Oracle Corporation et al v. SAP AG et al

Filing 1058

Declaration of Lisa Chin in Support of 1057 Opposition/Response to Motion for JMOL or New Trial filed byOracle International Corporation. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A part 1, # 2 Exhibit A part 2, # 3 Exhibit B, # 4 Exhibit C, # 5 Exhibit D, # 6 Exhibit E, # 7 Exhibit F, # 8 Exhibit G, # 9 Exhibit H, # 10 Exhibit I, # 11 Exhibit J, # 12 Exhibit K, # 13 Exhibit L, # 14 Exhibit M, # 15 Exhibit N, # 16 Exhibit O, # 17 Exhibit P, # 18 Exhibit Q, # 19 Exhibit R, # 20 Exhibit S, # 21 Exhibit T, # 22 Exhibit U, # 23 Exhibit V, # 24 Exhibit W, # 25 Exhibit X, # 26 Exhibit Y, # 27 Exhibit Z, # 28 Exhibit AA, # 29 Exhibit BB, # 30 Exhibit CC, # 31 Exhibit DD, # 32 Exhibit EE, # 33 Exhibit FF, # 34 Exhibit GG, # 35 Exhibit HH, # 36 Exhibit II, # 37 Exhibit JJ, # 38 Exhibit KK, # 39 Exhibit LL, # 40 Exhibit MM, # 41 Exhibit NN, # 42 Exhibit OO, # 43 Exhibit PP, # 44 Exhibit QQ, # 45 Exhibit RR, # 46 Exhibit SS, # 47 Exhibit TT, # 48 Exhibit UU, # 49 Exhibit VV)(Related document(s) 1057 ) (Howard, Geoffrey) (Filed on 4/8/2011)

Oracle Corporation et al v. SAP AG et al

Doc. 1058 Att. 3

EXHIBIT B
Dockets.Justia.com

! # $ #
!

&, # # " # 7 # # # $ # # # # ! # " ! $ " +& % & '
!!

!

! " +& , & %& &

% & '()*

! .

! " / (' 4 0 0 4 4 5 8 " (' 0 0 & 6 5 ' 2 6 0 5 2 2 / 2 6 0 ('

+& -

1( 2 3 4 5 2 0 5 & & ! ! " 2 !! 8 ! ! " &1

" 6 4 "5

"

+& 9 2 5 0 : &+& !! 4 '8 & 0 & & ! ' &( +& % & . ! 8 & & ! . 5 2 . 3 . # & "5 2

5 6 5: & &

2

5

2 3 4

! " 5 4 2 2& ( 2 % 2 & ! " 5 < 8 6 ( 2 3& ( 2 <

"

"

" 7 " # " $ " " " ! " " "
!

+& ;

!! . !! 4 &

"

+& ;

! " / 2 3

7 29 2 2 < 2

"

" " "

+& 3

'

= =

7'%

'

4

" " ! " " ! " " " " " " " " " " " " " 7 " # " $ " ! "" $ "" "" ! "" "" "" "
!

7 # & $ +& 0 3

8 & ! 4 ! ! " 2 8 ! " 9 2 5 !! 4 4 0 6 2 4 & > 2 6 6 2 4 +& & ( !! ( ! 0 ! " 3 2 0 & ( ! ' 4 & 2 2 35 4 < &9 5 5 0 5 3 & +& &; < !! 2 % < 4 2 4 0
' 4

0

"

"

" ( !! & < 0 2 .0 !! 4 6 < 6 2 2 2 2 / 4 2 4 (3 7 6 29 28 5 & 7 6 8 . 3 2& # 8 5 !! 56 8 6 3 . A 0 ! !0 2 2 < 2 ! 58 3 2 #
? @

> ;( 9 < 2 4 2 52

.

2 5 0 2 & 4 2 / 2 2 4 & 0 5

5 4 0 5

2 54

29 2 2& ""

!

! " .

4

0

+& 5 &(

29 2

!! 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 " 7 # $ <

! "

&+&

. 3 0

2 2 45

'

= =

#'%

7 7 7 7 7 7 " 7
!!

& 2 . 2 2

2 .0 52 2 4 +& ; &9 & ! < ! " . 54 ) & & ! ! " 8 42 44

6

4 5 6 4 6 4 0

!! 4 5 3

2 &

5 2 58

!!! 77 77 77 77 77

" / ' 6 5 4' 6 4 2 5 &

!

! 7 7 7 7 7 7 " # # # # # " # 7 # # # $ # # # # # # # # # ! # # # # " # ! " 7 # +& &

" 2 0 2 2 & ) 4 '& ) / 4 4 8 29 2 0 5 4 ' 4 2< 5 2 A 6 0 54 45 52 6 5 & 7 5 '2 4 0 42 6 29 2 0 ' 4 ' 7 8 4 '& 4 ' & 0 5 & 5 & 8 5/ ' 8 2 4

$ ""

+& C D&& &+& &+& E 0 & & 2

29 2 3

5 !! (. &+& & 2

&+&

& 5 2 /

& (. ! ! " 0 54 D&& 2 8 ! ! "

# "

+& 5

#

7

# "

'

= =

#'%

'

4

# # # " # 7 # # # $ # ! # # # # #

4 '

> ;( 9 6 42 ' & & ( . !! 2 29 2 4 $ +& 44 8 &; ! ! " '& ! ! " 6 5 29 2 2 4 ' .

E

5 6 4 5 & (. 4 !! 46

6

44 /

7 "7 ' '

# $

&

& # $ +& 4 '2 4 ! ' 8 0 # 7

! # # # # ! #" #" #" #" #" " #" 7 #" # #" $ #" #" #" ! #$ #$ #$ " #$ 7 #$ # #$ $ #$ #$ #$ #$ #$ #$ #$ " 2 2 & +& ' $

% & '()*

& /

& ! ! " 0 44 4 3 ( 3 . A / 44 2 3 6 5 6 5 5 3 & ! 2 2 2 6 4 & ( !! %& 5. 4 2 ' 5 . 3 45 0 2 2 6 / %&' 2 52 %&; 0 5 3 45 0 3 5 2 3 ! " 5 8 4< 8 4< 65 2 5 4 3 5 ' 0 " #8 # " 7 . !! 4 4 !! 5 4 4 5 4 ' 4 . 3 < 4 2 5 ( 50 2 !! 2 2 / 8 4 # $ 7 "7

+& 5

&F

3 4 /

2

&( '

22 3 2

'

= =

#'%

'

" 4

# # # # # " # 7 # # # $ # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # " $ $ $ $ $ " $ 7 $ #
!

6 6 6 4 2

6 3 ' A 4' 6 2 ; . 3 3 & 9 2 4 " 7 # $ 3 2 ( 0 5 9 2 2 % 56 & ( 4 52 2 = 6 ( 44 . 5 2 5& : 6 ! ! " / 54 4 & . ! & ! " 45 / 34 8 &9 & ! ! " 4' ! 5 4 2 ' 5 / & 8 0 2 5 6 3 2 & 6 ' 0 0 6 2 4 . 3 4 56 44 & 2 3 4 . 45 . 3 2 & ( 0 44 4 2& (. < . 2 3 2 4 0 2 5 42 5. 0 & 5.0 5 5 & . . 0 4 2 5 " 5 5 4 C 4 42 2 6 2& 4 65 & C . 2 D&& 2 < 0

&

& $& 3 4 2

5

2 4 4 ( !! 5 & 0 5 3 & 8 & ( 8 % 56 & 5 3 56 5 0

0 5 . 5

"# 4

#

$ $ " $ 7 $ # ! $ $ $ $ $ "

+&

# < . 0 0 ' &

#

+& <

!

"

'

= =

#'%

'

7 4

$ $ $ " $ 7 $ # $ $
!!

+& 0 ' &-

5 44 4 =D&& 8 & 6 & ! . & ! " / 29 2& 52

2 2 6

6

'. 6 B

? @

$$ 7 $$ # $$ $ $$ $$ $$ $$ ! $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ " " 7 # $

+& < < &+& ' & +& / 2 & ( !! ( 2 0 !! , 6 4 2 3 4 4 < 2 5 0 0 & , 0 4 ' < 2 ! " 2 !! 2 2 & 7 # $ / 2 5 4 2 & ( 2 2 6 4 5 ( 0 5 2 +& ) / 5 ! 5 4 ! " 6 4 C 4 5 ' 8 2 5 5 !! ( 0 3 &(6 4 / # " " 5 0 0 55 4 5 4 5 / & , 4 & # %&: 44 8 & < 2 4 < 2 2 / / 5 4 < 2 3 & 65 2 / 0 ' & ! ! " & ; 4 0 52 2 ; 2 0 44 4 0 8 !! : 2 & 0 2 44 29 28 ; "$ 8 4' 8 2 4 4 4 2 /

!

+& 2 &

! 5

!!

'

= =

#'%

'

# 4

" " 7 # $ ! " 4 +& &+& ;

6 4 2

29 2& ; !! ( 6 2 . (2 / (2 5 (2 ! 5 & 54 ! 2 .0 8 ! " ( 2 4 4 ! " 0 5 4 5 4 4 6 4 4 !! 2 & ( 2

32 !! 3 3 44 4 5 & 4 3 2 !! ( 2 4 (. & $ 5 ! 5 5 5 4

3 3 44 6

2

& 2

7 2 8

"$

29 2. 8

!

4 / 2

"

> ;( 9 3

! ! !

7 7" 77 7# 7$ 7 7 7 7 7 & ( !! # #" #7 ## #$ # 5 $ ' +& 6 &( 0 +& +& & +& 4 &C +& ;

! 2 2

! " 5 54 8 52 5 . 5 4 4 52 58 2 5 8 & 5 2 !! 5 & 5 0 2 5 . !! 5 2& 2 2 6 < 4& 8 7 / 3 !! ( 2 (. . !! ( 5 4 42 52 5 & 5 ( . 42 2 29 2

$

7

8

!

!

! " 5 29 2

#

2

#

8 . 3 & ( ! 5 ! " 3 2& ( 5 45 . 3

!

#

#

!

!

! "

"

'

= =

#'%

'

$ 4

" ! " 7 # $ !

2

> ;( 9 2 5 +& ! 2 3 &; 2 6 +& ! 2 8 44 5 $ ' ! 2 8 ! " 52 6 6& ) &; 2 ! " 3 0 ! " 3 & ) 0 5 5 & 0 8 < 2 !!

!! 2

# 4 6

"

" 4 .

3

4 "

&

!

+& 5 5 2 0 ' 29 2 5 &9 & ! 3 & 5 ! ! " ! " 25 6 4

0 : 6 4

4 0 42 4

! F 3G & & ! " F 3G > !
!

" 0 6 5 0 : " & " 4 4 & ) 8 6

+& F

$ "

0 : 4 & 6 & ! 2 44 . < 2 2 !! 2 44 0 5 5 44 ! ! " 0 0 3 4 & ! " 6 4

5& 45 3 6 5 , 44 2 , & 0 5& ( 2

"

$

" " " " " " " " " 7 !

+& / &9 , 4 2 2

!! (

" "7 +& 5 / 8 "" 5

$ $

# # ! # 2

% & '()*

! 2

! "

$ "
? @

'

= =

#'%

'

4

# # #" #7 ## F 3G > ! F 3 G 7& & " " " " " " " ! "" $ "" "" ! F 3 G 7&$& "# "# "# "# " "# 7 "# # "# $ "# "#
!

< 0 ' 4 !! 4

5 44 0 +& : &: # $ +& F 2 ' ; &D +& 4 & +& 5 ' &+& ; & 4 & (. 4 ! 6 ! 3 4 ! " 6 5 4! & 5 4 5 4 & 6 & ! ! " ! 5 2 3 ! " 3 2 5 6 4 !! & %&H 4 & . 6 4 ! ! " 3 !! 0 %&H 5 0 & < 0 8 2

3 2 3 2 0

5 2 !! 2 . 2

#$

0

. 2 " 5 3

& 25 6 $7& ( . 6 "

3

5

38

" 2 3 / ' 8

4

7

$

" ' 4 0 2 %&H 3 8 ' 0 5& +& F . & %&H 3 12 1 4 5 A & 4 ' 5 4 8

? @

! ! 7 7

F 3 G $&

% & '()* & ! " 5

!

! ! 7" " 7" 7

""

+& ( & (2

F 3 G $&&

7" # 7" $

!

! ! 7" # 7" $ 7" 7" 7" 7"

(.

! '

! " 2 4 42 6 29 2

# 29 2

F 3 G $&&

. 0 5 3 5 42 6

65 <

&

'

= =

#'%

'

4

" " " " " ""
!

8

0 &(. 0 +&

& ; & 2 ' I2 6 2 5 0 4 4 29 2 & $ F 5 6 " " . 4 <44 & 4 0 65 5 ! ; ! " 5 0 ! ! " 2 4 0 & 5 ! & ! 6 ! " 6 0 2 2 2 2 6 4 4 '& 0 & 5 8 & 6 & 8 5 6 0 A 4 4 2 6 8 0 8 4 7 $ ! " 0 6 8 7 $ 6 4 2 5 & # " 8 5 & " 0 !"# . 29 2 & (2 / 35 2 2 '!< 3 D "# 6 # 0 : "#7 " ! "$ & " # 2 %& 2 5 44 8 5 & . 65 2 0

&> 6

!

!

7 # 7 $ 7

!

! " 4 :

F 3G

" & &

% & '()*

!

! 7 " # # # # #"
!!

+& '

!

! "

F 3G

" & &

6

#7 ## ! F 3G " & & " 7 # ! &! # $ &: " +& ( " &&+& 0 &( 2 0 2 +& +& 6 &;

2 52

+& ( 2

'

= =

#'%

'

$ 4

7 # $ 2 +& ' F 3G > &' +& A D " 7 # $
!

4 2

+& 5 &9 &

. 2 3 / / 5 5# 2 6 5 #8 6 5 A ( 65 ' ! 5 0 ' 65 ! " 0 8 & 0 "6 !!

5 8

5

.

2 6

6

42

2

&

5

/ 6 / & 58

&( +& D & +& ; 5 &: <

!! 2 A & 35 D 0 3 4. 5 #8 6

6

2 6 6 & "# #

" !

+&

5 4 '8 6 &

4

2 6

5 4 6A

&9 & 9 ! 2 & & 3 22 ! " .

8 . 6

$

+& < &&+& &

+& 5

5 3 & 8

8 7 =

8

3 & ! ! " 25 ' 2

!

7 6 ' & > 0 5 2 1 4 3

"

F 3G &

" 7 # $

+& F " "& ' && ! !" & & ! ! " ! " & 1D

5

6 4

8

!

!

" " " " 7 +& (4 5

"

7

$

F 3 G &7

! F 3 G &7&

!

2 0 ' 4 D&& 2
' 4

" "

+& " 4

5

'

= =

#'%

" " 7
! !

'8 & & ! ! " < 54 2 5 0 . ! 3 8 &+& & & ! ! " 0 2 & 5 3 4. 2 4 0 . 2 3 2 . 2 2 0 5 ! ! " 25 ! ! " 4 %&% 0 . 58 &' 5 & 4

. 4 4 0 & " & / 6

" 4 28

F 3 G &7&

7 7 " # # # # !

+& ; 6 5 & +& < 2 &

& ! " 2 3 4 #

F 3 G &7&

# # # "

+& &

F 3 G &7& F 3G >

$ $ $ ! # # # " # 7 # # # $ # # # # # # # " $ $

2 !

<

.

44 4 &

" ' 5 2 & 3 5

+& 0 4 & &: 4 ' +& ' & +& ; 58

2 5 &

!!

2

3 54 6 0 2 5 0 44 & : 5 6 & 6 4

29 2 5 . 5 4 5 & & 6 7& 7 3 5 5 0 " " ( 8

! ! !

F 3G

$ &
!

7 ! ! 7 7 7 7

+& F

4

'

= =

#'%

'

4