Viacom International, Inc. v. Youtube, Inc.

Filing 126

APPENDIX, on behalf of Appellant Black Entertainment Television, LLC, Comedy Partners, Country Music Television, Inc., Paramount Pictures Corporation and Viacom International, Inc., FILED. Service date 12/10/2010 by CM/ECF. [165101] [10-3270]

Download PDF
cO" I ::J -< o o Table of Contents page 1 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ A. Why Online is screwing up the TV Ad Model .........................................................................A 1. Viewership Many Predict TV Consumption will ShrinR.....................................................A-1 But We Have a Problem Even if It Doesn't...................................................A-2 2. Ad Sales: Online is Stealing our Buzz......................................................................A-3 table of contents A-501 o 5> < B. Why Online Video Alone is Not the Answer............................................................................B 1. Viewership More TV Online Has Not Increased Unique Visitors.......................................B-1 More TV Online Has Not Increased Time Spent.............................................B-2 We Can't Get TV Sized Audiences on our Sites...............................................B-3 We Don't MaRe Enough TV..................................................................................B-4 (MTVN Original Content) ...............................................................................B-4a More TV Online Has Not Crushed Our Competitors......................................B-5 2. AdSa[es.....~..........~...~.....~._...........~.....~ .....................................................................................B-6 Online Ad Loads are a Fraction of TV...............................................................B-7 Online CPMs are High on our Sites, Poor elsewhere......................................B-8 Per Episode Watched: On-Air> MTVN Sites> Syndication ..........................B-9 More TV Doesn't Bring BacR the Buzz...............................................................B-10 Side Bar: Why License Fees are Anathema to Ubiquity Online...................................B-ll The closed circuit is dying.......................................................................................B-12 New Distribution Systems have no GateReepers............................................B-13 3. Online Video Syndication ..............................................................................................B-14 Billions of Streams =Tens of Millions of Doliars...............................................B-15 _ _ Online "Distributor$" Hate UbigUiM.TV .. ~ N.ETWCi"RKS.r...... B-16 CO -.....J I\) o 0"> mtvn.com cO" I ::J -< o o Table of Contents page 2 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ table of contents ALTERNATIVE PERSPECTIVES C. Online Ad Sales Monetizes Time Online-Not Just Streams........................................................C 1. 91% of Online Ad Revenues from Non-Video...........................................................C-1 2. Portfolios are as Good as Portals.................................................................................C-2 3. Performance Beats Buzz...............................................................................................C-3 O. Understand the Online Consumer.....................................................................................................0 1. Qualitative Analysis-Understanding Why and How........................................... 0-1 A-502 E. Follow The Consumer............................................................................................................................E 1. Community and Communications Communications are 40% of All Online Activity.............................................E-1 Communications are 67% of Teen Online Activity...........................................E-2 YouTube is a-Social Networtl & MySpace·runs Videos.................-...................E-3 Its Not the Tools-Its How You Use Them............................................................E-4 A Oozen Ways to enable the User to Engage....................................................E-S Learn from NewsPapers...........................................................................................E-6 Our Audience Will Mabe Content for us-and watch it..................................E-7 Community is The Free Lunch (Time Spent) ......................................................E-8 Community increases Uniques (Viral Oistribution) ...........................................E-9 Community and Frequency....................................................................................E-10 o 5> < ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I I\) mtvn.com 0"> cO" I '1 j ::J -< o o Table of Contents page 3 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ table of contents E. Follow The Consumer (con't) A-503 2. Experiences.........................................................................................................................E-ll Content is Everywhere-Experiences Are Rare....................................................E-12 Experiences =Re-Aggregating Dispersed Audiences.........................................E-13 The Devoted Niche-How Cable Beat Broadcast..............................................E-14 What is An Experience? .............................................................................................E-l5 Experiences Can Mean Hyper-Demo Targeting .................................................E-16 Experiences Can Mean Re-Defining Affinities......................................................E-17 Embrace the Portfolio of Consumer Wants..........................................................E-18 The Vidiot-Horizontal Aggregation......................................................................E-19 The SuperFan-Let Users Go Deep.........................................................................E-20 The "Experience" Drives Integration of Community & Applications............. E-21 F. tV· is Still tV'-:BeatourCompefifors 'Silly With 'It...........................................................................F 1. TV is still TV.........................................................................................................................F-l 2. Old Habits Die Hard-so does TV viewing...............................................................F-2 3. Our Audiences still spend more time with us..........................................................F-3 4. Cultural Activators are Rare........................................................................................F-4 5. MTVN activates our audience online........................................................................F-5 6. Online and On-Air: Co-Viewing is Pervasive.........................................................F-6 7. Online is the New Water Cooler...................................................................................F-7 o - 5> TTT < ~ :f~·it'PrF!)'r:7P_5f1Ne." ~;; CO MTV NETWORKS I mtvn.com -.....J I\) 0"> I\) cO" I ::J -< o o Table of Contents page 4 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ table of contents G. How Do We Do It? Some Early Thoughts.......................................................................................C 1. Phase I - Nuts and Bolts.................................................................................................G-l Enable Email (Very Easy Viral Distribution) ........................................................G-2 Syndicate and Lin~-Bac~..........................................................................................G-3 Clean Out Video Search Noise..................................................................................G-4 Get Into Daily Consumption ......................................................................................G-5 Program Community..................................................................................................G-6 A-504 2. Phase II - Thoughts on Process....................................................................................G-7 Learn Lessons from Others - Newspapers and Music.........................................G-s 1. What Experiences Do We Want to Create? ......................................................G-9 2. Build Experiences (integrated Apps & Community) Across Platforms......G-l0 3. Distribution = Connecting Audiences with MTVN Experiences...................G-ll 4. Ad Sales = Harmoniously Monetizing New Consumer Behavior...............G-12 5. Research =Ta~ing Advantage of New Media Trac~ing ...............................G-13 H. Syndicate Video for Traffic. Monetize All Inventory for Revenue...........................................H 1. Own Video AND Display (or Community) to Ma~e Money.................................H-l 2. Pure Video Syndication: Optimal for non-core content or awareness............ H-2 o 5> < ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I I\) mtvn.com 0"> W A-505 E u c E :> c: ~ o I~ O! > I~ W Z Highly Confidential VIAO 1497264 cO· I ::J -< o o APPENDIX A - WHY ONLINE IS SCREWING WITH THE TV AD MODEL A-1 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ 1. Viewership: Many Predict TV Consumption Will Shrinb · Nol-M.O.IL. TIme spent with media - U S . ~~ For younger users, the Internet displaces TV 16 14 12 10 Hours 8 6 4 2 A-506 SQUr~~: if."" :".(I'lEn s....,"IEY De.in'.t;g r.'.<i! £'~!";;·.';(J.'Coon"".. r;(>m ""-{ Me.;iu) ~o .ry:'f'I.A:.'o.1l ..n;:;,;ol Time spent using the Internet per week _:tiltlc.a.CIt_ July 2006, Data Overview "The State Of Consumers And Technology: Benchmark 2006" Gen Yers spend more time online every week than they do watching television o Gen Yers Total Gen Xers Younger Boomers Older Boomers Seniors IIln a typical week, how many hours do you spend doing each of the following?" !ill Watching movies on video or DVD fIJ Playing video games 0 Reading newspapers o Using the Internet o Watching TV III Reading magazines hours spent 0 Listening to the radio Base: North American households Source: Forrester's North American Consumer Technology Adoption Study 2006 Benchmark Survey G(l'1:~~) 12.ll lsi 2.0 I 11.2 ~~ I 10.6 8.1 8.0 6.9 7.2 2.91 3.61 531 43.2 39.1 38.0 38.0 G(~7~h) 1~9.s1. 12.1 Younger B(~~;~) 13.7 I '; . .' 7.71 Older ~~;':~;) i· 6.61 wi Seniors (62+) I· 144 ·.· ·3~1 . 57 :0.6 36.1 (bars may not add up to totals because of rounding) Base: North American households o 5> < Source: Forrester's North American Consumer Technology Adoption Study 2006 Benchmark Survey ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I I\) mtvn.com 0"> U1 cO" I ::J -< o o APPENDIX A - WHY ONLINE IS SCREWING WITH THE TV AD MODEL A-2 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ 1. Viewership: But we Have A Problem Even if it Doesn't Media Consumption is Growing. New Media is growing faster than TV. Problem: If there are more "impressions" split among same Ad Dollars. TV can grow Ratings and Still Shrinb as % of Total Media Consumption. Change In Media Usage by Medium (1998 vs. 2008 Projected) Num ber of Hours per Person per Year 4000 716 3,774 3,500 1 J A-507 3,000 2,917 141 _ 2,500 2,000 1,500 I 1,000 1998 Growth In Traditional Media Growth In New Media Radio (inciudingsateilite) 500 0 < 5> pm 2008 0 t~~'M"~ ·''lt5Mn .. -]''''i 7!!l~"l11!il!!J!!!j ~ CO --...J MTV NETWORKS I I\) 0'> 0'> mtvn.com cO· I ::J -< o o APPENDIX A - WHY ONLINE IS SCREWING WITH THE TV AD MODEL A-3 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Daily Reach (per million) youtube.Gom 20,000 15,000 10,000 5000 , .! Feb' Debatable: The Profitability of Many New Media Business Models. ' M"ar' , , , I ' , , 1 Apr 2C05."'.pr 22 A-508 ®2C05;..lel<ll Rumormonger: Facebook turned down Yahoo's $1 ..:1- b i l l i o n Not Debatable: That almost no one cares. YouTube Nearly Doubles Traffic In May MySpace Rules the Web >- }- :. Traffic P-attenl5' o 5> < ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I I\) mtvn.com 0"> -.....J A-509 E u c E c: > Q) 0 .-c: Q) c: I- E .- !fJ 0:: 0 . M '" :J c: Q) Q) Q) X IZ W ::> 0:: I~ X X > c: ..'" "t Q) ::> '"C C) « .... Highly Confidential VIAO 1497268 cO" I ::J -< o o APPENDIX 8 - WHY ONLINE VIDEO ALONE IS NOT THE ANSWER - VIEWERSHIP 8-1 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ "More TV" Online HAS NOT Increased Unique Users Despite the online video explosion, we've seen modest online growth (excluding Nic~). All Networks - - - . - MTV Suite --VH1 CMT Nickelodeon -.- NeoPets -- 14000 A-510 :;: I~ - -- ; ,1:: til ... 0 til 12000 10000 Q) 8000 '2 ::::s C" ----I Film 6000 :::l 0 I- S -- - 4000 =~em~dYCerrtral 2000 - =-=: ! __~;;<-+-+---"''''''F==+==~I -~---~-------. -..--- Noggin Game Trailers o -+---~="--~~----'---~::-'--'r--'--~:: · Jun - Jul - Aug - Sep - Oct - Nov - Dec - Jan - Feb - Mar - Apr - May - J u n 05 05 05 05 05 05 05 06 06 06 06 06 06 Spike TV X-Fire TV Land o 5> < ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I I\) mtvn.com 0"> CO OLcL617 ~ OVIA IB!luep!!U 0 8 AILl6!H Minutes Per Week ...... 0 3-Jan-05 3-Feb-05 3-Mar-05 3-Apr-05 3-May-05 3-Jun-05 3-Jul-05 3-Aug-05 3-Sep-05 3-0ct-05 I\) I\) 01 0 01 0 01 0 w C S» 3-Nov-05 3-Dec-05 3-Jan-06 3-Feb-06 CD J <I 1m \(1 -I _. -I Z ~ 3-Mar-06 3-Apr-06 3-May-06 3-Jun-06 3-Jul-06 3-Aug-06 3-Sep-06 < (1 !~ ~ Z-i z S : : S : : 5 0 0 OIO-i-i os:: Ar;nG>«G>S::-i Z G)-=::: I\) Om -z 00 20 r C (J) "C CD ::l 3 CD en ... -I m ~ " 3 L .. _ .. -"" 0 AJ Ul o m m Zz m-i -< Zo C JJ 0 0 JJ JJ < m » r < ::J 3 0 -- < m h A-511 cO· I ::J -< o o APPENDIX 8 - WHY ONLINE VIDEO ALONE IS NOT THE ANSWER - VIEWERSHIP 8-3 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ We won't get TV-Sized Audiences on Our Sites Time Spent Online (Per User) is a Fraction of TV Time Spent (Per Viewer) Time Spent - On Air vs. Online 21:36:00 19:12:00 16:48:00 14:24:00 1: en CI) 8. 12:00:00 9:36:00 7:12:00 4:48:00 2:24:00 0:00:00 ---------~---- A-512 t= E ------- .. CJ :-\.. ~&~&~#~&~#~&~&#&~#~& 00 0 ~ ~o~o ~"o t-.,. ~. ~rv· ~. *-~ -<;: ~. Cj ~v :<;-...CJ .. 0~<:) 0~ .$- ~ ~~ ~o ~«),g." ~ ~o #. Brands (On-Air and Online) o 5> < (Average viewer during ABC.com "test" watched 5 min or less video) ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I I\) -.....J mtvn.com cO" I ::J -< o o B-4 APPENDIX 8 - W H Y ONLINE VIDEO ALONE IS NOT THE ANSWER - VIEWERSHIP 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ We won't win with Volume ~ Mostvaewed Video91·2001100 I ~! ~ I AI Time Iil .. Pokemoll Thelile Cit;:,., Evoilltlon of lTance ,l.,I1ded'1marthego Added'11monthotll!l!lO I,," rlDITtWB V!ews:7,5O'l,11J5 234mratiniJll ~ AUcle<d.41Mfl11w.!jJO Fr>=. ~ VIeI"{$6,430,191 FrOM1~ \''''W!; 1,569,57J AddNl'3mc:nnsego AdrjedemCll'ltl"l$.~ 03:14 From.~ Ftom 'l:mash \'Iew:>c.14,S11,s:30 45094ra1hgs "IIeWS' 29,740,361 ****~ **** __ MTVN produces about 50 hours per month of original content (excluding faRe news and live events) ... A-513 35548r6iio1s ****, ****~ 13181 rsings 2230rallrtgB ***" ~~ MOVIE! 01:1$ 05:l'I cw_ .~ 1I!!itm. .1:105 U!..Ih1U..Nitli ~ ... :n 11:11 AdlJ'>CI6monti1salJO Jl.dQ,-\d 7 rnonIhs 16I!jJO Ad(ject:1roonihs6llJO Aoi.X~ 10mDflttlsago _tr~~~_ -~_~~-~~i0~~::-~ -=- ~1~~~=---=_~~~~5-=_=-§§~~~-~-6677nl:ngs ...while YouTube's content library grows by over 2000 hours per cia" "/101"15"7.011,634 S1676rlllllings 239a!1rtangs 508Srllllngs 11159ralio1s ****.., ****, ****'i ****__ ****~ 13 A~c:Ie:I.:7morG'lsogo AND WE HAVE TO RE-THINK WHAT WORKS ... Of YouTube's top 100 viewed clips of all time, nearly ALL are usergenerated A<.$df:<.19mor1ml:l1lD Fro",: Nlkesoccer Atid ·.!Q SmOl1thsago ll..rJOOd 8 months fVJ A\l(l~etTlOf11l'1slll!jJO from: 8l()OdTemhle:;t VIf.)WSS,962,406 F"lom~ Views; 5,56;),009 '.11<;",,:;;8,241,491 ****'1 25337ratlgs From.~ View!<'S,129,393 ****1. 2012 rlIill'lgS rlom:~ Vie'l'/$"5,G15,914 ***'" 600DI'trtIngs 9862 r"'~ ****11 3622rt1!Flg! **** ___ o 5> < ~ CO -.....J I\) MTV NETWORKS I -.....J mtvn.com I\) cO" I ::J -< o o APPENDIX 8 - W H Y ONLINE VIDEO ALONE IS NOT THE ANSWER - VIEWERSHIP 8 - 40 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ MTVN Original Content Available Today via Archive 2007 Premieres 10** 10 to 12 6 to 8 6 to 8 4 4 4 to 6 8 54 to 62 330 100 328 42 32 25 96 150 1103 2007 Current - L o n g & Short 1000/0 of on ai r 12.5 new hours / month (10Spot and daytime) 6-8 hours / month I MTV VH1 A-514 Comedy 20 hours / month 5 hours / month 2 new hours / month 1 hour / month Included Spike Logo CMT TheN BET TSO 45 to 50 I Month (exci. TBOs) Total < 5> 0 f o ';-'7 ~ "~W"!r" "·'wr~£.;("~'qe7 p" ' 1 7 1 " " CO MTV NETWORKS I mtvn.com -.....J I\) -.....J W cO' II B- 5 ::J -< o 0 1 APPENDIX 8 - W H Y ONLINE VIDEO ALONE IS NOT THE ANSWER - VIEWERSHIP ~ ~I :::J I ~ "More TV" Online HAS NOT Crushed Our Competitors "Super-niche" online video providers-such as Heavy and Brea~-are generating more traffic than we are. comedycentral. com ':O:'I-n Daily Traffic Rank Trend rnetacafe. com mtv.com br ea k co ITI 100 ~+-:~-.-------..----~-;~~~=~~~------~~------~-.j · A-515 1 000 FJ ._~.r ·---.. ------------------------- ,.... I -.--====------~-~ ~ '-- --.J-.. -.-.-;:.~ i ....--....--::--:-" ..-------- -.. f II ,I ----}-_./ J ,,":::=:::=-::::=--==::.:;;;~~ __- . ~---... --_.-_. I "-~- .···· ... "'-~-~ ....-'-"'-- _- I ~T'-'----' \.., /i /-~_/'>-.---( .,,"1 'C" 1 Ie _ ----.--._-__~~----.----~--...--.-----.........r "'r' (-,..J ! 2006 Jan II 1 OOrOOO ~.... l II 'o, ~ Apr Jul 2006 Oct o 5> < AlelG3 sap 22 Get more traffK: Irformatbn at Alexa .com ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I I\) -.....J mtvn.com ~ A-516 E c: E u c :> '" -0 0 ..J C -0 « 0 Q) s:: -s:: M Q) 0- !=2 0 O'! '" :J · I- X Q) s:: :::> a: 0 00- Q) > I~ )( W Z s:: ~ '" :::> Q) « -0 u a. '" ~ Q) 0- o s:: s:: .... Highly Confidential VIAO 1497275 cO" I ::J -< o o APPENDIX 8 - W H Y ONLINE VIDEO ALONE IS NOT THE ANSWER B- 7 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Online Ad Loads are a Fraction of TV Online Ad Loads = 1/3 to 1/4 of On-Air Ad Loads Total Minutes Total :30 Avails On-AI. Ad Avails per 22 Minute Episode Ad Minutes Less Affiliate & Marketing On-Air 8 (2) 6 12 - A-517 Sh··t-P.rm Online Ad Avails per 22 Minute Episode Clips Per Episode 3 :15 to :30 Spots/Clip 1 Total :30 Avails Clips 3 Pall-Length Online Ad Avails per 22 Minute Episode Pre-Roll 1 Additional :15 to :30 Spots/Clip 1 Ad Every 7 Min Total :30 Avails I Full-Length 4 1 o 5> < ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I I\) -.....J mtvn.com 0"> cO" I ::J -< o o APPENDIX 8 - W H Y ONLINE VIDEO ALONE IS NOT THE ANSWER 8 -8 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Online CPMs are High on our Sites, Poor elsewhere MTVN Sites: Target Video CPM of --$35 Syndicated Video: Net Effective Video CPM of $9 " -~" ~--~ ~ ~ TABLE: NET EFFECTIVE CPM FOR SYNDICATED VIDEO . ,~- -. . .- - -- - - -- "._-- - .. . ". -~ ,,~--.~ -"---.-.,,---~ - "--_ .... A-518 Traffic Source 300/0 300/0 200/0 200/0 10 5 15 25 0/0 of Total Traffic (PM Rev Share 500/0 700/0 700/0 1000/0 Effective (PM 12.5 10.5 7.0 5.0 Weighted (PM 3.751 3.15 1.40 1.00 I Yahoo/Portals Video Aggregators HyperDistribution Viral Weighted Online Average CPM $ 9.30 I < 5> o ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I I\) mtvn.com -.....J -.....J cO" I ::J -< o o B- 9 APPENDIX 8 - W H Y ONLINE VIDEO ALONE IS NOT THE ANSWER 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Per Episode Watched: On-Air> MTVN Sites> Syndication Impact of Ad Loads and CPMs TABLE: NET REVENUE PER 22 MINUTE EPISODE (OR RELATED CLIPS) -- A d v e r t i s i n g Sales Ad Load Effective (PM 12 Ad Revenue Per Episode Traffic Source 4 4 A-519 MTVN On-Air $ 10 -18 $ $ 35 $ 180 -216 $ 9 140 MTVN Sites - T o d a y Online Syndication $ 36 5> pc < o -.....J ~ !'if!t:' T rnrnmmg1JF rF~;;q:!!n "T 77'·'7 T 77 ' 1 -' MTVNETWORKSI I\) mtvn.com ex> -.....J cO" I ::J -< o o APPENDIX 8 - W H Y ONLINE VIDEO ALONE IS NOT THE ANSWER B - 10 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ "More TV" Online Doesn't Bring BoeR the Buzz The Broadcast NetworRs are putting content online, launching their own video sites and partnering with portals. A-520 Availability Full-length content continues to grow online, yet ABC found the average online user watched only 5 minutes of their 44 minute episodes. Coogle, YouTube, MySpace-the folRs with the Mojo aren't providing content-they are connecting people to it. < 5> o ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I I\) mtvn.com -.....J CO cO" I l ::J -< o o 8 - 11 APPENDIX 8 - W H Y ONLINE VIDEO ALONE IS NOT THE ANSWER 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ SideBar: Why License Fees are Anathema to Ubiquity License Fees are anathema to Online Distributors A-521 · In the offline world, we partner with G.telleepe·· to enable them to charge fees to consumers for access to our content · · In the online world-unless users are charged an admission tee-content is ..tree" · Admission fee models have largely failed-they chili con.umptlon-in medium mart:?ed by unllmltecl content p.oulcle·· (no distribution costs =low barriers to entry) who are in a con.tant m ··llet.h··e b.ttle. (low switching costs). · Moreover, in an online world that is increasing "open"-where sites deep lint:? into other sites, where search generates 30+% of traffic-content th.t hlcle. be.oncl aclmlt.lon fee···e ue·· cllfflcult for u.e·· to set to [e.g., WSJ online-one of the most successful premium destination-suff-ers· tremendous loss ·of CIflciHary troffk ·andcanstantly battle .amount of· opent o - w e b content vs. premium walled garden]. · End Result: Content is EITHER free but ad-supported with broad distribution OR Premium and ad-free with a much narrower subscription base. < 5> Online, you pay to get distribute (i.e., Traffic costs money) · An extension of the above: When content is free, those who have excess traffic charge to share it. For non-relevant content, this is called advertising. For relevant content, it is usually a revenue share ranging from 30% to 50% of ad revenues generated from such content. See Appendix: More is Worse for Online "Distributors." o ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I I\) mtvn.com o ex> cO" I ::J -< o o APPENDIX 8 - W H Y ONLINE VIDEO ALONE IS NOT THE ANSWER 8 - 12 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ The closed circuit is dying ... = The ·CI··eel Cl,eulttt video distribution only through Broadcast TV or MVPDs. Wirel." A-522 Data (PC) Broadcast Television o 5> < ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I I\) ex> mtvn.com I II _. 8 - 13 <0 ::J -< o o APPENDIX 8 - W H Y ONLINE VIDEO ALONE IS NOT THE ANSWER ~. CD :::J 0.: ~ ~ New Distribution Systems have no Gatebeepers... ·Open Clrcalttt = Gateways (access is no longer an issue) I. Direct The Wireless A-523 Dato (Pc) Ie. Direct/via lelev,;ion t'~~led device Id. Direct via pee,. < 5> o ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I I\) ex> mtvn.com I\) A-524 E u c Q) .5 - E > c: ! c: l· ~ .- o u .'"C s:: V\ ~ o :p .9.s:: I'" Q) 3 Q) .::> ttl · Q) '" ::::s !Q Q! o Z 0" .- ::J c: o Q) '"C m · X tw ~ 5 > tX Q) '" c: Q) ::::s '" '"C 0 -oJ I~ 0 a:: C) c: .'" :e Q) Q) ::> '" J!! V\ 0 ~ :::> c: ..'t "" Q) C) <C Q) c: .-c: 0 N '"C · <C -0 ::> '" ::E I~ u Q) c .-c: 0 a. <i. ....· VIAO 1497283 "--------- "~------"-~ Highly Confidential cO· I ::J -< o o APPENDIX 8 - W H Y ONLINE VIDEO ALONE IS NOT THE ANSWER 8 - 15 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ We'd need to nearly match the number of streams we are doing today via HyperSyndication-or Inc......., h.lf via Yahoo-in order to mabe an incremental $10M in online advertising revenue via Video Syndication. Video Streams on Distributed Sites Required to Generate $10 Million for MTVN* A-525 Traffic Source (PM Rev Share 1000/0 700/0 700/0 500/0 7.0 10.5 12.5 5.0 --- Effective (PM Streams to Hit $10M 2,OOOMM --- --- 0/0 of MTVN Annual Streams* Viral (Embedded) $ 5 10 15 25 1100/0 1,428MM 952MM 800MM HyperDistribution** 790/0 530/0 440/0 Video Aggregators Yahoo/Portals *Excludes iFilm and Gametrailers **Assume 0% ad skip vs. current -25% ad skip < 5> o ~ CO -.....J I\) MTV NETWORKS I ex> mtvn.com ~ 1 -~ 1 cO' I J ::J -< o o APPENDIX 8 - W H Y ONLINE VIDEO ALONE IS NOT THE ANSWER 8 - 16 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Online "Distributors" Hate Ubiquity As the number of distributors grows, online content becomes less valuable to each distributor · Online distributors value content only to the extent that a consumer spends incremental time with that distributor by consuming the content (which 11111. I. lIIonellzed with advertising). · As the number of sites offering our content increases: · a given consumer is more libely to have already consumed that content somewhere else; · decreased consumption =less advertising revenue =lower incentive to use precious real estate to promote content instead of something which distributor can better monetize. · Don't Forget: This same "devaluation" can affect MTVN sites-i.e., cannibalization-as we are also a direct distributor of our content (through our sites). A-526 Example: · Yahoo cangeneraUygenerateatleast $1.3M promoting content areas on the 'lahooHomePage · If Yahoo is the ONLY or A PRIMARY place to get that content, users will clicl:?-thru to that content · But, if consumers are libely to have already been exposed, clicb-thrus value (and value to Yahoo to promote drops preCipitously) Click-Thru on Yahoo Homepage 5.00% 2.00% 0.50% 7 MTVN Distribution Strategy Uniques Users to Yahoo Comedy 1,250,000 500,000 125,000 Revenue per Unique User Total Revenue from Promotion Yahoo Exclusively $ $ $ 3.00 3.00 3.00 $ $ $ 3,750,000 1,500,000 375,000 MTVN sites + Yahoo o 5> < Broad Distribution F ~ \.fEf " "" 7 "TW · CO MTV NETWORKS I mtvn.com -.....J I\) ex> U1 cO" I ::J -< o o APPENDIX C - ONLINE AD SALES MONETIZES TIME ONLINE-NOT JUST STREAMS C- 1 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ 91 0/ 0 of Online Ad Revenues from Non-Video To generate an additional $10M from our sites we'd only need to increase traffic by an aelelilional 5%. 2006 Projected Online Ad Revenues A-527 . , -. -.. - - - - . Video Advertising Non-Video Video as % of Advertising Total Online $ 15M $ 145M 9.4% ------ o 5> < ~ ~_l<1iITnn'" "P CO MTV NETWORKS I mtvn.com -.....J I\) ex> 0"> cO' I -< o o ::J APPENDIX C - ONLINE AD SALES MONETIZES TIME ONLINE-NOT JUST STREAMS C- 2 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Portfolios are as Good as Portals MTVN Games/Entertainment 70 Younger We can sell Horizontally-across brands and sites-to meet advertiser-driven metrics Male SpikeTV.com .. Games/E,"*ertainment Older Male M ·· I Gametrailers.com 60 a I e I. AtomFilms.com 50 A-528 I F e m a I TVland.com 40 e % ~ Left/Right =younger/older Top/Bottom = Male/Female Size of bubble = Unique Visitors 30 22.6 27.6 32.6 37.6 42.6 47.6 52.6 Younger Female o '" 5> < Median Age Source: Comscore/MMx Aug 06, US Only Older Female MTV Networks RESEARCH Ii PLANNING Median Age Line represents total internet median age ,m;q TOItTr"'·rr· "T'I'I~"" . " h r ' · · .,. ,. MTV NETWORKS I ~ CO -.....J I\) mtvn.com ex> -.....J ~I .i ,<" ~I o o APPENDIX C - ONLINE AD SALES MONETIZES TIME ONLINE-NOT JUST STREAMS C- 3 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Performance Beats Buzz Ope··llon.1 I.cellence · Opllllliae .elllnil 1111. to generate more higher value impressions · Determine opll ..... p.icin··1.lIclll.e to both drive revenue and maximize impact of · · A-529 · house ads Explore and expand p ··lne ·· hip. with technology providers, traffic drivers and inventory managers to m·· imlaa ,ielel on every impression Leverage our c.o···lle con.llme. In.l.hl. - these are the game changers; shared data drive audience insights which drive advertiser commitments Establish leadership in IInowleel.e of online .lIellence. through data mining P.oclucl · 'c.le matters - f o r our sites and for content experiences outside our sites · Get the ....Ic. - frequency capping, sequential messaging, targeting, reporting · Cross-networi:? cI.l. capture · Inventory oplllllla.llon and yield management · Innovation and .peecl to mari:?et P.cll.,lng · OWN 1IIIIIIi-pl.lfo.m and convergence in the mari:?etplace · Power in numbers - h o . l a o n l . ' ····e ··llon according to advertiser-desired, data-driven o 5> < characteristics ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I I\) mtvn.com ex> ex> A-530 E :> C u c E !Q :c II~ o ~ > W Z Highly Confidential VIAO 1497289 cO" I ::J -< o o APPENDIX D - UNDERSTAND THE ONLINE CONSUMER D- 1 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Qualitative Analysis-Understanding Why and How Getting t ···e.t u.e. e.pe.lence··nllne A wl.ele·· Continuous usability testing (including multivariate testing) Persona-driven search, brand and competitive analysis Behavioral user experience heuristic analysis Reality mapping for attracting and retaining consumers Experience-based planning (relationships, dependencies, scenarios, features) A-531 E.pl··ln. new .n" p ··'lt...le ....n..·c.n.ume··el.tlon.hlp. Virtual world development Influencer, 'Net Promoter' activation Games' play and extending into new affinities External partnerships value creation Acquisition support (forward-facing, integration-minded) I"entl'wln. new, .wn."le .evenue c.nt.I"ut··· ROI excellence Social media expansion (brands, franchises, behaviors) Lifetime value exploration (portfolio, mindset-based) 7 T .. . Y o 5> < ~ ~vmN'··"~_1i?_'ir'.· CO MTV NETWORKS I mtvn.com -.....J I\) o CO cO" I -< o o ::J APPENDIX E - F O L L O W THE ONLINE CONSUMER E 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ A-532 "It's not just about bringing people to the site, it's about keeping them engaged, enticing them to share and create their own content, and making sure they come back./I Lloyd Braun, Head of Yahoo Media Group Business Week, March 13,2006 o 5> < ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I I\) mtvn.com CO cO" I I ::J -< o o APPENDIX E - F O L L O W THE ONLINE CONSUMER - C O M M U N I T Y E- 1 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Communications are 40 0/ 0 of All Online Activity Ac.oSS ALL Use.SI - Total Time Spent Online (Millions of hours) Total % 170/0 Commerce 39% of Time Spent on Communication A-533 Communications 50/0 1000/0 39% Content Search Total - C o m m u n i c a t i o n tied with Content as the Dominant Online Activity I Video = < 5% of Content Time Spent. o 5> < ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I I\) mtvn.com CO I\) I! I I . cO" ::J -< o o APPENDIX E - F O L L O W THE ONLINE CONSUMER - COMMUNITY E- 2 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Communications are 67% of Teen Online Activity 67% Total ime Spent = munications A-534 Teens Age 12 to 17 Top Categories - A v e r a g e Minutes Per Visitor February 2006 vs. February 2005 Year over Year Percentage of Grawth Time Scent Instant Messenger / 400/0, ............. 410/0" Email 330/0 t t 140/0 I Discussion/Chat \... 46%/ \. 13% / r , no 7% 5% Retail Online Gaming Auctions ~/o' .. 42 % . 11 % Entertainment - K i d s -29% \ \ 5% Growth in 4% 4% 3% Gaming Information Community - Teens Sports 20% -35% 73% \ \ Total 190/0 \. ~ 100% < 5> -""",.------ ..... ~ munications over last 12 months o co ~ -.....J MTV NETWORKS I co w I\) mtvn.com cO" I ::J -< o o APPENDIX E - FOLLOW THE ONLINE CONSUMER - C O M M U N I T Y E- 3 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ YouTube is a Social Networb & MySpace runs Videos 0.110" MarLet Share of US Internet Visits 0.15" 0.14" 0.12" "YouTube is BOTH a video viewing site and social networi:?ing site: 0.10" o. OS" 0.010" ..... 0.0810" A-535 0.04" :: 0.02" ~ I :; :::::::::: ...... - 0.034" 0.023" -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -7-. [it] allows users to create their own profiles, post videos, and comment on each other's posts." Hitwise, May 2006 18 25 04 11 18 FEB FEB "AR "AR "AR .. 111111. VOUlUBE. CO" .. IJ IDS .11¥SPACE. COI1 (I~lI(124~'; 25 01 08 15 22 29 010 13 "AR APR APR APR APR APR "AY "AY .. IJ IDEO. SEARCH. VAHOO. COI1 II IJ IDEO. GOOGLE. COI1 20 "AY 1I1I1I1I.GROUPER.COI1 ----CHART OF lliE IIEEKL Y ALL SITES I1ARKET SHARE IN ' ALL CATEGOR IES', BASED ON \ ISITS. TII1E PER 10DS REPRESENTED II Illi BROKEN LINES IND ICATE INSUFFIC lENT DATA. GENERATED ON = OS/26/2 0 06. COPVR IGHT 2006 (C) , HITII ISE PTV LTO' · Top Video Sites Domain Ranll Name Ma.llet 'ha.e Aue.ageVblt Length Note: Recent Comscore 1 YouTube WWW.,outube.colII uicl··m,.pace.colII 42.e4°tO 24.22% IJ,20 4,41 Video Report o 5> < 2 _,'pace Vieleo. shows lower ratings U~!~ ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS ISET t I\) mtvn.com CO ~ cO" I -< o o ::J APPENDIX E - F O L L O W THE ONLINE CONSUMER - COMMUNITY E- 4 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Its Not About the Tools-Its How You Use Them Context Will Rule the Next Generation of Social Networbs the next wave of successful social networbing (and userg e n e r a t e d content) communities will come from major media websites and other content providers that offer their audiences conte.t... llp specific reasons to aggregate. Eric Alterman CEO, Kicl:?Apps A-536 -Exomple!C-elbert -Gr-een-SreenGhGl-lenge·_· Content Creation is Not Just "Cats urinating in toilets" · 88 Unique Mashups of Colbert fighting Bears, Monsters · 7K Reviews and Ratings by viewers of Mashups · 1.7 Million Video Streams on YouTube Alone o 5> < ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I I\) mtvn.com CO U1 cO" I -< o o ::J APPENDIX E - FOLLOW THE ONLINE CONSUMER - C O M M U N I T Y E- 5 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ A (Baber's) Dozen Ways to enable the User to Engage Conlenl Made for Web UGC Parallel Storylines A-537 Extras, Outtakes o 5> < ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I I\) mtvn.com CO 0"> cO" I ::J -< o o APPENDIX E - F O L L O W THE ONLINE CONSUMER - COMMUNITY E- 6 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Newspapers Lessons - The First Internet-Disrupted Media As newspaper publishers become convinced current online growth rates will not counteract the downward spiral of print readership and ad revenues, more and more solutions are being brought to the table. Niche. user-generated and data-driven content as well as more targeted and cost-per-action advertising are among the recommended ways newspapers can open up new revenue streams. "We need to move from the old monolithic business model ... to a diverse and growing portfolio," declared Steve Gray, managing director of API and Newspaper Next. The recommended "portfolio solution" encompasses an array of free and paid products beyond just news. A-538 "The online strategy chosen by most newspapers -- e s s e n t i a l l y reproducing the newspaper online -- f a l l s into a common disruption trap .... attempting to reproduce the old product in the new technology, and thereby missing many of the best new opportunities," notes the recently-released "Newspaper Next: The Transformation Project" report. Serving niche audiences through vertical content is one obvious way newspaper companies can offer contextually-targeted advertising. The report suggests categories such as entertainment, travel and high school sports, as well as even more ad-themed verticals like autos, homes and coupons. Data-driven information resources and opportunities for users to create content are also recommended. For example, E.W. Scripps Company's naplesnews.com, the Web edition of Florida's Naples Daily News, has searchable databases for local team and athlete comparisons. And sites like Enterprise NewsMedia's Plymouth, MA-based WickedLocal provides news content and lets users write blogs, join in discussion forums, and submit photos. The American Press Institute (API)/lnnosight Report < ~ II If "' co ~ -.....J MTV NETWORKS I co I\) mtvn.com -.....J cO" I ::J -< o o APPENDIX E - FOLLOW THE ONLINE CONSUMER - C O M M U N I T Y E- 7 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Our Audience Will Mabe Content for us-and watch it By enabling our audiences to communicate through our platforms, we harness very powerful new content that we can monetize Web content creation 8% _us 4% POSTED A SLOG · Australia A-539 ADDED INFORMATION TO OWN WEBSITE · User-generated video is not the only form of consumer content · Blogs, Tags, Posts (Message Boards), Photos are significant contributions made by users · Moreover, the younger the audiences, the more litlely to engage in online content creation-nearly 500/ 0 of all online users between 18 and 29. Web content creation by age 'ill,' US r4qi~' _ _ Australia 10% ADDED INFORMATIONTO ,A. WORK OR GROUP WEBSITE OR A BLOG _ U S r3~:1 Australia 16% ~. HI SHAREDONTHE INTERNETCREATEDCONTENT SUCH AS PHOTOS, V1DWS, WORDS US 26q,~, Australia 29% , i-2~ l(H9 SO-'S4 ~S+ ACE 5> < SctJrce; A:-n.·inre....ilff' &A:n.en'ccn Lire- ~','"C}e.-t,~C'fcOjJ o }ATe 'rx," -~ , ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I I\) mtvn.com CO ex> cO' I ::J -< o o APPENDIX E - F O L L O W THE ONLINE CONSUMER - COMMUNITY E- 8 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ And More Community is a Free Lunch TheN initiated Community Features in Profile Pages: Traffic grew dramatically with NO adverse impact to content consumption. i 1 1,250,000 r , 1- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - . :; /~ ./ \\. .1 .(p A. m 1,000,000 ~ ~ j ... -._-."'..... ---'. /'" '9 11 750,000 "'--I' I I I r~~ I I ! ~ ~, /~t---~.v-' -.-.;:.,:;:~..~:.::; .V'-~. A-540 500,000 - .250.000 I -t:::::--__ .- _ _ ___ 17 19 21 ~...._._ _ __.___ ... -. J ./'....,.~.--;:..r . " iii i , iii oI 23 i , 25 27 29 3 5 7 13 15 17 19 21 Aug 14".~ Most Popular Site Sections mb a SCI ~ · profile 1QD6 - Tue. 22 Aug. 2006 · games J ntv · media player · G,rar.oh: Generated by SiteCetalys.1 \.iSIng Report A~eleratcc' at IJfl:50 r'M EDT, 23 Aug 2006 o 5> < ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I I\) mtvn.com CO CO cO" II E- 9 -< o o ::J APPENDIX E - FOLLOW THE ONLINE CONSUMER - C O M M U N I T Y 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Community increases Uniques (Viral Distribution) Let the Audience be the evangelist. Letting Others Know About Online Video Is Common A-541 Frequently 9 96 ::-.Jever 32--"<> Occasionally 29 96 Rarely 30 % o 5> < ~ CO ~-. ·f~] MTV NETWORKS I mtvn.com -.....J o o W cO" I ::J -< o o APPENDIX E - FOLLOW THE ONLINE CONSUMER - COMMUNITY E - 10 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Community and Frequency "-w+e"W'""w",#","'w,,*,,,~,,,,,,,"","''''_''''','''',"'''''''',''k,,"'','';';"";"""""""';' Communications, social networking, and game playing are the most common daily activities (sorted by % dOing activity daily of those that do it at all) More do activity daily A-542 < 5> o Base: North American online households Source: Forrester's North American Consumer Technology Adoption Study 2006 Benchmark Survey 2JjiA.~>lii n " l'll !!iJ ; 7" ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I o W mtvn.com A-543 c u C E E :> ~ o ~ ~ II~ > W Z H i g h l y Confidential VIAO 1497302 cO" I ::J -< o o APPENDIX E - FOLLOW THE ONLINE CONSUMER - EXPERIENCES E - 12 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Even for those who have been on the Web the longest (18-34), uncontexted TV content provides no added value to users. Jupiter, 2006 A-544 Experiences, not content, will be the basis of success for media companies -going forward. Media outlets have great expertise in creating one-size-fits-all experiences - liRe mabing a movie, producing an album, or filming a TV show. However, content experiences of the future will differ in many ways. Forrester, 2006 < 5> o ~ ;:~~~~;~:;~%~Sb~1,~~~1£t:1;k~~~1~M{gZri~tk?~~r.tlf~;'\\~%?;:it?~~"Wt{5,fiifkr~1f1~~J~f~~§'~~~~i CO -.....J o w W MTV NETWORKS I mtvn.com cO" I -< o o ::J APPENDIX E - FOLLOW THE ONLINE CONSUMER - EXPERIENCES E - 13 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ The Web Has Dispersed Traditional Audience Clusters "What we are experiencing in fragmentation is a little libe the aftermath in the Big Bang theory. After the "bang," all of the matter in the universe was deconstructed and dispersed. Over time, the pieces re-grouped in new, meaningful ways-- planets, stars, moons, et cetera. A-545 Similarly, the introduction and adoption of digital technologies in our sOciety has effected a deconstruction and dispersion of audiences across channels. The fear among media practitioners evolves from the disorder, the change in how we understand our universe~ the media-scape, and the implications on our business models. The opportunity -- in fact, the silver lining -- is in the discovery of new patterns that may ultimately prove more compelling for consumers and more instructive and efficient for advertisers. Let me put it more simply. Fragmentation is just an opportunity to re-aggregate audiences in more meaningful ways." ~<----·-W·~--'· -~':]] o 5> < -, "Ti." ~~~~~tm?#§x&W¥fm~~~~¥1lff'YnTrJ MTV NETWORKS I mtvn.com ~ CO -.....J W o ~ cO" I -< o o ::J APPENDIX E - FOLLOW THE ONLINE CONSUMER - EXPERIENCES E - 14 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ The "Focused" Approach Can Build a Meaningful Audience ~ Technorati" Blogs and MSM Washington Post 1$1&" . l i l l l U U i .___ .__ ~. _____ " __ "._____..._ ,__._.__._.. _..,,.._.. _ _____ ..._......__ .~__ Tahoo t\lews .. .. BBC u ' I::: ii; ;;i;; iii :t :::::~::i :: ;-: t: :::;; : Q LIlli New York Times ~ . ,,'.. , - . &ie.. I Wired News ~ Boing Boing ~ e:r==::I:%;;S:l:::m:::'.::.:i::a;:n ::: ::::::::: ::: .:::: ::: ~:::::y News.com Reuters SF Gate A-546 fJ DailKos : M~on =Mainstream Media Red I jnst'!rwnd it I ,~Times Glzmodo FA.R.K .$.;;' 810g . $. ; _t. ; , r:::::::::::::::::::C:::::: I r-__IiSlSI._ 10,000 Shinbun National Review Engadget ·,Boston.com ESPN PBS The Times ,_~._~_~.~ Talking Points Memo i NPR ! Dayene~C5 Binary Bonsai The fc:onomist Common Dreams Eschaton o 5> < o 20,000 30,000 40,000 50,000 60,000. ~ CO MTV NETWORKS I -.....J W mtvn.com o U1 cO" I ::J -< o o APPENDIX E - F O L L O W THE ONLINE CONSUMER - EXPERIENCES E -15 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Programming (1) Content + (2) Software + (3) Navigation for Specific Effects. Opportunities: "I Story telling techniques Tools and features Site navigation Interaction with audience Content selection · Reactions - a t t i t u d i n a l / i n t e l l e c t u a l / e m o t i o n a l Example: anti-authority Jacbass Portal · Interactions - w i t h content, functionality, community Example: "in control" of my video on Horizontal Platform · Activity - passive vs. full immersion Example: Watching TV vs. Networbed Video Game A-547 HiUh ooks out for people like me The JacRpot: Satisfying Experiences that are otherwise absent from Consumers' Lives (l) A credible. safe place And it worRs: ::J 11 2 c1i c 'lakab liiO e rI,'ly guilty pleasure be :9 'fIm1iJred for me Guides me to other media Gives. me something to talk about o U A walj to fIll my time co StarTribune created online version of newspaper edited for young adult experience- E Cl. Tries to persuade me Too much result outstripped traditional by a 2.1 ratio. Low Rille Low Priority Experiences Worries me Annoved by the ads o 5> < Experience Presence C.(IHHHOn ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I o W mtvn.com 0"> cO" I -< o o ::J APPENDIX E - FOLLOW THE ONLINE CONSUMER - EXPERIENCES E - 16 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ A-548 "Disney.com, when it relaunches in early '07, will create a customized point of entry so the experience matches the age and interests from pre-school up." PaidContent.org, 9/20/06 < o 5> ~ CO MTV NETWORKS I -.....J mtvn.com W o -.....J .! cO' I -< o o ::J APPENDIX E - FOLLOW THE ONLINE CONSUMER - EXPERIENCES E - 17 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Consumer-Regulateel; full con.u..er accett · A Full experience around a passion (e.g. music, politics) · Initiated by trusted entities-brands, franchises, characters 22 n :::t S ~ Vieleo Experience A-549 Vieleo it ........ Experience ~ We get: · More Engagement (Time) · Ability to guide/drive usage - experIences that go well beyond our video (e.g., we are now the voice of Political Satire) < o 5> nocont..mer entr" 7 itf_km~M.~~~_~Jlifj'·O;!"TLTrYniD1innflUi7,.'·r J~.: MTV NETWORKS I mtvn.com ~ CO -.....J W o ex> A-550 E 0 E ...I C > u v. z V. c( 11. a:: 0.. w M ii: N 0 0 i! z '". ;:) :x: :x: ii: U ,,:; ~ X Z W 0 ~ I- '" ::::i V. lI~ > 0 C Z c( > ...I c( a:: co N I- V. :> o 2i ... H i g h l y Confidential VIAO 1497309 cO" I -< o o ::J APPENDIX E - FOLLOW THE ONLINE CONSUMER - EXPERIENCES E - 19 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ They want to Control their Video · Breadth of Content · Personalization, Interactivity · Ability to Create, Edit, Mash-up YouTube ~!~IVJewlngHlst"rl!:i!t!!.l!dlL!!! Today they go to: S",d,'o,I¢OlIeftg_ f!.1!J!:!!l! §a.!!..u If we Build It: Feed/iFilm YOU(MIIIIBloadCJst Yourself !~ ~ tl!!..t!!..!. ~1~1~1~1~IMiSU~~COlttlu"·r~l~ A-551 ~ Ile!.<t!!! WINNER "~~~~i::;'::~:::':':---R_~ 't rG , 'r> Se~l<bM.dlfl.'':. ___ Vld.O'uuhfor·u.'".rt~ _ _ _ _ _ _ ~~_ h~;~~t~ 1(,0')·1 i:il:'J~' :" .... iii: \OJ~"""" .,.tI1!. UllbnAta · m_** *** .!-L ~ -~o DanotScenes s"·",P",,D ~ ~'<\!.!:HENOOlIlERTGREENSCREENCHA1lEtkiE , abouth~f'llIlIIhaverlgttsfol!hlngs.evenlhouptlhoyshOW&dacll)) ' tromft8aklrapliodsOJII ·.. plu611h1I11oyoUhiYlllobeanamarican . 6otmliaehl$.lhenr8ldaRlhatJabb~ronIhBemalll'ay"altallerln&~Dn CltIzen .. bah.welltrs(,OO"'!l ,., . · Tags:=~~~~~t!!!Il "."""""_IIgO"(-III,~,.,.~ n"",~ \"'..., 181~11 * ~~~~~~91y :HAT 5 H~T T'I IU': ~ 'C "';t ... .~ n;I~n -,- ....... =enls~ ***** ' .>i:cingular ~;;;:.,..w~"""ogQ <l("""""f.~ t.!!ImIJm£ll!lll:!l.~all'!n!ZnllWtt!l ThI$lsrrl)'utond ... -\i~~~ ~rtVO.C""'TIOlil ~ ,£~l*~ ==~!~E:=::~~:~<::I~:::~~~~~~~eone ~;~~~c:::: ~ ~ mMl _':::""L""'-.~______ m m~ 5> < _ ___ ~vtWlhAn_f~.~Gf o ~ CO MTV NETWORKS -.....J W mtvn.com o cO" I -< o o ::J APPENDIX E - FOLLOW THE ONLINE CONSUMER - EXPERIENCES E - 20 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ They want to Go Deep · Full access, immersive experiences · To interact, to shape, to identify with Franchises If we Build It: ?? Today they go to: UnOfficial Fan Sites A-552 !Cti~Hn (:.1'10 ....... 11 ..... RI" Think YOll Kno ... Kristin C..".II ..n? T.~·. Our Kristin Ca\'ailMI Quit How 5> < o ~ CO MTV NETWORKS I -.....J W mtvn.com cO· I -< o o ::J APPENDIX E - FOLLOW THE ONLINE CONSUMER - EXPERIENCES E - 21 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ "Design [must] lead users to community. [Creators must] analyze what community means to the organization and its constituents. Virtually live through the consumer to understand how they move through the site to understand how the idea of community should manifest itself. Message boards and other interactive community forums can't be located in just one area, on a separate subsite - they must be woven community features throughout the site -- no matter where someone is on the website, she should easily find her way to a chat room, message board or other appropriate tools." "People who need People," CIO A-553 Production capabilities are extremely high based on capital investment and expertise. Professionalism is a characteristic of mainstream media cuts both ways - there are clear standards and a high degree of talent, yet alism is a box th Marry the Unique Elements of Professional Content with the Power of Community Self-exposure is a more powerful driver of social media than selfexpression. The exhibitionism and associated voyeurism of blogs and social networks are a key factor driving participation. Future of Media 2006, Future Exploration Network Annotation is commentary on and reference to existing information and ideas. < o 5> ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I W mtvn.com I\) A-554 E c: E :> u c ~ o Z ~ I- X w ~ I- > H i g h l y Confidential VIAO 1497313 cO" I -< o o ::J APPENDIX F - TV IS STILL TV F-1 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ TV provides a crucial distinction-and critical advantage. A-555 · TV initiates behavior and induces shared passions and experiences · MTVN consistently demonstrates unparalleled creative leadership · We are the Inventors of breabthrough genres and content · We Innovators of popular culture · Our audiences want deep tailored "Experiences" that are easy to use--not just more content · Watching an event as it happens gives an indescribable jolt to those most engaged - q u i c b e n i n g their concentration, giving them a sense of participation < o 5> ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I W mtvn.com ~ cO" I -< o o ::J APPENDIX F - TV IS STILL TV F- 2 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ "The rate of change is larger for new media (Internet and e-mail) than the rate of decrease for traditional media. In other words, growth happens faster than decline. This goes a long way towards explaining why we can have overall increases in media consumption: new habits are acquired while old habits are maintained. A-556 Traditional media seems to be able to retain or even grow users in core areas. For example, TV was up in primetime, radio was steady or up in drivetimes, and newspapers were up in the morning. It mabes sense that traditional media will compete hardest to retain users in their most successful time periods." Jay Newell o 5> < ~ CO MTV NETWORKS -.....J I W mtvn.com U1 cO" I -< o o ::J APPENDIX F - TV IS STILL TV F- 3 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Time Spent on MTVN Nets Still Beats Even Top Internet Sites Time Spent - MTVN vs. Selected Online 21 :36:00 19:12:00 J: 16:48:00 ~ - c A-557 ~ ... 14:24:00 12:00:00 ~ o~" ~ ~'{ . ~ en c Q) c. 9:36:00 Q) j:: E 7:12:00 4:48:00 2:24:00 0:00:00 ~v -~ ~ ~ ~ (j ~ _ ~ ~. .., V -tX- h~ 0 ~'" # " ~ ~ ~ _~\..1 r-.~fb= ~""' ~ <<,if MTVN Brands vs. Sites 00 !&~~0~o# <Q# ~o~o 4.# 0" .<..fl)-¢b < o 5> ~ CO MTV NETWORKS I -.....J W mtvn.com 0"> cO" I -< o o ::J APPENDIX F - TV IS STILL TV F-4 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Cultural Activators: A-558 · They give audiences something to do - some activity, some roles and goals, some meaningful form of participation. · This can be literally the case in terms of the mechanisms of participation that surrounds reality television or computer games. · Or it can simply be the show embeds lots of secrets and thus opens itself up to a prolonged process of decryption, as seems to be the case of Lost Almost all TV attracts Culture-it tabes a unique show to activate it. MTV NETWORKS I mtvn.com o 5> < ~ CO -.....J W -.....J cO· I ::J -< o o APPENDIX F - TV IS STILL TV F- 5 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Initiation: Colbert films himself in mocb light-saber fight in front of green screen. Result: (on YouTube ALONE) · 88 Unique Mashups of Colbert fighting Bears, Monsters, the Star Wars Kid · 7K Reviews and Ratings by viewers of Mashups · 1.7 Million Video Streams (approx same number of mash-up streams as monthly streams of Colbert clips on Motherlode) Initiation: Colbert urges viewers to vote for him on online poll to name new bridge in Hungary. A-559 Result: Colbert leaps to first place with over 17M votes (leads second-leading votegetter by over 15M votes). - I n i t i a t i o n : Colbert encourages viewers to change Wibipedia entries to say the elephant population had tripled in the last six months. ["Any user can change any entry, and if enough other users agree with them it becomes true. If only the entire body of human bnowledge worbed this way."] Result: Under deluge of changes from audiences, Wibipedia bans further changes to Elephant entry. ;..~.~..":.~... 1(- I'! Due to recent vandalism, editing of this article by anonymous or newly registered users is currently disabled. Such users may discuss changes, request unprotection, or create an account. · o 5> < ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I W mtvn.com ex> cO" I ::J -< o o APPENDIX F - TV IS STILL TV F- 6 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Audiences are aoing Online while Watching TV · 16% of ALL online usage occurs in front of the TV · 66% of Users regularly/occasionally watch TV while online A-560 And they are loobing online for MORE from Us showswhiiethey are watching · 60%of Users visitwebsites of TV · 80% of Users visit the websites-at some point-of the television networRs and/or programs they watch o 5> < ~ CO -.....J W MTV NETWORKS I mtvn.com CO cO" I ::J -< o o APPENDIX F - TV IS STILL TV F- 7 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Initiate with TV, Enable with Online Online is the New Watercooler A-561 · 54% of Users would consider participating in online communities, discussion groups, chat rooms or blogs about T · 13% of Users currently DO! < 5> o ~ CO -.....J W MTV NETWORKS I o I\) mtvn.com cO" I ::J -< o o SUMMARY NUMBER SUMMARV 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ (!) Inillate with Oil. F.anchbes/B.ancls/Content @ A-562 Engage with @ Enalale -Comment - Post -Add - Create - Edit -Mix - Upload - Personalize @ Enable COlllmllnlcatlon (UnTethe. Content) - Share - Embed ~ < 5> o ~ CO -.....J W MTV NETWORKS I I\) mtvn.com A-563 u > e E o C -::;; V\ t: 0 -E 0) 0) '" ~ In x 0 ~ ~ IW 0 II- X v -~ ~ v e: 0) > l- Z = 0 e: e: 0) 0' 0) :::l ~ U. I- x Highly Confidential VIAO 1497322 cO" I ::J -< o o APPENDIX G - Some Thoughts on How We Do It G-1 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Increase Uniques 1. SEO - A p p r o v e Budget and Keep Implementation GOing 2. Enable .. Email or 1M A Friend" on Every File 3. Syndicate and LinR-BacR-You Tube and Others 4. Clean out the Video Search Noise 5. Go Viral-With a Plan A-564 Increase Frequency (aRa Change Consumption Patterns) 1. Alerts (e.g., Let Users RIJOW when new content is available) 2. BooRmarRs (e.g., "BooRmarR this page") 3. Get into Daily Consumption: Instant Messenger, Widgets & Modules o 5> < Increase Time Per Session 1. Get Search WorRing on Our Sites 2. Program Baseline Community 3. Enable Tagging ~ CO -.....J W MTV NETWORKS I I\) mtvn.com W cO" I ::J -< o o APPENDIX G - S o m e Thoughts on How We Do It G-2 ~f :::J CD ~ ~ It's the Most Popular Way to Share Video l::.lIlJ!~ ~ E-mail Is The Most Widely Used Method For Sharing Online Videos them the address of the Web site where I found Ii 480/0 I My Account I VIE'WlngHislorv I ~ I h9.9.J.rJ. You(mmr Seau:h1~1 :____ .~" ___________ ,_______________1I SeEl!ch Channels Top Rated I MostDisCllssed I Top Favorites Most Linked I Recently Featured Broadcast Yoursel! Videos ~ I FOf","ud iln e-fl!<1P I received containing a !ink. to the .Vide0l:::=::~~r ! 44% Home Groups Ca'e(!ories Upload Use the "Send to a friend" OP~OI1 prO'lkled on the ,Ideo player page Call my friends on the phone and tell ;:hem about the video 310t Most Recent 31 ~ Download the \l1deo and send ii 3S an a-mall attachment Post a hnk to tne video on nw personallJloQ Burn the vldeo to l CD or DVD and clrcutlte it A d d e d Augllet 25, 2016 1~% I A-565 DARIA ~Ji'i;]iTw nom Sliulokho Put Up the video on my own '¥"Jeb site 00'/0 -c..a't¢9<'I-Y--~ 20 % 40% 60% -.~ ..~ . . Views: 2,262 CQnllnent~; F.lII~lted: SUPdbowl ~ Ot:H FrDrR sotisun Ra1etllisvhlen L 2 15tlmes 9.~v~.. t2"f.."?Y"~I!~_~ Dalia .A.ddlo Groups Honol&: 0 Link5tO show Ihis vide-o:" - t.:12' Frorr, CmonsterBM 7 ratings ***** :.- l/iew::l.2232 P1eas:e[gg)alo ratetmvideo. < 5> X Y!"~~. a_s 1~~"ep.L~E.r"~.t"~ """ U:3$ Put a "Share" or "Email" Button every time we run a video clip ;:-rom~ o . ~ CO -.....J W MTV NETWORKS I I\) mtvn.com ~ cO· I ::J -< o o G-3 APPENDIX G - Some Thoughts on How We Do It 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Distribute Content with Focus to Drive Traffic Bacb 1. Call-To-Action on Our Sites 2. Leverage Content Mix that Generates Awareness ~ I MyAGCOuntl vlewmgHlsloD' I!::!!W! 1.b!&lQ Yoummr __ .. _____________ .. ___ ...J Channel" Broadca,t Yourself Videos I Search I ~ ~ Ciltegorlus ~ Most Recant I tv!ostVlewed I TapReled I MoslDlscussed I TopFavorltit$ I MostUnked I Re(9ntlyFaaty[ed A-566 What if: Click to Vote on Green Screen Finalists. Stephan Colbartnghts Iha StarWari>- kid .·· (~or~) Colbert Puts Grizzlies on Notice Colbert Spollings Y()uTLIbeCr()ve Traffic to Us? Td<Js .:1lli!tD. ~ M ~ (,!!9!'~) uru. m\:'$':0'.i! Morerrom~ ~ SI'IowIlg1-20of 14aQ47 ~ ~--------------------------~ st.8PII9nC(jlbert'llS..st<lr . :~SKld Video Aggregates generated new users? RJte this 'JIlleo Views: 289,879 ~--, S<NeloFavorlles 1t14ra1il~ ***** .:<IIowPt"Y'ng ~~"~)£.Q.r..O'JJ1.S. i.:f.~ §.~~Ie_YI.2~2. ... II ~;~~_\~ StephellColbertvsMI!lV fritt.wIll"lll jij ~ ~ ::~~~ Links 10 lhi& \/Ideo: ~j §J2"1.~1~2'.9. £!~.~.?~ 1.n.J.p'~!.C!P'!~'!!~ ~how _1," ~5S ~~:~c="",ren _lM~LLEHGE f'WL~ Commeltt$ & Responses r.,?,.~.~lJ~E c"?nl!!.!~ PltSI;'JVldMReslJ(lIiSe ...m .k L STEPHEN COLBERT o 5> < ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I W I\) mtvn.com U1 cO' I ::J -< o o APPENDIX G - Some Thoughts on How We Do It G-4 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Yahoo, Coogle, MSN, UnCut - All the "Search Engines" already have our content - w h y send users to us? We need to give them a reason ~oo ........... '~'"''"'" '< a\ '.m ._. ':::" !'r' e., ,\\ Gc~~m :i;~~~::i::;~~:"~" ._ ... ~-::C : ' : .. _..... , Because if you search "South ParR" on Yahoo Video: A-567 ... ~. :~~:-'·····'..-=f'is:~;~:,~~~....- ;~ Comedy Central :;:i~';~t~:::;~;;::.:::;;:· ~~: -;:,;"".'.:";:~"'"""''"' . :. rill f§':;;~:~;:;:''";·:·'''''··'' we're Just a IinR --one of 22-- - t h a t gets rotated-- Daily Motion g~::,:::::fi,;:::::::,:;·;;:;:;.;::'''· :::: :~::::.2·iE~;,·:::.~:;.:~-" f'Ii ...."_"'",, ...._. Ii! R '::, m ~;;;:::~;:::,;:; ......."..,.;:: "" f!!i !::::::::;.;~;~;::;:.",:,::",::.-"" ,~~: ~E~:,:'i::~:::::;"·"'-,,·~·v. ~:. ~;:2f,;~s:;~;,~.. " r;a So its Rind of hard to find us. !In!! o 5> < ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I W mtvn.com I\) 0"> cO" I ::J -< o o APPENDIX G - Some Thoughts on How We Do It G-s 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ 1:2 Buddies (6/11) ,.ZolaOrAOL RJI1"Me,;~"ger Identify Destinations!Applications Used Most Frequently and get integrated: 1. Email 2. Instant Messaging (Modules, Bots) 3. Personalized Home Pages (Feeds, Wi""No+~ 1:2 'WSJOl)!ine Smart...Chlld ~ graceaMIucy \'iSJ 1:2 Recent Buddies (0/31 Offline (8114) A-568 Or Go Straight-to-the-Des~top o 55, . 5> ' i < ~ CiJ~£~il§\t~~~T;5:,'~5' CO ,57 ~~~~"~'55==i' -.....J MTV NETWORKS I mtvn.com W I\) -.....J cO" I ::J -< o o APPENDIX G - Some Thoughts on How We Do It G-6 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ ask. ~ Open QlJ11!.tlon A<.<..,p!iIIY .UG'N{!I~ l1li answer. _ discover. _ L,,'_~_ Do Simple Things (not as lame as Yahoo's) And Put it on the Front Page I,'. II. 1h&1J'.&sofsom~n~peoj:,I&? =~~.~.h.~fc-:::;~:I~n:~~ W~b Images Video Audio Search: ~ yahoo! AruiWer.;i1 Ask a qUestion I Answer question:> MyYahooll~ II--=~===~~==--~:--~==--'-'---'C~~~~::J -A-569 .- a Autos . . Fantasy MLB Finance CiI \i' · More Ji:orllJ, 1'Ir"ld 10.::;.. 1 reso\Jrc,,~ Fntsy Sports Ii Gomes (9 GeoCities · Groups C$ ~TuH~:~:f!~:t:I~lnls · Hou~e Hotlobs III ;~I~':~~'b~I:~t:~~n~~~? to Ml ;~;t i~~o t~r~o~;;:,~rket and See Woodw<lrd V~, INhlte a Maps CqNFlqURE YOURS NOW ·)i ·.. f CHE~7-~~-~~:~ . ~ (i '-2' ",Isltchevy.com . Ad F!!!!!!dback Movies m '60 MIr.uteJ' ... Ideo A'rnERlCA. ME,E1YOUR TRUCK :»' ~, ~ Music --.Per-SOfl-otl-----_ ~-!ll_!}.!~_'i~VliS -L W?~ld .~~-~.~! ._1~~_ ~1IlsidaYahW)tSllOJlp.i119~_._. ____ _ stunned Q i TVI' J'OIwE!lry photos ,~ '~~~.~::~::~::~;;"~?~~·:~i:"~i'::::;Z, III ~ 'bI ;:::-.0 Find Products: :___ ~ ____ ~J i Real Estate ! : HilndbiilOjJ:;: i. i !.A' i·. MP!3 pliill''OIr,: tileClothmo; PI,Odticts Check oul H. ott,' est DVD plil';JOIrs (j .... Shopping fi) sports Yahoo! Pulse · · .. · J! Tech N'iilWIi : Poplilar- I HUlfinQliIi .. · (j Travel · Ge.lls of War It .. .. · Three ~Irls killed at Amish school 0 Community U.S. urges RUSSia, Georgia to tone down rhetOriC Brazil's Lula in high-stakes battle in runoffvo1e LeUer cntlClzed al·Qaida head In Iraq CDC: Black lung disease on rise In Virginia Aliilska storm cracks iceberg In Antarcllca· study Prosecutor: Steroids story cont<1ins 'Inaccuracies' NFL· MLB NCAA Foolb.1I . Golf· NASCAR Got GalYle7 Video GZlf1lCS YZlhool Users VVant " NBA Liv. 07 .. WWE Sru01ckd{)wu lIS. R.1W I .---~,.~"-~.-- _~~Iow !.,~~~_ I ~~i~i~_~o~~S,~~$-"l MarkBb: Dow: -0.1% Nasdaq: -0.9% M.:uketlll<lce SllI,,1I Business Think you .. Mario vs. Donkey Kong 2 .. FOIZ.lIYlOtuISIJOlt 2 .~ MOr"lll Popular- G a m a " t1 "".""".,' ~ .... '" .,,~.,., ............... ,,'.,J.< .. "...... · Web Hosting tp~~ntI.l ~:~~~oo~~Co;?g~;~c~I:~en~:}~;:~;l~nlh * i C-~i~~bdB I Mortgage rates near 39-yr lows · Domain Namefi · Sell Online .. Search Listings Shop Costume Express . Halloween costumes for the entire family Featured Services Attractive card for ugly credit" Our MasterCard is the 1st step 10 bUild or re-build credit. o 5> < .. .. .. · Downloads Health Kids Mobile What's your credit score 5607 678? 7207· See It $0 · MTV NETWORKS I mtvn.com ~ CO -.....J W I\) ex> cO' I -< o o ::J APPENDIX G - Some Thoughts on How We Do It 0-7 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ / II X ~ Frequency ~ Time/Session A-570 Unique Users II X J r·····················································.....................................................(!5··p·~·~~f~·ii~··Of··E~~~·;i~~~~~······················ ......................................................·············································1 ~ .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................: .....................L. ................................................................................r............................................~ ...................................................................................................................................................... <::::..... ..............·1"" .·....................................··········································L............................................................................................................................................................................................................: ! \31 Community & Applications r·········G5··i·~i~i~~~··~i~·h···TV··························1 ........................................................................................................ r·············································~·p;~~;~~··pi·~tf~;~·~=·TV~··o~·ii~~~···w·i·;~i·~·~~·=~·~···W·~~·b··T~~~th~~···························· ..·····..························1 .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. : o 5> < ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I W mtvn.com I\) CO A-571 ~ ~Q) Q) c:J" .~ t: t: ..t: ~ e :> o c E c: '" '- 0 :s E ~ Q) Q) ~ '" ... I O~ Q. .~ Q) Olc.-M Z Q)..t:~ Ol~ ::> ::> 0:: ~ I- -c 'cE :J 0 t: gJ (t: o IW Z I~ X > H i g h l y Confidential VIAO 1497330 cO· I ::J -< o o APPENDIX G - Some Thoughts on How We Do It G-9 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ 11 Laguna Beach ...............- ..~II. L a g u n a B e a c h . c o m - F o r SuperFans GOB.OAD i (TRL The Daily Show ~ MTV owns Music Comedy Central owns Fabe News f#~.."9 Social Engagement as Destination +- BII Social Engagement as Application (X-Fire) A-572 OLD NEW · Own the Horizontal (Music, FaRe News) · Own Depth (Enable the Laguna SuperFan) · Own the Occasion (Teen Angst) · And Liberate Ourselves from Destinations-we can have applications do the worR (see X-Fire) · Identify Key Audiences within Demo or Affinities · Manage by continuing to super-serve within respective areas o 5> < ~ CO -.....J MTV NETWORKS I W W mtvn.com cO" I -< o o ::J APPENDIX G - S o m e Thoughts on How We Do It G-l0 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ A-573 OLD NEW Create the Experience. that have been identified-while they are still on the Drawing Board: (1) Premium and Low-Cost Pro Content (2) Applications/Products (3) Community and Communications (4) How the experiences are IinRed across mobile/TV/online o 5> < · Balance Consumer Engagement and Advertiser Needs by creating/acquiring Conlenl designed for 10-foot experience · Experiment, Test, Revise to maximize loyalty and engagement · Build and maintain brands' strength and integrity with audience ~ CO MTV NETWORKS -.....J mtvn.com W W I\) cO" I -< o o ::J APPENDIX G - Some Thoughts on How We Do It G-ll 0.: ~ CD ~ ~ Online Marketing ~l G'?..!o>gle msn~ 'YA.Eoor .ttAOl.IMI.nl~>nli<r Google _msn" BlogliJJesl,lt, -" : : Plucl<.. 'W1WW?Wl1!@ ~~ .... I11III "YilHOOrMEsser:!~e,~ Youimmr _S;:,GUBA msnY.Me$Wlger NEW Tur~ ~ re\j!j"''';'''Jtf .111\. ~ III ~ A-574 -Each-1Ofo increase of Traffic to Our Sites =$2M·(atcurrentsen-throughs&~CPMs) OLD Connecting Online Audiences with MTVN Experiences · Coordinated Approach to Partnerships that Increase Traffic to Content (wherever that content resides) · Syndicate Video that DRIVES TO EXPERIENCES · Aggressively pursue relationships that enable Video + Display and/or Community Monetization o 5> · Broadly Distribute Video Content

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?