Oracle Corporation et al v. SAP AG et al

Filing 1058

Declaration of Lisa Chin in Support of 1057 Opposition/Response to Motion for JMOL or New Trial filed byOracle International Corporation. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A part 1, # 2 Exhibit A part 2, # 3 Exhibit B, # 4 Exhibit C, # 5 Exhibit D, # 6 Exhibit E, # 7 Exhibit F, # 8 Exhibit G, # 9 Exhibit H, # 10 Exhibit I, # 11 Exhibit J, # 12 Exhibit K, # 13 Exhibit L, # 14 Exhibit M, # 15 Exhibit N, # 16 Exhibit O, # 17 Exhibit P, # 18 Exhibit Q, # 19 Exhibit R, # 20 Exhibit S, # 21 Exhibit T, # 22 Exhibit U, # 23 Exhibit V, # 24 Exhibit W, # 25 Exhibit X, # 26 Exhibit Y, # 27 Exhibit Z, # 28 Exhibit AA, # 29 Exhibit BB, # 30 Exhibit CC, # 31 Exhibit DD, # 32 Exhibit EE, # 33 Exhibit FF, # 34 Exhibit GG, # 35 Exhibit HH, # 36 Exhibit II, # 37 Exhibit JJ, # 38 Exhibit KK, # 39 Exhibit LL, # 40 Exhibit MM, # 41 Exhibit NN, # 42 Exhibit OO, # 43 Exhibit PP, # 44 Exhibit QQ, # 45 Exhibit RR, # 46 Exhibit SS, # 47 Exhibit TT, # 48 Exhibit UU, # 49 Exhibit VV)(Related document(s) 1057 ) (Howard, Geoffrey) (Filed on 4/8/2011)

Oracle Corporation et al v. SAP AG et al

Doc. 1058 Att. 1

EXHIBIT A Part 1
Dockets.Justia.com

Page 306
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

Page 308
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

THAT IF A WITNESS DOESN'T TOUCH OR MENTION THE EXHIBIT, EVEN IF IT'S STIPULATED, IT'S NOT IN THE RECORD, IT'S NOT INTO EVIDENCE. AND SO TWICE MR. AGASSI WAS THE ONLY WITNESS WHO WAS ASSOCIATED WITH THE DOCUMENT. THEREFORE, WE WANTED TO GET IN THE UNOPPOSED EXHIBIT THROUGH HIS TESTIMONY. NOW, IF THAT -- IF THE WITNESS DOESN'T HAVE TO TOUCH IT, IF IT'S JUST IN, I THINK THAT'S FINE. THE COURT: IS THERE ANY REFERENCE TO IT IN HIS TESTIMONY THAT WILL REMAIN? MR. PICKETT: WELL, NOT -- NOT IF YOUR HONOR -- NOT IF YOUR HONOR'S SUSTAINING OF THE OBJECTIONS IN THESE TWO INSTANCES REMAIN. THE COURT: LET ME LOOK AT MR. AGASSI -- WHAT PAGE NUMBER IS HE? MR. PICKETT: THE FIRST ONE IS ON PAGE -- THIS IS -I'M LOOKING OFF THE AGASSI OBJECTION SHEET. IT IS ON -THE COURT: WHAT'S THE PAGE? MR. PICKETT: PAGE 3 AT THE BOTTOM. THERE'S A REFERENCE TO THE SECOND PAGE OF EXHIBIT 707, WHICH IS PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT 112 NOW. THE COURT: OKAY. 707. MR. LANIER: WE DO NOT OBJECT TO THE EXHIBIT. IT'S GOING TO COME IN THROUGH A VARIETY OF OTHER WITNESSES' TESTIMONY. I BELIEVE THAT'S -- IN A FEW OTHER WITNESSES' TESTIMONY. IT JUST MAY NOT HAVE BEEN BY THIS POINT, BUT WE

MR. PICKETT: SOMEBODY IN THE VIDEO CAN REFER TO IT. THE COURT: YES, THAT'S WHAT I'M SAYING. AS LONG AS THERE'S A WITNESS IN A VIDEO WHO REFERS TO 707, IT CAN STILL BE ADMITTED. MR. PICKETT: THAT'S MR. AGASSI. THE COURT: IS HE THE ONLY WITNESS THAT REFERS TO IT? MR. LANIER: NO. THE COURT: OKAY. MR. PICKETT: WELL, I -THE COURT: EXCUSE ME. LET ME ASK ANOTHER QUESTION. IS THE EXCERPT THAT WAS BOLDED IN THE OBJECTIONS THE ONLY EXCERPT THAT REFERS TO 707 DURING MR. AGASSI'S ENTIRE TESTIMONY? (OFF-THE-RECORD DISCUSSION.) MR. LANIER: I BELIEVE THAT IT IS THE ONLY EXCERPT OF THOSE THAT PRESENTLY REMAIN. AGAIN, WE HAVEN'T OBJECTED TO THE EXHIBIT. THE SUBSTANTIVE TESTIMONY WE DID OBJECT TO AND YOUR HONOR HAS RULED. THE COURT: RIGHT. MR. PICKETT: AND -THE COURT: OKAY. MR. PICKETT: ALL RIGHT. AND SO MR. AGASSI SAYS, WAS THIS A FACTOR IN FAVORING -- IN FAVOR OF SUPPORTING THE ACQUISITION, HE'S THE ONE WHO'S DECIDING TO MAKE THE ACQUISITION.

Page 307
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

Page 309
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

WOULDN'T OBJECT TO IT. THE COURT: YEAH, AS LONG AS SOME WITNESS IS TESTIFYING AS TO 707, IT CAN COME IN. MR. PICKETT: WE THOUGHT MR. AGASSI WAS THE WITNESS WHO WAS GOING TO, IN OUR WORDS, SPONSOR, I SUPPOSE, THE EXHIBIT. THE COURT: AND WHO'S -- WHAT WITNESS DO YOU THINK IS GOING TO SPONSOR THE EXHIBIT? MR. LANIER: THEY'VE ASKED, FOR EXAMPLE, TO SPEAK TO MR. ZEPECKI, WHO'S COMING UP LATER THIS WEEK, THE AUTHOR TO THE IT. THE COURT: WOULDN'T HE ACTUALLY BE A BETTER SPONSOR, THE AUTHOR OF THE EXHIBIT? MR. PICKETT: WELL, THIS IS THE ADDRESSEE. THE COURT: RIGHT. MR. PICKETT: HE'S NOT -THE COURT: WELL, I'M NOT GOING TO CHANGE MY RULING ON THIS PARTICULAR EXCERPT. SO YOU CAN GET THE EXHIBIT IN EITHER THROUGH -- AS LONG AS SOME WITNESS REFERS TO IT SO IT'S IDENTIFIED BY SOMEBODY. WHEN WE HAVE A WITNESS HERE IN COURT, IT'S NOT A PROBLEM. WHEN THERE'S A DEPOSITION IN LIEU OF THAT, WE STILL NEED TO HAVE SOMEBODY REFER TO IT. MR. PICKETT: BUT THE WITNESS -(SIMULTANEOUS COLLOQUY.)

WELL -THE COURT: WELL, I'M NOT GOING TO ENTERTAIN ARGUMENTS ON WHETHER OR NOT -- YOU ALL GAVE ME YOUR ARGUMENTS. I READ THEM LAST NIGHT. I RULED ON THEM. MR. PICKETT: ALL RIGHT. THE COURT: WE GAVE IT TO YOU. THE RULING STANDS. MR. HOWARD: FINE. THE COURT: YOU CAN GET IT IN IF SOME OTHER WITNESS, EITHER WHO IS PERSONALLY PRESENT IN COURT OR WHO ON A DEPOSITION -- DURING THE COURSE OF THE DEPOSITION, REFERS TO 707, IT CAN COME IN. MR. PICKETT: WE'LL TRY TO GET IT IN THROUGH MR. ZEPECKI. THE COURT: OKAY. MR. PICKETT: IF -- THE NEXT -- THE NEXT DOCUMENT I TOLD YOU ABOUT, WHICH IS ON PAGE 6 OF THE OBJECTIONS, REFERS TO PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT 183. IT'S MR. MACKEY IN AN EMAIL TALKING OR -- COMMUNICATING TO MR. AGASSI THAT TOMORROWNOW IS A SEPARATE ENTITY DUE TO THE THREAT OF LITIGATION, AND HE SAYS IN THIS EMAIL, HE SAYS SO. I DON'T BELIEVE THAT EXHIBIT IS OBJECTED TO. MR. LANIER: WOULD YOU JUST, MR. PICKETT, REMIND ME, IS THAT THE BUSINESS CASE DOCUMENT? THE COURT: YEAH. MR. PICKETT: NO, IT'S AN EMAIL FROM MR. MACKEY TO

EXHIBIT. I WOULD ASSUME THAT THEY WOULD BE TALKING TO HIM ABOUT 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

4 (Pages 306 to 309)
Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 4 - November 5, 2010
0,187( $1' 6(&21' 7$3( $%287 7(1 0,187(6 2) :+,&+ $5( 3/$,17,))6 '(6,*1$7,216 $1' $ /,77/( 29(5 )285 0,187(6 2) :+,&+ $5( '()(1'$176 :+(5(8321 9,'(27$3( :$6 3/$<(' 7+( &2857 ,6 7+$7 7+( &21&/86,21" 06 +286( 7+$7 6 ,7 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 1(;7 :,71(66" 06 +286( <28 // %( +$33< 72 +($5 +( 6 /,9( 7+( &2857 2+ 06 +286( 5,&+$5' $//,621 3$86( ,1 7+( 352&((',1*6 05 /$1,(5 <285 [phone]$571(5 -$621 0&'21(// :,// %( 7$/.,1* 72 +,0 72 7+( (;7(17 :( 1((' 72 7+( &/(5. 5$,6( <285 5,*+7 +$1' 5,&+$5' $//,621 &$//(' $6 $ :,71(66 )25 7+( 3/$,17,))6 +$9,1* %((1 '8/< 6:251 7(67,),(' $6 )2//2:6 7+( &/(5. 3/($6( %( 6($7(' 3/($6( 67$7( <285 )8// 1$0( $1' 63(// <285 /$67 1$0( )25 7+( 5(&25' $1' 63($. &/($5/< ,172 7+( 0,&523+21( 7+( :,71(66 5,&+$5' $//,621 /$67 1$0( $//,621 ',5(&7 (;$0,1$7,21 %< 06 +286( 4 $1' 05 $//,621 :+$7 ,6 <285 &855(17 326,7,21 $7 25$&/(" 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55 $//,621 ',5(&7 +286( 25$&/( 62)7:$5( ,1 25'(5 72 3529,'( 7(&+1,&$/ 6833257 72 25$&/( &86720(56" $ 1(9(5 4 $1' +$6 25$&/( (9(5 /,&(16(' $ 7+,5' 3$57< 6833257 3529,'(5 72 86( 62)7:$5( )25 :+,&+ 21( &86720(5 ,6 /,&(16(' 72 &5($7( 7(&+1,&$/ 6833257 0$7(5,$/6 72 6833257 27+(5 &86720(56" $ 12 4 +$6 25$&/( (9(5 $//2:(' $ &203(7,725 72 0$.( $ &23< 2) 21( &86720(5 6 62)7:$5( 72 &5($7( $ *(1(5,& (19,5210(17 72 86( 72 3529,'( 7(&+1,&$/ 6833257 72 27+(5 &86720(56" $ 12 :( 9( 127 4 +2: '2 <28 .12: 7+,6" $ 7+$7 :28/' %( $ 35(77< /$5*( (;&(37,21 72 285 67$1'$5' 35$&7,&(6 $1' 7+$7 :28/' %( (6&$/$7(' 72 0< 2)),&( 72 5(9,(: 62 ,) ,7 :$6 *2,1* 72 +$33(1 , ' 6(( ,7 4 :28/' *5$17,1* $ &203(7,725 68&+ $ /,&(16( 0$.( %86,1(66 6(16(" $ 12 127 $7 $// 05 0F'21(// 2%-(&7 72 7+( /,1( 7+( &2857 (;&86( 0(" 05 0F'21(// 2%-(&7,21 72 7+,6 /,1( 2) 48(67,21,1* 3(5 7+( ',6&866,21 ($5/,(5 7+( &2857 , '21 7 7+,1. 62 29(558/(' 7+( :,71(66 &$1 <28 5(3($7 7+( 48(67,21" 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

$//,621 ',5(&7 +286( $ 6(1,25 9,&( 35(6,'(17 2) */2%$/ 35$&7,&(6 4 +2: /21* +$9( <28 %((1 :25.,1* $7 25$&/(" $ 6(9(17((1 <($56 /$67 0217+ 4 29(5 7+( <($56 $7 25$&/( +$9( <28 +$' $1< 5(63216,%,/,7< )25 25$&/( 6 &86720(5 /,&(16( 7(506" $ , +$9( $&78$//< :+(1 , 67$57(' 6,& 7+( &203$1< , :$6 25,*,1$//< '5$)7,1* 7+( &2175$&76 $1' &855(17/< 0$1$*( 7+( *5283 7+$7 &5($7(6 $// 7+( 67$1'$5'6 )25 285 &2175$&76 4 '2 <28 +$9( $1< 5(63216,%,/,7< )25 $33529,1* &86720(5 (;&(37,216 72 67$1'$5' 7(506" $ , '2 21( 2) 285 7($06 , 0$1$*( $/62 +$1'/(6 (;&(37,216 72 67$1'$5' $*5((0(176 ',6&28176 121 67$1'$5' 7(506 7+$7 *2 72 7+( & ( 2 6 $1' 35(6,'(17 6 2)),&( 4 $1' +2: $%287 35,&,1*" '2 <28 +$9( $1< 5(63216,%,/,7< )25 7+( 35,&,1* 2) 25$&/( 6 67$1'$5' /,&(16(6" $ , '2 , +$9( $ 35,&,1* 25*$1,=$7,21 7+$7 35,&(6 $// 7+( /,1(6 2) %86,1(66 2) 62)7:$5( &2168/7,1* ('8&$7,21 6833257 +267,1* (7 &(7(5$ 06 +286( '2 <28 1((' +,0 72 6/2: '2:1" 7+( 5(3257(5 12'6 +($' %< 06 +286( 4 6/2: '2:1 , .12: <28 63($. 48,&./< 12: /(7 6 6(7 7+( 67$*( )25 7+( 7<3(6 2) /,&(16(6 7+$7 25$&/( '2(61 7 5287,1(/< *5$17 +$6 25$&/( (9(5 3529,'(' $ /,&(16( $//2:,1* $ &203(7,725 72 &5($7( $ 0$67(5 /,%5$5< 2) 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

$//,621 ',5(&7 +286( %< 06 +286( 4 :28/' *5$17,1* $ &203(7,725 68&+ $ /,&(16( 0$.( %86,1(66 6(16(" $ 12 4 :+< 127" $ ,7 '2(61 7 0$.( 6(16( 72 3529,'( $ /,&(16( 72 $ &203(7,725 72 75< 72 7$.( <285 &86720(56 $:$< )520 <28 72 86( <285 2:1 ,3 72 7$.( <285 &86720(56 4 12: 7+( -85< +$61 7 +($5' <(7 $%287 25$&/( 6 '$0$*(6 )520 '()(1'$176 ,1)5,1*(0(17 2) 7+( 25$&/( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( 72 6(7 7+( 67$*( /(7 0( 6+2: <28 7+( 67,38/$7,21 :+(5( '()(1'$176 $'0,7 :+$7 '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( 7+(< ,1)5,1*(' &28/' <28 387 7+$7 83" 3$86( ,1 7+( 352&((',1*6 06 +286( ,7 6 ,1 7+( -85< 6 %,1'(5 :(// 7+(5( :( *2 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 06 +286( 7+,6 ,6 ,1 <285 -85< %,1'(5 ,7 6 67,38/$7,21 12 4 $1' /(7 0( 6+2: <28 7+,6 ,6 7+( 7+( 0$7(5,$/6 7+$7 $5( /,67(' 7+$7 :(5( ,1)5,1*(' '2 <28 5(&2*1,=( 7+26( 0$7(5,$/6 81'(5 7+( 25$&/( '$7$%$6( 5(*,675$7,216 3$57 2) 7+( $'0,66,21" $ , '2 7+(6( $5( ',))(5(17 9(56,216 2) 7+( '$7$%$6( (17(535,6( (',7,21 67$57,1* :,7+ 25$&/( , $1' 7+(1 83 72 7+( 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 4 - November 5, 2010
SHEET 3

$//,621 ',5(&7 +286( 5(/($6( * 4 2.$< <28 &$1 387 7+$7 '2:1 7+$1. <28 /(7 0( $6. <28 72 $6680( 7+$7 7+( :$< 7+$7 7202552:12: ,1)5,1*(' 7+( 25$&/( (17(535,6( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( :$6 72 86( 9$5,286 &23,(6 21 ,76 6(59(56 72 $66,67 ,1 '(9(/23,1* $1' 7(67,1* 6833257 0$7(5,$/6 )25 &86720(56 )25 ,76 &86720(56 7+( 48(67,21 )25 7+( -85< ,6 +2: '2 <28 9$/8( $ /,&(16( )25 7+$7 86( 05 0F'21(// 7+( 6$0( 2%-(&7,21 <285 +2125 7+( &2857 29(558/(' %< 06 +286( 4 12: 6$3 6 (;3(57 ,6 9$/8,1* 7+$7 /,&(16( $6 ,) 7202552:12: :28/' -867 +$9( 72 +$9( +$9( 72 385&+$6( 21( 6,1*/( &86720(5 '$7$%$6( /,&(16(" :+$7 '2 <28 7+,1. 2) 7+$7 $3352$&+" $ :(// , '21 7 7+,1. ,7 0$.(6 6(16( 180%(5 21( :( /,&(16( 285 62)7:$5( )25 $ 63(&,),& &86720(5 )25 7+( ,17(51$/ 86( $/62 ,) :( $//2: 6,1*/( &86720(5 /,&(16( 72 6(59,&( 25 3529,'( %(1(),7 72 08/7,3/( &86720(56 :( :28/'1 7 +$9( 7+( $%,/,7< 72 6(// 62)7:$5( 72 7+26( 08/7,3/( &86720(56 2856(/9(6 4 ,6 7+(5( $1<7+,1* ,1 7+( 25$&/( 67$1'$5' /,&(16( $*5((0(17 7+$7 7+$7 :28/' %( 5(/(9$17 72 7+,6" $ 7+(5( ,6 $*$,1 ,7 6 /,0,7(' 72 $ &86720(5 $1' /,0,7(' 72 ,17(51$/ 86( 4 /(7 6 6+2: 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

$//,621 ',5(&7 +286( <28 +$9( 7+( /,0,7(' 86( 5,*+7 72 4 6/2: '2:1 $ /,0,7(' 5,*+7 72 86( 7+( 352*5$06 $1' 5(&(,9( $1< 6(59,&(6 25'(5(' 62/(/< )25 <285 ,17(51$/ %86,1(66 23(5$7,216 4 $1' &28/' <28 *,9( 620( 5($/ :25/' (;$03/(6 2) :+$7 6 $//2:(' ,17(51$/ 86(" $ 685( $1 (;$03/( :28/' %( $ &86720(5 6 $&&2817,1* 6<67(0 62 <28 581 *(1(5$/ /('*(5 3$<$%/(6 $1' 81'(5 7+$7 $33/,&$7,21 <28 // +$9( $ '$7$%$6( 7+$7 6725(6 7+( ,1)250$7,21 62 ,) $ &86720(5 6 5811,1* 7+(,5 $&&2817,1* 6<67(0 7+$7 ' %( 7+(,5 ,17(51$/ 86( $1' )25 7+(,5 %(1(),7 4 :+< '2(6 25$&/( +$9( 7+,6 5(675,&7,21 2) 8186( 6,& %(<21' 7+( &203$1< 6 ,17(51$/ 23(5$7,216" $ :(// 7+$7 6 +2: :( 9$/8( $1' 35,&( 285 62)7:$5( ,7 6 %$6(' 21 $ /,&(16( 72 $1 ,1',9,'8$/ &86720(5 $1' $ /,&(16( 72 7+(0 )25 7+(,5 ,17(51$/ 86( ,) 7+(< 5( *2,1* 72 %( $%/( 72 86( ,7 72 3529,'( 6(59,&(6 25 %(1(),7 72 $127+(5 7+,5' 3$57< $*$,1 7+$7 :28/' 7$.( $:$< 285 $%,/,7< 72 %( $%/( 72 6(// 62)7:$5( 72 7+26( 27+(5 7+,5' 3$57,(6 4 12: ,6 5(675,&7,1* $1 (1' 86(5 72 21/< ,17(51$/ 86( ,6 7+$7 $1 81868$/ 3529,6,21 ,1 <285 (;3(5,(1&(" $ 12 127 $7 $// :( 9( %((1 7+528*+ 0$1< $&48,6,7,216 ,1 7+( /$67 ),9( 6,; <($56 $1' 7+(< 5( 62)7:$5( &203$1,(6 /,.( 2856(/9(6 $1' , *(7 7+( 23325781,7< 72 5(9,(: 7+(,5 0$67(5 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

$//,621 ',5(&7 +286( <28 '21 7 +$9( $1< 2%-(&7,21 72 7+( 26/$ '2 <28" 05 0F'21(// , '2 127 06 +286( 2.$< 62 &$1 :( 6+2: 05 $//,621 3/$,17,))6 (;+,%,7 :+,&+ ,6 $'0,77(' ,172 (9,'(1&(" (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 06 +286( 7+$1. <28 4 &$1 <28 7(// 7+( -85< :+$7 7+,6 ,6" $ <(6 7+,6 ,6 25$&/( 6 /,&(16( $1' 6(59,&(6 $*5((0(17 7+,6 ,6 :+$7 :( 86( 72 /,&(16( 285 62)7:$5( 72 $1 ,1',9,'8$/ &86720(5 4 $1' &$1 <28 7(// 7+( '$7( 2) 7+,6 9(56,21" $ <(6 ,) <28 /22. $7 7+( /2:(5 /()7 +$1' 6,'( +$6 $ 9(56,21 7+$7 6 7+$7 ' %( 7+( '$7( 2) 7+( $*5((0(17 7+$7 9(56,21 2) 7+( $*5((0(17 4 62 7+,6 9(56,21 :28/' %( ,1 3/$&( $7 7+( 7,0( 2) -$18$5< 7+ :+(1 6$3 +$' $&48,5(' 7202552:12: ,6 7+$7 5,*+7" $ &255(&7 4 ,6 7+(5( $1<7+,1* 63(&,),&$//< ,1 7+( /$1*8$*( +(5( 7+$7 <28 7+,1. ,6 5(/(9$17 72 :+(7+(5 25 127 $ 6,1*/( /,&(16( 72 7202552:12: 72 '2 :+$7 ,7 ',' ,6 ,6 $9$,/$%/( 81'(5 7+( 67$1'$5' 7(506" $ <(6 ,) <28 /22. $7 7+( 5,*+76 *5$17(' 6(&7,21 6(&7,21 & 7+( +,*+/,*+7(' /$1*8$*( 8321 285 $&&(37$1&( 2) 7+( 25'(5 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

$//,621 ',5(&7 +286( $*5((0(176 $6 :( 67$57 72 ,17(*5$7( 7+(0 ,172 285 &203$1< $1' $// 2) 7+(0 +$9( ,17(51$/ 86( 5(675,&7,216 ,1 7+(,5 $*5((0(17 62 ,7 6 5($//< $1 ,1'8675< 67$1'$5' 7+$7 $// 62)7:$5( &203$1,(6 86( 4 7+$1. <28 12: &$1 <28 (;3/$,1 72 7+( -85< +2: 86,1* 25$&/( 6 '$7$%$6( 72 3529,'( (;7(51$/ 6833257 72 ,76 &86720(56 *$9( 7202552:12: ',))(5(17 %(1(),76 )520 7+( .,1' 2) 7<3,&$/ %(1(),76 2) 7+( 6,1*/( (1' 86(5 2) <285 67$1'$5' /,&(16(" $ 685( 7<3,&$/ (1' 86(5 $*$,1 *(76 7+( %(1(),7 )520 5811,1* 7+(,5 23(5$7,216 $1' 7+(,5 %86,1(66 7+,6 *$9( 7202552:12: 7+( 23325781,7< 72 .,1' 2) &2002',7,=( 7+( 86( 2) 7+$7 '$7$%$6( $1' 72 &+$5*( 3(23/( )25 7+( 86( %$6,&$//< $1' 7+( 6(59,&(6 7+(< 3529,'( 86,1* 7+$7 6<67(0 :+,&+ ,6 ',))(5(17 7+$1 5811,1* <285 2:1 %86,1(66 $1' +$6 *5($7(5 9$/8( 4 62 ,) $ 6,1*/( '$7$%$6( /,&(16( '2(61 7 &29(5 7202552:12: 6 86( 2) 25$&/( 6 '$7$%$6( 72 6833257 08/7,3/( &86720(56 :+$7 '2 <28 %(/,(9( ,6 7+( $335235,$7( /,&(16,1* $3352$&+" $ :(// $*$,1 05 0F'21(// 6$0( 2%-(&7,21 <285 +2125 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 6$0( 58/,1* 7+( :,71(66 , 7+,1. 7+( %(1(),7 ,6 $*$,1 72 7+( ,1',9,'8$/ &86720(56 :+2 $5( 5(&(,9,1* 7+( 9$/8( 2) 7+( 6(59,&(6 $1' 62 $*$,1 , 7+,1. $ /,&(16( )25 ($&+ 2) 7+( 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 4 - November 5, 2010
$//,621 ',5(&7 +286( &86720(56 7+$7 5(&(,9( 7+( %(1(),7 7+( &2857 6/2: '2:1 7+( :,71(66 685( %< 06 +286( 4 75< $*$,1 $ , 7+,1. 7+( 3523(5 :$< 72 /,&(16( $ 62)7:$5( %( %$6(' 21 7+( 9$/8( :+2 6 5(&(,9,1* 9$/8( )25 ,7 $1' 7+$7 :28/' %( 7+( 3(23/( 7+(< 5( 3529,',1* 6(59,&(6 72 62 ,7 :28/' %( ($&+ 2) 7+( ,1',9,'8$/ &86720(56 7+$7 $5( 5(&(,9,1* 7+( %(1(),7 2) 7+$7 6(59,&( 4 2.$< 12: /(7 6 7$/. $%287 7+( 35,&,1* )25 7+(6( ,1',9,'8$/ '$7$%$6( /,&(16(6 $6680,1* 7+( )$,5 $3352$&+ ,6 72 &+$5*( 7202552:12: $ '$7$%$6( /,&(16( )25 (9(5< &86720(5 ,7 6833257(' 86,1* 7+( 25$&/( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( ,7 ,1)5,1*(' 7+$7 6 21 ,76 6(59(56 :+$7 :28/' <28 86( 72 '(7(50,1( 7+( 35,&(" 05 0F'21(// 6$0( <285 +2125 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 6$0( 58/,1* *2 $+($' 7+( :,71(66 :( +$9( $ 38%/,&/< $9$,/$%/( 35,&( /,67 )25 285 '$7$%$6( $1' 62 :( ' 86( 7+$7 72 '(7(50,1( 7+( 35,&,1* %< 06 +286( 4 $1' :( 6$: )520 7+( 67,38/$7,21 7+$7 :$6 83 %()25( 7+$7 7+(5( 6 3$57,&8/$5 9(56,216 2) 7+( '$7$%$6( (17(535,6( (17(535,6( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( ,6 7+(5( $ 67$1'$5' 35,&,1* )25 7+$7 62)7:$5(" 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55 $//,621 ',5(&7 +286( 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 &5266 (;$0,1$7,21" 3$86( ,1 7+( 352&((',1*6 05 0F'21(// 0$< , <285 +2125" 3$86( ,1 7+( 352&((',1*6 &5266 (;$0,1$7,21 %< 05 0F'21(// 4 0251,1* 05 $//,621 $ 0251,1* 4 , 0 -$621 0&'21(// *22' 72 6(( <28 05 $//,621 , -867 +$9( $ )(: )2//2: 83 48(67,216 7+( /(7 0( %( &/($5 21 :+$7 7+( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( ,6 -867 ,1 025( /$< /$<0$1 6 7(506 62 '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( ,6 $ 62)7:$5( 352'8&7 7+$7 25$&/( 6(//6 &255(&7" $ &255(&7 4 $1' ,7 6 62)7:$5( 7+$7 6 86(' 72 &5($7( '$7$%$6(6 ,6 7+$7 5,*+7" $ ,7 6 $ ,7 6 62)7:$5( 7+$7 6 86(' 72 6725( ,1)250$7,21 4 6725(6 ,1)250$7,21" $ '$7$%$6( <(6 4 12: $ 6,1*/( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( ,167$1&( &$1 %( 86(' 72 &5($7( 0$1< ',))(5(17 '$7$%$6(6 ,6 7+$7 5,*+7" $ &255(&7 ,7 6 $*$,1 285 285 35,&,1* ,6 %$6(' 21 7+( 6,=( 2) 7+( 6(59(5 127 7+( 180%(5 2) '$7$%$6(6 21 7+$7 6(59(5 4 5,*+7 $1' <28 0$'( 620( $668037,216 $%287 7+( 6,=( 2) 7+( 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

$//,621 ',5(&7 +286( $ 7+(5( ,6 7+(5( 6 $ 67$1'$5' 35,&( )25 7+( '$7$%$6( ,7 6 $&78$//< ,55(63(&7,9( 2) 7+( 9(56,21 %(,1* 86(' :( +$9( 7+( 6$0( 35,&( 4 :( $/62 .12: )520 ,1)250$7,21 7+$7 :$6 3529,'(' %< '()(1'$176 :+$7 6(59(56 <28 .12: 7+( &20387(56 :+$7 &20387(56 7+( 6(59(56 127 7+( 21( 21 7+( '(6.723 %87 7+( $&78$/ 6(59(56 :+$7 6(59(56 7+( 62)7:$5( :$6 21 7+( 25$&/( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( +2: ,6 7+$7 6(59(5 ,1)250$7,21 5(/(9$17 72 35,&,1*" $ :(// 285 35,&,1* ,6 %$6(' 21 352&(66256 :+,&+ $5( :,7+,1 7+( 6(59(5 $1' 62 ,7 6 5(/(9$17 +2: /$5*( 7+( 6(59(5 ,6 +2: 0$1< 352&(66256 ,7 ,6 7+$7 6 1(('(' 72 581 7+(,5 6<67(0 62 :( 86( 7+$7 72 35,&( 287 7+( 62)7:$5( 4 12: ',' <28 +$9( $1< 23325781,7< 72 7$/. 72 25$&/( 6 '$0$*(6 (;3(57 $%287 7+( '$7$%$6( /,&(16( '$0$*(6 ,1 7+,6 &$6(" $ , ',' 7:,&( 4 $1' :+$7 ',' <28 63($. 72 +,0 $%287" $ ),567 7,0( :$6 *(1(5$//< $%287 +2: :( 35,&( 285 62)7:$5( $1' 7+( 0(75,&6 $1' 7+,1*6 7+$7 :( 86( 72 72 35,&( ,7 287 7+( 6(&21' 7,0( ,7 :$6 72 *2 29(5 +,6 $1$/<6,6 $1' 72 9(5,)< :+(7+(5 7+$7 0$7&+(' +2: :( $&78$//< 35,&( 285 62)7:$5( 4 $1' ',' <28 +$9( $1< ,668(6 :,7+ +,6 $3352$&+" $ , ',' 127 ,7 :$6 5($621$%/( 06 +286( 7+$1. <28 05 $//,621 7+( :,71(66 7+$1. <28 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

$//,621 &5266 0&'21(// 6(59(56 7+$7 7202552:12: :$6 86,1* ,1 7+,6 &$6( ,6 7+$7 5,*+7" $ <($+ , %(/,(9( ,7 :$61 7 $1 $668037,21 , %(/,(9( 7+$7 7+(< 3529,'(' 7+( 6(59(5 ,1)250$7,21 :+(5( 7+(< :(5( $&78$//< 5811,1* 7+( 62)7:$5( $1' 7+(< 86(' $9(5$*( &21),*85$7,21 7+$7 :$6 86(' :,7+,1 7+$7 (19,5210(17 4 $1' :+(1 <28 6$< 7+(< 86(' $1 $9(5$*( &21),*85$7,21 <28 5( 5()(55,1* 72 <28 86(' $1 $9(5$*( &21),*85$7,21 ,61 7 7+$7 5,*+7" $ $/21* :,7+ 7+( (;3(57 , 7+,1. :( /22.(' $7 7+( &21),*85$7,21 &$86( 7+(5( :(5( 08/7,3/( 6(59(56 :+(5( 7+( 62)7:$5( :$6 ,167$//(' ',))(5(17 6,=(6 $1' ,7 /22.(' $7 7+( $9(5$*( &21),*85$7,21 ','1 7 7$.( 7+( /$5*(67 &21),*85$7,21 ','1 7 7$.( 7+( 60$//(67 /22.(' $7 7+( $9(5$*( 4 $1' 7+(5( :(5( 620( 60$//(5 &21),*85$7,216 7+$7 <28 ','1 7 86( %(&$86( <28 %$.(' 7+$7 ,172 7+( $9(5$*( 5,*+7" $ &255(&7 4 12: :+$7 <28 7+(1 ',' ,6 <28 0$'( 7+( $668037,21 7+$7 25$&/( :28/' /,.( 72 &+$5*( )25 7+,6 /,&(16( 21 $ 3(5 &86720(5 %$6,6 ,6 7+$7 5,*+7" $ &255(&7 4 $1' :+$7 <28 ',' 7+(5( ,6 <28 $6680(' 7+$7 7202552:12: :$6 *2,1* 72 %( 86,1* '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( $1' ,7 :$6 *2,1* 72 +$9( $ 180%(5 2) &86720(56 62 (9(1 7+28*+ 7202552:12: &28/' &28/' '2 $// 2) 7+,6 :25. 21 $ 6,1*/( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( ,167$1&( <28 :(5( *2,1* 72 &+$5*( 7+(0 08/7,3/( 7,0(6 '(3(1',1* 21 7+( 180%(5 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 4 - November 5, 2010
$//,621 &5266 0&'21(// <28 72/' +,0 7+$7 7+,6 :$6 $ 81,48( 6,78$7,21 ,61 7 7+$7 5,*+7" $ <(6 , ',' 4 2.$< $1' <28 <28 .12: +( 6 *,9(1 $ '(326,7,21 ,1 7+,6 &$6( $5( <28 $:$5( 2) 7+$7" $ , $0 4 $1' <28 .12: +( +( 1(9(5 *27 )520 <28 $1< 5($/ :25/' 75$16$&7,21 :+(5( <28 *$9( +,0 $ /,&(16( 7+$7 :$6 $&78$//< 6,*1(' %< $ &86720(5 $1' 3$,' )25 %< $ &86720(5 7+$7 <28 6$,' :$6 $ &203$5$%/( 75$16$&7,21 )25 7+,6 385326( ,6 7+$7 5,*+7" $ $*$,1 ,7 '2(61 7 (;,67 27+(5 7+$1 7+( (;$03/( , 0(17,21(' 2) 2876285&(56 25 3(23/( 3529,',1* 6(59,&(6 )25 08/7,3/( &86720(56 4 12: &283/( 27+(5 7+,1*6 5($/ 48,&./< <28 '2 +$9( 67$1'$5' 35,&(' 352'8&76 ,6 7+$7 5,*+7" $ <(6 :( '2 4 )25 (;$03/( 7+( 67$1'$5' (17(535,6( (',7,21 352'8&7 ,6 620(7+,1* 25$&/( 6(//6 21 ,76 35,&( /,67 ,61 7 7+$7 5,*+7" $ &255(&7 4 $1' <28 $/62 6(// 7+( 67$1'$5' (',7,21 $/62 21 <285 35,&( /,67 ,6 7+$7 5,*+7" $ :( '2 4 $1' 7+( (17(535,6( (',7,21 :$6 3(5 /,&(16( %$&. ,1 7+( 7,0( )5$0( :( 5( 7$/.,1* $%287 &255(&7" $ $7 7+$7 7,0( ,7 :$6 <(6 4 $1' 7+( 67$1'$5' (',7,21 :$6 " 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55 $//,621 &5266 0&'21(// $ &255(&7 4 62 ,7 6 $ ,7 6 <285 81'(567$1',1* 7+$7 05 0(<(5 ,1 &21-81&7,21 :,7+ <28 ,6 ,6 6$<,1* 7+$7 21 7+( '$< :( 5( 7$/.,1* $%287 +(5( :+,&+ ,6 :+$7 :+(1 <28 :(5( /22.,1* $7 7202552:12: ,6 7+$7 7+( 7,0( )5$0(" $ &255(&7 4 7+$7 7202552:12: 21 7+$7 '$7( :28/' +$9( 72 +$9( %28*+7 $ /,&(16( )25 0,//,21 -867 72 +$9( $ '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( 62 ,7 &28/' '2 ,76 :25. 5,*+7" $ :(// 7+( ,17(5(67,1* 3$57 2) $%287 ,7 ,6 , :28/'1 7 +$9( *,9(1 7+(0 $ /,&(16( 72 '2 :+$7 7+(< 5( 6,& '2,1* 62 7+(6( $5( $// +<327+(7,&$/6 $1' ,) , :$6 72 *,9( 7+(0 21( , :28/' &+$5*( 7+(0 21( )25 ($&+ ,167$1&( 2) 7+( '$7$%$6( )25 ($&+ &86720(5 7+(< :(5( *2,1* 72 6833257 :+,&+ :28/' +$9( 5(68/7(' ,1 7+( 0,//,21 :( 5( 7$/.,1* $%287 <(6 4 0,//,21 $1' <28 5( $:$5( 7+$7 $7 7+$7 7,0( 7202552:12: +$' -867 %((1 62/' )25 $ 727$/ 2) 0,//,21 $ $%62/87(/< $1' 7+,6 ,6 7+( ,17(5(67,1* 3$57 $%287 ,7 $1' 7+,6 ,6 <28 .12: 620(7,0(6 7+,1*6 $5( 722 *22' 72 %( 758( $1' 7+,6 ,6 $%62/87(/< $ &$6( 2) 7+$7 <28 &$1 7 3529,'( 7+,6 6(59,&( :,7+287 +$9( 63(1',1* 7+( 7,0( $1' 021(< 72 ,19(67 $1' '(9(/23 7+( 352'8&76 $1' 62 +$1',1* 29(5 285 ,3 :+,&+ ,6 )5$1./< 7+( 9$/8( 2) 285 (17,5( &203$1< ,1 $ 62)7:$5( &203$1< ,7 6 $1 ,17$1*,%/( 7+,1* ,7 6 285 62)7:$5( ,7 6 285 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

$//,621 &5266 0&'21(// $ &255(&7 4 $1' $6 )$5 $6 <28 .12: -867 7(&+1,&$//< 63($.,1* &28/' 21( ,167$1&( 2) 7+( (17(535,6( (',7,21 62)7:$5( %((1 7(&+1,&$//< 68)),&,(17 72 6833257 7202552:12: 6 1(('6" $ 21( ,167$1&(" 4 <(6 $ &28/' <28 &/$5,)< :+$7 <28 0($1 %< $1 ,167$1&(" 4 $1 ,167$1&( 2) 25$&/( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( 5811,1* 21 $1 (,*+7 352&(6625 6(59(5 $ :(// ,7 6 $ +<327+(7,&$/ 48(67,21 )25 0( , .12: 7+(< :(5( 08/7,3/( 9(56,216 ,1 7+( '$7$%$6( 62 , 0 127 685( ,7 0$.(6 6(16( 72 +$9( $ 6,1*/( ,167$1&( :+(1 <28 5( 5811,1* 9(56,216 2) $1' , 7+,1. 7+(< :(5( '2,1* 7(67,1* $*$,167 $// 7+26( 9(56,216 $1' 62 7<3,&$//< <28 :28/'1 7 +$9( $ 6,1*/( ,167$1&( :,7+ 08/7,3/( 9(56,216 2) 7+( '$7$%$6( 5811,1* 21 ,7 62 , 0 127 685( 7+$7 :28/' :25. 4 7+(1 /(7 0( $6. ,7 72 <28 7+,6 :$< +2: 0$1< ',))(5(17 &23,(6 2) 7+( 62)7:$5( -867 7(&+1,&$//< :28/' 7202552:12: +$9( 1(('(' 72 581 7+( 72 6725( 7+( '$7$ 7+$7 7+(< :(5( 6725,1*" $ 7(&+1,&$//< , :28/'1 7 .12: :,7+287 .12:,1* 7+(,5 (19,5210(17 $1' 7+( $02817 2) '$7$ 7+(< 5( 5811,1* 4 12: '2 <28 .12: :+$7 180%(5 05 0(<(5 &$0( 83 :,7+ )25 7+,6 /,&(16( )25 7+( '$7$%$6(" $ <(6 4 $1' ,7 6 $%287 0,//,21 ,61 7 7+$7 5,*+7" 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

$//,621 &5266 0&'21(// ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< +$6 $ 9$/8( 2) %,//,216 2) '2//$56 62 0,//,21 72 %( $%/( 72 6(59,&( 25 $&78$//< 75< 72 5(3/$&( 285 &86720(5 %$6( '2(61 7 6((0 $1<7+,1* 27+(5 7+$1 5($621$%/( 4 %87 /(7 0( *2 %$&. 72 0< 48(67,21 $5( <28 $:$5( 7+$7 :+$7 <28 :(5( 6$<,1* $7 7+( 7,0( :$6 7+$7 7202552:12: :28/' +$9( 72 +$9( %28*+7 $ /,&(16( )25 0,//,21" $ , '2 ,) , :$6 *2,1* 72 $*5(( 72 *,9( 7+(0 $ /,&(16( 4 12: /(7 0( 6+,)7 *($56 6/,*+7/< 48,&. 48(67,21 $5( <28 $:$5( 7+$7 ,6 ,7 <285 81'(567$1',1* 7+$7 &2168/7$176 $5( (17,7/(' 72 *(7 $&&(66 72 25$&/( 62)7:$5( 81'(5 &(57$,1 &,5&8067$1&(6" $ 81'(5 620( /,&(16( $*5((0(176 7+(< $5( 4 $1' $1' 21( 2) 7+( (;$03/(6 2) +2: 7+(< &$1 '2 7+$7 ,6 ,) 7+(< *2 72 7+( &86720(56 6,7( $1' :25. 21 7+( 62)7:$5( 7+(5( $ &255(&7 4 2.$< $1' $1' <28 9( 6((1 /,&(16(6 /,.( 7+$7 )25 3(23/(62)7 ,6 7+$7 5,*+7" $ :(// $*$,1 :( 5( 7$/.,1* $%287 +81'5('6 2) &86720(56 +(5( $1' 29(5 $ /21* 7,0( 3(5,2'6 7+(< $// +$9( ',))(5(17 $*5((0(176 <28 +$9( 72 /22. $7 $1 ,1',9,'8$/ $*5((0(17 72 6(( :+$7 5,*+7 :$6 *5$17(' 620( $*5((0(176 *5$17 7+( 5,*+76 )25 $ 7+,5' 3$57< 25 &2168/7$17 72 +$9( $&&(66 620( 0$.( ,7 9(5< 63(&,),& 7+$7 7+(< &$1 21/< +$9( $&&(66 72 ,17(5)$&(6 620( 6$< 7+$7 7+(< &$1 7 5(029( 7+( 62)7:$5( $7 6,& 6,7( 25 &+$1*( ,7 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 4 - November 5, 2010
SHEET 5

$//,621 &5266 0&'21(// )520 21( 6(59(5 72 $127+(5 62 7+(5( 6 $ /27 2) ',))(5(17 5(675,&7,216 <28 +$9( 72 /22. $7 $1 ,1',9,'8$/ /,&(16( 72 5($//< %( $%/( 72 '(7(50,1( :+$7 7+( 5,*+7 ,6 4 $1' )2//2:,1* 83 21 7+$7 ,7 6 $/62 758( ,6 ,7 127 7+$7 7+(5( 6 $ 67$1'$5' 3529,6,21 :+(5( 7<3,&$//< 7+(6( /,&(16(6 $5( &21),'(17,$/ ,61 7 7+$7 5,*+7" $ 7+( $*5((0(176 <(6 4 <($+ 2.$< /$67 48(67,21 )25 <28 7+( 180%(5 2) &86720(56 7+$7 <28 $1' 05 0(<(5 $6680( )25 7+,6 /,&(16( :$6 7+$7 " $ , .12: ,7 :$6 3/86 , &$1 7 5(0(0%(5 7+( (;$&7 180%(5 <(6 4 $1' $*$,1 ,6 ,7 <285 81'(567$1',1* 7+$7 7+$7 6 %(&$86( 7+$7 :$6 7+( $&78$/ 180%(5 2) &86720(56 7+$7 7202552:12: :$6 6(59,&,1* :,7+ 7+$7 62)7:$5(" $ 7+(< :(5( 86,1* 7+( 25$&/( '$7$%$6( ,1 7+(,5 62)7:$5( <(6 4 )25 &86720(56 $ $*$,1 , '21 7 .12: 7+( (;$&7 180%(5 2)) 7+( 723 2) 0< +($' 4 $1' $5( <28 $:$5( 7+$7 7202552:12: (9(5 21/< +$' &86720(56" $ <(6 4 2.$< 62 7+( %(67 2) <285 81'(567$1',1* ,6 7+(5( :(5( $ 727$/ 2) 7202552:12: &86720(56 $1' 0$<%( $%287 +$/) 2) 7+26( :(5( 6833257(' %< 25$&/( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5(" 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

1(;7 :,71(66 05 +2:$5' 7+$1. <28 <285 +2125 , 1(*/(&7(' 72 *,9( 7+( (;+,%,76 )25 *5(* 1(/621 35(9,286/< 7+26( :(5( 3/$,17,))6 (;+,%,7 75,$/ (;+,%,7 $1' $1' '()(1'$176 (;+,%,7 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 7+26( :,// $// %( $'0,77(' 3/$,17,))6 (;+,%,76 5(&(,9(' ,1 (9,'(1&( '()(1'$176 (;+,%,7 $ 5(&(,9(' ,1 (9,'(1&( 05 +2:$5' 7+$1. <28 <285 +2125 7+( :,71(66 1(;7 :,71(66 :,// %( -2+1 %$8*+ 05 %$8*+ :$6 7+( 7202552:12: 3(23/(62)7 6 (19,5210(176 0$1$*(5 7+( (;+,%,76 )25 05 %$8*+ $5( 3/$,17,))6 75,$/ (;+,%,7 $1' $1' +,6 9,'(2 :,// 581 $%287 0,187(6 -867 81'(5 0,187(6 )25 7+( 3/$,17,))6 $1' 0,187(6 )25 7+( '()(1'$176 :+(5(8321 9,'(2 '(326,7,21 2) -2+1 %$8*+ :$6 3/$<(' 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 7+$7 &21&/8'(6 7+,6 7$3( &255(&7" 05 +2:$5' <(6 <285 +2125 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 ,6 7+( 1(;7 :,71(66 *2,1* 72 %( /,9(" 05 +2:$5' ,7 :28/' %( %< 9,'(27$3( , ','1 7 .12: <285 +2125 6 35()(5(1&( )25 :+(1 <28 :$17(' 72 7,0( 7+( %5($. 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

$//,621 &5266 0&'21(// $ 7+$7 6 0< 81'(567$1',1* <(6 4 $1' 7+$7 6 :+$7 <28 &+$5*( 7+( /,&(16( )25 $ 7+( +<327+(7,&$/ /,&(16( 7+$7 , :28/'1 7 +$9( *,9(1 <(6 4 +<327+(7,&$/ :( $// 81'(567$1' 7+$7 ,7 1(9(5 :28/' +$9( %((1 *,9(1 $1' :+$7 <28 5( 7$/.,1* $%287 +(5( ,6 :+$7 <28 :28/' +$9( &+$5*(' +$' 7+(5( %((1 $1 $*5((0(17 5,*+7" $ )25 $&&(66 72 285 ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< <(6 05 0F'21(// 7+$7 6 $// <285 +2125 7+( &2857 2.$< $// 5,*+7 5(',5(&7" 06 +286( -867 21( 48,&. )2//2: 83 5(',5(&7 (;$0,1$7,21 %< 06 [phone]+( -85< 6 127 &21)86(' 7+( 0,//,21 7+$7 <28 5( 7$/.,1* $%287 '2(6 7+$7 +$9( $1<7+,1* 72 '2 :,7+ 7+( /,&(16( 7+$7 :28/' %( 5(48,5(' )25 7+( 3(23/(62)7 $&&(66 7+( 3(23/(62)7 ,1)5,1*(0(17 25 7+( 6,(%(/ ,1)5,1*(0(17" $ 12 7+,6 ,6 62/(/< /,0,7(' 72 7+( 25$&/( '$7$%$6( 7+$7 5816 81'(5 7+( $33/,&$7,216 06 +286( 7+$1. <28 7+( :,71(66 7+$1.6 05 0F'21(// 127+,1* )857+(5 <285 +2125 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 7+$1. <28 05 $//,621 7+( :,71(66 7+$1. <28 7+( &2857 <28 5( (;&86(' 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

7+( &2857 :(// +2: /21* ,6 7+$7 05 +2:$5' ,7 6 48,7( $ /21* 21( $&78$//< :( 0$< $6. 7+( &2857 72 ,17(55837 ,7 72 &$// 05 %5$1'7 :+2 1(('6 72 :+2 6 21/< +(5( 72'$< 62 7+( 1(;7 21( ,6 $1'5(: 1(/621 $1' 7+( 727$/ 5811,1* 7,0( <285 +2125 ,6 $%287 $ 0,187( $1 +285 $1' 0,187(6 7+( &2857 2+ 2.$< :+< '21 7 :( &$1 :( 7$.( 7+( :,71(66 287 2) 25'(5 1(;7 $1' 7+(1 67$57 :,7+ 7+( 7$3(" 2)) 7+( 5(&25' ',6&866,21 05 +2:$5' :28/' <28 /,.( 72 '2 7+$7" 7+( &2857 :( 9( +$' 7+5(( %< 7$3( ,7 :28/' %( 1,&( 72 +$9( $ /,9( :,71(66 ,1 %(7:((1 05 +2:$5' 2.$< 7+( &2857 :+< '21 7 :( '2 7+$7" 05 +2:$5' 2.$< 7+( &2857 62 :+< '21 7 :( 7$.( 285 ),567 0,187( %5($. $1' 7+(1 :( // &20( %$&. )25 $ /,9( :,71(66 /$',(6 $1' *(17/(0(1 <28 5( (;&86(' 5(&(66 7$.(1 $7 $0 &217,18(' 1(;7 3$*( 127+,1* 20,77('

5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 4 - November 5, 2010
352&((',1*6 5(680(' $7 $0 352&((',1*6 +(/' ,1 7+( 35(6(1&( 2) 7+( -85< 7+( &/(5. 3/($6( %( 6($7(' $1' &20( 72 25'(5 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 1(;7 :,71(66" 05 %2,(6 :( &$// $6 285 1(;7 :,71(66 05 :(51(5 %5$1'7 05 /$1,(5 $1' <285 +2125 7+,6 :,71(66 ,6 7(67,)<,1* ,1 *(50$1 :( +$9( $*5((' 21 $ 75$16/$725 06 $5,$11$ 6&+1(,'(5 672&.,1* 6+( 6 $/5($'< %((1 6:251 7+( &2857 7+$1. <28 *22' 0251,1* 7+( ,17(535(7(5 *22' 0251,1* 05 /$1,(5 :( +$9( $/62 $*5((' 72 6$9( 620( 7,0( $6 :( +$9( '21( %()25( 7+$7 7+( 75$16/$725 '2(6 127 1((' 72 75$16/$7( 3257,216 2) '2&80(176 7+$7 :(5( :5,77(1 ,1 (1*/,6+ 7+$7 :(17 72 7+( :,71(66 %()25( 72 6$9( $ /,77/( 7,0( 7+( &2857 7+$1. <28 05 /$1,(5 7+$1. <28 7+( &/(5. 3/($6( 5$,6( <285 5,*+7 +$1' :(51(5 %5$1'7 &$//(' $6 $ :,71(66 )25 7+( 3/$,17,))6 +$9,1* %((1 '8/< 6:251 7(67,),(' $6 )2//2:6 7(67,021< *,9(1 7+528*+ *(50$1 ,17(535(7(5 7+( :,71(66 , 6:($5 7+( &/(5. 3/($6( %( 6($7(' ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'& %5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 6$3 &255(&7" $ 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 4 $1' <28 +$9( &217,18(' $6 &)2 $1' $6 $ 0(0%(5 2) 7+( (;(&87,9( %2$5' 2) 6$3 72 7+( 35(6(17 7,0( &255(&7" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 <28 $5( $/62 $ ',5(&725 2) 6$3 $0(5,&$ &255(&7" $ , $0 ',5(&725 2) 6$3 $0(5,&$ 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 4 +2: /21* +$9( <28 %((1 ',5(&725 2) 6$3 $0(5,&$" $ )25 0$1< <($56 4 :(5( <28 $ ',5(&725 2) 6$3 $0(5,&$ ,1 " $ , 7+,1. 62 <(6 4 :(5( <28 $ 0(0%(5 2) 6$3 $0(5,&$ :+(1 6$3 $&48,5(' 7202552:12:" $ , 7+,1. 62 <(6 4 <28 /(' 7+( 7($0 7+$7 +$1'/(' 7+( 7202552:12: $&48,6,7,21 &255(&7 6,5" $ 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 4 $1' <28 $5( 7+( 6$3 (;(&87,9( %2$5' 0(0%(5 35,0$5,/< 5(63216,%/( )25 ',5(&7,1* 7+,6 /$:68,7 $1' +2: 7+,6 /$:68,7 ,6 +$1'/(' &255(&7" $ 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 4 , :$17 72 %(*,1 :,7+ -867 620( %$&.*5281' 48(67,216 <28 :28/' $*5(( :28/' <28 127 7+$7 ,1 7+( 62)7:$5( %86,1(66 ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< ,6 9(5< ,03257$17" $ 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 3/($6( 67$7( <285 )8// )$0( $1' 63(// <285 /$67 1$0( )25 7+( 5(&25' 7+( :,71(66 0< 1$0( ,6 :(51(5 %5$1'7 % 5 $ 1 ' 7 05 %2,(6 <285 +2125 :( :28/' 2))(5 :,7+287 2%-(&7,21 3/$,17,))6 (;+,%,76 $1' 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 05 /$1,(5 12 2%-(&7,21 <285 +2125 7+( &2857 $'0,77(' 3/$,17,))6 (;+,%,76 $1' 5(&(,9(' ,1 (9,'(1&( ',5(&7 (;$0,1$7,21 %< 05 %2,(6 4 *22' 0251,1* 05 %5$1'7 $ *22' 0251,1* 05 %2,(6 4 :( +$9(1 7 0(7 %87 , 5(35(6(17 25$&/( $1' <28 81'(567$1' 7+$7 5,*+7" $ , 81'(567$1' 7+$7 <(6 4 :+(1 ',' <28 -2,1 6$3" $ , %(&$0( $1 (03/2<(( 2) 6$3 21 )(%58$5< 67 4 $1' $7 7+$7 7,0( <28 %(&$0( &+,() ),1$1&,$/ 2)),&(5 2) 6$3 &255(&7" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $1' <28 $/62 %(&$0( $ 0(0%(5 2) 7+( (;(&87,9( %2$5' 2) ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 4 6$3 6 %86,1(66 $1' 25$&/( 6 %86,1(66 '(3(1'6 21 ,76 ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< &255(&7 6,5" $ 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 4 $1' 6$3 7$.(6 67(36 72 3527(&7 ,76 ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< )520 ,1)5,1*(0(17 &255(&7 6,5" $ 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 4 $1' ,1 )$&7 6$3 +$6 $ '(3$570(17 '(927(' 72 3527(&7,1* 6$3 6 ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< &255(&7" $ 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 4 $1' :+(1 6$3 /,&(16(6 ,76 ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< ,76 62)7:$5( ,7 75,(6 72 *(7 7+( 0$;,080 5(7851 3266,%/( )520 ,7 &255(&7 6,5" $ ,7 6 7+( *2$/ 2) $1< (17(535,6( 4 , :$17 72 7$.( <28 %$&. 12: 72 '(&(0%(5 2) $1' $7 7+$7 7,0( 6$3 :$6 &216,'(5,1* $&48,5,1* $ &203$1< &$//(' 7202552:12: &255(&7" $ 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 4 $1' 7+( 385326( 2) $&48,5,1* 7202552:12: :$6 72 $&48,5( $ &203$1< 7+$7 &28/' +(/3 6$3 3529,'( 0$,17(1$1&( $1' 6833257 72 3(23/(62)7 &86720(56 &255(&7 6,5" $ 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 4 $1' 7+,6 :$6 3$57 2) $1 29(5$// 3/$1 2) 6$3 72 75< 72 &219(57 3(23/(62)7 &86720(56 $1' - ' (':$5'6 &86720(56 72 6$3 &86720(56 &255(&7 6,5" $ 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 4 - November 5, 2010
SHEET 6

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 4 , :28/' /,.( 72 ',5(&7 <285 $77(17,21 72 $ '2&80(17 7+$7 ,6 12: ,1 (9,'(1&( :+,&+ ,6 3/$,17,))6 (;+,%,7 ,7 ,6 %(+,1' 7$% 2) <285 %,1'(5 (;+,%,7 ',63/$<(' 21 6&5((1 $ :( +$9( $1' $1' 4 <(6 7+( 7$%6 *2 83 $// 7+( :$< 72 %87 7+( 7$% 7+$7 , $0 3$57,&8/$5/< ,17(5(67(' ,1 ,6 7$% 7+$7 +$6 (;+,%,7 %(+,1' ,7 3$86( ,1 7+( 352&((',1*6 '2 <28 +$9( 7+$7 '2&80(17 6,5" $ <(6 4 2.$< 12: 7+,6 $ (1*/,6+ 21( 6(&21' *,9( 0( $ &+$1&( 72 387 ,7 $5281' 4 685( $ (1*/,6+ 7+$1. <28 4 685( 7+,6 '2&80(17 :$6 $ 35(6(17$7,21 21 $ 352*5$0 &$//(' 6$)( 3$66$*( &255(&7 6,5" $ ,7 6 $ '2&80(17 (17,7/(' 6$)( 3$66$*( 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 4 $1' 6$)( 3$66$*( :$6 $ 352*5$0 7+$7 ,1 ($5/< 6$3 +$' 72 75< 72 &219(57 3(23/(62)7 $1' - ' (':$5'6 &86720(56 72 6$3 &86720(56 &255(&7 6,5" $ 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 4 $1' -867 72 $92,' $1< &21)86,21 7+,6 ,6 '$7(' -$18$5< 7+ $1' ,7 6$<6 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 2) 6+$5(' &86720(56 '2 <28 6(( 7+$7" $ , 6(( ,7 <(6 4 12: ,1 25'(5 72 '2 7+,6 ,7 :$6 ,03257$17 72 %( $%/( 72 2))(5 0$,17(1$1&( $1' 6833257 6(59,&(6 72 3(23/(62)7 $1' - ' (':$5'6 &86720(56 &255(&7 6,5" $ 7+$7 :$6 7+( 23,1,21 2) 620( 2) 285 (03/2<((6 ,1 7+( 0$5.(7,1* '(3$570(17 $7 7+( 7,0( 4 $1' ,1'((' ,7 :$6 025( 7+$1 -867 7+( 23,1,21 2) 7+( 0$5.(7,1* 3(23/( 7+$7 ,6 :+$7 7+( (;(&87,9( %2$5' %(/,(9(' &255(&7 6,5" $ 7+,6 ,6 +2: ,7 +$6 %((1 35(6(17(' $7 7+( 7,0( 72 7+( %2$5' 4 $1' :+(1 ,7 :$6 35(6(17(' 7+$7 :$< 72 7+( %2$5' 12%2'< $7 7+( %2$5' ',6$*5((' :,7+ ,7 &255(&7 6,5" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $1' ,7 :$6 6$3 6 3/$1 72 3529,'( 7+$7 ,03257$17 0$,17(1$1&( $1' 6833257 )25 3(23/(62)7 $1' - ' (':$5'6 &86720(56 7+528*+ 7202552:12: &255(&7 6,5" $ <(6 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $1' 7+( $&48,6,7,21 2) 7202552:12: :$6 ,03257$17 %(&$86( 6$3 %(/,(9(' 7+$7 7202552:12: :$6 7+( 21/< &203$1< ,1 1257+ $0(5,&$ 7+$7 +$' 7+( &$3$&,7< 72 '2 :+$7 6$3 :$17(' '21( &255(&7 6,5" $ <(6 :( 3(5)250(' $ 0$5.(7 $1$/<6,6 $1' 7+( 5(68/7 2) ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 '2 <28 6(( 7+$7" $ , 6(( 7+$7 <(6 4 $1' 7+$7 ,6 $1 (5525 ,7 ,6 &255(&7 6,5" $ , $6680( 62 <(6 4 %(&$86( <28 5(0(0%(5 7+$7 7+( 6$)( 3$66$*( 352*5$0 2&&855(' $)7(5 25$&/( +$' &203/(7(' ,76 $&48,6,7,21 2) 3(23/(62)7 &255(&7 6,5" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 12: 7+( *2$/ 7+$7 6$3 +$' :$6 72 &219(57 $3352;,0$7(/< 3(5&(17 2) 7+( 3(23/(62)7 $1' - ' (':$5' &86720(5 ,167$//$7,216 72 6$3 &255(&7" $ 7+( *2$/ :$6 72 5($&+ 25 72 &219(57 $6 0$1< &86720(56 $6 3266,%/( :+2 :(5( 9(5< ,16(&85( '8( 72 3(23/(62)7 6,78$7,21 ,1 7+( 0$5.(7 $1' 7+( 81&(57$,17,(6 $5281' ,7 $1' 72 &219(57 7+(6( &86720(56 72 6$3 %< 6+2:,1* 7+(0 7+$7 285 62/87,216 :(5( 7+( %(77(5 21(6 )25 7+(,5 %86,1(66 35$&7,&(6 4 $1' <285 *2$/ :$6 72 &219(57 $3352;,0$7(/< 3(5&(17 2) 7+( 3(23/(62)7 $1' - ' (':$5'6 &86720(5 ,167$//$7,216 72 6$3 &255(&7 6,5" $ 7+,6 ,6 &255(&7 7+,6 &$1 $/62 %( 6((1 ,1 '2&80(176 4 <(6 $1' )25 (;$03/( ,) :( *2 72 7+( 3$*( 7+$7 (1'6 ,1 7+( 180%(5 ,1 7+,6 '2&80(17 :( 6(( 21( 2) 7+( *2$/6 72 %( &219(57 $3352;,0$7(/< 3(5&(17 2) 7+( 3(23/(62)7 $1' - ' (':$5'6 &86720(5 ,167$//$7,216 72 6$3 $ +81'5(' 3(5&(17 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 7+,6 :$6 (;$&7/< :+$7 <28 -867 '(6&5,%(' 4 $1' (9(5< 0(0%(5 2) 7+( 6$3 (;(&87,9( %2$5' )8//< 6833257(' 7+( $&48,6,7,21 2) 7202552:12: &255(&7 6,5" $ 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 4 $1' 7+$7 ,1&/8'(' 05 26:$/' &255(&7" $ <(6 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 7+( 927( :$6 81$1,0286 4 $1' 7+$7 ,1&/8'(' 05 $327+(.(5" $ 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 4 7+( 9$/8( 72 6$3 2) 7+( 352*5$0 86,1* 7202552:12: ,1&/8'(' 127 21/< -867 7+( 0$,17(1$1&( $1' 6833257 5(9(18(6 7+$7 :(5( (;3(&7(' 72 %( ($51(' %87 $/62 7+( &$3$&,7< 72 029( &86720(56 )520 3(23/(62)7 $1' - ' (':$5'6 72 6$3 &255(&7 6,5" $ 7+( *2$/ 2) 6$)( 3$66$*( :$6 72 *$,1 $6 0$1< &86720(56 $6 3266,%/( 7+$7 6 :+$7 <28 -867 67$7(' ,6 &255(&7 4 $1' ,7 :$6 352-(&7(' 7+$7 <28 :28/' *(7 $/0267 0,//,21 ,1 5(9(18(6 29(5 7+( ,1,7,$/ 7+5(( <($56 2) 7+( 352*5$0 &255(&7 6,5" $ <(6 7+,6 ,6 &255(&7 7+,6 ,6 7+( 5(68/7 2) 6(9(5$/ 0$5.(7,1* 3/$16 7+$7 :(5( 387 72*(7+(5 $7 7+( 7,0( 4 ,1 $'',7,21 72 7+( 5(9(18( 7+$7 6$3 (;3(&7(' 72 *(7 )520 7+,6 352*5$0 6$3 $/62 (;3(&7(' 72 %(1(),7 )520 7+( ',65837,21 7+$7 7+( 352*5$0 :28/' &$86( 25$&/( &255(&7 6,5" $ 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 4 :28/' <28 (;3/$,1 72 7+( -85< :+< ,7 :$6 9$/8$%/( 72 6$3 72 75< 72 ',65837 25$&/(" ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 4 - November 5, 2010
%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 $ 62 2) &2856( :( :(5( ,1 $ 9(5< &203(7,7,9( 0$5.(7 6,78$7,21 $7 7+( 7,0( $1' 7+86 (63(&,$//< :,7+ 9,(: 72 7+( 81&(57$,17,(6 7+$7 :(5( 21 7+( 0$5.(7 $7 7+( 7,0( $1' :( :$17(' 72 $&+,(9( ,1 7+,6 9(5< 6+257 7,0( )5$0( )520 -$18$5< 72 )(%58$5< 2) 72 *$,1 7+,6 &203(7,7,9( $'9$17$*( 4 $5( <28 6$<,1* 7+$7 %(&$86( 2) 7+( &203(7,7,9( 6,78$7,21 $1<7+,1* 7+$7 ',65837(' 25$&/( :28/' %( 2) %(1(),7 72 6$3" $ ,7 6 $ 9(5< 6,03/( 6,78$7,21 ,) 21( &203(7,725 21 7+( 0$5.(7 *$,16 0$5.(7 6+$5( 7+,6 0($16 ',65837,21 25 ,16(&85,7< )25 7+( 27+(5 &203(7,725 ,1 7+( 0$5.(7 4 7+( *2$/ 2) ',65837,1* 25$&/( :$6 127 0(5(/< $ *2$/ 2) 7$.,1* $:$< 0$5.(7 6+$5( &255(&7 6,5" $ 12 127 $7 $// , 7+,1. :( +$' 9(5< &/($5 *2$/ ,1 0,1' $1' 7+$7 :$6 72 75$16)(5 $1' &219(57 7+( -'( $1' 3(23/(62)7 &86720(56 72 6$3 %(&$86( :( +$' $ 9(5< +,*+ 48$/,7< 352'8&7 4 /(7 0( *2 72 %$&. 72 3$*( 25 2) (;+,%,7 7+$7 :( :(5( /22.,1* $7 %()25( 7+,6 :$6 7+( 67$7(0(17 2) *2$/6 :( /22.(' $7 (;+,%,7 ',63/$<(' 21 6&5((1 $7 7+( 723 <28 6(( 7+( *2$/ :( 7$/.(' $%287 %()25( :+,&+ :$6 72 &219(57 $3352;,0$7(/< 3(5&(17 2) 7+( 3(23/(62)7 $1' - ' (':$5'6 &86720(5 ,167$//$7,216 72 6$3 '2 <28 6(( 7+$7" $ , 6(( 7+$7 <(6 4 7:2 %8//(76 '2:1 <28 6(( 7+( *2$/ 2) 6+5,1. 7+(,5 6+$5( 2) ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'& %5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 4 7+( (17(535,6( $33/,&$7,21 62)7:$5( 0$5.(7 7+$7 ,6 $ 3+5$6( 7+$7 <28 $5( )$0,/,$5 :,7+ &255(&7 6,5" $ 7+(5( ,6 $ ',))(5(1&( %(7:((1 7+( 62)7:$5( 0$5.(7 7+( (17(535,6( $33/,&$7,21 62)7:$5( 0$5.(7 ,76(/) $1' 7+( 6833257 6(59,&(6 &211(&7(' 72 ,7 +2:(9(5 , '21 7 7+,1. ,7 ,6 1(&(66$5< 12: 72 7851 7+,6 ,172 $ %,* ',6387( $1' ,1 *(1(5$/ 7(506 , $*5(( 7+( 0$5.(7 6+$5( 2) 6$3 :$6 ,1 *(1(5$/ %,**(5 7+$1 25$&/( 6 4 /(7 0( *2 72 7+( 27+(5 *2$/6 7+$7 $5( /,67(' +(5( ,1 $'',7,21 72 7$.,1* 0$5.(7 6+$5( $:$< )520 25$&/( 21( 2) 7+( *2$/6 7+$7 ,6 /,67(' ,6 ',65837 25$&/( 6 $%,/,7< 72 3$< )25 7+( $&48,6,7,21 287 2) &$6+ )/2: '2 <28 6(( 7+$7" $ <(6 4 :+< :$6 7+$7 ,03257$17 $1' 9$/8$%/( 72 6$3 72 '2 7+$7" $ )25 ,1 0< 23,1,21 ,7 ,6 $ 9(5< 6,03/( $1' 675$,*+7)25:$5' &216(48(1&( 2) 7$.,1* $:$< 0$5.(7 6+$5( )520 25$&/( ,7 0($16 /(66 6$/(6 /(66 5(78516 $1' /(66 $1' /(66 &$6+ )/2: 4 %87 0< 48(67,21 6,5 ,6 :+< :$6 ,7 9$/8$%/( $1' ,03257$17 72 ',65837 25$&/( 6 $%,/,7< 72 3$< )25 7+( $&48,6,7,21 287 2) &$6+ )/2:" :+< ',' 6$3 :$17 72 $&+,(9( 7+$7" $ , &$1127 $16:(5 7+,6 72'$< ,7 6 127 $ 5($//< 9$/,' ),1$1&,$/ )2508/$7,21 4 $7 7+( 7,0( %$&. ,1 -$18$5< 2) :+(1 7+,6 :$6 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 7+( $33/,&$7,21 0$5.(7 '2 <28 6(( 7+$7" $ , 6(( 7+$7 4 $1' :+(1 <28 7$/. $%287 6+5,1.,1* 7+(,5 6+$5( <28 $5( 7$/.,1* $%287 6+5,1.,1* 25$&/( 6 6+$5( &255(&7" $ <(6 4 $1' ,1 ($5/< :+$7 :$6 25$&/( 6 6+$5( ,1&/8',1* 3(23/(62)7 $1' - ' (':$5'6 2) 7+( (17(535,6( $33/,&$7,216 62)7:$5( 0$5.(7" $ , '21 7 5($//< +$9( 7+(6( ),*85(6 5,*+7 12: ,1 0< +($' %87 , %(/,(9( 7+$7 7+( 0$5.(7 6+$5( 2) 25$&/( ,1&/8',1* 3(23/(62)7 $1' - ' (':$5'6 :$6 620(:+$7 60$//(5 7+$1 7+( 6$3 0$5.(7 6+$5( $1' ,1 7+( 23(1,1* 67$7(0(176 7+$7 :(5( 0$'( 21 78(6'$< , %(/,(9( 7+(5( :$6 $ 67$7(0(17 0$'( $%287 7+( (;$&7 0$5.(7 6+$5( +2:(9(5 , $0 6255< , '21 7 5(0(0%(5 7+(6( 4 '2 <28 5(0(0%(5 7+$7 7+( '(6&5,37,21 ,1 7+( 23(1,1* 67$7(0(176 :$6 %$6,&$//< $&&85$7(" $ , +$9( 127 &+(&.(' 7+(6( 180%(56 25 ),*85(6 0<6(/) %87 , %(/,(9( 7+(6( $5( 5,*+7 4 $1' <28 :28/' $*5(( :,7+ 0( :28/' <28 127 6,5 7+$7 6$3 ,1 $1' +$' 025( 7+$1 3(5&(17 2) 7+( 0$5.(7 )25 (17(535,6( $33/,&$7,21 62)7:$5(" $ 7+,6 ,7 6 9(5< ,03257$17 +(5( 72 ',))(5(17,$7( (;$&7/< :+$7 0$5.(7 :( $5( 7$/.,1* $%287 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 35(6(17(' 72 <28 $6 $ 0(0%(5 2) 7+( (;(&87,9( %2$5' ',' <28 48(67,21 7+,6 *2$/" $ , '2 127 5(&$// 7+$7 7+,6 (17,5( '2&80(17 +$6 %((1 35(6(17(' 72 $// 6$3 %2$5' 0(0%(56 4 <28 $5( 127 '(1<,1* 7+$7 <28 6$: 7+,6 '2&80(17 $5( <28 6,5" $ , +$9( 6((1 7+,6 '2&80(17 +2:(9(5 , &$1127 7(// <28 ,) , +$9( $/5($'< 6((1 7+,6 '2&80(17 ,) , $/5($'< 6$: 7+,6 '2&80(17 ,1 -$18$5< 2) 4 /(7 0( %( 685( , 81'(567$1' :+$7 <28 $5( 6$<,1* ',' <28 6(( 7+,6 '2&80(17 ,1 " $ , &$1127 7(// <28 7+,6 72'$< $1<025( 4 ,6 ,7 <285 7(67,021< ,1 12 21( (9(5 72/' <28 7+$7 21( 2) 7+( *2$/6 2) 7+( 7202552:12: 352*5$0 $1' 6$)( 3$66$*( :$6 72 ',65837 25$&/( 6 $%,/,7< 72 3$< )25 7+( $&48,6,7,21 2) 3(23/(62)7 287 2) &$6+ )/2:" ,6 7+$7 <285 7(67,021<" $ 7+$7 6 127 :+$7 , 6$,' 4 12 12 , '21 7 0($1 72 6$< 7+$7 7+$7 ,6 :+$7 <28 6$,' , $0 5($//< -867 75<,1* 72 *(7 <285 7(67,021< 0$<%( 7+( 6,03/(67 :$< 72 '2 ,7 ,6 7+,6 :+(7+(5 <28 5(0(0%(5 7+,6 '2&80(17 25 127 :28/' <28 $*5(( 7+$7 7+( *2$/6 7+$7 $5( 67$7(' +(5( $5( *2$/6 7+$7 <28 :(5( 72/' ,1 -$18$5< 2) :(5( *2$/6 2) 7+( 7202552:12: $1' 6$)( 3$66$*( 352*5$06" $ ,) <28 $6. 7+( 48(67,21 7+,6 :$< 7+(1 , &$1 $16:(5 <(6 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 4 - November 5, 2010
%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 '2 <28 81'(567$1' 7+$7" $ , 81'(567$1' 7+$7 4 2.$< $1' <28 81'(567$1' 7+$7 :+$7 6$3 :28/' %( 35(3$5(' 72 3$< )25 $ /,&(16( :28/' '(3(1' ,1 3$57 21 +2: 9$/8$%/( 7+( 352*5$0 :$6 7+$7 6$3 1(('(' 7+( /,&(16( 72 81'(57$.( 25 +2: 9$/8$%/( ,7 :$6 (;3(&7(' 72 %( )$,5" $ ,1 7+(25< , &$1 )2//2: 4 2.$< 12: 21( 2) 7+( 5($6216 :+< 68&+ $ /,&(16( :28/' %( 9$/8$%/( ,6 %(&$86( ,7 :28/' (1$%/( 6$3 72 75< 72 &219(57 7+( $3352;,0$7(/< 3(5&(17 2) 7+( 3(23/(62)7 $1' - ' (':$5'6 &86720(5 ,167$//$7,216 7+$7 ,7 :$6 6((.,1* 72 &219(57 &255(&7 6,5" $ ,1 7+(25< 7+$7 6 &255(&7 <(6 4 $1' $127+(5 5($621 ,7 :28/' %( 9$/8$%/( :28/' %( %(&$86( ,7 :28/' +(/3 72 6+5,1. 25$&/( 6 6+$5( 2) 7+( $33/,&$7,21 0$5.(7 $1' ,1&5($6( 6$3 6 6+$5( &255(&7" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 12: , :$17 72 )2&86 21 :+< ,7 :28/' %( 9$/8$%/( ,1 7+,6 &217(;7 72 ',65837 $1' ',6&5(',7 25$&/( <28 81'(567$1'" $ <(6 4 $1' /(7 0( 387 6,1&( <28 $5( $1 $'9(56( :,71(66 /(7 0( 387 $ /($',1* 48(67,21 72 <28 ,6 ,7 7+( &$6( 7+$7 21( $'9$17$*( 2) 5('8&,1* 25 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'& %5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 $ $%62/87(/< 4 ,) 6$3 ,6 )281' 72 +$9( ,1)5,1*(' &23<5,*+76 7+$7 :28/' %( '$0$*,1* 72 ,76 5(387$7,21 &255(&7" $ 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 ,1 35,1&,3/( <(6 4 $1' ,6 ,7 )$,5 72 6$< 7+$7 6$3 :28/' 127 /,*+7/< 81'(57$.( $ 352*5$0 7+$7 +$' 6(5,286 /,$%,/,7< 5,6.6 %(&$86( 2) ,76 5,6. 72 6$3 6 5(387$7,21" $ 7+$7 6 $%62/87(/< &255(&7 4 $1' ,) 6$3 +$' $ 352*5$0 7+$7 :$6 9(5< ,03257$17 72 ,7 /,.( 7+( 7202552:12: $1' 6$)( 3$66$*( 352*5$0 $1' <28 1(('(' $ /,&(16( 72 '2 7+$7 /$:)8//< 6$3 :28/' 75< 72 *(7 7+$7 /,&(16( &255(&7 6,5" 05 /$1,(5 2%-(&7,21 <285 +2125 &$//6 )25 63(&8/$7,21 7+( &2857 2.$< %()25( +( $16:(56 12: <28 &$1 0$.( <285 2%-(&7,21 05 /$1,(5 ,7 &$//6 )25 63(&8/$7,21 <285 +2125 05 %2,(6 , '21 7 7+,1. ,7 &$//6 )25 63(&8/$7,21 *,9(1 7+,6 :,71(66 326,7,21 7+( &2857 , 7(1' 72 $*5(( :,7+ 3/$,17,))6 &2816(/ 29(558/(' <28 0$< $16:(5 7+( :,71(66 &$1 <28 3/($6( 5(3($7 7+( 48(67,21" 05 %2,(6 7+$7 ,6 3266,%/( :,7+ 7+( +(/3 2) 7(&+12/2*< ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 ',65837,1* 25$&/( 6 $%,/,7< 72 3$< )25 7+( 3(23/(62)7 $&48,6,7,21 287 2) &$6+ )/2: ,6 7+$7 25$&/( :28/' %( 5(48,5(' 72 86( &$6+ )/2: 7+$7 &28/' 27+(5:,6( %( 86(' )25 5(6($5&+ $1' '(9(/230(17 72 3$< )25 7+( 3(23/(62)7 $&48,6,7,21" $ ,1 7+(25< 7+$7 6 &255(&7 <(6 4 $1' )2&86,1* 21 7+( )2857+ *2$/ 7+$7 6 +(5( 7+$7 ,6 ',6&5(',7,1* 25$&/( $0 , &255(&7 7+$7 ,7 :28/' %( 9$/8$%/( 72 6$3 72 ',6&5(',7 25$&/( %(&$86( 25$&/( :$6 $ 0$-25 &203(7,725 $1' $1<7+,1* 7+$7 ',6&5(',76 <285 0$-25 &203(7,725 +(/36 <28" $ ,1 7+(25< 7+$7 ,6 $/62 &255(&7 4 ,1 -$18$5< 2) <28 (;3(&7(' 7+$7 7+( &20%,1$7,21 2) 6$3 $1' 7202552:12: :28/' %( $1 ,00(',$7( $1' 6(5,286 &+$//(1*( 72 25$&/( 127 0(5(/< $ 352326(' &+$//(1*( 72 %( )8/),//(' $1' 3529(1 620( <($56 '2:1 7+( 52$' &255(&7 6,5" $ 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 4 12: <28 :(5( $:$5( $7 7+( 7,0( 7+$7 6$3 :$6 &216,'(5,1* $&48,5,1* 7202552:12: 7+$7 7+(5( :(5( 48(67,216 &21&(51,1* 7+( /(*$/,7< 2) :+$7 7202552:12: :$6 '2,1* )$,5" $ 7+(5( :(5( 5,6. $66(660(176 ,1 7+,6 5(*$5' 4 <(6 $1' 7+( 5,6. $66(660(176 /(' <28 72 %(/,(9( 7+$7 7+(5( :(5( 6(5,286 /,$%,/,7< ,668(6 :,7+ 5(63(&7 72 7+( 23(5$7,21 2) 7202552:12: &255(&7 6,5" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $1' 6$3 6 5(387$7,21 )25 ,17(*5,7< ,6 9(5< ,03257$17 72 6$3 &255(&7" ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 %< 05 %2,(6 4 ,) 6$3 +$' $ 352*5$0 7+$7 :$6 9(5< ,03257$17 72 ,7 /,.( 7+( 7202552:12: $1' 6$)( 3$66$*( 352*5$0 7+$7 6$3 1(('(' $ /,&(16( 72 81'(57$.( $335235,$7(/< :,7+287 ,1)5,1*,1* 7+$7 ,6 620(7+,1* 7+$7 6$3 :28/' 3$< 72 *(7 &255(&7 6,5" $ , '2 127 $*5(( :,7+ 7+,6 )25 7+( )2//2:,1* 5($621 6$3 :28/' +$9( '85,1* 7+( &2856( 2) 7+( $&48,6,7,21 7+(< 3$< 6$3 3$,' $77(17,21 72 7+( 23(5$7,21$/ 352&('85(6 $7 7202552:12: $1' :28/' +$9( 0$'( 685( 7+$7 7+(6( :28/' +$9( %((1 &+$1*(' 62 7+$7 )25 7202552:12: 7+(5( :28/' +$9( %((1 12 &23<5,*+7 9,2/$7,216 4 , :$17 72 &20( %$&. 72 7+$7 ,668( %87 0< ,668( ,6 $ /,77/( %,7 ',))(5(17 5,*+7 12: <28 81'(567$1' 7+$7 6$3 +$6 $/5($'< $'0,77(' 7+$7 %27+ ,7 $1' 7202552:12: $5( /,$%/( )25 &23<5,*+7 ,1)5,1*(0(17 &255(&7" $ , '2 127 6(( ,7 7+,6 :$< 7202552:12: +$6 $'0,77(' 72 +$9,1* 9,2/$7(' &23<5,*+76 %87 127 6$3 4 7+$7 6 <285 81'(567$1',1* 6,5" $ <(6 7+,6 ,6 &255(&7 :( $&78$//< $&&(37(' ,17(50(',$5< 5(63216,%,/,7< 9,&$5,286 5(63216,%,/,7< )25 7+,6 4 <(6 /(7 0( %5($. ,7 '2:1 7+(5( &$0( $ 7,0( 7+,6 <($5 7+,6 )$// :+(1 7202552:12: $*5((' 7+$7 ,7 :$6 /,$%/( $1' 6$3 $*5((' 7+$7 ,7 :$6 9,&$5,286/< /,$%/( 7+$7 ,6 ,7 :28/' 3$< )25 :+$7 ,76 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 4 - November 5, 2010
%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 $)7(5 7+$7 4 2.$< ,7 :$6 127 67$7(' $7 7+( %2$5' 0((7,1*6 ,6 7+$7 :+$7 <28 $5( 6$<,1*" $ , &$1127 7(// <28 (;$&7/< :+,&+ 0((7,1* 7+,6 :$6 ',6&866(' 4 :+(7+(5 <28 &$1 7(// 0( (;$&7/< :+,&+ 0((7,1* ,7 :$6 ',6&866(' $7 $7 $1< 7,0( ,1 -$18$5< 25 )(%58$5< 2) :$6 ,7 &/($5/< 67$7(' $7 $ %2$5' 0((7,1* 2) 6$3 7+$7 7+( 352&('85(6 $1' %86,1(66 23(5$7,216 2) 7202552:12: +$' 72 &+$1*(" $ $6 , 67$7(' %()25( , '21 7 5(&$// (;$&7/< , .12: 7+(5( :(5( 7$/.6 $%287 7+$7 7+(5( :(5( ',6&866,216 $%287 7+$7 4 :(5( 7+(5( ',6&866,216 $7 7+( %2$5' 0((7,1*6" $ , &$1127 7(// <28 7+,6 72'$< %(&$86( 7+( 0(0%(56 2) 7+( %2$5' '21 7 21/< 7$/. '85,1* 7+( %2$5' 0((7,1*6 7+(< +$9( $/62 27+(5 0((7,1*6 2&&$6,216 72 7$/. 4 , $0 685( 7+$7 ,6 758( %87 0< 48(67,21 5,*+7 12: ,6 6,03/< %(&$86( <28 0(17,21(' 7+( %2$5' 0((7,1*6 ,6 $%287 7+( %2$5' 0((7,1*6 &$1 <28 7(// 0( 21( :$< 25 $127+(5 :+(7+(5 $7 $1< %2$5' 0((7,1* ,1 -$18$5< 25 )(%58$5< 2) $1<21( 67$7(' $6 <28 387 ,7 &/($5/< 7+$7 7+( 352&('85(6 $1' %86,1(66 23(5$7,216 2) 7202552:12: +$' 72 &+$1*(" $ , &$1 21/< 5(3($7 7+$7 , '21 7 5(0(0%(5 (;$&7/< $7 :+,&+ 0((7,1* 7+,6 :$6 25 '85,1* :+,&+ ',6&866,21 25 7$/. 7+,6 :$6 4 ,6 ,7 )$,5 72 6$< 7+$7 <28 5(0(0%(5 620(7,0( ,1 -$18$5< 25 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'& %5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 4 ,162)$5 $6 <28 $5( $:$5( ',' $1<%2'< '2 7+$7" $ ,7 :$6 7+( 5(63216,%,/,7< 2) 7+( %2$5' 0(0%(5 ,1 &+$5*( 2) 6833257 4 $1' :+2 ,6 7+$7 6,5" $ *(5+$5' 26:$/' 4 :+2 :$6 7+( &+,() (;(&87,9( 2)),&(5 $7 7+,6 7,0(" $ +(15< .$*(50$11 4 ',' +( $/62 +$9( 5(63216,%,/,7< 72 '2 7+$7 6,5" $ :,7+,1 7+( 6$3 $* :( +$9( $ ',9,6,21 ',))(5(17 )81&7,216 :( +$9( )81&7,21$/ 5(63216,%,/,7,(6 :,7+,1 7+( %2$5' 0(0%(56 $1' 7+( &(2 +$6 7+( 29(5$// 5(63216,%,/,7< 4 62 7+$7 7+( &(2 25 &(2 6 ,) <28 +$9( &2 &(2 6 +$9( 29(5$// 5(63216,%,/,7< 72 0$.( 685( $// 2) 7+( 23(5$7,216 $5( 3(5)250,1* 3523(5/< &255(&7" $ <(6 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 12: ',' <28 (9(5 $6. 05 26:$/' :+(7+(5 +( +$' +$' $1<%2'< *2 /22. $7 7+( 7202552:12: &20387(56 72 6(( :+(7+(5 7+,6 6(5,286 5,6. 7+$7 <28 9( ,'(17,),(' :$6 ,1 )$&7 $1 $&&203/,6+(' )$&7 7+$7 ,6 7+(5( :$6 $&78$/ ,1)5,1*(0(17 *2,1* 21 5,*+7 $7 7+( 020(17" $ 12 4 ,7 :$6 9(5< ($6< 72 &+(&. :$6 ,7 127 6,5" $ , &$1127 -8'*( 7+$7 4 :(// <28 .1(: 6,5 7+$7 ,7 :$6 ,1$335235,$7( )25 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 )(%58$5< 2) 6$3 %2$5' 0(0%(56 67$7,1* &/($5/< 7+$7 7+( %86,1(66 23(5$7,216 $1' 352&('85(6 2) 7202552:12: +$' 72 &+$1*( %87 <28 &$1 7 5(0(0%(5 :+(7+(5 7+$7 :$6 $7 $ %2$5' 0((7,1* 25 ,1 ',6&866,216 2876,'( 2) %2$5' 0((7,1*6 25 3(5+$36 %27+ ,6 7+$7 )$,5" $ 7+,6 ,6 &255(&7 %(&$86( ,) 7+(1 5,6. ,6 ,'(17,),(' (9(5<7+,1* 3266,%/( ,6 '21( 72 0,7,*$7( 7+( 5,6. 4 $1' $ 5,6. :$6 ,'(17,),(' &255(&7" $ <(6 $ 327(17,$/ 5,6. <(6 4 $1' 7+( 5,6. 7+$7 :$6 ,'(17,),(' :$6 $ 5,6. 7+$7 7202552:12: :$6 ,1)5,1*,1* 25$&/( 6 &23<5,*+76 &255(&7" $ 7+( 5,6. :$6 7+$7 (;$&7/< 7+$7 7+$7 7202552:12: :28/' 327(17,$//< %( ,1 9,2/$7,21 2) 25$&/( 6 &23<5,*+76 4 2.$< $1' 6$3 &216,'(5(' 7+$7 72 %( $ 327(17,$/ 6(5,286 /,$%,/,7< &255(&7 6,5" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 2.$< $7 $1< 7,0( ,1 -$18$5< 25 )(%58$5< 2) ',' $1<21( *2 72 7202552:12: 72 6(( :+(7+(5 25 127 7202552:12: +$' 62)7:$5( 21 ,76 &20387(56 7+$7 ,7 :$6 127 $87+25,=(' 72 +$9(" $ 7+$7 6 :+$7 , $6680( 4 :+(1 <28 6$< 7+$7 ,6 :+$7 <28 $6680(' ',' <28 $6. $1<21( :+(7+(5 7+$7 +$' %((1 '21(" $ 127 3(5621$//< , ',' 127 '2 7+,6 3(5621$//< ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 7202552:12: 72 3529,'( 6833257 )25 &86720(56 21 &20387(56 2) 7202552:12: $6 23326(' 72 21 7+( &20387(56 2) &86720(56 &255(&7" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 2.$< 62 $// <28 +$' 72 '2 :$6 /22. $7 7+( 7202552:12: &20387(56 $1' 72 6(( :+(7+(5 7+(< +$' 25$&/( 352*5$06 21 7+(0 25 127 &255(&7 6,5" $ 7+$7 0$< %( 62 4 :(// 127 21/< 0$< ,7 %( 62 %87 <28 .12: ,7 6 62 '2 <28 127 6,5" $ 12 , '21 7 .12: 7+$7 %(&$86( , '21 7 .12: $%287 7+,6 7(&+12/2*< 7+,6 7(&+12/2*,&$/ $63(&7 4 :+$7 7(&+12/2*,&$/ $63(&7 '2 <28 127 .12: $%287 7+$7 ,6 5(/(9$17 +(5(" $ , &$1127 '(7(50,1( 0<6(/) :+(1 , 2%6(59( 620(%2'< 6,77,1* $7 $ &20387(5 :+$7 +2: +( $&&(66(6 :+$7 62)7:$5( 4 , $335(&,$7( 7+$7 , :$61 7 68**(67,1* 7+$7 <28 :28/' 3(5621$//< *2 $1' /22. $7 7+( &20387(56 '2 <28 81'(567$1' 7+$7 12:" $ <(6 4 <28 .1(: 7+$7 ,7 :$6 ,1$335235,$7( )25 7202552:12: 72 +$9( 7+( 25$&/( 62)7:$5( 21 7+( 7202552:12: &20387(56 $6 23326(' 72 7+( &86720(5 &20387(56 (9(1 7+28*+ <28 0,*+7 127 3(5621$//< %( 48$/,),(' 72 &+(&. 7+( &20387(56 <2856(/) )$,5" ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 4 - November 5, 2010
SHEET 9

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 $ , .1(: 7+$7 7+( 5,6. (;,67(' 4 :(// ,7 :$6 025( 7+$1 7+( 5,6. +(5( :$6 ,7 127 6,5" <28 .1(: 7+$7 ,) 7202552:12: :$6 3529,',1* 6833257 21 &20387(56 2) 7202552:12: $6 23326(' 72 7+( &20387(56 2) 7+( &86720(56 7+$7 7+$7 :$6 ,1$335235,$7( 127 $ 5,6. 2) %(,1* ,1$335235,$7( %87 7+$7 :$6 ,1$335235,$7( <28 .1(: 7+$7 ',' <28 127 6,5" $ 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 %87 :( 7+( ,03257$17 7(50 +(5( ,6 ,) 4 <(6 $1' 7+$7 ,) 7+$7 ,6 ,) ,7 :$6 +$33(1,1* 7+$7 ,6 620(7+,1* 7+$7 620(%2'< &28/' +$9( ($6,/< &+(&.(' 0$<%( 127 <28 %(&$86( 7+$7 6 127 <285 $5($ %87 7+$7 ,6 620(7+,1* 7+$7 6$3 +$6 7+286$1'6 2) 3(23/( :+2 $5( 48$/,),(' 72 &+(&. &255(&7" $ , '21 7 .12: ,) ,7 ,6 7+286$1'6 %87 ,1 35,1&,3/( 7+,6 ,6 &255(&7 4 2.$< $1' '2 <28 .12: :+(7+(5 $1<21( ',' *2 72 &+(&. 7+$7 ,6 ',' $1<21( %27+(5 72 *2 72 7+( 7202552:12: &20387(56 $1' 6(( :+(7+(5 25 127 7+(< +$' 7+( 25$&/( 62)7:$5( 21 7+(0" $ ,7 :$6 0< &/($5 $668037,21 $7 7+( 7,0( 7+$7 7+,6 :28/' +$33(1 $1' ,7 :$6 0< (;3(&7$7,21 4 12: <28 6$,' 7+(5( ,7 :$6 <285 &/($5 (;3(&7$7,21 $7 7+( 7,0( <28 $5( 7$/.,1* $%287 -$18$5< )(%58$5< &255(&7" $ <(6 4 12: <28 '21 7 .12: :+(7+(5 $1<%2'< (9(5 72/' 7202552:12: 72 7$.( 25$&/( 62)7:$5( 2)) 2) ,76 &20387(56 )$,5" ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 $ <(6 4 :+(1 :$6 7+$7" $ ,7 :$6 $)7(5 25$&/( ),/(' 7+( /$:68,7 $1' :( &21&/8'(' 285 2:1 ,19(67,*$7,21 4 $1' :+(1 ',' <28 &21&/8'( <285 2:1 ,19(67,*$7,21" $ 7+(6( ,19(67,*$7,216 :(5( &$55,(' 287 29(5 6(9(5$/ 0217+6 $1' $&78$//< 6(9(5$/ <($56 $1' , %(/,(9( 7+(< :(5( &21&/8'(' ,1 4 $1' 7+(< 67$57(' ,1 ,6 7+$7 :+$7 <28 $5( 6$<,1*" $ , :28/' /,.( 72 $16:(5 <285 35(9,286 48(67,21 $*$,1 4 2.$< $ 62 ),567 :( +$' 25$&/( 6 /$:68,7 7+$7 :$6 67$57(' ,1 0$5&+ 2) $)7(5 7+,6 :( 67$57(' 285 2:1 ,19(67,*$7,21 7+( :,71(66 (1*/,6+ (;$0,1$7,21 7+528*+ ,17(535(7(5 :+,&+ 722. 0217+6 $1' '85,1* 7+( &2856( 2) 7+(6( (;$0,1$7,216 :( &21&/8'(' $1' '(7(50,1(' 7+$7 7+(5( :(5( 7+$7 7+( 23(5$7,21$/ 352&('85(6 +$' 127 %((1 &+$1*(' $1' 7+,6 :$6 $5281' 0,' 4 0,' 2.$< 12: :+(1 <28 6$< 7+( 23(5$7,21$/ 352&('85(6 +$' 127 %((1 &+$1*(' '2 <28 0($1 7+$7 7202552:12: ,6 &217,18,1* 72 86( 25$&/( 6 62)7:$5( 21 ,76 &20387(56" ,6 7+$7 :+$7 <28 0($1" ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 $ 7+,6 ,6 127 &255(&7 , .12: 7+$7 7+,6 &20081,&$7,21 722. 3/$&( +2:(9(5 , '21 7 .12: :+2 ,7 :$6 4 :+(1 <28 6$< 7+,6 &20081,&$7,21 <28 0($1 $ &20081,&$7,21 7(//,1* 7202552:12: 72 6723 ,1)5,1*,1* 25$&/( 6 &23<5,*+76" ,6 7+$7 :+$7 <28 0($1" $ , 86( 7+( :25' &20081,&$7,21 $6 <28 +$' 0(17,21(' ,7 ,1 <285 48(67,21 4 :,7+287 67233,1* 5,*+7 $7 7+( 020(17 72 3$56( 7+( :25' &20081,&$7,21 ,6 ,7 <285 7(67,021< 7+$7 $7 620( 32,17 6$3 &20081,&$7(' 72 7202552:12: 72 6723 ,1)5,1*,1* 25$&/( 6 &23<5,*+76" $ 7+$7 ,6 0< 81'(567$1',1* 0< 81'(567$1',1* ,6 7+$7 7+,6 :$6 $ 3,(&( 2) ,1)250$7,21 *,9(1 72 7+( 0$1$*(0(17 2) 7202552:12: 7+$7 7+( 23(5$7,1* 352&('85(6 +$9( 72 %( &+$1*(' 4 , :$17 72 -867 %( &/($5 :+(1 '2 <28 7+,1. 7+$7 7+,6 &20081,&$7,21 722. 3/$&(" $ ,1 $6 )$5 $6 , 5(0(0%(5 $7 7+( (1' 2) 7+( ),567 48$57(5 4 (1' 2) 7+( ),567 48$57(5 2) '2(6 7+$7 0($1 7+$7 $)7(5 7+( ),567 48$57(5 2) <28 $6680(' 7+$7 25$&/( 62)7:$5( :$6 127 %(,1* 86(' 21 7202552:12: &20387(56" $ <(6 7+$7 :$6 0< $668037,21 4 ',' 7+(5( &20( $ 7,0( :+(1 <28 )281' 287 <285 $668037,21 :$6 )$/6(" ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 7+( ,17(535(7(5 '2(6 ,7 0($1 7+$7 7+(< :(5( %< 05 %2,(6 4 &217,18,1* 72 86( 25$&/( 62)7:$5( 21 7202552:12: &20387(56" $ 81)25781$7(/< <(6 4 2.$< 12: ,1 0,' :+(1 $)7(5 7+( /$:68,7 :$6 ),/(' $1' $)7(5 <28 +$' &203/(7(' <285 ,19(67,*$7,21 $1' $)7(5 <28 +$' )281' 287 7+$7 7202552:12: +$' &217,18(' 72 ,1)5,1*( 25$&/( 6 &23<5,*+76 :+$7 ',' 6$3 '2 72 0$.( 685( 7+$7 7+$7 67233(' ,00(',$7(/<" $ ),567 2) $// :( 75$16)(55(' 7+( 0$1$*(0(17 2) 7202552:12: 72 0$5. :+,7( :,7+ $ &/($5 7$6. 72 ,00(',$7(/< $33/< 7+( 1(: 23(5$7,1* 352&('85(6 4 $1' 7+( 1(: 23(5$7,1* 352&('85(6 <28 .((3 5()(55,1* 72 23(5$7,1* 352&('85(6 :+$7 :( $5( 7$/.,1* $%287 +(5( ,6 :+(7+(5 7202552:12: ,6 ,1)5,1*,1* 25$&/( 6 &23<5,*+76 &255(&7 6,5" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 2.$< 12: 05 :+,7( 72/' <28 $6 /$7( $6 7+$7 7202552:12: :$6 &217,18,1* 72 ,1)5,1*( 25$&/( 6 62)7:$5( &255(&7" $ 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 <(6 $1' $7 7+( 7,0( 7+(5( :$6 $ 9(5< &/($5 3/$1 7+$7 :$6 '(9(/23(' 72 75$16)(5 $// &86720(56 $1' ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 4 - November 5, 2010
%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 7+$7 :$6 &203/(7(' ,1 $35,/ 2) 4 12: ,1 $35,/ 2) 7+$7 ,6 29(5 $ <($5 $)7(5 7202552:12: $1' 6$3 +$9( %((1 68(' &255(&7 6,5" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $1' ,7 6 $/0267 $ <($5 $)7(5 <285 ,19(67,*$7,21 &21&/8'(' 7+$7 7202552:12: :$6 &217,18,1* 72 ,1)5,1*( 25$&/( 6 &23<5,*+76 &255(&7 6,5" $ <(6 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 $1' ,1 +,1'6,*+7 , :28/' /,.( 72 $'' 7+$7 :( 6+28/' +$9( '(&,'(' 72 6+87 '2:1 7202552:12: ,00(',$7(/< :( ',' 127 '2 7+$7 %(&$86( )25 7+( &86720(56 2) 7202552:12: :( :$17(' 72 ),1' $ 62/87,21 +2: 7+(< :28/' %( $%/( 72 5(&(,9( 6833257 ,1 7+( )8785( $6 :(// :( *$9( 7+(6( &86720(56 $ +,*+ 35,25,7< /(9(/ $1' ,1 +,1'6,*+7 $6 , 6$,' ,7 :$6 $ 0,67$.( 4 12: 6,5 ,6 7+(5( $1<7+,1* 7+$7 <28 .12: 2) ,1 7+( %2$5' 0,187(6 2) 6$3 7+$7 7$/.6 $%287 <285 '2,1* 7+,6 72 +(/3 &86720(56 $6 23326(' 72 +(/3 6$3" $ , &$1127 $16:(5 7+,6 48(67,21 %87 7+$7 :$6 7+( 5($621,1* 4 :(// <28 $ 2) 285 '(&,6,21 4 :+(1 <28 6$< 7+$7 :$6 <285 5($621,1* 6,5 7<3,&$//< '2 <28 387 7+( 5($621,1* )25 0$.,1* '(&,6,216 ,172 %2$5' 35(6(17$7,216 /,.( :( -867 6$: ,1 %2$5' 0,187(6" ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'& %5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 620(%2'< (/6( &255(&7 6,5" $ <(6 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 :( 75,(' 72 ),1' %8<(5 )25 7202552:12: 4 $1' <28 &28/'1 7 ),1' $ %8<(5 )25 7202552:12: %(&$86( (9(5<%2'< ),*85(' 287 7+$7 ,7 :$6 ,1)5,1*,1* 25$&/( 6 &23<5,*+76 $1' 12%2'< :$17(' 72 %8< ,7 $6 $ 5(68/7 &255(&7 6,5" $ $7 7+( 7,0( 7+( ,668( 2) /,$%,/,7< :$6 7+( 0267 35(66,1* ,668( 4 7+( 0267 35(66,1* ,668( $6 72 :+< 12%2'< :28/' %8< ,7 ,6 7+$7 5,*+7" $ <(6 4 12: '2 <28 +$9( $1< (;3/$1$7,21 )25 7+,6 -85< :+< ,7 :$6 62 ($6< )25 $// 2) 7+( 327(17,$/ %8<(56 72 48,&./< ),1' 287 7+$7 7202552:12: ,6 ,1)5,1*,1* %87 ,7 722. 6$3 ,1 <285 7(67,021< 62 /21* 72 ),*85( 7+$7 287" 05 /$1,(5 2%-(&7,21 <285 +2125 ,7 6 $5*80(17$7,9( $1' &$//6 )25 63(&8/$7,21 7+( &2857 6867$,1(' 05 %2,(6 7+( 48(67,21 ,6 :,7+'5$:1 %< 05 %2,(6 4 %$&. ,1 6$3 722. 67(36 72 75< 72 ,168/$7( ,76(/) )520 7+( /,$%,/,7< 7+$7 ,7 .1(: 7202552:12: 5(35(6(17(' &255(&7 6,5" $ :( $7 7+( 7,0( :( &+26( 72 *2 7+( :$< 7+$7 0$1< ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 $ 1250$//< <(6 4 2.$< $1' ',' <28 7+,1. 7+$7 ,) <285 &21&(51 +$' 5($//< %((1 $%287 7+( &86720(56 7+$7 0$<%( $ :$< 72 $3352$&+ ,7 :28/' +$9( %((1 72 *2 72 25$&/( $1' 6$< :( +$9( -867 ',6&29(5(' 7+$7 :( $5( ,1)5,1*,1* <285 &23<5,*+76 $1' :( $5( 5($//< 6255< $%287 7+$7 $1' :( $5( *2,1* 72 6723 ,00(',$7(/< %87 &$1 <28 +(/3 86 %( 685( 7+$7 7+(6( &86720(56 $5( 127 ',6$'9$17$*(' ',' $1<%2'< 7+,1. 2) '2,1* 7+$7" $ %$6(' 21 0< ,1)250$7,21 7+,6 :$6 '21( ,1 7+( &2856( 2) 7+( :,1' '2:1 2) 7202552:12: )25 63(&,),& &86720(56 %87 , '21 7 +$9( $// '(7$,/6 $%287 7+,6 4 :+$7 3$57,&8/$5 &86720(56 $5( <28 7+,1.,1* 2) :+(5( 7202552:12: 25 6$3 :(17 72 25$&/( $1' 6$,' :( +$9( %((1 ,1)5,1*,1* <285 &23<5,*+76 $1' :( :$17 72 6723 ,00(',$7(/< %87 :( '21 7 :$17 72 ',6$'9$17$*( 7+(6( &86720(56 62 &$1 :( :25. 287 620(7+,1* 7+$7 3529,'(6 6833257 )25 7+(6( &86720(56 " $ ,1 $16:(5,1* 7+( 48(67,21 %()25( , $/5($'< +,17(' 72 7+( )$&7 7+$7 , '21 7 .12: 7+( '(7$,/6 4 '2 <28 .12: $1< 2) 7+(6( 683326(' &86720(56 :+(5( <28 6$< 7+$7 6$3 ',' 7+,6" $ 12 4 2.$< 12: ,1 )$&7 :+$7 <28 ',' ,1 /$7( $1' ($5/< $)7(5 ',6&29(5,1* 7+$7 7202552:12: :$6 ,1)5,1*,1* 25$&/( 6 &23<5,*+76 ,6 <28 75,(' 72 6(// 7+$7 &203$1< 72 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 ,17(51$7,21$/ &203$1,(6 *2 :+(1 7+(< 385&+$6( $1' $&48,5( $127+(5 &203$1< $1' 62 7+,6 &203$1< &217,18(' $6 $1 ,1'(3(1'(17 &203$1< 4 $5( <28 6$<,1* 7+,6 ,6 %86,1(66 $6 868$/ $1' ','1 7 +$9( $1<7+,1* 72 '2 :,7+ 7+( )$&7 7+$7 <28 .1(: 7+$7 7202552:12: +$' 6(5,286 /,$%,/,7< 5,6.6" $ 7+$7 ,6 127 :+$7 , 6$,' , 0 21/< 6$<,1* 7+$7 ,7 ,6 127 81&20021 4 7+( 5($621 7+$7 <28 ',' ,7 +(5( :$6 %(&$86( <28 :(5( &21&(51(' $%287 /,$%,/,7< &255(&7 6,5" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $7 21( 32,17 <28 +$' &216,'(5(' +$9,1* 7:2 0(0%(56 2) 7+( 6$3 3$5(17 %2$5' 7+( 6$3 $* )520 *(50$1< 6,7 21 7+( 7202552:12: %2$5' &255(&7" $ <(6 7+(6( :(5( 352326$/6 $1' 68**(67,216 7+$7 :(5( ',6&866(' 4 $1' ,1'((' <28 $1' 05 26:$/' ,1,7,$//< 120,1$7(' 7:2 3(23/( )520 6$3 0$1$*(0(17 21( )520 6$3 $* ,1 *(50$1< $1' 21( 6$3 $0(5,&$ 72 7+( 7202552:12: %2$5' &255(&7" $ , '21 7 5(0(0%(5 :+2 68**(67(' ,7 %87 7+( 67$7(0(17 ,6 &255(&7 4 $1' 7+(1 ,7 :$6 '(&,'(' 72 127 +$9( $1<%2'< )520 *(50$1< 21 7+( %2$5' %(&$86( <28 :(5( &21&(51(' 7+$7 7+(< 0,*+7 %( 68%-(&7 72 $ '(326,7,21 +(5( ,1 7+( 81,7(' 67$7(6 &255(&7" $ 7+( 5($621 :$6 7+( 327(17,$/ /,$%,/,7< ,668( ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 4 - November 5, 2010
SHEET 10

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 4 7+$1. <28 12: /(7 0( 5(7851 72 7:2 7+,1*6 7+$7 <28 0(17,21(' 21( ,6 7+$7 <28 6$,' 7+$7 <28 %(/,(9( 7+$7 $7 620( 32,17 3(23/( $7 7202552:12: :(5( 72/' 72 &+$1*( 7+(,5 352&('85(6 $1' 6723 ,1)5,1*,1* 25$&/( 6 &23<5,*+76 '2 <28 5(&$// 7+$7 *(1(5$//<" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 12: :(5( 7+(< 72/' 7+$7 ,1 $1 ( 0$,/ 25 ,1 $ /(77(5" :+$7 :$6 7+( )250 2) 7+( &20081,&$7,21 %< :+,&+ 7+(< :(5( 72/' 7+$7" $ , '21 7 .12: 7+$7 4 +$9( <28 (9(5 6((1 $1< ( 0$,/ 25 :5,77(1 &20081,&$7,21 2) $1< .,1' 72 3(23/( $7 7202552:12: 7(//,1* 7+$7" $ 12 4 <28 :28/' $*5(( :,7+ 0( :28/' <28 127 7+$7 7+,6 &20081,&$7,21 ,) ,7 :$6 0$'( :$6 $1 ,03257$17 &20081,&$7,21" $ $%62/87(/< 4 $1' ,) <28 0$'( $1 ,03257$17 &20081,&$7,21 /,.( 7+$7 ,7 :28/' %( 0$'( ,1 :5,7,1* ,1 620( :$< &255(&7 6,5" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 7+(1 -867 72 )2//2: 83 21 7+( +<327+(7,&$/ /,&(16( 32,17 , 81'(567$1' 7+$7 ,7 ,6 <285 7(67,021< 7+$7 ,1 <28 ','1 7 .12: 7+$7 7202552:12: :$6 ,1)5,1*,1* 7+$7 6 <285 7(67,021< &255(&7" $ $7 7+( 7,0( ,1 , .1(: $%287 7+( 5,6. 7+( 327(17,$/ ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 4 '2(6 7+$7 /($' <28 72 &21&/8'( 7+$7 0$<%( 7+(5( ,6 127 $ :5,77(1 &20081,&$7,21" $ :,7+ $// '8( 5(63(&7 12 4 <28 :28/' $*5(( :,7+ 0( 7+$7 ,) 7+(5( :$6 127 $ :5,77(1 &20081,&$7,21 7+$7 :$6 $ /$36( 72 86( $6 1(875$/ $ :25' $6 , &$1 7+,1. 2) $7 7+( 020(17 $ 7+(1 7+(5( :$6 $ /$36(" 7+( ,17(535(7(5 &28/' <28 (;3/$,1 :+$7 <28 0($1 %< /$36(" $ /$36(" %< 05 %$55< 4 $ )$,/85(" $ &$1 <28 0$<%( 5(3+5$6( <285 48(67,21 $1' 86( 620( ',))(5(17 :25',1*" 4 , 7+,1. , &$1 $&78$//< 029( 21 352%$%/< 7+( &2857 05 %2,(6 :( $5( *2,1* 72 1((' 72 7$.( $ %5($. 9(5< 6+257/< /(7 86 .12: :+(1 <28 $5( $7 $ *22' 32,17 05 %$55< , $0 $7 $ &219(1,(17 32,17 <285 +2125 7+( &2857 5,*+7 12:" /$',(6 $1' *(17/(0(1 <28 $5( (;&86(' )25 0,187(6 5(&(66 7$.(1 $7 30 352&((',1*6 5(680(' $7 30 7+( &/(5. 3/($6( %( 6($7(' $1' &20( 72 25'(5 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 /(7 6 5(680( ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 5,6. 7+$7 7202552:12: 0,*+7 127 )2//2: 7+( &23<5,*+7 /$:6 $1' 7+$7 7+(< :(5( 127 '2,1* 7+,6 ,1 $1 $'(48$7( :$< $1' :( ',' (9(5<7+,1* 3266,%/( ,1 25'(5 72 +$9( 7+(0 )2//2: 7+( &255(&7 352&('85( $1' 7+( 5(63(&7 2) 7+( &23<5,*+7 /$:6 4 :(// 6,5 <28 6$,' <28 ',' (9(5<7+,1* 3266,%/( 12 21( ,162)$5 $6 <28 $5( $:$5( (9(5 *$9( 7+(0 $1< :5,77(1 ,16758&7,216 72 6723 ,1)5,1*,1* &255(&7" $ 12 $// , 6$,' :$6 7+$7 , ','1 7 6(( 7+,6 :5,77(1 &20081,&$7,21 4 127 21/< +$9( <28 127 6((1 7+( :5,77(1 &20081,&$7,21 %87 <28 '21 7 .12: $1<%2'< :+2 +$6 (9(5 6((1 7+$7 :5,77(1 &20081,&$7,21 &255(&7 6,5" $ , &$1127 1$0( $1<%2'< 72'$< 4 2.$< 62 ,162)$5 $6 <28 .12: 7+(5( :$6 12 :5,77(1 &20081,&$7,21 &255(&7" $ 12 , '2 127 &20( 72 7+$7 &21&/86,21 $7 $// 4 :(// /(7 6 6(( <28 9( 1(9(5 6((1 $ :5,77(1 &20081,&$7,21 &255(&7" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 <28 '21 7 .12: 2) $1<%2'< :+2 +$6 6((1 $ :5,77(1 &20081,&$7,21 &255(&7" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 12 21( +$6 (9(5 72/' <28 7+$7 7+(< 6$: $ :5,77(1 &20081,&$7,21 &255(&7" $ &255(&7 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 05 %2,(6 7+$1. <28 <285 +2125 %< 05 %2,(6 4 05 %5$1'7 7+( 6$3 %2$5' :$6 ,1)250(' 7+$7 7+(5( :$6 68%67$17,$/ /(*$/ ,668(6 :,7+ 5(63(&7 72 7202552:12: 6 6(59,&( '(/,9(5< 352&(66(6 &255(&7" $ $7 :+$7 7,0(" 4 ,1 -$18$5< 2) :+(1 <28 '(&,'(' 72 *2 )25:$5' $ 72 $&48,5( 7+( &203$1<" 4 <(6 $ 2.$< :( .1(: 7+$7 $ 5,6. (;,67(' $1' 81'(5722. 7+( 1(&(66$5< 67(36 72 0,7,*$7( 7+( 5,6. 4 :(// 6,5 <28 6$< <28 722. 7+( 1(&(66$5< 67(36 :( +$9( 7$/.(' $%287 7+$7 %87 <28 .1(: 7+$7 7+(5( :$6 $ 6(5,286 /(*$/ ,668( *2,1* )25:$5' $1' <28 '(&,'(' 72 $&48,5( 7+( &203$1< $1<:$< &255(&7" $ :,7+ $// '8( 5(63(&7 :( ',' 6(( 7+( /(*$/ ,668(6 ,192/9(' $1' $7 7+( 7,0( 2) 7+( '(&,6,21 2) 7+( $&48,6,7,21 $7 7+( 7,0( 2) 7+( '(&,6,21 0$.,1* :( :(5( 5($'< 72 $&&(37 7+( 5,6. +2:(9(5 :,7+ 7+( '(7(50,1$7,21 72 0,7,*$7( 7+( 5,6. 4 :(// 6,5 /(7 0( -867 $6. <28 72 /22. $7 7:2 7+,1*6 ),567 (;+,%,7 :+,&+ ,6 7+( %86,1(66 &$6( $ ,6 ,7 ,1 0< %,1'(5" 4 7$% $ (1*/,6+ " ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 4 - November 5, 2010
%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 4 ,7 ,6 (;+,%,7 %87 ,7 ,6 %(+,1' 7$% $ <(6 4 $1' 7+,6 ,6 $ '2&80(17 7+$7 <28 5(&(,9(' $5281' -$18$5< 7+ 2) &255(&7 6,5" $ <(6 4 $1' ,) :( *2 72 7+( 180%(5(' 3$*( 81'(5 7+5($76" $ (1*/,6+ <(6 4 7+( ),567 7+5($7 ,6 7+( $&&(66 5,*+76 72 7+( 3(23/(62)7 62)7:$5( ,6 9(5< /,.(/< 72 %( &+$//(1*(' %< 25$&/( $1' 3$67 23(5$7,1* ,668(6 0$< %( $ 6(5,286 /,$%,/,7< ,) 25$&/( &+$//(1*(6 '2 <28 6(( 7+$7" $ (1*/,6+ <(6 4 7+$7 ,6 :+$7 <28 :(5( 72/' $7 7+( 7,0( &255(&7" $ &255(&7 4 $1' <28 %(/,(9(' 7+$7 $7 7+( 7,0( &255(&7" $ <(6 4 $1' /(7 0( 6+2: <28 <285 '(326,7,21 $7 3$*( $1' $7 /,1( 67$57,1* $7 /,1( $1' *2,1* 72 /,1( 21 7+( 1(;7 3$*( '2 <28 +$9( 7+$7" $ (1*/,6+ :+(5( ,6 7+,6 ,1 0< %,1'(5" :,71(66 7+528*+ ,17(535(7(5 :+(5( ,6 ,7 ,1 0< %,1'(5" ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'& %5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 7$% $ (1*/,6+ 7$% " 4 7$% (;+,%,7 ',63/$<(' 21 6&5((1 $1' 7+,6 ,6 $ 35(6(17$7,21 72 $ 0((7,1* ,1 2) 7+( ),1$1&( $1' ,19(670(17 &200,77(( &255(&7 6,5" 3/$,17,))6 (;+,%,7 5(&(,9(' ,1 (9,'(1&( 7+( :,71(66 <(6 %< 05 %2,(6 4 $1' <28 $77(1'(' 7+,6 0((7,1* ',' <28 127 6,5" $ <(6 4 $1' ,) <28 7851 72 7+( )2857+ 3$*( (;+,%,7 ',63/$<(' 21 6&5((1 :+(5( ,7 ,6 /,67,1* 7+( $&48,6,7,216 ,1 " $ <(6 , 6(( 7+( /,67 4 $1' <28 6(( 7+( /,67 )25 7202552:12:" 05 %2,(6 0$<%( :( &$1 %/2: 7+$7 83 %< 05 %2,(6 4 7+,6 ,6 $ /,67 2) 7+( (03/2<((6 $7 7202552:12: &255(&7" $ , 6(( 7+( /,1( 7202552:12: 4 $1' ,7 6$<6 7+$7 7202552:12: +$6 (03/2<((6 '2 <28 6(( 7+$7" $ , 6(( ,7 4 $1' <28 .1(: 7+$7 7202552:12: :$6 3529,',1* ),;(6 $1' ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 %(+,1' 7+( 7$% 7+$7 6$<6 75$16&5,37 (1*/,6+ <(6 $1' <28 6(( :+(5( :( 6$< 7+$7 21 :+$7 3$*(" 3$*( /,1( /(7 0( .12: :+(1 <28 +$9( ,7 3$86( ,1 7+( 352&((',1*6 $ $// 5,*+7 4 5($',1* 48(67,21 ,1 7+( (1' 6$3 :(17 )25:$5' :,7+ 7+( 7202552:12: $&48,6,7,21 81'(567$1',1* 7+$7 7+(5( :(5( ,1 )$&7 327(17,$/ /(*$/ ,668(6 &211(&7(' :,7+ 7202552:12: 6 6(59,&( '(/,9(5< 352&(66" $1' <285 $16:(5 ,6 &28/' %( 127 :(5( 48(67,21 029,1* )25:$5' :,7+ 7+( 81'(567$1',1* 7+$7 7+(5( &28/' %( 68%67$17,$/ /(*$/ ,668(6 :,7+ 7202552:12: 6 6(59,&( '(/,9(5< 352&(66(6 &255(&7" $16:(5 <(6 $1' <28 *$9( 7+$7 7(67,021<" $ (1*/,6+ <($+ 4 $1' 7+( 62/87,21 :$6 72 /($9( 7+( 7(;$6 &25325$7,21 ,1 (;,67(1&( $6 $ /,$%,/,7< 6+,(/' &255(&7" $ 12 7+$7 :$6 127 7+( 62/87,21 4 /(7 0( $6. <28 72 /22. $7 (;+,%,7 7+$7 ,6 %(+,1' ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'& 4 $ 4 $ 4

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 3$7&+(6 )25 3(23/(62)7 62)7:$5( &255(&7" $ <(6 4 $1' <28 .1(: 7+$7 7+$7 &28/'1 7 +$33(1 :,7+287 3(23/( '2,1* 5(6($5&+ $1' '(9(/230(17 :25. &255(&7 6,5" $ , ',' 127 .12: 7+$7 4 <28 ',' 127 .12: 7+$7" $ (1*/,6+ 12 4 ),567 <28 +$' 12 5(6($5&+ $1' '(9(/230(17 3(23/( 5,*+7" $ 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 %87 7+(< +$9( 6(59,&( (03/2<((6 4 $1' ',' <28 7+,1. 7+( 6(59,&( (03/2<((6 :(5( 7+( 3(23/( :+2 :(5( '2,1* 7+( 62)7:$5( '(9(/230(17 6,5" ,6 7+$7 <285 7(67,021<" $ 12 7+$7 ,6 127 :+$7 , 7+28*+7 4 2.$< , ','1 7 7+,1. 62 <28 .12: 7+$7 7+( .,1' 2) :25. 7+$7 6 5(48,5(' 72 35(3$5( 7+( .,1' 2) 62)7:$5( 7+$7 <28 1((' 72 '2 0$,17(1$1&( $1' 6833257 :25. ,6 7+( .,1' 2) :25. 7+$7 5(48,5(6 620( 5(6($5&+ $1' '(9(/230(17 3(23/( &255(&7" $ , $0 127 $1 (;3(57 ,1 7+( ),(/' +2:(9(5 , %(/,(9( ,7 ,6 3266,%/( 7+$7 7+,6 &$1 $/62 %( '21( %< 7+( 6(59,&( (03/2<((6 4 ',' <28 (9(5 ,148,5( 2) $1<%2'< $6 72 +2: ,1 7+( :25/' 3(23/(62)7 6833257 :$6 %(,1* 35(3$5(' $1' 3$7&+(6 $1' ),;(6 )25 &203/,&$7(' 62)7:$5( :$6 %(,1* 35(3$5(' :,7+287 $1< 5 ' (03/2<((6" ',' <28 (9(5 $6. $1<%2'< 7+$7 6,5" $ 12 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 4 - November 5, 2010
SHEET 11

%5$1'7 ',5(&7 05 %2,(6 4 7+(5( &$0( $ 32,17 :+(1 25$&/( $&48,5(' 6,(%(/ &255(&7" $ <(6 4 $1' 6$3 7+(1 $87+25,=(' 7202552:12: 72 6(59,&( 6,(%(/ $33/,&$7,216 &255(&7" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $1' $7 7+$7 7,0( 7202552:12: ','1 7 +$9( $1< 3(23/( $7 $// :+2 +$' $1< (;3(5,(1&( :,7+ 6,(%(/ 62)7:$5( &255(&7" $ 7+,6 0$< %( 758( 4 $1' ',' <28 +$9( $1< 81'(567$1',1* $7 $// $6 72 +2: 7202552:12: &28/' 6833257 6,(%(/ &86720(56 ,167$//$7,216 :,7+287 $1< 3(23/( :+2 :(5( (;3(57 ,1 6,(%(/ 62)7:$5( :,7+287 6,03/< ,1)5,1*,1* 7+( &23<5,*+76" $ $7 7+$7 7,0( , :$6 81'(5 7+( $668037,21 7+$7 7+( 23(5$7,21 352&('85(6 +$' %((1 ,03/(0(17(' $7 7202552:12: $1' 7+$7 :28/' +$9( 0($17 7+$7 ,7 :28/' +$9( %((1 1(&(66$5< 72 (03/2< 3(23/( :+2 +$' 6,(%(/ (;3(57,6( 4 :(5( $1< 2) 7+26( 3(23/( (9(5 (03/2<(' 6,5" $ , '21 7 .12: 4 ',' <28 (9(5 &+(&." $ 12 4 '2 <28 .12: ,) $1<21( (/6( )520 6$3 (9(5 &+(&.('" $ , &28/' 127 $16:(5 7+$7 48(67,21 , '21 7 .12: 4 ,7 :28/' +$9( %((1 9(5< ($6< 72 &+(&. :28/' ,7 127" <28 6,03/< :28/' +$9( +$' 72 &$// 83 <285 :+2//< 2:1(' 68%6,',$5< $1' $6. 7+(0 &255(&7" ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 &5266 05 /$1,(5 0,187(6 6,5 :( 9( 6((1 7+( %86,1(66 &$6( $1' , $0 *2,1* 72 7$/. $%287 620( 7+,1*6 7+$7 +$33(1(' $)7(5 7+$7 '2 <28 5(&$// :+(7+(5 <28 5(&(,9(' $1< 025( ,1)250$7,21 $%287 +2: 7202552:12: :25.(' $)7(5 7+,6 -$18$5< %86,1(66 &$6(" 7+( ,17(535(7(5 21 7+( 7+ 2) -$18$5<" 05 /$1,(5 $)7(5 7+( :,71(66 &$1 <28 3/($6( 5(3($7 7+( 48(67,21" %< 05 /$1,(5 4 <28 5(&$// +$9,1* 6((1 7+( %86,1(66 &$6( '2&80(17 5,*+7" $ <(6 4 $)7(5 7+$7 '2&80(17 ',' <28 (9(5 5(&(,9( 025( ,1)250$7,21 $%287 +2: 7202552:12: :25.(' %()25( &21&/8',1* 7+( $&48,6,7,21" $ 6(9(5$/ $'',7,21$/ 3,(&(6 2) ,1)250$7,21 :(5( (;&+$1*(' $)7(5 7+$7 %87 , '21 7 5(&$// $1<7+,1* 63(&,),& 25 ,1 3$57,&8/$5 $%287 7+(,5 %86,1(66 02'(/ 4 /(7 6 /22. $7 21( 2) 7+26( 3,(&(6 2) ,1)250$7,21 :28/' <28 7851 72 7$% ,1 7+$7 6$0( %,1'(5 <28 $/5($'< +$9( $1' 7+$7 6 '()(1'$176 (;+,%,7 $ (1*/,6+ <($+ 05 /$1,(5 <285 +2125 7+,6 +$6 127 <(7 %((1 67,38/$7(' ,1 62 , $0 *2,1* 72 $6. $ )(: 35(/,0,1$5< 48(67,216 %< 05 /$1,(5 4 05 %5$1'7 '2 <28 5(&$// 6((,1* 7+,6 ( 0$,/" $ 7+,6 ,6 7+( ( 0$,/ %< -,0 0$&.(< '$7(' -$18$5< 7+ ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 &5266 05 /$1,(5 $ ,7 6 127 7+( 7$6. 2) 7+( &)2 72 0$.( 7+$7 3+21( &$// 4 %87 ,6 ,7 7+( 7$6. 2) $ 0(0%(5 2) 7+( %2$5' 72 %( 685( 620(%2'< 0$.(6 7+( 3+21( &$//" $ , $*5(( :,7+ 7+$7 05 %2,(6 , +$9( 12 025( 48(67,216 7+( &2857 '2 <28 :,6+ 72 (;$0,1( $7 7+,6 7,0(" 05 /$1,(5 <(6 <285 +2125 7+( &2857 +( 6 21 <285 /,67 $6 :(// 05 /$1,(5 :( 0$< :$1'(5 $ /,77/( %(<21' %87 127 722 08&+ 7+( &2857 2.$< &5266 (;$0,1$7,21 %< 05 /$1,(5 4 *22' $)7(51221 05 %5$1'7 $ (1*/,6+ +(//2 4 :( /($51(' $ /,77/( $%287 <285 %$&.*5281' , -867 :$17(' 72 /($51 $ &283/( 025( 7+,1*6 :+(5( :(5( <28 %251 6,5" $ ,1 *(50$1< 4 :+(1 <28 :(5( 5$,6(' :(5( <28 5$,6(' 63($.,1* (1*/,6+" $ 12 4 $5( <28 3(5621$//< &20)257$%/( :,7+ $0(5,&$1 /(*$/ 7(50,12/2*< ,1 (1*/,6+" $ 12 4 /(7 6 7$/. $%287 7+( 7202552:12: $&48,6,7,21 )25 $ )(: ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 &5266 05 /$1,(5 4 $1' ',' <28 5($' ,7 :+(1 <28 *27 ,7 25 620(:+(5( $5281' 7+(1" $ 2) &2856( 4 $1' :$6 7+( ,1)250$7,21 &217$,1(' ,1 7+,6 ( 0$,/ 3$57 2) :+$7 :$6 ,1 <285 0,1' :+(1 <28 0$'( 7+( '(&,6,21 72 %8< 7202552:12:" $ 0$< , 5($' 7+528*+ ,7 ),567" 4 2) &2856( $ <(6 4 $1' :$6 7+,6 ,1)250$7,21 3$57 2) :+$7 <28 5(/,(' 21 ,1 <285 2:1 '(&,6,21 :+(7+(5 72 $33529( 7+( $&48,6,7,21 2) 7202552:12:" $ (1*/,6+ $%62/87(/< 05 /$1,(5 <285 +2125 :( 029( $'0,66,21 2) '()(1'$176 $ " 7+( &2857 $1< 2%-(&7,21 05 %2,(6 <(6 <285 +2125 %27+ +($56$< $1' $1 ,1&203/(7( '2&80(17 05 /$1,(5 <285 +2125 ,7 :$6 5('$&7(' )25 35,9,/(*( 5($6216 $1' ,7 6 $'0,66,%/( 81'(5 ,7 *2(6 72 67$7( 2) 0,1' 7+,6 &$6( ,6 $33$5(17/< $%287 7+(,5 67$7( 2) 0,1' :+(1 7+(< 0$'( 7+( '(&,6,21 72 385&+$6( 7202552:12: 7+( &2857 , $0 *2,1* 72 $//2: ,7 &2816(/ 05 %2,(6 &$1 , +$9( 21( 020(17" , $&&(37 :+$7 7+( &2857 $//2:6 21 +($56$< %87 21 ,1&203/(7( '2&80(17 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 4 - November 5, 2010
%5$1'7 &5266 05 /$1,(5 $/7+28*+ :( '21 7 2%-(&7 72 7+(0 5('$&7,1* )25 35,9,/(*( 7+(< &$1 7 $)),50$7,9(/< 86( $ 3$57,$/ '2&80(17 , :28/' 68**(67 72 7+( &2857 7+( &2857 7+( 5('$&7(' 3257,21 ,6 $ 6(17(1&( 25 7:2 $7 7+( %27720" 05 /$1,(5 7+$7 6 &255(&7 <285 +2125 7+( &2857 $1' <28 6$< 7+$7 6 %$6(' 21 $77251(< &/,(17 35,9,/(*(" 05 /$1,(5 $%62/87(/< 7+( &2857 , 0 *2,1* 72 $//2: 7+(0 72 86( ,7 ,7 6 $'0,77(' 05 /$1,(5 7+$1. <28 '()(1'$176 (;+,%,7 $ 5(&(,9(' ,1 (9,'(1&( 05 /$1,(5 387 83 &$1 :( %/2: 83 7+( ( 0$,/" (;+,%,7 ',63/$<(' 21 6&5((1 %< 05 /$1,(5 4 05 0$&.(< $*$,1 :+2 :$6 +(" $ (1*/,6+ +( :$6 $ 0(0%(5 2) 0< 0$1$*(0(17 7($0 6255< :,71(66 7+528*+ ,17(535(7(5 +( :$6 $ 0(0%(5 2) 0< 0$1$*(0(17 7($0 +( :$6 $ 0(0%(5 2) 0< 0$1$*(0(17 7($0 $1' +,6 5(63216,%,/,7< :$6 0 $ $1' (;(&87,21 0 $ (;(&87,21 4 62 05 %5$1'7 , :,// ',9(57 )25 $ 6(&21' ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'& %5$1'7 &5266 05 /$1,(5 $ <(6 4 3/($6( '(6&5,%( 7+26( 67(36 $ )25 86 ),567 2) $// ,7 :$6 9(5< ,03257$17 7+$7 12 6$3 '(9(/23(56 25 6833257 7($0 0(0%(56 2) 6$3 7+$7 7+(6( 6$3 '(9(/23(56 $1' 6833257 67$)) :28/' 1(9(5 +$9( $&&(66 72 ,1)250$7,21 :+,&+ :$6 1(&(66$5< )25 7+( (03/2<((6 2) 7202552:12: 72 3(5)250 7+(,5 6833257 $1' 6(59,&( 6(59,&(6 4 $5( <28 '21( 6,5" $ ,1 $'',7,21 :( $/62 ,668(' &(57$,1 58/(6 2) (1*$*(0(17 $1' 7+(6( 5()(55(' 0$,1/< 72 7+( *2 72 0$5.(7 6,'( 4 05 %5$1'7 , :28/' $6. <28 72 7851 72 7$% ,1 7+( %,1'(5 7+$7 ,6 ,1 )5217 2) <28 $*$,1 67$<,1* :,7+ 7+( %,1'(5 <28 9( *27 %()25( 7+$7 6 '()(1'$176 (;+,%,7 (;+,%,7 ',63/$<(' 21 6&5((1 $ <(6 , +$9( 7+,6 ,1 )5217 2) 0( 4 12: 05 %5$1'7 '2 <28 5(&2*1,=( 7+,6 '2&80(17 $6 7+( 58/(6 2) (1*$*(0(17 <28 -867 0(17,21('" $ <(6 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 $1' 7+(6( 58/(6 2) (1*$*(0(17 +$9( %((1 &20081,&$7(' 72 $// 7202552:12: (03/2<((6 ,1 :5,77(1 )250 05 /$1,(5 $1' 7+$7 6 $&78$//< 7+( :521* '2&80(17 21 7+( 6&5((1 '21 7 387 7+( 1(;7 21( 83 <(7 %(&$86( , '21 7 .12: ,) 7+,6 +$6 %((1 '21( :( :28/' 029( $'0,66,21 2) '()(1'$176 $ 7+( &2857 :+(5( '2 , ),1' 7+$7" ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 &5266 05 /$1,(5 , 127,&( <28 2%9,286/< '2 63($. (1*/,6+ &255(&7" $ <(6 , '2 4 $1' 29(5 7+( <($56 <28 $1' , +$9( 7$/.(' $ /27 2) 7,0(6 5,*+7" $ &255(&7 4 :,7+287 6$<,1* $1<7+,1* 7+$7 :( +$9( 7$/.(' $%287 +$9( :( 127 2856(/9(6 %(7:((1 86 1(('(' $ 75$16/$7,21 2&&$6,21$//< 72 0$.( 685( :( &20081,&$7(" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 <(6 0< %86,1(66 (1*/,6+ , %(/,(9( ,6 2.$< +2:(9(5 0< 7(50,12/2*< $1' .12:/('*( 2) (1*/,6+ ,6 127 (128*+ )25 /(*$/ 352&((',1*6 4 7+$1. <28 6,5 62 12: 7851,1* %$&. 72 , :21 7 5($' 7+528*+ $// 2) 7+( 6(17(1&(6 12: ,7 6 /$7( ,7 6 )5,'$< $1' :( &$1 7$/. $%287 7+,6 '2&80(17 /$7(5 %87 , -867 :$17 72 &21),50 7+$7 7+( :$6 7+( ,1)250$7,21 7+$7 6 ,1 +(5( 3$57 2) :+$7 :$6 ,1 <285 0,1' :+(1 <28 0$'( 7+( '(&,6,21 72 %8< 7202552:12:" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 7+$1. <28 6,5 <28 &$1 387 7+$7 $:$< 12: 7+(5( :$6 $ /27 2) ',6&866,21 :,7+ 05 %2,(6 $%287 0,7,*$7,21 '2 <28 5(&$// 7+$7 *(1(5$//<" $ <(6 2) &2856( 4 :+(1 <28 $33529(' $6 $ %2$5' 0(0%(5 7+( $&48,6,7,21 2) 7202552:12: :(5( <28 $:$5( 2) $1< 67(36 7+$7 :(5( 7$.(1 72 0,7,*$7( 5,6.6 7+$7 +$' %((1 ,'(17,),(' $%287 7202552:12:" ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 &5266 05 /$1,(5 05 /$1,(5 ,7 6+28/' %( ,1 7$% 2) +,6 %,1'(5 , 0,*+7 +$9( *27 7+( :521* 7$% ,7 6 $1 ( 0$,/ <285 +2125 7+( &2857 ,6 ,7 3/$,17,))6 '(326,7,21 (;+,%,7 7+$7 +$6 %((1 5(0$5.(' 05 /$1,(5 <(6 $1' ,7 ,6 $/62 $ :,7+ 7+( 75,$/ 180%(5 7+( &2857 2.$< 05 /$1,(5 :( 029( $'0,66,21 2) $ 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 ,6 7+(5( $1< 2%-(&7,21" 05 %2,(6 ,6 7+,6 3/$,17,))6 (;+,%,7 " 05 /$1,(5 7+(5( 6 352%$%/< 025( 7+$1 21( &23< , -867 +$33(1 72 +$9( '()(1'$176 05 0,77(/67$('7 7+( $16:(5 ,6 <(6 05 %2,(6 12 2%-(&7,21 7+( &2857 ,7 6 21( ,1 7+( 6$0( :( :,// &$// ,7 %27+ $ $1' '()(1'$176 (;+,%,7 $ 5(&(,9(' ,1 (9,'(1&( %< 05 /$1,(5 4 '()(1'$176 12: $*$,1 :( $5( 127 *2,1* 72 *2 7+528*+ 7+,6 7+(5( $5( 0$1< 3$*(6 7+(5( :,// %( 27+(5 :,71(66(6 :+2 &$1 7$/. $%287 ,7 :28/' <28 &21),50 )25 7+( -85< 7+$7 7+,6 ( 0$,/ &217$,16 :+$7 <28 5()(5 72 $6 7+( 58/(6 2) (1*$*(0(17" ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 4 - November 5, 2010
SHEET 12

$ <(6 4 7+$1. <28 :( &$1 387 7+$7 '2:1 7+(5( :$6 $/62 620( ',6&866,21 :,7+ &2816(/ $%287 ',5(&7,216 *,9(1 72 &+$1*( 7202552:12: 6 23(5$7,1* 352&('85(6 '2 <28 5(&$// 7+$7" $ <(6 4 $1' <28 (9(1 5(&$// 620( ',6&866,21 $%287 :+(7+(5 ,7 :$6 ,1 :5,7,1* 25 127" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 :28/' <28 7(// 7+( -85< :+$7 :$6 7+$7 ',5(&7,21 )520 7+( %2$5'" $ &$1 <28 3/($6( %( 025( 35(&,6( :,7+ <285 48(67,21" 4 2) &2856( <28 +$' $ /27 2) &219(56$7,21 $%287 :+(7+(5 620( ',5(&7,21 :$6 ,1 :5,7,1* $ (1*/,6+ <($+ 4 7+( 48(67,21 ,6 :+(7+(5 ,7 :$6 ,1 :5,7,1* 25 127 :+$7 :$6 7+( %2$5' 6 *8,'$1&( <28 +$' %((1 7$/.,1* $%287" :+$7 :$6 7+( 0(66$*( '(/,9(5('" $ ,1 5(/$7,21 72 7+( 23(5$7,1* 352&('85(6 4 '2 <28 5(&$// 025( 63(&,),&$//< :+$7 7+( *8,'$1&( :$6 +2: 72 &+$1*( 7+26( 352&('85(6" $ ,1 '(7$,/ :,7+ 5(*$5'6 72 7+( 63(&,),& 67(36 12 4 '2 <28 5(&$// :+(7+(5 ,1 7+( %2$5' *$9( 63(&,),& ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 &5266 05 /$1,(5 (;+,%,7 ',63/$<(' 21 6&5((1

%5$1'7 &5266 05 /$1,(5 4 :( 63(17 $ /27 2) 7,0( $1' :( :,// -867 %( %5,() '2 <28 6(( $7 7+( 723 :+(5( ,7 6$<6 &219(57 $3352;,0$7(/< 3(5&(17 2) 7+( 3(23/(62)7 $1' - ' (':$5'6 $1' ,7 *2(6 21" $ (1*/,6+ <(6 :,71(66 7+528*+ ,17(535(7(5 <(6 4 $7 7+( 7,0( <28 :(5( $33529,1* 7+( 7202552:12: $&48,6,7,21 ',' <28 $&78$//< (;3(&7 72 )8/),// 7+$7 *2$/" $ 3(5621$//< (63(&,$//< %(&$86( 2) 0< 326,7,21 $6 $ ),1$1&( &)2 , $0 9(5< &5,7,&$/ :+(1 , 6(( 3,(&(6 2) ,1)250$7,21 /,.( 7+,6 $1' , $/:$<6 48(67,21 ,1)250$7,21 7+$7 &20(6 )520 7+( 0$5.(7,1* '(3$570(17 , 7+,1. 7+$7 7+,6 *2$/ :$6 5($//< +$5' 72 +,'( $1' 7+( 5($/,7< ,1'((' 3529(' 7+$7 :,7+ 7202552:12: :( 21/< +$' &86720(56 4 $// 5,*+7 :( $5( '21( :,7+ 7+$7 21( 7+$1. <28 6,5 :( 9( $/62 6((1 $ /27 '85,1* 7+( 75,$/ $%287 $ %86,1(66 23325781,7< 6/,'( $1' , $0 *2,1* 72 $6. <28 72 /22. $7 7$% 2) <285 %,1'(5 ,7 6 3/$,17,))6 ,7 ,6 $/5($'< ,1 (9,'(1&( $1' ,7 ,6 7+( 7+ 3$*( 2) 7+( '2&80(17 05 /$1,(5 ,) <28 &$1 387 7+$7 83 0$<%( %/2: 83 7+$7 723 3$57 (;+,%,7 ',63/$<(' 21 6&5((1 7+( :,71(66 (1*/,6+ <($+ ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 &5266 05 /$1,(5 ',5(&7,21 7+$7 3(23/(62)7 62)7:$5( 6+28/' 127 %( 21 7202552:12: 6 &20387(56" 05 %2,(6 2%-(&7,21 /($',1* <285 +2125 7+( &2857 ,7 ,6 %87 , $0 *2,1* 72 3(50,7 ,7 $1<:$< 7+( :,71(66 $%62/87(/< %< 05 /$1,(5 4 :$6 ,7 <285 %(/,() 83 817,/ 7+( 7,0( 2) 7+,6 /$:68,7 7+$7 7+$7 ',5(&7,21 +$' %((1 )2//2:('" 06 +286( 2%-(&7,21 <285 +2125 7+( &2857 29(558/(' 7+( :,71(66 $%62/87(/< $1' , 7+28*+7 , +$' $/5($'< $16:(5(' ,7 7+,6 :$< ,1 7+( 35(9,286 48(67,21,1* %< 05 /$1,(5 4 7+$1. <28 /(7 6 7851 72 620( 27+(5 723,&6 )25 -867 $ )(: 0,187(6 620( 180%(56 $1' 7+,1*6 <28 63(17 $ /27 2) 7,0( 21 3/$,17,))6 (;+,%,7 7+$7 ,6 ,1 7$% 2) <285 %,1'(5 05 /$1,(5 ,) :( &$1 387 83 7+( 6,;7+ 3$*( 7+( 21( 7+$7 6$<6 7+( *2$/ (;+,%,7 ',63/$<(' 21 6&5((1 %< 05 /$1,(5 4 7+(5( :( *2 $ (1*/,6+ <($+ ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

%5$1'7 &5266 05 /$1,(5 %< 05 /$1,(5 4 6,5 %()25( 7+,6 /,7,*$7,21 +$' <28 6((1 7+,6 6/,'( 25 7+,6 35(6(17$7,21" $ <(6 , +$9( 6((1 7+,6 6/,'( %()25( 7+( 75,$/ 4 $1' '85,1* 7+( 7,0( <28 :(5( 0$.,1* 7+( '(&,6,21 72 %8< 7202552:12: ',' <28 %(/,(9( 7+$7 ,7 :28/' &2175,%87( 0,//,21 72 6$3" $ 12 4 ',' <28 5(/< ,1 $1< :$< 21 7+,6 7<3( 2) 352-(&7,21 ,1 7+( '(&,6,21 72 %8< 7202552:12:" $ 127 $7 $// ,1 7+( %86,1(66 &$6( :( (67$%/,6+(' 67$1' $/21( $66(660(17 2) $%287 0,//,21 $1' 7+,6 7+( 9$/8( $1' 7+,6 +$6 127+,1* ,7 '2(61 7 &203$5( ,1 $1< :$< 4 62 /(7 6 /22. $7 7+( %86,1(66 &$6( ,7 6 3/$,17,))6 (;+,%,7 :+,&+ ,6 $/62 ,1 (9,'(1&( ,7 6 ,1 7$% $1' , 7+,1. ,7 6 6/,'( ),9( ,7 6 7+( 6/,'( 7+$7 ,6 7,7/(' 9$/8$7,21 29(59,(: $ ,6 ,7 7$% " 4 ,7 6 7$% $ (1*/,6+ 6255< 4 ,7 6 (;+,%,7 180%(5 (;+,%,7 ',63/$<(' 21 6&5((1 05 /$1,(5 7+$7 6 ,7 7+$1. <28 7+( :,71(66 (1*/,6+ 6255< , +$9( ,7 12: <($+ ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR