Oracle Corporation et al v. SAP AG et al

Filing 1058

Declaration of Lisa Chin in Support of 1057 Opposition/Response to Motion for JMOL or New Trial filed byOracle International Corporation. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A part 1, # 2 Exhibit A part 2, # 3 Exhibit B, # 4 Exhibit C, # 5 Exhibit D, # 6 Exhibit E, # 7 Exhibit F, # 8 Exhibit G, # 9 Exhibit H, # 10 Exhibit I, # 11 Exhibit J, # 12 Exhibit K, # 13 Exhibit L, # 14 Exhibit M, # 15 Exhibit N, # 16 Exhibit O, # 17 Exhibit P, # 18 Exhibit Q, # 19 Exhibit R, # 20 Exhibit S, # 21 Exhibit T, # 22 Exhibit U, # 23 Exhibit V, # 24 Exhibit W, # 25 Exhibit X, # 26 Exhibit Y, # 27 Exhibit Z, # 28 Exhibit AA, # 29 Exhibit BB, # 30 Exhibit CC, # 31 Exhibit DD, # 32 Exhibit EE, # 33 Exhibit FF, # 34 Exhibit GG, # 35 Exhibit HH, # 36 Exhibit II, # 37 Exhibit JJ, # 38 Exhibit KK, # 39 Exhibit LL, # 40 Exhibit MM, # 41 Exhibit NN, # 42 Exhibit OO, # 43 Exhibit PP, # 44 Exhibit QQ, # 45 Exhibit RR, # 46 Exhibit SS, # 47 Exhibit TT, # 48 Exhibit UU, # 49 Exhibit VV)(Related document(s) 1057 ) (Howard, Geoffrey) (Filed on 4/8/2011)

Oracle Corporation et al v. SAP AG et al

Doc. 1058 Att. 2

EXHIBIT A Part 2
Dockets.Justia.com

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 6 - November 9, 2010
( " " !! + # ( ! " !! ) & " " # ! ! ( & " ! '' '' ! ! ! '' " !! ! ! '' # & "! $ " !! " ) & ! !! '' !! ! ! " '' " ! ! ! " ! " " ! !! ! !! " " ! %# ' # & $ " " !! ! " " !! ) !& )!! ) " ! " !! '' ) !! ! ! ! !! '' "" " '' " " ! & " ! '' ( ! ") " ") 1 ! " ! ! " ! ) ! " # ") ) ) " " ! & ! !! ' $ " $ ! ! # " ( " ! & " 1) " " ! + ") " ! ! ) ! ") ! ! '' " " & '' ! & ! !! " '' " '' " " * $ " (

) " " %# '

( ! " ! # ! ( ! % " ! ! ! ( !! ! $ ! " ! " # ( ! ) " - !! " !! " !! " " ! " $ !! " ) ) # $ ! " $ ! ! !! %# ' # ! $ %# ' ) " ! & ! ! ! ! ! ! ! & & " ) !! " " ! " ( " + " !! & % ) )!! ) " !! '' " !! ! ! " '' " " & # " " ! ! * & " ! ! % ) !! & " " % !! ! !! " " !! ! " " ! " " ! ! !& # !! ! !! & & ! ) " $ ) !! " & " " ! "

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 6 - November 9, 2010
SHEET 4

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 $1' ,) , &28/' *(7 6/,'( :+,&+ 7+( -85< +$6 35(9,286/< 6((1 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 &28/' <28 %5,()/< 5(0,1' 7+( -85< 05 0(<(5 -867 72 6(7 7+( 67$*( :+$7 7+,6 5(35(6(176" $ 2.$< :( :(5( 7$/.,1* $%287 7+( 9$5,286 )$&7256 7+$7 :28/' %( &216,'(5(' %< 6$3 $1' , %(/,(9( :( ' :25.(' 7+528*+ )$&725 7+(5( 7+( *2$/6 2) 86,1* 7+( 62)7:$5( ,1 7+( :,7+ 7202552:12: $1' ,1 7+( 6$)( 3$66$*( 352*5$0 $1' 7+( %(1(),76 7+(5( :( %(*$1 72 029( , %(/,(9( ,172 )$&7256 $1' 7$/.,1* $%287 7+( ,03$&76 $1' 8/7,0$7(/< 7+( ),1$1&,$/ *$,16 7+$7 :(5( (;3(&7(' 4 $1' :( 5( 7$/.,1* $%287 :+$7 :28/' %( ,1 6$3 $* 6 0,1' 7+(,5 (;3(&7$7,216 *2,1* ,172 7+( 1(*27,$7,21" $ 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 4 $// 5,*+7 $// 5,*+7 , '21 7 7+,1. :( 48,7( ),1,6+(' 1(*27,$7,21 )$&725 6/,'( 3/($6( (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 7+$7 <28 9( *21( 7+528*+ 7+( )285 )$&7256 <(67(5'$< $7 7+( (1' 2) 7+( '$< $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 %< 05 3,&.(77 4 /(7 6 *2 21 7+(1 72 )$&725 12 :+$7 :28/' %( ,1 7+( 0,1' 2) 6$3 :( 5( 029,1* )520 7+(,5 *2$/6 72 (;3(&7(' ,03$&7 21 25$&/( &$1 <28 5(0,1' 7+( -85< :+$7 7+$7 )$&725 ,192/9(6" $ <(6 7+,6 :$6 ,1 7+( )520 7+( 3(563(&7,9( 2) 7+( 6$3 1(*27,$7256 +2: 86,1* 7+( 62)7:$5( :28/' 7+(1 ,03$&7 25$&/( $1' $6 <28 5(&$// )520 7+( ',6&866,21 <(67(5'$< 7+$7 :$6 $1 ,668( 72 /$81&+ 5,*+7 $)7(5 7+( 25$&/( &20%,1$7,21 :,7+ 3(23/(62)7 $1' 62 :( 5( *2,1* 72 6(( 620( 2) 7+(6( '2&80(176 , 7+,1. ,1 $ 020(17 , 7+,1. 7+$7 7+$7 7+( ),567 ,7(0 7+(5( ,1 7+( )$5 5,*+7 +$1' 6,'( :( // 6(( 7+$7 7+,6 :$6 35(6(17(' 72 25 5(&(,9(' %< 05 $*$66, 05 26:$/' $1' 05 0$&.(< $1' :,7+ 7+,6 352*5$0 ,7 6$<6 0$< )25&( 25$&/( 72 &+$1*( ,76 %(+$9,25 25 3/$16 $5281' 35,&,1* 25 326,7,21,1* $1' 7+(1 7+( 1(;7 21( ,7 6 35(77< ,03257$17 $))(&7,1* 25$&/( 6 $%,/,7< 72 0$,17$,1 7+,6 5(9(18( 675($0 &28/' ,03$&7 7+( 52, $668037,216 7+$7 0($16 5(7851 21 ,19(670(17 2) 7+( 25$&/( 3(23/(62)7 '($/ 62 7+$7 0($16 7+$7 ,7 :28/' ,03$&7 7+( $%,/,7< )25 25$&/( 72 0$.( 5(7851 21 7+( %,//,21 ,19(670(17 4 62 ,) 7+$7 7+( ,'($ ,6 7+$7 ,) 6$3 :$6 68&&(66)8/ ,1 &219(57,1* &86720(56 ,7 :28/' ',9(57 )81'6 7+$7 :28/' 3$< )25 7+( 3(23/(62)7 %,//,21 $&48,6,7,21" 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 4 $1' 7+(1 7+(5( $5( 620( 025( 7+(5( 6 620( 025( (9,'(1&( :,7+ 5(63(&7 72 6$3 6 *2$/6 ,) :( &28/' *2 72 6/,'( (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 :+$7 '2(6 7+,6 6/,'( 6+2:" 7+,6 ,6 1(: 12: )520 :+(5( :( :(5(" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 7+(6( :(5( 7+( 7+5(( $'',7,21$/ '2&80(176 21 7+( 6(&21' 6/,'( 2) )$&725 $1' 7+(6( )857+(5 ,//8675$7( 21&( $*$,1 7+( ,03257$1&( 2) 7+( 62)7:$5( ,1 7+( 7202552:12: 2))(5,1* , 7+,1. 21( 2) 7+( .(< ,7(06 +(5( :$6 $7 7+( %27720 7+(5( ,7(0 21 7+( %27720 5,*+7 +$1' 6,'( ,7 6$<6 7202552:12: :,// 6(59( $6 $ 0$-25 &251(56721( 2) 285 *2 72 0$5.(7 675$7(*< $6 285 .(< 6(59,&( '(/,9(5< 81,7 62 7+$7 :$6 9(5< ,03257$17 7+$7 :$6 67(3 21( ,1 7+( 6$)( 3$66$*( 352*5$0 4 :+< :$6 ,7 ,03257$17 7+$7 6$3 *2,1* ,172 7+,6 1(*27,$7,21 )25 /,&(16( :28/' +$9( 7+28*[phone]:12: :28/' 6(59( $6 $ 0$-25 &251(56721( 2) 7+,6 352*5$0" $ ,7 :$6 7+(,5 %(/,() 7+$7 ,7 :28/' *,9( 7+(0 $ &+$1&( 72 &219(57 &86720(56 )520 7+( 3(23/(62)7 0$,17(1$1&( %(,1* 3529,'(' %< 25$&/( $1' 3(23/(62)7 72 7202552:12: $1' 8/7,0$7(/< 7+( *2$/ 2) &219(57,1* 7+$7 &86720(5 72 0<6$3 7+( 6$3 $33/,&$7,21 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 $ 7+$7 6 5,*+7 :+,&+ :28/' 7+(1 ,03$&7 &$6+ )/2: 72 25$&/( $1' 3(23/(62)7 :+,&+ :28/' ,03$&7 '(9(/230(17 4 $1' 6$3 :28/' 9,(: 7+$7 +2: (17(5,1* 7+( 1(*27,$7,21 7$%/(" +2: :28/' 7+$7 )$&725 ,03$&7 ,76 7+,1.,1*" $ 7+$7 &5($7(6 $'',7,21$/ 9$/8( )25 6$3 ,1 7+( 1(*27,$7,21 ,7 6 $ 5($621 :+< 7+(< :28/' 3$< 025( )25 7+( /,&(16( (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 $// 5,*+7 /(7 6 *2 72 )$&725 12 ,1 6$3 6 0,1' 21 7+,6 1(*27,$7,21 2) $ /,&(16( $1' 7+$7 6 7+( 6$3 6 (;3(&7(' ),1$1&,$/ *$,16 7+$7 6 35(77< 2%9,286 :+$7 7+$7 ,6 :+$7 +$9( <28 6800$5,=(' +(5(" $ :+$7 , 9( 6800$5,=(' +(5( $5( 620( 2) 7+( .(< '2&80(176 25 ,03257$17 '2&80(176 ,1 7+,6 7,0( )5$0( 2) '(&(0%(5 $1' -$18$5< $1' 6,0,/$5 72 7+( 27+(5 &+$576 ,7 6 6(7 83 6+2:,1* :+2 5(&(,9(' 25 :$6 35(6(17(' 7+( '2&80(176 $1' $1' <28 // 6(( (;(&87,9( %2$5' 0(0%(56 ,1 7+$7 &2/801 $1' , 9( 127(' ,1 5(' 620( 2) 7+26( 352-(&7,21 ),*85(6 $%287 7+( 327(17,$/ &219(56,21 2) &86720(56 )520 3(23/(62)7 29(5 72 7+( 6$3 $33/,&$7,21 62 <28 6(( 0$,17(1$1&( &86720(56 <28 // 6(( &86720(56 72 6$3 %< 62 7+$7 6 %< 7+( (1' 2) $ 6+257 3(5,2' 2) 7,0( $1' 7+(1 '2:1 7+( 3$*( <28 // 6(( &219(57 7+( 0$-25,7< , 7+,1. ,7 6 ,03257$17 72 127( 21 ,7(0 7+(5( $%287 7+( 7,0,1* ,668( 7+,6 :$6 3$57 2) $ -$18$5< 7+ 6257 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 6 - November 9, 2010
0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 2) /$81&+ $7 6$3 ,7 6$<6 $**5(66,9(/< &219(57 2) */2%$/ 29(5 7+( 1(;7 '$<6 62 7+$7 0($16 7+( *2$/ :$6 )25 6$3 ,1 7+( 1(;7 '$<6 %(7:((1 -$18$5< 7+ 287 )25 7+( 1(;7 0217+ 72 *2 72 7+( 723 &86720(56 7+(< +$' $1' 72 $**5(66,9(/< &219(57 7+(0 72 6$3 , 7+,1. ,7 6 9(5< ,03257$17 21 7,0,1* $1' 352-(&7,216 7+(1 <28 // 6(( 7+( -2,17 6$3 &86720(56 %(,1* $ 7$5*(7 &219(57 3(5&(17 $1' 7+(1 $6 <28 :25. '2:1 7+( 3$*( 72 :$6 :$6 $/62 $ 352-(&7,21 $1' 7+(1 8/7,0$7(/< 7+(5( :$6 7(67,021< %< 05 $*$66, 7+$7 +( )(/7 81'(5 620( &,5&8067$1&( 7+$7 6$3 &28/' &219(57 3(5&(17 2) 7+( &86720(56 , $&78$//< ',' 7+( 0$7+ 7+(5( 7+( :+,&+ &$0( 287 2) $ '2&80(17 06 &$7= 6+2:(' <(67(5'$< 7,0(6 3(5&(17 62 ,7 :28/' %( &219(57(' &86720(56 4 $1' $// 2) 7+,6 (9,'(1&( 21 7+,6 &+$57 ,6 )520 :+20" $ 7+,6 (9,'(1&( ,6 (,7+(5 %((1 35(6(17(' 72 25 35(3$5(' %< 25 $33529(' %< 7+( (;(&87,9( %2$5' 7+( ,1',9,'8$/6 7+$7 0$1$*( 6$3 '$< 72 '$< 4 62 :( .12: (;$&7/< :+$7 7+(< :(5( 7+,1.,1* $7 7+( 7,0( $%287 +2: 0$1< &86720(56 7+(< &28/' 7$.( 21 7+( 3(23/(62)7 6,'( )520 25$&/( ,) 7+(< /$81&+(' 7+,6 352*5$0 ,6 7+$7 5,*+7" $ 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 4 $1' :+$7 ,03$&7 '2(6 7+$7 +$9( 21 7+(,5 7+,1.,1* *2,1* ,172 7+( 1(*27,$7,21 )25 7+( /,&(16(" 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55 0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 $ 7+,6 '2&80(17 ),76 ,172 7+( &$7(*25< 2) *2$/6 $1' 21&( $*$,1 ,7 $)),506 7+$7 67(3 21( $1' ,7 :$6 &$//(' 7+( &251(56721( :$6 72 3529,'( &855(17 6$3 &86720(56 3(23/(62)7 6833257 $1' 7+$7 :28/' %( 3529,'(' %< 7202552:12: 86,1* 7+( ,1)5,1*,1* 62)7:$5( 62 ,7 -867 6+2:6 7+$7 7+( &251(56721( $1' 7+( 0267 ,03257$17 3$57 2) 7+,6 352*5$0 :$6 67(3 21( 7202552:12: :,7+ 7+( 62)7:$5( 4 $1' 21( 67(3 67(3 21( :$6 7202552:12: %87 :+$7 ',' ,7 /($' 72 67(3 7:2 $1' 67(3 7+5((" $ :(// $1' 67(3 7:2 :$6 21&( 7+( &86720(5 722. 7+( 62)7:$5( 7+( 6833257 21 7+( 62)7:$5( :$6 ,7 6$<6 '5,9( ,1&5(0(17$/ 5(9(18( 7+528*+ &20326,7( $33/,&$7,216 7+$7 :$6 72 7+(1 6(// $127+(5 352'8&7 )520 6$3 72 7+$7 &86720(5 7+(< +$' $ 352'8&7 &$//(' 1(7:($9(5 7+$7 :28/' +(/3 7+(0 ,17(*5$7( 7+(,5 352'8&76 :,7+ 27+(5 352'8&76 $1' 7+$7 6 $1 ,17(*5$7,21 352'8&7 62 7+$7 :28/' %( $127+(5 /,&(16( 6$/( )25 6$3 $1' $'',7,21$/ 5(9(18( $1' 352),76 %27+ )520 /,&(16( $1' 7+(1 7+( 0$,17(1$1&( 21 7+$7 352'8&7 $1' 7+(1 8/7,0$7(/< 7+( 7+( 3$<2)) ,6 67(3 7+5(( :+,&+ ,6 83*5$'( 3(23/(62)7 &86720(56 72 0<6$3 (53 $1' 7+$7 6 7+( 727$/ &219(56,21 2) 7+$7 35,25 &86720(5 21 3(23/(62)7 72 7+( 6$3 $33/,&$7,21 $1' 7+(1 6$3 ($516 %27+ 7+( /,&(16( $1' 7+( 5(9(18( $1' 352),76 21 7+$7 4 <28 &$// 7+$7 /$67 67(3 7+( 3$<2)) :+<" 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 $ :(// )520 0< 3(563(&7,9( ,7 6 9(5< ,03257$17 2%9,286/< 7+(< 9( /$,' 287 $ 9$5,(7< 2) *2$/6 %87 $ %,* *2$/ :$6 72 &219(57 &86720(56 $1' 7+,6 ,6 7+(,5 (;3(&7$7,21 7+(,5 %(67 326,7,21 ,1 7+( ,1)250$7,21 7+(< 86( 72 0$.( 7+( '(&,6,21 72 *2 )25:$5' 72 72 /$81&+ 7+,6 7+,6 352'8&7 $1' 62 ,7 6 5,*+7 )520 7+( %2$5' 0(0%(56 $1' ,7 6 )520 0< 3(563(&7,9( 9(5< $335235,$7( $1' $&&85$7( $1' +,*+ 48$/,7< ,1)250$7,21 4 $// 5,*+7 $1' <28 &$1 %$6( 7+(,5 (;3(&7(' *$,1 %$6(' 21 7+( 180%(5 2) &86720(56 7+$7 7+(< (;3(&7(' 72 *$,1" $ 7+$7 6 5,*+7 21&( <28 81'(567$1' 7+( 180%(5 2) &86720(56 <28 7+(1 *2 7+528*+ ),1$1&,$/ 02'(/6 $1' 387 $ 9$/8( 21 7+$7 7+( .(< ,1)250$7,21 :28/' &20( )520 7+( %2$5' 0(0%(56 $7 6$3 7+( 352-(&7(' &86720(56 72 &219(57 4 $// 5,*+7 12: 62 :( 9( *21( 7+528*+ 7+( )$&7256 $1' <28 9( 5()(5(1&(' $ :+2/( /27 2) (9,'(1&( +(5( , :$17 72 7$.( <28 7+528*+ -867 $ )(: 2) 7+( 0$1< '2&80(176 7+$7 <28 9( %$6(' <285 23,1,21 21 05 05 0(<(5 $1' 620( 2) 7+(6( :,// %( 9(5< )$0,/,$5 72 7+( -85< /(7 6 ),567 /22. $7 3/$,17,))6 (;+,%,7 6+28/' %( 7+( 1(;7 6/,'( (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 05 3,&.(77 5,*+7 3/$,17,))6 (;+,%,7 4 :+$7 '2(6 7+,6 +2: 7+,6 '2&80(17 5(/$7( 72 <285 23,1,21 05 0(<(5" 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 $ %(&$86( 8/7,0$7(/< 7+(1 <28 9( 7$.(1 $ &86720(5 7+$7 :$6 $1 25$&/( &86720(5 $1' 727$//< &219(57(' ,7 72 6$3 $1' 62 7+$7 %(&20(6 %27+ 21*2,1* 352'8&7 6$/(6 :+,&+ ,6 /,&(16( $1' 7+(1 7+( 7+( ,03257$17 $118,7< :+,&+ ,6 7+( 0$,17(1$1&( :+,&+ <28 &$1 *2 21 )25 '(&$'(6 ,7 6 9(5< ,03257$17 4 $// 5,*+7 /(7 6 *2 21 7+(1 72 (;+,%,7 :+,&+ ,6 7+( 1(;7 6/,'( (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 7+,6 ,6 $ '2&80(17 :( 9( 6((1 $ 180%(5 2) 7,0(6 :+$7 6 ,6 7+,6 $ 6,*1,),&$17 '2&80(17" $ <(6 ,7 ,6 ,7 6 6,*1,),&$17 21 $ 9$5,(7< 2) )52176 :( 9( 7$/.(' $%287 7+( )$&7 7+$7 7+,6 :$6 ,1 ,7 ,192/9(' 7+( (;(&87,9( %2$5' 0(0%(56 2) 6$3 $1' $1' ,7 $&78$//< 6+2:6 %< 5(9(18( &$7(*25,(6 7<3(6 2) 5(9(18(6 0$,17(1$1&( $1' 27+(5 $'',7,21$/ 5(9(18(6 $ 352-(&7,21 7+$7 *2(6 287 7+528*+ 62 )25 7+5(( <($56 $1' ,7 $&78$//< 6+2:6 $ 352-(&7,21 2) &86720(56 72 5(&(,9( 0$,17(1$1&( &86720(56 72 %( &219(57(' $1' 7+(1 7+( 5(9(18( 9$/8( 7+$7 :$6 352-(&7(' %< 6$3 6 0$1$*(0(17 $7 7+$7 7,0( 4 12: 7+( 7+(5( 6 7+5(( &2/256 21 7+( *5$3+ 6257 2) $ 127 *22' :,7+ &2/256 .,1' 2) $ /$9(1'(5 0$<%( $ /,/$& $1' $ 3($&+ :+$7 '2 7+26( &2/256 5(35(6(17" $ 7+(5( 6 7+5(( ',))(5(17 :+$7 , // &$// 5(9(18( &$7(*25,(6 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 6 - November 9, 2010
SHEET 5

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 $1' 7+( ),567 21( :+,&+ ,6 7+( /$9(1'(5 ,6 , 7+,1. 7+$7 6 /$9(1'(5 %87 7+$7 6 7+( 0$,17(1$1&( 5(9(18( $1' 62 7+$7 0($16 7+$7 $6 7202552:12: 3529,'(6 7+( 0$,17(1$1&( 7+$7 6 7+( 5(9(18( 7+$7 7+(< :,// ($51 29(5 7+$7 7+5(( <($5 3(5,2' ,7 7+(1 029(6 ,172 620(7+,1* 7+$7 7+(< 5()(5 72 $6 $6 &5266 6(// $1' 7+$7 6 $1 $'',7,21$/ 5(9(18( 6285&( 7+$7 6 7+( 1(;7 &2/25 7+(5( $1' 7+$7 &5266 6(// ,6 /,.( 6(//,1* 7+( 1(7:($9(5 352'8&7 $ /,&(16( 21 7+$7 $1' 7+(1 5(9(18( )25 0$,17(1$1&( 8/7,0$7(/< 21 7+$7 $1' 7+(1 /$67/< :+$7 6 &$//(' 836:,7&+ $1' $1' 836:,7&+ 6$3 6 3+5$6( 62 :+(1 7+(< 8/7,0$7(/< &219(57 &86720(5 72 0<6$3 7+$7 6 7+( 5(9(18( )520 )520 7+$7 6285&( $1' :+$7 6 ,03257$17 +(5( 127 21/< '2 <28 6(( ',))(5(17 &$7(*25,(6 2) 5(9(18( :+,&+ ,6 ,03257$17 )25 6$3 $1' ,76 ),1$1&,$/ 5(78516 7+(5( 6 $/62 75(0(1'286 *52:7+ %(7:((1 <($56 62 %(7:((1 7+( ),567 <($5 $1' 7+( 6(&21' <($5 7+( *52:7+ 7+(< 352-(&7 ,6 3(5&(17 $1' 7+(1 , %(/,(9( ,7 6 3(5&(17 $)7(5 7+$7 62 ($&+ <($5 7+( 5(9(18(6 $5( 21 $1 83:$5' *52:7+ &<&/( 62 ,7 21/< *2(6 )25 7+5(( <($56 %87 7+( 9$/8( :,// &217,18( 21 ,172 7+( )8785( :+,&+ , // 7$/. $%287 ,1 $ 020(17 %87 ,7 6+2:6 *52:7+ ,7 6+2:6 $ 9$5,(7< 2) 5(9(18(6 $1' ,7 6+2:6 7+( $%,/,7< 72 &219(57 7+( &86720(56 72 0<6$3 $1' 8/7,0$7(/< ,7 6+2:6 &86720(56 7+$7 :28/' 7$.( 0$,17(1$1&( )520 7202552:12: 86,1* 7+( 62)7:$5( $1' 7+( 9$/8( 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 7+(< :,// 7+(1 %( 0<6$3 &86720(56 327(17,$//< )25 '(&$'(6 %(&$86( 7+(< 12: $5( 3$57 2) 7+( 6$3 $33/,&$7,21 )$0,/< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 $1' 62 7+(5( :28/' %( %,//,216 2) 5(9(18(6 5(68/7,1* $ 2+ $%62/87(/< 4 $// 5,*+7 12: :+2 '2 <28 81'(567$1' +$' ,1387 ,172 7+( &$/&8/$7,216 7+$7 6$3 :$6 0$.,1* $7 7+( 7,0(" $ :(// 7+,6 '2&80(17 +(5( :$6 35(3$5(' %< 05 =,(0(1 :+2 :$6 $&78$//< ,1 7+( 6(59,&( 62/87,216 *5283 62 +( $&78$//< :$6 ,1 ,1 $ 6833257 *5283 +( :$6 ,1 7+$7 ,1 7+$7 %86,1(66 6(*0(17 %87 7+,6 '2&80(17 +(5( :$6 3529,'(' 72 05 $*$66, 05 .$*(50$11 05 $327+(.(5 $1' 05 26:$/' 62 7+(< $// +$' ),567 +$1' .12:/('*( 2) 7+( 352-(&7,216 $1' $1' 7+,6 ,6 %$&. ,1 '(&(0%(5 :+(1 7+( %86,1(66 :$6 %(,1* 3/$11(' 4 $// 5,*+7 $1' /(7 6 /22. $7 7+( 1(;7 (;+,%,7 (;+,%,7 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 :+$7 6 7+( 6,*1,),&$1&( 2) 7+,6 '2&80(17 05 0(<(5" $ 7+,6 '2&80(17 7+,6 :28/' %( 35(77< 48,&. +(5( %$6,&$//< :+$7 7+,6 6$<6 $1' 7+,6 :$6 6(17 %< $ 05 :(/= :+2 :$6 7+( 6(1,25 9,&( 35(6,'(17 2) 6(59,&(6 $1' 6833257 $7 6$3 7+,6 :$6 $77$&+(' , %(/,(9( 72 ,7 :$6 6(17 72 05 26:$/' %87 ,1 7+( %2'< 2) (0$,/ 7+,6 :$6 :+$7 :$6 05 :(/= 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 29(5 7+( 7+5(( <($56 2) 5(9(18( ,6 $%287 0,//,21 62 ,7 6 $1 ,03257$17 352-(&7,21 '2&80(17 '21( $7 7+( 7,0( $1' $&&(37(' %< 7+( (;(&87,9( %2$5' 4 12: 7+( /,&(16( 7+$7 :28/' %( 1(*27,$7(' :28/' 127 (1' ,1 :28/' ,7" $ 12 ,7 :28/' 127 7+( /,&(16( :28/' *2 21 7+528*+ 2&72%(5 2) $1' 62 7+(5( ' %( 620( 025( ),1$1&,$/ %(1(),76 7+528*+ 7+( /,&(16( 3(5,2' $1' 7+(1 $6 , 9( 0(17,21(' ($5/,(5 7+( %(1(),76 *2 :(// ,172 7+( )8785( %(&$86( 7+( &219(57(' &86720(56 $5( 7+(1 3$57 2) 6$3 4 $1' ,) 7+,6 :(5( ,1 7+( 0,1' 2) 6$3 *2,1* ,172 7+$7 1(*27,$7,21 )25 7+( /,&(16( )25 7+( 3(23/(62)7 62)7:$5( :+$7 ,03$&7 :28/' 7+$7 +$9( 21 7+( 1(*27,$7,21 7+( 35,&( 7+$7 7+(< ' (1' 83 :,7+" 05 0,77(/67$('7 <285 +2125 &28/' , -867 67$7( $*$,1 285 &217,18$7,21 2%-(&7,21 72 7+,6 :+2/( /,1( 2) 48(67,21,1* &$//,1* )25 63(&8/$7,21 7+( &2857 <(6 29(558/(' 05 0,77(/67$('7 7+$1. <28 7+( :,71(66 ,1 0< 23,1,21 7+,6 :28/' ,1',&$7( 7+$7 6$3 :28/' 6(( 6,*1,),&$17 9$/8( ,1 86,1* 7+( 62)7:$5( $1' $&48,5,1* 7202552:12: $1' 7+(1 /$81&+,1* 7+,6 352*5$0 %(&$86( 7+(5( 6 75(0(1'286 5(9(18( 29(5 7+5(( <($56 :( *2 287 $127+(5 7(1 0217+6 ,1 7+( /,&(16( 3(5,2' $1' 7+(1 $// 7+26( &219(57(' &86720(56 :+(7+(5 ,7 6 :+(7+(5 ,7 6 :+(7+(5 ,7 6 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 72 05 26:$/' +( 6$,' +, %(51' $1' *5(* ,7 6$<6 7+20$6 =,(0(1 ,1 0< 7($0 +$6 387 72*(7+(5 )25 7+( %2$5' $ 3(23/(62)7 $77$&. 352*5$0 $1' 7+( '2&80(17 :( 6$: $ 020(17 $*2 :,7+ 7+( 352-(&7,216 7+$7 :$6 3$57 2) 7+,6 3(23/(62)7 $77$&. 352*5$0 $1' $1' 7+$7 :$6 7+,6 '2&80(17 7+,6 '2&80(17 ,6 &$//(' $ 52$' 0$3 )25 3(23/(62)7 &86720(56 72 6$3 62 12: 7+( (0$,/ ,6 $77$&+,1* 7+,6 '2&80(17 7+( 52$' 0$3 $1' ,7 6 &20081,&$7,1* ,7 6$<6 05 =,(0(1 ,1 0< 7($0 +$6 387 72*(7+(5 )25 7+( %2$5' $ 3(23/(62)7 $77$&. 352*5$0 (1&/26(' 3/($6( ),1' 7+( /$7(67 9(56,21 $1' 7+(1 ,7 6$<6 +(11,1* /(2 *(5' $1' 6+$, +$9( *,9(1 ,1387 $1' (;7(16,9( *8,'$1&( 21 7+,6 $1' +(11,1* 6 05 .$*(50$11 21 7+( (;(&87,9( %2$5' /(2 ,6 05 $327+(.(5 *(5' 6 05 26:$/' $1' 7+(1 6+$, ,6 05 $*$66, 62 ,7 &/($5/< ,1',&$7(6 72 0( 7+$7 7+( %2$5' 0(0%(56 $5( ,192/9(' ,1 7+( 352&(66 7+(< 5( &5($7,1* 7+( 352-(&7,216 7+(< 5( $&&(37,1* 7+( 352-(&7,216 $1' ,7 6 9(5< 67521* ,1)250$7,21 $%287 :+$7 7+( 0$1$*(0(17 7($0 :$6 3/$11,1* 72 '2 4 62 $1' 7+$7 ,6 7+( '2&80(17 :,7+ 7+( 0,//,21 ,1 7+( ),567 7+5(( <($56" $ <(6 ,7 ,6 4 7+$7 +$6 7+$7 '$7( ,1 ,7 $1' 7+$7 :$6 6(17 72 7+26( )285 %2$5'6 0(0%(56 5,*+7" 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 6 - November 9, 2010
0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 $ <(6 4 :( .12: 7+$7 )520 7+( 35,25 (;+,%,7 $ :( .12: 7+$7 4 12: 7+( ),)7+ %2$5' 0(0%(5 ,6 7+( 21/< 21( :+2 6 7(67,),(' ,1 7+,6 &28575220 05 %5$1'7 5,*+7" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 <28 // 5(&$// +( 7(67,),(' 7+$7 +( ','1 7 %(/,(9( 7+( 0,//,21 +( 6$,' 127 $7 $// , '21 7 %(/,(9( ,7 12: +2: '2 <28 &2175$67 :+$7 7+( )285 %2$5' 0(0%(56 :(5( '2,1* $7 7+( 7,0( 9(5686 :+$7 05 %5$1'7 6$,' /$67 )5,'$<" 05 0,77(/67$('7 <285 +2125 , 2%-(&7 7+$7 6 $5*80(17$7,9( 7+( &2857 29(558/(' 7+( :,71(66 :(// ,7 :$6 ',)),&8/7 72 $&&(37 05 %5$1'7 6 7(67,021< %(&$86( 2) 7+( 6,*1,),&$17 ,192/9(0(17 2) $// 7+( (;(&87,9( %2$5' 0(0%(56 $1' 3$57,&8/$5/< 7+( )$&7 7+$7 7+(< :(5( 3(5621$//< ,192/9(' $1' 7+( )$&7 7+$7 05 =,(0(1 :$6 )520 7+( 6833257 6(59,&(6 *5283 '2,1* 7+( 352-(&7,216 $1' :25.,1* 7+( 180%(56 83 )25 7+( %2$5' 72 $33529( 62 , :28/'1 7 $&&(37 7+$7 7(67,021< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 $1' ,1 7+( 23(1,1* 67$7(0(17 6$3 6 /$:<(56 6$,' 7+$7 7+(6( 180%(56 :(5( 0$5.(7,1* +<3( ,6 7+,6 0$5.(7,1* +<3(" $ 12 ,7 6 127 7+(6( 180%(56 $5( &20,1* )520 7+( %86,1(66 3(23/( 7+$7 581 7+( %86,1(66 7+(< 5( &20,1* 287 2) $ 6833257 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55 0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 $1' 7+(1 ,7 6$<6 6$3 :,// 6,3+21 2)) 7+( &$6+ )/2: 7+$7 25$&/( 1(('6 72 %8,/' 25 $&48,5( ,76 1(;7 *(1(5$7,21 $33/,&$7,216 62 7+$7 :$6 $1' 7+(1 ,7 *2(6 21 $1' 6$<6 6$3 :,// (67$%/,6+ 25 5(,19,*25$7( 5(/$7,216+,36 :,7+ 327(17,$//< 7+286$1'6 2) 1(: $1' (;,67,1* &86720(56 $1' , 7+,1. 7+(< +$' '2&80(17(' 7+(5( :(5( -2,17 &86720(56 7+$7 +$' 6$3 $1' 3(23/(62)7 $1' 7+(< :(5( *2,1* 72 7$5*(7 7+$7 *5283 4 /(7 0( $6. <28 -867 21( 48(67,21 ,) , &28/' ,17(55837 <28 3/($6( 81'(5 675$7(*< :+(5( ,7 67$576 %< 2))(5,1* )8// 0$,17(1$1&( $1' 6833257 2) 3(23/(62)7 $1' -' (':$5'6 6<67(06 :+$7 ',' 7+$7 +$9( 72 '2 :,7+ 7+( 1(*27,$7,216 7+$7 6+28/' +$9( %((1 7$.,1* 3/$&( )25 $ /,&(16(" $ :(// 7+$7 6 5($//< .(< %(&$86( :+(1 ,7 6$<6 )8// 0$,17(1$1&( $1' 6833257 7+$7 6 &$//(' 9(1'25 /(9(/ 6(59,&( $1' 72 +$9( 9(1'25 /(9(/ 6(59,&( 21 7+( 25$&/( 352'8&76 <28 1((' 7+( 62)7:$5( $1' 7+( 0$7(5,$/6 7+$7 $5( &23<5,*+7(' 62 7+(< :28/' 1((' 7+26( 0$7(5,$/6 $1' &23<5,*+7(' 3523(57,(6 72 2))(5 7+$7 7+$7 0$,17(1$1&( 7+$7 )8// 0$,17(1$1&( 6(59,&( :+,&+ :$6 67(3 21( 2) 352*5$0 4 $// 5,*+7 $1' 7+(1 ),1$//< .(< 7$&7,&6 :+$7 6 7+( 6,*1,),&$1&( 2) 6$3 6 7+,1.,1* 7+(5(" $ :(// 7+,6 21( ,6 9(5< ,03257$17 &$86( 21( 2) 285 7+28*+76 <(67(5'$< :$6 7+( ,03257$1&( 2) 7,0,1* $1' 7+,6 6+2:6 +2: )2&86(' 6$3 6 0$1$*(0(17 :$6 21 7+( 7,0( 72 '2 7+,6 ,7 :$6 2) 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 *5283 7+(< 5( %(,1* $33529(' %< 05 $*$66, +($' 2) 352'8&76 05 $327+(.(5 +($' 2) 6$/(6 $1' 7+,6 ,6 5($//< $ 352*5$0 72 7$.( 352'8&7 $1' $1' $/62 05 26:$/' +($' 2) 6(59,&( 62 7+( +($' 2) 6(59,&( 7+( +($' 2) 352'8&7 $1' +($' 2) 6$/(6 $5( 7$.,1* 7+,6 1(: 352'8&7 2))(5,1* 72 7+( 0$5.(7 $1' 62 )520 0< 3(563(&7,9( ,7 6 7+2528*+/< ,1',&$7,9( 2) 0$1$*(0(17 6 (;3(&7$7,216 $7 7+( 7,0( (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 $// 5,*+7 /(7 6 /22. $7 7+( 1(;7 (;+,%,7 (;+,%,7 3/($6( :+$7 '2(6 7+,6 7(// <28 $%287 6$3 6 7+,1.,1* $7 7+( 7,0( 7+(< 6+28/' +$9( %((1 1(*27,$7,1* )25 $ /,&(16(" $ 7+,6 *2(6 72 )$&7256 $1' 62 21( 7+( ,03$&7 21 25$&/( )520 6$3 6 3(563(&7,9( $1' $/62 7+( (;3(&7$7,216 32,17 287 81'(5 *2$/ , // 32,17 287 285 *2$/ ,6 72 &219(57 7+( 0$-25,7< 2) 7+( 3(23/(62)7 $1' -' (':$5'6 &86720(56 %$6( 72 6$3 $1' &217$,1 25$&/( 6 327(17,$/ *52:7+ ,1 7+( 1(;7 *(1(5$7,21 $33/,&$7,21 0$5.(7 62 7+$7 6 7+( *2$/ $1' 7+(1 81'(5 675$7(*< ,7 &20(6 %$&. 72 67(3 21( %< 2))(5,1* )8// 0$,17(1$1&( $1' 6833257 3(23/(62)7 $1' -' (':$5'6 6<67(06 $1' 7+(1 ,7 *2(6 21 $1' 6$<6 :,7+ )$925$%/( 83*5$'( /,&(16,1* 7(506 72 6$3 1(7:($9(5 7+$7 6 67(3 7:2 :+,&+ ,6 7+( ,17(*5$7,21 352'8&76 $1' 8/7,0$7(/< 67(3 7+5(( 6 0<6$3 (53 7+$7 6 7+( &219(56,21 72 6$3 7+(,5 $33/,&$7,216 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 7+( (66(1&( ,7 6$<6 5($&+ 287 72 7+( -2,17 62 ,7 6$<6 -2,17 6$3 3(23/(62)7 -'( $&&28176 ,7 6$<6 :,7+,1 7+( */2%$/ (67$%/,6+(' , 7+,1. ,7 6 7+(< +$' 2) */2%$/ :(5( 7+(,5 &86720(56 29(5 7+( 1(;7 '$<6 :+,&+ ,6 )(%58$5< $1' $**5(66,9(/< &219(57 7+(,5 0$,17(1$1&( &2175$&76 72 6$3 $1' 7+(1 )$&,/,7$7( $'237,21 ,00(',$7( $'237,21 2) 1(7:($9(5 $1' 7+( 3/$11(' $'237,21 2) 0<6$3 (53 $7 3(23/(62)7 $1' -'( ,167$//$7,216 :,7+,1 7+26( (17(535,6(6 $1' 62 ,7 6+2:6 7+$7 7+( 1(;7 '$<6 7+(< :$17(' 72 *2 $)7(5 $/0267 &86720(56 $1' &219(57 7+(0 62 ,7 6+2:6 0( 7+$7 7+,6 :$6 9(5< ,03257$17 72 0$1$*(0(17 $7 7+$7 7,0( 72 *(7 ,172 7+( 0$5.(7 $1' 7+(< 1(('(' 7+( 62)7:$5( 4 62 7+(< 5( *2,1* $)7(5 7+( */2%$/ 67(3 21( 67(3 7:2 67(3 7+5((" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 62 /(7 6 /22. $7 <(7 $127+(5 '2&80(17 7+,6 21( ,6 (;+,%,7 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 :+$7 ,6 7+( 6,*1,),&$1&( 2) 7+,6 (9,'(1&(" $ 7+,6 7+,6 ,6 )520 &200(176 7+$7 05 $*$66, 0$'( 7+(5( :$6 $ &21)(5(1&( &$// 21 -$18$5< 7+ :+(5( 6$3 ,1752'8&(' 7+( 7202552:12: $1' 6$)( 3$66$*( 352*5$0 $1' 7+(< :(5( 7(//,1* 7+(,5 &86720(56 $1' 7+( 38%/,& $1' $1$/<676 $%287 :+$7 7+(< :(5( *2,1* 72 '2 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 6 - November 9, 2010
SHEET 6

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 $1' )520 7+,6 75$16&5,37 7+(5( 6 620( ,03257$17 &20081,&$7,21 05 $*$66, 0$'( :+2 6 7+( &+,() 7(&+12/2*< 2)),&(5 $1' (;(&87,9( %2$5' 0(0%(5 $1' , $/62 5($' 7+528*+ 7+,6 %(&$86( ,7 7$/.6 $%287 5($//< :+$7 , // &$// 7+( 9$/8( 352326,7,21 +2: ,03257$17 7+,6 :$6 72 6$3 ,7 6$<6 $1' 7202552:12: ,6 7+( 9(+,&/( 7+528*+ :+,&+ 7+(< *(7 7+( 0$,17(1$1&( 6(59,&(6 6257 2) 7+$7 ),567 6(17(1&( $1' $ +$/) $1' 7+(1 ,7 '5236 '2:1 $1' +( 6 %(,1* $6.(' $ 48(67,21 $%287 6257 2) 7+( *2$/ 2) 7+,6 7+(< 7+(1 6$< 62 $6 $ 5(68/7 2) 7+$7 %$6,&$//< +( 6$<6 ,) <28 :$17 72 /22. $7 ,7 )520 6257 2) 7+( ),1$1&,$/6 3(563(&7,9( 7+( 5$7,21$/( ,6 025( $5281' 7+( 9$/8( $1' 7+(1 ,7 6$<6 7+$7 7+(6( &86720(56 5(35(6(17 $6 $ 327(17,$/ 6(7 2) &86720(56 )25 6$3 $33/,&$7,216 5,*+7 7+528*+ 7+(5( $33/,&$7,216 62 12: +( 6 6$<,1* :+$7 6 7+( 9$/8( 2) 7+,6 72 6$3 ,1 285 $33/,&$7,21 %86,1(66" $1' ,7 6$<6 $1' ,7 6 7+( 9$/8( :$6 (67,0$7(' %< 25$&/( ,7 6$<6 5,*+7)8//< 25 :521*)8//< $6 %,//,21 $1' 7+(1 ,7 6$<6 7+,6 ,6 05 $*$66, 12: 7+( (;(&87,9( %2$5' 0(0%(5 +( 6$<6 :+$7 :( %(/,(9( ,6 7+$7 7+,6 &86720(5 %$6( 7+$7 6 %$6,&$//< 7+( &86720(56 2) 3(23/(62)7 ,6 127 1(&(66$5,/< &$37,9( %< 25$&/( 62 %(&$86( 7+(< +$9( 7+( 62)7:$5( 12: 7+(< '21 7 7+(< .12: 7+(< &$1 *2 &203(7( )25 7+(6( &86720(56 $1' ,7 6$<6 , 7+,1. 7+( &86720(5 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 %< 05 3,&.(77 4 ,7 6 $ '2&80(17 :( 9( 6((1 :+$7 '2(6 7+,6 +2: '2(6 7+,6 '2&80(17 5(/$7( 72 7+( 1(*27,$7,21 2) 7+( /,&(16( 7+$7 6+28/' +$9( 7$.(1 3/$&(" $ 7+,6 '2&80(17 :$6 35(6(17(' 72 7+( 7+( %2$5' $7 6$3 21 -$18$5< 7+ 2) $1' ,7 6 &216,67(17 :,7+ :+$7 :( %((1 7$/.,1* $%287 7+( /$67 )(: 0,187(6 , 7+,1. :+$7 6 ,03257$17 ,1 7+$7 ),567 7+$7 ),567 3+5$6( ,7 6$<6 7+( *2$/ ,7 6$<6 &219(57 $3352;,0$7(/< 3(5&(17 2) 7+( 3(23/(62)7 $1' -' (':$5'6 &86720(5 ,167$//$7,216 72 6$3 62 7+$7 6 7+( &219(56,21 $1' , 7+,1. :+$7 6 (9(1 025( ,03257$17 12: ,7 6$<6 3(5&(17 2) 6+$5(' &86720(56 $1' 7+$7 0($16 :+(5( $ &86720(5 $/5($'< +$6 6$3 ,1 ,76 , 7 6+23 $1' $/62 +$6 3(23/(62)7 25 -' (':$5'6 62 %$6,&$//< $ /27 2) 7,0(6 7+(5( 6 ,7 6 $ 6+$5(' -2,17 $&&2817 $1' 7+,6 $//2:6 6$3 12: 72 75< 72 %5,1* 7+$7 3(23/(62)7 $33/,&$7,21 6$< )25 +80$1 5(6285&( ,172 7+(,5 %86,1(66 62 7+$7 6 $1 ,03257$17 *2$/ 2) 7+$7 &219(56,21 $1' ,7 *2(6 '2:1 7+( 3$*( 7$/.6 $%287 7+5(( 27+(5 2%-(&7,9(6 ',65837 25$&/( 6 $%,/,7< 72 3$< )25 7+( $&48,6,7,21 287 2) &$6+ )/2: 7+$7 6 )$&725 7:2 ,7 6$<6 6+5,1. 7+(,5 7+$7 6 25$&/( 6 6+$5( 2) 7+( $33/,&$7,21 0$5.(7 7+$7 6 *2$/ 7:2 $1' 7+(1 ,7 6$<6 ',6&5(',7 7+(,5 ())2576 7+$7 6 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 %$6( +$6 72 0$.( 7+( &+2,&( 5,*+7 12: 62 7+,6 7(//6 0( 7+$7 ,7 6 7+( (;3(&7$7,21 ,7 6 7+( *2$/ ,7 6 7+( 2%-(&7,9( 2) 6$3 6 0$1$*(0(17 72 *2 $)7(5 $// &86720(56 $1' 72 75< 72 $&+,(9( $ %,* 3,(&( 2) 7+$7 %,//,21 9$/8( 4 $1' 21/< )25 0$,17(1$1&(" $ 12 7+,6 :28/' %( )25 (9(5<7+,1* ,7 %$6,&$//< 6$<6 ,1 7+(5( )25 6$3 $33/,&$7,216 62 0$,17(1$1&( ,6 21/< 6257 2) 7+( 9(+,&/( 7+( (1$%/(5 72 *(7 72 7+( $33/,&$7,21 6$/( 4 $1' 7+,6 ,6 $ 67$7(0(17 0$'( %< 05 $*$66, :+(1" $ 7+,6 :$6 21 -$18$5< 7+ $1' ,7 :$6 $ &21)(5(1&( &$// :,7+ ,7 :$6 $ 38%/,& &21)(5(1&( &21)(5(1&( &$// 72 ,19(67256 $1' 7+( $1$/<676 $1' 7+( &86720(56 4 $1' :+$7 6 7+( '$< 7+( /,&(16( 6+28/' +$9( 67$57('" $ %$6,&$//< 7+$7 :28/' %( 7+( '$< 7+(< :28/' 1((' 7+( /,&(16( 72 $&78$//< +$9( 7+,6 3+21( &$// $1' $11281&( 7+,6 352*5$0 ,1 $ :$< 7+$7 :28/' %( <28 .12: /(*$/ 4 62 ,6 7+(5( $1< '28%7 $%287 :+$7 6$3 :28/' %( 7+,1.,1* ,1 1(*27,$7,1* 7+,6 /,&(16( +$' 7+(< '21( 7+$7" $ 0< 3(563(&7,9( 7+(< :28/' 7$.( 7+( /,&(16( $1' 3$< 7+( $335235,$7( 9$/8( 72 72 %( $%/( 72 *2 $1' 387 7+,6 3/$1 ,172 3/$&( 4 $// 5,*+7 /(7 6 /22. $7 (;+,%,7 1(;7 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 25$&/( $*$,1 ',6&5(',7 25$&/( 6 ())2576 72 &5($7( $ 1(;7 *(1(5$7,21 $33/,&$7,21 3/$7)250 62 7+(6( *2 72 *2$/6 7:2 $1' 7+5(( $1' :28/' 0$.( 7+( /,&(16( 08&+ 025( 9$/8$%/( 72 6$3 4 $1' ,1 <285 23,1,21 :28/' 6$3 3$< )25 7+( $&&(66 72 62)7:$5( ,1 25'(5 72 ,1,7,$7( $1' $&+,(9( 7+(6( *2$/6" $ <(6 72 +$9( 7+( $%,/,7< 72 72 &219(57 3(5&(17 2) 7+( &86720(56 25 72 +$9( $ +81'5(' 3(5&(17 2) 7+( 6+$5(' &86720(56 7+( <(6 7+(< :28/' '2 7+$7 4 %( :257+ $ /27 $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $// 5,*+7 /(7 6 7$.( $ /22. $7 $127+(5 '2&80(17 ,1 (9,'(1&( 3/$,17,))6 (;+,%,7 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 :+$7 6 7+( 5(/(9$1&( 2) 7+,6 '2&80(17 05 0(<(5" $ 7+,6 '2&80(17 &20(6 %$&. 72 )$&725 :+,&+ ,6 7+( (;3(&7(' ),1$1&,$/ %(1(),76 25 *2$/6 $1' 7+,6 ,6 -$18$5< 7+ 7+ ,7 6 $ 0((7,1* :+(5( 7+(5( 6 $1 ,17(*5$7,21 %(7:((1 7202552:12: $1' 6$3 $1' :+$7 :$6 ,03257$17 +(5( :$6 7+(5( :$6 620( &20081,&$7,21 ,1 7+( ,17(*5$7,21 0((7,1* $%287 7+( 327(17,$/ &86720(56 $1' ,7 6$<6 :,7+ 6&(1$5,2 ,7 6$<6 &86720(56 ,1 $1' 7+(1 :+$7 <28 // 6(( :+,&+ ,6 ,03257$17 72 7+( 5,*+7 +$1' 6,'( 7+$7 6$<6 ),9( 7,0(6 25,*,1$/ 7202552:12: 3/$11,1* 62 7+$7 ,1',&$7(6 72 0( 7+$7 6$3 12: ,6 *2,1* 72 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 6 - November 9, 2010
0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 7$.( 7202552:12: )520 %(,1* $ 60$// 23(5$7,21 $1' 7+(1 386+ ,7 $6 3$57 2) 6$)( 3$66$*( 72 %(,1* 08&+ %,**(5 23(5$7,21 ,7 6 $ ),9( 7,0(6 08/7,3/( ,1 7(506 2) (;3(&7$7,216 $1' 7+(1 ,7 6$<6 6&(1$5,2 7+( (;3(&7$7,216 :28/' %( &86720(56 ,1 $1' 21&( $*$,1 7+( 5()(5(1&( 72 7202552:12: $1' $ ),9( 7,0(6 )$&725 $1' , %(/,(9( 7+$7 05 =,(0(1 7(67,),(' ,1 '(326,7,21 7+$7 7+( 352-(&7,21 :$6 025( &216(59$7,9( $1' 7+( :$6 :+$7 +( &$//(' 025( 83%($7 4 $// 5,*+7 /(7 6 /22. $7 6/,'( 2) 7+$7 6$0( '2&80(17 ,7 6 7+( 1(;7 3257,21 7+,6 ,6 3$*( 2) (;+,%,7 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 :+$7 '2(6 7+,6 6+2:" $ 7+,6 :$6 $/62 3$57 2) 7+( ,17(*5$7,21 $1' 7+,6 *2(6 %$&. 72 )$&725 7+( *2$/6 2) 86,1* 7+( 62)7:$5( ,7 6$<6 7+,6 ,6 7+( 0(5*(5 $1' 7+( 0(5*(5 0($16 7+,6 ,6 7+( 0(5*(5 :,7+ 7202552:12: 62 7+,6 ,6 7+( &20%,1$7,21 2) 6$3 :,7+ 7202552:12: 7+( 0(5*(5 35(6(176 $ +8*( 23325781,7< )25 86 62 12: 7+,6 ,6 7+( &20%,1(' 6$3 7202552:12: *5283 $1' 7+(1 ,7 6$<6 $1' 7+,6 *(76 %$&. 72 7+( ,03257$1&( 2) 7+( 62)7:$5( $1' 7202552:12: ,7 6$<6 7202552:12: :,// 6(59( $6 $ 0$-25 &251(56721( 2) 285 *2 72 0$5.(7 675$7(*< $6 285 .(< 6(59,&( '(/,9(5< 81,7 $1' 62 :( %((1 7$/.,1* $%287 +2: 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55 0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 4 :+< ',' <28 )2&86 21 -$18$5< 21 '(&(0%(5 '(&(0%(5 -$18$5< " $ :(// $6 , 0(17,21(' 72 7+( -85< <(67(5'$< 7+$7 :+(1 <28 9$/8( 7+( )$,5 0$5.(7 9$/8( 2) 7+( 3523(57< 7+( 3523(57< ,1 7+,6 &$6( <28 )2&86 21 :+$7 6 .12:1 $7 7+( 7,0( $1' :+$7 :(5( 7+( (;3(&7$7,216 2) 7+( 3$57,(6 $1' , 0 /$<,1* 287 )25 <28 7+( (;3(&7$7,216 2) 21( 3$57 2) 7+$7 1(*27,$7,1* *5283 $1' 7+$7 6 6$3 4 $// 5,*+7 12: %$6(' 21 $// 7+( (9,'(1&( <28 5(9,(:(' 05 0(<(5 ',' <28 &$/&8/$7( 6$3 6 (;3(&7(' ),1$1&,$/ *$,16 )520 7+( /,&(16( +2: 08&+ 7+(< :28/' (;3(&7 72 *$,1 )520 7+,6 /,&(16(" $ <(6 , +$9( 4 $1' +2: ',' <28 '2 7+$7" $ :(// , '(9(/23(' $ ),1$1&,$/ 02'(/ $1' )520 7+$7 , :$6 $%/( 72 &20( 83 :,7+ &(57$,1 ),1$1&,$/ '$7$ 7+$7 , // 7$/. 72 <28 $%287 $1' 6+2: <28 $1' 7+(1 &$0( 83 :,7+ :+$7 , // &$// 7+( 6257 2) 7+( 35(6(17 9$/8( 2) 2) 7+( *$,16 7+$7 6$3 :28/' :28/' &20( ,172 ,) 7+(< :(5( 72 $&48,5( 7+( 62)7:$5( ,1 7+,6 1(*27,$7,21 62 , +$9( $ 6/,'( 7+$7 6+2:6 7+26( 5(9(18( 6285&(6 05 3,&.(77 /(7 6 6+2: 7+( 1(;7 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 05 3,&.(77 7+(5( :( *2 4 7+,6 ,6 (;+,%,7 $*$,1 %87 <28 9( $''(' 620( $1$/<6,6 72 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 ,03257$17 7+$7 :$6 4 12: ,1 +,6 23(1,1* 67$7(0(17 6$3 6 $77251(< 72/' 7+( -85< 7+$7 4827( 7202552:12: :$6 $ 9(5< 9(5< 60$// 3$57 &/26(' 4827( 2) 6$3 6 6$)( 3$66$*( 352*5$0 ,6 7+( (9,'(1&( &216,67(17 :,7+ 7+$7 67$7(0(17" $ 12 ,7 6 127 $1' &(57$,1/< ,7 6 127 &216,67(17 $7 7+( 7,0( 2) 7+( 3/$11,1* $1' 7+( (;3(&7$7,216 $1' 7+( 52//287 2) 7+,6 352*5$0 $1' ,7 :$6 ,7 :$6 $%62/87(/< 5()(55(' 72 $6 7+( &251(56721( ,7 :$6 127 $ 60$// 3$57 $1' 7+(< :(5( *2,1* 72 7$.( 7202552:12: :,7+ 7+( 62)7:$5( $1' 5$03 ,7 83 $1' 0$.( ,7 $ %,* 3$57 2) 7+(,5 352*5$0 72 &219(57 4 12: :( 9( *21( 7+528*+ 620( 2) 7+( (9,'(1&( 2) 5(/$7,1* 72 7+( )$&7256 7+$7 7+$7 :28/' %( ,1 6$3 6 0,1' :+(1 ,7 :28/' (17(5 ,172 $ 1(*27,$7,21 )25 $ 3(23/(62)7 /,&(16( ,6 7+(5( 27+(5 (9,'(1&( 5(/(9$17 72 7+26( )$&7256" $ <(6 7+(5( ,6 4 $1' :,7+287 )25 7+( 6$.( 2) 7,0( :( 5( 127 *2,1* 72 6+2: ,7 $// %87 +$9( <28 %$6(' <285 23,1,21 21 127 -867 7+,6 (9,'(1&( %87 $// 2) 7+( (9,'(1&(" $ <(6 $1' , :$6 3$57,&8/$5/< )2&86(' 21 7+( '(&(0%(5 $1' -$18$5< 7,0( ,1 7+2528*+/< 81'(567$1',1* 7+( (;3(&7$7,216 2) 6$3 0$1$*(0(17 29(5 7+( '(9(/230(17 $1' /$81&+ $1' 352-(&7(' *2$/6 $1' 2%-(&7,9(6 $1' &86720(56 2) 86,1* 7+( 62)7:$5( $1' $&48,5,1* 7202552:12: $1' /$81&+,1* 6$)( 3$66$*( 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 ,7 :+$7 '2(6 7+$7 6+2:" $ 5,*+7 62 :+(1 <28 0(17,21(' ',' , '2 $ &$/&8/$7,21 <(6 , '(9(/23(' $ 02'(/ $1' , :(17 %$&. 72 7+( 7+( '2&80(176 )520 6$3 $1' :+$7 , )2&86(' 21 :$6 7+( 5(9(18( 7+$7 7+(< :28/' *$,1 )520 7+5(( 0$-25 6285&(6 $1' 7+( %/8( 7+(5( , 9( +,*+/,*+7(' 7+(< ' +$9( 0$,17(1$1&( 5(9(18(6 7+$7 7+(< :28/' ($51 )520 6(59,&,1* 3(23/(62)7 6(&21'/< 7+(< :28/' +$9( 6$/(6 2) 27+(5 6$3 352'8&76 , 0(17,21(' $ 020(17 $*2 7+$7 :28/' %( 7+( &5266 6(// ,7(06 /,.( 1(7:($9(5 $1' 8/7,0$7(/< ,1 7+( *5((1 7+(5( 7+$7 6 7+( &219(56,21 5(9(18( 7+$7 7+(< :28/' ($51 )520 6(//,1* 7+(,5 352'8&76 72 7+( 6$3 $33/,&$7,216 $1' 62 , :(17 %$&. 72 7+(,5 3/$11,1* '2&80(176 $1' , %8,/7 $ ),1$1&,$/ 02'(/ 72 7$.( 7+26( 5(9(18(6 352-(&7 287 7$.( 7+( &86720(56 $7 7+( $02817 2) 7+(< :28/' %( &+$5*(' 3(5 <($5 )25 7+( 9$5,286 352'8&76 352-(&7 ,7 287 29(5 7,0( /22. $7 7+( &267 7+$7 7+(< :28/' +$9( 72 63(1' 72 72 0$.( 7+26( 5(9(18(6 &$0( 83 :,7+ 352),76 $1' %528*+7 7+$7 %$&. ,7 6 &$//(' ',6&2817,1* 72 -$18$5< $1' ,7 3529,'(6 %$6,&$//< 7+( 1(7 35(6(17 9$/8( 352),7 25 *$,1 7+$7 6$3 :28/' ($51 ,) 7+(< :(5( 72 86( 7+( 62)7:$5( 4 $// 5,*+7 /(7 6 *2 72 7+( 1(;7 6/,'( 7+(1 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 6 - November 9, 2010
SHEET 7

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 %< 05 3,&.(77 4 :+$7 ,6 7+,6 6((06 7+,6 0$< +$9( 0$< 6(7 7+( 5(&25' )25 0267 &203/,&$7(' 6/,'( :+$7 '2(6 7+,6 21( 6+2:" $ :(// 7+,6 21( 6 48,7( %86< %87 , :$17(' 72 ,1',&$7( $1' 6+2: 72 7+( -85< 7+( 9$5,286 ,13876 7+$7 *2 ,172 7+( ),1$1&,$/ 02'(/ $1' 81'(5 )$&725 %$6,&$//< , 0(17,21(' 72 ),*85( 287 7+( 5(9(18(6 7+$7 7+(< :28/' ($51 '('8&7 7+( &2676 ,7 :28/' 7$.( 72 ($51 7+26( 5(9(18(6 $1' &20( 83 :,7+ 352),76 $1' 62 ,7 6 $/0267 /,.( '2,1* $ $1 ,1&20( 67$7(0(17 )25 352-(&7(' %86,1(66 127 ',66,0,/$5 72 :+$7 06 &$7= 7(67,),(' 72 <(67(5'$< $%287 :+(1 <28 :+(1 <28 9$/8( $1 $&48,6,7,21 $1' /22. $7 352-(&7(' 5(9(18(6 $1' &2676 $1' 352),76 62 7+( ,13876 +(5( :(5( ),567 180%(5 2) &86720(56 %(&$86( ,7 $// 67$576 :,7+ &86720(56 $1' ,1 7+,6 &$6( , :25.(' 2)) 2) 0$,17(1$1&( &86720(56 $1' $1' , 02'(/(' 287 7:2 6(3$5$7( 6&(1$5,26 7+$7 <28 // 6(( ,1 $ 020(17 21( :$6 :(5( 3529,'(' 0$,17(1$1&( )25 7+( 3(5,2' 2) 7,0( :+(1 7202552:12: 23(5$7(' 7+528*+ %$6,&$//< 2&72%(5 $1' 7+(1 $)7(5 7+$7 32,17 ,1 7,0( &86720(56 &219(57(' 72 6$3 $1' 7+(1 6(&21' 02'(/ 6+2:6 &219(57,1* $1' 21&( , +$' 7+26( &86720(56 7+(1 , -867 '2 &$/&8/$7,216 7+$7 6$< 2.$< 29(5 7,0( <28 7$.( 7+( &86720(56 <28 ),*85( 287 )520 1250$/ $775,7,21 +2: 0$1< :,// /($9( 3(5 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 $ 62 , 67$57(' :,7+ 7+(,5 352-(&7,216 , :(17 72 7+( $775,7,21 5$7(6 $1' 7+(1 7+( 7+,5' 52: 7+(5( , 08/7,3/,(' 7+( $9(5$*( 5(9(18( 3(5 &86720(5 %$6,&$//< 7,0(6 7+( 180%(5 2) &86720(56 $1' 62 )25 0$,17(1$1&( ,7 :$6 $ <($5 7+$7 6 7+( $9(5$*( <28 *(7 )25 ($&+ &86720(5 7+$7 6 7$.,1* 0$,17(1$1&( $1' 7+$7 :$6 3(5 6$3 6 %86,1(66 5(&25'6 $1' 7+(1 )520 7+(5( , :(17 $1' ,7 &$0( 83 :,7+ $1' 7+(1 21 7+( 5,*+7 +$1' 6,'( , '($/7 :,7+ :+(1 7+(< &219(57 $ &86720(5 7+(< 0$.( ,1 $ &219(56,21 $1' 7+(1 )25 7+( 27+(5 6$/(6 :+,&+ ,6 7+( &5266 6(// ,7(0 7+(< 0$.( 3(5 &5266 6(// 62 , 86(' 7+26( ,7(06 72 &20( 83 :,7+ 7+( $9(5$*( 5(9(18( 3(5 <($5 $1' 7+(1 08/7,3/,(' 7+$7 7,0(6 7+( 180%(5 2) &86720(56 $1' &$0( 83 :,7+ 727$/ 5(9(18( $1' 6(( 7+$7 6 7+( 1(;7 52: 62 7+$7 6 <285 &$/&8/$7,216 7+(5( $1' $6 <28 :25. '2:1 <28 7+(1 +$9( 72 '('8&7 &2676 $1' , 6$: )520 6$3 6 ),1$1&,$/ 5(&25'6 7+$7 7+(< %$6,&$//< :28/' +$9( 352),7 0$5*,16 2) 3(5&(17 62 , '('8&7 &267 2) 3(5&(17 $1' 7+$7 /($9(6 3(5&(17 7+(5( )25 7+( 352),7 7+$7 7+$7 6$3 :28/' 0$.( 4 7+$7 6 6$3 6 352),7 $6 352-(&7(' %< :+20" $ 7+$7 6 %$6(' 21 6$3 6 2:1 5(&25'6 4 80 +00 $ $1' 7+(1 ,7 6 08/7,3/,(' %< $ ',6&2817 )$&725 %(&$86( , 581 7+( &$/&8/$7,216 )520 287 72 62 7+(< 5( ',6&2817(' %$&. 72 -$18$5< :+,&+ %(&20(6 7+$7 6 7+$7 3(5&(17 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 <($5 7+$7 :$6 3(5&(17 $1' 7+$7 &$0( )520 620( (;3(&7(' $775,7,21 5$7(6 :( 6$: <(67(5'$< 4 /(7 0( *2 %$&. )25 $ 020(17 05 0(<(5 72 7+( &86720(56 <28 6$,' <28 67$57 :,7+ 7+( 180%(5 2) &86720(56 :+< '2 <28 :+$7 6 7+( 6,*1,),&$1&( 2) 7+$7" $ %(&$86( 7+( &86720(56 5(35(6(17 327(17,$/ 5(9(18(6 62 ,) <28 +$9( $ &86720(5 7+$7 <28 5( 3529,',1* 0$,17(1$1&( 6(59,&( 72 25 /,&(16( 352'8&7 72 <28 &+$5*( 7+(0 )25 7+( /,&(16( 25 <28 &+$5*( 7+(0 )25 7+( 0$,17(1$1&( 62 ,7 67$576 :,7+ $ 180%(5 2) &86720(56 $1' 7+(1 <28 /22. $7 +2: 0$1< :,// /($9( 3(5 <($5 %$6(' 21 +,6725,&$/ 75(1'6 $1' <28 387 $ 9$/8( 21 7+26( &86720(56 3(5 <($5 $1' 7+$7 *,9(6 <28 <285 5(9(18( 62 ,7 6 &86720(56 $9(5$*( $02817 3(5 <($5 ,1 5(9(18( 727$/ 5(9(18(6 $1' 7+(1 <28 '('8&7 &2676 )520 7+$7 4 $1' ',' <28 6(( (9,'(1&( 7+$7 6$3 6 723 0$1$*(0(17 :$6 7+,1.,1* $%287 7+,6 '($/ ,1 7(506 2) 7+( 180%(5 2) &86720(56 ,7 &28/' &219(57" $ <(6 4 $1' 62 +2: ',' <28 %$6( <285 (67,0$7(6 ,1 <285 ),1$1&,$/ 02'(/ 7+( $1' 7+(1 7+( &219(56,216 72 0<6$3 $33/,&$7,216 $1' 7+( &5266 6(//6" $ , 86(' 7+(,5 352-(&7,216 4 6$3 6 2:1 352-(&7,216" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $// 5,*+7 *2 $+($' 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 $1' 7+$7 6 )520 6$3 9$/8$7,21 '2&80(176 $1' 7+(1 , %5,1* ,7 %$&. 72 -$18$5< $1' 7+$7 6$<6 $6 &$/&8/$7(' $1' 7+(1 21&( , '2 7+$7 , .12: 7+( 9$/8( 2) 7+26( &86720(56 7+(1 , 581 ,7 29(5 5($//< 7:2 3(5,2'6 7+528*+ 7+( (1' 2) 5,*+7 %$6(' 21 +2: 7+(< ',' ,7 )25 7+( ),567 7+5(( <($56 $1' , $/62 581 ,7 287 7+528*+ 7+( (1' 2) 2&72%(5 :+,&+ :$6 7+( (1' 2) 7+( /,&(16( 3(5,2' $1' 7+(1 , +$' 21( 025( ,7(0 72 $'' 72 7+$7 $1' , .12: 7+$7 21&( $ &86720(5 ,6 &219(57(' ,7 +$6 )8785( 9$/8( 62 , '2 $ &$/&8/$7,21 6$<,1* 7+$7 7+$7 $ &219(57(' &86720(5 +$6 9$/8( 287 ,172 7+( )8785( $6 06 &$7= 7(67,),(' 72 <(67(5'$< &$1 %( )25 '(&$'(6 21&( <28 &219(57(' $1' 62 , 6$< :+$7(9(5 &86720(56 &219(57 , /22. $7 7+$7 9$/8( $1' , '2 ,7 7:2 :$<6 21( ,6 &$//(' $ 5(9(18( 08/7,3/( :+,&+ <28 08/7,3/< 7+( /$67 <($5 6 5(9(18( %< )285 7,0(6 $1' 7+$7 6 7+( )8785( 9$/8( 2) +$9,1* 7+$7 &86720(5 $1' 7+(1 6(&21'/< $ 3(5 &86720(5 9$/8( :+,&+ 0($16 7+$7 )25 (9(5< &86720(5 <28 +$9( <28 7+(5( 6 $ 35(6(17 9$/8( 2) 7+$7 $1' 7+(1 , 86(' 0,//,21 $1' 62 , 7$.( $// 7+26( ,7(06 $1' , 35(6(17 7+(0 $6 2) -$18$5< $1' 7+$7 6 +2: '2 , 0< ),1$1&,$/ *$,1 &$/&8/$7,216 4 62 <28 &$1 &$/&8/$7( %$6(' 21 6$3 6 7+,1.,1* $7 7+( 7,0( +2: 08&+ 021(< 7+(< 7+28*+7 7+(< :(5( *2,1* 72 352),7 )520 '2,1* 7+$7" $ 7+$7 6 5,*+7 )520 0$,17(1$1&( $1' &219(57,1* &86720(56 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 6 - November 9, 2010
0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 4 $// 5,*+7 /(7 6 *2 72 $1 (;$03/( 2) +2: <285 &$/&8/$7,216 :25. %(/,(9( 7+( 1(;7 6/,'( 6+2:6 7+$7 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 7+,6 ,6 7+,6 ,6 :+$7" $ 7+,6 ,6 21( 2) 7+( &$/&8/$7,216 2) , ',' 7+5(( $1' 62 7+,6 ,6 7+( 21( 7+$7 ,6 %$6(' 21 0$,17(1$1&( &86720(56 :,7+ &219(57,1* 72 6$3 $1' :( -867 '(6&5,%(' 7+( &$/&8/$7,21 , 7+,1. +(5( :+$7 6 ,03257$17 ,6 -867 72 6(( 7+$7 7+(5( 6 21 7+( /()7 +$1' 6,'( 7+5(( 6285&(6 2) 5(9(18( 62 <28 +$9( 0$,17(1$1&( 5(9(18( <28 +$9( 7+( $'',7,21$/ 352'8&7 6$/(6 :+,&+ ,6 7+( ,17(*5$7,21 352'8&76 $1' 7+(1 <28 +$9( 7+( &219(57(' &86720(5 6$/(6 $1' 7+(1 <28 // 6(( <28 +$9( $ 9$5,(7< 2) 52:6 %87 ,7 6 :+$7 , '(6&5,%(' $ 020(17 $*2 <28 +$9( 727$/ (;3(&7(' 5(9(18( /(66 &2676 <28 &20( 83 :,7+ 7+( (;3(&7(' 352),76 ,1 7+,6 &$6( 7+( 5(9(18( ,6 <28 7$.( 7+$7 '('8&7 7+( &2676 <28 &20( 83 :,7+ 7+( (;3(&7(' 352),76 $1' 7+(1 , $''(' 7+( $02817 72 7+( 5,*+7 +$1' 6,'( 7+(5( 2) 7+( )8785( ),1$1&,$/ *$,16 )520 7+26( &219(57(' &86720(56 $1' 8/7,0$7(/< <28 6(( 7+$7 7+( 9$/8( ',6&2817(' $6 %,//,21 ,7 6 $&78$//< $6 2) 86,1* )520 86,1* 7+,6 6&(1$5,2 :+,&+ ,6 0$,17(1$1&( &86720(56 :,7+ &219(57(' 62 7+$7 6 $1 ,//8675$7,21 2) 7+$7 &$/&8/$7,21 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55 0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 $%287 21 7+( %27720 /()7 7+( %,//,21 $1' 7+$7 :$6 %$6(' 21 0$,17(1$1&( &86720(56 :,7+ &219(57,1* $1' , 86(' $ 5(9(18( 08/7,3/( 7+(5( 2) $1' &$0( 83 :,7+ %,//,21 $1' 7+( 5,*+7 +$1' 6,'( 180%(5 $&78$//< ,6 $1 ,03257$17 180%(5 %(&$86( ,7 6+2:6 7+( )8// 9$/8( 2) 7+( &86720(5 &219(56,21 $1' 7+$7 6 $/62 %$6(' 21 0$,17(1$1&( &86720(56 &219(57 72 0<6$3 $1' 7+(1 7+(5( , 86(' $ 0,//,21 '2//$56 3(5 &86720(5 :+,&+ 5(35(6(176 %$6,&$//< 3(5 <($5 )25 <($56 7+$7 6 0$'( 83 2) 0$,17(1$1&( &5266 6(// %$6(' 21 +2: ,7 6 /22.(' $7 %< 6$3 6 0$1$*(0(17 $1' 7+( 836:,7&+ 62 )25 (9(5< &86720(5 7+$7 6:,7&+(' 29(5 72 6$3 $ 48$57(5 0,//,21 '2//$56 :28/' %( 0$'( 3(5 <($5 $1' 29(5 7(1 <($56 :+(1 , ',6&2817 7+$7 %$&. ,7 6 $%287 $ 0,//,21 '2//$56 2) 1(7 35(6(17 9$/8( 72 +$9( 7+$7 &219(57(' &86720(5 $1' 7+$7 6 7+( %,//,21 62 0< 5$1*( 2) %(1(),76 72 6$3 %$6(' 21 7+(,5 2:1 352-(&7,216 ,6 0,//,21 83 72 %,//,21 4 12: <28 ($5/,(5 5()(5(1&(' 72 7+( -85< 620( 6$3 (67,0$7(6 $7 7+( 7,0( 7+$7 7+(< &28/' *(7 &86720(56 25 7+( 0$-25,7< 2) 7+( &86720(56 25 05 $*$66, 6$,' &86720(56 ,) <28 86( 25 &86720(56 ,1 7+(6( &$/&8/$7,216 :+$7 :28/' %( 7+( 5(68/7" 127 7+( 35(&,6( 5(68/7 %87 :+$7 :28/' 7+$7 +2: :28/' 7+$7 ,03$&7 7+( &$/&8/$7,21" 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 4 $1' <28 6$,' <28 ',' 7+5(( &$/&8/$7,216 7+,6 ,6 21( 2) 7+(0" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $1' )25 7+( 27+(5 7:2 &$/&8/$7,216 <28 &+$1*(' 7+( 7+( $668037,21 $%287 &86720(56 $1' 5(&$/&8/$7('" $ 21( &$/&8/$7,21 +$6 $ ',))(5(17 180%(5 2) &86720(56 , 86(' , %(/,(9( ,7 6 $1' 7+(1 7+( 27+(5 &$/&8/$7,21 3876 $ +,*+(5 9$/8( 21 7+( )8785( ,7 3,&.6 83 $// )8785( 9$/8( ,1&/8',1* 0$,17(1$1&( &5266 6(// $1' 7+( 836:,7&+ 62 ,7 *,9(6 <28 $ 727$/ 9$/8$7,21 2) 7+$7 &86720(5 21&( ,7 6 &219(57(' 2)) 2) 3(23/(62)7 29(5 72 7+( 6$3 3/$7)250 4 $// 5,*+7 /(7 6 6(( 7+( 5(68/76 2) <285 7+5(( &$/&8/$7,216 05 0(<(5 &$1 <28 '(6&5,%( )25 7+( -85< :+$7 7+,6 6+2:6" (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 7+( :,71(66 <(6 7+,6 ,6 $ 6800$5< $1' ,7 6+2:6 81'(5 7+( 7+5(( &$/&8/$7,216 :+$7 , &$0( 83 :,7+ $1' 7+(1 &$/&8/$7,21 $ ,6 %$6(' 21 7+( 0$,17(1$1&( &86720(56 7+528*+ 7+( 3(5,2' 2) 7202552:12: 6 23(5$7,216 ,1 7+$7 3(5,2' %$6(' 21 :+$7 :$6 352-(&7(' %< 6$3 7+(5( :(5( &86720(56 7+$7 +$' 7+( &5266 6(// $1' :(5( $&78$//< &219(57(' 72 6$3 $1' 7+( (;3(&7(' 9$/8( 81'(5 7+$7 &$/&8/$7,21 $ :$6 0,//,21 21 $ 35(6(17 9$/8( %$6,6 $1' 7+(1 , 21 7+( 5,*+7 +$1' 6,'( , +$9( 7:2 287&20(6 )520 7+( &$/&8/$7,21 % 21( 2) 7+(0 :( -867 7$/.(' 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 $ :(// ,) <28 5( $7 &219(57(' &86720(56 ,1 &$/&8/$7,21 % $1' /(7 6 6$< <28 '28%/( 7+$7 72 21 7+( /2: (1' ,7 :28/' %( %,//,21 $1' 21 7+( +,*+ (1' ,7 :28/' %( ),9( 32,17 ,7 :28/' %( ),9( 32,17 $/0267 ),9( $1' $ +$/) %,//,21 $7 62 <28 &$1 6(( 7+( 9$/8( 3$57,&8/$5/< :+(1 <28 /22. $7 7+( )8785( 9$/8( 2) 7+( &219(57(' &86720(5 72 6(// 025( 352'8&7 $1' 025( /,&(16( 4 :+< ','1 7 <28 7$.( 05 $*$66, 6 (67,0$7( &86720(56" $ :(// , )(/7 7+$7 , +$' $ 5$1*( 2) &219(57(' &86720(56 , )(/7 7+$7 , 6$: :+$7 0$1$*(0(17 :$6 3/$11,1* 72 '2 $1' , :$17(' 72 %( 620(:+(5( :+(5( , 7+28*+7 :$6 5($621$%/( $1' , 7+,1. :,7+ 7+(6( 180%(56 +(5( , :28/' )2&86 <28 .12: 21 $// 7+5(( %87 <28 // 6(( ,1 $ 020(17 +2: , /22. $7 7+(0 ,1 &21-81&7,21 :,7+ 25$&/( 6,'( %87 , )((/ /,.( 7+(6( )8//< ,//8675$7( 7+( 327(17,$/ *$,16 $1' , 7+,1. 7+$7 7+( &86720(5 180%(5 6 5,*+7 7+(5( ,1 7+( 0,''/( 2) 7+( (;3(&7$7,216 4 $// 5,*+7 %()25( :( *2 72 7+( 25$&/( 6,'( 2) 7+( 7$%/( , :$17 72 5()(5(1&( 620( 7(67,021< )520 05 %5$1'7 21 )5,'$< 7+( 21/< %2$5' 0(0%(5 72 &20( 72 7+,6 75,$/ 6$,' 7+,6 ,6 $7 3$*( :( &$1 , 7+,1. :( +$9( 7+$7 75$16&5,37 ,) <285 +2125 :28/' 35()(5 , &28/' 5($' )520 ,7 +(5( :( *2 7+( 0$*,& 2) 7(&+12/2*< 7+,6 ,6 127 +2: :( ',' ,7 <($56 $*2 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 6 - November 9, 2010
SHEET 8

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 62 %(*,11,1* $7 /,1( 7+( 48(67,21 72 05 %5$1'7 /$67 )5,'$< 6$3 6 %86,1(66 $1' 25$&/( 6 %86,1(66 '(3(1'6 21 ,76 ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< &255(&7 6,5" 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 $1' 6$3 7$.(6 67(36 72 3527(&7 ,76 ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< )520 ,1)5,1*(0(17 &255(&7 6,5" 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 $1' ,1 )$&7 6$3 +$6 $ '(3$570(17 '(927(' 72 3527(&7,1* 6$3 6 ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< &255(&7" 7+$7 6 &255(&7 $1' 7+(1 ),1$//< :+(1 6$3 /,&(16(6 ,76 ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< ,76 62)7:$5( ,7 75,(6 72 *(7 0$;,080 5(7851 3266,%/( )520 ,7 &255(&7 6,5" ,7 ,6 7+( *2$/ 2) $1< (17(535,6( '2 7+(6( 67$7(0(176 +$9( $1< ,03$&7 21 <285 $1$/<6,6" $ <(6 , %(/,(9( 7+$7 ,7 $)),506 7+( 352&(66 :( 5( *2,1* 7+528*+ +(5( $%287 9$/8,1* 7+( ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< ,1 7+,6 &$6( 7+( 62)7:$5( ,1 7+,6 1(*27,$7,21 $1' , %(/,(9( , 0 &20,1* 83 :,7+ $ )$,5 0$5.(7 9$/8( 2) 7+,6 62)7:$5( ,7 6 127 7+( 0$;,080 9$/8( 7+$7 0$<%( 25$&/( :28/' :$17 %87 ,7 6 7+( )$,5 0$5.(7 9$/8( %87 7+,6 6+2:6 7+$7 7+,6 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 (;&/86,9( 5,*+76 72 7+26( &23<5,*+7(' 0$7(5,$/6 :+,&+ ,6 $ %,* ,03$&7 21 9$/8( $1' 7+(1 8/7,0$7(/< , '2 620( &$/&8/$7,216 81'(5 7+( 326,7,21 7+$7 25$&/( :28/' (;3(&7 72 72 /26( 7+5(( 7,0(6 &86720(56 $1' 7+(1 , '(021675$7( :+$7 7+( ,03$&7 2) 25$&/( 21 25$&/( 2) :+$7 7+$7 ,6 $7 7+( 7,0( 2) 7+( 1(*27,$7,21 62 7+,6 ,6 7+( 6758&785( 7+$7 , 6(7 83 72 (9$/8$7( 7+(,5 6,'( 2) 7+( 1(*27,$7,21 4 62 <28 <28 5(9,(:(' $// 7+( 5(/(9$17 (9,'(1&( $1' $1$/<=(' 7+(6( 7+5(( ,668(6 )520 25$&/( 6 67$1'32,17" $ 7+$7 6 5,*+7 4 $1' $6 72 *2$/6 25$&/( 6 *2$/6 )25 ,76 3(23/(62)7 $&48,6,7,21 <285 0$,1 &21&/86,216 :$6 7+$7 7+(< :$17(' $ 5(9(18( 675($0 021(< 7+$7 :28/' %( &20,1* )520 7+26( &86720(56" $ :(// 7+$7 6 5,*+7 7+(5( :$6 $%287 %,//,21 2) 0$,17(1$1&( 5(9(18( ,1 7+( 3(23/(62)7 $*5((0(17 3(23/(62)7 $&48,6,7,21 $1' 7+$7 :28/' &20( 72 25$&/( 81'(5 3527(&7,21 2) 7+( 62)7:$5( 4 $1' :( 6$: )520 7+( 0$5.(7 6/,'( <(67(5'$< 7+( 180%(5 7:2 $1' 180%(5 7+5(( 25$&/( $1' 62)7:$5( &20%,1(' 3/86 72 3(5&(17 $*$,167 3(5&(17 )25 6$3 +2: '2(6 7+$7 5(/$7( 72 7+(,5 *2$/" $ 21&( $*$,1 ,7 *$9( 25$&/( $ 08&+ %,**(5 )22735,17 ,7 :$6 08&+ 025( 2) $ 327(17,$/ 7+5($7 72 6$3 21&( 7+(< ',' 7+( 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 ,6 +2: /$5*( 7(&+12/2*< &203$1,(6 $3352$&+ 7+(,5 ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< 7+(< :$17 0$;,080 9$/8( ,7 6 :+$7 05 %5$1'7 6$,' %87 :( 5( +(5( &$/&8/$7,1* 7+( )$,5 0$5.(7 9$/8( 7+$7 :28/' %( /(66 7+$1 0$;,080 9$/8( 4 $// 5,*+7 /(7 6 7851 72 7+( 25$&/( 6,'( $1' :+$7 )$&7256 :28/' %( ,03257$17 72 25$&/( ,1 ,76 7+,1.,1* 6,77,1* 21 7+( 27+(5 6,'( 2) /,&(16( 1(*27,$7,21 7$%/(" $ , +$9( $ 6/,'( 21 7+$7 ,7 6 6,0,/$5 72 7+( 6758&785( 2) 7+( 6$3 6,'( $1' 62 <28 // 6$< 7+$7 <28 // 6(( 7+( 6$0( 7+5(( 1(*27,$7,21 )$&7256 $1' , -867 6(7 7+26( 83 21&( $*$,167 25 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 7+( :,71(66 7+,6 7,0( ,7 6 25$&/( 6 *2$/6 $1' , )2&86(' 21 7+( 3(23/(62)7 $&48,6,7,21 7:2 ,6 7+( 5,6. 72 25$&/( 2) ,76 ,19(670(17 ,1 3(23/(62)7 ,) ,7 *,9(6 $ /,&(16( 72 6$3 $1' 7+(1 /$67/< 25$&/( 6 (;3(&7(' ),1$1&,$/ ,03$&76 $1' 7+26( $5( -867 620( +,*+/,*+76 )520 7+( 5(68/76 2) 0< $1$/<6,6 7+$7 %$6,&$//< 7+(5( 6 0$,17(1$1&( 5(9(18( &86720(56 $6 3$57 2) 7+( 3(23/(62)7 $&48,6,7,21 :,7+ 7+( $&48,6,7,21 7+$7 '28%/(6 25$&/( 6 (17(535,6( 0$5.(76+$5( )25 $33/,&$7,216 7+$7 6 81'(5 *2$/ 21( 62 ,7 6 $ 9(5< ,03257$17 $&48,6,7,21 6(&21'/< 7+( 83)5217 3$,' 2) %,//,21 ,1&/8',1* 7+( 62)7:$5( $1' 0$7(5,$/6 ,1 7+,6 &$6( $1' :,7+ 7+,6 /,&(16( $ 9(5< ,03257$17 ,668( ,6 7+$7 25$&/( :,// %( *,9,1* 83 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 $&48,6,7,21 :,7+ 3(23/(62)7 4 12: 7+( 5,6. 7+$7 6 7+( 5,6. 2) *,9,1* 7+,6 /,&(16( *5$17,1* 7+,6 /,&(16( 72 72 :+2" 72 6$3" $ 72 6$3 7+$7 6 5,*+7 4 $1' :+$7 $5( 7+( 7:2 0$,1 5,6.6 <28 7+,1. 25$&/( ,) 25$&/( +$6 72 6,*1 /,&(16( 72 72 6$3 )25 7+,6 62)7:$5( $1' 6833257 0$7(5,$/6 :+$7 $5( 7+26( 5,6.6 7+$7 <28 &21&/8'( $5( 0267 ,03257$17 ,1 7+(,5 0,1'" $ ,7 6 ,00(',$7( ,03$&7 21 7+( 75$16$&7,21 %(&$86( 7+(< // +$9( &203(7,7,21 )25 7+26( &86720(56 $1' 7+(< /26( 7+( (;&/86,9( 5,*+76 72 7+$7 62)7:$5( 62 ,7 6 $ %,* ,03$&7 21 7+(,5 &$6+ )/2: 4 $1' 7+(1 ),1$//< 7+(< ' +$9( ,1 0,1' :(// :( :28/' /26( 620( 021(< ,) :( '2 7+,6 /,&(16( 62 :( 1((' 620(7+,1* 72 3$< 83 )25 ,7" $ 7+$7 6 5,*+7 7+(< 1((' 72 *(7 3$,' 83)5217 $1' 7+(< 1((' 72 81'(567$1' :+$7 7+$7 $02817 6+28/' %( 4 $// 5,*+7 /(7 6 /22. $7 620( 2) 7+( (9,'(1&( 7+$7 /(' <28 72 7+26( &21&/86,216 ),567 /(7 6 *2 72 (;+,%,7 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 :+$7 ,6 7+,6 $1' :+$7 '2(6 ,7 6+2:" $ 7+,6 :$6 4 $ '2&80(17 , 7+,1. :( ),567 6$: :,7+ 05 3+,//,36 $1' 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 6 - November 9, 2010
0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 7+(1 :( 6$: $/62 <(67(5'$< :,7+ 06 &$7= $ 5,*+7 7+,6 :$6 $ '2&80(17 7+$7 05 3+,//,36 $1' 06 &$7= 35(6(17(' 72 7+( 5$7,1* $*(1&,(6 :+(1 25$&/( $&48,5(' 3(23/(62)7 $1' -867 /$<6 287 7+26( ,03257$17 2%-(&7,9(6 $1' , 7+,1. 7+(< 5( &216,67(17 :,7+ +2: :( %((1 7$/.,1* $%287 7+( 75$16$&7,21 %87 21&( $*$,1 <28 +$9( 72 <28 .12: (;3$1' 7+( &86720(5 %$6( +$9( $ /$5*(5 $33/,&$7,216 5(6($5&+ $1' '(9(/230(17 %8'*(7 , 7+,1. 7+(< 7+( &203(7,7,9( 326,7,21,1* %$6,&$//< ,6 ,03257$17 7+$7 6 7+( ,1&5($6(' 0$5.(76+$5( ,1 7+( (17(535,6( 63$&( $1' 7+(1 7+,6 025( +,*+ 0$5*,1 5(&855,1* 5(9(18( %(&$86( 7+$7 6 7+( %,//,21 2) 0$,17(1$1&( 5(9(18( $7 7+( +,*+ 0$5*,16 7+$7 %5,1* 025( 7+$1 $ %,//,21 '2//$56 2) &$6+ )/2: 72 25$&/( $1' 7+(1 7+( 1(;7 7:2 5(/$7( 72 7+( 6+$5(+2/'(56 7+$7 7+,6 :$6 $ 326,7,9( 75$16$&7,21 72 7+( 6+$5(+2/'(56 ,1 7(506 2) 7+( ($51,1*6 $1' 7+(1 7+( /$67 21( 6 35(77< ,03257$17 ,7 6$<6 ,7 6 $ /2: 5,6. $&48,6,7,21 %$6(' 21 3/$11(' ,17(*5$7,21 62 25$&/( $7 7+( 7,0( 7+(,5 0$1$*(0(17 )(/7 7+$7 %(&$86( 7+(< +$' 7+( &86720(56 :+2 :(5( *(77,1* 6(59,&( 7+$7 :$6 3527(&7(' %< 7+( 62)7:$5( 7+$7 7+,6 :$6 *2,1* 72 %( ,7 6 $ /2: 5,6. $1' 12: :( 5( 3877,1* 7+(0 ,172 $ 1(*27,$7,21 :+(5( 7+(,5 5,6. *2(6 08&+ +,*+(5 62 7+$7 ,7 6 *2,1* 72 &+$1*( 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55 0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 &+$1*(5 +(5( 6 :+$7 +$33(16 7+(< 12: +$9( 121 (;&/86,9( 5,*+76 %$6,&$//< %(&$86( 7+(< +$9( 72 7+(< 5( ,1 $ 6,78$7,21 :+(5( 7+(< 5( 6+$5,1* 7+(,5 62)7:$5( :,7+ 7+( &203(7,1* 3529,'(5 7+$7 %(,1* 6$3 $1' 7+(< 5( *2,1* 72 +$9( $1 (;3(&7(' /266 2) &86720(56 0$5.(76+$5( $1' 5(9(18( 62 7+$7 6 :+$7 +$33(16 72 25$&/( $1' 7+(1 21 7+( *$,1 6,'( 6$3 3,&.6 83 7+( 62)7:$5( $1' &$1 *2 $1' &203(7( 72 72 +$9( 7+( &219(57(' &86720(56 7+( 0$5.(76+$5( *$,16 $1' 7+(,5 5(9(18(6 62 ,7 63/,76 %$6,&$//< 7+( %(1(),76 2) 7+( 75$16$&7,21 ,172 7+26( 7:2 &$7(*25,(6 4 '2(6 25$&/( +$9( $1< $7 7+,6 32,17 :( .12: 7+$7 6$3 +$6 7$.(1 7+( 3(23/(62)7 62)7:$5( :,7+287 $1< $87+25,=$7,21 :( .12: 7+(< 9( $'0,77(' $// /,$%,/,7< 21 $// &/$,06 7+(< 9( $'0,77(' 7+( &2175,%8725< ,1)5,1*(0(17 9,&$5,286 ,1)5,1*(0(17 '2(6 6$3 +$9( $1< &+2,&( 72 6$< 2+ 12 :( :21 7 /,&(16( 7+,6 72 <28 6$3" '2(6 '2(6 7+$7 ,6 7+$7 $1 237,21 $7 7+,6 32,17 $)7(5 $// 7+$7 6$3 +$6 '21(" $ :(// ,1 7+( 1(*27,$7,21 , 0 3877,1* %27+ 3$57,(6 ,1 7+(5( $6 %(,1* :,//,1* /,&(1625 $1' :,//,1* /,&(16(( $1' 62 -867 -867 /,.( :( :( +$9( 72 +$9( 25$&/( ,1 7+,6 1(*27,$7,21 $*5(( 72 *,9( 7+( 62)7:$5( 83 6$3 +$6 72 $*5(( 72 3$< 7+( )$,5 9$/8( )25 7+$7 62 ,7 6 7+$7 6 7+( $668037,21 , 0$.( ,1 7+,6 352&(66 4 7+$7 %27+ 6,'(6 +$9( 72 %( :,//,1*" 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 7+( 5,6. 352),/( :+(1 7+(< *2 ,172 7+( 1(*27,$7,21 4 :+(1 , $6.(' 05 3+,//,36 :+(1 :( :(17 7+528*+ 7+,6 ),567 /$67 7+856'$< , $6.(' +,0 +2: :28/' 7+,6 &+$1*( ,) <28 :(5( *2,1* 72 +$9( 72 1(*27,$7( $ /,&(16( :,7+ 6$3" $1' +( 6$,' 7+( :+2/( (9(5< )$&725 :28/' &+$1*( +2: :+$7 '2(6 7+,6 7(// <28 $%287 25$&/( 6 7+,1.,1* *2,1* ,172 $ 1(*27,$7,21 ,) 7+(< +$' 72 *,9( $ /,&(16( 72 6$3" $ , 7+,1. ,7 &20(6 %$&. 72 7+( )$&7 7+(< :28/' 1((' &(57$,17< 7+(< ' 1((' $1 83)5217 3$<0(17 ,7 :28/' +$9( 72 %( &+$5*( (128*+ 72 7$.( $:$< 7+( 67,1* 2) *,9,1* 83 7+( %,//,21 (;&/86,9( 5,*+76 72 3(23/(62)7 3523(57< 4 $// 5,*+7 /(7 6 *2 72 <285 1(*27,$7,21 )$&725 12 3/($6( 7+( 5,6.6 7+$7 :28/' 25$&/( :28/' (1&2817(5 ,1 1(*27,$7,1* 7+,6 /,&(16( 72 6$3 72 &29(5 :+$7 7+(< 722. 7+( 3523(57< 7+(< 722. )520 25$&/( :+$7 '2(6 7+,6 6/,'( 6+2:" (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 7+( :,71(66 7+,6 6/,'( 6+2:6 %$6,&$//< 21 /()7 +$1' 6,'( -$18$5< 7+ :,7+ 7+( $&48,6,7,21 2) 3(23/(62)7 25$&/( +$6 (;&/86,9( 5,*+76 72 7+( 62)7:$5( 0$7(5,$/6 7+(< // +$9( 1(: &86720(56 &20,1* ,1 72 %( 3$57 2) 7+( &20%,1(' %86,1(66 3(5&(17 ,1&5($6( ,1 0$5.(76+$5( $1' %,//,21 2) $118$/ 0$,17(1$1&( 5(9(18( $1' 7+(1 7+( 1(;7 '$< :+(1 7+(< '2 7+( /,&(16( 1(*27,$7,21 7+$7 $// &+$1*(6 $1' ,7 ,7 6 5($//< $ *$0( 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 $// 5,*+7 /(7 6 *2 72 1(*27,$7,21 )$&725 12 :+$7 25$&/( :28/' %( 7+,1.,1* $%287 7+( ),1$1&,$/ ,03$&7 21 ,7 2) 68&+ $ /,&(16( <28 +$9( $1 $1$/<6,6 2) 7+$7 05 0(<(5" $ <(6 , 9( *27 $ &+$57 7+$7 6+2:6 7+$7 48,&./< 6257 2) 7+( $3352$&+ , 722. $1' ,7 6 6,0,/$5 72 7+( $3352$&+ :,7+ 6$3 %87 , 5(9(56(' 7+( 52/(6 12: $1' ,167($' 2) 12: &$/&8/$7,1* 7+( *$,1(' 6$3 , 0 /22.,1* $7 7+( ,03$&7 72 25$&/( $1' , 67$57 21 7+( /()7 +$1' 6,'( , 86( ,1 7+,6 &$6( , 0 86,1* (;3(&7(' 0$,17(1$1&( &86720(56 72 %( /267 $1' 7+(1 , 0 *2,1* 72 ),*85( 287 ,1 7+$7 352&(66 :,7+ 7+( %/8( $5($ 7+(5( :+$7 6 *2,1* 72 +$33(1 :,7+ 5(1(:$/ 5$7(6 $1' 7+( (;3(&7(' $118$/ 5(9(18(6" $1' , // /22. $7 25$&/( 6 352),7 0$5*,16 $1' 7+(1 8/7,0$7(/< , // 6+2: <28 21 7+,6 5,*+7 +$1' 6,'( 7+(5( 7+( (;3(&7(' ),1$1&,$/ *$,1 (;3(&7(' ),1$1&,$/ ,03$&7 72 25$&/( ,) 7+(< $*5(( 72 7+,6 /,&(16( $1' , '2 7+(6( &$/&8/$7,216 29(5 $ 7(1 <($5 3(5,2' %(&$86( $6 :( 9( %((1 7$/.,1* $%287 7+(6( &86720(56 21&( 7+(< 5( &219(57(' 7+(< 5( :,7+ 7+( 1(: 3529,'(5 2) 7+( 62)7:$5( )25 $ /21* 7,0( 3(5,2' 2) 7,0( 4 12: :( 6$: 9$5,286 6$3 352-(&7,216 2) 7+( %(1(),76 7+(< 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 6 - November 9, 2010
SHEET 9

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 :28/' *(7 %(&$86( :(// :( 6$: $ /27 2) :( 6$: 0$1< 2) 7+26( 352-(&7,216 7+( %(1(),7 2) 7+(0 )520 '2,1* 7+,6 352*5$0 7+528*+ 7202552:12: %87 25$&/( ','1 7 .12: 7+$7 ,76 62)7:$5( :$6 %(,1* 7$.(1 ',' 7+(< +$9( $1< 352-(&7,216 2) 7+( ,03$&7 2) 6$3 7$.,1* ,76 62)7:$5(" $ 12 7+(< :(5(1 7 $:$5( 2) 7+( 62)7:$5( %(,1* 7$.(1 62 7+(5( 6 12 352-(&7,216 7+$7 $5( $9$,/$%/( ,1 25$&/( 6 5(&25'6 $7 7+( 7,0( $1' 62 , :25.(' )520 7+( 6$3 0$1$*(0(17 (;3(&7$7,216 $1' 86(' 7+26( ,1 0< &$/&8/$7,216 4 7+( &86720(56 $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $// 5,*+7 <28 0(17,21(' 7+$7 <28 86(' $1 25$&/( $&48,6,7,21 ),1$1&,$/ 02'(/ :+$7 ,6 7+$7 02'(/" $ 7+$7 :$6 7+( 02'(/ 7+$7 06 &$7= 7$/.(' $%287 <(67(5'$< 7+( 352-(&7 63,&( 02'(/ , 86(' 620( ,1)250$7,21 )520 7+$7 02'(/ 72 3529,'( ),1$1&,$/ ,1)250$7,21 $%287 $9(5$*( 5(9(18( $1' $775,7,21 5$7(6 $1' 27+(5 ,1)250$7,21 7+$7 :28/' %( .12:1 $%287 25$&/( 6 327(17,$/ 5(9(18(6 $1' 352),76 )520 7+( 3(23/(62)7 &86720(56 4 :(// /(7 6 6(( +2: <285 &$/&8/$7,21 2) 7+( ,03$&7 21 25$&/( :25.(' &28/' <28 '(6&5,%( 7+$7 72 7+( -85< 3/($6(" $ <(6 , +$9( $ 6/,'( 6,0,/$5 72 7+( 21( 7+$7 , 35(6(17(' :,7+ 6$3 $1' 21&( $*$,1 ,7 6 %86< %87 ,) :( :$/. '2:1 )520 723 72 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 &267 2) 3(5&(17 72 *(7 72 3(5&(17 $1' 7+(1 , 86( ',6&2817 5$7( )520 620( 25$&/( 9$/8$7,21 '2&80(176 7+$7 3(5&(17 72 %5,1* 7+( 180%(56 %$&. 72 -$18$5< -867 /,.( , ',' :,7+ 6$3 $1' 7+(1 8/7,0$7(/< , 7$.( 7+(6( &$/&8/$7,216 287 )25 7(1 <($56 $1' 7+(1 , '2 $ 6,0,/$5 &$/&8/$7,21 21 7+( %27720 /,.( , ',' :,7+ 6$3 72 /22. $7 6257 2) 7+( )8785( /266 2) 127 +$9,1* 7+$7 &86720(5 $1' , 0(17,21(' ,7 6 &$//(' $ &$3,7$/,=$7,21 5$7( %87 %$6,&$//< <28 7$.( 7+( 352),7 $7 7+$7 7,0( $1' 86( $ 08/7,3/( $1' 6$< 7+$7 %$6,&$//< ,) <28 +$9( 7+$7 &86720(5 $1' <28 5( 0$.,1* 7+$7 /(9(/ 2) 352),76 ,7 6 :257+ 62 08&+ *2,1* )25:$5' ,7 6 6257 2) 7+( 9$/8( 2) +$9,1* $ &86720(5 62 , '2 7+26( &$/&8/$7,216 :+,&+ <28 // 6(( ,1 $ 020(17 %87 7+26( $5( $// 7+( ,13876 72 /22.,1* $7 7+( ,03$&7 21 25$&/( *,9,1* 83 7+( /,&(16( 4 62 ,7 6 9(5< 6,0,/$5 72 7+( 6$3 &$/&8/$7,216 ,7 6 -867 )520 7+( 25$&/( 6 9,(:32,17 $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $// 5,*+7 /(7 6 /22. $7 $ &$/&8/$7,21 <28 0$'( :,7+ 7+( 1(;7 6/,'( :+$7 '2(6 7+,6 6+2:" $ 7+,6 &$/&8/$7,21 6 %$6(' 21 0$,17(1$1&( &86720(56 83 7+528*+ 2&72%(5 $1' 7+(1 $)7(5 2&72%(5 ,7 6 %$6(' 21 &86720(56 &219(57,1* $:$< )520 25$&/( 62 7+$7 6 7+( %$6,& &86720(5 ,1387 ,172 7+( ),1$1&,$/ ,03$&7 &$/&8/$7,21 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 %27720 ,7 +$6 6,0,/$5 6758&785( (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 7+( :,71(66 $1' 21&( $*$,1 :( 5( )2&86,1* 21 12: 7+( ,03$&7 21 25$&/( 62 7+(6( $5( 327(17,$/ /267 &86720(56 7+$7 $5( &219(57(' 72 6$3 , 67$57 7+(5( $1' 7+( 723 6,'( , $&78$//< 86( ,1 7+( 25$&/( 02'(/ , 86( 7+( 6$3 352-(&7,216 7+$7 , 0(17,21(' $ 020(17 $)25( 6,& %()25( , )2&86(' 21 7:2 ,7(06 , 86(' %$6,&$//< 7+( 0$,17(1$1&( &86720(56 21 7+( 723 7+(5( 7+$7 $5( /267 ,1 7+( ),567 7+5(( <($56 7+5(( $1' $ +$/) <($56 $1' 7+(1 , 7+(1 /22. $7 7+( ,03$&7 *2,1* )25:$5' :,7+ &86720(56 &219(57(' $1' 83 72 $1' 62 , 581 620( ',))(5(17 02'(/6 7+(5( 7+( 1(;7 52: , 86( 7+( &86720(5 $775,7,21 5$7(6 7+$7 7+$7 $ 7+5(( $1' $ +$/) 3(5&(17 7+$7 21&( $*$,1 :28/' 6+2: 29(5 7,0( 620( &86720(56 $5( (;3(&7(' 72 /($9( %$6(' 21 1250$/ $775,7,21 $1' 7+(1 , 08/7,3/< 7+( 5(68/7 2) 7+26( $028176 %< 7+( $9(5$*( 5(9(18( 3(5 &86720(5 ,1 7+,6 &$6( )520 25$&/( 6 9$/8$7,21 '2&80(176 , 86( 3(5 <($5 )25 7+$7 5(9(18( 7+$7 :,// %( /267 3(5 &86720(5 $1' , &20( 83 :,7+ $ 727$/ 5(9(18( 7+$7 :,// %( /267 %$6(' 21 7+( 180%(5 2) &86720(56 $1' 7+$7 6 7+( &$/&8/$7,216 7+(5( ,7 6 08/7,3/,(' %< $ 352),7 0$5*,1 7+$7 , 7$.( )520 25$&/( 6 ),1$1&,$/ 5(&25'6 $1' 7+(,5 5(&25'6 ,1',&$7( 7+$7 7+(< 0$.( $%287 3(5&(17 2) 7+,6 7<3( 2) 5(9(18( 62 , '('8&7 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 $1' 7+(1 <28 // 6(( 7+$7 , 352-(&7 287 7+( 5(9(18( '('8&7 7+( &2676 $7 3(5&(17 5,*+7 7+(5( /(66 &2676 &20( 83 :,7+ 7+( ,03$&7 72 352),76 $1' 7+(1 '(7(50,1( 7+( )8785( 9$/8( 2) +$9,1* /267 7+26( &86720(56 7+$7 6 7+( &86720(56 $7 7+$7 32,17 $1' 7+(1 <28 // 6(( 7+( 8/7,0$7( $02817 :+,&+ ,6 $1 ,03$&7 :,7+ 7+,6 6&(1$5,2 2) $6 2) -$18$5< $1' 7+,6 ,6 7+( 5(68/7 2) 21( 2) 0< 6&(1$5,26 25 21( 2) 0< &$/&8/$7,216 4 $// 5,*+7 $5( :( 5($'< 72 387 7+( 7:2 6,'(6 72*(7+(5 $7 7+( 7$%/(" $ , 7+,1. :( +$9( 21( 6800$5< $1' 7+(1 :( *(7 7+(5( 4 $// 5,*+7 $ 21( 29(5$// 6800$5< 4 /(7 6 6(( 7+( 6800$5< 7+(1 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 7+( :,71(66 ,6 :+$7 <28 +$9( +(5( ,6 $ 6800$5< 6,0,/$5 72 :+$7 , +$' )25 6$3 7+,6 ,6 7+( )/,3 6,'( 7+,6 ,6 7+( 25$&/( ,03$&7 $1' <28 // 6(( 7+$7 , 9( '21( 7+5(( &$/&8/$7,216 7+( ),567 &$/&8/$7,21 :( -867 :$/.(' 7+528*+ :+,&+ ,6 ,1 5(' 7+$7 6 7+( &$/&8/$7,21 :,7+ &86720(56 &219(57,1* 72 6$3 $1' 62 7+( /266 72 25$&/( ,6 %,//,21 7+( 6(&21' &$/&8/$7,21 ,6 %$6,&$//< ,6 &86720(56 &219(57,1* 72 6$3 $1' 7+$7 /266 ,6 %,//,21 $1' 8/7,0$7(/< ,) &86720(56 :(5( 72 &219(57 $:$< $1' *2 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 6 - November 9, 2010
0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 72 6$3 7+$7 /266 72 25$&/( :28/' %( %,//,21 62 7+( 62 7+26( $5( 7+( 7+5(( &$/&8/$7,216 7+$7 , &$0( 83 :,7+ $1' 7+( 7+(< 6+2: <28 7+( ,03$&7 %$6(' 21 7+( 180%(5 2) &219(57(' &86720(56 4 0$,17(1$1&( &86720(56 $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $// 5,*+7 12: /(7 6 *(7 7+(6( 3$57,(6 72 7+,6 1(*27,$7,21 7$%/( )25 7+( /,&(16( /22.,1* $7 :+$7 6 ,1 6$3 6 0,1' 7+( )$&7256 5(/(9$17 72 7+(0 /22.,1* $7 25$&/( 6 6,'( 7+( )$&7256 5(/(9$17 72 7+(0 +2: ',' <28 '(7(50,1( 7+( $02817 2) $ 5($621$%/( /,&(16( )(( 7+$7 25$&/( $6 $ :,//,1* 6(//(5 6$3 $6 $ :,//,1* %8<(5 :28/' +$9( $*5((' 72" $ :(// )25 $// 7+( 180%(56 72*(7+(5 $1' , 1((' 72 6(7 7+,6 &+$57 83 %(&$86( ,7 ,7 6 5($//< 3876 %27+ 6,'(6 72*(7+(5 :,7+ 7+(,5 ,03$&76 $1' *$,16 %$6,&$//< 21 7+( /()7 +$1' 6,'( 2) 7+( $;,6 <28 // 6(( ,7 6 ,1 %,//,216 2) '2//$56 7+(1 21 7+( %27720 , 6257 2) 35(6(17 7+( 5(68/76 2) 7+( 7+5(( ',))(5(17 &$/&8/$7,216 7+( ),567 21( 7+(5( 6 7+( &86720(56 &219(57(' 72 6$3 7+( 6(&21' 21( ,1 7+( 0,''/( ,6 7+( &219(57(' &86720(56 $1' 8/7,0$7(/< 21 7+( )$5 5,*+7 +$1' 6,'( ,7 6 &86720(56 &219(57(' 72 6$3 4 $1' -867 72 %( &/($5 7+$7 ,6 % ,7 6+28/' %( $ % $ <($+ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55 0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 $ :(// )520 0< 3(563(&7,9( ,7 6 ,7 6 %$6(' 21 7+( )$&7 7+$7 7+(5( :(5( 2%9,286/< 352-(&7,216 7+$7 :(17 08&+ +,*+(5 $1' 7+(5( 6 $// 7+( 27+(5 &216,'(5$7,216 327(17,$//< 7+( %,* ,03$&7 21 25$&/( 6 $&48,6,7,21 2) 3(23/(62)7 $1' 7+( )$&7 7+$7 %,//,21 :$6 3$,' $1' 7+$7 :$6 )$,5 0$5.(7 9$/8( )25 7+$7 &203$1< $1' $// 7+( ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< $7 7+$7 7,0( 62 7+$7 3529,'(6 :+$7 , :28/' 6$< ,6 7+,6 83:$5' 35(6685( 21 6$<,1* ,7 6 $7 /($67 %,//,21 4 $1' :+< ,6 ,7 7+$7 7+( 180%(5 2) &86720(56 7+$7 :( $6680( $5( *2,1* 72 %( &219(57(' 72 6$3 :+(7+(5 ,7 6 :+(7+(5 ,7 *2(6 83 72 025( :+< '2(6 7+$7 +$9( 7+( ,03$&7 ,7 +$6" $ :(// 7:2 7+,1*6 +$33(1 21( 7+(6( &86720(5 &219(56,216 $5( '5,9(1 %< 86,1* 7+( 62)7:$5( ,1 7+,6 &$6( $1' 6(&21'/< 21&( $ &86720(5 ,6 &219(57(' ,1 0<6$3 180%(56 , +$9( 7+( )$&7 7+$7 7+(< 0$.( 025( 0$,17(1$1&( 7+(< 6(// 025( /,&(16( $1' 7+(< 5( 8/7,0$7(/< 6(//,1* $ )8// 6(7 2) 352'8&76 62 7+(< +$9( /276 2) 5(&855,1* 5(9(18( )520 %27+ /,&(16( $1' 0$,17(1$1&( $1' 7+( 6$0( 7+,1* +$33(16 21 7+( 25$&/( 6,'( :,7+ 21&( 7+(< /26( $ &86720(5 21 0$,17(1$1&( 7+$7 /266 *2(6 21 )25 327(17,$//< '(&$'(6 4 12: $// 2) 7+( 7(67,021< *,9(1 +$6 %((1 %$6(' 21 7+( 1(*27,$7(' /,&(16( )5$0(:25. ,6 7+$7 5,*+7" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $1' <28 81'(567$1' 7+$7 6$3 ,6 $ 352321(17 2) $ ',))(5(17 0($685( 2) '$0$*(6 ,1 7+,6 &$6( 5,*+7" 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 6,08/7$1(286 &2//248< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 ,6 %,//,21" $ <(6 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 7+$7 6 0,//,21 62 :+$7 <28 +$9( ,) <28 67$57 )520 7+( %27720 21 7+( /()7 +$1' 6,'( :,7+ 7+( &86720(56 &219(57(' 7+$7 *$,1 72 6$3 ,6 0,//,21" 7+( ,03$&7 72 25$&/( ,6 %,//,21 62 <28 *(7 $ 5$1*( 7+(5( $1' 7+(1 :+(1 <28 029( 72 7+( 0,''/( <28 // 6(( 7+( ,03$&7 ,) &86720(56 *2 72 6$3 7+( *$,1 72 6$3 6 %,//,21 /266 72 25$&/( *52:6 72 %,//,21 7+(1 8/7,0$7(/< 21 7+( 5,*+7 +$1' 6,'( 7+( /266 :,7+ &86720(56 72 25$&/( 6 %,//,21 $1' 7+( *$,1 72 6$3 6 $7 %,//,21 62 , /22.(' $7 7+( 5(68/76 2) 7+$7 $1' 7+(1 $/62 &216,'(5(' $// 7+( 27+(5 )$&7256 :( 7$/.(' $%287 7+( /$67 '$< 25 62 $1' )520 0< 3(563(&7,9( ,1 0< 23,1,21 , :28/' 6(7 7+$7 7+( 7+( 9$/8( 2) )$,5 0$5.(7 /,&(16( )25 7+( 3(23/(62)7 $1' -'( 62)7:$5( :28/' %( $7 /($67 %,//,21 , :28/' 7$5*(7 ,7 ,1 7+( 0,''/( 81'(5 7+( &86720(56 &(57$,1/< , )((/ ,7 6 5($621$%/( ,1 /,*+7 2) :+(5( <28 *2 :,7+ 7+( &86720(5 &$/&8/$7,216 $1' , $/62 81'(567$1' 7+$7 6$3 6 0$1$*(0(17 +$' 27+(5 +,*+(5 352-(&7,216 %87 , )((/ $7 %,//,21 $7 /($67 7+(1 7+$7 :28/' %( $1 $335235,$7( 9$/8( )25 7+,6 /,&(16( $)7(5 $// 2) 0< 5(6($5&+ $1' $1$/<6,6 $1' $1' &216,'(5$7,216 4 :+< ,6 ,7 $7 /($67 %,//,21" 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 :+$7 ,6 7+$7 0($685(" $ , %(/,(9( ,7 6 6$3 6 23,1,21 7+$7 7+( '$0$*(6 6+28/' %( 0($685(' -867 %$6(' 21 7+( 180%(5 2) &86720(56 7+$7 25$&/( /267 8/7,0$7(/< /267 $1' 7+(1 7+(5( 6 7+(5( 6 $ &$/&8/$7,21 7+(< '2 2) , 7+,1. 7:2 &86720(56 :+(5( 7+(< &$// 7+$7 ,1)5,1*(56 *$,16 62 ,7 6 /267 &86720(56 $1' ,1)5,1*(56 *$,16 4 $1' 7+$7 6 /22.,1* $7 ,7 )520 7+( 3(563(&7,9( 2) -$18$5< $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 :+(1 7+(< 67$57(' ,1)5,1*(" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $1' 7+(1 *2,1* )25:$5' ,1 7,0( :+(1 <28 '2 $ /267 352),76 ,1)5,1*(56 352),76 &$/&8/$7,21" $ %$6,&$//< ,7 :28/' %( )520 -$18$5< 7+528*+ 7+( 32,17 ,1 7,0( :+(1 7202552:12: &($6(' 23(5$7,216 $1' 7+(1 $/62 /22.,1* $7 :+(7+(5 7+(5( 6 $/62 )8785( ,03$&7 )520 6$3 6 3(563(&7,9( 7+(< '21 7 /22. $7 )8785( ,03$&7 7+(< 6723 $7 2&72%(5 4 '2 <28 $*5(( :,7+ 7+( 0(7+2'2/2*< 2) 0($685,1* '$0$*(6 7+$7 6$3 ,6 $5*8,1* )25" $ )520 0< 3(563(&7,9( ,1 7+(6( &,5&8067$1&(6 7+( 7+( 21/< :$< 72 9$/8( 7+( 62)7:$5( $1' 7+( 62)7:$5( 0$7(5,$/6 7+$7 :(5( 7$.(1 7+$7 3523(57< 2) 25$&/( ,6 7+( )$,5 0$5.(7 9$/8( 2) 7+( 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 6 - November 9, 2010
SHEET 10

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 /,&(16( ,1 7+(6( &,5&8067$1&(6 4 :+< ,6 7+$7" $ 7+(5( 6 21( ,7 *,9(6 <28 $ &+$1&( 72 $&78$//< 9$/8( 7+( &23<5,*+7(' 3523(57< <28 &$1 /22. $7 7+( 3523(57< 7$.(1 $1' 387 ,7 ,172 3(563(&7,9( 2) :+$7 :+$7 <28 :28/' 3$< )25 7+$7 $1' +2: 21( :28/' 86( ,7 $7 7+( 7,0( 2) 7+$7 1(*27,$7,21 ,7 $//2:6 <28 72 9$/8( 7+( ,03257$1&( 2) 7+( 62)7:$5( 7+$7 6 86(' %< 7202552:12: ,1 7+( 6$)( 3$66$*( 352*5$0 <28 $&78$//< &$1 ,16(57 7+$7 62)7:$5( $6 7+( 0$1$*(0(17 2) 6$3 ',' ,172 7+$7 352*5$0 $1' 387 $ 9$/8( 21 7+$7 $1' '(7(50,1( 7+$7 9$/8( :,7+ 7+( /,&(16( ,7 $/62 $//2:6 <28 72 387 $ 9$/8( 21 7+( 7+( %(1(),76 72 6$3 :+(1 7+(< +$9( 7+( 62)7:$5( &$1 *2 287 $1' +$9( 7+(< 5( ,03529(' &86720(5 5(/$7,216+,36 $7 6$3 (9(1 :+(1 7+(< '21 7 &219(57 $ &86720(5 7+(< +$9( $'',7,21$/ 5(6285&(6 7+$7 7+(< ','1 7 +$9( :,7+287 +$9,1* 7+( /,&(16( <28 &$1 387 $ 9$/8( 21 7+$7 $1' ,7 &(57$,1/< ,6 7+( 21/< :$< ,7 6 7+( 21/< :$< ,1 7+,6 &$6( 72 387 $ 9$/8( 21 7+( ,03$&7 72 25$&/( 2) 7+( 3(23/(62)7 $&48,6,7,21 25$&/( 3$,' %,//,21 $1' 7+(5( 6 127 $1< :$< 7+$7 7+( /267 352),76 $3352$&+ 3876 $ 9$/8( 21 7+( ,03$&7 2) 25$&/( 2) 63(1',1* %,//,21 21 3(23/(62)7 $1' 7+(1 ,7 $//2:6 25$&/( 72 %( %$6,&$//< 3$,' )25 7+( 9$/8( 2) ,76 3523(57< $7 $7 7+( 32,17 ,1 7,0( :+(1 6$3 /$81&+(' 7+( 352*5$0 $1' $1' +$' 7+( 3523(57< 2) 25$&/( 72 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 7+( :$< <28 +$' 72 0($685( 7+26( 7+26( 5(0(',(6 4 62 /(7 0( 6(( ,) , +$9( 7+,6 5,*+7 <285 0(7+2' 9$/8(6 7+( 3523(57< 7+$7 6$3 722." $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $1' '2(6 7+(,5 0(7+2' '2 7+$7" $ 12 ,7 '2(6 127 4 7+(,5 0(7+2' 9$/8(6 :+$7 7+(< 8/7,0$7(/< ',' :,7+ 7+$7 3523(57< ,6 7+$7 )$,5" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $1' 7+$7 6 127 $335235,$7( ,1 <285 9,(:" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $// 5,*+7 /(7 0( $6. <28 7+,6 ',' <28 /22. $7 ',' <28 /22. $7 &$/&8/$7,1* ,7 81'(5 7+( :521* 0(7+2' 7+( /267 352),76 ,1)5,1*(56 352),76 0(7+2'" $ , ',' $ &$/&8/$7,21 2) /267 352),76 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $1' :+< ',' <28 '2 7+26( &$/&8/$7,216" $ :(// 7+(5( :$6 7:2 5($6216 21( , :$17(' 72 .12: :+$7 7+( 5(68/7 :$6 ,1 7(506 2) :+$7 :(5( 7+( /267 352),76 $1' :+$7 :(5( 7+( ,1)5,1*(56 352),76 $1' 6(&21'/< , 0(17,21(' $ 020(17 $*2 )25 620( 27+(5 &$86( 2) $&7,21 ,7 :$6 7+( 21/< :$< 7+$7 21( &28/' 0($685( 7+$7 :$6 7+( 0(7+2' :$6 /267 352),76 $1' 62 , 9( '21( $ &$/&8/$7,21 2) /267 352),76 ,1 7+( ,1)5,1*(5 352),76 4 $1' :+$7 :(5( 7+( 5(68/76" $ 7+( /267 352),7 180%(5 ,6 0,//,21 7+$7 6 7+( /267 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 /$81&+ 6$)( 3$66$*( $1' 72 0$.( 7+( 352-(&7,216 $1' 72 *2 72 7+( 0$5.(7 :,7+ ,76 3/$16 72 ,03$&7 25$&/( 4 $// 5,*+7 $1' , 7+,1. 7+(5( ,6 $ 6/,'( :,7+ 620( %8//(7 32,176 21 7+$7 '2(6 7+,6 (;3/$,1 :+< 7+( 0(7+2' 6$3 ,6 $5*8,1* )25 ,6 127 $'(48$7(" $ ,7 3529,'(6 620( 2) 7+$7 6800$5< $6 , 0(17,21(' 21( 7+(5( 6 12 :$< 7+$7 7+( /267 352),76 $1' 7+( , *8(66 7+(< &$// 7+(0 ,1)5,1*(56 352),76 0($685(6 7+( )8// 0$5.(7 9$/8( 2) 7+( &23<5,*+7(' :25.6 $1' 2%9,286/< /267 352),76 '2(6 127 0($685( 7+( 727$/ ,03$&7 21 25$&/( :+,&+ , 0(17,21(' ,7 $/62 '2(6 127 &$3785( $// 7+( $&.12:/('*(' %(1(),76 7+$7 :( 9( 6((1 ,1 7+( 5(&25'6 2) 7+( ,1)5,1*(0(17 62 $// 7+( 3/$16 $1' $1' 0$1$*(0(17 )2&86 2) 6$3 6 0$1$*(0(17 :,7+ 6$)( 3$66$*( $1' ,7 6 7+( 1(;7 32,17 ,7 '2(6 127 0($685( $1< 9$/8( %(<21' /267 &86720(5 5(9(18(6 $1' 352),76 :+,&+ ,6 $ %,* 352%/(0 :,7+ 7+( $3352$&+ $1' 7+,5' 32,17 ,7 6 '(3(1'(17 21 6$3 6 (;(&87,21 $1' 62 7+(< 9( 7$.(1 7+( 3523(57< 62 ,7 ,7 6 '(3(1'(17 21 +2: 6$3 6 (;(&87(6 7+( 3523(57< ,7 6 127 7+( 9$/8( 2) 7+26( &23<5,*+7(' :25.6 $1' $ /27 2) 3523(57< <28 6$: 7+(0 21 0< 6&23( 6&+('8/( ,7 '2(61 7 9$/8( 7+$7 $1' 7+(1 21( 5($621 , ',' $ /267 352),76 &$/&8/$7,21 :$6 7+(5( :(5( 620( 27+(5 &/$,06 ,1 7+( &$6( $1' 7+(< :(5( 121 &23<5,*+7 $1' 7+$7 :$6 21( 2) 7+( 7+$7 :$6 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 352),7 180%(5 $1' 7+(1 7+( ,1)5,1*(5 6,& 352),7 6 180%(5 ,6 0,//,21 $1' 7+$7 5()/(&76 127 $// 7+( &86720(56 7+$7 7+$7 :(5( 6$3 &86720(56 $1' $/62 7202552:12: &86720(56 %87 $ 68%6(7 62 , 7+,1. ,7 6 $%287 620( &86720(56 $5( ,1 7+( 0,//,21 $1' 7+(1 7+(5( 6 7+5(( &86720(56 , 7+,1. ,1 7+$7 *5283 2) 7+( :+(5( 7+(5( 6 620( ,668(6 67,// 7+$7 6257 2) (;,67 $%287 7+( 52/( 2) 7202552:12: ,1 &219(57,1* 7+26( &86720(56 72 6$3 $1' 62 ,) , /22. $7 7+( ,03$&7 2) 7+26( 7+5(( &86720(56 , 7+,1. 7+( 180%(5 :28/' %( 0,//,21 62 0< ,1)5,1*(5 352),7 6 6,& 180%(56 0,//,21 $1' 7+(1 5$1*(6 '2:1 72 0,//,21 '(3(1',1* 21 7+(6( 7+5(( &86720(56 $1' 62 7+$7 6 :+(5( , 9( &20( 287 :,7+ 7+26( &$/&8/$7,216 4 62 ,) , &20%,1( 7+( 0,//,21 ,1 /267 352),76 :,7+ 7+( 0,//,21 ,1 ,1)5,1*(5 6 352),76 :+$7 '2 :( *(7" $ , 7+,1. ,7 6 4 %87 '2(6 7+$7 )8//< &203(16$7( 25$&/( ,1 7+,6 &$6(" $ 12 ,7 :28/' 127 ,7 :28/' 127 &203(16$7( )25 7+( 9$/8( 2) ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< 4 :+$7 &203(16$7(6 25$&/( )25 7+( 9$/8( 2) :+$7 6$3 722." $ 7+( 21/< :$< 72 '2 ,7 ,6 7+( )$,5 0$5.(7 9$/8( 2) 7+( /,&(16( $3352$&+ $7 7+( %,//,21 4 62 7+$7 6 7+( $1$/<6,6 <28 ',' :,7+ 7+( %,//,21 25 025( 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 6 - November 9, 2010
0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 $7 /($67 %,//,21" $ $// 5,*+7 62 7+$7 6 7+( 3(23/(62)7 /,&(16( 4 12: 7+(5( $5( 7:2 27+(5 /,&(16(6 %87 :( &$1 *(7 7+528*+ 7+(0 $ /27 025( 48,&./< , 7+,1. /(7 6 *2 72 7+( 6,(%(/ /,&(16( +$9( <28 $/62 $1$/<=(' +2: $ 1(*27,$7,216 )25 $ /,&(16( )25 7+( 6,(%(/ 62)7:$5( :28/' *2" $ <(6 4 $1' :+$7 :$6 <285 &21&/86,21 )25 7+( 9$/8( 2) 7+( 3523(57< 7+$7 7+( 6,(%(/ 3523(57< 7+$7 6$3 722." $ ,7 6 $7 /($67 0,//,21 4 $7 /($67 0,//,21" $ 7+$7 6 5,*+7 4 :+$7 $3352$&+ ',' <28 86( 72 &$/&8/$7( 7+$7 )$,5 0$5.(7 9$/8(" $ ,7 :$6 7+( 6$0( $3352$&+ , 86(' :,7+ 3(23/(62)7 6(7 83 7+( 6$0( 6758&785( 6$0( 1(*27,$7,1* 6758&785( 4 $1' :( +$' 6(7 7+( 67$*( <(67(5'$< )25 7+( 3(23/(62)7 /,&(16( $1' , $6.(' <28 $%287 7+( 6&23( 2) 7+( /,&(16( 7+$7 :28/' %( 1(('(' :+$7 :,// ,7 &29(5 ,1 7(506 2) 7+( 6,(%(/ :(// 7+(1 3(23/(62)7 %87 12: :( 5( 7851,1* 72 6,(%(/ 7+( 7,0,1* 2) 7+( /,&(16( 6$3 6 1((' )25 7+( 62)7:$5( 7+(,5 .12:/('*( 2) /(*$/ 5,6.6 $1' 7+( )$&76 7+(< :(5( &203(7,7256 $5( 7+26( )$&7256 6,0,/$5 )25 <285 $1$/<6,6 2) 7+( 6,(%(/ 1(*27,$7,21" $ <(6 62 7+( 6$0( 6758&785( 6$0( )$&7256 2%9,286/< 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55 0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 '(&,'(' 72 '2 7+,6 7+(< +$' 72 127 21/< 7202552:12: ,) <28 // 5(&$// :,7+ 3(23/(62)7 $&78$//< +$' (;3(5,(1&( :,7+ 3(23/(62)7 6(59,&( +(5( 7+( 7202552:12: *5283 +$' 72 5$03 83 $1' ),*85( 287 +2: 7+(< &28/' $&78$//< +$9( 6,(%(/ 6(59,&( $1' 7+(1 8/7,0$7(/< 7+(< 86(' 7+( 62)7:$5( 7+$7 :$6 2:1(' %< 25$&/( 62 ,7 :$6 $// 1(: 72 7202552:12: 7+(< +$' 72 5$03 83 4 :+$7 6 7+( 6,*1,),&$1&( ,1 <285 23,1,21 2) 7+( )$&7 7+$7 25$&/( 3$,' %,//,21 72 $&48,5( 6,(%(/" $ , 7+,1. ,7 6 6,0,/$5 72 7+( 6,78$7,21 :,7+ 3(23/(62)7 2%9,286/< ,7 6 $ /$5*( $02817 3$,' ,7 :$6 $ 9(5< ,03257$17 $&48,6,7,21 )25 &50 62)7:$5( 7+$7 25$&/( 0$'( ,7 :$6 1(: &86720(56 72 25$&/( $1' 62 7+( 6$0( '<1$0,&6 7+( 6$0( 6,78$7,21 :+(5( 25$&/( 0$'( $ /$5*( 83)5217 ,19(670(17 ,1 6,(%(/ $/62 :28/' %( 9(5< ,03257$17 72 7+,6 1(*27,$7,21 )25 7+( 6,(%(/ /,&(16( 4 $1' &86720(56 $7 67$.( 7+,6 7,0( 5$7+(5 7+$1 7+( )25 3(23/(62)7" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $// 5,*+7 ',' <28 6(( $1< (9,'(1&( 7+$7 6$3 )(/7 7+5($7(1(' %< 25$&/( 6 $&48,6,7,21 2) 6,(%(/ ,1 " $ <(6 7+(5( :$6 ,1)250$7,21 7+$7 7+$7 :$6 ),567 ,1 7+( ),/(6 2) 6$3 ,1 /$7( 4 $// 5,*+7 7+,6 ,6 21( (;$03/( 2) 7+$7" (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 7+( :,71(66 <(6 7+,6 ,6 $ '2&80(17 )520 6$3 $1' 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 ',))(5(17 ,13876 $1' &216,'(5$7,216 %87 7+( 6$0( 6758&785( /22.,1* $7 %27+ 6,'(6 4 2.$< $// 5,*+7 $ 2.$< 4 62 :+$7 6 7+( 7,0,1* 2) 7+,6 /,&(16(" $ 7+$7 :28/' %( ,1 6(37(0%(5 :+(1 7+(5( :$6 ),567 $ &2175$&7 )25 7202552:12: 72 387 6(59,&( 21 6,(%(/ $ 6,(%(/ 352'8&7 4 7+$7 6 7+( ),567 '$7( :( .12: 2) :+(1 6$3 722. 7+( 6,(%(/ 3523(57<" $ 7+$7 6 5,*+7 7+(< 3/$11(' )25 $ :+,/( %87 7+$7 6 7+( ),567 '$7( :( .12: 4 $// 5,*+7 $1' 7+$7 6 %$6(' &$1 <28 (;3/$,1 :+$7 7+$7 6 %$6(' 21" $ <(6 62 %$6,&$//< 7+,6 -867 6+2:6 7+$7 25$&/( $11281&(6 $1 $*5((0(17 72 385&+$6( 6,(%(/ ,1 6(37(0%(5 7+( $&48,6,7,21 6 ,1 -$18$5< %< 0$< 2) 6$3 $11281&(6 (;7(16,21 2) 7202552:12: 6 6(59,&( 21 7+( 6,(%(/ 352'8&76 $1' 8/7,0$7(/< ,1 6(37(0%(5 7+ 2) 7+$7 6 7+( ),567 7202552:12: &2175$&7 62 7+$7 6 :+(1 :( '2 7+( 1(*27,$7,21 )25 7+,6 /,&(16( 4 $1' $1' 81/,.( :,7+ 7+( 3(23/(62)7 ,7 722. 620( 7,0( %(&$86( 2) :+$7" $ 7+,6 :$6 $ 6,78$7,21 :+,&+ :$6 ',))(5(17 %(&$86( 7202552:12: +$' 1(9(5 3529,'(' 6(59,&( 21 6,(%(/ 352'8&76 $1' 62 :+(1 6$3 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 7+( 7+( 7,7/( ,6 25$&/( $&48,6,7,21 2) 6,(%(/ ,7 6$<6 ,03$&7 21 &50 $1' %86,1(66 68,7( 5(9(18(6 %< 05 3,&.(77 4 7+,6 ,6 (;+,%,7 " $ <(6 ,7 :28/' %( 4 $// 5,*+7 $ $1' ,7 6$<6 +(5( 7+$7 6$3 &203(7,7,9( ('*( ',0,1,6+(' %< 3(5&(17 3267 6,(%(/ $&48,6,7,21 $1' 62 :+$7 7+,6 '2&80(17 ,6 $''5(66,1* ,6 7+$7 7+( &50 62)7:$5( ,6 9,(:(' %< 6$3 $6 %(,1* 9(5< ,03257$17 $1' 25 6257 2) /($',1* 72 27+(5 6$3 5(9(18(6 $1' 62 :+$7 6 ,03257$17 +(5( ,7 6$<6 5(9(18( 81'(5 7+5($7 7+528*+ 5('8&7,21 $1' &203(7,7,9( $%,/,7< $1' 7+$7 :$6 &$/&8/$7(' $7 3(5&(17 %< 6$3 6 0$1$*(0(17 $1' 62 :+$7 7+(< 5( 6$<,1* ,6 7+$7 :,7+ 6,(%(/ 12: $7 25$&/( 7+( &203(7,7,9( 2))(5,1*6 2) 6$3 ,1 7+,6 $5($ +$9( ',0,1,6+(' %< 3(5&(17 $1' 7+(< $&78$//< '2 $ &$/&8/$7,21 :+,&+ ,6 35(77< 5(0$5.$%/( 5,*+7 7+(5( ,7 6$<6 $7 5,6. $1' 7+,6 ,6 ,1 %,//,216 2) (8526 ,7 6$<6 7+( ,03$&7 2) 7+,6 &28/' %( %,//,21 (8526 :+,&+ , 7+,1. ,6 $%287 %,//,21 4 $7 7+( &219(56,21 5$7( 72 '2//$56" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 62 7+,6 ,6 127 -867 5(/$7(' 72 0$,17(1$1&( 21 6,(%(/ %87 ,7 6 7+( 29(5$// 7+5($7 7+$7 6$3 6 6((,1* :,7+ 25$&/( 7($0,1* 83 :,7+ 6,(%(/ 4 $// 5,*+7 /(7 6 *2 %$&. 72 7+$7 1(*27,$7,21 7$%/( :,7+ 7+( 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 6 - November 9, 2010
SHEET 11

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 1(;7 6/,'( 3/($6( (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 12: 7+,6 ,6 127 )25 3(23/(62)7 ,7 6 )25 6,(%(/ $1' $1' 7+( '$7( ,6 ',))(5(17 5$7+(5 7+$1 -$18$5< :( 5( 83 $ /,77/( 29(5 $ <($5 $1' $ +$/) 6(37(0%(5 :+$7 ,6 :+$7 '2(6 7+,6 6+2:" $ 6$0( 6758&785( $6 , 86(' %()25( :,7+ 3(23/(62)7 %87 , /$< 287 12: 7+( *2$/6 :,7+ :,7+ 7+( 6,(%(/ /,&(16( 7+,6 ,6 )520 6$3 6 3(563(&7,9( $1' 2%9,286/< 7+( ),567 *2$/ , 6(( 7+(5( ,7 6 $ *2$/ 72 &219(57 &86720(56 72 7+( 0<6$3 &50 7+$7 6 7+( &203(7,7,9( 2))(5,1* 7+$7 6$3 +$6 7+$7 &203(7(6 :,7+ 6,(%(/ $1' 7+(1 7+(5( 6 $ '2&80(17 , // 6+2: <28 ,1 $ $ 020(17 7+$7 6$<6 7202552:12: ,6 (1$%/(5 )25 )8785( /,&(16( 5(9(18( 62 ,7 6 ,03257$17 )520 7+( 3(563(&7,9( 2) 6$3 $6 $ *2$/ 72 %( $%/( 72 +$9( 7202552:12: 3529,'( 6(59,&( :+,&+ /($'6 72 025( 5(9(18( )25 6$3 $1' 7+(1 <28 &20( '2:1 72 7+( ,03$&7 21 25$&/( $1' 7+(5( 6 620( ,1)250$7,21 7+$7 6+2:6 7+( ,03$&7 21 25$&/( %(7:((1 0,//,21 $1' 0,//,21 5(/$7(' 72 7+( 6,(%(/ 0$,17(1$1&( $1' 7+(1 8/7,0$7(/< 7+( 6$3 (;3(&7(' ),1$1&,$/ *$,16 7+(5( 6 620( ,1)250$7,21 7+$7 7+(< (;3(&7(' 72 &219(57 &86720(56 %< $1' , 9( '21( 620( &$/&8/$7,216 /,.( 7+( 27+(5 21(6 , 9( 6+2:1 <28 )25 3(23/(62)7 %87 12: )25 6,(%(/ 352'8&76 $1' 7+26( $5( 0,//,21 72 0,//,21 $1' 7+(6( 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 5(35(6(176 2) 25,*,1$//< (;3(&7(' 25$&/( 5(9(18( 62 7+,6 -867 6+2:6 7+( ,03$&7 7+$7 7202552:12: +$6 21 25$&/( 6 %86,1(66 62 7+26( $5( $// ,03257$17 &216,'(5$7,216 4 62 7+,6 %86,1(66 3/$1 9(5< 6,0,/$5 72 7+( 3(23/(62)7 3/$1 5,*+7" $ <(6 <(6 4 -867 ',))(5(17 180%(56 ',))(5(17 (;3(&7$7,216 $%287 &86720(56 $1' ',))(5(17 &$/&8/$7,216 $ ',))(5(17 352'8&76 $1' ',))(5(17 (;3(&7$7,216 %87 6,0,/$5 ,1 7+( 6(16( 2) 2))(5,1* 7202552:12: 72 6(59,&( 6,(%(/ &86720(56 $6 :( 7$/.(' $%287 21 7+( 3(23/(62)7 6,'( 4 $// 5,*+7 $1' /(7 6 /22. $7 620( 2) 7+( (9,'(1&( <28 5(/,(' 21 )25 6+2:,1* :+$7 6 :+$7 :28/' %( ,1 6$3 6 0,1' )25 7+( 6,(%(/ 1(*27,$7,21 7+( 1(;7 6/,'( 3/($6( (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 7+,6 ,6 (;+,%,7 :+$7 '2(6 7+,6 6+2: 05 0(<(5" $ 7+,6 :$6 $ '2&80(17 7+$7 :$6 35(3$5(' ,1 2&72%(5 , 7+,1. 05 =,(0(1 $1' 05 :(/= 6$: 7+,6 '2&80(17 ,7 :$6 35(6(17(' 72 05 26:$/' 21( 2) 7+( (;(&87,9( %2$5' 0(0%(56 $1' ,7 6$<6 7+$7 ,1 7+$7 ),567 6257 2) $5($ 7+$7 6 +,*+/,*+7(' ,7 6$<6 7+( 6,(%(/ &86720(5 %$6( &216,676 2) &86720(56 $1' 7+(1 6$<6 ,1&/8',1* $ /$5*( 180%(5 2) -2,17 (;+,%,7 6$3 6,(%(/ &86720(56 $1' 35(6(176 $ +8*( 0$5.(7 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 $5( *$,16 72 6$3 4 62 :( .12: )520 6$3 6 2:1 '2&80(176 $7 7+( 7,0( :+$7 :28/' %( ,1 7+(,5 0,1' $7 7+( 1(*27,$7,21 7$%/(" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 62 /(7 6 *2 72 7+( ),567 *2$/ *2$/ 21( $&78$//< :( // *2 72 $// 7+5(( *2$/6 7+,6 7,0( )25 7+( 6$.( 2) 63((' :+$7 '2(6 7+,6 &+$57 6+2: :,7+ 5(63(&7 72 *2$/ 21( )$&725 :+$7 6$3 6 *2$/ :$6 )$&725 :+$7 6$3 7+28*+7 7+( ,03$&7 21 25$&/( :28/' %( $1' 12 :+$7 7+(< 7+28*+7 7+(< ' *$,1 )520 ,7" $ :(// 7+(5( 6 6(9(5$/ 7+,1*6 1(('(' 72 32,17(' 287 2%9,286/< 7+( ),567 ,7(0 7+(5( 21 7+( 5,*+7 +$1' 6,'( 81'(5 7+,6 2&72%(5 '2&80(17 ,7 6$<6 7+( 23325781,7< ,6 72 029( 7+( 3/86 6$3 &86720(56 6$3 $1' 6,(%(/ +$9( ,1 &20021 72 0,*5$7( 7+(0 72 0<6$3 &50 62 7+$7 6+2:6 21&( $*$,1 7+( 7$5*(7,1* %< 6$3 /$<6 287 620( 2%-(&7,9(6 7+(5( .(< 3(5)250$1&( ,1',&$7256 , 7+,1. ,) <28 &20( '2:1 ,7 6$<6 '2:1 7+(5( ,1 7+( 6(&21' %2; 6$<6 7+( 0$,17(1$1&( 2))(5,1* ,7 6$<6 $ .(< 3$57 2) 7+( 6$)( 3$66$*( 352*5$0 $1' 3529,'(' %< 7202552:12: &$1 %( 86(' $6 (1$%/(5 )25 )8785( /,&(16( 5(9(18( 62 7+$7 6+2:6 +2: 7202552:12: )25 6,(%(/ &$1 +(/3 6$3 ($51 27+(5 5(9(18(6 $1' , 7+,1. ,1 $ 020(17 :( // 7$/. 025( $%287 7+,6 %87 7+(5( 6 $ '2&80(17 7+$7 6$<6 29(5 7+( /21* 7(50 (9(5< '2//$5 2) 7202552:12: 67$1' $/21( 5(9(18( 7+,6 <($5 ,1 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 23325781,7< 62 7+$7 6 ,03257$17 72 81'(567$1' 6$3 6 *2$/6 $1' $1' 327(17,$/ *$,16 $1' 7+(1 7+( ,7 *2(6 21 $1' 6$<6 7+( 1(;7 %2; 7+( 0$,17(1$1&( 2))(5,1* $ .(< 3$57 6$)( 3$66$*( 352*5$0 $1' 3529,'(' %< 7202552:12: &$1 %( 86(' $6 (1$%/(5 )25 )8785( /,&(16( 5(9(18( 72 *52: 0$,17(1$1&( &2175$&7 92/80( 7$.(1 $:$< )520 25$&/( $1' 72 *(1(5$7( $'',7,21$/ 0$,17(1$1&( 5(9(18( )25 6$3 62 21&( $*$,1 *2(6 72 :+< ,7 :28/' %( $ 9$/8$%/( /,&(16( )25 6$3 4 5,*+7 &/($5/< *2,1* 72 +$9( 72 *(7 $ 1(: 6(7 2) */$66(6 +(5( *,9(1 7+$7 6/,'( %87 /(7 6 *2 21 72 $127+(5 3$*( 2) 7+,6 6/,'( 6$0( '2&80(17 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 $1' :+$7 '2(6 7+,6 6+2: ,1 7(506 2) 6$3 6 3/$11,1* )25 7+( 6,(%(/ $&48,6,7,21 %< 25$&/(" $ :(// 7+,6 ,6 7+(,5 %86,1(66 3/$11,1* $6 3$57 2) 7+( %86,1(66 &$6( $1' 7+,6 21( :28/' 6+2: 7+$7 29(5 7+( 3(5,2' 7+528*+ 62 7+,6 ,6 7+528*+ 7+(5( :28/' %( &86720(56 7+$7 :28/' %( &219(57(' 62 ,7 6 ,1',&$7,9( 21&( $*$,1 2) 7+( (;3(&7$7,216 2) 6$3 4 $1' 7+$7 6 ,6 7+$7 7+( 180%(5 <28 86(' ,1 <285 &$/&8/$7,216" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 6 - November 9, 2010
0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 4 7+(,5 2:1 180%(5" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $// 5,*+7 ',' <28 &$/&8/$7( 7+( ,03$&7 , 0 6255< /(7 0( *2 72 7+( 1(;7 6/,'( (;+,%,7 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 $1' <28 0(17,21(' 7+,6 :+$7 '2(6 7+,6 6+2:" :+$7 6 7+( 6,*1,),&$1&( 2) 7+,6" $ 7+,6 ,6 $ '2&80(17 7+$7 :$6 $87+25(' %< 05 1(/621 $7 7202552:12: $1' ,7 :$6 $87+25(' ,1 $1' ,7 0(17,216 7+$7 29(5 7+( /21* 7(50 (9(5< 21( '2//$5 2) 7202552:12: 67$1' $/21( 5(9(18( 7+,6 <($5 5(35(6(176 2) 25,*,1$//< (;3(&7(' 25$&/( 5(9(18( )520 7+(,5 0,6*8,'(' $&48,6,7,21 675$7(*< 62 ,7 5()(5(1&(6 %$&. 72 25$&/( 6 $&48,6,7,21 2) 3(23/(62)7 $1' %$6,&$//< 7+( :$< ,7 :25.6 ,6 7+$7 )25 (9(5< '2//$5 2) 7202552:12: 5(9(18( %(&$86( 7+(< 5( $7 +$/) 7+( 35,&( 2) 25$&/( ,7 ' %( 72 25$&/( $1' 7+(1 7+$7 6 2) 0$,17(1$1&( $1' ,7 6 $ 7(1 <($5 /22. 62 ,7 6 7:2 7,0(6 7+( 1(;7 1,1( <($56 62 7+$7 2) 7202552:12: 12: 6(59,&( 5(9(18( ,1 <($5 21( 7$.(6 $:$< )520 25$&/( ,1 <($5 21( $1' 7+(1 7+(5( 6 $ /266 )25 7+( 1(;7 1,1( <($56 72 25$&/( ,6 72 7+$7 6 7+( $1' 62 <28 6(( 7+( /(9(5$*( ,1 7+( 0,1'6(7 2) 7202552:12: 7+$7 ,1 7+,6 &$6( 05 1(/621 6 &20081,&$7,1* 72 7+( 0$1$*(0(17 $7 6$3 6$<,1* :( 0$.( ,03$&76 25$&/( %(&$86( 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55 0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 1(*27,$7,1* )25 7+,6 /,&(16(" $ 7+$7 6 5,*+7 4 $// 5,*+7 /(7 6 *2 72 7+( 7+,5' )$&725 +2: 08&+ 6$3 7+28*+7 ,7 :28/' 0$.( %< 7$.,1* 7+( 6,(%(/ 3523(57< )520 25$&/( +2: ',' <28 &$/&8/$7( 7+$7" $ , 86(' $ 6,0,/$5 02'(/ $6 72 +2: , ',' 7+( &$/&8/$7,216 )25 3(23/(62)7 62 ,7 6 7+( 6$0( 6758&785( $1' , 7+,1. +(5( :( 5( -867 6+2:,1* 7+( 5(68/76 2) 7+( &$/&8/$7,21 7+,6 21( 6 )25 7+( 0$,17(1$1&( &86720(56 , 0(17,21(' $ 020(17 $*2 7+$7 :28/' %( &219(57(' 72 6$3 $1' 62 <28 // 6(( 7+$7 6$0( 5(9(18( &$7(*25,(6 <28 +$9( 21 7+( /()7 +$1' 6,'( 7+(5( 0$,17(1$1&( 5(9(18( <28 +$9( 7+( $'',7,21$/ 352'8&7 6$/(6 2) 7+( &5266 6(// $1' 7+(1 <28 +$9( 7+( &219(57(' &86720(56 7+( 836:,7&+ $1' 7+(1 <28 // 6(( 7+( 7+5(( &86720(5 180%(56 $1' , 387 7+26( 9$/8(6 ,1 72 7+( 02'(/ $1' &$0( 83 :,7+ (;3(&7(' 5(9(18( 7+$7 :28/' %( *$,1(' '('8&7(' 7+( &2676 ,7 :28/' 7$.( 72 7(1 5(9(18( $1' 7+(1 <28 // 6(( 7+( 352),76 7+(5( 21 7+( 1(;7 &2/801 $1' 7+(1 %$6,&$//< 7+(1 ',' $ 6,0,/$5 &$/&8/$7,21 $6 , ',' )25 7+( 3(23/(62)7 *$,16 72 6$3 $1' &$0( 83 :,7+ $ )8785( 9$/8( 7+(5( 72 6$3 $1' 8/7,0$7(/< <28 // 6(( 7+$7 7+( 727$/ 9$/8( $6 2) -$18$5< 25 $6 2) 6(37(0%(5 7+( 7,0( 2) 7+( 1(*27,$7,21 :28/' %( 0,//,21 72 6$3 7+$7 6 7+(,5 (;3(&7(' *$,1 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 7+(< /26( 7+$7 0$,17(1$1&( )25 $ 7(1 <($5 3(5,2' 62 ,7 6 35(77< 6,*1,),&$17 21 ,03$&7 4 ',' <28 &$/&8/$7( 7+( ,03$&7 72 25$&/( 2) $ /,&(16( 72 6$3 2) 7+( 6,(%(/ 3523(57<" $ <(6 , ',' 4 $1' +2: ',' <28 '2 7+$7" $ +(5( 6 7+( &$/&8/$7,21 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 7+( :,71(66 ,7 6 $&78$//< 35(77< 6,03/( , %$6,&$//< 6$< 7+$7 ,) , /22. $7 6,(%(/ 5(9(18( $1' , &$1 21 7+( ),567 %2; 7+(5( ,) ,7 6 %$6,&$//< 3(5&(17 2) 25$&/( 6 35,&( 7+$7 6 0,//,21 $1' 62 :( 6$: )25 (9(5< 6,(%(/ +$' 7,0(6 ,03$&7 21 25$&/( 62 7,0(6 0,//,21 ,6 0,//,21 25$&/( 6 352),7 0$5*,1 3(5&(17 62 7+( ,03$&7 72 25$&/( ,6 $ +81'5(' 0,//,21 ,) )520 7+$7 '2&80(17 ,7 6 81&/($5 (;$&7/< :+$7 7+( $02817 5(35(6(176 :+(7+(5 ,7 6 $7 )8// 9$/8( 25 +$/) 9$/8( ,) ,7 6 $7 )8// 9$/8( ,7 6 0,//,21 2) 6,(%(/ 5(9(18( 08/7,3/,(' 7,0(6 ,7 6 $%287 0,//,21 $7 3(5&(17 7+$7 6 $ 0,//,21 ,03$&7 21 25$&/( 62 ,7 6+2:6 <28 ,) <28 7$.( 05 1(/621 6 /2*,& $1' <28 $&&(37 ,7 +2: $ 60$// $02817 2) 7202552:12: 5(9(18( &$1 5($//< ,03$&7 25$&/( 6 5(9(18( $1' 7+,6 ,6 5(9(18( 7+$7 +$' %$6,&$//< $&48,5(' ,1 7+( 3(23/(62)7 $*5((0(17 4 ,6 72 7+,6 ,6 (9,'(1&( 2) :+$7 :28/' %( ,1 6$3 6 0,1' 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 4 $1' 7+$7 6 21( &$/&8/$7,21 ',' <28 0$.( 620( 27+(56" $ <(6 , %$6,&$//< +$9( $ 6800$5< 7+$7 6+2:6 , ',' 7+( 6$0( 7<3( 2) $3352$&+ $6 :,7+ 3(23/(62)7 62 ,) :( *2 29(5 +(5( (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 7+( :,71(66 , 86(' )25 7+( 6,(%(/ *$,16 7+( 6,0,/$5 6(7 2) &86720(56 7+$7 :(5( /267 81'(5 7:2 6257 2) &$/&8/$7,216 :( -867 6$: 7+( 0,//,21 7+(5( 21&( $*$,1 :,7+ &86720(56 &219(57,1* $1' 7+(1 21 7+( 5,*+7 +$1' 6,'( , /22.(' $7 7+( )8// 9$/8( 2) 7+26( &86720(56 /($9,1* :+,&+ ,1&/8'(6 %27+ 7+( ,1 7+,6 &$6( 7+( *$,1 2) 0$,17(1$1&( 5(9(18( 7+( *$,1 2) &5266 6(// $1' 7+( *$,1 2) 836:,7&+ &86720(56 72 6$3 :+,&+ 0$.(6 ,7 $%287 0,//,21 21&( $*$,1 86,1* 7+$7 0,//,21 9$/8( 3(5 &86720(5 62 7+$7 6 7+( 287&20( 21 7+( 6,(%(/ *$,1 6,'( 4 :+$7 6$3 :28/' 7+,1. ,7 :28/' %(1(),7 )520 7+528*+ $ /,&(16( )25 7+,6 3523(57<" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $// 5,*+7 /(7 6 *2 7+(1 72 7+( 25$&/( 6,'( 2) 7+( 7$%/( :( 9( '21( 6$3 7+,6 ,6 )25 6,(%(/ /(7 6 *2 72 7+( 25$&/( 6,'( :+$7 )$&7256 :28/' +$9( %((1 ,03257$17 72 25$&/( (17(5,1* ,172 7+$7 1(*27,$7,21" (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 7+( :,71(66 :(// <28 // 6(( 7+( *2$/6 7+(5( 21&( $*$,1 7+,6 ,6 ,1 7+(,5 6,'( 2) 7+( 1(*27,$7,21 $1' 7+( *2$/6 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 6 - November 9, 2010
SHEET 12

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 +(5( :(5( /22.,1* $7 25$&/( 6 *2$/ )25 7+( 6,(%(/ $&48,6,7,21 :+,&+ :$6 $'',7,21$/ &86720(56 $1' 7+$7 0$,17(1$1&( 5(9(18( $1' 21&( $*$,1 +(5( 25$&/( %(&$0( 7+( /($'(5 ,1 7+( 0$5.(7 $5($ 2) 7+( &50 62)7:$5( 62 25$&/( %(&$0( 0$5.(7 /($'(5 :,7+ 7+( $&48,6,7,21 2) 6,(%(/ $1' $1' 7+$7 :$6 9(5< ,03257$17 72 25$&/( 7+(1 , *2 '2:1 $1' , $''5(66 7+( 5,6. 2) 7+$7 ,19(670(17 $1' 7+(1 8/7,0$7(/< 7+( (;3(&7(' ,03$&76 21 25$&/( <28 // 6(( 7+$7 7+( 6,(%(/ $&48,6,7,21 :$6 %,//,21 ,1&/8'(' 7+( 62)7:$5( $1' 6833257 0$7(5,$/6 :,7+ 7+,6 /,&(16( <28 ' *,9( 83 7+( (;&/86,9( 5,*+76 $1' 7+( ,03$&7 86,1* 6$3 6 352-(&7,21 2) 0$,17(1$1&( &86720(56 , &20( 83 :,7+ 620( &$/&8/$7,216 7+(5( $/62 4 $// 5,*+7 +2: :28/' $ /,&(16( :,7+ 6$3 )25 7+,6 6,(%(/ 3523(57< 387 ,1 25$&/( 6 %,//,21 ,19(670(17 $7 5,6." $ :(// 21&( $*$,1 -867 /,.( :( 6$: :,7+ 3(23/(62)7 7+(5( 6 7+( &86720(56 21 7+( /()7 +$1' 6,'( 7+(5( 6 0,//,21 2) $118$/ 0$,17(1$1&( 5(9(18( 7+( 0$5.(76+$5( %(&$0( 7+( /($'(5 )25 25$&/( $1' 7+$7 :28/' $// %( 6257 2) *,9(1 83 $1' ',/87(' :,7+ 7+( /,&(16( $1' 62 25$&/( 21&( $*$,1 :28/' +$9( 7+,6 6,78$7,21 :+(5( ',' 127 +$9( 7+( (;&/86,9( 86( ,7 :28/' /26( &86720(56 0$5.(76+$5( $1' 5(9(18( $1' 6$3 6 %(1(),76 ,) 7+(< 7$.( 7+( /,&(16( 7+(< +$9( 7+( 86( 2) 7+( 0$7(5,$/6 81'(5 &23<5,*+7 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 &21&/8'( 7+$7 $ 5($621$%/( /,&(16( %(7:((1 $ :,//,1* 6(//(5 :,//,1* %8<(5 :28/' %(" (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 7+( :,71(66 %$6,&$//< , 6(7 7+( 6758&785( 83 +(5( :,7+ 6$3 6 (;3(&7(' *$,16 $1' 25$&/( 6 327(17,$/ ,03$&76 $1' &216,'(5(' 7+( 27+(5 )$&7256 :( 9( 7$/.(' $%287 $1' )520 0< 3(563(&7,9( 7+( /,&(16( :28/' %( $7 /($67 0,//,21 %< 05 3,&.(77 4 $*$,1 $7 /($67 0,//,21" $ $7 /($67 0,//,21 4 $1' :+< $7 /($67 " $ 21&( $*$,1 )25 $// 7+( 27+(5 )$&7256 $1' 3$57,&8/$5/< :,7+ 7+( ,03257$1&( 2) 7+( 6,(%(/ $&48,6,7,21 $1' 63(1',1* 7+( %,//,21 )25 7+$7 &203$1< $1' 7+( 62)7:$5( )520 0< 3(563(&7,9( :28/' %( $7 /($67 0,//,21 4 $// 5,*+7 7+$1. <28 12: /(7 6 *(7 72 7+( 7+,5' $1' ),1$/ /,&(16( 7+$7 6$3 6+28/' +$9( 1(*27,$7(' 7+$7 6 7+( /,&(16( 72 7+( 25$&/( '$7$%$6( 7+( &2857 (;&86( 0( &2816(/ 12: 0,*+7 %( $ *22' 7,0( 72 7$.( $ %5($. %()25( <28 *(7 ,172 7+( /$67 21( 05 3,&.(77 9(5< *22' 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 /$',(6 $1' *(17/(0(1 2) 7+( -85< <28 $5( (;&86(' )25 0,187(6 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 7+(< *$,1 &86720(56 0$5.(76+$5( $1' 5(9(18( 4 12: /(7 6 7851 72 7+( 7+,5' )$&725 +2: 08&+ 021(< :28/' 25$&/( (;3(&7 72 /26( ,) ,7 *$9( 7+,6 /,&(16( 83 72 6$3 )25 6,(%(/ 352'8&76" (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 7+( :,71(66 :(// , 6(7 83 7+( 6$0( 6758&785( $6 <28 6$: %()25( ,1 7+,6 &$6( , /22.(' $7 7+( /267 327(17,$/ &86720(56 72 25$&/( /22. $7 7+( 9$/8(6 7+$7 25$&/( :28/' +$9( +$' 7+(5( )25 ,76 5(9(18(6 $1' ,76 0$5*,16 $1' ',' $ 6,0,/$5 &$/&8/$7,21 29(5 7+( 7(1 <($5 3(5,2' 2) +$9,1* $ &86720(5 &219(57 $:$< 2)) 7+( 25$&/( 3/$7)250 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 $1' :+$7 '2 7+( &$/&8/$7,216 5(68/7 ,1" $ 7+( &$/&8/$7,21 +(5( 6+2:6 0$,17(1$1&( &86720(56 7+$7 $5( &219(57(' $:$< $)7(5 2&72%(5 <28 // 6(( 7+( 0$,17(1$1&( 5(9(18( 7+(5( %$6( 2) &86720(56 <28 // 6(( 7+( 7+( 5(9(18( 7+$7 6 *2,1* 72 %( /267 /(66 7+( &2676 $1' 7+( 352),76 2) 0,//,21 $1' 7+(1 7+( )8785( ,03$&7 21 7+$7 2) 0,//,21 $1' 62 7+( 727$/ (;3(&7(' ,03$&7 ,6 0,//,21 4 $// 5,*+7 /(7 6 387 7+( 7:2 6,'(6 72*(7+(5 21/< 7+,6 7,0( )25 6,(%(/ /22.,1* $7 7+( 6$3 6,'( :+$7 6 7+(,5 7+,1.,1* /22.,1* $7 7+( 25$&/( 6,'( :+$7 6 7+(,5 7+,1.,1*" :+$7 <28 ',' 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 7+( )2//2:,1* 352&((',1*6 :(5( +($5' 287 2) 7+( 35(6(1&( 2) 7+( -85< 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 &2816(/ %()25( <28 %5($. , /22.(' $7 7+( /,0,7,1* $1' &203(7,1* /,0,7,1* ,16758&7,216 :,7+ 5(*$5' 72 7+( &2:/,7= &2817< (9,'(1&( $1' , 0 *2,1* 72 7$.( $ /,77/( %,7 )520 ($&+ 21( 7+( ,16758&7,21 7+$7 , :28/' *,9( :,// 5($' $6 )2//2:6 '85,1* &5266 (;$0,1$7,21 2) 25$&/( 6 (;3(57 :,71(66 3$8/ 0(<(5 '()(1'$176 0$< 35(6(17 7:2 '(&/$5$7,216 )520 &86720(5 &2:/,7= &2817< :$6+,1*721 :+,&+ :(5( 5(/,(' 8321 %< 05 0(<(5 ,1 )250,1* +,6 (;3(57 23,1,21 7+,6 (9,'(1&( ,6 7+( (9,'(1&( ,6 $'0,66,%/( 21/< )25 7+( 385326( 2) (;3/$,1,1* 7+( %$6,6 2) 7+( (;3(57 6 23,1,21 ,7 ,6 127 2))(5(' )25 7+( 7587+ 2) 7+( ,1)250$7,21 &217$,1(' 7+(5(,1 $1' 6+28/' 127 %( &216,'(5(' )25 7+$7 385326( 7+$7 6 7+( ,16758&7,21 , // *,9( , 0 67,// :25.,1* 21 7+( 27+(5 ,16758&7,21 , 0 *2,1* 72 *2 7<3( 620(7+,1* 83 '85,1* 7+( %5($. $1' :( &$1 *2 29(5 7+$7 /$7(5 05 &2:$1 <285 [phone],&./< , ','1 7 6$< $1<7+,1* 7+( ),567 7,0( &2816(/ 6$,' 620(7+,1* $%287 7+( 21/< %2$5' 0(0%(5 :+2 7(67,),(' $1' , ','1 7 6$< 620(7+,1* 7+( ),567 6,; 7,0(6 7+(< 6$,' ,7 , 7+,1. :+$7 7+(< 5( ,03/<,1* ,6 ,03523(5 7+(< 5( ,03/<,1* 7+$7 7+(5( 6 $ 0,66,1* :,71(66 ,668( +(5( 7+26( %2$5' 0(0%(56 +$9( %((1 9,'(27$3(' '(326,7,21 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 6 - November 9, 2010
0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 7+(< 5( (48$//< $9$,/$%/( 72 %27+ 6,'(6 72 3/$< 7+26( '(326,7,216 $1' , 7+,1. 81'(5 7+( /$: ,7 6 ,03(50,66,%/( ,03523(5 72 )25 7+(0 72 .((3 7$/.,1* $%287 7+(5( 6 21/< 21( %2$5' 0(0%(5 :+2 +$6 &20( 72 7(67,)< $6 ,) 7+( 27+(56 +$9(1 7 7(67,),(' ,1 7+,6 &$6( 05 3,&.(77 7+(5( 6 $ +8*( ',))(5(1&( %(7:((1 $ /,9( :,71(66 $1' $ 9,'(27$3(' :,71(66 $1' 7+(6( $5( 7+(,5 %2$5' 0(0%(56 <285 [phone]+(0 :25. )25 7+(0 05 $327+(.(5 12 /21*(5 '2(6 %87 $6 <28 .12: +( 6 %((1 $92,',1* 6(59,&( ,1 7+,6 &$6( $1' , 7+,1. ,7 6 3(5)(&7/< $335235,$7( 72 0$.( $ ',67,1&7,21 %(7:((1 $ /,9( :,71(66 05 3+,//,36 +$6 $ %5$1' 1(: -2% 7:2 :((.6 ,172 $ 1(: -2% $6 & ( 2 $1' +( )/(: 287 +(5( )520 7+( ($67 &2$67 72 &20( , 7+,1. 7+$7 6 $1 $335235,$7( ',67,1&7,21 72 0$.( 3(5)(&7/< $335235,$7( $1' 7+(< // +$9( $1 (;3/$1$7,21 )25 ,7 , 0 685( 05 0,77(/67$('7 7+(< &$1 6$< 05 3+,//,36 ',' :+$7(9(5 7+(< :$17 72 6$< $// , 0 6$<,1* ,6 ,7 6 ,03(50,66,%/( ,7 6 ,03/<,1* 7+$7 7+(5( 6 $ 0,66,1* :,71(66 352%/(0 $1' 81'(5 7+( /$: $6 , 6$< ,7 6 &/($5 7+$7 $6 /21* $6 7+( 3(5621 :$6 $9$,/$%/( )25 '(326,7,21 7+( ,1)(5(1&( 7+(< 5( 75<,1* 72 68**(67 72 7+( -85< ,6 ,03(50,66,%/( 05 3,&.(77 12 05 &2:$1 $1' 7+(< '21 7 $1' <28 .12: 21( 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55 0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 7+( ',67,1&7,21 ,6 %(7:((1 :+2 $33($5(' $1' :+2 ','1 7 , +$9(1 7 127,&(' 7+$7 ,7 6 $1 81'8/< 35(-8',&,$/ .,1' 2) 2%6(59$7,21 21 7+( 3/$,17,)) 6 &2816(/ 6 3$57 05 0,77(/67$('7 72 0( ,7 6 025( 7+$1 '(6&5,37,9( $1' ,) 7+(< '21 7 &+226( 72 3/$< 25 :( '21 7 &+226( 72 3/$< 7+( 5(0$,1,1* 9,'(27$3( 2) 7+( 5(0$,1,1* %2$5' 0(0%(56 7+(1 ,7 :28/' &/($5/< %( ,03(50,66,%/( , 0($1 7+( ,03/,&$7,21 7+( &2857 , '21 7 $*5(( , '21 7 $*5(( 2%-(&7,21 6 29(558/(' $// 5,*+7 7$.( 7$.( $ %5($. 05 3,&.(77 7+$1. <28 5(&(66 7$.(1 $7 $0 352&((',1*6 5(680(' $7 $0 7+( )2//2:,1* 352&((',1*6 :(5( +($5' ,1 7+( 35(6(1&( 2) 7+( -85< 7+( &/(5. 3/($6( %( 6($7(' $1' &20( 72 25'(5 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 &217,18( 05 3,&.(77 7+$1. <28 <285 +2125 4 +20(675(7&+ 05 0(<(5 :( 5( 72 7+( 7+,5' /,&(16( 7+$7 6 $ 7+$7 6$3 :28/' 1(*27,$7( 81'(5 7+,6 0($685( 2) '$0$*(6 7+$7 6 $ /,&(16( 72 7+( 25$&/( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( +2: ',' <28 $1$/<=( 7+$7 /,&(16( $1' 7+( 1(*27,$7,216 )25 ,7" $ ,1 620( 5(63(&76 , )2//2:(' 7+( 6$0( 352&(66 ,7 :$6 $ /,77/( 6,03/(5 %87 ,7 6 $ /,&(16( )25 7+( 86( 2) 25$&/( 6 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 7,0( 0$<%( 7:2 7,0(6 %87 (9(5< 7,0( :( +($5 $%287 05 %5$1'7 :( $/62 +($5 +,0 '(6&5,%(' $6 7+( 21/< %2$5' 0(0%(5 :+2 :28/' &20( 287 +(5( $1' )$&( 7+( -85< $1' , 7+,1. 7+$7 6 ,03(50,66,%/( 05 3,&.(77 7+( ',))(5(1&( ,6 :( '21 7 +$9( 7+( 32:(5 72 %5,1* 7+(0 ,1 %(&$86( 285 68%32(1$ 32:(5 ,6 /,0,7(' 72 $ &(57$,1 180%(5 2) 0,/(6 )520 7+( &2857+286( 7+(< +$9( 7+( 32:(5 7+(< +$9( 7+(< 5( 7+(,5 :,71(66(6 62 ,7 6 7+$7 6 7+( ',))(5(1&( 7+( &2857 '2 <28 +$9( <28 0$'( 7+26( 5()(5(1&(6 ,1 025( 7+$1 6,03/< $ '(6&5,37,9( )$6+,21" 25 $5( <28 ,1'((' 75<,1* 72 ,16,18$7( 620(7+,1* 21 7+( 3$57 2) 7+( '()(1'$176 ,1 127 352'8&,1* 68&+ $6 127 352'8&,1* (9,'(1&( 7+$7 7+(< 5( $%/( 72 352'8&(" , 0($1 7+(5( $5( &(57$,1 ,16758&7,216 05 3,&.(77 <($+ ,7 6 127 ,7 6 127 7+$7 7+(< 5( 127 ,7 '2(61 7 *2 7+$7 )$5 $7 $// ,7 6 127 7+$7 7+(< 5( 127 352'8&,1* (9,'(1&( 7+$7 7+(< 5( 68335(66,1* ,1 620( :$< ,7 6 -867 $ 9(5< &20021 6(16( 35$&7,&$/ ',))(5(1&( 7+$7 7+( -85< &$1 6(( $1' , 7+,1. ,7 6 :( &$1 &200(17 21 ,7 7+( &2857 , &(57$,1/< 127,&(' ,7 $1' ,7 +$6 127 $33($5(' 72 0( 72 %( $1 ,03523(5 2%6(59$7,21 21 7+( 3$57 2) 3/$,17,))6 &2816(/ , 0($1 7+( -85< .12:6 7+(< 9( 6((1 7+5(( 2) 7+( ),9( %2$5' 0(0%(56 7(67,)< %< '(326,7,21 62 )25 <28 72 6$< 7+$7 +( 6 68**(67,1* 7+$7 7+(< +$9(1 7 7(67,),(' :(// 7+(< .12: 7+$7 +( 6 7+(< 7(67,),(' 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( $1' ,1)250$7,21 :28/' %( 7$.(1 287 2) 7+$7 287 2) 7+$7 '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( $1' 387 ,172 7+( $33/,&$7,216 7+$7 7202552:12: +$' 0$'( $1' 62 ,7 6 ,7 6 $ 1(*27,$7,21 )25 7+( 86( 2) 7+$7 62)7:$5( 4 $1' :+$7 :28/' 7+$7 /,&(16( &29(5 7+( 25$&/( '$7$%$6( /,&(16( 7+$7 6$3 :28/' 1(('" $ ,7 :28/' &29(5 7+( &86720(56 7+$7 :(5( %(1(),7,1* )520 7+$7 86,1* 7+$7 '$7$%$6( /,&(16( )25 7+( 3(5,2'6 2) 7,0( :+(1 7+(< %(1(),7(' 62 , +$' ,1)250$7,21 $%287 :+(1 7+26( &86720(56 :(5( ),567 6(59,&(' %< 7202552:12: $1' 7+(1 , 581 7+$7 &$/&8/$7,21 )520 7+26( '$7(6 287 7+528*+ 2&72%(5 4 '2 <28 .12: :+$7 7+( 9$5,286 9(56,216 2) 7+( 7<3( 2) '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( :28/' %( &29(5(' %< 7+( /,&(16(" $ 7+,6 :28/' %( 7+( 7+( 9(56,21 7+$7 :$6 3$57 2) 7+( 67,38/$7,21 2) ,1)5,1*(0(17 :+,&+ &29(5(' 7+( (17(535,6( (',7,21 62 7+( (17(535,6( (',7,21 2) 7+( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( :$6 3$57 2) 7+( 67,38/$7,21 $6 72 :+$7 :$6 ,1)5,1*(' %< 6$3 7202552:12: $1' 7+$7 6 7+( 9(56,21 :( 5( )2&86,1* 21 4 62 :( :( .12: :+$7 7+( /,&(16( :28/' &29(5 %(&$86( :( /22.(' $7 7+( 67,38/$7,21" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 7+$7 6 6,0,/$5 72 :+$7 <28 ',' )25 7+( 3(23/(62)7 $1' 6,(%(/ /,&(16(6" $ (;$&7/< 4 $1' 7+(1 7+( /(7 6 /(7 6 &87 72 7+( 6$3 6,'( +2: 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 6 - November 9, 2010
SHEET 13

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 :+$7 :(5( 6$3 6 *2$/6 )25 86,1* 7+( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5(" $ :(// )520 0< 3(563(&7,9( %$6,&$//< 7202552:12: $6 ,7 3529,'(' ,76 6(59,&( 72 ,76 &86720(56 0$'( &23,(6 $1' ',' 27+(5 7<3(6 2) ,1)5,1*(0(17 2) 7+( 62)7:$5( 7+( $33/,&$7,21 62)7:$5( 5(/$7(' 72 3(23/(62)7 $1' -' (':$5'6 %87 $/62 +$' 72 86( 7+( 25$&/( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( 62 )520 0< 3(563(&7,9( ,) 7+$7 6$3 ,6 7$.,1* $ /,&(16( )25 7+( $33/,&$7,21 62)7:$5( $1' $// 7+( 0$7(5,$/6 7+(< ' $/62 +$9( 72 ,1 7$1'(0 7$.( $ '$7$%$6( /,&(16( 27+(5:,6( 7+(< :28/'1 7 %( $%/( 72 (;75$&7 7+( '$7$ )520 7+( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( 7+$7 7+(< :28/' 1((' $7 7,0(6 :+(1 7+(< 5( '2,1* 7+(,5 9$5,286 83'$7(6 $1' :+$7 127 ,1 6(59,&,1* 7+26( &86720(56 4 ,6 7+$7 758( 2) $// &86720(56 7+$7 7202552:12: $1' 6$3 6(59,&('" $ 127 $// 7+( &86720(56 12 -867 ,7 :$6 $ 68%6(7 2) 7+26( &86720(56 4 $// 5,*+7 :(// 7+(1 /(7 6 /(7 6 /22. $7 +2: <28 0($685(' 7+( 9$/8( 2) 7+( '$7$%$6( /,&(16( (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 7+,6 ,6 6/,'( :+$7 '2 <28 6+2: +(5(" $ +(5( , -867 +$9( 6257 2) $ 6758&785( 723 72 %27720 2) $ &283/( 2) 7+,1*6 7+$7 , :(17 7+528*+ $1' &216,'(5(' 72 &20( 83 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 $ 7+(5( :$6 $1 ,668( $%287 7+( 7+( 6(59(5 &21),*85$7,21 2) 7202552:12: %(&$86( 7+( :$< 25$&/( 35,&(6 287 7+( '$7$%$6( /,&(16( ,7 6 %$6(' 21 7+( 6,=( 2) 7+( 6(59(5 $1' 62 :( +$' 7+$7 ,1)250$7,21 )520 7202552:12: 6 5(&25'6 $1' ,1 7+$7 352&(66 :( :(5( 8/7,0$7(/< &$0( 72 81'(567$1' , %(/,(9( ,7 :$6 6,; 352&(66256 $1' 7+(< &+$5*( )25 7+( 62)7:$5( %$6(' 21 7+( 180%(5 2) 352&(66256 62 :( :(5( $%/( 72 &20( 83 :,7+ $ &$/&8/$7,21 2) 2) 6,; 352&(66256 7,0(6 $ 9$/8( 72 &20( 83 :,7+ 7+( 727$/ 35,&,1* 62 ,7 :$6 ,03257$17 72 81'(567$1' 7+( +$5':$5( &21),*85$7,21 2) 7202552:12: 4 <28 +$' 72 81'(567$1' 7+( +$5':$5( &21),*85$7,21 7202552:12: 86(' ,1 25'(5 72 81'(567$1' +2: 7+( 35,&(6 :28/' $33/<" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $// 5,*+7 /(7 6 *2 72 67(3 7+5(( :+$7 ,6 7+$7" $ $1' 7+(1 67(3 7+5(( :( +$' 72 &20( 83 :,7+ $ 35,&( $1' 62 ,7 7851(' 287 ,7 :$6 6,; 352&(66256 $7 3(5 352&(6625 62 )25 7+,6 '$7$%$6( /,&(16( ,7 :28/' %( 3$,' $1' 7+(1 7+(5( :28/' %( $118$/ 0$,17(1$1&( $7 $%287 $ <($5 62 7+$7 6 6257 2) 7+( 35,&( )25 ($&+ 2) 7+( '$7$%$6( /,&(16(6 4 )25 ($&+ 2) 7+( /,&(16(6 7+$7 &86720(5 '$7$%$6( 7+$7 7202552:12: :$6 $&&(66,1*" $ 7+$7 6 5,*+7 62 )25 ($&+ &86720(5 8/7,0$7(/< 7+$7 6 ,1 7+( &$/&8/$7,21 7+(< :28/' 1((' $ '$7$%$6( /,&(16( $7 $ 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 :,7+ 7+( 29(5$// /,&(16( 8/7,0$7(/< , 67$57(' :,7+ 81'(567$1',1* 25$&/( 6 '$7$%$6( /,&(16,1* 35$&7,&(6 $1' , ',' 7+$7 %(&$86( , :$17(' 72 81'(567$1' ,) 25$&/( +$' (9(5 /,&(16(' ,76 '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( ,1 7+(6( .,1'6 2) &,5&8067$1&(6 $1' , )281' 287 7+(< 1(9(5 +$9( 7+(< ' 1(9(5 /,&(16(' 7+( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( 72 $ &203(7,725 72 2))(5 +($' 72 +($' &203(7,7,21 ,1 3529,',1* 0$,17(1$1&( 6(59,&(6 /,.( 7202552:12: :$6 '2,1* 62 7+,6 :28/' %( $ ),567 7,0( (9(5 7+,1* 62 )520 7+$7 3(563(&7,9( , :$17(' 72 81'(567$1' 7+$7 352&(66 $1' , 7$/.(' 72 05 $//,621 $ &283/( 7,0(6 )520 25$&/( , %(/,(9( +( 7(67,),(' ,1 7+( 75,$/ /$67 :((. 4 21 )5,'$< $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 $1' , 5($' +,6 7(67,021< $1' ,7 :$6 &216,67(17 :,7+ :+$7 +( 72/' 0( ,1 7+( 3$67 $%287 7+( 25$&/( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( $1' :+< 7+,6 :28/' %( 6257 2) $ 81,48( /,&(16,1* %(&$86( 7+(< -867 '21 7 /,&(16( &203(7,7256 72 &203(7( /,.( 7+,6 4 :$6 +,6 7(67,021< 72 7+( -85< 7+( 6$0( $6 +,6 67$7(0(176 72 <28 35,25 72 <285 '2,1* 7+,6 $1$/<6,6" $ <(6 6,5 4 $// 5,*+7 ,1 285 67(3 7:2 62 +( *$9( <28 7+( '$7$%$6( /,&(16(6 35$&7,&(6 $6 +( '(6&5,%(' 7+(0 21 )5,'$<" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $1' 7+(1 67(3 7:2 ,6 :+$7" 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 <($5 3/86 0$,17(1$1&( 4 $1' :+$7 :$6 <285 1(;7 67(3 )25 7+( 180%(5 2) &86720(56 :+2 %(1(),7('" $ 7+$7 :$6 72 '(7(50,1( +2: 0$1< %(1(),7,1* &86720(56 $1' , +$' ,1)250$7,21 $%287 7+$7 $1' , %(/,(9( , +$9( $ 6/,'( 7+$7 6+2:6 7+$7 620(:+(5( 7+$7 &2817 2) &86720(56 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 7+( :,71(66 $1' 62 :( .1(: )520 6,0,/$5 5(63216(6 %< 6$3 ,1 ',6&29(5< 7+$7 &86720(5 (19,5210(176 +$' %((1 &5($7(' 21 7+( 7202552:12: 6(59(56 62 :+(1 7+26( (19,5210(176 :(5( &5($7(' 21 7+( 7202552:12: 6(59(56 7+(< 7+(1 $&&(66(' 25$&/( 6 '$7$%$6( $1' 62 7+26( &86720(56 :28/' 1((' $ /,&(16( 72 25$&/( 6 '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( $1' 7+(1 :( :(5( $%/( 72 '(7(50,1( 7+$7 7+(5( :(5( ),;(6 7+$7 :(5( '(9(/23(' 21 7+( &86720(5 (19,5210(176 7+$7 7+$7 :(5( 86,1* 7+( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( 62 7+$7 6(&21' *5283 ,6 %$6,&$//< :+$7 6 &$//(' &21),50(' &5266 86( :,7+ 25$&/( /2&$/ '$7$%$6( (19,5210(176 $1' 7+$7 6 7+( 1(;7 &86720(56 $1' 7+(1 7+( /$67 *5283 ,6 -867 &86720(56 2) 7202552:12: 7+$7 +$' 7+( +80$1 5(6285&( $33/,&$7,21 $1' 7+$7 180%(5 %$6,&$//< $6680(6 7+$7 7+26( &86720(56 722. 722. %(1(),76 )520 7+( ),;(6 $1' 83'$7(6 7+$7 &$0( 287 2) 7+( ),567 7:2 *52836 62 7+( 727$/ ,6 &86720(56 7+$7 :28/' 1((' $ 6(3$5$7( '$7$%$6( /,&(16( )520 7+( 3(563(&7,9( 2) 7+,6 7+,6 1(*27,$7,21 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 6 - November 9, 2010
0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 4 $1' +2: 08&+ ',' <28 &21&/8'( 7+( '$7$%$6( /,&(16( )(( :28/' %(" $ 7+( +(5( 6 7+( &$/&8/$7,21 ,7 6 35(77< 6(3$5$7( )25:$5' (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 7+( :,71(66 , 0(17,21(' $ 020(17 $*2 7+(5( :(5( &86720(56 ($&+ 21( :28/' 7$.( $ /,&(16( $7 7+( $118$/ 0$,17(1$1&( 5816 $1' 7+(1 7+( 7,0( 3(5,2' ,6 )520 7+( 7,0( ($&+ 2) 7+( &86720(56 %(&$0( $ 7202552:12: &86720(5 7+528*+ 2&72%(5 $1' 7+(1 :+(1 <28 '2 7+( 0$7+ 2) 7+$7 ,7 6 0,//,21 7+$7 6 7+( 727$/ )25 7+( '$7$%$6( /,&(16( 05 3,&.(77 $// 5,*+7 /(7 0( *2 72 7+( 1(;7 6/,'( (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 2+ , 0 6255< , 0$<%( ','1 7 +($5 ,7 0$<%( <28 0,6632.( '2 7+( &86720(56 7$.( 7+( '$7$%$6( /,&(16( 25 '2(6 7202552:12: 7$.( $ '$7$%$6( /,&(16( )25 ($&+ &86720(5 $6 72 :+2 6 '$7$%$6( ,7 $&&(66(6" $ ,7 :28/' %( 7202552:12: 7+$7 :28/' %( 7$.,1* 7+( /,&(16( $1' 7+(< 5( 7+( 21(6 3529,',1* 6(59,&( 72 7+( &86720(56 62 7+(6( $5( $// 21 7202552:12: 6(59(56 7+$7 6 :+(5( 7+( '$7$%$6( 5(6,'(6 4 $1' <28 &$/&8/$7( ,7 2)) 7+( &21),*85$7,216 7+$7 7202552:12: +$' 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55 0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 05 3,&.(77 $// 5,*+7 7+$1. <28 , +$9( 12 )857+(5 48(67,216 , :28/' /,.( 72 029( 127 ,172 (9,'(1&( %87 $6 $1 (;+,%,7 )25 7+( 5(&25' 7+( '(021675$7,9(6 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 ,6 7+(5( $1< 2%-(&7,21 05 &2:$1 12 <285 +2125 7+( &2857 72 05 3,&.(77 $// 5,*+7 :( // 35(3$5( 7+$7 (;+,%,7 <285 +2125 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 7+$7 :,// %( $'0,77(' 05 0,77(/67$('7 $5( <28 *2,1* 72 &21'8&7 7+( &5266 (;$0,1$7,21" 05 0,77(/67$('7 <(6 <285 +2125 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 $1' ,6 12: 7+( $335235,$7( 7,0( )25 0( 72 *,9( 7+( /,0,7,1* ,16758&7,21" $5( <28 *2,1* 72 86( 7+$7 (9,'(1&(" 05 0,77(/67$('7 /$7(5 21 %87 *2 $+($' 7+( &2857 2.$< $// 5,*+7 05 0,77(/67$('7 -867 62 :( '21 7 )25*(7 7+( &2857 2.$< $// 5,*+7 /$',(6 $1' *(17/(0(1 '85,1* 7+( &5266 (;$0,1$7,21 2) 25$&/( 6 (;3(57 :,71(66 7+$7 :( -867 +($5' $1' $%287 :+,&+ 05 0,77(/67$('7 ,6 $%287 72 (1*$*( ,1 7+( '()(1'$176 0$< 35(6(17 7:2 '(&/$5$7,216 )520 &86720(56 2) &2:/,7= &2817< :$6+,1*721 7+(6( '(&/$5$7,216 $5( 5(/,(' 8321 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 $ (;$&7/< 4 $// 5,*+7 12: /(7 6 680 83 7+(1 +(5( (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 7+( ),567 /,&(16( 7+( 3(23/(62)7 /,&(16( :( 9( &$//(' ,7 ,1&/8'(6 7+( -' (':$5'6 62)7:$5( <28 6$< 7+$7 6 $7 /($67 %,//,21" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $1' ,6 ,7 ,03257$17 :(// 7+(5( :( *2 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 ,6 ,7 ,03257$17 7+$7 ,7 6 $7 /($67 ,1 <285 9,(: , 0($1 <28 5( 127 $7 %,//,21 <28 5( $7 /($67 5,*+7" $ , 7+$7 6 &255(&7 $1' , 7+,1. )520 7+( &+$576 :( 6+2:(' 72'$< $1' 7+( 5(68/76 2) 0< &$/&8/$7,216 7+(5( 6 &(57$,1/< 5($621 72 +$9( 7+( 9$/8( +,*+(5 %87 , )(/7 7+$7 7+,6 :$6 $ 5($621$%/( 3/$&( 72 %( $1' , 0 &20)257$%/( :,7+ $7 /($67 $1' &(57$,1/< 21( &28/' &28/' &20( 83 :,7+ &20( 83 :,7+ 9(5< 6281' /2*,& 72 +$9( $ +,*+(5 $02817 4 $// 5,*+7 $1' :( 6(( 7+( 6,(%(/ $1' 7+( '$7$%$6( 62 ,1 <285 23,1,21 05 0(<(5 7+( 727$/ '$0$*(6 ,1 7+,6 &$6( $5( $7 /($67 6,; +81'5(' 7+286$1'" <28 &$1 352%$%/< 6$< 7+$7 180%(5 %(77(5 7+$1 , $ 0$<%( 127 %87 ,7 6 :28/' %( 7+( '$0$*(6 $7 /($67 7+$7 $02817 7+$7 6 &255(&7 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 ',5(&7 5(680(' 3,&.(77 %< 3/$,17,))6 '$0$*(6 (;3(57 ,1 )250,1* +,6 23,1,216 7+( (9,'(1&( &217$,1(' ,6 $'0,66,%/( 21/< )25 7+( 385326( 2) 7+( 385326( 2) (;3/$,1,1* 7+( %$6,6 2) 05 0(<(5 6 23,1,21 ,7 ,6 127 2))(5(' )25 7587+ 2) 7+( ,1)250$7,21 &217$,1(' ,1 7+( '(&/$5$7,21 $1' 6+28/' 127 %( &216,'(5(' %< <28 )25 7+$7 385326( $// 5,*+7 &2816(/" &5266 (;$0,1$7,21 %< 05 0,77(/67$('7 4 *22' 0251,1* 05 0(<(5 $ *22' 0251,1* 4 0< 1$0( ,6 %2% 0,77(/67$('7 , 0 *2,1* 72 $6. <28 620( 48(67,216 <28 $5( %(,1* 3$,' %< 25$&/( 72 7(67,)< 21 ,76 %(+$/) ,1 7+,6 &$6( ,6 7+$7 &255(&7" $ 0< ),50 :28/' %( 4 $1' <285 ),50 <28 2:1 :,7+ 21( 27+(5 3(5621 ,6 7+$7 &255(&7" $ 7+$7 6 127 &255(&7 4 <28 9( %((1 3$,' +2: 08&+" $ :(// 0< ),506 &$86( , :+(1 , %(*$1 7+,6 $66,*10(17 ,1 , :$6 :,7+ $ /$5*( 38%/,&/< 75$'(' &203$1< &$//(' 1$9,*$17 &2168/7,1* $1' , 7+,1. ,1 7+$7 7,0( )5$0( :( :(5( $7 1$9,*$17 :28/'1 7 +$9( 7+( (;$&7 $02817 %87 1$9,*$17 &2168/7,1* :$6 3$,' $%287 7:2 $1' $ +$/) 0,//,21 '2//$56 $1' 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 6 - November 9, 2010
SHEET 17

0(<(5 &5266 05 0,77(/67$('7 4 7+( 1(;7 6(17(1&( 6$<6 7+( '2:1/2$'6 :(5( &21'8&7(' %< 7202552:12: 6 (03/2<((6 86,1* &(57$,1 /$37236 $1' '(6.7236 $6 :(// $6 '(',&$7(' '2:1/2$' 6(59(56 /2&$7(' $7 7202552:12: 6 '$7$ &(17(5 ,1 %5<$1 7(;$6 '2 <28 6(( 7+$7" $ 5,*+7 7+$7 6 )520 7+( (,*+7+ $0(1'(' 6833/(0(17$/ 5(63216( 72 7+,6 ,6 7+( '()(1'$176 ,17(552*$725< 5(63216(6 '(&(0%(5 7+ 4 $1' <285 81'(567$1',1* :$6 7+$7 7+,6 /,&(16( 7+$7 <28 5( 7(//,1* 86 :+$7 7+( 52<$/7< :28/' %( :28/' 3(50,7 7202552:12: 72 (1*$*( ,1 7+$7 &21'8&7 &255(&7" $ :(// %$&. ,1 0< 5(3257 :+(5( , $&78$//< $''5(66 7+( 9$/8( 2) 7+( /,&(16( , +$9( $ 6&23( 6(&7,21 $1' , $''5(66 :+$7 7+( 6&23( ,6 %87 , :28/' /($9( ,7 72 27+(56 $6 72 :+(5( 7+,1*6 +$33(1(' 7+( 6&23( 2) 7+( 0$7(5,$/6 7+$7 :(5( 7$.(1 ,6 7+( 6&23( 2) 7+( /,&(16( 4 %87 6,5 , :$17 72 +$9( <28 %( 025( 35(&,6( 7+$1 7+$7 7+,6 /,&(16( 7+$7 :( +$9( $// +($5' $%287 7+( /,&(16( :28/' ,1 3$57 3(50,7 7202552:12: 72 '2:1/2$' 7+( 0$7(5,$/6 7+$7 ,7 '2:1/2$'(' &255(&7" $ $6 $ :+2//< 2:1(' 68%6,',$5< 2) 6$3 <(6 7+(< :28/' +$9( $ /,&(16( 7202552:12: :28/' +$9( $ /,&(16( 72 '2 :+$7 7+(< $&78$//< ',' ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

0(<(5 &5266 05 0,77(/67$('7 48(67,21 4 )25 (;$03/( $ ,7 6281'6 /,0,7,1* )25 620( 5($621 , 1((' 72 81'(567$1' :+< 4 , :$17 72 81'(567$1' :+$7 6 7+( 6&23( 2) /,&(16( 7+$7 <28 +$9( ,1 0,1' 62 /(7 0( $6. 7+( 48(67,21 7+,6 :$< 81'(5 7+( /,&(16( 7+$7 <28 5( 7$/.,1* $%287 &28/' 7202552:12: *2 287 $1' 6(// 25$&/( 62)7:$5( $6 ,76 2:1 62)7:$5(" $ 12 ,7 &$1 '2 :+$7 ,7 $&78$//< 722. ,1 7+( 5($/ :25/' ,1 7+( 5($/ :25/' 62 ,7 $&78$//< ,1 7+( 5($/ :25/' '2:1/2$'(' 0,//,216 2) 7+,1*6 &5($7(' 7+286$1'6 2) &23,(6 $// 7+(6( (19,5210(176 7+$7 $&78$//< ',' 7+$7 7+$7 6 $// %((1 $*5((' 8321 62 7+$7 %8&.(7 2) :+$7 ,7 ',' $&78$//< ',' $// 7+$7 3523(57< ,6 ,1 7+( 6&23( 2) 7+( /,&(16( 7+$7 6 :+$7 , 9$/8(' 4 2.$< :( $5( $ 7+$7 6 $&78$//< :+$7 :+$7 7+(< 722. ,6 :+$7 +$6 %((1 9$/8(' 7+( $&78$/ 7$.,1* 4 :( $5( *(77,1* &/26( +(5( 7202552:12: ',' 7+$7 )25 7+( 385326( 2) 3529,',1* 6833257 72 ,76 &86720(56 &255(&7" $ ,) <28 $5( $6.,1* :$6 7202552:12: $ 6(59,&( (17,7< 7+$7 :$17(' 72 3529,'( 6833257 72 3(23/(62)7 &86720(56 , +$9( %((1 7(67,)<,1* $%287 7+$7 <(6 7+$7 6 :+$7 7+(< :28/' '2 :,7+ ,7 $6 3$57 2) 7+( 6$)( 3$66$*( 352*5$0 <(6 , $*5(( :,7+ 7+$7 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

0(<(5 &5266 05 0,77(/67$('7 4 , $0 127 $6.,1* <28 $%287 7+( &25325$7( 2:1(56+,3 , $0 -867 $6.,1* $%287 7+( 6&23( 2) <285 /,&(16( ,7 :28/' %( 72 3(50,7 7202552:12: 72 '2:1/2$' 0$7(5,$/6 )25 7+( 385326(6 2) 3529,',1* 6833257 72 ,76 &86720(56 &255(&7" $ , '21 7 )2//2: <285 48(67,21 12: ,7 :28/' $//2: 7202552:12: 72 '2 7+( 7+,1*6 7+$7 ,7 ',' ,76 '2:1/2$',1* $&7,9,7< :+$7 ,7 $&78$//< ',' :,7+ '2:1/2$'6 ,7 &28/' '2 7+$7 $6 3$57 2) 7+( /,&(16( 4 %87 ,7 :$6 ,03257$17 72 <28 72 81'(567$1' :+$7 7202552:12: ',' ,1 25'(5 72 ),*85( 287 :+$7 7+,6 /,&(16( :$6 5,*+7" $ :(// , +$9( 7+$7 ,7 6 )281' 7+( 67,38/$7(' /,$%,/,7< ,1)5,1*(0(17 ,668(6 , +$9( 7+$7 62 $1' , +$9( ,7 $6 3$57 2) 7+( ,17(552*$725,(6 , '21 7 81'(567$1' <285 48(67,21 4 /(7 0( 75< 72 (;3/$,1 ,7 72 <28 25 $6. ,7 $ ',))(5(17 :$< ,1 *(1(5$/ 7(506 6,5 <285 /,&(16( :28/' $//2: 7202552:12: 72 '2:1/2$' 62)7:$5( 6833257 0$7(5,$/6 )520 25$&/( 6 :(%6,7( &255(&7" 3$57 2) :+$7 ,7 :28/' '2" $ <(6 , :28/' $*5(( :,7+ 7+$7 7+$7 :$6 3$57 2) :+$7 7+( '2:1/2$'6 $&78$//< ',' 7+(1 7+(< &28/' '2 7+$7 4 2.$< )25 7+( 385326( 2) 3529,',1* 6833257 72 7202552:12: 6 &86720(56 &255(&7" $ 6(( 7+$7 6 :+(5( , '21 7 81'(567$1' 7+( 48(67,21 ,7 6 /,.( <28 $5( 75<,1* 72 0$.( 7+,6 , '21 7 81'(567$1' 7+( ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

0(<(5 &5266 05 0,77(/67$('7 4 2.$< $6 23326(' 72 5(3$&.$*,1* ,7 $6 7202552:12: 62)7:$5( $1' *2,1* 29(56($6 620(3/$&( 72 5(6(// ,7 $6 7+(,5 2:1 727$//< 815(/$7(' 72 6833257 $&7,9,7,(6 &255(&7" $ 5,*+7 4 7+( /,&(16( :28/'1 7 3(50,7 7+$7 :28/' ,7" $ 7+$7 6 5,*+7 ,7 6 *($5(' 72:$5'6 7+( $&78$/ '2:1/2$',1* 2) :+$7 :$6 7$.(1 4 $1' <28 :,// $*5(( 7+$7 7+$7 '2:1/2$',1* $1' 7+( &23<5,*+7 ,1)5,1*(0(17 :$6 '21( %< 7202552:12: ,1 6(59,&,1* ,76 6833257 &86720(56 &255(&7" $ , &$1 $*5(( 7+$7 ,1 $ *(1(5$/ 6(16( ,7 -867 :$61 7 3$57 2) +2: , +$' 72 9,(: 7+( 6&23( 2) 7+( /,&(16( , .1(: 7+( $&78$/ 3523(57< $1' 7+$7 6 :+$7 ,7 &29(56 62 :+$7(9(5 4 2.$< /(7 6 7851 12: 72 7+,6 +<327+(7,&$/ /,&(16( $1' $6 , 81'(567$1' <285 &21&(378$/ $3352$&+ <28 $5( 75<,1* 72 &21'8&7 $ +<327+(7,&$/ 1(*27,$7,21 $1' 72 ),*85( 287 :+$7 :,//,1* %8<(56 $1' 6(//(56 :28/' %( :,//,1* 72 3$< )25 7+,6 /,&(16( &255(&7" $ , $*5(( :,7+ 7+$7 4 $1' 7+( 7(67 ,6 7+( $02817 7+$7 $ /,&(1625 $1' /,&(16(( +(5( 25$&/( $1' 6$3 :28/' +$9( $*5((' 8321 $7 7+( 7,0( 7+( &23<5,*+7 ,1)5,1*(0(17 %(*$1 ,) %27+ +$' %((1 5($621$%/< $1' 92/817$5,/< 75<,1* 72 5($&+ $1 $*5((0(17 $ 5,*+7 7+$7 6 7+( '(),1,7,21 2) :,//,1* ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 6 - November 9, 2010
0(<(5 &5266 05 0,77(/67$('7 4 2.$< $1' ,1 27+(5 :25'6 7+( $02817 <28 $5( 75<,1* 72 $55,9( $7 7+( $02817 7+$7 $ 358'(17 /,&(16(( :+2 :$17(' 72 (17(5 ,172 7+,6 %86,1(66 352326,7,21 :28/' +$9( %((1 :,//,1* 72 3$< $6 $ 52<$/7< $1' <(7 %( $%/( 72 0$.( $ 5($621$%/( 352),7 :+,&+ $02817 :28/' +$9( %((1 $&&(37$%/( %< $ 358'(17 /,&(1625 :+2 :$6 :,//,1* 72 *5$17 $ /,&(16( ,6 7+$7 $127+(5 :$< 2) 6$<,1* :+$7 <28 $5( 75<,1* 72 *(7 $7" $ 12 127 1(&(66$5,/< , 7+,1. 7+$7 <28 $5( 12: 75<,1* 72 /,0,7 ,7 $1' 7+(5( 6 '(%$7( $%287 :+(7+(5 7+( /,&(16(( +$6 72 0$.( 352),76 %87 7+$7 6 29(55,' %< 27+(5 ,668(6 7+,6 ,6 :+$7 7:2 3$57,(6 :28/' $*5(( 72 7+$7 $5( %27+ 7+(5( ,1 $ :,//,1* )$6+,21 21( 1(('6 $ /,&(16( 21( +$6 72 *,9( 7+( /,&(16( 7+(< $5( 127 7+(5( 81'(5 $1< .,1' 2) '85(66 7+(< $// +$9( 23(1 ,1)250$7,21 $9$,/$%/( 72 7+(0 ,1 -$18$5< %87 7+(5( 6 12 (;3(&7$7,21 7+$7 620(21( +$6 72 0$.( 5($621$%/( 352),7 7+$7 6 127 :+$7 $/:$<6 &20(6 287 2) 7+(6( 1(*27,$7,216 4 :28/' <28 7851 72 3$5$*5$3+ $7 3$*( 2) <285 5(3257" 7+( &2857 &2816(/ :+$7 ,6 7+( 7$% 180%(5 2) 7+( 5(3257" :+$7 ,6 7+( (;+,%,7 180%(5" '2(6 $1<21( .12:" 7+( :,71(66 :+$7 3$*( :$6 7+$7" 05 0,77(/67$('7 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'& 0(<(5 &5266 05 0,77(/67$('7 /,&(16(( :+2 '(6,5(' $6 $ %86,1(66 352326,7,21 72 2%7$,1 $ /,&(16( 72 0$18)$&785( $1' 6(// $ 3$57,&8/$5 $57,&/( (0%2'<,1* 7+( $1' , 9( ,16(57(' &23<5,*+76 :28/' +$9( %((1 :,//,1* 72 3$< $6 $ 52<$/7< $1' <(7 %( $%/( 72 0$.( $ 5($621$%/( 352),7 ,1 :+,&+ $02817 :28/' +$9( %((1 $&&(37$%/( %< $ 358'(17 /,&(1625 :+2 :$6 :,//,1* 72 *5$17 $ /,&(16( 62 ,7 +$6 72 %( 21( :$176 7+( 352),7 $1' 21( +$6 72 %( $%/( 72 *5$17 ,7 21 7+26( 7(506 7+$7 6 *(25*,$ 3$&,),& $1' , $*5(( :,7+ 7+$7 4 ',' <28 5($' 7+( 3$57 $%287 <(7 %( $%/( 72 0$.( $ 5($621$%/( 352),7 " $ 5,*+7 %87 ,7 6 ,1 &21-81&7,21 :,7+ 7+( /,&(1625 +$6 72 %( :,//,1* 72 *5$17 ,7 21 7+26( 7(506 62 7+(5( 6 $ *,9( $1' 7$.( 21 7+$7 7+$7 6 +2: 7+$7 :25.6 4 62 :( $5( &/($5 :( $5( 75<,1* 72 5(&216758&7 :+$7 :28/' +$9( +$33(1(' ,1 $ 1(*27,$7,21 7+$7 ',' 127 $&78$//< 7$.( 3/$&( &255(&7" $ 5,*+7 , +$9( %((1 &/($5 72 7+( -85< 7+$7 7+,6 ,6 $ 1(*27,$7,21 7+$7 ',' 127 7$.( 3/$&( 4 ,7 1(9(5 +$33(1(' %(&$86( )25 21( 5($621 25$&/( ',' 127 $3352$&+ 6$3 72 2))(5 $ /,&(16( %(&$86( 25$&/( ,6 127 ,1 7+( %86,1(66 2) 2))(5,1* /,&(16(6 )25 ,76 62)7:$5( $1' 6833257 0$7(5,$/6 72 7+,5' 3$57,(6 7+$7 6 21( 5($621 ,7 ','1 7 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

0(<(5 &5266 05 0,77(/67$('7 7+( :,71(66 7+$1. <28 05 0,77(/67$('7 , $0 72/' ,7 6 127 ,1 7+( %,1'(5 %87 7+( :,71(66 +$6 21( :,7+ +,0 %87 <285 +2125 '2(61 7 62 :( :,// 05 3,&.(77 3$5$*5$3+ 67$576 $7 3$*( 3$86( ,1 7+( 352&((',1*6 %< 05 0,77(/67$('7 4 <28 &$1 5($' $6 08&+ 2) ,7 $6 <28 :$17 72 %87 , $0 5()(55,1* 72 7+( 3$5$*5$3+ 7+$7 <28 4827(' 05 3,&.(77 7+( 3$5$*5$3+ 67$576 21 3$*( 3$86( ,1 7+( 352&((',1*6 7+( &2857 *2 $+($' 05 0,77(/67$('7 05 0,77(/67$('7 :( :,// 3529,'( 21( 7+( &2857 , :,// ),1' 21( %< 05 0,77(/67$('7 4 '2 <28 6(( 7+( 3$57 7+$7 <28 4827( 7+(5(" $ <(6 )520 *(25*,$ 3$&,),& <(6 , 6(( 7+$7 4 <28 6(( $%287 +$/):$< '2:1 :+(5( ,7 67$576 7+$7 ,6 7+( $02817 " $ <(6 , $0 :,7+ <28 4 :28/' <28 5($' 287 /28' :+$7 ,7 6$<6" $ , /267 0< 7+28*+7 :28/' +$9( $*5((' 8321 ,) %27+ +$' %((1 5($621$%/< $1' 92/817$5,/< 75<,1* 72 5($&+ $1 $*5((0(17 7+$7 ,6 7+( $02817 :+,&+ $ 358'(17 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

0(<(5 &5266 05 0,77(/67$('7 +$33(1" 05 3,&.(77 2%-(&7,21 7+( &2857 6867$,1(' %< 05 0,77(/67$('7 4 $6 <28 81'(567$1' ,7 7+,6 +<327+(7,&$/ 1(*27,$7,21 +$6 72 %( 5($621$%/( &255(&7" $ , $*5(( :,7+ 7+$7 4 $1' ,7 0867 %( %$6(' 21 2%-(&7,9( ,1)250$7,21" $ , $*5(( :,7+ 7+$7 4 5$7+(5 7+$1 68%-(&7,9( 25 (;&(66,9(/< 63(&8/$7,9( ,1)250$7,21 &255(&7" $ , :28/' $*5(( :,7+ 7+$7 4 :28/' <28 $/62 $*5(( 7+$7 7+( 385326( +(5( ,6 127 72 %( 381,7,9(" $ 5,*+7 , +$9( %((1 &/($5 $%287 7+$7 ,668( 7+( )$,5 0$5.(7 9$/8( 2) 7+( /,&(16( 7+(5( 6+28/'1 7 %( $1<7+,1* 381,7,9( $%287 ,7 , $*5(( :,7+ 7+$7 4 7+( 385326( ,6 127 72 381,6+ %$' %(+$9,25 ,6 ,7" $ , $*5(( :,7+ 7+$7 4 '2 <28 $/62 $*5(( <28 '21 7 -867 $6. 7+( 6(//(5 +2: 08&+ +( :28/' ,16,67 21" $ $%62/87(/< 7+$7 6 127 3$57 2) 7+( 352&(66 4 7+$7 :28/' 352%$%/< 5(68/7 ,1 $ 180%(5 7+$7 6 722 +,*+" $ :(// 7+$7 :28/' *2 %$&. 72 21( :$176 72 0$;,0,=( ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< 9$/8( %87 7+$7 6 7+( 0$;,080 9$/8( ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 7 - November 12, 2010
SHEET 2

<28 $// &$1 $5*8( <285 9(5< <285 5(63(&7,9( 326,7,216 21 :+$7 7+$7 7(67,021< 0($16 <28 &$1 7$.( 7+( 326,7,21 7+$7 ,7 %($56 21 7+(,5 &5(',%,/,7< <28 &$1 7$.( 7+( 326,7,21 7+$7 :(// ,7 21/< *2(6 72 7+( (;7(17 2) 7+( '$0$*(6 ,1 7+( &$6( , '21 7 7+,1. 7+$7 7+$7 ,6 5($//< 2) 75(0(1'286 6,*1,),&$1&( :+$7 , 7+,1. ,6 ,03257$17 62 , :28/' $//2: 7+,6 7(67,021< ,1 $1' %27+ 2) <28 &$1 $5*8( $%287 ,7 :+,&+(9(5 :$< <28 %(/,(9( <28 <28 7+,1. ,6 $335235,$7( %87 0< &21&(51 ,6 ,6 7+$7 7+( -85< +$6 72 %( 72/' $1' :( // '2 7+$7 7+528*+ $ &85$7,9( ,16758&7,21 7+$7 ,55(63(&7,9( 2) :+$7 7+( ',5(&7256 6$< 7+$7 7+(5( ,6 12 ,17(17 72 ',6$92: /,$%,/,7< 21 7+( 3$57 2) 7+( 6$3 7+$7 1(('6 72 %( 6$,' &/($5/< $1' )5$1./< :,7+ 5(*$5' 72 7+( &85$7,9( ,16758&7,216 <28 $// 6$< 7+$7 .,1' 2) %87 127 $6 ',5(&7/< $6 , 7+,1. ,7 6+28/' %( 6$,' $1' 7+(1 <28 *2 21 72 $5*8( :+$7 7+( ,03257 ,6 $1' , 0 127 $6 &21&(51(' $%287 7+( 6(&21' 3$57 2) ,7 %(&$86( , )5$1./< 7+,1. 7+$7 7+,6 &$6( ,6 $// $%287 '$0$*(6 :( 9( 72/' 7+( -85< 29(5 $1' 29(5 $*$,1 ,7 6 $// $%287 '$0$*(6 , 7+,1. <28 $// 6+28/' 387 21 :+$7(9(5 (9,'(1&( <28 7+,1. 68332576 <285 326,7,21 $1' 0$.( :+$7(9(5 $5*80(176 <28 7+,1. $5( $335235,$7( 21 7+( %$6,6 2) 7+( (9,'(1&( 7+$7 <28 9( 387 21 $1' , '21 7 7+,1. ,7 6 5($//< 7+( &2857 6 5(63216,%,/,7< 72 7(// 7+( -85< +2: 7+(< 6+28/' %( /22.,1* $7 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

7+(,5 /$67 3$5$*5$3+" 05 %2,(6 , 7+,1. :( :(5( /22.,1* , :$6 /22.,1* $7 285 /$67 3$5$*5$3+ 7+( &2857 2.$< 05 %2,(6 $1' , 7+,1. 7+$7 7+( <28 &28/'1 7 +$9( -867 7+( ),567 7+5(( :,7+287 +$9,1* $ )2857+ 3$5$*5$3+ 7+$7 (;3/$,1(' +2: 7+(< 28*+7 72 +2: 7+( -85< 28*+7 72 ,17(535(7 620( 2) 7+$7 62 , '2 7+,1. 7+$7 7+( )2857+ 3$5$*5$3+ +$6 ,6 ,03257$17 7+( &2857 :(// , $*5(( $1' 7+( ),567 6(17(1&( ,6 ),1( %87 , 0 127 , 0 127 *2,1* 72 7(// 7+( -85< 7+$7 7+(< $5( 72 ',65(*$5' 7+( 7(67,021< %(&$86( 7+(< &$1 &216,'(5 7+( 7(67,021< )25 7+( 385326(6 7+$7 <28 $// $5( %27+ $'9$1&,1* , 7+,1. $1' , :28/'1 7 *,9( (;$03/(6 2) $5*80(17 25 48(67,216 7+$7 6+28/' %( ,*125(' (,7+(5 05 %2,(6 <28 &28/' <285 +2125 <28 &28/' 6723 $)7(5 7+( (1' 2) 7+( ),567 6(17(1&( <28 &28/' +$9( 7+( ),567 7+5(( 3$5$*5$3+6 $1' 7+(1 7+$7 ),567 6(17(1&( 2) 7+( /$67 3$5$*5$3+ 7+( &2857 <($+ , &28/' '2 7+$7 05 /$1,(5 :( :28/' 127 2%-(&7 72 7+$7 <285 +2125 7+( &2857 2.$< ',' <28 +$9( 620(7+,1* 72 $'' 05 +2:$5'" 05 +2:$5' 127 72 7+$7 3$5$*5$3+ <285 +2125 7+( &2857 2.$< 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

7+$7 (9,'(1&( 7+(< 6+28/' /22. $7 ,7 ,1 $1< :$< 7+$7 6 3(50,66,%/( $1' $6 /21* $6 7+(5( 6 620(7+,1* 21 7+( 5(&25' 7+$7 6$<6 7+$7 7+(5( ,6 12 ',6$92:$/ 2) /,$%,/,7< , 7+,1. 7+$7 :( 9( 7$.(1 &$5( 2) 7+( ,668( 7+$7 &21&(516 0( :+,&+ ,6 0< &21)86,21 2) 7+( -85< 62 05 /$1,(5 <285 +2125 7+(1 7+$7 :28/' /($' 86 7+(1 72 $ 3266,%,/,7< 2) 5(62/9,1* 7+( &85$7,9( ,16758&7,21 ,668( 7+( ),567 7+5(( 3$5$*5$3+6 , 7+,1. $5( $&78$//< $*5((' $7 7+,6 32,17 7+( &2857 <($+ 05 /$1,(5 $1' 7+$7 /$67 3$5$*5$3+ &28/' 6,03/< %( 620(7+,1* $6 675$,*+7)25:$5' $6 127:,7+67$1',1* :+$7 (9,'(1&( <28 0$< +$9( +($5' <28 6+28/' %( ,16758&7(' 25 , $0 ,16758&7,1* <28 7+$7 6$3 $* $1' 6$3 $0(5,&$ +$9( 67,38/$7(' 72 &2175,%8725< $1' 9,&$5,286 /,$%,/,7< 7+(< 67$1' %(+,1' 7+$7 67,38/$7,21 $1' '2 127 ',6$92: ,7 7+(< $5( 127 $5*8,1* 7+(< $5( 127 /,$%/( 7+$7 /$67 6(17(1&( :$6 %$' %87 :( &$1 &20( 83 :,7+ 620(7+,1* %(77(5 7+( &2857 <($+ 05 /$1,(5 $1' , 7+,1. 7+$7 :28/' *(7 72 <285 +2125 6 &21&(51 $1' 7+$7 2%9,286/< ,6 285 326,7,21 05 %2,(6 <285 +2125 , '2 7+,1. 7+$7 :,7+ 5(63(&7 72 7+$7 /$67 3$5$*5$3+ 7+( &2857 $5( :( /22.,1* $7 <285 /$67 3$5$*5$3+ 25 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

2)) 7+( 5(&25' ',6&866,21 7+( &2857 2.$< , 7+,1. 7+$7 7+$7 6 35(77< 08&+ $.,1 72 <2856 ,7 6 ,7 6 :+$7 &20(6 $)7(5 7+$7 ),567 6(17(1&( 2) 7+( 7+,5' 3$5$*5$3+ 7+$7 <28 $// 67$57 &203(7,1* $1' 2.$< $5( <28 $5( :( ,1 $*5((0(17 7+(1" 05 %2,(6 :(// <(6 <285 +2125 ,7 6 32,17(' 287 72 0( 7+$7 0< )5,(1' $1' , 0$< +$9( %((1 29(5/< 237,0,67,& 05 +2:$5' 6$<6 7+$7 7+(5( :$6 21( ,668( 7+$7 <28 +$' :,7+ 285 :,7+ 285 ),567 7+5(( 3$5$*5$3+6 05 /$1,(5 <($+ 7+(5( ,6 $ 05 %2,(6 ,6 5,*+7 ,1 ,7(0 7+(5( 6 $ ',))(5(1&( %(7:((1 ,1 7+( $57,&8/$7,21 2) 32,17 ,1 7+( 6(&21' 3$5$*5$3+" 7+( &2857 5,*+7 05 /$1,(5 7+(,56 6$<6 7+(< ,17(17,21$//< 0$7(5,$//< &2175,%87(' 72 25 ,1'8&(' :( $&78$//< 722. )520 ,7 7+( 02'(/ ,16758&7,21 $1' 6$,' 7+(< ,17(17,21$//< ,1'8&(' 25 0$7(5,$//< &2175,%87(' 72 :+,&+ :+,&+ :( 68%0,7 ,6 )520 7+( 02'(/ ,16758&7,21 7+(5( 6 ,6 7+$7 6 $ ',))(5(1&( 7+( &2857 :+$7 ',))(5(1&( '2(6 ,7 0$.( ,1 7(506 2) -867 7+( 25'(5" ,7 +$6 %27+ &20321(176 05 +2:$5' 7+$7 6 127 7+( ',))(5(1&( , :$6 32,17,1* 287 <285 +2125 7+$7 ,6 $ ',))(5(1&( %87 , '21 7 7+,1. 7+( 25'(5 2) 7+( :25' ,6 6,*1,),&$17 7+( 025( ,03257$17 ',))(5(1&( ,6 7+$7 $)7(5 ,1$&7,21 :( +$9( ,16(57(' 7+( /$1*8$*( &20%,1(' :,7+ 63(&,),& .12:/('*( 38568$17 72 285 ',6&866,21 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 7 - November 12, 2010
0(<(5 &5266 5(680(' 0,77(/67$('7 ,1 <285 &$/&8/$7,21 ,167($' 2) :( 86( $1' :( 86( %(,1* $// 7+( &86720(56 7+$7 :(17 72 7202552:12: $1' $// 7+( &86720(56 :+2 %28*+7 $1<7+,1* )520 6$3 :+,/( 7+(< :(5( $ 7202552:12: &86720(5 62 :( 7$.( 7+26( 723 180%(56 <285 52<$/7< &$/&8/$7,21 :28/' %( &216,'(5$%/< /2:(5 :28/'1 7 ,7" $ 7+( &86720(56 $5( 21/< 21( )$&725 7+$7 *2(6 ,172 7+( (17,5( $1$/<6,6 %87 ,) :( :(5( 72 &+$1*( 7+$7 )$&725 :( ' +$9( 72 *2 %$&. $1' '2 7+( $1$/<6,6 $1' $// 7+( 27+(5 7+,1*6 7+$7 :(17 ,172 7+( '(7(50,1$7,21 , 9( 63(17 $ &283/( '$<6 7(67,)<,1* $%287 <28 :28/' 7+(1 '2 7+$7 $1$/<6,6 $1' , '(6&5,%(' ,7 ,1 '(326,7,21 29(5 7+5(( '$<6 +2: 7+$7 :28/' +$33(1 4 2.$< %87 &$1 <28 $16:(5 <(6 25 12 " ,) <28 86( 7+26( $&78$/ 180%(56 <285 52<$/7< &$/&8/$7,21 :28/' %( &216,'(5$%/< /2:(5 :28/'1 7 ,7 <(6 25 12 " $ ,) <28 387 7+26( 180%(56 ,1 7+( &$/&8/$7,216 $1' &216,'(5(' (9(5<7+,1* (/6( , $*5(( 7+( 180%(56 :28/' *2 '2:1 4 +$9( <28 581 <285 02'(/ :,7+ 7+26( $&78$/ 180%(56" $ 12 ,7 :$6 127 5(/(9$17 72 0( 4 '2 <28 +$9( $1< ,'($ :+$7 7+( 287&20( :28/' %(" $ , 9( 127 581 7+$7 4 :28/'1 7 ,7 %( $%287 0,//,21" $ , 1((' 72 .12: <285 0$7+ 4 2.$< 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55 0(<(5 5(',5(&7 3,&.(77 4 $// 5,*+7 12: :( 6$: 27+(5 (67,0$7(6 2) 6$3 6 723 0$1$*(0(17 7+(,5 *2$/ :$6 3(5&(17 2) 7+( &86720(56 +2: 0$1< :28/' 3(5&(17 2) 7+( &86720(56 %(" $ :(// %$6,&$//< 7+(5( :$6 &86720(56 62 ,7 :28/' %( 0$,17(1$1&( &86720(56 $1' ,) 7+26( $/62 &219(57(' 72 0<6$3 ,7 :28/' %( 21 7+( &219(56,21 21 7+( /,&(16( 6,'( 4 $1' ,) <28 (;3(&7(' 72 *(7 7+$7 180%(5 5$7+(5 7+$1 7+( /2:(5 180%(5 <28 86(' :+$7 :28/' %( 7+( /,&(16( )(( 81'(5 7+26( &,5&8067$1&(6 ,1 <285 23,1,21" $ :(// ,7 :28/' *2 83 ,7 :$6 2%9,286/< ,7 :28/'1 7 '28%/( %87 ,7 :28/' %( &/26( 72 %,//,21 &219(57(' 4 12: /(7 6 /22. $7 6$3 6 /$:<(56 $668037,21 ',' $1<%2'< +$9( $ &5<67$/ %$// %$&. ,1 -$18$5< 72 0$.( $1 (;3(&7$7,21 72 0$.( $ 35(',&7,21 72 0$.( $ 352-(&7,21 $%287 +2: 0$1< &86720(56 :28/' %( &219(57(' 21&( 6$3 67$57(' 7$.,1* 7+( 62)7:$5(" $ 12 7+(5( :$6 12 &5<67$/ %$// ,7 :$6 -867 %$6(' 21 0$1$*(0(17 6 %(67 81'(567$1',1* :+(5( 7+( 3/$1 :$6 *2,1* 72 *2 $1' :+$7 7+(< :$17(' 72 $&&203/,6+ 4 12: /(7 6 7$/. )25 $ 0,187( $%287 7+( /267 352),76 ,1)5,1*(56 352),76 0($685(6 <28 81'(567$1' 7+(5( $5( 7:2 0($685(6 2) '$0$*(6 &255(&7" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $1' 21( <28 7+,1. $335235,$7( $1' 21( <28 7+,1. ,6 '($' 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 &5266 5(680(' 0,77(/67$('7 05 0,77(/67$('7 12 )857+(5 48(67,216 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 5(',5(&7" 5(',5(&7 (;$0,1$7,21 %< 05 3,&.(77 4 *22' 0251,1* 05 0(<(5 %((1 $ )(: '$<6 $ *22' 0251,1* 4 /(7 0( -867 67$57 21 7+$7 /$67 32,17 <28 9( 581 620( 02'(/6 )25 7+( )$,5 0$5.(7 9$/8( 2) $ /,&(16( 7+$7 6$3 6+28/' +$9( 5(&(,9(' ,1 -$18$5< 6+28/' +$9( *277(1 ,1 -$18$5< 5,*+7" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $1' <28 86(' +2: 0$1< 0$,17(1$1&( &86720(56 ,1 7+$7 &$/&8/$7,21" $ ,1 7+( &$/&8/$7,21 )25 0$,17(1$1&( , 86( &86720(56 7+$7 *2(6 83 7+528*+ 2&72%(5 4 $// 5,*+7 $1' :+$7 6 7+( 0,1,080 $02817 7+$7 <28 %(/,(9( 7+( 3(23/(62)7 /,&(16( 7+( /,&(16( )(( )25 7+$7 3(23/(62)7 62)7:$5( 6+28/' +$9( %((1 $6 2) -$18$5< " $ 7+( <28 5( $6.,1* :+$7 7+( 0,1,080 $02817 2) 7+( /,&(16( 4 0,1,080 $02817 5,*+7" $ ,7 6 %,//,21 $7 /($67 %,//,21 )25 )25 7+( /,&(16( $7 7+$7 32,17 ,1 7,0( $1' 7+$7 ,1&/8'(6 7+( 0$,17(1$1&( &86720(56 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 5(',5(&7 3,&.(77 :521*" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 12: 81'(5 7+( 21( 7+$7 ,6 '($' :521* 7+$7 6 :+$7 0($685( ,6 7+$7" $ 7+( 7+( 0($685( 2) /22.,1* $7 7+( /267 352),76 ,1 7+,6 &$6( 72 0($685( 7+( 9$/8( 2) 7+,6 /,&(16( 7+$7 :28/' %( 727$//< ,1$335235,$7( 4 $// 5,*+7 <28 1(9(57+(/(66 /22.(' $7 7+$7 $1' :+$7 :$6 7+( 727$/ 180%(5 81'(5 <285 &$/&8/$7,216 81'(5 7+( 352),76 0($685( 7+( :521* 0($685(" $ ,7 :$6 0,//,21 )25 &$/&8/$7,21 287 7+528*+ 4 $1' +2: $%287 7+( ,1)5,1*(56 352),76" $ 7+$7 180%(5 :$6 0,//,21 :$6 0< 833(5 %281' $1' 7+(1 7+(5( 6 7+5(( &86720(56 , 0(17,21(' 72 05 0,77(/67$('7 7+$7 7$.(6 ,7 '2:1 72 21 7+( /2:(5 (1' 2) 7+$7 4 62 :+$7 6 ,1 <285 23,1,21 81'(5 7+$7 0($685( :+$7 6 7+( 727$/ $02817 2) '$0$*(6" $ :(// , 7+,1. 7+( 3/86 0,//,21 7+$7 6 , 7+,1. ,7 6 ,7 5281'6 72 0,//,21 62 21 05 0,77(/67$('7 6 &+$57 ,7 6+28/' %( 4 0,//,21 $1' 7+(1 21 7+( 6$3 6,'( 05 0,77(/67$('7 6$,' 0,//,21 ,1 +,6 23(1,1* $1' 12: :( +($5' 0,//,21 $6 <28 &255(&7(' +,0 78(6'$< 5,*+7" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 %87 7+( 25 $// 7+( :$< 72 0,//,21 7+$7 6 127 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 7 - November 12, 2010
SHEET 17

0(<(5 5(',5(&7 3,&.(77 (128*+ ,6 ,7" $ 7+(5( 6 12 :$< 7+$7 7+$7 :28/' &203(16$7( 25$&/( )25 7+( 3523(57< 7+$7 :$6 7$.(1 ,1 -$18$5< 72 /$81&+ 7+( %86,1(66 7+$7 6$3 /$81&+(' 4 $1' :+< ,6 7+$7" $ %(&$86( :+(1 <28 /22. $7 7+( *2$/6 $1' 7+( ,03$&7 21 25$&/( $1' 7+( (;3(&7$7,216 7+$7 6$3 +$' :+(1 7+(< /$81&+(' 7+( 6$)( 3$66$*( 352*5$0 $7 7+$7 32,17 ,1 7,0( :+(1 25$&/( +$' -867 63(17 %,//,21 $1' +$' &86720(56 7+$7 ,7 :$17(' 72 %5,1* ,172 ,76 %86,1(66 7+$7 6 (;$&7/< :+(1 6$3 /$81&+(' 7+$7 &203(7,1* 352*5$0 72 7$.( 7+26( &86720(56 7+$7 :(5( 81&(57$,1 $1' %5,1* 7+(0 29(5 72 6$3 62 ,7 6 &5,7,&$/ 7+( 7,0,1* $1' 7+$7 6 (;$&7/< :+< 7+(5( 6 $// 7+$7 6(1,25 (;(&87,9( ,192/9(0(17 ,1 7+( 6$)( 3$66$*( 352*5$0 $1' 7+$7 ),9( :((.6 2) 3/$11,1* ,1 '(&(0%(5 $1' -$18$5< 4 $// 5,*+7 /(7 6 *2 %$&. 72 <285 $1$/<6,6 2) 7+( 3(23/(62)7 /,&(16( /(7 6 6+2: 6/,'( 3/($6( $*$,1 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 $// 5,*+7 7+,6 ,6 $ &+$57 :( 6$: 2+ 021'$< 25 78(6'$< $1' &$1 <28 5(0,1' 7+( -85< :+$7 7+,6 6+2:6" $ 5,*+7 7+,6 5(/$7(6 72 7+( 3(23/(62)7 /,&(16( $1' 7+( 3523(57< 7+$7 :$6 :$6 7$.(1 %< 6$3 $1' 7202552:12: $1' 7+( 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 5(',5(&7 3,&.(77 4 /(7 6 *2 72 7+( (9,'(1&( )520 6$3 $%287 7+( 180%(5 2) &86720(56 7+(< (;3(&7(' 72 *(7 )520 7+,6 '($/ /(7 6 *2 72 6/,'( (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 12: :+$7 '2(6 7+,6 6+2:" $ 7+,6 ,6 $ 6800$5< 7+$7 :( :(17 7+528*+ 21 0< ',5(&7 7(67,021< $1' )520 0< 3(563(&7,9( ,7 &/($5/< ,192/9(6 $1' '(021675$7(6 7+( 7+( (;(&87,9( %2$5' $7 6$3 $1' :+$7 ,7 )(/7 ,7 &28/' $&&203/,6+ ,) ,7 /$81&+(' 7+( 7202552:12: %86,1(66 :,7+ 7+( ,1)5,1*,1* 62)7:$5( ,1 7+,6 3$&.$*( 2) 27+(5 5(6285&( $7 6$3 7+$7 %(&$0( 6$)( 3$66$*( $1' <28 // 6(( 7+26( 9$/8(6 7+(5( %$6,&$//< 5$1*( , 7+,1. 21 7+( &219(57(' &86720(5 6,'( ,7 5$1*(6 )520 $ /2: 2) &86720(56 ,1 7+( ),567 '2&80(17 $7 7+( 723 $1' 7+(1 21 7+( +,*+ 6,'( ,7 :28/' %( 05 $*$66, $7 &86720(56 7+$7 6 21 7+( &219(56,21 $1' 21 0$,17(1$1&( , %(/,(9( ,7 5$1*(6 )520 %$6,&$//< , 7+,1. 7+( 5$1*( ,6 72 0$,17(1$1&( &86720(56 7+,6 $// &20(6 )520 7+( '2&80(176 2) 7+( 0$1$*(0(17 $7 6$3 4 $7 7+( 7,0( 2) 7+( /,&(16( 7+$7 6+28/' +$9( %((1 1(*27,$7('" $ 7+$7 6 (;$&7/< 5,*+7 7+$7 6 :+(1 7+( 3523(57< :$6 :$6 7$.(1 $1' 7+( 352*5$0 :$6 /$81&+(' $1' 7+( ,03$&7 21 25$&/( :$6 628*+7 7+,6 ,6 (;$&7/< :+$7 7+26( 352-(&7,216 :(5( 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 5(',5(&7 3,&.(77 :$< ,7 :25.6 ,6 7+$7 7+( 9$/8(6 &+$1*( %$6(' 21 7+( 180%(5 2) &86720(56 7+$7 &219(57 72 6$3 62 21 7+( /2: (1' 7+$7 $6680(6 7+$7 &86720(56 &219(57 72 6$3 $1' <28 // 6(( 7+$7 7+( 7+( *$,1 ,6 0,//,21 72 6$3 $1' 7+(1 7+( ,03$&7 72 25$&/( ,6 %,//,21 $1' 7+(1 $&5266 7+( &+$57 <28 *2 72 &219(57(' &86720(56 $1' 7+(1 72 &219(57(' &86720(56 21 7+( 6,'( <28 // 6(( 7+$7 8/7,0$7(/< 7+(5( 6$3 $&78$//< *$,16 %,//,21 %(&$86( 7+(< +$9( 75(0(1'286 836,'( 72 7+( $%,/,7< 72 &5266 6(// $1' 836(// &219(57(' &86720(56 72 6$3 62)7:$5( 25$&/( 6 ,03$&7 ,6 7+$7 7:2 $1' $ +$/) %,//,21 21 7+( &86720(5 &$/&8/$7,216 ,1 7+( 0,''/( ,6 :+(5( , 6257 2) &(17(5(' 0< )2&86 $7 7+( %,//,21 $7 /($67 7+$7 $02817 $1' 7+$7 6 81'(5 7+( 326,7,21 7+$7 6$3 6 0$1$*(0(17 :28/' &219(57 &86720(56 29(5 72 6$3 $1' 7+(1 +$9( 7+26( &86720(56 $9$,/$%/( )25 0$,17(1$1&( $'',7,21$/ ,17(*5$7,21 /,&(16( $1' 7+(1 6(//,1* 7+( :+2/( 68,7( 2) 7+( 6$3 $33/,&$7,216 72 7+26( &86720(56 4 $1' -867 72 %( &/($5 ,) <28 $6680( :(// :( 6$,' &86720(56 7+$7 :28/' %( (9(1 +,*+(5 5,*+7" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 ,7 :28/' 7$.( <28 287 72 7+( 5,*+7 7+(5( $7 $ +,*+(5 /(9(/ 4 %87 <28 )2&86(' 21 7+,6 21( :,7+ &86720(56 $ 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 7+$7 6 :+(5( , )2&86(' 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 5(',5(&7 3,&.(77 4 <28 ','1 7 6(( $1< (9,'(1&( 7+$7 7+( 6$3 %2$5' :$6 7+,1.,1* 2+ :( 5( 21/< *2,1* 72 *(7 &86720(56 ',' <28" 05 0,77(/67$('7 2%-(&7 /($',1* $1' $5*80(17$7,9( 7+( &2857 29(558/(' 7+( :,71(66 12 , ',' 127 ,1 )$&7 :+(1 05 0,77(/67$('7 $6.(' 0( 7+,6 0251,1* $%287 7+( 7202552:12: 180%(56 7+$7 :$6 7202552:12: $6 $ 67$1' $/21( &203$1< , )2&86(' 21 7202552:12: ,17(*5$7(' ,172 6$)( 3$66$*( $6 3$57 2) 7+( 67(3 21( 67(3 7:2 $1' 67(3 7+5(( %86,1(66 23325781,7< 72 &219(57 25$&/( &86720(56 29(5 72 7+( 6$3 3/$7)250 %< 05 3,&.(77 4 $// 5,*+7 /(7 6 *2 72 (;+,%,7 7+( ),567 21( <28 /,67 +(5( $7 6/,'( :( 9( 6((1 7+$7 21( %()25( (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 /(7 6 *2 72 7+( *5$3+ 7+$7 6+2:6 7+( 0,//,21 352-(&7,21 2) 6$3 6 (;(&87,9( %2$5' (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 05 3,&.(77 7+$7 6 7+( 21( 4 12: <28 +($5' 6$3 6 &2816(/ 6$< 7+,6 :$6 21/< $1 $668037,21 '2 <28 $*5(( :,7+ 7+$7 &+$5$&7(5,=$7,21 2) 7+( 6,*1,),&$1&( 2) 7+,6 (9,'(1&(" $ 12 , '21 7 %(&$86( 7+,6 '2&80(17 :$6 6+$5(' $1' 5287(' $1' +$' ,1387 )520 05 %5$1'7 $1' 05 $*$66, :+2 :(5( /($',1* 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 7 - November 12, 2010
0(<(5 5(',5(&7 3,&.(77 7+( $&48,6,7,21 2) 7202552:12: %87 7+(1 ,7 :(17 72 7+( 27+(5 (;(&87,9( %2$5' 0(0%(56 $/62 62 7+(< $// 5(&(,9(' 7+,6 ,1)250$7,21 +$' ,1387 21 ,7 $1' 7+,6 ,6 7+( '2&80(17 :+(1 <28 $'' 83 7+( 7+( ',))(5(17 &86720(5 &28176 7+(5( )25 0$,17(1$1&( ,7 &20(6 83 72 $1' 7+$7 6 21/< 7+528*+ '(&(0%(5 2) 7+$7 6 ,1 7+5(( <($56 7+( 0,''/( /,1( 2) &5266 6(// :+,&+ ,6 7+( ,17(*5$7(' 62)7:$5( $''6 83 , 7+,1. &86720(56 $)7(5 7+5(( <($56 $/21( $1' 7+(1 8/7,0$7(/< $7 7+( 723 7+( 7+(< &$// 836:,7&+ 7+$7 5($//< ,6 7+( 6:,7&+,1* 29(5 72 7+( 6$3 3/$7)250 7+$7 6 $7 &86720(56 )25 7+5(( <($56 $1' 62 7+(< :28/' +$9( $127+(5 7(1 0217+6 81'(5 /,&(16( $1' 7+(1 $)7(5 7+$7 7+(< :28/' +$9( $ *5283 2) &86720(56 7+$7 :28/' %( :,7+ 6$3 $6 06 &$7= 6$,' )25 327(17,$//< '(&$'(6 4 62 81'(5 6$3 6 %2$5' 2:1 $1$/<6,6 0,//,21 ,1 7+( ),567 7+5(( <($56 $1' %,//,216 72 )2//2:" $ :(// 7+$7 6 5,*+7 %87 /22. $7 7+( %27720 2) 7+,6 &+$57 /22. $7 7+( *52:7+ 7+$7 6 %(,1* 352-(&7(' 7+$7 6 (9(1 $6 ,03257$17 , 0(17,21(' ,7 21 0< ',5(&7 7(67,021< <28 *2 )520 %$6,&$//< $ +81'5(' 0,//,21 ,1 7+( ),567 <($5 72 0,//,21 ,1 7+( 6(&21' <($5 72 $/0267 0,//,21 ,1 7+$7 /$67 <($5 62 <28 6(( 7+$7 7+(< 5( 352-(&7,1* 7+$7 7+(< 5( 3,&.,1* 83 75$&7,21 7+(< 5( 029,1* &86720(56 7+(< 5( +$9,1* 68&&(66 $1' 7+$7 6 7+( 5($/ 3$<2)) 2) '2,1* 86,1* 7+( 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55 0(<(5 5(',5(&7 3,&.(77 620( 3257,216 <28 :(5( 127 6+2:1 %< 6$3 6 &2816(/ 5(&$// )25 7+( -85< :+2 (;$&7/< 05 $*$66, ,6 $ 05 $*$66, ,6 21 7+( (;(&87,9( %2$5' $1' 7+(< &$// +,0 7+( 7+,1. 7+( &72 7+( &+,() 7(&+12/2*< 2)),&(5 , %(/,(9( +( 6 ,1 &+$5*( 2) 352'8&7 $7 6$3 62 +( 6 $ %2$5' 0(0%(5 $ /($' 0$1$*(0(17 3(5621 $1' $/62 ,1 &+$5*( 2) 352'8&7 4 $// 5,*+7 /(7 6 6(( ,) :( &$1 *(7 7+( 5,*+7 3$*( +(5( /,1( 72 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 2)) 7+( 5(&25' ',6&866,21 %< 05 3,&.(77 4 2.$< +(5( :( +$9( ),567 48(67,21 72 05 $*$66, 7+,1. , 722. 7+,6 '(326,7,21 62 , 6+28/' +$9( 5(0(0%(5(' , $6.(' +,0 ',' <28 6(( $1< 352-(&7,216 2) (,7+(5 7+( 5(9(18(6 25 7+( 180%(56 2) &86720(56 7+$7 :28/' %( &219(57('" $ ,7 :$6 ,1 7+( 25,*,1$/ &$6( 4 ,1 7+( %86,1(66 352326$/" <(6 4 $1' 7+$7 6 7+( 21/< 7,0( <28 5( $:$5( 2) $1< 68&+ &$/&8/$7,21" 12 7+(5( :$6 21 $ 3(5,2',& %$6,6 :( :28/' 6(( 75$&.,1* 180%(56 2) :+(5( :( :(5( 3267 $&48,6,7,21" 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 5(',5(&7 3,&.(77 62)7:$5( 72 &219(57 7+( &86720(56 4 12: /(7 6 *2 72 $ 9(5< 08&+ 5(/$7(' (;+,%,7 3; ,7 6 7+( 1(;7 6/,'( (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 -867 62 7+(5( 6 12 '28%7 $%287 ,7 7+,6 52$' 0$3 ,6 7+$7 '2&80(17 :( -867 6$: ,6 3$57 2) 7+( 52$' 0$3 5,*+7" $ 7+$7 6 5,*+7 ,7 6 ,1 7+,6 05 =,(0(1 '2&80(17 ,7 6 7+( 52$' 0$3 4 $1' :+2 *$9( ,1387 ,172 7+$7 $1$/<6,6 $1' (;7(16,9( *8,'$1&( ,172 7+$7 $1$/<6,6 7+$7 /(' 72 7+( 0,//,21 ,1 7+( ),567 <($56 $1' %,//,216 72 )2//2:" $ 7+(5( 6 7+( :( '5(: 7+$7 83 21 7+( ',5(&7 7(67,021< $1' ,7 6$<6 5,*+7 7+(5( ,7 6$<6 +(11,1* /(2 *(5' $1' 6+$, +$' *,9(1 ,1387 $1' (;7(16,9( *8,'$1&( 21 7+,6 '(9(/23,1* 2) 7+,6 3/$1 $1' /(2 2%9,286/< ,6 05 $327+(.(5 $1' 6+$, ,6 05 $*$66, *(5' , %(/,(9( ,6 05 %5$1'7 $1' , 7+,1. ,7 6 ,6 ,7 +(11,1* .$*(50$11" , 7+,1. 7+$7 6 +2: ,7 3/$<6 287 7+26( :(5( 7+( (;(&87,9( %2$5' 0(0%(56 7+$7 :(5( 5811,1* 7+( &203$1< '$< 72 '$< $1' ,1 &+$5*( 2) $// 7+( )81&7,21$/ ',6&,3/,1(6 6$/(6 $1' $1' 352'8&7 $1' 6(59,&( $1' $1' $1' ),1$1&( $// 2) 7+26( ,03257$17 )81&7,216 4 $// 5,*+7 $1' ),1$//< 21 7+,6 32,17 -867 62 7+(5( 6 12 '28%7 $%287 ,7 /(7 6 *2 72 05 $*$66, 6 '(326,7,21 7(67,021< 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 5(',5(&7 3,&.(77 $ 3267 $&48,6,7,21 $1' 7+(1 7+( '(326,7,21 &217,18(6 $1' ',' <28 +$9( 5($621 72 48(67,21 7+26( 352-(&7,216 (,7+(5 7+( 21(6 35(6(17(' ,1 -$18$5< %86,1(66 3/$1 25 68%6(48(17/<" $ , 7+28*+7 :( &28/' :( &28/' '2 %(77(5 $1' 7+( -$18$5< %86,1(66 3/$1 ,6 7+( 21( :( -867 6$: :,7+ 7+( 0,//,21 ,1 7+( ),567 7+5(( <($56 $ :(// 7+$7 6 5,*+7 7+$7 :$6 '(9(/23(' ,1 '(&(0%(5 $1' 7+$7 %(&$0( 7+( %$6,6 )25 7+( *2 )25:$5' ,17(*5$7,21 2) 6$)( 3$66$*( $1' /$81&+ 4 62 7+(1 , $6.(' 05 $*$66, -867 72 %( 685( , 6$,' $1' %(77(5 7+$1 7+( 25,*,1$/ 352-(&7,21 -$18$5< 7+" $1' %(77(5 7+$1 7+( (;(&87,21 12: 7+( (;(&87,21 ,6 :+$7" $ 7+$7 7+$7 0($16 7+$7 %$6,&$//< :+(1 6$)( 3$66$*( :,7+ 7202552:12: :(17 72 0$5.(7 7+(1 6$3 :28/' +$9( '21( $ %(77(5 -2% 2) (;(&87,1* 21 7+( 3/$1 7+(< :28/' +$9( *277(1 7+(,5 6$/(6 )25&( 025( &225',1$7(' 025( ()),&,(17 025( 7,(' ,172 7+( *2$/6 2) 7+( 3/$1 $1' 7+(1 +2: 7+(< $/62 :5$33(' ,1 7202552:12: :,7+ 7+(,5 %86,1(66 62 7+$7 6 6257 2) 7+( (;(&87,21 2) 7+( 3/$1 $)7(5 -$18$5< 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 7 - November 12, 2010
SHEET 18

0(<(5 5(',5(&7 3,&.(77 4 48(67,21 :+< ',' <28 7+,1. <28 &28/' '2 %(77(5 7+$1 7+( 25,*,1$/ 352-(&7,21 -$18$5< " $ %(&$86( , 7+28*+7 7+$7 *,9(1 7+( ',65837,21 25$&/( +$6 387 21 7+( 0$5.(7 7+(5( :,// %( %(77(5 $&&(37$1&( %< 3(23/(62)7 6 &86720(56 7+(1 7+( ),1$/ ',' <28 +$9( $1< $66(660(17 2) +2: 0$1< 2) 7+( 3(23/(62)7 &86720(56 0,*+7 %( 68%-(&7 72 &219(56,21 %< 6$3" 12 127 (;$&7 180%(5 $1' , 6+28/' 6$< , '21 7 7+,1. 7+(5( 6 $1< ',6$*5((0(17 ,7 6 7+,6 :$6 ($5/< ,1 7+( &$6( 62 :( :(5( 67,// 75<,1* 72 3,1 7+$7 '2:1 62 12 127 (;$&7 180%(5 7+(1 , $6.(' 05 $*$66, +$/)" , 7+28*+7 7+$7 ,) 25$&/( :28/' '2 $ %$' -2% :( &28/' 6(( $ 6,0,/$5 ',675,%87,21 2) 7+( &86720(56 $6 7+( 6+$5( 2) &86720(56 %(7:((1 6$3 $1' 25$&/( $1' :+$7 6 7+$7 5$7,2" <28 5( %,**(5 7+$1 25$&/( <(6 '2 <28 .12: :+$7 528*+/< 7+$7 ,6" " <($+ 620(7+,1* /,.( 7+$7 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 5(',5(&7 3,&.(77 4 62 7+( 352-(&7,21 :( 86(' 72 7+( 352-(&7,21 :$6 86(' %< 7+( %2$5' 72 /$81&+ 7+( 6$)( 3$66$*( 352*5$0" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 7+( 352-(&7,21 :$6 86(' %< 7+( %2$5' 72 7$.( $:$< 25$&/( 6 3(23/(62)7 62)7:$5(" $ 7+$7 ,6 &255(&7 4 7+( %2$5' 86(' 7+( 352-(&7,21 72 5,6. 6(5,286 /,$%,/,7< ,6 7+$7 &255(&7" $ 7+$7 7+$7 6((06 &255(&7 4 $1' <28 86(' 7+( %2$5' 6 352-(&7,21 72 0($685( '$0$*(6" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 12: , 0 *2,1* 72 *2 7+528*+ -867 $ )(: 723,&6 7+$7 :(5( 5$,6(' <(6 25 78(6'$< $1' 7+,6 0251,1* $1' &/($5 83 $ &283/( 2) 7+,1*6 ),567 <28 6$: 620( (9,'(1&( 7+,6 0251,1* 7+$7 05 =(3(&., :$6 5()(55,1* 72 $ 3(5&(17 3(1(75$7,21 5$7( 2) 7+( &86720(5 %$6( '2 <28 5(&$// 7+$7" $ <(6 , '2 4 $1' :$6 +( 7$/.,1* $%287 7+,6 .,1' 2) $ 352*5$0 7+$7 7+( %2$5' :$6 7$/.,1* $%287" $ 12 ,7 :$6 (17,5(/< ',))(5(17/< +( :$6 7$/.,1* $%287 7202552:12: $6 6257 2) $ 67$1' $/21( %86,1(66 6257 2) &20,1* ,1 %$6,&$//< -2,1,1* 6$3 $1' %(,1* '($/7 :,7+ 6257 2) ,1 ,62/$7,21 $1' '2,1* 7+( 6$0( 2/' 7+,1* 7+(< +$' '21( %()25( 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 5(',5(&7 3,&.(77 62 :+$7 6 7+( 6,*1,),&$1&( 2) 05 $*$66, 6 7(67,021< 05 0(<(5" $ :(// )520 0< 3(563(&7,9( 05 $*$66, 21( +( 0(17,216 7+( ',65837,21 72 25$&/( 6 &86720(56 %(&$86( +( 5($/,=(' 7+$7 7+( &86720(56 :(5( &20,1* ,172 25$&/( )520 3(23/(62)7 $1' 7+(5( :$6 7+( 23325781,7< 72 &219(57 7+26( &86720(56 $1' +( )(/7 7+$7 ,) 25$&/( ','1 7 '2 $ *22' -2% 7+$7 7+,6 352*5$0 2) 6$3 6 &28/' +$9( *$7+(5(' &28/' +$9( *$,1(' )25 6$3 83 72 7+(,5 0$5.(7 6+$5( :+,&+ :$6 %$6,&$//< 3(5&(17 $1' 62 +( )(/7 7+$7 :$6 7+( 23325781,7< 7+(< +$' ,) 25$&/( ','1 7 '2 $ *5($7 -2% $1' 6$3 +$' $&78$//< (;(&87(' 21 7+( 3/$1 7+( :$< +( )(/7 7+(< :(5( &$3$%/( 4 62 7+$7 :28/' /($' 72 $%287 &86720(56" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $// 5,*+7 12: 7+( %2$5' 0$'( $ '(&,6,21 72 /$81&+ 7+( 6$)( 3$66$*( 352*5$0 %$6(' 21 $ 352-(&7,21 ,6 7+$7 $ )$,5 67$7(0(17" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 12: :+(7+(5 <28 &$// ,7 $ *2$/ $ 352-(&7,21 $ 6&(1$5,2 7+(5( :$6 $1 $1$/<6,6 '21( ,6 7+$7 )$,5" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $1' ',' 7+( %2$5' +$9( $1< ,1387 ,172 7+$7 $1$/<6,6" $ <(6 7+(< +$' 68%67$17,$/ ,192/9(0(17 ,1 )$&7 , :28/' 6$< 7+(< :(5( ',5(&7/< ,192/9(' ,1 7+( %86,1(66 3/$1 $1' 7+( 352-(&7,216 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 5(',5(&7 3,&.(77 ,7 :$61 7 $ 3(5&(17 3(1(75$7,21 %$6(' 21 &20%,1,1* 7202552:12: ,172 6$)( 3$66$*( $6 7+( &251(56721( 67(3 21( 62 5($//< ,7 6 ,7 6 $33/(6 $1' 25$1*(6 ,7 6 7202552:12: 6(3$5$7( ,62/$7(' $1' 127 $6 3$57 2) $1 ,17(*5$7(' *2 72 0$5.(7 675$7(*< 7+$7 7+(< $&78$//< '(9(/23(' :,7+ 7202552:12: ,1 7+( )2/' 4 <28 :(5( $6.(' 21 78(6'$< $%287 $ &219(56$7,21 29(5 7+( 3+21( <28 +$' :,7+ 7+5(( 25$&/( (;(&87,9(6 '2 <28 5(&$// 7+$7" $ <(6 , '2 4 $1' 62 7+(5( 6 12 &21)86,21 ',' <28 6,03/< $&&(37 :+$7 05 (//,621 $1' 06 &$7= $1' 05 3+,//,36 72/' <28 $%287 7+(,5 (;3(&7$7,216" $ 12 , ',' 127 , +$' 7+$7 &219(56$7,21 -867 72 *(7 $1 29(5$// 3(563(&7,9( )520 0$1$*(0(17 $%287 +2: 6,*1,),&$17 $1' :+$7 7+( 29(5$// ,03$&7 &28/' %( 72 7+( &203$1< ,) 7+(< $*5((' 72 7+,6 /,&(16( %$&. ,1 -$18$5< $1' 62 , '(6&5,%(' 72 7+(0 7+$7 7+( 1$785( 2) 7+( /,&(16( /,.( :( 9( 7$/.(' $%287 ,1 &2857 $1' 7+(1 , 628*+7 )520 7+(0 -867 7+(,5 *(1(5$/ )((/,1* $1' )(('%$&. %(&$86( 7+(< +$' -867 %((1 3$57 2) 7+( %,**(67 $&48,6,7,21 2) $ 62)7:$5( &203$1< ,1 +,6725< %8<,1* 3(23/(62)7 )25 %,//,21 $1' 62 7+(,5 ,1)250$7,21 :$6 +(/3)8/ $6 %$&.*5281' %87 $6 , 6$,' $7 75,$/ 7+,6 :((. $1' , 6$,' ,1 0< '(326,7,21 )285 25 ),9( 7,0(6 ,) , +$' 1(9(5 7$/.(' 72 7+(0 , 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 7 - November 12, 2010
0(<(5 5(',5(&7 3,&.(77 :28/' +$9( &20( 72 7+( 6$0( 23,1,216 7+$7 , 9( *,9(1 <28 +(5( 72'$< 4 ,1 )$&7 :+$7 ',' 7+(< 7(// <28 7+(< 7+28*+7 7+( ,03$&7 :28/' %(" $ :(// 7+(< 6$,' 7+$7 327(17,$//< &28/' %( 72 3(5&(17 $1' $6 7+( &219(56$7,21 :(17 21 7+(< 6$,' ,7 6 $7 /($67 %,//,21 7+(< 1(9(5 &$0( %(/2: %,//,21 7+(< )(/7 ,7 :28/' $&78$//< %( '(9$67$7,1* 72 7+( &203$1< %(&$86( 7+(< -867 %28*+7 7+,6 9(5< ,03257$17 $66(7 )25 $ /27 2) 021(< 4 12: /(7 0( *2 %$&. )25 -867 $ 020(17 72 $ +<327+(7,&$/ 7+$7 6$3 6 &2816(/ $6.(' <28 72 $6680( $7 21( 32,17 21 78(6'$< +( $6.(' <28 72 $6680( 7+$7 7+( 3$57,(6 7+$7 25$&/( 6 (;(&87,9(6 +$' 72/' <28 620(+2: 7+$7 7+(< :28/' 21/< /26( &86720(56 ,6 7+(5( $1< (9,'(1&( :+$762(9(5 7+$7 25$&/( :28/' +$9( +$' 7+$7 (;3(&7$7,21 ,1 -$18$5< " $ 12 -867 ,7 6 -867 127 3$57 2) 7+( $1<7+,1* $7 $// 7+(5( :28/' -867 25$&/( +$' 12 ,'($ $%287 7+( 86( 2) 7+( 62)7:$5( %< 6$3 $1' $1' 7+(5( 6 12 ,1)250$7,21 $7 $// 7+$7 , 9( 6((1 $1' ,7 6 -867 127 ,7 6 -867 $ 12167$57(5 '2(61 7 (;,67 4 12: <28 7(67,),(' $%287 5811,1* 52<$/7< ,1 <285 9,(: ,6 7+(5( ,6 7+(5( $1< %$6,6 72 &21&/8'( 7+$7 7+( 3$57,(6 :28/' +$9( $*5((' 72 $ 5811,1* 52<$/7<" $ ,1 7+(6( &,5&8067$1&(6 $%62/87(/< 127 ,7 '2(61 7 0$.( $1< 6(16( $7 $// 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55 0(<(5 5(',5(&7 3,&.(77 $ <(6 , '2 4 /(7 6 7$.( $ /22. $7 6/,'( )520 <285 ',5(&7 (;$0,1$7,21 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 &28/' <28 5(0,1' 7+( -85< $*$,1 :+$7 7+,6 6/,'( '(3,&76 :,7+ 5(63(&7 72 6&23( 2) 7+( /,&(16(" $ <(6 ,7 6 $1 ,03257$17 6/,'( $1' ,7 6 $ ',)),&8/7 &21&(37 %(&$86( $ /,&(16( ,6 +$5' 72 6257 2) *(7 <285 +$1'6 $5281' $1' :+$7 7+,6 &+$57 :$6 0($17 72 '2 $1' 0$<%( ,7 :$61 7 2%9,286 ,6 7+$7 ,1 7+,6 &$6( 7+(< 5( 127 -867 *(77,1* $ /,&(16( 72 %( $%/( $1' *2 *,9( 6(59,&( 21 3(23/(62)7 &86720(56 7+(< $&78$//< 5(&(,9(' 5($/ 3523(57< 5($/ 62)7:$5( $1' 62 21 7+( /()7 +$1' 6,'( ,6 -867 6257 2) /(*$/ 5,*+76 $7 7+( 723 &23<5,*+7 5(*,675$7,216 $1' 7+(1 ,7 6257 2) '(3,&76 +2: 7+$7 722. )250 <28 .12: ,7 6 $7 /($67 +81'5('6 2) 7+286$1'6 2) 62)7:$5( ),/(6 $7 /($67 7+286$1'6 2) &23,(6 2) (17,5( $33/,&$7,216 $1' $7 /($67 +81'5('6 2) 7+286$1'6 2) '2:1/2$'6 62 7+$7 6 6257 2) 7+( $&7,9,7< %87 7+( 9,68$/ 2) 7+( 3523(57< ,6 21 7+( 5,*+7 +$1' 6,'( 7+( 5,*+7 +$1' 6,'( 7+(6( $5( 7+,6 ,6 $&78$/ 3523(57< 7+$7 7+$7 6$3 7202552:12: 5(&(,9(' $1' 7+(< 5(&(,9(' 7+(6( ,1 7+( )250 2) 62)7:$5( 2%-(&76 62)7:$5( 83'$7(6 7+(6( %8* ),;(6 $1' 3$7&+(6 7+$7 05 (//,621 7$/.(' $%287 +(5( $7 75,$/ 7+( 62)7:$5( $33/,&$7,216 7+( ,16758&7,21$/ 0$18$/6 $1' 7+(6( &86720 62/87,216 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 5(',5(&7 3,&.(77 4 :+< 127" $ %(&$86( 2) 7+( 0$*1,78'( 2) 7+( 5,6. 72 25$&/( 2) /,&(16,1* ,76 ,03257$17 62)7:$5( 72 ,76 &+,() &203(7,725 6$3 $1' , -867 &$1 7 (03+$6,=( (128*+ +2: ,03257$17 ,7 ,6 7+$7 :( 5( ,1 -$18$5< 21 7+( +((/6 2) 7+( 3(23/(62)7 $&48,6,7,21 )25 %,//,21 $1' 7+( 1(;7 '$< <28 5( *,9,1* <285 &+,() &203(7,725 :+2 +$6 67,// '28%/( <285 0$5.(76+$5( ,1 7+( (53 0$5.(7 7+,6 9(5< ,03257$17 /,&(16( 7+$7 %$6,&$//< ,6 7+( .(<6 72 23(1,1* 83 7+( &86720(5 '225 $1' &86720(56 $1' *2,1* ,1 $1' 6$<,1* +(< :( +$9( 7+( 6$0( 7+,1* 7+$7 25$&/( +$6 :( &$1 6(59,&( <28 )520 12: )25 7+( 1(;7 7(1 <($56 21 <285 2/' 6<67(06 $1' +(/3 <28 *(7 72 1(: 6<67(06 29(5 7,0( 7+$7 6 -867 $ 9(5< 9$/8$%/( $66(7 7+$7 25$&/( 3$,' %,//,21 )25 62 <28 +$9( 72 :25. 7+$7 ,172 7+( (48$7,21 7+(5( 6 -867 ,7 6 -867 +2: ,7 +$6 72 %( '21( $1' ,7 +$6 72 %( 3$,' 83 )5217 62 7+$7 25$&/( ,6 127 6,77,1* 7+(5( :21'(5,1* $0 , *2,1* 72 %( 3$,' 0,//,21 0,//,21 $ +81'5(' 0,//,21 '2//$56" $1' <28 9( 6((1 7+( 5(68/76 2) 7+( 27+(5 6,'( 2) 7+( &$/&8/$7,216 $1' 7+(5( 6 12 :$< 7+(< &28/' (9(5 -867,)< $1' $&&(37 7+( 5811,1* 52<$/7< 4 /(7 0( 7851 72 7+( 1(;7 723,& 05 0,77(/67$('7 $6.(' <28 620( 48(67,216 $%287 7+( 6&23( 2) :+$7 6 72 %( 9$/8(' )25 7+(6( /,&(16(6 '2 <28 5(&$// 7+$7" 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

0(<(5 5(',5(&7 3,&.(77 7+,6 ,6 $ :,'( 9$5,(7< 2) 5($/ 3523(57< 7+$7 <28 +$9( %$6,&$//< ,1 -$18$5< 72 *2 287 $1' 6(59,&( 62 <28 '21 7 +$9( 72 6,7 7+(5( <2856(/) $1' $&78$//< &5($7( 7+( 62)7:$5( <28 +$9( 7+( 62)7:$5( $1' 7+$7 6 7+( 5($/ 3523(57< 7+$7 7+$7 , 0 9$/8,1* ,7 6 127 620(7+,1* ,7 6 127 (9(1 ,17$1*,%/( ,7 6 5($/ 3523(57< 7+$7 :$6 7$.(1 4 $1' :28/' <28 /2:(5 7+( 9$/8( 2) :+$7 7+(< 722. ,) 620(+2: 7+(< +$' '(&,'(' 127 72 86( ,7 <($56 /$7(5" $ 12 %(&$86( 7+(< %$6,&$//< +$' 7+,6 ,1 7+(,5 ,1 7+(,5 3266(66,21 72 '2 :+$7(9(5 7+(< :$17(' 72 '2 ,7 &28/' +$9( *21( 72 3(23/(62)7 &86720(56 3/86 025( ,03257$17/< 7+( -2,17 &86720(56 7+( &86720(56 7+$7 $/5($'< :(5( 6$3 7+$7 +$' 3(23/(62)7 $1' 7+(< &28/' *2 72 7+26( &86720(56 $1' 6$< :( +$9( 7+,6 62)7:$5( $1' :( &$1 12: 6(59,&( 3(23/(62)7 $1' 0$.( <28 21( &20%,1(' 81,),(' 3/$7)250 4 12: $127+(5 48(67,21 <28 *27 $6.(' 21 78(6'$< :$6 $%287 :+(7+(5 7+(5( :$6 5220 )25 6$3 72 0$.( $ 352),7 '2 <28 5(&$// 7+$7" $ <(6 , :$6 $6.(' 7+$7 4 $1' $6680,1* '()(1'$176 +$9( 72 0$.( $ 352),7 $6680,1* 7+$7 $7 <285 23,1,21 2) 7+( 9$/8( 2) 7+( 7+5(( /,&(16(6 7+( 3(23/(62)7 7+( 6,(%(/ $1' 7+( '$7$%$6( ,6 7+(5( 67,// $1 23325781,7< )25 6$3 72 0$.( $ 352),7 $7 7+( /,&(16( )(( 23,1,216 7+$7 <28 +$9(" $ <(6 %$6(' 21 0< 9$/8$7,21 2) /,&(16(6 6$3 &28/' +$9( 7$.(1 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 7 - November 12, 2010
SHEET 25

0$1',$ ',5(&7 05 +2:$5' :( &2035(66(' $127+(5 7(1 7(5$%<7(6 2) '$7$ :( /22.(' $7 $3352;,0$7(/< $1' $ +$/) 7(5$%<7(6 2) '$7$ 4 <28 9( 86(' 7+,6 7(50 7(5$%<7( &$1 <28 *,9( 7+( -85< $ 6(16( 2) +2: 08&+ '$7$ <28 $5( 7$/.,1* $%287 :+(1 <28 $5( 7$/.,1* $%287 $ 7(5$%<7(" $ <(6 , &$1 $ 7(5$%<7( :+(1 <28 67$57 7$/.,1* $%287 ,7 , 67$57 5($/,=,1* ,7 6 /,.( 7$/.,1* $%287 7+( 6,=( 2) 7+( 81,9(56( 25 7+( 63((' 2) /,*+7 ,7 %(&20(6 7+$7 ',)),&8/7 7+,1* 72 (;3/$,1 , :,// '2 0< %(67 ,) <28 7$.( 21( 7(5$%<7( /(7 6 *2 '2:1 72 $ %<7( 7+,1. 2) $ /(77(5 $6 $ 6,1*/( %<7( 2) ,1)250$7,21 ,) <28 7$.( 7+$7 $1' 0$.( ,7 $ 7(5$%<7( 7+$7 6 $ 75,//,21 /(77(56 ,) <28 35,17 287 -867 7+( 7(5$%<7( 25 $ 75,//,21 /(77(56 7+$7 (1'6 83 %(,1* $3352;,0$7(/< 0,//,21 3$*(6 2) 0$7(5,$/ %27+ 6,'(' )5217 $1' %$&. 7+$7 :28/' %( $ 0,/( 67$&. 2) 3$3(5 ,) <28 -867 67$&.(' ,7 21 723 2) ($&+ 27+(5 7+$7 6 0,/(6 2) 3$3(5 )25 $ 6,1*/( 7(5$%<7( $1' :( +$' 72 /22. $7 ,1 7+,6 &$6( 29(5 7,0(6 7+$7 $02817 2) '$7$ 7+$7 :$6 5(/(9$17 72 7+,6 ,19(67,*$7,21 4 ',' <28 '2 7+$7 $// %< <2856(/)" $ 12 , ','1 7 , 5(/,(' 21 27+(5 0$1',$17 (03/2<((6 72 $66,67 ,1 7+,6 0$77(5 , +$' $3352;,0$7(/< 72 72 7+( %(67 2) 0< ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

0$1',$ ',5(&7 05 +2:$5' 62 ,) :( 35,17(' 287 $ 6,1*/( 7(5$%<7( 2) 3$3(5 $127+(5 :$< 72 (;3/$,1 $ 7(5$%<7( ,) :( /$< 7+$7 3$3(5 (1' 72 (1' $ 6,1*/( 7(5$%<7( :28/' &,5&/( 7+( */2%( ,1 '28%/( 6,'(' 35,172876 21( $1' 7+5(( 48$57(56 7,0(6 7+$7 6 :+$7 7+( */2%(6 5(35(6(17 ,6 7+( $02817 2) '$7$ 7+$7 :$6 '2:1/2$'(' %< 7202552:12: 5(35(6(176 1($5/< 1,1( &,5&/(6 $5281' 7+( */2%( 2) 35,17(' '$7$ '28%/( 6,'(' 4 '2(6 7+,6 5(35(6(17 $// 2) 7+( '2:1/2$'6 7+$7 7202552:12: (9(5 722. )520 25$&/( 6 :(%6,7(" $ 12 7+,6 5(35(6(176 7+( /2:(5 %281'6 7+(5( 6 620( 5($6216 :+< 21( :( .12: %$6(' 21 7(67,021< 7+$7 $7 /($67 $ 0,//,21 ),/(6 :(5( '2:1/2$'(' '85,1* 7+( '(9(/230(17 2) 7,7$1 $1' 7+$7 7+26( 0,//,21 ),/(6 :(5( '(/(7(' 6(&21' :( ','1 7 '(&2035(66 (9(5< 21( 2) 7+(6( ),/(6 $ /27 2) 7+(0 :(5( ,1 $ &2035(66(' )250$7 62 7+( 180%(5 &$1 21/< *2 83 )520 7+$7 $1' 7+,5' :( ','1 7 *(7 72 6(( (9(5< 6<67(0 7+(5( :(5( 0$&+,1(6 352'8&(' 72 0$1',$17 7+528*+ 7+,6 ,19(67,*$7,21 $)7(5 , +$' 68%0,77(' 0< 6833/(0(17$/ 5(3257 $1' 7+(< +$' +81'5('6 2) 7+286$1'6 2) '2:1/2$'6 21 7+26( 6<67(06 %87 :( 6,03/< &28/'1 7 7$//< 7+(0 83 ,1 7,0( 72 387 7+(0 ,1 285 5(3257 62 7+,6 5(35(6(176 7+( /2:(5 %281'6 05 +2:$5' 7+$1. <28 <28 &$1 7$.( 7+$7 '2:1 12: ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

0$1',$ ',5(&7 05 +2:$5' 5(&2//(&7 27+(5 0$1',$17 (03/2<((6 72 +(/3 0( *2 7+528*+ 7+,6 '$7$ $1' :( 63(17 620(:+(5( %(7:((1 72 [phone] ,19(67,*$7,21 72 81'(567$1' +2: ',' 7202552:12: 2%7$,1 &23< 02',)< $1' ',675,%87( 25$&/( 62)7:$5( $1' 6833257 0$7(5,$/6 4 :+$7 &21&/86,21 :(5( <28 $%/( 72 5($&+ $%287 7202552:12: 6 '2:1/2$',1* 2) 25$&/( 6 0$7(5,$/6" $ :(// 7+( &21&/86,21 , 5($&+(' ,6 7+$7 7202552:12: 5(/,(' 21 0$66 '2:1/2$',1* 2) 25$&/( 62)7:$5( $1' 6833257 0$7(5,$/6 )520 7+( 25$&/( :(%6,7( $1 ,03523(5 $&&(66 72 7+$7 6,7( ,1 5(*$5'6 72 7(506 2) 86( $1' /,&(16,1* 4 $1' '2 <28 +$9( $ '(021675$7,9( 72 +(/3 <28 (;3/$,1 :+$7 <28 )281' ,1 7(506 2) 7+( 92/80( 2) '2:1/2$',1*" $ <(6 , '2 05 +2:$5' /(7 6 387 7+$7 83 21 7+( 6&5((1 3/($6( 6/,'( ',63/$<(' 21 6&5((1 %< 05 +2:$5' 4 7+$7 ,6 $7 7$% 2) <285 %,1'(5 6,5 7+$7 ,6 3/$,17,))6 '(021675$7,9( :+$7 '2(6 7+,6 6+2: 86" $ :(// :+(1 :( /22.(' $7 7+( '2:1/2$'6 :( )281' 29(5 0,//,21 25$&/( ),/(6 +$' %((1 '2:1/2$'(' %< 7202552:12: 7+$7 6 :+$7 +$33(1(' 72 %( 7+(5( :+(1 :( ',' 285 ,19(67,*$7,21 $1' 5($&+(' ,172 7202552:12: 6 6(59(56 $1' 6<67(06 72 6(( :+$7 7+(< +$' ,7 :$6 29(5 ),9( 7(5$%<7(6 ,1 6,=( ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

0$1',$ ',5(&7 05 +2:$5' %< 05 +2:$5' 4 029,1* )520 '2:1/2$'6 72 &23,(6 2) 25$&/( 6 (17(535,6( $33/,&$7,21 62)7:$5( $1' '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( ',' 7202552:12: +$9( &23,(6 2) 7+$7 62)7:$5( $6 :(// 21 ,76 6<67(06" $ <(6 7+(< ',' 4 +2: ',' 7+( $02817 2) 7+( 62)7:$5( $33/,&$7,21 &23,(6 $1' 7+( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( &23,(6 &203$5( 72 7+( $02817 2) 7+( '2:1/2$'6 7+$7 <28 )281'" $ %< 6,=( 5($/,=( 7+$7 7+( &23,(6 2) 25$&/( $33/,&$7,21 62)7:$5( $1' 25$&/( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( 7+(5( 6 67,// 7+286$1'6 2) ),/(6 %< 6,=( 7+(5( :$6 ),9( 7(5$%<7(6 2) '$7$ )25 7+( '2:1/2$'6 7+(5( :$6 29(5 7:,&( 7+$7 25 29(5 7(1 7(5$%<7(6 2) '$7$ )25 7+( 25$&/( $33/,&$7,21 62)7:$5( $1' 7+( 25$&/( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( %< 92/80( ,7 6 $ &216,'(5$%/( $02817 4 :+$7 .,1'6 2) (17(535,6( $33/,&$7,21 62)7:$5( &23,(6 $1' '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( &23,(6 ',' <28 ),1' 21 7202552:12: 6 6<67(06" $ :(// , 7+,1. $7 7+( +,*+(67 /(9(/ :( 6$: 3(23/(62)7 -'( 6,(%(/ $1' 25$&/( '$7$%$6( 352'8&76 7+(1 <28 &20( '2:1 $ 581* 7+(5( 6 620( 352'8&76 68&+ $6 7+( ),1$1&,$/6 +506 7+(5( 6 678'(17 $'0,1,675$7,21 (30 &50 3(23/( 722/6 :( (66(17,$//< )281' , 7+,1. $// 2) 7+( 62)7:$5( 7+$7 :$6 5(/(9$17 72 7+( )2857+ $0(1'(' &203/$,17 ,1 7+,6 &$6( ,7 :$6 $// 7+(5( 4 :+(1 <28 6$< -'( <28 0($1 - ' (':$5'6" ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 7 - November 12, 2010
0$1',$ ',5(&7 05 +2:$5' $ , 0($1 - ' (':$5'6 :25/' $1' 21( :25/' 25 (17(535,6( 21( 4 62 7+26( $5( 7:2 ',))(5(17 352'8&7 /,1(6 81'(5 - ' (':$5'6" $ <(6 4 +2: 0$1< &23,(6 2) 25$&/( 6 (17(535,6( $33/,&$7,21 62)7:$5( $1' 25$&/( 6 '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( ',' <28 ),1'" $ :(// 7+(5( :$6 $%287 25 025( &23,(6 2) 25$&/( $33/,&$7,21 62)7:$5( $1' 25$&/( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( , 0$'( $ '(021675$7,9( 72 *2 7+528*+ 7+(6( 180%(56 05 +2:$5' /(7 6 387 7+$7 83 3/($6( 6/,'( ',63/$<(' 21 6&5((1 %< 05 +2:$5' 4 :+$7 '2(6 7+,6 6+2:" $ :(// 7+,6 6+2:6 7+$7 ,1 7+( &' %,1'(56 $1' 7+(5( 6 &23,(6 2) 25$&/( $33/,&$7,21 62)7:$5( 25$&/( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( :+$7 7+(6( &' %,1'(56 :(5( ,6 :+(1 7202552:12: /$1'(' $ 1(: &/,(17 25 2%7$,1(' $ 1(: &/,(17 7+(< +$' $1 21 %2$5',1* 352&(66 '85,1* 7+$7 21 %2$5',1* 352&(66 7+(< &2//(&7(' 3+<6,&$/ &23,(6 2) 25$&/( $33/,&$7,216 62)7:$5( $1' 25$&/( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( $1' 7+(< 387 ,7 ,172 %,1'(56 $1' :+(1 :( :(17 7+528*+ 7+26( %,1'(56 7+(5( :$6 $&78$//< 0(55,// /(*$/ 62/87,216 :$6 $*5((' %< %27+ 6,'(6 72 *2 7+528*+ 7+( %,1'(56 $1' '2 $1 ,19(1725< 2) 7+26( %,1'(56 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'& 0$1',$ ',5(&7 05 +2:$5' 6,(%(/ (19,5210(176 $1' 25$&/( '$7$%$6( &23,(6 7+(6( $5( $// 180%(56 7+$7 '()(1'$176 $*5(( :,7+ 4 12: <28 9( 86(' 7+( 7(50 (19,5210(17 +(5( &$1 <28 (;3/$,1 :+$7 7+$7 ,6" $ , 7+,1. 7+( 6,03/(67 :$< 72 '(),1( $1 (19,5210(17 ,6 ,7 6 $1 ,167$//$7,21 2) 25$&/( $33/,&$7,21 62)7:$5( 25 ,76 &255(6321',1* '$7$%$6( (,7+(5 25 4 12: <28 6$,' 7+$7 7+( '()(1'$176 +$9( $*5((' :,7+ 7+(6( 180%(56 $6 :(// $1' <28 9( 0(17,21(' $ 67,38/$7,21 /(7 6 /22. $7 7+$7 %5,()/< 7+$7 6 ,1 <285 %,1'(5 $7 7$% 05 +2:$5' <285 +2125 7+$7 6 -2,17 75,$/ (;+,%,7 ,7 ,6 $/62 ,1 7+( -85< 127(%22.6 7,7/(' 75,$/ 67,38/$7,21 $1' 25'(5 180%(5 7+5(( 7+$7 6 7+( )2857+ '2&80(17 ,1 7+( -85< 6 127(%22. %< 05 +2:$5' 4 $1' 05 0$1',$ ,) , &$1 7851 <285 $77(17,21 72 :+$7 , %(/,(9( 7+( %27720 2) 3$*( 3$5$*5$3+ $1' ,7 6 83 21 7+( %2$5' '2&80(17 ',63/$<(' 21 6&5((1 $ 8+ +8+ 4 '2 7+26( 180%(56 7+(5( +$9( 0($1,1* 72 <28" $ :(// 7+(6( 180%(56 :(5( '(5,9(' )520 7+( 0$1',$17 5(3257 4 $1' ,7 6$<6 7+(5( 7+$7 ($&+ 2) 7+26( &23,(6 7+$7 <28 )281' 7+( '()(1'$176 +$9( 67,38/$7(' 72 ($&+ 2) 7+(0 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

0$1',$ ',5(&7 05 +2:$5' :( )281' &23,(6 2) 25$&/( $33/,&$7,21 62)7:$5( $1' 25$&/( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( 7+$7 :$6 $ 67$57,1* 32,17 )25 7+( &5($7,21 2) (19,5210(176 )520 7+(5( 7+( 25$&/( $33/,&$7,21 62)7:$5( $1' 25$&/( '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5( :$6 &23,(' 72 7+( &' -8.(%2; 7+( &' -8.(%2; :$6 +$5' '5,9(6 7+(< :(5( 7$.,1* 7+( ,167$// 0(',$ 7+( 3+<6,&$/ ',6.6 6(7 2) 7202552:12: 7+$7 7+(< :(5( &2//(&7,1* )520 7+(,5 &86720(56 $1' 7+(1 )25 7+( 0267 3$57 7+(< :28/' 387 7+(0 21 $1 ,17(50(',$7( 6725$*( $5($ &$//(' 7+( &' -8.(%2; $1' 7+(1 )520 7+(5( 7+(< :28/' 0$.( 7+( (19,5210(176 7+$7 :,// *2 29(5 ,1 7+( 1(;7 6/,'( 4 $5( 7+(6( 180%(56 ,1 ',6387(" $ 12 7+(< $5( 127 4 '()(1'$176 +$9( $*5((' 72 7+(0" $ ,7 ,6 0< 81'(567$1',1* 7+$7 ,1 7+( 67,38/$7,21 '$7(' 6(37(0%(5 7+ 2) 7+,6 <($5 7+$7 7+(6( 180%(56 :(5( $*5((' 72 $6 %(,1* 7+( $7 /($67 7+,6 0$1< &23,(6 :(5( ,1 7+( &' %,1'(56 $1' 7+( &' -8.(%2; 05 +2:$5' /(7 6 *2 72 <285 1(;7 6/,'( 6/,'( ',63/$<(' 21 6&5((1 %< 05 +2:$5' 4 :+$7 '2(6 7+,6 6+2: 86" $ 7+,6 6+2:6 7+( 180%(5 2) (19,5210(176 7+$7 (;,67(' 29(5 7,0( $7 7202552:12: 7+(5( 6 3(23/(62)7 (19,5210(176 7+$7 (;,67(' 29(5 7,0( 7+(5( - ' (':$5'6 (19,5210(176 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

0$1',$ ',5(&7 05 +2:$5' &2167,787( $1 ,1)5,1*(0(17 2) 21( 25 025( 2) 7+( 67,38/$7(' 5(*,67(5(' :25.6" $ <(6 4 +2: /21* ',' ,7 7$.( <28 72 ),1' $// 2) 7+(6( &23,(6 2) 25$&/( 6 $33/,&$7,21 62)7:$5( $1' '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5(" $ :(// ,7 722. $ %,7 2) 7,0( ,7 :$61 7 /,.( 7+( '$7$ :$6 *,9(1 72 86 $// $7 21&( 7+( '$7$ &$0( ,1 6(48(1&(6 $6 ,7 :$6 %(,1* 352'8&(' :( ' 5(9,(: ,7 $1' :( 67$57(' 5(9,(:,1* 7+( '$7$ :( *27 ,192/9(' ,1 7+( &$6( ,1 %87 7+( '$7$ 67$57(' %(,1* 352'8&(' 72 0$1',$17 620(:+(5( ,1 5(9,(:(' 7+$7 '$7$ ,1 $1' 68%0,77(' 285 ),567 5(3257 ,1 129(0%(5 2) 7+(5( :$6 1(: '$7$ (0(5*,1* 7+( :+2/( 7,0( 72 ,1&/8'( :( ',' $ 6833/(0(17$/ 5(3257 ,1 )(%58$5< 2) )(%58$5< , %(/,(9( 7+ %$6(' 21 $// 7+( 1(: '$7$ &20,1* )25:$5' (9(1 6,1&( :( 9( 68%0,77(' 285 6833/(0(17$/ 5(3257 7+(5( 6 %((1 $'',7,21$/ '$7$ 352'8&(' 7+$7 :( 6,03/< &28/' 127 ,1&/8'( 7+$7 :28/' %2/67(5 0< &21&/86,216 4 +2: /21* ',' ,7 7$.( )25 7+( '()(1'$176 72 $*5(( 72 7+( 180%(56 7+$7 <28 )281' 7+( 180%(56 2) &23,(6 2) 7+( 62)7:$5( 7+$7 <28 )281'" $ :(// 7+(6( 180%(56 :(5( &20081,&$7(' %< )(%58$5< 7+ 2) 7+( 67,38/$7,21 ,6 '$7(' 6(37(0%(5 2) 62 29(5 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 7 - November 12, 2010
SHEET 26

0$1',$ ',5(&7 05 +2:$5' 6(9(1 0217+6 4 12: +2: :(// '2 7+(6( 180%(56 7+(6( &23,(6 7+$7 <28 )281' 5(35(6(17 $// 2) 7+( &23,(6 2) 25$&/( 62)7:$5( 7+$7 7202552:12: (9(5 +$' 21 ,76 6<67(06 2) $33/,&$7,216 62)7:$5( $1' '$7$%$6( 62)7:$5(" $ $*$,1 ,7 6 $ /2:(5 %281'6 <28 &$1 21/< ),1' :+$7 <28 &$1 ),1' 0$1',$17 ',' 127 *(7 72 5(9,(: (9(5< 6<67(0 $7 7202552:12: :( ','1 7 *(7 72 /22. $7 $// 7+( ',))(5(17 ),(/' 2)),&(6 :( )2&86(' 285 ,19(67,*$7,21 21 %5<$1 7(;$6 4 :(5( <28 $%/( 72 5(9,(: 620( 2) 7+( ,167$17 0(66$*( &+$76 7+$7 7+( '()(1'$176 352'8&(' $)7(5 <28 68%0,77(' <285 6833/(0(17$/ 5(3257" $ , ',' 5(9,(: 620( 4 , :$17 <28 72 +$9( 7+26( ,1 0,1' <28 81'(567$1' 7+$7 6$3 $&48,5(' 7202552:12: ,1 -$18$5< 2) " $ <(6 4 7$.,1* ,172 $&&2817 7+( ,167$17 0(66$*( &+$76 7+$7 <28 9( 5(9,(:(' $1' <285 21/< $1$/<6,6 :+$7 ',' <28 2%6(59( $%287 7+( 1$785( 2) 7202552:12: 6 '2:1/2$',1* 35,25 72 -$18$5< 2) &203$5(' 72 $)7(5" $ :( '21 7 +$9( (;$&7 180%(56 2) '2:1/2$'6 7+$7 2&&855(' '85,1* 7+$7 7,0( )5$0( %87 :+$7 :( '2 .12: ,6 7+$7 7,7$1 :$6 '(9(/23(' $)7(5 -$18$5< 2) $1' 7,7$1 72 5()5(6+ <285 5(&2//(&7,21 ,6 $ 0$66 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

0$1',$ ',5(&7 05 +2:$5' 7+( &5266 86( $&78$//< *2(6 83 )520 35,25 72 -$18$5< 2) 72 $)7(5:$5'6 ,7 :$6 $3352;,0$7(/< 3(5&(17 35,25 72 -$18$5< 67 2) $1' *2(6 83 72 3(5&(17 29(5 7,0( :+$7 7+$7 0($16 ,6 ,) , 5(&(,9(' $ ),; )520 7202552:12: 7+(5( :$6 $ 3(5&(17 &+$1&( 25 025( 7+$7 620(%2'< (/6( 6 62)7:$5( :$6 86(' 72 '(9(/23 7+$7 ),; 25 0< 62)7:$5( ,6 86(' 72 '(9(/23 7+$7 ),; %87 27+(5 )2/.6 %(1(),7(' )520 ,7 4 $1' +2: $5( <28 86,1* 7+( 7(50 ),; " $ $ ),; ,6 -867 $1 83'$7( ,7 6 $ &2'( ,7 &28/' %( 27+(5 7+,1*6 %87 ,7 ,6 -867 $1 83'$7( 25 $ ),; 72 62)7:$5( 4 12: :+$7 ',' <28 2%6(59( $%287 7202552:12: 6 &5266 86( 2) 21( &86720(5 6 /2*,1 &5('(17,$/6 )25 &86720(5 &211(&7,21 72 '2:1/2$' )25 $127+(5 &86720(5" $ , 7+,1. :( +$9( $ 63(&,),& (;$03/( 6+2:,1* 7+$7 7+(5( :$6 &5266 86( 2) &5('(17,$/6 0($1,1* :+(1 62)7:$5( ,6 %(,1* '2:1/2$'(' )520 25$&/( 6 :(%6,7( ,7 6 683326(' 72 %( '2:1/2$'(' ,) <28 $5( '2:1/2$',1* 21 %(+$/) 2) &86720(5 $ <28 $5( 683326(' 72 86( &86720(5 $ 6 86(5 $&&2817 $1' 3$66:25' $1' 21/< '2:1/2$' 7+26( ),/(6 )25 &86720(5 $ $1' 7+(1 21/< 86( 7+(0 )25 &86720(5 $ 6 %(1(),7 %87 :( 6$: &5266 86( :+(5( 7+( &5('(17,$/ ,6 %(,1* 86(' 5$7+(5 0,6+$1'/(' 4 :28/' <28 7851 72 7$% ,1 <285 %,1'(5 3/($6(" $1' 7+$7 6 $7 ,167$17 0(66$*( &+$7 %(7:((1 6+(//(< 1(/621 $1' 52' 5866(// '$7(' $35,/ ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

0$1',$ ',5(&7 05 +2:$5' '2:1/2$',1* 722/ ,7 :$6 0$'( %< 7202552:12: 72 *(7 25$&/( 62)7:$5( $1' 6833257 0$7(5,$/6 )$67(5 7+$7 :$6 ,76 35,0$5< 385326( 62 ,7 6 /,.(/< %(&$86( 7,7$1 :$6 '(9(/23(' $)7(5 -$18$5< 67 $1' ,7 (1+$1&(' 7+( 63((' $7 :+,&+ 7202552:12: &28/' 2%7$,1 25$&/( 62)7:$5( $1' 6833257 0$7(5,$/6 7+$7 7+( '2:1/2$',1* 21/< ,1&5($6(' 4 &203$5,1* 7+( 6$0( 7:2 7,0( 3(5,2'6 %()25( -$18$5< 2) $1' $)7(5 :+$7 ',' <28 2%6(59( $%287 7+( $02817 2) &23,(6 2) 25$&/( 6 (17(535,6( $33/,&$7,21 62)7:$5( $7 7202552:12:" $ :(// 7+(5( :(5( 025( &23,(6 0$'( 025( (19,5210(176 0$'( $)7(5 -$18$5< 67 7+$1 %()25( 4 12: &$1 <28 (;3/$,1 :+$7 <28 0($1 %< &5266 86( " $ &5266 86( ,1 7+( %(67 :$< 72 (;3/$,1 ,6 ,7 6 86,1* 620(21( (/6( 6 %$6,&$//< <28 $5( 5(&(,9,1* 620(7+,1* 7+$7 :$6 %8,/7 ,1 620(21( (/6( 6 62)7:$5( 25 <285 62)7:$5( ,6 $&78$//< 86(' 72 %(1(),7 620(%2'< (/6( ,7 6 $ 0,6$/,*10(17 2) 7+( 62)7:$5( 86(' 72 &5($7( 620(7+,1* )25 620(%2'< (/6( &$6( ,1 32,17 :28/' %( &86720(5 $ 62)7:$5( %(,1* 86(' 72 %(1(),7 &86720(56 % & 25 ' 4 12: &203$5,1* 7+(6( 6$0( 7:2 7,0( 3(5,2'6 %()25( -$18$5< $1' $)7(5 -$18$5< :+$7 ',' <28 2%6(59( $%287 7+( $02817 2) &5266 86( 7+$7 ,6 86,1* 21( &86720(5 6 62)7:$5( 72 &5($7( ),;(6 )25 27+(5 &86720(56" $ )25 7+( ),;(6 7+$7 35('20,1$7(' $)7(5 -$18$5< 67 2) ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

0$1',$ ',5(&7 05 +2:$5' '2 <28 .12: :+2 6+(//(< 1(/621 ,6" $ <(6 4 :+2 ,6 6+(" $ 6+(//(< 1(/621 ,6 7+( 93 2) */2%$/ 6833257 )25 7202552:12: $1' 6+( 6 7+( :,)( 2) $1'5(: 1(/621 :+2 ,6 7+( &(2 2) 7202552:12: 25 :+2 :$6 7+( &(2 4 ,6 6+( 5(/$7(' 72 *5(* 1(/621 7+( &+,() ,1)250$7,21 2)),&(5" $ , %(/,(9( 7+(< $5( 5(/$7(' 4 12: :+$7 ,6 7+( '$7( 2) 7+,6 &+$7" $ 7+,6 ,167$17 0(66$*( ,6 '$7(' $35,/ 7+ 2) 4 ,6 7+$7 %()25( 25 $)7(5 25$&/( %528*+7 7+,6 /$:68,7" $ 7+,6 ,6 $3352;,0$7(/< $ 0217+ $)7(5 7+( /$:68,7 7+( /$:68,7 :$6 ),/(' , %(/,(9( 21 0$5&+ 1' 4 :+$7 '2(6 7+,6 &+$7 0($1 72 <28" $ 0< ,17(535(7$7,21 2) 7+,6 &+$7 $6 <28 6(( 52'(5,& 5866(// $7 6$< '2 <28 +$9( $ 6(&21' )25 $ 48(67,21" , 1((' 72 5(6($5&+ $ ),; 7+$7 :$6 *,9(1 72 $ &/,(17 %< 25$&/( $1' , 1((' 72 ),1' $ &/,(17 :,7+ $ &855(17 0$,17(1$1&( (1' '$7( 62 , &$1 /2*,1 72 &86720(5 &211(&7,21 7+$7 6 +2: &86720(5 &211(&7,21 :25.(' ,) <28 +$' $ 0$,17(1$1&( $*5((0(17 :,7+ 25$&/( <285 86(5 ,' $1' 3$66 3+5$6( :28/' :25. :,7+ 25$&/( %87 29(5 7,0( ,) <28 67233(' '2,1* ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 7 - November 12, 2010
0$1',$ ',5(&7 05 +2:$5' 0$,17(1$1&( :,7+ 25$&/( <285 &5('(17,$/ :28/' 12 /21*(5 :25. 21 25$&/( 6 &86720(5 &211(&7,21 6,7( 62 :+$7 52'(5,& 5866(// ,6 $6.,1* ,6 , 1((' $ &86720(5 6 86(5 ,' $1' 3$66 3+5$6( 7+$7 ,6 67,// 21 25$&/( 6 0$,17(1$1&( 62 , &$1 /2*,1 72 7+( &86720(5 &211(&7,21 6,7( 72 5(6($5&+ 620(7+,1* $1' 7+( $16:(5 :,7+,1 6(&21'6 , '2 0< 0$7+ 6(&21'6 ,6 )520 6+(//(< 1(/621 :+2 ,6 5(35(6(17(' $6 71:,)(7(; ,6 52%(57 +$/) %($5 67($516 7+(5( 6 <285 &86720(5 &211(&7,21 ,' 127 21/< '2(6 6+( 127 6+2: $1 ,17(5(67 ,1 :+$7 &86720(5 $5( <28 $%287 72 6833257 05 5866(// %87 6+( $/62 *,9(6 +,0 7:2 237,216 52%(57 +$/) 25 %($5 67($516 7+,6 ,6 $ 9(5< &20021 3$77(51 :( 6$: ,1 7+(6( ,167$17 0(66$*(6 :+(5( 7+(5( 6 ,1',9,'8$/6 $7 7202552: 6$<,1* , 1((' $ :25.$%/( $1' :25.,1* &5('(17,$/ 62 , &$1 /2*,1 72 '2 7+,1*6 )25 :+2(9(5 7+(< +$' 72 +(/3 4 7+$1. <28 05 +2:$5' <28 &$1 7$.( 7+$7 '2:1 %< 05 +2:$5' 4 05 0$1',$ , :$17 <28 72 )2&86 21 $ ',))(5(17 7,0( 3(5,2' 12: :( +$9( 7$/.(' $%287 7+( /$:68,7 %(,1* ),/(' ,1 0$5&+ 2) :+$7 ',' <28 2%6(59( $%287 7+( 1$785( 2) 7202552:12: 6 '2:1/2$',1* %()25( 0$5&+ 2) &203$5(' 72 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'& 0$1',$ &5266 05 &2:$1 ($5/,(5" $ <(6 ,7 ,6 4 05 0$1',$ +2: 0$1< &20387(5 )25(16,& ,19(67,*$7,216 +$9( <28 %((1 ,192/9(' :,7+ 29(5 7+( &2856( 2) <285 &$5((5" $ $3352;,0$7(/< $ +81'5(' 4 +2: '2(6 7+,6 ,19(67,*$7,21 &203$5( 72 7+26( 27+(56" $ 7+(5( :$6 025( 5(/(9$17 '$7$ )25 86 72 5(9,(: $1' 025( '$7$ 7$.(1 )520 21( 6,7( 7+$1 ,1 $1< 2) 0< 27+(5 ,19(67,*$7,216 %< 92/80( $1' $ +$/) 7(5$%<7(6 ,6 7+( 0267 , +$9( 6((1 05 +2:$5' 7+$1. <28 127+,1* )857+(5 <285 +2125 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 &5266 (;$0,1$7,21" 05 &2:$1 0$< , $3352$&+ <285 +2125" 7+( &2857 <(6 &5266 (;$0,1$7,21 %< 05 &2:$1 4 *22' $)7(51221 05 0$1',$ +2: $5( <28" $ , $0 '2,1* *22' 6,5 4 <28 5(&$// :( 0(7 $ /,77/( /(66 7+$1 6,; 0217+6 $*2 )25 7:2 '$<6 '85,1* :+,&+ 7,0( , +$' 7+( 23325781,7< 72 '(326( <28 )25 7+( %(77(5 3$57 2) 7:2 '$<6 '2 <28 5(&$// 7+$7" $ , 5(&$// 7+$7 4 :( 0$< 7$/. $ /,77/( %,7 $%287 620( 2) 7+26( 7+,1*6 %87 , ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

0$1',$ ',5(&7 05 +2:$5' $)7(5" $ 7+( '2:1/2$',1* )520 7202552:12: 6 %5<$1 ,3 $''5(66 ,6 8/7,0$7(/< 67233(' :,7+,1 $ 0217+ 2) 7+( /$:68,7 4 ',' 27+(5 '2:1/2$',1* &217,18(" $ 7+(5( $5( 620( ,167$17 0(66$*(6 7+$7 68**(67 7+$7 620( 27+(5 '2:1/2$',1* &217,18(' 4 ,6 7+,6 21( 7+$7 :( -867 6$: 21( 2) 7+26(" $ ,7 6+2:6 7+$7 &5('(17,$/6 $5( %(,1* 6+$5(' %87 :( ',' 127 6(( $ &255(6321',1* '2:1/2$' )520 7+( %5<$1 ,3 $''5(66(6 )25 7+$7 &211(&7,21 4 +2: $%287 7+( &23<,1* 2) 25$&/( 6 (17(535,6( 62)7:$5( $33/,&$7,216" +2: '2(6 7+$7 &203$5( %()25( 0$5&+ 2) :+(1 25$&/( %528*+7 7+( /$:68,7 $1' $)7(5" $ , /22.(' ,172 7+,6 $1' 21( 2) 7+( 7+,1*6 , 127,&(' :$6 )520 0$5&+ :+(1 7+( /$:68,7 :$6 ),/(' 72 $%287 $35,/ 2) 7202552:12: &5($7(' $ 0,1,080 2) $'',7,21$/ (19,5210(176 62 7+(< &217,18(' 72 0$.( (19,5210(176 $)7(5 7+( /$:68,7 4 $1' +2: $%287 &5266 86( ',' 7+$7 &+$1*( )520 %()25( 0$5&+ 2) 72 $)7(5 0$5&+ 2) " $ 2) 7+( ),;(6 7+$7 , 5(9,(:(' $1' , 5(9,(:(' 29(5 3(5&(17 2) 7+(0 7+( &5266 86( 5(0$,1(' 7+( 6$0( '85,1* 7+$7 7,0( )5$0( 0($1,1* 7+( &5266 86( %(,1* '21( ,1 $1' :$6 9,578$//< ,'(17,&$/ 4 ,6 7+$7 7+( 6$0( 3(5&(17 5$7( 7+$7 <28 '(6&5,%(' ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

0$1',$ &5266 05 &2:$1 :,// 75< 72 %( %5,() 2.$<" $ 2.$< 4 %()25( :( *(7 ,172 (;3/$,1,1* )25 7+( -85< +2: ,) $7 $// :+$7 <28 -867 7+( ,1)250$7,21 <28 -867 3529,'(' ,1 5(63216( 72 05 +2:$5' 6 48(67,216 5(/$7( $1< :$< 72 '$0$*(6 , :$17 72 81'(567$1' $ /,77/( %,7 025( $%287 7+( 6&23( 2) <285 (;3(57,6( 2.$<" $ 2.$< 4 <28 $5( 127 $1 (;3(57 :+2 &$1 *,9( 23,1,216 21 '$0$*(6 ,1 62)7:$5( &$6(6 5,*+7" $ , '21 7 +2/' 0<6(/) 287 $6 $1 (;3(57 7+$7 &$1 *,9( $1 23,1,21 21 '$0$*(6 12 4 $1' 62 72 %( &/($5 <28 $5( 127 2))(5,1* $1< (;3(57 23,1,216 5(*$5',1* '$0$*(6 ,1 7+,6 &$6( $1' 025( 63(&,),&$//< <28 +$9(1 7 '21( $1< $1$/<6,6 6,& 2) $1< 5($6216 :+< $1< 63(&,),& &86720(5 /()7 25$&/( 72 *2 72 7202552:12: +$9( <28" $ , +$9( 127 4 $1' <28 $5( 127 $1 (;3(57 21 62)7:$5( /,&(16(6 $5( <28" $ , '21 7 +2/' 0<6(/) 287 $6 $1 (;3(57 ,1 62)7:$5( /,&(16,1* 4 <28 $5( 127 $ &23<5,*+7 (;3(57 (,7+(5 $5( <28" $ , $0 127 $ &23<5,*+7 (;3(57 4 <28 +$9( 1(9(5 :25.(' $6 $ '(9(/23(5 ,1 '(9(/23,1* (17(535,6( $33/,&$7,21 62)7:$5( +$9( <28" $ , +$9( 127 :25.(' $6 $ '(9(/23(5 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 9 - November 16, 2010
&/$5.( ',5(&7 0,77(/67$('7 :+,&+ :$6 7+( 7+( 6$3 &20321(17 2) 7+$7 ,6 %$6(' 8321 )285 &86720(56 62 127 -867 )285 4 2.$< $*$,1 ,1 7+( 23(1,1* 67$7(0(17 , 7+,1. , 6$,' 7:2 &86720(56 :+< 7+( ',))(5(1&(" $ :( :25. 62 +$5' 72 '2 7+,6 $1$/<6,6 %87 ,1 7+( 7+( 581 83 72 7+( 75,$/ <28 &$1 ,0$*,1( 7+$7 7+( ,17(16,7< 2) :25. *(76 (9(1 *5($7(5 $1' , 9( %((1 29(5 $// 2) 7+(6( &86720(56 $*$,1 72 6(( :+(7+(5 , )(/7 *22' $%287 %5,1*,1* :+$7 , +$' /($51(' 72 <28 $1' ,1 '2,1* 7+$7 , )281' 7:2 &86720(56 7+$7 , ','1 7 7+,1. 5($//< 6+28/' %( (;&/8'(' )520 7+( '$0$*(6 62 :+(1 05 0,77(/67$('7 6$,' ,7 6 7:2 &86720(56 %$&. 7+(1 ,7 67,// :$6 7:2 &86720(56 %87 6,1&( 7+(1 , 9( , 9( 387 7+(6( 7:2 27+(56 ,1 62 ,7 6 12: )285 &86720(56 7+$7 :( $5( &$/&8/$7,1* 7+( '$0$*(6 21 4 $1' 7+$7 ,1&5($6(' 7+( $02817 2) &203(16$7,21 2:(' 72 25$&/(" $ ,7 '2(6 4 12: :( 5( *2,1* 72 *(7 ,172 7+,6 ,1 025( '(7$,/ %87 ,1 $ 1876+(// &$1 <28 7(// 86 +2: <28 7+,1. 05 0(<(5 :(17 :521* ,1 7+( +<327+(7,&$/ 1(*27,$7,21 5($621$%/( 52<$/7< &$/&8/$7,21 7+$7 +( ','" $ :(// , %(/,(9( +( :(17 :521* ,1 0$1< $5($6 %87 7+( 7+(< )$// ,172 0$-25 &$7(*25,(6 7+( ),567 ,6 7+$7 , 7+,1. 7+( '2&80(176 +( 5(/,(' 8321 72 &$/&8/$7( +,6 180%(5 '21 7 6$< :+$7 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55 &/$5.( ',5(&7 0,77(/67$('7 62 7+$7 6 7+( ),567 ',))(5(1&( %(7:((1 :+$7 +$33(16 ,1 7+( +<327+(7,&$/ 1(*27,$7,21 $1' :+$7 +$33(16 ,1 5($/ /,)( ,1 5($/ /,)( 7+(6( 3$57,(6 :28/' 1(9(5 +$9( $*5((' %87 ,1 7+( +<327+(7,&$/ 1(*27,$7,21 7+(< +$9( 72 $*5(( $1' 7+( :$< :( '2 7+$7 ,6 , *$7+(5 83 $// 2) 7+( ,1)250$7,21 $1' ,1 ())(&7 +$9( 7+,6 52/( 2) 62/2021 2) %$/$1&,1* 7+(6( 7+(6( 3,(&(6 2) ,1)250$7,21 72 75< $1' '(7(50,1( :+$7 :28/' %( 5($621$%/( )25 7+(6( 7:2 3$57,(6 ,1 7+$7 1(*27,$7,21 :+$7 :28/' 7+(< &20( 72 ,) 7+(< :(5( )25&(' 72 $*5(( $1' 62 7+$7 6 7+( ),567 7+,1* 7+$7 +$33(16 ,1 7+( +<327+(7,&$/ 1(*27,$7,21 7+( 1(;7 7+,1* 7+$7 +$33(16 ,6 7+$7 :( +$9( 72 7$.( 7+( 3(5621$/,7,(6 287 2) 7+,6 62 7+(5( 6 12 $1*(5 $//2:(' 7+(5( 6 12 381,6+0(17 $//2:(' 7+( 3$57,(6 -867 +$9( 72 '2 $1 $335235,$7( %86,1(66 '($/ $1' $*$,1 7+$7 6 0< 52/( ,6 72 7$.( 7+( 3(5621$/,7,(6 2)) 7+( 7$%/( , 0 685( <28 9( <28 9( 6((1 3(23/( &20( $1' 6,7 ,1 7+( &+$,5 $1' 7(// <28 7+$7 <28 .12: 7+(< :(5( ',6$332,17(' 25 $1*5< 25 :+$7(9(5 7+$7 '2(61 7 3/$< $1< 52/( ,1 7+( +<327+(7,&$/ 1(*27,$7,21 4 ,1 7+,6 +<327+(7,&$/ 1(*27,$7,21 :+< '21 7 <28 -867 $6. 7+( 21( 6,'( +2: 08&+ 7+(< :$17 72 3$< $1' 7+( 27+(5 6,'( +2: 08&+ 7+(< 5( '(0$1',1*" $ %(&$86( <28 :28/'1 7 *(7 9(5< *22' $16:(56 72 7+26( 48(67,216 <28 <28 &$1127 5(/< 21 7+( 3$57,(6 :+2 0,*+7 :(// 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&/$5.( ',5(&7 0,77(/67$('7 +( 7+,1.6 7+(< 6$< $1' &(57$,1/< '21 7 6$< :+$7 +( 72/' <28 7+(< 6$< 62 ,7 6 7+( ,1)250$7,21 +( 86(' ,6 7+( ,6 $ &5,7,&$/ 3,(&( 2) 7+( ',))(5(1&( $1' 7+(1 +( $/62 )2&86(' 62/(/< 21 $ /803 680 52<$/7< $1' <28 .12: +( +( 6$,' 7+,6 180%(5 +$6 72 %( /$5*( 72 &203(16$7( 25$&/( %(&$86( 7+(< -867 %28*+7 3(23/(62)7 $1' 7+$7 /803 680 ,'($ 7+( 7+( $33/,&$7,21 2) 7+$7 /803 680 $3352$&+ 72 7+( 5($621$%/( 52<$/7< , 7+,1. /(' +,0 72 &20( 72 $ )$8/7< &21&/86,21 $1' :( // *2 ,172 7+( ',))(5(1&(6 %(7:((1 +( $1' , $6 :( &217,18( 4 2.$< , :$17 72 %5($. 7+,6 (;$0,1$7,21 ,172 7+5(( 7+5(( 3$576 :( // ),567 7$/. $%287 7+( +<327+(7,&$/ 1(*27,$7,21 $1' 7+(1 :( // 7$/. $%287 7+( /267 6833257 352),76 $1' $1' 7+(1 :( // ),1,6+ 83 21 7+( ,1)5,1*(5 6 352),76 62 /(7 6 67$57 :,7+ +<327+(7,&$/ 1(*27,$7,21 $1' /(7 6 7$.( $ 67(3 %$&. :28/' <28 (;3/$,1 72 86 <285 9,(: 2) +2: $ +<327+(7,&$/ 1(*27,$7,21 ,6 683326(' 72 :25. :+$7 6 7+( &21&(37" $ 7+( ,'($ ,6 7+$7 :( *(7 7+( 3/$,17,)) $1' 7+( '()(1'$17 ,1 5220 $1' )25&( 7+(0 72 &20( 72 $1 $*5((0(17 :( 67$59( 7+(0 72 '($7+ :( '21 7 /(7 7+(0 287 2) 7+( 5220 817,/ 7+(< $*5(( $1' 2) &2856( $6 <28 0,*+7 ,0$*,1( 7+( $&78$/ 3/$,17,)) $1' 7+( $&78$/ '()(1'$17 ,) 7+(< :(5( 7+( 5($/ 3(23/( *2,1* ,172 7+$7 5220 ,1 7+,6 &$6( 7+(< :28/' 1(9(5 +$9( 0$'( $1 $*5((0(17 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&/$5.( ',5(&7 0,77(/67$('7 %( $1*5< 25 ',6$332,17(' 72 *,9( <28 $ )$,5 (67,0$7( )520 7+(,5 32,17 2) 9,(: $1' , &$1 7(// <28 7+$7 ,1 0$1< 0$1< 2) 7+(6( &$6(6 7+( 3/$,17,)) 6$<6 :(// :( :$17 $ /27 2) 021(< :( :28/' 1(9(5 +$9( 6(77/(' )25 7+( +<327+(7,&$/ 5($621$%/( 52<$/7< 62 7+( 52<$/7< , &20( 83 :,7+ 7+( 3/$,17,)) 6$<6 :(// 7+$7 6 127 (128*+ 21 7+( 27+(5 +$1' 7+( '()(1'$176 $/:$<6 6$< 7+$7 6 :$< 722 08&+ $1' 2) &2856( 7+$7 6 *2,1* 72 %( 7+(,5 326,7,21 7+26( 7+26( 9,(:6 '21 7 *(7 72 58/( ,1 7+( +<327+(7,&$/ 1(*27,$7,21 , *(7 72 '2 7+$7 , 7+,1. , '2 $ *22' -2% 2) %$/$1&,1* $// 2) 7+26( ,03257$17 (/(0(176 , &20( 72 <28 $1' '(6&5,%( 7+26( 7+,1*6 72 <28 $1' ,) <28 7+,1. , ',' ,7 &255(&7/< 7+(1 7+$7 6 :+$7 <28 0$.( <285 '(&,6,21 $&&25',1*/< 4 :+(7+(5 <28 6$< 381,6+0(17 '2(61 7 3/$< $1< 52/( ,1 7+,6 :+< 127" ,) ,) 7+( '()(1'$17 +$6 ,1)5,1*(' 7+( 3/$,17,)) 6 &23<5,*+7 :+< '2(61 7 381,6+0(17 3/$< 620( 52/(" $ 7+$7 6 $ 7+$7 6 $&78$//< 7+( 7+,5' 3,(&( 2) 7+( +<327+(7,&$/ 1(*27,$7,21 :+,&+ , ','1 7 *(7 72 ,1 7+( 7+( 7,0,1* 2) 7+( +<327+(7,&$/ 1(*27,$7,21 :( 5( /22.,1* $7 $ 3(5,2' 5,*+7 %()25( 7+( ,1)5,1*(0(17 %(*,16 62 ,1 7+$7 1(*27,$7,21 7+(5( ,6 12 ,1)5,1*(0(17 7+(5( 6 12 381,6+0(17 7+(5( 6 12 $1*(5 7+,6 ,6 7:2 %86,1(66 3(23/( 75<,1* 72 5($&+ $ '($/ 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 9 - November 16, 2010
&/$5.( ',5(&7 0,77(/67$('7 7202552:12: &20321(17 7+$7 :$6 817(67(' 7+(< +$' $7 7+( 7,0( 2) 7+( 75$16$&7,21 &86720(56 62 7+(< :(5( 127 9(5< 68&&(66)8/ 7+(< 21/< +$' &86720(56 ,1 $// 7,0( 7+(< ','1 7 67,// +$9( $7 7+$7 020(17 62 7+(< :(5( 7+(< :(5( 7(67(' %87 127 9(5< 68&&(66)8/ 7+( &+$1*(5 :$6 :+(1 6$3 %28*+7 7+(0 $1' 2) &2856( 7+$7 :$6 $ &203/(7(/< 1(: $3352$&+ 72 7+,6 %86,1(66 12 21( +$' (9(5 '21( 7+$7 %()25( $1' 05 (//,621 (9(1 &$//(' ,7 $ %5,//,$17 675$7(*,& 029( 25 620(7+,1* /,.( 7+$7 62 :,7+ $ %5$1' 1(: 7+,1* /,.( 7+$7 1(,7+(5 6,'( 127 25$&/( 127 6$3 :28/' :$17 $ /803 680 7+( 5,6. :28/' %( :$< 722 +,*+ )25 %27+ 2) 7+(0 <28 :28/' '2 $ 5811,1* 52<$/7< 4 2.$< 12: :,7+ 7+( 5811,1* 52<$/7< <28 1((' 72 ),*85( 287 :+$7 7+( 52<$/7< 5$7( ,6 *2,1* 72 %( $1' :+$7 7+( %$6( ,6 *2,1* 72 %( 5,*+7" $ &255(&7 4 $1' +2: ',' <28 *2 $%287 '(7(50,1,1* :+$7 7+( 52<$/7< 5$7( :28/' %( 7+( 5$7(" $ 7+( :$< , ',' 7+,6 5$7( :$6 ',))(5(17 )25 7202552:12: $1' 6$3 %87 ,1 %27+ &$6(6 , 6(7 7+( 5$7( $6 +,*+ $6 , 3266,%/< &28/' $1' 67,// %( $%/( 72 6$< ,7 :$6 5($621$%/( 0< 5$7,21$/( )25 '2,1* 7+$7 :$6 7+(6( 7:2 &203$1,(6 $5( /2&.(' ,1 0257$/ &20%$7 7+(< :$17 72 ),*+7 72 7+( '($7+ $1' 7+$7 0($16 7+$7 :28/' 7+$7 :28/' 0($1 $ 9(5< +,*+ /,&(16( 5$7( $1' , &$/&8/$7(' 7+( +,*+(67 5$7( , 9( (9(5 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55 &/$5.( ',5(&7 0,77(/67$('7 4 )25 7202552:12:" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 <(6 4 $1' :+< ,6 7+$7" $ :,7+ 7202552:12: 7+(< 6(7 7+(,5 35,&,1* $7 +$/) 2) 25$&/( 6 35,&( 62 ,) 25$&/( +$' &86720(5 )25 0$,17(1$1&( 7202552:12: 6 35,&( :$6 $%287 ,7 :$61 7 $ +$5' $1' )$67 58/( %87 ,7 :$6 $%287 +$/) 2) 7+$7 62 7+( 7+( 7+(< 1(9(5 5($//< 0$'( $1< 021(< 7+(< /267 $ /27 2) 021(< 29(5 7+( <($56 62 (9(1 3877,1* $1< 52<$/7< ,1 7+(5( :28/' -867 0($1 7+(< /267 025( 021(< $1' <28 .12: , , 7+,1. 7+$7 6 2.$< 7+(5( 6 127+,1* 81'(5 7+( /$: 7+$7 6$<6 7+(< +$9( 72 0$.( 021(< %87 67,// 7+( 52<$/7< +$6 72 %( 5($621$%/( 62 ,) <28 /22. $7 7+( +81'5(' 7+286$1' 7+$7 25$&/( :28/' +$9( &+$5*(' $1' 7+( 7+$7 7202552:12: &+$5*(' , 6$,' :( // 7$.( 7+( +$/):$< 32,17 21 7+(5( :+,&+ :,// %( 3(5&(17 2) 25$&/( 6 35,&( $1' 7+$7 :,// %( 3(5&(17 2) 7202552:12: 6 35,&( 62 7+$7 6 +2: , ',' ,7 4 2.$< :( 9( +($5' $%287 7+( *(25*,$ 3$&,),& )$&7256 05 0(<(5 0(17,21(' 7+26( , 7+,1. +( +$' $ 6/,'( 21 7+(0 $6 :(// ',' <28 &216,'(5 7+( *(25*,$ 3$&,),& )$&7256 ,1 5($&+,1* <285 23,1,21" $ , ',' 4 2.$< :( +$9( $ 6/,'( 21 7+26( )$&7256 $1' , 7+,1. ,7 :,// 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&/$5.( ',5(&7 0,77(/67$('7 &$/&8/$7(' ,1 $1< &$6( ,6 ,1 7+,6 &$6( 62 7+$7 :$6 0< 5$7,21$/( , 86(' $1 $1$/<6,6 2) 0$1< )$&7256 72 &20( 83 :,7+ 7+$7 %87 $7 7+( (1' 2) 7+( '$< 7$.,1* $// 2) 7+26( )$&7256 ,172 $&&2817 , 6(7 7+( 5$7( $6 +,*+ $6 , 3266,%/< &28/' $1' 67,// %( $%/( 72 6$< ,7 :$6 5($621$%/( 4 $1' :+$7 5$7( ',' <28 '(7(50,1(" $ )25 7202552:12: , 6(7 7+( 52<$/7< $7 3(5&(17 2) 7+(,5 5(9(18(6 62 ,) 7+(< +$' $ &86720(5 7+(< :28/' 3$< 2) 7+$7 $1' 3$< ,7 72 3$< ,7 72 25$&/( 7+$7 ,6 $6752120,&$//< +,*+ 52<$/7< 5$7( $1' , , 0 35(3$5(' 72 %(7 $1<7+,1* 7+$7 12 21( &28/' &20( ,172 7+,6 &28575220 $1' 3529( 7+$7 7+(5( :$6 620( +,*+(5 5$7( 7+$7 ,6 9(5< +,*+ 21 7+( 6$3 6,'( :+$7 , ',' 7+(5( :$6 , 6$,' 6$3 6 '2,1* $ /27 2) :25. 7+(< +$9( 7+,6 27+(5 352*5$0 7+(5( 6 $ +,*+ 352%$%,/,7< 7+(< :28/' *(7 7+( 6$/(6 $1<:$< %87 , 0 *2,1* 72 5()/(&7 7+$7 ,1 $ 5$7( 7+$7 6 67,// 67,// 6+$5,1* 7+( 632,/6 %(7:((1 7+( 7:2 3$57,(6 %87 7+,6 7,0( , :28/' 127 %$6( ,7 21 6$3 6 5(9(18(6 , ' %$6( ,7 21 7+(,5 352),76 62 , &$/&8/$7(' 7+( 352),76 6$3 0$'( $1' , 722. +$/) 2) 7+$7 $1' &$//(' 7+$7 $ $ 5($621$%/( 52<$/7< )25 )25 7+(0 72 3$< 72 25$&/( 4 /(7 0( *2 %$&. $ 67(3 72 72 7202552:12: <28 6$,' 3(5&(17 2) 5(9(18( ,167($' 2) 3(5&(17 2) 352),7 $ 21 7202552:12: 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&/$5.( ',5(&7 0,77(/67$('7 +(/3 86 -867 :$/. 7+528*+ 7+(0 6/,'( 3/($6( '(021675$7,9( 38%/,6+(' 72 7+( -85< %< 05 0,77(/67$('7 4 2.$< /(7 6 127 *2 29(5 $// %87 *5283 7+(0 72*(7+(5 $1' , ' /,.( 72 $6. <28 72 67$57 :,7+ 12 12 12 $1' 12 :+,&+ +$9( 72 '2 :,7+ 1250$/ 52<$/7,(6 5(&(,9(' $1' 3$,' %< 7+(6( 3$57,(6 $1' 7+(,5 1250$/ 32/,&,(6 $1' 352),76+$5,1* +2: ',' <28 :+$7 ,6 7+$7 :+$7 '2 7+26( )$&7256 0($1 $1' +2: ',' <28 $33/< 7+(0" $ 7+( 7+( ,'($/ 7+,1* 7+$7 :( $5( /22.,1* )25 :+(1 :( 5( '2,1* 7+,6 $1$/<6,6 ,6 $1 (67$%/,6+(' 52<$/7< ,) <28 &$1 *2 287 ,172 7+( 0$5.(73/$&( $1' ),1' $1 (67$%/,6+(' 52<$/7< 7+(1 <28 -867 86(' 7+$7 , ','1 7 ),1' 7+$7 ,1 7+,6 &$6( $6 ,7 +$33(16 %87 7+(6( )$&7256 7+$7 :( 5( /22.,1* $7 +(5( $// +$9( 72 '2 :,7+ ,6 7+(5( $1 (67$%/,6+(' 52<$/7< ,1 7+( 0$5.(73/$&( '2 7+( &203$1,(6 +$9( $1 (67$%/,6+(' :$< 2) &+$5*,1* )25 7+,6 7,0( 7<3( 2) 6(59,&(" 62 7+$7 6 :+$7 7+26( )$&7256 $5( 5(/$7(' 72 4 ',' <28 /22. $7 7+( 5(6(//(5 $*5((0(17 )25 25$&/( 6 '$7$%$6( 7+( 5(6(//(5 $*5((0(17 :+(5( 6$3 /,&(16(6 25$&/( 6 '$7$%$6( )25 86( ,1 6(//,1* $/21* :,7+ 6$3 6 $33/,&$7,216" $ , ',' 4 $1' &28/' <28 '(6&5,%( 72 86 <285 81'(567$1',1* 2) +2: 7+$7 :25.6 $1' :+(7+(5 7+$7 :+$7 6,*1,),&$1&( 7+$7 +$6 +(5( ,) 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 9 - November 16, 2010
SHEET 8

&/$5.( ',5(&7 0,77(/67$('7 $1<" $ :(// , '21 7 ,7 6 $ 9(5< 6,*1,),&$17 '2&80(17 , '21 7 7+,1. ,7 3529(6 $ 3$57,&8/$5 180%(5 %87 ,7 '2(6 3529( $1 ,'($ $1' 25$&/( $1' 6$3 $5( $5&+ &203(7,7256 ,1 7+( 0$5.(73/$&( %87 6$3 6 352'8&7 )25 0$1< &203$1,(6 )25 0$1< 2) 6$3 6 &86720(56 7+(< 581 ,7 21 $1 25$&/( '$7$%$6( 62 25$&/( , %(/,(9( 6$3 6 25$&/( 6 %,**(67 &86720(5 :+,&+ ,6 5($//< .,1' 2) ,17(5(67,1* %87 25$&/( &+$5*(6 6$3 $ /,&(16( )(( )25 6(//,1* 7+$7 62)7:$5( $1' ,7 6 $ 5811,1* 52<$/7< 62 :( 9( *27 $/0267 ,'(17,&$/ 6,78$7,216 72 :+$7 :( +$9( ,1 7+,6 &$6( :( +$9( $ $1 $*5((0(17 %(7:((1 7:2 5,9$/6 $1' $ 5811,1* 52<$/7< $1' , , 7+,1. 7+$7 ,6 ,7 6 7+( &/26(67 7+,1* :( 9( *27 72 +$9,1* 620( ,1',&$7,21 7+$7 $ 5811,1* 52<$/7< %(7:((1 7+(6( 3$57,&8/$5 3$57,(6 :28/' +$9( %((1 7+( :$< 7+(< :28/' *2 7+(< :28/' ),1' 7+$7 $1 $&&(37$%/( :$< 72 *2 4 )$&725 ,6 5(/$7,216+,36 7(// 86 :+$7 7+$7 ,6 $1' :+$7 ())(&7 7+$7 +$6 +(5( $ , +,17(' $7 7+,6 $ /,77/( ($5/,(5 7+( 5(/$7,216+,3 %(7:((1 7+(6( 7+(6( 3$57,(6 ,6 0257$/ (1(0,(6 62 , , 86( 7+$7 72 ,1&5($6( 7+( 52<$/7< 5$7( , :$17(' 72 5()/(&7 $ 9(5< +,*+ 5$7( %(&$86( 2) 7+$7 5(/$7,216+,3 4 )$&7256 ,6 5(/$7(' 6$/(6 :+$7 '2(6 7+$7 0($1 $1' $1' +2: ',' 7+$7 :25. +(5(" $ 5(/$7(' 6$/(6 $5( 620(7,0(6 &$//(' &2192<(' 6$/(6 :+(5( <28 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&/$5.( ',5(&7 0,77(/67$('7 ',' <28 (9$/8$7( 7+$7" $ , ',' 4 $1' :( +$9( $ 6/,'( 21 7+$7 :+,&+ ,6 6/,'( 3/($6( '(021675$7,9( 38%/,6+(' 72 7+( -85< %< 05 0,77(/67$('7 4 7+,6 6/,'( 1(('6 620( (;3/$1$7,21 62 ,) <28 :28/' :$/. 86 7+528*+ ,7 3/($6( $ 7+,6 ,6 21( 8*/< 6/,'( %87 05 %2,(6 <285 +2125 :( +$9( $1 2%-(&7,21 72 7+( 6/,'( $1' :( 28*+7 72 7$.( ,7 '2:1 %(<21' 7+( :,71(66 6 (;3(57,6( 7+,6 '2(6 127 5(/$7( 72 7+( $5($6 ,1 :+,&+ +( 6 48$/,),(' $6 $1 (;3(57 7+( &2857 5(63216(" 05 0,77(/67$('7 7+,6 *2(6 72 7+( +<327+(7,&$/ /,&(16( ,7 6 21( 2) 7+( *(25*,$ 3$&,),& )$&7256 $1' 7+,6 ,1)250$7,21 +$6 %((1 &203,/(' %< 7+( :,71(66 )520 7+( 7<3( 2) 0$7(5,$/6 (;3(576 5(/< 21 ,7 6 $ '(021675$7,9( $6 :(// 05 %2,(6 ,7 '2(6 *2 72 7+( *(25*,$ 3$&,),& )$&7256 %87 7+( :$< +( &203,/(' ,7 :$6 %< $66(66,1* 7+(6( 7+,5' 3$57< 3529,'(56 $1' 7+$7 ,6 %(<21' +,6 (;3(57,6( $// +( ,6 '2,1* ,6 :+$7 7+( /$: 35(&/8'(6 +,0 )520 '2,1* :+,&+ ,6 6800$5,=,1* $ 9$5,(7< 2) ,1)250$7,21 7+$7 6 %(<21' +,6 (;3(57,6( $1' ,7 6 +($56$< 7+( &2857 , 0 *2,1* 72 $//2: ,7 29(558/(' '(021675$7,9( 38%/,6+(' 72 7+( -85< 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&/$5.( ',5(&7 0,77(/67$('7 6(// 21( 352'8&7 $1' %(&$86( <28 9( 62/' 7+$7 <28 6(// $127+(5 352'8&7 $1' 6(//,1* $ 3,(&( 2) 62)7:$5( 68&+ $6 $7 ,668( ,1 7+,6 &$6( +$6 $ 5(/$7(' 6$/( 72 ,7 ,) <28 6(// 7+( 62)7:$5( <28 868$//< *(7 7+( 6833257 $1' 0$,17(1$1&( $*5((0(17 72 *2 $/21* :,7+ ,7 62 7+( 0$,17(1$1&( $*5((0(17 ,6 ,6 $ 5(/$7(' 6$/( 4 12: $6 <28 /22.(' $7 7+,6 $1' $1$/<=(' ,7 :(5( 7+(5( $1< ,1',5(&7 %(1(),76 72 6$3 )520 7+,6 /,&(16(" $ 7+(5( :(5( 620( %(1(),76 $7 /($67 7+(< 7+28*+7 7+(5( :(5( *2,1* 72 %( 620( , 0 127 685( 7+(5( :(5( $&78$//< $1< $6 $ 0$77(5 2) )$&7 %87 7+(< 7+28*+7 7+(5( :(5( *2,1* 72 %( %(1(),76 %(&$86( 7202552:12: :28/' $//2: 7+(6( &203$1,(6 72 (67$%/,6+ $ 5(/$7,216+,3 :,7+ $1 6$3 23(5$7,21 $1' 7+(1 7+(< :28/' %( $%/( 7+(< 7+28*+7 72 *2 ,1 $1' 675(1*7+(1 7+$7 5(/$7,216+,3 $1' 68%6(48(17/< 6(// 7+(0 620( 62)7:$5( $1' 0$<%( *(7 7+(0 72 6:,7&+ )520 25$&/( 72 6$3 4 $1' ,) ,7 :25.(' 287 /,.( 7+$7 )25 $1< 3$57,&8/$5 &86720(5 +2: '2(6 <285 5811,1* 52<$/7< $&&2817 )25 7+$7" $ :( :( &$/&8/$7( 7+( 5811,1* 52<$/7< %$6(' 8321 7+( &86720(56 7+$7 7+$7 0,*5$7(' 7+(,5 6<67(06 72 6$3 $6 $ 5(68/7 2) 25 $775,%87$%/( 72 7+( 7+( &23<5,*+7 ,1)5,1*(0(17 , &$/&8/$7( 7+( 52<$/7< 21 7+26( 4 62 3877,1* $// 7+26( $&78$//< /(7 0( $6. <28 $%287 21( 025( /(7 6 *2 72 12 7+( %(1(),7 2) 7+( 68%-(&7 ,3 $1' $/7(51$7,9(6 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&/$5.( ',5(&7 0,77(/67$('7 %< 05 0,77(/67$('7 4 12: &28/' <28 -867 :$/. 86 7+528*+ ,7 3/($6( $1' , 6+28/' 6$< 7+( 7+( 3257,21 7+$7 ,6 ',)),&8/7 72 6(( ,6 -' (':$5'6 :( 9( 3(5+$36 6+28/' +$9( 3,&.(' $ ',))(5(17 &2/25 $ <(6 :( 6+28/' +$9( :( 75,(' $%287 7(1 ',))(5(17 &2/256 %87 7+(6( $5( 352%$%/< 7+( :2567 7+( *5((1 %,76 7+( *5((1< .+$., &2/25(' 678)) ,6 -' (':$5'6 7+( 3853/( ,6 3(23/(62)7 $1' :+$7 7+,6 ,6 75<,1* 72 6+2: ,6 $ 7,0( /,1( 2) 7+( &203$1,(6 7+$7 :(5( 2))(5,1* 7+,5' 3$57< 6833257 ,1 $1< 3$57,&8/$5 <($5 62 ,) <28 /22. 21 7+( /()7 +$1' 6,'( 2) $1< 2) 7+26( 52:6 7+$7 ,6 :+(1 7+$7 &86720(5 2+ %(* <285 3$5'21 7+$7 9(1'25 &$0( ,172 7+( 0$5.(73/$&( $1' 62 :( +$9( 7+( 7202552:12: 75$16$&7,21 7+(5( $7 7+( %(*,11,1* 2) 62 <28 &$1 6(( $7 7+( %(*,11,1* 2) 7+(5( 5($//< :(5(1 7 7+$7 0$1< $/7(51$7,9(6 ,1 7+,5' 3$57< 9(1'256 4 7+$1. <28 $ 5,*+7 +(5( ,1',&$7,1* 7+(5( :(5( 127 9(5< 0$1< $/7(51$7,9(6 ,1 7+( 7+,5' 3$57< 0$5.(7 %87 29(5 7,0( 0$1< 27+(5 &203$1,(6 -2,1(' ,1 $1' 7+(< 2))(5(' 6(59,&( )25 -' (':$5'6 7+$7 6 :+$7 7+(6( *5((1 21(6 $5( +(5( $1' 7+( 5($621 ./(( 67236 5,*+7 7+(5( ,6 7+(< :(17 287 2) %86,1(66 $7 7+$7 32,17 7+( 27+(56 $5( $// 67,// ,1 %86,1(66 %87 7+( ,03257$17 7+,1* ,6 7+,6 3,(&( '2:1 +(5( $1' 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 9 - November 16, 2010
&/$5.( ',5(&7 0,77(/67$('7 7+,6 ,6 :+< 7+,6 $552: *2(6 2)) 21 7+( /()7 +$1' 6,'( ,1',&$7,1* 7+(6( $5( $// $/7(51$7,9( :$<6 &203$1,(6 &$1 '2 :+$7 7+(< :(5( '2,1* :,7+ 7+(,5 25$&/( 62)7:$5( 62 7+( $/7(51$7,9(6 :(5( 127 -867 7+,5' 3$57< 9(1'256 7+(5( :(5( 0$1< 27+(5 :$<6 $1' <28 21 +(5( ,1 )$&7 ,7 6 ,7 6 0,66,1* ,6 6+28/' %( 6(/) 6833257 62 &86720(56 &28/' *2 21 6(/) 6833257 7+(< -867 +,5( 7+(,5 2:1 3(23/( $1' /22. $)7(5 7+(,5 2:1 6<67(06 62 7+$7 6+28/' %( 21 7+,6 /,67 $1' ,7 6 2) &2856( $/:$<6 $9$,/$%/( 72 7+(6( &203$1,(6 72 7+(6( &86720(56 $1' 7+(1 7+(6( $5( $// 7+(6( *8<6 29(5 +(5( ,1',&$7,1* 7+(6( $5( 3(23/( :+2 6$< 0$1$*( 3$<52// 62 21( 2) 7+( 7+,1*6 7+$7 $ 3(23/(62)7 7<3( 86(5 0,*+7 86( 0,*+7 86( $ 62)7:$5( )25 ,6 72 352'8&( $ 3$<52// :(// <28 &$1 *2 72 $'3 )25 3$<52// $1' +80$1 5(6285&( 0$1$*(0(17 6(59,&(6 7+(1 <28 '21 7 1((' $ &20387(5 6<67(0 $7 $// <28 -867 6(1' 7+(0 $ 3,(&( 2) 3$3(5 $1' 7+(< ,1387 7+( '$7$ $1' 352'8&( 7+( &+(&.6 7+$7 6 758( 2) $// 2) 7+26( $&&(1785( '(/2,77( $1' 62 21 7+26( $5( %,* :+$7 :( &$// 6<67(06 ,17(*5$7256 7+(6( $5( +8*( &203$1,(6 $1' 7+,6 ,6 :+$7 7+(< '2 7+(< +(/3 &203$1,(6 ,167$// 6<67(06 6(/(&7 7+( 6<67(06 75$,1 3(23/( '2 &2168/7,1* )25 7+(0 :+(1 ,7 *2(6 :521* $1' 62 21 $1' 7+(1 ,17(5(67,1*/< :$< 29(5 (;&86( 0( 0< 32,17(5 6((06 72 +$9( 67233(' 32,17,1* :$< 29(5 +(5( ,1',&$7,1* <28 9( *27 &203$1,(6 7+$7 6(// 62)7:$5( 7+$7 '2(6 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55 &/$5.( ',5(&7 0,77(/67$('7 21 7+( /()7 +$1' 6,'( +(5( :( +$9( 7+( <($56 7+( 5(9(18( ,6 ,1 7+,6 &2/801 7+,6 :$6 7+( 727$/ 5(9(18( :$61 7 $&78$//< 7+(,5 $&78$/ 5(9(18( , 0$'( 620( $'-8670(176 72 ,7 , ,1&5($6(' 7+( 5(9(18(6 %(&$86( 6$3 :$6 *(77,1* 7+(0 72 '2 ',6&28176 )25 620( &86720(56 62 ,) 7+(< ',6&2817(' ,7 +($9,/< , $''(' %$&. :+$7 7+(< 5($//< 6+28/' +$9( &+$5*(' &$86( , )(/7 7+$7 :$6 .,1' 2) /,.( $ /266 /($'(5 23(5$7,21 )25 6$3 $1' 7+(1 21 7+( 52<$/7< &2/801 7+( &2/801 29(5 21 7+( 5,*+7 , 6,03/< 722. +$/) 2) 7+,6 7+( 3(5&(17 $1' &$/&8/$7(' 7+$7 52<$/7< $1' 7+(1 %(&$86( 7+( 52<$/7,(6 :28/' +$9( 25 6+28/' +$9( %((1 3$,' ,1 7+26( ($5/,(5 <($56 :+$7 , ',' :$6 , $''(' ,17(5(67 72 *(7 ,7 72 7+( '$7( 2) 75,$/ 62 7+$7 ,1 :28/' +$9( *52:1 72 620(7+,1* 025( 7+$1 7+$7 %< 7+( %< 7+( '$7( 2) 75,$/ $1' 62 , (67,0$7(' 7+( '$7( 2) 75,$/ )25 7+( 7+ 2) '(&(0%(5 $&78$//< 62 :( 0,*+7 *(7 /8&.< $1' ),1,6+ %()25( 7+$7 $1' 7+$7 6 7+$7 ,17(5(67 &$/&8/$7,21 7+(5( 7+( 0,//,21 $1' $'' 7+26( 7:2 72*(7+(5 $1' 7+( 727$/ ,6 0,//,21 4 2.$< $1' 7+$7 6 )25 7202552:12: /(7 6 7851 72 6$3 7+$7 6 7+( 1(;7 6/,'( '(021675$7,9( 38%/,6+(' 72 7+( -85< %< 05 3,&.(77 4 $1' :28/' <28 7(// 86 +2: <28 &$/&8/$7(' 7+( 5($621$%/( 52<$/7< )520 7+,6 +<327+(7,&$/ 1(*27,$7,21 21 7+( 6$3 6,'(" $ <(6 $*$,1 86,1* 7+( *(25*,$ 3$&,),& )$&7256 , &$0( 83 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&/$5.( ',5(&7 0,77(/67$('7 7+( 6$0( 7+,1* 62 :( 6$: &203$1,(6 7+$7 86(' 72 %( 21 3(23/(62)7 $1' :+$7 7+(< ',' :$6 7+(< 6,03/< &/26(' 7+$7 '2:1 $1' :(17 72 *5($7 /$.(6 )25 $&&2817,1* 7+(< 0$< +$9( *21( 72 0,&5262)7 )25 (53 7+$7 6 $127+(5 9(1'25 08&+ &+($3(5 127 62 &$3$%/( %87 )25 &203$1,(6 7+$7 :(5( 5($//< 6758**/,1* 72 3$< 7+( 25$&/( 0$,17(1$1&( )(( $ 9,$%/( 237,21 62 7+$7 $// 7+(6( :$<6 7+$7 7+(6( &86720(56 &28/' +$9( $&+,(9(' :+$7 7+(< +$' 72 '2 72 .((3 7+(,5 %86,1(66 *2,1* :,7+287 86,1* 25$&/( $1' 7+$7 6 9(5< 9(5< ,03257$17 4 2.$< 3877,1* $// 7+26( *(25*,$ 3$&,),& )$&7256 72*(7+(5 <28 &$0( 83 :,7+ $ 52<$/7< )25 7202552:12: &255(&7" $ &255(&7 4 $1' 7+$7 6 3(5&(17 2) 7202552:12: 6 5(9(18(6 $ &255(&7 4 5(9(18(6 21 :+$7 %$6(" $ , , ',' 7+( 52<$/7< 21 $// 2) 7+(,5 5(9(18(6 )25 7202552:12: 4 2.$< $ , 722. (9(5< 6,1*/( '2//$5 $1' &$/&8/$7(' 7+( 52<$/7< 21 7+$7 4 2.$< $1' /(7 6 /22. $7 6/,'( '(021675$7,9( 38%/,6+(' 72 7+( -85< %< 05 0,77(/67$('7 4 :+$7 '2(6 7+,6 6+2:" $ 7+,6 6+2:6 7+( 7202552:12: 5(9(18( %< <($5 $1' <28 &$1 6(( 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&/$5.( ',5(&7 0,77(/67$('7 :,7+ $ 3(5&(17 2) 352),7 5$7( :+,&+ ,6 $ 9(5< +,*+ 5$7( $1' , ',' $ '(7$,/(' $1$/<6,6 2) 7+( &86720(5 %(+$9,25 $1' )281' 7+$7 2) 7+( &86720(56 +$' *21( 72 6$3 )25 27+(5 5($6216 62 7+(5( $5( 21/< )285 5(0$,1,1* &86720(56 $1' , )281' 7+( 5(9(18( )520 6$3 6 ),1$1&,$/ ,1)250$7,21 )25 7+26( &86720(56 , &$/&8/$7(' 7+( 352),7 , +$' ,1)250$7,21 5(/$7(' 72 7+( &203$1< 6 &2676 62 , 68%&2175$&7(' 7+( &2676 )520 7+( 5(9(18(6 7+$7 *$9( 0( 7+( 352),7 $1' 7+(1 , 722. 3(5&(17 2) 7+$7 352),7 3(5&(17 2) 7+$7 ,6 7+$7 ,1',&$7,1* $''(' 7+( 83 &$0( 72 0,//,21 4 2.$< 12: 72 :5$3 83 7+( +<327+(7,&$/ /,&(16( 3$57 2) 7+,6 /(7 0( $6. <28 -867 ),1$//< )25 <285 5(63216( 72 620( 2) 05 0(<(5 6 &5,7,&,60 :+(1 +( :$6 7$/.,1* $%287 :+< ,1 +,6 9,(: $// 7+( 021(< 6+28/' %( 3$,' 83 )5217 $1' ,7 6+28/' %( $ /$5*(5 $02817 +( 6$,' $7 3$*( 6$3 :$6 $:$5( 7+$7 %$6,&$//< 25$&/( 3$,' 83)5217 ,1 <285 9,(: ,6 7+$7 $ -867,),&$7,21 72 +$9( $ 3$,' 83)5217 /,&(16( 5$7+(5 7+$1 $ 5811,1* 52<$/7<" $ 12 7+$7 :28/'1 7 0$.( $1< 6(16( )25 $// 2) 7+( 5($6216 7+$7 , '(6&5,%(' 72 <28 /$7( ($5/,(5 25$&/( $1' 6$3 :28/' +$9( %((1 7$.,1* $ +8*( 5,6. ,) 7+(< ' '21( 7+$7 $1' <28 +$9( 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 9 - November 16, 2010
&/$5.( ',5(&7 0,77(/67$('7 4 '2 <28 +$9( $ 9,(: %$6(' 21 <285 5(9,(: 2) 7+,6 5(&25' $1' <285 $1$/<6,6 2) :+(7+(5 '2,1* 7+( /803 680 $3352$&+ $1' 75<,1* 72 ),*85( 287 :+$7 7+(6( 3$57,(6 25 5($621$%/( 3$57,(6 ,1 7+,6 6,78$7,21 :28/' $*5(( 72 21 $ /803 680 %$6,6 :+(7+(5 7+$7 :28/' 5(48,5( $ /27 2) 63(&8/$7,21" $ :(// 7+(< %27+ 3$57,(6 ,) 7+(< ',' $ /803 680 :28/' %( 63(&8/$7,1* 21 :+$7 :$6 *2,1* 72 +$33(1 /$7(5 ,) :+$7 :$6 *2,1* 72 +$33(1 /$7(5 :$6 7,1< 7+(1 7+(< 0,*+7 +$9( '21( $ /803 680 %87 ,7 :28/' +$9( %((1 )25 $ )(: +81'5(' '2//$56 25 $ )(: 7+286$1' '2//$56 %87 $6 <28 +($5' 25$&/( 0$< :(// +$9( 7+28*+7 7+$7 7+,6 :28/' %( $ 68%67$17,$/ 352%/(0 )25 7+(0 7+(< ','1 7 .12: +2: 0$1< &86720(56 7+(< 0,*+7 /26( $1' 7+(< :28/'1 7 :$17 72 *(7 7+$7 :521* 6$3 21 7+( 27+(5 +$1' ,6 $ 1(: 23(5$7,21 7+(< 9( -867 7$.(1 29(5 7+,6 &203$1< ,7 6 5($//< $1 $3352$&+ 7+$7 6 1(9(5 %((1 '21( %()25( 7+(< :28/'1 7 :$17 72 0$.( $ 0,67$.( (,7+(5 7+( 21/< :$< 72 *(7 7+$7 5,6. 287 2) 7+(5( ,6 $ 5811,1* 52<$/7< 4 +2: :28/' <28 &203$5( 7+( $02817 2) 63(&8/$7,21 7+$7 :28/' %( 5(48,5(' 72 &20( 72 620( /803 680 $3352$&+ +(5( :,7+ 7+( 27+(5 &$6(6 7+$7 <28 +$9( 6((1 :+(5( 7+(5( $5( &203$5$%/( /,&(16(6 7+$7 &$1 %( 86(' $6 $ %$6,6 )25 $1 83)5217 3$<0(17" $ :(// ,) :( +$9( &203$5$%/( /,&(16(6 7+,6 ,6 /,.( <28 0$< +$9( +($5' $1 $335$,6(5 ,) <28 9( (9(5 %28*+7 $1' 62/' $ 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55 &/$5.( ',5(&7 0,77(/67$('7 7+( 21/< 7+,1* 7+$7 0,*+7 %( ,192/9(' +(5( :28/' %( 620( &' 6 %87 7+( &' 6 $5( :257+ $ %8&. ,7 6 :+$7 6 21 7+( &' 7+$7 0$77(56 $1' $ /27 2) 7+,6 ,6 '2:1/2$'(' 29(5 7+( ,17(51(7 62 <28 '21 7 (9(1 *(7 $ &' ,7 6 7+$7 ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< :+,&+ ,6 $6 $/0267 $6 ,17$1*,%/( $6 <28 &$1 *(7 7+$7 :( 5( 75<,1* 72 9$/8( 62 7+$7 67$7(0(17 :$6 -867 &203/(7(/< %$))/,1* 72 0( 4 2.$< /(7 6 029( 21 12: 72 7+( '$7$%$6( 52<$/7< $1' 7+,6 7+,6 ,6 025( &203/,&$7(' $7 /($67 )25 0( 62 &$1 :( 67$57 2)) :,7+ <28 '(6&5,%,1* :+,&+ :$< ,6 ($6,(5" 72 '(6&5,%( +2: <28 ',' ,7 25 '(6&5,%( +2: 05 0(<(5 ',' ,7 :+(5( :28/' <28 /,.( 72 67$57" $ /(7 6 67$57 :,7+ +2: +( ',' ,7 4 2.$< +2: ',' +( '2 ,7" $ , .1(: <28 :(5( *2,1* 72 $6. 0( 7+$7 7+( :$< +( ',' ,7 :$6 +( &$/&8/$7(' $ 180%(5 2) 4 $&78$//< /(7 0( /(7 0( -867 7$.( 86 %$&. $ 67(3 7+( '$7$%$6( 52<$/7< :+$7 $5( :( 7$/.,1* $%287" $ 7+( 25$&/( '$7$%$6( ,6 $ ,6 $ ,7 6 $ '$7$%$6( ,7 6 $ 352*5$0 7+$7 &203$1,(6 86( 72 0$1$*( ,1)250$7,21 ,7 ,7 6 $%/( 72 6725( ,1)250$7,21 $1' 7+(1 *,9( $&&(66 72 7+$7 ,1)250$7,21 $1' $//2:6 ,7 72 %( 0$1,38/$7(' ,1 &(57$,1 :$<6 62 ,7 6 , 7+,1. 620(21( ,1 7+( &$6( 6$,' ,7 :$6 *5281'%5($.,1* $7 7+( 7,0( ,7 &$0( 83 62 ,7 6 $ 6,*1,),&$17 3,(&( 2) :25. 7+(5( $5( 0$1< 27+(5 '$7$%$6(6 287 7+(5( ,%0 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&/$5.( ',5(&7 0,77(/67$('7 +286( 7+( $335$,6(5 &20(6 287 $1' 6$<6 :(// :( 9( /22.(' $7 7+( &2036 ,1 <285 1(,*+%25+22' $1' 7+( :$< 7+(< 9$/8( <285 +286( ,6 7+(< /22. $7 7+( 27+(56 7+$7 $5( /,.( ,7 $1' 7+(< 6$< :( 7+,1. %$6(' 21 7+$7 <285 +286( :,// 6(// )25 7+,6 08&+ ,) 7+(5( :(5( &203$5$%/( /,&(16(6 +(5( :( :28/' +$9( 86(' 7+(0 , ','1 7 ),1' $1< &203$5$%/( /,&(16(6 72 7+,6 3$57,&8/$5 6&23( 2) ,1)5,1*(0(17 62 7+( /,&(16( :( 5( 7$/.,1* $%287 :,7+ /,0,7(' '85$7,21 /,0,7(' *(2*5$3+< /,0,7(' $%,/,7< 72 6(// $1' %8< $1' $0(1' 7+( 62)7:$5( ,6 7+$7 7+$7 :28/' %( 620(7+,1* 7+$7 7+(< :28/' 127 :$17 72 '($/ :,7+ 7+(< :28/' 7+(< ' :$17 7+( 5811,1* 52<$/7< 72 '2 7+$7 $1' , 7+,1. :( 9( *21( 29(5 5811,1* 52<$/7< 72 '($7+ 12: 4 2.$< 7+(1 21( /$67 48(67,21 $1' :( // 029( 21 :( 5( *2,1* 72 029( 21 72 '$7$%$6( 7+28*+ 62 %( &$5()8/ :+$7 <28 $6. )25 %87 /$67 7+,1* 3$*( 05 0(<(5 6$<6 7+$7 6 7+( 5($/ 3523(57< 7+$7 , 0 9$/8,1* ,7 6 127 620(7+,1* ,7 6 127 (9(1 ,17$1*,%/( ,7 6 5($/ 3523(57< 7+$7 :$6 7$.(1 :+$7 6 <285 9,(: 2) 7+$7" $ 5($/ 3523(57< ,6 7+,1*6 /,.( %5,&.6 $1' 0257$5 62 0$<%( +( :$6 -867 0($1,1* ,7 :$6 $ 7+,1* ,167($' 2) %5,&.6 $1' 0257$5 62 +( 6 86,1* 7+( 7(50 ,1$335235,$7(/< %87 /(7 6 $6680( +( -867 0($16 ,7 6 $ 7+,1* ,7 :$61 7 $ 7+,1* 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&/$5.( ',5(&7 0,77(/67$('7 +$6 ,76 2:1 0,&5262)7 +$6 ,76 2:1 4 +2: /(7 0( ,17(55837 +2: ',' 7202552:12: 86( 7+( 25$&/( '$7$%$6(" $ 7+(< 86(' ,7 )25 620( 2) 7+( &86720(56 62 127 $// 2) 7+( 2) 7+( 7202552:12: &86720(56 5$1 21 &203/(7(/< '$7$%$6(6 620( 5$1 21 7+(6( 27+(5 '$7$%$6(6 7+$7 7+(< +$' %28*+7 62 7+( /,&(16( 7+$7 :( 5( 7$/.,1* $%287 :,7+ '$7$%$6( 6+28/' 21/< $33/< 72 7+( $&78$/ 86( 7+$7 7202552:12: 0$'( 2) 2) 7+( 25$&/( '$7$%$6( 4 2.$< $1' 7202552:12: %$6,&$//< 86(' 7+( 25$&/( '$7$%$6( 72 +(/3 3529,'( 6(59,&( 72 &86720(56 7+$7 +$' 3(23/(62)7 62)7:$5( 5811,1* 21 $1 25$&/( '$7$%$6(" $ &255(&7 4 2.$< $1' +2: ',' 05 0(<(5 &$/&8/$7( +2: 08&+ 7202552:12: :28/' 2:( )25 7+( /,&(16( )25 7+( '$7$%$6( 72 86( ,7 7+( :$< ,7 86(' ,7 ,) ,7 +$'1 7 ,1)5,1*('" $ :(// +( +( 5(&2*1,=(' , 7+,1. ,7 6 (19,5210(176 &86720(56 $1 (19,5210(17 ,6 -867 620( 62)7:$5( $1' 7+( ,1)250$7,21 7+$7 7+$7 &86720(5 ,6 ,6 0$1$*,1* $1' 7+(5( :(5( 2) 7+26( 7+$7 :(5( 25$&/( '$7$%$6(6 $1' 7+(1 +( $''(' 7+,1*6 )25 &5266 86( $1' 27+(5 385326(6 72 *(7 83 72 62 :+$7(9(5 +( :$6 *2,1* 72 '2 +( :$6 *2,1* 72 08/7,3/< %< 7+(1 +( /22.(' $7 7+( 180%(5 2) 352&(66(6 $1' &25(6 7+$7 7202552:12: +$' $1' ',' 620( 0$7+ 21 7+$7 $1' +( 6$,' 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 9 - November 16, 2010
SHEET 10

&/$5.( ',5(&7 0,77(/67$('7 7+$7 7202552:12: :28/' 1((' $ $ /,&(16( ,7 6 &$//(' $1 (17(535,6( (',7,21 /,&(16( )25 25$&/( 6 '$7$%$6( 72 581 21 ($&+ 2) 7+26( 352&(66(6 62 7+$7 *,9(6 $127+(5 08/7,3/( $1' $1' 7+(1 7+(5( 6 0$,17(1$1&( 72 %( 3$,' )25 21 7+$7 '$7$%$6( $1' 62 +( $''(' 7,0(6 7+( &267 2) 7+( '$7$ 7+( 0$,17(1$1&( )25 +2:(9(5 /21* 7+(< 1(('(' 7+$7 :+,&+ ,6 620(:+(5( $5281' 7+( 7+5(( 72 )285 <($5 3(5,2' 4 62 ,1 6800$5< +( 6$<6 7202552:12: :28/' 1((' $ ',))(5(17 '$7$%$6( $ 1(: '$7$%$6( /,&(16( )25 ($&+ 2) 7+( (19,5210(176 $1' ,7 :28/' $&78$//< 1((' ,7 )25 7+( 6,; &25( 352&(66256 86(' )25 ($&+ 2) 7+26( &86720(56 $ <(6 +( +( $&78$//< &2817(' 7+( 6,; ,6 %$6(' 8321 $1 $9(5$*( +( &$//(' ,7 $1 $9(5$*( 127 $&78$//< $1 $9(5$*( 7+( $9(5$*( ,6 025( /,.( )285 %87 +( &$//(' ,7 $1 $9(5$*( 6758&785( )25 7+( &20387(5 $1' 6$,' 7+$7 6 $ 6,; &25( &20387(5 $1' <28 1((' <28 1((' 7+( (17(535,6( (',7,21 )25 ($&+ &86720(5 )25 ($&+ &20387(5 $1' 7+$7 6 $ 68%67$17,$/ ',))(5(1&( %(7:((1 +( $1' , 21 7+,6 3$57,&8/$5 $5($ 4 2.$< $1' /(7 6 /22. $7 +2: <28 ',' ,7 $1' :( +$9( 6/,'( ,7 :,// +(/3 :$/. 7+528*+ 7+,6 '(021675$7,9( 38%/,6+(' 72 7+( -85< %< 05 0,77(/67$('7 4 2.$< ,) <28 &28/' 86( 7+,6 72 '(6&5,%( +2: ,1 <285 9,(: $ 5($621$%/( 52<$/7< )25 7+( '$7$%$6( /,&(16( 6+28/' %( (67$%/,6+(' 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&/$5.( ',5(&7 0,77(/67$('7 *2 21 72 7+(,5 :(%6,7( <28 &$1 6(( :+$7 7+(< 6(// $1' 7+(6( $5( 7+( )$&7256 7+$7 $33/< 72 7+,6 7<3( 2) (48,30(17 62 ,7 6 ,7 6 $ ',))(5(17 )(( '(3(1',1* 21 +2: ',))(5(17 )$&725 '(3(1',1* 21 7+( 1$785( 2) 7+( (48,30(17 $1' , , 0 35(77< 685( 05 0(<(5 $'237(' 7+( 3(5&(17 , '21 7 7+,1. +( $'237(' 7+( 3(5&(17 , '21 7 7+,1. , 7+,1. +( ,*125(' 7+(6( &20387(56 $1' 7+,6 3(5&(17 $1' +( :(17 :,7+ (66(17,$//< &25(6 :+,&+ +( *27 )520 7+(1 08/7,3/,(' %< 7+( 3(5&(17 62 ,) <28 '2 7+$7 0$7+ 7+(5( $5( $&78$//< &25(6 7+$7 6 :+$7 7+$7 6 :+$7 7202552:12: $&78$//< 86(' $1' +2: 7+(< :28/' +$9( %((1 35,&(' %< 25$&/( 127 21 7+( 3(5 '2//$5 <(7 %87 3(5 &25( $1<:$< 7+(5( :(5( 2) 7+(0 4 $1' 7+(1 :+$7 6 7+( 1(;7 67(3 ,1 <285 &$/&8/$7,21 2) 7+( 52<$/7< )25 7+( '$7$%$6(" $ 7+( 1(;7 67(3 ,6 72 /22. $7 7+( &267 7+$7 25$&/( &+$5*(6 )25 $ '$7$%$6( $1' , $6680( $1 (17(535,6( (',7,21 :+,&+ ,6 62 7+$7 <28 :28/' 1((' , 0 6255< 4 $&78$//< /(7 0( *2 21 72 6/,'( :+,&+ :,// +(/3 (;3/$,1 ,7 '(021675$7,9( 38%/,6+(' 72 7+( -85< 7+( :,71(66 2.$< 62 7+( /,&(16( )(( )25 25$&/( 6 '$7$%$6( ,6 $1' ,7 6 )25 ($&+ 352&(6625 62 7+(5( $5( 352&(66256 7+(1 7+( 0$,17(1$1&( ,6 $ <($5 )25 ($&+ 352&(6625 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&/$5.( ',5(&7 0,77(/67$('7 $ <(6 21 7+( /()7 +(5( 7+(< 5( 127 7(55,%/< *22' 5(35(6(17$7,216 %87 7+(6( $5( $&78$//< &20387(56 ,1',&$7,1* $1' 6(59(56 $1' ,16,'( 7+( &20387(5 :( +$9( 352&(66256 $1' ($&+ 7+,6 21( +$6 )285 352&(66256 $1' ($&+ 352&(6625 ,6 $ '8$/ &25( 62 7+( 727$/ 180%(5 2) &25(6 ,1 7+$7 &20387(5 ,6 (,*+7 $1' 7+,6 ,6 :+$7 7202552:12: $&78$//< +$' $1' 7+(1 7+(< +$' $127+(5 &20387(5 7+$7 +$' (,*+7 &25(6 ,1 ,7 $6 :(// 7+( :$< 25$&/( /,&(16(6 7+( 7+( '$7$%$6( ,6 <28 '21 7 3$< )25 (9(5< &25( 7+(5( 6 $ )$&725 $1' ,1 7+,6 )25 7+,6 3$57,&8/$5 7<3( 2) (48,30(17 7+$7 )$&725 :$6 3(5&(17 62 <28 7$.( 3(5&(17 2) $1' <28 *(7 $1' ,) <28 '2 7+( 0$7+ 2) 3(5&(17 2) 7+(6( &25(6 <28 *(7 7+,6 0$1< &25(6 $1' 7+(1 7+(< $/62 +$' 7+(6( &20387(56 '2:1 +(5( $1' 7+,6 :$6 $ '8$/ 352&(6625 '8$/ &25( 62 7+(5( $5( )285 2) 7+26( :( 9( *27 0$&+,1(6 /,.( 7+$7 21( :,7+ -867 21( 352&(6625 '8$/ &25( $1' 7+,6 21( +$' :+$7(9(5 7+$7 ,6 (,*+7 352&(66256 $1' 7+(< :(5( '8$/ &25( 62 %(&$86( 2) 7+( 7<3( 2) 0$&+,1(5< 7+$7 7+(< $5( 7+( 08/7,3/( )25 25$&/( )25 7+26( ,6 21/< 3(5&(17 62 7+$7 *,9(6 <28 7+,6 180%(5 2) &25(6 4 05 &/$5.( &$1 , ,17(55837 <28" :+(1 <28 6$< 7+( /,&(16,1* )$&725 )25 25$&/( $5( <28 7$/.,1* $%287 7+( /,&(16,1* )$&725 7+(< 5( $33/<,1* ,1 7+,6 &$6( 25 620(7+,1* ',))(5(17" $ 7+,6 ,6 :+$7 &20(6 2)) 7+( /,&(16( :+(1 <28 /22. :+(1 <28 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&/$5.( ',5(&7 0,77(/67$('7 $1' 25$&/( 0$.(6 $ $ 352),7 21 7+(6( '$7$%$6(6 2) 3(5&(17 62 <28 7$.( 08/7,3/,(' %< 7$.( 7,0(6 )25 ($&+ <($5 7+$7 7+(< :(5( 86,1* 7+$7 (48,30(17 $1' 7+(1 08/7,3/< %< 3(5&(17 $1' 7+( 9$/8( 2) 86( ,6 0,//,21 4 2.$< /(7 6 *2 72 7+( 1(;7 6/,'( $1' 6800$5,=( :+(5( :( $5( 21 7+( +<327+(7,&$/ /,&(16( '(021675$7,9( 38%/,6+(' 72 7+( -85< %< 05 0,77(/67$('7 4 :28/' <28 -867 :$/. 86 7+528*+ 7+,6 $1' 7+(1 :( // %( 5($'< 72 029( 21 72 /267 352),76 $ 7+,6 ,6 -867 $ 6800$5< 6/,'( 7+$7 7$.(6 7+( ,1)250$7,21 7+$7 :( 9( -867 *21( 29(5 7+( 7202552:12: 5($621$%/( 52<$/7< ,) <28 5(0(0%(5 :$6 0,//,21 7+( 6$3 5($621$%/( 52<$/7< :$6 0,//,21 $1' 7+( 25$&/( '$7$%$6( 52<$/7< :$6 0,//,21 $1' , 6+28/' 32,17 287 7+$7 21 7+( 25$&/( '$7$%$6( :( +$9( $ $1 (67$%/,6+(' 35,&( )25 7+,6 62 25$&/( '$7$%$6( ,61 7 5($//< %(,1* 35,&(' 7+528*+ *(25*,$ 3$&,),& ,7 6 %(,1* 35,&(' 7+528*+ /22.,1* $7 21 7+(,5 :(%6,7( <28 &$1 6(( 7+( 35,&( 7+$7 7+(< &+$5*( )25 $1 (17(535,6( (',7,21 $1' 7+$7 6 7+( 180%(5 , 387 ,1 +(5( 7+( 05 0,77(/67$('7 2.$< <285 +2125 7+,6 :28/' %( $ *22' 7,0( 72 %5($. 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 7+$1. <28 /$',(6 $1' *(17/(0(1 2) 7+( -85< <28 5( (;&86(' 7+(1 )25 0,187(6 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 9 - November 16, 2010
&/$5.( ',5(&7 05 0,77(/67$('7 6$: $1' ,7 352037(' $ /27 2) 27+(5 7+,1.,1* :+(1 , 6$: ,7 4 /(7 6 *2 72 6/,'( 6/,'( ',63/$<(' 21 6&5((1 ,6 7+,6 $ /,67 2) 7+( &86720(56 <28 (;&/8'(' %$6(' 21 (9$/8$7,1* &203(7,7256 /,.( /(;0$5." $ <(6 4 /(7 6 *2 72 6/,'( 6/,'( ',63/$<(' 21 6&5((1 7+,6 ,6 $/62 %$6(' 21 $ &800,16 ( 0$,/ 05 0,77(/67$('7 , 029( 7+( 81'(5/<,1* '2&80(17 $ ,172 (9,'(1&( 7+( &2857 $1< 2%-(&7,21" 05 %2,(6 0$< , +$9( 21( 020(17 <285 +2125" 3$86( ,1 7+( 352&((',1*6 05 %2,(6 12 2%-(&7,21 <285 +2125 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 $'0,77(' '()(1'$176 (;+,%,7 $ 5(&(,9(' ,1 (9,'(1&( %< 05 0,77(/67$('7 4 ,6 7+,6 $1 (;$03/( 2) <285 67$1'$5',=$7,21 %8&.(7" $ <(6 (;$&7/< 4 &28/' <28 -867 (;3/$,1 ,7 48,&./<" $ <(6 7+,6 +21(<:(// +$' %((1 $ 6$3 86(5 )25 $ :+,/( $1' +$' 25$&/( 6<67(06 ,1 +$/) 7+( &203$1< $1' +$' 0$'( $ '(&,6,21 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'& &/$5.( ',5(&7 05 0,77(/67$('7 %< 05 0,77(/67$('7 4 :( $5( $/0267 '21( :28/' <28 (;3/$,1 72 86 :+< <28 (;&/8'(' 7+,6 &86720(5" $ , :,// $%,7,%, ,6 $ 3$3(5 38/3 $1' 3$3(5 &203$1< 7+(5( :$6 $ 3/$1 )25 - ' (':$5'6 72 &5($7( 7+$7 )81&7,21$/,7< 7+( 62)7:$5( 63(&,),& 72 38/3 $1' 3$3(5 23(5$7,216 ,7 :$6 3520,6(' $6 <28 &$1 6(( - ' (':$5'6 &200,77(' %87 7+(< 1(9(5 ',' ,7 $1' 62 $%,7,%, :$6 &21&(51(' 7+$7 7+(< :(5( 5811,1* /21*(5 $1' /21*(5 21 7+,6 12163(&,),& 62)7:$5( ','1 7 '($/ :,7+ 38/3 $1' 3$3(5 23(5$7,216 $1' 7+$7 +( :$6 /22.,1* 72 38// $// 2) 7+$7 287 $1' *2 :,7+ 6$3 $*$,1 &28/' 127 %( 5(/$7(' 72 7202552:12: 4 2.$< 62 %$6(' 21 $// 7+,6 :25. $// 7+( 5(9,(: 2) 7+( &86720(5 ,1)250$7,21 $1' 3/$&,1* 7+( &86720(56 ,172 9$5,286 %8&.(76 (,7+(5 (;&/86,21 25 ,1&/86,21 <28 5($&+(' 620( &21&/86,216 $%287 7+( $02817 2) &203(16$7,21 6$3 2:(' 72 6$3 $1' 7202552:12: 2:(' 72 25$&/( 5,*+7" $ &255(&7 4 $1' /(7 6 /22. ),1$//< $7 7:2 6/,'(6 6/,'( 72 67$57 :,7+ 6/,'( ',63/$<(' 21 6&5((1 $6 <28 ',' )25 7+( /267 6833257 352),76 ,) <28 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

&/$5.( ',5(&7 05 0,77(/67$('7 72 67$1'$5',=( 7+,6 352&(66 :+(5( 7+(< *2 $// 21 72 21( 7<3( 2) 62)7:$5( 62 $*$,1 7+$7 '(&,6,21 ,6 ,1&5(',%/< (;3(16,9( )25 7+( &203$1< 9(5< ',)),&8/7 7,0( &21680,1* ',65837,9( $1' 7+(< :28/'1 7 0$.( 7+$7 '(&,6,21 :,7+287 6,03/< %(&$86( 2) 7202552:12: $1' 7+( ,1)5,1*,1* $&76 4 /(7 6 *2 72 6/,'( 6/,'( ',63/$<(' 21 6&5((1 ,6 7+,6 $ /,67 2) 7+( &86720(56 7+$7 <28 (;&/8'(' )25 $ 6,0,/$5 5($621 7+( 67$1'$5',=$7,21" $ ,7 ,6 4 2.$< 63(&,),& )81&7,21$/,7< :$6 $127+(5 21( 2) <285 %8&.(76 $1' 7+,6 1(;7 21( 6/,'( ,6 %$6(' 21 $1 25$&/( ( 0$,/ $ 05 0,77(/67$('7 $1' , 029( 7+$7 ,172 (9,'(1&( 7+( &2857 $1< 2%-(&7,21" &2816(/ &21)(5 05 %2,(6 12 2%-(&7,21 <285 +2125 7+( &2857 $'0,77(' '()(1'$176 (;+,%,7 $ 5(&(,9(' ,1 (9,'(1&( %< 05 0,77(/67$('7 4 :,// <28 (;3/$,1 72 86 7+( &2857 , '21 7 .12: :+(5( 7+( 12,6( ,6 &20,1*" ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

&/$5.( ',5(&7 05 0,77(/67$('7 :28/' :$/. 86 7+528*+ +2: <28 $&78$//< ',' 7+( &$/&8/$7,21 21&( <28 '(7(50,1(' 7+( 180%(5 2) &86720(56" $ <(6 :+(1 , /22.(' $7 7+( &86720(56 , )281' 7+$7 7+( 727$/ 5(9(18( :$6 7+( 0,//,21 7+( 180%(5 5,*+7 $7 7+( 723 7+(5( 7+$7 6 0,//,21 ,6 7+$7 727$/ 62 7+,6 ,6 5(9(18( 2) 6$3 $)7(5 7+( 7202552:12: 67$57 '$7( 62 7+$7 6 ,03257$17 :( $5( 21/< /22.,1* $7 7+( 5(9(18( 7+$7 7+(< *(1(5$7(' $)7(5 7+( 7202552:12: 67$57 '$7( $1' ,) 7+$7 :$6 $ &217,18$7,21 ,) 7+(5( :$6 620( &217,18$7,21 2) :+$7 7+(< :(5( '2,1* %()25( 7+(1 62 7+(< :(5( $/5($'< 21 0$,17(1$1&( )25 $ 180%(5 2) 352'8&76 $1' 3$<,1* /(7 6 6$< +$/) $ 0,//,21 '2//$56 $ <($5 ,1 0$,17(1$1&( $1' 7+$7 :28/' -867 &217,18,1* 7+$7 6+28/'1 7 %( $775,%87(' 72 7+,6 %(&$86( 7+( 6$/( :$6 0$'( 35,25 62 ,7 :28/' 127 %( $))(&7(' %< :+$7 :( $5( '2,1* +(5( 62 7+$7 0,//,21 5()/(&76 7+( $'-8670(17 )25 $)7(5 7+( 7202552:12: 67$57 '$7( $1' 127 ,1&/8',1* $1< 2) 7+$7 21*2,1* 5(9(18( 4 05 &/$5.( /(7 0( -867 6723 <28 )25 $ 0,187( 7+( (1' '$7( )25 7+,6 &$/&8/$7,21 ,6 , $0 127 685( ,) <28 6$,' ,7 ,7 6 7+( 6$0( (1' '$7( 7+$7 05 0(<(5 86(6" $ $&78$//< , 7+,1. 7+,6 ,6 025( /,.( , $0 35(77< 685( 7+$7 6 7+( '$7( :( 86(' 4 ,1 $1< (9(17 7+( 7:2 2) <28 <28 $1' 05 0(<(5 +$9( ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 9 - November 16, 2010
SHEET 16

&/$5.( ',5(&7 05 0,77(/67$('7 &$/&8/$7(' 7+( ,1)5,1*(56 352),76 )25 7+( 6$0( 7,0( 3(5,2'" $ <(6 :( %27+ 86( 7+( 6$0( 7,0( 3(5,2' ,7 6 -867 7+5(( 0217+6 /21*(5 7+$7 6 $// 4 *2 $+($' $ 7+( 815(/$7(' 5(9(18(6 7+$7 :$6 $1 $&48,6,7,21 7+$7 6$3 0$'( 7+$7 6 127 ,1&/8'(' ,1 7+,6 &$6( 62 , 722. 7+$7 287 $1' 62 7+( 5(9(18(6 )25 7+( (;&/8'(' &86720(56 7+(6( $5( $// 7+( 3(23/( $// 7+( &86720(56 , (;&/8'(' :(5( 0,//,21 62 , 68%75$&7 7+$7 %(&$86( 7+(< $5( 12 /21*(5 ,1&/8'(' 62 7+( 68%727$/ ,6 0,//,21 $1' , *(7 72 '('8&7 7+( (;3(16( 7+$7 6 7+( $335235,$7( 7+,1* 72 '2 62 7+$7 6 7+( 5(9(18( <28 7$.( $:$< 7+( (;3(16( 7+$7 :,// %( 7+( 352),7 7+$7 7+( ,1)5,1*(56 0$'( 7+( (;3(16(6 :(5( 0,//,21 7+$7 /($9(6 6$3 352),76 72 %( ',6*25*(' 2) 0,//,21 $1' 7202552:12: 352),76 :(5( 0,//,21 <28 $'' 7+( $1' 7+( 0,//,21 $1' <28 *(7 0,//,21 $6 7+( ,1)5,1*(56 352),76 4 $1' ),1$//< /(7 6 (1' :+(5( :( 67$57(' 6/,'( $1' ,) <28 :28/' :$/. 86 7+528*+ 7+,6 3/($6( 6/,'( ',63/$<(' 21 6&5((1 $ 7+,6 ,6 6,03/< $ 6800$5< 2) (9(5<7+,1* :( +$9( 7$/.(' $%287 62 )$5 62 ,) <28 /22. $7 7+( 723 7+,6 ,6 ,) <28 5(0(0%(5 7+( ),567 6/,'( 7+$7 , 6+2:(' <28 +$' 7:2 :$<6 2) '2,1* ,7 $7 7+( 723 25 7+( 5($621$%/( 52<$/7< $7 7+( %27720 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

&/$5.( &5266 05 %2,(6 $ , 5($//< +$9( 12 ,'($ 7+(5( 6 $ 63(&,),& &$/&8/$7,21 7+$7 :28/' $//2: 7+$7 %87 ,7 -867 &20(6 ,1 $ /803 680 0,;(' ,1 :,7+ $// 0< 27+(5 &203(16$7,21 62 , 5($//< +$9( 12 ,'($ 4 :(// <28 .12: 7+$7 <28 *(7 $ 63(&,),& 3(5&(17$*( 2) <285 7,0( &255(&7" $ &255(&7 4 $1' <28 .12: 7+$7 <28 *(7 $ 63(&,),& 3(5&(17$*( 2) (9(5<%2'< (/6( 6 7,0( 7+$7 :25.6 21 ,7" $ 7+$7 6 &255(&7 4 $1' <28 .12: :+$7 7+26( 3(5&(17$*(6 $5( 5,*+7" $ , '2 4 :+$7 $5( 7+26( 3(5&(17$*(6" $ 3(5&(17 2) 0< 7,0( &20(6 72 0( $1' 3(5&(17 2) (9(5<21( (/6( 6 7,0( 4 :+$7 <28 $5( 6$<,1* ,6 <28 +$9(1 7 %27+(5(' 72 '2 7+( $5,7+0(7,& 72 ),*85( 287 +2: 08&+ 7+$7 ,6" $ , +$9( 1(9(5 '21( 7+$7 4 <28 6$,' 7+$7 <28 7(67,),(' ,1 $ 180%(5 2) &$6(6 ,192/9,1* 7+( 9$/8$7,21 2) ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< ,6 7+$7 &255(&7" $ <(6 4 +$9( <28 (9(5 7(67,),(' %()25( ,1 $ &23<5,*+7 ,1)5,1*(0(17 &$6( 7+$7 ,192/9(' $ +<327+(7,&$/ 52<$/7<" $ <(6 4 +2: 0$1< 7,0(6" $ , &28/'1 7 6$< ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

&/$5.( &5266 05 %2,(6 62 $7 7+( 723 +(5( :( +$9( 25$&/( 6 /267 6833257 352),76 2) 0,//,21 7+( ,1)5,1*(56 6$3 352),76 2) $1' 7202552:12: ,1)5,1*(56 352),76 2) 0,//,21 62 7+( 727$/ /267 352),76 $1' ,1)5,1*(56 352),76 2) 0,//,21 25 <28 &28/' /22. $7 7+( 5($621$%/( 52<$/7< )25 7202552:12: 7+$7 :$6 0,//,21 6$3 0,//,21 $1' )25 7+( 25$&/( '$7$%$6( 0,//,21 ,) <28 $'' 7+$7 21( 83 ,7 6 0,//,21 05 0,77(/67$('7 7+$1. <28 12 )857+(5 48(67,216 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 &5266 (;$0,1$7,21" 05 %2,(6 7+$1. <28 <285 +2125 &5266 (;$0,1$7,21 %< 05 %2,(6 4 *22' 0251,1* 05 &/$5.( $ *22' 0251,1* 4 $6 <28 .12: , $0 '$9,' %2,(6 $1' :( 0(7 ,1 7+( (/(9$725" $ :( ',' 4 /(7 0( -867 %(*,1 :,7+ 620( %$&.*5281' 48(67,216 &2816(/ )25 6$3 ,1',&$7(' 7+$7 <28 +$' %((1 3$,' 0,//,21 )25 <285 :25. ,1 7+,6 &$6(" $ &255(&7 4 12: 7+$7 ',' 127 $// *2 72 <28 &255(&7" $ , :,6+ 4 +2: 08&+ 2) 7+$7 :(17 72 <28" ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

&/$5.( &5266 05 %2,(6 4 :(// $3352;,0$7(/< $ /(66 7+$1 7(1 4 /(66 7+$1 7(1 /(66 7+$1 ),9(" $ , &28/'1 7 7(// <28 4 /(66 7+$1 )285" $ , '21 7 .12: , '21 7 .((3 75$&. 2) &$6(6 7+$7 :$< 7+( 21/< :$< , &28/' '2 7+$7 :,// %( ,) <28 *$9( 0( $ /,67 2) $// 7+( &$6(6 , +$9( 7(67,),(' ,1 , &28/' 352%$%/< &2817 7+(0 83 4 /(7 0( $6. <28 7+,6 :+$7 $5( 7+( &$6(6 7+$7 <28 &$1 5(0(0%(5 ,1 :+,&+ <28 7(67,),(' $%287 $ +<327+(7,&$/ 52<$/7< ,1 $ &23<5,*+7 ,1)5,1*(0(17 &$6(" $ 7+( &25(/ &$6( :$6 ,1 )('(5$/ &2857 ,1 6$&5$0(172 , :28/' +$9( 72 /22. $7 , +$9( $ /,67 ,) <28 :$17(' 72 *2 %(<21' 7+$7 4 7+( &25(/ &$6( ,6 7+( 21( 7+$7 <28 &$1 5(0(0%(5 12:" $ <(6 4 $1' :+$7 ',' <28 (67,0$7( 7+( )$,5 0$5.(7 9$/8( 2) 7+$7 52<$/7< 72 %( ,1 7+( &25(/ &$6(" $ 127 9(5< 08&+ , 7+,1. 4 ,6 ,7 )$,5 72 6$< 7+$7 7+,6 ,6 7+( /$5*(67 &23<5,*+7 ,1)5,1*(0(17 &$6( 7+$7 <28 +$9( (9(5 +$' 72 75< 72 (67,0$7( 7+( 9$/8( 2) $ )$,5 0$5.(7 9$/8( /,&(16(" ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 11 - November 19, 2010
SHEET 3

&$7= ',5(&7 +286( 0,//,216 83)5217 4 $1' 7+( 6$0( ,6 758( )25 6$3 72 <285 .12:/('*(" $ <(6 4 2.$< 12: /(7 6 7$/. $ %,7 $%287 352-(&7,216 <28 :(5( ,192/9(' ,1 35(3$5,1* 352-(&7,216 $7 25$&/( $6 <28 72/' 7+( -85< /$67 :((. &255(&7" $ <($+ 2%9,286/< , 9( %((1 ,192/9(' $7 25$&/( )25 )25 48,7( $ /21* 7,0( $1' %()25( 7+$7 $6 $1 ,19(670(17 %$1.(5 )25 0$1< <($56 06 +286( &28/' <28 3/($6( 387 83 21 7+( 6&5((1 7+( 6$3 352-(&7,21 )520 3/$,17,))6 (;+,%,7 7+$7 6 7+( 7+5(( <($5 352-(&7,21 2) 0,//,21 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< %< 06 +286( 4 2.$< <28 9( 6((1 7+$7 $ )(: 7,0(6 7+,6 /$67 &283/( :((.6 ,6 7+,6 7+( 6257 2) '2&80(17 7+$7 25$&/( 7<3,&$//< *(1(5$7(6 ,1 '(9(/23,1* $ %86,1(66 &$6(" $ <(6 620(7+,1* -867 /,.( 7+$7 $&78$//< 4 $1' '2 <28 5(&$// 7(67,021< ,1 7+,6 &$6( ,) <28 &$1 7851 %$&. 72 7+( )5217 3$*( 2) 7+,6 '2&80(17 (;+,%,7 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 06 +286( $1' 7+( 38// 83 7+( ),567 3$5$*5$3+ 4 '2 <28 5(&$// 7+( 7(67,021< ,1 7+,6 &$6( 7+$7 7+( 0(0%(56 2) 7+( (;(&87,9( &200,77(( 2) 6$3 3529,'(' (;7(16,9( ,1387 $1' 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&$7= ',5(&7 +286( $:$< )520 7+,6 3/$1 4 $// 5,*+7 :( 5( '21( :,7+ 7+$7 7+$1. <28 12: '2 <28 5(&$// 7+$7 05 &/$5.( 7(67,),(' 7+$7 6$3 6 352-(&7,216 )25 7202552:12: 6+28/' %( ,*125(' %(&$86( 6$3 +$' 1(9(5 3529,'(' 6833257 )25 25$&/( $33/,&$7,216 %()25(" '2(6 7+$7 0$.( 6(16( 72 <28" $ 6$3 +$6 %((1 ,1 7+( %86,1(66 2) 3529,',1* 6833257 )25 (17(535,6( 62)7:$5( (63(&,$//< (53 62)7:$5( )25 /21*(5 7+$1 25$&/( :$6 ,1 7+( %86,1(66 2) (53 62)7:$5( 7+(< $5( 7+( (;3(576 ,1 3529,',1* 6833257 )25 (53 62)7:$5( 4 12: $5( $// 0$7(5,$/6 68%0,77(' 72 7+( %2$5' 25 (;(&87,9( 0$1$*(0(17 &216,'(5(' 25 $5( $1< 0$5.(7,1* +<3(" $ 0$5.(7,1* 72 <285 %2$5' ,6 -867 '2(61 7 0$.( $1< 6(16( 2.$<" <28 '2 127 7$.( 7+(6( 7+,1*6 /,*+7/< <28 '2 127 0$.( 7+(0 83 <28 '2 127 +$9( <28 .12: <28 '2 127 387 ,1 7+,1*6 7+$7 <28 '21 7 %(/,(9( ,1 ,1 )5217 2) <285 6(1,25 0$1$*(0(17 7($0 $1' ,1 )5217 2) <285 %2$5' 7+$7 -867 '2(61 7 0$.( 6(16( 4 12: %$6(' 21 <285 (;3(5,(1&( ,6 ,7 815($621$%/( 72 5(/< 21 $ ),1$1&,$/ )25(&$67 25 352-(&7,21 -867 %(&$86( ,7 6 %$6(' 21 $668037,216 7+( :25' $668037,216 " $ <($+ 2.$< 62 $668037,216 $5( 7+( 0267 ,03257$17 7+,1*6 $&78$//< 7+( $668037,216 $5( 5($//< :+$7 <28 %(/,(9( $5( 7+( ,03257$17 '5,9(56 $1' :+$7 <28 %(/,(9( ,6 *2,1* 72 +$33(1 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&$7= ',5(&7 +286( *8,'$1&( 72 7+,6 '2&80(17" $ $%62/87(/< 4 '2(6 25$&/( 6 (;(&87,9( 0$1$*(0(17 (9(5 3529,'( (;7(16,9( ,1387 $1' *8,'$1&( ,172 ,76 $&48,6,7,21 352-(&7,216" $ 685( , 0($1 :( $// *(7 ,192/9(' 7+(6( $5( 9(5< 6(5,286 0$77(56 62 :( $// <28 .12: *(7 72*(7+(5 $1' $1' 3529,'( 285 7+28*+76 4 $1' :+(1 25$&/( 6 +,*+(67 (;(&87,9(6 3529,'( (;7(16,9( ,1387 $1' *8,'$1&( ,172 25$&/( 6 352-(&7,216 :+$7 '2(6 7+$7 0($1 $%287 7+26( 352-(&7,216 :,7+,1 25$&/(" $ ,7 0($16 7+(< 5( 6(5,286 ,7 0($16 :( 9( &20( 72*(7+(5 7+,6 ,6 :+$7 :( 5($//< 7+,1. ,6 *2,1* 72 +$33(1 $1' 7+,6 ,6 :+$7 :( :$17 72 %$&. 4 $1' ,1 <285 (;3(5,(1&( $7 25$&/( :+(1 $ %86,1(66 3/$1 25 352-(&7,21 ,6 5(-(&7(' %< 7+( %2$5' 25 '((0(' 815(/,$%/( ,6 7+(5( 620( 6257 2) (9,'(1&( 2) 7+$7" $ :(// <28 .12: 2%9,286/< 0267 2%9,286 <28 '21 7 $&78$//< *2 $+($' $1' '2 7+( '($/ 62 7+$7 6 7+( ),567 7+,1* <28 '21 7 *2 )25:$5' :,7+ <285 352*5$0 $1' $/62 72 %( +21(67 7+(5( 6 868$//< $ 3$3(5 75$,/ 2) 3(23/( $5*8,1* $1' <28 .12: 3$3(5 :+(5( 7+(< 6(1' <28 $1 (0$,/ 7+,6 ,6 7+$7 7+,6 ,6 722 +,*+ 7+,6 ,6 722 /2: :+,&+ :( ','1 7 6(( $7 $// ,1 7+,6 &$6( %87 2%9,286/< 7+( 0267 2%9,286 ,6 7+$7 <28 '21 7 '2 7+( '($/ $1' <28 .12: ,1 7+,6 &$6( )5$1./< , ,1 7+( (17,5( 7+5(( :((.6 , ','1 7 6(( $ 6,1*/( 6$3 (;(&87,9( :$/. 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&$7= ',5(&7 +286( 7+( :+2/( -2% 2) $ 0$1$*(0(17 7($0 :+(1 <28 5( /22.,1* ,172 7+( )8785( :+,&+ 2) &2856( <28 &$1 7 6(( 3(5)(&7/< ,6 72 0$.( $668037,216 , , +$9( :+2/( 35(6(17$7,216 :+(5( 7+( 0267 ,03257$17 3$*( ,6 7+( $668037,216 %(&$86( 7+26( $5( 7+( ,13876 ,172 <285 %86,1(66 &$6( :+$7 &20(6 287 $7 7+( 27+(5 (1' ,6 7+( 287&20( ,6 <285 352-(&7,216 <285 )25(&$67 <285 7$5*(76 %87 7+( $668037,216 ,6 :+(5( 7+( 5($/ 0$1$*(0(17 :25. ,6 '21( $1' <28 $6 $ 0$1$*(0(17 7($0 7+$7 6 <285 -2% ,6 72 0$.( 5($621$%/( $668037,216 4 $1' ,) ,1 7+( 5($/ :25/' ,) <28 '21 7 $&+,(9( 7+( 352-(&7,216 '2(6 7+$7 0($1 7+$7 7+( $668037,216 :(5( 815($621$%/( *2,1* ,1" $ 12 7+( $668037,216 $5( 7+( %(67 ,1)250$7,21 <28 +$9( $7 7+( 7,0( <28 0$.( ,7 7+$7 6 :+$7 7+,6 ,6 $%287 <28 5( /22.,1* ,172 7+( )8785( <28 '21 7 +$9( 3(5)(&7 &/$5,7< <285 $668037,216 $5( <28 .12: $5( 5($621$%/( 7+(< 5( :+$7 <28 %(/,(9( 7+(< $5( ,) ,7 '2(61 7 7851 287 7+$7 :$< :(// ','1 7 7851 287 7+(5( &$1 %( $ /27 2) )$&7256 <28 ','1 7 (;(&87( :(// 7+( (&2120< , 0($1 7+(5( &$1 %( $ /27 2) 7+,1*6 '2(61 7 0($1 <285 $668037,216 :(5( 5($621$%/( $7 7+( 67$57 4 $1' ,1 7+( 5($/ :25/' 06 &$7= ,) <28 '21 7 (;(&87( 21 <285 3/$16 &$1 <28 *2 %$&. $1' 6$< /(7 6 35(7(1' , 1(9(5 0$'( 7+26( 352-(&7,216" 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 11 - November 19, 2010
&$7= ',5(&7 +286( $ 127 127 $1' .((3 <285 -2% :+(5( , :25. %87 7+( 7+( 5($/,7< ,6 7+26( 7+26( $5( :+$7 <28 5( 0($685(' $*$,167 <28 '21 7 <28 &$1 7 -867 6$< 2+ <($+ /(7 6 35(7(1' 7+$7 1(9(5 +$33(1(' 4 12: %$6(' 21 <285 (;3(5,(1&( $7 25$&/( :28/' ,7 $33($5 72 <28 7+$7 6$3 6 352-(&7,216 :(5( 5($621$%/(" $ $&78$//< , 7+,1. 7+(< :(5( 5($621$%/( $7 7+(< :(5( %27+ 5($621$%/( $7 7+( 7,0( $1' <28 .12: ,1 /22.,1* $7 7+( 180%(56 $6 7+,1*6 3/$<(' 287 7+(< $&78$//< 0$'( 7+( '2//$56 7+(< 7+28*+7 7+(< :28/' , 7+,1. 7+(< $&78$//< ',' %(77(5 4 :( +$9( $ 6/,'( 21 7+,6 7+$7 <28 9( +(/3(' 86 35(3$5( &28/' <28 387 7+$7 83 3/($6( ,7 6 /(7 6 6(( ,7 6 '(021675$7,9( 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 7+( :,71(66 <($+ , &$1 (;3/$,1 7+,6 7+,6 :$6 620(7+,1* 05 &/$5.( 387 83 $1' ,7 6 $ 180%(5 7+$7 ,) <28 /22. $7 7+( 723 180%(5 21 7+(5( 7+,6 ,6 6$3 6 5(9(18( )520 7202552:12: &86720(56 )520 /,.( 2) 7+26( &86720(56 $/21( ,1 , '21 7 .12: 81'(5 7+5(( <($56 , 7+,1. 62 7+(< 0$'( 0,//,21 )520 2) 7+( &86720(56 :+,&+ ,6 -867 $1 ,1&5(',%/( $02817 $1' %< 7+( :$< 7+(< $/62 12 '28%7 :+(1 <28 6(// /,&(16(6 2) <28 .12: 7+,6 08&+ <28 <28 +$9( 6833257 &20,1* ,1 )25 08/7,3/( <($56 %87 (9(1 ,) ,7 6 21( <($5 2) 6833257 ,7 6 /,.( $127+(5 0,//,21 /(7 6 6$< 7+(< &+$5*( /,.( 62 7+(< 62 7+(< ' *(7 /,.( 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55 &$7= ',5(&7 +286( 5(9(18( <285 +2125 ,6 7+( :,71(66 6 7(67,021< ,1',&$7(' :$6 ,) 7+(< ',' 7+,6 ,) ,7 6 $ &(57$,1 180%(5 2) <($56 (7 &(7(5$ 7+$7 ,6 127 7+( &$/&8/$7,21 05 &/$5.( %8,/7 , // &5266 (;$0,1( +(5 21 7+( $33/(6 $1' 25$1*(6 %87 7+$7 ,6 63(&8/$7,21 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 <28 &$1 0$.( $5*80(17 , 0 *2,1* 72 $//2: ,7 72 67$1' %< 06 +286( 4 62 $*$,1 -867 62 ,7 6 $ /,77/( &/($5(5 &28/' <28 7$.( 7+( -85< 7+528*+ :+< ,7 ,6 7+$7 7+( 352-(&7,21 180%(5 7+$7 :( 9( 6((1 ,1 7+( (;+,%,7 )520 6$3 :+(1 7+(< :(5( 352-(&7,1* +2: 7+( 180%(56 $/,*1 :,7+ :+$7 7+(< 387 ,1 )25 :+$7 7+(< $&78$//< $&+,(9(' $ :(// 05 &/$5.( 7(67,),(' ,7 :$6 <(67(5'$< +( 7(67,),(' 620( 27+(5 180%(5 %87 7+( '(021675$7,9( +( +$' 7+( 35(9,286 '$< :$6 0,//,21 0,//,21 ,6 7+( 71 5(9(18( 7202552:12: 5(9(18( 7+$7 , 7+,1. $/62 +( 7$/.(' $%287 $1' 7+(1 7+(< +$' 6$,' 7+(< &+$5*( 3(5&(17 )25 6833257 , 7+,1. 7+( 180%(5 620(7,0(6 620(7,0(6 , +($5' 3(5&(17 %87 , 86(' 3(5&(17 7+$7 :28/' %( $%287 0,//,21 21 7+( $1' 7+$7 6 -867 )25 21( <($5 (9(1 ,) ,7 :$6 ),9( <($56 , 0($1 7+( 7587+ ,6 21&( <28 +$9( $ &86720(5 7+(< 5( <285 &86720(5 )25(9(5 62 ,) ,7 :$6 $&78$//< <($56 ,7 :28/' %( $ %,//,21 7+5(( , 0($1 ,7 6 :$< 29(5 $1< .,1' 2) 180%(5 7+$7 7+$7 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&$7= ',5(&7 +286( $127+(5 0,//,21 $ <($5 )25 0$1< <($56 72 &20( %87 /(7 6 -867 &$// ,7 21( <($5 $1' , 7+,1. 7+(< $/62 0$'( $%287 0,//,21 )520 7202552:12: 4 62 :( $&78$//< +$9( $ 6/,'( 7+$7 0,*+7 0$.( ,7 ($6,(5 )25 7+( -85< 21 7+$7 $ 2+ 2.$< '(021675$7,9( 38%/,6+(' 72 -85< 05 /$1,(5 <285 +2125 2%-(&7,21 72 7+,6 6/,'( 7+,6 ,6 63(&8/$7,21 $%287 :+$7 6$3 ',' 25 ','1 7 0$.( $6 7+( :,71(66 6 /$67 7(67,021< &/($5/< ,1',&$7(6 7+( &2857 <(6 ,7 &(57$,1/< 6281'6 /,.( ,7 72 0( 7+,6 /$67 21( 06 +286( 7+,6 ,6 %$6(' 21 (;$&7/< :+$7 05 &/$5.( 72/' 7+( -85< :(5( 7+( 180%(56 7+$7 +( &$0( 83 :,7+ 7+( &2857 7+26( 180%(56 &20( )520 6/,'( " 06 +286( <($+ 62 ,) <28 /22. $7 7+( 7+$7 &20(6 )520 6/,'( 7+( 3(5&(17 6833257 5(9(18( :$6 7+( 180%(5 7+$7 :( +($5' +,0 7(67,)< ,6 7+( 6$3 180%(5 21 6833257 :( *27 7+( 0,//,21 2)) 2) $127+(5 21( 2) +,6 6/,'(6 7+$7 +( 6$,' :$6 7+( $&78$/ 7202552:12: 5(9(18( 62 7+,6 ,6 $// &20,1* ,1 (;$&7/< )520 05 &/$5.( 7+,6 ,6 127 620(7+,1* 7+$7 6+( 6 &5($7(' 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 :+$7 6 <285 2%-(&7,21" 05 /$1,(5 7+( 2%-(&7,21 (63(&,$//< 72 7+( 6833257 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&$7= ',5(&7 +286( 7+(< :(5( 352-(&7,1* , 7+,1. :+$7 7+(< ',' ,17(5(67,1*/< ,6 7+(< %$6,&$//< $33($5 72 +$9( *277(1 72 $7 /($67 7+( '2//$56 :+$7 7+(< 81'(59$/8(' :$6 +2: 9$/8$%/( 7+(6( &86720(56 :(5( 0($1,1* +2: 08&+ 7+(< :28/' %8< 2) 62)7:$5( )520 6$3 21&( 7+(< 387 ,1 $ :('*( %(7:((1 86 $1' 7+26( &86720(56 4 7+$1. <28 $// 5,*+7 /(7 6 7$/. $%287 $ ',))(5(17 352-(&7,21 7+$7 :( 9( +($5' $%287 ,1 7+,6 &$6( ,1 )$&7 7+( 21/< 21( 7+$7 :( 9( +($5' $%287 )520 05 &/$5.( ,7 6 7+( 6$3 6 -$18$5< %86,1(66 &$6( 7+( 6/,'( 7+$7 6$,' 7+$7 +$' 7+( 7+( 3$57 ,1 ,7 7+$7 6$,' )520 7202552:12: 0$1$*(0(17 ),1$1&,$/6 &$1 <28 (;3/$,1 :+$7 7+$7 67$1' $/21( 352-(&7,21 :$6" $ 685( , 0($1 7+$7 6 7202552:12: $6 $ 7+( &2857 -867 $ 020(17 05 /$1,(5 2%-(&7,21 <285 +2125 6+( 6 $6.,1* 7+( :,71(66 72 (;3/$,1 :+$7 :$6 0($17 %< $1 6$3 '2&80(17 6+( &28/' *,9( +(5 81'(567$1',1* 2) ,7 %87 (;3/$,1,1* :+$7 :$6 ,17(1'(' %< 7+( $87+256 ,6 &/($5/< 63(&8/$7,21 7+( &2857 , $*5(( 06 +286( , ','1 7 0($1 72 $6. 7+$7 /(7 6 75< ,7 7+,6 :$< 7+( &2857 -867 5(3+5$6( %< 06 +286( 4 &28/' <28 (;3/$,1 72 7+( -85< :+$7 $ 67$1' $/21( 352-(&7,21 ,6 -867 *(1(5$//< 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 11 - November 19, 2010
SHEET 4

&$7= ',5(&7 +286( $ 685( $ 67$1' $/21( 352-(&7,21 ,6 :+$7 $ &203$1< /(7 6 6$< $ /,77/( &203$1< %8,/'6 21 %8,/'6 2) 7+(,5 2:1 %86,1(66 ,) 7+(< $5( 127 $&48,5(' ,7 6 $&78$//< ,1 7+,6 &$6( 7+( 21/< 352-(&7,21 7+$7 :( .12: )25 685( :21 7 +$33(1 %(&$86( 7202552:12: :21 7 %( $ 67$1' $/21( 62 (9(1 :+(1 ,7 :$6 35(6(17(' 25 387 72*(7+(5 <28 .12: ,1 7+$7 3$&.$*( ,7 6 $&78$//< :+$7 7+( /,77/( &203$1< :,// '2 $// %< 7+(06(/9(6 :,7+287 7+( 6$3 %5$1' 1$0( $1' 7+( 6$3 -867 0$66,9( ',675,%87,21 &+$11(/ ,7 6 :+$7 7+(< :28/' '2 ,) 7+(< 67$<(' $1 ,1'(3(1'(17 /,77/( &203$1< 4 $1' ,1 1(*27,$7,1* $ /,&(16( :,7+ 6$3 )25 7+( 3(23/(62)7 $1' -' (':$5'6 $1' 6,(%(/ 0$7(5,$/6 7+$7 :(5( ,1)5,1*(' +(5( ,6 7+( 67$1' $/21( 352-(&7,216 2) 7202552:12: $7 $// 5(/(9$17" $ 12 %(&$86( 7+(< 5( 127 67$1',1* $/21( 7202552:12: ,6 $ 3$57 2) 6$3 7+( 6$3 ',675,%87,21 &+$11(/ *27 %(+,1' ,7 7+(< +$' 7+( 6$3 %5$1' 1$0( 62 -867 7+,6 &203$1< %()25( 7+(< *27 $&48,5(' ,7 6 &203/(7(/< ,55(/(9$17 ,1 7+,6 &$6( 4 $1' ,6 :+$7 6$3 3$,' )25 7202552:12: 5(/(9$17 72 (9$/8$7,1* 7+( /,&(16(" $ ,7 6 &203/(7(/< ,55(/(9$17 , 0($1 :+(1 , +($5' 7+$7 , 7+28*+7 <28 .12: , +$9( '2//$5 &52:%$5 , %5($. ,172 $ 0,//,21 '2//$5 +286( , &/($1 ,7 287 :+$7 , 3$,' )25 7+( &52:%$5 ,6 &203/(7(/< ,55(/(9$17 , 0($1 ,7 6 -867 6,//< 4 12: '2(6 25$&/( &5($7( 352-(&7,216 7+$7 9$/8( $1 $&48,5(' &203$1< $7 08/7,3/(6 2) :+$7 7+( $&48,5(' &203$1< 6 67$1' $/21( 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&$7= ',5(&7 +286( -867 7+( 021(< 7+$7 :( :28/' +$9( 27+(5:,6( 86(' 72 0$<%( %8< $'',7,21$/ 7(&+12/2*< 25 %8,/' $'',7,21$/ 7(&+12/2*< 4 '2 <28 5(&$// 05 &/$5.( 6$< 7+$7 $1' 21 :+(1 +( :$6 21 7+( 67$1' 7+$7 62)7:$5( &203$1,(6 /,.( 25$&/( $1' 6$3 '21 7 0$1$*( 7+(,5 &203$1,(6 72 7$.( $'9$17$*( 2) (&2120,(6 2) 6&$/(" $ :(// , // 63($. )25 25$&/( %(&$86( :( $&78$//< 7$/. $%287 7+( (&2120,(6 2) 6&$/( , 9( 7$/.(' $%287 ,7 ,1 ,1 , 7$/.(' $%287 ,7 ,1 0< &/$66 7+$7 , 0 0,66,1* 5,*+7 12: , 7+( 7+,1* ,6 ,6 7+( 7+,1* 7+$7 '5,9(6 $ /27 2) 0(5*(56 $1' $&48,6,7,216 ,1 )$&7 ,1 7+( 62)7:$5( ,1'8675< $5( (&2120,(6 2) 6&$/( $1' ,1&5($6,1* 352),7$%,/,7< 3(5 81,7 $6 <28 *(7 %,**(5 4 62 05 &/$5.( $/62 6$,' 7+$7 7+(5( :(5( /276 2) 27+(5 7+,5' 3$57< 6833257 237,216 )25 25$&/( 6 3(23/(62)7 $1' -' (':$5'6 62)7:$5( %(6,'(6 7202552:12: $)7(5 6$3 722. 7202552:12: 81'(5 ,76 80%5(//$ ,6 +( 5,*+7 ,1 <285 (;3(5,(1&(" $ :(// ),567 2) $// <28 .12: , :$6 7+(5( , /,9(' ,7 7+(5( :$6 21/< 21( 7+$7 :$6 %$&.(' %< 6$3 7+(5( :$6 21/< 21( 7+$7 :( :(5( :( +$' $ 6:$7 7($0 )25 7+(5( :$6 21/< 21( :( +$' $ :,1 %$&. 352*5$0 7+(5( :$6 21/< , 0($1 ,7 :$6 $// 7202552:12: 0251,1* 1221 $1' 1,*+7 <28 .12: ,7 :$6 7202552:12: $1' 7+$7 6 :+$7 :( :(5( )2&86(' 21 4 7+(5( 6 $/62 %((1 $ 68**(67,21 7+$7 25$&/( :$61 7 5($//< :255,(' $%287 6$3 86,1* 7202552:12: 12: 72 7$.( 25$&/( 6 3(23/(62)7 $1' -' (':$5'6 $1' 7+(1 6,(%(/ &86720(56 :$6 25$&/( 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&$7= ',5(&7 +286( 352-(&7,216 :(5( 25,*,1$//<" $ 685( , 0($1 :( '2 (;$&7/< :+$7 <28 :28/' (;3(&7 ,) :( %8< $ 7(&+12/2*< $ &203$1< :( ),*85( :( 5( *2,1* 72 %5,1* 7+$7 ,172 7+( ),567 2) $// :( 5( *2,1* 72 387 7+( 25$&/( ',675,%87,21 &+$11(/ %(+,1' ,7 $1' 25$&/( :,// %( 67$1',1* 7+(5( :,7+ 285 6833257 6<67(06 $1' 285 0$5.(7,1* $1' $// 7+$7 $1' 62 :( (;3(&7 72 6(// 08/7,3/(6 08/7,3/(6 2) 7+( 352'8&7 25 7+( 6(59,&( :+$7(9(5 ,7 ,6 , 0($1 620(7,0(6 :( 9( 62/' 025( 7+$1 7(1 7,0(6 7+( $02817 7+( /,77/( &203$1< :28/' +$9( 62/' 21 7+(,5 2:1 ,1 7+( ),567 <($5 4 $// 5,*+7 12: /(7 6 7$/. %5,()/< $%287 (&2120,(6 2) 6&$/( '2(6 $ 60$//(5 &203$1< %(&20( 025( 9$/8$%/( :+(1 ,7 6 $&48,5(' %< $ /$5*(5 &203$1<" $ :(// 685( , 0($1 <28 6(( :( $/5($'< +$9( 7+(6( ,19(670(176 ,1 285 ,1)5$6758&785( 62 72 ',675,%87( $1 $'',7,21$/ 352'8&7 '2(61 7 &267 9(5< 08&+ /(7 6 6$< 7+( 6$/(63(5621 *2(6 $1' 6(//6 ),9( 2) 285 352'8&76 $1' 12: +$6 $ 6,;7+ 352'8&7 25 6(59,&( 72 6(// :( $5( 7+$7 6$/(63(5621 $/5($'< +$6 $1 2)),&( :( 9( $/5($'< %8,/7 $1' 6833257 7+( 352'8&7 ,) <28 6(// $1 6,& 0$5*,1$/ $1 (;75$ 352'8&7 ,7 '2(61 7 &267 86 08&+ 025( 7+$1 *(1(5$//< 7+( 6$/(63(5621 6 &200,66,21 $1' %< 7+( :$< 7+( 23326,7( ,6 758( 722 ,) :( 7+28*+7 :( ' 6(// 6,; $1' 7+(1 :( (1' 83 6(//,1* 21/< )285 25 ),9( 25 :+$7 7+5(( $ /27 2) :+$7 6 /267 ,6 $/62 -867 352),7 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&$7= ',5(&7 +286( &21&(51(' $%287 6$3 6 7202552:12: 6833257 2))(5,1*" $ <($+ :( :(5( 9(5< &21&(51(' , -867 /,67(' +$/) $ '2=(1 7+,1*6 :( ',' 72 75< 72 <28 .12: :25. 9(5< 9(5< +$5' , 0($1 :( 5($//< 63(17 (;75$ 7,0( :,7+ $// 7+( &86720(56 :( 5($//< :25.(' 9(5< 9(5< +$5' $1' , 7+,1. ,7 :$6 2%9,286 ,1 7+( '2&80(176 6+2:1 4 2.$< $1' :$6 7202552:12: 68&&((',1* ,1 7$.,1* $:$< 25$&/( 6 &86720(56 29(5 7,0(" $ 7+(< $&78$//< :(5( , 0($1 7+(< :(5( 5($//< *$,1,1* 75$&7,21 , 7+,1. 7+( 21/< 7+,1* 7+$7 <28 .12: 67233(' 7+(0 :$6 7+(0 ),1$//< 6+877,1* '2:1 0217+6 $)7(5 :( &$8*+7 7+(0 $1' $)7(5 :( 68(' , 0($1 7+(< :(5( 5($//< *$,1,1* 75$&7,21 :,7+ 620( 2) 7+( %,**(67 &86720(56 :( +$' 4 2.$< 12: 7+(5( +$6 $/62 %((1 $ 68**(67,21 7+$7 $// 7+( &86720(56 7+$7 7202552:12: 722. $:$< )520 25$&/( :(5( 60$// 25 81'(6,5$%/( 25 81352),7$%/( ,6 7+$7 758(" $ 12 , 0($1 21 ,76 )$&( ,7 6 2%9,286/< 127 758( ,7 :$61 7 758( ,1 0267 2) 7+( (;$03/(6 86(' %< 6$3 (9(1 4 2.$< '2(6 7+( $02817 7+$7 6$3 352326(6 72 3$< 25$&/( ,1 7+,6 /$:68,7 )$,5/< &203(16$7( 25$&/( )25 7+( 9$/8( 2) 7+( 6833257 0$7(5,$/6 $1' 7+( 62)7:$5( 7+$7 7202552:12: $1' 6$3 722." $ :(// $&78$//< ,7 '2(61 7 9$/8( 7+( ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 11 - November 19, 2010
&$7= ',5(&7 +286( $7 $// %< 7+( :$< $1' 7+26( 0$7(5,$/6 , .((3 +($5,1* 0$7(5,$/6 2.$< $1' , -867 :$17 72 0$.( 685( <28 81'(567$1' ,7 ,6 ,1 )$&7 $// 7+( 62)7:$5( 12: <(6 7+(5( $5( '2&80(176 $1' +(/3 *8,'(6 $1' 7+,1*6 /,.( 7+$7 %87 ,7 6 $/62 7+( 62)7:$5( ,76(/) ,7 6 352%$%/< 0,//,216 2) /,1(6 2) 62)7:$5( &2'( :+,&+ ,6 :+$7 7+( 352'8&76 5($//< $5( ,7 6 :+$7 <28 1((' 72 581 7+( 352'8&76 ,7 6 :+$7 <28 1((' 72 127 21/< 86( 7+( 352'8&76 %87 8/7,0$7(/< ,7 ,6 :+$7 <28 1((' 72 6833257 7+( 352'8&76 :+,&+ ,6 :+< :+(1 7+(< &28/'1 7 +$9( ,7 $1<025( 7+(< +$' 72 6+87 '2:1 7202552:12: 4 :(// 25$&/( 6 '$0$*(6 &/$,0 ,6 29(5 $ %,//,21 '2//$56 :+< ,6 7+( '$0$*(6 $02817 ,1 7+( (;&(66 2) $ %,//,21 '2//$56 025( $335235,$7(" $ 7+,6 :+2/( %86,1(66 ,6 $ %86,1(66 $%287 %,//,216 :( 63(17 <28 .12: , .12: (9(5<%2'< 6 +($5' ,7 12: $ +81'5(' 7,0(6 :( 63(17 29(5 %,//,21 21 7+( 352'8&76 %87 :( $/62 63(1' 29(5 %,//,21 $ <($5 ,1 5 ' ,1 7+( %86,1(66 &86720(56 63(1' %,//,216 21 7+(6( 352'8&76 +$9( 0$'( &200,70(176 7+( 7+,6 ,6 $ %86,1(66 :+(5( 7+( ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< ,6 :257+ %,//,216 ,7 ,6 :+$7 285 &203$1,(6 $5( ,7 6 $ %,// 08/7, %,//,21 '2//$5 %86,1(66 4 &$1 <28 5(0,1' 7+( -85< :+$7 ,6 7+( 9$/8( 21 -867 $1 $7 $118$/ 21&( $ <($5 %$6,6 :+$7 6 7+( 9$/8( 2) 7+( 0$,17(1$1&( 675($0 7+$7 :$6 81'(5 $77$&." 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55 &$7= &5266 /$1,(5 '$0$*(6 $028176 :(5( )$,5 5($621$%/( (7 &(7(5$ <28 ' $*5(( :,7+ 0( :28/'1 7 <28 7+$7 :+$7(9(5 7+( -85< 1(('6 72 '(&,'( ,6 *2,1* 72 %( %$6(' 21 7+( /$: $6 *,9(1 72 7+(0 %< -8'*( +$0,/721 29(5 7+(5( 5,*+7" $ <(6 2) &2856( 4 2.$< <28 7$/.(' $ /27 $%287 7+( 9$/8( 2) ,3 7+(5( :(5( 9$/8$7,216 2) 7+( ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< $&48,5(' 7+528*+ 3(23/(62)7 $1' -' (':$5'6 $1' 6,(%(/ '21( ,1 7+26( $&48,6,7,216 5,*+7" $ <(6 %< 7+,5' 3$57,(6 )25 $&&2817,1* 385326(6 4 $1' 7+26( 7+,5' 3$57< 9$/8$7,216 2) 7+( ,3 )520 3(23/(62)7 $1' -'( $1' 6,(%(/ $// 72*(7+(5 $''(' 83 $5( /(66 7+$1 7+( '$0$*(6 <28 5( &/$,0,1* ,1 7+,6 &$6( 5,*+7" $ :(// 7+(< '21 7 9$/8( 7+( :+2/( , 0($1 7+$7 ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< /($'6 72 ,6 7,(' 72 $ 5(9(18( 675($0 $1' 7+(< $5( 75<,1* 72 $//2&$7( )25 $&&2817,1* 385326(6 :+$7 6 &$//(' (;&(66 385&+$6( 35,&( 62 4 $1' ,7 /($'6 72 5(9(18( $1' 5(9(18( &20(6 )520 &86720(56 5,*+7" $ <(6 4 62 ,1 7+( (1' :+$7 <28 -867 72/' 7+( -85< ,6 7+$7 5($//< :+(5( 7+( $&7,21 ,6 +(5( ,6 7+( &86720(56 5,*+7" $ ,7 6 7+( ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< 7+$7 6 /,&(16(' 4 127 7+( &86720(56 $7 $//" $ 7+( &86720(56 3$< )25 ,7 29(5 7,0( 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&$7= ',5(&7 +286( $ -867 %(7:((1 3(23/(62)7 -' (':$5'6 $1' 6,(%(/ :( 5( 7$/.,1* $%287 29(5 $ %,//,21 6(9(1 $ <($5 2) -867 0$,17(1$1&( -867 6833257 $1' 7+$7 6 :+$7 7+$7 %$6( 7+$7 $1' 7+$7 6 $118$//< (9(5< <($5 7+$7 6 :+$7 :$6 (;326(' 4 ,6 7+( %,//,21 180%(5 7+$7 25$&/( 6((.6 ,1 '$0$*(6 )$,5 72 25$&/( $1' 72 6$3 ,1 <285 23,1,21" $ <28 .12: 7+( :$< , 7+,1. 2) ,7 ,6 ,7 6 ,7 6 $5281' 3(5&(17 2) :+$7 :( $&78$//< 3$,' )25 7+( )25 ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< ,7 6 , 7+,1. ,7 6 &216(59$7,9( 3(5621$//< &216,'(5,1* 7+( 5($/ 9$/8( 2) 7+( ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< %87 , 7+,1. ,7 6 5($621$%/( , 7+,1. ,7 6 $ 5($621$%/( 180%(5 06 +286( 7+$1. <28 06 &$7= 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 &5266" 05 /$1,(5 7+$1. <28 <285 +2125 3$86( ,1 7+( 352&((',1*6 7+( &2857 $// 5,*+7 05 /$1,(5 7+$1. <28 &5266 (;$0,1$7,21 %< 05 /$1,(5 4 06 &$7= , $32/2*,=( ,1 $'9$1&( , 0 *(77,1* 29(5 $ &2/' 62 ,) , +$&. $1' &28*+ 3/($6( )25*,9( 0( , 0 6255< <28 +$' 72 0,66 <285 &/$66 :( +($5' $ %,7 $%287 <285 3(563(&7,9( $%287 :+$7 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&$7= &5266 /$1,(5 4 $1' 7+( 9$/8( 7+$7 25$&/( 8/7,0$7(/< *(76 )25 7+,6 ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< ,7 $&48,5(6 ,6 :+$7 ,7 *(76 )520 6(//,1* ,7 72 &86720(56 0$,17(1$1&( 675($06 (7 &(7(5$ 5,*+7" $ <(6 4 2.$< 12: /(7 6 7$/. $ /,77/( $%287 7+,6 /803 680 :( +($5' $%287 :+< <285 3(563(&7,9( 21 :+< $ /803 680 :28/'1 7 6,& 0$.( 6(16( (7 &(7(5$ , -867 :$17 72 0$.( 685( , 81'(567$1' $ /,77/( $%287 7+,6 /803 680 $ (;&86( 0( , 6$,' $ /803 680 83)5217 3$<0(17 :28/' 0$.( 6(16( 4 , 0 6255< , 0,6632.( <28 &28/' 7(// , +$9( $ &2/' <28 5( 5,*+7 <28 9( $5*8(' 7+$7 $ /803 680 0$.(6 6(16( , :$17 72 0$.( 685( 7+$7 :( 81'(567$1' 7+$7 , ',' 127 0($1 72 0,663($. 06 &$7= , 0 6255< 62 :( &203$5(' )25 (;$03/( <28 *$9( <285 3(563(&7,9( 21 7+( 681 /,&(16( $*5((0(17 :+,&+ <28 &+$5$&7(5,=(' $6 $ /803 680 &255(&7" $ <(6 4 $// 5,*+7 62 /(7 6 -867 0$.( 685( :( +$9( 7+(0 ,1 %$/$1&( +(5( 7+( /803 680 3$<0(17 7+$7 25$&/( ,6 6((.,1* ,1 7+,6 &$6( ,6 $7 /($67 %,//,21 :,7+ $ % 5,*+7" $ <(6 4 7+( /803 680 $6 <28 &+$5$&7(5,=(' ,7 ,1 7+( 681 /,&(16( $*5((0(17 ,6 0,//,21 :,7+ $1 0 &255(&7" $ <(6 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 11 - November 19, 2010
SHEET 6

&$7= &5266 /$1,(5 $%287 7+,6 $)7(5 :( )281' 287 :+$7 +$33(1(' 7+( )$&7 ,6 7+$7 :( $&78$//< 7+28*+7 7+$7 <28 .12: 6$3 &28/' 0$.( $ /27 2) 021(< 7$.,1* +81'5('6 7+286$1'6 2) &86720(56 $1' )5$1./< (9(1 $1' 7+(< ',' 7+(< ',' 4 $// 5,*+7 62 /(7 6 , -867 :$17 72 *(7 %$&. 72 7+( 48(67,21 , $6.(' <28 7+28*+ 06 &$7= :+$7 :28/' 7+( 180%(5 %( ,) ,7 :$6 &86720(56 ,) 7+$7 :$6 7+( $668037,21" $ , 7+,1. <28 +$9( 72 $6. 05 0(<(5 $%287 +,6 02'(/ $1' :+(7+(5 ,7 0$77(56 ,7 72 0( ,7 6 5($//< $%287 '2//$56 $1' &(176 &$86( 7+$7 6 :+$7 7+,6 %86,1(66 ,6 $%287 4 '2//$56 $1' &(176 7+$7 &20( )520 &86720(56 5,*+7" $ <($+ $1' 7+( 48(67,21 ,6 +2: 08&+ '2(6 ($&+ &86720(5 *,9( <28 , ' 5$7+(5 +$9( &86720(56 :+2 *,9( 0( 0,//,21 ($&+ 7+$1 &86720(56 :+2 *,9( 0( 0,//,21 ($&+ 4 :+$7 $%287 &86720(56" '2(6 7+$7 &+$1*( 7+( 180%(5 7+( '$0$*(6 180%(5 +(5(" $ :(// ,1 7+,6 &$6( ,7 '2(61 7 %(&$86( 7+( )$&7 ,6 7+( ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< 67,// ,1&5(',%/< 9$/8( 72 6$3 7+$7 6 :+< 7+(< 722. ,7 4 2.$< <28 5( 21 7+,6 6$3 722. ,7 $*$,1 $1' , -867 :$17 72 %( &/($5 $ <28 .12: 4 &$86( 7+,6 ,6 6(5,286 $*$,1 06 &$7= 7202552:12: 86(' 7+( ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< 5,*+7" :( 5( &/($5 $%287 7+$7" 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&$7= &5266 /$1,(5 $ &23< $1' 7+(< *27 &$8*+7 $1' :$17(' 72 *,9( ',61(< %$&. +$/) 2) :+$7 7+(< 0$'( ,6 ',61(< 6 /,%5$5< 21/< :257+ " , 0($1 ,7 5($//< , 0 5($//< 127 685( :+$7 <28 5( $6.,1* 7+( )$&7 7+$7 ,7 :$6 &23,('" ,7 :$6 &23,(' ,7 6 9$/8$%/( ,7 '2(61 7 &+$1*( 7+$7 ,7 :$6 9$/8$%/( 6,5 4 %87 06 &$7= $*$,1 7+,6 ,6 6(5,286 %86,1(66 $1' 62 , :( 1((' 72 %( &$5()8/ $%287 127 0$.,1* 7+,1*6 83 (9(1 &2/25)8/ $1$/2*,(6 6$3 6,& 68%6,',$5< 7202552:12: 62 :( '21 7 +$9( 72 +$9( 7+$7 ),*+7 86(' 7+( 62)7:$5( 72 6(59( &86720(56 &255(&7" $ 7+$7 6 +2: 0$1< &86720(56 7+(< 72/' 86 $%287 7+$7 3$,' 7+(0 620(7+,1* , '21 7 .12: +2: 0$1< 27+(5 &86720(56 7+(< 86(' 7+( ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< ,1 $1< 27+(5 :$< 4 06 &$7= <28 .12: )8// :(// 7+$7 7+(6( 3$57,(6 +$9( $*5((' 7+$7 7+(5( $5( &86720(56 $7 ,668( +(5( 5,*+7" <28 5( 127 5($//< $5*8,1* :,7+ 7+$7 $5( <28" $ 7+26( $5( 7+( 180%(56 7+$7 +$9( %((1 35(6(17(' $7 75,$/ 4 2.$< $// 5,*+7 $1' 62 7202552:12: ','1 7 $&78$//< 6(// 7+$7 62)7:$5( /,.( <285 &2/25)8/ :$51(5 %527+(56 $1$/2*< 7+(< ','1 7 6(// 7+$7 62)7:$5( 72 $1<%2'< 7+(< *27 3$,' )25 3529,',1* 6(59,&( 83'$7(6 (7 &(7(5$ 21 7+$7 62)7:$5( &255(&7" $ ,7 6 7+(< *$9( )2/.6 7+( 5,*+7 72 86( 285 62)7:$5( &255(&7 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&$7= &5266 /$1,(5 $ <($+ 4 2.$< $ , 0($1 :( &$1 /22. $7 7+( $&78$/ :25'6 2) 7+( 67,38/$7,216 $1' $// 7+$7 $1' %87 :( &$1 35(7(1' 7+$7 7202552:12: 6 127 $ 68%6,',$5< 2) 6$3 %87 ,7 ,6 4 $// 5,*+7 62 :( +($5' $ /27 $%287 :$7&+(6 $1' &52: %$56 $1' $// 6257 2) 678)) /,.( 7+$7 $1' , -867 :$17(' 72 )2//2: 83 $ /,77/( %,7 21 7+,6 722 7+,6 ,6 $ &23<5,*+7 &$6( <28 .12: 7+$7" $ <(6 4 2.$< $1' $ &23<5,*+7 &$6( 0($16 7+$7 620(%2'< .,1' 2) $ %52$' /(*$/ 0($1,1* &23,(' 620( 62)7:$5( 5,*+7" $ <(6 4 62 25$&/( 6 67,// *27 ,7 5,*+7" 7+(< 67,// +$9( 7+$7 62)7:$5( $ <($+ 4 2.$< $ <28 4 $1' 7+( 9$/8( 7+$7 25$&/( /267 ,1 620(%2'< (/6( &23<,1* 7+$7 62)7:$5( ,6 7+$7 25$&/( '2(61 7 *(7 7+( &+$1&( 72 6(// 7+$7 62)7:$5( 72 620(%2'< (/6( &255(&7" 7+$7 6 :+$7 6 $7 ,668( +(5( 5,*+7" $ ,) <28 .12: ,) :$51(5 %527+(56 +$' $ /,77/( 68%6,',$5< 7+$7 &23,(' $ ',61(< 6 (17,5( /,%5$5< $1' 67$57(' 6(//,1* ,7 )25 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

&$7= &5266 /$1,(5 4 /(7 6 %( 9(5< &/($5 +(5( 7+(< ','1 7 *,9( $1<21( $ 6(7 2) 7+( 81'(5/<,1* $33/,&$7,21 62)7:$5( 7+$7 '2(61 7 $/5($'< +$9( $ /,&(16( $1' ,) <28 ',6$*5(( *,9( 0( 21( 6,1*/( (;$03/( $ 5(0(0%(5 7+(< 7+26( 83'$7(6 :(5( $33/,(' 72 &86720(56 6<67(06 7+$7 7+(< ','1 7 +$9( 7+( 5,*+7 72 7+( 83'$7( 7+(< ','1 7 4 2.$< $&78$//< 06 &$7= /(7 6 %( /(7 6 %( &/($5 $%287 7+,6 $1' $*$,1 ,7 6 722 %$' <28 ','1 7 6(( 05 0$1',$ 6 7(67,021< :+(1 05 0$1',$ &21),50(' 7+$7 7+$7 6,78$7,21 +( '(6&5,%(' ,192/9(' 86,1* 620(7+,1* 21( &86720(5 :$6 /,&(16(' )25 %87 -867 86,1* 7+( :521* &23< 2) ,7 $1' <28 $&78$//< &$1 7 ',6$*5(( :,7+ 7+$7 &$1 <28" $ 86,1* 7+( :521* &23< 2) ,7" 4 <($+ $ , 4 $1' $*$,1 <28 :(5(1 7 +(5( , '21 7 0($1 72 7$.( $'9$17$*( 2) 7+$7 %87 <28 '21 7 ',6$*5(( 06 +286( -867 :$17 72 2%-(&7 ,162)$5 $6 7+,6 0,6&+$5$&7(5,=(6 05 0$1',$ 6 7(67,021< ,) +( :$176 72 3529,'( 7+( $&78$/ 7(67,021< 62 :( '21 7 +$9( $1< 0,65(35(6(17$7,216 2) :+$7 05 0$1',$ 6$<6 7+$7 6 $1 237,21 %87 +( 6+28/'1 7 7+( &2857 (;&86( 0( &2816(/ 7+( -85< +$6 +($5' 05 0$1',$ 6 7(67,021< 7+(,5 5(&2//(&7,21 2) +,6 7(67,021< &21752/6 5(*$5'/(66 2) +2: <28 $// &+$5$&7(5,=( ,7 21( :$< 25 7+( 27+(5 5$<1(( + 0(5&$'2 &65 505 &55 )&55 &&55

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR

ORACLE USA, INC., et al. v. SAP AG, et al. - Jury Trial - Volume 11 - November 19, 2010
05 %2,(6 7+( )2857+ 3$5$*5$3+ 2) %" 7+( &2857 <(6 $/7+28*+ 7+( ),567 6(17(1&( %27+ 2) <28 620(:+(5( ,1 7+( ,16758&7,216 '2 6$< 7+$7 ,7 6 127 '(3(1'(17 8321 :+(7+(5 25 127 7+( 3$57,(6 :28/' +$9( $&78$//< $*5((' 7+( ),567 6(17(1&( ,6 ),1( 7+( 6(&21' 6(17(1&( 7+( 3$57,(6 +$9( ',))(5(17 9,(:6 21 7+( 9$/8( 2) $ 327(17,$/ /,&(16( '2(6 127 35(9(17 25$&/( )520 5(&29(5,1* 7+( )8// 0$5.(7 9$/8( , :28/'1 7 *,9( 7+$7 , -867 7+,1. ,7 6 $5*80(17 $1' , $0 127 685( $%287 7+( /$67 6(17(1&( ,1 '(7(50,1,1* 7+( )$,5 0$5.(7 9$/8( 2) 7+( 5,*+76 ,1)5,1*(' <28 0867 &216,'(5 7+( (17,5( 6&23( 2) ,1)5,1*(0(17 ,1&/8',1* $// :25.6 ,1)5,1*(' :+(7+(5 25 127 $1< '()(1'$17 0$'( $1< $'',7,21$/ 86( 2) 7+( :25. $)7(5 &23<,1* ,7 7+,6 ,6 :+$7 , 6$,' ($5/,(5 ,7 6((06 72 0( 25$&/( ,6 )2&86,1* 21 -867 7+( &23<,1* $6 %(,1* 7+( ,1)5,1*(0(17 $1' 7+( '()(1'$176 )2&86,1* 21 7+( $&78$/ 86( 7+( 1,17+ &,5&8,7 ,16758&7,21 '2(6 5()(5 72 $&78$/ 86( 62 , &$1 7 727$//< ,*125( 7+$7 05 /$1,(5 <285 +2125 , 7+,1. 7+( 68**(67,21 +(5( , 7+,1. 7+( :$< 72 %5,'*( 7+,6 *$3 ,6 72 6$< <28 0867 &216,'(5 7+( (17,5( 6&23( 2) ,1)5,1*(0(17 7+( 3$57,(6 +$9( 67,38/$7(' 72 7+( 6&23( 2) ,1)5,1*(0(17 12: 7+$7 :( +$9( 5($&+(' 67,38/$7,216 (9(1 *2,1* %(<21' 7+26( 7+$7 (;,67(' :+(1 :( ),/(' 7+(6( ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'& 7+( &2857 &$1 :( *2 72 &" 7+( 6(&21' 3$5$*5$3+ 2) 3/$,17,))6 & ,6 $5*80(17$7,9( $1' , :28/' 127 ,1&/8'( 7+$7 $1' 7+( '()(1'$176 , $0 -867 127 685( $%287 7+( *(25*,$ 3$&,),& )$&7256 6(9(5$/ , 0($1 7+( 6(9(5$/ :,71(66(6 (9(1 %(6,'(6 7+( 7:2 (;3(576 0(17,21(' 7+( *(25*,$ 3$&,),& )$&7256 <28 $// +$9( %27+ 352&(('(' 21 7+( %$6,6 7+$7 7+( *(25*,$ 3$&,),& )$&7256 $5( 9$/,' &216,'(5$7,216 (9(1 ,1 $ &23<5,*+7 &$6( &255(&7" 05 /$1,(5 68%-(&7 72 285 21*2,1* 2%-(&7,21 $%287 7+,6 0($685( 2) '$0$*(6 <(6 21&( <28 *(7 72 7+( 9$/8$7,21 *(25*,$ 3$&,),& ,6 $335235,$7( , 7+,1. $&78$//< :( &28/' :,7+'5$: 285 & ,7 '2(61 7 (;$&7/< &255(6321' 72 7+(,56 %(&$86( 7+(5( 86(' 72 %( $ *(25*,$ 3$&,),& ,16758&7,21 :( $5( &217(17 72 :,7+'5$: ,7 $6 :(// ,7 '2(61 7 +(/3 7+( &2857 , :$6 *2,1* 72 68**(67 :( (,7+(5 7(// 7+(0 :+$7 7+( *(25*,$ 3$&,),& )$&7256 $5( 7+(5( :$6 $ 6/,'( :( 7(// 7+(0 ($&+ (;3(57 5(/,(' 8321 620( 2) 7+( )$&7256 025( 7+$1 27+(56 (,7+(5 :( 7(// 7+(0 7+(6( $5( 7+( )$&7256 <28 &$1 &216,'(5 25 :( '21 7 7(// 7+(0 $1<7+,1* $%287 *(25*,$ 3$&,),& , 7+,1. 72 5()(5 72 7+( )$&7 7+$7 620( 2) 7+( :,71(66(6 7(67,),(' 72 ,7 '2(61 7 5($//< *,9( 7+(0 $1< ',5(&7,21 05 /$1,(5 :( $5( &217(17 $1' :( // 2%9,286/< ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

05 %2,(6 , 7+,1. :( &$1 '2 620(7+,1* /,.( 7+$7 <285 +2125 , 7+,1. :( &$1 :25. 620(7+,1* /,.( 7+$7 287 7+( &2857 2.$< 12: 7+$7 '2(61 7 0($1 , $0 $&&(37,1* % ,1 ,76 (17,5(7< :,7+ -867 7+26( 7:2 6(17(1&(6 7851,1* 72 '()(1'$176 % , $0 75<,1* 72 *(7 <28 $// 72 :25. 72*(7+(5 72 &20( 72 620(7+,1* 7+$7 6 -867 127 48,7( 62 $5*80(17$7,9( 05 %2,(6 8+ +8+ 05 /$1,(5 ,1 285 % :( :(5( 75<,1* 72 6(7 83 7+,6 &+2,&( :( +$9( <285 +2125 6 *8,'$1&( 12: 21 %5($.,1* ,7 '2:1 ,172 )285 63(&,),& ,16758&7,216 %87 7+$7 6 3$57/< :+$7 :( :(5( 75<,1* 72 '2 7+( &2857 75<,1* 72 '2 , 7+,1. 7+$7 7+( , /,.( 7+( ),)7+ 3$5$*5$3+ $1' 3(5+$36 7+,6 ,6 7+( 3/$&( 7+$7 6$<6 7+$7 6$<6 7+$7 <28 ,7 6 127 72 %( %$6(' 8321 81'8( 63(&8/$7,21 05 /$1,(5 2.$< 05 %2,(6 7+,6 ,6 7+( ),)7+ 3$5$*5$3+ 7+( &2857 7+( ),)7+ $1' 6,;7+ 3$5$*5$3+6 $5( ),1( 2) '()(1'$176 % 05 /$1,(5 7+$7 6 21 3$*( 05 %2,(6 5,*+7 7+( &2857 62 ,) <28 &$1 .,1' 2) &20%,1( 7+( 7:2 % 6 :,7+ 7+26( 3529,6,216 ,7 :28/' %( 2.$< 05 /$1,(5 $// 5,*+7 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

',6&866 ,7 :,7+ &2816(/ ,) <285 +2125 ,6 &20)257$%/( :,7+ ,7 :( :28/' %( &217(17 -867 72 :,7+'5$: 7+,6 ,16758&7,21 $1' 7+(1 ($&+ 6,'( &$1 $5*8( 5$7+(5 7+$1 75<,1* 72 $*5(( 21 $ *(25*,$ 3$&,),& ,16758&7,21 05 %2,(6 , 7+,1. 7+$7 6 5,*+7 <285 +2125 , 7+,1. ,7 ,6 &21)86,1* 72 5()(5(1&( 7+( *(25*,$ 3$&,),& )$&7256 ,1 3$57 %(&$86( :+$7 *(25*,$ 3$&,),& )$&7256 0($1 ,6 127 -867 7+( )$&7256 7+$7 $5( /,67(' ,1 *(25*,$ 3$&,),& %87 ,1 7+( 68%6(48(17 1,17+ &,5&8,7 &$6(6 7+$7 +$9( ,17(535(7(' ,7 7+( &2857 685( $1' 7+( (;3(576 0(17,21(' 620( 2) 7+( 05 %2,(6 5,*+7 7+( &2857 3529,6,216 $1' 127 $// 2) 7+(0 , 7+,1. ,7 ,6 811(&(66$5< $1' &21)86,1* 05 /$1,(5 :( $5( &217(17 72 :,7+'5$: 7+,6 352326(' ,16758&7,21 05 %2,(6 , 7+,1. 7+$7 6 5,*+7 , '2 7+,1. +2:(9(5 7+( &2857 1(('6 72 &216,'(5 ,16758&7,1* 7+( -85< $6 72 :+$7 7+( %$6,& )$&7256 $5( 72 127 %< 1$0( $1' *(25*,$ 3$&,),& %87 :+$7 7+( %$6,& &5,7(5,$ $5( 72 86( 72 '(7(50,1( $ )$,5 0$5.(7 9$/8( 7+( &2857 7+$7 6 :+$7 , 6$,' (,7+(5 :( '21 7 6,03/< 5()(5 72 7+( )$&7 7+$7 :,71(66(6 +$9( 5()(55(' 72 ,7 (,7+(5 <28 /($9( ,7 287 &203/(7(/< 25 <28 *,9( 7+(0 $ /,67 2) 7+( *(25*,$ 3$&,),& )$&7256 ',$1( ( 6.,//0$1 2)),&,$/ &2857 5(3257(5 86'&

Raynee H. Mercado, CSR, RMR, CRR, FCRR, CCRR & Diane E. Skillman, CSR, RPR, FCRR