Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al
Filing
1140
Administrative Motion to File Under Seal filed by Apple Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Wheeler Declaration in Support of Administrative Motion, #2 Proposed Order, #3 Declaration of Jason R. Bartlett, #4 Exhibit 1, #5 Exhibit 2, #6 Exhibit 3, #7 Exhibit 4, #8 Exhibit 5, #9 Exhibit 6, #10 Exhibit 7, #11 Exhibit 8, #12 Exhibit 9, #13 Exhibit 10, #14 Exhibit 11, #15 Exhibit 12, #16 Exhibit 13, #17 Exhibit 14, #18 Exhibit 15, #19 Exhibit 16, #20 Exhibit 17, #21 Exhibit 18, #22 Exhibit 19, #23 Exhibit 20, #24 Exhibit 21, #25 Exhibit 22, #26 Exhibit 23, #27 Exhibit 24, #28 Exhibit 25, #29 Exhibit 26, #30 Exhibit 27, #31 Public Declaration of Peter W. Bressler, #32 Exhibit 1, #33 Exhibit 2, #34 Exhibit 3, #35 Exhibit 4, #36 Exhibit 5, #37 Exhibit 6, #38 Exhibit 7, #39 Exhibit 8, #40 Exhibit 9, #41 Exhibit 10, #42 Exhibit 11, #43 Exhibit 12, #44 Exhibit 13, #45 Exhibit 14, #46 Exhibit 15, #47 Exhibit 16, #48 Exhibit 17, #49 Exhibit 18, #50 Exhibit 19, #51 Exhibit 20, #52 Exhibit 21, #53 Exhibit 22, #54 Exhibit 23, #55 Exhibit 24, #56 Exhibit 25, #57 Exhibit 26, #58 Exhibit 27, #59 Exhibit 28, #60 Exhibit 29, #61 Exhibit 30, #62 Exhibit 31, #63 Exhibit 32, #64 Exhibit 33, #65 Exhibit 34, #66 Exhibit 35, #67 Exhibit 36, #68 Exhibit 37, #69 Exhibit 38, #70 Exhibit 39, #71 Exhibit 40, #72 Exhibit 41, #73 Exhibit 42, #74 Exhibit 43, #75 Exhibit 44, #76 Exhibit 45, #77 Exhibit 46, #78 Exhibit 47, #79 Exhibit 48, #80 Exhibit 49, #81 Exhibit 50, #82 Exhibit 51, #83 Exhibit 52, #84 Exhibit 53, #85 Exhibit 54, #86 Exhibit 55, #87 Exhibit 56, #88 Exhibit 57, #89 Exhibit 58, #90 Exhibit 59, #91 Exhibit 60, #92 Exhibit 61, #93 Exhibit 62, #94 Exhibit 63, #95 Exhibit 64, #96 Exhibit 65, #97 Exhibit 66, #98 Exhibit 67, #99 Exhibit 68, #100 Exhibit 69, #101 Exhibit 70, #102 Exhibit 71, #103 Exhibit 72, #104 Exhibit 73, #105 Exhibit 74, #106 Exhibit 75, #107 Exhibit 76, #108 Exhibit 77)(Jacobs, Michael) (Filed on 6/26/2012) Modified on 6/27/2012 pursuant to General Order No. 62, attachment #1 sealed (dhm, COURT STAFF).
Exhibit 71
Page 1 of 6
Engadget Distro for iPad - get the app now!
MAIL
THE NEW IPAD
GALAXY NOTE
OS X 10.8
PS VITA
ENGADGET DISTRO
GALAXY TABS
Pantech Crossover review
By Brad Molen
posted Jun 7th 2011 12:00PM
A closer look at Apple TV's
software update and 1080p
movies
1 hour ago
Liveblogging Apple's 'cash
balance' conference call
Time to ditch the pull-ups, because Pantech's a big kid now. It's hard to fathom that the company
responsible for hits like the Zoolander-ish C300, Helio Ocean and dual-sliding Duo is only now -- after
five long years -- taking a chance at the Android market in the US. Certainly its long-time partnership
with AT&T is finally looking to pay off in a big way, as the network introduces the appropriately-named
Crossover. The carrier's been starving for a decent physical QWERTY to add to its (fortunately) blooming
Android lineup, so seeing Pantech step up to the plate and fill the void should come as a huge relief.
Though it's serving up monoliths in Korea that feature 1.5GHz dual-core processors and other outlandish
specs, Pantech looks to be starting its stateside tour with a less-risky investment: at $70 with a 2-year
agreement, its modest first impression appears targeted toward first-time smartphone buyers. Is it worth
dropping a Grant and a Jackson to adopt the Pantech Crossover for the next two years? Read on to find
out.
7 hours ago
NetZero launches '4G' wireless
service, we go hands-on
9 hours ago
How would you change the
Nook Tablet?
17 hours ago
Refresh Roundup: week of
March 12th, 2012
20 hours ago
Hardware
APLNDC-Y0000233489
Page 2 of 6
Sign Up
Create an account or log in to see
what your friends are doing.
Facebook social plugin
We're going to give Pantech a little credit here -- the Crossover looks well done for its first US attempt. It
opts for a sporty and rugged look instead of sleek and sexy, which is fine; we don't think the company's
really wanting to win any beauty pageants right away. Instead, it looks and feels like a fun device to use
on an everyday basis. Don't let the "rugged" talk fool you, though, because it's not technically certified or
professionally tested. It may be slightly more durable than any other standard smartphone, but this is not
one you'll want to throw against the wall in a fit of fury. The rugged nature of the Crossover is due to the
extra weight -- at 5.2 ounces, it has a little more heft, a primary side effect of adding a full QWERTY slide
-- but aside from some rubberized buttons on the top and a textured battery cover, the remainder of the
phone is plastic.
The most commented posts on Engadget over the
past 24 hours.
Is your new iPad heating up?
1103
Apple to announce plans for its $100 1502
billion cash reserves tomorrow
morning
Apple announces dividend and
share repurchase program for
2012, expects to spend $45 billion
over three years
Apple's Tim Cook says 'pipeline is
full of stuff,' AT&T affirms record
sales of new iPad
Unnamed Samsung exec
says quad-core Exynos
inside Galaxy S III, LTE
on-chip
Using a textured battery cover can be a good decision in theory because it ideally adds friction and
prevents phones from slipping out of your hand as often as one made out of smooth plastic. When using
the Crossover, there wasn't any noticeable improvement in grip, as the cover was still incredibly slick
despite being adorned with the texture here. At least the battery cover actually enhances the phone's
appearance, making it much more aesthetically pleasing when looking at it as a whole. Besides, we
absolutely love that we don't have to worry about leaving behind fingerprints every time we set it down.
Pantech chose to go a different route in its design by angling the Crossover's corners, rather than
rounding or squaring them off. We discovered that this actually makes a huge difference, offering more
places to easily grip the phone. In fact, there is nothing uncomfortable about holding the Crossover at all;
at 4.45 x 2.28 x 0.56 inches, it's small enough to feel like it naturally belongs nestled in the palm of your
434
384
310
A look back on popular stories from today in a
specific year.
In the year 2011
Beautiful Earth's NYC solar
powered EV charger follows
the sun to Brooklyn Bridge
Park
0 comments
APLNDC-Y0000233490
Page 3 of 6
hand.
In the year 2010
AnyDATA to preview new
embedded 2G, 3G wireless
modules at CTIA
Pantech Crossover Review 1
1 comments
In the year 2009
HDTV Listings for March 17,
2009
3 comments
One of the best things about the Crossover's design is the selection -- and positioning -- of the side
buttons. Pantech incorporated two of them into the top corners of the phone. The power / lock button is
on the top right corner, a perfect place for us to press it without much hassle. It sits close to where your
index finger naturally settles when gripping the phone, so it's all the more easy to actuate. On the
opposite corner there's a function key that opens up a clever shortcut menu on the phone, and a
dedicated camera button.
In the year 2008
Channel Nine HD launches in
Australia
6 comments
In the year 2007
On the front, the Crossover offers a 3.1-inch display with a meager HVGA 480x320 resolution, which
doesn't surprise us much considering its entry-level status. We were pleasantly surprised by how it
looked, though; there was only slight pixelation experienced as we moved closer to the screen, and the
colors are still bright and deep enough to see normally. It could be difficult to transition to for anyone
who's used an HD-quality screen such as qHD or Retina Display before, but first-time smartphone
buyers probably won't express much disappointment here. Our only issue with the screen is that the
colors get almost completely washed out when viewed in the sunlight. Our ability to do anything on the
screen was highly diminished outside because we simply couldn't see it. The capacitive digitizer is
responsive enough, but there were occasions in which we had to swipe the screen several times to get our
intended result (such as unlocking the screen).
DARwIn will be America's first
humanoid RoboCup competitor
12 comments
Four standard Android buttons occupy the front and keep the screen from getting lonely. With two small
physical keys sandwiched by two larger touch-sensitive ones, it flows nicely with the phone's angular
theme. These capacitive touch buttons, back and search, carry a much heavier focus and emphasis than
the other two when considering how much more real estate is being taken up by them. Overall, we felt the
phone was designed rather solidly on the outside. The keyboard slider was weighted properly, slid out
smoothly with only minimal (but not too minimal) force, and wasn't loose at all when it was open.
The Crossover is outfitted with a 600MHz ARM v6-compatible processor, par for the course for most
entry-level devices on AT&T's Android lineup; we didn't have high expectations for the CPU going into
the review, but it was exciting at first when we noticed there was little to no slowing in order to perform
normal tasks. However, after a few attempts to push the limits of the phone by throwing processorintensive tasks at it -- most notably multitasking -- we could tell this tiny CPU just doesn't have the
muscle to do more than the simple everyday stuff. Everything slowed to a crawl constantly, and the
phone even put up a white flag and rebooted at one point. On two separate occasions, the digitizer froze
up entirely for a couple minutes.
Beyond that, the other specs are typical of a less expensive Android phone and don't leave much in the
way of surprises: Android 2.2.1, 512MB RAM, 500MB internal memory (with 2GB microSD included),
HSPA support at a max of 7.2 Mbps, 1500 mAh battery and 3 megapixel camera. We were also excited to
see AT&T following through with its promise of allowing sideloaded apps on its new entries to the
Android lineup.
The Crossover's battery life is on the high end of most Android phones. Considering the 1500 mAh
battery is a decent size for a smartphone and it's not powering state-of-the-art equipment, it lasts almost
the entire day on moderate use. The rated talk time is 5 hours, but we got a lot more; we checked emails,
surfed the web, texted, made calls, and even streamed the Engadget Podcast from our dedicated app, and
the battery still made it a full 12 hours before it died. Our phone calls were clear with only a small amount
of fuzz, and the speakerphone was wonderful to use because of the large grill on the back. Our only gripe
was that when listening to the aforementioned podcast or other audio, the music came through great but
voices had a tinny or echoey sound.
Keyboard
JOYSTIQ
Babel Rising gets wrathful trailer, screens
Runner2 delayed until November, Gaijin
Pantech Crossover Keyboard
'thinking' about Wii U version
Alan Wake's Night Springs: The Complete
Series - 'Man in the Mirror'
TUAW
APLNDC-Y0000233491
Page 4 of 6
TECH
A full QWERTY slider phone lives and dies by its physical keyboard, so having a lousy keyboard would
almost certainly be the final nail in the Crossover's coffin. We had a rather pleasant time using the
keyboard though, as the keys are reasonably spaced and ever-so-slightly elevated, offering a little give
when pressed. As huge fans of these kinds of depressing buttons, we were highly impressed at the ease
and speed at which we could type. The only issue we had with mistyping was the 'M' and 'N' keys, mainly
because the third row of letters is pushed over to the left to make room for the d-pad. Our typing was
slowed whenever searching for the comma, because it's found on the other side of the up arrow rather
than snuggling up with the 'M' key.
DESIGN
gdgt
FFFFOUND!
Slashdot
Core77
MAKE
Popcorn Shower
Technology Review
MoCo Loco
Ars Technica
Design*Sponge
TechMeme
The Sartorialist
Phone Scoop
NEWS
HuffPost Politics
The Daily Beast
Huffington Post
Taxes
Stock Quotes
DJIA
LIFESTYLE
ENVIRONMENTAL
Lifehacker
Inhabitat
HuffPost Women
Good
StyleList
Autoblog Green
Personal finance
ShelterPop - Green Living
Gadling
ENTERTAINMENT
Massively
The Onion
i09
HuffPost Celebrity
Spinner
Moviefone
As with any smaller phone, concessions have to be made. One such sacrifice made on the Crossover is the
four-row keyboard. When possible, we like a fifth row on the top that's dedicated to numbers, but in this
case it was integrated with the top row of letters in order to leave more space for each individual key.
Specialized keys -- the .com, dedicated question mark, and voice search buttons, for instance -- were
nowhere to be found on the phone. The debate on whether these buttons should be included could rage
on for eons, but suffice to say we'd at least like to see them offered as an ALT selection so they're
accessible; on the Crossover, they're just gone.
Sadly enough, we went out of our way to not use the on-screen keyboard in portrait mode. It was a polar
opposite in terms of how much space is provided for individual keys; in fact, we were constantly typing
the wrong letters and hitting delete or return at inopportune times. We understand that not much can be
done about this because of the narrow screen, so we turned to Swype instead. Thankfully this was the
default keyboard, though the standard Android keyboard was also pre-installed, just in case this is your
APLNDC-Y0000233492
Page 5 of 6
preferred input method.
Apple adds 'Answers from the community'
to product web pages
Camera
F.A.A. might review policy on iPads and
other gadgets during takeoff, landing
Daily iPhone App: Draw Something
Pictures taken with the included 3 megapixel camera were better than we would have expected for an
entry-level device. Everything was clear and crisp, though the colors were a bit more washed out than
we'd like. It's nothing to write home about, but unless you're an afficionado of camera sensors, you'll be
happy enough with the results here. Pantech wisely included a macro mode on the Crossover, making
close-up images much more detailed. Autofocus also made a difference by ensuring the pictures came out
crystal clear, though we were saddened by the obligatory three seconds of focus time. That extra amount
may not sound like much, but that's all it takes for a child to stop smiling or that cool-looking bird to fly
away.
In a move that seems standard on most mid-range phones, Pantech left out the LED flash, crippling the
camera in low-light situations. Without it, most pictures taken closer to dusk or dawn are a bit grainier.
Besides this, the pictures were pretty decent, but try comparing it side-by-side with a Nokia N8 and then
let us know how good they are. Here are a few sample images taken with the Crossover camera:
TECHCRUNCH
Fly Or Die: Highlight
VeriFone’s Payments Gateway And
Square Competitor Reaches $10B In
Yearly U.S. Transaction Volume
Analysis Confirms iPad Display Really Is
One Of The Best Ever Made
HUFFPOST TECH
SPACEX-PECTATIONS
iPhone 5 Rumors Are BACK, Baby!
IBM Smarter Analytics Leadership Summit
Simulcast
Pantech Crossover Samples
Videos taken on the Crossover were captured with a mediocre 800 x 480 resolution. When perfectly still,
the camcorder took smooth videos; it was when panning across and around that we noticed choppiness.
We also weren't in love with the audio, since all voices sounded muffled when behind the camera.
Software
Pantech Crossover Software
As expected, the Crossover is running a custom version of Android 2.2. Going into the review we weren't
sure if we would see a UI similar to Pantech's global phones such as the Vega Racer. As it turns out, it's a
whole new creation. The lock screen has a "sticker" circle in the middle that you peel off. A small bar at
the bottom of this screen gives you the option to drag a notification -- such as new texts, missed calls, or
APLNDC-Y0000233493
Page 6 of 6
voicemails -- into that circle. Doing so will unlock the screen and take you directly into that particular
app. We were frustrated to see a row of shortcuts along the bottom of the home screen that cannot be
customized. We don't understand why, with countless other personalization options for Android, a
feature like this would be front and center and yet cannot be changed. We'd at least like the option of
turning it off and going back to the stock Android shortcuts at the bottom of the screen.
As a counter to the frustration, the UI allows us to reorganize everything in the App Menu. Instead of
only being able to sort the apps out in a particular way, we were able to actually move the icons around to
whatever fits us best. This is a feature we'd like to see available on most Android phones. Additionally,
the function button found on the top left corner of the phone is something else not normally seen on
other Android phones. Pressing it takes you into a customizable shortcut menu, allowing you to
checkmark any apps you want quick access to. This is handy, but it's just a new way (of many) to give the
phone your own personal touch.
Wrap-Up
All in all, the Pantech Crossover is exactly what it sets out to be, a simple low-end offering on AT&T's
Android lineup. It's doesn't pretend to be a significant flagship phone, nor should it. It was a satisfying
experience when we realized that we weren't looking at the next Nexus, Atrix 4G, or anything of the sort,
and set our expectations accordingly. The Crossover is the best option AT&T has for an Android with a
full physical QWERTY keyboard, which doesn't say much given its void of devices in this category. It
performs well as long as it's not pushed too hard, and we had a wonderful time using the keyboard. Aside
from that, it's like any entry-level Android device in performance and specs. The Pantech Crossover is a
decent choice for its price point, but it's a mighty hard sale if the dollar sign is no obstacle to you.
13
Like
21 likes. Sign Up to see what your friends like.
3
600MHz, android, android 2.2, android froyo, Android2.2, AndroidFroyo, ARM, ATT, autofocus,
Crossover, froyo, hvga, keyboard, macro, macro mode, MacroMode, mobile, Pantech, Pantech Crossover,
PantechCrossover, physical keyboard, PhysicalKeyboard, qwerty, review
powered by
Google Android 2.2
key specs
user reviews 29
answers 100
TYPE
SOURCE MODEL
RELEASED
Mobile / embedded
Open
2010-06-23
see all specs
Pantech Crossover
blog comments powered by DISQUS
LATEST NEWS
HUBS
GALLERIES
VIDEO
PODCASTS
TOPICS
REVIEWS
© 2012 AOL Inc. All rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Trademarks | AOL A-Z HELP | Advertise With Us
APLNDC-Y0000233494