Apple, Inc. v. Motorola, Inc. et al

Filing 93

Declaration of Christine Saunders Haskett filed by Plaintiffs Apple, Inc., NEXT SOFTWARE, INC. re: 90 Motion Requesting Claims Construction (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 21 IEEE Dictionary, # 2 Ex. 22 '575 file history, # 3 Ex. 23 '486 file history, # 4 Ex. 24 Order No. 18, # 5 Ex. 25 '705 file history, # 6 Ex. 26 '647 file history, # 7 Ex. 27 Brad Cox, # 8 Ex. 28 Microsoft Press Dictionary, # 9 Ex. 29 '002 file history, # 10 Ex. 30 Dictionary of Computer Words, # 11 Ex. 31 Computer Dictionary, # 12 Ex. 32 Academic Press Dictionary, # 13 Ex. 33 IBM Dictionary, # 14 Ex. 34 Black's Law Dictionary, # 15 Ex. 35 About 3GPP, # 16 Ex. 36 '919 patent, # 17 Ex. 37 '713 provisional application) (Haslam, Robert)

EXHIBIT 23

THE UNITED STATES

IN

AND TRADEMARK

PATENT
APPLICANT

Michael

NO

APPLICATION

cC

10/408789

DATE

FILING

Cleron

OFFICE

April3

TITLE

2003

.EXAItINERi

St

John

NETWORK COMPONENT

REPLACEABLE

EXTENSIBLE

EIVED

ID

Courtenay

62004

Jul

GROUP ART UNIT

2126

Afl DKT NO

18602-07124

Technology

CERTIFICATE
hereby

cntfr

that

to

envetopraddreued
the

date

shown below

is

eoncspondeacc

this

Mail

Ameodmait

Stop

the

tr

being

Express

Mail

Convtalona
Nunther

MaSing

For
Is

United
Patents

flied

In

Postal

States

P.O

below

ServIce

Boa 1450

then

this

as

Class

First

VA

Meatandtia

Is

correspondence

LA

2OD9
NUMBER

MAIL MAILING

In

being

at
on

deposited

By
Rimma

EXPRESS

Mall

22313-1450

1.10

wIththeUtfitsdsweePontaseeEtpreUMlPOntOneetoAddrtSneeserVitePWnualttto37CPR

Dated

2100

OF MAILING

with the

deposited

Center

Budnitskaya

Reg No.48237

EL5999075171JS

STOP AMENDMENT
COMIvUSSIONER FOR PATENTS

MAIL

P.O BOX

1450

VA

AISEXAIIDRIA

22313-1450

AMENDMENT
iO/01J2004

00004004

hItHER

10400789

192555

SIR
54.00

FC1202

05

04

Tha Amendment
Action

dated

March

17/13/200411900110111

It

FC

00000057

begin

92555

the patent

application

identified

above

is

in response

to the

0111cc

92004

Amendments
Remarks

fbr

to

the

on

Claims begin

page

of

this

on

page

of

this

paper

paper

104091119

110.19

IlaOzatltZd/5F/StflOOtJ

486

RE

101

WI-App1e0002281

PATENT

AMENDMENTS
Please

amend

1.

the claims

An

Original

arrangement

on

residing

TO THE CLAIMS

follows

as

and

extensible

computer

coupled

replaceable

to

layered

the

network

computer

computing

component

arrangement

layered

comprising
software

architecture

component

control

the

component

layer

services

provide

layer includes

first

class

for

navigation

available

on

coupled

to the

the

to

the

application

computer

computer

network

network

among

wherein

the

the

computing

that

components
network

the

component

and

different

architecture

component

and

interfaces

programming

to

architecture

component

navigation

interfaces

that represents

object

software

network

system

operating

software

components

programming

conununication

facilitate

computer

developing

directed

in the

the

of computing

application

included

network

the

plurality

layer defining

network

of

operations

with an

layer interfacing

to construct

network

network

first

resources

component

layer in integrating

and network

layer
relation

to

navigation

components.

2.

Original
are

components

3.

navigation

interfaces

object

computing

arrangement

of

claim

wherein

the

network

The

computing

arrangement

of

claim

wherein

the

application

navigation

objects.

Original

programming

The

further

data

representing

second

comprise
stream

class

second

for constructing

for transferring

information

among

network
objects

of

the

arrangement.

4.

navigation

Original
object

is

The

an Item

computing

object

and

the

arrangement
second

of claim

network

wherein

navigation

the

object

first

is

network

Stream object

186021011241SE15122004.3

486

RE

102

WI-App1e0002282

PATENT

and wherein

Item

that the

resource

the

tem

object

object

additional

representing

component
components

further

interfaces

architecture

and

arrangement
computing

for providing

arrangement

to

provided

from

information

wherein

claim

computing

navigation

the

network

the

application

network

third

for constructing

of

components
between

communication

enable

the

the

navigation

software

computing

components

An

Original

third class

comprise

to thereby

layer

of

arrangement

behaviors

network

the

to obtain

object

represents

The computing

Original
programming

Stream

the

spawns

object

and

extensible

services

replaceable

to information

directed

component

layered

computing

on computer

available

the

networks

comprising

processor
an

system

operating

software

architecture

component

operations

of

defining

plurality

network

the

and

network

obtain

ensure

is

network

available

integrally

navigation

the

computer

on

coupled

communication

to the

among

the

the

layer

network

the

different

network

architecture

and network

and

interfaces

that represents

wherein

to

the

networks

programming

component

computing

configured

components

computer

component

software

the

and

application

network

architecture

navigation

on

available

to control

system

operating

component

components

layer includes

component

resources

layer

of computing

information

for constructing

means

software

layer for creating

component

search

the

processor

to the

coupled

layer

component
layer to

navigation

components

Original
component
components

layer

and

within

The computing

software

one

another

component
to

form

arrangement

of claim

architecture

layer

compound

wherein

comprise

document

having

the

means
mixed

network
for

embedding

data

types

and

formats

18602107124/5F1$122004.3

486

RE

103

WI-App1e0002283

PATENT

The

Original

8.

programming

interfaces

implements

computing

arrangement

means

arrangement

means

wherein

claim

for constructing

The computing

of

network

for constructing

the

application
that

protocol.

Original

9.

programming

among

the

flinctionatity

to existing

The computing

Original
comprises

component

computing

computing

functions

component

coupled

to

to the

13.

screen

networks

Original
component

navigation

of

the

the

wherein

claim

network

application

that

component

navigation

communication

to enable

components

The

computing

Currently

the

over

computing

claim

10

of

data

of

the

computing

content.

wherein

remotely

screen

the

the

computing

onto

log

computing

another

arrangement.

10

claim

wherein

the

network

10

wherein

the

network

component.

arrangement

component

and

networks

arrangement

browsing

editor

of

and view images on

wherein

claim

for

of claim

one of

text

displaying

and

movies

displaying

arrangement.

Cancelled.

15.

of

viewing

arrangement

files

The computing

comprises

14.

having

part

transfer

comprises

component

navigation

one of

Original

12.

arrangement

The computing

Original

11.

computer

comprise

of

component

navigation

components.

10.

on

interfaces

additional

provides

comprise

object

navigation

16.

navigation

17.

navigation

is

adapted

Currently
object

is

is

to

Amended

adapted

Currently
object

Amended The

adapted

browse

the

The

layered

to display

Amended
to

layered

The
display

text

computer

on

layered

of claim

arrangement

the

network

network.

arrangement
computer

arrangement

images on

wherein

12

of claim 12 44

wherein

the

network

wherein

the

network

display.

of claim

computer

j.Q

4.4

display.

18602/0712415F5122004.3

486

RE

104

WI-App1e0002284

PATENT

The

18 Currently Amended
navigation

object

includes

between

information

on

residing

in the

objects

19 Original

An

computer

commands

software

and

extensible

adapted

replaceable

be coupled

to

for creating

component

layered

computing

network

the

arrangement

component

computing
the

network

computer

wherein

for transferring

datastream

layered

on

i4-4

of claim

arrangement

layered

arrangement
arrangement

layered

comprising
software

architecture

component

control

the

layer defining

network

layer

of

least

that represents

20 Original
network

navigation

location

on

the

computer

navigation

components

of

component

abstract

class

to

coupled

the

software

among

in the

the

computer

navigation

the

network

navigation

and

programming

architecture

component

network

the

interface

application

network

navigation

network

programming

application

the

one network

computer

for defining

on

available

least

to the

included

one

object

network

layer

component

to

and

at

component

arrangement

that represents

object

21 Original
network

layered

at

to

directed

abstract

one computing

The

be coupled

classes

architecture

component

components

an

communication

facilitate

to

service

resource

layer

component

least

of computing

to

system

operating

software

layer including

interconnected

at

the

computer

adapted

component

interface

the

that provides

component

number

plurality

component

network

of

operations

with an

layer interfacing

of

claim

method

19 wherein

of downloading

the

abstract

class

from

information

defines

remote

network

The

object

layered

that

arrangement

represents

of

claim

additional

19 wherein

behaviors

the

abstract

provided

to the

layer for integrating

with

class

defines

computing

layer

22
lions

the

software

Currently

component

Amended

architecture

computer

which when executed by

readable

prococcor

medium

hnving

inn computer
erm-mne

operations

oyetein

of

otorod

the

network

thereon

adapted

to

computer

ho coupled

to

pronram_

186021071

2415F151

220043

486

RE

105

WI-App1e0002285

PATENT

p4jct

for

pter

providing network
the

networks
computer

containing

comnuter

network

constructing

of

computer

23
object

is

adapted

24
object

is

object

between

New

New

includes

system

to

browse

the

to

text

on

images on

The computer program

software

commands

the

product

at

meditia

computer-readable

on

at

least

one

abstract

class

from

and

class

least

enable

to

interaction

one computing
with an
of

operations

of

to

the

in

component

operating

system on

computer

ihc

software

system

22 wherein

claim

between

the

network

the

navigation

network

product

computer

The computer program

classes

and

system coupled

computer

operations

based

layer interfacing

program

computer

the

abstract

control

The computer program
to display

the

object

architecture

The computer

to display

adapted

26
object

New

adapted

25
is

New

with

of

user

comprising

object

abstract

navigation

component

oroduct

navigation

associated

network

to

foerforming

interconnected

methods

using

services

program

code

program

set

information

22 wherein

the

network

navigation

22 wherein

the

network

navigation

22

the

network

navigation

claim

display

product

computer

product

for creating

of

of

claim

display

of

claim

datastream

wherein

for transferring

information

objects

1860V01124/5F15122004.3

486

RE

106

WI-App1e0002286

REMARKS
Claims

15-18 and

claims

was

without

of

as to

U.S

Serial

No

of

inaccessibility

the third

In

C.F.R

U.S

Patent

not

which

upon

under 37

Certificate

of

the

23-26

claims

have

Examiner

Action

offer

Office

that

to surrender

In

patent

14

been

been

has

original

reissue

or

patent

an

Affidavit

submit

Applicants

response

cancelled

added

that the

indicated

the

identifies

it

3.73

Examiner

Action

reissue

present

C.F.R

Office

the original

the

in

proper

new

claim

response

or

original

Bl

6212575

paragraph

is

3.73

the

In

rejected

and

the required

Declaration

Patent

stand

amended

paragraph

filed

and

pending

22 have been

second

In the

application

were

1-22

the present

correctly

reissue

based

is

application

indicated

identifying

of

instead

application

Patent

under 37

Certificate

Applicants submit

U.S

the

that

the

the

requisite

No

Serial

62 12575B1
In

Reissue

Michael

that adequately

Cleron and

filed

petition

Decision
In

U.S.C

251

based

from

In

the

an improper

broadened
limitation

Office

the

U.S

in

claim

No

Serial

have

22

subject

paragraph

eleven

first

the patent

class

however

matter

claim

upon

as

is

claims

rejected

subject

cancelled

matter

of

with

included

did

the

62l2575Bl

Examiner

the

of

of

Office

the

by

Fisher

1.47a
The

in the

submitted
14-18

and 22 under

during

present

and amended

14

Reissue

inventors

37 C.F.R

indicated

suffendered

which

as

error

original

signed

Stephen

of which

copy

Examiner

is

under

Petition

inventor

nonsigning

one

corrected

Declaration

the

that

1.47

Action

recapture

The

error

least

at

claims

35

the

reissue

15-18

application

to

depend

19

claim
of

recapture

Action

Office

submit

Applicants

that the

indicated

identi

adequately

and Trademark

Patent

37 C.F.R

Applicants

claim
to

respect

of

the

Patent

response

Indeed

of

being improper

independent

With

patent

as

of

prosecution

is

nine

paragraph

the

Examiner

Action

submit

of

States

Under

Status

According

not

one

least

at

behalf

United

Office

response

Applicants

on

52003

the

does

it

In

identifies

the

by

granted

because

Timo Bruck

on September

was

of

eight

al

1.175

by 37 C.F.R

Declaration

through

defective

is

Declaration

required

was

four

paragraphs

not

provided

surrendered

the

Office

new

reissue

in the

Examiner

haa

Action

details

the

how claim 22
of

14

that

has
eliminates

claim

22

the

Nowhere

interfaces..

how new independent

being

is

the original

stated

claim

programming

on

prosecution

Examiner

independent

application

indicate

during

any

is

in the

an improper

18602107124/5Ff5122004.3

486

RE

107

WI-App1e0002287

PATENT

of

recapture

surrendered

22

to

claim

In

respect

paragraph

matter

subject

Examiner

is

If

Examiner
invited

respectfully

continues

maintain

to

further

to provide

his

details

with

position

of

in support

his

position

defective

upon

reissue

respectfully

l3

In the

103a
Byte

October

being

1991

of

information

services

performing

the

methods

at least

claimed

invention

between
component

component-based
the

is

Smarts
edition

traversed

respectfully

network

for providing

product

program

With

Primer

Stanley

rejection

the

system..

computer

program

on

with

of

the

for

product

one

interconnected

least

at

abstract

approach

layer

object

The

browsing

application-based

with

an
the

to control

directed

to

computer

at

least

at

least

invention

retrieving

approach of

one
with

abstract

the

beneficially

prior

browsing

product

claimed

class

abstract

one computing

network-oriented

program

The

system

computer
on

associated

and

claimed

and

is

of

based

methods

uses

navigation

layer

to

object

and

object

Emphasis added

22
user

enable

software

system

system

to

to

interfacing

in claim

navigation

in

computer

services

network

class

navigation

component

the

as recited

architecture

abstract

network

computer

advantageously

monolithic

the

the

architecture

system on

network

the

based

object

of

set

one computing

information

also

navigation

between

invention

network

constructs

to

computer

Network

U.S.C

35

and

operations

opposed

alia

computer

associated

operating

software

inter

251

and Llppman

claim 22 under

The

Applicants

U.S.C

35

Reinhardt

of

Reinhardt

This

Therefore

under

rejected

Lippman

Lippman

from

class

component

interaction

to

of

interaction

claimed

Reinhardt

Andy

error

1-22

View

in

Examiner

of

network

classes
using

invention

103a

view

one

least

at

being based

as

Applicants submit

response

to claims

rejection

Action

in

In

1-22

operations

abstract

for providing

Office

recites

user

constructing

The

the

394-394

pages

to

the

1-64

claim 22

Amended

identifies

claim

rejected

251

U.S.C

35

adequately

unpatentable

1994 pages

Addison-Wesley

under

remove

to

Examiner

Action

Under 35 USC

paragraph

as allegedly

Office

that

Rejection

to

the

declaration

Examiner

request

esponse

of

Declaration

Reissue

corrected

twelve

The

class

to enable

in

component

employs
information

as

systems

86021071241SF/5

122004.3

486

RE

108

WI-App1e0002288

PATENT

Reinhardt
that discusses

does

intelligent

networks

discloses

muting
hehall

Reinhardt

does

Line

not

altehiative

with

Lippman

classes

Since

the

layer interfacing

claimed

invention.

Reinhardt

and

does

their patentable

not

an

abstract

does

with an

operating

would
depend
the

not

of

deficiency

base

operating

of

usage
class

disclose

nor Lippman

Accordingly

from

claim 22

is

as

agents

is

is

Lippman

class

software

computer

mentioned

layer

Reinhardt

merely
Although

language.

as

at

an

are

architecture

over

patentable

and

claimed.

architecture

standard

the

object

component

or suggest

system on

navigation

layer

Reinhardt.

designed

to this

getwork

software

the

corollary

network

the

employing

from which

other

component
to control

system

the

system.

Reinhardt

with an

the

and programming

Lippman

computer

cure

the

object-oriented

not

Accordingly

system.

As

to

respect

users

the

on

system of

operating

system.

that

col.

agents

page 395

and Lippman

their patentability

and

col.

network

at

Claims 23-26

64

an

architecture

component

to the

features

neither

between

modular

layer interfacing

of

operations

interaction

the

operating

can be derived

architecture

computer

software

page

at

the

discloses

Lippman

the

services

similarly

tutorial describing

of

with

on-line

respect

with an

interfacing

in

interfacing

layer

with

network

the

or services

Reinhardt

in

publication

Reinhardt

Although

information

disclosure

is

move around

that

proxies

out

seeking

no

Reinhardt

technology.

or

agents

is

operations

or suggest

suggests

to monolithic

by Reinhardt

the

component

Reinhardt

Although

there

invention.

agent-based

and

user

architecture

disclose

computing

utilize

sofiware

to

col.

software

to control

system

Reinhardt

sent

51

page

that

to host

claimed

the

or suggest

networks

messages

component-based
computer

disclose

designed

or filtering

least

not

not

either

disclose

system

combination

person of

ordinary

find

the

directly

independent

claimed

of

the

invention

from which

references

in the

skill

or indirectly

claim

software

component-based

art

not

produce

the

considering

the

teachings

of

obvious.

from independent
they

does

architecture

depend

claim

in addition

22 and

derive

to reciting

features.

1860

2/071245

F/i

122004.3

486

RE

109

WI-App1e0002289

For

13

and

these

15-26

reasons

are allowable

Applicants

over

the

submits

respectfully

cited

art

of

that

and

record

all

the

pending

that

request

the

claims

Examiner

claims

allow

1-

the

case

submitted

Respectfully

MICHAEL
Dated

OO

CLERON

et

By_________________________
Rinuna

Rudnitskaya

Attorney

for

Fenwick
Silicon

801

West
Valley

California

Mountain

Tel
Fax

No

48237

LLP

Center
Street

View CA

415

Reg

Applicant

94041

875-2401

415281-1350
8602/07142/SF/5122004

10

86O2/O7l24/SF$l22OO4.3

486

RE

110

WI-App1e0002290