Vargas et al v. Pfizer Inc. et al

Filing 87

DECLARATION of Christopher Keegan in Support re: 85 SECOND MOTION for Summary Judgment.. Document filed by Brian Transeau. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit Ex B# 2 Exhibit Ex C# 3 Exhibit Ex D# 4 Exhibit Ex E# 5 Exhibit Ex F# 6 Exhibit Ex G# 7 Exhibit Ex H# 8 Exhibit Ex I# 9 Exhibit Ex J part 1# 10 Exhibit Ex J part 2# 11 Exhibit Ex K# 12 Exhibit Ex L# 13 Exhibit Ex M# 14 Exhibit Ex N part 1# 15 Exhibit Ex N part 2# 16 Exhibit Ex O# 17 Exhibit Ex P# 18 Exhibit Ex Q# 19 Exhibit Ex R# 20 Exhibit Ex S# 21 Exhibit Ex T# 22 Exhibit Ex U# 23 Exhibit Ex V)(Ahrens, Julie)

Vargas et al v. Pfizer Inc. et al

Doc. 87 Att. 15

EXHIBIT NPART 2

Dockets.Justia.com

Fig11. Spear Sonogram 1-bar Loop (Funky Drummer High Frequency Content)

Fig12. Spear Console 1-bar Loop (Aparthenonia DATA)

Fig13. Spear Console 1-bar Loop (Funky Drummer DATA)

Boulanger

11: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

Fig14. Spear Sonogram (Analysis Settings)

Boulanger

12: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

Fig15. Spear Sonogram Beat 1 (Aparthenonia) Boulanger

13: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

Fig16. Spear Sonogram Beat 1 (Funky Drummer) Boulanger

14: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

Fig17. Spear Sonogram Beat 2 (Aparthenonia) Boulanger

15: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

Fig18. Spear Sonogram Beat 2 (Funky Drummer)

Boulanger

16: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

Fig19. Spear Sonogram Beat 3 (Aparthenonia) Boulanger

17: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

Fig20. Spear Sonogram Beat 3 (Funky Drummer) Boulanger

18: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

Fig21. Spear Sonogram Beat 4 (Aparthenonia) Boulanger

19: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

Fig22. Spear Sonogram Beat 4 (Funky Drummer) Boulanger

20: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

Fig23. Audacity Waveform & Spectrum 1-bar Loop (Aparthenonia above Funky Drummer)

Fig24. Audacity Waveform & Pitch 1-bar Loop (Aparthenonia above Funky Drummer)

Boulanger

21: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

Fig25. Audacity Enhanced Correlation Frequency Analysis 1-bar Loop (Aparthenonia)

Fig26. Audacity Enhanced Correlation Frequency Analysis 1-bar Loop (Funky Drummer)

Boulanger

22: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

Lag (seconds) 0.000023 0.000045 0.000068 0.000091 0.000113 0.000136 0.000159 0.000181 0.000204 0.000227 0.000249 0.000272 0.000295 0.000317 0.000340 0.000363 0.000385 0.000408 0.000431 0.000454 0.000476 0.000499 0.000522 0.000544 0.000567 0.000590 0.000612 0.000635 0.000658 0.000680 0.000703 0.000726 0.000748 0.000771 0.000794 0.000816 0.000839 0.000862 0.000884 0.000907 0.000930 0.000952 0.000975 0.000998 0.001020 0.001043 0.001066 0.001088 0.001111 0.001134 0.001156 0.001179 0.001202 0.001224 0.001247 0.001270 0.001293 0.001315 0.001338 0.001361 0.001383 0.001406 0.001429 0.001451 0.001474 Boulanger 23:

Frequency (Hz) Level 1.000000 0.000000 0.500000 0.000000 0.333333 0.000000 0.250000 0.000000 0.200000 0.000000 0.166667 0.000000 0.142857 0.000000 0.125000 0.000000 0.111111 0.000000 0.100000 0.000000 0.090909 21.553040 0.083333 20.215500 0.076923 0.759315 0.071429 0.000000 0.066667 0.000000 0.062500 3.803909 0.058824 6.605278 0.055556 0.634415 0.052632 0.000000 0.050000 3.611328 0.047619 0.000000 0.045455 0.000000 0.043478 0.000000 0.041667 0.000000 0.040000 0.000000 0.038462 0.000000 0.037037 0.000000 0.035714 0.000000 0.034483 0.000000 0.033333 0.000000 0.032258 0.000000 0.031250 0.000000 0.030303 0.000000 0.029412 0.000000 0.028571 0.000000 0.027778 0.000000 0.027027 0.000000 0.026316 0.000000 0.025641 0.000000 0.025000 0.000000 0.024390 0.000000 0.023810 0.000000 0.023256 0.000000 0.022727 0.000000 0.022222 0.000000 0.021739 0.000000 0.021277 0.000000 0.020833 0.000000 0.020408 0.000000 0.020000 0.000000 0.019608 0.000000 0.019231 0.000000 0.018868 0.000000 0.018519 0.000000 0.018182 0.000000 0.017857 0.000000 0.017544 0.000000 0.017241 0.000000 0.016949 0.000000 0.016667 0.000000 0.016393 0.000000 0.016129 0.000000 0.015873 0.000000 0.015625 0.000000 0.015385 0.000000 "Var gas v. Pfi z er , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o . 04- CV-9772 ( W HP) - Ex per t o p i n i o n a n d F F T A na l ysi s"

0.001497 0.001519 0.001542 0.001565 0.001587 0.001610 0.001633 0.001655 0.001678 0.001701 0.001723 0.001746 0.001769 0.001791 0.001814 0.001837 0.001859 0.001882 0.001905 0.001927 0.001950 0.001973 0.001995 0.002018 0.002041 0.002063 0.002086 0.002109 0.002132 0.002154 0.002177 0.002200 0.002222 0.002245 0.002268 0.002290 0.002313 0.002336 0.002358 0.002381 0.002404 0.002426 0.002449 0.002472 0.002494 0.002517 0.002540 0.002562 0.002585 0.002608 0.002630 0.002653 0.002676 0.002698 0.002721 0.002744 0.002766 0.002789 0.002812 0.002834 0.002857 0.002880 0.002902 0.002925 0.002948 0.002971 Boulanger

0.015152 0.000000 0.014925 0.000000 0.014706 0.000000 0.014493 0.000000 0.014286 0.000000 0.014085 0.000000 0.013889 0.000000 0.013699 0.000000 0.013514 0.000000 0.013333 0.000000 0.013158 0.000000 0.012987 0.000000 0.012821 0.000000 0.012658 0.000000 0.012500 0.000000 0.012346 0.000000 0.012195 0.000000 0.012048 0.000000 0.011905 0.000000 0.011765 0.000000 0.011628 0.000000 0.011494 0.000000 0.011364 0.000000 0.011236 0.000000 0.011111 0.000000 0.010989 0.000000 0.010870 0.000000 0.010753 0.000000 0.010638 0.000000 0.010526 0.000000 0.010417 0.000000 0.010309 0.000000 0.010204 0.000000 0.010101 0.000000 0.010000 0.000000 0.009901 0.000000 0.009804 0.000000 0.009709 0.000000 0.009615 0.000000 0.009524 -0.000000 0.009434 0.000000 0.009346 0.000000 0.009259 0.000000 0.009174 0.000000 0.009091 0.000000 0.009009 0.000000 0.008929 0.000000 0.008850 0.000000 0.008772 0.000000 0.008696 0.000000 0.008621 0.000000 0.008547 0.000000 0.008475 0.000000 0.008403 -0.000000 0.008333 0.000000 0.008264 -0.000000 0.008197 0.000000 0.008130 -0.000000 0.008065 0.000000 0.008000 -0.000000 0.007937 0.000000 0.007874 -0.000000 0.007812 0.000000 0.007752 -0.000000 0.007692 0.000000 0.007634 -0.000000 24: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.002993 0.003016 0.003039 0.003061 0.003084 0.003107 0.003129 0.003152 0.003175 0.003197 0.003220 0.003243 0.003265 0.003288 0.003311 0.003333 0.003356 0.003379 0.003401 0.003424 0.003447 0.003469 0.003492 0.003515 0.003537 0.003560 0.003583 0.003605 0.003628 0.003651 0.003673 0.003696 0.003719 0.003741 0.003764 0.003787 0.003810 0.003832 0.003855 0.003878 0.003900 0.003923 0.003946 0.003968 0.003991 0.004014 0.004036 0.004059 0.004082 0.004104 0.004127 0.004150 0.004172 0.004195 0.004218 0.004240 0.004263 0.004286 0.004308 0.004331 0.004354 0.004376 0.004399 0.004422 0.004444 0.004467 Boulanger

0.007576 0.000000 0.007519 -0.000000 0.007463 0.000000 0.007407 -0.000000 0.007353 0.000000 0.007299 -0.000000 0.007246 0.000000 0.007194 -0.000000 0.007143 0.000000 0.007092 -0.000000 0.007042 0.000000 0.006993 -0.000000 0.006944 0.000000 0.006897 -0.000000 0.006849 0.000000 0.006803 -0.000000 0.006757 0.000000 0.006711 -0.000000 0.006667 0.000000 0.006623 -0.000000 0.006579 0.000000 0.006536 -0.000000 0.006494 0.000000 0.006452 -0.000000 0.006410 0.000000 0.006369 -0.000000 0.006329 0.000000 0.006289 -0.000000 0.006250 0.000000 0.006211 -0.000000 0.006173 0.000000 0.006135 -0.000000 0.006098 0.000000 0.006061 -0.000000 0.006024 0.000000 0.005988 -0.000000 0.005952 0.000000 0.005917 -0.000000 0.005882 0.000000 0.005848 -0.000000 0.005814 0.000000 0.005780 -0.000000 0.005747 0.000000 0.005714 -0.000000 0.005682 0.000000 0.005650 -0.000000 0.005618 0.000000 0.005587 -0.000000 0.005556 0.000000 0.005525 -0.000000 0.005495 0.000000 0.005464 -0.000000 0.005435 0.000000 0.005405 -0.000000 0.005376 0.000000 0.005348 -0.000000 0.005319 0.000000 0.005291 -0.000000 0.005263 0.000000 0.005236 -0.000000 0.005208 0.000000 0.005181 -0.000000 0.005155 0.000000 0.005128 -0.000000 0.005102 0.000000 0.005076 -0.000000 25: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.004490 0.004512 0.004535 0.004558 0.004580 0.004603 0.004626 0.004649 0.004671 0.004694 0.004717 0.004739 0.004762 0.004785 0.004807 0.004830 0.004853 0.004875 0.004898 0.004921 0.004943 0.004966 0.004989 0.005011 0.005034 0.005057 0.005079 0.005102 0.005125 0.005147 0.005170 0.005193 0.005215 0.005238 0.005261 0.005283 0.005306 0.005329 0.005351 0.005374 0.005397 0.005420 0.005442 0.005465 0.005488 0.005510 0.005533 0.005556 0.005578 0.005601 0.005624 0.005646 0.005669 0.005692 0.005714 0.005737 0.005760 0.005782 0.005805 0.005828 0.005850 0.005873 0.005896 0.005918 0.005941 0.005964 Boulanger

0.005051 0.000000 0.005025 -0.000000 0.005000 0.000000 0.004975 -0.000000 0.004950 0.000000 0.004926 -0.000000 0.004902 0.000000 0.004878 -0.000000 0.004854 0.000000 0.004831 -0.000000 0.004808 0.000000 0.004785 -0.000000 0.004762 0.000000 0.004739 -0.000000 0.004717 0.000000 0.004695 -0.000000 0.004673 0.000000 0.004651 -0.000000 0.004630 0.000000 0.004608 -0.000000 0.004587 0.000000 0.004566 -0.000000 0.004545 0.000000 0.004525 -0.000000 0.004505 0.000000 0.004484 -0.000000 0.004464 0.000000 0.004444 -0.000000 0.004425 0.000000 0.004405 -0.000000 0.004386 0.000000 0.004367 -0.000000 0.004348 0.000000 0.004329 -0.000000 0.004310 0.000000 0.004292 -0.000000 0.004274 0.000000 0.004255 -0.000000 0.004237 0.000000 0.004219 -0.000000 0.004202 0.000000 0.004184 -0.000000 0.004167 0.000000 0.004149 -0.000000 0.004132 0.000000 0.004115 -0.000000 0.004098 0.000000 0.004082 -0.000000 0.004065 0.000000 0.004049 -0.000000 0.004032 0.000000 0.004016 -0.000000 0.004000 0.000000 0.003984 -0.000000 0.003968 0.000000 0.003953 -0.000000 0.003937 0.000000 0.003922 -0.000000 0.003906 0.000000 0.003891 -0.000000 0.003876 0.000000 0.003861 -0.000000 0.003846 0.000000 0.003831 -0.000000 0.003817 0.000000 0.003802 -0.000000 26: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.005986 0.006009 0.006032 0.006054 0.006077 0.006100 0.006122 0.006145 0.006168 0.006190 0.006213 0.006236 0.006259 0.006281 0.006304 0.006327 0.006349 0.006372 0.006395 0.006417 0.006440 0.006463 0.006485 0.006508 0.006531 0.006553 0.006576 0.006599 0.006621 0.006644 0.006667 0.006689 0.006712 0.006735 0.006757 0.006780 0.006803 0.006825 0.006848 0.006871 0.006893 0.006916 0.006939 0.006961 0.006984 0.007007 0.007029 0.007052 0.007075 0.007098 0.007120 0.007143 0.007166 0.007188 0.007211 0.007234 0.007256 0.007279 0.007302 0.007324 0.007347 0.007370 0.007392 0.007415 0.007438 0.007460 Boulanger

0.003788 0.000000 0.003774 -0.000000 0.003759 0.000000 0.003745 -0.000000 0.003731 0.000000 0.003717 -0.000000 0.003704 0.000000 0.003690 -0.000000 0.003676 0.000000 0.003663 -0.000000 0.003650 0.000000 0.003636 -0.000000 0.003623 0.000000 0.003610 -0.000000 0.003597 0.000000 0.003584 -0.000000 0.003571 0.000000 0.003559 -0.000000 0.003546 0.000000 0.003534 -0.000000 0.003521 0.000000 0.003509 -0.000000 0.003497 0.000000 0.003484 -0.000000 0.003472 0.000000 0.003460 -0.000000 0.003448 0.000000 0.003436 -0.000000 0.003425 0.030350 0.003413 0.720607 0.003401 0.000000 0.003390 -0.000000 0.003378 0.000000 0.003367 -0.000000 0.003356 0.000000 0.003344 -0.000000 0.003333 0.000000 0.003322 -0.000000 0.003311 0.000000 0.003300 -0.000000 0.003289 0.000000 0.003279 -0.000000 0.003268 0.000000 0.003257 -0.000000 0.003247 0.000000 0.003236 -0.000000 0.003226 0.000000 0.003215 -0.000000 0.003205 0.000000 0.003195 -0.000000 0.003185 0.000000 0.003175 -0.000000 0.003165 0.000000 0.003155 -0.000000 0.003145 0.000000 0.003135 -0.000000 0.003125 0.000000 0.003115 -0.000000 0.003106 0.000000 0.003096 -0.000000 0.003086 0.000000 0.003077 -0.000000 0.003067 0.000000 0.003058 -0.000000 0.003049 0.000000 0.003040 -0.000000 27: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.007483 0.007506 0.007528 0.007551 0.007574 0.007596 0.007619 0.007642 0.007664 0.007687 0.007710 0.007732 0.007755 0.007778 0.007800 0.007823 0.007846 0.007868 0.007891 0.007914 0.007937 0.007959 0.007982 0.008005 0.008027 0.008050 0.008073 0.008095 0.008118 0.008141 0.008163 0.008186 0.008209 0.008231 0.008254 0.008277 0.008299 0.008322 0.008345 0.008367 0.008390 0.008413 0.008435 0.008458 0.008481 0.008503 0.008526 0.008549 0.008571 0.008594 0.008617 0.008639 0.008662 0.008685 0.008707 0.008730 0.008753 0.008776 0.008798 0.008821 0.008844 0.008866 0.008889 0.008912 0.008934 0.008957 Boulanger

0.003030 0.000000 0.003021 -0.000000 0.003012 0.000000 0.003003 -0.000000 0.002994 0.000000 0.002985 -0.000000 0.002976 0.000000 0.002967 -0.000000 0.002959 0.000000 0.002950 -0.000000 0.002941 0.000000 0.002933 -0.000000 0.002924 0.000000 0.002915 -0.000000 0.002907 0.000000 0.002899 -0.000000 0.002890 0.000000 0.002882 0.331496 0.002874 0.000000 0.002865 -0.000000 0.002857 0.000000 0.002849 -0.000000 0.002841 0.608095 0.002833 -0.000000 0.002825 0.000000 0.002817 -0.000000 0.002809 0.000000 0.002801 -0.000000 0.002793 0.655745 0.002786 2.066183 0.002778 1.835125 0.002770 -0.000000 0.002762 0.000000 0.002755 -0.000000 0.002747 0.000000 0.002740 -0.000000 0.002732 0.000000 0.002725 -0.000000 0.002717 0.463953 0.002710 -0.000000 0.002703 0.000000 0.002695 -0.000000 0.002688 0.000000 0.002681 -0.000000 0.002674 0.000000 0.002667 2.051878 0.002660 0.000000 0.002653 -0.000000 0.002646 0.000000 0.002639 -0.000000 0.002632 0.000000 0.002625 -0.000000 0.002618 0.000000 0.002611 -0.000000 0.002604 0.000000 0.002597 -0.000000 0.002591 0.000000 0.002584 1.412363 0.002577 0.000000 0.002571 -0.000000 0.002564 0.000000 0.002558 -0.000000 0.002551 1.779446 0.002545 4.637920 0.002538 3.199990 0.002532 1.678653 28: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.008980 0.009002 0.009025 0.009048 0.009070 0.009093 0.009116 0.009138 0.009161 0.009184 0.009206 0.009229 0.009252 0.009274 0.009297 0.009320 0.009342 0.009365 0.009388 0.009410 0.009433 0.009456 0.009478 0.009501 0.009524 0.009546 0.009569 0.009592 0.009615 0.009637 0.009660 0.009683 0.009705 0.009728 0.009751 0.009773 0.009796 0.009819 0.009841 0.009864 0.009887 0.009909 0.009932 0.009955 0.009977 0.010000 0.010023 0.010045 0.010068 0.010091 0.010113 0.010136 0.010159 0.010181 0.010204 0.010227 0.010249 0.010272 0.010295 0.010317 0.010340 0.010363 0.010385 0.010408 0.010431 0.010454 Boulanger

0.002525 2.088795 0.002519 2.363193 0.002513 1.266256 0.002506 -0.000000 0.002500 2.719098 0.002494 7.756382 0.002488 4.127491 0.002481 1.837810 0.002475 4.841058 0.002469 3.711902 0.002463 1.286673 0.002457 0.594875 0.002451 0.000000 0.002445 0.304012 0.002439 2.858684 0.002433 3.015993 0.002427 0.429845 0.002421 -0.000000 0.002415 0.000000 0.002410 1.522691 0.002404 2.656686 0.002398 0.696606 0.002392 0.000000 0.002387 -0.000000 0.002381 0.000000 0.002375 -0.000000 0.002370 2.894464 0.002364 3.453092 0.002358 2.339815 0.002353 2.558439 0.002347 1.485211 0.002342 0.084416 0.002336 0.158762 0.002331 2.922977 0.002326 4.784974 0.002320 4.644542 0.002315 3.335803 0.002309 0.286866 0.002304 0.000000 0.002299 -0.000000 0.002294 0.000000 0.002288 -0.000000 0.002283 0.000000 0.002278 -0.000000 0.002273 0.701921 0.002268 1.547218 0.002262 0.000000 0.002257 -0.000000 0.002252 0.000000 0.002247 -0.000000 0.002242 0.000000 0.002237 -0.000000 0.002232 0.000000 0.002227 -0.000000 0.002222 0.000000 0.002217 -0.000000 0.002212 0.000000 0.002208 -0.000000 0.002203 0.000000 0.002198 -0.000000 0.002193 0.000000 0.002188 -0.000000 0.002183 0.000000 0.002179 -0.000000 0.002174 0.000000 0.002169 -0.000000 29: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.010476 0.010499 0.010522 0.010544 0.010567 0.010590 0.010612 0.010635 0.010658 0.010680 0.010703 0.010726 0.010748 0.010771 0.010794 0.010816 0.010839 0.010862 0.010884 0.010907 0.010930 0.010952 0.010975 0.010998 0.011020 0.011043 0.011066 0.011088 0.011111 0.011134 0.011156 0.011179 0.011202 0.011224 0.011247 0.011270 0.011293 0.011315 0.011338 0.011361 0.011383 0.011406 0.011429 0.011451 0.011474 0.011497 0.011519 0.011542 0.011565 0.011587 0.011610 0.011633 0.011655 0.011678 0.011701 0.011723 0.011746 0.011769 0.011791 0.011814 0.011837 0.011859 0.011882 0.011905 0.011927 0.011950 Boulanger

0.002165 0.000000 0.002160 -0.000000 0.002155 0.000000 0.002151 -0.000000 0.002146 0.000000 0.002141 -0.000000 0.002137 0.000000 0.002132 -0.000000 0.002128 0.000000 0.002123 -0.000000 0.002119 0.000000 0.002114 -0.000000 0.002110 0.000000 0.002105 -0.000000 0.002101 0.000000 0.002096 -0.000000 0.002092 0.000000 0.002088 -0.000000 0.002083 0.000000 0.002079 -0.000000 0.002075 0.000000 0.002070 -0.000000 0.002066 0.000000 0.002062 -0.000000 0.002058 0.000000 0.002053 -0.000000 0.002049 0.000000 0.002045 -0.000000 0.002041 0.000000 0.002037 -0.000000 0.002033 0.000000 0.002028 -0.000000 0.002024 0.000000 0.002020 -0.000000 0.002016 0.000000 0.002012 -0.000000 0.002008 0.000000 0.002004 -0.000000 0.002000 0.000000 0.001996 -0.000000 0.001992 0.000000 0.001988 -0.000000 0.001984 0.000000 0.001980 -0.000000 0.001976 0.000000 0.001972 -0.000000 0.001969 0.000000 0.001965 0.499373 0.001961 0.000000 0.001957 -0.000000 0.001953 0.000000 0.001949 -0.000000 0.001946 0.000000 0.001942 -0.000000 0.001938 0.000000 0.001934 -0.000000 0.001931 1.356868 0.001927 4.854334 0.001923 4.315751 0.001919 1.718317 0.001916 0.000000 0.001912 -0.000000 0.001908 0.000000 0.001905 0.936441 0.001901 2.429510 0.001898 2.214805 30: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.011973 0.011995 0.012018 0.012041 0.012063 0.012086 0.012109 0.012132 0.012154 0.012177 0.012200 0.012222 0.012245 0.012268 0.012290 0.012313 0.012336 0.012358 0.012381 0.012404 0.012426 0.012449 0.012472 0.012494 0.012517 0.012540 0.012562 0.012585 0.012608 0.012630 0.012653 0.012676 0.012698 0.012721 0.012744 0.012766 0.012789 0.012812 0.012834 0.012857 0.012880 0.012902 0.012925 0.012948 0.012971 0.012993 0.013016 0.013039 0.013061 0.013084 0.013107 0.013129 0.013152 0.013175 0.013197 0.013220 0.013243 0.013265 0.013288 0.013311 0.013333 0.013356 0.013379 0.013401 0.013424 0.013447 Boulanger

0.001894 0.892802 0.001890 -0.000000 0.001887 0.000000 0.001883 -0.000000 0.001880 0.000000 0.001876 -0.000000 0.001873 0.000000 0.001869 0.025088 0.001866 1.994829 0.001862 3.205456 0.001859 2.777256 0.001855 2.714776 0.001852 1.461185 0.001848 0.395720 0.001845 1.759557 0.001842 2.951923 0.001838 2.695057 0.001835 3.505614 0.001832 5.741745 0.001828 7.321740 0.001825 7.582151 0.001821 6.061100 0.001818 4.741284 0.001815 3.527966 0.001812 2.788777 0.001808 4.519060 0.001805 4.264087 0.001802 1.632328 0.001799 1.228737 0.001795 1.463804 0.001792 2.220574 0.001789 4.607594 0.001786 4.977704 0.001783 3.510398 0.001779 3.565978 0.001776 3.363751 0.001773 2.296714 0.001770 3.110151 0.001767 3.916647 0.001764 2.927113 0.001761 2.402445 0.001757 3.132883 0.001754 4.282025 0.001751 4.805913 0.001748 4.724681 0.001745 4.125867 0.001742 3.765930 0.001739 4.530559 0.001736 5.425923 0.001733 6.530627 0.001730 6.867395 0.001727 4.325947 0.001724 2.271319 0.001721 3.287029 0.001718 6.055679 0.001715 8.705225 0.001712 8.019490 0.001709 4.341346 0.001706 1.849572 0.001704 0.790190 0.001701 0.628326 0.001698 -0.000000 0.001695 0.000000 0.001692 0.183877 0.001689 1.495579 0.001686 -0.000000 31: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.013469 0.013492 0.013515 0.013537 0.013560 0.013583 0.013605 0.013628 0.013651 0.013673 0.013696 0.013719 0.013741 0.013764 0.013787 0.013810 0.013832 0.013855 0.013878 0.013900 0.013923 0.013946 0.013968 0.013991 0.014014 0.014036 0.014059 0.014082 0.014104 0.014127 0.014150 0.014172 0.014195 0.014218 0.014240 0.014263 0.014286 0.014308 0.014331 0.014354 0.014376 0.014399 0.014422 0.014444 0.014467 0.014490 0.014512 0.014535 0.014558 0.014580 0.014603 0.014626 0.014649 0.014671 0.014694 0.014717 0.014739 0.014762 0.014785 0.014807 0.014830 0.014853 0.014875 0.014898 0.014921 0.014943 Boulanger

0.001684 0.000000 0.001681 0.861865 0.001678 1.096002 0.001675 0.013170 0.001672 0.000000 0.001669 0.507202 0.001667 1.663264 0.001664 1.978921 0.001661 0.115023 0.001658 -0.000000 0.001656 0.055234 0.001653 0.499235 0.001650 2.110765 0.001647 3.940285 0.001645 4.165462 0.001642 4.840200 0.001639 6.204906 0.001637 7.203015 0.001634 6.864990 0.001631 4.430894 0.001629 3.072311 0.001626 2.894165 0.001623 3.616418 0.001621 4.441782 0.001618 4.741677 0.001616 4.617462 0.001613 3.583952 0.001610 2.733568 0.001608 4.090377 0.001605 6.580335 0.001603 6.149681 0.001600 4.826411 0.001597 3.966119 0.001595 3.205339 0.001592 3.423096 0.001590 2.907916 0.001587 2.983257 0.001585 3.743700 0.001582 3.890339 0.001580 4.677491 0.001577 5.615147 0.001575 5.518929 0.001572 4.613779 0.001570 4.550924 0.001567 5.604510 0.001565 5.620639 0.001563 5.184771 0.001560 5.056959 0.001558 5.203800 0.001555 4.194970 0.001553 3.315416 0.001550 3.956429 0.001548 4.400735 0.001546 4.974723 0.001543 5.874137 0.001541 5.405963 0.001538 4.419878 0.001536 4.960225 0.001534 4.826321 0.001531 3.584028 0.001529 3.572710 0.001527 3.791602 0.001524 3.301149 0.001522 3.791604 0.001520 5.605894 0.001517 6.445282 32: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.014966 0.014989 0.015011 0.015034 0.015057 0.015079 0.015102 0.015125 0.015147 0.015170 0.015193 0.015215 0.015238 0.015261 0.015283 0.015306 0.015329 0.015351 0.015374 0.015397 0.015420 0.015442 0.015465 0.015488 0.015510 0.015533 0.015556 0.015578 0.015601 0.015624 0.015646 0.015669 0.015692 0.015714 0.015737 0.015760 0.015782 0.015805 0.015828 0.015850 0.015873 0.015896 0.015918 0.015941 0.015964 0.015986 0.016009 0.016032 0.016054 0.016077 0.016100 0.016122 0.016145 0.016168 0.016190 0.016213 0.016236 0.016259 0.016281 0.016304 0.016327 0.016349 0.016372 0.016395 0.016417 0.016440 Boulanger

0.001515 6.136918 0.001513 5.659092 0.001511 5.450059 0.001508 4.910730 0.001506 4.340757 0.001504 3.302335 0.001502 2.114852 0.001499 1.719238 0.001497 2.551761 0.001495 3.630986 0.001493 4.258947 0.001490 4.624305 0.001488 3.679489 0.001486 2.228204 0.001484 2.334379 0.001481 2.737811 0.001479 3.051713 0.001477 3.851770 0.001475 4.390267 0.001473 3.940096 0.001471 4.257960 0.001468 4.004947 0.001466 2.431141 0.001464 1.112686 0.001462 0.463080 0.001460 0.776010 0.001458 2.342703 0.001456 3.990129 0.001453 4.085196 0.001451 2.596519 0.001449 0.744969 0.001447 0.630498 0.001445 1.491628 0.001443 0.484389 0.001441 0.810620 0.001439 2.524523 0.001437 1.623435 0.001435 -0.000000 0.001433 0.000000 0.001431 -0.000000 0.001429 0.195276 0.001427 0.583048 0.001425 0.933940 0.001422 1.318214 0.001420 1.376323 0.001418 0.757218 0.001416 0.007257 0.001414 0.249780 0.001412 0.286080 0.001410 -0.000000 0.001408 0.000000 0.001406 0.749603 0.001404 1.921491 0.001403 1.218330 0.001401 1.394638 0.001399 1.181827 0.001397 0.000000 0.001395 0.000000 0.001393 0.000000 0.001391 0.000000 0.001389 0.000000 0.001387 0.000000 0.001385 0.000000 0.001383 -0.000000 0.001381 0.000000 0.001379 -0.000000 33: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.016463 0.016485 0.016508 0.016531 0.016553 0.016576 0.016599 0.016621 0.016644 0.016667 0.016689 0.016712 0.016735 0.016757 0.016780 0.016803 0.016825 0.016848 0.016871 0.016893 0.016916 0.016939 0.016961 0.016984 0.017007 0.017029 0.017052 0.017075 0.017098 0.017120 0.017143 0.017166 0.017188 0.017211 0.017234 0.017256 0.017279 0.017302 0.017324 0.017347 0.017370 0.017392 0.017415 0.017438 0.017460 0.017483 0.017506 0.017528 0.017551 0.017574 0.017596 0.017619 0.017642 0.017664 0.017687 0.017710 0.017732 0.017755 0.017778 0.017800 0.017823 0.017846 0.017868 0.017891 0.017914 0.017937 Boulanger

0.001377 0.000000 0.001376 -0.000000 0.001374 0.000000 0.001372 -0.000000 0.001370 0.553173 0.001368 1.575709 0.001366 2.408798 0.001364 2.360337 0.001362 2.376034 0.001361 1.247967 0.001359 0.000000 0.001357 0.528015 0.001355 2.911263 0.001353 2.656713 0.001351 0.394078 0.001350 -0.000000 0.001348 0.000000 0.001346 -0.000000 0.001344 0.000000 0.001342 0.396407 0.001340 1.414532 0.001339 0.681775 0.001337 0.620630 0.001335 0.000000 0.001333 0.000000 0.001332 1.421151 0.001330 3.110968 0.001328 2.851162 0.001326 3.015875 0.001325 3.297527 0.001323 1.795864 0.001321 0.513878 0.001319 1.111261 0.001318 1.303059 0.001316 0.667004 0.001314 1.096223 0.001312 1.932258 0.001311 1.999059 0.001309 2.085066 0.001307 1.070184 0.001305 0.000000 0.001304 -0.000000 0.001302 0.332317 0.001300 0.473074 0.001299 0.000000 0.001297 -0.000000 0.001295 0.000000 0.001294 0.000000 0.001292 0.000000 0.001290 0.000000 0.001289 0.000000 0.001287 -0.000000 0.001285 0.000000 0.001284 -0.000000 0.001282 0.000000 0.001280 -0.000000 0.001279 0.000000 0.001277 0.000000 0.001276 0.000000 0.001274 0.000000 0.001272 0.000000 0.001271 0.000000 0.001269 0.000000 0.001267 0.000000 0.001266 0.000000 0.001264 0.000000 34: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.017959 0.017982 0.018005 0.018027 0.018050 0.018073 0.018095 0.018118 0.018141 0.018163 0.018186 0.018209 0.018231 0.018254 0.018277 0.018299 0.018322 0.018345 0.018367 0.018390 0.018413 0.018435 0.018458 0.018481 0.018503 0.018526 0.018549 0.018571 0.018594 0.018617 0.018639 0.018662 0.018685 0.018707 0.018730 0.018753 0.018776 0.018798 0.018821 0.018844 0.018866 0.018889 0.018912 0.018934 0.018957 0.018980 0.019002 0.019025 0.019048 0.019070 0.019093 0.019116 0.019138 0.019161 0.019184 0.019206 0.019229 0.019252 0.019274 0.019297 0.019320 0.019342 0.019365 0.019388 0.019410 0.019433 Boulanger

0.001263 0.000000 0.001261 0.000000 0.001259 0.000000 0.001258 0.000000 0.001256 0.000000 0.001255 0.000000 0.001253 0.000000 0.001252 0.000000 0.001250 0.000000 0.001248 0.000000 0.001247 0.000000 0.001245 0.000000 0.001244 0.000000 0.001242 0.000000 0.001241 0.000000 0.001239 0.000000 0.001238 0.000000 0.001236 0.000000 0.001235 0.000000 0.001233 0.000000 0.001232 0.000000 0.001230 0.000000 0.001229 0.000000 0.001227 0.000000 0.001225 0.000000 0.001224 0.000000 0.001222 0.000000 0.001221 0.000000 0.001220 0.000000 0.001218 0.000000 0.001217 0.000000 0.001215 0.000000 0.001214 0.000000 0.001212 0.000000 0.001211 0.000000 0.001209 -0.000000 0.001208 0.000000 0.001206 0.000000 0.001205 0.000000 0.001203 0.000000 0.001202 0.000000 0.001200 0.000000 0.001199 0.000000 0.001198 0.000000 0.001196 0.000000 0.001195 -0.000000 0.001193 0.000000 0.001192 -0.000000 0.001190 0.000000 0.001189 -0.000000 0.001188 0.000000 0.001186 0.000000 0.001185 0.000000 0.001183 0.000000 0.001182 0.000000 0.001181 0.000000 0.001179 0.000000 0.001178 0.000000 0.001176 0.000000 0.001175 0.000000 0.001174 0.000000 0.001172 0.000000 0.001171 0.000000 0.001170 0.000000 0.001168 0.000000 0.001167 0.000000 35: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.019456 0.019478 0.019501 0.019524 0.019546 0.019569 0.019592 0.019615 0.019637 0.019660 0.019683 0.019705 0.019728 0.019751 0.019773 0.019796 0.019819 0.019841 0.019864 0.019887 0.019909 0.019932 0.019955 0.019977 0.020000 0.020023 0.020045 0.020068 0.020091 0.020113 0.020136 0.020159 0.020181 0.020204 0.020227 0.020249 0.020272 0.020295 0.020317 0.020340 0.020363 0.020385 0.020408 0.020431 0.020454 0.020476 0.020499 0.020522 0.020544 0.020567 0.020590 0.020612 0.020635 0.020658 0.020680 0.020703 0.020726 0.020748 0.020771 0.020794 0.020816 0.020839 0.020862 0.020884 0.020907 0.020930 Boulanger

0.001166 0.000000 0.001164 0.000000 0.001163 0.000000 0.001161 0.000000 0.001160 0.000000 0.001159 0.000000 0.001157 0.000000 0.001156 0.000000 0.001155 0.000000 0.001153 0.000000 0.001152 0.000000 0.001151 -0.000000 0.001149 0.000000 0.001148 -0.000000 0.001147 0.000000 0.001145 -0.000000 0.001144 0.000000 0.001143 -0.000000 0.001142 0.000000 0.001140 -0.000000 0.001139 0.000000 0.001138 0.000000 0.001136 0.000000 0.001135 0.000000 0.001134 0.000000 0.001133 0.000000 0.001131 0.760966 0.001130 0.401430 0.001129 0.171665 0.001127 -0.000000 0.001126 0.275582 0.001125 1.217449 0.001124 1.233897 0.001122 0.502745 0.001121 0.265510 0.001120 0.800075 0.001119 1.024715 0.001117 0.690821 0.001116 1.016031 0.001115 1.421884 0.001114 0.584732 0.001112 -0.000000 0.001111 0.257285 0.001110 0.991919 0.001109 0.297135 0.001107 -0.000000 0.001106 0.000000 0.001105 0.023706 0.001104 0.689815 0.001103 0.881162 0.001101 0.000000 0.001100 0.125918 0.001099 1.572866 0.001098 1.180145 0.001096 0.000000 0.001095 -0.000000 0.001094 0.478009 0.001093 1.104993 0.001092 0.616622 0.001091 -0.000000 0.001089 0.000000 0.001088 -0.000000 0.001087 0.000000 0.001086 -0.000000 0.001085 0.000000 0.001083 -0.000000 36: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.020952 0.020975 0.020998 0.021020 0.021043 0.021066 0.021088 0.021111 0.021134 0.021156 0.021179 0.021202 0.021224 0.021247 0.021270 0.021293 0.021315 0.021338 0.021361 0.021383 0.021406 0.021429 0.021451 0.021474 0.021497 0.021519 0.021542 0.021565 0.021587 0.021610 0.021633 0.021655 0.021678 0.021701 0.021723 0.021746 0.021769 0.021791 0.021814 0.021837 0.021859 0.021882 0.021905 0.021927 0.021950 0.021973 0.021995 0.022018 0.022041 0.022063 0.022086 0.022109 0.022132 0.022154 0.022177 0.022200 0.022222 0.022245 0.022268 0.022290 0.022313 0.022336 0.022358 0.022381 0.022404 0.022426 Boulanger

0.001082 0.000000 0.001081 -0.000000 0.001080 0.000000 0.001079 0.670733 0.001078 0.957052 0.001076 -0.000000 0.001075 0.207806 0.001074 1.231452 0.001073 0.891344 0.001072 0.042181 0.001071 0.368850 0.001070 0.589769 0.001068 0.000000 0.001067 -0.000000 0.001066 0.000000 0.001065 -0.000000 0.001064 0.194579 0.001063 0.577821 0.001062 0.627626 0.001060 0.913529 0.001059 0.800466 0.001058 -0.000000 0.001057 0.200410 0.001056 1.077616 0.001055 0.879951 0.001054 0.624668 0.001053 1.003232 0.001052 1.434390 0.001050 1.194049 0.001049 0.627762 0.001048 0.000000 0.001047 -0.000000 0.001046 0.000000 0.001045 0.027955 0.001044 0.000000 0.001043 -0.000000 0.001042 0.000000 0.001041 -0.000000 0.001040 0.000000 0.001038 -0.000000 0.001037 0.000000 0.001036 0.427477 0.001035 0.329204 0.001034 0.139784 0.001033 0.366731 0.001032 0.387541 0.001031 0.319853 0.001030 0.865504 0.001029 1.142160 0.001028 1.831300 0.001027 2.265506 0.001026 1.520689 0.001025 1.556800 0.001024 1.242693 0.001022 0.000000 0.001021 -0.000000 0.001020 0.000000 0.001019 -0.000000 0.001018 0.000000 0.001017 -0.000000 0.001016 0.823129 0.001015 1.259904 0.001014 1.456160 0.001013 1.302391 0.001012 1.545004 0.001011 1.260239 37: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.022449 0.022472 0.022494 0.022517 0.022540 0.022562 0.022585 0.022608 0.022630 0.022653 0.022676 0.022698 0.022721 0.022744 0.022766 0.022789 0.022812 0.022834 0.022857 0.022880 0.022902 0.022925 0.022948 0.022971 0.022993 0.023016 0.023039 0.023061 0.023084 0.023107 0.023129 0.023152 0.023175 0.023197

0.001010 0.001009 0.001008 0.001007 0.001006 0.001005 0.001004 0.001003 0.001002 0.001001 0.001000 0.000999 0.000998 0.000997 0.000996 0.000995 0.000994 0.000993 0.000992 0.000991 0.000990 0.000989 0.000988 0.000987 0.000986 0.000985 0.000984 0.000983 0.000982 0.000981 0.000980 0.000979 0.000978 0.000978

0.009849 -0.000000 0.115056 0.270359 0.000000 -0.000000 0.000000 -0.000000 0.000000 0.086462 0.000000 -0.000000 0.000000 -0.000000 0.000000 -0.000000 0.114648 0.426149 0.210781 -0.000000 0.019569 0.781381 1.247215 0.943327 0.784468 0.320760 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 -0.000000 0.000000 -0.000000

Fig27. Audacity Enhanced Correlation Frequency Analysis DATA 1-bar Loop (Aparthenonia) Lag (seconds) 0.000023 0.000045 0.000068 0.000091 0.000113 0.000136 0.000159 0.000181 0.000204 0.000227 0.000249 0.000272 0.000295 0.000317 0.000340 0.000363 0.000385 0.000408 0.000431 0.000454 0.000476 0.000499 0.000522 0.000544 0.000567 0.000590 0.000612 0.000635 Boulanger 38: Frequency (Hz) Level 1.000000 0.000000 0.500000 0.000000 0.333333 0.000000 0.250000 0.000000 0.200000 0.000000 0.166667 0.000000 0.142857 0.000000 0.125000 0.000000 0.111111 18.669552 0.100000 49.882973 0.090909 62.977875 0.083333 69.884865 0.076923 58.590759 0.071429 51.701046 0.066667 43.640594 0.062500 33.619461 0.058824 25.040897 0.055556 10.577820 0.052632 0.000000 0.050000 0.000000 0.047619 0.000000 0.045455 0.000000 0.043478 0.000000 0.041667 0.000000 0.040000 0.000000 0.038462 0.000000 0.037037 0.000000 0.035714 0.000000 "Var gas v. Pfi z er , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o . 04- CV-9772 ( W HP) - Ex per t o p i n i o n a n d F F T A na l ysi s"

0.000658 0.000680 0.000703 0.000726 0.000748 0.000771 0.000794 0.000816 0.000839 0.000862 0.000884 0.000907 0.000930 0.000952 0.000975 0.000998 0.001020 0.001043 0.001066 0.001088 0.001111 0.001134 0.001156 0.001179 0.001202 0.001224 0.001247 0.001270 0.001293 0.001315 0.001338 0.001361 0.001383 0.001406 0.001429 0.001451 0.001474 0.001497 0.001519 0.001542 0.001565 0.001587 0.001610 0.001633 0.001655 0.001678 0.001701 0.001723 0.001746 0.001769 0.001791 0.001814 0.001837 0.001859 0.001882 0.001905 0.001927 0.001950 0.001973 0.001995 0.002018 0.002041 0.002063 0.002086 0.002109 0.002132 Boulanger

0.034483 0.000000 0.033333 0.000000 0.032258 0.000000 0.031250 0.000000 0.030303 0.000000 0.029412 0.000000 0.028571 0.000000 0.027778 0.000000 0.027027 0.000000 0.026316 0.000000 0.025641 0.000000 0.025000 0.000000 0.024390 0.000000 0.023810 0.000000 0.023256 0.000000 0.022727 0.000000 0.022222 0.000000 0.021739 0.000000 0.021277 0.000000 0.020833 0.000000 0.020408 0.000000 0.020000 0.000000 0.019608 0.000000 0.019231 0.000000 0.018868 0.000000 0.018519 0.000000 0.018182 0.000000 0.017857 0.000000 0.017544 0.000000 0.017241 0.000000 0.016949 0.000000 0.016667 0.000000 0.016393 0.000000 0.016129 0.000000 0.015873 0.000000 0.015625 0.000000 0.015385 0.000000 0.015152 0.000000 0.014925 0.000000 0.014706 0.000000 0.014493 0.000000 0.014286 0.000000 0.014085 0.000000 0.013889 0.000000 0.013699 0.000000 0.013514 0.000000 0.013333 0.000000 0.013158 0.000000 0.012987 0.000000 0.012821 0.000000 0.012658 0.000000 0.012500 0.000000 0.012346 0.000000 0.012195 0.000000 0.012048 0.000000 0.011905 0.000000 0.011765 0.000000 0.011628 0.000000 0.011494 0.000000 0.011364 0.000000 0.011236 0.000000 0.011111 0.000000 0.010989 0.000000 0.010870 0.000000 0.010753 0.000000 0.010638 0.000000 39: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.002154 0.002177 0.002200 0.002222 0.002245 0.002268 0.002290 0.002313 0.002336 0.002358 0.002381 0.002404 0.002426 0.002449 0.002472 0.002494 0.002517 0.002540 0.002562 0.002585 0.002608 0.002630 0.002653 0.002676 0.002698 0.002721 0.002744 0.002766 0.002789 0.002812 0.002834 0.002857 0.002880 0.002902 0.002925 0.002948 0.002971 0.002993 0.003016 0.003039 0.003061 0.003084 0.003107 0.003129 0.003152 0.003175 0.003197 0.003220 0.003243 0.003265 0.003288 0.003311 0.003333 0.003356 0.003379 0.003401 0.003424 0.003447 0.003469 0.003492 0.003515 0.003537 0.003560 0.003583 0.003605 0.003628 Boulanger

0.010526 0.000000 0.010417 0.000000 0.010309 0.000000 0.010204 0.000000 0.010101 0.000000 0.010000 0.000000 0.009901 0.000000 0.009804 0.000000 0.009709 0.000000 0.009615 0.000000 0.009524 0.000000 0.009434 0.000000 0.009346 0.000000 0.009259 0.000000 0.009174 0.000000 0.009091 0.000000 0.009009 0.000000 0.008929 0.000000 0.008850 0.000000 0.008772 0.000000 0.008696 0.000000 0.008621 0.000000 0.008547 0.000000 0.008475 0.000000 0.008403 0.000000 0.008333 0.000000 0.008264 0.000000 0.008197 0.000000 0.008130 0.000000 0.008065 0.000000 0.008000 0.000000 0.007937 0.000000 0.007874 0.000000 0.007812 0.000000 0.007752 0.000000 0.007692 0.000000 0.007634 0.000000 0.007576 0.000000 0.007519 0.000000 0.007463 0.000000 0.007407 0.000000 0.007353 0.000000 0.007299 0.000000 0.007246 0.000000 0.007194 0.000000 0.007143 0.000000 0.007092 -0.000000 0.007042 0.000000 0.006993 -0.000000 0.006944 0.000000 0.006897 -0.000000 0.006849 0.000000 0.006803 -0.000000 0.006757 0.000000 0.006711 -0.000000 0.006667 0.000000 0.006623 -0.000000 0.006579 0.000000 0.006536 -0.000000 0.006494 0.000000 0.006452 -0.000000 0.006410 0.000000 0.006369 -0.000000 0.006329 0.000000 0.006289 -0.000000 0.006250 0.000000 40: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.003651 0.003673 0.003696 0.003719 0.003741 0.003764 0.003787 0.003810 0.003832 0.003855 0.003878 0.003900 0.003923 0.003946 0.003968 0.003991 0.004014 0.004036 0.004059 0.004082 0.004104 0.004127 0.004150 0.004172 0.004195 0.004218 0.004240 0.004263 0.004286 0.004308 0.004331 0.004354 0.004376 0.004399 0.004422 0.004444 0.004467 0.004490 0.004512 0.004535 0.004558 0.004580 0.004603 0.004626 0.004649 0.004671 0.004694 0.004717 0.004739 0.004762 0.004785 0.004807 0.004830 0.004853 0.004875 0.004898 0.004921 0.004943 0.004966 0.004989 0.005011 0.005034 0.005057 0.005079 0.005102 0.005125 Boulanger

0.006211 -0.000000 0.006173 0.000000 0.006135 -0.000000 0.006098 0.000000 0.006061 -0.000000 0.006024 0.000000 0.005988 -0.000000 0.005952 0.000000 0.005917 -0.000000 0.005882 0.000000 0.005848 -0.000000 0.005814 0.000000 0.005780 -0.000000 0.005747 0.000000 0.005714 -0.000000 0.005682 0.000000 0.005650 -0.000000 0.005618 0.000000 0.005587 -0.000000 0.005556 0.000000 0.005525 -0.000000 0.005495 0.000000 0.005464 -0.000000 0.005435 0.000000 0.005405 -0.000000 0.005376 0.000000 0.005348 -0.000000 0.005319 0.000000 0.005291 -0.000000 0.005263 0.000000 0.005236 -0.000000 0.005208 0.000000 0.005181 -0.000000 0.005155 0.000000 0.005128 -0.000000 0.005102 0.000000 0.005076 -0.000000 0.005051 0.000000 0.005025 -0.000000 0.005000 0.000000 0.004975 -0.000000 0.004950 0.000000 0.004926 -0.000000 0.004902 0.000000 0.004878 -0.000000 0.004854 0.000000 0.004831 -0.000000 0.004808 0.000000 0.004785 -0.000000 0.004762 0.000000 0.004739 -0.000000 0.004717 0.000000 0.004695 -0.000000 0.004673 0.000000 0.004651 -0.000000 0.004630 0.000000 0.004608 -0.000000 0.004587 0.000000 0.004566 -0.000000 0.004545 0.000000 0.004525 -0.000000 0.004505 0.000000 0.004484 -0.000000 0.004464 0.000000 0.004444 -0.000000 0.004425 0.000000 41: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.005147 0.005170 0.005193 0.005215 0.005238 0.005261 0.005283 0.005306 0.005329 0.005351 0.005374 0.005397 0.005420 0.005442 0.005465 0.005488 0.005510 0.005533 0.005556 0.005578 0.005601 0.005624 0.005646 0.005669 0.005692 0.005714 0.005737 0.005760 0.005782 0.005805 0.005828 0.005850 0.005873 0.005896 0.005918 0.005941 0.005964 0.005986 0.006009 0.006032 0.006054 0.006077 0.006100 0.006122 0.006145 0.006168 0.006190 0.006213 0.006236 0.006259 0.006281 0.006304 0.006327 0.006349 0.006372 0.006395 0.006417 0.006440 0.006463 0.006485 0.006508 0.006531 0.006553 0.006576 0.006599 0.006621 Boulanger

0.004405 -0.000000 0.004386 0.000000 0.004367 -0.000000 0.004348 0.000000 0.004329 -0.000000 0.004310 0.000000 0.004292 -0.000000 0.004274 0.000000 0.004255 -0.000000 0.004237 0.000000 0.004219 -0.000000 0.004202 0.000000 0.004184 -0.000000 0.004167 0.000000 0.004149 -0.000000 0.004132 0.000000 0.004115 -0.000000 0.004098 0.000000 0.004082 -0.000000 0.004065 0.000000 0.004049 -0.000000 0.004032 0.000000 0.004016 -0.000000 0.004000 0.000000 0.003984 -0.000000 0.003968 0.000000 0.003953 -0.000000 0.003937 0.000000 0.003922 -0.000000 0.003906 0.000000 0.003891 -0.000000 0.003876 0.000000 0.003861 -0.000000 0.003846 0.000000 0.003831 -0.000000 0.003817 0.000000 0.003802 -0.000000 0.003788 0.000000 0.003774 -0.000000 0.003759 0.000000 0.003745 -0.000000 0.003731 0.000000 0.003717 -0.000000 0.003704 0.000000 0.003690 -0.000000 0.003676 0.000000 0.003663 -0.000000 0.003650 0.000000 0.003636 -0.000000 0.003623 0.000000 0.003610 -0.000000 0.003597 0.000000 0.003584 -0.000000 0.003571 0.000000 0.003559 -0.000000 0.003546 0.000000 0.003534 -0.000000 0.003521 0.000000 0.003509 -0.000000 0.003497 0.000000 0.003484 -0.000000 0.003472 0.000000 0.003460 -0.000000 0.003448 0.000000 0.003436 -0.000000 0.003425 0.000000 42: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.006644 0.006667 0.006689 0.006712 0.006735 0.006757 0.006780 0.006803 0.006825 0.006848 0.006871 0.006893 0.006916 0.006939 0.006961 0.006984 0.007007 0.007029 0.007052 0.007075 0.007098 0.007120 0.007143 0.007166 0.007188 0.007211 0.007234 0.007256 0.007279 0.007302 0.007324 0.007347 0.007370 0.007392 0.007415 0.007438 0.007460 0.007483 0.007506 0.007528 0.007551 0.007574 0.007596 0.007619 0.007642 0.007664 0.007687 0.007710 0.007732 0.007755 0.007778 0.007800 0.007823 0.007846 0.007868 0.007891 0.007914 0.007937 0.007959 0.007982 0.008005 0.008027 0.008050 0.008073 0.008095 0.008118 Boulanger

0.003413 -0.000000 0.003401 0.000000 0.003390 -0.000000 0.003378 0.000000 0.003367 -0.000000 0.003356 0.000000 0.003344 -0.000000 0.003333 0.000000 0.003322 -0.000000 0.003311 0.000000 0.003300 -0.000000 0.003289 0.000000 0.003279 -0.000000 0.003268 0.000000 0.003257 -0.000000 0.003247 0.000000 0.003236 -0.000000 0.003226 0.000000 0.003215 -0.000000 0.003205 0.000000 0.003195 -0.000000 0.003185 0.000000 0.003175 -0.000000 0.003165 0.000000 0.003155 -0.000000 0.003145 0.000000 0.003135 -0.000000 0.003125 0.000000 0.003115 -0.000000 0.003106 0.000000 0.003096 -0.000000 0.003086 0.000000 0.003077 -0.000000 0.003067 0.000000 0.003058 -0.000000 0.003049 0.000000 0.003040 -0.000000 0.003030 0.000000 0.003021 -0.000000 0.003012 0.000000 0.003003 -0.000000 0.002994 0.000000 0.002985 -0.000000 0.002976 0.000000 0.002967 -0.000000 0.002959 0.000000 0.002950 -0.000000 0.002941 0.000000 0.002933 -0.000000 0.002924 0.000000 0.002915 -0.000000 0.002907 0.000000 0.002899 -0.000000 0.002890 0.000000 0.002882 -0.000000 0.002874 0.000000 0.002865 -0.000000 0.002857 0.000000 0.002849 -0.000000 0.002841 0.000000 0.002833 -0.000000 0.002825 0.000000 0.002817 -0.000000 0.002809 0.000000 0.002801 -0.000000 0.002793 0.000000 43: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.008141 0.008163 0.008186 0.008209 0.008231 0.008254 0.008277 0.008299 0.008322 0.008345 0.008367 0.008390 0.008413 0.008435 0.008458 0.008481 0.008503 0.008526 0.008549 0.008571 0.008594 0.008617 0.008639 0.008662 0.008685 0.008707 0.008730 0.008753 0.008776 0.008798 0.008821 0.008844 0.008866 0.008889 0.008912 0.008934 0.008957 0.008980 0.009002 0.009025 0.009048 0.009070 0.009093 0.009116 0.009138 0.009161 0.009184 0.009206 0.009229 0.009252 0.009274 0.009297 0.009320 0.009342 0.009365 0.009388 0.009410 0.009433 0.009456 0.009478 0.009501 0.009524 0.009546 0.009569 0.009592 0.009615 Boulanger

0.002786 -0.000000 0.002778 0.000000 0.002770 -0.000000 0.002762 0.000000 0.002755 -0.000000 0.002747 0.000000 0.002740 -0.000000 0.002732 0.000000 0.002725 -0.000000 0.002717 0.000000 0.002710 -0.000000 0.002703 0.000000 0.002695 -0.000000 0.002688 0.000000 0.002681 -0.000000 0.002674 0.000000 0.002667 -0.000000 0.002660 0.000000 0.002653 -0.000000 0.002646 0.000000 0.002639 -0.000000 0.002632 0.000000 0.002625 -0.000000 0.002618 0.000000 0.002611 -0.000000 0.002604 0.000000 0.002597 -0.000000 0.002591 0.000000 0.002584 -0.000000 0.002577 0.000000 0.002571 -0.000000 0.002564 0.000000 0.002558 -0.000000 0.002551 0.000000 0.002545 -0.000000 0.002538 0.000000 0.002532 -0.000000 0.002525 0.000000 0.002519 -0.000000 0.002513 0.000000 0.002506 -0.000000 0.002500 0.000000 0.002494 -0.000000 0.002488 0.000000 0.002481 -0.000000 0.002475 0.000000 0.002469 -0.000000 0.002463 0.000000 0.002457 -0.000000 0.002451 0.000000 0.002445 -0.000000 0.002439 0.000000 0.002433 -0.000000 0.002427 0.000000 0.002421 -0.000000 0.002415 0.000000 0.002410 -0.000000 0.002404 0.000000 0.002398 -0.000000 0.002392 0.000000 0.002387 -0.000000 0.002381 0.000000 0.002375 -0.000000 0.002370 0.000000 0.002364 -0.000000 0.002358 0.000000 44: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.009637 0.009660 0.009683 0.009705 0.009728 0.009751 0.009773 0.009796 0.009819 0.009841 0.009864 0.009887 0.009909 0.009932 0.009955 0.009977 0.010000 0.010023 0.010045 0.010068 0.010091 0.010113 0.010136 0.010159 0.010181 0.010204 0.010227 0.010249 0.010272 0.010295 0.010317 0.010340 0.010363 0.010385 0.010408 0.010431 0.010454 0.010476 0.010499 0.010522 0.010544 0.010567 0.010590 0.010612 0.010635 0.010658 0.010680 0.010703 0.010726 0.010748 0.010771 0.010794 0.010816 0.010839 0.010862 0.010884 0.010907 0.010930 0.010952 0.010975 0.010998 0.011020 0.011043 0.011066 0.011088 0.011111 Boulanger

0.002353 -0.000000 0.002347 0.000000 0.002342 -0.000000 0.002336 0.000000 0.002331 -0.000000 0.002326 0.000000 0.002320 -0.000000 0.002315 0.000000 0.002309 -0.000000 0.002304 0.000000 0.002299 -0.000000 0.002294 0.000000 0.002288 -0.000000 0.002283 0.000000 0.002278 -0.000000 0.002273 0.000000 0.002268 -0.000000 0.002262 0.000000 0.002257 -0.000000 0.002252 0.000000 0.002247 -0.000000 0.002242 0.000000 0.002237 -0.000000 0.002232 0.000000 0.002227 -0.000000 0.002222 0.000000 0.002217 -0.000000 0.002212 0.000000 0.002208 -0.000000 0.002203 0.000000 0.002198 -0.000000 0.002193 0.000000 0.002188 -0.000000 0.002183 0.000000 0.002179 -0.000000 0.002174 0.000000 0.002169 -0.000000 0.002165 0.000000 0.002160 -0.000000 0.002155 0.000000 0.002151 -0.000000 0.002146 0.000000 0.002141 -0.000000 0.002137 0.000000 0.002132 -0.000000 0.002128 0.000000 0.002123 -0.000000 0.002119 0.000000 0.002114 -0.000000 0.002110 0.000000 0.002105 -0.000000 0.002101 0.000000 0.002096 -0.000000 0.002092 0.000000 0.002088 -0.000000 0.002083 0.000000 0.002079 -0.000000 0.002075 0.000000 0.002070 -0.000000 0.002066 0.000000 0.002062 -0.000000 0.002058 0.000000 0.002053 -0.000000 0.002049 0.000000 0.002045 -0.000000 0.002041 0.000000 45: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.011134 0.011156 0.011179 0.011202 0.011224 0.011247 0.011270 0.011293 0.011315 0.011338 0.011361 0.011383 0.011406 0.011429 0.011451 0.011474 0.011497 0.011519 0.011542 0.011565 0.011587 0.011610 0.011633 0.011655 0.011678 0.011701 0.011723 0.011746 0.011769 0.011791 0.011814 0.011837 0.011859 0.011882 0.011905 0.011927 0.011950 0.011973 0.011995 0.012018 0.012041 0.012063 0.012086 0.012109 0.012132 0.012154 0.012177 0.012200 0.012222 0.012245 0.012268 0.012290 0.012313 0.012336 0.012358 0.012381 0.012404 0.012426 0.012449 0.012472 0.012494 0.012517 0.012540 0.012562 0.012585 0.012608 Boulanger

0.002037 -0.000000 0.002033 0.000000 0.002028 -0.000000 0.002024 0.000000 0.002020 -0.000000 0.002016 0.000000 0.002012 -0.000000 0.002008 0.000000 0.002004 -0.000000 0.002000 0.000000 0.001996 -0.000000 0.001992 0.000000 0.001988 -0.000000 0.001984 0.000000 0.001980 -0.000000 0.001976 0.000000 0.001972 -0.000000 0.001969 0.000000 0.001965 -0.000000 0.001961 0.000000 0.001957 -0.000000 0.001953 0.000000 0.001949 -0.000000 0.001946 0.000000 0.001942 -0.000000 0.001938 0.000000 0.001934 -0.000000 0.001931 0.000000 0.001927 0.808258 0.001923 0.641052 0.001919 0.892074 0.001916 0.843530 0.001912 0.589923 0.001908 1.221856 0.001905 1.812258 0.001901 2.073065 0.001898 1.794521 0.001894 0.163437 0.001890 -0.000000 0.001887 0.000000 0.001883 -0.000000 0.001880 0.000000 0.001876 -0.000000 0.001873 0.000000 0.001869 0.818218 0.001866 1.101695 0.001862 1.196628 0.001859 1.232234 0.001855 0.712272 0.001852 0.453743 0.001848 0.694763 0.001845 0.668010 0.001842 1.090125 0.001838 1.728920 0.001835 1.970919 0.001832 2.547507 0.001828 3.284037 0.001825 3.554055 0.001821 3.288257 0.001818 2.104790 0.001815 0.905991 0.001812 0.921656 0.001808 1.113813 0.001805 1.346493 0.001802 2.479781 0.001799 3.920736 46: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.012630 0.012653 0.012676 0.012698 0.012721 0.012744 0.012766 0.012789 0.012812 0.012834 0.012857 0.012880 0.012902 0.012925 0.012948 0.012971 0.012993 0.013016 0.013039 0.013061 0.013084 0.013107 0.013129 0.013152 0.013175 0.013197 0.013220 0.013243 0.013265 0.013288 0.013311 0.013333 0.013356 0.013379 0.013401 0.013424 0.013447 0.013469 0.013492 0.013515 0.013537 0.013560 0.013583 0.013605 0.013628 0.013651 0.013673 0.013696 0.013719 0.013741 0.013764 0.013787 0.013810 0.013832 0.013855 0.013878 0.013900 0.013923 0.013946 0.013968 0.013991 0.014014 0.014036 0.014059 0.014082 0.014104 Boulanger

0.001795 4.347955 0.001792 4.023615 0.001789 3.671635 0.001786 3.517332 0.001783 2.688346 0.001779 2.186292 0.001776 2.877953 0.001773 2.996251 0.001770 2.103060 0.001767 1.160695 0.001764 0.499367 0.001761 0.983003 0.001757 2.233394 0.001754 2.969776 0.001751 3.546423 0.001748 3.884597 0.001745 3.748905 0.001742 3.979084 0.001739 3.627683 0.001736 2.714820 0.001733 2.546650 0.001730 2.532441 0.001727 1.813203 0.001724 1.321680 0.001721 1.647390 0.001718 2.777740 0.001715 3.624499 0.001712 3.254443 0.001709 2.728869 0.001706 2.261204 0.001704 1.098860 0.001701 0.561560 0.001698 0.942437 0.001695 1.284463 0.001692 1.317001 0.001689 0.763905 0.001686 0.039849 0.001684 0.213438 0.001681 0.512577 0.001678 0.084196 0.001675 -0.000000 0.001672 0.756541 0.001669 1.570849 0.001667 1.034311 0.001664 0.166570 0.001661 0.422000 0.001658 0.478493 0.001656 0.196840 0.001653 0.905499 0.001650 1.644683 0.001647 2.048052 0.001645 2.208261 0.001642 2.126045 0.001639 2.679866 0.001637 3.443489 0.001634 3.578214 0.001631 3.534057 0.001629 3.165654 0.001626 2.384752 0.001623 2.491642 0.001621 2.589838 0.001618 2.275225 0.001616 2.441985 0.001613 2.196888 0.001610 1.586583 0.001608 2.125755 47: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.014127 0.014150 0.014172 0.014195 0.014218 0.014240 0.014263 0.014286 0.014308 0.014331 0.014354 0.014376 0.014399 0.014422 0.014444 0.014467 0.014490 0.014512 0.014535 0.014558 0.014580 0.014603 0.014626 0.014649 0.014671 0.014694 0.014717 0.014739 0.014762 0.014785 0.014807 0.014830 0.014853 0.014875 0.014898 0.014921 0.014943 0.014966 0.014989 0.015011 0.015034 0.015057 0.015079 0.015102 0.015125 0.015147 0.015170 0.015193 0.015215 0.015238 0.015261 0.015283 0.015306 0.015329 0.015351 0.015374 0.015397 0.015420 0.015442 0.015465 0.015488 0.015510 0.015533 0.015556 0.015578 0.015601 Boulanger

0.001605 2.935488 0.001603 3.047837 0.001600 2.773730 0.001597 2.255352 0.001595 2.017529 0.001592 2.095798 0.001590 1.960902 0.001587 2.189210 0.001585 2.431791 0.001582 2.658551 0.001580 3.874837 0.001577 5.247653 0.001575 5.339801 0.001572 5.091010 0.001570 4.866868 0.001567 4.730077 0.001565 4.290058 0.001563 3.744851 0.001560 3.781959 0.001558 4.053973 0.001555 3.532215 0.001553 3.325413 0.001550 3.787084 0.001548 4.419772 0.001546 5.202283 0.001543 5.391574 0.001541 4.839568 0.001538 4.589694 0.001536 4.094831 0.001534 3.645138 0.001531 3.962634 0.001529 3.992508 0.001527 3.289826 0.001524 2.622720 0.001522 2.549607 0.001520 3.114512 0.001517 3.766804 0.001515 4.219452 0.001513 4.830597 0.001511 5.485577 0.001508 5.632105 0.001506 5.611520 0.001504 4.957497 0.001502 4.080578 0.001499 3.738961 0.001497 3.660589 0.001495 3.687729 0.001493 4.012693 0.001490 3.976528 0.001488 3.466408 0.001486 3.192668 0.001484 3.483256 0.001481 3.482003 0.001479 3.122925 0.001477 3.307907 0.001475 3.678283 0.001473 3.490303 0.001471 3.517976 0.001468 3.459229 0.001466 2.501504 0.001464 1.589100 0.001462 1.268119 0.001460 1.198435 0.001458 1.912790 0.001456 2.571959 0.001453 2.365465 48: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.015624 0.015646 0.015669 0.015692 0.015714 0.015737 0.015760 0.015782 0.015805 0.015828 0.015850 0.015873 0.015896 0.015918 0.015941 0.015964 0.015986 0.016009 0.016032 0.016054 0.016077 0.016100 0.016122 0.016145 0.016168 0.016190 0.016213 0.016236 0.016259 0.016281 0.016304 0.016327 0.016349 0.016372 0.016395 0.016417 0.016440 0.016463 0.016485 0.016508 0.016531 0.016553 0.016576 0.016599 0.016621 0.016644 0.016667 0.016689 0.016712 0.016735 0.016757 0.016780 0.016803 0.016825 0.016848 0.016871 0.016893 0.016916 0.016939 0.016961 0.016984 0.017007 0.017029 0.017052 0.017075 0.017098 Boulanger

0.001451 1.859181 0.001449 1.675969 0.001447 1.911246 0.001445 2.490105 0.001443 2.399604 0.001441 1.935895 0.001439 1.641896 0.001437 1.234890 0.001435 1.096938 0.001433 1.727972 0.001431 1.966495 0.001429 1.695510 0.001427 1.538760 0.001425 1.615469 0.001422 1.589440 0.001420 1.103308 0.001418 0.429720 0.001416 0.000000 0.001414 -0.000000 0.001412 0.076131 0.001410 1.226439 0.001408 1.678581 0.001406 1.894006 0.001404 2.155167 0.001403 1.655574 0.001401 1.063557 0.001399 0.940283 0.001397 0.892614 0.001395 0.936819 0.001393 0.545576 0.001391 -0.000000 0.001389 0.406217 0.001387 1.123076 0.001385 0.837564 0.001383 0.435499 0.001381 0.246314 0.001379 0.118038 0.001377 0.338763 0.001376 0.529351 0.001374 0.794399 0.001372 1.654784 0.001370 2.405742 0.001368 1.871537 0.001366 0.867389 0.001364 0.754460 0.001362 1.446466 0.001361 1.685025 0.001359 1.797152 0.001357 2.423989 0.001355 3.046635 0.001353 3.150455 0.001351 2.919232 0.001350 2.608751 0.001348 2.323983 0.001346 1.684370 0.001344 1.122727 0.001342 1.132645 0.001340 1.045161 0.001339 0.524435 0.001337 0.636367 0.001335 1.073568 0.001333 1.488142 0.001332 1.923570 0.001330 2.200573 0.001328 2.569500 0.001326 3.227269 49: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.017120 0.017143 0.017166 0.017188 0.017211 0.017234 0.017256 0.017279 0.017302 0.017324 0.017347 0.017370 0.017392 0.017415 0.017438 0.017460 0.017483 0.017506 0.017528 0.017551 0.017574 0.017596 0.017619 0.017642 0.017664 0.017687 0.017710 0.017732 0.017755 0.017778 0.017800 0.017823 0.017846 0.017868 0.017891 0.017914 0.017937 0.017959 0.017982 0.018005 0.018027 0.018050 0.018073 0.018095 0.018118 0.018141 0.018163 0.018186 0.018209 0.018231 0.018254 0.018277 0.018299 0.018322 0.018345 0.018367 0.018390 0.018413 0.018435 0.018458 0.018481 0.018503 0.018526 0.018549 0.018571 0.018594 Boulanger

0.001325 3.167816 0.001323 2.781547 0.001321 2.726778 0.001319 2.699819 0.001318 2.176764 0.001316 1.349809 0.001314 0.842351 0.001312 1.044726 0.001311 1.466872 0.001309 1.626019 0.001307 1.176054 0.001305 0.617188 0.001304 0.675509 0.001302 1.274149 0.001300 1.338144 0.001299 0.939047 0.001297 0.558172 0.001295 0.356975 0.001294 0.462404 0.001292 0.649068 0.001290 0.424842 0.001289 0.074442 0.001287 -0.000000 0.001285 0.000000 0.001284 -0.000000 0.001282 0.000000 0.001280 -0.000000 0.001279 0.000000 0.001277 -0.000000 0.001276 0.000000 0.001274 -0.000000 0.001272 0.000000 0.001271 0.000803 0.001269 0.000000 0.001267 -0.000000 0.001266 0.000000 0.001264 -0.000000 0.001263 0.000000 0.001261 -0.000000 0.001259 0.000000 0.001258 -0.000000 0.001256 0.000000 0.001255 -0.000000 0.001253 0.000000 0.001252 -0.000000 0.001250 0.000000 0.001248 -0.000000 0.001247 0.000000 0.001245 -0.000000 0.001244 0.000000 0.001242 0.021137 0.001241 0.000000 0.001239 -0.000000 0.001238 0.000000 0.001236 -0.000000 0.001235 0.000000 0.001233 -0.000000 0.001232 0.000000 0.001230 -0.000000 0.001229 0.000000 0.001227 -0.000000 0.001225 0.488376 0.001224 0.602517 0.001222 0.100377 0.001221 -0.000000 0.001220 0.000000 50: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.018617 0.018639 0.018662 0.018685 0.018707 0.018730 0.018753 0.018776 0.018798 0.018821 0.018844 0.018866 0.018889 0.018912 0.018934 0.018957 0.018980 0.019002 0.019025 0.019048 0.019070 0.019093 0.019116 0.019138 0.019161 0.019184 0.019206 0.019229 0.019252 0.019274 0.019297 0.019320 0.019342 0.019365 0.019388 0.019410 0.019433 0.019456 0.019478 0.019501 0.019524 0.019546 0.019569 0.019592 0.019615 0.019637 0.019660 0.019683 0.019705 0.019728 0.019751 0.019773 0.019796 0.019819 0.019841 0.019864 0.019887 0.019909 0.019932 0.019955 0.019977 0.020000 0.020023 0.020045 0.020068 0.020091 Boulanger

0.001218 -0.000000 0.001217 0.000000 0.001215 -0.000000 0.001214 0.000000 0.001212 -0.000000 0.001211 0.000000 0.001209 -0.000000 0.001208 0.000000 0.001206 -0.000000 0.001205 0.016803 0.001203 -0.000000 0.001202 0.000000 0.001200 -0.000000 0.001199 0.000000 0.001198 -0.000000 0.001196 0.000000 0.001195 -0.000000 0.001193 0.000000 0.001192 -0.000000 0.001190 0.000000 0.001189 -0.000000 0.001188 0.000000 0.001186 -0.000000 0.001185 0.000000 0.001183 -0.000000 0.001182 0.000000 0.001181 -0.000000 0.001179 0.000000 0.001178 -0.000000 0.001176 0.000000 0.001175 -0.000000 0.001174 0.000000 0.001172 -0.000000 0.001171 0.000000 0.001170 -0.000000 0.001168 0.000000 0.001167 -0.000000 0.001166 0.000000 0.001164 -0.000000 0.001163 0.000000 0.001161 -0.000000 0.001160 0.000000 0.001159 -0.000000 0.001157 0.000000 0.001156 -0.000000 0.001155 0.000000 0.001153 -0.000000 0.001152 0.000000 0.001151 -0.000000 0.001149 0.000000 0.001148 -0.000000 0.001147 0.000000 0.001145 -0.000000 0.001144 0.000000 0.001143 -0.000000 0.001142 0.000000 0.001140 -0.000000 0.001139 0.000000 0.001138 -0.000000 0.001136 0.000000 0.001135 -0.000000 0.001134 0.000000 0.001133 -0.000000 0.001131 0.000000 0.001130 -0.000000 0.001129 0.000000 51: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.020113 0.020136 0.020159 0.020181 0.020204 0.020227 0.020249 0.020272 0.020295 0.020317 0.020340 0.020363 0.020385 0.020408 0.020431 0.020454 0.020476 0.020499 0.020522 0.020544 0.020567 0.020590 0.020612 0.020635 0.020658 0.020680 0.020703 0.020726 0.020748 0.020771 0.020794 0.020816 0.020839 0.020862 0.020884 0.020907 0.020930 0.020952 0.020975 0.020998 0.021020 0.021043 0.021066 0.021088 0.021111 0.021134 0.021156 0.021179 0.021202 0.021224 0.021247 0.021270 0.021293 0.021315 0.021338 0.021361 0.021383 0.021406 0.021429 0.021451 0.021474 0.021497 0.021519 0.021542 0.021565 0.021587 Boulanger

0.001127 -0.000000 0.001126 0.000000 0.001125 -0.000000 0.001124 0.000000 0.001122 -0.000000 0.001121 0.000000 0.001120 -0.000000 0.001119 0.000000 0.001117 0.139502 0.001116 0.016664 0.001115 -0.000000 0.001114 0.000000 0.001112 -0.000000 0.001111 0.000000 0.001110 -0.000000 0.001109 0.000000 0.001107 -0.000000 0.001106 0.000000 0.001105 -0.000000 0.001104 0.000000 0.001103 -0.000000 0.001101 0.000000 0.001100 -0.000000 0.001099 0.000000 0.001098 -0.000000 0.001096 0.000000 0.001095 -0.000000 0.001094 0.143600 0.001093 0.112649 0.001092 0.000000 0.001091 -0.000000 0.001089 0.000000 0.001088 -0.000000 0.001087 0.000000 0.001086 -0.000000 0.001085 0.000000 0.001083 -0.000000 0.001082 0.000000 0.001081 -0.000000 0.001080 0.000000 0.001079 -0.000000 0.001078 0.000000 0.001076 -0.000000 0.001075 0.000000 0.001074 -0.000000 0.001073 0.000000 0.001072 -0.000000 0.001071 0.000000 0.001070 -0.000000 0.001068 0.000000 0.001067 -0.000000 0.001066 0.000000 0.001065 0.505641 0.001064 0.402523 0.001063 0.130359 0.001062 0.000000 0.001060 -0.000000 0.001059 0.000000 0.001058 -0.000000 0.001057 0.000000 0.001056 -0.000000 0.001055 0.000000 0.001054 -0.000000 0.001053 0.000000 0.001052 -0.000000 0.001050 0.000000 52: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.021610 0.021633 0.021655 0.021678 0.021701 0.021723 0.021746 0.021769 0.021791 0.021814 0.021837 0.021859 0.021882 0.021905 0.021927 0.021950 0.021973 0.021995 0.022018 0.022041 0.022063 0.022086 0.022109 0.022132 0.022154 0.022177 0.022200 0.022222 0.022245 0.022268 0.022290 0.022313 0.022336 0.022358 0.022381 0.022404 0.022426 0.022449 0.022472 0.022494 0.022517 0.022540 0.022562 0.022585 0.022608 0.022630 0.022653 0.022676 0.022698 0.022721 0.022744 0.022766 0.022789 0.022812 0.022834 0.022857 0.022880 0.022902 0.022925 0.022948 0.022971 0.022993 0.023016 0.023039 0.023061 0.023084 Boulanger

0.001049 0.137918 0.001048 0.273002 0.001047 0.046379 0.001046 0.000000 0.001045 -0.000000 0.001044 0.000000 0.001043 -0.000000 0.001042 0.000000 0.001041 -0.000000 0.001040 0.000000 0.001038 -0.000000 0.001037 0.000000 0.001036 0.113582 0.001035 0.275741 0.001034 0.514726 0.001033 0.680490 0.001032 0.751012 0.001031 0.587506 0.001030 0.573894 0.001029 0.574298 0.001028 0.461707 0.001027 0.470955 0.001026 0.586178 0.001025 0.740651 0.001024 0.609034 0.001022 0.166547 0.001021 -0.000000 0.001020 0.183208 0.001019 0.451758 0.001018 0.752521 0.001017 1.040144 0.001016 0.997396 0.001015 0.889589 0.001014 0.988313 0.001013 1.154893 0.001012 1.037488 0.001011 0.403398 0.001010 0.000000 0.001009 -0.000000 0.001008 0.140138 0.001007 0.754326 0.001006 0.803037 0.001005 0.543962 0.001004 0.354530 0.001003 -0.000000 0.001002 0.000000 0.001001 -0.000000 0.001000 0.000000 0.000999 -0.000000 0.000998 0.000000 0.000997 -0.000000 0.000996 0.000000 0.000995 -0.000000 0.000994 0.151725 0.000993 0.151030 0.000992 0.293448 0.000991 0.448877 0.000990 0.448485 0.000989 0.765448 0.000988 0.955394 0.000987 0.570674 0.000986 0.097096 0.000985 -0.000000 0.000984 0.000000 0.000983 -0.000000 0.000982 0.000000 53: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

0.023107 0.023129 0.023152 0.023175 0.023197

0.000981 0.000980 0.000979 0.000978 0.000978

-0.000000 0.000000 -0.000000 0.000000 -0.000000

Fig28. Audacity Enhanced Correlation Frequency Analysis DATA 1-bar Loop (Funky Drummer)

Fig29. Audacity Frequency Analysis Beat 1 (Aparthenonia)

Boulanger

54: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

Fig30. Audacity Frequency Analysis Beat 1 (Funky Drummer)

Boulanger

55: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

Fig31. Audacity Frequency Analysis Beat 2 (Aparthenonia)

Boulanger

56: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

Fig32. Audacity Frequency Analysis Beat 2 (Funky Drummer)

Boulanger

57: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

Fig33. Audacity Frequency Analysis Beat 3 (Aparthenonia)

Boulanger

58: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

Fig34. Audacity Frequency Analysis Beat 3 (Funky Drummer)

Boulanger

59: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

Fig35. Audacity Frequency Analysis Beat 4 (Aparthenonia)

Boulanger

60: "Var gas v. Pfi zer , I nc . et al . , SD NY Ca use N o. 04- CV-9772 ( WHP) - Ex pert o pi ni o n a n d F F T A na lysis"

Fig36. Audacity Frequency Analysis Beat 4 (Funky Drummer)

If required, I would be happy to provide and even more detailed set of data, figures, and a more detailed analysis of these figures and data, but in my expert opinion, it does not seem necessary given that, even to the non-expert eye, these illustrations clearly indicate that the frequency content of the two works at issue, on a 1-bar level, and on an individual beat by beat level are distinct. Waveform views can look deceivingly similar (although it is shown above that these too have clearly original characteristics), however, as all of these comparison figures show, an FFTAnalysis (in which the algorithm has the same exact analysis settings) reveals what is truly and completely unique about an audio signal ­ the unique DNA of the sound, the sonic fingerprint. All of these figures above clearly show that the audio source materials used in Aparthenonia is unique and original, and is not at all based on or copied or derived from Funky Drummer II.

Richard Boulanger, Ph.D.

Boulanger

61: "Var gas v. Pfi