Overture Services, Inc. v. Google Inc.

Filing 82

DECLARATION in Support re 70 (Christine P. Sun) Opposition to Overture's Motion for Protective Order filed by Google Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A# 2 Exhibit B# 3 Exhibit C# 4 Exhibit D# 5 Exhibit E# 6 Exhibit F# 7 Exhibit I# 8 Exhibit J# 9 Exhibit K# 10 Exhibit L# 11 Exhibit M# 12 Exhibit N# 13 Exhibit O# 14 Exhibit P# 15 Exhibit Q# 16 Exhibit R)(Related document(s) 70 ) (Sun, Christine)

Overture Services, Inc. v. Google Inc.

Doc. 82 Att. 16

Case 3:02-cv-01991-JSW

Document 82-17

Filed 08/11/2003

Page 1 of 22

-1/7
:~r(

LAW OFFICES

KEKER & VAN NEST
L.P.
710 SANSOME STREET SAN FRANCISCO . CA 94111- 1704 TELEPHONE [phone] FAX 141S1 397- 7188

August 5 ,

2003

VIA FACSIMILE AND FIRST CLASS MAIL
Charles M. McMahon, Esq. Brinks Hofer Gilson & Lione NBC Tower - Suite 3600 455 N. Cityfront Plaza Drive Chicago , IL 60611
Re:
Overture Services,

Inc. v. Google Inc.

Dear Mr. McMahon:
Enclosed please find copies of documents bates numbered THD 0000 1 through THD 00021.

These documents were received in response to document subpoenas relating to GaTa' s System prior to June 1998.
Thank you.

Amy Zell Paralegal

(2;'

Enclosure

316628.

Dockets.Justia.com

.~
Case 3:02-cv-01991-JSW Document 82-17 Filed 08/11/2003 Page 2 of 22

1*( CARECOUNSEL
EXPERT HELP WHEN You NEED IT MOST

RECEIVECJ
JUL () 8 2003
KEKEF~ g VAN NEST

July 7 ,

2003

Christine P. Sun Keker & Van Nest 710 Sansome Street San Francisco , CA 94111
Dear Ms. Sun:

We received the subpoena from you requesting documents and financial records relating to our relationship with GOTO. com. We have searched old emails and invoices in our accounting system. It appears that we did not do business with GOTO. com before September 1998 (the date of the first bill paid by CareCounsel , LLC to GOTO. com for advertising).

Based on our recent phone conversation , this letter acknowledges that fact.
Sinyer,ely,

1--"

V'e/V\J Gelb

f) 1

, President and CEO

THD 00001

CareCounsel, LLC 68 Mitchell Boulevard Suite 200 San Rafael, California 94903 Phone: [phone] Fax: [phone] E-mail: staOOcarecounsel.com

-"

p ) .... .
B7/B9/2BB3

p~

"?! ".......

-EB SUJTH

~('

~_\
Page 3 of 22
PAGE 62
t" . '-

Jul 10 a03 3:02-cv-01991-JSW C se 07:07a
IG:45 5164517931

Document 82-17

Filed 08/11/2003

C~!!EX
f. Ra:ord SOOjcct:

C~rtifiCltiOD
Goto ' s S Y1Iam

ord~

I. the undcn;jgBCd, bc:i:ng !.be duly autborizcd rnSiOdWl of f'CCOf'ds Of other
AcJ Uo Corooratioa

qnal1.titd Mt.a(sa fur the (oUow1I1,!; cnlity

'20 Wubinf1Oll Bou1cvaro

With pcnon1I know~ oCthc facts set forth bclow , a.od authority 10
I) A compkIe aDd tborou~
scardi of

said fach, 00 hacby att.CQ 86 fuI.Iows: Y..
/'Ie

all iICtM., inacti~

and stored

2) All tdent:iJyiDg infoI1Jlll1ion p.-orided, includi~
rovided, and DO

fila; hti been made for the m:onts..

mambc:n rL IIUlInc1Il or tavice , aDd II.ame5 err J) AD poKiblc inEora:lXion tb8I can be UKd to search fa- the
4) All bruch offices aDd otha

b.t noIlimilcd 10 IWa

of bi.rth, JOCiaI JCcurity Dt1IDben, fiJc panic::s \O'aS used in tbc 8t2rclJ, of

-di

~) The cntiry
6) To the

bell of my know~ ad the CDriJy lUted does IICJIt now and DCYI7 has operated name:, 01' 31 Other locabom thai were in any way cu:tudcd from !be ICarCh (0( !hac I'OC()(ds.. 7) To the tat of my knowkdgc a.ud belief, IIOftC of the RqUe$&((I records
CWTCIJdy CWI

c~

furt.ber search wUh addiUonaJ infunnatioo U 1X*ibk.

the record RIb;ect named IIbovc
Jal'l:hcd

C8I

ti~ above hx DO separate privalc rccotdl or other ICp8nde fib, tDcbJdiq oous:ultatioDII, trcat:JneuI
OJ

bmiDOa.looldon5 for the mtity lisicd 3bwc h8vc bcOJ

tiles, that

in auy way ClCJodcd from the iC8tCb. for these rtCOfds,
under other

11~ lilY "No" lUt",cn,

The ICCOf'ds cal.Iod for ADd dekribcd cannot be product;d (Qr the
ItMwoM

AllI'tCO!:d5 described in

'1

provide. ck:taikd

,.~...arlo.;

fDIJowins spccifk rt:a&owi:

PokY

Attac.bmmI A"

that \.be

f~goill8 is true and oom:d.

Euancd 08:

Sip.tuc:

hiGt J:WDe;

9tM1

1o

\Y)eJ

o(~ LcpI Scmca Inc" I brreby dcr\8I"c that a1J , iDfomatioa pnn1d.od 10 Compcx rcprding theic ra:aW was allJlmUlUCalod 10 !be custodl8C\ prior' &0

the c:xcaJtioo of thU Cc1ifocalcl of No

HOD: n.e c.to4t.. -.. rwhn4. mne-d te

te alp dIU cerUftaU ....
. aJmllN'

Dak:

CDtDpC:!'

OTtkr 8,

~IS-OO

THD 00002

Case Sent By: DayanPR; 3:02-cv-01991-JSW

[phone] Document 82-17;

17:33 13. ulFiledJ08/11/2003;

age Page 4 Pof 221/2

FACSIMILE TRANSMITTAL SHEET
TO: COMPEX LEGAL SERVICES, INC. CIO KEKER & VAN NEST LLP, AnN: CHRISTINE P SUN
FROM: GARY DAVIS

FAX NUMBER: 415-391-7156
COMPANY:

JULY 13 2003
TOTAL. HO. OF PAGES INCLUDING COVER: SENDER' S PHONE NUMBER:

PHONE NUMBER:

650-864-2200
RE.: Letter 0( June 19, 2003 (Subp0en8 in Ctn8 No, C
02"'()1991 JfYN

SENDER' S FAX NUMBER:
6 so.- S6 4-2006

(EDL) - CNertu--e

y. Google)

0 URGENT

0 FOR REVIEW

0 PLEASE

COMMENT 0 PLEASE REPLY 0 PLEASE RECYCLE

~NTS
Door ~- Sun

Attached is the DeOO"ation we have been asked to sign 00. Please note that, relating to Goto fotJowing a review of cu files. we v.oere not abfe to find
e i1hef as a vendor or aJStomer of CornmtoLK;h.

Please notify Compex of our respcnse.

Sincerely,
Gary Davis

Genera I Counsej
Commtooch Inc.

1300 CRITTENDEN LAHE . SUITE 102 . MOUNTAIN VIEW. CA 940...3 PHO"E: e~O, 8&", ::r2PO . FAX: [phone]

THD 00003

.*..~.......*....................*.........*................

.

J1.."e~v"u: ~e/ tJ/O3 0:04; Case 3:02-cv-01991-JSW
Sent By: Com~ToUch Software , Inc.

Document 82-17 Filed 08/11/2003 Page 5 of 22 850 8M 2002; Jun- 25- 0a 2:02PM; Page 7/11
146 SOUTH SPRUCE SOUTH SAN FRANCISCO , CA 94080 . (650) 246- 1201
ORDER # :AS 79916
-

~~n e~~ 2002 '

~ DayanPA;

F'ag.. 7

COMPEX
LrpJ SdV!CQ,

lite.

OOB

NOTICE TO PARTY BEING SUBPOENAED
You may satlliy (h~ provi.~ions of this subpoenl\. by following any of the
.1.

(o/lOwill~ instructions:

ALLOW COMPEX ' m PHOTOCOPY THE REQUES'fRD RECORD

W~l~~oWrJ1' YOu THE IF THE SUBPOENA CALLS FOR RECORDS TO BE PRODUC~~J1..E.ASE COMPLETE THE FOLLOWING DECLARATION AND INCLUDE IT
WIlli THE
'PLEA..4;jE

8k1~I'JA tl611~lPffl~~WEE

~:r~D~gr~iN

FILL OUT mOI!OUGHLY

K.C\..vRDS-

DECLARATION OF CUSTODIAN OF RECORDS

h~thcsc recrlrm. in
1300 CRITTENDON LANE , SUITE 104 MOUNTAIN VIEW
of with personaJ knowJedg~

J. uud~rs.iploo. bciDs.! the duly autharized cu~todla.n of reccrds for: COMMTOUCH SOFTWARE , INC.
the fa(:(.~

, CA 94043
set forth bclo-w. and authority to cenify said rccord.!

, do hereby atlest to th.e foUowUt&

I am AA employee of

the O!ganizatioll listed above and .have perso.n..aI knawiedge
GOTO S SYSTEM DATE OF' BIRTH:

of the ptocedures and prac:tiCC$ te&q~

The (ccorc4

pertain

to:

0/00/00

SOCIAL SEC. NO. I

to A COMPEX a&ent
wI of

llicluding (hi~ certificate, ;ill t.b..e rtcordts

documenu: (ItCtIIS must be desrib~ jn g1'L~ar O1loudl

called for in the :Attached Subpoc:na with which I for the purp06e of copying puuuant to Evidence Code:

w~ served lave:.

specifcity to

IS6/), with the ~cption of theilltached identify rocl1 a;cluded items) ;

.Provid~d

rocw& identity and method of
mdiC3te their rruslwortbines! O~th to t..hc forcgoing f:1cu,

The; records were pr~pared in tbe ordilUr)' C(ltJf~ oJnodian of records , at or near me time of the

of uid for which I' aJn the dcpictro t11ercin. As cu6todilU1. 1 tesrlly to the preparation. Tb~ Jour~ of the iufonulltion and of preparation W~e as to ff I were called

of bu.riPOM, by the

acts. conrlitior3S. or evcn4

pascmnc:l

8.3 a wil11e!s in. t:Ms matter, I could tnd would

s~

I h~reby declare under penally of perjury und~r the laws of the State of
.BXECUTED ON

true and correct.
J...,
(DATE)

compct~JItJy I"Ui/y under

California.., that the foreg,oing

C~ ~OO
b-y~e. A~~A,J

EXECUTED AT
(ADD IUJSS)

s--t

~STAT'
SIGNED
I'lUNT NAME
Gary

~NP""

coo~
R1JCORDS)

:X
(S

OF CU

~F

Davis

THD 00004

General Counsel and Secretary

Commtouch
?,/?, a6ed
Tnr- E:~

~E:E::H E:O-

~E:SS?'?'S E:

U6+

~BdueAea :A8 ~ua9

...

~~

. -..

n..' vv Case 3:02-cv-01991-JSW

Document 82-17

Filed 08/11/2003

Page 6 of 22

C~,!!EX
Record Subject:

Certification of No Records
Date of Uinh:
N/A
Soc See 11-: N/

GOlo s System

AK/1:-1!M__,___
records or other qu.1.lificd wiLJICSS

, the undersigned , being the duly authori/.cd cuslOd.ian.

of

for Ihe

folJowing CJI111)':

Distinct Corporation
3315 AJIIl!1den Exprcs5
i.1

e J()
l"u

With pcl"$Onal knowledge of the fa(.1s $(.1 forth below . and ;mthority to eenify $;.lid fact:;. do hereby attest as follows:
I) A complete and thorough seareh of aU active , inaCtive, and stored files lkLS been made for the records-

2) All idcnti(ving infomution provided, including but not Ii lIli LCd to d.-1lCs ofbil1h , soci-11 security numbcrs.. ok
numbel'$.. dates of I reat ment or service..
u.scd in the scolrch.

I2J
C8J

4)

and romes of involved panics was v.ras J) AU possible information that can be used to $C..1rch for the records of the record subject named above provided , and no fur1h~ search with additional information is possible. All br:mch offices and other bu.~nc..,-o; 100000uons for tlIC entity li~ted :\bove have been sc:trchcd. , tr~J\menl 5) The entity listed above h.;Js no scp;lr.1te private records or other sqxmlte files.. including eonsuJt.;ltions ~reh for these rOCQ rds classifications. or ehronoJogical files.. that wcre in any way excluded from the 6) To the best of my knowledge 3nd belief, the entity listed. above docs not now and never has Opcr:llCd under other namC$ or at otocr loc.1.tiol1..o; that were in any way excluded from the sc:uch for Ihe~ records.
curTcntly exist. 7) To the best of my knowledge and belief. none oCthe requested records

!Xl
(;8j

!Xl

rZJ

For any "'

~ answers. plca:IC provide;J. dcbilcd c:xplan:rtion:

1hc records called for ;md described ~nnol be produced for thc following specific TCa.o;ons:
RKv...I(.) RM.J.~.-.I

N~"r Ed"tr;!

1),,:..1"")'.-.1

RPtM.rkI.. P...lky

()t""" (1'1t'.

n~ HI""ln)

All documents requested in
- ~ Allachmcnt A- for the any d,1IC$

prior to 06/0 U98 .

0- ,

0, '..- ...--

I hereby declare under penalty of pcJjury. pursu;.lnt to the laws of the Slate of

that thc foregoing is true ;Jnd oolTCC1,

Executed on:

7/,

e-

0~
P.",

at -

I))-Q,,~

Si~3ture:

~ 'L-:-~
to the cu..~todi:m prior to the

Print name:

T1\1t C I c;. /

P CDfLQ IT!

As JJ1 :I(',CJ11 of Compc.x Lcgnl Services, Inc" I hereby dccJlITe Ih.1t :Ill information provilk-u to Compcx rq;!1riling thl.::oc rL-.:.unJ~ WU~ c.olruuwli~tL'-d

execution of this CcrtifiCJ.te of No Record.~

NOTE: The Cwtodian W1U reque,ted to ~il:D thi,

certifialtc aDd

refused , electing

ilUtu. to CD ntc a

,imilnr documcnt

Date:
Compc:x Orderlt:
A1I7?916..o11

THD 00005

Case 3:02-cv-01991-JSW

Document 82-17

Filed 08/11/2003

Page 7 of 22

Citysearch

3731 W,lshue Blvd. 3rd Floor, Los Angeles , CA 900 I 0

Direct: (213)739- 3511

fax: [phone]

VIA OVERNIGHT MAIL

July 16

2003

Christine p, Sun Keker & Van Nest LLP 710 Sansome Street San Francisco , CA 94111- 1704
Re:

Overture Services, Inc. v. Google , Subpoena dated June 19, 2003

Dear Ms, Sun:

In response to the above-referenced subpoena , please be advised that after a diligent search we
have determined Citysearch, com does not have any documents responsive to the above-

referenced subpoena. If we do discover documents that we determine are responsive , we will
contact you.

Please do not hesitate to contact me if you have any questions,

~(~UShl
cc:

~J7?
Beth Lovejoy-Corrigan
Ed Weiss

General Counsel

THD 00006

J
Case 3:02-cv-01991-JSW Document 82-17 Filed 08/11/2003

~\,~;:" \ :\'"

~\~~

Page 8 of 22

~~!f5
::1

'fl; l.tiNf. \\
i:'ii"4~

I;' I : 'I'

I "'

'

r '11'.II1 !, I!

f E /:;
I"

'IE.

uly 15

2003

f\

'\L.i',

v L , ; d: ' 'rJ\'
C:l

i'J Nc~: (

','O

VIA U. S. Mail

Christine P. Sun Keker & Van Nest LLP 710 Sansome Street San Francisco , CA 94111- 1704
Re:

Overture Services,

Inc. v, Google

Case No, C 02- 01991

JSW

Dear Ms. Sun

Ask Jeeves has diligently conducted a review of its documents and records in response to the third-party subpoena propounded on it by Google Technology, Inc. in the above-captioned matter, and has found nothing responsive to produce.

Should you have any questions, I can be reached at 510-985- 7509.

5h~A.
Sharon A. Anolik Associate General Counsel and Chief Privacy Officer

THD 00007

5858 Horton Street, Suite 350 Emeryville, CA 94608 moln: 5109857400 fox: 510985 7410

C~,!!EX
Record Subject:
AKA:

Case 3:02-cv-01991-JSW

Document 82-17

Filed 08/11/2003

Page 9 of 22

Certification of No Records
Date of Birth:
N/A

Sex: Sec #: N/A

Goto s System
N/A

, the undersigned , being the duly authorized custodian of records or other qualified witness for the following entity:

Classic FX
6754 Barbara

With personal knowledge of the facts set forth below
1) A complete and thorough search of all active

, and authority to certify said facts , do hereby attest as follows:
, file

Yes

, inactive , and stored files has been made for the records,

to dates of birth, social security 2) All identifying information provided, including butofnot limitedparties was used in the search, numbers , and names involved
numbers , dates of treatment or service

3) All possible infonnation that can be used to search for the records of the record subject named above was
provided , and no further search with additional information is possible,

been searched, 4) All branch offices and other business locations for the entity listed above haveincluding consultations, treatment ,
5) The entity listed above has no separate private records or other separate files

classifications , or chronological files , that were in any way excluded from the search for these records. , the entity listed above does not now and never has operated under other 6) To the best of my knowledge and belief names or at other locations that were in any way excluded from the search for these records, , none of the requested records currently exist. 7) To the best of my knowledge and belief
For any "

" answers, please provide a detailed explanation:

The records called for and described
Reconl
uested
Never Existed

Lo5t

Retention Poli

Othe

lea5e ex

All documents requested in n Attachment A" for the any dates

l&1

Jrior to 06/01/98

that the foregoing is true and correct.
I hereby declare under penal

Executed on:
Signature:

Sebasta
Print name:

tt5

As an agent ofCompex Legal Services , Inc. , I hereby declare that all infonnation provided to Compex regarding these records was communicated to the custodian prior to the execution of this Certificate of No Records,

NOTE: The Custodian was requested to sign this certificate and
refused, electing instead to geneT1lte a similar document

Agent' s
Date:

signature:

-if'
THD 00008
A879916-007

' -7/;~
Compex Ordern:

\
Case 3:02-cv-01991-JSW
FROM : ATTORNEYS 1RUST SERVICE

1
Filed 08/11/2003
9257439259

Document 82-17
PHCt-E HJ. :

Page 10 of 22

Jul. 1'3 2003 12: 16PM P2

OO'To. COM. CLI!NT AC1r~1TY

ft9'Of\T I"ERtOO:

DtOH:It1l11f2000

R~T

PAOg 2 OF 2

COMPANY: Attorneys Trullt Service

ACCOUNT~; ~1
eAAc
T fRJ116

~6~
UJU.

lItO
AAfOI.JH T

flOP
CLICKS

TOT~
$a,
$O.os

con
so~

IiI"I1gIMt

~II

hC(p~, ..HOI11V)'M~
aII 0!7ICI

~p:fOOtW,

TOTAL. 'Oil Title IUJ'OIlT

nlUoo.

tue

T::/'

1/ '/OW

*'" 1& bloodb..C Q 2jfO

In I'w:I .

oF

ClJC)CJ
not

It'IIII'nf6N 11* ..
beoIUIM

net

. cJcIt. lie( I: If

hr/t

!wi ..

IWd htry, I .

Ihn

,..wts peoe 10 dit1

t1t

'fOC1l\IItII

rid

for thoM pIrtIcuQr 'ImM..

OoTo.-. 7.. N. Pa~ 1\.,...1tdF1oot.

cA IttO'. rd:

1.28IIU~FM: fUI) UUA1

THD 00009

000001

F
Case 3:02-cv-01991-JSW
FRO1 : ATTrntB'5 TRL6T SERVICE

Document 82-17

Filed 08/11/2003

Page 11 of 22

PI-DE I'D. : 9257439259

Jul. 10 2003 12: 16PM Pl

/?J~ NATkUEGOTO. COM
CLlI!NT ACTIVITY RIiPORT
RIiPORT PIIUODI MONTH I!NDING; 01/31/2000

COMPANY: Attorneys Tru5t Service NAME: James N, Wood EMAlL.: jwoodat~m5n. com

ACCOUNT *: 3513fdff7685
$0.

TOTAL CUCKTHROUGH CHARGES FOR JANUARY 2000:

IUlanct II of Dtc:.m~ 31, un:
D&p osits I n J IIOUat)' 2 000:

Total Cllck1hrough Ch8rgc. In January 2000:

$8, $0. ($0. 90) $7.

B.lllnc:. II of Janulry :11. 2000:

For an

Popul8r~

DI/'tICTratfK: ctn:ter, which ~n more 0etMIed summary of your account IctMty, p~aq uu our for a list or our upoom!ng Cartel"

U houri 8 day, 7 dayll

week. Alto ,

Click hereto log In:

T~'-T~J: - '

httPt:II~~,OQtQ. corn1&IlitcfCII~ h~:mi:~O:n;:n:Q2.C:QrnII~~~';;'~"fv:m~'
to

log In to ClreoTraMc

Want MOle Tra1'nc? ChJnoea are you can dTMtica.lly Inc:ru...

Click hw8 for ::I11.t or 10 -ys you CAn maxlml:e r:J1c1cthroughs

M1p:"'-'

~~~~~W

~IC to your 5ite If )'QU optimize your account.
your stt.:

00 T

6.~ 7.. No

A....., W Roof'.

1'1

Yden8. CA 11 tt3 - T et: fI2f)

ax: f'1"

THD 00010

000002

E
Case 3:02-cv-01991-JSW
FRCN : ATTCR-EYS TRlET SERVICE

Document 82-17

Filed 08/11/2003

Page 12 of 22

PI-Dt NO. : 9257439259

Jul. 102003 12:17PH

C2~~~

. [phone]

2001 BROADWAY, SUIT& 100 O~KLAND, CA 94612

ORDER # IA679916 . 003

NOTICE TO PARTY BEING SUBPOENAED
You roilY I!lUd)' tho provldon.1 of tbh 1ubpoel\1\ try following MY of tho foUowiul:\ itulluctlon.,:

ALLOW COMPEX 10 PHOTOCOfY TIlE 1\EQUESTED RECORDS
APPEAR AT 'mE SCHEDULED 11ME AND PLACE

BRING WITH YOU TIlE ORIGINALS OF ALL TIlE RECORDS DESCRIDED u~ TI,ffi SUBPOENA

~D

If WE SUBPOENA CAliS FOR RECORDS TO BE PRODUCE~ PLEASE COMPLETE 'THE FOLLOWING DEClARATION AND INCLUDE IT WITI:I THE Rt:CORDS.
PLEASE FlLL OUT

11fOROUGHLY.

II"..... ........ .................... ........ at.........,......

DECLARATION OF CUSTODIAN OF RECORDS
, undersigned, being the duly authariz.ed custodian of rcoords (or:
ATrORNE'/' S TRUST SERVICE ,I 1\

A ~"::L 11':

2*1 QJW1 KJd. 1M v.u..LU
SAN RAMON, CA
t.h~ f;)cU ~cl forth

~:7

wiili pcl'1ona! blowledJe of

94S83~ ~low.

!JbVD., ~n;., 1

Cl

'V~.,,~~'

:AJld duUlurlty to ccrt.ify ~aid Iewrds. do hereby ..~t to the fol1owi.clt

u.:u:

I ~ ;!J). employ~ of the Oti!.~li(ln IUI~d above :and have persOnal knowlWBc of the ploadur~ and pr:lC1.!ces IclJect~d
in !l1es~ records.

Tho lCOOIas pertain to;

GaTe' S SYSTEM DATE OF BIRTH:

0/00/00

SOCIAL SEC. NO.:
y.iUcll I W:IS served hl\ve been providtrl
of the att3cbcd

II-ith the Q;CCptjon 1560. oC copyi:cg pur&lW1t (0 Evid~n~ Code to a COMPEX 8!;cnt for the purpos~ !in of docomc:n.ts: (l1t:mJ must be iksribed in &Ioa( eno\lg.h s~cifclty to identify ~c:h excluded itllnu)
The r~Hls Wc:c pIcpUtd
in tho ord.in3ly count of

Includilli tni$ ccrliIic:ate, ill Ihe tccorcU c:aIkd for

in tho attached SubpoeJ1a with

cunodUD of recOrds, at or DC&!: !l1c time of tho ilCt.s.. conditions, Iecords idt:ntlty and method of preparation. 'The sOUIca of th~
04th to the forcgoinp, facts,

busines'- by the penonud of laid butin= for whkb 1 am tho or CVCIJU depicted. thc:rdn, As cu&todi!.n. J lC3tUy to the
iuformatiDli and

I!\clh.od of prcpanltion wc:re ouc.h

u to

indictJe their trU\twortbin~. If 1 wa~ ~Icd. M .!I witne~ in thl8 matter, t could and would compdently testify under
I hereby declare under pcna1ty
true ana correct., f\ff~

of perjury

und~ the Jaws of the SUic of Ca1ifomi~
CIi'tJk1t~'t"y d.6~

1---

~H
?J

~ ~ Iv

that tbe foregoing is

XECUTED ON
EXECUTED AT

j!O 2.0C?
(DATI!)

III ~trw~"
/IM~

~..J) Su
(ADD RES$)

ttVSB3
(CI"O'. STA'IEM'D

SIGNED
PRINT NA.tvffi

:X

THD 00011

000003

f
Case 3:02-cv-01991-JSW Document 82-17 Filed 08/11/2003 Page 13 of 22

Custodian
I. un ~crslg,nc . being, the duly authorized eustod!un

Certi~ication

of Records

of records

for:

ATTORNEY' S TRUST SERVICE 2491 SAN RAMON VALLEY BLVD. , STE, 1-303 SAN RAMON , CA 94583- 1601
wi(h person..! knowJcugc of the facts !ct forth below, !lnd authorlly to certify said records do hereby attc.st to the following
of I am an employee or the above organization rind have pcrsonw knowledge

f..cts:

the procedures !lnd practices reflected In tlJe records.

Thc records pcrtain 10: GOTO' S SYSTEM
Date of Birth:

0/00/00

Social Security Number:

Including this certificate, all records called for and described in the attached subpoena pursuant to Evidence Code Section 1560, with the exception of mth which I was served have been pro ' ed to a COMPEX agent
the documents (if

any) listed be

These records were:

ailed to COMPEX on:

7-/
or duplication.
custodian of

Presented to COMPEX on
The records were prepared in the ordinary COUIse

of busjneos, by tbe personnel of saidbusiness for which I attllhe

r~ords, at or near the time of the acts, conditions, or events depicted therein. A5 custodian, I testify to the records identity and
method

Record Types

of preparation. The source of the information and method of preparation were such as to indicate their trustworthiness, If I were called as a witnc:ss in this matter, I could and would competently testify under oath to these facts.

If any records were not provided , explain het'e

Total number of pages provided:
1 hereby declare, under penalty of pe~ury. pursuant to tbe laws of the State of

Dlifomia that tbe foregoing Is true and correct.

Sign name:

Print Name:
Date Signed:

Title:

Agent' s Certification of Records
As an agent of Compcx"Serviccs, lne., I hereby declare iliat
the attached are true and complete copies of documents provided to me on tbis date. AU copies will be delivered to

NOTE: The Custodian was requested to sign this certificate at the time of document production, and refused to sign or
gener;lte a simi1ar document.

party that caused this request to be issue
:::::,1 "
~d

d.

Dale: ~
COMPEX Order Number: A879916-003-

Signed:
DDlc:

THD 00012

-' Case 3:02-cv-01991-JSW Document 82-17

=,,~"
Page 14 of 22

,:'"' :

Filed 08/11/2003

, AO DD (II".11fQ11

aU~nOI" "'.

QyO 0.:..11

QIInitrb

~tatpz

iBiztrtf"t QIourt
DISTRIaf OF
CALIfORNIA

NORTHERN

OVERTURE SERVICES , INC"

PLAINTIPFlS) ,
GOOGLE INC.

SUBPOENA IN A CML CASE
C 02- 01991 JSW (EDL)

CASE NUMBER: 1

DEFENDANT(S) ,

TO:

ATTORNEY' S TRUST SERVICE

2491 SAN RAMON VALLEY BLVD. , STE. 1 - 303 SAN RAMON, CALIfORNIA 94583- 1601
YOU ARE COMMANDED to appear In the United States District Court at the place , date , and I1me specified below to

testify k1 the above case,
I'I.ACIO Of TESTIMONY

DATE At-IO 11ME

YOU ARE COMf\W..IOEO to appear at the place , date, and time specified below to testify at the taking of a depos~ion

In the above case,
PLAce OF DEPOSITION

I ,,~'"'".,
(Xj YOU ARE COMMANDED to produce and permit Inspectkm and copying of the foJlowing documents or oblec~ at the

place , date, and time specified below (list documents or objects):
SEE ATTACHMENT A.

P L.ACI;

DATE AND TIME

COMPEX LEGAL SERVICES, INC. 1 46 SOUTH SPRUCE SOUTH SAN FRANCISCO 94080

7/21/03

, CA

9:00AM
of the following premises at th e date and time specified below.

YOU ARE COMMANDED to permit inspection
PREMISES

I "'~ '"' "M'
Any organization not a party to the suh that Is
otrlCars, directors ,

person

subpoenaed for the taking of a deposition shall designate one or more or managing agents , or other persons who consent to testify on its behalf , and may $9t forth , .for each 01 CMf Procedure, 30 (b)(6). daslgnated, the matters on which the person wm testify, Federal Rules
SUN ATTORNEY- 1I.

ISS\J1NG OFflCEJlSIntlATUREAHOnTl,E pNDlCATE IF ATIOI1NEY FOR. PlAIN11FF OR DEFENDANT) DATE
. CHRISTINE P. ATTORNEY (S) FOR DEFENDANT

LAW '

6/19/03

GOOGLE INC.
ISSUING OFFICER'S NA.J.lE, ADDP.E&:5 AND PHONE NUIoIDEI\

I:..-.-941t1 IS..

KEKER & VAN NEST 710 SANSOME STRE&T SAN FRANCISCO CA
It

~1S 391- S400

lIull ~ F.d....IRuI.. ot QvUPtoooduro,P.,u C ~D on R...."ol actlDO b pending in clbulal olh~ than district Df bsuancII stato Ol8trlct undor ca.. n~bcr.

THD 00013

000005

Case 3:02-cv-01991-JSW

Document 82-17

Filed 08/11/2003

Page 15 of 22

Attachmcnt A

DEFINITIONS

A) "YOU" or " YOUR" refers to Attorneys Trust Service , its subsidiaries
divisions , predecessor companies, any joint venture to which it may be a party, and/or each of its employees , agents , officers , directors, representatives consultants , accountants, and attorneys , including any person who served in any
such capacity at any time,

S SYSTEM" means any GOTO system wherein paid search listings are ranked through an auction process.
means GoTo.com, and/or each of its employees, agents officers, directorstrepresentatives , consultants, accountants , and attorneys
C) GOTO"

B) "GOTO'

including any person who served in any such capacity at any time.

D) "DOCUMENT(SY means and includes any kind of written
typewritten , or printed material whatsoever , and any computer readable media including, but without limitation, papers , agreements , contracts , notes, memoranda presentations , presentation materials , correspondence , letters , emails , telegrams, statements , invoices, personal diaries , records , books, maps, blueprints, fonns transcriptions andrecordings , translations to any language , magnetic tapes, discs printed cards, progra111.Irllng instructions , assembly diagrams, schematic diagrams data books , data sheets , application notes, brochures, specifications , and manuals of which YOU have knowledge or infonnation, .either in YOUR possession or
under YOUR custody or control , relating to or pertaining in any way to the subject

matters in connection with which it is used and includes , without limitation originals , all file copies, and other copies, no matter how or by whom prepared and all drafts prepared in connection with any such writings , whether used or not regardless of whether the document still exists , and regardless of who has maintained custody of such documents.
reflecting, constituting, containing, embodying, pertaining to , involved with mentioning, discussing, consisting of, comprising, showing, commenting upon

E) "RELATING TO" means concerning, referring to , summarizing,

evidencing, describing or otherwise RELATING TO the subject matter.

INSTRUCTIONS
In answering this subpoena , YOU are required to furnish all documents that are available to YOU, under YOUR custody or control , not merely

A)

311314.

THD 00014

000006

Case 3:02-cv-01991-JSW

Document 82-17

Filed 08/11/2003

Page 16 of 22

such documcnts as the pcrsons preparing the responses know of their own personal . knowledge , but including, without limitation , docUI 11cnts in the possession of YOUR att01l1cys , employees , or other persons directly or indirectly cmp!oyed by, or connected with YOU or YOUR attorneys or consultants , or anyone acting on YOUR bchalf or otherwise subject to YOUR control. In answering this subpoena YOU are requested to make a diligcnt search of YOUR records and of other papers and materials in YOUR possession or control or in the possession or control of YOUR employees , attorneys, consultants , or other representatives.
privilege or work product doctrine , YOU are required to provide a privilege Jog

B) In the event any infonnatlon is withheld on a claim of attorney-client

which includes at least the following information: the nature of the information contained in the withheld document , the date oftbe document , its source and subject matter , and to whom that information was disclosed , such as would enable the privilege claim to be adjudicated and cite any authority which YOU assert

supports any claim of privilege.
If YOU cannot respond to this subpoena fully, after a diligent attempt to attain the requested information , YOU are required to answer the subpoena to the extent possible , specify the portion of the subpoena YOU are unable to answer and provide whatever information YOU have regarding the unanswered portion.

C)

DOCUMENTS REO VESTED
All DOCUMENTS RELATfNG TO GOTO' S SYSTEM prior to June 1998.

2.

All financial records reflecting any payments to GOTO RELATING TO

GOTO' S SYSTEM prior to June 1998.

THD 00015
3113H.

000007

...

---,"'Filed 08/11/2003 Page 17 of 22

Case 3:02-cv-01991-JSW

Document 82-17

c~~f~?!
DECLARATION ESTABLISHING PROOF OF SERVICE OF SUBPOENA
CASE NUMBER. : C 02 - 01991

JSW (EDL)

VS....,..... :

CASE CAPTION: OVERTURE SERVICES I INC., GOOGLE INC.,

I served the attached subpoena by personally delivering a copy to the person served as follows:

PERSON SERVED.. . . . . ,

1: 50

KYRA L.

ADDRESS WHERE SERVED: 2491 SAN RAMON VALLEY BLVD. , STE. 1- 303 SAN RAMON, CA 94583- 1601
PHONE NUMBER. . . . .
: 925

8309431

DATE OF DELIVERY.. . .
TIME OF

7/02/03

DELIVERY....

0:00:00
15.
for

WITNESS FEES

PAID...

CHECK NUMBER:

6545632

I received the attached subpoena

service on...
of

7/02/03

Person serving:

California process server.
Is a registered professional photocopier.
Name, address, telephone number, county

Is an employee or independent contractor

a registered

registration, and of registration number: ROBERTO DE LA FUENTE , 2001 BROADWAY, SUITE 100
OAKLAND,

CA 94612

LOS ANGELES COUNTY NUMBER 666

510 9861727
of

I declare under penalty of

perjury under the laws

California that the foregoing is true and

correct.

of

the State

EXECUTED AT: 2001 BROADWAY, SUITE 100

OAKLAND, CA 94612

DATE, . . . . . . :

7/02/03

IcU4

ORDER# A87991600301
SIGNATURE)

THD

00016

000008

Case 3:02-cv-01991-JSW C~,!!EX
Record Subject: . Goto s System

Document 82-17

Filed 08/11/2003

Page 18 of 22

Certification of No Records

, the undersigned , being the duly authorized custodian of records or other qualified witness for the following entity:

Brave New World. Inc.

221 East Walnut Street, Suite 215
With personal knowledge of the facts set forth below , and authority to certify said facts
, do hereby attest as follows:
IS)

I) A complete and thorough search of all active , inactive , and stored files has been made for the records.

2) All identifying information provided , including but not limited to dates of birth , social security numbers
numbers , dates of treatment or service , and names of involved parties was used in the search.

, file

IS) IS) IS) IS) IS)

3) All possible infonnation that can be used to search for the records of the record subject named above was

4)

provided, and no further search with additional infonnation is possible. All branch offices and other business locations for the entity listed above have been searched. , including consultations , treatment 5) The entity listed above has no separate private records or other separate files classifications , or chronological files , that were in any way excluded from the search for these records. 6) To the best of my knowledge and belief, the entity listed above does not now and never has operated under other names or at other locations that were inany way excluded from the search for these records. 7) To the best of my knowledge and belief, none of the requested records currently exist.
For any "

IS)

" answers, please provide a detailed explanation:

The records called for and described cannot be produced for the following specific reasons:
Record(s) Requested
Never Existed Lost

Destroyed

Retention Policy

Other (please explain)

Any and All records described in
-n

Attachment An

I hereby declare
Executed on:

that the foregoing is true and correct

Signature:

W;~

Print name:

'tSr,

Oe~~

As an agent ofCompex Legal Services , Inc. , I hereby declare that all information provided to Compex regarding these records was commun.icated to the custodian prior to the execution of this Certificate of No Records.
NOTE: The Cu5todian wa5 requested to sign thi5 certificate an

refused, electing instead to genenlte a similar document Agont' s
Date:

Si""atn"

L--

THD 00017
A879915-006

Compex Order #:

,,; ':

~(). .

~~~ ;;"" ;-.)

-..

""""'

.-

~~~"(

,~~~"~.~.,. ~" ~ , ~
,.... ,....'......

q;;. "",,'

. "".

F RCJ1 :

Cas0 lDtO~~t e 3:02-cv-01991-JSW

SUbJc:t:
H':A:

~~r
~;d&~M*

Document 82-17 FAX t.n

Ju I. Filed 08/11/2003 24 2003 12: 09PM 22 Page 19 of

Certification orN
Dale ofBlnh:
See Sed

9.'~6)J

1. the undc~ign~.

being (he: duly authorized CU5todian of records or 01 her qualified witness for the follov.ing cntin' 57. S;JIYL ' tJASHI.u"T~N

8:~~CtKt
SCI forth below ,

SIC(

f3

With pe1;Onal knowledge: of the faCH

and autboriry 10 certify said facts. do hereby allest as follows:
Ytt

s..

I) A complete and thorough SUtCh of aU acuve. inactive:. and stored files has been made for the r~rds.

2) All idcnr~ing information P/'OY1dcd. including but not limited to dates ofbirth. 5OC1al ~ri!rnumbc~, file'
nwnbcrs. d3tesollrurmenr or sc/'\;cc. and

~S

o( im'Olvcd .panies U'1lS used

in1he

~h,

J) All poS5rble information Ih.lI CUI be used to sc.an:b (or 1M records of the record SUbJoc1 namcd above was
prmided.. and no further scan:b with addiUon.al information is possibk.
~) AU bldnch offices and other bu5incss locations (or the entity liSled abo\eha\' c been sarr:hcd,
5) The
f,) To
entity li.s1cd

above Iw no

~tc pri\'atc reCQrdS or other scpar;ite tiles. including consulUuons. tre.abnent

c~ssificat.ion.s.. Of chtonolopcaJ files. Uut wcre in wy away t..'tcluded fcom the
the: bc-st of rumes or at orner

~h for these rcrords.

-;) To the

my Imowl~gc and belicf. the entity listed above d\Xs not now and nev~r has OpeJdled under other for these rc:c.ord.s. localloru thai ....~ in any aw;ry excluded from the bc-st of my Imowlcdge aJ1d belief. none of the: requested ~rd.s CUITcntly exist,

~h

J2i

For U)y W

~ 3..OTfU:n.. plei3oC

prtnide a detailed explanation:

The records C3l1ed for and described c::IMOI bI! produced for the following

sp:6fic rt:3.SOl\S:

R",onl(., R"I~'"

:'i.....r EtbU"d
'to UortIS

~"'t~
r~4',)tIA~

R~

Ot",.tp~ npWnj
l\LL ~p-s

/WAy \~,..

.B:
Ufuf

r(;qt...b

t.F:ta?tx ~LA.'t('.b TO

l.f!ll~"W

~t.V~~1"
t...cnT' (

(,r7rQ

~~~I. \'

I,J c.u.~1)

cAA~.

0I hcrcb\ dCCl.liC under pcJ"\alty of pt:r)Uf), pUI5l1.:UI! to the la\\ ~

.'...oo
wr\f (I

~, c*A."T'.

M:JJ

fW.) ct.b.

It9A . IIT;wc

of the SLitI' or' (Au

EIt'(:ultd on:
::;i'in~lun:";
\, .1..'\ "~d'lt')(

at

(ft~

AI;!~T

thaI the fore:~oing is lrue and 'om:~1. ~W"" \ 'g'mHl..., "Y C4

Print n:.lme:

LDtZI;

:)'J oetr&
I~~ bclO" !il( lIus
J.J\ 11"

C0mpo-;\ (

",pi Scr\' ,c:..::s,

lnc , I h~~b\' ,1.0.:1&1" Uul

;111

Th., Im\f\l1T)~:" "as ~(~J'\')"

1I\I~.\r:"\~IIN\ :HO"J,..,j 10 l' vmpc\ :~~arJln~ lhex r~orJ..s ,," C ,""\:"WII, the eJ.."oJIJJ1;1T'.Qf 10 the "\0::"1101\ olthJS I.: ~'f1I1 Ic..JI" 1 ;1.."..",.;,

(0:

::= "OTE Th" Cu ;,..ai.O""
.nd r~(u'cd. d~c'iD.t. in"U
""~~nl ~ ,ien:.tllJre:
1);1,\(;

rcqueHcd 10 \i~D rbi, "n.ilic.,c

Dt"'1t I ..mil.r d~umcnl
~OTARY DI 'TIUC
SU""

ot'

(uml'"' 0....... -;
11& 74-'11("

M\ commiSSIon e~plr"~:

. CD

THD 00018

:i

- -. .."

.",
1),He (\I ' f3inl1:

1

T
Filed 08/11/2003
Sac See #:

~

Case 3:02-cv-01991-JSW
;Zecord Subjcct: O(t) G( l/(I :

~Yt71

Document 82-17

Page 20 of 22

~2fIIJ
III

:, lh:: undcrsigf\ed. being the duly a~orized

cusrodi:m 01' rccorcis or ou,,::, --~u '

I!:~_

::S le)r lhe I ollowing

entity:

:CXC(L L:c(LJU I lJ'-3
04((

L H Ic.,

fi Jhd

c,

1tf2-(~A

(bL0')
,; i:'
:c::' :::J~ :.:,r

L/ yC:,- Ie,

ll1 ':~rsonaj Knowledge oflhe facts ser ronh l:elo\\' :na :uII1,xir::

'0 ':elii,

'by ~Htcst as follows:

., complete and thorough search of all active, inacti\' c, ~nd oLored rile, ;' ::S,

,he records,

3)

\11 identifying information provided. including but not t;mit~d (0 G;:HC~ ,i:' ~::::I' .:cc!rirv numbers. file .lUmbers, dates oftremment or service, and names of ;,l\'oil'c'j ;:J.n;es ':,, " :::rc~, -\11 Dossible iniormation that can be uscd to search ror ,he records of \i1l: :CC()~U ' i::' i ':c: :1:ln1cd above was provided. and no funher search with additionai information is possioil'
-\ II branch offices and other business locations 1 01'
the e::tity

ill

htcd ::001',,; "
:

\:ic;:i:d,
::'!:5~lt:H!CnS ,

r;-/

The entity listed above has no separate private recoros or 1)11121' cc~o::rJ!,~ !:::,:
c!Jssirlcations. or chronological files, that were in unv \vay e\ciuacu riO,i1
Ii)

tre3tment

I

C ' :::1':;; " ~" l!l~se records,

To the best of my knowledge and belief. the entity listcd :\OO\' C Jo~s ;lames or at other locations that were in any way c:-.:ciuded frem 1:1;: s~,

'\.1\'.' :'
::1 : ,1'

illi !:,

,:~ !::15 operated

under other

;::2~~ :~::niCS,

T a the best of my knowledge and belief, none of the rc:aues:d reco,cis cuITc:ni\ "
for ::ny " "10 "

E( C

:lnswers, please provide:1 detailed C\pl:1n:1tion:

Ti~e records called for and described cannot be produced for i:,C : 1iI0, :in~'
:1~c"rli(,1 l~cnllcSlcd

:;'-' : :::::;,,;,5:

~eI' rr

f.xiSlcli '

:oS!

l"'C~";'"

rK.R
I-

1--:; ~

fZD/ J?

1--'

L....;

! hereby declare under penalty

::.\ccllted on: (.--1/'(
:;I~!1;Jrure:

fA

a. Datle
9f P

L.:
l~;e 51:te

ury, pursuant to the .

(iO

;:;r '
::5,,:5'
~:;i:,)\' :idged before me this
0:'
IPnn! C"SlCOlan "'mOl
d;:1\'

,1r
(EnIHY)

,!.!.('!1t

s signature:

:~;HC:

It 1vJ

Compel Order #:

HD

00019

;1f:!2fN7 ozrl

r

Case 3:02-cv-01991-JSW

Document 82-17

Filed 08/11/2003

Page 21 of 22

hA-0~ (\0
~~cv:

b-ec
J-L.

5lJYv'f

ls ljJ;t~ '-f~ ~o Cfl/V'\ftn\_ A~ (10("" 00 I- ~aVJ ~~ Nt ~ uv
~~ kvu
h6 ~~'i

A Y\

~L(

Y\

1tV\ t'\;

ze

THD

00020

A"

t'l-qql

\P

~oo

Case 3:02-cv-01991-JSW

Document 82-17

Filed 08/11/2003

Page 22 of 22

Custodian s Certification of Records
, undersigned , being the duly authorized custodian of records for:

DEAN B. MAZZEI 118 DUFOUR STREET SANTA CRUZ , CA 95060
with personal knowledge of the facts set forth below , and authority to certify said records do hereby attest to the following facts:

1 am an employee of the above organization and have personal knowledge of the procedures. and practices reflected in the records.

The records pertain to: GOTO' S SYSTEM
Date of Birth:

0/00/00

Social Security Number:

Including this certificate , all records called for and described in the attached subpoena with which I was served have been provided to a COMPEX agent pursuant to Evidence Code Section 1560,
the documents (if any) listed below.
These records were

with the exception of

~ailed to CO MPEX on:
Presented to COMPEX on

"I \3\~=3
for duplication.

The records were prepared in the ordinary course of business, by the persOnnel of said business for which I am the custodian of records , at or near the time of the acts, conditions , or events depicted therein. As custodian , I testify to the records identity and method of preparation. The source of the information and method of preparation were such as to indicate their trustworthiness.

If I were called as a witness in this matter , I could and would competently testify under oath to these facts.
Record Types

If any records were not provided, explain here

Total number of pages provided:
I hereby declare, under penalty of perjury, pursuant to the laws of the State of California that the foregoing is true and correct.

Sign name:

Print Name:
Date Signed:

Title:

Agent' s Certification of Records
As an agent of Compex Services, Inc. , I hereby declare that
the attached are true and complete copies of documents provided to me on this date. All copies will be delivered to

NOTE: The Custodian was requested to sign this certificate at the time of document production , and refused to sign or
generate a similar document.

party that caused this request to be issued.

THD 00021
Signed:

The total number of pages copied was:
Signed--

Date:

' ~((C)

Date:

COMPEX Order Number: A879916-009-