In Re: Methyl Tertiary Butyl Ether ("MTBE") Products Liability Litigation
Filing
4583
JUDICIAL CONSENT ORDER AS TO GETTY PETROLEUM MARKETING, INC.; LUKOIL AMERICAS CORPORATION individually and as f/k/a, d/b/a and/or successor in liability to Getty Petroleum Marketing Inc., Lukoil North America LLC and/or Lukoil OilCompany; LUKOIL NORTH AMERICA LLC, individually and as f/k/a, d/b/a and/or successor in liability to Getty Petroleum Marketing, Inc., Lukoil Americas Corporation and/or OAO Lukoil; LUKOIL OIL COMPANY, a/k/a OAO Lukoil a/k/a Public Joint Stock Company Oil Company LUKOIL a/k/a/PJSC Oil Company Lukoil, individually and as f/k/a, d/b/a and/or successor in liability to GettyPetroleum Marketing Inc., Lukoil Americas Corporation and/or Lukoil North America LLC; LUKOIL PAN AMERICAS, LLC ONLY:THEREFORE, with the consent of the Parties to this JCO,it is hereby ORDERED and ADJUDGED: Within fourteen (14) Days after the effective date of this JCO, GPMI and/or the Lukoil Defendants shall pay, or cause to be paid on their behalf, the Plaintiffs Twenty Two Million Dollars ($22,000,000.00) in full and complete satisfaction of Plaintiffs' claims that are released or for which a covenant not to sue is provided in Section VI of the JCO. Nothing contained in this JCO shall be considered an admission by the Settling Defendants, or a finding by the Plaintiffs or this Court, of any wrongdoing or liability on the Settling Defendants' part. Within thirty days of the Plaintiffs' receipt of payment as set forth in Section V above, Plaintiffs shall request that the Court dismiss this Complaint as to GPMI and the Lukoil Defendants with prejudice pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 41 (a) (2). The Parties to this JCO agree that it was negotiated fairly between them at arms' length and that the final terms of this JCO shall be deemed to have been jointly and equally drafted by them, and that the provisions of this JCO therefore should not be construed against a Party to it on the grounds that the Party drafted or was more responsible for drafting the provision(s) and further set forth in this Order. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Vernon S. Broderick on 3/27/2020) (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit, # 2 Exhibit, # 3 Exhibit, # 4 Exhibit, # 5 Exhibit, # 6 Exhibit, # 7 Exhibit, # 8 Exhibit, # 9 Exhibit, # 10 Exhibit, # 11 Exhibit, # 12 Exhibit, # 13 Exhibit, # 14 Exhibit, # 15 Exhibit, # 16 Exhibit, # 17 Exhibit, # 18 Exhibit, # 19 Exhibit, # 20 Exhibit, # 21 Exhibit, # 22 Exhibit, # 23 Exhibit, # 24 Exhibit, # 25 Exhibit, # 26 Exhibit, # 27 Exhibit, # 28 Exhibit, # 29 Exhibit, # 30 Exhibit, # 31 Exhibit, # 32 Exhibit)Filed In Associated Cases: 1:00-cv-01898-VSB, 1:08-cv-00312-VSB-DCF (rro)
6104
6105
6106
6107
610S
610!3
6110
S111
6112
6113
6114
611S
6116
6117
6118
S119
6120
6121
6122
6123
6124
6125
5103
6077
6078
6079
6080
6081
6082
6083
6084GOSS
GOBS
6087
6088
6089
6090
6091
6092
6093
6094
6095
609S
6097
5098
6099
6100
610l.
6102
NJEMS
22387
43776
583
13152
664
147683
S1274
S:2096
32517
35S
359219
626
14444
469.35
636
14453
676
439794
441266
13164
718
4SS45
387138
371
44044
49866
60151
80406
687
9409S
27165
13160
22543
19787
690
686
52253
43193
772Z7
15039
45392
714
726
744
745
44469
13174
733
734
srre_io
680
SITE ID
Fonner
NJEMS
LUKOtLSERVICE STA1"tDN
CUM BERLAND FARMS GULF SERVlCE STATION #60490
ASPLUNDH TREE EXPERT CO
4AAUTOMOTIVE
NJ ENERGY CORP SERVJCESTATtON #32236
SCCTCH 22SEfMCESTATION
SHElLSERVlCESTATION #138499
UNION CNTY DPW & ROADS
CUSTOM INSTRUMENT
BP SERVICE STATION #12841
G&BCORP
LEHtGH GAS SERVtCE STA'TlON
PERRELUSTEXACO SERVtCE STATION
EXXON SERVICESTATtON #33425
SPRINGFIELD TWP DPW MUNtCIF'Al GARAGE
590 MORRJS AV~NUE
BP SERVICE STATION #20522
DELTA SERVICE STATION
UNlON CNlY HOUDAllLE QUARRY
!EPMFGCO
SUNOCO SERVICE STAT!Ol'II FORM ER
RACEWAY SUMMfT SERVICE STAT[Ol'II
SUMMIT ClTYTRANSFER STATtON
SPRING HOUSE LAWN & TREE SERVICE 1NC
COLlJ MBlA CLEANERS tNC
EXXON SERVICE STATION #33411 FORMER
SMYTHE VOLVO INC
LEHIGH GAS SERVICE STATION
SUMMIT SHELL SERIVlCc SlAilON
EXXON SERVICE STATION #33425
ASHWOOD EXXON SERVICE STATION
SALERNO OUANEAUTO DEALERSHIP SERVICE GARAGE
36 42 RIVER ROAD
CELGENE CORP
86WOOOLAND AVENUE
AMERADA HESS SERVlCE STATION
MERCK SHARP OOHME CORP
J&STEXACO SERVICE STATION
LYNCH METALS
BP SERVICE STATION #553
1099 BURNET AVENUE
UNION INDUSTRIAL ASSOC
US POSTAL SERVICE UNION POST OFFICE
JIFFY LUBE #484
OiEVRON OILCO
GASLANO SERVICE STATION
VILLAGE SUNOCO SERVICE STATION
GOLD STAR GAS
CARLS SERVICE STATION
MOST RECENT SITE NAME
Page 125 of 128
2239 NORTH AVE
2246 NORTH AVE
24SO Pl.A.INFIELD AVE
2.590 PLAINFIELD AVE
2:591 RTZ2.&.GL!;NSIDEAVE
26SO RT22 & MOUNTAIN AVE
RT 22 E & SCOTLAND ST
2.371 SOUTH AVE
2460 PLAINFIELD AVE
:l.28 HflLSIOEAVE &SPRINGFt!::LD AVE
155Ri22
245 MOUNTAIN AVE & SPRINGFtElO AVE
251 MORRtS AVE
4 CALDWELL PL& MORRIS AVE
54CENTERST
590 MORRIS AVE
9 MEISELAVE
9SB S SPRINGFIELD AVE & OUN DON l'!D
SHUNPIKERO
10 FADEM RD
46 MORRIS AVfa
1 CHATHAM RD & RIVER RD
1 NEW PROVlDENCE AVE
lPEARLST
29 31 CHATHAM RD
31 EUCLID AVE
326 MORRIS AVE
342 MORRlS AVE 336 SUMMIT AVE 530 SPRTNGFlELD AVE
6 RlVER RD & PASSAIC
795 OLD SPRINGFIELD AVE
8 lO ASHWOOD AV~
280 284 BROAD ST
36 42 RIVER RO
556560 MORRlSAVE
86W00DLANDAVE
1000 MORRIS AVE
1011 MORRIS AVe
1050 SALEM Rt>
10S1 LOUSONS RD
l.080 GALLOPING Hll.1. RD & CHESTNUT ST
1099 BlJRNET AVE
1110SPRINGFIELD RD
1130 W CHESTNUT ST BLDG #330 REDWING
1:1.74 MORRIS AVE
12GELBAVE
1201SPRtNGRELO RD
1225 MAGtE AVE
1225 STUYVESANT AVE
1276 STUYVESANT AVE
ADDRESS
NEW JERSEY MTBE ~ PLAINTIFF'S REVISED SITE LIST
SCOTCH PLAINS
SCOTCH PLAINS
SCOTCH PLAlNS
SCOTCH PLA!NS
SCOTCH PLAlNS
SCO"fCH PLAINS
SCOTCH PLAINS
SCOTCH PLAINSTWF'
SCOTCH PLAINS "TWP
SPRlNGFIELD
SPRlNGFlELD
SPRINGFIELD
SPRINGFIELD
SPRINGl'IELO
SPRlNGFIELD
SPRINGFIELD
SPRlNGFtELD
SPRINGF[ELO
SPRINGFlELD
SPRINGFIELD TWP
SPRINGFIELD TWP
SUMMIT
SUMMIT
SUMMIT
SUMMIT
SUMMIT
SUMMIT
SUMMtT
SUMMlT
SUMMtT
SUMMIT
SUMMIT CITY
SUMMIT CITY
SUMMIT CITY
SUMMIT CITY
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNlON
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
CITY/ LOCA~ NAME
· SCOTCH PLAINS TWP
SCOTCH PLAINS'TWP
SCOTCH PLAINS TWP
SCOTCH PLAINS TWP
SCOTCH PLAINS TWP
SCOTCH Pl.A[NS 1WP
SCOTCH PLA.tNS lWP
SCOTCH PLAINS TWP
SCOTCH PI.AtNS 1WP
SPRlNGFIELD TWP
SPRINGFIELD TWP
SPR!NGFJELO TWP
SPRJNGFIELD 'TWP
SPRlN SERVICE STATION
BASF CORPORATION
DOUBLE D SERVlCE CO INC
2738 SPRUCE STREET
DUNPHEY SMllll CO
CHAMPlON ENVELOPE CORP
OELTASERVtCE STATION
CEF;DANCORP
CHESTNUT SHELL SERVICE STATION
AMERICAN PRODUCTS CO lNC
WELLtNGTON REALlY CORP
K KALUSiYAN ORJENT EXPERT CORP
&GS CARTERT AVENUE
979 CARTERET AVENUE
SUNOCO SERVICE STATION #0297•23S8m4s
PUREX CORP BARON BLAKESLEE DIV
S'l'lJYI/ESANT AV!:NU I: SHELL SERVICE STAilON
PLANTHONOA
BP SERVICE STATION #95680
LUKOIL SERVICE STATION #57315
GETTY SERVICE STATION #S6843
MILLBURN MALL
GEO JAEKEL INC
UNION 1WP OPW
BP SERVICE STATlON #22323
LUKOIL SERVICE STATION #57244
EXXON SERVICE STATION
AM AIJTO CENTER tNC
Page 126 of 12.8
1351 MAG[E AVE & GALLOPING
1401 MORR1SAVE & LORRAINE AVE
1444STUYVESANT AVE
1701 STUYVl:SANT AV£
1722 RT 22 &SAYRE'RD
1865 VAUXHAlL RD
2031RT22
2091 SPRINGFIELD AVE
2:l.4S RT 22 & LAFAYffiE AVE
2210RT2.2
2240RT.2l
:U70 MORRIS AVE
2322 MORRIS AVE
2350RT22
2369 MORRIS AVE
2400 VAUXHALL RD
2425 VAUXHAl.l RD
2449 MORRlSAVE & BURNET AVE
244S MORRIS AVE & BURNETT AVE
2490 RT 22 & S?RINGFlELD AVE
2545 Rr l l & GREELE:Y AVE
2S68i,570 RT22
2655RT22
Z674 MORRIS AVE
2738SPRUCEST
30 PROGRESS ST
400450 CLERMONTTER
437 LEHIGH AVE
481485 LEHJGHAVE
S75 CHESTNUT ST & COLONlALAVE
610 RAHWAY AVE
625 RAHWAY AVE
SSS RAHWAY AVE
869 CARTERET AVE
979 CARTERET AVE
GARDEN STATE PKWY MM 142.2
10 MILLTOWN CT
1568 SiUWE:SANT AVE & STANU!.YTER
2285 RT22
2352 MORRIS AVE & RAHWAY AVE
2446 RT 22 & CENTER ISLAND
2701 MORRIS AVE
2933 VAVXHALI.. RD
S1S U\HlGH AVE
790 JEFFERSON AVE
2195 SPRINGF! ELD AVE
2200 SPRINGFIELD AVE & VAUXKALL RD
2201SPRINGflELD AVE & VAUX HAU RD
1144 W SOUTH AVE
MOST RECENT srre NAME
NEW JERSEY M'IBE- PLAINTIFF'S REVISED SITE LIST
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNtON
UNION,
UNtON
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNlON
UNION
UNION
UNJON
UNlON
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNJO]ll
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNIONiWP
UNIONlWP
UNIONTWP
UNION TWP
UNION TWP
UNION'TWP
UNION TWP
UNION TWP
UNIONlWP
VAUX HALL
VAUX HALL
VAUXHALL
WESTFIELD
CITY/ LOCAL NAME
UNION TWP
UNtONlWP
UN[ONTW!'
UNtON1WP
UNtON1WP
UNfDNTWP
UNtDNlWP
UNION1WP
UNfON'TWP
UNtONlWP
UNtONTWP
UNtONTWP
UNtON1WP
UNIONTWP
UNtONTWF'
UNrON1W?
UNtONTWF'
UNION TWP
UNJON1Wl'
UNtON1WP
UNION1WP
UNION TWP
UNION TWP
UNION1WP
UNIONTINP
UNtONTWP
UNION TWP
UNJONTWP
UNION TWP
UNlONTWP
UN!ON1WP
UNJON1WP
UNION1WP
UNION TWP
UNIONlWP
UNION TWP
UNION TWP
UNION TWP
UNION TWP
lJNIONTWP
UNION1WP
UNlONTWP.
UNION TWP
UNION1WP
UNION1WP
I.JNIONTWP
UNIONTWP
UNlONlWP
WESTFIELD TOWN
MUNICIPALITY
ZIP CODE
07090
07088
07083
08005
08005
070S8
07083
07083
07088
07088
osoos
07083
070$
07083
08005
07088
07083
07083
07083
07083
0708aOODO
07083
07083
070831933
07083
07036
07083
07083
07083
07083
07083
070S
07083
07083
07083
07083
07083
07083
07083
0708a
0708S
07083
07083
07083
0708S
070330000
07083
07083
07003
10/14/2016
UNION
UNlON
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNlON
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNlON
UNlON
UNlON
. UNlON
UNION
UNION
UNlON
UNlON
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNION
UNtON
UNtON
UNtON
COLINTY
Case 1:08-cv-00312-VSB-DCF Document 593-2 Filed 02/27/20 Page 45 of 52
6l23
6222
6221
6220
6219
6212
6213
6214
6215
6216
6217
6218
6211
6206
6207
6208
6209
62:J.O
620S
6182
6183
6184
6185
6186
6187
618!!
6189
6190
6191
6192
6193
6194
6195
6196
6197
6198
6199
6200
6201
6202
6203
!ii04
6181
6175
6176
6177
617B
6179
6180
452
47689
SSS79
46971
482
483
185285
67296
440
26608
492
1.:25;.44
179312
381
400
374
.23040
171789
518128
383
384
377547
1695:IS
485
120!!80
14555
418
141803
123829
94419
258510
438991
421
734$9
512158
486
435
433
:1.20891
168097
196741
459
450
466
60401
38B
41960
47986
4228$
NJEMS
SITE_lD
28218
486
SITE lD
~EMS
Fonner
JD &SONS AUTO & TRUCK REPAIR
SUNOCO SERVICE STATION #0006 9104
TORCON CO INC
UNION CN1Y DPW COMPLEXPOLlCE HDQTRS & FORENSIC 1-Aa
40 CANTERBURY LANE
RACewAYWESTFIELD SERVICE STATION
BP SERVICE STATION #22334
WESTFIELD EXXON SERVICE STATION
NEW NORRlS CHEVROLET PARTS DEPT
KOP COAT DIV OF CARBOLINE
668 SHADOWlAWN ORNE
C&G GULF SERVICE STA110N #160136
wmPIELD AMOCO sEtRVICE STATlON
922 CLEVELAND AVENUE
201 HARR1SON AVENUE
SHELL SERVICE STATION #9519
3S KASPER ROAD
GRAHAM PACKAGING !'LASTIC PRODUCTS INC
SCOTT AINSWIRTH SCHOOL SUS SERVICE
145ROUTE94
FUEL RlTE PETROLEUM INC
20 COOKE ROAD
44 KELlER HI i.l. RD
45 GAJSLER ROAD
BLAIRSTOWN SUNOCO SERVICE STATION
16 CEDAR LAKE ROAD
COLUMBIA TRAVEL CENTl:R
TRAVEL CENTERS OF AMERtCA
VICTAUUC CO OF AMERICA APEX FACILllY
SILLS COASTAlSERVtCE STATlON
EDISON ROAD & CLIFFSIDE PRIVE GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION
DARLING FARMS
285 MAIN STREET
MAIN·STIU:ET SUNOCO SERVlCE STATION
LEHIGH GAS SERVICE STATION
SlNGH & SINGH SERVlCESTATJON
SHELL SAP NO: 138366
OSA TIRE
MOBIL SERVICE STATION #2635147
NJDEP HACKETISTOWN STATE FISH HATCHERY
INTERCOUNlY.PAVING INC
NJDEP WORTHINGTON STATE FOREST
US GAS SERVICE STATION
HOPE AUTO CARE GARAGE
NEWTON TRUST
INDEPENDENCE TWP GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION
ANDYSJOHNSONBURG EXXON SERVICE STATION
ACI BROTHERS lNC
COLUMBIA SPARTAN SERVICE STATION @ COLUMBIA GULF SERVICE STATION
MOST RECENT SITE NAM!::
sr
Page 127 of 128
196 ROSSPL&SOUTH AVE
200 SOUTH AVE & CENTRAL AVE
215 e GROVE ST
300 NORTH AVE E
40 CANTERBURY LN
400 CENTRALAVE & ROSS PL
416 SOUTH AVE
421 CENTRAi. AVE
433 NORTH AVE
449 SOUTH AVE
668 SHADOWI.AWN DR
800 CENTRAL AVE & GROVE
809 CENTRAL AVE
922 CLEVELAND AVE
201 HARRISON AVE
1151 RT 5:1.7106 RT 5:1.7 & OLD AUAMUCHY RD
3SlSBlJRG
PHILLIPSBURG
PHILUPSBURG
PHILLIPSBURG
PHllLIPSBlJRG
PH,WPSBUR6 TOWN
PHtLUPSBURGTOWN
POHATCONG TWP
POHATCONG TWP
POHATCONG TWP
WASHINGTON
WASHINGTON
WASHINGTON
WASHlNGTON
WASHINGTON SORO
WASHINGTON BORO
WASHINGTON BORO
WASHINGiON TWP
WASHINGTON 1WP
WASHlNGiON TWP
WHITETWP
WHITETWP
WHITE1WP
CITY/ LOCAL NAME
1.lSERTYTWP
L!BERTYTWP
LOPATCONG TWP
LOPATCONG TWP
LOPATCONG TWP
OXFORD TWP
PHlt..llPSBURG TOWN
PHIUlPSBURG TOWN
PHILUPSBURG TOWN
PHILUPSBURG TOWN
PHILLIPSBURG TOWN
PHIUIPSBURGTOWN
PHILLIPSBURG TOWN
POHATCONG TWP
POHATCONG TWP
POHATCONG TWP
WASHINGTON BORO
WASHINGTON SORO
WASHINGTON BORO
WASHINGTON BORO
WASHINGTON SORO
WASHlNGTON BORO
WASHINGTON BORO
WASHINGTONlWP
WASHINGTON TWP
WASHINGTON TWP
WHITElWP
WHITETWP
WHITETWP
MUNICIPALITY
08865
08865
08865
08865
07882
07882
07882
07882
07882
07882
07882
07882
08827
078S2
07410
07823
07829
08865
07863
08865
08865
0.8865
08865
08865
08885
07823
078230000
08865
08$5$
ZIP CODE
10/14/2016
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
WARREN
COUNTY
Case 1:08-cv-00312-VSB-DCF Document 593-2 Filed 02/27/20 Page 47 of 52
Case 1:08-cv-00312-VSB-DCF Document 593-2 Filed 02/27/20 Page 48 of 52
I
I
I.
I
!
EXHIBIT B
I•
r-...
!
I.
I.
I
!,·
!
!.