Apple, Inc. v. Motorola, Inc. et al

Filing 93

Declaration of Christine Saunders Haskett filed by Plaintiffs Apple, Inc., NEXT SOFTWARE, INC. re: 90 Motion Requesting Claims Construction (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 21 IEEE Dictionary, # 2 Ex. 22 '575 file history, # 3 Ex. 23 '486 file history, # 4 Ex. 24 Order No. 18, # 5 Ex. 25 '705 file history, # 6 Ex. 26 '647 file history, # 7 Ex. 27 Brad Cox, # 8 Ex. 28 Microsoft Press Dictionary, # 9 Ex. 29 '002 file history, # 10 Ex. 30 Dictionary of Computer Words, # 11 Ex. 31 Computer Dictionary, # 12 Ex. 32 Academic Press Dictionary, # 13 Ex. 33 IBM Dictionary, # 14 Ex. 34 Black's Law Dictionary, # 15 Ex. 35 About 3GPP, # 16 Ex. 36 '919 patent, # 17 Ex. 37 '713 provisional application) (Haslam, Robert)

EXHIBIT 25

705FH001

WI-AppIe000000

Our

THE UNITED

IN

In

Re the Patent

Fisher

Stephen
Serial

280

Examiner

No. 08/084288

ArtUnit

Nguyen

C.

2609

06/28/93

Filed

For

QRop

of

Mathew Trehus

Eric

04860.P

PATI3r4FJFFICE

STATES

Application

Ref.

MESSAGING

PROTOCOL

FROM AN

FOR

USER INTERFACE

CONTROLLING

APPLICATION

INACTIVE

PROGRAM

AMENDMENT

AND RESPONSE TO

HONORABLE

COMMISSIONER

PATENTS

FINAL OFFICE ACFION

ANT TRADEMARKS

Washington

D.C.

OF

20231

Sir
In

amend

the Office

to

response

the application

Action

dated

June

27 1994

Applicants

offer

to

as follows

INJHE DRAWINGS

Please

amend

Figures

shown

and

as

as

follows

in the enclosed

drawings.

IWFHE CLAIMS
Please

Please

/V
-j

cancel

amend

in

said

6.

the claims

Amended

1.

operative

claim

computer

In

comput4r

system

system

iQJcontrol

method
user

interface

first

on

process

computer

MES/aeg

705FH 107

WI-AppIe0000l

07

sjstem display

under control

system comprising

first

said

b.

11

event

handling

pross.ythen

of

first

said

c.

for

process

first

process

14

of functions

interface

prst

first

generating/

display

set

said/irst

performed b/said

16

generated

17

updating

18

according

19

received

first

by said first/rocess

in

in

user

comprising

in

set

ent

first

in the

said

second process

interface

is

gcneratedby
under

display

functions

of

handling

said

computer
computer

said

computer

performed by the
the following

first

in

said

syste$

s/stem

said

said

set

to

first

and

said

first

set

handling

first

of events

process

system display
and

process

to

said

processora

coy4rising

opeiyÆve

systyrt

controlling

related

process

event

for

process.

systzt

ocess

events

by said

system

process

computer

of

events

of

on said computer

generated

computer

set

receiving

in the

and

user

second

perform
first

computer

further

to

for

display

information

the second

control

the

for

th

for

operations

under

system

method

process

process

display.

on said

interface

display

on said computer/ystem

interface

operative

operations

04560F974

In

ihrface

e/ents

device

operative

process

10

by said

process

process

said

pross

system dispiajijinder the control 0/the

ccoiputer
first

to

Amended

second process

c/

said user

user ingut

said

process

handling

gnory.

computer

part of said second

as

controlling sail user

said event

7.

said

system

user

d.

in

operati

systm. ervicing events

performing

process

13

15

computer

said second

computer

12

said

process

control
10

process

in

operative

3/

handling

said

process

the

steps

an event

installing

second

following

the

of

second

nd control

of the second

regarding

the

process said method

steps

MES/aeg

705FH 108

WI-AppIe0000l

08

11

a.

12

second process

13

operative

14

process

15

second

event

said event

in said

proces/

handling

handling

process

interface

as

part of said

said second

wijLn

sys1em servicing ents

computer

controlling said user

for

process

by the

generated

is

first

under control

dilay

said

of

process
said second

b.

16

17

an

installing

18

second

for said

operations

said

c.

19

computer
d.

first

said

said

requestiqg

first

perform

to

process

process

process

process

said operations

performi4

generatir/g

in

said

system

20

process

21

interface

22

the operations

display

first

said events

performed by said
said event

23

24

said

25

on said computer

26

said

first

first

process

process

add

Please

system

the following

process

set

set

In

user input
operative
display

04860.F974

computer

device
in

the

under

first

the control

system

system
of

the

to

ac4ording

claim

in

forth

process

computer

the second

events

events

said

handling

and

process

by

generated

user interface

said

updating

process

wherein

nd proce

as

for

receiving

by said event

forth

process

10.

rocess

regarding

by

generated

process.

claims

an

The method

9.

display

information

providing

pross

handlir4

and received

as

first

handling

said event

The method
background

t91

controlling said user

for

events

in

cI

foreground

said

comprisin1/a

and a/ser

first

process

secoytprocess

on

first

process

to

system

said

an apparatus

not

memory
second process

computer
method

is

operations

display

processor

interface

is

process

process.

computer

operativejtthe

first

said

im

reques

3---

the

system

for

the

first

MES/aeg

705FH 109

WI-AppIe0000l

09

to

process
said

computer

computer
first

perform

system
to

system

the second

for

process

a.

10

//11

said event

in

operative
12

said

method

said

process

an event

handling

computer

the

regarding

the following

steps

is

process

by the

generated

under control

interface

said

said second

of

part

system servicing 1ents

in

on

performed by the

opeyAtions

said/second

interface

operative

pr/cess

proces/as

when

process

the user

conty1

compris1g

handling

controlling said user

for

process

information

installing

process

and

process

under control of the second

display

display

the second

for

operations

first

of said

difrlay
13

second

14

process
said second

b.

15

first

to

process

16

17

interface

18

operations

19

first

process

said event

20

said

providig

events

21

on said computer

22

said

controlling said user

for

the second

by said event

and

process

events

said events

handling

by

generated

said user

updating

to

system disp/ay according

the

regarding

receiving

process

ha/dung

and receivd4

process

for

said

for initiating

process

information

handlinlprocess

said event

process

first

second

s/id

performed by said firstkrocess

e.

first

for

genera/mg

said events

display

means

comprIng

perform operations

said

d.

process

interface

by

generated

process.

REMARKS

In the

final

under 35 U.S.C.
and

figures
claim

failing

is

to

office

103
should

rejected

as

being

unpatentable

35 U.S.C.

point

out

regards as the invention.

Figures

and

04860.P974

have canceled
of

by

112

and

applicant

Reconsideration

June

be designated

under

particularly

dated

action

In

as

1994

over

second

claims

such

and 6-7 are

art.

prior

Applicants

is

rejected

Furthermore

as

being

In addition
indefinite

claim the subject matter

and have added

-4--

as

paragraph

response

amended

1-4

Diefendorff.

legend

distinctly

claim

the application

27

have

claims

for

which

amended

8-10.

respectfully requested.

MES/aeg

705FH1

10

WI-AppIe0000l

10

As noted
the concept

view

of

providing

small portion

the

of

when

the porthole

of

in

porthole
an

it is

window

area

and

then

will then

porthole

be

within

the

operating

graphics

reads

porihole
location

The Examiner

window

target

to

corresponds

of

over

the

cited

the function

differences

buffer

reference.

art.

and

is

not

second process
the second

is

must be
that

is

to

window.

be

The

the process

established

in

memory.

by definition of the

bits to

the claimed

to

the

to

first

the appropriate

believe

that

process

the

claimed

and the

cited

process

but

art.

is

the event

Thus

events

not executing

claims

part

handler

is

the event

to the

of

distinguishable
in order

to

clarify

the

emphasize

the event

of the second

utilized

handling

second

interface

controller

example

actually

the

are

further

For

the

corresponds

the graphic

the event

when

the user

the claims

to

that

language

process

to

corresponds

process.

services

generate

the porthole

foreground

bitmap stored

and the second

embodiment

process

is

have further amended

separate

and

the

the appropriate

of the elements

loop of the second

as

the porthole

respect

handler

between the invention

In the preferred

if

with

Applicants

structure

to

size

display.

window

Applicants

process.

Thus

the

by the

In order

foreground delineating

corresponds

the event

process

the

for

Diefendorff

handling

operational

and copies

the porthole

the tiefendorff

Once

delimited

teaches

user can

by some process

the instructions provided

upon

contends

window and

source

the

hidden window updates

the bitmap

in the screen

to

that

delineate the portion

window back

displayed.

based

controller

window

reference

such

window.

and controlled

The user can then

the second

bringing

the portion

hidden by the overlying

the

window

an overlying

window

underlying

system.

by bringing

porthole

the Diefendorff

prior response

porthole the window established

active in the

of

in

previously

is

main

is

process

process

handling

the

as

part

operative.

process

is

not

executing.

04860.P974

5--

MES/aeg

705FH

111

WI-AppIe0000l

11

The event
services events

disclosed

second

handling

by the Diefendorff
and

the

Therefore

system

first

handling

and

events

the user

claims

1-3

This

process.

process

and 7-10

by the

first

of functions

second process

not part of the

process.
in

the

computer
display

and

receives those
For

generated.

the Diefendorff

over

distinguished

handling

interface

the events

to

according

are

is

controlling the user

for

interface

of

set

part of the

is

controller

similarly

nor

taught

which the event

generated

performing

process

neither

is

The graphics

events

that

process

updates

these reasons

of

of the second

part

events

when

set

first

is

second

the

service

process

generates

the event

not

first

reference.

therefore

of does

part

is

process

by the

generated

process

which

process

reference.

one embodiment

In

by the second

initiated

which

refers

the

to

the event

process

for

process

is

events

for

regtrding
handling

first

process

the operations

04860.P974

events

is

does

process

does

events

generated

neither

disclosed

process

these

performed

for

the

and

such

first

not perform
not generate

providing

events

for

for

information

process
then

second

first

the second

process
the

first

generates

information

as providing

and the event

the user

interface

by the Diefendorff

according

operations

claim

display

process.

taught nor disclosed

by Diefendorff

in

by the

process

second process
updates

by the

the second

first

process

as part of the

generated

The

display

for

receives those events

process

interpretation

display

operations

reflected

Thus when

display.

interface

this

first

perform

is

process

events

servicing

interface

This

handling

controlling the user

Again

the

needed.

background

is

process

perform these operations.

those

first

when

an event

of

process

to

first

to

initiated

to

according

the

installation

handling

the

only

process

controlling the user

requests the

process

described

to

the

the second

as

Examiners

process

controlling the user

regarding

reference

operations

and therefore
interface

performed by

MES/aeg

705FH1

12

WI-AppIe0000l

12

the

first

that

the

first

process

first

the second

for

process

is

process

perform
is

clearly

be

window and

window

that

are

active

show

to

the present invention

Therefore

cited

art

in

in

and are

in

be

process.

Diefendorff

able

define

to

and furthermore

claim

condition

to

in

contend

that

as

this

as set

This additional

the

first

limitation

forth

Allowance

of

the

that

requests

the portions

This

system is

in

must

process
of the

is

claim

the claims

forth

set

in

10.

the claims are distinguished

allowance.

for

of

process

via the porthole.

through

Applicants

the second

for

nor taught
order

example

typical

the second

until

operations

not disclosed

aspect
in

not operative

the

One

process.

over

the

is

respectfully requested.

Respectfully

Dated

ltaA L417tC

11994

Wilshire

Boulevard

hreby
United

Los

408

Floor

Angeles
720-8598

to

CA

90025-1026

44tq

Sobrino

that

this

ostal

Commissioner

of

bein8 deposited with the
addressed
mail in an envelope
Trademarks
Box AP Washington
D.C.

corresaondence

Service
Patents

as

First

and

is

Class

ULe4

20231

Dated

Adri

04860.P974

certify
States

ZAFMAN

No. 31639

Reg.

Seventh

TAYLOR

.vv_cA.eC.

McCormack

Maria

12400

submitted

SOKOLOFF

BLAIKELY

epoeit

E.

.JUI\48.

Cf berson

o/sj9J
te

MES/aeg

705FH1

13

WI-AppIe0000l

13