Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al

Filing 87

Declaration of Patrick Zhang in Support of #86 MOTION for Preliminary Injunction filed byApple Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit 1, #2 Exhibit 2, #3 Exhibit 3, #4 Exhibit 4, #5 Exhibit 5, #6 Exhibit 6, #7 Exhibit 7, #8 Exhibit 8, #9 Exhibit 9, #10 Exhibit 10, #11 Exhibit 11, #12 Exhibit 12, #13 Exhibit 13, #14 Exhibit 14, #15 Exhibit 15, #16 Exhibit 16, #17 Exhibit 17, #18 Exhibit 18, #19 Exhibit 19, #20 Exhibit 20, #21 Exhibit 21, #22 Exhibit 22, #23 Exhibit 23, #24 Exhibit 24, #25 Exhibit 25, #26 Exhibit 26, #27 Exhibit 27, #28 Exhibit 28, #29 Exhibit 29, #30 Exhibit 30, #31 Exhibit 31, #32 Exhibit 32, #33 Exhibit 33, #34 Exhibit 34, #35 Exhibit 35, #36 Exhibit 36, #37 Exhibit 37, #38 Exhibit 38, #39 Exhibit 39, #40 Exhibit 40, #41 Exhibit 41, #42 Exhibit 42, #43 Exhibit 43, #44 Exhibit 44, #45 Exhibit 45, #46 Exhibit 46, #47 Exhibit 47, #48 Exhibit 48, #49 Exhibit 49, #50 Exhibit 50, #51 Exhibit 51, #52 Exhibit 52)(Related document(s) #86 ) (Bartlett, Jason) (Filed on 7/1/2011)

Exhibit 39

Case 1:09-cv-00791-GMS Document 227

Filed 02/23/11 Page 1 of 19 PageID #: 8827

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE
NOKIA CORPORATION,

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

Plaintiff,
v.
APPLE INC.,
Defendant.
APPLE INC.,

)
)
Counterclaim Plaintiff,
)
)
v.
)
)
NOKIA CORPORATION and NOKIA INC.,
)
)
Counterclaim Defendants. )

C.A. No. 09-791 (GMS)

JOINT CLAIM CHART
Pursuant to the Court’s January 21, 2011 Order (D.I. 168), Plaintiff and
Counterclaim-Defendant Nokia Corporation and Counterclaim-Defendant Nokia Inc.
(collectively, “Nokia”), and Defendant and Counterclaim Plaintiff Apple Inc. (“Apple”) hereby
submit the attached Joint Claim Chart. As set forth below, this Joint Claim Chart includes, for
each disputed claim term or phrase, Nokia’s and Apple’s proposed construction and citations to
the intrinsic evidence upon which they rely.

Case 1:09-cv-00791-GMS Document 227

Filed 02/23/11 Page 2 of 19 PageID #: 8828

MORRIS, NICHOLS, ARSHT & TUNNELL LLP

/s/ Rodger D. Smith II
OF COUNSEL:
Patrick J. Flinn
Peter Kontio
John D. Haynes
Mark A. McCarty
Adam J. Biegel
ALSTON & BIRD LLP
1201 W. Peachtree Street
Atlanta, GA 30309-3424
[phone]

Jack B. Blumenfeld (#1014)
Rodger D. Smith II (#3778)
1201 North Market Street
P.O. Box 1347
Wilmington, DE 19899
[phone]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
Attorneys for Nokia Corporation and Nokia
Inc.
POTTER ANDERSON & CORROON LLP

OF COUNSEL:

/s/ David E. Moore

William F. Lee
WILMERHALE
60 State Street
Boston, MA 02109
[phone]

Richard L. Horwitz (#2246)
David E. Moore (#3983)
Hercules Plaza, 6th Floor
1313 N. Market Street
Wilmington, DE 19899
[phone]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]

Mark D. Selwyn
WILMERHALE
950 Page Mill Road
Palo Alto, CA 94304
[phone]

Attorneys for Apple Inc.

Kenneth H. Bridges
Michael T. Pieja
WONG CABELLO
540 Cowper Street, Suite 100
Palo Alto, CA
[phone]
February 23, 2011
4107235

-2-

Case 1:09-cv-00791-GMS Document 227

Filed 02/23/11 Page 3 of 19 PageID #: 8829

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on February 23, 2011, I caused the foregoing to be
electronically filed with the Clerk of the Court using CM/ECF, which will send notification of
such filing to:
Richard L. Horwitz, Esquire
David E. Moore, Esquire
POTTER ANDERSON & CORROON LLP
I further certify that I caused to be served copies of the foregoing document on
February 23, 2011, upon the following in the manner indicated:
Richard L. Horwitz, Esquire
David E. Moore, Esquire
POTTER ANDERSON & CORROON LLP
Hercules Plaza – 6th Floor
1313 North Market Street
Wilmington, DE 19801

VIA ELECTRONIC MAIL

William F. Lee, Esquire
Mark D. Selwyn, Esquire
WILMERHALE
60 State Street
Boston, MA 02109

VIA ELECTRONIC MAIL

Nina S. Tallon, Esquire
Joseph J. Mueller, Esquire
WILMERHALE
1875 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20006

VIA ELECTRONIC MAIL

Kenneth H. Bridges, Esquire
Michael T. Pieja, Esquire
Brian C. Kwok, Esquire
BRIDGES & MAVRAKAKIS LLP
540 Cowper Street
Palo Alto, CA 94301

VIA ELECTRONIC MAIL

/s/ Rodger D. Smith II
Rodger D. Smith II (#3778)

Case 1:09-cv-00791-GMS Document 227

Filed 02/23/11 Page 4 of 19 PageID #: 8830

Joint Claim Chart
Proposed Construction of Disputed Claim Terms with Citations to Supporting Evidence
Term
No.
1.

Term To Be Construed
“a first polling code
representative of a first
polling state provided in a
header portion of the
downlink transfer”
(Nokia 135 patent)

Nokia’s Proposed
Construction
This phrase does not
require construction.
Plain and ordinary
meaning applies.

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Nokia’s
Construction
135 Patent Specification

Apple’s Proposed
Construction

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Apple’s
Construction
“a value representative of 135 Patent Specification
a first polling state
135 Patent at Figures 1-3, provided in a header field 135 patent at Figures 2-3;
Tables 1-4, 2:16-49, 3:23- of the downlink transfer” Tables 1-4; 2:16-27, 2:3647, 4:1-3, 4:15-17, 4:1549, 4:1-3, 4:15-17, 4:1942, 4:55-59, 4:64-67,
42, 4:55-59, 4:64-67,
5:12-15, and 5:29-34.
5:12-15, 5:29-34
135 Patent File History

135 Patent File History

Aug. 9, 2002 Response at
NKDEL00001671-1672,
1673, 1675-1677

Aug. 9, 2002 Response at
NKDEL00001671-1672,
1676-1677

October. 24, 2002 Office
Action at
NKDEL00001683-1685

Jan. 24, 2003 Response at
NKDEL00001701

Jan. 24, 2003 Response at
NKDEL00001701
Feb. 10, 2003 Office
Action at
NKDEL00001713-1714
Jul. 28, 2003 Response at

Jul. 28, 2003 Response at
NKDEL00001739-1741

Case 1:09-cv-00791-GMS Document 227

Term
No.

2.

Term To Be Construed

“a second polling coded
representative of a second
polling state provided in a
header portion of the
downlink transfer”
(Nokia 135 patent)

Nokia’s Proposed
Construction

This phrase does not
require construction.
Plain and ordinary
meaning applies.

Filed 02/23/11 Page 5 of 19 PageID #: 8831

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Nokia’s
Construction
NKDEL00001739-1741
Jul. 30, 2003 Notice of
Allowance at
NKDEL00001745-1747
135 Patent Specification

Apple’s Proposed
Construction

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Apple’s
Construction

“a value representative of
a second polling state
135 Patent at Figures 1-3, provided in a header field
Tables 1-4, 2:16-49, 3:23- of the downlink transfer
47, 4:1-3, 4:15-17, 4:15- that is separate from the
42, 4:55-59, 4:64-67,
header field of the first
5:12-15, and 5:29-34.
polling code”

135 Patent Specification

135 Patent File History

135 Patent File History

Aug. 9, 2002 Response at
NKDEL00001671-1672,
1673, 1675-1677

Aug. 9, 2002 Response at
NKDEL00001671-1672,
1676-1677

Oct. 24, 2002 Office
Action at
NKDEL00001683-1685

Jan. 24, 2003 Response at
NKDEL00001701

Jan. 24, 2003 Response at
NKDEL00001701
Feb. 10, 2003 Office
Action at
NKDEL00001713-1714

-2-

135 patent at Figures 2-3;
Tables 1-4; 2:16-27, 2:3649, 4:1-3, 4:15-17, 4:1942, 4:55-59, 4:64-67,
5:12-15, 5:29-34

Jul. 28, 2003 Response at
NKDEL00001739-1741

Case 1:09-cv-00791-GMS Document 227

Term
No.

Term To Be Construed

Nokia’s Proposed
Construction

Filed 02/23/11 Page 6 of 19 PageID #: 8832

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Nokia’s
Construction
Jul. 28, 2003 Response at
NKDEL00001739-1741

Apple’s Proposed
Construction

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Apple’s
Construction

Jul. 30, 2003 Notice of
Allowance at
NKDEL00001745-1747
3.

“setting up a real data
communication
channel”/“establishment
of a real data
communication channel”
(Nokia 465 patent)

This phrase does not
require construction.
Plain and ordinary
meaning applies.

465 Patent Specification

“assembling a channel for
the transfer of real data,
465 Patent at Title,
where there is no channel
Abstract, 1:53-2:26, 2:59- permanently available for
67, 3:9-24, 4:66-5:30,
the transfer of real data”
7:8-23, 7:33-12:35,
11:31-35, Figs. 1B, 2, 49, 14 and 15, Claims 1
and 28.
465 Patent File History
Feb. 20, 1996 Office
Action Response at 17-18
(NKDEL00000187-188)
and 21-22
(NKDEL00000191-192).
Aug. 19, 1996 Office
Action Response at 11-14
(NKDEL00000229-232).

-3-

465 Patent Specification
465 patent Abstract, 1:5360, 2:7-26, 2:59-67, 4:37, 4:13-34, 4:46-68
The embodiments
described in the 465
patent from column 7,
line 33 through column
12, line 35, and Figures
1A, 1B, 2-9 and 15,
including: ’465 patent at
7:33-8:25, 8:30-8:60,
9:63-67, 11:9-25, 11:4149, 12:30-33
465 Patent File History
Aug. 19, 1996 Response
at NKDEL000002290232, 0234

Case 1:09-cv-00791-GMS Document 227

Term
No.
4.

Term To Be Construed
“access transmission
comprising a preamble
and at least one message
frame” (Nokia 548
patent)

Nokia’s Proposed
Construction
This phrase does not
require construction.
Plain and ordinary
meaning applies.

Filed 02/23/11 Page 7 of 19 PageID #: 8833

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Nokia’s
Construction
548 Patent Specification

Apple’s Proposed
Construction

“a transmission to gain
access to a network,
548 Patent at Title, Figs where the mobile station
4A, 4B and 5, 1:52-2:19, transmits the preamble
2:40-3:25, 3:40-46, 6:61- and at least one message
7:39, 7:47-49, 7:57-60,
frame, without waiting
8:34-39, and 8:58-9:3, see for an acknowledgment
generally 548 patent at
before sending the
6:61-9:53
message frame”

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Apple’s
Construction
548 Patent Specification
548 patent Title; Figs 4A,
4B and 5; 1:52-2:19,
3:40-46, 6:61-7:39, 7:4749, 7:57-60, 8:34-39,
8:58-9:3

548 Patent Specification

See generally 548 patent
at 6:61-9:53

July 21, 2003
Supplemental Brief at
NKDEL00002180-2181,
2193

548 Patent File History

Examiner’s Mar. 11,
2003 Response to
Applicant’s Appeal Brief
at NKDEL00002089

July 21, 2003
Supplemental Brief at
NKDEL00002180-2181,
2193
Examiner’s Mar. 11,
2003 Response to
Applicant’s Appeal Brief
at NKDEL00002089

-4-

Case 1:09-cv-00791-GMS Document 227

Term
No.
5.

Term To Be Construed
“pilot channel” (Nokia
548 patent)

Nokia’s Proposed
Construction
This term does not
require construction.
Plain and ordinary
meaning applies.

6.

“channel coding means”
(Nokia 904 patent)

7.

“speech coding means for Function:
coding a speech signal” coding a speech signal
(Nokia 178 patent)
Structure: A processor or
integrated circuit that is
programmed to employ
two or more speech
encoders 202 having
mutually different speech
coding transmission rates
(S1, S2,…, SN) where:

Filed 02/23/11 Page 8 of 19 PageID #: 8834

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Nokia’s
Construction
548 Patent Specification

Apple’s Proposed
Construction
“a channel over which
pilot signals are sent”

548 Patent at Figure 4A,
and 6:43-60.

Function:
904 Patent Specification
channel coding of a radio
block using a coding
904 Patent at 5:52-60;
method
6:66-8:20; 9:21-30; Table
1; Claims 1 and 5; and
Structure:
Figs. 3 and 4.
a microprocessor
programmed to perform 904 Patent File History
convolutional coding
having a coding rate of
April 17, 2001 Office
1/2, 2/3, or 3/4.
Action Response at 5-7.

178 Patent Specification
178 Patent at 1:20-38,
2:16-25, 2:60-3:2, 3:664:6, 5:41-6:16, 6:23-47,
6:67-8:20, 10:4-23,
11:11-53, and Fig. 2.

-5-

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Apple’s
Construction
548 Patent Specification
548 patent at 6:43-60

Function:
904 Patent Specification
channel coding of a radio
block using a coding
method
904 patent at Figs. 3a and
3b; Table 1; 5:52-6:6,
Structure:
7:10-8:18
a block coder and
convolutional coder as
shown in elements 3a and
3b of Figure 3, which
perform channel coding
using the coding schemes
illustrated in Table 1
Function:
coding a speech signal

178 Patent Specification
178 patent at 11:11-53

Structure:
a processor programmed
to combine a Full Rate
speech coder with a
speech coder that has a
transmission rate of 8
kilobits per second and
that divides the speech

Case 1:09-cv-00791-GMS Document 227

Term
No.

Term To Be Construed

Nokia’s Proposed
Construction

Filed 02/23/11 Page 9 of 19 PageID #: 8835

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Nokia’s
Construction

a first one of the speech
encoders 2021 is an
existing speech encoder
having a speech coding
transmission rate of S1,
such as the known RPELTP speech encoder used
in a full-rate speech
transmission channel of
the GSM mobile
telephone system having
a speech coding
transmission rate of
S1=13 kbit/s; and

Apple’s Proposed
Construction

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Apple’s
Construction

signal into 10-millisecond
frames, each containing
80 bits

a second one of the
speech encoders 2022 is a
newer or later-added
speech encoder having a
speech coding
transmission rate of S2,
where S1 > S2.
8.

“channel encoding means Function:
for channel-encoding the channel-encoding the
speech-encoded signal” speech-encoded signal
(Nokia 178 patent)
Structure:
a processor or integrated
circuit that is
programmed to employ

178 Patent Specification
178 Patent at 1:20-38,
2:16-25, 2:60-3:2, 3:664:6, 5:41-6:16, 6:23-47,
6:67-8:20, 10:4-23,
11:11-53, and Fig. 2.

-6-

Function:
channel-encoding the
speech-encoded signal

178 Patent Specification

Structure:
a processor programmed
to combine a Full Rate
channel encoder with a

178 patent at 11:11-53

Case 1:09-cv-00791-GMS Document 227

Term
No.

Term To Be Construed

Nokia’s Proposed
Construction

Filed 02/23/11 Page 10 of 19 PageID #: 8836

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Nokia’s
Construction

two channel encoders
203, 205, where:

Apple’s Proposed
Construction
channel encoder that
takes the output of the
speech coding means and
adds 100 error-correction
bits

(i) the first channel
encoder 203 provides a
first channel coding bit
rate that is specific to a
speech encoder 202,
where
the speech encoder 202 is
selected from one of N≥2
speech encoders 2021,
2022, …202N having
mutually different speech
coding transmission rates
of S1, S2, …, SN, where
the transmission rates of
the N different speech
encoders have the
following relationship:
S1≥S2≥…≥SN, and
where
the first channel coding
bit rate of the first
channel encoder 203 is
correspondingly 0, S1-S2,
…, S1-SN, depending on
which speech encoder
202 is employed,

-7-

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Apple’s
Construction

Case 1:09-cv-00791-GMS Document 227

Term
No.

Term To Be Construed

Nokia’s Proposed
Construction

Filed 02/23/11 Page 11 of 19 PageID #: 8837

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Nokia’s
Construction

Apple’s Proposed
Construction

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Apple’s
Construction

such that the transmission
rate obtained as a result of
the selected speech
encoder 202 and first
channel encoder 203 is
kept constant at S1
regardless of the
transmission rate of the
speech encoder
employed; and
(ii) the second channel
encoder 205 provides a
second channel coding bit
rate of C > 0 that is
always the same
irrespective of which
speech encoder 202 and
first channel encoder 203
are used,
such that, at the output of
the second channel
encoder 205, the total
transmission rate is a
constant S1+C.
9.

“input parameter” (Nokia This term does not
727 patent)
require construction.
Plain and ordinary
meaning applies.

727 Patent Specification

“a discrete parameter that 727 Patent Specification
is input into an algorithm
727 Patent at Abstract,
separately from any other 727 patent at Figs. 4A,
Figs. 4A-4C, Fig. 6, 1:5- parameters”
4B, 4C, 6; 2:15-23, 2:302:53, 2:66-67, 3:2-3,
32, 2:40-43, 2:66-67, 3:2-8-

Case 1:09-cv-00791-GMS Document 227

Term
No.

Term To Be Construed

Nokia’s Proposed
Construction

Filed 02/23/11 Page 12 of 19 PageID #: 8838

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Nokia’s
Construction
6:30-54 (including Table
1), 9:3-18:31.
727 Patent File History
Original and priority
claims

Apple’s Proposed
Construction

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Apple’s
Construction
3, 9:9-20, 9:52-60, 10:1722, 12:38-18:31 (claims
1-25); see also ’727
patent at 2:27-28, 2:36-37
727 Patent File History
Mar. 6, 2000 Original
claims 1-7, 16-21, 30-36
Mar. 8, 1999 Priority
claims 1-6, 16-21, 31-36

10.

“input value” (Nokia 940 This term does not
patent)
require construction.
Plain and ordinary
meaning applies.

940 Patent Specification

“a discrete value that is
940 Patent Specification
input into an algorithm
940 Patent at Abstract,
separately from any other 940 patent at Figs. 3-6;
Figs. 3-6, 1:9-4:47, 4:62- values”
3:30-37, 4:62-5:2, 8:185:2, 8:4-12:51, 15:3720, 10:63-67, 11:10-17,
18:37.
11:35-37, 11:41-58, 12:439, 15:45-18:37 (claims
940 Patent File History
1-21); see also 940 patent
at 8:21-28, 9:56-60,
Original and priority
10:22-29
claims
940 Patent File History
Feb. 22, 2000 Priority
claims 2, 3, 4

-9-

Case 1:09-cv-00791-GMS Document 227

Term
No.

Term To Be Construed

Nokia’s Proposed
Construction

Filed 02/23/11 Page 13 of 19 PageID #: 8839

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Nokia’s
Construction

Apple’s Proposed
Construction

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Apple’s
Construction
May 5, 2005 Office
Action at 2
Aug. 6, 2005 Response at
2, 9

11.

“theme” (Apple 795
patent)

“a coordinated design of 795 Patent Specification
interface objects and
object parts that creates a 795 Patent at 5:60-62.
distinct visual appearance
on the display”

“a coordinated design of 795 Patent Specification
interface objects and
object parts that creates a 795 patent at 5:60-62,
distinct visual appearance 9:26-34, 19:57-59
on the display”
795 Patent File History
May 9, 2000 Office
Action Response at
AppDel0001637

12.

“control means for
switching the display
from one set of
graphical interface
objects to another set of
graphical interface
objects” (Apple 795
patent)

Function:
switching the display
from one set of graphical
interface objects to
another set of graphical
interface objects
Structure:
appearance management
layer that (1) loads the
theme by switching
pointers to drawing
procedures or switching

795 Patent Specification
795 Patent at Abstract,
3:17-29, 5:13-67, 6:1344, 7:30-34, 9:23-40;
10:7-67; see also 795
patent at Figs. 4, 9-10,
12-14, 6:45-7:30, 7:349:23, 9:40-10:7, 10:6719:48, 21:25-53

- 10 -

Function:
switching the display
from one set of
graphical interface
objects to another set of
graphical interface
objects

795 Patent Specification

795 patent at Abstract,
3:17-29, 5:13-67, 6:1344, 7:30-34, 9:23-40;
see also 795 patent at
Figs. 4, 12, 6:45-7:30,
7:34-9:23, 9:40-11:5,
Structure:
17:56-18:31, 20:34-37,
appearance management 21:25-53
layer that switches
pointers to drawing
procedures or switches

Case 1:09-cv-00791-GMS Document 227

Term
No.

Term To Be Construed

Nokia’s Proposed
Construction

Filed 02/23/11 Page 14 of 19 PageID #: 8840

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Nokia’s
Construction
795 Patent File History

Apple’s Proposed
Construction

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Apple’s
Construction
795 Patent File History

data used by drawing
procedures, and (2) draws
the theme by using a
AppDel0001636,
pattern look-up table to AppDel0001648
instruct a graphic
subsystem to draw a
pattern on the display

13.

“notification source”
(Apple 703 patent)

data used by drawing
procedures

“a software data
structure”

No construction required; 703 Patent Specification
or “source of an
indication of an event”
703 patent at claims 1, 2,
6-9, 13, 14; Abstract,
1:60-63, 2:43-45, 11:3550, 11:52 – 12:37, 15:6468, 17:15-23, 21:45-51,
24:24-32, 31:22-30; see
also 703 patent at Fig. 18

703 Patent Specification
703 Patent at 12:21-24
and 11:58-61.

May 9, 2000 Office
Action Response at
AppDel0001636
Oct. 13, 2000 Office
Action response at
AppDel0001648

703 Patent File History

14.

“connection object”
(Apple 703 patent)

“an object containing a
method for selectively
dispatching notifications
from the notification
source to the specific
ones of the plurality of

703 Patent Specification
703 Patent at 11:63-67
and 12:25-30.

- 11 -

Sept. 17, 1993 Response
at 8
703 Patent Specification

“object that provides the
dispatch of a notification
from the notification
703 patent at claims 1, 2,
source to at least one of 6-9, 13, 14; Abstract,
the plurality of objects” 1:47-52, 11:52 – 12:37,
17:65 – 18:6, 23:68 –

Case 1:09-cv-00791-GMS Document 227

Term
No.

Term To Be Construed

Nokia’s Proposed
Construction

Filed 02/23/11 Page 15 of 19 PageID #: 8841

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Nokia’s
Construction
703 Patent File History

Apple’s Proposed
Construction

objects that have
identified to the
connection object an
AppDel0000359
interest in specific source
object events”

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Apple’s
Construction
24:5; see also 703 patent
at Fig. 18
703 Patent File History
Sept. 17, 1993 Response
at 8-9

15.

16.

“connecting a plurality of
objects to a notification
source” (Apple 703
patent)

“at least one of the
703 Patent Specification
plurality of objects
invoking a method in the 703 Patent at 12:9-17.
connection object to
connect to the notification 703 Patent File History
source”
AppDel0000359

No construction required;
or “creating at least one
connection for a plurality
of objects to receive
notification from a
notification source.”

“telephony element”
(Apple 854 patent)

“a particular hardware
element or protocol of the
telephony system, with
identifiable status and
features”

“any identifiable aspect of 854 Patent Specification
the telephony system”
854 patent at claims 1-4,
8-16, 20-24; Abstract,
2:50-53, 12:5-9; see also
854 patent at Figs. 1, 6

854 Patent Specification
854 Patent at Abstract;
2:50-56; 10:64-11:2;
12:29-33; and 51:28-32.
Examples of Telephony
Objects that represent
Telephony Elements:
Telephone Line Handle
(12:35-13:2); Telephone
Handset Handle (13:313:32); Telephone Call

- 12 -

703 Patent Specification
703 patent at claims 1, 2,
6-9, 13, 14; 1:39-52,
9:45-57, 12:3-37, 18:5819:11, 21:66-22:5, 23:6224:32; see also 703 patent
at Figs. 3, 4, 18

Case 1:09-cv-00791-GMS Document 227

Term
No.

17.

18.

Term To Be Construed

“beacon signal” (Apple
074 patent)

“linear combining
means for weighting
and summing said
output signals to
produce an estimate of
said signal of interest”
(Apple 105 patent)

Filed 02/23/11 Page 16 of 19 PageID #: 8842

Nokia’s Proposed
Construction

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Nokia’s
Construction
Handle (13:60-14:4);
Telephone Feature
Control (14:6-19);
TTelephoneLine (34:2847).

“a signal, from which a
physical signaling
characteristic for use in
subsequent
communications with the
I/O device can be
determined, that begins a
self-configuring startup
procedure”

074 Patent Specification
074 Patent at 1:49-51;
2:58-62; 2:66-3:1; and
3:10-26.
074 Patent File History

Apple’s Proposed
Construction

No construction required; 074 Patent Specification
or “identifying signal”
074 patent at claims 1-5;
Abstract, 1:58-66, 2:1112, 2:48-56, 2:57-3:2,
3:10-26, 3:28-51, 3:5255, 3:59-65, 4:29-44; see
also 074 patent at Fig. 3A

AppDel0000934-936 and
AppDel0000984
Function:
105 Patent Specification Function: “weighting and
weighting the time shifted
summing said output
105 Patent at Abstract;
output signal and
signals to produce an
2:56-65; 3:13-21; 3:22- estimate of said signal of
frequency shifted output
signal and then summing 40; 3:54-63; 18:9-38;
interest”
19:10-42; 20:38-52;
the weighted time shifted
22:34-54; 23:13-29;
output signal and
24:35-56; and Figs. 22,
weighted frequency
Structure: Matrix-Vector
24, 35, and 36.
shifted output signal to
Multiplier [58]
produce an estimate of
the signal of interest
Structure:
Adaptation apparatus 44

- 13 -

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Apple’s
Construction

105 Patent Specification
105 patent at Figs. 4-18,
22, 24; 5:25-32, 10:44-50,
15:16-20, 16:60-67,
18:23-19:1, 22:34-56,
23:13-29, 24:39-45

Case 1:09-cv-00791-GMS Document 227

Term
No.

Term To Be Construed

Nokia’s Proposed
Construction

Filed 02/23/11 Page 17 of 19 PageID #: 8843

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Nokia’s
Construction

Apple’s Proposed
Construction

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Apple’s
Construction

calculates weighing filter
coefficients Wk using
either the trainingaugmented constantmodulus (TACM)
partially blind adaptive
equalization or trainingconstrained constantmodulus (TCCM)
partially blind adaptive
equalization adaptation
algorithms and provides it
to a linear combiner in the
form of Matrix-Vector
Multiplier 58. MatrixVector Multiplier 58
applies the weighing filter
coefficients Wk to said
time-shifted output signal
and frequency-shifted
output signal to produce
an estimate of said signal
of interest.
19.

“means for producing an
estimate of said signal of
interest” (Apple 105
patent)

Function:
105 Patent Specification
producing an estimate of
105 Patent at 18:9-35;
said signal of interest
20:38-52; 22:34-54;
23:13-29; 24:35-56; and
Structure:
Figs. 22, 24, 35, and 36.
The matrix vector

- 14 -

Function:
105 Patent Specification
producing an estimate of
said signal of interest
105 patent at Figs. 4-18,
22, 24; 5:25-32, 10:44-50,
Structure:
15:16-20, 16:60-67,
Matrix-Vector Multiplier 18:23-19:1, 22:34-56,

Case 1:09-cv-00791-GMS Document 227

Term
No.

Term To Be Construed

Nokia’s Proposed
Construction

Filed 02/23/11 Page 18 of 19 PageID #: 8844

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Nokia’s
Construction

multiplier 58 operating in
conjunction with the
switch 46 which is
controlled by the
adaptation apparatus 44
20.

21.

[58]

“call director unit” (Apple “a faceless background
034 patent)
process loaded at
initialization of the
computer system that
initiates the automatic
launching of a
conferencing application
when a call is received
and initiates and interacts
with the demon
conference component to
control the transfer of
calls to a conferencing
application”

034 Patent Specification

“demon conference
component” (Apple 034
patent)

034 Patent Specification

“a faceless background
task created by the call
director unit that engages
in persistent listening for
incoming call signals and
communicates with other
conference components to
transfer call signals to the
intended recipient

Apple’s Proposed
Construction

034 Patent at 5:66-6:16;
7:22-29; and 8:63-9:9.
034 Patent File History
AppDel0001418,
AppDel0001446, and
AppDel0001362.

034 Patent at 6:18-28;
6:35-39; 7:5-29; and
9:15-20.
034 Patent File History
AppDel0001418-19,

- 15 -

“unit responsible for
launching, and
transferring incoming call
signals to, conferencing
applications”

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Apple’s
Construction
23:13-29, 24:39-45

034 Patent Specification
034 patent at 5:62-6:14,
7:5-12, 7:26-29, 7:56-8:6,
9:2-9, 9:34-40, 11:31-61,
12:14-19, 12:56-61
034 Patent File History
Aug. 15, 2000 Appeal
Brief at AppDel0001418

“component responsible 034 Patent Specification
for listening for incoming
call signals”
034 patent at 4:38-47,
4:58-62, 5:19-22, 5:2829, 5:58-59, 5:62-64,
6:18-28, 6:35-39, 7:5-16,
7:23-25, 7:56-8:6, 8:1222, 9:15-20, 11:31-47

Case 1:09-cv-00791-GMS Document 227

Term
No.

22.

Term To Be Construed

Filed 02/23/11 Page 19 of 19 PageID #: 8845

Nokia’s Proposed
Construction

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Nokia’s
Construction
application using a shared AppDel0001446-47,
data structure in memory” AppDel0001362, and
AppDel0001339.

“listen string” (Apple 034 “the encapsulation of the 034 Patent Specification
patent)
parameters of a
conference API including 034 Patent at 5:28-40
two parts, a fixed portion
identifying a service name
and a variable portion
identifying one or more
service types”

- 16 -

Apple’s Proposed
Construction

Intrinsic Evidence
Supporting Apple’s
Construction

“parameters used for
034 Patent Specification
directing an incoming call
signal”
034 patent at 5:28-40,
8:25-30, 8:55-62, 9:2-9
034 Patent File History
Mar. 9, 1999 Office
Action Response at
AppDel0001339