In Re: Methyl Tertiary Butyl Ether ("MTBE") Products Liability Litigation
Filing
4583
JUDICIAL CONSENT ORDER AS TO GETTY PETROLEUM MARKETING, INC.; LUKOIL AMERICAS CORPORATION individually and as f/k/a, d/b/a and/or successor in liability to Getty Petroleum Marketing Inc., Lukoil North America LLC and/or Lukoil OilCompany; LUKOIL NORTH AMERICA LLC, individually and as f/k/a, d/b/a and/or successor in liability to Getty Petroleum Marketing, Inc., Lukoil Americas Corporation and/or OAO Lukoil; LUKOIL OIL COMPANY, a/k/a OAO Lukoil a/k/a Public Joint Stock Company Oil Company LUKOIL a/k/a/PJSC Oil Company Lukoil, individually and as f/k/a, d/b/a and/or successor in liability to GettyPetroleum Marketing Inc., Lukoil Americas Corporation and/or Lukoil North America LLC; LUKOIL PAN AMERICAS, LLC ONLY:THEREFORE, with the consent of the Parties to this JCO,it is hereby ORDERED and ADJUDGED: Within fourteen (14) Days after the effective date of this JCO, GPMI and/or the Lukoil Defendants shall pay, or cause to be paid on their behalf, the Plaintiffs Twenty Two Million Dollars ($22,000,000.00) in full and complete satisfaction of Plaintiffs' claims that are released or for which a covenant not to sue is provided in Section VI of the JCO. Nothing contained in this JCO shall be considered an admission by the Settling Defendants, or a finding by the Plaintiffs or this Court, of any wrongdoing or liability on the Settling Defendants' part. Within thirty days of the Plaintiffs' receipt of payment as set forth in Section V above, Plaintiffs shall request that the Court dismiss this Complaint as to GPMI and the Lukoil Defendants with prejudice pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 41 (a) (2). The Parties to this JCO agree that it was negotiated fairly between them at arms' length and that the final terms of this JCO shall be deemed to have been jointly and equally drafted by them, and that the provisions of this JCO therefore should not be construed against a Party to it on the grounds that the Party drafted or was more responsible for drafting the provision(s) and further set forth in this Order. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Vernon S. Broderick on 3/27/2020) (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit, # 2 Exhibit, # 3 Exhibit, # 4 Exhibit, # 5 Exhibit, # 6 Exhibit, # 7 Exhibit, # 8 Exhibit, # 9 Exhibit, # 10 Exhibit, # 11 Exhibit, # 12 Exhibit, # 13 Exhibit, # 14 Exhibit, # 15 Exhibit, # 16 Exhibit, # 17 Exhibit, # 18 Exhibit, # 19 Exhibit, # 20 Exhibit, # 21 Exhibit, # 22 Exhibit, # 23 Exhibit, # 24 Exhibit, # 25 Exhibit, # 26 Exhibit, # 27 Exhibit, # 28 Exhibit, # 29 Exhibit, # 30 Exhibit, # 31 Exhibit, # 32 Exhibit)Filed In Associated Cases: 1:00-cv-01898-VSB, 1:08-cv-00312-VSB-DCF (rro)
2929
2930
2931
2932
2933
2934
2935
2936
2937
2938
2939
2940
1327
2928
2892
2893
2894
2895
2896
2897
2898
2899
2.900
2901
2902
2903
2904
2905
2906
2907
2908
2909
2910
2911
2912
291;1
2914
2915
2916
2917
2918
Z!:11'3
2920
2921
2922
2923
2924
2925
2926
NJEMS
153914
79340
1S7546
364190
12853
12861
6680
S6094
12836
46996
6746
431679
356864
14S69
6662
196686
16189
14499
45653
153907
45497
66848
12866
6676
55999
57054
57763
2l475l
66729
186234
189860
S7142
78&62
358032
43357
94321
39557
54418
14966
79722
145023
227031
12850
154:18
66$9
88614
6693
353232
6690
SlTE_tD
44381
:<;[TE IO
N.!EMS
Former
MILFORD SERVICE CENTER FORMER
FIVE STAR GAS SERVICE STAT[ON & FOOD MART
PATIENBURG EXXON SERVlCESTATJON #36210
YALE MATERlAlS HANDLING CORP
171 PENNSYLVANIA AVENUE
:l,93 SERGEANTSVILLE ROAD
EXXON CO USA FLEMINGTON TERMINAL#3018
BUCKEYE PIPELINE: CO TERMINAL·
202 OLD CROTON ROAD
FLEMINGTON BUICKCHeVORLETGMC
!'LEMINGTON Ars'NAY INC ENE:RGY PRODUCTS
EM HAYNES JR MOTOR FUEl.
US FUELSERVlCESTATION
FLEMJNGTON JEEP EAGLE INC
PENNSYLVANJAA\/ENUE CoROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION
HUNTERDON CN1Y ROAD DS'T GARAGE & HAZ MAT
RARITAN TWP POLlCE DEPT
STAS STORE
D&O AUTO SERVlce
EQUlPCO SALES & Rl:NTAL CO
S7 PLEASANT RUN ROAD
WJLLOCKS COURT PRIVATE WELLS
170 PLEASANT RUN ROAD
2 PLEASANT RUN ROAD
SAi.EM REALTY CO @ SALEM IND PK
3 TEN EYCK ROAD
5 HICKORY LANE
NORTH POLE lNSULATlON CORP
WHITEHOUSE STATION GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATlON
SPEEDWAY SERVICE STATION .jt03476
LEHIGH GAS SERVICE STATJON
14 BRIDGE STREET JNC SERVICE STATION
STONE VALLEY FARM
BAKER TiiOMAS
5 ROUND TOP ROAD
SF>EEDWAY SERVICESTA'l10N #03469
LEHIGH GAS SERVICE STATlON
LEHlGH GAS SERVlCE STATION
23 LEICESTER LANE
BRUSH WELLMAN INC CERAMICS DlV
100 PLEASANTVALLEYHARBOURTON ROAD
NJDOT WEST AMWELL MAINTENANCE FAC!lm'
LEHIGH FLUID POWER INC
RALPHS REPAIRS
228 ROCK ROAD WEST
26 BARRY ROAD
367 ROC1{ ROAD E:AST
WHITEHOUSE Dl:AN SERVICE STATION
VAN DOREN OIL CO
MOST R.!aCENT SITE NAME
Page 60 of 128
30 FRENOiTOWN RD
170 RT 173 & STROTZ RD
l-78& PATIENBURG RD
15 FLEMINGTON JUNCTION RD AKA RT 523 & 31
171 PENNsYl.VANIAAVE
193 SERGEANTSVJLLE RD AKA RT 523
19S RT 202/31
201RT202
202 OLD CROTON RO
211 RT202/31
223 RIVER RD & RT523 AKA FLEM JUNCTION RO
307 S MAllll ST AKA RT 6:J.1
63 RT31
7l RT31 & PENNSYLVANIA AVE
PENNSYLVANJA AVE
RT12W
RT 523 & DAYrON RO
101 STANTON RD AKA RT 62S
441MA1NST
61COUN1YLlNE RD
87 PLEASANT RUN RD
WllLOCt
EWINGTWP
EWlNGTWP
EWING TWP
EWINGTW?
EWING TWP
EWlNGTWP
EWINGTWP
EWINGTINP
EWING TWP
EWINGTWP
ewlNGTWP
EWING TWP
EWINGTWP
EWINGTWI'
MUNICIPAliTY
086180000
08638
0863&
08618
08628
08618
08628
08628
08638
08S38
08618
08638
0&638
08628
08618
0863&
08618
08638
086;1.8
08638
08638
08638
08528
08628
0&889
08889
OSSl2
OSS20
08543
08520
08520
OSS43
OS520
08520
0SS2o
08S20
08520
08520
08520
08520
08520
08638
08638
08638
08638
08618
08638
03638
ZJPCODE
10/14/2016
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MEltCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
ME:RCER
MERCER
HUNTERDON
HUNTERDON
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
COUNTY
Case 1:08-cv-00312-VSB-DCF Document 593-1 Filed 02/27/20 Page 62 of 82
3035
3036
3037
3038
3SSSS
6448
46524
46190
6515
15387
190953
6517
lS408
47429
6547
13817
6443
ll!033:
51145
6505
6495
13016
6508
6533
6451
391451
56666
560936
45449
6520
16178
6541
164447
3011
3012
3013
3014
3015
3016
3:017
3018
3019
3020
3021
3022
3023
3024
3025
3026
3027
3028
3029
3030
3031
3032
3033
3034
15884
SOlO
181455
16789
15405
6545
6551
6518
66535
6428
6611
6621
303709
36259
89319
214250
6454
6558
6550
6444
61460
3002
3003
3004
3005
3006
3007
3008
3009
3000
3001
2990
2991
2992
2993
2994
2995
2996
2997
2998
2999
HJE~S
SITIUD
6579
89318
Fonner
NJEMS
SITii 10
Cll'Y /LOCAL NAME
WALKER MOBILSERVfCESTATION
PARKWAY SHELL SERVICE STATION #138522
MIKES BODMAN ALIGNMENT
WW GRAINGER INC
MERCER CNTY AlRPORT
10 MASON COURT
LUKOIL SERVICE STATION #57340
HESS SERVICE STATION #30259
SUNOCO SERVICESfATION
SUNOCO SERVICESTATION #00119610
NJ STATE POLICE CENTRAL RGNL LAB@HORIZON CENTER
LEHIGH GAS SERVlCE STATION
AMERICAN CONCRm CO FORMER
PSE&G TRENTON SWITCHING STATION
ROGERS SERVICE STATtON
NATIONAL PERFORMANCE PACKAGING CO
CHAMBERS 1406 SERVtCE STATION
DUCK lSLAND TERMINAL lNC
ARCO PETROLEUM PRODUCTS
CONSUMERS on. CORP
LEHIGH GAS SERVICE STATION
MERCERVILLE EXXON SERVtCE STATION #36620
EAST STATE AUTOMOTIVE
GASCO SERVICE STATION
Q,UINN BROTHERSGULFSERVlCESTATtON
1835 ROUTE 33
WHITEHORSE GETTY SERVICE STATtON
LEHIGH GAS SERVICE STATION
FEDERAL EXPRESS CORP @ SOUTH GOLD lND PK
WASTE MANAGEMENT OF NJ INC
EXXON SERV1CE STATION #30247
SELMONS SHELL SERVICE STATION
O.UIK MART SERVtCE STAilON fORMER
HAMtLTON TWP DPW
MOBILSERVICE STATION #15C5P
INDEPENDENCE CLEANERS @ IND!:PENDENC!: PLAZA
EXPRESS FUEL SERVICE: STATtON
LUKOIL SERVICE STA110N #57326
STARR TRANSIT CO INC
STRYKER MACHINE PRODUCJ'S CO FORM ER
GULF SERVICE STATION
StMCOXS FLOWERS INC
SHELL SERVICE STATION #138425
GETTY SERVICE STATION #00656
EXXONMOBJL Oil, CORP TRENTON TE:RMINA!.it2S005
EXXON SERVtCE STAilON #32026
LEHIGH GAS SERVICE STATtON
ACCUMTE DOCUM!:Ni DESTRUCTION INC
CAROLINA FREIGHT CARRtERS CORP
Page 62 of 128
EWINGTWP
EWlNGTWP
EWJNGTWP
c;WlNGlWP
EWINGTWP
HAMlLTON
HAMILTON
HAMll.TON
HAM!L'TON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
HAMtLTON
HAMILTON
HAMtLTON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
HAMllTON
HAMILTON
HAMlL'TON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
HAMILiON
HAMILTON
HAMtLTON
HAMILTON
HAMtLTON
HAMlLTON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
HAMlLTON
HAMlLTON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
A!)DRESS
577 GRANO AVE & W UPPcR FERRY RD
780 PAR'!WJAY AVE & OLDEN AVE
9 11 INDUSTRY DR
MERCER COUNTY AlRPORT
SCOTCH RD
10 MASON CT
1070 WHITEHORSE MERCERVILLE RD
1106 CHAM BERS ST
1140 1144 CHAMBERS ST & E FRANKLIN ST
1150 WHITEHORSJ; MERCeRVILLE RD
1200 NEGRON DR & kLOCKNER RD
1201 RT33
129 2951.AMBERTON RD
1325 KLOCKNER RD
1380 S OLDEN AVE
!1400 ESTATE ST
1406 CHAMBERS ST
1463 l.AMBERTON RO
1470 LAMBERTON RD
1473 LAMBERToN Im
1SU lSlS $OLDEN AVE
16 MERCERVlLLE EDINBURG RD
1579 ESTATE ST
1685 NOTIINGHAM WAY
1704 GREENWOOD AVE
1l!3SRT33 E
1870 KUSER RD
1930 NOTTINGHAM WAY
2SGOLDDR
208 PATTERSON AVE
2142 S BROAD ST
2231 S OLDEN AVE & WHITEHORSE AVE
1231 S OLDEN AVE & WHrreHORSE MERCERVILLE RD
24DTAMPAAVE
2409 NOTTINGHAM WAY & GRAYSON AVE
2465SSROAOST
2482 S BROAD ST
249 RT 33 & WHITEHORSE MERCERVILLE RD
2531 ESTATESTEXT
2560 ESTATESTEXT
2582 WHITEHORSE MERCERV! Ll.E RD
2615 HAMILTON AVE
2683 NOiTINGHAM WAY
2735 27'37 S SROAD ST
2785 !AMBER.TON RD
3151 S SROAD ST
3217 Q,UAlROAD ST
5 ELKSH EAD TER
511 RT33 & SHADY LN
S3 FLOCK RD
86 KLOCKNER RD
.861 SLOAN AVE
866RT33
1-195 E S:d-295
NEW JERSEYTPKE MM 58.7
NEW JERSEY TPKE MM 58.7 N
RT 33 & GEORGE DYE RO
1060 RT33 & PAXON AVE
1296RT33
2101RT33
135149 WWARDST
160 164 MERCER ST
180 MERCER ST & ACADEMY ST
315 MERCER ST AKA RT33
401415 MERCER ST
BANK ST
MAXWELLAVE
40 E BROAD ST & HAMILTON AVF.
59 PRINCEiON AVE
65 BROADST
71EBROADST
130 W BROAD ST
10 !'LOWER HILL LN
101 LAMBERTVILLE HO?E:WELL RD
102 WASHINGTON CROSSING PENNlNGTON RD & REED RD
10SRT3l
107 SEARCH AVE
127 RT31 & RT654
1427TRENTON HARBOURTON RD
3 WASHINGTON CROSSlNGPENNtNGTON RD&SCOTCH RDAKART546 &SCOTCH
210 HOPEWELL PRINCETON RD
:US RT 31@ PENNINGTON CIR
230 PENNINGTON HOPEWElL RD
2551 RT 31 & PENNINGTON ClR
255S PENNINGTON RD AKA RTS1 @ CIR
:100 HOPEWELL PRINCETON RDAKART569
311 PENNtNGTON ROCKY HILL RD
326 LAMBERTVILLE HOPEWELL RD
355 WASHlNGTDN CROSSING PENNINGTON RD AKA RT546
404 WASHINGTON CROSStNG PENNINGTON I'm
47WSHOREDR
65 r£ATHERBED LN
KINGS PATH
MOORES MILL MT ROSE RD & HOWARD WAY
LAKESIDE SHELL SERVlCE STATION & AUTO SERVICE
YARDVJLLE SUPPl.Y C:O
5 ELKSHEAD TERRACE
SPEEDWAY SERvtCE STA110N t/03435
MERCER CONTRACTING CO
B&5 SERVIcE INC
CONGOLEUM CORP'
COOPERS CYCLE RANCH uitc
DANA TRANSPORT INC MVA
NJ TURNPIKE AUTH RICHARD STOCKTON SERVICE AREA #GS
NJ TURNPIKE AUTH WOODROW WILSON SeRVICE AREA #6N
SHELL SERVlCE STATION #9509
BP SERVICE STATlON #14637
GETTY SERVfCE STATlON
HAMILTON SQUARE GASCO SERVICE STATION
GORDON & WILSON CO INC
CITY GAS HlGHTSiOWN SE!iV[CE STATION
SUNOCO SERVICE STATION ~0004 9932
LS RIGGINS SERVICE STATION
GF>U ENERGY [NC HIGHTSTOWN CENTRAL DISTRlCf
NAMERICAN PHII.IPS LIGHTING CORP
AGWAY INC ENERGY PRODUCTS
SUNOCO SERVICE SiATlDN #0013 6226
LEIGHSSERVICESTAT[ON lNC
MALEK CHEVROLEi tNC
CASTO RO GMCTRUCK CO #3S222
ANDYS AUTO REPAtR
ARDLEIGH POND INC
101 LAMBERTVILLE HOPEWELL ROAD
PENNINGTON CtrGD SERVICE STATION
ALS SUNOCO SERVICE STATION
107 Si:ARCH AVENUE
AMOCO SERVICE STATION #60761
STEFfANELLI RESIDENCE
HOPE'\NELL TWP MUNICl?AL RECYCLING CENTER
210 HOPEWELL PRINCETON ROAD
PENNlNGTON GAS SERVICE STATION
HOPEWELL VETERINARY GROUP
LEHIGH GAS SERVICE STA110N
LUKOIL SERVICE STATION /t57703
AT&T COMMUNICATIONS INC
MOB1l. OIL CORP
SEIB!:Ri RES10ENCE
NJDE? WASHINGTON CROSSING STATE PARK
404 WASHINGTON CROSSING PENNINGTON ROAD
47WEST SHORE DRIVE
65 FEATHERBED LANE
KlNGSPAl'l-l GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION
?RtNCETON !'ARMS GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION
Page 63 of 128
HAMtLTON
HAMILTON
HAMIL'l'ON
HAMIL'TON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
HAMILTON
HAMl!.iON
HAMll.TON
HAMl1.TON
HAMILTON SQ.1.IARE
HAMtLTO!ll SQ.VARE
HAMft.TON SQ.lJARE
HtGHTSTOWN
HIGHTSiOWN
HIGHTSTOWN
HIGHTSTOWN
HIGHTSTOWN
HIGHTSTOWN
HIGHTSTOWN
HOPEWELL
HOPEWELL
HOPEWaL
HOPEWELL
HOPEWELL SORO
HOPEWELL TWP
HOPEWE:1.L TWP
HOPEWELL TW?
HOPEWELL TWP
HOPEWELL "TWP
HOPEWELL 1WP
HOPEWELL 1WP
HOPEWELL 1WP
HOPEWELL 1WP
HOPEWELL 1WP
HOPEWELL 1WP
HOPEWELL TWP
HOPEWaLTWP
HOPEWELL TWP
HOPEWELL 1WP
HOPEWELL TWP
HOPEWELL TWP
HOPEWELL 'TWP
HOPEWELL TWP
HO?EWELL TWP
HOl"EWELL TWP
HOPEWaL TWP
ADDRESS
MOST RECENT SITE NAME
I\1EW JERSEY MTBE - PLAINTJFF'S REVISED SITE LIST
HAMILTON1WP
HAMILTON TWP
HAMILTON TWP
HAMILiON TW?
HAMILTON 1WP
HAMILTON TW?
HAMILTDN1W?
HAMILTON TWP
HAMILTON TWP
HAMILiONiWP
HAMU.iON n,vp
HAMlLTON n,vp
HAMll.TON7WP
HAMll.TON 7WP
HAMll.TON TWP
HIGHTSTOWN BORO
!-IIGHiSTOWN SORO
HIGHTSTOWN SORO
HIGHTSTOWN BORO
HIGHTSTOWN SORO
HIGHTSTOWN BORO
HIGHTSTOWN BORO
HOPEWELL BORO
HOPEWELL BORO
HOPEWELLBORO
HOPEWELL BORO
HOPEWELLBORO
HOPEW.1:1.LTWP
HOPEWEL.L 1'Wf'
HOPEWELL 1WP
HOPEWEl..L 1WP
HOPEWELL TWP
HOPEWELL TWP
HOPEWELL TWP
HOPEWELL 1WP
HOPEWELL TWP
HOPEWELLTWP
HOPEWEU. TWP
HOPEWELL. 1WP
HOPEWELL TWP
HOPEWELl.lW?
HOPEWELL TWP
HOPEWE1.l 1WP
HOPEWELL TW?
HOPEWELL TWP
HOPEWELL TWP
HOPEWELL lWP
HOPEWELL TWP
HOPEWELL TW?
MUN!ClPALITY
0.8520
08520
08520
07962
08520
08520
06525
08525
08525
08525
08525
08638
P852S
08534
06534
08534
08560
08534
08535
08525
08534
08525
08534
08665
08525
OS534
08530
08650
08560
OSS34
08525
08650
08525
ossio
08610
08620
08690
08619
086190000
08609
08690
08690
08066
08330
08650
08690
OS690
086900150
08690
ZIP CODE
10/14/2016
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCl:R
MERCcR
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERcEfl
MERCER
MERcER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
MERCER
COUN'iY
Case 1:08-cv-00312-VSB-DCF Document 593-1 Filed 02/27/20 Page 64 of 82
3129
3130
3131
3132
3133
3134
3135
3136
31ZS
3126
3127
3124
3125
3119
3120
3121
3122
3123
;!118
3117
3U6
3088
3039
3090
3091
3092
3093
3094
3095
3096
3097
3098
3099
3:100
3101
3102
3103
3104
3105
3106
3107
3108
3109
31l0
3:!.11
3112
3113
31l4
311S
6347
370262
46022
455422
4$.532
15395
22082
21159
6173
6174
6177
45940
73610
75699
28861
35545
6332
6S49
42169
45427
6479
63'75
2l617
6380
144914
3.58070
6379
6374
14631
6366
6372
74820
6360
6392
6387
6362
73350
66099
169547
4:1875
6386
47153
75548
12o;rr4
43983
45393
6371
6368
41874
NJEMS
SITE_to
43.418
NJEMS
SITE ID
Former
CITY/ LOCA.L NAME
RT31 & YARD RD .
1100 1120 SPRUCI! ST
2480 BRLINSWICK PK & COLONlAL LAKE DR
2515 BRIJNSWICK PK
990 SPRUCE ST
1365 LAWRENCEVILLE RD"AKA RT 206
1545 NEW YORK AVE
1930 BRUNSWICK AVE 768 CHERRYTREE l.N
21SLACKAVE
2501 BRUNSWICK PK & TEXAS AVE
2798 BRUNSWtCK PK Al