Apple, Inc. v. Motorola, Inc. et al

Filing 107

Declaration of Winslow B. Taub filed by Plaintiffs Apple, Inc., Next Softward, Inc. re: 90 Motion Requesting Claims Construction by Plaintiffs. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. A, '486 Inf. Chart, # 2 Ex. B, '354 file history excerpt, # 3 Ex. C, '354 file history excerpt, # 4 Ex. D, Spielman report excerpts, # 5 Ex. E, '983 file history excerpts, # 6 Ex. F, '983 file history excerpts, # 7 Ex. G, '337 Inf. Chart, # 8 Ex. H, '002 Inf. Chart, # 9 Ex. I, '002 file history excerpt, # 10 Ex. J, '002 file history excerpt, # 11 Ex. K, '002 file history excerpt, # 12 Ex. L, dictionary definitions, # 13 Ex. N, JPS63-167588 cert. trans., # 14 Ex. O, appl. 08/050952 file history excerpt, # 15 Ex. P, invalidity conten. excerpt, # 16 Ex. Q, 6,371,977, # 17 Ex. R, 5,474,831) (Haslam, Robert) Modified on 7/18/2011 (llj).

EXHIBIT F

IVCIC\

OF COMMERCE

UNITED STATESDEIARTMENT
and Trademark Office

Patent

C4/

Address

COMMISSIONER
Wasflngton.

APPLICATION

fyILING

NO.

09/141.

DATE

523

NAMED

FIRST

05/26/98

OF PATENTS

INVENTOR

ATTORNEY

.3011IN

NE.W

YORK

NY

cc

EXAMINER

CRAY IS

FINNF1iAN

NO.

F-- 3.1.0-.

FIU

s.

DOCKET

CIRTON

LNO2/020T1
MURlANF

AND TRADEMARKS

20231

D.C.

.3

LLF
ART

PAPER

UNIT

10154

NUMBfLJ

2762
13
DATEMAILED

Please

find

below

and/or

attached

an

Office

communication

concerning

thia

2/0100

or

application

proceeding.
Commissioner

PTO4OC

IRiv.

of

Patents

and

Trademarks

2196
1-

PII.Gopy

983FH 168

WI-AppIe00006l

No.

Apptcation

Office Action

Applicants

Summary

Examiner

Group

LvLg
the
Period

for

MAILING DATE

of

Extensions

lithe

It

for

to

reply

for

period

may

date

melting

period

NO

time

of

the

-Failure

lion

on

appears

cover

the

Art Unit

7.4.

sheet beneath

the

address

correspondence

Reply

SHORTENED
STATUTORY
OF THIS COMMUNICATION.

tram

communics

this

Orhwtd/

vfictosfl

le

under

available

above

epedtted

the

the

provisIons

MONTHS FROM

SET TO EXPIRE

IS

CPA

sf31

1.135a.

no

In

event

however.

maya

be

reply

timely

THE

slier

tiled

DATE

MAILING

SIX

I5MONThS

communication.

thie

specified

reply

within

reply

be

at

FOR REPLY

PERIOD

eel

Is

than

lees

such

above
exlended

or

30

thIrty

tar

days.

shell

period

period

cause

minimum

etatulory

MONTHS

SIX

expire

by statuta

replywit

the

within

reply

by defeuli

the

tram
to

application

of

the

30

thIrty

mailing

will

days

dale

ot

be

considered

timely.

communication.

this

becoma ABANOCNED

35

U.S.C.

133.

Statua

Peeponaive

thle

action

SInce

communications

to

this application

accordance

of

Disposition

on

filed

F1AL

is

with

the

is

In

condition

for

under

practice

allowance

Experte

for formal

except

1935

Qugyte

matters

as

prosecution

11 4530G.

C.D.

is/are

claims

pending

closed

Is

Clalma

___

I1

Clalniej

withdrawn

In

__

Claims

sppIIcaton.

fnn

allowed.

rare

Claims

the

In

is/are

Is/are

above

the

the merita

Claims

ii
Of

to

213.

rejected.

is/are

objected

era

to.

to

subject

rusuuucr

yr

uwuuv.

requirement.

Application

Papers
Notice

See

the

The

proposed

The

drewings

The

speciticetion

The

oath

Priority

attached

under

drawing
tiled

is

35

U.S.C.

Acknowledgment

Some

All

Drawing

Patent

objected

is

to

bi

the

approved

Is

to

objected

by

dlaepproved.

Exeminet

the

Eitaminer.

to

objected

PTO-94e.

Review

on________________

flied

lefare

by

the

Examiner.

e-d

1119
is

Dreftepemons

on

declaration

or

of

correction

made

of

claim

icr

foreign

CERTIFIED

of the

Nope

under

priority

of the

copies

35

U.S.C.

11

9a-d.

documents

priority

have

been

received.
received

in

Apptication

received

in

this national

tCartiiied

copies

not

No.

Series

Slage

Number

Code/Serial

application

the

trom

tnlemationai

Bureau

PCT

Rule

7.2e.

racelved..._..__

Attachments
Intormation

NotIce

of

NotIce

of

Disclosure

Roterences
Dreftepersons

Statements
Cited
Patent

PTO-

449

Paper

Nos.

Drawing

Notice

Review

PTO-948

Office

.t

5.

Petent

PTO-s25trtnv

end

Trademark

57l

Summary

interviow

PTO-892

of

informal

PTO-413

Patent

Application

PTO-1

52

Other_______________________________

Action

Summery

Office

16. GPO

1957.433.221162717

Part

of

Paper

No.

1.3

983FH 169

WI-AppIe00006l

Number

Application/Control
Art

Unit

09/140523

Page

2762

DETAILED

Claim

The

in

prior Office

Claims

2.

cited

text

in

3.

the

those

11-30

fUnctions

as

proof

or

discuss

error

not

103a

U.S.C.

and

checking

methods

at

features

are indicated

to

run-time

is

via

benefit

which

in

included

as being

does

this

action

befound

can

ovr

unpatentable

examiner

details

not

considers

of

of

the

his

been

does

to

not

respond

The

irrelevant

The

Ohecking.

as

Schi4iidt

to

responding

Schmidts

Portability

invocations

system

and

since

to the

to

of

invocations

the

also

mentions

checking

neither

claims

the

the

inline

term

applicant

not

are

they

at

applicants

also

do

not

claims.

of the

support

Extensibility

but

error

applicants

response

to

use of

Schmidts

as allowing

technique

considered

considered

fUlly

to compile-time.

examiners

the

system

system

limited

is

have

references

for error

designed

neither

the

is

system

to the

Schmidts

the

and makes

run-time

system

1999

Schmidts

that

Schmidts

than

November

run-time

repeatedly

rather

In reference

at

that

filed

indicates

applicant

Schmidts

system

Code

U.S.

103

action.

Schmidt refers

compile-time

Title

under 35

are rejected

methods

object-oriented

35

sections

arguments

Applicants

The

of

-35 Usc

Rejections

action.

previous

persuasive.

that

of

ACTION

the

object-oriented

features.

subheadings

The

on page

4.

983FH 170

WI-AppIe00006l

Number

Application/Control

09/1

Under

the

notice

portability section

API which

object-oriiented

access

the

function

particular

that

while

ie.

Page

goal

is

under

feature

to allow

of

rejection

policy

as

CFR

shortened

mailing

of the

the

end of

the

will

expire

on

CFR 1.136a
however
this

will
final

the

mailing

date

will

be

the

appropriate

mapping

written

using

that

calls

system

run-time

inherently

is

single

date

the

the

in

the

of the

extensibility

reference

to

OS

existing

APis without

action

previous

in

view

of

dynamic

the

modifying

binding

The

interfaces.

and

the

ddign

or

above

responses

teachings

the

is

Applicant

for reply to

of this

of

this

final

action

from

period

the

this

In

action.

action

shortened

advisory

calculated

statutory

notice

the

infrastructure.

proper

period
date

THREE-MONTH
the

he

then

of

Schmidt.

reminded

of

the

extension

of time

1.136a.

statutory

from

MONTHS
MONTHS

the

Transparent

original

MADE FINAL

IS

37

in

cited

consider

ACTION
forth

set

is

the

wrapper

reasons

11-30

claims

THIS

4.

existing

the

improve

to extend

for the

Therefore

onto

subheading

extensibility

help

to

of the

may

programs

transparently

OS mechanisms.

the

applications

implementation

Application

or executing.

running

mn-time

also

mapped

is

underlying

Furthermore

of

40523

Unit 2762

Art

and

statutory
is

expire

action

event

the

date
later

is

first

advisory

period

mailed and

mailing

for reply

final

the

then

set

action
the

any

of

extension

the

advisory

than

SIX

to

THREE

expire
is

not

within

filed

is

reply

mailed

shortened

statutory

fee pursuant
action.

MONTHS

TWO
until

In

to

after

period

37

no event

from

the

mailing

date

action.

this communication
or earlier
Any inquiry concerning
communications
from the examiner should
be directed
to Examiner
Chavis whose
number
is
telephone
703 305-9665. The examiner can
from 800am
on Monday-Friday
to 430pm.
normally be reached
5.

to reach
the examiner by telephone
attempts
are
the examiners
New Art
supervisor Tang Hafiz
2762 can be reached on 7031 305-9643.
The fax phone
If

unsuccessful
Unit

number

for

this

Group

is

703

305-0040.

983FH

171

WI-AppIe00006l

-A

ApplicatioControl
Unit

Art

Number

09/140523

Page

2762

nature
or relating
to the
status
Any
inquiry of
general
this application
or proceeding
should
be directed
to the Group
whose
number
is
305-3900.
receptionist
telephone
7.03

of

JQC
January

26

2000

983FH 172

WI-AppIe00006l