Claim

an executable

906

of the

the

Patent

40

and enable interactive

the

requires that

interactive

sending

by using

the

mouse

discusses

interactive

the

to

object 259-60
describing

how

graphics

946-104

stereo

fi

high
object

124-23

thereon

the

workstation 137-9

Audio

displayed

processing

42 The

and the graphics

does not point

processing

some

aspects of

the Examiner

an object

43 Nor

is

this

within

interactive

processing

design

when

of

that

the main book

external

program

to

reader
finish

output
to

output

the

to

object

data from the

...

presentation
disk player

is

the

at

support

the appropriate

discuss

.. and

displayed

the audio

graphic

190 which

.. as the graphics

in

Cohen

discusses

Cohen

is

interactive

as

for the element of
single unit
cites

longer
in

support

But none of the material

discloses interactive

portion

Cohen

for

cited by

processing

of

window
Cohen
with

Displaying

an

object

does not

the object

with interactive

program invokes
before

to

and the Examiner

inherent in

incompatible

object 831-35

window

the user can interact

Cohen was

to

display coupled

audio

output

for the audio

of the claim

that

this

ALT_OBJECT

is

any support

portion

the notion

is

browser

browser-controlled

necessarily require

44 The

longer

supports

Cohen

from the multimedia

Nowhere does Cohen

32

at

the

244-47 transferring

on the display 208

generated

The Examiner

Action

of the claim Office

to

is

is

at

to

...
fi

picture

110

data in the object

within

the structure

of the object

from the compact

the object

208

Examiner

interactive

high

animation for the

of the object

the user

that

must occur within

data from the audio

presentation

information

on the display

visible

it

displayed 846-56 displayed

is

the stereo

data form

The

software

support

to

means

of the multimedia

the audio

of the resulting motion

the presentation

1352-1410

transfer

of the video

p1aying

1321-51

the presentation

to produce the audio

stored

nowhere

See e.g Cohen

an animation object

to

at

enable

also

make

can change

processing

the multimedia data

device

support

device

Patent

processing

but
to

is

processing

processing

the object but

of the object

the multimedia output

audio

interactive

display

906

of interactive

said

displayed

is

object

display

or similar input

The

displaying

processing

order to

in

the object

Interactive

does not expressly disclose interactive

repeatedly

to

To

invoke

of said object

the element

lacks

device

or keyboard

display area where

workstation

client

system not only display said object

of the object

or presentation

41 Cohen

Cohen

an output

to

it

automatically

processing

of the object

processing

e.g by

to

Processing

on said

execute

emphasis added

browser

by

the browser

requires that

application

Claim

format display of the object

text

Interactive

Required

said object

to

the

application

executable

1824-27

For example Cohen lacks

Cohen

and the use of type information

Cohen Lacks

39

in

an embed

processing

window

within

are absent

In

processing

an external program

it

Cohen

waits for the

resuming the main book reader program

While

the external

cannot accept

e.g

in

description

This

input

After

Columns

the completion

started

back

proceeds

step 420 to

to

program had

external

tried

would have frozen

switch

Cohen

45 By

book

it

to

wait

in

contrast

interactive

the invention

reader

the option

activate

by the user

of the external
If

for user

interaction

the user no

giving

the

would have

this

processing

program

The

way

role of the external program

in

and then stop running
of the 906 Patent

in Claim

defined

and the external program can both be active
so the user has

to

requested

running waiting

book

the main

pointer

input from the user

program can accept

to continue

is

was

the flow

the completion

after

only

page of the e-book

different

new page

execution

FIG

mouse

for another

until

to provide

display the object

to

is

is

reader

the external program

required

to

Notably

the main

that

program

which

1122-27

at

program whose

handler

link tag or alternatively to wait

Cohen

of Cohen and the accompanying

of the flow diagram of

of step 426

result

as

of the 110

and

frozen

is

program

For example

and 11

10

reader

from Fig

evident

is

book

the main

running

is

program

of seamlessly

and accepting

input

the object

with

interacting

the browser

same time

the

at

or navigating

the browser

46 One

of the main achievements

with

objects

but cannot provide

element of the invention

906

Web

within

an object seamlessly

display

of the

defined

page

interactive
in

Claim

47

Claim

of the

document

906

includes

an embed

hypermedia document

distributed

of an object

external

wherein said embed
said executable
processing
the portion

the

to

of the

is

in

application

of said object

at

which

can

an important

missing

the location

document

at

document

in

said

of at least

to

..

first

portion

and
invoke

automatically

and enable

display said object
area created

hypermedia

location

first

by said browser

hypermedia

Cohen

Patent

distributed

hypermedia

display

distributed

first

parsed

order to

within

first

specifies

distributed

first

format

text

that

is

Text Format

format located

text

906

interaction

provide

like

processing
of the

said

Patent requires that

to

system

Embed

Cohen Lacks the Required

was

inventors

interactive

said first location

.. 906

Patent

within
at

1814-29

48 The
in

of an

use

Claim

Mosaic
states

embed

of the
is

that

that

the

Patent

they lacked

NCSA

parses

format
least

an important

executing

format

text

references

element of the invention

of many prior

browsers

defined

such

as

For example the examiner

.. are not

browser

art

seen

application

to
at

teach

the combination

said client

workstation

hypermedia document having an embed text
hypermedia document that specifies the location

distributed

included in the

portion of an object

document..

49 Cohen

first

is

One drawback

an embed

Mosaic

of limitations requiring
that

format

text

906

Office

Action

external
at

to the

paragraph

first

distributed

14 emphasis

does not disclose the use of an embed

text

format

in

hypermedia

original

of at

50 The

Examiner

embed

states

format

text

respectfully

51 The LDESC

Action

Office
with

disagree

link

the

that

embed

claim

includes

an embed text format
document

Patent

1814-28

at

embedded

e.g

document

format within

The

prologue
invention

to

Cohen

the

The link

book

description
with

text

fact

in

being

in the

The

of the document

la

Figure
in

figures

rather than in

the files prologue

the structure

depicts

in
tags 102 also depicted
104 which is also depicted

54 The link
embed

the

text

external

to

format ..

the

the location

specify

document

This

embed

appear

ib See

file

from the

are distinct

Figure

in the

e.g

it

lacks

of anything

not
that

text

but

the required

also Figs

book

is

text

906

one

claims

cannot be the

it

claim

element of an

portion

906

the location

external

the

of at least

document

specify
is

in

format of the

text

book

the location

hypermedia

Cohen does

location

at

be the embed

specifies

distributed

first

tag of

link

that

not

appear

either because

format

text

Cohen does

of

tag

embed

The

LDESC tag does
LDESC tag cannot

the

that

why

reason

18

tags

LDESC

tag

58-li emphasis added

at

the

with

8b

8a and

53 The

the

For example Figure

text

link description

.. Cohen
LDESC tags as

text

files

in accordance

upon

embed

location

in the document

tag appears

document

906
the

of the

the required

at

tags are improved

new multimedia

provide

processing

hypermedia

the location

to

the document

in

distributed

first

and enable interactive

the distributed

in

the

satisfy

at said first location

corresponds

link description

also depict

book

that

appear

BookMaster

of the

prologue
in

tag does not

LDESC

the

Instead

Web

said

in

claim element requires that

This

location

at

page
document

the

52 The LDESC

display

location

first

said object

emphasis added

the

below

hypermedia document

distributed

at

area created

be displayed

object

are the

format because they do not

first

located

.. to display

within

Cohen

of

For the reasons described

text

element wherein said

required

of said object

31

at

LDESC

tags

conclusion

this

tags cannot be the

hypermedia

description

of an object

Patent

1815-

at

of an object nor does

to the first distributed

it

hypermedia

format

text

55 Cohens
more

design

why

that

electronic

Cohen was

books

often repeat

in the document

repeat

in

document

where

the object

suited for use

separately
or inherently

For

solve

Cohen was

Web

Cohen allowed an element

the document

each time

at least

described

prologue
was

on the
this
in

to

Web

to

that

By

be used
where

to

without

there could

pages

single tag

the

be
at

files that

the link tag and
to

having

single link

each place

The claimed 906 design by

individual

larger

given

multi-page

separating

and one small link tag

the

for use with

designed

be repeated

Instead

refers

makes sense

are large

pages

reason the use of

Cohen

Cohen cannot be

prologue

elements on different pages

the full link description

description

better

trying

to

of

tag

small simple link tag

These books unlike

graphic

link description

the link

of having

strategy

detailed link description

problem

is

one reason

is

in

the

contrast

are provided
is

not expressly found

56

Another reason

Cohen and Mosaic

that

Cohen nor Mosaic

had an embed

Cohen Lacks

57

Claim

906

of the

within
Patent

Patent

27-30 Cohen

discloses displaying

59 The

Examiner

single unit

Examiner

of the object

on

screen but there

to

Cohen

in

Cohen

in

any support

window

some

for

discloses displaying

of the object

no disclosure of the

is

32

at

aspects of this longer

Cohen

of the

portion

the notion

supports

as

discusses

and the

that

display area in the browser-

within

window
within

within

window

The Examiner

But none of the material cited by the Examiner

Displaying

906

the object

for the element of

Action

claim

60

take place

element of displaying

of the claim Office

portion

support

controlled

Window

window

browser-controlled

first

the browser-controlled

longer

cites

said

the required

the object

does not point

within

displaying

the display

an area of the browser-controlled

within

happening

neither

that

window

the browser-controlled

display

is

Display within the Browser

requires that

lacks

Claim

format

text

Required

within

area ..

display
at

58 Cohen

the

do not anticipate

In

Cohen

displaying

place

does not necessarily

window

controlled
in

window

the browser-controlled

The

separate

window

as

take place

Cohen

disclosure in

Mosaic

with

is

is

inherent in

not

helper

either

the browser-

within

consistent

Cohen

with

the display
or on

applications

taking

separate

device

61 One

reason

Claim

that

Cohen and Mosaic
display

is

lack

Browser
Claim

906

of the

associated

with

it

Patent

utilized

1819-22

Cohen

63 The Examiners only

Use of Type Information

wherein

by said browser

lacks

first

this

discussion

the object

and Locate an Executable

requires

that

is

both

within

window

Required

to Identify

external to the

application
at

element of displaying

the require

the

by Cohen and Mosaic

anticipated

area in the browser-controlled

Cohen Lacks

62

not

to

distributed

said object

the

Application

has

type

identify and locate

hypermedia

by

information

an executable

906

document

Patent

element
of this element of Claim

in relation

to

Cohen

is

as follows

See Fig

DATA

graph.exe

graph.exe

Office

Action

reading

the

whereby

at

program

disclosure

1-32

pp

DATA

being the executable
of

executable
the browser

is

..

the external

external

to

application

application

FORMAT

line

utilizing

as being

in

is

specified

However

the Examiner

la of

Cohen

to

the

document

the Examiner

information

as

Fig la wherein

is

apparently

the type information and graph.exe

the type

Nor does Fig

seen

the hypermedia

In this discussion

application

browser

executable

\GOCA

does not point

identify

depict

to

and locate

as

any
the

any steps performed

by

64

Cohen

In

utilize

the book

reader

type information

the

does with

this

information

which invokes

is to

that

it

pass

it

follows

to the operating

reader

system

does not have any kind of

reader

identify and locate

to

not

book

All the

anything

on unexamined

The book

browser does

to

equates

to identify and locate

the application

or procedure

algorithm

the Examiner

which

be

to

an application

used

65 The

identify and locate

an important

example

as

Web

pages

cause an executable

of

or modify the state

that

that

defined

his

done by the browser

is

step

Claim

in

of the

come from

that

If

choice

Patent

For
to

sources such

untrusted
of such

the author

site

can

be invoked on the users system

to

to gain access

application

906

is

Users often want

security protection

sites

arbitrary

application

can use

then the site author
files

that

hypermedia documents

come from

that

fact

an important

step provides

distributed

display

of the invention

aspect

this

step and the

of the users computer

to

the users private

for example to install

spyware or

virus

66

the browser

Having

executable

application
written

properly

protecting
malicious

application

author

References
locate

67 The

that

is

which the browser does not

in

importance of

68

because

site
is

it

identifying and locating the application
utilize

be run thereby
cannot run

the browser
that

will be

type information

claim element was reinforced
of which

the question

to

author

to

not the

run

identify and

lack this protection

application

this

litigation in which

ifi

problems

security

the

the user from this danger

hostile

on the users computer

the executable

an important

the browser protect

browser will only allow trusted applications

the user against

site

identify and locate

program trusted by the user
lets

by the Eolas
had

references

this

Microsoft

was

claim element

one

Conclusion
For the reasons given
being

is

unpatentable

anticipated

declare

by

that

statements

the references

all

statements

made on

these statements
the like
Section

so

made

conclude

above
incorrect

The

the rejection

that

claims

cited in the Office

made

information

herein

of

are punishable
that

such

27

by

fine

that

2007

statements

to

Edward

Felten

all

be true and further
false

statements

or both under 18

may jeopardize

the patent

Dated September

as

are true and that

willful

or imprisonment

false

and

patent were not

Action

and belief are believed

willful

of claims

my knowledge

were made with the knowledge

1001 and

906

of the

that

and

U.S.C

the validity of

Edward
Dept

Felten

of Computer

Princeton

University

35 Olden
Princeton

Science

Street

NJ 08540

609258-5906

609

258-1771

fax

[e-mail]

Education
Ph.D

in

B.S

in

title

Physics

Engineering

University

and

with Honors

Lazowska

Engineering

Communication

and

California Institute

John

for

Zahorjan
1991

of Washington

University

1993

of Washington

Compilation High-Performance

Advisors Edward

Science

Computer

in

and

Protocol

Programs

Parallel

M.S

Science

Computer

Dissertation

1985

of Technology

Employment
Professor

of Computer

Associate

Professor

Assistant Professor
Senior

University

Secure

Director

Princeton

U.S Dept
case

2003-present

Science Princeton

of Computer

Science Princeton

Computing Analyst Caltech Concurrent

1999-2003

University
University

1993-99

Computing Project California

Institute

1986-1989

of Technology

Internet

Programming Laboratory

University

of Computer

Dept

Science

1996-present

of Justice Antitrust

Division

consulting and

testimony

in

Microsoft

antitrust

1998-2002

Robins Kaplan Miller
Keker

Princeton

Science

of Computer

Van Nest

Electronic

Frontier

Ciresi

Consulting

Foundation

Consulting
in intellectual

Consulting

and

in patent

testimony

property
in intellectual

lawsuit

speech

lawsuit

free

property

free

1998-2003

2002

speech

lawsuits

2001-present
Certus

Ltd

consultant

Cigital

Inc

Technical

Cloakware
Propel.com

Ltd

Technical

Technical

LLC

Java

design and

analysis 2000-2002

Board member 2000-present

Advisory

Advisory

Scientific

Sun Microsystems
Finjan Software

product

Technical

NetCertainty.com

FullComm

in

Advisory

Board member 2000-present

Board member 2000-2002

Advisory

Advisory

Board member 1999-2002
Board member

1999-2001

Board member 1997-present
Board member 1997-2002

Security Advisory

Technical

Advisory

EXHIBIT

Creative

International

consultant

Technologies

Bell Communications

Research

consultant

in

in

product design and analysis

computer

security

research

1997-98

1996-97

Honors and Awards
America 50 Award 2003

Scientific

Alfred

Sloan

Emerson

Electric

University

NSF

Best Paper

ATT

Lawrence

Young

Investigator

1995

award

Ph.D

ACM

Computer

security

SIGMETRICS

Systems

Principles

Conference

1991-93

Fellowship

especially

relating

systems

Operating

and operating

languages

on Operating

Interests

software

Internet

Symposium

1991-93

Fellowship

Mercury Seven Foundation

Research

Princeton

award 1994

1997

award

Award

1996

of Engineering

Paper

Advancement

Keyes Faculty

School

National

Outstanding

1997

Fellowship

to

consumer products
of security

Interaction

systems Distributed computing

Technology law and policy
with programming

Parallel

computing

architecture

and software

Professional

Service

Pro fessional Societies and Advisory Groups

ACM

Advisory

DARPA

ISAT

Co-chair
National

USENIX

IEEE

Reconciling

group 2002-present
2001-2002

Security with Privacy

on Foundations

on Foundations

of Computer

Science

2001-present

on

2004
2003
2001
Management

of Computer

Digital

Rights

Security

Communications Security 2001

Conference

on

Computer

and

Conference

on

Electronic

Commerce 2001

on Security and

Society

on

Technical

USENIX Windows
Society

Privacy

Symposium

Symposium

USEND
Internet

2002-2003

JSAT advisory

Committees

Workshop

Workshop
Internet

on

study committee

General Conference

Workshop

Privacy

and Technology

Science

study committee

Academy

Program

ACM
ACM
ACM

Committee on Security and

Information

Security

in Digital

on Network
and

and

Rights

Management 2001

Distributed

System Security

2001

Privacy 2000

Conference 2000
Systems

Symposium

Conference 2000
on Network

and

Distributed

System Security 2000

IEEE Symposium

on

Security and

ACM

on

Computer

Conference

USENIX
USENIX

1998

Privacy

and

Communications Security 1998

Symposium 1998

Security
Technical

1998

Conference

Symposium

on Operating

Corporate

and

1996

Advisory Boards

Systems Design

Sun Microsystems Java Security Advisory
Cigital

Inc

Technical

Ltd

Cloakware
Propetcom

Fiujan Software
Netcertainty

FullComm

LLC

Faculty

Advisory

Board

Service

Committee on Policy

of the Princeton

University

2002-present

Community

Committee on Athletics

Advisory

Academic

Science

Computer

Board

Board

and Departmental

Advisory

Council

Advisory

Advisory

Scientific

Board

Board

Advisory

Technical

University
Faculty

Advisory

Technical

Council

Board

Advisory

Technical

Technical

Implementation

Executive

2002-present

Committee

1998-2000

Advisor B.S.E program

of 1998

class

approx

25

students
Faculty-Student

Committee on Discipline

1996-98

Faculty-Student

Committee on Discipline

Subcommittee on Sexual Assault and

Harrassment 1996-98

Students Advised
Ph.D Advisees
Minwen

Ji

Ph.D 2001

Researcher
Dirk

at

Ph.D 2000

Balfanz

Researcher

Dan

at

Wallach

Robert

Distribution

File

Ph.D

expected

Systems

using

Ad Hoc

New
Rice

Science

2004

Control for

Web

Dynamic

Content

Collaboration

Center

Dissertation

of Computer

for

Center

Access

Xerox Palo Alto Research

Shillner

Distributed

Data

Dissertation

Ph.D 1998

Professor

Assistant

Dissertation

Compaq Systems Research

Approach

to

Mobile Code

Security

University

Tentative

dissertation

Disk

Shared

Logical

2003

Dissertation

title

Technical

Improving

staff

member

at

Google
Michael

Schneider

Denial

PhD

of Service

Significant Advisory

Drew Dean Ph.D
Stefanos
Pei

expected

University

Network

Defenses

against

Role

1998

Damianakis Ph.D

Cao Ph.D 1996

topic

Attacks

Advisor Andrew
1998

at SRI International
Appel Researcher
Advisor Kai Li President Netrics Inc

Advisor Kai Li

of Wisconsin

On leave

Assistant Professor
at Cisco Systems

of Computer

Sciences

Lujo

Bauer Ph.D 2003

Advisor Andrew

Postdoctoral

Appel

researcher at Carnegie-

Mellon University

Publications

Books and Book
Freedom

to

Securing

Chapters

Tinker

Java

Edward
Java

Edward

Down

Getting

Felten

John

Web

Security

Felten

Scofflaws

Beyond Drew Dean

Browsers and

Dorothy

Internet

In

and

Denning

Gary McGraw

and

Sons New York 1999

Wiley and

and Dirk Balfanz

Wallach

Code

Business with Mobile

to

2004

Publication expected

Edward

Besieged Countering

Peter

eds

Denning

Dan

Felten

Cyberspace

ACM

New York

Press

1997
Java

Applets Holes

Hostile

Security

Tree

Dynamic

Performance

and

Gary McGraw

Antidotes

and Edward

Sons New York 1996

John Wiley and

Felten

Steve

Searching

Otto and

Sabot

Computing Gary

Felten

Edward

ed

In

Addison Wesley

High

1995

Journal Articles

Mechanisms

for

Modular Programming

Secure

The

illinois

DRM

Journal

and

ACM
The

Millennium

Digital

of

Fair

April

Java

Software

Practice

and

and

its

Technology and Policy

View

Skeptical

View

Legacy
Fall

Edward

from the Trenches

2002
Communications of

Felten

the

2003

Known

Security Architecture Formerly

Mechanism

for

Andrew

Appel

94

Act

Copyright

Law

Use

in

2003

Experience 33461-480

Systems Dan

Language-based

ACM

as Stack

on Software

Transactions

Inspection

Wallach

Security

Edward

Engineering

Felten

and

and

Methodology

2000

October

Statically

Scanning

Mutdosch

Gary

Java

Code

McGraw

and

Finding

John

Security Vulnerabilities

Edward

Felten

IEEE Software

Viega

175

Tom

Sept/Oct

2000
Client-Server Computing on the

Angelos Bilas Cezary Dubnicki
February
Fast

RPC

Bilas

and

SHRIMP
and

Multicomputer Stefanos
Edward
Felten
IEEE Micro

Damianakis

1718-18

1997
on

the

SHRIMP

Edward

Computing

February

Virtual

Felten

1997

Memory Mapped Network

IEEE Transactions

on

Parallel

Interface
and

Angelos

Distributed

and Performance

and

Prefetching

ACM

Li

Kai

Transactions

Edward

Dubnicki

Caching

Karlin and

Blumrich Cezary

15121-

Malena Mesarina IEEE Micro

and

Articles

Receiver

via

Anonymity

ACM

Felten

Public

Incomparable

on Computer

Conference

Brent

Keys

Waters

Edward

and

Communications Security

and

2003

November

Obfuscated

an

Attacking

Edward

and

Designs Matthias

Interface

Li

Kai

Anna

Felten

Systems Nov 1996

on Computer

Felten

File

Application-Controlled

Cao Edward

1995

February

Symposium

15

Pei

Memory Mapped Network

Virtual

28

of Integrated

Disk Scheduling

Implementation

by

Cipher

Faults

Injecting

ACM Workshop

Felten

on

Jacob Dan Boneh
Management November

Matthias
Rights

Digital

2002
Genera

and Flexible Access-Control
Edward

Schneider and

Sstem

Web

for the

USENIX

lIt

Felten

Michael

Lujo Bauer

Security

Symposium August

2002
Informed
Batya

Consent

Conference

in the

Mozilla

Browser

Howe

Daniel

Friedman

on System Sciences

Implementing

and Edward
January

Value-Sensitive

Felten

2002

Hawaii

Design

International

Best Paper award

organizational

systems track

Reading

Between

the

Lines Lessons

McGregor Mm
Drew Dean

John

Wallach

Wu

Bede Liu

Adam

Edward

and

SDMI

from the

Ben Swartzlander

Stubblefield

USENIX

Felten

Craver

Scott

Challenge

Dan

Symposium

Security

August 2001
Cookies

Browser Design Toward

Millett Batya

Attacks

Timing

ACM

Conference

An

Archipelago
Internet

6th

ACM

An

Empirical

Edward

of the

Windows

Yuqun Chen
Felten

Douglas

Liviu

International

Iftode

for

Systems

Andrew

SHRIMP

Schneider

and Communications Security

System

on Computer

Study

Online

Consent

Proc of CHI 2001

Felten and Michael

Edward

File

Authentication

Felten

Computing Systems April 2001

on Computer

USENIX

Conference

Proc of 25th

in

Privacy

Island-Based

Services

Proof-Carrying

Alpert

Web

on

Realizing Informed

Friedman and Edward

on Human Factors

Conference

of 7th

Web

and

Lynette

and

Highly

Symposium

August

Nov 2000
Scalable

2000

Appel and Edward

Felten

Communications Security

Nov

System

Matthias

Clark Stefanos
Margaret

Symposium

Available and

Martonosi

on Computer

Proc

Proc of
1999

Blumrich Richard
Cezary

Dubnicki

Shiliner and

Kai

Dainianakis
Robert

Architecture

June

1998

Li

Performance

Measurements

and

Felten

Java

Understanding
of 1998

Li Proc

Kai

for

Stack

SIGMIETRICS Conference
Dan

Inspection

Wallach and

on Security and

IEEE Symposium

Dan

Dean

Oct

Principles

Web

1997 Outstanding

Spoofing An

Dean

Dan

and

Drew

Dirk Balfanz

Symposium

on Operating

Dirk

Felten

National

20th

Proc

Felten

Systems

Award

Paper

Proc of

Edward

Wallach

ACM

Con Game Edward

Internet

Wallach

Conference Oct
Reducing

Proc of 16th

Felten

1998

June

1998

May

Privacy

Extensible Security Architectures for Java

and Edward

Programs Minwen Ji Edward

Multithreaded

of 1998

Information

Balfanz Drew

Systems

Security

1997
Communication

Costs in User-Level

Waiting

Yuqun Chen

and

Edward

Symposium

April

Stefanos

Damianakis

1997

Stream

Sockets

Edward

on

as

Lecture Notes

Bilas

Angelos

Damianakis
23rd Intl

Symposium

Dan

and

Felten

Felten

Wallach

to

Multicomputer Richard

Netscape

Proc of 1996

Iftode

Prefetching
Brian

Karlin and
and
and

Kai Li Proc of

and

1996

Patterson

Anna

Architectural

Proceedings

Clark Stefanos

Liviu

for Parallel

Hugo

Systems Design

From HotJava

SHRIMP

the

Architecture

Gibson

Garth

on Operating

Security

on

Edward

Tonikins

and

1199

Blumrich Douglas

on Computer

Processing

1997

February

Science

Comparison of Algorithms

Felten

Symposium
Java

Matthias

Kimbrel Andrew

Edward

Computing

Computer

in

Parallel

on Communication and

Workshop

Parallel

Cezary Dubnicki

Trace-Driven
Tracy

1st Intl

Intl

Damianakis Cezary Dubnicki

with Message-Passing

Early Experience
Alpert

Stefanos

Network-Based

for

available

SHRIMP
Proc of

Felten

Support

Proc of 11th

Felten

and

Caching

Bershad Pei

Cao

Kai Li Proc of 1996

Implementation

Beyond Drew Dean

IEEE Symposium

Edward

on Security and

Privacy
Parallel

Integrated

Felten

Anna

Software
Liviu

Support

Iftode

Symposium
Protected

Prefetching

Improving
Liviu

DMA

Symposium

for the

High-Performance

Cezary Dubnicki
on

SHRIMP

Edward

Release-Consistent

Iftode

Edward

Conference

1996

Blumrich Cezary Dubnicki
on

Cao

Memory-Mapped Communication Cezary Dubnicki
Felten and Kai Li Proc of Intl Parallel Processing

Edward
April

Pei

SIGMETRICS

for Virtual

User-Level

Symposium

and Caching Tracy Kimbrel

Karlin and Kai Li Proc of 1996

Edward

High-Performance

Felten

Computer

Shared

Network

Virtual

Matthias

and Kai Li Proc of 2nd

Architecture

Memory

Felten

Computer

Interface

and

Feb

using Automatic
Kai Li Proc

Architecture

Feb

Intl

1996

1996

Update

of 2nd Intl

Wei

Multicomputer Bin
Kai Li Parallel

Felten

Anna

Gordon

Clark Edward

Stoll Douglas

and

Prefetching

Caching Strategies Pci

ACM

Karlin and Kai Li Proc of 1995

Best Paper

Multi-Port

and

Cao

Edward

SIGMETRICS

Conference

award

Evaluating

Felten

Symposium Oct 1995

Rendering

of Integrated

Study

Mesh-Connected

Frame Buffer on

Multi-Port

for

Synchronization

and

Implementation

Edward
and

File

Application-Controlled

Li Proc
Virtual

USENIX

of

Technical

Network

Interface

Blumrich Kai Li Richard

and Jonathan

Performance

Issues

in

Juan

Multiprocessors

Non-Blocking

and

Felten

and Kai

Felten

171-182

1994

Multicomputer

Dubnicki

Edward

on Computer

Chess

Parallel

on

Conference

Symposium

Applicatkns

by Multithreading

of Scalable

Proceedings

High-Performance

1992

Program Edward

Generation

Fifth

of

Proceedings

1992

McNamee

SHPCC

on Shared-Memory

Felten

of Messige-Passing

Dylan

Computing Conference
Highly

SHRIMP

Cezary

Synchronization

Computing

Performance

the

Edward

Edward

Symposium

Intl

Edward

and

Alemany

of Distributed

Principles

Improving

Cao

for the

Cao

Systems

1994

Conference pages

Alpert

Proc of

Sandberg

Caching Pei

1994

Architecture

on

1994

Pei

File

on Operating

165-178 November

Caching Policies

Summer

Memory Mapped

Matthias
Felten

of Application-Controlled

pages

Patrick

Architecture

Kai Li Proc of 1st Symposium

Implementation

Multicomputer

Li and

Kai

Felten

on Computer

Symposium

Performance
and

Felten

Intl

Mesh-Connected

for

Clark Edward

Douglas

Proc of 22nd

Hanrahan

Design

Frame Buffer Designs

Wei

Gordon Stoll Bin

Computer

Felten and

Otto 1988

Steve

Systems

Other Publications

Freedom

technology

Secure

Tinker

to

weblog

law and

policy

Proofs

Private

for

publication

An

Efficient

using Route-Based
Felten
Written

testimony

Internet

and

Property

on

to

to

Brent

4000
Waters

for

Defense

Against

Felten

of Service

Packet

publication

Distributed

Filtering

January

Submitted

Michael

Property

and

Edward

Subcommittee on Courts the

oversight hearing on

Networks

Schneider

Attacks

2003

House Commerce Committee

Peer

Edward

Denial

and

on

per day

readers

2003

for

Intellectual

Peer

Approximately

Distributed

Submitted

Commentary

http//www.freedom-to-tinker.com

of Location

January

Heuristic

at

September 2002

Piracy of

Intellectual

Written

to

testimony

Protect

Digital

Informed

Online

Mechanisms

for

Appel

Computer

Java Filter

Felten
Princeton

DirkBalfanz

404130

Distributed

Contention

Princeton

File

Results

University

Using

Technical

Department of

567-97 Dept

Report

1997
Communications of

the

ACM

technical

report

of

NX

Felten

University

Ph.D

and

TR-524-96

report

and Margaret

Felten

and
Martonosi

TR-508-96

Message Passing Using
Richard

Alpert

technical

University

SHRIMP

Virtual

Cezary Dubnicki

Edward

TR-507-96

report

Communication

Dept

dissertation

of Computer

for Parallel

Programs

and Engineering

Science

August 1993

of Washington

Counting

Disk.Robert

Logical
technical

Multicomputer Analytical

Wenjia Fang Edward

Compilation High-Performance

Edward

Shared

University

an Experimental

and Kai Li Princeton

LaMarca

Dec 2000

Bauer Andrew

CS-TR-603-99

Felten

Princeton

Memory Mapped Communication

Building

Java Lujo

October

Edward

Systems

in

and Implementation

Protocol

in

Batya

Report 2000-12-2

of Washington

University

Felten

University

Felten

and Queueing

Simulation-based

Felten

to

July 1999

University

Security

Edward

and

Design

Working

1997

Simplifying
Shillner

Competition

and Design Principles

Report

and Edward

RISKS Webware

Inside

Technical

Princeton

Science

on

Marketplace

Millett Technical

Modular Programming

Secure

Science

of Computer

and Lynette

and Engineering

Science

and Edward

Model

Conceptual

Felten

of Computer

the

Is

March 2002

Creativity

Consent

Age

Policy in the Digital

Friedman Edward
Dept

Judiciary Committee hearings

Senate

and Public

Innovation

Networks

from Larger Balancers

Richard Ladner

Univ

of Washington

Edward

Felten

technical

Anthony

UW-CSE-93-

report

04-09
Case

Univ

for

Application-Specific

of Washington

technical

Centralized Token-Based
Felten

and Michael

Issues

in the

report

Implementation

of

Univ

Univ

Edward

Felten

TR-92-03-1

Algorithm

Rabinovich

Felten and John Zahorjan

Communication Protocols

for

Distributed

of Washington

Mutual Exclusion
technical

Remote Memory Paging
of Washington

technical

report

System
report

Edward

TR-92-02-02

Edward

TR-9 1-03-09