Apple, Inc. v. Motorola, Inc. et al
Filing
107
Declaration of Winslow B. Taub filed by Plaintiffs Apple, Inc., Next Softward, Inc. re: 90 Motion Requesting Claims Construction by Plaintiffs. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. A, '486 Inf. Chart, # 2 Ex. B, '354 file history excerpt, # 3 Ex. C, '354 file history excerpt, # 4 Ex. D, Spielman report excerpts, # 5 Ex. E, '983 file history excerpts, # 6 Ex. F, '983 file history excerpts, # 7 Ex. G, '337 Inf. Chart, # 8 Ex. H, '002 Inf. Chart, # 9 Ex. I, '002 file history excerpt, # 10 Ex. J, '002 file history excerpt, # 11 Ex. K, '002 file history excerpt, # 12 Ex. L, dictionary definitions, # 13 Ex. N, JPS63-167588 cert. trans., # 14 Ex. O, appl. 08/050952 file history excerpt, # 15 Ex. P, invalidity conten. excerpt, # 16 Ex. Q, 6,371,977, # 17 Ex. R, 5,474,831) (Haslam, Robert) Modified on 7/18/2011 (llj).
EXHIBIT F
IVCIC\
OF COMMERCE
UNITED STATESDEIARTMENT
and Trademark Office
Patent
C4/
Address
COMMISSIONER
Wasflngton.
APPLICATION
fyILING
NO.
09/141.
DATE
523
NAMED
FIRST
05/26/98
OF PATENTS
INVENTOR
ATTORNEY
.3011IN
NE.W
YORK
NY
cc
EXAMINER
CRAY IS
FINNF1iAN
NO.
F-- 3.1.0-.
FIU
s.
DOCKET
CIRTON
LNO2/020T1
MURlANF
AND TRADEMARKS
20231
D.C.
.3
LLF
ART
PAPER
UNIT
10154
NUMBfLJ
2762
13
DATEMAILED
Please
find
below
and/or
attached
an
Office
communication
concerning
thia
2/0100
or
application
proceeding.
Commissioner
PTO4OC
IRiv.
of
Patents
and
Trademarks
2196
1-
PII.Gopy
983FH 168
WI-AppIe00006l
No.
Apptcation
Office Action
Applicants
Summary
Examiner
Group
LvLg
the
Period
for
MAILING DATE
of
Extensions
lithe
It
for
to
reply
for
period
may
date
melting
period
NO
time
of
the
-Failure
lion
on
appears
cover
the
Art Unit
7.4.
sheet beneath
the
address
correspondence
Reply
SHORTENED
STATUTORY
OF THIS COMMUNICATION.
tram
communics
this
Orhwtd/
vfictosfl
le
under
available
above
epedtted
the
the
provisIons
MONTHS FROM
SET TO EXPIRE
IS
CPA
sf31
1.135a.
no
In
event
however.
maya
be
reply
timely
THE
slier
tiled
DATE
MAILING
SIX
I5MONThS
communication.
thie
specified
reply
within
reply
be
at
FOR REPLY
PERIOD
eel
Is
than
lees
such
above
exlended
or
30
thIrty
tar
days.
shell
period
period
cause
minimum
etatulory
MONTHS
SIX
expire
by statuta
replywit
the
within
reply
by defeuli
the
tram
to
application
of
the
30
thIrty
mailing
will
days
dale
ot
be
considered
timely.
communication.
this
becoma ABANOCNED
35
U.S.C.
133.
Statua
Peeponaive
thle
action
SInce
communications
to
this application
accordance
of
Disposition
on
filed
F1AL
is
with
the
is
In
condition
for
under
practice
allowance
Experte
for formal
except
1935
Qugyte
matters
as
prosecution
11 4530G.
C.D.
is/are
claims
pending
closed
Is
Clalma
___
I1
Clalniej
withdrawn
In
__
Claims
sppIIcaton.
fnn
allowed.
rare
Claims
the
In
is/are
Is/are
above
the
the merita
Claims
ii
Of
to
213.
rejected.
is/are
objected
era
to.
to
subject
rusuuucr
yr
uwuuv.
requirement.
Application
Papers
Notice
See
the
The
proposed
The
drewings
The
speciticetion
The
oath
Priority
attached
under
drawing
tiled
is
35
U.S.C.
Acknowledgment
Some
All
Drawing
Patent
objected
is
to
bi
the
approved
Is
to
objected
by
dlaepproved.
Exeminet
the
Eitaminer.
to
objected
PTO-94e.
Review
on________________
flied
lefare
by
the
Examiner.
e-d
1119
is
Dreftepemons
on
declaration
or
of
correction
made
of
claim
icr
foreign
CERTIFIED
of the
Nope
under
priority
of the
copies
35
U.S.C.
11
9a-d.
documents
priority
have
been
received.
received
in
Apptication
received
in
this national
tCartiiied
copies
not
No.
Series
Slage
Number
Code/Serial
application
the
trom
tnlemationai
Bureau
PCT
Rule
7.2e.
racelved..._..__
Attachments
Intormation
NotIce
of
NotIce
of
Disclosure
Roterences
Dreftepersons
Statements
Cited
Patent
PTO-
449
Paper
Nos.
Drawing
Notice
Review
PTO-948
Office
.t
5.
Petent
PTO-s25trtnv
end
Trademark
57l
Summary
interviow
PTO-892
of
informal
PTO-413
Patent
Application
PTO-1
52
Other_______________________________
Action
Summery
Office
16. GPO
1957.433.221162717
Part
of
Paper
No.
1.3
983FH 169
WI-AppIe00006l
Number
Application/Control
Art
Unit
09/140523
Page
2762
DETAILED
Claim
The
in
prior Office
Claims
2.
cited
text
in
3.
the
those
11-30
fUnctions
as
proof
or
discuss
error
not
103a
U.S.C.
and
checking
methods
at
features
are indicated
to
run-time
is
via
benefit
which
in
included
as being
does
this
action
befound
can
ovr
unpatentable
examiner
details
not
considers
of
of
the
his
been
does
to
not
respond
The
irrelevant
The
Ohecking.
as
Schi4iidt
to
responding
Schmidts
Portability
invocations
system
and
since
to the
to
of
invocations
the
also
mentions
checking
neither
claims
the
the
inline
term
applicant
not
are
they
at
applicants
also
do
not
claims.
of the
support
Extensibility
but
error
applicants
response
to
use of
Schmidts
as allowing
technique
considered
considered
fUlly
to compile-time.
examiners
the
system
system
limited
is
have
references
for error
designed
neither
the
is
system
to the
Schmidts
the
and makes
run-time
system
1999
Schmidts
that
Schmidts
than
November
run-time
repeatedly
rather
In reference
at
that
filed
indicates
applicant
Schmidts
system
Code
U.S.
103
action.
Schmidt refers
compile-time
Title
under 35
are rejected
methods
object-oriented
35
sections
arguments
Applicants
The
of
-35 Usc
Rejections
action.
previous
persuasive.
that
of
ACTION
the
object-oriented
features.
subheadings
The
on page
4.
983FH 170
WI-AppIe00006l
Number
Application/Control
09/1
Under
the
notice
portability section
API which
object-oriiented
access
the
function
particular
that
while
ie.
Page
goal
is
under
feature
to allow
of
rejection
policy
as
CFR
shortened
mailing
of the
the
end of
the
will
expire
on
CFR 1.136a
however
this
will
final
the
mailing
date
will
be
the
appropriate
mapping
written
using
that
calls
system
run-time
inherently
is
single
date
the
the
in
the
of the
extensibility
reference
to
OS
existing
APis without
action
previous
in
view
of
dynamic
the
modifying
binding
The
interfaces.
and
the
ddign
or
above
responses
teachings
the
is
Applicant
for reply to
of this
of
this
final
action
from
period
the
this
In
action.
action
shortened
advisory
calculated
statutory
notice
the
infrastructure.
proper
period
date
THREE-MONTH
the
he
then
of
Schmidt.
reminded
of
the
extension
of time
1.136a.
statutory
from
MONTHS
MONTHS
the
Transparent
original
MADE FINAL
IS
37
in
cited
consider
ACTION
forth
set
is
the
wrapper
reasons
11-30
claims
THIS
4.
existing
the
improve
to extend
for the
Therefore
onto
subheading
extensibility
help
to
of the
may
programs
transparently
OS mechanisms.
the
applications
implementation
Application
or executing.
running
mn-time
also
mapped
is
underlying
Furthermore
of
40523
Unit 2762
Art
and
statutory
is
expire
action
event
the
date
later
is
first
advisory
period
mailed and
mailing
for reply
final
the
then
set
action
the
any
of
extension
the
advisory
than
SIX
to
THREE
expire
is
not
within
filed
is
reply
mailed
shortened
statutory
fee pursuant
action.
MONTHS
TWO
until
In
to
after
period
37
no event
from
the
mailing
date
action.
this communication
or earlier
Any inquiry concerning
communications
from the examiner should
be directed
to Examiner
Chavis whose
number
is
telephone
703 305-9665. The examiner can
from 800am
on Monday-Friday
to 430pm.
normally be reached
5.
to reach
the examiner by telephone
attempts
are
the examiners
New Art
supervisor Tang Hafiz
2762 can be reached on 7031 305-9643.
The fax phone
If
unsuccessful
Unit
number
for
this
Group
is
703
305-0040.
983FH
171
WI-AppIe00006l
-A
ApplicatioControl
Unit
Art
Number
09/140523
Page
2762
nature
or relating
to the
status
Any
inquiry of
general
this application
or proceeding
should
be directed
to the Group
whose
number
is
305-3900.
receptionist
telephone
7.03
of
JQC
January
26
2000
983FH 172
WI-AppIe00006l
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?