WI-LAN Inc. v. Alcatel-Lucent USA Inc. et al
Filing
329
NOTICE by Alcatel-Lucent USA Inc., Ericsson Inc., Exedea INC., HTC America, Inc., HTC Corporation, Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., Sony Mobile Communications AB, Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson, WI-LAN Inc. re 99 Order JOINT REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A - Wi-LAN's rebuttal deposition designations and objections to Alcatel-Lucent, Ericsson and Sony Mobiles deposition designations, # 2 Exhibit B - Wi-LANs rebuttal deposition designations and objections to HTCs deposition designations, # 3 Exhibit C - Defendants Alcatel-Lucent, Ericsson, Sony Mobile and HTCs rebuttal deposition designations and objections to Wi-LANs deposition designations)(Weaver, David)
EXHIBIT B
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
TYLER DIVISION
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
WI-LAN INC.,
Plaintiff,
v.
ALCATEL-LUCENT USA INC.; et al.
Defendants.
Civil Action No. 6:10-cv-521-LED
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PLAINTIFF WI-LAN INC.'S REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO
DEFENDANTS HTC CORPORATION, HTC AMERICA, INC. AND EXEDEA INC.’S
DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS
Please take notice that Plaintiff Wi-LAN Inc. ("Wi-LAN") hereby makes the following
objections and rebuttal-designations to Defendants’ trial deposition designations served February
13, 2013:
Witness
Brandt, David
BS/ 403
403
BS/ 403/ 402 R
403/ I
49:11 - 50:8
51:17 - 56:8
56:18 - 60:25
68:17 - 69:13
87:3-25
93:18 - 95:10
96:11-24
Bezryadina, Natalya
HTC Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
21:15 - 22:16
29:11-25
35:20 - 38:16
44:5 - 45:21
Wi-LAN’s Objections
F/ 403/ H/ CS
402 R/ BS/ F/ CS
CS/ BS/ 403/ 402 R
CS/ I
BS
BS/ CS/ F
BS/ CS/ F/ 403
69:16-69:17
15:16-24
22:14 - 24:16
106
20:5—25:4 (already
1
Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal
Designations
46:25-47:01;
47:03-47:08
Witness
HTC Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
Wi-LAN’s Objections
Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal
Designations
designated)
41:17 - 43:19
46:4 - 47:25
64:18 - 65:8
68:20 - 69:11
108:19 - 109:12
117:4 - 122:21
124:23 - 125:24
106
129:10 - 130:23
132:15 - 134:4
148:14 - 150:23
402 R/ 403/ ID
159:3 - 160:20
173:7 - 175:23
176:11 - 181:25
182:12 - 183:1
184:14-21
186:17-21
210:11 - 214:16
403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ L
402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ L
223:23 - 228:2
229:10-21
230:14-19
235:1 - 236:8
Dubuc, Christian
402 R/ 403/ BS
CS/ 403/ BS/ E/ L
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ L
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ 106
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
22:13 - 23:11
33:1 - 34:17
69:13-23
402 R/ 403
CS/ 402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
73:19 - 75:22
402 R/ 403/ BS
85:14 - 86:6
87:23 - 89:9
89:25 - 90:6
92:6 - 93:2
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/
E/ L
2
120:1—124:9
(already designated)
236:9—237:8
124:23—127:21
(already designated)
236:9—237:8
210:11—14
(already designated)
236:9—237:8
Witness
HTC Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
99:10 - 100:5
107:3-8
158:25 - 159:18
161:11-19
163:17-24
164:1-20
165:4 - 167:20
176:6-18
176:24 - 177:1
182:5 - 183:12
191:1-7
191:13-19
202:13 - 203:17
207:4 - 209:2
214:2 - 215:6
225:12 - 226:2
227:19 - 228:22
231:1-11
234:17 - 235:13
236:6-16
237:8 - 238:12
238:24 - 239:20
244:12 - 245:15
246:24 - 247:16
254:17 - 255:2
299:1-16
308:11 - 309:13
327:12-17
344:17 - 346:15
350:6 - 351:16
357:12 - 358:1
McEwan, Shaun
22:21 - 23:16
26:8 - 27:17
29:6-25
33:11-17
34:11 - 36:25
45:2-13
Wi-LAN’s Objections
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/
E/ L
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ E/ L/ ML
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ P
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ BS/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ BS/ ML
402 R/ 403/ BS/ ML
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ ML
402 R/ 403/ L
403/ BS/ F/ CS
403/ BS/ F/ CS
403/ BS/ F/ CS
403/ BS/ F/ CS
403/ I
3
Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal
Designations
Witness
HTC Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
73:20 - 74:12
79:11 - 82:13
87:1 - 88:15
90:23 - 92:7
94:16 - 96:10
105:3-15
113:22 - 114:18
115:20-24
117:10-20
133:4 - 134:13
141:4-17
171:21 - 172:23
182:25 - 183:19
184:22 - 185:12
199:22 - 201:7
206:16 - 207:8
209:10 - 210:9
218:4-25
221:17 - 223:6
Wi-LAN’s Objections
402 R/ 403/ BS/ CS/ H
402 R/ 403/ ML
403/ I
403/ I
96:12-96:18
403/ CS
402 R/ 403/ CS
403
403
402 R/ 403/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
403/ BS/ CS/ F/ L
403/ BS/ I/ MS/ML
403/ BS
403/ BS/ CS/ F
403/ BS/ CS/ F/ I
231:10-15
232:22 - 233:15
247:14 - 248:4
252:24 - 253:13
Middleton, William
Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal
Designations
BS/ F
403/ BS/ CS/ F
403/ BS/ CS/ F/ L
209:15 - 210:10
212:11 - 213:18
227:21 - 228:16
230:12 - 231:22
237:17 - 238:9
239:14-23
242:16 - 243:25
246:12-21
249:19 - 250:23
255:20 - 256:16
275:22 - 278:17
294:24 - 295:15
297:1-16
312:4 - 313:6
402 R/ BS
402 R/ 403/ BS
403/ BS
403/ BS
403/ BS
403/ BS
403/ BS
403/ BS
401/ 402 R/ 403/ BS
401/ 403/ BS/ P/ F
402 R/ 403/ BS
403/ BS/ ML
403/ BS/ ML
401/ 403/ BS
4
207:14-208:02
223:14-224:25;
225:02-225:21
Witness
Lysejko, Martin
HTC Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
316:24 - 318:7
322:18 - 325:12
344:24 - 345:10
353:6 - 354:6
359:8-24
367:20 - 370:2
Wi-LAN’s Objections
403/ BS/ I
403/ BS
403/ BS
401/ 402 R/ 403/ BS/ F
401/ 402 R/ 403/ BS
401/ 403/ BS/ CS/ P
12:4
12:9-12
12:20 - 14:10
15:21 - 16:7
19:7 - 20:25
21:15 - 22:19
23:15 - 24:24
28:21 - 29:23
39:1-17
47:7-11
106
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
48:13 - 50:2
58:22 - 59:4
59:10-14
73:7 - 76:25
77:15-25
78:22 - 81:5
82:4 - 86:8
98:13 - 102:1
113:21 - 117:2
117:15 - 119:21
120:22-24
129:1-14
131:15 - 132:8
134:17 - 135:6
135:14 - 140:12
173:13 - 176:8
176:16 - 177:10
202:14 - 203:6
210:25 - 212:12
212:23 - 213:6
214:8 - 215:5
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ E/ L
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ E/ L
CS/ H/ 402 R/ 403/ E/ L
CS/ 402 R/ 403/ L
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
5
Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal
Designations
Witness
Kuo, Ming-Chieh
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
237:1-23
238:17 - 239:23
242:11 - 243:22
245:2-7
245:10 - 248:9
255:2 - 256:14
261:16 - 265:12
Struhsaker, Paul
HTC Deposition
Designations
[Page:lines]
217:4 - 218:7
224:19 - 225:1
Wi-LAN’s Objections
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
7:21-23
10:17 - 11:6
87:19 - 89:2
101:4-12
115:5 - 116:13
127:20 - 130:25
182:10-25
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403/ E/ L
402 R/ 403
402 R/ 403
7:15-25
108:1 - 109:23
403
112:25 - 113:6
189:18 - 191:25
199:17 - 203:2
403/ 106
403
403
246:20 - 253:12
403
271:11 - 274:13
403
6
Wi-LAN’s Rebuttal
Designations
221:4—221:17;
227:17—228:14
105:7—106:23,
164:7—24; 252:3—11
(already designated)
256:10--19
105:7—106:23,
164:7—24; 252:3—11
(already designated);
256:10--19
105:7—106:23,
164:7—24; 256:10-19
Wi-LAN further objects to any testimony designated by any Defendant that violates any
ruling of the Court, including rulings related to the parties’ forthcoming Motions in Limine. WiLAN further objections to Defendants’ designations to the extent they exceed the length
permitted by the Court’s standing order. Wi-LAN reserves the right to amend its objections and
deposition designations to respond to issues raised and/or resolved after the submission of this
list. Wi-LAN also reserves the right to designate the depositions of any witnesses that Defendant
HTC removes from its Witness List identified as “will call” and/or “may call.” In making any
designations above, Wi-LAN is not in any way waiving any objections to the admissibility of
any of Defendant HTC’s designations.
OBJECTION KEY TO DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS
Abbreviation
CS
H
402/R
403
BS
E
I or 106
P
L
ID/WD
MS/ML
F
xxx
Objection
Calls for Speculation
Hearsay
Irrelevant
Unduly Prejudicial / Confusing / Vague / Misleading / Cumulative / Out of
Context/ Attorney Objection
Improper 30(b)(6) testimony / Beyond Scope
Improper Expert Testimony
Incomplete
Privileged
Call for Legal Conclusion
Inaccurate Description/Insufficient Identification of Exhibit
Subject to Motion to Strike or Motion in Limine
Lack of proper foundation
FRE xxx
7
Dated: February 25, 2013
Respectfully submitted,
By:
Local Counsel
Johnny Ward (TX Bar No. 00794818)
Wesley Hill (TX Bar No. 24032294)
WARD & SMITH LAW FIRM
P.O. Box 1231
1127 Judson Rd., Ste. 220
Longview, TX 75606-1231
Tel: (903) 757-6400
Fax: (903) 757-2323
jw@jwfirm.com
wh@jwfirm.com
/s/ David B. Weaver
David B. Weaver (TX Bar No. 00798576)
Lead Attorney
Avelyn M. Ross (TX Bar No. 24027817)
Ajeet P. Pai (TX Bar No. 24060376)
Syed K. Fareed (TX Bar No. 24065216)
Jeffrey T. Han (TX Bar No. 24069870)
Seth A. Lindner (TX Bar No. 24078862)
Janice Ta (TX Bar No. 24075138)
VINSON & ELKINS LLP
2801 Via Fortuna, Suite 100
Austin, TX 78746
Tel: (512) 542-8400
Fax: (512) 542-8612
dweaver@velaw.com
aross@velaw.com
apai@velaw.com
sfareed@velaw.com
jhan@velaw.com
slindner@velaw.com
jta@velaw.com
Steve R. Borgman (TX Bar No. 02670300)
Gwendolyn J. Samora
(TX Bar No. 00784899)
VINSON &ELKINS LLP
1001 Fannin Street, Suite 2500
Houston, TX 77002-6760
Tel: (713) 758-2222
Fax: (713) 758-2346
sborgman@velaw.com
Chuck P. Ebertin (CA Bar No. 161374)
VINSON & ELKINS LLP
525 University Avenue, Suite 410
Palo Alto, CA 94301-1918
Tel: (650) 687-8204
Fax: (650) 618-8508
cebertin@velaw.com
8
Constance S. Huttner
(NY Bar No. 1722024)
VINSON & ELKINS LLP
666 5th Avenue, 26th Floor
New York, NY 10103-0040
Tel: (212) 237-0040
Fax: (9l7) 849-5339
chuttner@velaw.com
Wi-LAN@velaw.com
Attorneys for Plaintiff, Wi-LAN Inc.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
The undersigned certifies that the foregoing document was filed electronically in
compliance with Local Rule CV-5(a). As such, this document was served on all counsel who are
deemed to have consented to electronic service. Local Rule CV-5(a)(3)(A). Pursuant to Fed. R.
Civ. P. 5(d) and Local Rule CV-5(d) and (e), all other counsel of record not deemed to have
consented to electronic service were served with a true and correct copy of the foregoing by
email and/or fax, on this the 25th day of February, 2013.
/s/ David B. Weaver
David B. Weaver
9
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?