In Re: Methyl Tertiary Butyl Ether ("MTBE") Products Liability Litigation
Filing
4583
JUDICIAL CONSENT ORDER AS TO GETTY PETROLEUM MARKETING, INC.; LUKOIL AMERICAS CORPORATION individually and as f/k/a, d/b/a and/or successor in liability to Getty Petroleum Marketing Inc., Lukoil North America LLC and/or Lukoil OilCompany; LUKOIL NORTH AMERICA LLC, individually and as f/k/a, d/b/a and/or successor in liability to Getty Petroleum Marketing, Inc., Lukoil Americas Corporation and/or OAO Lukoil; LUKOIL OIL COMPANY, a/k/a OAO Lukoil a/k/a Public Joint Stock Company Oil Company LUKOIL a/k/a/PJSC Oil Company Lukoil, individually and as f/k/a, d/b/a and/or successor in liability to GettyPetroleum Marketing Inc., Lukoil Americas Corporation and/or Lukoil North America LLC; LUKOIL PAN AMERICAS, LLC ONLY:THEREFORE, with the consent of the Parties to this JCO,it is hereby ORDERED and ADJUDGED: Within fourteen (14) Days after the effective date of this JCO, GPMI and/or the Lukoil Defendants shall pay, or cause to be paid on their behalf, the Plaintiffs Twenty Two Million Dollars ($22,000,000.00) in full and complete satisfaction of Plaintiffs' claims that are released or for which a covenant not to sue is provided in Section VI of the JCO. Nothing contained in this JCO shall be considered an admission by the Settling Defendants, or a finding by the Plaintiffs or this Court, of any wrongdoing or liability on the Settling Defendants' part. Within thirty days of the Plaintiffs' receipt of payment as set forth in Section V above, Plaintiffs shall request that the Court dismiss this Complaint as to GPMI and the Lukoil Defendants with prejudice pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 41 (a) (2). The Parties to this JCO agree that it was negotiated fairly between them at arms' length and that the final terms of this JCO shall be deemed to have been jointly and equally drafted by them, and that the provisions of this JCO therefore should not be construed against a Party to it on the grounds that the Party drafted or was more responsible for drafting the provision(s) and further set forth in this Order. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Vernon S. Broderick on 3/27/2020) (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit, # 2 Exhibit, # 3 Exhibit, # 4 Exhibit, # 5 Exhibit, # 6 Exhibit, # 7 Exhibit, # 8 Exhibit, # 9 Exhibit, # 10 Exhibit, # 11 Exhibit, # 12 Exhibit, # 13 Exhibit, # 14 Exhibit, # 15 Exhibit, # 16 Exhibit, # 17 Exhibit, # 18 Exhibit, # 19 Exhibit, # 20 Exhibit, # 21 Exhibit, # 22 Exhibit, # 23 Exhibit, # 24 Exhibit, # 25 Exhibit, # 26 Exhibit, # 27 Exhibit, # 28 Exhibit, # 29 Exhibit, # 30 Exhibit, # 31 Exhibit, # 32 Exhibit)Filed In Associated Cases: 1:00-cv-01898-VSB, 1:08-cv-00312-VSB-DCF (rro)
4SS7
4888
4SS9
4$90
4891
4892
4893
4894
4S9S
4896
4897
4898
4899
4900
4386
4885
4884
4883
4878
4879
4880
4881
4382
-48'77
4865
4866
4867
4868
4869
4870
4871
4872
4873
4874
4875
487S
4864
4852
4853
4854
4855
4856
4857
4858
4859
4860
4861
4862
4863
NJEMS
85564
2947
83827
l34a5
38455
3008
148652
15856
3002
44839
57101
15175
15153
3015
3026
13495
3019
35682
3013
85405
3023
3021
14573
84376
147580
66289
341603
204882
45208
13491
66699
3240
124738
13497
12.998
2981.\"
2S30
299:1
60788
2921
2963
2996
2924
:2971
2.58512
2965
2931
341480
2929
SITE_tD
MOST RECENT SITE NAME
ASSOCIATED HUMANE SOCIETIES INC@ POPCORN ZOO
WAWAFOOD MARKET#SS8
EXELON GENERATING CO INC@OYSTER CREEK NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION
FORKED RlVER SHaL SERVlCE STATION
ISLAND HEIGHTS BORO SEWER AUTH
TOMS RIV£RAUTO BODY
SUNOCO SERVJCE STATION #0004 6268·04
EXXON SERVICE STATlOJII #8157
SUNOCO SERVICE STATION #00119701
SUNOCO SERVICI': STATION # AKA RT 537 & 526
575 MONMOUTH RD AKA RT5371S1X FLAGS Bl.VD
7 COUNTY LINE RD
734HYSON RD
W COUNTY UNE RD AKA RT 526
1003 CLAIRMOREAVE
315 CONSTITUTION DR
621RT:t
GARDEN STATEP~MM76.0
I.ANOKA HARBOR
MULE RD & DOVER RD
PARKER AVE & OAK ST
RT 9 & I.ACEY RD
99 lff70.
RT70 & ElSENHOWERCJR
, 100 RIVER AVE AKA RT9
1001 MADISON AVE & 10TH ST AKA RT 9 & 10TH ST
103 RNER AVE AKA RT9
1255 RIVER AVE AKA RT9 & CHESTNUT ST
1441 RT 88 & LANES MtLL RD AKA OCE;AN AVE & LANES MIU. RD
1444 OCEAN AVEAKART88
1460 RT 88 & CHAMBERS BRIDGE RD
1505 RIVER RD & LOCUST ST AKA RT .9
155 POWDERHORN DR
1650 RT70 & GARDEN STATE PKWY
1715 MADISON AVE AKA RT 9 & KENNEDY BLVD
1785 SWATHMORE AVE
27 MADISON AVE AKA RT9
685 SO.UANKVM RD
9TH ST & PRINCETON AVE
130 LIBERTY DR
1300 KENNEDY BLVD
192.5 SWARTHMORE AVE
ADDRESS
NEW JERSEY MI'BE - PLAINTIFF'S REVISED SITE LlST
FORKED RIVER
FORlrmer
NlEMS
SITE ID
MONE AUTO SUPPLY
310 JOE PARKER ROAD
JCP&l. lAKEWOOD MGP FORMER
GPU ENERGY INC LAKEWOOD GARAGE COMPLEX #9966
DELTA SERVICE STATION
CONGREGATION SONS OF ISRAEL PARK AVENUE
LAVALLETTE SORO DPW
KELLYS SEA BAY SUNOCO STATION #100610
TIJCKeRTON SUNOCO SERVlCE STATION
251 CENTE;R STRSET
BRENNANS GAS & GO SE1WlC£ STATION
GULF SERVICE STATION
TEXACO SERVICE STATION #100272
US GAS SERVlCESTATION
NJDEP RUSSOS BP SERVICE STA110N
SHELL SERVICE STA110N #13841.1
SHELL SERVICE STA110N #138412
GETTY SERVICE STATION #OOS23
HERlTAGE MINERALS INC
USOOO NAVALAtRSTATlON LAKEHURST@JB MDL
SERVJCE STATION FORMER
GULF SERVtCE STATION
MARSHALLs CORNER GULi' Sl::IWICE STATION
EXXON SERVICE STA110N #36025
SUll!VANS ISLAND SERV[CE CENTER
JEI\SEY SHORE WATER CRAFT
SUNOCO SERV1CESTA110N #0010-0362
ORTLEY BEACH CITGO SERVICE STA110N
LUKOILSERVlCE STATION #5720S
10 EVERGREEN ROAD
NEW EGYPT CITGO SERVICE STATlON
CREAM RlDGE MOSlL SERVICE STATION
C&H TIRE & PERFORMANCE CENTER
98 MAGNOLIA AVENUE
307 ARNOLD AVENUE
SINGIN SERVICE STATION
SAY & BRIDGE SUNOCO SER.VIC£ STATtON
BORO CLEANERS & TAILORS
GETIY SERVICE STA110N #56255 FORMER
EXXON SERVlCE STATION #33019
CITGO SEIWICE STATION
BRIGGS TRANSPORTATION SERVICE
EXXON SERVICE STATION #81Z4
GU lF $Ell.VICE STATION
BRlTE & KLEEN COIN OPERATED LAUNDRY
SUNOCO SERVICE STA'TION-#0004-5872
KEATtNG LlNDA
1216 MIDDLE AVENUE
242 EASTHAM ROAD
MOSTRi:CEN"f SITE NAME
Page 101 of 128
244MAlNST
310 JOE PARK~ RD STEC
378 lAU~I.AVe &CLOVER ST
5SS SClUAN KUM RD
951 MADISON AVE & 10TH ST AKA RT 9
PARKAVE& l'\IDGEAVE
12.0 WASHlNGTON AVE
2007 GRAND CENTRAi.AVE & PRINCETON AVE
:l,0801520 RT539
251 CENTER ST
8101 WNG BEACH Bl.VD
136011.0NG: BEACH BLVD
138 RT72 & UNION AVE
524 RT72&JUG HANDLE
SSEBIWAVE
700 Fff72 & MILLCREEK RD
RT72 &JENNINGS RD
1741 RT37
RT70MM41
SHOPE CHAPEL l'\D & HANOVER RD AKA RT 547
771RT9
199 MATHISTOWN RO & CENT!aR sr
2951.AKEWOOD RD RTS28&539
55 N MAIN ST
3587 RTSS
101 BAlTlC AVE
409 412 RT 9 & MAIN ST
1956 RT35 &4TH AV!i
400 RT 9 & AVON RD
10 EVERGREEN RD
34NMA1NST
410 RTS39
787 RT537
98MAGNOUAAVE
307 AA.NOLD AVE
2149 BRIDGE AVE
219 BRIDGE AVE
2251 SRIDG:laAVE
2501 BRIDGE AVE
656 RT 88 & BAY AVE
700RT88&BAYAVE
1104 RICHMOND AVE
200 RIVER AVE & RT35
601 RlCHMOND AVE
603 605 RICHMOND AVE
901 RICHMOND AVE &ATlANTICAV
1666W END DR
2216 MIOOlEAVE
:242 EASTHAM RD
ADDRESS
NEW JERSEY MTBE - PLAINTIFF'S REVISED SITE LIST
'
LAKEWOOD TWP
LAXEWOOD TWP
LAKEWOOD1WP
LAKEWOOD TWP
LAKEWOOD TWP
LAKEWOOD TWP
·LAVALLmE
1.AVAI.Lrn£
llTTLE EGG HARBOR
LITil.E EGG HARBOR
LONG BEACH
LONG BEACH TWP
MANAHAWlI.EASANT SORO
CITY/ LOCAL NAME
LAKEWOOD TWP
lAKEWOODTWP
LAKEWOOD TWP
LAKEWOOD TWP
·L.A1(EWOOOTWP
1.AKEWOOOTWP
LAVALLITTE SORO
l.AVALLE1TE SORO
LlffiE EGG HARBOR TW?
l.lTTl.E EGG HARBORTWP
LONG BEACH iWP
LONG BEACH TWP
stA!'FORD TWP
STAFFORD TWP
STAFFORD TWP
STAFFORD TWP
STAFFORDTW?
MANCHESTER TWP
MANCHESTER TWP
MANCHESTER TWP
STAFFORD TWP
LlmE E;GG HARBOR TWP
l'LUMsrED TWP
PLUMSTED TWP
TOMS RIVER1WP
OCEAN.WP
OCEAN TWP
TOMSRlVERiWP
Pl NE BEACH SORO
PLUMSTED TWP
PLUMSTED TWP
PLUMSTED TWP
PLUMSTED TWP
PLUMSTED 1WP
OINT PLEASANT !?.EACH BOR
POINT PLEASANT SORO
POtNT PLEASANT BORO
l'OtNT PLEASANT BORO
?OtNT PLEASANT SORO
POINT PLEASANT BORO
POINT PLEASANT SORO
OINTPLEASANTBEACH SOR
OlNTPLEASANTBEACH BOR
OlNTPLEASANTBEACH BOR
OlNT!'LEASANTBEACH BOR
OlNTPLEASANTBEACH BOR
POINT PLEASANT SORO
POINT PLEASANT BORO
POINT PLEASANT SORO
MUNlCIPAllTY
08533
08742
08742
08742
06742
OS74:25198
OS742
08142
08742
08742
08742
08742
08742
08742
08742
08742
OSS14
08742
08741
08533
08533
08514
08758
08791
08701
OS701
08754
08754
08701
087350000
08735
08721
080872108
08092
08008
08050
08573
08050
08050
080500000
08753
08733
08733
08092
08087
085330000
08533
087390000
087582416
ZIP CODE
10/14/2016
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OC£AN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCl=AN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
COUNTY
Case 1:08-cv-00312-VSB-DCF Document 593-2 Filed 02/27/20 Page 20 of 52
4962
4963
4964
496S
4966
4967
4968
4969
4970
4971
4972
4973
4974
4975
4976
49n
4978
4979
4980
4981
4982
4983
4984
4985
49S6
4987
4988
4989
4990
4991
4992.
4993
4994
4995
4996
4997
4998
4/361
4955
4956
4957
495S
4959
4960
4954
4953
49S2
4S50
4951
MJEMS
3097
3088
30S7
46059
3078
3072
3151
:!152
3119
3085
15174
3082
46718
3094
13447
2774
2775
15164
2$66
126633
3121
13449
3233
16:1372
3073
53693
3113
2807
45818
87295
168613
:2.00760
41678
44485
2815
4$S26
2822
44572
2812
2811
2816
2817
45586
2S1S
S14:1
38404
45959
55802
2S3l
smuo
Former
157326
NJEMS
SITE 1D
Cl'TY / LOCAL NAME
CLAR1<5 LANDING MARINA lNC
SEASIDE ?ARK SORO WELL#6
LUKOIL SERVICE STATION
6,E;RlIO STATIOI
WARETOWN
WHrT!NG
ADDRESS
847 ARNOLD AVE
1201 BARNEGAT AVE & 13TH AVE
808 E CENTRALAVE
CENTAA~ AVE; &J Si
1701 LONG SEACH SJ.VD & 17TH ST
2218TH ST & CENTRAL AVE
237WSTHST
3058THST
6TH ST& BARNEGAT AVE
STH ST & LONG BEACH Bl.VO
1820 1S26 li00Pl:R AV~ & POLHEMUS RD
1CRA8BERD
144 MILL ST & DREW LN
225 RT 166 &ATLANTIC CITY BLVD
300 DOVERR!>
38SOOVERRD
RT166
46FUNTRO
137S PAUL BLVD
l452MAINST
460 EIAYAVE
610 BAY AVE
980 BAY AVE
109S ITT 37 & BANANIER DR
l1308AYAVE
1194 RTS7 &SUMNER AVE
125:1 RTS7
130WWATERST
1690 RT37 & VAUGHN AVE
1699 HOOPER AVE & FISHER BLVD AKA RT 549 & RT 549 S?UR
1900 HOOPER AVE & CHURCH RD
2063 RT37 &COOLlDGE AVE
264 RT 37 & GERMANIA STATION RD
281 RT37 & CLIFTON AVE
700 RT37 &TANAG!:R DR
735 FISCHER BLVD & MATSO DR
S:20 FISCHER BLVD
851 RT 37 & MULE RD
869 FISCHER BLV!> FORMERLY935 FISCHER BLVD
919 FISCHER BLVD & HAZLEWOOD RO
940 ITT 166 &. PRESIDENTIAL BL.VD
ADAFRE AVE 581 HlGKLAND PKWY
400STRICKLAND Bl.VD
109 EMAlNST AKART9 &539
118WMAINST
7 E MAlN ST AKA RT9 & WATER ST
924 RADIO RD & DYKE ?L
S2.&530 RT9
1180RT70
MOS! RECENT SITE NAME
NEW JERSEY MTBE - PLAINTIFF'.$ REVISED SITE LIST
MUNICIPALITY
ZIP CODE
POINT PLEASANT SORO
08742
SEASIDE PARK BORO
087S2
SEASIDE PARK BORO
08752
SEASIDE PARK SORO
OS7SZ
SHIP BOTTOM SORO
osoos
SHIP BOTTOM BORO
08008
SHIP BOTTOM BORO
08008
SHIP BOTTOM BORO
08008
SHIP BOTTOM BORO
0800S
SHIP BOTTOM BO.RO
08008
TOMS RIVER lW?
08753
SOUTH TOMS RIVER SORO 08754
SOUTH iOMS RIVER BORO 08757
SOUTH TOMS RIVER SORO 08757
SOUTH TOMS RIVER BORO 08757
SOUTH TOMS RIVER BORO 08757
SOUTH TOMS RIVER BORD 08753
SOUTH TOMS RIVER BORO 08757
STMFORDTWP
08050
STAFFORD1WP
080503010
STAF!'ORD 1WP
08050
STAFFORD TWP
08008
STAFFORD 1WP
08721
TOMS RIVER lWP
08756
TOMS RIVER TW1'
08753
TOMS RIVER TWP
08753
TOMSRIVERTW?
08753
087539998
TOMS RIVER TWP
TOMSRIVeRTWP
08753
TOMS RIVER TINP
08753
TOMS RIVER 1WP
08753
TOMS RIVER TINP
08753
TOMS RIVER TWP
087530000
TOMS RIVER TW?
087S3
TOMS RIVER TWP
08753
TOMS RIVERTWP
08734
TOMS RIVER TWP
08753
08753
TOMS RIVER TWP
08753
TOMS RIVERTWP
TOMS RJVER TWP
08753
TOMS RIVeR TWP
08753
TOMS RIVER TWP
08753
08735
TOMS RIVER TWP
TUCKERTON BORD
080S7
0$087
TUCKERTON BORD
TUCKERTON BORO
08532
1.rm.E EGG HARBOR lWP
08087
OCEAN TWP
087S8
MANCHESTER TW?
08759
10/14/2016
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OC!:AN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
OCEAN
COUNTY
Case 1:08-cv-00312-VSB-DCF Document 593-2 Filed 02/27/20 Page 21 of 52
4999
S046
5047
504S
5036
5037
S038
5039
5040
5041
5042
5043
5044
S035
S001
5002
5003
5004
5005
5006
5007
S008
5009
5010
5011
5012
50:13
5014
5015
S016
5017
S018
S019
5020
5021
5022
5023
5024
5025
5026
5027
5028
5029
5030
5031
5032
503;!
5034
sooo
2729
18460
2638
2736
2671
2G42
2706
:2593
:13429
29389
2623
2674
43114
2640
2692
42210
2746
166!}31
4SSS8
16344
13433
2679
126238
57$55
2624
27515
3SS54
2S79
479441
2756
53601
175797
2757
22469
25984
2763
92363
2761
13434
14286
2673
2719
2731
35475
43465
39909
2646
2735
2555
r.JEMS
SITE.JO
SITE 10
NJEMS
FC!l'mer
VILLAGE GULF SERVICE STATION #6l957
KEN Al.TA INC
VtBRATION MOUNTINGS & CONrROt..s
NORMAN SHEET METAL CO iNC
GULFSEfMCESTA110N
US OIL CORP SERVICE STATION
BUTLER !=OREIGN CAR INC
PRITCHARD AUTOMOTtVE tNC
LUKOtL SERVICE STAT[ON
SO VAN DAM AVENUE
MOBIL SERVICE STATION #15BFW
LUBRIZOL ADVANCED MATERIALS INC
GIVAUDAN ROURI; CORI'
RIVERWALK!l
MARDI GRAS CLEAN™ @ CLIFTON PLAZA
BROAD SiREET SERVICE STATION
~ON SERVICE STATION #35595
CENTERLINE GEITY SERVICE STATlON
CLIFTON ELECTRIC SUPPLY
GETIYS!;RVlC~ STATION
REGISTER LITHOGRAPHER
f>ARKWAY SERVICE CENTER
CLIFTON CITY FIRE DEPT ENGfNE #6
PEOPLES AUTO SERVICE INC
GREATER NEW YORK BOX CO
CLIFTON Cl"TY SD Of ED SC1-!00L#11
CITY t.INESERVICESTATION
US GAS SERVICE STATION
COMMf;RC!AL PROPER1Y
ELARREALTYCD
CLIFTON CITY FlRE DEPTENGINE#3
EAGLE PETROLEUM SERVICE STA'rtON
NORTH JEJ:!SEY DlSTWATER COMM SALANO NG RESERV
SHELtSERVtCESTATION #138320
VICTORY PETROLEUM SERVICE STATION
SJ-I EU.SERVICE SfA'TlON #138322
HY GRADE OIL CO
CLIFTON CITY DPW GARAGE
LEXlNGTON GB SERVICE STATION
US GAS 8t AUTO SERVtCE STATlON
ELEMEN11S PERFORMANCE POLYMERS
EXXON SERVICE STATION #35012
SHELLSERVIC!:'. STATION #13S32:l
NATIONAL FOOD SALES
SMITIYS MIDDLE VILLAGE GULF SERVICE STATION #121336
JERSEY GAS SERVICE STATION
ATLANTIC COASTAL TRUCKING FORMER
GlmY SER.VICE STATION 1#56868
561.AUREL AVENUE
MOST RECENT SITE NAME
Page 103 ofl28
498RT530
12286 °BARRANCA RD
113 MAIN ST
132 UNION AVE
146 MAIN ST AKA HAMSURG TPKE
149 PATERSON HAMBURGTPKE
15!} GLENWILD AVE
:1.72 Gt.ENWtlD AVc
SO MAIN ST
SO VAN DAM AVE
6 MAIN ST & VAN DAM AVE
1 INDUSTRIALSTW &STYERTOWNE RD
100125 DELAWANNA AVE
100 254 Rl\11:RWALICWAY 100111 PEBBLEBROO!( DR 100139 ROCK CREEK OR
1006 PIAGET AVE AKA RT 46
1037 1045 BROAD ST
:1.050 PlAGEi AVE AKA RT 46
1058 MAIN AVE
1094 MAIN AVE
11 LEXINGTON AVE & E 1STST
1155 BLOOMFlELD AVE
1201 VAN 1-!0UTEN AVE
1202 VAN HOUTEN AVE
1313 MA[N AVE
141149 ENTlN RD
147 MER.SELISAVE
1646 MAIN AVE
1665 MAIN AVE & CROOlASSAIC
COUNTI
Case 1:08-cv-00312-VSB-DCF Document 593-2 Filed 02/27/20 Page 23 of 52