Securities and Exchange Commission v. Nadel et al
Filing
265
DECLARATION of Kieran Roe re #264 Response to order to show cause by Carolina Mountain Land Conservancy. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit 1, #2 Exhibit 2, #3 Exhibit 3, #4 Exhibit 4, #5 Exhibit Composite Exhibit 5, Part I, #6 Exhibit Composite Exhibit 5, Part II, #7 Exhibit Composite Exhibit 5, Part III, #8 Exhibit 6, #9 Exhibit 7, #10 Exhibit 8, #11 Exhibit 9, #12 Exhibit 10, #13 Exhibit 11, #14 Exhibit 12, #15 Exhibit 13, #16 Exhibit 14, #17 Exhibit 15, #18 Exhibit Composite Exhibit 16, #19 Exhibit 17, #20 Exhibit 18, #21 Exhibit Composite Exhibit 19)(Solomon, Marty)
91 TIBIHXE ETISOPMOC
tnediserP-tsaP ,yerhpmuH nhoJ
eeL
lclaW boB enotS yrreJ llewoP ttoillE htidireM ttalP IA rennoC'O tnerB
nagilluM
hstinieH geR drifE divaD
yraterceS ,notatS drailliH rerusaerT ,relleK divaD
tnediserP-eciV
hcninAcM lli8 sirasseK semaJ trebloH ennazuS
airbalaC noJ
,namregnuoYboB
tnediserP ,laeN miJ
yeltneB
araS
seetsurT fo draoB
ycnavresnoC
rotanidrooC
gninnalP
&
pihsdrawetS
ralliM einnoB
,ylerecniS
.erutuf eht otni llew uoy htiw gnikrow ot drawrof skool CLMC .aera eht ni noitavresnoc dnal ot tnemtimmoc deunitnoc ruoy sa llew sa ,ssecorp gnirotinom launna ruo htiw noitarepooc dna emit ruoy rof uoy knahT
.wonk
ot
su tel esaelp ,ypoc rehtona ekil dluow uoy ff ,slaog tnemeganam ruoy htiw uoy tsissa ot elba eb yan· ohw stsilaiceps dna slanoisseforp tnemeganam dnal suoirav rof stcatnoc dna margorp pihsdrawets ruo no noitamrofni htiw "launaM s'renwO" na detubirtsid ew raey tsal ;ylreporp devresnoc ruoy no seussi tnemeganam dnal yna gnidrager llac ot eerf eerf leef esaelp ,tnemesae noitavresnoc ruoy ro
.ytreporp siht
.tisiv eht
era
ew
leef ,eromrehtruF .7775-796 )828( ta em tcatnoc troper eht gnidrager snoitseuq yna evah uoy fI gnidrager sdrocer ruoy ni siht elif esaelP
eW
llaf siht reilrae
morf )yna fi( sotohp dna troper gnirotinom eht fo ypoc a noitamrofni ruoy rof gnisolcne .gnirotinom launna ruo rof tnemesae noitavresnoc a rednu decalp uoy ytreporp eht detisiv ,seitilibisnopser pihsdrawets s'ycnavresnoC dnaL niatnuoM aniloraC fo trap sA
,ledaN .srM dna .rM raeD
03782 CN ,weivriaF daoR keerC nerraG 131 evreserP niatnuoM leruaL
6002 ,92 rebmeceD
gro.niatn uomanilorac.www
gro.niatnuomanilorac@ofni
CN
)xa˘(
2062-796 )828(
)enohp(
7775-796 )828(
2282-39792
,ellivnosredneH
etiuS ,teertS
notgnihsaW
.N 7 13
2282 xoB OP
YCNAVRESNOC DNAL NIAI-NUOM ANILO IA .
oN
X·
seY
?tisiv etis siht
ta
desserdda eb
oN
ot
renwodnal eht fo
snrecnoc
yna ereht erA
X·
seY
?detavitca neeb
eht rof
seY
sthgir
devreser yna evaH
oN.·...X
seY
?'ytreporp
reganam/rekaterac
tnereffid
a
ereht
eht sI
oN·X__
oN
?'deggol ylevitca gnieb ytreporp
,sdnop ,serutcurts
X_ seY__ yllaitraP _X___
?edam
stnemevorpmi
seY__
yna ro/dna sliart
yna ereW
oN
?deklaw seiradnuob tnemesae noitavresnoc eht ereW
oN_.N.,.X
oN X
seY
?dedividbus neeb ytreporp eht saH
dnal eht fo trap
ro
seY
?dlos
ro
,desael ,derrefsnart neeb
launna tsal ecnis
dnal eht saH
)tisiv gnirotinom
etadpu(
snoitseuQ gnirotinoM
a/n
wef
a
:)renwo morf tnereffid fi( nosrep tcatnoC
tisiv gnirud setunim ynapmocca rekaterac/renwo diD
no
rof ledaN xelA
tem tub ,on
:yficepS ?noitcepsni
sruoh 52.2
:)s(rotinom yb ytreporp
tneps emiT
6002 ,61 rebmevoN :tisiV fo etaD
hcninAcM lliB ,etaP haraS ,renliM esahC
,ralliM
ledaN
eimloB
:)s(rotinoM :)s(renwO
geP
& trA
evreserP niatnuoM leruaL :enlaN tnemesaE
tropeR gnirotinoM ycnavresnoC dnaL niatnuoM
6002
aniloraC
cr·tlpxe
.emit siht la devresbo smelborp oN .tnemesac strap elddim/nretsae rotinom ot liart keer;( driB gnola dcklaW .lnemesae eht fo trap nretsew eht daoR evreserP .ntM leruaL gnola evorD .noitidnoc doog ni deraeppa aera tnemesaE :setoN
)·t
)seru|cur·s dna ,senil ytreporp ,sesu dnal deniatniam-llew ,ytisrevidoib ,noitategev fo aera tnemesae detcepsni fo noisserpmi lareneG
ytilauq .e.i(
enon
:seloN
gnizargrcvO
noitacihportuE
noisorE
ro
ytilauQ
)woleb ebircsed ro/dna kcehc(
saera
rehtO retaW tnemhcaorcnE
tnemeganam dnal elbissop
snoitca
pihsrentrap pu-wolloF
:setoN
noitarcllA maertS noitcurtsnoC
ro
dnalteW
rehtO noitcurtsnoC yawevirD/daoR g·irebmiT ro lavomeR burhS/eerT noitcurtsnoC dnoP noitavacxE
gnipmuD/owlitisopeD erutcurtS/gnidliuB
).cte ,kcor ,lios(
noitapuccO emoH ytivitcA laicremmoC/.dnI
ro
)woleb ebircsed dna kcehc( egaugnal
tnemesae fo noitanimaxe
noissucsid fo deen ni saerA
tisiV
gnirotinoM
.sesoprup lanoitaercer rof dewolla
cruluf eht ni sliart
sa
,aera tnemesae eht
no
pool
emos
gnitcurtsnoc spahrep
fo
gnikniht
era
yeht
taht deton xelA
:setoN
eta)[
rotanidr6oC pihsdrawetS
:yb devorppA
dna deweiveR
tropeR
etaD
noitisoP
.ceD
etaicossA
__6002 ,12
rotinoM
dnaL
rcnliM esahC
margorP
:yb detelpmoC tropeR
.m',of siht ot pam dna sotohp eht fo ypoc a hcatta dna sevihcra enilesab s'ytreporp eht ni pam dna txet gnitroppus eht htiw
saw
ycnavresnoC
sotohp gnirotinom
eht ni rednib eht eliF
otohp
llew
sa
hcae erehw noitacol eht
gniwohs
pam
a sa
,otohp
hcae
,gnibircsed
oN
txet
gnitroppus
X
Lmkat dna ,fo ypoc a
seY__ ?gnirotinom
edivorp ,tisiv etis eht gnirud nekat c1'.,,,v shpargotohp fI elihw etis eht fo nekat shpargotohp ereW
on
:yficepS
?noitamrofni
pihsrentrap gnidrager
on
dedeen snoitca
ynA
:yficepS ?deriuqer pu-wollof ynA
gnirotinoM-tsoP
rotanidrooC
gninnalP
dna pihsdrawetS ralliM einnoB
,ylerecniS
e o i ll uoy w gnikrow ot drawrof skool CLMC .aera eht ni noitavresnoc dnal.erouttuftnhetmttinmmocew deunithntoic ruoy sa llew sa ,ssecorp gnirotinom launna ruo htiw noitarepooc dna emit ruoy rof uoy knahT .yaw yna ni uoy tsissa nac ew fi ro ypoc rehtona ekil dluow uoy fi wonk su tel esaelP .tisiv 6002 ruo morf troper gnirotinom eht htiw ypoc a uoy tnes dna srenwodnal ruo rof ecruoser a sa "launaM s'renwO" na delipmoc evah ew ;ytreporp devresnoc ruoy no seussi tnemeganam dnal yna gnidrager llac ot eerf leef ,eromrehtruF .7775-796 )828( ta su tcatnoc ot cerf leef esaelp ,tnemesae noitavresnoc ruoy gnidrager snoitseuq yna evah uoy fi ,emitnaem eht nI
.deriuqer ton si ti hguoht tisiv etis ruo gnirud ynapmoc ruoy emoclew eW .dnekeew a gnirud tisiv laiceps a eludehcs ot ekil dluow uoy sselnu ,syadkeew no MP 00:5 ot MA 00:9 fo sruoh eht neewteb rucco lliw stisiv etis ehT .eriannoitseuq renwodnal feirb a retsinimda dna ytreporp ruoy ot tisiv gnirotinom a mrifnoc ot ,ecnavda ni skeew owt ot eno ,enohpelet aiv uoy tcatnoc lliw nosrep ffats CLMC A .rebmevoN fo htnom eht gnirud seitreporp launna eht tcudnoc lliw ew ,rehtaew relooc fo lavirra eht htiW
devresnoc fo
gnirotinom
.derised fi sreganam ytreporp htiw klat ot elbaliava osla era eW .ytreporp ruoy rof slaog mret-gnol dna etaidemmi ruoy ssucsid dna snoitseuq ksa ot renwodnal eht sa uoy rof ytinutroppo doog a sedivorp tisiv gnirotinom A .sisab launna na no sdnal devresnoc lla fo gnirotinom eht si noitagilbo siht teem ot esu ew loot tnatropmi tsom ehT .detpecca evah ew taht tnemesae noitavresnoc hcae fo snoisivorp eht dlohpu ot noitagilbo lauteprep a sah CLMC taht dnatsrednu uoy erus ma I ,dnal detcetorp snwo ohw enoemos sA .stnemesae noitavresnoc htiw detcetorp seitreporp fo gnirotinom nosaes llaf s'raey siht gnikatrednu eb lliw ew ,seitilibisnopser pihsdrawets s'ycnavresnoC dnaL niatnuoM aniloraC fo trap sA
noos
,ledaN .srM & .rM raeD
03782 CN ,weivriaF daoR keerC nerraG 131 evreserP niatnuoM leruaL lcdaN geP & trA
7002 ,51 rebotcO
evol uoy
secalp
eht
gnivaS
etiuS ,teertS
gro.niatnuomanilorac.www
2282-39782 CN ,ellivnosredneH
gro.niatnuomanilorac@ofni
2282 xoB OP
7775-796 )828( notgnihsaW .N
713
YCNAVRESNOC DNAL NIATNUOM ANILORAC
ruoy tceffa
yllaitnetop
dluoc taht
seitivitca
yna ni
degagne srobhgien
oN ?dnal devresnoc ruoy fo yna evaH .9
.sressapsert htiw smelborp oN
?smelborp
sesu
yna neeb ereht evah ,os fI
?cilbup
eht
yb
dnal ruoy fo
lanoitaercer yna ereht erA .8
oN .7
?sretsasid larutan fo tluser
a sa
ytreporp ruoy fo snoitaretla yna neeb ereht evaH
.gnesnig
ro
dna
nees
reppils ydaL
uoy evaH .6 .erutuf
?stnalp
ni "nibac erutan" redisnoc
ro
efildliw
gnitseretni
dna sliart
lausunu yna
thgiM .egangis
poleved
gnisicrexe
ot
.skcolmeh detceffa
?sthgir
tceles ot woh
devreser ruoy fo yna
no
gniunitnoc-noitaerceR evomer-yrtseroF gninnalp uoy erA .5
tcatnoc ot woh
moc.tnemeganampoocs@gep dna moc.tnemeganampoocs@tra :ot noitamrofni dnes esaelP )tsevrah ro taert ot seert hcihw yllacificeps( tnemtaert AWH no noitamrofni gniviecer ni detseretni ,seY )...cte ,ecivres noisnetxe evitarepooc ,retserof gnitlusnoc .g.e( ?tnemeganam dnal gnidrager noitamrofni yna ekil uoy dluoW .4
oN
?dnal ruoy fo
sesu ro
tnemeganam eht degnahc uoy evaH .3
ylimaf
rehto
ro
nerdlihc ot
nevig
serahs
ynA ?dedividbus neeb ytreporp
oN ?srebmem eht saH .2
.derrefsnart ro dlos neeb sah dnal oN .sserdda evoba eht ot ypoc a dnes esaelp ,troper s'raey tsal eviecer ton did yehT 63243 LF atosaraS ,teertS niaM 8161 :sserdda siht esu esaelP ?dnal ruoy fo trap yna derrefsnart ro dlos uoy evaH ?tcerroc sserdda ruoy sI .1
srenwodnaL rof eriannoitseuQ launnA ycnavresnoC dnaL niatnuoM aniloraC
kceB refinneJ :yb dellaC 70/9/11 :etaD tisiV etiS 70/32/01:etaD )sledaN( evreserP niatnuoM leruaL :tcejorP
.sreyub wen rof pihsrebmem raey eno a gnisahcrup gniredisnoc era yehT .liame aiv ogol detadpu eht dnes esaelp ,ton f I ?melborp a siht si ,sesoprup gnitekram rof CLMC eht gnisu ni detseretni era yehT .oN ereht sI .11
?tnemesae ruoy
ro
CLMC tuoba wonk ot ekil dluow uoy esle
gnihtyna
.ytreporp
ot
tnecajda
stol
erca
ynA ?dnal lanoitidda
01 htiw srenwodnal detseretni yllaitnetop tuoba nareiK htiw ekops trA ?stneve CLMC gnimocpu ot etivni dluohs ew sdneirf ro srobhgien yna gnivresnoc ni detseretni srobhgien ruoy ro uoy erA .01
70/9/11 :etaD tisiV etiS kceB refinneJ :yb dellaC 70/32/01:etaD )sledaN( evreserP niatnuoM leruaL :tcejorP
rotanidrooC
gninnalP
& pihsdrawetS ralliM einnoB
,ylerecniS
gnikrow
ruoy
sa
llew
.erutuf eht otni llew uoy htiw ot drawrof skool CLMC .aera eht ni noitavresnoc dnal ot tnemtimmoc deunitnoc ,ssecorp gnirotinom launna ruo htiw noitarepooc dna emit ruoy rof uoy knahT
sa
.wonk su tel esaelp ,siht fo ypoc rehtona ekil dluow uoy fI .slaog memeganam ruoy htiw uoy tsissa ot elba eb yam ohw stsilaiceps dna slanoisseforp memeganam dnal suoirav rof stcatnoc dna margorp pihsdrawets ruo no noitamrofni htiw "launaM s'renwO" na detubirtsid ylsuoiverp evah ew ;ytreporp devresnoc ruoy no seussi tnemeganam dnal yna gnidrager llac ot eerf leef ,eromrehtruF .7775-796 )828( ta em tcatnoc ot eerf leef esaelp ,tnemesae noitavresnoc ruoy ro troper eht gnidrager snoitseuq yna evah uoy fI
.tcejorp siht gnidrager sdrocer ruoy ni siht elif esaelP .tisiv eht morf )elbacilppa fi( sotohp dna troper gnirotinom eht fo ypoc a noitamrofni ruoy rof gnisolcne era eW .gnirotinom launna ruo rof tnemesae noitavresnoc a rednu decalp uoy ytreporp eht delisiv ew llaf siht reilrae ,seitilibisnopser pihsdrawets s'ycnavresnoC dnaL niatnuoM aniloraC fo trap sA
,ledaN
.srM dna .rM raeD
63243 ,IF ,atosaraS teertS niaM 8161 ledaN geP & trA 7002 ,)(2 rebmevoN
evol uoy
secalp
eht
gnivaS
etiuS ,teertS 7775-796 )828( notgnihsaW .N
7!3
gro.niatnuomanilorac.www
2282-39782 CN
gro.niatnuomanitorac@ofni
2282 xoB OP
,ellivnosredneH
:setoN oNx· seY ?tisiv etis siht ta desserdda eb ot renwodnal eht fo snrecnoc yna ereht erA tnemucod tnemesae eht fo 1.1 elc-]tr·, yb dewolla sa ,sliart wen* devreser yna evaH
noitce·III
oN
seY
x
oNx·
seY
?ytreporp
eht rof
?detavitca neeb sthgir reganam/rekaterac
no ro
tnereffid
a
ereht sI
eht sI
tnemesae fo
oN
oN_.3_x seY edis nretsae
rehto
?deggol ylevitca gnieb ytreporp
deraelc sliart wen*
seY__3..x ?tliub stnemevorpmi
oN _x_
,sliart ,sdnop ,serutcurts
tnemesae
yna ereW
yllaitraP
seY__
?deklaw seiradnuob
noitavresnoc eht ereW
oN_A...x
oN x_A.. seY ?dlos
ro
seY
?dedividbus neeb ytreporp eht saH
eht fo trap
ro
,desael ,derrefsnart neeb ytreporp
launna tsal ecnis
ytreporp eht saH
)tisiv gnirotinom
snoitseuO RnirotinoM
etadpu(
a/n :)renwo morf tnereffid fi( nosrep tcatnoC
oN
:yficepS ?noitcepsni ynapmocca rekaterac/renwo
sruoh 2 :)s(rotinom yb ytreporp
7002
no
diD
tneps emiT
fo etaD
,9 rebmevoN :tisiV
sdrahciR anaiD & kceB refinneJ ,ralliM einnoB :)s(rotinoM
ledaN
geP
& trA
:)s(renwO
evreserP niatnuoM leruaL :emaN tnemesaE
ycnavresnoC
tropeR gnirotinoM
dnaL niatnuoM aniloraC 7002
.tisiv eht gnirud deton erew smelborp oN .edis taht no sepols detserof hguorht deklaw dna aera tnemesae nretsew rof tniop ssecca ot tnempoleved hguorht evord osla srotinoM .sliart fo noitcesretni ta pu delip neeb sah noitategev tuC .maerts ot txen ecaps taif ta gnidne ,sdebdaor gniggol dlo gnola yradnuob raen ecalp nekat sah ytivitca gniraelc liart weN .aera tnemesae fo strap lartnec dna nretsae ni smetsys liart dehsilbatse hguorht deklaw srotinom ;noitidnoc doog ni sraeppa aera tnemesaE
:setoN
)serutcurts dna ,senil ytreporp ,sesu dnal
aera
fo
ytilauq .e.i(
tnemesae
detcepsni
deniatniam-llew ,ytisrevidoib ,noitategev lareneG
fo
noisserpmi
enon
:setoN
gnizargrcvO noitacihportuE
noisorE
ro
tnem
rehtO ytilauQ retaW hcaorcnE
)woleb ebircsed ro/dna kcehc(
saera
tnemeganam dnal elbissop
snoitca
pihsrentrap pu-wolloF
enon
:setoN
noitaretlA maertS
ro
dnalteW
gnirebmiT
rehtO noitcurtsnoC yawevirD/daoR lavomeR burhS/eerT noitcurtsnoC dnoP
ro
).cte ,kcor ,lios( noitavacxE )woleb ebircsed dna kcehc( egaugnal
tnemesae fo noitanimaxe
gnipmuD/gnitisopeD noitcurtsnoC erutcurtS/gnidliuB noitapuccO emoH ytivitcA laicremmoC/.dnI
ro
noissucsid fo deen ni saerA
tisiV
gnirotinoM
etaD
rotanidrooC
pihsdrawetS
CLMC
:yb detelpmoC tropeR
eht
gniwohs
pam
a sa
lolNew=7=a
,otohp
hcae
seYX· ?gnirotinom
,gnibircsed
txet
elihw etis eht fo nekat
.nekat saw otohp hcae erehw noitacol gnitroppus dna ,fo ypoc a dnif esaelp dehcatta ,os fI shpargotohp ereW
on
:yficepS
?noitamrofni
pihsrentrap gnidrager
dedeen snoitca
ynA
on
:yficepS ?deriuqer pu-wollof ynA gnirotinoM-tsoP
tnemesae nretsae raen
gniraelc
.)N gnicaf( yradnuob
hsurb fo weiV
.2 otohP
liart morf
elip
\
.)WS gnicaf( yradnuob
raen aera
tnemesae nretsae ta maerts
deraelc morf liart
wen
sdrawot kcab
gnikooL
.1 otohP
ralliM einnoB :rehpargotohP evreserP niatnuoM leruaL :tcejorP
7002 ,9 rebmevoN :etaD
ledaN
geP
& trA :renwodnaL
shpargotohP tropeR gnirotinoM
launnA
e{amixorppA seiradnuoB & snoitacoL opoT K001 ellivehsA $GSU
s{niopo·ohP gniro{inoM
006,1
70.9,
evreserP niatnuoM leruaL
002,1
008 004 0O2
gro.naiLnuomanilorac)_b(ofni gro.niatnuomanilorac.www 2282-39782 ANILORAC HTRON ,EL.LIVNOSREDNEH 2282 XOB
2062.796.828:XF
7775.796.828:HP
OP
drav·of skool CL·( .aera eht ni noitawesnoc .erutuf oteht o,nh llew uoy h,·*· g·,;k-,,(·' sa n llew sa ,ssecorp g·otinom launna ruo btd· noitardeaplooc dtnnaemermJtm·mu(oc,; deun,it.·m··y(c n r·mt>(.; i r r·(· k }· >poc rehtona ekh dluow uo,) ·u" --·nlpelet aiv ·t·., vc·un·v. ll·x nosrep ffats C,I·( A .rebmevoN dnskeew a rebolcO fo shtnom eht gnirud seiircp·m: devresnoc fo gnirolJnom launna eht tcudnoc lliw ew ,rehlaew reloocro lavirra eh{ h!iW .derised fi sreganam ytreporp ht· klat ot cra elbaliava >treporp ruoy r·h slaog mr'u dna ctaidcmmi ruoy smcsid dna snoitseuq soaslat mw ·W o hsiv gnirotinom A .sisab launna na no sdnal de·eksnoc ruo rof ytJnu:·oppo doog a sedivorp fo lla rotinom cw ,n,citagNh,, si,·q ·eem oT .stnemesae noita,·esnoc ruo fo snoisivorp l p ot noitagilbo lauteprep · ·:· C.IMk.( taht dnatsrednu uoy erus ma I ,dnal detcetehrtp dsoho u · o enoemos ·.A .stne· c;· c noita'·esnoc ht· detcetorp sei·eporp fo gnirotinom lamohw ma s'raey siht gmkatrcicuu · lliw ew ,scitidbisnopscr pihsd:,awets s'vcnavresm.O dnal niatnuoM aniI·
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?