Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al
Filing
1129
MOTION for Reconsideration re 1115 Order on Motion for Miscellaneous Relief,,,,,, #1105 Order on Administrative Motion to File Under Seal,,,,,,,,, filed by Samsung Electronics America, Inc.(a New York corporation), Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd., Samsung Telecommunications America, LLC(a Delaware limited liability company). (Attachments: #1 Exhibit to Samsung's Motion, #2 Declaration of Hankil Kang in Support of Samsung's Motion, #3 Exhibit 1 to the Kang Declaration, #4 Exhibit 2 to the Kang Declaration, #5 Exhibit 3 to the Kang Declaration, #6 Exhibit 4 to the Kang Declaration, #7 Exhibit 5 to the Kang Declaration, #8 Exhibit 6 to the Kang Declaration, #9 Exhibit 7 to the Kang Declaration, #10 Exhibit 8 to the Kang Declaration, #11 Exhibit 9 to the Kang Declaration, #12 Exhibit 10 to the Kang Declaration, #13 Exhibit 11 to the Kang Declaration, #14 Exhibit 12 to the Kang Declaration, #15 Exhibit 13 to the Kang Declaration, #16 Exhibit 14 to the Kang Declaration, #17 Exhibit 15 to the Kang Declaration, #18 Exhibit 16 to the Kang Declaration, #19 Exhibit 17 to the Kang Declaration, #20 Proposed Order Granting Samsung's Motion for Reconsideration)(Maroulis, Victoria) (Filed on 6/25/2012)
KANG DECLARATION
EXHIBIT 16
EXHIBIT 18
FILED UNDER SEAL
Confidential
VZWA"SCH-i905(P4_LTE)"
Market Requirement Document
0 1 01_
,= ,_
N Al-
;-1
.
Electronic Approval
Product Planning
XH
Kihwan Suh
Junho Park
Group
AMSIIN
2011. 03. 31.
Product Planning Group
SAMSUNG CONFIDENTIAL
[ Product Planning Group ]
I. Product Overview
Confidential
1. Project Name : P4_LTE
2. Concept : Android Tablet
3. Target Launch : Jun. '11 (TA: May)
4. Target Positioning: Wholesale:
5. Current Material Cost
6. Target Market : North America
7. Target Carrier : VZW
8. Target Segment : Mobile Pioneer
9. Project Level : Basic
10. Backbone : N/A
11. Industrial Design
12. Project Concept & Main features
- Iconic Design
- Fully Interactive PC-like experience with Honeycomb
a) Design
- Solid & Compact in 256.6 x 175.3 x 8.6mm
©User Experience
- Android Honeycomb Google Experienced Device
- Network: LTE, WiFi (802.11 a/b/g/n)
- Chipset: nVidia T20 + CMC220 + VIA7.1
- Display: 10.1" WXGA TFT, Capacitive type
- Camera: 3MP AF + 2MP VT
- Memory: 16GB iNand + 1GB LPDDR
- Sensor: Accelerometer, Light, Compass, Gyro
- USB 2.0 HS, BT 2.1+EDR, 3.5mm Standard
Headset
13. Basic Package(Small sized Eco Packaging)
Device, MTA , Data Cable, QRG
SAMSUNG CONFIDENTIAL
Verizon Reality2
[ Product Planning Group ]
2
II. Product Concept & Sales Point
1. STP Strategy (1/2)
Mobile pioneers
I
Tech enthusiasts
Business
Priggaii0116
_
Confidential
= = = _
_
=
=
_
clia_trib e
Expressionist
Value maximizers
Voice-centric
Simplicity seekers
,
=*
I
liFrintaiRS
*
1114
I i tiJ
,
..
et r
' ),
,
I.
4..z-
■
01
..... :
II
12%
6%
•26-35yrs 41%
49%
12%
14%
8%
16%
12%
20%
• 36-45 yrs 27%
• 46-55 yrs 35%
•13-18yrs 11%
•19-25 yrs 23%
•26-35 yrs 38%
•13-18yrs 29%
•19-25 yrs 27%
•26-35yrs 24%
•36-45 yrs 24%
•46-55 yrs 32%
•46-55 yrs 35%
•56-65 yrs 26%
•46-55 yrs 30%
•56-65 yrs 33%
•Male 69%
s 31%
•Male 54%
•Female 55%
•Female 68%
•Female 58%
•Female 61%
0
E
•Male 67%
•A quintessential
part of my life
everyday, and it is
my connection to
the world
ation
•Re
of my
sophisticated
taste and
enthusiasm for
technology
•An essential tool
to increase work
efficiency
•Social center
to stay closely
with my
relationship
and share
experience
•A tool to
express my
unique style &
interests
• A utility tool
that helps me
through the
day
•A simple &
reliable tool to
communicate
with close
relationship
•An emergency
tool to be
reachable
•Core techie &
lead user
•Want to catch
up with newest
trend to be
cool
•Typical
business
person
looking for
productivity
•Socially active
& extrovert
• Phone is self
expression
• Family
centric
• Want simple &
UI & design
• Has multi
layered
relationship
• Personal
customization of
UI and exterior to
be unique
•Want value
for quality
• SMS and voice
are main usage
• Primary usage
is call
reception
usually in case
of urgency
• Utilize all the
key functions
& features
that think
practical
• Reliable core
functions/
features
• Tech
aversive
•Web addicted
(Always
connected)
Cn
0
0
•S/w, H/w
upgrade for
performance
optimization
•Love for latest
technology
•Phone =Status
symbol
(in particular while
on-the go)
0
0
• Heavy
messaging &
SNS
•Small in
numbers but
deep social
circle
•Highly price
sensitive
cri
N.)
N.)
O
O
cia
SAMSUNG CONFIDENTIAL
Verizon Reality2
[ Product Planning Group ]
3
II. Product Concept & Sales Point
1. STP Strategy (2/2)
Confidential
Mobile Pioneers (6%) - lifestyle and personality
I LOVE
I have a active and exciting life. I am an online
shopper, a blogger, a video gamer, a movie junkie,
and a sports enthusiast.
I AM
PERSONALITY
49%
Leader
I love the power that technology gives me. I can
really improve my life. I always adopt new
technology when it's first released.
Brand Style
Early Adopter
87%
I am a tech geek and an expert. I'm only
impressed by genuine innovation and
improvement.
Extrovert
Price Conscious _39%
-90% -60% -30% 0%
30% 60% 90%
* % deviation from the average
ENTERTAINMENT & NEW MEDIA USE (across all platforms)
Listen to music
SAMSUNG CONFIDENTIAL
Verizon Reality2
20%
30%
64%
28%
79%
33%
Everyday
X1 /week
0%
64%
Everyday
X1/week
Use SNS
47%
74%
36%
Everyday
X1 /week
Use IM
77%
r veryday
X1/week
Play games
Market % of
everyday
Everyday
X1 /week
View/Take photo
or video
% of
everyday
40%
60%
80%
1 00%
[ Product Planning Group ]
4
II. Product Concept & Sales Point -1.
Product Concept Development
Confidential
"Android Honeycomb Tablet"
Honeycomb, Dedicated Android version for Tablet
Massive Google Contents & Mobile Services
"Optimized Device for Multimedia"
Dual Core CPU : PC-like powerful multitasking
Maximized view experience (10.1" WXGA)
HoneycombE Tablet I
Light & Compact design(8.6mm thicknesS)
"World First LTE 10.1"
High Speed LTE connectivity
Fastest wireless connection
SAMSUNG CONFIDENTIAL
Dual Band
(2.4G + 5G)
Lte
50Mbps
[ Product Planning Group ]
5
II. Sales Point -
Confidential
Design
Design Concept
Weight
• Lighter ever (590g)
Dynamic & Tension Design and Ergonomic Comfortable Grip
Slim & Light for Portability
No front H/W keys for giving 4 way rotating usages
(Only Power & Volume keys on left top side)
Wide & Large Touch Display : 10.1" WXGA (1280x800) TFT
Dimension
• Wider view with compact size
< Thickness : P4 vs iPad >
Other Facts
Thickness
8.6mm
8.8mm
• Dual speaker for Stereo sound
• No front Hard key for 4 way use
A
< iPad2 >
E
241.2 mm
SAIVi3UNC C0NF:DENT:AL
8.8mm
256.6mm
8.6 mm
Prc,duct Planning Crcup
II. Sales Point - Android Honeycomb
Android Honeycomb Tablet
- Honeycomb, Android Tablet version with dedicated Tablet UX
. Tablet Home Screen
. Split screen etc
SAMSUNG CONFIDENTIAL
[ Product Planning Group ]
7
II. Sales Point -
aVflEiMig-
Chipset
"Faster Web & Advance Services "
"Powerful Chipset "
• 30% faster speed than single core
• Faster Web experience
< Elipse Time (ms) >
Tegra 250
< Web Loading Time >
Sites
Rate
1.5 sec
1.1 sec
27%
6.6 sec
4.2 sec
36%
Youtube
C110
(1GHz)
T20 1GHx2
Yahoo
-
.
C110 1GHz
Google
as vec
9 5S
(1GEL*2)
4.7 sec
3.5 sec
26%
*P101,9 79 DMC
10000 15000 20000
R--2
SunSpider Java script benchmark
('109 79 DMC R-^0
• Dual core efficiently executes multi-threading
• Faster and More power effective
< Power Efficiency >
< Split Screen with Multi Threading >
137
240
219m
2/0
200
Power Effi.
mW/GBps
1 92mW
10.=.
1.1.11Olins
Power
180
60
160
mDDP.
LPDDR
< Augmented Reality with additional information >
< Spec, mDDR vs LPDDR>
V1-1-
mDDR (iPad)
LPDDR (P3)
CLK Freq.
-200MHz
-400MHz
Bandwidth
-1.6GB/s
-3.2GB/s
Clock Speed of LPDDR2 for P3_LTE is 300MHz
SAMSUNG CONFIDENTIAL
j
0=1
Memory AM' ZFz ('100 109)
[ Product Planning Group ]
8
II. Sales Point -
aVflEiMiWIL
Display & Others
Best viewing experience ever
- Wide view with high resolution (1280x800)
1/ Easy and fast way to use
- 10 Finger Multi-touch for
More Creative game scenario
Exclusive theme of application
- Fast, Clear, Less Power with PLS TFT LCD
PLS
VA
TN
Viewing Angle
GOOD
NORMAL
BAD
Contrast Ratio
800:1
900:1
500:1
Black
t o White
20ms
15ms
30ms
Grey
to Grey
25ms
80ms
55ms
320mW
367mW
Communicate with any devices
350mW
Response
Time
BLU Power Consumption
(Test w/ 3" WVGA)
- USB On The Go enables any connection
with USB devices
''1(:.A 8D H/W Platform
SAMSUNG CONFIDENTIAL
[ Pronict Planning Group ]
•
9
II. Sales Point -
Confidential
Seamless Connection
0
0
0
ST)
.
53
Advanced Network Service
"Fast data transfer speeds
CD
%.<
m
* Based on LTE 50M1.42__
Based on HSDPA 21Mbps
Ill. Product Realization Plan
1. Project Schedule
Confidential
9 010
Dec
Design
9011
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Product
Planning
4
N;- .D=.
MRD
►
IOT
Standard
Approval
3/7 - 4/22
FC".; /CTIA
SIL J
DV
DV
W15(L/11)
-
4/LL
MR
W15(4/15)
PV
.1DVR
W13(3/29-)
PV
W17(4/30)
PiRic
PR
TA
wi9(5/9)
TA
W20(5/2))
0
Shipment
Launch
W2015/201
SAMSUNG CONFIDENTIAL
SRA
W9:11R/R1
[ Product Planning Group ]
11
III. Product Realization Plan
Confidential
3. Project Members
al-glE1
LH El
1= 1
7g
A-1711- 1- EHEI
EH
AF 1=1
o
nablin
01, ,1:1H
3
11] El,
011,&!
[Hal
?=1(1111
1
kl 1 0=1
A-1
PL
HIW
S/VV
-25;a1. I AF=
1:1H ^
A-I
= 1.1
gcg; Lab.
gi TT EH g
7=1 df
—SE
, 01 1,T41Ls-1
62
°MITT Lig
-2E` )
4,
Acr:›1-m
l=
o
21=11
7,1
,
0120=1 A-101
,
x-I Ell
JI_A-1 A-101 , HOI,
2
a
-
=, gl
,
01 g )4 21
SAMSUNG CONFIDENTIAL
2* H/W
SAN
-
2.1
P! 21
01 TT,
,s,1 AH 01
21
1 11-
o
01 g W
01
,21 LI- LH P-1
XH
-
g
71E1.1A I JA- 1=
UX
3
=
g, LE
--A- --A- A-I
CS g
01
A F
-
2
LE,- ER
4
g '1 LH
1
(
3[01
O[gl
[Product Planning Group ]
12
Highly Confidential - Attorneys' Eyes Only
SAMNDCA00522013
I. Product Specification
1. F1/1/1/ Specification
Description
Category
B/B Chipset
Category
VIA CBP 7.1
WiFi 802.11 a/b/g/n (2.4GHz & 5GHz)
Connectivity
Standard
BT v2.1
USB 2.0 High Speed
EVDO Rev A, LTE
IF Connector
RF Band
Description
30 pin connector
CDMA/PCS(800MHz/1900MHz), LTE(700MHz)
. Size
Additional Chip
Dual Core T20 (1GHz x 2)
Dimension
10.1" WXGA TFT LCD (PLS type)
Camera
3MP AF , 2MP FF
Flash
Memory
LED Flash
Ex. Memory
CMF
VPS
Sliding Type, 3V Only
Battery
Li-pol 6800 mAh (LH g c$100,000(31%)
36-45
(30% )
26-35
(41%)
By value
11°A
0% 10% 20% 30%
GENDER
Female
(33%)
Male
(67% )
$50,000
-$99,000(46%)
$30,000
-$49,999(15%)
Mobile Pioneers (6%) - product & service needs
Innovative new phones & services that push the limit on existing technology
HIGHLIGHTS
Mobile addicted (Always connected) & Big data spenders
Owns a smart phone
Internet usage via mobile
phone (more than once per
day)
Mobile streaming
(more than once per
day)
84%
75.4%
54.1%
(av 23%)
(av 25.2%)
Monthly spend for media,
games, and apps.
(av 12.8%)
Sync the phone with other
devices everyday
$34.2
39%
Per month
(av $7.2 per mth)
(ay. 7%))
CURRENT USE OF SERVICE AND FEATURE
Heavy monthly service spend. Largest segment of data plan subscribers. Highest smart phone ownership.
SERVICE
Post-paid
92% (av 86%)
Monthly spend
$103 (av $89)
Voice 300min+
78% (av 56%)
Touch
> 6 SMS/MMS a day
71% (av 42%)
Qwerty
Unlimited data plan
100% (av 27%)
Touch&Qwerty
CURRENT
PHONE
Multiple phone
54% (av 32%)
Smart phone
3844 (av 3
%% (av 130/) (inc, iPhone 15%)
v 30%)
34% (av 27%)
30% (av 14%)
Mobile Pioneers (6%) - lifestyle and personality
I have an active life filled with excitement and entertainment. I hunt down the newest
technology and must always be connected to the digital world
I AM
I LOVE
I have a active and exciting life. I am an online
shopper, a blogger, a video gamer, a movie
junkie, and a sports enthusiast.
PERSONALITY
49%
Leader
I love the power that technology gives me. I
can really improve my life. I always adopt new
technology when it's first released.
Brand Style
Early Adopter
87%
I am a tech geek and an expert. I'm only
impressed by genuine innovation and
improvement.
Extrovert
Price Conscious _39%
-90% -60% -30% 0%
30% 60% 90%
* % deviation from the average
ENTERTAINMENT & NEW MEDIA USE (across all platforms)
Listen to music
20%
30%
64%
28%
79%
33%
Everyday
X1/week
0%
64%
Everyday
X1/week
Use SNS
47%
74%
36%
Everyday
X1/week
Use IM
77%
everyday
X1/week
Play games
Market % of
everyday
Ever da
X1/week
View/Take photo
or video
% of
everyday
40%
60%
80%
1 00%
Mobile Pioneers (6%) - detailed usage & attitude
I constantly communicate and get information through phone. I love the infinite adaptability to
expand the phone's feathers through using apps
MY CURRENT PHONE
Smart phone: 84% (av 23%)
WiFi: 95% (av 72%)
Multi SIMs: 36% (av 17%)
WHAT I DO WITH MY PHONE TODAY
Qwerty: 34% (ay. 27%)
Touch :33% (av13%)
Touch&Qwerty: 30% (av 14%)
2-3 MP: 54% (av 33%)
5-8 MP or above: 31% (av 9%)
Avg.
Voice min/mth
O
a
BRAND
7% 8%3%
LG (av 21%)
25%
43%
SMS/day 1 0
I
Emails sent/day I
0
Use IM I
—= Nokia (av 8%)
Samsung (av 20%)
120-300
Others (av 19%)3
Motorola (av 18%)
SNS(update status))
SNS(upload content) I
301 - 600
1-2
3 - 5
600 - 1200
11 - 20
6 - 10
1-2
21 -40
11 - 20
6 - 10
3 - 5
>1200
Market Av.
617mins
466 mins
16.71
11
11 79
>40
21-40
2 64
hi. everyday
62..3%
Mkt avg % everyday
Everyday
Everyday
63.9%
18.1%
Everyday
42.6%
11.2%
X1/week
Xl/week
X1/week
29.8°/0
Blackberry (av 14%)
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Music
X1/week
4:
1
MY PHONE MEANS
42%
Convergent devices
Internet
User Interface 15% (av 13%)
>
49.2%
13.8%
Everyday
54.1%
12.8%
75.4%
25.2%
36.1%
7.7%
Everyday
52.5%
24.0%
Everyday
62.3%
17.1%
50.8%
11.4%
Everyday
X1/week
Everyday
X1/week
Manage calendars
Productivity Function 9% (av 4%) 8
48%
Work email
.u
=
-
-1%
0_
40%
X1/week
a
0
c
a
-0
80%
20%
App. 4 . 35
download per month
-cs
0%
X1/week
0%
42%
Business necessity
X1/week
Doc view/edit
Expandable Functionality 6% (av
2%)
6%
Basic comm tool
-40%
22.4%
19%
Fashion/Status symbol
-80%
X1/week
Data Speed & Access 25% (av 9%)
Advanced social comm.
Emergency Calls only
X1/week
GPS
4%
Freedom and Security
Games
Streaming
19.5%
50.8%
Everyday
X1/week
E
0
KEY BUYING
FACTORS
68.9%
Everyday
Everyday
Photo/video viewing
s
Fveryday
40%
60%
App. Multimdia 36%
choice Infotnmnt 36%
80%
100%
Spending on media,
games and apps
$34.2
per month
Content HIGH
>
>1/week
Sync ..
96% (av 28%) sharing 19% (av 10%)
a
COMMERCIAL
Monthly Spend
HIGH $
103 (av $90)
Willingness to pay
HIGH (> $190)
% Post Pay
% bill spent on data
HIGH 92% (av 86%)
HIGH 27% (av 10%)
Replacement Frequency
More than 1 handset
HIGH
15mth (av 23mth)
HIGH 54%
(CHANNEL
31%
20%
26%
Gn. Electronic store (5%)
Network Store (49%)
Netwrk website (16%). Gn Retail store (5%)
Other (6%)
specialty store(14%)
3°
(av 32%)
Operator store (6%)
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
* NOTE:
I Tie
shows average across all segments
Mobile Pioneers (6%) - detailed needs & preferences
Full-featured smart phone with the best technology and the coolest design.
FEATURE NEEDS
MY NEXT PHONE SHOULD BE
The best technology and newest features
HIGH
The latest and coolest design
HIGH
Price as the driving factor in purchase
LOW I
HARDWARE NEEDS
67%
I 40%
Window Mobile 25% (av 17%)
INPUT METHOD
Large and vivid screens
AVG
Full touch experience
HIGH
89%
Long battery life
AVG
89%
Wi-Fi as internet connection
HIGH
901
Built-in GPs
HIGH
Bluetooth
Blackberry OS 38% (av 16%)
Screen
GPS/Nay.
Smartphone 93% (av 55%)
HIGH
Battery
OPERATING SYSTEM
Large storage for multimedia
Wi Fi
TYPE
50%
HIGH
Full touch
25%
Built-in high resolution camera
Storage
23%
0%
Bluetooth connectivity
HIGH
Eco Friendly
'Green' handset made of
recyclable materials
HIGH
-
Touch 18% (av 21%)
Qwerty 34% (av 27%)
Touch & Qwerty 36%(ay.41 %)
BRAND
Motorola (av 12%)
AppleiPhone(av15%)
LG (av15/o)
36%
8%
20%
82%
84%
77%
66%
Blackberry (av 16%)
Samsung (av 11%)
Others (av 23%)
Nokia (av 8%)
0%
89%I
Apple OS 18% (av 11%)
Traditional (12 keys): 0% (av 11%)
2w" .°A1 0%
82%
Camera
60%
80%
Music
100%
DESIGN
Listen to music on phone
Select and stream content on
phone
50%
75%
100%
82 04
HIGH
Movies/video
40%
25%
0%
SOFTWARE NEEDS
HIGH
I 79 %
1q0%
APPEARANCE
CHROMATIC COLORS
Games
Play games online/offline
HIGH
Tough or waterproof 84% (av 83%)
Easy to carry 85% (av 89%)
Has a case, clip for easy transport and access
72% (av 56%)
Navy blue 45%
(av 37%)
Internet
High speed data capability
e.g. HSDPA
HIG
Expandable functionality through
HIGH
I 89%
SNS
SNS on mobile, allowing realtime updates
HIGH
184%
IM
IM on mobile
HIGH
Email
Easy to use, PC-like email
experience
Transportation
Buy or recharge my tickets on
public transportation
Aqua Blue 23%
(av 23%)
NEUTRAL COLORS
Black 75% (ay. 66%)
Silver 8% (ay. 16%)
Gray 10% (ay. 12%)
White 7% (ay. 6%)
Red 23%
(av 19%)
0%
*
on I
lig
Ii
iig n
i
doll
Apps download aps
NOTE:
89% I
77%1
82% 1
I
59 %
25%
50%
75%
100%
I ine shows average across all segments
VI. Competitiveness Analysis
P 4 LTE
i-Ra d2
Launch
'11 Jun
'11 Mar
Price(T/P)
LTE : 16GB($629)
AP
nVidia T20 (Cortex A9 1GHz x 2)
A5 (Cortex A9 1GHz)
Dimension
256.6 X 175.3 X 8.6mm, 599g(TBD)
241.2 x 185.7 x 8.8 mm
WiFi+3G (607g), WiFi (601g)
Band
CDMA 900/1800
LTE 700MHz Upper C Band
CDMA 900/1800
LCD
10.1" WXGA (1280x800) (PLS)
9.7" XGA (1024x768) (IPS)
Camera + Flash
3MP AF /w Flash, 2MP FF
Front & Rear Cam(VGA)
Battery
6800 mAh (25W, 3.7V)
25W, 3.7V
Memory
. RAM : 1GB LPDDR2
. ROM : 16(Default)/32GB iNand
. RAM : 512MB DRAM
. ROM : 16/32/64GB Nand
Connectivity
WiFi a/b/g/n, BT2.1+EDR, GPS, USB2.0 HS
WiFi a/b/g/n, BT2.1+EDR, GPS, USB2.0
OS
Android Honeycomb
iOS 4.3
Sensor
Accelerometer, Light, Compass, Gyroscope
Accelerometer, Light, Compass, Gyroscope
Additional
Features
Google Contents & Mobile Services
TPL,1- 14Li 31 LH
1
HDMI Port Accessory
-
—
Design
3G(CDMA) : 16GB($629), 32GB($729), 64GB($829)
I
z
w
I
Highly Confidential - Attorneys' Eyes Only
SAMNDCA00522025
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?