Oracle Corporation et al v. SAP AG et al

Filing 1058

Declaration of Lisa Chin in Support of 1057 Opposition/Response to Motion for JMOL or New Trial filed byOracle International Corporation. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A part 1, # 2 Exhibit A part 2, # 3 Exhibit B, # 4 Exhibit C, # 5 Exhibit D, # 6 Exhibit E, # 7 Exhibit F, # 8 Exhibit G, # 9 Exhibit H, # 10 Exhibit I, # 11 Exhibit J, # 12 Exhibit K, # 13 Exhibit L, # 14 Exhibit M, # 15 Exhibit N, # 16 Exhibit O, # 17 Exhibit P, # 18 Exhibit Q, # 19 Exhibit R, # 20 Exhibit S, # 21 Exhibit T, # 22 Exhibit U, # 23 Exhibit V, # 24 Exhibit W, # 25 Exhibit X, # 26 Exhibit Y, # 27 Exhibit Z, # 28 Exhibit AA, # 29 Exhibit BB, # 30 Exhibit CC, # 31 Exhibit DD, # 32 Exhibit EE, # 33 Exhibit FF, # 34 Exhibit GG, # 35 Exhibit HH, # 36 Exhibit II, # 37 Exhibit JJ, # 38 Exhibit KK, # 39 Exhibit LL, # 40 Exhibit MM, # 41 Exhibit NN, # 42 Exhibit OO, # 43 Exhibit PP, # 44 Exhibit QQ, # 45 Exhibit RR, # 46 Exhibit SS, # 47 Exhibit TT, # 48 Exhibit UU, # 49 Exhibit VV)(Related document(s) 1057 ) (Howard, Geoffrey) (Filed on 4/8/2011)

Oracle Corporation et al v. SAP AG et al

Doc. 1058 Att. 9

EXHIBIT H
Dockets.Justia.com

! # ## ! # # # #1 ! 1 ## 1 # 1# ! > , ? #%#%# 1 #5 1 # ! 11 11 11 1 11 5 11 11 " 11 # > , ? #%#% 11 ## 11 # 11 # 11 # ! 15 # 15 #1 15 #5 15 # 15 #" ! 15 15 1 # 1 1 1 $% * + *% $% * ' *% A ( + . ( *% 4 $% * *% A . 7 % . ' 7 % . *2 . .8 .) (2 ( . + . ! "! ( , ' ) % # 5 " $% * *% *% @ $% *% @ $% * *% / $% * ! *2 *A% / 9 . ) ( ( - % ' ' ) ! "! . ' % #1 # ## " % ' % ' % . . ) ' !! (( 2 . 2 ) . ! ) ; 3 ' ) *% / 5 ! "! !
: =

$% & *% . *% 2 ' ( ! "! 6 7 9 , .% ! "! =& ' , . 9 " ,
: =

! "! ' % ! "! ) 3 / 4 # ' , . .8 .) % #5 *2 ( 0 # '+ ' ( )

$% +, '% *

1

$% :4 % ;+<

2

##B B #

#5 24

2

# ( #"

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

$% :4 % ;+< *2 F % . ! "! '

# 3 . ) 3 -' , . ' .

5

*2 '

2

##B B #

#5 "24

2

( #"

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

2

##B B #

#5 "24

2

( #"

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

$% :4 % ;+<

2

##B B #

#5 "24

2

( #"

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

.8 .% &

$% :4 % ;+<

$% :4 % ;+<

2

##B B #

#5 "24

2

( #"

5 5 ! > , ? #55%#%# ! 1 1 1 1 5 1 1 " 1 # 1 ## > , ? #55%#% 1 # 1 # 1 # 1 # 1 #1 1 #5 1 # ! 1 1 1 1 ! > , ? #55%%# 1" # 1" # 1" # 1" #1 1" #5 > , ? #55%% 1" # 1" #" 1" 1" # > , ? #55%% 1" 1" 1" 1" ! > , ? #55%5% 51 # 51 ##
2 ##B B # #5 "24

% / ) *% . A ! "! , ! "! / F ( ( ' ( *% $% * & *% $% * *% ; . . $% * *% @ ) % $% * *% F $% * ) *% $% * *% & $% 3 3 . ( % ! "! ( ( ( . ! "! F . ! "! ) H #5#5 &

( ,

" # 4%+ .

" #"% 6 ' / 4%

#

% - # "% # - # " .8 . . A 2 . .8 .) % , % 3 4%+ . . ' % # !! *2 4%+ . # " 1 1 9 ) ( % % / + . # 1 5 " # 5 ##

1

$% > 9

'#

F

#5#"

-

" ( B . ' ( . . , ( ( F' . 3 % (( 3 ( ) B/ ( 9 -

#

#

(

' ) % . ( *2% /

*2% /

# ( 3 % '

#

#

% / 9 #5#

2

5 ( #"

51 # 51 # ! 5 # 5 5 5 5 5 1 ! 5 # 5 # > ,? ; ! " # " # " # " # " #1 ! " " " " 1 " 5 " " " " # " ## ! > ,? %# " # " ## " # " # ! " #5 " # " #" " " # " " " & *% * 7 $% * ' *% @ % ' % @ ) ) ' % . * 7 ('- ( *% ( ! "! ,/ 4 ! "! =* . /, ' . . 93 % . % #5 # 3 *2 .8 . 7 % , . ' % /9 .8 .
: =

) *% / E $% *% $% 6 *% / ' . . 9 , .% % $% ( K *% 8 % ! "! = ' ' 3 . *% / 4%L . *% @ $% F . 7 3 % # #1 " % / . 1 % ' .8 . ) % 4%* , ' ( , % ! "! ' 7 .8 .% ' 3 ) 1 #1 .8 . . '( + ) *2 . , # . 3 #1 #" ' 1 ' ) ! "! 3 . - ( 5 . #1 # , ( ) 3 3 ! "! 3 . ) % - ( % #5 . #

5 #

$% :4 % ;+<

$% 4 % 6 K9 !

$% +, '% > 9 ( #

1 2 . 2

$% :4 % ;+<

2

##B B #

#5 "24

2

( #"

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

$% :4 % ;+<

$% :4 % ;+<

2

##B B #

#5 "24

2

" ( #"

( *% $% * 1 > ,? %%5 5 " > ,? %% # ## # # # # #1 ! # #" ! ! ! 1 ! #" # > ,? %#% ! #" #" #" #" # #" #" #" ! 1 5
2

*2 % . (

%C

) ' . % & 1% ) . )

*% $% * *% & $% F . . *% $% + % *% & E *% / 3 ! "! . ( ! "! =* % = . 3 ) * ) ! "! 3 3 . !! . 3 + ' % ( .8 . .

'%

. 3 % -' ' 3 ) 3 . 9 . ' " 3 , ( ( % & ## ' 3 !! 3 ( % # # '. ' # '. ' ) # 1 #" " #" ' % & # ) # ( *2% '

$% :4 % ;+<

.8 . . )

$% :4 % ;+<

*% / #" # ' *% @ $% * % 9 ,

! "! .% !# ! # .' .

# 5 ,

#"
: =

$% +, '% > 1% !# ! # K . .8 . *% / $% * *% * / $% * 7 *% ( % !# ! # ' , -

# ) 2 . 2 3 / # .. %% ( .8 .% / . ' '% / % '

# ##

#"
: =

)

# 1 )

#" "

4%L

)

##B B #

#5 "24

2

#

( #"

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

2

##B B #

#5 "24

2

## ( #"

11 ## 11 # 11 # 11 # 11 # ! 7 1 5 " ! ! ! > , ? 15%# ## # # # # #1 #5 # ! > , ? 15% # # #1 > , ? 15% % #5 # #" # #
2 ##B B # #5 "24

. *% / % & ' -' * )

' '

3 . .8 %

.8 . , '

D

' (

-

.

!# ! # 93 *2 , . 3 . ( 3 K -

1 ( % & !! - ( - % !!

# + .8 . ) 3 3

"#

$% +, '% 8 . ' + 9 - ! .

*% 6 .

$% 6 *% A ' 3 $% * *29 *% * F ( . . . (

!# ! # ) + . , - % !# ! # 3 F !# ! # =& ( 8!+ ' . .8 . ( !# ! # 4 % ;+< F + =* 9 , & ( % # +, '% > 9 ' * ' ' ' F * "" . ( , A 5 ) % # #5 F " . (

## - ' .8 .

##

5) & + . % /9 ' 3 ) -' "% / 5%

$% :4 % ;+< .8 .!

*% * . (

# .8 . +((

1

- % (! % ' ' )

$% :4 % ;+<

*% @ $% * ( *% @ $% * ,

% *2% ' % ' '( *2)
2 # ( #"

) 3 3 .8 .

> , ? 15% % (( 1 5 3 " # ## # # > ,? ; ! # #" # ! $% 3 1 5 2 " # ! ## # # # # #1 #5 # #" ! # !
2 ##B B # #5 "24

*% @ $% + (

% & C 3 C , ' -' ( , ) . '( 3 ( + *2%C . '% ' % !# ! # ' 3 3 .8 . ) 3 ' . + 3 # . .8 . . ( *2 ' ' . ( .8 . C 3 ( C ( 2 C . 4 2 9

-

(

*% $% *% @

3 )

#

$% 6 (( *% 8 % '

!# ! # !! ' .8 . . ( , D . % . . '. 3 ) ( ' 3

1 (( '

3 *% /

$% . 3 2 *% / $% 6 ' *% / . 3 $% . ( *% 8 ' / 3 ' '

!# ! # 3 ' ( BD ( 3 ) ' !! !# ! # 3 . ) % !# ! # ' ' # '. 3 3 ' . % '. ' (( ' . ) ( .

1 " .8 . '

#1

.

'

% 5 #5 .8 . 3

5

2 #1 ( #"

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

$% :4 % ;+<

!# ! # =* .8 . (. (

$% :4 % ;+<

$% :4 % ;+<

2

##B B #

#5 "24

2

#5 ( #"

! "5 "5 "5 "5 1 "5 5 "5 "5 " "5 # ! > ,? %#%# "" "" 1 ! "" "" " ! "" # ! > ,? %# %# " # ## # # # ! 1 5 *% " # 2 ' ' ( 2 ( % *% $% +, '% .8 . ( ' *% @ $% * ( 2 % !# ! # ( 2 . % 6 .8 . . . ) #" 1 #" % +(( 3 6 .8 .% ' *2 ) !! ) *% @ ' , % $% 8 . !# ! # 4 ( *2 . % # !# ! # .8 . A > 4 # ) *% 8 % $% 6 *% & $% * ' *% 8 * % !# ! # #
: =

$% 6 ' ) ' % . ( /

!# ! # ( '

#" (

"

##

E '-

( ' ) % (

') *2 .

!# ! # % 5

" "

1
: =

2

##B B #

#5 "24

2

#

( #"