Apple, Inc. v. Motorola, Inc. et al

Filing 107

Declaration of Winslow B. Taub filed by Plaintiffs Apple, Inc., Next Softward, Inc. re: 90 Motion Requesting Claims Construction by Plaintiffs. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. A, '486 Inf. Chart, # 2 Ex. B, '354 file history excerpt, # 3 Ex. C, '354 file history excerpt, # 4 Ex. D, Spielman report excerpts, # 5 Ex. E, '983 file history excerpts, # 6 Ex. F, '983 file history excerpts, # 7 Ex. G, '337 Inf. Chart, # 8 Ex. H, '002 Inf. Chart, # 9 Ex. I, '002 file history excerpt, # 10 Ex. J, '002 file history excerpt, # 11 Ex. K, '002 file history excerpt, # 12 Ex. L, dictionary definitions, # 13 Ex. N, JPS63-167588 cert. trans., # 14 Ex. O, appl. 08/050952 file history excerpt, # 15 Ex. P, invalidity conten. excerpt, # 16 Ex. Q, 6,371,977, # 17 Ex. R, 5,474,831) (Haslam, Robert) Modified on 7/18/2011 (llj).

EXHIBIT E

/- 73048-7035

DocketNo.

iN

TREtNLTEDSATESXTENT
NOv

Orton

Applicants

No.

Serial

et

04

AND TRADEMARK
OTLC

09/140523

26

Docket

Group

1999

al.

Art Unit

P-046.63

2762

Examiner

Filed

August

1998

For

OBJECT-ORIENTED

OPERATING

OFFICE

3.

Chavis

SYSTEM

AMENDM

Commissioner

Honorable

Assistant

of Patents

and Trademarks
D.C.

Washington

20231

Sir

Please

consider

the

remarks

following

in response

to the

Action of August

Office

1999

as

follows

REMARKS

Claims

The

Examiner

Patent

In

l-30remain

case.

claims

rejected

11-30

double

for non-statutory

over

patenting

claims

1-4

of

US

5379432.

the

terminal

herewith

is

response

and

filed

The

Examiner

the

response

respond

rejected

claims

to

overcome

must

Applicant

of

the

this

Report

assert

that

object-oriented

103

over

October

Schmidts
methods

accompanying

the

communication

rejection.

Systems

Schmidt

1992

disclosed
at

this

Examiners

of the

ground

USC

under 35

11-30

Wrappers

to invocations

CFR l.321

under 37

disclaimer

believed

With

Programming

In

in the

technique
as

run-time

is

does

definitely

claimed

by

not

the

Applicant.

Instead Schmidts
is

limited

allowing
references

repeated

error
to

checking

references

Schmidt

to compile-time.
at

to using

also

compile-time

stronger type-checking

inline functions

refers repeatedly
rather

type-safe

than

is

proof

to the benefit

run-time.

operations

and

He

of
also

that

his the

his

technique

makes

type mismatch

technique
a.s

repeated

detection

9530_I

983FH164

WI-AppIe00006O7

Docket

Serial

No.

09/140523

which

are

compile time

time

as

own wrappers

fails

Schmidt

C-i--i-.

to disclose

claimed by

claimed

the differences

in the

the object

invention

while running
Schmidt

By

the

above

resolved.

claims

allow

1.17

the

or credit

whereas
even

is an

of

pass

the

methods

timely

the

the

all

of

the issues

hereby

authorized

of

to Deposit

Account

2f

by

the

by

the

Examiners

this

to

No.

any

charge

amendment

under

Thus

in

claimed

at run-time

system

at

and simply

once

development

time.

Examiner

have been
of

reconsideration

the

Bt

additional

37

C.F.R.

fees

which

1.16

and

Order No. __________

13-4503

submitted

FINNEGAN

LL.P.

rlohnE.Hoet
Registration

No.

26279

202-857-7887

Telephone

202-857-7929

Facsimile

ADDRESS
Finnegan LL.P.

Morgan
Eye

run-

invention.

raise

the

requests

it

wrapper.

completed

claimed

MORO

1775

at

to issue

consideration

any overpayment

located
is

locating

Applicants

respectfully

is

compiling

appropriate

are

wrapper

Schmidt

in

the

Respectfully

SENDERS

to learn

programmers

object-oriented

program once

using

the case

Commissioner

for the

Dated

for

way

and

designing

developers

effective

use

runs

it

believes

Applicant

and

writing

suggest

Applicant

the

claims

Assistant

required

statements

or

the

remarks

allows

on which

platform

executing

Accordingly

The
may be

or

about

talks

it

to invocations

responding

invention

oriented

to disclose

fails

also

stating

3048-7035

the Applicant.

The Applicants
by

Schmidt

featuyes.

their

implementing

No.

Street

Washington

NW.

Suite

400

D.C. 20006

9330_I

983FH165

WI-AppIe00006O8