Viacom International, Inc. v. Youtube, Inc.

Filing 126

APPENDIX, on behalf of Appellant Black Entertainment Television, LLC, Comedy Partners, Country Music Television, Inc., Paramount Pictures Corporation and Viacom International, Inc., FILED. Service date 12/10/2010 by CM/ECF. [165101] [10-3270]

Download PDF
Viacom International, Inc. v. Youtube, Inc. Doc. 126 Att. 7 A-701 Dockets.Justia.com A-702 A-703 A-704 A-705 Schapiro Exhibit 14 A-706 Ticket 257649695 http://trax.corp.google.com/html/trax.html?tickeUd=2418807 5 7 Joanna Ging <jging@youtube.com> Re: YouTube Account and Clip URL removed #257649695 I 17 messages 3/27/2008 14:28 "Joanna Ging" <jging@youtube.com> to "Marni Harris" <marnih@google.com>, "Copyright Service" <copyright@youtube.com> Cc: "Dickehut, Robb - Paramount" <Robb_Dickehut@paramount.com>, "Arneson, Latham - Paramount" < Latham_ Arneson@paramount.com>, "Tiffany Bowers" <tbowers@google.com> Subject: Re: YouTube Account and Clip URL removed Thanks Marni! Hi Copyright team, can you please look and see which videos under the account *http://www.youtube.com/profile_videos?user=tastefullymine*<http://www.youtube.com /profile_videos?user=tastefullymine> have been removed as indeed this is Paramount Picture's channel and they have the copyright to the video contents. Please help, thanks! "Arneson, Latham - Paramount" <Latham_Arneson@Paramount.com> to "Joanna Ging" <jging@youtube.com>, "Marni Harris" <marnih@google.com>, "Copyright Service" <copyright@youtube.com> Cc: "Dickehut, Robb - Paramount" <Robb_Dickehut@Paramount.com>, "Tiffany Bowers" <tbowers@google.com> Subject: RE: YouTube Account and Clip URL removed Hey all - 3/28/2008 11 :56 Any update here? We'd like to have up for this weekend. Also, assuming we figure out the issue, can we just reinstate the videos (views included) or will we have to re-upload the videos? Thanks, Latham 1 of 12 11118/097:07 PM Confidential GOOOOl-0968ll39 A-707 Ticket 257649695 http://trax.corp.google.com/html/trax.html?tickeUd=2418807 57 From: jging@google.com [mailto:jging@google.com] On Behalf Of Joanna Ging Sent: Thursday, March 27, 2008 2:29 PM To: Marni Harris; Copyright Service Cc: Dickehut, Robb - P a r a m o u n t ; Arneson, Latham - P a r a m o u n t ; Tiffany Bowers Subject: Re: YouTube Account and Clip URL removed Thanks Marni! Hi Copyright team, can you please look and see which videos under the account http://www.youtube.com/profile_videos?user=tastefullymine <http://www.youtube.com /profile videos?user=tastefullymine> have been removed as indeed this is Paramount Picture's channel and they have the copyright to the video contents. Please help, thanks! "Joanna Ging" <jging@youtube.com> to "Arneson, Latham - Paramount" <Latham_Arneson@paramount.com> 3/28/2008 13:01 Cc: "Marni Harris" <marnih@google.com>, "Copyright Service" <copyright@youtube.com>, "Dickehut, RobbParamount" <Robb_Dickehut@paramounLcom>, "Tiffany Bowers" <tbowers@google.com> Subject: Re: YouTube Account and Clip URL removed Hi Latham, Can we get an email confirmation from you stating that Paramount Pictures would like to retract the DMCA claims submitted on the videos below. Once we get this, our copyright team will be able to reinstate the videos today. Thanks! On 3/28/08, Arneson, Latham - P a r a m o u n t <Latham_Arneson@paramount.com> wrote: > > Hey all > > > > Any update here? We'd like to have up for this weekend. Also, assuming > we figure out the issue, can we just reinstate the videos (views included) > or will we have to re-upload the videos? > > > > Thanks, > > Latham > > > > > 2 of 12 11118/097:07 PM Confidential GOOOOl-0968ll40 A-708 Ticket 257649695 http://trax.corp.google.com/html/trax.html?tickeUd=2418807 5 7 > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > *From:* jging@google.com [mailto:jging@google.com] *On Behalf Of *Joanna Ging *Sent:* Thursday, March 27, 2008 2:29 PM *To:* Marni Harris; Copyright Service *Cc:* Dickehut, Robb - P a r a m o u n t ; Arneson, Latham - P a r a m o u n t ; Tiffany Bowers *Subject:* Re: YouTube Account and Clip URL removed Thanks Marni! Hi Copyright team, can you please look and see which videos under the account http://www.youtube.com/profile_videos?user=tastefullymine have been removed as indeed this is Paramount Picture's channel and they have the copyright to the video contents. Please help, thanks! "Harry Smith" <hsmith@google,com> to "Copyright Service" <copyright@youtube.com> 3/28/200813:06 Subject: Re: [#257649695] YouTube Account and Clip URL removed "Joanna Ging" <jging@youtube,com> to "Arneson, Latham - Paramount" <Latham_Arneson@paramount.com> 3/28/2008 13:08 Cc: "Marni Harris" <rnarnih@google.com>, "Copyright Service" <copyright@youtube.com>, "Dickehut, Robb Pararnount" <Robb_Dickehut@paramount.com>, "Tiffany Bowers" <tbowers@google.com> Subject: Re: YouTube Account and Clip URL removed Hey Latham, Here are the 7 videos and would like you to state that you would like to retract the DMCA claims submitted for these videos. Thanks! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aWt-fduKFmo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SjKP6pT8eD http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xLUPs8zZ-mA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t2x6N4qnGdM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rig59Nf9qRw http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sxNuomEUGGO http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AgGf xsoOHI "Harry Smith" <hsmith@google,com> to "Copyright Service" <copyright@youtube.com> 3/28/200813:29 3 of 12 11118/097:07 PM Confidential GOOOOI-09681141 A-709 Ticket 257649695 http://trax.corp.google.com/html/trax.html?tickeUd=2418807 5 7 Subject: Re: [#257649695] YouTube Account and Clip URL removed "Arneson, Latham - Paramount" <Latham_Arneson@Paramount.com> to "Joanna Ging" <jging@youtube.com> 3/28/2008 14:02 Cc: "Marni Harris" <rnarnih@google.com>, "Copyright Service" <copyright@youtube.com>, "Dickehut, Robb Pararnount" <Robb_Dickehut@Paramount.com>, "Tiffany Bowers" <tbowers@google.com> Subject: RE: YouTube Account and Clip URL removed Hi Joanna - I can confirm the account "Tastefullymine" has authorization to post all of the videos regarding Drillbit Taylor it has posted to date. And we will not issue takedown orders for these videos. Quick question as well - o n c e the videos are reinstated, will they retain their view count? Thanks! Latham From: jging@google.com [mailto:jging@google.com] On Behalf Of Joanna Ging Sent: Friday, March 28, 2008 1:01 PM To: Arneson, Latham - P a r a m o u n t Cc: Marni Harris; Copyright Service; Dickehut, Robb - P a r a m o u n t ; Tiffany Bowers Subject: Re: YouTube Account and Clip URL removed Hi Latham, Can we get an email confirmation from you stating that Paramount Pictures would like to retract the DMCA claims submitted on the videos below. Once we get this, our copyright team will be able to reinstate the videos today. Thanks! 4 of 12 11118/097:07 PM Confidential G00001-09681142 A-710 Ticket 257649695 http://trax.corp.google.com/html/trax.html?tickeUd=2418807 5 7 "Copyright Service" <copyright@youtube.com> to "Arneson, Latham - Paramount" <Latham_Arneson@Paramount.com> Cc: "Joanna Ging" <jging@youtube.com> Subject: Re: [#257649695] YouTube Account and Clip URL removed Dear Latham, 3/28/2008 14:14 Thank you for your email. If you wish to retract the DMCA claims filed by Paramount Pictures Corp. against the material below. We require a statement of retraction of the DMCA claims and the URL links to the material claimed by Paramount Picture Corp. Once we receive this retraction we will be able to reinstate the material with all statistics intact. Thank you for your patience and understanding. Material Claimed by Paramount Pictures Corp. from the Tastefullymine account. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aWt-fduKFmo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SjKP6pT8eD http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xLUPs8zZ-mA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t2x6N4qnGdM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rig59Nf9qRw http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sxNuomEUGGO http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AgGf_xsoOHI Sincerely, Harry The YouTube Team "Arneson, Latham - Paramount" <Latham_Arneson@Paramount.com> to "Copyright Service" <copyright@youtube.com> Cc: "Joanna Ging" <jging@youtube.com> Subject: RE: [#257649695] YouTube Account and Clip URL removed Hi P a r a m o u n t would like to retract the DMCA claims on the following videos. reinstate them and notify us when this has been completed. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aWt-fduKFmo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SjKP6pT8eD http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xLUPs8zZ-mA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t2x6N4qnGdM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rig59Nf9qRw http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sxNuomEUGGO http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AgGf_xsoOHI Thanks! Latham -----Original Message----F r o m : Copyright Service [mailto:copyright@youtube.com] Sent: Friday, March 28, 2008 2:15 PM To: Arneson, Latham - P a r a m o u n t Cc: Joanna Ging Subject: Re: [#257649695] YouTube Account and Clip URL removed Please 3/28/2008 14:31 5 of 12 11118/097:07 PM Confidential GOOOOI-09681143 A-711 Ticket 257649695 http://trax.corp.google.com/html/trax.html?tickeUd=2418807 5 7 Dear Latham, Thank you for your email. If you wish to retract the DMCA claims filed by Paramount Pictures Corp. against the material below. We require a statement of retraction of the DMCA claims and the URL links to the material claimed by Paramount Picture Corp. Once we receive this retraction we will be able to reinstate the material with all statistics intact. Thank you for your patience and understanding. Material Claimed by Paramount Pictures Corp. from the Tastefullymine account. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aWt-fduKFmo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SjKP6pT8eD http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xLUPs8zZ-mA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t2x6N4qnGdM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rig59Nf9qRw http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sxNuomEUGGO http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AgGf_xsoOHI Sincerely, Harry The YouTube Team "Copyright Service" <copyright@youtube.com> to tastefullymine@tempinbox.com Subject: Re: [C#257649695] DMCA Claims Retracted Hi there, 3/28/2008 14:43 Paramount Pictures Corp. has retracted its copyright claim with respect to the following videos: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aWt-fduKFmo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SjKP6pT8eDO http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xLUPs8zZ-mA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t2x6N4qnGdM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rig59Nf9qRw http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sxNuomEUGGO http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AgGf_xsoOHI This content has been restored and your account will not be penalized. For technical reasons, it may take a day for the video to be available again. Sincerely, Harry The YouTube Team "Copyright Service" <copyright@youtube.com> to "Arneson, Latham - Paramount" <Latham_Arneson@Paramount.com> 3/28/2008 14:44 6 of 12 11118/097:07 PM Confidential GOOOOl-0968ll44 A-712 Ticket 257649695 http://trax.corp.google.com/html/trax.html?tickeUd=2418807 5 7 Cc: "Joanna Ging" <jging@youtube.com> Subject: Re: [#257649695] YouTube Account and Clip URL removed Dear Latham, Thank you for the retraction. The material has been reinstated. Sincerely, Harry The YouTube Team "Mail Delivery Subsystem" <MAILER-DAEMON@google.com> to bounce20-257649695@trakken.google.com Subject: Returned mail: see transcript for details 3/28/2008 14:48 7 of 12 11118/097:07 PM Confidential GOOOOl-0968ll45 A-713 Ticket 257649695 http://trax.corp.google.com/html/trax.html?tickeUd=2418807 5 7 The original message was received at Fri, 28 Mar 2008 21:48:42 GMT from zps19.corp.google.com [172.25.146.19] ----- T h e following addresses had permanent fatal errors ----<tastefullymine@tempinbox.com> ----- T r a n s c r i p t of session follows ----5 5 0 5.1.2 <tastefullymine@tempinbox.com> ... Host unknown (Name server: dev.null.: host not found) From: "Copyright Service" <copyright@youtube.com> To: tastefullymine@tempinbox.com Date: Fri, 28 Mar 2008 21:43:06 -0000 Subject: Re: [C#257649695] DMCA Claims Retracted Hi there, Paramount Pictures Corp. has retracted its copyright claim with respect to the following videos: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aWt-fduKFmo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SjKP6pT8eDO http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xLUPs8zZ-mA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t2x6N4qnGdM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rig59Nf9qRw http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sxNuomEUGGO http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AgGf_xsoOHI This content has been restored and your account will not be penalized. For technical reasons, it may take a day for the video to be available again. Sincerely, Harry The YouTube Team "Harry Smith" <hsmith@google.com> to "Copyright Service" <copyright@youtube.com> 3/28/200815:01 Subject: Re: [#257649695] YouTube Account and Clip URL removed "Joanna Ging" <jging@youtube.com> to "Arneson, Latham - Paramount" <Latham_Arneson@paramount.com>, "Copyright Service" <copyright@youtube.com> 3/31/2008 14:00 Cc: "Marni Harris" <rnarnih@google.com>, "Dickehut, Robb - Pararnount" <Robb_Dickehut@pararnount.com>, "Warrnan, Bryan - Paramount" <Bryan_Warman@pararnount.com>, "Lawson, Josh - Paramount" <Josh_Lawson@paramount.com> Subject: Re: [#257649695] YouTube Account and Clip URL removed Hi Latham, Sorry about this but let me ask Harry to look into this for you again. 8 of 12 11118/097:07 PM Confidential GOOOOl-0968ll46 A-714 Ticket 257649695 http://trax.corp.google.com/html/trax.html?tickeUd=2418807 5 7 Copyright/Harry - c a n you please help and reinstate the videos below? Thanks! On 3/31/08, Arneson, Latham - P a r a m o u n t <Latham_Arneson@paramount.com> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Hi Joanna/Marni It seems two of our promoted Drillbit Taylor videos have been removed again. The specific URLs for these videos are: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AgGf_xsoOHI - P u n c h Me Harder http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rig59Nf9qRw - T e a c h e r ' s Lounge Both of these videos were included in the URLs we sent along to Copyright Service. Is there something more we can do to make sure they do not get taken down? For reference, here is one of the promoted videos that is still live. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sxNuomEUGGO - I n t e r v i e w i n g Bodyguards Thanks, Latham *From:* Arneson, Latham - P a r a m o u n t *Sent:* Friday, March 28, 2008 4:27 PM *To:* 'Joanna Ging' *Cc:* Dickehut, Robb - P a r a m o u n t ; Warman, Bryan - P a r a m o u n t ; Marni Harris; Lawson, Josh - P a r a m o u n t *Subject:* RE: [#257649695] YouTube Account and Clip URL removed Thanks Joanna. *From:* jging@google.com [mailto:jging@google.com] *On Behalf Of *Joanna Ging *Sent:* Friday, March 28, 2008 4:26 PM *To:* Arneson, Latham - P a r a m o u n t *Cc:* Dickehut, Robb - P a r a m o u n t ; Warman, Bryan - P a r a m o u n t ; Marni Harris; Lawson, Josh - P a r a m o u n t *Subject:* Re: [#257649695] YouTube Account and Clip URL removed 9 of 12 11118/09 7 :07 PM Confidential GOOOOI-09681147 A-715 Ticket 257649695 http://trax.corp.google.com/html/trax.html?tickeUd=2418807 5 7 > > > > Hi Latham, > > > > I'm not too familiar with the process you can take to prevent this from > happening in the future but let me find out from our copyright team to see > what you need to do :) > > > > Stay tuned ... thanks! > > > > On 3/28/08, *Arneson, Latham - P a r a m o u n t * <Latham_Arneson@paramount.com> > wrote: > > Hi Joanna > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Thanks for the help on this; the videos are all live again. I was also hoping you could let us know how we can avoid situations like these in the future? I think we assumed on our side that since we were promoting the videos the account would be "white listed" or the videos tagged not to be removed. Is there some process we need to go through in the future before we launch our videos? Thanks, Latham -----Original Message----From: Copyright Service [mailto:copyright@youtube.com] Sent: Friday, March 28, 2008 2:44 PM To: Arneson, Latham - P a r a m o u n t Cc: Joanna Ging Subject: Re: [#257649695] YouTube Account and Clip URL removed Dear Latham, Thank you for the retraction. The material has been reinstated. Sincerely, Harry The You Tube Team "Copyright Service" <copyright@youtube.com> to "Arneson, Latham - Paramount" <Latham_Arneson@paramount.com>, "Dickehut, Robb - Paramount" <Robb_Dickehut@paramount.com>, "Warman, Bryan - Paramount" <Bryan_Warman@paramount.com>, "Lawson, Josh - Paramount" <Josh_Lawson@paramount.com> Cc: jging@google.com, "Marni Harris" <marnih@google.com> Subject: Re: [#257649695] YouTube Account and Clip URL removed 3/31/2008 14:47 10 of 12 11118/097:07 PM Confidential GOOOOl-0968ll48 A-716 Ticket 257649695 http://trax.corp.google.com/html/trax.html?tickeUd=2418807 5 7 Dear Latham, The url links listed below were claimed by a third party agent, BayTSP, working on behalf of Paramount Pictures Corp. BayTSP can be contacted at copyright-compliance@baytsp.com They may have an approved listed that your account can be added to avoid re-claiming this material again. If you would like the material below reinstated please forward a statement retracting the DMCA claims against the material. Thank you for your patience and understanding. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SjKP6pT8eDO http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AgGf_xsoOHI http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rig59Nf9qRw http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t2x6N4qnGdM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xLUPs8zZ-mA Sincerely, Harry The YouTube Team "Arneson, Latham - Paramount" <Latham_Arneson@Paramount.com> to "Copyright Service" <copyright@youtube.com>, "Dickehut, Robb - Paramount" <Robb_Dickehut@Paramount.com>, "Warman, Bryan - Paramount" <Bryan_Warman@Paramount.com>, "Lawson, Josh - Paramount" <Josh_Lawson@Paramount.com> Cc: jging@google.com, "Marni Harris" <marnih@google.com> Subject: RE: [#257649695] YouTube Account and Clip URL removed Hello Harry - 3/31/2008 17:04 I contacted our people at BayTSP regarding these videos so hopefully they will no longer make claims against them. Is it possible for me to state now that we retract any DMCA claims against the material below (the URLs) and ask that you reinstate the videos in question? Pleas let me know if there is anything more we need to do. Thanks, Latham -----Original Message----F r o m : Copyright Service [mailto:copyright@youtube.com] Sent: Monday, March 31, 2008 2:47 PM To: Arneson, Latham - P a r a m o u n t ; Dickehut, Robb - P a r a m o u n t ; Warman, Bryan - P a r a m o u n t ; Lawson, Josh - P a r a m o u n t Cc: jging@google.com; Marni Harris Subject: Re: [#257649695] YouTube Account and Clip URL removed Dear Latham, The url links listed below were claimed by a third party agent, BayTSP, working on behalf of Paramount Pictures Corp. BayTSP can be contacted at copyright-compliance@baytsp.com They may have an approved listed that your account can be added to avoid re-claiming this material again. If you would like the material below reinstated please forward a 11 of 12 11118/097:07 PM Confidential GOOOOl-0968ll49 A-717 Ticket 257649695 http://trax.corp.google.com/html/trax.html?tickeUd=2418807 5 7 statement retracting the DMCA claims against the material. and understanding. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SjKP6pT8eDO http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AgGf xsoOHI http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rig59Nf9qRw http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t2x6N4qnGdM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xLUPs8zZ-mA Thank you for your patience Sincerely, Harry The YouTube Team "Copyright Service" <copyright@youtube.com> to "Arneson, Latham - Paramount" <Latham_Arneson@Paramount.com> Cc: "Dickehut, Robb - Paramount" <Robb_Dickehut@Paramount.com>, "Warman, Bryan - Paramount" <Bryan_Warman@Paramount.com>, "Lawson, Josh - Paramount" <Josh_Lawson@Paramount.com>, jging@google.com, "Marni Harris" <marnih@google.com> Subject: Re: [#257649695] YouTube Account and Clip URL removed Dear Latham, 3/31/2008 19:41 Thank you for the retraction. The material has been reinstated. For technical reasons, it may take a day for the video to be available again. Sincerely, Harry The YouTube Team 12 of 12 11118/097:07 PM Confidential GOOOOl-0968ll50 A-718 S c h a p i r o Exhibit 18 A-719 FIOIl'C O<1~; "Hllii~, Mk!)!l1,,!J'I;t" "'Mlt:heW!na,Hal~@m1¥!'1. (()1'tl:> Thtj, '1 Ot!c 2(l% 09:Sl:3l ,0500 To: "Astwndt»f, $;)!l{Iy, MTVN' '<:.."ar>!jy.A~~ndn1iJ'I"Mwf1.(:om>". ' aillli!;tJ, Ro!wit' ~bb@yj;K(lm.tmtl)o, 'uMr<, Marn" ~Ad;.m..( .... h;m$ml'in_ {(1m". ·Ch~\;:S. G~QigeY~Ge()tge.Cbe~h@\mMtaf!.((lm>, "Dit;on, Wdl<'!lle <:Oilloi1.Mk!~Utg;.mt¥Il't .,!)m;.. , "OW'tiqi:!.!tl. Chfi.J ' if~M " "ct'tr$,OoI!\1tlgu(!:z,g>I'fI1¥sliIifA:{im~, "81ls., C«t)'" -o<Elb.Gtl.,),@ Il1IVM,ttHl1)o, -F'alwy-Rush. C';fMI'I~ <C~~$1 _ Faj1eyRIJ$h$'mt'$"~aff. (om» . "frkHas, MkhJ,e!' -o<Midl<le!.frll;kJas@vli)(OllI,(ortll>, " Co!I!ock, Btian· <:B~ilJI.Gottl!x,.$>Coolea~'(.eIflf3J.wm", 1 f<'INiMlfl, mal; - inm~ (BI..il,Hw5(,n@lmlv5t"ILcDm'>-. ril1-1mg, O(}ug"~_ 0ClIJgJ!trt!)9$CMI~Qy(tlllral<-Q/t\>, 'Hut\-ilZ, L~\l~/I' .. l<'IWNI, HII!Vit:z1Pm!1l~itt:9m>, 'J a~b:otl, GenWl,' <-gei1ki('~d;;ron('iI Himedycetl!ril),tt>m->. "KIm, CI;lffl~ .::Oar<'lJ<..lm·'jfmMtaff.(!t/\J', ~ Mallhit-w:;, Bel}( qteth.Mat\h~ @rni'lt;("j'ttllllr>, -O<fI'ltal(rli@aU"!!tH<lIll ~, "MOO1oIlkl. rlealhtlt · Ml\'W ~Hutl*r,Moo~~k~@'Ilili'".\Ul!f,nm\>, ~ M<::'f'il, !ol;lr\" .;M;o.!kMo(li!@\·~CO!'ll,tl)fl)->, 'i{oiJl<!snll, (i\rl)joe~" t.!!rol/e,robl!'!$()rdPtmV.!Cll1l>, 'Shap%m, Atlrlra-" -o<Mora,Shiipiw@ mMtalt(om'o>, "~mc>n, Joe." <!.Joo.sirnol'l~h·j<lrefTI.(Qm.". 'Suss:mim, !)t\\Ikl' o!{)a\'id5w'i,>ftWl#'mwl'I,rom>, "SUti}11t"f\, D.1\11d" ..J:hvktSomherl (J;\lk\t.om.oom>, "\N~iflStdfl, C"k!l>" ~Q1lo<bWI!in.m'F.I@nw.',,,,::Offl;,, · ~P311~rtt,WI'Il@mNMilff.=>, 'W,,~t, We!!, Paulifl{'" In,,,,ail' ;;JQf:iIa .WtSl ~((ltI1eift~e.ntrl!,(()tI1;>, ·William..~, Reggre' -o<R;e9:9~,Wi{klrn$@ F-w: M1VN ~w:li!kJy ~Qlll>I' No~trr.btf n PR"lil£GEl) AND CONnO£NflAi mrvn.tom>, ~"'clr, Mkh'ler <Mi{ha~JWolf@mM~.(;om" ~(1l"mwt 03. 1:006 ' Midle-,!erta HaHle 5i.' mm Vi(e Pfttti'kllI !:fflP0tV Ge!lera! C(fu<\$l, mtf!Iie<\tl,1! Pm~r;y Confidentia l MtV Nll\WQr\$.., lll..i~,i)'!l!s$ 3t"14l.,i.'ipl Aiblr.; 1S 15 e:w."dw,ly', J.f\" n()or . N'.l.'lf y~, NEW Yml 10036 VIA 16072901 A-720 From: Deana Arizala [manto:deanaa@baytsp.comj Sent: Wednesday, December 06, 2006 5:19 PM To: Hallie, Michelena Cc: Mark M.lshikawa; Co tJ rtney Nieman ; Ev~lyn Espinosa; Morales, Cindy; Sarah Cruz Subject MTVN Weekly Report November 27 - December 03, 2006 Mithelena, Endosed is the November 27 - Decem ber OJ, 2006 Weekly Report. I will be out of the office al3PM (PST) today, so you if you have any question please redirect them to Courtney Nieman. Thank you. Best Regards, Deana Arizala Deana Arlzala Client Services Manager. BayTSP, Inc 408.341.2365 (direct) 408.341.2300 (voice) 408.341.2]99 (fax) List of attachments: Wed.lyReporI 12.03.06. pdf Con fi dential VIA 16072902 A-721 B A V :: T S P l!iI;v.tW_Ij'~ N~a 21 .. ()K>.oOO- 0Cl. 2106 Weekly Report MTVN November 27 ~ December 03, 2006 Tobie of Contents 1~1ic1;!.1E11'r ..... __ ._ .. _ .. ___ . ________ . ____ .. _ , .. 1 ~ 'It\~ !t'~~""'" ""0: ' 1m ,n''''''i; 'w&c'" ho,· """""',,,; '" 't ... <",,,. ;;1 h~~,<,·....!'"i, ""'~' .. t ... ","'"~" ;, ,ON ,.,~<ri ,... I"",""~ r.1<!'"" pc>t.. d,,,,~, '!"l '''~?'''''>:!. ~ c/!'"",.,., '01 ·...,~ i... ;".. ,~_ I.~~~n.'''''' ">'C".....:.,~,~\'<"'_~ !' ,"'P<l'!. , ., Xl Con fidentia l V I A 16072903 A-722 B A Y :: T S P ~otic .. s ~T VN ~.,""" W"',1I' R"po~ 27 · o..o-\>Or03. 2():')6 Sent Novemt>ef 21- Oe c e m _ 03, 2_ Confidential VIA 16072904 A-723 B A V :: T S P No AClbn T k M O tj~""""b <" ~' ~\· '! W.""'f~'i1«' "'"... , " " ' , ~l ' :!"""" ",,'l:! , 1':<<' 17 . D ~ .'<"m!:. ~ . ~J , 1M" Confidential VIA 1607 2 9 0 5 A-724 B A Y :: T S P Numl'J.er 01 Views per Asset No ......... ber 27 · O<tc .. mber O~. MlVN Wee~ 1)' R ~porI Nov .. mbe< 27 - D(!C&mWr 03, 2006 2006 : ... 10 .... "". ~ c l\on, Nclt:e, "ere ,enl , ... _ . No ",,-lion, No rlQt'cel wele,.<'11 Confidential VIA 16072906 A-725 B A Y :: T S P Clp ll?nglti ~Umtll(){Y No.-i>!t1boo' 27 - tIe<::",mb~r 03, '100' N=! ' tl\.~ n· MrV?'1 W~ ~"R"@,,1 :::.x_,"!'~lJ<:,,' roo 2'::05 '0' f! <'It" w~ ,,-,I ~"'j" '.''''-''''''''r ,""" '..""" ' Confiden tial VIA 16072907 A-726 < ~8 l~. , ~~ ,0 11i n · ! · j , 0 " , ! , " jI , t · ,· ~ 1 ~ , , · · i I ~ I , , 1 j 0.. UJ .".. 8. d l- · .. ·, " ·. ~· [D nri _ 0 ~g " 00 ~ ::.. .Q. ~ u~ · > 0' ' Confidential VIA 16072908 A-727 . , j 1 !L UJ f,. Confidential VIA 16072 9 0 9 A-728 l~ ~~ ,. "'''' , . · fi · ~ 1 .. Con fiden tial VI A 160 7 2 9 10 A-729 ~ ., · " Con fi dentia l VIA 16072911 A-730 , " 0:: Confiden ti al VIA 16072912 A-731 " ~~ , z H ". ~8 u · f , " 0 0 . j 11 I.. ·· UJ Confidential VIA 16072913 A-732 0. In I.. .. Con fidentia l VIA16072914 A-733 [L [fJ t.. ·· Confidential VIA16072915 A-734 ·· B A Y · · TSP P2P Infringement Counts By Asset November 27 . Oecember 03, 2006 MTVN Weekly Report November 27 - December 03, 2006 No Toke Down Action · ConhOenl ial · 14 of 20 Con fi dent ia l VIA 160729 16 A-735 ii ., ~~ , u i, · z , " . " , Ul I- ·· e. ., ·8 ,0 00 :2 1; 5, o· 0 ~ In Confide ntia l VIA 16072917 ~ .. · N _ u E" ~] " ~,:. :S ~ .f ~ .z · A-736 , " . Do: Ul I- C o nfiden tial VIA 16072918 A-737 H {~ ') ~. ."l " , I " !, " 0.. UJ f·· ., Confidential VIA 16072919 A-738 ·· ·· Confidential VIA 16072920 A-739 (L to f·· ·· Confidential VIA 16072921 A-740 j~ , , til B .9 ,.;; n · I · ·· ·· Con fi dential VIA 16072922 A-741 Schapiro Exhibit 22 A-742 From: Sent: Mark M. Ishikawa Saturday, October 07,20066:50 AM Hallie, Michelena paramount_cc To: Cc: Subject: Assets remaining on YouTube Michelena, We have completed our initial scans and removal of the selected assets from YouTube as per your instructions. We will continue to scan and remove assets as they are uploaded. I did some scanning of the remaining assets which did not meet the "appears like entire episodes" model and quite a bit remains. e are eavmg a majority 0 t e content on ou u e. have other clients that will send takedown notices for clips as short as 4 seconds as long as its identifiable as the content. Let me know if you want to discuss this. Thx Mark 6/11/2008 HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL BAYTSP 003723588 A-743 Schapiro Exhibit 23 A-744 A-745 A-746 Schapiro Exhibit 24 A-747 A-748 A-749 A-750 Schapiro Exhibit 25 A-751 Subject: RE: trailers on youtube From: "Scott Roesch" <EX:/O=ATOMSHOCKWAVE/OU=SAN FRANCISCO/CN= RECIPIENTS/CN=SROESCH> Megan O'Neill To: Date: Fri, 23 Feb 2007 17:58:06 +0000 Cc: Redacted for Privilege ~exceplted content under 2:30 (ie, stuff that is promotional Would be great -- w e ' v e done this with other pieces as well. From: Megan O'Neill Sent: Friday, February 23, 20078:27 AM To: Scott Roesch Subject: trailers on youtube Hi Scott: In light of MTVN's relationship with YouTube, do you think they will allow us to upload trailers that promote studio pieces? The chicks guys want to upload a trailer that gives their af uri to help drive more traffic. Thx, Megan Confidential VIA11918145 A-752 Schapiro Exhibit 28 A-753 From: Date: To: "Frank, Kristin - MTVN" <Kristin.Frank@logostaff.com> Wed, 11 Oct 2006 10:01:34 -0400 "Sherman, Lisa" <Lisa.Sherman@logostaff.com>, "Witt, jason" < jason.Witt@mtvstaff.com>, "Parent, Richard" <Richard.Parent@ logostaff.com> "Leonard, Marc" <Marc.Leonard@Logostaff.com> Cc: Subject: RE: YouTube Weekly Report Richard - please continue pulling full episodes and as we had discussed, leave random clips up because they are promotional in nature for us. Thanks all -----Original Message----From: Sherman, Lisa Sent: Wednesday, October 11, 2006 7:39 AM To: Witt, jason; Frank, Kristin - MTVN; Parent, Richard Cc: Leonard, Marc Subject: Re: YouTube Weekly Report I'm inclined to keep clips on there for now ... Sent from my BlackBerry Wireless Handheld -----Original Message----From: Witt, jason To: Frank, Kristin - MTVN; Parent, Richard CC: Leonard, Marc; Sherman, Lisa Sent: Wed Oct 11 01:02:05 2006 Subject: RE: YouTube Weekly Report We are going to try to do something with them--actually taking it upstairs tomorrow to get green light. But that shouldn't change anything you'd do in normal course--so if you typically yank 'em, keep doing it until we have something. Generally folks from other brands are pulling down full eps, and leaving other stuff up for now. From: Frank, Kristin - MTVN Sent: Tue 10/10/2006 7:49 PM To: Parent, Richard; Witt, jason Cc: Leonard, Marc; Sherman, Lisa Subject: RE: YouTube Weekly Report Now, there also is a deal going down with You Tube where we would get ad sales dollars from these ... jason - should we not be pulling down our content from YOU TUBE at this point based on where we are with the deal Please advise - thanks -----Original Message----From: Parent, Richard Sent: Tuesday, October 10, 2006 7:49 PM To: Frank, Kristin - MTVN Confidential VIA11918146 A-754 '""""Ori~if\<i! f;,~'~~~~i~~t"'"""' Ftnm~ h""m!i:, KrbVf!" MT\lN T;~: l~::::lS)a:J\~,Mil:N:; Pi3;r~f'l:t, Rid~Mf$; Op,,~ti.lt, ti~$'~\ J¥;~~i~(i~~, ·.hj,;;!i3tl~: $h~tJ'n¥\ u~~ Sentl\~~ 0u"lO 1'941:11 2::..ID® St!~~"ett: Rt.~ Y!JullJh~ l;-V~~k~y R~P~)f{ Ftum: S~nt: L~l)tl:i.§JtL Ma:fc h.~<t$di.W. O;;.~()t~"l:H P~r:-e~t, 10, ;W06 452 F'M E~{Nm:: r"r<~~k; l;): Rich:.trJ; OP~~t<it, Kris1l:ri, MlVN; J~wh~tm, j~Mm1~; Shit~'nMr,:, liM St~I:ijf:'{t:~\V~ Ym~li.Jb~ ~V~~kfy R~port frw:,r $~r,:t Mm;~Jes, On~t Tlms{i:~),. Oc~OOOt 10, 2(lO~ 4:44 PM 1(1: Md~n~, R0ofl:li~: P:;)~~mer, M~~i$~;$; Lewal<d, B~ti<; CUi1~fI, M$~,' B~§h: VVetn$~e'b, C;ale:b: tl?vj~, S~h· te9~1; t~'l)::'lm'd, M~~: t)~B~~I>.'ihnis, P~ul J ' MTV [>'rl§b~ }Oit\ U~n~~ Ch@~ks, G~:Q1'9~\ G!)tlkKk,~d;ln; Cc: Sh~t,i:m, AI'i;(j:j'a: JiKk~t.·Hl, G~d§~; AtKkw&'ll, Md~ St-@&'l@; t);:m; M~l~h}, J{lM!~h -" ,MTVN; H~dl~, M}(:h(:k::fl,:l: NiAll, Confidential VIA 11918147 A-755 Redacted for Privilege .,.;;",; Fi~~; M1VN Hf!rOtLW.(}K{)6,~b ><> Citl:lJ~' MlJof<lI!?:$ M.an<1lfef; !nte!I'e~·j.mtl Pmp:<:!~li" M'lV ISt~ N~tMir~~ §3:t\1ikdwav Y!)tk, N'{ m(n~ p., n;Ut!46Jt:892 t 211JNK1?14 N~?w Confidential VIA11918148 A-756 Schapiro Exhibit 31 A-757 To: From: Cc: Bcc: Received Date: Subject: "Heather Gillette" <hgillette@google.com> "Courtney Nieman" <courtneyni@baytsp.com> 2006-12-1416:44:29 GMT RE: [html] Re: Thanks - mybad. I just looked it up and servicerep is the contact for another organization. Please forgive the mix up. Hope all is well in the land of video. Have a great day. Courtney Nieman From: Heather Gillette [mailto:hgillette@google.com] Sent: Thursday, December 14, 20068:39 AM To: Courtney Nieman Cc: heather gillette Subject: [html] Re: Hey there Courtney, This is down. Also, please make sure you email~nd not _ otherwise my 24/7 team won't see th~ I will respond to your other email soon, I have not yet had a chance! Heather On 12/14/06, Courtney Nieman <courtneyni@baytsp.com> wrote: Please take down http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CAI8KEOaTgg <http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CAI8KEOaTgg>.This director account put up the entire movie and is in violation of the DMCA and Copyright laws. This request is made by BayTSP on behalf of Paramount Pictures Corporation. Thank you for your attention and quick response. Courtney Nieman Manager Client Services BayTSP, Inc. 408-341-2314 AIM: BayTSPCanne Have you checked out BayTSP's Piracy news web log? http://www. baytsp. com/weblog <http://www.baytsp.com/weblog> The information contained in this email message may be confidential and is intended only for the parties to whom it is addressed. If you are not the intended recipient or an agent of same, please notify us of the mistake by telephone (408-341-2300) or email and Confidential GOOOOI-00222788 A-758 delete the message from your system. Please do not copy the message or distribute it to anyone. Courtney Nieman Manager Client Services BayTSP, Inc. 408-341-2314 AIM: BayTSPCanne Have you checked out BayTSP's Piracy news web log? http://www. baytsp. com/weblog <http://www.baytsp.com/weblog> The information contained in this email message may be confidential and is intended only for the parties to whom it is addressed. If you are not the intended recipient or an agent of same, please notify us of the mistake by telephone (408-341-2300) or email and delete the message from your system. Please do not copy the message or distribute it to anyone. Confidential GOOOOI-00222789 A-759 Schapiro Exhibit 43 A-760 To: From: Cc: Bcc: Received Date: Subject: "chris@youtube.com" <chris@youtube.com> "Dean_Garfield @mpaa. org" <Dean_Garfield @mpaa. org> 2007-06-0722:56:46 CST RE: Video Fingerprinting Agreemen Thanks Chris. I appreciate the call. I will take a look at the document and get back to you in the next few days with our thoughts. -----Original Message----From: Chris Maxcy [mailto:chris@youtube.com] Sent: Thursday, June 07,20072:43 PM To: Garfield, Dean Subject: Video Fingerprinting Agreemen Hi Dean, It was great catching up with you today. Here is the document that I mentioned (hopefully you will find it as benign ;-). We are looking forward to the opportunity to work with you on our upcoming video fingerprinting test. Please let me know when you are ready to chat further. Best, Chris Chris Maxcy YouTube . . .com This email and the information it contains are confidential and may be privileged. If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately and do not copy it for any purpose, or disclose its contents to any other person. Internet communications are not secure and, therefore, Google does not accept legal responsibility for the contents of this message as it has been transmitted over a public network. If you suspect the message may have been intercepted or amended please call me. Confidential GOOOOI-00021505 A-761 Schapiro Exhibit 44 A-762 To: From: CC: BCC: Sent Date: Subject: <chris@youtube.com> <Dean Garfield@mpaa.org> <ingh~lbrecht@google.com> 2007-06-16 01:25:16 GMT Re: Video Fingerprinting Test Hello, i am doing well. I was in your neck of the woods today. I was at a CEOs conference and was supposed to be on a panel with Messr. Drummond. He did not show and took a lot of ribbing for not being there. Anyway, I will check in with our GC on the NDA and get back to you next week. Have a great weekend. Sent from my BlackBerry Wireless Handheld ----- O r i g i n a l Message ----F r o m : Chris Maxcy <chris@youtube.com> To: Garfield, Dean Cc: 'Philip Inghelbrecht' <inghelbrecht@google.com> Sent: Fri Jun 15 17:13:52 2007 Subject: Video Fingerprinting Test Hi Dean, Hope you had a good week. Just checking in to see if you have any thoughts on the fingerprint test agreement? We'd love to get you guys up an running on the test. Look forward to speaking soon. Best, Chris Chris Maxcy YouTube chris@youtube.com This email and the information it contains are confidential and may be privileged. If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately and do not copy it for any purpose, or disclose its contents to any other person. Internet communications are not secure and, therefore, Google does not accept legal responsibility for the contents of this message as it has been transmitted over a public network. If you suspect the message may have been intercepted or amended please call me. Highly Confidential GOOOOl-0709l995 A-763 Schapiro Exhibit 45 A-764 To: From: Rachel Claflin <rclaflin@youtube.com> Kip Welch <KWelch@movielabs.com> Dean_Garfield@mpaa.org <Dean_Garfield@mpaa.org>; Zahavah Levine Steve Weinstein <SWeinstein@movielabs.com>; anna_gunning@mpaa.org mpaa.org> 2007-07-2623:33:02 GMT RE: MPAAIYouTube Content Verification Test Agreement Bcc: Received Date: Subject: Thanks, Rachel. Attached is an electronic copy executed by MovieLabs. Kip From: rclaflin@google.com [mailto:rclaflin@google.com] On Behalf Of Rachel Claflin Sent: Thursday, July 26,20074:02 PM To: Kip Welch Cc: Dean_Garfield@mpaa.org; Zahavah Levine; Steve Weinstein; anna_gunning@mpaa.org Subject: MPAAIYouTube Content Verification Test Agreement Hi Kip, Attached is a PDF of the signed version of the MPAAIYouTube Content Verification Test Agreement. Dean suggested that you would be able to sign this in Steve Weinstein's absence. Please sign the attached _ · .. -II". _ ·· return to me by either e-mail or fax. Our fax number is Kind Regards, Rachel Rachel Claflin Legal Assistant YouTube, LLC 1000 Cherry Ave, Suite 2 Attachments: Scann001 .pdf Confidential Expert - L i e s GOOOOI-06126509 A-765 MPA INTERNATIONAL Fax:8183821796 Jul 26 2007 9:28 P.02 I I ,.\ I ! CONTENT veRIFICATION TEST AGRI!E!MENT I ; tfConfidential Expert - L i e s GOOOOI-06126510 A-766 MPR INTERNRTIONRL Fax:8183821796 Jul 26 2007 9:29 P.03 , "1 I i i I 2 Confidential Expert - L i e s GOOOOI-06126511 A-767 MPA INTERNATIONAL Fax:8183821796 Jul 26 2007 9:30 P.04 3 Confidential Expert - L i e s GOOOOI-06126512 A-768 Schapiro Exhibit 52 A-769 Hollister. Jesse Crom: Jent: To: Subject: yourfriends@atom.com Tuesday, September 05, 2006 5:41 PM akspellicy@yahoo.com.au Addicting Clips Content Removal [Copyright] (KMM519159121263LOKM) Counter-Notification of Infrigement.doc Attachments: RE: I Closed My Eyes http://www.addictingclips.com/Clip.aspx?key=AOFOD4934C9D1068 Hello, As a passive conduit, we cannot monitor user clips, but we respond to breaches of our Terms of Service when we learn of such behavior. It was brought to our attention that your content violated our Terms of Service. It was therefore removed from Counter-Notificatio n of Infrig ... the Addicting Clips web site. If you believe that the content was removed in error, and specifically was not infringing on the copyright of another, and you want to put the materials back on the Addicting Clips website, you must provide us with a ~ormal Counter-Notification of Infringement. Please be advised that we are obligated by the terms of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) of 1998 to disclose the information you supply in this form to the original notifier. This CounterNotification is both embedded in this email and attached for your convenience. Please note that under Section 512( f) of the Copyright Act, any person who knowingly materially misrepresents that material or activity was removed or disabled by mistake or misidentification may be subject to liability. Please also be advised that we enforce a policy that provides for the termination in appropriate circumstances of subscribers who are repeat infringers. ********************************************************** Counter-Notification of Infringement I hereby certify under penalty of perjury that I am the owner or am authorized to act on behalf of the owner of the intellectual property rights. I have a good faith belief that material identified below was removed by mistake. Please promptly restore the material described below. Description of the Material Removed: Previous Location of the Material Removed: Date: I can be contacted at: Name: Title: Company or Organization: Highly Confidential VIA 16075524 A-770 Street Address: City: State: ~ip: Telephone: Facsimile: Email: I certify under penalty of petjury the truth of the above information. I hereby consent to the jurisdiction of the federal court in which I reside and that I will accept service of process from the original notifier. Signature: ********************************************************** Regards, User Abuse Manager, Addicting Clips Atom Entertainment, Inc. 2 Highly Confidential VIA 16075525 A-771 Schapiro Exhibit 56 YouTube Blog: Your 15 Minutes of Fame..ummm...Make that 10 Minutes or Less Page 1 of 9 A-772 Share Report Abuse Next Blog» Search Create Blog Sign In Home Videos Channels Shows SUNDAY, MARCH 26, 2006 Your 15 Minutes of Fame..ummm...Make that 10 Minutes or Less The past few months have been phenomenal for us here at YouTube, thanks to all of you. We've been going through unprecedented growth. Most days it seems we can barely catch our breath trying to keep up with everything, and sometimes I sit at my desk and look around at the 20 or so people around me and cannot believe how far we've come in such a short period of time. No matter how fast we grow or how large we may become, our primary goal is, and will always be, about being in touch with our users and providing them the best online video experience possible. That being said, we've gotten a fair amount of emails lately about the new 10 minute limit we've implemented for video uploads. For those of you not familiar with this change, we've always had a 100MB file limit for uploads. We also recently implemented a 10 minute length limit. This change won't impact the vast majority of our users. We know that over 99% of videos uploaded are already under 10 mins, and we also know that most of our users only watch videos that are under about 3 minutes in length. Search This Blog Search powered by Subscribe To Community Gatherings So, if most of our users are uploading and watching short form video clips, why even bother to make the change? If it ain't broke, don't fix it right? Well, if you've followed our blog postings or any of the press articles, you know we're constantly trying to balance the rights of copyright owners with the rights of our users. We poked around the system a bit and found that these longer videos were more likely to be copyrighted videos from tv shows and movies than the shorter videos posted. However, we also recognize that there are legit content creators out there who may have videos over 10 mins, so we've created a Premium Content Program for those of you with professional-produced videos. Portland, OR - June 26-27, 2010 Los Angeles, CA - Vidcon - July 911, 2010 Los Angeles, CA - Noncon - July 911, 2010 London, UK - Aug. 6-8, 2010 Past Gatherings Hosting a meetup? Leave a comment on this channel with details Twitter / youtube youtube: Congrats to @MysteryGuitarM, featured in @cnnmoney's Best Jobs series http://goo.gl/7OhV youtube: Inform, engage and mobilize voters with YouTube and @google campaign toolkits: http://goo.gl/rd0S youtube: @cpayne12 Um, Disco, of course! Best, Maryrose youtube: @PecosRoyBean Not at all :) youtube: @mediocrefilms Nice congrats! What We're Watching Adopt a Feature What about the little guys you ask? We hear ya. We know that although most users are uploading short form clips, there are those of you out there that are video bloggers or amateur film makers that have legitimate, user generated content over 10 mins, and obviously, this is not an ideal situation for you. We recognize that, and we're actively working on a solution that will allow for those of you with longer form user generated content, while still preventing copyrighted full length episodes from entering the system. In fact, if you are a user with videos over 10 mins, please contact us. We want to hear from you. We want to know how you've been impacted by this change and any thoughts or ideas you may have. Remember: this site is about you, and we're listening. The YouTube Team 23 comments: kieranmullen said... Citizentube EDU Movies MusicTuesday http://youtube-global.blogspot.com/2006/03/your-15-minutes-of-fameummmmake-that-10.h... 6/4/2010 YouTube Blog: Your 15 Minutes of Fame..ummm...Make that 10 Minutes or Less Page 2 of 9 A-773 The linke to Premium Content Program no longer works. News KieranMullen http://360oregon.com August 19, 2009 11:27 AM BattlefieldDoktor said... Kiearan ... check the date of this very old blog .... the Premium Content Program got already replaced by the Director Program and later by the Partner Program ;o)) August 27, 2009 4:40 AM Mike Lisanke said... Also, the email for Maryrose using the "contact us" link is no longer a valid email address. I was replying that this limit is a barrier to educational meeting content. I understand that's not your market, but; I thought I'd mention it anyway. I'll look elsewhere to find a video repository for our material. November 5, 2009 11:03 AM zeroxy said... Nice Thx sinema , vizyondakiler December 16, 2009 8:25 AM a11000 said... My daughter's 17 minute piano piece I recorded CANNOT be severed in half. This 10 minute limit is arbitrary and there should be some way users can purchase for a small fee a bit of additional time on a one-time basis. January 5, 2010 8:40 PM trompetejogador said... I am totally disgusted with YOUTUBE. I have a video blog called "Politically Incorrect Radio". My latest "attempt" was about 9.5 minutes long. I timed it with my watch. I use MS Movie maker. It's time line is set up so it shows minutes and seconds. Now I have to "divide" my blog. I did that B4. This 1st have was watched. The 2nd half was not. I am unemployed and cannot afford ANY "Premium" channel. I do not post material from other people. Then there's my "copy right"Issue concerning the sound track from Spring Lake Iron & Steel Charles Wesley Works. That music came from ROXIO PHOTO. Not me. I tried to use music I made such as on my other videos with Roxio. But it wouldn't let me. However the video is available with a ad for "Sonny Rollands". So now I go to waste time splitting my video up knowing the 1st part will be watched and not the 2nd. How a 9.5 minute video ends up being 23.56 minutes is beyond me!!!! I DO NOT POST OTHER PEOPLE'S VIDEOS. Now it will make me spend TWICE the time and cut my viewership. SOMEBODY FROM YOUTUBE RESPOND TO ME strobx1 February 10, 2010 5:11 AM Rehd said... This post has been removed by the author. March 31, 2010 11:28 PM Korsan said... thank you Online Film Online divx Film türkçe dublaj Film izle virgin film izle kaliteli film izle vizyon filmleri izle Already a member?Sign in Screening Room Shows YouTube Channel What We're Reading Citizentube Creator's Corner Partner & Advertiser Blog Blog Archive 2010 (129 ) 2009 (284 ) 2008 (251 ) 2007 (131 ) 2006 (37) December (2) November (5) October (7) September (3) August (3) July (1) June (3) May (3) April (2) March (3) YouTube Labs Introduces The Smiley Face Factory Your 15 Minutes of Fame..ummm...Make that 10 Minut... That's Entertainment February (3) January (2) 2005 (15) Followers Follow with Google Friend Connect Followers (4675) More » Copyright © 2009 YouTube Inc. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service http://youtube-global.blogspot.com/2006/03/your-15-minutes-of-fameummmmake-that-10.h... 6/4/2010 YouTube Blog: Your 15 Minutes of Fame..ummm...Make that 10 Minutes or Less Page 3 of 9 A-774 April 16, 2010 12:56 PM ibrahim said... Sesli SohbetgelSesli Chatgor SesliSohbetsendeSesliChatbize Sesli Sohbet siteleri katilSesli Chat siteleri hadi SeslibeklemeChatyoksa Sohbetpisman kamerali Chatolursun kamerali Sohbet amaSesli siteler is isten Sohbet sitelerigecmis Chat siteleriolacak thanks. Sohbet merkezi chat merkezi Sesli merkezi sesli Sohbet merkezi Sesli chat merkezi Sohbetmerkezi Sesli Sohbet gelSesli Chatgor SesliSohbetsendeSesliChatbize Sesli Sohbet siteleri katilSesli Chat siteleri hadi SeslibeklemeChatyoksa Sohbetpisman kamerali Chatolursun kamerali Sohbet amaSesli siteler is isten Sohbet sitelerigecmis Chat siteleriolacak thanks. May 6, 2010 5:00 PM nike said... Edhardy-uk/au ed hardy clothing | cheap ed hardy| ed hardy online store | ed hardy clothes | discount ed hardy | cheap ed hardy| ed hardy uk| discount ed hardy shirts| cheap ed hardy shirts | ed hardy t shirts| ed hardy long sleeve | ed hardy mens| ed hardy womens | ed hardy outerwear | ed hardy shoes| ed hardy boots| ed hardy snow boots | ed hardy kid's| ed hardy hoodies | ed hardy jackets | ed hardy sunglasses | ed hardy handbags| ed hardy wallets | ed hardy swimwear | cheap ed hardy shirts | cheap ed hardy hoodies | ed hardy long sleeve | ed hardy men| ed hardy women | ed hardy jackets | ed hardy men's shoes | ed hardy boots| ed hardy snow boots | ed hardy winter boots | ed hardy kid| ed hardy hoodies | ed hardy sunglasses | ed hardy handbags| ed hardy wallets | ed hardy swimwear | http://youtube-global.blogspot.com/2006/03/your-15-minutes-of-fameummmmake-that-10.h... 6/4/2010 YouTube Blog: Your 15 Minutes of Fame..ummm...Make that 10 Minutes or Less Page 4 of 9 A-775 May 7, 2010 5:43 PM nike said... Ed-hardy-shirts cheap ed hardy clothing | ed hardy t shirts| ed hardy shirts| ed hardy online store | ed hardy womens | ed hardy mens| ed hardy bags| ed hardy boots| ed hardy shoes| ed hardy men's jeans | ed hardy women's jackets | ed hardy men's shirts | ed hardy women's handbags | christian audiger long sleeve | ed hardy wholesale | ed hardy christian audigier | christian audigier shirts | ed hardy women's long sleeve | ed hardy outerwear | ed hardy jacket| ed hardy swimwear | christian audigier hoodies | wholesale ed hardy shirts | ed hardy shirts for men| ed hardy shirts cheap | ed hardy t shirts for women | Nike Chaussures Remise Chaussures Sport | Chaussure de Sports | Marques Chaussures Sport | 2010 Air Max Chaussures | Nike Shox R4| nike tn requin| nike max tn| nike tn | tn requin | nikemaxtn| Chaussures Sport | Nike chaussures hommes | Nike chaussures femmes | Nike chaussures enfants | Nike chaussures sport | nike femmes chaussures | chaussure nike tn requin | chaussure nike air max | chaussure nike tn | nike tn| May 7, 2010 5:44 PM nike said... Ed-hardy-clothing ed hardy clothing us | ed hardy clothing | ed hardy clothes | ed hardy ugg boots | ed hardy wear| ed hardy polo shirts | ed hardy love kills slowly | ed hardy love kills slowly boots | ed hardy love kills slowly shoes | ed hardy love kills slowly shirts | ed hardy trousers | http://youtube-global.blogspot.com/2006/03/your-15-minutes-of-fameummmmake-that-10.h... 6/4/2010 YouTube Blog: Your 15 Minutes of Fame..ummm...Make that 10 Minutes or Less Page 5 of 9 A-776 ed hardy jackets| ed hardy women's t shirts | ed hardy boots| ed hardy womens shirts | ed hardy outerwear | christian audigier jackets | ed hardy womens jeans | ed hardy handbags | ed hardy winter boots | ed hardy t shirts| christian audigier hoodies | ed hardy mens jeans | ed hardy mens shoes | ed hardy womens hoodies | Ed-hardy-us cheap ed hardy| cheap ed hardy clothing | ed hardy clothes | ed hardy wholesale | ed hardy clothing | ed hardy outerwear | ed hardy t shirts| ed hardy long sleeve | ed hardy hoodies | ed hardy men's| ed hardy women's | ed hardy shoes| ed hardy kid| ed hardy jeans| ed hardy handbags | ed hardy pants| christian audiger t shirts | christian audigier hoodies | christian audigier shirts | May 7, 2010 5:45 PM Seyhan said... yeni oyunlar en yeni oyunlar www.aslanmax.com www.aslanmax.com oyunu ben 10 alien force oyunu bütün oyunlar tüm oyunlar dinle mp3 May 12, 2010 7:04 PM nike said... Honour to be here! Truly a nice work! Greatest post I have ever seen! Thank you for sharing it! Have a good day! sport shoes shop | cheap nike air| cheap nike shox| cheap nike max| cheap puma shoes | cheap nike shoes | puma shoes| discount puma shoes | nike sports shoes | nike air force ones | cheap sport shoes | nike shox torch| puma cat | puma future cat | nike shox r4| nike shox nz| nike air max ltd| nike running shoes | nike tn dollar | http://youtube-global.blogspot.com/2006/03/your-15-minutes-of-fameummmmake-that-10.h... 6/4/2010 YouTube Blog: Your 15 Minutes of Fame..ummm...Make that 10 Minutes or Less Page 6 of 9 A-777 ferrari shoes| air jordan shoes| nike air max tn| jordan mens shoes | nike air max| nike women shoes | cheap puma ferrari shoes | nike shox rival| nike mens shoes| nike air max 360 | nike air max 2010| nike air max 2009| nike air max 90| May 16, 2010 7:56 PM nike said... Ed-hardy-clothing ed hardy clothing us | ed hardy clothing | ed hardy clothes | ed hardy ugg boots | ed hardy wear| ed hardy polo shirts | ed hardy love kills slowly | ed hardy love kills slowly boots | ed hardy love kills slowly shoes | ed hardy love kills slowly shirts | ed hardy trousers | ed hardy jackets | ed hardy women's t shirts | ed hardy boots| ed hardy womens shirts | ed hardy outerwear | christian audigier jackets | ed hardy womens jeans | ed hardy handbags | ed hardy winter boots | ed hardy t shirts| christian audigier hoodies | ed hardy mens jeans | ed hardy mens shoes | ed hardy womens hoodies | Ed-hardy-us cheap ed hardy| cheap ed hardy clothing | ed hardy clothes | ed hardy wholesale | ed hardy clothing | ed hardy outerwear | ed hardy t shirts| ed hardy long sleeve | ed hardy hoodies | ed hardy men's| ed hardy women's | ed hardy shoes| ed hardy kid| ed hardy jeans| ed hardy handbags | ed hardy pants| christian audiger t shirts | christian audigier hoodies | christian audigier shirts | May 16, 2010 7:58 PM nike said... http://youtube-global.blogspot.com/2006/03/your-15-minutes-of-fameummmmake-that-10.h... 6/4/2010 YouTube Blog: Your 15 Minutes of Fame..ummm...Make that 10 Minutes or Less Page 7 of 9 A-778 Nike Chaussures Remise Chaussures Sport | Chaussure de Sports | Marques Chaussures Sport | 2010 Air Max Chaussures | Nike Shox R4| nike tn requin| nike max tn| nike tn | tn requin | nikemaxtn| Chaussures Sport | Nike chaussures hommes | Nike chaussures femmes | Nike chaussures enfants | Nike chaussures sport | nike femmes chaussures | chaussure nike tn requin | chaussure nike air max | chaussure nike tn | nike tn| May 16, 2010 8:01 PM nike said... Edhardy-uk/au ed hardy clothing | cheap ed hardy| ed hardy online store | discount ed hardy shirts| cheap ed hardy shirts | ed hardy t shirts| ed hardy long sleeve | ed hardy mens| ed hardy womens | ed hardy outerwear | ed hardy shoes| ed hardy boots| ed hardy snow boots | ed hardy kid's| ed hardy hoodies | ed hardy jackets | ed hardy sunglasses | ed hardy handbags| ed hardy wallets | ed hardy swimwear | ed hardy clothes | discount ed hardy | cheap ed hardy| ed hardy uk| cheap ed hardy shirts | cheap ed hardy hoodies | ed hardy long sleeve | ed hardy men| ed hardy women | ed hardy jackets | ed hardy men's shoes | ed hardy boots| ed hardy snow boots | ed hardy winter boots | ed hardy kid| ed hardy hoodies | ed hardy sunglasses | ed hardy handbags| ed hardy wallets | ed hardy swimwear | Ed-hardy-shirts http://youtube-global.blogspot.com/2006/03/your-15-minutes-of-fameummmmake-that-10.h... 6/4/2010 YouTube Blog: Your 15 Minutes of Fame..ummm...Make that 10 Minutes or Less Page 8 of 9 A-779 cheap ed hardy clothing | ed hardy t shirts| ed hardy shirts| ed hardy online store | ed hardy womens | ed hardy mens| ed hardy bags| May 16, 2010 8:03 PM ideal said... bedava oyunlar en güzel oyunlar Oyunlar zuma oyunu balon patlatma oyunu scooby doo zuma May 17, 2010 12:32 PM YouTube Holic said... Youtube is Great Video Broadcast site, .. May 24, 2010 3:33 AM nokia-021 said... Sesli SohbetgelSesli Chat siteleri Sesli Sohbet siteleri sendeSesli Chat Sesli Sohbet gelSesli Chat siteleri Sesli Sohbet siteleri dostum beklemeSesli Chat Sesli Sohbetyoksa pismanSesli Chat siteleri Sesli Sohbet siteleri olacaksinSesli Chat Sesli SohbettiklagelSesli Chat siteleri Sesli Sohbet siteleri bizim siteyeSesli Chat Sesli Sohbetsende katilSesli Chat siteleri Sesli Sohbet siteleri ortamimizaSesli Chat Sesli Sohbetbizi bekletmeSesli Chat siteleri Sesli Sohbet siteleri dostluklarSesli Chat Sesli SohbetarkadasliklarSesli Chat siteleri Sesli Sohbet siteleri asklarSesli Chat Sesli Sohbetmuhabbet eglence Sesli Chat siteleri Sesli Sohbet siteleri hersey burdaSesli Chat Sesli Sohbethaydi ne bekliyorsunSesli Chat siteleri Sesli Sohbet siteleri sohbet zamaniSesli Chat Sesli Sohbethep birlikteSesli Chat siteleri Sesli Sohbet siteleri guzel dostluklaraSesli Chat May 27, 2010 12:42 AM Mesut said... | | Unterkunft in Alanya | home in Alanya | | Full Dizi izle Dizi Seyret Dizi izle FullDizi Diziseyret Full Dizi Dizi izle.com Kurtlar Vadisi Pusu Son Bölüm izle indirmeden film izleme sitesi film izle bedava filmler sinema filmi izle film seyret binlerce filmler film izle online sinema izletir sinema izle bedava film izle filmini full izle film ücretsiz sinema izleme sitesi izle filmini izle film seyret direk filmler sinema seyret film izle seyret vizyondan sonra sinema film izle full sinema izleme sitesi sinema izle filmleri tam izle film indirmeden izlesene film bedava izle filim bedava film izle filmler full ve bedava full film izle May 29, 2010 6:13 AM http://youtube-global.blogspot.com/2006/03/your-15-minutes-of-fameummmmake-that-10.h... 6/4/2010 YouTube Blog: Your 15 Minutes of Fame..ummm...Make that 10 Minutes or Less Page 9 of 9 A-780 OsmaNetworkS said... türk pornosu için türk pornosu sitesine bakabilirsiniz Sex izle sitesini ziyaret etmenizi önerebiliriz sitesini ziyaret edin film izlemek isteyenler içinde film izle sitesini ziyaret edin porno için kesinlikle Porno izle sitesi ve en güzel porno videolar için Porno izle kesinlikle ziyaret edin türk pornosu sitesi sitesi jigolo arayan bayanlar ve gayler için jigolo sitesi isteklerinize cevap verecektir jigolo arayan bayanlar ve gayler için jigolo hizmeti vermektedir jigolo arayan bayanlar ve gayler için jigolo uzman jigolodur May 30, 2010 5:21 AM RJ said... glad this changed over time austin weddings austin wedding venues austin wedding photographer austin wedding planners wedding blogs June 1, 2010 10:25 AM P os t a C o m m e nt Comment as: Select profile... Post Comment Preview Links to this post Create a Link Newer Post Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom) Home Older Post http://youtube-global.blogspot.com/2006/03/your-15-minutes-of-fameummmmake-that-10.h... 6/4/2010 A-781 Schapiro Exhibit 154 A-782 Subject: From: To: Cc: Date: RE: Viral Internet Marketing Clips Kadetsky, Deborah < EX:/O=VIACOM/OU = MTVUSA/CN = RECIPIENTS/CN = USER ACCOUNTS/CN=USER/CN=KADETSKD> Hallie, Michelena Morales, Cindy, Carbone, Tony, Imm, Tina Fri, 27 Oct 2006 22:35: 10 +0000 I can only speak to youtube, but cc'ing tony carbone to address google. It would be great if you guys could sweep based on username, because we are consisntely only adding youtube videos under the "vh1staff" username. There MAY be future instances where we are posting outside of that, and can alert you to leave it posted. But it would be a significant task to keep you updated on each and every clip we post ongoing ... Let me know if the username concept is one you can consider. Thanks! deb -----Original Message----From: Hallie, Michelena Sent: Friday, October 27, 20066:25 PM To: Kadetsky, Deborah Cc: Morales, Cindy Subject: RE: Viral Internet Marketing Clips And in answer to your question on frequency, it's going to be pretty constant and actually expanding to myspace, google video and yahoo video. Could you send any other/future approved clips on any of these sites to Cindy so that she can make sure they are not removed? -----Original Message----From: Kadetsky, Deborah Sent: Friday, October 27, 20066:07 PM To: Cheeks, George; Maxwell, Tony Cc: Wilson, Adam; Hallie, Michelena; Imm, Tina Subject: RE: Viral Internet Marketing Clips George, are you able to do your sweep of clips according to who's posted them? If that is the case, the clips that we've authorized to be posted are under the usernames "vh1staff" and "reaction2006" If you need specific links, here is a list of what we've posted as approved clips to date: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qWGT7Rfrvk http://www.youtube.com/watch ?v=j FoQNdwaGys http://www.youtube.com/watch?v= _5vjL2stAzO http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M-G_NQZb11I http://www.youtube.com/watch ?v= qvUzUOSbs9Y http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xPfTPn-eGKk http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3saVM096328 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PjiZqOOAipw http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x1ycbHjePjM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hFoCygnKOaA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4CtHP6Ut-zM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dy9IYAELqIE http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kihSHIoW-Tg http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yZ1SEDh_JPc Confidential VIA 11789373 A-783 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ia_pI6rVg_k http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zlbL-zhMK8k http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ynJmXSht2jl http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uXnx5QxpIRc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zgBI1BKpwjQ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pAkp_Hr5rN4 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v= BRbM2qfD08U http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QQxyhtYk3CI Do you have a sense of how frequently we'll be doing this takedown sweep? I want to make sure than any future postings through our current process don't get removed accidentally. Thanks, deb -----Original Message----From: Cheeks, George Sent: Friday, October 27,2006 1:33 PM To: Kadetsky, Deborah; Maxwell, Tony Cc: Wilson, Adam Subject: Re: Viral Internet Marketing Clips If you could send a copy directly to Michelina Hallie and copy me that would be great! -----Original Message----From: Kadetsky, Deborah To: Cheeks, George; Maxwell, Tony CC: Wilson, Adam Sent: Fri Oct 27 09:48:26 2006 Subject: RE: Viral Internet Marketing Clips Hi George, Did you get my list via Tina Imm? I can send to you directly if not ... Deb -----Original Message----From: Cheeks, George Sent: Friday, October 27, 20068:47 AM To: Maxwell, Tony Cc: Wilson, Adam; Kadetsky, Deborah Subject: Re: Viral Internet Marketing Clips We need everything that you have seeded thusfar as we are engaging an outside service to send take down notices for full episodes and clips in excess of 2 minutes and 30 seconds and we don't want to have notices sent for content we seeded. That said, if that is too big a task I would at least hit the stuff that we seeded over the past several months. Thanks. -----Original Message----From: Maxwell, Tony To: Cheeks, George CC: Wilson, Adam; Kadetsky, Deborah Sent: Wed Oct 25 11:10:262006 Confidential VIA11789374 A-784 S u b j e c t : Viral Internet Marketing Clips Hello George, Nigel asked me to follow up with you about your request for a list of viral clips we are currently supplying to websites like youtube.com. Are you looking for a monthly figure or total amount since a certain date. Please inform. Many thanks, Tony Tony Maxwell VP Vh1 On Air Promotions 212-846-7867 tony. maxwell@vh1staff.com Confidential VIA 11789375 ~ f ) ORIGINAL UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK A-785 1 - - - - .... - - - C SDNY jlDOCUMENT '.li ELECTR ONICALLY FILED .. DOC#: r[UTh ... L~ATEi~ED:_ 7/ltf/;U . ~~.-----t:_ VIACOM INTERNATIONAL INC., COMEDY PARTNERS, COUNTRY MUSIC TELEVISION, INC., PARAMOUNT PICTURES CORPORATION, and BLACK ENTERTAINMENT TELEVISION LLC, Plaintiffs, 07 Civ. 2103 (LLS) -against YOUTUBE, INC., YOUTUBE, LLC, and GOOGLE INC., -------- Defendants. ---x RULING ON VIACOM'S DISPUTED PRIVILEGE CLAIMS I have considered the ies' submissions regarding the two In sequence, the decisive claims of privilege asserted by Viacom. issue 1. each claim is disposed of as follows: Plaintiffs' claim that the statement of Viacom's General Counsel Fricklas that Viacom "Can't say to press that they offered to filter and we decided not to participate" should be redacted from page 75 of Defendants' Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motions for Partial Summary Judgment, and from Schapiro Exhibit 163, is denied. The statement was rendered in a business setting and is business advice, not legal advice. 2. There was no relationship of confidence between Viacom and sed TagWorld to stop flagging material as TagWorld when Viacom "potentially infringing" and TagWorld discontinued that practice. fact that Viacom's lawyers referred to that discussion in their report to Viacom management does not render the underlying report TagWorld-Viacom exchange confidential. Its inclusion in A-786 told the nothing ts confident matters, The not attorney-client mere factual privilege communi cat Its use describes the confidential defendants' brief ts this distinction: TagWorld, and makes no scussion between Viacom argument based on the fact that Viacom's lawyers later referred to it in their The rest of to Viacom management. section of the Capit Appropriation Request (Schapiro Exhibit 115) redacted, entitled Legal Department Summary may be 52 of Defendants' Summary Judgment. but not the portion quoted on a opposition to So ordered. DATED: iffs' Motions for Part New York, New York July 28, 2010 LOUIS L. STANTON U. S. D. J. 2 A-787 1 1 1 2 2 3 3 4 4 5 5 6 6 7 7 8 8 9 9 10 10 11 11 12 12 13 13 14 14 15 15 16 16 17 17 18 18 19 19 20 20 21 21 22 22 23 23 24 25 09srviam UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK ------------------------------x VIACOM INTERNATIONAL, INC., et al., Plaintiffs, v. YOUTUBE, INC., et al., Defendants. ------------------------------x New York, N.Y. September 28, 2010 2:45 p.m. HON. LOUIS L. STANTON District Judge 07 Civ. 2103 (LLS) 07 Civ. 3582 (LLS) Premotion Conference Before: APPEARANCES MAYER BROWN LLP Attorneys for Plaintiffs BY: ANDREW SCHAPIRO JOHN MANCINI JENNER & BLOCK LLP Attorneys for Defendants Viacom International, et al. BY: SUSAN J. KOHLMANN SCOTT WILKENS SHEARMAN & STERLING Attorneys for Defendants Viacom International, et al. BY: KIRSTEN CUNHA SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. (212) 805-0300 A-788 2 09srviam 1 2 2 3 3 4 4 5 5 6 6 7 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 APPEARANCES PROSKAUER ROSE LLP Attorneys for Defen

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?