Apple, Inc. v. Motorola, Inc. et al

Filing 93

Declaration of Christine Saunders Haskett filed by Plaintiffs Apple, Inc., NEXT SOFTWARE, INC. re: 90 Motion Requesting Claims Construction (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 21 IEEE Dictionary, # 2 Ex. 22 '575 file history, # 3 Ex. 23 '486 file history, # 4 Ex. 24 Order No. 18, # 5 Ex. 25 '705 file history, # 6 Ex. 26 '647 file history, # 7 Ex. 27 Brad Cox, # 8 Ex. 28 Microsoft Press Dictionary, # 9 Ex. 29 '002 file history, # 10 Ex. 30 Dictionary of Computer Words, # 11 Ex. 31 Computer Dictionary, # 12 Ex. 32 Academic Press Dictionary, # 13 Ex. 33 IBM Dictionary, # 14 Ex. 34 Black's Law Dictionary, # 15 Ex. 35 About 3GPP, # 16 Ex. 36 '919 patent, # 17 Ex. 37 '713 provisional application) (Haslam, Robert)

EXHIBIT 22

10
10
Cd

10

UTILITY

PATENT

OH/4353iI

SERIAL

DATE

APR

IPATENT

zo

ci

NUMBER
SERIAL

INUMBER

NLIMBEF1

DATE

FILING

GROUP

UBCLASS-.A...-

iki.

UNrT

AJ9T

r.pi..

.lu.n

LL

EXAMINER

ILIil

..

I.i.

Lii

CLASS

.i

Ir

II

II

I\lrl.

Ii

r1I

It

II.

Ii

Forolgnpflorltycllmed

cI.li.
STATEOR

SHEETS

TOTAL

COUNTRY

AS

DRWGS.

CLAIMS

INDEI
CLAIMS

.i

tIll

.L/

Ill

I/I

i.i/lLI

iIFi..

IiE.

ltIL1FL

lIjlrlIIl1

I.

lfl/il.l-l

U.S.

.--

FILED

DOCKETNO.

RECEIVED

ilillr

Flij.

PARTS

ATIORNEYS

FILINOFEE

FILED

Examlneralnfllala

iIE
liii.

.1.

t2O

YOU

andAcknowledgOd

Verified

tIi

0iiO

S5USCllOcondWonentUt

0Op7

.r

l_

.-

DEPT.

OFC0MM./PAIIMplo.4eeL

flev.12-94

4__t____.__.

__________._____..._._.__i_

OF APPLICATION
SEPARATELY

rN0TICE

CLAIMS

MAILED
/2

/i/-GO
ISSUE
Amount

Due

Examiner

ADolications

OF ALLOWANCE

FEE
Date

Assistant

Total

Claims

ALLOWED
Print

Claim

Examiner

DRAWING

L-kkSheets

Paid

Dg.

Drwg.

Fi

-aL

1AW

PriFig.

...

ISSUE
BATCH

PREPAREI

Label

NUMBER

Examiner

Primary

FOR ISSUE

Area
WARNING

The
by

intormation
the

Patent

United

disclosed
States

Code

Trademark

herein
Title

may be restricted.
35 Sections
122
tricted

to

authorized

Unauthorized
181

and

368.

employees

disclosure

may

Possession
and

contractors

be

outside

prohibited
the

U.S.

only.

shtIset

FanS

PTO-436A

Iflaw

8/92

FACE

575FH001

WI-AppleOl

28448

siC

OP

UNITED STATEt
Patent
Address
POTSB

NO

APPLICATION
Cl0/l

FILING

COMMISSIONER
WashIngton

DATE

FIRST

0515195

Hii

NAMED

EPARTMENT

and Trademark
D.C

OF COMMERCE

Office

OF

PATENTS

AND TRADEMARKS

20231

INVENTOR

ATTORNEY

LLFroN

DOCKET

NO

P1525/i

12007

EXAMINER
LIi
I\IJ

31

U..2

I91pIJ\It\Ir

CALDVJrEL.L

tjIi55
JRCi3

rhr

frIfl

ART

1.2110

UNIT

PAPER

NUMBER

275.5
DATE

MAILED

/20/00

Please

flnÆ

below and/or

attached

an

Office

communicaticn

concerning

thia

application

or

proceeding
Commissioner

PTOSOC

lAce

2/95

us

P.O

1595459.553

of

Patents

and

Trademarks

File

Copy

575FH362

WI-AppleOl

28809

No

Application

Applicants

CLERON

08/435377

Office

Summary

Action

Pat

Period

for

DATE

MAILING

The

of

communication

this

time

of

for

period

reply

considered

NO

be

may

MONTHS

SIX

after

If

the cover

sheet

with

the

address-

conespondence

Reply

Eetenatone

be

Unit

2755

CeIdwell

on

appears

STATUTORY
PERIOD FOR REPLY
SHORTENED
THE MAILING DATE OF THIS COMMUNICATION

lithe

Art

Examiner

AL

ET

the

under

above

apecified

the

a

ieee

above

the

of

1.136a

no

In

however

event

be

reply

may

timely

riled

cammanloatlon

this

then

CFR

37

of

provisions

date

mailing

FROM

30

thirty

days

the

within

reply

minimum

atatutory

of

30

thirty

will

days

timely

for

period

available
from

MONTHS

SET TO EXPIRE

IS

reply

is

specified

maoimum

etatutory

will

period

and

apply

will

MONTHS

SIX

evplre

the

from

mailing

date

of

this

communication
Failure

to

the

within

reply

eetended

set or

for

period

reply

will

statute

by

the

cause

application

to

ABANDONED

become

35

u.s.c

133

Status

This

action

3fl

Since

this

closed

of

Disposition

40
50
60
70
80

application

and

above

the

Claims
Claims

11-19

and

12.4-8
17-19

Claims

non-final

is

for

eXcept
parfe

formal

Quayle

matters

C.D

1935

11

prosecution

as

0G

213

453

to

the merits

is

are

pending

in

the application
from

withdrawn

is/are

consideration

allowed

is/are

rejected
to

objected

is/ale

Claims

is/are

11-16

is/are

to

subject

and/or

restriction

requirement

election

Papers
The

is

specification

The drawings

110

The

proposed

120

The

oath

under

35

130

correction

or declaration

bE

All

is

Examiner

objecthd

filed

on

by the

tp

_is

by the

to

objected

EXaminpr

aD

bLJ

approved

disapproved

Examiner

119

made

is

Some

claim

of

None

cLI

1.0

received

in

Application

3.fl

received

in

this

the

of

foreign

for

under

priority

CERTIFIED

copies

of

35
the

U.S.C

11

9a-d

documents

priority

have

been

received

2.0

See

140

the

by
is/are

on

drawing

U.S.C

to

objected

filed

Acknowledgment

afl

Altec

2000

action

Ex

under

practice

claims

100

Priority

with

April

This

allowance

for

condition

in

is

1.248

Of the

Application

90

05

Claims

Claims

4a

on

2b

FINAL

is

accordance

in

filed

communications

to

Responsive

2afl

the

attached

detailed

Acknowledgement

is

No

National

Stage

Office

made

Series

Serial

from

application
for

action

claim

of

Code

for

list

of

domestic

the

Number
the

priority

copies

under

35

PCT

Bureau

International

certified

Rule

17.2a

not received

U.S.C

119e

hmentlsl

cted

Plobce

at

References

1610

Notice

at

Drahepereons

Patent

Disclosure

stetementsl

information

US vatent
PTO-32B

and

Tadematk

Rev

a-ai

180
190
200

PTO.aa2

isi0

Drawing

Review

IPT0-l

449

PTO-946
Paper

Nos

Inlervlew

summery

Notice

Informal

of

PTO-413
Patent

Paper

Application

Nos
PTO-152

Other

COca
Office

Action

summary

Pert

of

Paper

No

31

575FH363

WI-AppleOl

28810

Number 08/435377

Application/Control

Page

2755

Unit

Art

DETAILED ACTION

This

3910

action

in

are

amendment

to

response

20 were canceled.

and

811-19

is

was

that

received

247111217

Claims

4-5-00.

Claims

were amended.

124-

Claims

pending.

currently

Allowable Subject Matter

Claims

2.

are allowed.

124-812-16

35 USC

Claim RejectionsThe

3.

form

the basis

person

lal

the

et

The

be

shall

in

Claims

al

the

invention

publication

4.

for

was

this

or

17-19

under

rejections

entiflØd

of

patent

used

or

foreign

are

architedture

to

known

the appropriate

of

quotation

is

following

by

country

in

this

35

U.S.C.

102

that

action

Office

unless

in

others
before

under

rejected

of

paragraphs

made

section

this

102

the Tallgent

the

country

this

invention

35 U.S.C.

system

or

patented

thereof

102a

Dr.

by

or

the

described

as being

in

for

applicant

printed
patent.

by

anticipated

Dobbs on CD-ROM

Spring

Potel

1994.

Asperclaiml7
Potel

et

coupled

al

to

disclose

controlling

software

operations

component

extensible

software

frameworks

integrated

service

platform

hardware

multiple

for

and software computer
operating

systems and

of

architecture

that

layer

are

collection

frameworks

multiple

operating

with

Taligent architecture
of objects

components

developing
systems

system

computer

hardware

for

that

that

operation

can

on

of

an

provide

variety

be deployed

platforms and

system

of

on

network

575FH364

WI-App1e012881

Number 08/435377

Application/Control
Unit

Art

component

layer

network

service

microkernel

tpp

1-3

Page

2755

of

for

network

creating

frameworks such as
and

services

components

navigation

systems

file

110

providing

database

devices

protocols that deliver services

network

and

configured

to

the

access

system

copy

enclosed

As per claim

18

Potel

combination

which

et

al

in

APA

with

provides interfaces

teach

extending

extensions of frameworks Potel page

for

API

components

navigation

enclosed

of

copy

19

As per claim
Potel

of

et

al

combination

in

APA

with

teach

Claim RejectlanE
The

set

rejections

patent
in

may

prior

Patentability

art

be

not

102

section

invention

was made
shall

admitted

forth

thst
to

not

in

obtained

of this

are such

Claims 17-19

Applicants

quotation

is

following

obviousness

the

jPotel

page

copy

enclosed

fcrth

dynamic browsers

browsing

title
the

if

are

prior

art

matter

103a

ss

Spring

not

whole

in

in

the

which

have

art to

the

The

view

of

disclosed
matter
been

which

invention

103a

Potel

1994

subject

would

in

skill

identically

the

ie

35 U.S.C

pp 2-8

whichforms the basis

between

manner

under

103

for

all

action

invention

ordinary

by the

APA

system Dr Dobbs on CD-ROM

the

differences

having

negatived

rejected

Office

though

subject

parson
be

this

the

U.S

35

of

USCj

35

obvious

said

as being

architecture

Anderson

to
at

be

ae

eet

patented

the time

and

the

matter

pertains

unpatentable

over

subject

was

described

or

sought

made

of

US

the Taligent

5537526

575FH365

WI-AppleOl

28812

Number 081435377

Application/Control
Art

Page

2755

Unit

As per claim

17

APA

network

teaches

and

components

for

computer

system

to

cdupled

operations

on

of

controlling

software

frameworks

integrated

servie

platform

and software

hardware

operating

would have

discussed
diverse

in

which

been

above

for

computer

that

obvious

systems

computer

service

of

plurality

pp 2-8
and

layer

hardware and

hardware

provides

the

of

capability

platform

software

and hardware

for

operating
architecture

that

can

variety

be deployed

of

on

1-3
the

by implementing

extending

of

an

provide

on

operation

platforms

APA
for

Taligent

that

frameworks

multiple

with

of objects

components

systems

system

layer

collection

modify the system

to

it

are

developing

systms and

because

operating

As per claim

APA

of

variety

architecture

component

software

It

creating

architecture

component

operations

for

for

network

provide

software

extensible

multiple

to

services

systems

etal disclose

Potel

not teach

components

developing

Web

layer

component

invoking

APA does

However

component

services

limitations

across

platforms

18

combination

provides

with

interfaces

Potel

for

et

al

teach

extensions

of

extending

navigation

frameworks

components
page

of

API

enclosed

copy

As per claim

APA
of

in

19

combination

enclosed

with Potel

et

al

teach

browsing

dynamic

browsers

page

copy

575FH366

Wl-AppleOl

28813

Number 081435377

ApplicationlControl
Art

Unit

Page

2755

Response

Applicants

moot

view

in

Any
examiner

3805

should

assigned

Final

new

Arguments

with respect

to

claims

grounds

be

directed

phone

of

to

Pat

numbers

are 703-308-9051

for

for

Caldwell

be

normally

1719

been

have

considered

but are

rejection

communication

this

concerning

examinercan

The fx

is

the

of

inquiry

TPie

arguments

to

or earlier

whose

reached

telephone

number

is

from the

703-305-

FLEXTIME

on

where

the organization

regular

communications

communications

this application

or

proceeding

and 703-308-9052

for After

communications

Any

proceeding

inquiry

should

of

general

be directed

nature

to

the

or relating

receptionist

to

the

whose

status

of

this application

telephone

number

PRIMARY

or

EXAMINER

is

703-305-

9600

une

17

2000

575FH367

WI-AppleOl

28814

ts

CPQ%

UNITED STATES
Patent
Address
4Te5

/I

APPLICATION

NO

FILING

and

COMMISSIONER
Washington

DATE

FIRST

NAMED

DEPARTMENT

Trademark
D.C

OF

PATENTS

AND TRADEMARKS

20231

ATTORNEY

INVENTOR

DOCKET

1/U

N127b/1

1i1J

II

IYIUNI\I1

ART

.lI

UNIT

DATE

find

NO
117

EXAMINER

121

1/1

Please

OF COMMERCE

Office

below

andior attached

an

Office

communication

this

NUMBER

/21

MAILED

concerning

PAPER

application

or

proceeding
commissioner

P10-900

Rev

2195

LIP

GPO

of

Patents

end

Trademarks

File
1909

490-993

Copy

575FH392

WI-AppleOl

28839

No

Application

081436

Notice

of Allowabthty

Applicants

CLERON ET AL

377

MAILING

The
claims

herewith

THIS

allowable

being

mailed
or previously
NOTICE
OF ALLOWABILITY
of the

initiative

Office

or

upon

communication

This

2.Z

Th

3.0

The

4.0

filed

of

amendment

to

after

as

formal

for foreign

None

1.313

und

35

in

documents

have

been

the

Ap

documents

have

been

or

of the

certified

PCT

claim

of

comply

will

is

AMENDMENT

FORMAL
by

required

or

to

21

Paper

Notice

of

required

by

the

proposed

required

by

the

sftsched

Any

the

reply

spplicsnt

such

indicia

ALLOWANCE

letter should

should

comment

Examiners

received

of

to

stage

INFORMAL

file

reply

complying

with

THREE-MONTH

THIS

from

application

IS

the

PERIOD

APPLICATION

OR DECLARATION

Patent

the

requirements

reasons

gives

noted

EXTENDABLE

NOT

iS

which

PTO-152
REQUIRED

Review

Drawing

drawing

upper
end

correction

right
Issue

which

filed

Examiners

regsrding

the

in

communication

Drafispersons

Amendment

37

CFR 1.84c

see

transmittal

Allowance

include

Notice
also

national

119e

application

OF

OATH

number

as the application
psper with

separate

attached

to this

has

as

this

why

PTO-948

attached

No

changes

filed

No
in

DRAWINGS

the

changes

Note

fl

received

35 U.S.C

of this
of thIs

NOTICE

or

SUBSTITUTE

deficient

NEW

submit

under

priority

in

EX.AMINES

changes

domestic

for

including

be

have

172s

Rule

including

should

documents

priority

FROM THE MAiLING DATE
ABANDONMENT
result

MONTHS

hereto

of the

copies

Buresu

made

MUST

Identifying

course
at the

received

riot

declaration

including

fl

Application

received

attached

cant

RJ

due

issue

received

priority

copies

oath

in

from

9a-d

been

priority

to timely

the

be mailed

to withdrawsl

subject

1308

11

U.S.C

of the

THREE

Note

will

is

included

the

of

of the

Acknowledgementis

has

address-net

drawings

priority

copies

International

Failure

If

1-13

as

copies

Copies

below

the correspondence
this application

11/3/00

received

Certified

Applicant

Unit

communication

in

application

MPEP

renumbered

been

with

appropriate

This

Certified

Certified

sheet

CLOSED

other

and

was

that

final

have

cover

the

Due or
RIGHTS

CFR

37

which

acceptable

claim

Soms

All

on

Fee

Issue

See

applicant

12.4-8.11-15
are

made

and

CaidwelI

OR REMAINS

IS

GRANT OF PATENT

the

respbnsive

2151

appears

MERITS

Allowance

of

by

on
is

ON THE

NOT

15

islsre

claims

drawings

Notice

petition

is

Acknowledgment

illowed

communication

DATE of this
PROSECUTION

Art

Pat

All

Examiner

letter

addrssed

FOR

REQUtREMENT
hand
Fee

corner

Due

the

Comment

should
to

the

THE

or

be

hex
in

the

written

Official

DEPOSIT

been

spproved

Office

action

on the

by
of

examiner

the

No

Paper

The

drawings

drawlngs

Draftsperaon

OF

BIOLOGICAL

APPLICATION NUMBER SERIES
ISSUE BATCH NUMBER end DATE

MATERIAL

CODE

the

of the

SERIAL
NOTICE
OF

NUMBER

If

be included

Attschments

10
30
SO
70

Notice

of

References

Notic

of

Drsftpersons

Information

Disclosure

Examiners

Cr-mment

of Biological

Cited

20
40

Drawing

Statements

Review

PTO-1449

No

Material

Regarding

Requirement

Paper
for

Examiners

Amendment/Comment

Examiners

PTO-948

Notice

60

PTO-892

Pstent

Statement

Deposit

90

of

Interview

Informal

Summary

Patent

of

5-001

Notice

et Aliowsbility

No.

Paper

Reasons

for

Allowancu

Other

PRIMARY

PTO-37

PTO-152

Application

PTO-413

EXAMINER

Pert

of

Paper

No

36

575FH393

WI-AppleOl

28840

Number 08/435377

Application/Control
Art

Unit

Page

2151

DETAILED
This

11/03/00

communication

Claims

is

in

to

response

ACTION
amendment

after

final

that

was received

were canceled

17-19

Allowable Subject Matter
Claims

The

is

arrangement

11-16

directed

towards

on

residing

recites

components

that

layer includes

provid

services

represents

different

network

network

layer coupled

to

relation

to

the

interfaces

the

and means

represents

different

for

computer

ion

claim

amono

first

configured

to

network

navigation

on the computer

wherein

layer

the

qpponent

for

available

on

programming

application

network

that

navigation

and obtain information

navigation

the

in integrating

component

layer includes

in

object

network

and network

network

claim

component

class included

architeure layer

search

comnonent

available

net work

present

navigation

the network

on the computer

recites

The

Independent

network

first

the computing

uniquely

constructing

resources

and

1-13

component

layered

developing

network

construct

component

the network

for

layer

to

allowance

network

computer

oftware

navigation

interfaces

to

Thtedsces

to

for

and replaceable

available

comræunicaf

computer networks

the

renumbered

been

reasons

of

resources

Independent

network

coupled

programming

apblication

programming

developing

extensible

to

have

Claims

component

network

facilitate

an

computer

application

components

are allowed

examiners statement

an

is

following

application

uniquely

124-8

that

wherein

the network

575FH394

WI-AppleOl

28841

Number 08/435377

Application/Control
Unit

Art

layer

admitted

environment

or

above

of

Applicants

Any comments
the

payment

accompany
Statement

Any
examiner

3805

Final

to

layered

teach

to

corresponding

and

or

nor

prior

art

the

suggest

are

fairly

class included

in

in

interpreted

teach

means

the claimed

first

communication

Taligent

the claim elements

does not teach

art

fee

Reasons

for

of

inquiry

should

Such

the

same

for

the

application

directed

can

and

to

avoid

submissions

must be

by applicant

processing

be

should

delays

clearly

submitted

should

labeled

no

later

preferably

Comments

on

Allowance

to

Pat

normally

numbers

are 703-308-9051

communication

this

concerning

be

necessary

the issue fee

the issue

The examiner

assigned

fails

priorart

component

navigation

considered

of

The fax phone

is

extensible

ensure

to

The closest

comnonents

when

prior

layered

interfaces

programming

than

The

function

and

network

onstructing

the

limitations

specification

ecture

teaches

Potel

underlined

structure

equivalent

erchif

navigation

However

arrangement

combination

of

art

prior

ware

soft

and network

the comDuting

Applicants

the

to

integra/lycoupled

is

among

light

Page

2151

for

for

Caidwell

be

reacned

whose

on

the organization

regular

or

earlier

communications

telephone

number

is

from the

703-305-

FLEXTIME
where

communications

this

application

or proceeding

and 703-308-9052

for After

communications

575FH395

WI-AppleOl

28842

Application/Control
Art

Unit

Number 08/435377

Page

2151

Any

proceeding

inquiry

of

should

be directed

general

nature

to

the

or relating

receptionist

to

the

whose

status

of

telephone

this application

number

is

or

703-305-

9600.

PC

PRIMARY

EXAMiNEF

575FH396

Wl-Appleol

28843