Elan Microelectronics Corporation v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 214

Declaration of Jennifer Liu in Support of 212 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment of Infringement of U.S. Patent 5,875,352 [Public Version] MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment of Infringement of U.S. Patent 5,875,352 [Public Version] filed byElan Microelectronics Corporation. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3-6 MFN, # 4 Exhibit 7, # 5 Exhibit 8, # 6 Exhibit 9, # 7 Exhibit 10, # 8 Exhibit 11, # 9 Exhibit 12, # 10 Exhibit 13, # 11 Exhibit 14, # 12 Exhibit 15, # 13 Exhibit 16, # 14 Exhibit 17, # 15 Exhibit 18, # 16 Exhibit 19, # 17 Exhibit 20, # 18 Exhibit 21, # 19 Exhibit 22, # 20 Exhibit 23-25 MFN, # 21 Exhibit 26, # 22 Exhibit 27 MFN, # 23 Exhibit 28, # 24 Exhibit 29-33 MFN, # 25 Exhibit 34, # 26 Exhibit 35-37 MFN, # 27 Exhibit 38 Part 1, # 28 Exhibit 38 Part 2, # 29 Exhibit 38 Part 3, # 30 Exhibit 39-45 MFN, # 31 Exhibit 46, # 32 Exhibit 47 MFN, # 33 Exhibit 48)(Related document(s) 212 ) (Liu, Jennifer) (Filed on 5/24/2011)

EXHIBIT 17

!

fmoRQURSSR

6ZYR]L_`WL_TZY^$!dZ`!LYO!dZ`]!@LN5ZZV
bP]P!XLOP!QZ]!PLNS!Z_SP]&

!

3

fmoRQURSTZ

6SL[_P]!*!!!E\YX!j\g[!Rbhe!FTV;bb^

CZbP]!M`__ZY
Mhea!lbhe!FTV;bb^!ba!be!bYY'!be!chg!\g!gb!f_XXc)!Ab_W!Wbja!gb!eXfgTeg!lbhe!FTV;bb^!
Whe\aZ!gebhU_Xf[bbg\aZ)

EWZ_%WZLOTYR!E`[P]7]TaP
Rbhe!bcg\VT_!We\iX!VTa!eXTW!TaW!je\gX!gb!fgTaWTeW(f\mX!<=!TaW!=O=!W\fVf)

=YQ]L]PO!"=D#!]PNPTaP]
NfX!Ta!bcg\baT_!9cc_X!KX`bgX!$fb_W!fXcTeTgX_l!Tg!jjj)Tcc_X)Vb`*fgbeX%!j\g[!g[X!BK!
eXVX\iXe!gb!Vbageb_!?ebag!Kbj!TaW!DXlabgX!ba!lbhe!FTV;bb^!Yeb`!hc!gb!.+!YXXg!$4),!
`XgXef%!TjTl)!

EWPP[!TYOTNL_Z]!WTRS_
9!j[\gX!_\Z[g!ch_fXf!j[Xa!g[X!FTV;bb^!\f!\a!f_XXc)

F]LNV[LO!LYO!_]LNV[LO!M`__ZY
FbiX!g[X!cb\agXe!j\g[!baX!Y\aZXe!ba!g[X!geTV^cTW'!be!fVeb__!j\g[!gjb!Y\aZXef)!MTc!g[X!
geTV^cTW!gb!V_\V^!be!WbhU_X(V_\V^!T!fX_XVg\ba)

5L__P]d
Kha!g[X!FTV;bb^!hf\aZ!UTggXel!cbjXe!j[Xa!lbh!TeX!TjTl!Yeb`!T!cbjXe!bhg_Xg)!
KX`bi\aZ!g[X!UTggXel!Z\iXf!lbh!TVVXff!gb!g[X!`X`bel!\a!lbhe!FTV;bb^)

5`TW_%TY!^_P]PZ!^[PLVP]^
E\fgXa!gb!`hf\V'!`bi\Xf'!ZT`Xf'!TaW!`h_g\`XW\T!Y\_Xf)

5`TW_%TY!TETRS_!NLXP]L!LYO!NLXP]L!TYOTNL_Z]!WTRS_
O\WXbVbaYXeXaVX!j\g[!bg[Xef!hf\aZ!\<[Tg!9O'!gT^X!c\VgheXf!j\g[!I[bgb!;bbg['!be!VTcgheX!
i\WXb!j\g[!\Fbi\X)!M[X!\aW\VTgbe!_\Z[g!Z_bjf!j[Xa!g[X!\L\Z[g!VT`XeT!\f!bcXeTg\aZ)

5`TW_%TY!XTN]Z[SZYP
<TcgheX!fbhaWf!j\g[!g[X!`\Vebc[baX!$_bVTgXW!gb!g[X!_XYg!bY!g[X!\L\Z[g!VT`XeT%!be!gT_^!
j\g[!Ye\XaWf!_\iX!biXe!UebTWUTaW!hf\aZ!g[X!\aV_hWXW!\<[Tg!9O!Tcc_\VTg\ba)

)1

*,

6SL[_P]!*!!!E\YX!j\g[!Rbhe!FTV;bb^

!

fmoRQURSUU

Mb!YbejTeW!WX_XgX'![b_W!Wbja!g[X!?haVg\ba!$Ya%!^Xl!j[\_X!lbh!ceXff!g[X!=X_XgX!^Xl)

7 *BEJ4E7!78?8G=A;!WX_XgXf!V[TeTVgXef!gb!g[X!e\Z[g!bY!g[X!\afXeg\ba!cb\ag)!IeXff\aZ!g[X!
=X_XgX!^Xl!WX_XgXf!V[TeTVgXef!gb!g[X!_XYg!bY!g[X!\afXeg\ba!cb\ag)

Mb!fXg!g[\f!bcg\ba'!fX_XVg!rNfX!gjb!Y\aZXef!gb!fVeb__s!TaW!r9__bj![be\mbagT_!fVeb__\aZs!\a!
g[X!MeTV^cTW!cTaX!bY!DXlUbTeW!#!FbhfX!ceXYXeXaVXf)

7 1JB%9=A;8E!F6EB??=A;!_Xgf!lbh!WeTZ!gjb!Y\aZXef!gb!fVeb__!dh\V^_l!hc'!Wbja'!be!f\WXjTlf!\a!
g[X!TVg\iX!j\aWbj)!

Rbh!VTa!T_fb!fXVbaWTel!V_\V^!Ul![b_W\aZ!Wbja!g[X!<bageb_!$Vge_%!^Xl!j[\_X!lbh!V_\V^)

Mb!fXg!g[\f!bcg\ba'!fX_XVg!rI_TVX!gjb!Y\aZXef!ba!geTV^cTW!TaW!V_\V^!Uhggba!Ybe!
fXVbaWTel!V_\V^s!\a!g[X!MeTV^cTW!cTaX!bY!DXlUbTeW!#!FbhfX!ceXYXeXaVXf)

7 086BA74EK!6?=6>=A;!BE!LE=;<G%6?=6>=A;M!_Xgf!lbh!TVVXff!f[begVhg!`Xah!Vb``TaWf)

AXeX!TeX!fb`X!hfXYh_!geTV^cTW!TaW!^XlUbTeW!g\cf!TaW!f[begVhgf5

NfX!g[X!geTV^cTW!gb!`biX!g[X!cb\agXe!TaW!gb!fVeb__'!gTc'!WbhU_X(gTc'!TaW!WeTZ)!Abj!YTe!
g[X!cb\agXe!`biXf!bafVeXXa!\f!TYYXVgXW!Ul![bj!dh\V^_l!lbh!`biX!lbhe!Y\aZXe!TVebff!g[X!
geTV^cTW)!Mb!`biX!g[X!cb\agXe!T!f[beg!W\fgTaVX'!`biX!lbhe!Y\aZXe!f_bj_l!TVebff!g[X!
geTV^cTW6!g[X!YTfgXe!lbh!`biX!lbhe!Y\aZXe'!g[X!YTeg[Xe!g[X!cb\agXe!`biXf)!Mb!Y\aX(ghaX!
g[X!geTV^\aZ!fcXXW!\a!LlfgX`!IeXYXeXaVXf'!V[bbfX!9cc_X!$!%!7!LlfgX`!IeXYXeXaVXf'!V_\V^!
DXlUbTeW!#!FbhfX'!TaW!g[Xa!V_\V^!MeTV^cTW)!

7?6;4!@52!6>.07=.1!.;1!)2E/<.>1

BagX_'!BagX_!<beX'!TaW!QXba!TeX!geTWX`Te^f!bY!BagX_!<bec)!
\a!g[X!N)L)!TaW!bg[Xe!Vbhage\Xf)

>G>K@R!LM9KX!\f!T!N)L)!eXZ\fgXeXW!geTWX`Te^)

9cc_X<TeX'!9cc_X!LgbeX'!TaW!\MhaXf!LgbeX!TeX!fXei\VX!
`Te^f!bY!9cc_X!BaV)'!eXZ\fgXeXW!\a!g[X!N)L)!TaW!bg[Xe!
Vbhage\Xf)!

?\aWXe'!g[X!?\eXP\eX!_bZb'!\I[baX'!\PXU'!Lcbg_\Z[g'!TaW!
M\`X!FTV[\aX!TeX!geTWX`Te^f!bY!9cc_X!BaV)

9cc_X'!g[X!9cc_X!_bZb'!9\eIbeg'!9\eIbeg!>kgeX`X'!<biXe!
?_bj'!>kcbfˆ '!?\_XOTh_g'!?\eXP\eX'!@TeTZX;TaW'!\<T_'!\<[Tg'!
\E\YX'!\Fbi\X'!\I[bgb'!\IbW'!\L\Z[g'!\MhaXf'!DXlabgX'!FTV'!
FTV;bb^'!FTV\agbf['!FTV!HL'!FTZLTYX'!I[bgb!;bbg['!
LTYTe\'!TaW!LhcXe=e\iX!TeX!geTWX`Te^f!bY!9cc_X!BaV)'!
eXZ\fgXeXW!\a!g[X!N)L)!TaW!bg[Xe!Vbhage\Xf)

9cc_X
,!BaY\a\gX!Ebbc
<hcXeg\ab'!<9!!40+,/(-+3/
/+3(441(,+,+
jjj)Tcc_X)Vb`!

>iXel!XYYbeg![Tf!UXXa!`TWX!gb!XafheX!g[Tg!g[X!
\aYbe`Tg\ba!\a!g[\f!`TahT_!\f!TVVheTgX)!9cc_X!\f!abg!
eXfcbaf\U_X!Ybe!ce\ag\aZ!be!V_Xe\VT_!Xeebef)

z!-++4!9cc_X!BaV)!9__!e\Z[gf!eXfXeiXW)!
NaWXe!g[X!Vbcle\Z[g!_Tjf'!g[\f!`TahT_!`Tl!abg!UX!
Vbc\XW'!\a!j[b_X!be!\a!cTeg'!j\g[bhg!g[X!je\ggXa!VbafXag!
bY!9cc_X)

(!9cc_X!BaV)

fmoRQURSZZ

L\`h_gTaXbhf_l!chU_\f[XW!\a!g[X!Na\gXW!LgTgXf!TaW!
<TaTWT)

9ccTeTghf!<_T\`f!bY!N)L)!ITgXag!Gbf)!/'1.,'1+.'!/'022'-,1'!
/'3,4'+43!TaW!/'4+2'+4.!_\VXafXW!Ybe!_\`\gXW!i\Xj\aZ!
hfXf!ba_l)

M[X!cebWhVg!WXfVe\UXW!\a!g[\f!`TahT_!\aVbecbeTgXf!
Vbcle\Z[g!cebgXVg\ba!gXV[ab_bZl!g[Tg!\f!cebgXVgXW!Ul!
`Xg[bW!V_T\`f!bY!VXegT\a!N)L)!cTgXagf!TaW!bg[Xe!
\agX__XVghT_!cebcXegl!e\Z[gf!bjaXW!Ul!FTVebi\f\ba!
<becbeTg\ba!TaW!bg[Xe!e\Z[gf!bjaXef)!NfX!bY!g[\f!
Vbcle\Z[g!cebgXVg\ba!gXV[ab_bZl!`hfg!UX!Thg[be\mXW!Ul!
FTVebi\f\ba!<becbeTg\ba!TaW!\f!\agXaWXW!Ybe![b`X!TaW!
bg[Xe!_\`\gXW!i\Xj\aZ!hfXf!ba_l!ha_Xff!bg[Xej\fX!
Thg[be\mXW!Ul!FTVebi\f\ba!<becbeTg\ba)!KXiXefX!
XaZ\aXXe\aZ!be!W\fTffX`U_l!\f!ceb[\U\gXW)

FTahYTVgheXW!haWXe!_\VXafX!Yeb`!=b_Ul!ETUbeTgbe\Xf)!
r=b_Ul's!rIeb!EbZ\V's!TaW!g[X!WbhU_X(=!fl`Ub_!TeX!
geTWX`Te^f!bY!=b_Ul!ETUbeTgbe\Xf)!<baY\WXag\T_!
NachU_\f[XW!Pbe^f'!z!,44-o,442!=b_Ul!ETUbeTgbe\Xf'!
BaV)!9__!e\Z[gf!eXfXeiXW)

Hg[Xe!Vb`cTal!TaW!cebWhVg!aT`Xf!`Xag\baXW![XeX\a!
TeX!geTWX`Te^f!bY!g[X\e!eXfcXVg\iX!Vb`cTa\Xf)!FXag\ba!
bY!g[\eW(cTegl!cebWhVgf!\f!Ybe!\aYbe`Tg\baT_!checbfXf!
ba_l!TaW!Vbafg\ghgXf!aX\g[Xe!Ta!XaWbefX`Xag!abe!T!
eXVb``XaWTg\ba)!9cc_X!Tffh`Xf!ab!eXfcbaf\U\_\gl!j\g[!
eXZTeW!gb!g[X!cXeYbe`TaVX!be!hfX!bY!g[XfX!cebWhVgf)

M[X!;_hXgbbg[{!jbeW!`Te^!TaW!_bZbf!TeX!eXZ\fgXeXW!
geTWX`Te^f!bjaXW!Ul!g[X!;_hXgbbg[!LB@'!BaV)!TaW!Tal!
hfX!bY!fhV[!`Te^f!Ul!9cc_X!BaV)!\f!haWXe!_\VXafX)