In Re: Methyl Tertiary Butyl Ether ("MTBE") Products Liability Litigation
Filing
4583
JUDICIAL CONSENT ORDER AS TO GETTY PETROLEUM MARKETING, INC.; LUKOIL AMERICAS CORPORATION individually and as f/k/a, d/b/a and/or successor in liability to Getty Petroleum Marketing Inc., Lukoil North America LLC and/or Lukoil OilCompany; LUKOIL NORTH AMERICA LLC, individually and as f/k/a, d/b/a and/or successor in liability to Getty Petroleum Marketing, Inc., Lukoil Americas Corporation and/or OAO Lukoil; LUKOIL OIL COMPANY, a/k/a OAO Lukoil a/k/a Public Joint Stock Company Oil Company LUKOIL a/k/a/PJSC Oil Company Lukoil, individually and as f/k/a, d/b/a and/or successor in liability to GettyPetroleum Marketing Inc., Lukoil Americas Corporation and/or Lukoil North America LLC; LUKOIL PAN AMERICAS, LLC ONLY:THEREFORE, with the consent of the Parties to this JCO,it is hereby ORDERED and ADJUDGED: Within fourteen (14) Days after the effective date of this JCO, GPMI and/or the Lukoil Defendants shall pay, or cause to be paid on their behalf, the Plaintiffs Twenty Two Million Dollars ($22,000,000.00) in full and complete satisfaction of Plaintiffs' claims that are released or for which a covenant not to sue is provided in Section VI of the JCO. Nothing contained in this JCO shall be considered an admission by the Settling Defendants, or a finding by the Plaintiffs or this Court, of any wrongdoing or liability on the Settling Defendants' part. Within thirty days of the Plaintiffs' receipt of payment as set forth in Section V above, Plaintiffs shall request that the Court dismiss this Complaint as to GPMI and the Lukoil Defendants with prejudice pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 41 (a) (2). The Parties to this JCO agree that it was negotiated fairly between them at arms' length and that the final terms of this JCO shall be deemed to have been jointly and equally drafted by them, and that the provisions of this JCO therefore should not be construed against a Party to it on the grounds that the Party drafted or was more responsible for drafting the provision(s) and further set forth in this Order. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Vernon S. Broderick on 3/27/2020) (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit, # 2 Exhibit, # 3 Exhibit, # 4 Exhibit, # 5 Exhibit, # 6 Exhibit, # 7 Exhibit, # 8 Exhibit, # 9 Exhibit, # 10 Exhibit, # 11 Exhibit, # 12 Exhibit, # 13 Exhibit, # 14 Exhibit, # 15 Exhibit, # 16 Exhibit, # 17 Exhibit, # 18 Exhibit, # 19 Exhibit, # 20 Exhibit, # 21 Exhibit, # 22 Exhibit, # 23 Exhibit, # 24 Exhibit, # 25 Exhibit, # 26 Exhibit, # 27 Exhibit, # 28 Exhibit, # 29 Exhibit, # 30 Exhibit, # 31 Exhibit, # 32 Exhibit)Filed In Associated Cases: 1:00-cv-01898-VSB, 1:08-cv-00312-VSB-DCF (rro)
Case 1:08-cv-00312-VSB-DCF Document 593-1 Filed 02/27/20 Page 1 of 82
I··
l:
'
EXHIBI·T A
I
•
~
!
•I
:j
,,
I
j
1
I
43562
15586
363012
15585
12828
15587
15564
15567
51126
15584
12781
83564
12786
64369
65303
171948
171941
485717
46113
65110
12778
U7S43
G
7
48
49
43
44
45
46
47
42
40
41
39
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
2S
12829
12818
56340
147546
93368
171;133
12821
83751
14605
23031
12790
229905
52546
12804
124275
202988
56542
17225
84298
63910
47102
Sl.189
S5818
55620
1280S
12802
12754
23
24
2S
26
27
28
:u
21
20
19
16
17
18
15
14
13
10
11
12
s
s
2
3
4
5
:r.
NJEMS
SITE_ID
m
49552
SlrE
NJl;MS
Forme:r
U HAUL CENTER
SICO CO DIRECT SERVICE STATION #4/841
;L;J.1 li:NAPE LANE
ABSECON SHELL SERVlCE STATION
SUNOCO SERVICE STATION #00045328
SAFETY BUS SERVICE
SUNOCO SERVICE STATION #0004-6649
Tl:XACO S1:llVICESTATION #100230
H&.B TEXACO SERVICE STATlON
EXXON SERVICE STATtON #3635:L
SUNOCO SERVICE STATION
lOS MASSACHUsms AVENUE
ATtANTIC crrv SERVICE STATION
137 LIBERTY AVENUE
:139 NORTH tOWAAVENUE
1607 ATLANTIC AVENUE
1612 ARCTIC AVSlfUE
SPENCER GIFTS
ARCTIC AVENUE GULF SERVICE STATION #l22686
SOUTH JERSEY GAS CO
TEXACO SERVICE STATION #1404501334
THE SALVATION ARMY
VINAS MOBILSERVtCESTATION #15KYO
VANS SUNOCO SERVICE STATION
SOLTZPAINTSTORE
262 CONNECTICUT AVENUE
SOUTH JERSEY AUTO SUPPI.Y
30 NOFffH KENTI..lc:KY AVENUE
CUMBERLAND FARMS INC GULi' SERVICE S'rATION #2910
BOYS & GIRLS CLUB OF ATLANTIC ClTY
AiLAN11C CLUB CASINO HOiEL
PARKWAY AUTO SERVICE INC
CUMBERLAND FARMS GULF SERVICE STATlON #2946
TAUAFERROS DAY CARE CENTER
ENGINES INC
TRUMP CASTLE ASSOC FRANK FARLEY STATE MARINA
BUTLER AVIATION @ BADER Fll:'.LD AIRPORT
HARRAHS RESOITT ATI..ANTtC CtTY
SEASHORE FRUIT & PRODUCE
!'MG #2503 SERVICE STATlON
EDS FURNtruRE
ATLANTlC CITY COAL GAS #2
USDOD NAVAL RESERVE CENTER @ US COAST GU ARO STATION
ATLANTIC CITY aecrRIC co
HURON NORTH REDEVELOPMENT
NORTH RtVERS!OE DRIVE & PARK AVENUE
BRlGAN11NE GULF SERVICE STATlON #122El6S
FR111NDLY MANAGEMENr CO SERV1CE STATtON
AN DYS SH ELL SERVICE STATION #138303
MOST RECENT SITE NAME
Or
Page lof128
1 ABSECON BLVD
101 ABSECON BLVD & SHORE RD
:1.1:r.!.ENAPHN
128 A8SECON BLVD AKA RT 30
2ABSECON BLVD & NEW YORK AVE
235 ABSECON BlVD
471 WHITEHORSE PK AKA RT30
802 ABSECON BLVD
ABSECON Bl.VD & NEW RD
RT9 &.ABSECON Bl..VDAKA RHO WHITIHORSE PK
101. lllAl.BANY AVE & WlNCHESTERAVE
105 MASSACHUSE:TTSAVE
1125 N ALBANY AVE
137 LtBERTY AVE
139 N IOWAAVE
1607 ATLANilCAVE
1612ARCTICAVE
1635 N ALBANY AVE
1928 ARCTIC AVE
2001ATLAN11CAVE & MICHIGAN AVE
2140ATLANTICAVE AKAWDATl.ANTlCAVE
22 s 1'EXA5 AVE
2401ARCTlCAVE
2507 ATLANTIC AVE
2517 AiLANTICAVE
262 N CONNECTICUT AVE
2919ATLANTtCAVE
30 N KENTUCKY AV5
3114ARCTICAVE&MONTPEL!ERAVE
317 PENNSYLVANIA AVE
3400 BOARDWALK & BOSTON AVE
3609 VENTNOR AVE&ALBANY AVE
3701 VENTNOR AVE
423 N TENNESSEE AVE
435 MASSACHUSETTS AVE
600 HURON AVE
601 N ALBANY AVE
777 KARRAHS BLVD AKA 1725 BRIGANTlVE BLVD
800 NEW YORK AVE
9 N ARKANSAS AVE
91SATLANTICAVE
GEORGIAAVE&SUNSET AVE
HURON AVE fT
LEXINGTON AVE & CONNECTTCUT AVE
MASSACHUSEITSAVE & BRIGANTlNE BLVD & HURON AVE
N R1VERS10E OR& PARK AVE
3401 AilANitC BRIGANTINE BLVD
3600 ATLANTlC BRIGANTlN E BLVD
4012 ATLANTIC BRIGANTINE BLVD
ADDRESS
NEW JERSEY MT.BE - PLAINTIFF1S REVISED SITE LIST
ABSECON
ABSl:CON
ABSECON
ABSECON
ABSECON
ABSECON
ABSECON
ABSECON
ABSECON
ABSECON
ATLANTIC CITY
ATLANTIC CITY
ATLANT[CCl1Y
ATLANrrc CITY
AiLAN'l'tCCITI
ATLANT[C CITY
ATLANrlCCITY
ATlANTtC CITY
ATLANrlC CITY
ATLANTtC CITY
ATLANrrc CITY
ATLANTtC CITY
ATLANr!C CITY
ATLANTlC CITI
ATLANTTC CITY
ATLANTTC CITY
ATLANTfC CITY
ATLANTTC CITY
ATLANTIC CITY
Ait.ANilC CITY
ATLAN11C CITY
ATLANTIC CITY
· ATLANTtC CITY
ATLANTTC ClTY
ATLANTIC ClTY
ATLANTIC CITY
ATLANTIC CITY
ATLANTIC CITY
ATLANTJC CITY
ATLANTIC CITY
ATLANTIC ClTY
ATLANTICCITY
ATLANTIC CITY
ATLANTlCCITY
ATLANTIC CrTY
ATLANTIC CrTY
BRIGANTINE
llRIGANTINE
BRIGANTINE
CITY/ LOCAL NAME
ABSECON CITY
ABSECON CITY
ABSECON CITY
ABSECON CITY
ABSECON CITY
ABSECON CITY
ABSECON CITY
ABSECON CITY
ABSECON CITY
ABSECON CITY
ATLANilC CITY
AilANTICCITY
ATLANTIC CITY
ATLANTIC ClTY
All.ANTIC CITY
AT1ANTfCCITY
ATLANTltCITY
ATI.ANTICC!TY
ATLANTICClTI
ATLANTIC CITI
ATLANTIC CITY
ATLANilC CITY
ATLANTIC CITY
ATLANTltCITY
ATLANTIC ClTY
ATLANTICClTY
AilANTIC CITY
ATl.ANTICCITI
ATLANTIC CITI
ATLANTIC CITI
ATLANTIC CITI
ATLANTIC CITY
ATLANTIC CITY
ATLANTlc CITY
ATLANTlC CITY
ATLANTICCITY
ATLANTIC CITY
ATLANTtC CITY
ATLANTIC CITY
ATLANrlC CITY
ATLANi!C CJ'TY
ATLANT[C CITY
ATLANTIC CITY
ATLANTlC CITY
ATLANTIC CITY
ATLANTIC CITY
BRIGANTI NE CrTY
BRIGANllNECITY
BRIGANTINE CITY
MUNJCIPAUTY
08201
08201
08201
08201
08201
08109
0823.2
08201
08201
08201
0840l
08401
08401
08400
08401
08401
08401
08201
08401
08401
070$40000
08401
08401
08401
08201
08401
08401
08401
08401
08401
08401
08012
08401
08401
08401
08401
08401
08401
08401
08411
08401
08401
08021
08401
OS401
08401
OS203
082030000
08203
ZIP CODE
10/14/2Dl6
ATLANTlC
ATLAN11C
ATLANTIC
AiLAN11C
ATLAN"YlC
ATLAN11C
ATLANTIC
ATLAN11C
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
AiLANTIC
ATLANrtC
All.ANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLAN'l'lC
ATLAN'l'IC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATtANTlC
ATLANilC
A1'LANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
AiLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLAN11C
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATlANTlC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
COUNTY
Case 1:08-cv-00312-VSB-DCF Document 593-1 Filed 02/27/20 Page 2 of 82
so
96
97
98
ss
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
S1
82
83
84
85
S6
S7
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
72
64
65
66
G7
68
69
70
71
63
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
S9
60
61
62
NJEMS
125798
177SO
64328
12708
35497
153163
12688
30180
12718
1269S
224057
187316
64:l.73
45282
15865
44888
15578
54631
12725
15577
45995
12722
56245
75344
64291
64785
147438
39S8S
12679
122669
12700
18097
12701
12674
44738
12728
12737
65425
12740
57299
44421
443475
12745
S634S
12720
127$8
127SS
124476
74935
srra_10
MOSf RECENT SITE NAME
JERSEY STATE MARINE
t.ASAMMANA HOTEL
3 SHERlDAN PLACE
TRADE IMAGES CORP
NJOOTBUENA BORO MAINTENANCHARD
VAN CANT LOT@ 502 NORTH WEST BOUl.EVARO
SCtENTiflC PRODUCTS INC WILMAD GlASS otv
BUENA SUNOCO SERVICE STATION
FIVE POINTS SERVICE STATION @ FlVE: POINTS
12742
BACHAN PETROL
AMOCO SERVtCE STATION @ VINELAND TRUCK STOP
DELTONA DISCOUNTTIRES INC
MOBIL SERVICE STATION #57l90
CORSI N CITY SD OF ED
DORSEYS OLD PLACE INC
SUNOCO SERVICE STATION #0627-6479
LAMAN LOESCHE SUPPLY CO INC
£GG HAR.SOR Crrf STATION
HERRS FOOD INC
CUMBERLAND FARMS tNC #2903
FERRARI OtL 1NC
RAVs SF>ORTS MAAlNE CENTRE
223 BUFFALO AVENUE
CITGO SERVICE STATION
327 WHliEHORSl: PIKE
PEMBROKE CLOTHING
SOUTH JERSEY GAS CO EGG HARBOR CITY COAL GAS FORMER
HESS SERViCE STATION #30244
BERTUCCt PROPERTY
ARFA SERVICE STATtON
EGG HARBOR lWP SUNOCO SERVICE STATtON
SUNOCO SERVlCE STATtON #0004 5351
PMG #2506 SERVICE STATION
NATIONAL HOM!a lNSULATDRS
NJDM&VA AlR NATIONAL GUARD 177TH FtGHTER GROUP@ ATLANTIC CITY INTNL AIRP
DINOS DELl & SUBS
SUNOCO SERVICE STATION #0360-7702
AVALON MARBLE CO
LUKOILScRVICE Sl'AilON #57725
WEEDS TEXACO SERVICc STATlON
WAWA FOOD MARKET #947
CARDIFF RIGGINS SERVICESfATION
15572
BENNETT CHEVROLET GEO INC
lUKOJLSERVtCESTATION #57201
TILTON ROAD SUNOCO SERVICE STATtON
aEGANCE DRY CLEANERS @HEATHERCROFTSHOPPlNG CENTER
MOONEY THOMAS
DELANCY AVENUE GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION
BUTLER AVIATtON INC@ ATLANTIC CITY INTNL AIRPORT
NJEMS
SITE ID
Former
CITY/ LOCAL NAME
601 BAYSHORE AVE
14001406-W BRIGANTINE AVE
3 SHERIDAN PL
701 HARDING HWY
7.22 HARDING HWY 500 W OF RT 54
502 N WEST BLVD
1002 HARDING HWY & OAK RD
377 RT54
52.04 LANDiSAVE
751 HARDtNG HWY
760 HARDING HWY & BLUE ANCHOR RD AKA RT 40
6700 BLACKHORSE PK & CARD]FF CtR
BLACKHORSE Pl< & Tll.iON RO CARDIFF ClR
112 RTSO
218 MAIN 5T & RT 50
1451 WHITEHORSE PK & ANTWERP AVE
402 WHITEHORSE PK
600 WHITEHORSE PK & PH1 lADELPH tA AVE AKA RT 30 & PH1LADELPH1A AVE
801 BREMEN AVE & DUERE:R ST
827 WHITF:'.HORSE PK
1020 WHITl::HORS~ PK
1300 1308 WHITEHORSO: PK
223 BUFFALO AVE
27 WHITEHORSE PK
327 Wl-ilTEHORSE PK LOT
801ATLANTICAVE
ATlANTIC AVE & BUFFALO AVE 700 WHITEHORSE F>K
1600 VERONA AVE FORMERLY7058 Bl.ACKHORS!c PK
2043 OCEAN HEIGHTS AVE
2154 OCEAN HEIGHTS AVE & LEAP ST
2601 FIRE RD
2652TILTON RD &1900 BLCKHRSE PK
3001 OCEAN HEIGITTS AVE~ ZION RD
3l64f1RERD
400 LANGLEY RD
402ZION RD
6027 SLACKHORSI: PK & TILTON RO
6084 REEGA AVE
6101 SLACKHORSE PK & MCKEE AVE
6223 BLACKHORSE PK
6678 BLACKHORSE PK
6710 BLACKHORSE PK
6721 BLACKHORSE PK
6752 BLAClK AKA RT 30
547 WHITEHORSE PK
60512TH5T
72512TH ST &CHEW RD
73412TH ST & CHEW RD
B:l.O S EGG HARBOR RD
849 WHITEHORSE PK SAKA RT30 FORMERLY 701 WHITEHORSE ?KS
880SWHITEHORSE ?KAKA Rno
950SWHITEHORSE PK AKA RT30
9991001 S GRAND ST
EGG HARBOR RO
!.AKESHORE DR & LAKEVIEW AVE
10 N WH rTEHORSE PIC
:120 PLEASANT ST
12TH ST & LINCOLN ST
301 WHITEHORSE PK AKA RT30
ADDRESS
1'1--:EW JERSEY MTBE" PLAINTIFF'S :REVISED SITE LIST
EGG HARBOR TWP
ELWOOD
FARMTNGTON
FARMTNGTON
FOLSOM
FOLSOM
FOLSOM
GALLOWAY TWP
GALLOWAYTWP
GALLOWAY TWP
GALLOWAY TWP
GALLOWAY TWP
GALLOWAY TWP
GAL'..OWAYTWP
GALLOWAY TWP
GALLOWAY TWP
GALLOWAY TWP
GALLOWAY TWP
GALLOWAY TWP
GALLOWAY TWP
GALLOWAYTW!>
HAMILTON iWP
HAMILTON TWP
HAMfLTONTWP
HAMIi.TON TWP
HAMMONTON
HAMMONTON
HAMMONTON
HAMMONTON
HAMMONTON
HAMMONTON
HAMMONTON
HAMMONTON
HAMMONTON
HAMMONTON
HAMMONTON
HAMMONTON
HAMMONTON
HAMMONTON
HAMMONTON
HAMMONTON
HAMMONTON
HAMMONTON
HAMMONTON
HAMMONTON
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
ClTY / LOCAL NAME
EGG HARSORTWP
MlJl.LICATWP
EGG HARBORTWP
EGGHARBORTWP
POlSOMBORO
FOlSOMBORO
FOLSOMBORO
GALLOWAY TWP
GALLOWAY TWP
GN..LDWAYTWP
GALLOWAY TWP
GALLOWAY TWP
GALLOWAY TWP
GALLOWAY TWP
GALLOWAYT'NP
GALLOWAY'TW/>
GA1.LOWAYTWJ>
GA!.LOWAYTWP
GA!.LOWAYTWP
GA!.LOWAYTWP
GALLOWAY TWP
HAMll.TON TWP
HAMll.'roN 1WP
HAMILTON TWP
HAMIL'roN TWP
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMDN'rON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
HAMMONTON TOWN
MUNICI.PALl'N
08232
08217
08232
08234
08037
08332
08094
OS21S
08201
08215
08201
OB215
08201
08205
08215
08213
08201
08215
0821S
08215
08023
08330
08037
0$037
08330
08037
OS037
08037
08037
08037
08037
08037
080370000
08037
0803'.7
08330
08037
08037
08037
08037
08037
08037
08037
08037
08031
08037
08037
08500
08037
ZIP CODE
10/14/2016
ATLANTtC
ATLANTtC
ATLANTtC
ATLANTIC
ATLAN'rlC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
AiLANTtC
ATLANTtC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
AiLANTIC
ATLANTTC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTtC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTfC
ATLANTIC
Ail..AN11C
An.ANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
A1l.ANTIC
ATLANT1C
ATLANT1C
Ail..AN'l1C
ATLANT1C
ATLANT1C
ATLANT1C
ATI.ANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATI.AN11C
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
A11.ANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLAN'l1C
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
Ail.ANTIC
ATLANTIC
ATLANTIC
COUNTY
Case 1:08-cv-00312-VSB-DCF Document 593-1 Filed 02/27/20 Page 4 of 82
12577
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
1S6
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
l8S
178
17S
180
181
182.
183
184
177
174
175
176
3.7~
51142
165
146235
341159
92874
62643
59481
118896
12622
12637
60121
47241
12625
1262.4
44844
45563
0
127710
70831
12556
19.565
125SO
125S4
12551
16997
44845
294991
327077
46563
54416
12548
12549
l257S
l2746
44950
202731
127$/30
147009
1.53622
12587
12579
184177
413960
126349
12582.
12571
43862
65639
191702
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
1.57
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
148
I\IJEMS
Sm:_10
NJEMS
SITE 10
65640
Fonner
cm' I LOCAL I\IAME
NORTHFIELD CITGO SERVICE STATION
WECO CONSTRUCTION lNC
TEXACO SERVlCESTATION #101792
HALlS NORTHFIELD SERVICE STATION
MILLER JOHN
STAR ENTERPRfSE
EXXON SERVICE STATION #30657
HADDON AVENUE GROUNDWATER CONTAMINA'l10N
SOUTK JERSEY GAS CO PLEASANTVILLE COAL GAS
ATLANTIC CITY MUA
Page4 ofl28
520 548 564 WHITEHORSE PK N AKA RT 30
73012TH ST AKA RT54
787 WHtTEHORSE: PK AKA R.T30
OAK RD & UNION RD
104 HARDING HWY &TtJc:KAHOl: RD & BUENA VISTA AVE
300 SUMMER RD &SUMNER ST
1221 WABASH AVE
17l1 NEW RD AKA RT9
501 l