Schoolcraft v. The City Of New York et al
Filing
308
DECLARATION of NATHANIEL B. SMITH in Support re: 305 MOTION for Summary Judgment .. Document filed by Adrian Schoolcraft. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit, # 2 Exhibit, # 3 Exhibit REDACTED, # 4 Exhibit, # 5 Exhibit, # 6 Exhibit REDACTED, # 7 Exhibit REDACTED, # 8 Exhibit, # 9 Exhibit, # 10 Exhibit REDACTED, # 11 Exhibit, # 12 Exhibit, # 13 Exhibit, # 14 Exhibit, # 15 Exhibit, # 16 Exhibit REDACTED, # 17 Exhibit, # 18 Exhibit, # 19 Exhibit REDACTED, # 20 Exhibit)(Smith, Nathaniel)
PLAINTIFF'S MOTION
EXHIBIT 9
Command Ser. No. 2009-081-0017
Schedui~T~JA--
SUPERVISOR'S COMPLAINT REPORT/
COMMAND DISCIPLINE ELECTION REPORT
PO 468-123
(R~:w.
o·s--·-··-----
04-06)
From:
Integrity Control OHicer. 081 Precinct
To:
Commanding Officer. 081 Precinct
Subject:
REPORT OF VIOLATION OF THE RULES AND PROCEDURES
Member
Rank
Full Name
Commnnu
Complained
o_t_:_ _ _ _. . . . . ._.P_o_ _ ._....L._S_c____
h o?lcraft~..~~~ian_________ _
81
Location where violation occurred
BNAAB
---·-
Complainant
-----.--------1-------·-· ---··------·-·· ··--
Time
Date
02/03/09
1517
D<1y of Week
Tuesda
-·~-··------· -----~·-··-------------~------+------'-------
Name and /\tJ<.Jp;ss
TdHpllone Number
---··---- . ··--
(If any):
---------·----------'-----------------···---·
Details of Violation:
Subject Officer arrived at BN MB at 1517 hours, 4 7 minutes after proper arrival time. Officer was dressed improperly,
arriving in court wearing jeans and sneakers.
The Member was
was
I I
was not Owarned and admonished, and
D
was not Oinstructed in tho proper performance of duty and/or procedure.
--------.--~---.--··---------··--·-----.....---
Signature
-----....---------.----------
D
D
Unsubstantiated
Charge and Specifications
Precinct Ser. No. _ __
0
0
Cornmand
Date
81
Tax Number
02/05/09
Command Discipline Accepted
Command Discipline Review Panel
Final Disposition;
Rank
Signature of Commanding Officer
Tax Number
Command
Date
Instructions:
Commanding Officers must investigate and report disposition under FOLLOW-UP.
If a schedule "B" violation is substantiated, send a completed copy of this report (Front and Rear), to the Department
Advocate's Office.
0000083
COMMAND DISCIPLINE REPORT/ELECTION
Command Ser. No.
-- r-n~O -- _____
Member's Name
Schoolcraft, Adrian
2008-081-001 7
------------------
----'-Com"2'~1d_/_A_ss•g~n•: ------
_._l_T_a_x_ _ _ _
u_m_b_e_r_--_-·_·
Investigation has been completed concerning the violation charged herein. The finding and tile disciplinary action recommended are
indieOSed disciplin<.Jry action.
Accept lim finding but elect to hOJve the disciplinary action reviewed by the Cornrnand Discipline Review Panel.
Decline to accept any discip inary adion wiU10ut a statutory hearing.
Any decision arrived at relative to this case is apart from and does not preclude further exercise of management prerogative
--------------·=r=._____
such as roduction in grade, transfer,reassignmcnt,etc.
Officer'3 Signature
R_a_n_k._S_h_i~e-ld_)
'-W-il-n-es_s_e_d_B_y_:(_N_a_r_n_e_.
_ _ _ __
If a schedule "8" violation is substantiated, send a completed copy of this report (Front and Rear) to the
Department Advocate's Office.
0000082
l~·:~::
;)1/:)/::P!r:
1
·. ---..
',.
.':P"'~
::,~
SUPFRVI~>OR'S COMPLAlflll R.LPORI/
1
. .
·.'..
· ,
P'-'1
Corr~and ::;cr. t~o.
2010-081 -O~"i...
s.:~;-d~ie{;Ji:
COMMANUOISCIPLIN[ElECfiONRF.f'ORT
F'CJ 4(.5-1 2l (Re~ 0.1-0f,)
. .
Frorn
l.t. Rafael Mascol
To:
Co:-r• m anding Officer. 81 st Pr<:Jcinct
Subject
--[JB
REPORT OF VIOLA T!ON OF n-tE RULES AND PROCEDURES
~:::,::~,~--l-;'"~;'""N;;;,Ad. -~, -~- -~- --f~-- ----~T,:u N~
or
.
.
nan vC 100 era
,
~"~'~""'~~~~~:~:;~:;'~t~~on
CompiJ'nI1C Nt-Jm_IN''"/~
Ne011e ar>d Addr .. r.r.
:
(lf.:Jny):
--------.c~~,~~;~~d---
- - -
i
I
N/A
De-taBs--of\iiolatioP:-·
On the above date and time mernernbers of the Quality Assurance Oivision assigned to the CPR
Testing and Monitoring Unit telephoned the 081 Precinct's T. S.
1} Inadequate preformance on T. S
2) Officer
not list the assignment on the Telephone Dispatch Log,
3) A call for service was not addressed
did
The MeMber was
LX: j
was not [Jw.arned rformance of duty nnd/or procedure.
l__j Unsubstantiated
[Jcornrnand Disclplil'le Accepted
... [']ct;~;g~-;~ICl.Specifications
[~]Command Discipline Rovlew Panf!l
Precinct Ser. No.
Fin ill 0\sro~tuon:
·~~------e;,~;,.~~~;~,~:~·
__ -
---]~~~"~~-- _t~~--
-1.
--~~
,., .. trur.do.'ls:
Comm•ndino Orlio:a" rnust lnvc>!ig;,ta
;.
~ ~
·• · •'n'•
"n-
violat:on Is
~nc
su!l~l"nl;~l~d.
rrport disposition unc!Qr FOLLQW .. UP.
•uod <> complet"ll copy of rh;r. '"port (Front ond
Ae~r),
to U1Q Dop.'f1menl
.... ·1vot:.~tlt ·' ~,.Jtiic"
000169~
COMMAND DISCIPLINE RlPOfHIELfCfiON
Command
•
~embor';
Sf~r
2010- 091- OOJ
No.
N:;roo
Ad nan
~>chocb
r o.
aft
\IJOJ::ti9s:ic., h.,~ b-ee." c.o·:J~lo\cd c:oncar·)ing tnc. ";oloti~:r. ch"''''eo ;1ereuL l'~c 411 :-'ld\"0 arc.! ~'0 d!:.c•o~inJry =I chon recommended Jre
ldlC:~llnr final d~:ormil'l-.~0~. ~·' cJcct,~e to accept the flndtng and the propoatld
iscipiin 8 r 1 acbon in Ire~ of
11
s:a:utorv hcarinr, on "''l~r.n charges tlobr& a T•a11 C()rnmiss•oner Yo•• mu'l cornplde an~ r~turn !hi.- form
)_~e_ur>derl'igned wolh111 li11eC WO!iclr.g d~yS
.
.
ank
IC<>mm'"d
-·· __L ______ - -··----· ..
i -·
0 BE COMPL.FfElJ BY MEMBER CHARGED:
mdor:;tdnd that' do not havy
y r1gntto
--·-,--- ---
h~vG !his m~:lll'
<> ~ta•utory hl!fjring
t" occopt tile
finding And !h(' di~coplinory ~c~n~ rec;;urnrnrn::led Ly my C..'>mn•anding oificor or unit lla_&Sr's Offlr:e.
[)001603
Received
01/14/201B
13:29
Jar. ~4 /010 01 :27r>m
81 ICO OFFICE ·•JPD
718574/'"':lf,v-\-,-hl_CK~iL_ --fi -the_
C"·;~ f-l~. ~l.l.«O s-, (u~ "1"b A Qia.. ~ ~fu• ~-<:\ Ut- f,\kJ,
"Fb ~(_~-\ F~~h..-o -tP '(Y~~ --ne, 1\Jo\-.-f;l.P'r>t- \k-t£~. G,c:,;~ f_tiT.
13-w\'t\-,_,.
The Member was
was
0
was nol
llll WRmed
.Da' wa~ ~ol 0
and admoni&hed, and
-
-------·
instrucled in the proper pcrformnnce of duty and/or procodure.
~~s:~~:.~~]"''~,~---
o.-.\-.
w-~-----···--·
Till< Nurnbl'.>r
--T
Comm;l;;d·---F ----_-
Preparin~~~~: ~I- _ J~-~l_ __\__~~-----·---- .]Jt.·ZZJ ___ _L~f..t
_j~-~~£?5.
EQU.QW:J.Jr
U
Unsubstantiated
Ll
Command Discipline Acc"epto-d
0
Chorge and Spec:lflcations
[]
Gommaod Dlst.lplioa Review Panel
Precinct Ser. No.
R~;;- --
-!.""""';;;' c;;~~"''"'"' o-;·
·------
.
------~--~-~-----------~------------
-·. ~------------
T-.
;. .
;,~-.-
--
-I
Commo<>d
--~--~---
•
r;,,
-------
--·
Instructions:
Comm01nding Officers mus·t lnva!>tigate ;md report disposition undar FOLLOW-UP
If a schedule "I:!." violation is sub~3ntiated, send a complatad copy of this report (front and
re;:~r),
to the Department
Advocate's Oftlcu.
NYC00002853
Rtce i ved.
Bl/14/2010
~
13:29
71857<1-
.:ar,
"""lf)q
81 ICU
COUMANO DISCIPLINE REPORT/ ELECTION
'd 2GF 01 2SJJw
'PP
OFFIC~
PAGt
tl4/1 rogatlve
such as reduction In grade, transfer. reassignment, etc.
~~gnalt;re ---~~---·-~·~
---~
j"'' =-~r·,-oo~;~,.;::N;,,,~.,,:~=-==··
If a Schedule "B" violation is substantiated, son !.I a completed copy nf this report (frnnt and rear), to the Department Advocate's
Ortice.
NYr.nnnn?At:;A
Re..:e i 'ed ·
01114/i'Ol'-3
•
.. . :·._..
'
.
·...
__
./
.
·
.
13:2'3
718574~
Jar. 14 201G 01 27Prn
"'154
El ICO UFFICt
SUPERVISOR'S COMPLAINT fcipliro~: Reviow Punel, anti my rl\jhl
toil stsiUtory hc1uing bofore" Trail Commi~slon_,r hove bo4::1\ e>Cpld .1! rtl;~llvelo thi' ce~e h o~part from :lnd does not pr<~chtd~ furthH oxer~:-.u of m~n•gomtnt prerogative
suc~oductio~~-~~: ~~~\~l~r!r_e~~3!~'-"f!~~!:.':!~.: ..
Otncer'F Sign aiL•"'
f.Niin~~~~e~-A~-~-~Ji'l;n~. Rank Shield)
I
.l
If a schedul!! "B" violation Is substantiated. sencJ a completed copy of
Department Advocate's Office.
thi~ report
(honl and Rear} to the
Re~~ i v~rl
lS: '3":
Cotnmttnd Ser. No.
SUPERVISOR'S COMPLAINT REPORT/
COMMAND OISC\PLINE ELECTION REPORT
®
,
PD
46A-1~3
Schedule:
(Rev 04·Clt3]
ru
A
2010-081-02
CJB
Integrity Control Officer, 0')() Prt!c.iact.
fro on.
"
Conu::tanding Off leer, 08l Precinct
To:
---------
Subject: REPORT OF VIOLATION OF THE RULES ANO PROCEDURES
Momber
Rank
Full N~mo
----:_r-~------------·-
Compfa.ned
PO
01
---- Where
Loc-ation
34~0
-Violallan
Schoolcrait, Adrian
- - ----0C(•Irred
---r---·--·--------,.--Tax Number
Ofll
931186
Kingsbrldge Avenue
Compt;;;-.~~~1 N;~;;;-nd Ad.J.;c.~
(II :ony)
------
- - ---·------••r• - -
Details or Violation:
On Honday December 14,
Wednesday January 6, 2010, PO Schoolcraft
as directed by LT. Rudne.ll, Brooklyn North
visit.
lA'B notiC led . IAB log fl 2010-00885
16, 18, 21, 23, n, 28, 30 of 2009 until
did failP.d lo report to c.he 50th Precinct
Inve9t1g~t1rms \Jni c. for a sur,penJed member' r;
lla6 ns6ignecl.
- - - - · -------The Member was
0
was not
kJ
______ ____ _
..
warned and
U
Unaub!>tantlated
fJ
0
Charge and SpecificatlonK
U Command Discipline Roviow Panel
Command Oi:.dpllne Acc:eplad
Preclnd Sor. No. -----------··
•~• - y~;C~oi~omm;~~ o~- ~ ~~~~=--=]T" ''"m'"
1:"'"' -1"" ~
Instructions:
Commanding Officers mus1 hwe~tiQala and report dlspoGition undBr FOLLOW-UP.
If II Gchadule "D" violation Is sub!>taniiOI!ed, -send a completed copy of ltd~; roped (front ant1 ,.,~n. to thr. 0&p3rlfl'lllnl
Advoc;;&tcr's Offico.
TUff:IL f-'. ~12
-v~
I
()
Rec~i,ed
•Tf~t·J-06-2010
.
1[,:37
su•· f'rrdnc\
aoth ~tteeErt~.:;.':_: ~
3450 KingsbS? J
h~
111
,o.s-~:~-L·:t-:
lnteg~rc~v !CoD'b~~Gu
8
5771
Wrii'1cer
Fax
Frorn:
Conlrol Ollicer
_______________ ____
~{lU· Preturr;llnlegr•ly
____ ____.
--
,
------ ---~:•!le~_=_ ;2.
. --~alo: ()1 I Q(QL[l}____ _________ ·
---·------·---··--- ---Fax:
Pho11c: 710-543-STJU
nc:
--·~ ~----- -~-----
cv
-- ··----------..-------
··-····
---.
------------- -----:--0 Phrase Recydo
~... \)
.•.
~~--y
}- JC,(vbs;
l-~~5\- ~~ ()<;~[_£
K
NYCOOClO?R1?
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?