Cambridge University Press et al v. Patton et al
Filing
328
DEPOSITION of Vincent William Lloyd, Ph.D. taken on April 20, 2011 by Cambridge University Press, Oxford University Press, Inc., Sage Publications, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit D-1, # 2 Exhibit D-2, # 3 Exhibit D-3, # 4 Exhibit D-4, # 5 Exhibit P-5, # 6 Exhibit P-6, # 7 Exhibit P-7, # 8 Exhibit P-8)(Rains, John)
E
X
H
I
B
I
T
8
Case
08-cv-01425-ODE
1JS..J
Document
Filed 09/30/10
235-2
of 19
Page
ragc
s...vpyigiit
Use of CopyrightedWorks
Education and Research
Policy on the
system devoted
As
pursuing
exclusive
the
including
in
to
right
faith
University
full
of
System
copyright
107 and
make
and
inquiry
scholarly
graduate
and creative
education
students
to
endeavors
and
bringing
on
of
the University
materials
and
the
right
to
works
or display
perform
in
the
activities
of Georgia facilitates
law and where appropriate
the exercise
with
compliance
copyright
use rights by faculty and staff in teaching
Specifically the
research and service activities
of Georgia
fair
and
use
licensing
not
of
of
materials
270
Washington
U.S.A
Source
at
staff
U.S
about
and
tools
determining
resources
Street
for faculty
whether use
currently licensed
of
work
the
law including
of the four
fair
limited
use
exclusive
factors
in
17
rights
U.S.C
by the University
System
and
staff
in
specific
to
assist
in
situation
determining
would
be
copyright
use
fair
law
by the University
the University
of the
copyright
the application
106
exceptions
of copyright
Pisctaime
USG
17
in
materials
third-party
Regents
and
faculty
an infnngement under copyright
application
of
USG
forth
available
individuals
regarding
Board
copyright
ownership and
therefore
identifies
students
as set
holders
other
facilitates
Qontact
and
undergraduate
quality
research
use of copyrighted
fair
teaching
and makes
develops
status
the citizenry
and educates
informs
of
2009
highest
applied
System
University
Content
to
of face-to-face
good
and
is
committed to respecting the rights
System of Georgia
that
the
holders and complying
with copyright
law The University System of Georgia recognizes
of copynght
holders are balanced
on those rights under federal copyright law
rights
by limitations
copyright
course
the
providing
basic
resources
intellectual
The
to
leading-edge
in
System
and
System
and member institutions
of
Georgia and
who can
counsel
provides
faculty
information
and
staff
law
University
System
of
Georgia
Privacy
Atlanta
GA
30334
Copyright
Plaintiffs Exhibit
Jr
q-2c-i/
Si
ESQUIRE
Appendix
http//www.usg.edu/copyright/
Page
Exhibit 8 - 1
6/12/2009
Case
opyngrn
1425-ODE
08-cv-0
roucy
Document
USU
Lopyrigru LJeneralty
235-2
Filed
09/30/10
of 19
Page
Ut
ragc
Lopyrigrit
CopyrightGenerally
Most copyright
ownership
copyrights
The
answers
of
copy
to
the public
useful
Copyright
and
and
of
developing
intended
is
for
distribute
copies
the
perform
display
to
the
their
the
words
of
works
in
Time
limited
owners
works
to
work
work
balances
the constitution
of
and
Authors
to
with
authorship
The law
the exclusive
are
based
on
materials
to
Web
servers
few fundamental
with
begin
our
managing
Inventors
set
of
exclusive
limited
to promote the Progress
the exclusive
Right
to
the
rights including
of copyright
interests
the pnvate
Science
of
their
with
owners
and
respective
rights
to
the original
publicly
and
publicly
rights
to
integral
are
listed
in
the balance
One of the exceptions
to
uses of works
work Copyright law applies
copyrighted
Sections
of
copyright
to
107
exclusive
through
rights
holders
intellectual
diverse
sound
and
122
of
of the
chapter
productive
exclusive
is
rights
socially
the
right
U.S
to
Act
Copyright
new and
beneficial
make
fair
fair
use of
works
original
Copyright law applies to nearly
and
always
posting
of copyright
to
the public
the exclusive
exceptions
wide
and
issues
respect
work
derivative
prepare
music
with
arise
libraries
almost
will
around
revolve
questions
digital
questions
works
original
perform
gives copyright
reproduce
These
Related
Discoveries
law
Limitations
existing
agreements
of Georgra
System
works
other copyright
the creators
by securing
and
Writings
many
the University
of
law
distribute
interest
Arts
and
at
use
publication
copyright
provides
Copyright
right
these
to
arise
fair
or
negotiating
principles
that
questions
new Works
in
all
and
creative
works
range of materials
recordings
computer
are protectable
under copyright
websites and
programs
many
law Books journals
other materials
photographs
are within
the reach
art
of
law Also protectable are motion
dance choreography
and architecture
pictures
you can see it read
or watch it chances are
is works
of the U.S
is
law One important exception
protectable
by copyright
Works
Government
or created
published
are not subject to copyright
by the U.S Government
copyright
it
hear
If
it
it
Works are protected automatically without copyright
notice
or registration
These
different
many
works
are
does not require placing
did in the past The
Office as
law
work
owner
today
it
but
you are the copyright
under copyright
protected
any tangible medium of expression
or on the drive of your computer
clay
in
notice
In
other
of
copyright
if
they are original
wo
you create an original
the work now receives instant
and automatic
provides
even
words
some
without
once
on the work or
important
these
registering
benefits
if
the
ks
of
authorship
work and
copyright
that
are fixed
on paper in
The law
protection
fix
it
work with the u.s copyright
you do use the notice or
register
the
formalities
http//www.usg.cdu/copyrightlsite/copyright_generally/
Exhibit 8 - 2
Appendix
Page
6/12/2009
Case
08-cv-01425-ODE
.roitcy
t.opyngnt
Document
USC
Jenerally
uopyrigflt
235-2
of
basic
term
works
trade
120 years
works
of
protection
for
hire
from creation
often
receive
for
works
explained
of the
created
below
work The
today
is
for
Page
of 19
Page
works
o12
many decades
for
the copyright
rules
09/30/10
Copyright
Copyright protection lasts for
The
Filed
the
lasts
of the
life
created
author plus seventy
years In the case
95 years from pubUcation
or
of either
the lesser
for
before
1978
are altogether
and foreign
different
treatment
distinctive
Copyright ownership
in the
work
rule the author is the initial owner of the copyright
you wrote the book or took the
the work as an employee
acting within the scope of your
you are the copyright owner if you created
the work may be
work made for hire in that event the employer is the copyright owner If you
employment
to
are an employee
and your job is to create softare code the copyright in that code probably belongs
your
As
genera
If
photograph
employer Ownership
University
System
of
of copyrights
Georgia
and
other forms
institutions
is
of
intellectual
property
by the University
governed
created
System
of
by faculty
Georgia
staff
or students
InteiJectual
at
Property
Policy
For Further Information
U.S Copyright
Full text p1 the
Qatabase
of International
summary of copyright
Research by Kenneth
02009 Board
Contact
270
of
JSG
Washington
fundamentals
Law
for
academic
work can be found
in
copjrjght
Jaw
and
Qraluate
crews
Regen
Disclaimer
Street
Act
Copyright
the
University
System
of
Qgrgi
Privacy
Atlanta
34 30334
U.S.A
content SourceS
IJSG Copyright
http//www.usg.edu/copyrightJsite/copyright
generally/
Exhibit 8 - 3
Appendix
Page
6/12/2009
Case 108-cv-01425-ODE
LupyrigaL
roncy
The
Fair
One may make
whether
the nature
effect
four factors
intended
to
Moreover
each
four factors
to
arise
is
and
the portion
character
of the factors
is
Simple
institutions
to
such
use
commercial nature or
of
is
is for
is
only
therefore
one
of
the University
the
outcome
While
use
fair
purpose alone does not make
users must analyze
in order
tO
an educational
four factors
that
lawful
work
as courts
to
to
the
of
System
the
apply
the
law Working through
and applying the
but by understanding
may be compelling
solutions
determine
will
and
whole
work
of the copyrighted
activities
laws application
the
of
wIthin
such
work as
the copyrighted
to
or value
no one factor
and
other
use
in relation
for
interpretation
and
rules
the benefits
the
and
subject
is
case
and
of
fair
used
market
each
in
research
use
or not the
member
at
whether
including
potential
the
teaching
receive
in
work
be evaluated
to
of
purposes
of
important
users
use
use upon
the
should
whether
1.01
Page
Copyright
the copyght
holders
The determination
permission
reasoned and balanced
use depends upon making
factors are
107 of the U.S Copyright Act Those
Section
fair
forth
substantiabty
The purpose
lair
of the
the copyrighted
apply
conclude
factors
character
and
of
of 19
Page
without
within
is
use factors set
fair
and
amount
the
use
work
work
copyrighted
of
the
is
of
educational
nonprofit
All
use
purpose
Filed 09/30/10
235-2
Use Exception
of the four
the
USU
Exception
copyrighted
fair
use of
application
Use
tair
tie
Document
many new needs and
continue
that
technologies
Georgia
Understanding the Four Factors
The
following
explanation
brief
is
and
weighing
balancing
of the four
four factors
all
nonexciusive so other factors
may be
Purpose and Character
of the
The
law
explicitly
university
are
in
favors
transformative
adds to or changes
is
more
the context
of
that multiple
Nature
is
fact
examines
to different
weighing
other highly
the
copies
or
and
for
against
creative
work which
works
uses over
are
is
whether
use
in
the
Additionally
commercial uses
receive
to
likely
mind that
four
fair
factors
use requires
are
fair
is
give
may
mixed
also
into
into
be given
Activities
that
treatment
favorable
are
Courts
use has been
transformative
to
transformed
work
of
analysis
truly
also
defined
as
new expression meaning or message
new or of new utility such as
something
multimedia
for
product
The use
teaching
The
treatment
statute
also
of
works
to
use
Fair
quotations
of
works
in
notes
are permitted
the
work being
used
Quite
courts
simply
For
courts have concluded
example
Courts more readily
favor the fair use
that
of
have
tended
the unpublished
nonfiction
as
to
fair
apply
opposed
to
novels short stories poetry and modem art images
Only those
should
carefully
purpose favoring fair use should be used Instructors
such as
test
forms
and
http//www.usg.edu/copyrightlsite/the_fair_useexccptionl
workbook
Exhibit 8 - 4
pages
that
are
meant
Appendix
Page
to
use
of
work
fiction
and
nature
portions of
including
materials
the
uses that
use that
it
favorable
to
confined
favor
Work
use
fair
are relevant
uses of consumable
work
characteristics
of
Keep
use statute
fair
determining
mere reproductions
in such
way as
classroom use
types
in
the
conclusion
Use
pieces
critical
of the Copyrighted
This factor
differently
work
the copyrighted
criticism
considered
education
are not
that
original
paper
into
incorporated
or
the
when
likely
nonprofit
from
reaching
educational
nonprofit
of
support
factors
before
review
be used and
6/12/2009
Case 108-cv-01425-ODE
vv.7hL6ttL
soc
utn..y
repurchased
as
Amount
of the
Amount
measured
is
law Quantity
seive
Any
less
proper
an
user
as
qualify
235-2
Filed 09/30/10
of 19
Page
rage Lot
eopyrignt
use
fair
Work Used
both
neaily
relative
The amount
wants
always
to
from
weighs
the
of
the
measures
work and
in
should
use Images
amount
full
allowable
of
of the
tight
be narrowly
fair
against
or
exact
entire
the
work
heavily
fu image
the
No
qualitatively
the length
taken
work usually
entire
and
quantitatively
objective
of
to
likely
must be evaluated
copying
because
is
tmu
USC cxcepuon
Fair
use
their
Document
tailored
serious
generate
thumbnail
needed
these
serve
to
exist
quantity
amount
in
the
to
purposes
controversies
or low-resolution
version
image might be an acceptable
amount Motion pictures are also problematic because even short clips
small
may borrow the most extraordinary or creative elements of the work One may also reproduce only
portion of any work but still take the heart of the work This concept
is
qualitative
measure that may weigh
of the
fair
against
on the Value
Effect
This factor
for
the
lhe
use
assesses
work The
against
fair
weIghing
use
in
four
Revised
Copyright
factors
for
of
to
is
given
factor
is
Work
use serves
closely
as
linked
to
use
of
substitute
Occasional
quotations
and videotapes
must be considered
can
in
or
make
photocopies
direct
determinIng
for
the
markets or
potential
markets
For example
of the use factor
purpose
from that commercial use weighs
resulting
the
any adverse market effect
the use is non-commercial however
commercial
purpose
fair
for the
which
on the market
of software
reproductions
All
use
the
If
favor
the extent
effect
of the
purpose
of or Market
inroads
whether
an adverse
may have
on
market
no adverse
the
work
markets
potential
use of
effect
Is
fair
is
less
market effect
for
if
likely
but
such works
use
use by the University
Advisory
Office
at
System of Georgia based upon the fair use resources
provided
by the
Columbia University
bffpiIwww.co.pyfigfit.columbia.edu/copyright/Zqfour
factors
02009 Board
Contact
of Regents
USG
Disclalme
270
Washington
U.S.A
Street
Content Source
USG
http
oLthe
University
Systq.gLGeorgta
Priv.acy
Atlanta
GA
30334
Copyright
//www.usg.edulcopyri
ght/site/thejairyse_exception/
Exhibit 8 - 5
Appendix
Page
6/12/2009
.1
Case
-tarts
425-ODE
08-cv-01
Introduction
The
use checklist
fair
factors
circumstances
and
factors
assist
to
against
use The
fair
weighs
make
using the checklist
You
should
materials
notice
license
need
not
that
activities
E17
fair
work
Board
of
USG
Washihgton
S.A
Content Source
work
that
from
use
fair
factual
the tour
use
fair
weight
of
favor
one
use and
others
the factors
weighs
you are probably
project
box
more than
fair
in
in
will
favor
each
weigh
of
use
fair
best positioned
to
work
first
the
be used
to
threshold
following
is
published
to
prior
be presumed
be considered
should
If not
fair use analysis
by copyright
employees as part of their official duties
All
are no longer protected
by copyright
protected
U.S government
by
questions
to
1923
be protected
even
by copyright
if
no copyright
in
in
within
for
that
nonprofit
or
federal
link
copyright
work
of
1101
If
by
your
For
or
to that
law
legally
work without
use
in
into
falls
for
the
this
also
web
If
fair
conducting
allows
performance
course
or permission
license
materials
on the
available
or students
proposed
some
use The work may
specifically
instructors
has
institution
example
educational
library
directly
you or your
if
license
of
be available
to
with
distributed
are
an
through
so you may be
able
to
use analysis
or display
but
face-to-face
statutory exception
you
riot
teaching
need
not
use analysis
whether
materials
and
notice
copyright
270
LI
derives
check
to
likely
with your
familiar
created
should
institutions
your
U.S.C
copyrighted
regarding
Contact
to
the checklist
of
copyrighted
@2009
will
use analysis
fair
falls
allows
at
distribution
conduct
of
use
your
exception
and
proper
Works
1978
after
specifically
separate
copying
the
works
conduct
to
database
students
direct
dispute
It
the tour
present
electronic
copy
boxes
use analysis
fair
by copyright
use the work and
uses
conduct
published
first
is
You do
include
to
determine whether
first
are not protected
All
are
checked
the cumulative
whether
is
you are most
necessary For example
not
is
concern
of
various
law
use you
your proposed
columns
Some
use Because
use
fair
application
outhnes
checklist
decision
that
Before
ultimate
fair
against
and balanced
contemplated
to
it
ot
I-age
copyright
use The
fair
of
of 19
Page
Use Checklist
reasoned
making
work is
copyright
interpreting
As you use the checklist and apply
column and even check boxes across
or
in
the evaluation
to
decisions
judicial
you
use of
given
are important
that
from
tool
is
09/30/10
Filed
USU
LlieckiLst
Use
Parr
235-2
to the Fair
whether
determining
in
me
to
ttiuuuualun
tnn..j
Document
use
be found here Complete
can
order
fair
to
use
under
license
or
use under other exceptions
should
attribution
establish
reasonable
and
retain
and good
copy
of
this
faith attempt
at
checklist
applying
for
each
fair
fair
use
use should
of
any
such use arise
Regents.of
Disclmer
Street
USC
the
Universify
$ystem
of
Georgia
Pdvay
VI
Atanta
GA
30334
Copyright
Appendix
Page
bttp//www.usg.edulcopyrightlsite/introduction_to_the_fair_use_checkl
Exhibit 8 - 6
ist
6/12/2009
Case 108-cv-01425-ODE
Document
Fair Use
Name______________
Class
or
235-2
of 19
Checklist
09/30/10
Filed
Page
Date
______
Project
Course and Term
______
Work
Title of
Copyrighted
Author
and Publisher
Portions
be used
to
e.g
pages
timer
counts
Where the factors favoring
Where fewer than half the
justified
Where
from the rights holder
permission
Instructions
use
fair
the
consider
against
any
fair
use
in
given
of
the Office
whether
Check
fair
of
use
favor
in
weighing
deciding
situation
determinative
or at
facts
total
fair
only
the Board
of
the
of
use
those facts
should
Instructors
Regents
if
use
factors
is
outnumber those against
favor
use
Not
justified
that
apply
consult
to
the
to
of
all
your
the
the
facts
use No
Affairs
Legal
they have questions
facts
total
regarding
present
in
or factor
item
single
office
weighing
be
will
fair
seek
should
split instructors
use as opposed
on
reliance
it
should
instructors
are evenly
factors
fair
is
fair
is
at their institution
of
analysis
the four
factors
For more information regarding
Policy
of
on the Use
which
Georgia
Complete and
of
retain
such
regarding
use
on
copy of this
and good
in
the
for
multiple
copies
Comment News
utility
Personal
Use
is
Factor
uses of
applying
copyrighted
use
fair
or
of the
should
any
work
in
dispute
purpose
educational
in
activity
from use
Profiting
distribution
Use exceeds
necessary
educational
to
Use
Weighs Against Fair Use
For public
use changes work
Study
Weighs
fair
For publication
Parody
necessary
intended
at
Non-transformative
Scholarship
Transformative
new
attempt
each
Entertainment
Criticism
for
for
Purpose and Character
use
or
or
System
httpIlwww.usgedu/copyright/
Commercial
Research
Reporting
at
Favor of Fair Use
including
classroom
web
of the
arise
Nonprofit Educational
Teaching
use factors please see the fair use sections
in Education
and Research for the University
checklist
faith
Factor
Weighs
fair
Works
Copyrighted
can be found
areasonable
establish
the
achieve
that
to
which
achieve
is
your intended
purpose
your
purpose
Favor of
Fair
Use
Factor
Weighs Against
Appendix
Exhibit 8 - 7
Page
Fair Use
order to
Case
425-ODE
08-cv-01
Document
actor
Weighs
films plays
objectives
Weighs
Favor
in
of
Fair
Small
significant
Amount
to
taken
is
Factor
research
Weighs
Favor
in
Favor
in
of
Fair
market
of
for
Factor
is
work
or
more than necessary
comment
Weighs Against
or
work
similar
for original
marketed by the
product
copyright holder
in
longer
Licensing
or
potential
work
market
Supplemental
classroom
few
made
copies
owns
lawfully
of
purchased copy
Restricted access
or permission
or distributed
Required
original
made
affects
classroom
User does not own
work
to students
copies
purchased copy
Unrestricted
access
other appropriategroup
other public
that
the market
for
Factor
Factor
reading
lawfully
acquired
of original
on
the
work
web
forum
Revised
Columbia
Weighs
for
in
or
or
or distributed
work
the
or
reasonably
or long-term use
demonstrably
reading
acquired
or
copyrighted
available
Repeated
unavailable
for
Use
Fair
or derivative
Numerous
print
permission
Use
Fair
impairs market
Significantly
Favor of Fair Use
Weighs Against
Fair
or
Use
use by the University System of Georgia based upon the Copyright Advisory Office
Fair use Checklist http //www copyrtght.colu
mbia.edu/fair-use-checkiist
Universitys
Appendix
Exhibit 8 - 8
Page
for
or subject
research
Weighs Against
Licensing
or
to
Effect on Market for Odginal
work
One
work used
enUre
central
being taught
Use
copyrighted
Use stimulates market
User
Use
Fair
work
taken
Fair Use
on market
effect
significant
potential
No
is
Use
Fair
being taught
Weighs
No
the
of
criticism
or
Factor
No
heart
Amount
tailored
narrowly
comment
cribcism
whole
purpose such as
educational
subject
work as
to entire
or
portion
Portion used
or
test
Used
of Portion
Substantiality
Large
not central
is
work workbook
Weighs Against
work used
of
portion
fiction
poetry
Weighs Against
Favor of Fair Use
in
Portion used
Factor
Amount and
Factor
Weighs
Use
work art music novels
creative
Consumable
Factor
Fair Use
work
Unpublished
educational
to
Work
of CopyrIghted
Highly
of 19
Page
Weighs Against
work
or nonfiction
Important
09/30/10
Filed
Favor of Fair Use
in
work
Published
Factual
Nature
235-2
at
Case 108-cv-01425-ODE
.aJyI81LL
nuuiLIunat
uitcy
rnnn
Document
235-2
uuiaeirnes ror tiectrornc
University
09/30/10
tJU
twserves
of 19
Page
oi
rage
Lopyrigni
Georuia Copyright Policy
of
Systorn
Filed
Additional Guidelines for Electronic
Reserves
The
University
The
primary
related
System of Georgia
function
library
these
on electronic
instruction
supports
services
resources Course
be made available
electronic
of
to
is
materials
assure
authored
The
reserves
electronic
with
by
will
teachers
electronic
similar
have
services
access
timely
to
course-
such as syllabi lecture notes or exams may
works for
apply to use of copyrighted
professors
standards
following
and
reserves
and
students
that
reserves
Instructors
are
on electronic
for
responsible
reserves
requires
must complete
instructors
on
evaluating
permission
copy
the
of
case-by-case
or
fair
use checklist
fair
the
whether
basis
as
qualifies
use
If
before submitting
use of
copyrighted
the
upon
relying
fair
electronic
for
material
work
use exception
reserves
Inclusion
publicaon and
The instructor
form
library
for
Access
course
to
rather
be
will
at
the request
of the
include
citation
for
instructor
his
or her
the
reserves
through
than
in
should
to
the
of
source
original
of
unit
the
must possess
institution
lawfully
obtained
copy
of
any material
reserves
on electronic
and
responsible
reserves
for
the
should
be
by password
be terminated
restricted
course Access
should
students
to
as
and
soon as the student
course
staff
and
staff
to see whether
materials
submitted for electronic
reserves are
database or are otherwise legally available
If
so staff should provide
check
should
an electronic
scanning
Library reserves
reserves
notice
copyright
or other
material
enrolled
available
of
electronic
has completed
on electronic
available
submitted
instructors
reserves
needs
made
Materials
Library
on electronic
of materials
educational
posUng
should
link
the material
delete
materials
available
on electronic
reserves
of
at the conclusion
each
semester
lnstitutions
at
on electronic
@2009
C.ntact
270
Board
of
U$1
Washington
the University
System
of Georgia
will
impose
no charge
to
students
for
access
to
materials
reserves
Regents
the
Disclaimer
Street
University
System
of
Georgia
Privacy
Atlanta
GA 30334
U.S.A
Content Source
USG
Copyright
Appendix
Page
http//www.usg.edu/copyright/siteladditiona1
guidelines
for
Exhibit 8 - 9
electronic
reserves
6/12/2009
Case
rUUiUUt1th
425-ODE
08-cv-01
JSU
LSCSOWtCS
235-2
Filed 09/30/10
Page 10
of 19
rage
Copyrtgnt
orit
Ut
Document
Systnrr
or
Corqia Cop7 riqht
ox
Policy
Additional Resources
Other Exceptions
Permissions
Identifying
Collective
the
Copyright
Licensing
Owner
Agencies
Qrphan.Works
Act
TEACH
2009
Board
Contact
of
USG
Reg.ntsof
Disclaimer
270
Washington
U.S.A
Street
Content Source
USG
the
University
System
of
Georgia
Pthacy
Atlanta
GA 30334
Copyright
http//www.usg.edu/copyright/additionaJ_rcsources/
Exhibit 8 - 10
Appendix
Page
10
6/12/2009
Case
tuuzt1unal
425-ODE
08-cv-01
kesources
Utter
USU
hxceptions
ULvPrsty
HflT
Document
System
235-2
09/30/10
Filed
Page
of 19
11
Georgia Copyright
of
of
Page
Copyright
Policy
Other Exceptions
are subject
Copyrights
of
copyrighted
many
use
to
works
dozen
more than
and depend
upon
includes
in
and
application
course one
can
paris of
The
following
LIBRARY
brief
COPYING
to
security
loan
offer
with
lawful
some
the
of
and
use
fair
these
of
service
use
fair
means
with permission
make
are narrow
from
is
making
for
uses
certain
Act however
exceptions
the University
at
to
Copyright
By contrast
several
gives
and
works
copyrighted
about
of
summary
of
uses
guidance
most
that
conditions
the law
that
is
point
mind
in
specific
research teaching
U.S
of
Georgia Of
of
owner
the copyright
their
generat
uses
lawful
System
in
and
flexible
Other
permissions
with
exceptions
statutory
references
to
the provision
of the
U.S
Act
Copyright
and
make
also
is
important
connection
in
website
this
The
scope
works
copyrighted
Keep
of
variety
the public
permit
ultimately
exceptions The
of these
exceptions
meeting
that
exceptions
known
the best
is
statutory
application
and
limitations
Fair
Like
Section
108
to
users
give copies
most of the exceptions
This
provision
for their
this
provision
libraries
permits
applies
make
materials
of
copies
send copies
and
types of works
certain
to
only
to
research and
study or
private
to
for
through
preservation
interlibrary
under certain
only
circumstances
109a
FIRST SALE Section
once
that
providing
passed along
and bookstores
PUBLIC
but
is
others
to
loan
109c
One
the
owner of
An art museum that owns
windows and
library
may put
DISPLAYS
AND PERFORMANCES
may
institutions
and
It
and
classroomriot
the
colleges
and
the
programs
to
law
known
to
to
display
on
it
the display
works
recite
SOFTWARE
allows
may
libraries
in
to
holder
turn
by
be
lend materials
on
of
to
the wall
cases
the
is
right
the public
all
to
to
make
can
displays
work
public
where
the place
at
bookstore
for
the
books on display
place
see
1101
Under this exception
Section
classroom or similar place at most educational
read plays show videos play music
poetry
project slides
TEACHING
in
works
of
digital
in
permits
works
classroom setting This exception
and performances in the
the
only displays
on servers
1102
iN
posting
his
it
at
of materials
with
117
Section
or her
damage
this
Section
to
and
This exception
to
or
the
many
allows
of
the
rights
Architectural
of
to
instead
on
owner
platform
of
and
long
fair
copy
to
of
make
list
of conditions
are
protected
exceptions
Exhibit 8 - 11
Many
use or permissions
computer
program
to
back-up copy of the
most commercial
copy
Realistically
use may be governed by license
original
designs
resources/other
subject
rely
the
computer
or destruction
120
right/additional
or
but only
servers
statute
computer
use on multiple platforms
ARCHITECTURAL WORKS
http//www.usg.edu/copy
or the posting
are struggling
program to work
use in the event
for
copies
DISTANCE EDUCATION
When materials are
Section
remote locations
or transmitted to students
at any location
the rules
as the TEACH Act and was revised in 2002 to address issues of online
students
allows
universities
are sold
in
FACE-TO-FACE
types of
students
of copies
making
is
COMPUTER
software
and
work
may hang
materials
owners
of copyright
rights
it
to
new
of the copyright
those
This exception
performances and displays of protected
but keep in mind that
simple and broad
or performed
education The
rights
work
of
copies
other
This exception
change
all
AND PERFORMANCES
DISPLAYS
displayed
lawful
or other transfer
of the
painting
iN
display
instructors
many
comparatively
actually
modify
perform
allows
in
engage
of
copy of
lawful
located
educators
gift
the distribution
limits
exception
the release
rental
by sale
Section
allows
This important
authorizes
books
sell
DISPLAYS
statute
this
in front
is
to
owner
the
by copyright
but
Appendix
Pagell
agreements
this
exception
6/12/2009
Case 108-cv-01425-ODE
Document
uu
cccpuofls
makes
clear
picture
of that
that
once
building
when we reproduce
and
photograph
building
without
blueprints
use
it
SPECIAL
FORMATS
exception
permits
order
that
in
constructed
infringing
book
or
may be
and
libraries
to
may be
the
of 19
rage
visible
place
Trump
in
the
to
the
architectural
we
but
Tower
design
are not
may make and use
anyone
public
We
oi
might
infringe
copyright
when we snap
infringing
on postcards
organizations
useful
at
Page 12
uopyrignt
the copyright
or duplicate
FOR PERSONS
certain
they
institutions
is
Filed 09/30/10
235-2
WHO
to
ARE BLIND OR HAVE OTHER
make
specific
persons who are
able
to
make
blind
large-print
formats
or
have
or
other
Braille
non-dramatic
disabilities
versions
of
Section 121 This
works in
DISABILITIES
of published
For
literary
some
example
some works
in
educational
the collection
For Further Information
US
Full text of.the
Revised
for
Copyright
2009
use by the University
Advisoiy
Board
Contact
copyright Act
Office
at
System
Columbia
of
Georgia based upon
Untversity
the
fair
use resources
provided
by the
httpj/twww.copyjjght.cojumPia.eciu/appropriate-use
of the niyeiityystem of Georgia
Regnts
Disc latmer
Privacy
of
USG
270
Washington
U.S.A
Street
Content Source
USG
Atlanta
GA
30334
Copyright
Appendix
http//www.usg.edu/copyright/additiorial
resources/other
exceptions
Exhibit 8 - 12
6/12/2009
Case
08-cv-01425-ODE
Document
uu
cctiiIlstOElS
235-2
Filed 09/30/10
Page 13
of 19
oi
rage
eopyrtgni
Permissions
you are seeking
owner may be the
If
transterred
or
agency
to
decide
if
permission
protected
@2009
of
work you may have to obtain permission from the copyright owner The
work or that persons employer The original
author may also have
the
the owner
to
In some
instances
publisher or some other party
you may contact
an industry licensing
you can secure
permission on behalf of the owner by contacting
You have
Sometimes
the copyright
fee or impose other conditions
publisher
owner may require
the cost and conditions
feel free
to negotiate
are acceptable and you should
Keep in mind that
is
if1
not necessary
at
by copyright
Board
Contact
copyrighted
creator
cases
Commons
Creative
use
original
the copyright
other
In
directly
to
all
license
or
from
your
Washington
U.S.A
Street
Content Source
USG
within
is
within
fair
use or another
the terms
of
copyright
license
2the
exception
agreement
including
work
for
is
not
example
the author
of the University
Regents
Disclaimer Privacy
270
is
your use
of
USGI
use
Atlanta
Sy
of
Georgia
GA 30334
Copyright
http//www.usg.cdulcopyrightladditionalresources/permissions/
Exhibit 8 - 13
Appendix
Page
13
611
2/2009
Case
08-cv-01
tteSuufCCS
425-ODE
Inc
tcenuryng
Document
Copynght
rrt System
Jr
235-2
Uwner
of
Filed 09/30/10
USIi
source
first
copyright
United
States
the copyright
for identifying
2005 XYZ
Copyright
Office
For
owner
is
about
irifbrrnation
source
searching
ci
Policy
Owner
the copyright
Another important
Corporation
of 19
age
copyright
000rql3 Copynght
Identifying the Copyright
The
Page 14
notice
the
is
on the work
registration
of
which often locks
the claim
like
of copyright
this
with the
records see
registration
httpllwww.copyrtghlgovlrecords/
However
the law
publisher
or
does not require
Sometimes
the copyright
benefactor
Sample pejpsion
2009
Board
Contact
of
USG
notice
or registration
and
the
associated
any person
and ownership
original
with the
owner
may have transferred
work such as the author
status
letters
Regents.pf.the
Oisclaimer
270
Content Source
us
University
Syt of Georg$a
privacy
Street
WashIngton
U.S.A
copyright
you simply need to contact
and ask about the copyright
Atlanta
GA
30334
copyright
Appendix
Page
http//www.usg.edu/copyright/additionaI
resources/identify
ing
Exhibit 8 - 14
the
copyright
owner
1/
14
6112/2009
Case 108-cv-01425-ODE
wsa
rH
t.unccitvc
licensing
owner
copyright
or
for their
type
Page 15
of 19
tagc
Ut
Georlid Copyright Policy
of
can
centers
expedite
the copyright
negotiating
to
your
usage
centralize
search
itself
ownership information
copyright
either
for
their
with
in
touch
you directly
most of these agencies do charge
by
However
putting
fee
services
Select
09/30/10
uu Lopyrtgnt
i-tgcncies
meant
are organizations
These
by
Filed
235-2
Licensing Agencies
agencies
industries
respective
Licensing
Unversity System
Collective
Collective
Document
work below
of
Works
in
Onlue
view
to
on
information
censing
for that
agencies
industry
Work
Musical
Musical
print
Works
Works
Performance
Rights
Mechanical
Rights
Oramatic Works
Works
Graphic and Sculptural
Motion Pictures
and other Audio-Visual Works
Pictoral
Software
Comics
Works
Syndicated
Religious
Works
Cartoons1 and
Editorials
In Print
Copyright clearance Center
The CCC should
be your starting
can
grant
permission
The Authors
point
thousands
you are looking
if
many
works
of
to
instantly
get permission
for
text-based
work
The
CCC
online
Registry
collaboration
Authors The
for
of
literary
Dramatists
rights
Guild
The
organizations
and
The
Association
Authors
of
Guild
The American
Society
of Journalists
Authors Representatives
Access Copyright
Licenses
works
under
Canadian
Authors Licensing an4
copyright
Collecting
Society
The largest licensing
agency in the united Kingdom the ALCS
book authors to poets and radio dramatists
writers of
all
genres
from text
Works
Online
Most online
your best
represents
sources
starting
have
point
contact
information
However
if
this
Copyright Clearance Center
The CCC should be your starting
can
grant
permission
for
Directly
information
point
thousands
of
is
contacting
not helpful
the
try
owner or administrator
these
of the
site
is
usually
agencies
you are cooking to get permission
works many instantly
online
If
for
text-based
work
The
CCC
iCopyright
Focused
Musical
on copyrights
of
digital
and
Works Performance
online
content
Rights
Appendix
Page
http//www.usg.edu/copyrightladditional_resources/collecvejicensing_agencies
Exhibit 8 - 15
15
6/12/2009
Case 108-cv-01425-ODE
oucttivc
n.cuuzccp
-utnttuuaa
Performance
Document
Licensing
235-2
Filed
uu
agencies
09/30/10
Page 16
uses associated
all
an
to
PSCAP Amvjcan
with public
Ainbors
Composers
composers
of
these
Together
three
Publishers
and
lyncists
songwriters
from
everything
artists
of
Society
association
Membership
Ut
rage
Lopyngnt
performance of copyrighted music
music on overhead speakers in
retail space
performances
playing
music
the vast majority of published American
licensing
agencies encompass
are
rights
concert
of 19
musical
publishers
BMI Broadcast Music Inc
Performance
works
and
media Ecensing
center
sSA
One
of the
fastest
and
Works
Musical
performance
growing
London
Angeles
rights
with
organizations
offices
New
Nashville
in
Los
York
Atlanta
Mechanical
Rights
of copyrighted
derivatives
work such as recording
album
the work as part of
collection
be reproducing
song
examples
as
Once
has been commercially
ringtone
recorded anyone may obtain
compulsory
composition
mechanical
license pursuant
to 115
of the United
States Copyright
Act The royalty fee for using the material
Mechanical
cover
by law and
set
are those
Rights
of another
known
is
associated
with
reproducing
would
Other
artists
as the statutory
or
is
rate
Harry Fox Aatrty
Works
Dramatic
Dramatic works
without permission either in their entirety
or in smaller portions
may not be publicly performed
such as excerpts acts scenes monologues
dramatic work
etc The rights
that
are needed
to publicly
perform
that
combines
musical work together
with
etc are
choreography
staging
dialogue costuming special lighting
referred to as grand performing
from the creator of the work
rights Grand performing
are typically
obtained
rights
or
their
The
publisher
ASCAP
play
to
rights
referred
to
of
piece
piece
of
Small
performing
qualify
as
SESAC
of
from
musical
of
non-dramatic
play
the use as
disqualifies
in
play
piece
etc even
For
non-dramatic
obtained
typically
performance
choreography
musical
original
are
lithe
example
of
from
fashion
music taken
from
use of any of these
your own dance
creating
use and
non-dramatic
are often
such as
organizations
permission
for
musical
elements
is
not
to
steps
the grand
Rqd.g.cs
lrtc2
Theatre International
Harnrnnteip
MusIc
Tams7wjtmaij
qr.
the
play
layJervice
MTt.MusLcal
Qrganization
tnc
Library4
Publishing
Samuel Freici
Bakers
1w
Plays
Pioneer
Drama
BPPI
Pictoral
Broadway
Play
Publlshingjncj
Graphic and Sculptural Works
organizations
industry
that
part
musical
rights
must be sought
rights
Dramatists
Many
To
any form of staging
any
represent
music
performing
single
rights
make use
not
may
intended
music from
perform
performing
publicly
as small
BMI and
to
Instead
specializes
List of
license
contact
in
the use of
Still
the publisher
the dissemination
of
images
Unfortunately
of the picture
free
stock
or
in
there
is
the alternative
not
real
seek out
collective
agency
royalty-free
for this
organization
photography
stqck p9JQjgfllfl4
pppendiDc
page
http//www.usg.edu/copyright/additiona1
resources/collective
Exhibit 8 - 16
licensing
agencies
LI
16
6/12/2009
Case 108-cv-01425-ODE
ttuUSUUttdt
rcesources
Motion
Pictures
Start your
search
Credits Some
collective
Licensing
235-2
JSU
Agencies
09/30/10
Filed
Page 17
of 19
Page
Copyright
.i
of
and other Audio-Visual Works
MpytQatabase
with the Internet
of the licensing
Motion Picture
Criterion
Document
agencies
Ucensjng
to
identify
who owns
the
film
listed
under the Company
are
Corporation
Pictures
Licenses
non-theatrical
provides
licenses
for
performances
public
the
of
feature
films
entertainment
in
Canada critervnuSA
US
Pictures inc
$waqic.Mption
Kinp International
Source
world
for
cinema
independent
films classics
and
documentaries
Software
must be secured
Permission
Nearly
software
all
CNET
CNET
through
publishers
to
reproduce
may be
has comprehensive
reviews
its download
section
Syndicated
perform display
distribute
contacted
through
of software
Comics Cartoons and
it
their
or
make
derivative
homepage
on the
as
for
also acts
hub
works
of software
Internet
the dissemination
of
free software
Editorials
Creators
Etoon
Kingjeatures
Syndicate
TribunMdia
Syndicate
comics Page
United F$ure
Unversaj
Syndicate
-Comlczo
Press Syn4tate
C.artconBa.nk
CartoonStosk
Religious
Works
Christian
Revised
Copyright
for
Copyrightjicens
ing
Internatjonal
use by the University System of Georgia based upon the fair use resoumes provided
by the
Office
at Columbia
University
hffpJ1www.copyrj.gt.9jurgjiedu/cOllective-Iicensjng-
Advisoiy
agencies
02009 Boartof Rne.ettotth.e Universty
ConJtcIUSG
Disclaimer Privacy
270
Washington
U.S.A
Street
Content Source
USG
S.W
Atlanta
GA
System
of
Georgi
30334
Copyright
Appendix
Page
http//www.usg.edulcopyright/additionaljesources/collectivejiccnsing_agencies
Exhibit 8 - 17
17
6/i
2/2009
Case 108-cv-01425-ODE
nuutUUtldI
r.xsuureeSJ
iirpnan
Document
USU
Works
235-2
Filed
09/30/10
Page 18
of 19
Page
Copyright
ot
Orphan Works
situation
is
common You want to use
work beyond the limits of fair use or other copyright
copyrighted
down
to seek
exception You tracked
likely copyright
owner and have attempted
permission but the effort
no conclusion
simply has produced
Worse perhaps you did receive permission but with burdensome conditions
or
high price
and the permission was flatly
denied
Perhaps you wrote for permission
The
In
some
you might have
situations
little
choice
but
to
absorb
the
bad news
and
change
Return to
however
frustrating
plans Much
your
when you exert an honest effort but you simply cannot
owner or your efforts go unanswered
When you cannot identify or locate the current owner
materials
are sometimes
called orphan
works In the meantime what do you do when you
dead end of the quest
mysterious
and
complex
find
is
more
copyright
the copyright
reach
that
use
fair
When
fair
use you may have focused on an assumption about the potential market for
you originally evaluated
the work in question and the possible harm to that market caused by your use of the work
you discover that
there is truly no permissions
market for this work you should
the fourth factor
in
the fair use analysis
reevaluate
You may find that this factor now weighs in favor of fair use For more information
visit the fair use pages of the
It
USG
Copyright
the materials
Replace
If
dead
you reach
materials
public
Policy
that
domain
will
with alternative
end
you should
works
ask yourself
whether
those
specific
and
copyrighted
your goals In many cases you can achieve your desired end
available for use without copyright
restriction
or from other copyright
satisfy
works
are the only
results
with
works
in
the
owners
your planned
use of the copyrighted works
Your ambitious plans may have involved scanning
Internet access
and
dissemination
digitizing
uploading
for students
and colleagues
multiple copies
the copyright
owner to deny permission for such broad
causing
uses changing your ambitious plans to something more modest and controllable may either change the
Alter
holders mind or increase the likelihood
that you are within
in the
number of copies
fair
use Reigning
or potential
for rapid digital
in favor
of fair
scope of access
and dissemination
duplication
may tip the balance
copyright
use
Revised
for
Copyright
@2009
use by the University System of Georgia based upon the fair use resources
provided
Office
at Columbia
University
http//www.copyrigft..coIurnbia.edu/orphn-works
by the
Advisory
Bqar
USQ
of
Contact
Regents
Disclimerf
270
Washington
U.S.A
Street
content Source
USG
of the University
System
of
Georgia
Privacy
Atfanta
GA
30334
Copyright
http//www.usg.edu/copyright1additionaIresources/orpftaziworks/
Exhibit 8 - 18
Appendix
Page
18
6/12/2009
Case 108-cv-01425-ODE
rk%as4uuska1
nLuuna
Document
ctn.rl net
University
235-2
Filed 09/30/10
Page 19
of 19
Js
LopytIgLu
System
of
Gorqia Copyhqht
Policy
.IILI
TEACH
For
Act
more intormation
regarding
Georgias Guide to the
2009
Board
Contact
requirements
of
USG
Regents.of the University
Disclaimer privacy
270
Washington
U.S.A
Street
Content Source
USG
of the
TEACH
Act please
visit
the university
System
of
lEACH Act
Atlanta
System
of
Georgia
GA 30334
Copyright
http//www.usg.edu/copyrightJadditional
resources/teach
act/
Exhibit 8 - 19
Appendix
Page
19
6/12/2009
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?