Elan Microelectronics Corporation v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 214

Declaration of Jennifer Liu in Support of 212 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment of Infringement of U.S. Patent 5,875,352 [Public Version] MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment of Infringement of U.S. Patent 5,875,352 [Public Version] filed byElan Microelectronics Corporation. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3-6 MFN, # 4 Exhibit 7, # 5 Exhibit 8, # 6 Exhibit 9, # 7 Exhibit 10, # 8 Exhibit 11, # 9 Exhibit 12, # 10 Exhibit 13, # 11 Exhibit 14, # 12 Exhibit 15, # 13 Exhibit 16, # 14 Exhibit 17, # 15 Exhibit 18, # 16 Exhibit 19, # 17 Exhibit 20, # 18 Exhibit 21, # 19 Exhibit 22, # 20 Exhibit 23-25 MFN, # 21 Exhibit 26, # 22 Exhibit 27 MFN, # 23 Exhibit 28, # 24 Exhibit 29-33 MFN, # 25 Exhibit 34, # 26 Exhibit 35-37 MFN, # 27 Exhibit 38 Part 1, # 28 Exhibit 38 Part 2, # 29 Exhibit 38 Part 3, # 30 Exhibit 39-45 MFN, # 31 Exhibit 46, # 32 Exhibit 47 MFN, # 33 Exhibit 48)(Related document(s) 212 ) (Liu, Jennifer) (Filed on 5/24/2011)

Download PDF
EXHIBIT 17 ! fmoRQURSSR 6ZYR]L_`WL_TZY^$!dZ`!LYO!dZ`]!@LN5ZZV bP]P!XLOP!QZ]!PLNS!Z_SP]& ! 3 fmoRQURSTZ 6SL[_P]!*!!!E\YX!j\g[!Rbhe!FTV;bb^ CZbP]!M`__ZY Mhea!lbhe!FTV;bb^!ba!be!bYY'!be!chg!\g!gb!f_XXc)!Ab_W!Wbja!gb!eXfgTeg!lbhe!FTV;bb^! Whe\aZ!gebhU_Xf[bbg\aZ) EWZ_%WZLOTYR!E`[P]7]TaP Rbhe!bcg\VT_!We\iX!VTa!eXTW!TaW!je\gX!gb!fgTaWTeW(f\mX!<=!TaW!=O=!W\fVf) =YQ]L]PO!"=D#!]PNPTaP] NfX!Ta!bcg\baT_!9cc_X!KX`bgX!$fb_W!fXcTeTgX_l!Tg!jjj)Tcc_X)Vb`*fgbeX%!j\g[!g[X!BK! eXVX\iXe!gb!Vbageb_!?ebag!Kbj!TaW!DXlabgX!ba!lbhe!FTV;bb^!Yeb`!hc!gb!.+!YXXg!$4),! `XgXef%!TjTl)! EWPP[!TYOTNL_Z]!WTRS_ 9!j[\gX!_\Z[g!ch_fXf!j[Xa!g[X!FTV;bb^!\f!\a!f_XXc) F]LNV[LO!LYO!_]LNV[LO!M`__ZY FbiX!g[X!cb\agXe!j\g[!baX!Y\aZXe!ba!g[X!geTV^cTW'!be!fVeb__!j\g[!gjb!Y\aZXef)!MTc!g[X! geTV^cTW!gb!V_\V^!be!WbhU_X(V_\V^!T!fX_XVg\ba) 5L__P]d Kha!g[X!FTV;bb^!hf\aZ!UTggXel!cbjXe!j[Xa!lbh!TeX!TjTl!Yeb`!T!cbjXe!bhg_Xg)! KX`bi\aZ!g[X!UTggXel!Z\iXf!lbh!TVVXff!gb!g[X!`X`bel!\a!lbhe!FTV;bb^) 5`TW_%TY!^_P]PZ!^[PLVP]^ E\fgXa!gb!`hf\V'!`bi\Xf'!ZT`Xf'!TaW!`h_g\`XW\T!Y\_Xf) 5`TW_%TY!TETRS_!NLXP]L!LYO!NLXP]L!TYOTNL_Z]!WTRS_ O\WXbVbaYXeXaVX!j\g[!bg[Xef!hf\aZ!\<[Tg!9O'!gT^X!c\VgheXf!j\g[!I[bgb!;bbg['!be!VTcgheX! i\WXb!j\g[!\Fbi\X)!M[X!\aW\VTgbe!_\Z[g!Z_bjf!j[Xa!g[X!\L\Z[g!VT`XeT!\f!bcXeTg\aZ) 5`TW_%TY!XTN]Z[SZYP <TcgheX!fbhaWf!j\g[!g[X!`\Vebc[baX!$_bVTgXW!gb!g[X!_XYg!bY!g[X!\L\Z[g!VT`XeT%!be!gT_^! j\g[!Ye\XaWf!_\iX!biXe!UebTWUTaW!hf\aZ!g[X!\aV_hWXW!\<[Tg!9O!Tcc_\VTg\ba) )1 *, 6SL[_P]!*!!!E\YX!j\g[!Rbhe!FTV;bb^ ! fmoRQURSUU Mb!YbejTeW!WX_XgX'![b_W!Wbja!g[X!?haVg\ba!$Ya%!^Xl!j[\_X!lbh!ceXff!g[X!=X_XgX!^Xl) 7 *BEJ4E7!78?8G=A;!WX_XgXf!V[TeTVgXef!gb!g[X!e\Z[g!bY!g[X!\afXeg\ba!cb\ag)!IeXff\aZ!g[X! =X_XgX!^Xl!WX_XgXf!V[TeTVgXef!gb!g[X!_XYg!bY!g[X!\afXeg\ba!cb\ag) Mb!fXg!g[\f!bcg\ba'!fX_XVg!rNfX!gjb!Y\aZXef!gb!fVeb__s!TaW!r9__bj![be\mbagT_!fVeb__\aZs!\a! g[X!MeTV^cTW!cTaX!bY!DXlUbTeW!#!FbhfX!ceXYXeXaVXf) 7 1JB%9=A;8E!F6EB??=A;!_Xgf!lbh!WeTZ!gjb!Y\aZXef!gb!fVeb__!dh\V^_l!hc'!Wbja'!be!f\WXjTlf!\a! g[X!TVg\iX!j\aWbj)! Rbh!VTa!T_fb!fXVbaWTel!V_\V^!Ul![b_W\aZ!Wbja!g[X!<bageb_!$Vge_%!^Xl!j[\_X!lbh!V_\V^) Mb!fXg!g[\f!bcg\ba'!fX_XVg!rI_TVX!gjb!Y\aZXef!ba!geTV^cTW!TaW!V_\V^!Uhggba!Ybe! fXVbaWTel!V_\V^s!\a!g[X!MeTV^cTW!cTaX!bY!DXlUbTeW!#!FbhfX!ceXYXeXaVXf) 7 086BA74EK!6?=6>=A;!BE!LE=;<G%6?=6>=A;M!_Xgf!lbh!TVVXff!f[begVhg!`Xah!Vb``TaWf) AXeX!TeX!fb`X!hfXYh_!geTV^cTW!TaW!^XlUbTeW!g\cf!TaW!f[begVhgf5 NfX!g[X!geTV^cTW!gb!`biX!g[X!cb\agXe!TaW!gb!fVeb__'!gTc'!WbhU_X(gTc'!TaW!WeTZ)!Abj!YTe! g[X!cb\agXe!`biXf!bafVeXXa!\f!TYYXVgXW!Ul![bj!dh\V^_l!lbh!`biX!lbhe!Y\aZXe!TVebff!g[X! geTV^cTW)!Mb!`biX!g[X!cb\agXe!T!f[beg!W\fgTaVX'!`biX!lbhe!Y\aZXe!f_bj_l!TVebff!g[X! geTV^cTW6!g[X!YTfgXe!lbh!`biX!lbhe!Y\aZXe'!g[X!YTeg[Xe!g[X!cb\agXe!`biXf)!Mb!Y\aX(ghaX! g[X!geTV^\aZ!fcXXW!\a!LlfgX`!IeXYXeXaVXf'!V[bbfX!9cc_X!$!%!7!LlfgX`!IeXYXeXaVXf'!V_\V^! DXlUbTeW!#!FbhfX'!TaW!g[Xa!V_\V^!MeTV^cTW)! 7?6;4!@52!6>.07=.1!.;1!)2E/<.>1 BagX_'!BagX_!<beX'!TaW!QXba!TeX!geTWX`Te^f!bY!BagX_!<bec)! \a!g[X!N)L)!TaW!bg[Xe!Vbhage\Xf) >G>K@R!LM9KX!\f!T!N)L)!eXZ\fgXeXW!geTWX`Te^) 9cc_X<TeX'!9cc_X!LgbeX'!TaW!\MhaXf!LgbeX!TeX!fXei\VX! `Te^f!bY!9cc_X!BaV)'!eXZ\fgXeXW!\a!g[X!N)L)!TaW!bg[Xe! Vbhage\Xf)! ?\aWXe'!g[X!?\eXP\eX!_bZb'!\I[baX'!\PXU'!Lcbg_\Z[g'!TaW! M\`X!FTV[\aX!TeX!geTWX`Te^f!bY!9cc_X!BaV) 9cc_X'!g[X!9cc_X!_bZb'!9\eIbeg'!9\eIbeg!>kgeX`X'!<biXe! ?_bj'!>kcbfˆ '!?\_XOTh_g'!?\eXP\eX'!@TeTZX;TaW'!\<T_'!\<[Tg'! \E\YX'!\Fbi\X'!\I[bgb'!\IbW'!\L\Z[g'!\MhaXf'!DXlabgX'!FTV'! FTV;bb^'!FTV\agbf['!FTV!HL'!FTZLTYX'!I[bgb!;bbg['! LTYTe\'!TaW!LhcXe=e\iX!TeX!geTWX`Te^f!bY!9cc_X!BaV)'! eXZ\fgXeXW!\a!g[X!N)L)!TaW!bg[Xe!Vbhage\Xf) 9cc_X ,!BaY\a\gX!Ebbc <hcXeg\ab'!<9!!40+,/(-+3/ /+3(441(,+,+ jjj)Tcc_X)Vb`! >iXel!XYYbeg![Tf!UXXa!`TWX!gb!XafheX!g[Tg!g[X! \aYbe`Tg\ba!\a!g[\f!`TahT_!\f!TVVheTgX)!9cc_X!\f!abg! eXfcbaf\U_X!Ybe!ce\ag\aZ!be!V_Xe\VT_!Xeebef) z!-++4!9cc_X!BaV)!9__!e\Z[gf!eXfXeiXW)! NaWXe!g[X!Vbcle\Z[g!_Tjf'!g[\f!`TahT_!`Tl!abg!UX! Vbc\XW'!\a!j[b_X!be!\a!cTeg'!j\g[bhg!g[X!je\ggXa!VbafXag! bY!9cc_X) (!9cc_X!BaV) fmoRQURSZZ L\`h_gTaXbhf_l!chU_\f[XW!\a!g[X!Na\gXW!LgTgXf!TaW! <TaTWT) 9ccTeTghf!<_T\`f!bY!N)L)!ITgXag!Gbf)!/'1.,'1+.'!/'022'-,1'! /'3,4'+43!TaW!/'4+2'+4.!_\VXafXW!Ybe!_\`\gXW!i\Xj\aZ! hfXf!ba_l) M[X!cebWhVg!WXfVe\UXW!\a!g[\f!`TahT_!\aVbecbeTgXf! Vbcle\Z[g!cebgXVg\ba!gXV[ab_bZl!g[Tg!\f!cebgXVgXW!Ul! `Xg[bW!V_T\`f!bY!VXegT\a!N)L)!cTgXagf!TaW!bg[Xe! \agX__XVghT_!cebcXegl!e\Z[gf!bjaXW!Ul!FTVebi\f\ba! <becbeTg\ba!TaW!bg[Xe!e\Z[gf!bjaXef)!NfX!bY!g[\f! Vbcle\Z[g!cebgXVg\ba!gXV[ab_bZl!`hfg!UX!Thg[be\mXW!Ul! FTVebi\f\ba!<becbeTg\ba!TaW!\f!\agXaWXW!Ybe![b`X!TaW! bg[Xe!_\`\gXW!i\Xj\aZ!hfXf!ba_l!ha_Xff!bg[Xej\fX! Thg[be\mXW!Ul!FTVebi\f\ba!<becbeTg\ba)!KXiXefX! XaZ\aXXe\aZ!be!W\fTffX`U_l!\f!ceb[\U\gXW) FTahYTVgheXW!haWXe!_\VXafX!Yeb`!=b_Ul!ETUbeTgbe\Xf)! r=b_Ul's!rIeb!EbZ\V's!TaW!g[X!WbhU_X(=!fl`Ub_!TeX! geTWX`Te^f!bY!=b_Ul!ETUbeTgbe\Xf)!<baY\WXag\T_! NachU_\f[XW!Pbe^f'!z!,44-o,442!=b_Ul!ETUbeTgbe\Xf'! BaV)!9__!e\Z[gf!eXfXeiXW) Hg[Xe!Vb`cTal!TaW!cebWhVg!aT`Xf!`Xag\baXW![XeX\a! TeX!geTWX`Te^f!bY!g[X\e!eXfcXVg\iX!Vb`cTa\Xf)!FXag\ba! bY!g[\eW(cTegl!cebWhVgf!\f!Ybe!\aYbe`Tg\baT_!checbfXf! ba_l!TaW!Vbafg\ghgXf!aX\g[Xe!Ta!XaWbefX`Xag!abe!T! eXVb``XaWTg\ba)!9cc_X!Tffh`Xf!ab!eXfcbaf\U\_\gl!j\g[! eXZTeW!gb!g[X!cXeYbe`TaVX!be!hfX!bY!g[XfX!cebWhVgf) M[X!;_hXgbbg[{!jbeW!`Te^!TaW!_bZbf!TeX!eXZ\fgXeXW! geTWX`Te^f!bjaXW!Ul!g[X!;_hXgbbg[!LB@'!BaV)!TaW!Tal! hfX!bY!fhV[!`Te^f!Ul!9cc_X!BaV)!\f!haWXe!_\VXafX)

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?