Apple, Inc. v. Motorola, Inc. et al
Filing
107
Declaration of Winslow B. Taub filed by Plaintiffs Apple, Inc., Next Softward, Inc. re: 90 Motion Requesting Claims Construction by Plaintiffs. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. A, '486 Inf. Chart, # 2 Ex. B, '354 file history excerpt, # 3 Ex. C, '354 file history excerpt, # 4 Ex. D, Spielman report excerpts, # 5 Ex. E, '983 file history excerpts, # 6 Ex. F, '983 file history excerpts, # 7 Ex. G, '337 Inf. Chart, # 8 Ex. H, '002 Inf. Chart, # 9 Ex. I, '002 file history excerpt, # 10 Ex. J, '002 file history excerpt, # 11 Ex. K, '002 file history excerpt, # 12 Ex. L, dictionary definitions, # 13 Ex. N, JPS63-167588 cert. trans., # 14 Ex. O, appl. 08/050952 file history excerpt, # 15 Ex. P, invalidity conten. excerpt, # 16 Ex. Q, 6,371,977, # 17 Ex. R, 5,474,831) (Haslam, Robert) Modified on 7/18/2011 (llj).
EXHIBIT I
Corr
and Mat
jr/X
BOXAF
under
Response
37
CFR
1.116
Expedited
Examining Group
THE UNITED STATES
IN
In
re
Application
eoi
No
Filing
Date
trite
Procedure
237
PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
of
Steven
Serial
Patent
Examiner
Christensen
Art
08/316237
30
September
Unit
Dela Torre
2415
1994
-ne-na
For
METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR
AND ACCESSING
CONTROL AND STATUS
DISPLAYING
INFORMATION
COMPUTER
IN
SYSTEM
fl
-I
AMENDMENT TO
FINAL OFFICE
ACTION
-o
Assistant
Commissioner
Washington
D.C
for
Patents
20231
C-
Sir
In
Applicant
to
response
the Final Office
respectfully
amendments and
the
requests
consider
Action
Examiner
the following
FtRSLCI.A.SSRTIF1CATE
hereby certify that this correspondence
mail with sufficient
in an envelope
postage
D.C 20231
Ienian17
is
mailed November 20
to
1996
enter the following
remarks
OF
being deposited with the
sddresse8 to the Assistant
MAILING
Untied States
Postal
Service
Commissioner for Patents
as
first class
Washington
1Q07
Date
of
Deposit
Chrtsre
Name
of
Person
Miiing
4enst
Signatur
Serisl
No
08/316237
Correspondence
PDate
t91
04860
P1365
OO2FH 175
WI-AppIe000l
080
THE CLAIMS
IN
Twice Amended
Art
interactive
computer-controlled
display
system comprising
processor
data
cursor
control
on said data
cursor
window
data
device
10
wherein the window
11
first
12
screen wherein each
13
the plurality
window
of
one
control
the
individual
16
information
17
window region wherein
at
18
associated
module
19
wherein
20
logic use
21
coordinate
22
display
programming
the
window
of
of
and
indicia
and
functions
displays
on said data
associated
is
display
one
with
the
modules
of
plurality
to
user
logic
of
generation
logic
to
to
areas
display
and
execute
to
generate
in the
areas
input
and
exchange
to
screen
display
programming
control
communication
the
areas
the data
to
sensitive
is
control
modules
coupled
one
least
plurality of
generates
areas
and
the processor
and
one of the plurality of display
generation
message-based
activities
in
logic
of display
of the plurality of individual
display
positioning
for
status
provide
programming
logic
to
coupled
of display
plurality
at
for
for
environment
control
plurality
15
least
that
and
generation
of
logic
an operating
modules
an indicia generation
14
and
having
region
processor
said processor
screen
create
programming
the
to
coupled
generation
to
to
coupled
display
screen
display
individual
screen
display
first
and
its
further
the indicia generation
information
enable
to
interactive
activity
Once
wherein said
at
least
Amended
one
of
the
The display
plurality
system defined
of display
ai
in
Claim
is
variably
sized
Serial
No
08/316237
04860.P1365
OO2FH 176
WI-AppIe000l
081
Twice
8.
id
wherein
at
The display
Amended
one of the
least
system defined
of
plurality
areas
display
Claim
in
only
displays
information.
wherein id.
to
Amended
Twice
9.
at
one of the
least
information
when
Twice
control
The display
plurality..of
Amended
11.
defined
system
display
areas
Claim
in
acts
to
provide
access
selected.
An
interactive
display
computer-controlled
system comprising
processor
data
cursor
control
on said data
cursor
window
display
display
create
to
wherein the window
11
first
12
screen wherein each
13
the plurality
window
14
at
least
and
16
indicia
17
in
18
of individual
Serial
least
environment
modules
provide
the
for
positioning
and
of display
logic
display
logic
generates
area
areas
areas
data
control
and
is
functions
displays
on said data
display
with one
associated
of
modules
generation
control
and
generates
logic
and
the processor
plurality of
for
status
of display
plurality
graphics
generation
control
programming
generation
one data
and
plurality
having
indicia
that
to
coupled
logic
an operating
programming
08/316237
control
generation
of
processor
screen
individual
one
graphics
at
No.
of
window
15
the
region
said
to
coupled
and
programming
10
the processor
to
coupled
device
generation
screen
individual
screen
display
logic
to
coupled
wherein said
user
by executing
sensitive
at
least
the
at
least
graphics
one
of
processor
one
for
display
the plurality
modules
04860.P1365
OO2FH 177
WI-AppIe000l
082
wherein the window
19
20
said
21
at
22
further
wherein said
23
response
from said
at
least
one
indicia
14
said
at
data
one
least
graphics
at
one data
15
area
is
Amended
Twice
by the user and
system
user
to
response
generation
of the plurality of
The display
display
in
logic
when
determines
logic
selected
indicia graphics
one
one
least
Amended
least
generation
least
control
been
area has
display
at
and
generation
selection
said
and
initiates
logic
modules
programming
defined
signals
Claim 11 wherein
in
sized
variably
method
for
information
control
generating
comprising the steps of
an operating
creating
modules
programming
first
generating
areas
indicia
for
individual
areas
is
that
associated
sized
to
with one
control
at
least
wherein each
modules
plurality of
for
plurality of display
of the plurality of
one
of
individual
functions
accommodate
from executing
resulting
and
status
provide
window
programming
environment
the plurality
of the plurality of individual
of
display
programming
modules
10
tha
displaying
ara
11
display
12
modules
13
one
display
module
programming
15
least
16
programming
17
responsible
No
module
for
08/316237
each
ara
is
said plurality of
of
of
least
of individual
plurality
one
programming
indicia
one of the indicia
first
Serial
to
each
one
by executing
corresponding
selecting
14
in
indicia
wherein the step
determining
selected
of
said plurality
generating
display
which
of
selecting
comprises
of said plurality of
and sending
message
of
programming
of
individual
to
modules
selected indicia
04860.P1365
OO2FH 178
WI-AppIe000l
083
18
19
said
function
performing
in
to
response
selection.
Amended
16.
said
of
said
status
comprises
The method
first
sending
method
Claim 15 wherein one
of
information.
control
module wherein
message
first
said
to
said
in
Claim 15 wherein one
of
information.
defined
in
Claim 15
further
said
step of
comprising
as
set
forth
second
first
comprises
indicative
message
module such
programming
supported by
and
that
with said programming
interacts
with the
interaction
requesting
module
returning
supported by said programming
module
of features
set
requesting
programming
module
programming
programming
features
in
defined
module
programming
programming
user
The
Amended
the
features
defined
of
the steps
to
indicia
of indicia comprises
18.
said
The method
Amended
17.
10
module
programming
module
said
module
of
first
in
response
based on indicated
module.
by said programming
REMARKS
Applicant
amended.
respectfully
requests
Claims 1-24 remain
in
reconsideration
the application.
of
No
this
application
claims
have
as
been
canceled.
Claims 1-3 8-24 were
anticipated
teaches
Serial
No.
by EPO
status
08/316237
Patent
indicator
rejected
No.
which
584
under
392
indicates
35
Al
to
U.S.C.
102a
Cohausz
the location
as being
Cohausz.
at
which
one
Cohausz
is
in
04860.P1365
OO2FH 179
WI-AppIe000l
084
program
or information
text
of individual
fields
information
Clicking
individual
on the
leads
field
are arranged
fields
of the individual
portions
represent
timed running of the program
the
of the area
Claim
of
window
data
of
areas
with the
logical
in
of the
sizes
fields
to
correspond
claims
control
to
coupled
logic
an
create
the
first
window
display
screen
with
having
region
wherein
one
each
for
the
of
the
plurality
plurality
and
generates
areas
of display
plurality
individual
of
control
logic
of display
plurality
of
and
processor
environment
operating
that
modules
status
programming
provide
the
window
and
control
generation
associated
is
accordance
The
area
wherein
data
said
to
screen
individual
on
program
The
invention
and
generation
functions
and displays
or
text
represented
the present
display
program
the respective
to
successively
and/or
size
number
The status indicator includes
range
programming
modules
an
indicia
at
least
information
and
areas
and
the
The present
program The
one
single
However
fields
information
No
i.e
08/316237
logic
display
display
modules
text
one
the
of
to
to
execute
generate
display
of
in
areas
plurality
of
plurality
the
display
areas
which
does
which
range
represent
Cohausz
portions
is
not
with
location
single
within
the
The Examiner
refers
programming
modules
states
specifically
chapters
with
such display
provide
the
to
generation
added
associated
of the individual
paragraphs
indicia
are associated
indicates
plurality of individual
of
the
of
Emphasis
activitu
Cohausz
communication
message-based
activities
Cohausz
or information
paragraph
sections
use
status indicator
indicator of
as teaching
page
individual
Serial
status
the
least
coordinate
provides
teaches
program
paragraph
to
interactive
programming
areas Cohausz
of
at
screen
display
modules
wherein
generation
invention
data
module
is
sensitive
to
user
programming
the
window
and control logic
generation
associated
further
enable
one
the
to
programming
of
wherein
information
to
logic
in
display
indicia
exchange
plurality
region
its
and
input
individual
for
window
first
the
of
coupled
logic
generation
one
or
that
program
segments
of
to
page
the
text
of
information
04860.P1365
OO2FH 180
WI-AppIe000l
085
Thus Cohausz
with each
field
Claim
that
uses
to
lead
of
the present
to
assertion
communication
The
communication
which
module
to
for
5-7
lines
There
communication
invention
the
dependent
Milk
teaches
the use of
of sequential
information
having certain
components
Serial
No
rates
08/316237
15
stop
of
and
display
rate
such
fast
that
pg 32
based
the present
similar limitations
Therefore based on
submits
obtain
to
claims
dependent
its
to
messages
not anticipate
also include
Claims
the
and
11
same
15
rational
and
their
by Cohausz
under
U.S
35
Patent
control
Specifically
the playback
reverse
and
slider
control
one of these
and
of
any
rejected
Cohausz
over
indicators
11
or
based
Specifications
does
which
message-based
do or
to
Contrary
fields
such message
that
Cohausz
of
passes
capabilities
Cohausz
in
Claim
also
unpatentable
to
its
are not anticipated
Claims 4-7 were
strip
and
respectfully
Applicant
claims
what
environment
the operating
above
module
not teach
exchange
message
strip
Therefore
Claims
forth
the control
the
tell
module
in
Independent
given
either
used
as claimed
regarding
sets
the use
logic
to
does
of individual
teaching
invention
that
information
information
for
generation
Cohausz
logic
not teach
means
indicia
an
exchange
does
no indication
is
is
Cohauszs
present
example
about
information
to
generation
areas
program
claims
also
based communication
message
respective
invention
indicia
by Cohausz
not anticipated
is
associated
modules
programming
communication
of the
activities
of
individual
claim
Therefore
Examiners
the
not teach
message-based
coordinate
the use
does
bar
video
as
standard
forward
Claims
4-7
103
5202961
for
Milk
of
U.S.C
to
as being
controlling
teaches
playback
Milk uses
depend
the
strip
Milk
of display
rate
of such
the use
This control
et al
Mills
control
defined
is
as
direction/velocity
control
icon
on independent
to
select
Claim
04860.Pi365
OO2FH
181
WI-AppIe000l
086
discussed
the indicia
of
or
make
in
of
102a
remarks and
such action
is
Please
is
Cohausz
of
not
fields
or
obvious
does not
based
message
in
view
respectfully submits
that
earnestly
overcome
been
Cohausz
of
of these
Claims
is
rejections
1-24
are
that
the
rejection
by the amendments
now
respectfully
in
condition
and
any shortages
and
credit
for
Attorney
any overcharges
to
our Deposit
submitted
Wilshire
ZAFMAN
LLP
allie
for
Registration
Applicant
No. 36591
Blvd.
Floor
Los Angeles
serial
and
allowance
____________________________
Michael
408
the
02-2666.
__________1997
Seventh
35
requested.
BLAKELY SOKOLOFF TAYLOR
12400
under
solicited.
Respectfully
Dated
teach
not
the plurality
to
corresponding
Because
plurality
invention
103 have
charge
No
invention.
the use of
Applicant
withdrawal
submits
Applicant
Account
and
programs
Miih does
that
y.uilla.
Accordingly
U.S.C.
acknowledged
plurality of
the present
view
has
in the present
obvious
communication
further
or
generator
as claimed
fields
teach
The Examiner
above.
CA
90025-1026
720-8598
No.
08/316237
04860.P1365
OO2FH 182
WI-AppIe000l
087
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?