WI-LAN Inc. v. Alcatel-Lucent USA Inc. et al

Filing 329

NOTICE by Alcatel-Lucent USA Inc., Ericsson Inc., Exedea INC., HTC America, Inc., HTC Corporation, Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., Sony Mobile Communications AB, Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson, WI-LAN Inc. re 99 Order JOINT REBUTTAL DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A - Wi-LAN's rebuttal deposition designations and objections to Alcatel-Lucent, Ericsson and Sony Mobiles deposition designations, # 2 Exhibit B - Wi-LANs rebuttal deposition designations and objections to HTCs deposition designations, # 3 Exhibit C - Defendants Alcatel-Lucent, Ericsson, Sony Mobile and HTCs rebuttal deposition designations and objections to Wi-LANs deposition designations)(Weaver, David)

EXHIBIT C

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
TYLER DIVISION
)
)
)
)
Plaintiff,
)
v.
)
) Civil Action No. 6:10-CV-521-LED
ALCATEL-LUCENT USA INC.;
)
TELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET LM
) JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
ERICSSON; ERICSSON INC.; SONY MOBILE )
COMMUNICATIONS AB; SONY MOBILE
)
)
COMMUNICATIONS (USA) INC.; HTC
CORPORATION; HTC AMERICA, INC.;
)
)
EXEDEA INC.
)
)
Defendants.
)
WI-LAN INC.,

DEFENDANTS’ OBJECTIONS AND REBUTTAL DEPOSITION
DESIGNATIONS TO WI-LAN’S OPENING DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS
Defendants Alcatel-Lucent USA Inc., Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson, Ericsson Inc.,
Sony Mobile Communications AB, Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., HTC
Corporation, HTC America, Inc., and Exedea Inc. hereby serve their rebuttal deposition
designations and objections to Plaintiff Wi-LAN’s Opening Deposition Designations.1
Defendants object on hearsay grounds to the use of designations from one Defendant’s
employees against any other Defendant. Defendants reserve the right to amend their objections
and deposition designations to respond to issues raised and/or resolved after the submission of
this list. Defendants also reserve the right to designate the depositions of any witnesses that
plaintiff Wi-LAN removes from its Witness List identified as “will call” and/or “may call.” In
1

For the reasons stated in Defendants’ opening designations, Defendants Alcatel-Lucent,
Ericsson, and Sony Mobile submit their counter designations and HTC submits its designations
separately.
1

making any designations below, Defendants are not in any way waiving any objections to the
admissibility of any of Wi-LAN’s designations.
OBJECTION KEY
R = Lacks Relevance (FRE 401/402)
H = Hearsay (FRE 802)
O = Improper Opinion
F = Lacks Foundation/Speculative (FRE 602)
V = Vague/Ambiguous
M = Misleading/Mischaracterizes prior
testimony
P = Privilege
408 = Settlement (FRE 408)
LC = Legal Conclusion
D = Duplication

A = Argumentative
C = Compound
L = Leading
N = Nonresponsive
I = Improper/Incomplete Designation
PERSONAL = Testimony by 30(b)(6) designee
outside scope of noticed topics
403 = Unduly prejudicial/confusion/waste of
time (FRE 403)
ATTY = Attorney objections not removed
S = Speculation
AF = Assumes facts not in evidence

ALCATEL-LUCENT, SONY MOBILE, AND ERICSSON’S
COUNTER DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS2

Witness
Mattias Akervik
08.29.2012

Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]
5:05-5:11
6:21-7:4
25:8-25:15
39:20-40:13
42:9-43:20
45:21-46:4
46:22-47:11
50:25-52:23

Defendants’ Objections

AF; F; R

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]

2

Alcatel-Lucent, Sony Mobile, and Ericsson hereby incorporate by reference all of HTC’s
counter designations and objections.
2

Witness
Stephen Becker
12.21.2012

5:3-5:11 (OC)3
6:8-6:14
49:16-50:3 (OC)
50:12-50:24 (OC)
56:3-56:12 (OC)
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]
47:23-49:2
49:4-49:10
49:11-49:20
134:23-136:14
136:21-137:10
138:1-138:3

Witness
Per Johan Beming
08.29.2012

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
136:15-136:20 (OC)
137:12-137:25 (OC)
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]
5:3-5:9
5:15-5:17
47:6-48:8
49:3-49:14
60:23-61:3

Defendants’ Objections
47:23-48:25 – F; M; V
49:1 – F; M; V; A
F; M; V; A
F
135:25-136:7 – M; V
136:11-136:14 – M; I
137:4-137:10 – I

Defendants’ Objections

61:25-63:1

47:21 – 48:8 403; ATTY
V; PERSONAL; ATTY
F; S; I; 403; PERSONAL
62:17 – 63:1 V; F; AF; S; 403; C;
PERSONAL

66:25-67:24

V; S; 403; ATTY; PERSONAL

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
48:9-48:15 (OC)
60:10-60:22 (OC)
61:4-61:6 (OC)
61:20-61:24 (OC)
67:25-68:17

Witness

Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]

3

Defendants’ Objections

Sony Mobile and Ericsson’s notations of “OC” signify that the identified designations are made
under the rule of optional completeness in that in fairness, they should be considered with the
designation of Wi-LAN.
3

David Brant
06.29.2012

15:8-16:17
20:6-25:4
42:6-43:19
120:1-124:9
124:23-127:21
129:10-129:18
129:20-129:25
130:2-130:6
130:16-130:23
132:15-133:20
167:19-168:11
173:7-173:25
196:7-196:25
210:11-210:14
215:11-216:22
235:17-236:8

H
ATTY; H; C
ATTY; H; S
ATTY; H; S; R
ATTY; H; S; V
ATTY; H
ATTY; H
ATTY; H
ATTY; H
ATTY; H
ATTY; H; F
ATTY; H; F; AF; V
S; V; H
ATTY; D; V; H
ATTY; S; H
D; H

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
117:4-117:16
117:20-118:4
118:6-118:17
118:19-119:4
127:22-128:9
128:11-128:19
128:22-129:4
129:6-129:9
174:9-174:11
174:14-174:15
174:17-175:2
175:4-175:4
175:6-175:7
175:11-175:15
175:18-175:19
175:21-175:23
197:19-197:25
198:3-198:3
198:5-198:5
198:7-198:11
198:14-198:15
198:22-198:24
199:2-199:2
199:4-199:6
199:8-199:8
199:10-199:14
199:17-199:19
199:21-199:23
200:1-200:5

4

Witness
Deborah Butler
08.15.2012

200:7-200:9
200:12-200:14
201:17-201:19
201:22-201:22
201:24-202:2
202:5-202:9
212:22-213:6
213:8-213:11
213:13-213:18
213:21-213:24
214:1-214:5
214:8-214:10
214:12-214:13
236:9-236:16
236:18-236:18
236:20-236:22
237:1-237:1
237:3-237:5
237:8-237:8
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]

Defendants’ Objections

6:25-7:4
7:10-7:11
7:12-7:18
34:7-34:20
50:10-50:18
75:20-75:24
124:16-124:17
124:19-124:20

R; 403; V; I; S; F
R; 403; V; M; ATTY
R; 403; I
R; 403; V; O; F; S
R; 403; V; O; F; S

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
33:18-34:4
48:22-49:6
49:19-50:1
50:3-50:5
74:12-74:20
74:22-75:13
75:15-75:19
75:25-76:3
100:8-100:15
100:17-100:19
119:25-120:1
120:4-120:4
120:6-120:11
123:25-124:1
124:3-124:11
124:13-124:14

5

Witness
Asok Chatterjee
08.03.2012

125:10-125:13
125:15-125:16
125:18-125:20
126:24-126:25
127:2-127:3
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]
5:9-5:11
7:6-7:9
11:14-11:23

Defendants’ Objections

45:15-46:2
46:4-46:9
46:11-46:12

Witness
Michael Cromie
09/13/2012

Witness
Johannes Derksen
08.24.2012

V; R; S; PERSONAL
45:21 – 46:2 R; S; O; 403;
PERSONAL
R; S; O; 403; PERSONAL
R; S; O; 403; PERSONAL

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
5:15-5:16 (OC)
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]

Defendants’ Objections

5:6-5:8
8:23-9:3
9:10-9:15
31:24-33:7
107:02-107:12
109:12-110:5

R; V
ATTY; R; V
I; R; V; F

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
110:6-110:10 (OC)
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]

Defendants’ Objections

6:3-6:6
7:8-7:14
21:8-21:10
22:7-22:8
22:12-22:15
22:19-22:23
35:8-36:1
37:23-37:25
39:11-40:11
41:23-42:9
43:17-45:6
45:9-45:10
45:15-45:20
45:21-46:16

M
F
A; M
V; S
A; M; V
F; S; V; M
F; V
F; V; S
F; V; S
M; F; V; S
F; V; S

6

46:23-47:11
66:17-67:2
69:4-69:17
75:22-76:4
85:19-86:17
86:18-86:22
87:6-87:11
114:20-114:24
118:7-119:7
127:15-127:22

Witness
Emad Farag
09.06.2012

M; F; V
M; V; F; R
F; V; S
R
V; S
F; V
F; V
M; V
F; M; A; 403

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
20:19-21:7
21:11-21:19
22:9-22:11 (OC)
22:16-22:18 (OC)
36:2-36:14 (OC)
37:4-37:22 (OC)
42:10-42:12
42:13-42:21
43:9-43:12
47:12-48:7
66:9-16 (OC)
69:18-20 (OC)
125:14-126:5
127:9-127:14 (OC)
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]
11:22-12:9
15:3-15:7
20:24-21:14
27:25-28:2

Defendants’ Objections

V; F; 403; I; R; ATTY
V; F; 403; I
V; F; 403; I; R; PERSONAL;
ATTY
V; F; 403; I; ATTY
V; F; I; M; ATTY
V; F; 403; I; R; ATTY
V; F; M; ATTY
V; F; 403
V; F; 403; I
V; F; 403
V; F; 403; I; R; ATTY
V; F; 403; I; R; ATTY
V; F; 403; I; R; ATTY
V; F; 403; I; R; ATTY
V; F; 403; I; R; C; ATTY
V; F; 403; I; R; C; ATTY

28:10-28:22
31:11-32:16
42:24-43:12
46:5-46:10
55:20-56:1
69:15-69:20
71:24-72:9
78:21-79:5
82:5-82:14
88:4-89:15
91:12-92:6
93:12-95:4
95:15-97:5
99:10-103:20

7

116:15-119:23
121:7-121:10
129:4-129:18
131:8-131:23
134:19-135:5
149:4-149:14
149:24-158:19
159:8-160:20
180:7-182:2

V; F; 403; M; I; R; C; ATTY
V; F; 403; M; I
V; F; 403; M; I; D; ATTY
V; F; 403; M; I; C; ATTY
V; F; 403; I; C; ATTY
V; F
V; F; 403; I; M; C; R; ATTY
V; F; 403; I; M; LC; R; ATTY
V; F; 403; I; M; C; R

190:9-192:9

V; F; 403; I; M; LC; C; R; ATTY

255:1-256:16

V; F; 403; I; M; LC; C; R; ATTY

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
22:15-23:8
24:11-24:17
34:15-34:15
34:17-34:24
37:14-37:16
37:18-37:25
38:15-38:17
38:19-38:22
43:13-43:17
56:2-56:11
71:11-71:14
71:16-71:22
83:4-83:6
83:8-83:17
89:16-89:19
89:21-90:6
92:7-92:10
92:12-92:16
119:24-120:1
120:3-121:6
121:11-121:14
121:16-122:1
134:6-134:9
134:11-134:18
135:6-135:9
135:11-135:22
148:22-149:3
160:21-160:24
161:1-161:9
167:12-167:13
167:15-167:19
167:21-168:6
174:19-175:5

8

Witness
Nils Frederik Gessler
08.28.2012

176:23-176:25
177:2-177:14
179:4-179:6
179:8-179:22
182:24-183:8
185:6-185:12
186:1-186:3
186:5-186:5
186:7-186:9
188:22-188:25
189:2-189:19
189:21-190:3
190:5-190:8
231:25-232:22
250:7-250:10
251:10-251:13
251:15-252:7
252:9-253:13
253:15-254:13
254:16-254:25
312:14-313:23
314:11-315:18
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]
9:21-10:4
12:13-12:21
14:2-14:9
16:07-16:11
18:1-18:5
23:19-23:21
26:4-26:4
26:7-26:14
26:17-27:2
29:17-29:25
31:14-31:22
34:2-34:13
44:11-45:8
51:14-52:5
71:4-72:2
72:11-73:20
74:4-76:7
87:23-88:6
88:18-88:22
93:11-95:8
100:12-101:10
101:15-101:25
104:22-105:12

Defendants’ Objections

I; 403
I; R
I; R

S; F
V; S; R; AF; F
R; S; F; AF
V; R; F
V; F; AF
V; F; AF; R
V; F; AF
V; F; AF

9

122:2-122:6
122:7-122:11
122:18-122:19
122:21-123:4
123:13-124:1
124:9-124:18
131:20-132:22
135:15-135:17
155:12-155:22
156:17-156:20
156:22-156:23
156:24-157:7
157:9-157:13

Witness
Helmut Hansen
08.27.2012

V; F; AF

V; I; S; F; AF; PERSONAL
V; I; S; F; AF; PERSONAL
V; I; S; F; AF; PERSONAL
V; I; S; F; AF; PERSONAL

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
23:23-24:2 (OC)
30:1-30:5 (OC)
30:22-31:13 (OC)
34:14-34:15 (OC)
50:14-50:24
51:4-51:5
105:13-105:21 (OC)
124:2-124:4 (OC)
124:6-124:8 (OC)
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]

Defendants’ Objections

V; F; AF; S
V; F; AF
V; F; AF
V; F; AF
V; F; AF

11:10-12:11
18:9-19:7
19:15-20:11
35:6-36:18
41:1-41:24
55:25-58:7
63:3-64:23
72:14-73:2
76:18-77:7
78:10-78:18
81:17-82:15
82:16-83:3
84:15-85:20
97:4-98:25
109:12-109:25
110:3-110:18
126:11-126:15
171:1-171:9
189:18-190:4
210:5-211:10
216:5-216:25

R
V; F; R; ATTY
V; F; AF; S; 403
V; F; AF; 403; ATTY
403; ATTY
S; PERSONAL
F; 403
V; 403
V; F; AF
V; F; AF; 403
V; 403
V; F; AF; M; S; R; 403
109:16-25 V; F; AF; 403
V; F; AF; C; 403
V; F
V; F
V; F; I; 403; ATTY
V; F; AF; C; ATTY
V; F; AF; 403

10

217:18-218:4

Witness
Timothy Hernquist
08.17.2012

V; F; AF; 403

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
7:6-7:11 (OC)
19:8-19:10 (OC)
19:12-19:14 (OC)
58:8-58:10 (OC)
58:11-58:14
58:16-58:16
58:25-59:4
59:17-59:22
62:9-62:16
67:10-67:14 (OC)
75:23-76:3 (OC)
76:11-76:14 (OC)
83:4-83:9 (OC)
85:21-86:2 (OC)
86:13-17 (OC)
93:10-93:25
96:5-96:25
102:10-102:15
103:11-103:15
105:14-106:8
114:12-114:25
115:6-115:11
122:24-123:8 (OC)
124:6-124:9 (OC)
127:9-128:1
183:9-183:13
183:15-183:17
189:8-189:17
208:4-208:11
209:11-209:22
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]

Defendants’ Objections

7:12-7:20
20:6-20:11
27:7-27:21
28:5-28:9
28:19-29:17
31:23-32:24
33:9-33:15
33:16-33:24
37:13-37:24
37:25-38:7
38:11-38:12
40:17-40:25

R

F; V; ATTY
I; F; V; ATTY

11

46:7-46:17
47:2-47:17
94:15-94:16
95:18-95:20
116:9-116:10
116:11-117:5
153:19-154:04
154:22-155:08
159:6-159:21
159:23-159:24
160:1-160:5

Witness
Albert Lee Hill
08.07.2012

I
I; F; S; ATTY
I

S; F; R
M

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
6:2-6:6
6:13-6:14
27:22-28:4 (OC)
48:6-48:14
78:18-78:24
78:25-79:5
83:9-83:19
91:20-92:10
94:17-95:17 (OC)
115:13-116:8
126:4-126:17
126:20-126:24
126:25-127:5
134:4-135:15
141:13-143:10
154:5-145:7 (OC)
160:23-160:24
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]
9:23-10:2
10:7-10:10
30:14-30:21
34:14-34:19
34:25-35:19
41:9-41:13
41:15-41:17
42:13-42:17
42:19-42:24
43:5-43:11
43:14-43:20
47:20-47:23
48:3-48:9
48:21-49:3
49:19-50:19

Defendants’ Objections

R; 403
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403; I
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403

12

50:20-50:24
55:20-55:24
56:2-56:15
58:23-59:2
59:6-59:8
69:3-69:5
69:6-69:7
69:13-69:19
69:25-70:01
70:11-70:13
70:24-71:5
74:25-75:3
75:5-75:5
77:7-77:9
77:11-77:13
77:15-77:25
80:18-80:21
80:22-81:4
143:4-143:12
143:21-144:5
144:13-145:4
146:14-146:19
147:15-147:22
149:7-149:16

Witness
Matthew Hodulik
09.11.2012

R; 403
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403
V; R
V; R
F; V; M
F; V; M
R; 403
R; PERSONAL; S
R; PERSONAL; S
R
R
R; 403
403; F
R; 403

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
5:22-5:25
8:25-9:6
10:3-10:6 (OC)
10:11-10:16 (OC)
16:1-16:10
49:3-49:18 (OC)
75:5-75:11 (OC)
148:22-149:6
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]

Defendants’ Objections

17:18-17:25
41:21-41:25
43:5-44:9
44:20-45:17
45:22-46:11
46:12-46:14
46:17-46:25
51:22-52:1
52:3-52:5
52:7-52:17
52:20-53:6

ATTY; R; 403; V
ATTY; R; 403; V
ATTY; R; 403; V
ATTY; R; 403; V
R; 403; V
R; 403; V
R; 403; V
R; 403; V
R; 403; V
R; 403; V

13

53:8-53:12
80:15-80:22
144:2-144:4
144:6-144:10
161:20-161:21
161:23-162:12
162:14-162:15
163:21-163:25
164:4-164:20
164:22-164:24
165:12-165:15
165:17-165:17

R; 403; V
R; 403
R; 403; V
R; 403; V
R; 403; V; F; S
R; 403; V; F; S
R; 403; V; F; S
R; 403; V
R; 403; V
R; 403; V
R; 403; V
R; 403; V

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
36:22-36:25
37:2-37:7
38:22-38:25
39:2-39:21
40:5-40:8
40:10-40:14
40:24-40:25
41:2-41:7
41:9-41:10
42:1-42:3
42:5-42:7
45:18-45:19
45:21-45:21
51:1-51:5
51:7-51:12
51:14-51:21
53:13-53:20
53:22-54:13
54:22-55:1
55:3-55:13
55:15-55:25
56:2-56:23
56:25-57:9
65:4-65:19
145:23-146:17
154:4-154:7
154:12-154:21
155:4-155:8
165:18-165:20
168:5-169:3
169:5-169:10
169:12-169:16
169:18-169:18

14

Witness
David Irving
08.21.2012

Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]
11:2-11:4
11:5-12:3
12:4-12:8
22:23-23:15
27:25-28:2
28:9-28:18
28:24-29:1
29:4-29:6
29:9-29:13
30:4-30:18
34:22-35:9
38:11-38:14
38:20-39:04
47:4-47:23
48:05-48:19
49:10-49:14
52:24-54:3
88:14-88:22
88:23-89:5
95:3-95:21
96:1-96:20
98:7-99:11
107:13-108:3
109:14-110:4
110:23-111:7
115:6-116:2
124:14-125:5
125:9-126:04

Defendants’ Objections

132:1-132:22
161:5-162:2
163:23-164:16
165:14-165:25

V; I
V; I
V; I
M; I; ATTY; LC; 403; S
F; V
F; V; 403; R; I
F; V
F; V
F; V
R; V; C; F
V; R; F; I
V; F
V; C; 403; R
C; 403; ATTY; R; S; F
F; V; 403; ATTY; S; R
O; V; 403; ATTY; LC; S; R
V; M; 403; ATTY; F; R
F; V; 403; S; D; R
F; V; M; 403; ATTY; R
V; 403; ATTY; F; R
V; C; 403; ATTY; F; R; M
V; I; 403; ATTY; R; A; F; S
V; I; 403; ATTY; F; S; R
V; C; 403; ATTY; F; S; R
V; C; 403; ATTY; F; S; R
V; M; C; 403; ATTY; F; S; R
V; 403; ATTY; F; R
F; V; 403; ATTY; S; R; O; A
V; M; C; I; 403; ATTY; F ; S; R;
O; A
V; C; 403; ATTY; F; S; R
V; M; C; 403; ATTY; F; S; R
O; F; V; C; 403; ATTY; S; R

168:17-169:12
169:14-169:23
174:18-174:23
198:20-200:9
204:15-205:1
205:2-205:9

O; F; V; 403; ATTY; LC; S; R
V: 403: ATTY; O; LC; S; R
V; 403; ATTY; D; M
O; F; V; 403; ATTY; R; S
V; 403; ATTY; F; S; R; O
V; 403; ATTY; F; S; R; O

209:22-210:4
211:23-212:13

O; F; V; 403; ATTY; LC; R; S
O; V; 403; ATTY; R

214:6-215:14
216:18-217:15

O; F; V; 403; ATTY; M; LC; R
O; F; V; 403; ATTY; LC; R

15

218:6-219:18
222:6-222:10
228:13-229:10

V; 403; ATTY; R; F; D
V; 403; ATTY; D; M
O; F; V; 403; ATTY; S; R

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
22:13-22:15
34:19-34:21
48:20-48:23
49:1-49:8
49:15-49:19
49:21-49:24
54:4-54:8
54:10-54:20
58:2-58:4
58:6-58:16
89:6-89:8
89:10-89:15
95:22-95:25
97:13-97:16
97:18-98:6
108:4-108:7
108:9-108:15
108:17-108:19
110:5-110:12
110:14-110:22
116:3-116:5
116:7-116:17
116:19-116:25
121:9-121:13
121:21-122:4
123:23-124:1
124:3-124:10
127:9-127:12
127:16-127:16
127:19-128:4
164:17-164:19
164:21-165:7
165:9-165:12
166:9-166:13
166:16-166:21
166:24-168:1
168:3-168:7
169:24-170:13
170:15-170:23
170:25-171:2
171:4-171:7
171:9-171:21

16

Witness
Bengt-Peter Karlsson
08.31.2012

Witness
Ming-Chieh Kuo
09.28.2012

171:23-171:25
172:5-172:6
172:8-172:15
203:10-203:13
203:15-203:20
204:6-204:10
204:12-204:14
210:5-210:8
210:16-210:18
210:20-211:4
212:22-212:24
213:1-213:13
215:25-216:2
216:4-216:10
228:4-228:6
228:8-228:11
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]
7:11-7:18
13:13-13:16
21:23-23:20
39:8-40:13
41:4-41:10
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]
10:4-10:16
13:25-14:23
25:20-25:24
68:11-68:14
106:10-106:13

Defendants’ Objections

V; F; AF
V; F; AF; R
F; AF; R; ATTY

Defendants’ Objections

F; AF
F; AF
R; F; Not Testimony; Not for Jury;
403; I
R; I
ATTY; V
S; V; F

157:11-157:15
157:18-158:2
159:3-159:16
162:22-163:6
164:16-164:21
216:5-216:8
221:21-222:3
234:15-234:20
252:3-252:11
259:16-260:4
261:10-261:16
264:20-265:9
265:10-265:23
266:24-267:9
268:5-268:20

I; R
F; V
F; V; S
F; V

ATTY; V; F
ATTY; V; F
ATTY; V; F

17

Witness
Yan Liu
01.17.2013

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
7:15-7:17
7:21-7:25
260:19-21
260:23-261:3
261:5-261:6
271:20-272:7
272:9-272:12
272:14-272:14
272:17-272:19
272:21-273:1
273:4-273:9
273:11-273:14
273:16-273:19
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]
10:23-11:3
11:15-11:20
21:14-22:1
25:18-25:23
27:10-27:16

Defendants’ Objections

V; F; AF; PERSONAL4
V; F; AF
V; F; AF; R; 403
V; F; AF; R; 403;
Error! Bookmark not
PERSONAL
defined.

33:5-33:9

V; F; AF; R; 403;
Error! Bookmark not
PERSONAL
defined.

33:17-33:20

V; F; AF; R; 403;
Error! Bookmark not
PERSONAL
defined.

63:4-64:8
Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
19:8-19:12 (OC)
19:15-19:24 (OC)
25:24-25:24 (OC)
26:21-27:9 (OC)
27:17-28:3 (OC)

Witness

Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]

4

Defendants’ Objections

Testimony is beyond the scope of the deposition as defined Court Order DN 19 of 3:12-cv02564-GPC-MDD – Order Denying Without Prejudice Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Non-Party
Qualcomm, Inc.
18

Martin Lysejko
06.28.2012

Witness
James Mahon
08.07.2012

13:4-14:1
43:4-43:6
211:18-212:1

H; F; V; I; R
H; F; V; I
H; F; V; I; R

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
12:16-12:19
210:25-211:17
212:2-212:2
212:4-212:4
212:6-212:12
213:24-214:14
214:16-215:5
224:19-224:24
225:1-225:1
226:19-226:23
227:1-227:9
228:16-228:22
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]

Defendants’ Objections

4:25-5:1
5:14-5:17
6:1-6:2
6:5-6:6
7:5-7:22
8:22-9:5
10:11-10:14
10:19-11:1
11:12-11:17
12:1-12:3
15:25-16:21
19:11-19:15
22:5-22:15
22:20-23:1
23:7-23:13
24:15-24:25
25:9-25:12
26:18-27:7
27:8-27:12
27:15-27:21
36:6-36:14

R; 403
R; 403

S; R; M
I; F
I; F; M
D

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
4:23-4:24
5:2-5:13 (OC)

19

Witness
Luke McLeroy
09.19.2012

7:3-7:4
9:22-10:2
11:18-11:18
11:22-11:25
12:4-12:9 (OC)
12:10-12:19
18:23-19:10
20:7-21:1
22:18-22:18 (OC)
23:3-23:6 (OC)
23:18-20 (OC)
23:22-24:13 (OC)
28:2-28:19 (OC)
30:12-30:15
30:24-31:18
36:15-37:10 (OC)
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]

Defendants’ Objections

6:12-6:13
6:18-6:24
44:23-45:12
49:9-49:12
50:8-50:21
58:22-59:1
59:9-59:15
61:2-61:17
63:21-64:07
65:8-65:16
67:24-68:5
73:4-73:12

S; V
V; R; S
S; R
R
S; V; R
I; V; S
M; R; V

74:9-74:19
92:21-92:23
93:2-93:11
93:21-94:08
115:5-116:16
117:2-117:15
122:14-123:7
123:8-123:12
140:4-140:13

M; R; V
74:17 – N
74:18-19 – A
R
R
R
F; R
F; R
F; V; R
F; V; R
R; V

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
59:16-60:10 (OC)
116:17-116:25 (OC)
117:20-118:15 (OC)

20

Witness
William Middleton
09.28.2012

Witness
Susan Miller
08.02.2012

Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]

Defendants’ Objections

151:08-151:13
151:15-151:24
178:22-179:01
179:03-179:08
179:15-179:25

H; I; LC; R; 403; F; S
H; I; LC; R; 403; F; S
H; I; LC; 403; F; S
H; I; LC; 403; F; S
H; I; LC; 403; F; S

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
178:15-178:21 (OC)
179:10-179:11 (OC)
179:13-179:13 (OC)
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]

Defendants’ Objections

8:4-8:18
15:7-15:17
41:22-42:4
48:4-48:8

V: ATTY; F; R; 403
V; ATTY; F; R
V; 403; R; F
V; M; F; LC
O; F; V; M; ATTY; PERSONAL;
403; S
V; C; F; S; R
F; V; 403; ATTY; PERSONAL; I;
R; S
F; V; C; 403; ATTY;
PERSONAL; I; R; S
F; V; PERSONAL; 403; ATTY; I;
R; S
F; V; 403; PERSONAL
F; V; 403; PERSONAL
F; V; 403; PERSONAL
F; V; 403; PERSONAL
F; V; 403; PERSONAL
F; V; 403; PERSONAL
F; V; 403; PERSONAL
F; V; 403; PERSONAL
F; V; 403; PERSONAL
F; V; 403; PERSONAL
F; V; 403; PERSONAL

63:23-64:11
76:6-76:19
85:25-86:4
86:10-86:16
87:2-88:4
141:11-141:17
141:24-142:7
142:11-142:16
142:20-142:24
143:3-143:7
143:11-143:17
146:24-147:11
147:15-147:23
148:15-148:21
148:25-149:4
156:8-156:14
Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
9:16-9:17
9:19-9:22
63:2-63:4

21

Witness
Lennart Marten Pehrson
08.23.2012

Witness
Douglas Pulley
07.26.2012

63:6-63:9
63:11-63:12
85:13-85:22
85:24-85:24
86:5-86:6
86:9-86:9
88:16-88:25
89:3-89:6
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]
9:14-9:21
22:8-22:10
23:16-23:19
24:18-25:1
31:18-32:5
33:17-34:6
48:10-50:1
67:23-68:2
98:24-99:18

Defendants’ Objections

V; F; AF; 403; PERSONAL
V; F; PERSONAL
V; F; PERSONAL
V; F; PERSONAL
V; F; PERSONAL
V; F; PERSONAL
V; R; 403

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
29:6-29:20 (OC)
68:3-68:10
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]

Defendants’ Objections

50:22-51:4
113:22-114:23
126:7-126:16
128:10-128:15

F; V; ATTY; O; S; 403: R; I
V; 403: ATTY; H; R; I; F
F; V; ATTY; H; R; I; 403; S
V; 403; ATTY; H; R; I; F; S

156:13-156:23
158:12-158:19

V; C; 403: ATTY; F; H; R; I; S
403; F; V; C; H; R; I; S

185:20-186:18

V; 403: ATTY; F; C; H; R; I; S

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
11:14-11:16
11:19-11:22
11:24-12:1
12:4-12:4
49:20-49:22
49:24-50:3
53:4-53:5
53:10-53:16
54:16-54:17

22

Witness
Mikael Rylander
08.23.2012

Witness
Stephen Sneeden
08.17.2012

54:20-54:25
103:1-103:5
103:10-103:13
137:22-138:3
156:1-156:3
156:6-156:11
203:8-203:10
203:13-203:17
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]

Defendants’ Objections

9:6-9:13
18:12-18:14
19:16-19:25
31:11-32:01
Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
17:23-18:4
19:5-19:11 (OC)
34:21-35:4
35:8-35:12
46:24-47:6
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]
7:5-7:9
7:23-7:24
12:9-12:12
13:5-13:7
32:25-33:7
34:1-34:4
34:23-35:10
41:8-41:13
42:21-43:2
43:4-43:10
44:3-44:8
44:24-45:3
49:18-50:7
50:14-51:1

Defendants’ Objections

PERSONAL; ATTY; R
S; F
ATTY
F; S; ATTY

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
5:1-5:3
5:21-5:23
7:25-8:12 (OC)
8:20-9:16
12:13-13:4 (OC)
31:19-32:7

23

Witness
Malek Shahid
09.11.2012

33:8-33:15 (OC)
34:4-34:11 (OC)
34:14-34:21
39:9-39:11
39:13-39:14
39:16-40:3
44:10-44:23 (OC)
45:5-45:13 (OC)
50:8-50:13 (OC)
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]
10:22-11:18
17:15-17:23
36:21-37:5
39:16-40:3
41:1-41:23
42:12-42:14
43:9-43:11

Defendants’ Objections
V; 403: I
N; I; 403
F; V; M; ATTY; S; O
F; V; M; 403: ATTY
C; V; 403; N; I; F; R
V; I; 403; F; R
V; I; 403; F; R
C; F; PERSONAL; 403; ATTY; S;
V; R; O
F; V; 403; S; R
C; V; I; M; 403
F; I; 403; S
F; I; 403; ATTY; S; V
F; 403; ATTY; V; S; I
F; 403; ATTY; V; S; I
F; 403: ATTY; V; S; I
F; 403: ATTY; V; S; I
F; 403: ATTY; V; S; I
C; F; V; 403; S; R; I
H; F; 403; V; S; I
F; 403: ATTY; V; S; I; R

68:21-69:17
81:12-81:20
101:23-102:4
102:25-103:7
106:12-106:22
111:2-111:13
112:12-113:3
115:13-116:12
117:3-117:19
119:4-119:19
141:25-143:16
153:24-156:12
174:15-174:22
Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
17:24-18:12
42:8-42:11
42:15-42:18
42:24-43:8
43:12-43:23
43:25-44:1
52:3-52:5
52:8-52:18
101:8-101:22
106:4-106:6
106:8-106:10
113:24-114:1
114:3-114:4

24

138:1-139:22
140:20-141:2
156:23-157:4
157:8-157:22
159:20-159:24
160:1-160:12
160:14-161:9
166:11-166:13
166:15-166:18
203:22-203:24
204:1-204:5
262:22-263:3
263:5-263:9
263:11-263:15

Witness
Paul Struhsaker
07.02.2012

Witness
Said Tatesh
09.13.2012

Witness

Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]

Defendants’ Objections

115:17-116:13

H; F; V; I; ATTY

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
117:15-117:18
123:16-123:23
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]

Defendants’ Objections

7:6-7:10
7:23-8:7
8:14-8:23
33:16-34:6
34:25-35:7
37:15-38:5

I
I; 403
I; V; 403
C; F; V; 403; R; O; S
F; V; 403; ATTY
F; V; I; M; 403: ATTY; S

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
7:11-7:22
21:25-22:3
22:17-22:24
34:7-34:24
35:9-36:22
42:2-42:10
43:7-44:18
44:20-45:6
45:8-46:16
Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]

Defendants’ Objections

25

Frank Vecella
09.05.2012

7:08-7:17
14:12-14:14
15:18-16:3
16:6-16:6
16:7-16:15
16:18-16:19
17:18-17:24
18:2-18:6
18:8-18:12
18:15-18:18
18:20-18:24
19:15-19:16
19:19-19:19
24:8-24:22
25:15-25:24
32:10-32:13
32:17-32:19
33:6-33:8
34:20-34:24
35:18-35:18
35:21-35:23
35:24-35:25
36:18-36:25
37:6-37:20
37:22-37:25
39:3-39:14
44:10-44:15
50:4-50:25
51:2-51:3
51:7-51:11
54:3-54:13
54:16-54:17
55:14-55:17
55:19-55:22
56:8-56:13
64:17-64:19
65:18-66:6
66:9-66:11
68:3-68:7
68:11-68:20
Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
38:1-38:4 (OC)
38:6-38:11 (OC)
40:12-40:24 (OC)
42:9-42:17
43:18-44:6 (OC)

26

R; PERSONAL
R; PERSONAL
R; PERSONAL
R; PERSONAL
R; PERSONAL
R (17:23-24); A; S; O
R; A; S; O
R; A; S; O
R; A; S; O
R; A; S; O
R; A; S; O
R; A; S; O
R; 403; F
R; 403; F

R; 403; 408
R; 403; 408
R; 403; 408
R; 403; 408
R; 403; 408
R; 403; 408
R; 403; 408
R; 403; 408
R; 403; 408
R; 403; 408

Witness
William Zucker
12.06.2012

Wi-LAN's Deposition
Designations [Page:lines]

Defendants’ Objections

13:2-13:12
25:23-26:1
26:13-26:18
34:18-35:1
40:3-41:1
43:1-43:12
73:7-73:18
75:6-75:10
87:24-88:15
95:17-97:6
98:5-98:20
144:9-144:20

R; 403
R; 403; F; S
R; 403
R; 403
R; 403; S; F
R; 403; S; F
R; 403; S; F
R; 403 S; F
R; 403; S; F; H; O; M
R; 403; S; F; O; M
R; 403; S; F; M

Defendants’ Counter
Designations [Page:lines]
26:2-26:12
27:14-28:7
35:15-35:25
39:8-39:13
42:4-42:6
73:19-73:20
75:22-76:1
76:16-77:2
83:25-84:22
86:8-87:8
89:17-90:4
97:7-97:9
97:11-97:17
99:13-99:18
158:17-158:22
174:15-175:5
176:11-176:15
176:24-177:2

27

HTC’S COUNTER DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS5
Wi-LAN's Deposition Designations
[Page:lines]

HTC's Objections

15:8-16:17

H

20:6-25:4

ATTY; H; C

42:6-43:19

ATTY; H; S

120:1-124:9

ATTY; H; S; R

124:23-127:21
129:10-129:18
129:20-129:25
130:2-130:6
130:16-130:23
132:15-133:20

ATTY; H; S; V
ATTY; H
ATTY; H
ATTY; H
ATTY; H
ATTY; H

167:19-168:11

ATTY; H; F

173:7-173:25
196:7-196:25

ATTY; H; F; AF; V
S; V; H

210:11-210:14

ATTY; D; V; H

215:11-216:22
235:17-236:8
HTC's Counter Designations
[Page:lines]
117:4-117:16
117:20-118:4
118:6-118:17
118:19-119:4
127:22-129:9
174:9-174:11
174:14-174:15
174:17-175:2
175:4-175:4
175:6-175:7
175:11-175:15
175:18-175:19
175:21-175:23

Witness
David Brant
06.29.2012

ATTY; S; H
D; H

5

HTC hereby incorporates by reference all of Alcatel-Lucent, Sony Mobile, and Ericsson’s
objections and counter designations and includes them herein prior to the Court’s ruling on the
motion to sever.
28

Witness
Ming-Chieh Kuo
09.28.2012

197:19-197:25
198:3-198:3
198:5-198:5
198:7-198:11
198:14-198:15
198:22-198:24
199:2-199:2
199:4-199:6
199:8-199:8
199:10-199:14
199:17-199:19
199:21-199:23
200:1-200:5
200:7-200:9
200:12-200:14
201:17-201:19
201:22-201:22
201:24-202:2
202:5-202:9
212:22-213:6
213:8-213:11
213:13-213:18
213:21-213:24
214:1-214:5
214:8-214:10
214:12-214:13
236:9-236:16
236:18-236:18
236:20-236:22
237:1-237:1
237:3-237:5
237:8-237:8
Wi-LAN's Deposition Designations
[Page:lines]
10:04-10:16
13:25-14:23
25:20-25:24
68:11-68:14
106:10-106:13
157:11-157:15
157:18-158:02
159:03-159:16
162:22-163:06
164:16-164:21
216:05-216:08
221:21-222:03
234:15-234:20

HTC's Objections

F; I; R
F; I; R; V
F; I; R; V
F; I; S; V
F; I; S; V

29

Witness
Hsiu Fen Lai
08.09.2012

Witness
Yan Liu
07.17.2013

Witness
Martin Lysejko
06.28.2012

252:03-252:11
259:16-260:04
261:10-261:16
264:20-265:09
265:10-265:23
266:24-267:09
268:05-268:20
HTC's Counter Designations
[Page:lines]
159:17-161:16
163:7-163:11
164:22-165:6
220:12-223:11
234:2-236:21
246:20-253:12
Wi-LAN's Deposition Designations
[Page:lines]
9:15-9:16
9:20-9:24
76:16-76:21
77:17-78:03
HTC's Counter Designations
[Page:lines]
76:22-77:16
Wi-LAN's Deposition Designations
[Page:lines]
10:23-11:03
11:15-11:20
21:14-22:01
25:18-25:23
27:10-27:16
33:05-33:09
33:17-33:20
63:04-64:08
HTC's Counter Designations
[Page:lines]
24:13-26:07
33:21-34:23
Wi-LAN's Deposition Designations
[Page:lines]
13:4-14:1
43:4-43:6
211:18-212:1
HTC's Counter Designations
[Page:lines]
12:16-12:19

30

F; I; S

HTC's Objections

76:16 - F; S; H; PERSONAL

HTC's Objections

I

V; S; P; I

HTC's Objections
H; F; V; I; R
H; F; V; I
H; F; V; I; R

Witness
Marcia Markovich
09.19.2012

210:25-211:17
212:2-212:2
212:4-212:4
212:6-212:12
213:24-214:14
214:16-215:5
224:19-224:24
225:1-225:1
226:19-226:23
227:1-227:9
228:16-228:22
245:10-245:16
245:21-246:2
246:4-246:16
246:19-246:21
246:24-247:7
247:10-247:15
247:17-248:6
248:9-248:9
255:2-255:4
255:8-256:4
256:7-256:12
256:14-256:14
261:16-262:1
262:4-262:7
262:10-262:11
262:13-262:18
262:22-263:9
263:11-264:8
264:12-264:22
264:24-265:12
Wi-LAN's Deposition Designations
[Page:lines]
09:16-09:20
11:23-12:04
63:23-64:14
69:01-69:07
70:15-70:19
76:07-76:08
76:10-76:17
80:08-80:11
84:14-84:21
90:20-91:01
100:20-100:23
115:08-115:13
122:21-123:13
HTC's Counter Designations
[Page:lines]

31

HTC's Objections

H; S
F; S
S; F; PERSONAL

S; V
S; F; PERSONAL
F; S; V

Witness
William Middleton
09.28.2012

Witness
Paul Struhsaker
07.02.2012

Witness
Frank Wu
08.07.2012

76:18-76:23
80:12-80:20
91:02-91:07
94:12-94:19
95:10-95:24
100:14 - 100:19
114:02-114:24
120:07-120:25
122:02-122:05
Wi-LAN's Deposition Designations
[Page:lines]
151:08-151:13
151:15-151:24
178:22-179:01
179:03-179:08
179:15-179:25
HTC's Counter Designations
[Page:lines]
178:15-178:21 (OC)
179:10-179:11 (OC)
179:13-179:13 (OC)
Wi-LAN's Deposition Designations
[Page:lines]
115:17-116:13
HTC's Counter Designations
[Page:lines]
117:15-117:18
123:16-123:23
Wi-LAN's Deposition Designations
[Page:lines]
8:05-8:12
15:25-16:08
16:22-16:23
16:24-17:04
24:16-24:23
25:08-25:11
25:21-27:03
27:25-30:01
30:03-30:22
31:06-31:24
36:15-37:02
39:16-40:21
46:21-47:06
51:01-51:17
HTC's Counter Designations
[Page:lines]

32

HTC's Objections
H; I; LC; R; 403; F; S
H; I; LC; R; 403; F; S
H; I; LC; 403; F; S
H; I; LC; 403; F; S
H; I; LC; 403; F; S

HTC's Objections
H; F; V; I; ATTY

HTC's Objections

H; F; S
H; F; S
H; F; S
F; I; S
F; I; S
F; H; S; I
F; H; S; I
F; H; S; I
F; H; I; S
H; F; S; I
H; F; S; I
F; I; H; S

Witness
Lin Yu
08.08.2012

14:12-14:23
17:05-17:10
34:10-35:01
35:14-35:25
43:09-43:12
45:24-46:08
53:08-54:05
57:09-57:18
61:09-61:16
Wi-LAN's Deposition Designations
[Page:lines]
06:18-06:18
08:05-08:10
17:01-17:06
20:13-20:18
20:21-21:03
31:08-31:11
31:12-31:15
31:16-31:17
31:18-31:18
47:03-47:15
48:24-49:07
55:19-56:03
58:20-58:23
59:02-59:04
59:06-59:11
61:11-61:13
61:14-61:19
64:07-64:25
74:14-74:24
75:01-75:19
76:11-76:13
93:03-93:06
93:08-93:12
93:23-93:24
94:01-94:04
98:25-99:04
141:23-141:25
142:01-142:06
HTC's Counter Designations
[Page:lines]
83:23-83:10
84:05-84:13

33

HTC's Objections

R; 408; 403; M
R; 408; 403; M
R; 408; M; 403
R; M; 408; 403
R; M; 408; 403
M; 408; R; I
R; M; 408; 403
408; 403; R; I; M; S
408; 403; R; S; I; M
A; 408; 403; S; R
R; I; V; S
R; I; V; S
R; I; S
R; V; S
R; S; I; V

Dated: February 25, 2013

Respectfully submitted,
By:

/s/ Akshay S. Deoras______________

Gregory S. Arovas (pro hac vice)
Robert A. Appleby (pro hac vice)
Akshay S. Deoras (pro hac vice)
KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP
601 Lexington Avenue
New York, NY 10022
Tel: [phone]
Fax: [phone]
[e-mail]
Michael E. Jones
Allen F. Gardner
POTTER MINTON PC
110 N. College, Suite 500 (75702)
P.O. Box 359
Tyler, Texas 75710
[phone]
[phone] (Facsimile)
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT ALCATELLUCENT USA INC.

/s/ Martin R. Bader (with permission)
Stephen S. Korniczky (pro hac vice)
Martin R. Bader (pro hac vice)
Daniel N. Yannuzzi (pro hac vice)
Lee Hsu (pro hac vice)
Graham M. Buccigross (pro hac vice)
SHEPPARD MULLIN RICHTER & HAMPTON LLP
12275 El Camino Real, Suite 200
San Diego, CA 92130
Tel: [phone]
Fax: [phone]
[e-mail]
Eric Hugh Findlay (TX Bar No. 00789886)
Brian Craft (TX Bar No. 04972020)
FINDLAY CRAFT
6760 Old Jacksonville Hwy, Suite 101
34

Tyler, TX 75703
Tel: [phone]
Fax: [phone]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANTS HTC
CORPORATION, HTC AMERICA INC., AND
EXEDA INC.

/s/ Richard L. Wynne, Jr. (with permission)
Bruce S. Sostek (TX Bar 18855700)
Richard L. Wynne, Jr. (TX Bar 24003214)
Adrienne E. Dominguez (TX Bar 00793630)
J. Michael Heinlen (TX Bar 24032287)
Timothy E. Hudson (TX Bar 24046120)
Justin S. Cohen (TX Bar 24078356)
THOMPSON & KNIGHT LLP
1722 Routh Street
Suite 1500
Dallas, Texas 75201-2533
Tel: [phone]
Fax: [phone]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
William J. Cornelius (TX Bar 04834700)
Jennifer Ainsworth (TX Bar 00784720)
WILSON ROBERTSON & CORNELIUS PC
909 ESE Loop 323, Suite 400
P.O. Box 7339
Tyler, TX 75711-7339
Tel: [phone]
Fax: [phone]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANTS ERICSSON INC.,
TELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET LM ERICSSON, SONY
MOBILE COMMUNICATIONS (USA) INC., AND
SONY MOBILE COMMUNICATIONS AB
35