Apple, Inc. v. Motorola, Inc. et al

Filing 93

Declaration of Christine Saunders Haskett filed by Plaintiffs Apple, Inc., NEXT SOFTWARE, INC. re: 90 Motion Requesting Claims Construction (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 21 IEEE Dictionary, # 2 Ex. 22 '575 file history, # 3 Ex. 23 '486 file history, # 4 Ex. 24 Order No. 18, # 5 Ex. 25 '705 file history, # 6 Ex. 26 '647 file history, # 7 Ex. 27 Brad Cox, # 8 Ex. 28 Microsoft Press Dictionary, # 9 Ex. 29 '002 file history, # 10 Ex. 30 Dictionary of Computer Words, # 11 Ex. 31 Computer Dictionary, # 12 Ex. 32 Academic Press Dictionary, # 13 Ex. 33 IBM Dictionary, # 14 Ex. 34 Black's Law Dictionary, # 15 Ex. 35 About 3GPP, # 16 Ex. 36 '919 patent, # 17 Ex. 37 '713 provisional application) (Haslam, Robert)

EXHIBIT 26

-a

.s

6948647

BEST COPY

Li

Nihii

lT

in

ri_rii

JlI1NlllihlL

I-IN

ifth

IL
ii-

Il

1F11

lYII_tlLLri

Liiil

llF.lILll

L...ii.iI

4Ii.1.4li4.Ii4.4Il.urII44rI

I1

HLftHIIN/PCT

LICENSE
puShy

Foreign
36

usc

Verified

119

claimed

condItions

yes

Rtp

STSOR

fl/no

no

FILED

lnerelnss

ui.iui

SHEETS

cPi\

.FpIF-Ii-

TOTAL
CLAIMS

DRWGS

CGJTRY

met

andAcknowledged

/96

Oil/UI

INOEP
CLAIMS

uo

Itr-n/I

i/

SQ.L/t..J

\//9//c
ji

jjt

HNL

H4ftr

1l

.Nl

NIETblOD.ERfrERFIDRrILINc

H1

DOCKET NO

RECEIVED

ii

rLltFriett

--i-r-rnr
EM

ATtORNEYS

FEE

FILING

-/..
NMl

Hi

/11

IkVi 1ftAiI/

itY

t7I
U.S

OFCOMMJ

DEPT

PAt

TMPTO-436L

Rev.12-S4

-U

PARTS
FILED

OF APPLICATION
SEPARATELY

Examiner

Applications

NOTICE

OF

ALLOWANCE

CLAIMS

MAILEQ
ii
Assistant

ISSUE

IQ
Amount

Due

FEE

DDu

Print

Fig

5/zgi
FORESTER

ISEN

PATENT

BATCiI

e4Ry1Viner

PREPARED

FOR

Iqt

ISSUE

EXAM1NER

NUMBER

ISSUE

Area

.1

WARNING

The
by

information

the

Patent

PTO-43eA

Drwg

ShOeta

Label

fl/92l

DRAWING

it

DatePaid

wrJ4Nng

lRev

Claim

Print

\2f

Examiner

-/41

SUPERVISORY

Form

Claims

total

ALLOWED

United

disclosed

States

Trademark

Code
Office

herein
Title

is

may be restricted
35 Sections
122

restricted

to

authorized

Fwm

Unauthorized
161

and

368

employees

disclosure

may

Possession
and

contractors

be

prohibited

outside

the

U.S

only

DgsLShts set_

647

001

Wl-Apple0004094

THE UNITED

IN

STATES

PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
MR
APPLICANTS

Miller

James

251999

al

et

Groitn

SEPJAL

NO

FILING

DATE

February

2710

08/595257
1996

TITLE

System and Method

EXAMINER

Patrick

for

NO

ATTY DKT

Structure

P1716/357US

OF MAILING

CERTIFICATE
hereby
Service

the date

Date

certify

as

Commissioner
on

on

244-

ART UNIT

Postal

an Action

Performing

Edouard

first

for

class

Patents

printed

March

that

this

mail

is

paper
in

an

being

envelope

Box Non-Fee

degosited

with

addressed

to

Amendment

the United

States

Assistant

Washington

D.C 20231

below

15

1999

Tuan

Ngo

AMENDMENT
ASSISTANT

COMMISSIONER

WASHINGTON

D.C

FOR PATENTS

20231

Sir
In

please

r/fl1

O11jEt

response

amend

POO@O3

to

the

Office

Action

the above-identified

mailed

application

December
as

15

1998

paper

11

follows

O111527

2OO

OP

1-

647FH1

16

WI-App1e0004209

THE

1.

Once amended

and performing

device

an output

user

10

linked

to

server

the

13

processing

memory

for

in data

comprising

data

program

including

interface

for

detecting

detected

routines

the

program

structures

in the

data and

LQZ

structures

enabling

the

selection

detected

of

structure

and

and

the selected structure

12

the

presenting

an action processor

11

14

action

structures

including

analyzer

actions

detecting

data

storing information

comprising

linking

structures

receiving

for

device

memory

an

for

for

system

on detected

actions

an input

routines

computer-based

unit coupled

controlling

the

for

performing

the

selected

action

linked

and

to

execution

the

input

device

the

program

of

the

output

device

and the

routines.

-2-

647FH1

17

WI-AppIe00042l

Ms Once amended

program
for

therein

program

least

at

linking

enabling

the

executin

action

one

selection

to

the

perform

steps

of

data

in the

structure

detecting

computer

causing

computer

stoyig

data

computer

receiving

medium

storage

of

the

to

detected

the

and

structure

action

selected

structe

linked

linked

to

the

action

selected

and

structure

14-

bt%Once amended
for

causing

computer

the

In

computer

to

computer

memory

having

perform an

action

on

storing actions

structure

system

identified in

data comprising

means

for

receiving

computer

means

for

detecting

structure

means

for

linking

at least

means

for

selecting

the

means

for

executing

one

data

in

action

structure

the

the

selected

data

to

and

action

the detected

linked

structure

action

linked

to

and

the

selected

structure

-3-

647FH1

18

WI-AppIe00042l

Once amended
for

computer

34

the

causing

In

linking

enabling

structure

executing

the

the steps

of

and

retrieving

identifythestring

of

the

selected

t% Once amended
strings

in

the

one action

selection

an

perform

action

on

storing actions

structure

identified

method

in

data

computer

at least

memory

having

the steps of

data comprising

detecting

Qfr

to

computer

receiving

contains

comFuter

data

to

the detected

structure

action

linked

The method

recited

wherein

step

sfring

the

and

of

in

structure

linked

to

the

claim

detecting

from the memory and

action

selected

and

structiire

wherein

structure

scang

the

memory

further comprises

the data

to

-_____

-4-

647FH1

19

WI-AppIe00042l

Q. Once amended
identify

and

select

presenting

the

at least

one

structure

as

ID

detected

structure

and

11

and

12

action

performing

the

in the

linked

have been

by

the

the

the

action

selected

action

causing

in

computer

computer

to

said

dataf

said application

application

user the method

comprising

the steps of

application

computer

to

for

structure

data

detected

the application

presented

selected

on

running

from

action

with

detected

to

data

structure

communicating

linked

data

computer

detecting

linking

concurrently

computer

receiving

an action

perform

from

data received

method

computer-based

to

structure

determine

application

and

to

to

the location

enable

determine

if

selection

the detected

of

of

the

the

structure

and

linked

to

the

detected

pattern.

-5Cl

647FH120

WI-AppIe00042l

AddThe f1owing

The system

detected

of

claims

recited

structure

in

claim

and

wherein

linked

the

interface

user

action using

enables

the

selection

sound activation

scli

22.

The system

second

one

of

recited

in

claim

wherein

one

first

of

the

of

enabling

actions

may

invoke

the actions

lt
The method

recited

in claim

recited

in

wherein

the

step

uses

sound

activation

24 The method

second

one

of

claiml wherein

first

one

of the actions

may

invoke

the actions

-6-

30

647FH

121

WI-AppIe00042l

REMARKS
Claims

U.S.C

1-20

103a

In response

are

Applicants

that

that

is

amendments

reconsider

the

cover

to

respectfully submit

above

all

and

first

lines

to

claims

the

over

the following

rejected

claims

amending

correct

aspects

pending

in

21

the

IN

THE

the invention

of

1-20

and

added

art of

prior

under

and

11-13

typographical

20

and

error

Applicants

claims 21-24

present

record and in view

remarks request

that

of

the

Examiner

the

and

22

for

added

claims

is

follows

as

23

and

one of

FOR ADDED CLAIMS

SPECIFICATION

specification

sound activation

Claims

are

been

all

application

Support

using

17

further

patentable

SUPPORT

Claims

claim

and have

case

in this

Applicants

amending

also

adding claims 21-24

subject matter

pending

are

page 11

9-12

lines

24

the

actions

may

invoke

second

of the actions

one

page

6-13

REJECTIONS UNDER
In

under 35 U.S.C

Sobotka

et

of

paragraph

in

103

view

of

the

as

U.S

Office

Action

unpatentable

Patent

No

the

over

5247437

35

103

U.S.C

Examiner

U.S

to

al

rejected

Patent

No

Vale

claims

1-20

at

et

5164899

to

-7-

647FH122

WI-AppIe00042l

claims

Regarding
al

do not

asserted

that

maintained

Vale

response

iii

the linking

teach

structure

provide

might be applied

Amended

to

the

amended

recites

claims

claims

actions

memory

instance

structures

MN

could

et

then

structure

nodes

the system

in

Sobotka

that

have obvious.

of

and

to

Sobotka

et

al

faster In

be retrieved

and 20

11-13

as

the

rejections

respectfully traverse

relevant

in

computer-based
performing

by Vale

where data

amending

claim

detected

the

it would

taught

system

are

Applicants

as

to

by page

provided

concluded

action

linking

would

is

action

of

conceded

the linking between DIN and

that

Examiner

the

the

incorporate

it

et

by data

Consequently

because

teach

explicitly

and 20 the Examiner

11-13

part

for

system

on detected

structures

detecting

storing information

in data

and

comprising

structures

including

routines

program

including
an
linking

an
to

the

The linked

of

subroutine

node

in the

application

the

for

detecting

detected

for

structures

in the

data and

structures

the

performing

selected action linked

structure

of

the claimed

MN

structure

CPU

causing

server
to

action processor

selected

an action page

Additionally

another

actions

actions

from the heading

execution

analyzer

..

for

16

to

perform

claimed

loading

line

the

22

invention

are

patentably

of

Vale

The linked

to

page

17

sequence

invention

identified

line

of

structure

actions enable

which

operations

action

into

distinguished

may

computer

is

page

specify

lines

4-

opening

an appropriate

field

-8-

647FH123

WI-AppIe00042l

An

and closing the application
and

external

actions

deficiencies

page

of

lines

In

which

includes

defines

the

is

thus

headings

for

used

given

references

recites

linking

lack of

to

linking

structures

combination

is

performing

the

index

heading

25-29

to

an

to

an

or

as

action

distinguished

because

there

in

the claimed

selected

action

is

is

linking
from

no

to

the

of

or

to

invention

but

does

that

the claimed

actions

to

and

an

selection

selected

CPU

structure

to

string

key words

the

cause

of

HN

The

15-17

linking

Sobotka

linking

invention

linked

heading

but cannot

Therefore

claimed

column

stores

of

and

56-57

lines

relationship

structure

informational

each

nodes

the heading

the claimed

can

cure

processes

also

in

lines

structural

as

col

entry

ID col

lines

col

of heading

node

the

actions can

14

listed

headings

linked

the

actions

internal

and disruptive

consists

not teach or suggest

linking

Consequently claim

Vale

action

an action

as

of

does

Further

be

line

page

or an

patentably

there cannot

Thus

6-11

Each heading

and

index

In brief Sobotka

Vale discloses

the

delineate

to

perform an operation

of

12-13

string

to

associated

its

one

lines

see

string

structure

for

11

structure

of

title

col

list

HN

the

information

keyword

sort

contrast

further include

employing laborious
line

page

may

lines

page

prior systems

17-21

action

structure

an

not cure

invention

action

the

which

the detected

Vale

action

of

to

in

..

alone

either

Sobotka

linked

emphasis

or

in

or Vale

action

or

added

patentable

-9-

647FH124

WI-AppIe00042l

Claims

2-10

for

patentable

at

Claim

the data

least

highlights detected

for

patentable

menu

the

linked

patentable

for

Claim

memory

application

application

passages

of

patentable

this

10

or

the

program

emphasis

Sobotka

for

this

is

or

reason

interface

in

suggested

the

cited

claim

Therefore

is

wherein

the output

alone

or in

the user

device

or

to

display

suggested

combination

interface

in

pop-up

the

Therefore

cited

claim

is

reason

an

limitation

application

that

either

additional

of

not disclosed

provides

added which

or Vale

or

combination

in

or

user

the

is

alone

either

Vale

additional

wherein

not disclosed

is

by causing

further

interface

of

limitation

either

further comprise

for this

alone

which

Vale

patentable

which

added

or

receives

reason

action

additional

recites

are therefore

device

input

emphasis

of Sobotka

which

further

action

of Sobotka

passages

the

of an

selection

of

the

and

the

passages

limitation

either

additional

recites

is

further

the

wherein

concurrently

cited

claim

or Vale

this

Claim

the

structures

Sobotka

of

passages

in

of

limitation

running

Therefore

recites

from claim

indirectly

same reasons

or suggested

Claim

enables

the

from an application

combination

or

directly

the further

recites

not disclosed

in

depend

alone

is

of

wherein

running

interrupts

in

programs

and communicates

combination

or

suggested

Therefore

in

stored

and an

concurrently

not disclosed

or

the

with

in the

the

cited

claim

10

is

reason

10

647FH125

WI-AppIe00042l

Claims

and

are therefore

Claims

therefore

patentable

patentable

for

one

for at

for

action

least

alone

in

at least

the

limitation

the

which

combination

the

those

of

claim

same reasons

from claim 13 and

or indirectly

are

same reasons

to

corresponding

claim

and

therefore

is

reason

the

is

to

corresponding

further limitation

includes

structure

limitations

directly

additional

recites

detected

or

recite

depend

recites

this

Claim 16

20

patentable

14-19

Claim 14

least

and

11-13

step

of

linking

not disclosed

Therefore

of

claim

wherein

the

is

in

patentable

of

action

particular

or suggested

16

the step

linking

to

the

Sobolka or Vale

for

this

at

either

additional

reason

Claim 18

patentable

for

recites

this

limitation

additional

corresponding

to

claim

and

is

therefore

reason

11

647FH126

WI-AppIe00042l

SUMMARY
In conclusion

and

added

art of

the

If

pending

the

contact

claims 21-24

record and

has

Applicants

clearly

therefore

claims

Examiner

respectfully submit

Applicants

present

request

consider

the

that

added

patentable

claims

this

undersigned

15

1999

claims

pending

matter

withdraw

over

the

the prior

rejections

pass the application

the

Examiner

is

1-20

issue

to

invited

of

to

attorney

James

March

and

case

submitted

Respectfully

Date

all

subject

Examiner

the

questions regarding

that

it

Miller

et

al

By

Ngo RkNojh259

Tuan
Carr

Ferrell

LLP

2225

East Bayshore

Palo

Road

Alto

Phone
Fax

Suite 200

CA 94303
650 812-3400

650

812-3444

12

647FH127

WI-App1e0004220