Cambridge University Press et al v. Patton et al

Filing 328

DEPOSITION of Vincent William Lloyd, Ph.D. taken on April 20, 2011 by Cambridge University Press, Oxford University Press, Inc., Sage Publications, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit D-1, # 2 Exhibit D-2, # 3 Exhibit D-3, # 4 Exhibit D-4, # 5 Exhibit P-5, # 6 Exhibit P-6, # 7 Exhibit P-7, # 8 Exhibit P-8)(Rains, John)

E
X
H
I
B
I
T
3

CUPX

00290

Exhibit 3 - 1

Exhibit 3 - 2

The
This book
mental

is

vulnerable

the

original

deserve

addresses

aspects

Cooess

FragWi

and

classicists
interested

in the

preface

its

is

nor

problems

its

hook

This

interrelated

of

asks

in

how

views

recovers

contribution

of

them

central

of both

treatment

life

affects

this

ethical

contemporary

funda

the

well-lived

profound
Greek

the
thus

issues

major

at

the

has proven

nontechnical

difficult

literary

are

our
to

have

dimension

theory

One

and philo

University

to

style

problems

it

be

makes
tackles

important
it

This

for philosophers

reading

accessible

new

to

and

any educated

person

an

entirely

edition

features

Nussbaum

by Martha

Nussbaum

Martha
Ethics

they

and

and

control

examines

It

constituents

The Greeks made

their lives
the

moral luck

valued

texts

sophical
The

yet

the

persons

ncither

attention

thought

most

its

new

outside

questions

of Greek
of

factors

and

about

views

many of

that

of persons

received

ancient

problem

to

appraisal
these

of

study

ethical

of Goodness

Fragility

is

Ernst Frcund

Distinguished

Service

Prokssor

of Chicago

Exhibit 3 - 3

of

Law and

Exhibit 3 - 4

The
Luck

Fragility
and Ethics

in

of Goodness

Greek

Tragedy

and

Philosophy

Revised Edition

Nussbaum

Martha
Unisenigy

of Chicago

CAMBRIDGE
UNIVERSITY

PRESS

Exhibit 3 - 5

book

This

ethical

is

of

study
that

problem

to factors

outside

and

lives

their

neither

the

deserve

interrelated

The
and

treatment

is

the

is

questions

But

it

and

not

because

and

argument

also

is

Greek

she

the

Taylor

and

demanding

ical

gifted

can

profit

that

of the
afford

from

isa

that

of the

reafilrnution

exploration
ethIcs

way

in

reflection

ical

to

of Goodness

Fragility

is

kind

it

an

is

losophy

in

There

are

perception

it

rare in

which

subject

of

is

its

person

new

entirely

Law and

of

Professor

because

book

Journal

..required

one

than

to

grap

books

philosophy

more

in

of

of moral

grasp

ambitious

most

com

author

the

understanding

imaginative

very

debate

New

The

book

is

It

is in

it

is

field

of Philosophy
for

reading

which

and

is

Browne
and

inter

anyone

-Jasper

leave
This

is

fabric

of

human eth

philosophical
inheritance

quality

It

tradition

richly

responsive

No one with an
moral

pursues

to

interest

of

is

eth

sensitive

Greek

in

will

philosophy

Journal

Australasian

book

important
fur

Griffin in

which

altered

an

of Books

fail

book
In

unusual

to the

alert

itself

provides

persuasive

sadly

York Review

our Greek

book and no one who

account

work

an

our contemporary

Nussbaum

this

many books

of the

an

scholars

unlike

Canadian

in

that there

truth

become

has

single

not

addresses

aspects

for philosophers

features

partly

to write

rewarding

marvelous

powerfully

engrossing

world where

in

Knox

unsurpassed

miss

to

is

Derek
This

yet
they

or literature..

philosophy

experience

tenour

richly

is

with

And

issues

change

This

together

chosen

has

Bernard

The

book

these

pereniThtl

should

It

intellectually
in

and

any educated

to

Service

found together

often

Charles

ested

attention

original

reading

edition

Distinguished

stimulating

of

fundamental

read

to

delight

new

tackles.This

it

the

thought

accessible

it

persons

questions

texts

important

makes

these

most

its

vulnerable
of

appraisal

received

Greek

of
of

are

Chicago

qualities

degree

rigour

with some

One

be

to

to

have

philosophical

style

Freund

Ernst

rich

with

them

of

proven

our

this affects

fundamental

the
life

Nussbaum

an immensely

text

has

problems

difficult

of

rare

and

well-lived

cuntribution

theory

literary

examines

It

of

dimension

ccntral

ethical

both

University

to

views

nontechnical

Nussbaum

at the

This

of

its

by Martha

Ethics

ple

and

In the

Martha

recovers

of Goodness

Fragility

preface

bines

thus

how

asks

profound

Greek

the

constituents

and

control

contemporary

in

classicists

interested

nor

luck

about moral

valued

The Greeks made

book

This

of the

persons

problems

issues

major

views

ancient

many

scholar

The Times

the

reader

one

of

Its

to

with

is

scope

tackle

Literary

them-

of Philosophy

the

both

very

wide

tragedy

in

and phi

Supplement
of

sense

had

having

ChristopherTaylor

in

his

Mind

CAMERI GE
UNIVERSITY

PRESS

www.cambridqe.org
ISBN

Cover

illustration

J.M.W.Thrner

CloreCollcetionTate

Regulus

GaileryLondon/Art

1828

courtesy

Resource

9780-521

of

NY

780521
Cover

design

by

jamea

79472-5

Brisson

Exhibit 3 - 6

794725

CAMBRIDGE

UNIVERSITY

PRESS

New York

Cambridge

Cambridge

Melbourne

of

New

Americas

the

Town

Cape

Sic

Singapore

Paulo

Delhi

Press

University

32 Avenue

Madrid

NY

York

USA

10013-2473

www.cambridge.org
Information

it

Cambridge

no

the

to

23rd

record

for

Library of Congress

the

written

Press

University

of

fragility

Nusabaum

of America

States

this publication

is

in

Cataloging

Marsha

Ntsssbaurn
The

agreements

without

place

2001

United

the

catalog

exception

2009

printing

in

take

statutory
licensing

1986

edition

Printed

collective

may

part

to

Subject

relevant

of Cambridge

published

Revised

copyright
of

of any

permission

1986

Press

2001

in

is

provisions

reproduction

First

www.cambridge.org19780521794725

Nussbauni

publication

and

title

University

Martha

This

this

on

Pub

as al/able

British

the

front

Librant

Data

ication

1947

Craven

and

luck

goodness

ethics

Greek

in

and

tragedy

Martha

philosophy

ed

2nd

cm
Includes

ISBN

bibliographical

and indexes

references

79l26-X

hardcover

0-521

Greece

Ethict

Fortune

Ethics

in literature

RJl92.N87

ISBN
Greek

History

Ancient

pbk

79472-2

0-521

drama

Tragedy

and

History

criticism

Title

in literature

2000

l70.938dc2l

00-062128

ISBN

978-0-521-79126-7

hardback

ISBN

978-0-521-79472-5

paperback

Cambridge

URLs

will

remain
and

timetables
the

time

the

accuracy

of

first

of

has

for external

and

this publication
or

Press

University

of

accuracy

does

accurate
other

or
factual

printing

such

not

but

or

no

responsibility

guarantee

appropriate

that

information

any

given

the

in

University

sites

an

such

regarding
this

work

Press

or

perststcnce

Web

content

Information

information

Cambridge

for

Internet

third-party

Web
prices

are

does

to in

referred

correct
not

thereafter

Exhibit 3 - 7

sites
travel

at

guarantee

is

For Rachel

Exhibit 3 - 8

Some

for

pray

limbs

my

until

who

gold

to delight

pray

are

and sowed

blame

land

citizens

earth

in

deserves

But human

houndlesa

for

fellow

wrapped

what

praised

others

my

man

praise

excellence

like

grows
fed

for

tree

vine

dew

the green

by

raised

liquid

have

most

kinds

all

in

of needs

just

down

love

too

joy

shst

eyes

we

those

for

but

hardships

to track

strains

and

sky

all

of

men

wise

up among

to the

We

wrong-doers

an

it

trust

Nemeas

Pindsr

He

will

and

see

it

all

see

the

that

when

rn he

any

dear

as

if

Socrates

place

where

would

be

he

faculty

that

but

he

forth

brings

it

is

looked

way

and
he

since

and

out

with

sees

the

possible
it

he

is

is

can

it

Well

crsianzs

then

dont

what

know

is

human

what

it

think

Or dont

heautiftil
for

him

with
to give
he

truth

And

he

will

life

and

is

as

become

immortal

Plato

socltxras

you

my

the

simulacrum

grasping

nourishes

being

no

comes
place

being

there

was

be

will

this

Do

itself

who

since

tn

human

for

unitary

msnner

never

it

destroyed

beautiful

is

such

in

it

alterstinn

livable

visible

human

are

any

of excellence

ever

of

where

alone

true excellence
if

is

the

to true excellence

and

and

sufiŁrs

and

eternal

itself

partaking

appropriate

simulacra

to

grasping

to he

person

there

which

to

god-loved

an

in

understand

that

for

as

life

contemplates

it

you

birth not

anywhere

misersble

contemplated

come

or less nor

with

itself

hy

besutifula

the others

mnre

itself

being

other

Vtts

Symposius

lwri

to say

being

Plato

Exhibit 3 - 9

Aleibiades

129E

Contents

to

Prefaa

revised

the

editthn

aljj

xli

Preface

Acknowkdgemenzr

xlii

Abhrr via/ions

xlv

Luck

Chapter

on

through

modern

in

of

components
elements

an

of

good

lift

Chapter
Greek
without

remainder

she

the

and
of

dependent

seldom

are

into

the

ungoverned

these

of

literature

questions

and ambition

that

dilemmas

this

23

conflict

practical

pssctieal

charge

us

for

works

Why

inquiry

is

self-sufficiency

vulnerable

of values

argument

philosophical

fragility

depiction

important

conflict

of

life

for

sub-problems

contingent

Aeschylus

tragedf

search

questions

Three

Sketch

of

part

Tragedy

these

human

good

not control The

writing

pessonality

indispensable

Part

Why

the

thought

do

beings

ethical

the

the

ethics
ethical

limits

its

reason

treated

are

human

that

things

and

of Greek

preoccupation

is

as

of

sign

as

serious

and not
and

primitive

resolvable
illogical

thought
of

sketch

of

assessment
distinction

ill

before

1V

the

say

of

cases

The

to

our

This

implicit

these

II The

view

to

in

the

the

moral/non-moral

problem

30

Agamcmnon

Arschylua

might

confronted

positive

Chapter

of proper

experiences

view

tragic

Section

in

important

the

Aulis

as

Eteocles

gates

plays

that

not making

discussion

conflict

tragic

consider

usually

fir

solutions

philosophical

Two

Reasons

cases
so

we

Factors

problem

central

Some

II

the
these

with

achievement

What

cases

It

means

learning

the

of

theories

of

Anhgone

Sophocles

such

in

response

give

the

the

47

and

vision

conflict

of

philosophers

account

Aeschylesn

simplification
Could
far as

scope
The
II

I-lit

rational

of ones
guard

Creon
clever

motivation

person

One

possible

way

life

plan

of doing

so

as

this

to

avoid

would

be

the
to

of Chapters

situations

simplify

and

narrow

cosnmitnsenta

35

of

an example

Tension

among

redefinitions
for

this

as

the

ordinary

values

strange

strategy

its

practical

precluded

consequences

by

reason

torn

recognizing
for

love

and
only

and

conflicted

one

religion

33

value

The

Ilulure

34

vu

Exhibit 3 - 10

viii

Contents

HI

Her

Antigone

flawed
IV

is

done

scrusinize

of

ode

on

The

she

human

Danae

she

ode

she

play

in

difkrent

Why

The

parodos
she

being

isa

Her

way

her

though

strategy

the

of

itself

so

conflict

is

justice

lyrics

and

simple

grounds
relation

our

conflict

concerning

choral

and seeing

of

about

The

which

in

synthesis

value

Di

eyes

depth

pcssiniisos

to

points

spheres

competing

conflict

higher-order

narrows

and conceptions

63

that

claim

this

value

retina

Creons

suggestion

bosh

to

certain
to

superior

Hcgela

of

conception

of

re-intespretasioss

in

civic

to

us

help

The

complex
life

contingency

Schopenhauert

pessimistic

response

luck

The

Part

the

of

vulnerability

Plato

II

relation

Its

rasionalisy

harmony

so

79

Part

to

on

human

flexible

of Dionysus

invocation

Conclusion
Tragedy

Harmon

and

Tiresias
to

values

individual

without

goodness

83

fragility

Introduction
The

87
of

continuity

problems

The

she

saving

The
The

II

of

power

dramatic

IV

how

The

make

does

atesia

commensurability
Socratic

of

reaches
stylistic

The

dialogues

break

of

role
to

what

as

pleasure

he

standard

is

progress

could

How

of choice

io6

aksasia

557

myth

theater

debs

true

The

and

philosophical

and

to

moral

profound

Republic

does

techni

too

it

kind of writing

positive

expresses

science

What

problems

eliminate

new
she

our

mosivares

Protagorass

between

The

Chapter

what

as

19

Greek

over traM
with

and-tragic

dialogue

89
of

stories

mythic

95

progress

the

reasoning

practical

progress

Pre-Plascasic

its

works
so

distinction

human

for

form

dialogue

of traM

progress

values

Platos

antecedent

Platos

make

argument

philosophical

ethical

it

conclusion

Interlude
The

ferMi

human

of measurement

science

The

of

of

methodological

art or science and

techni

hope

of

story

rime

science

and

problems

concept

and

the

tsthsi

setting

general

teach

over

Aithf

Prosagorass

III

Two

Protagora.e

between

antithesis

wish riagedy

development

philosophical

Chapter
The

thought

Platos

absence

of

any

The

literary
of

repudiation

as

poet

tragedy
522

criticism

and

value

she

the

of

standpoint

s6

perfection

The

dialogues

The

alleged

opening

over

other

need and

concerning

of

insulliciency

contemplative

about

quesrion

Platos

lives

intrinsic

what

support

though

ix

Repablir

worth

truly
to

arguments

profound
value

is

pumuing

his

parallels

of

rassking

the

argument

puzzling

from

Gsras

Pbikbss
11
those

HI

that

of

are

How

Its

Phsds

relevance

lsssmorsy

how

asceticism

Questions about

reached
IV

sS

defense

and
the
so

activities

that

axe

not

truly

valuable

undercut

Itep4

is

from

standpoint
aesthetic

amung

values

which

judgment
is

to

true

mural

judgments
education

achieved

Exhibit 3 - 11

of

value

are

in
ts$

Content
The

of motivation

problem

Platos

of

use

and

negative

positive
i6o

arguments

of Alcibiades

The speech

Chapter

of

reading

the

s6

Sjmsium
The

that

charge

muat

this

The

be

Plato

and

prospect

of

one

of

rIsc

of unique

individual

unique

another

for

dialogue

Dramatic

dialogue
love

speech

iGj

dates

167

individuals

one

for

another

its

171

problems

and

she

of judgments

role

she

love

whole

the

against

of

irs

Diotima

the

neglects

assessed

construction

Arissophanes

Ill

of love

ascent

of

Its

motivations

practical

How

homogeneity

qualitative

she

The

lover

enabling

achieves

self-suffIciency

IV

The

The

images

two

176

of Alcibiades

entrance

The

of

place

and

love

argued

as

Socrates

in

life

of

poetic

IV

cdsicized

and

reason

middle

dialogues

dialogues

The

the

on

the

zoo

life
in

she

other

for

position

which

two

first

has

Plato

seriously

for

203

view

of

its

rihical

restored
this

so

the

even
of

valuable

and

soul

and

guiding

cognitive

and

love

of

part

personal

elements

the

bess

The

identity

action

views

253

of
of

place

The

recantation

AnBtotle

the

intellectual

non

interweaving

intrinsically

condemnation

the

The

good

an

as

so

in

the

The

Their

energy

towards

Platos

madness

of

sorts

motivational

relation

now

is

UI

good

is

passion

psychology

speech

the

certain
of

foe
in

Motivations

Part

of

Personal

dialogue

Moral

III

in

aspiration

Implications
she

between

dialogues

sources

understanding

154

knowledge

confrontation

and

Pbaednss

elements of

certain

our

for

through

zoo
the

howls

is

praise

important

flinesion

desire

true madness

isnt

between

it

middle

in

slavery

truth

Pbaedrn

madness

what

develop

speeches

lovers

the

tell

193

story

distance

Madness

the

will

valise

in the

apparent

he

that

Jr and

love

particular

This

recantation

His daim

of Aleibiades
of

Chapter

II

of

story

indienasent

conceptions

The

the

honor

exsenr

and

its

style

human

good

life

237

of

role

the

II

How

relevant
ill

The

defended
principle

The

intention

this

method

Puazles

The

as

necessary

method

Their

there

is

in

difficulty

connection

How

works

basic

rake

240

within

philosophize

the

of

confines

the

and

reconstructing

240

are

most

can

237

view

pheusomesa
she

and action

appearances

so

Why

appearances

appreciating

What

Aristotles

Saving
announced

phathomesa

of method

discuasiona

general

Chapter
Atissoeles

223
2a8

truths

its

of the

fragility

what

Philosophy
of

status

To

poets

Introduction
The

ix

return

to

appearances
for

place

defended

against

the

appearances
of

the

all

and

The

and

language
are

appearances

thought

within

with

discourse

and

gathered

of

role

principle

of

How

ordinary

the

which

belief

competent

judge

of

243

non-contradiction
refueaoon

of
23

appearances
charge

243

are

laziness

and

conservatism

The

Exhibit 3 - 12

Contents

and

negative

the

of

tasks

positive

Aristotelian

with

contrast

philosophy

Witrgenstein

Rational

Chapter
Connections

oddness

apparent
for

between

reducrionistic

of

of

issues

that

science
criticisms

its

defense

his

and

between

of

of

other

.nx

word

connection

combination

273

of

physiological

and

logical

seen

cxplanandum

Why

account

the

of self-sufficiency

The
and

caplanantia

The

desiring

inrentionality

absence

the

desire

from

intellect

isolates

conception
nooons

and

cognition

an advantage

as

not

is

description

a$
seen

to

attack

attack

III

The

the

The

these

claims

for

the

590
life

good

291

of values

294
of

defense

Aristotles

generality

the

of

priority

of

the

19$
non-intellectual

elements

deliberation

in

and

Aristotle

the

compared

The

307

person of

An

example

vulnerable

so

when
Two

what

this

of

versions

Partial

The

important

to

the

human

good

from

things

good

of

risk

luck

on

position
view

this

disruption

role

leans

the

309

agent

life

outside

which

things
31$

is

or

and

is

human

is

character

factor

in an

319

having

Aristotelian

inquiry

completely

invulnerable

on

case

to
of

dir

to

activity

Prism

322
Related

tragic

cases

in

ronsorutiog

317

33

themselves

hmiraoon

320

luck

good-condition

attack

the

decisive

value

impediment

activity

matenal

and

life

method

dialectical

single

Aristotles

severe

of

the
fact

rejected

of good
states

Aristotles

luck

good

position

of complete

Damage

of

of good

view

opposing

cases

view

358

need

positions

How

life

The

this

circularity

312

vulnerability

in

extreme

first

How

of

extent

rarrense

The

problem

apparent

disaster

stands

so

an

deliberation

Aristotelian

The

Eudsossssa

and

contingency

and

activity

wisdom

practical

of

Chapter

view

of

choice

correct

particular

role

Phaedras

of

criterion

connecoon

apparent

search

the

for

290
the

self-auffluency

commensurability

demand

Platonic

The

Platonic

of

the

on

concrete

IV

Two

on

aIr

understanding

wisdom

practical

Its connections

motion

deliberation

scientific

anthropocentnsm

The

good

not

is

of voluntary

assessment

legal

Non-scientific

Aristotles

The

an account

as

and

ethical

person of

the

with

VI

early

Platos

implications

generic

Aristotles

wisdom

Practical

IV

movement

animal

z66
in

explanation

their

motion

by

explanation

Chapter

III

of

explanation

explanation

with

II

explanation

desire

ordinary

goal-directed

This

VI

In

rescuing

connection

causal

causal

explanation

interest
in

dcct

not

II

coninwss

264

The

animal

Explanation

causal

the

causal

and

the

Aristotles

IV

of

psychological

of

between

and

belief

model

of

function

its

action

of action

theory

164

tendencies

model

faculties

is

of

physiological

III

of

explanation

and

of proceeding

way

about

beliefa

inrentionality

of

the

questions

Aristotles

Greek

Ordinary

II

ethical

animal movements

all

The

of

and

animals

our

the

virtues

value

of

certain
340

Exhibit 3 - 13

Contents

The

Chapter
relational

and

the

and

of

and

of an

in

Aristotles

ethical

controversial

Aristotles
the

value

the

phi/ia

in

the

of

connnuity

in

activity

lives

terms of

in

theft

divine

373
Plaeonitt

god-centered
their

position

The

goodness

with

uscompanbility

the

the

special

of

rest

and

for

action

the

theorist

being good

and

and

Luck

and

connection
the

well

living

of luck

opponents

but

of

Platonist

Why

pity

valuable

to

with

this

Tragedy
and

fear

are

of

sources

ha/barth

tragic

linked

action

tragic

The

eadeimonth

she

iS

of

primacy

in

Aristotelian

the

emotions

tragic

P.eek

rhe

good-condition

between

useless

for

recognition

341

of

nature

in

political

conflict

371

in

the

on

gap

and

irrational

of

x.6-8

and

character

attack

explores

for

she

thought

passage

about

thoughts

and
mote

for

ranking

Luck

Interlude

character

Human

Ethic

The

in

value

Aristotle

overall

of Nicomachesa

of

instrumental

Its

of good

value

Consequences

management

goods

343

instrumental

Its

character

external

vulnerability

III

evidence

Conflicting

the

intrinsic

Part

to

Appendix

Evidence

life

vulnerability

special

inasabulicy

political

maintenance

Its

self-knowledge

its

Its

their

of good

The
of

greateat

ilk

good

affiliation

value

sources

developnsene

the

maintenance

intrinsic

Its

Pbilsiaa

case

and

activity

development

types

human

good

343
of

constituenca

Political

II

the

goods

Relational

theory

of

vulnerability

own

Aristotles

378

writing

Epilogue

The

13

Corcysa
II

The

the

child

about

speech

in

position

of

the

plays

play

by

who

those

believe

397

an example

unity

this

of good

firmness

natureconvention

Polyxena

of

Rejecoon

decline

cannot

character

Hecuhas

reading

397

murdered

of

ghost

of convention

betrayal

Hecuba

Euripides

good

395

Tragedy

Chapter

The

debate

of noble

Poiymestors

character

Connections

flee

in adversity

with

Thucydides

crime

The

IV

on
399

simplicity
dislocation

of Hecubas

character
III

xi

406

Revenge
The

as

human

and

negative

new

connection

plays

Nothing

Hecubas

positive

is

convention

with

Aristotelian

The

enastwosthy
liecubas

rock

as

Its

structure

and

409

point

views

significance

guiding

418
of
mark

this
for

thought
tailors

both
419

Notes

422

Bibliograply

512

General

index

527

of passages

536

Index

Exhibit 3 - 14

Exhibit 3 - 15