Spreadbury v. Bitterroot Public Library et al
Filing
261
Statement of Undisputed Fact re: 259 MOTION for Summary Judgment DEFENDANT LEE ENTERPRISES INC'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A - Aff of Backus - Newsworthy, # 2 Exhibit B - Petition to Ravalli County, # 3 Exhibit C - Pl to Messina (10-19/2007), # 4 Exhibit D - Pet Recall Sheriff Hoffman, # 5 Exhibit Pet Recall Ravalli Co Attorney Corn, # 6 Exhibit F - Ltr Pl to McCulloch (2/10/2009), # 7 Exhibit G - Ltr Commrs to Pl (2/17/2009), # 8 Exhibit H - Ltr PL to McCulloch w Recall Pet, # 9 Exhibit I - Ltr Kimmet to PL (3/13/2009), # 10 Exhibit J - Ltr Quintana to PL (3/23/2009), # 11 Exhibit K - Ravalli Republic Article (2/19/2009), # 12 Exhibit L - Blog Bitterroot Rising (2010), # 13 Exhibit M - Blogger User Profile, # 14 Exhibit N - Crystal Cox Blog (2011), # 15 Exhibit O - Blog - Ravalli Co Sheriff Dept (8/8/2009), # 16 Exhibit P - Crystal Cox Blog (2012), # 17 Exhibit Q - Library Thing, # 18 Exhibit R - Spreadbury Youtube MT, # 19 Exhibit S - Ravalli Republic Article (11/3/2009), # 20 Exhibit T - Find My Threat Story (11/17/2011), # 21 Exhibit U - Ravalli Republic Article (6/9/2010), # 22 Exhibit V - USDC Complaint (7/30/20100, # 23 Exhibit W - Aff Backus (Standard of Care), # 24 Exhibit X - Aff Devlin (4/2/2012), # 25 Exhibit Y - Bitterroot Rising Archives (2010)) (Smith, Jeffrey)
EXHIBIT
P
Michael Spreadbury - Crystal Cox Blog Exposing Montana Comrption.
Share Repod Abuse
Next
BlogD
Create
Blog
Sign In
Michael $preadbury - Crystal Cox Elog Exposing Montana Corruption.
into not pL:hlished el*etvhere
They *ayspen in Monta*a
*b**t civil rights, c*rrupticn,*nd thi*g*
we nev€r thought would hfippan i* the United gtates.
The Ecoilomy of Corrupt Politicffl Subrlivisisns
l-G'chl
Morday.
Fr]arcn
19 2012
Bitterroot Public Library
Bitterroot Public Library wants your house.
Dece0lion al the Bitlenool Public Librarv Hamilton Montana
Psysorogyroday.@h
In the lasl two editions of the Bittenoot Star, the Bittenoot Public library is claiming that they have funding "gaps" for their FALL FUNDING DRIVE. The only
gap is the public misinformation about the Bitterroot Public Library budget.
Lel me help you wilh that one.
In the 2oo9-2010 budget the Bitlerroot Public Library had $500,000,00 us In ths bank of your lax money. Apparenlly, this is nol enough for a small one room
library to operale with their 9500,000 combined annual budget from Ravalli County and the magical unincorporated City of Hamilton. Vvhen the Bitterroot
Public Library spends yourtax dollars from the unincorporated City of Hamilton, MT and Ravalli County MT taxpayers purchases of books only amounts to
1
In 9 budget dollars.
The North Valley Library in Stevensville, MT has plans for expansion, has far superior community programs, slafi, and operates on a fraclion of the Bitlerrool
Public Library lax revenue (see link below for the North Valley Library). Moreover, The Norlh Valley Library ACCEPTED the US President letter denied by the
Bittenoot Public Library (link is below). Here is a PDF view of the remodel/expansion plans in Slevensville MT at the North Valley Library: (wail for upload)
http:i/comnraq.comlcq/wp-contentuploads/201 1/1 z/NVpL-Public-lnfo-Boards04l 1 1 1. pdf
Here is a vision, a snippet of life in Hamilton, MT site of the Bittenoot Public Library: Hamilton Montana Police mor€ than willing to transfer expertise to the
Bitlerroot Publ ic Library when asked.
Pulled over for "Being in Wrong Lane"
lwaming, gunfire, death of American by Hamitton Police]
http://www.michaelspreadbury.com/search?updated-min:2012-01-01T00:00:00-08:00&up...
312612012
Michael Spreadbury - Crystal Cox Blog Exposing Montana Corruption.
The City of Haminon is not lawfully incorporated, not historically eilher.
The Davis family has cause of action for WRONGFUL DEATH.
NOTE: an unincorporated city cannot have police, employees or a gov't
Now if anyone brings this up, beware of the 15 police officers who are far from imaginary.
lt
1,
! irt:|.;.
You RnE 87 TIMES
MORS LIKELY TO NR
DIE IN A TERAORIST ATT
I i
Y#rJ
, jr;:;:
:. ;
As* 17,&**
: ..:, . 'ii-tllll "i{irl r'1 4:: l, !. tii t ;aa.:.1t *!:'r
!-:if iriritl:ii i i {!.it1:ii'jttt?..: rr:: it ,i
(.1i1|,!11
i1t;
Tth'|H$ frq[}'il€ t.iKfr-Y Ts) ${s t-&*rd
t:pl(}tl A TI:HFISfiIST fiY?"&frK
F,|fi
ffi ffirdffi ffi tilir
TS'Erfr "Kl'U[:H'fr' BY A FOil
f,
-f
l.fAlrt'tsry*-TEffiR SRIST A
ro
You
1048 rrurs
;!tr#[h:ruffi
rffi
' -
'f
()i,.j &,ni:.'i
,1
r1 ..i?;-r!
n
1itur#,* tultj{tg t-ll{fl.t-Y 'tr{J f}tfi. f
AR€
f1{.}11x
d1t:{)1fi[,!,rT*i.
MoEE LTKELY
otE
CAH ACCIPENT T}IAN FRO" A TERRORIST ATTAC
x,ti:.::iiN, I l,iilii illt.iLrlil !.iliir:l Y Il1 i..iit:l'it;l{,:1"{
t,';':i{:::.i:l 1:ri"il^l,jt!.'l\tjt:t i'. ?{i\.liia:)l,l!tt!'l .A jlhllrl
YoU ABE NIiIE TII'.IES
YOUR OWN VOMIT
'!IE
!liJi
LTKEL
Hamilton Montana is a community with many older seniors, so why shouldn't the Bitterroot Public Library seek those estales for use of their budget? How
would the public know thal the Bittenoot Public Library actually have a giant surplus? lt is called deception al besl, and fraud is nol loo far off.
read more: hlip /lwvrw.rndusirywhistleblower.comlZ0l lioslbitterroot-public-iibtaryjraud. html
In the 2009-201 O budget, 63% of the funds went to pay lhemselves (Administrative Costs). Lets compare the Bitterroot Public Library with the North Valley
Library, a bigger, more community minded outreach, AND had plans to expand, with ACTUAL GAPS in their budget.
The North Valley Library is a great organization. Their volunteers laugh, are fun to talk to, and are hel plul. Please give to the Stevensville Library if you have
money lo give. They operate a much better library with MUCH LESS tax revenue (or deception).
http://northvalleylibrary.orgi
It is proof thai the Bitterroot Public Library feels money from lhe public is lheirs io spend, at their desire, and ask for more in Hamillon Montana. The Bitterroot
Public library has anolher secret: Hamllton Montana taxpay€rs have footed a court blll for an estlmated S250,000 lor removing privileges, charging crime
for sitting on public property as the former director admitted no requests were made to leave the library (under oath) for any behavior issue in violation of their
policies, or Montana Law [MCA 22-1-3111which slates a '\Millful violation of the rules" is needed prior lo removal from the library. Many people in Hamilton
were removed outside of this policy.
http://www.michaelspreadbury.com/search?updated-min:2012-01-01T00:00:00-08:00&up...
3/2612012
Michael Spreadbury - Crystal Cox Blog Exposing Montana Comrption.
The Bittenoot Public Library commons
It is estimated that the Bitterrool Public Library has removed at least 10 patrons rights to enter the library, and the details are nol known beyond that.
What is known is that the Bitleroot Public Library wanls more ot your gifts, be it your house or your hard eamed money when they mis-use public funds as they
violate Moniana law, and palrons rights.
An upshol of the "Ban" from the Bittenoot Public Library has been the "Library Thing" website with a revolving readership of 3Million readers about the
Bittenoot Public Library. The other upshot is the letter to the first African-American US President asking for CIVIL RIGHTS within the FIRST paragraph
;
the Montana US Prssident letter has hed more than 10 mllllon confimed views.
Read the 1O page letter banned from the Bitterrooot Public Library in 2OO9:
http://www.ethicscomplaint.com/2011/06lopen-letter-to-president-obama-pleading.html
The Bitterroot Public Library pays $1 per yoar for their space to the City of Hamilton. They want more from you, although you pay for their mislakes, as
improper uss of public funds is the #1 criminal priority of the FBI although no one is seemingly breaking a sweal at the US DePt. of Justice.
com
Former prosecuto, Guofi M"n"l''"'"dormrrupton
(photo from bankrupt Lee Enterprises)
While the public, and The Bitterroot Sta/s M ichael Howell go ballistic over spending $250,000 of public money for Geoff Mahafs retirement al the Ravalli
County Attorney Office, no one is making a pe€p over the misuse of Ham ilton Taxpayer tunds to the same sum to improperly benefit tho BitleFool Public
Library in Hamilton Montana.
read more: http:/lwww.prosecutorcorruption.coml2A1Ol12ldepay-county-attorney-resigns-ravalli.htrnl
http://www.michaelspreadbury.com/search?updated-min:2012-01-01T00:00:00-08:00&up...
3/2612012
Michael Spreadbury - Crystal Cox Blog Exposing Montana Comrption.
here is the Library Thing webpage about the Bittenoot Public Library: 3 Miilion hits on one site.
hltp://www.librarything.com/work/1 0769795
Aboul 6 months ago, this blog network encouraged the boycotl of the Bitterroot Public Library and a link to the reasons should make it very ctear that
something is very wrong in Hamillon Montana:
industrywhistleblower.com/201 l l06lboycott-bitterroot-public-library. html
It jusl seems intuitive to give to a library. The Bittenool Public Library is not an ordinary library. lt has lost a direcior, and the state director for protecting tho
Bitterroot Public Library in Hamilton Montana. A library is for the public, to discuss ideas, obtain reading material, and congregate oulside to enjoy peace.
Peace is nol whal is at hand at 306 Stale Street in Hamillon Montana, site of the Bitterroot Public Library.
Please guard your finances from the Bitterroot Public Library. They have a right to ask you for money,
spent, or not being spent.
bu1
you have a right to know how public funding is being
Source of Posl: irliil:iiw'vr! harnill*r'irronlBns n$i301 111?ibiili3rro*i-publki.li*ri1'y wonis-yotrr hlrrl
Posted by i'lrchael Streacb.iry at lt.l:21
Ibf(iry, 8av*l| Counlv
Fecomme6d inis oil iiooqie
puhliq. lii)ra.y
Tue$day. Felrruary
Ah, ).#,
1. 2.tJi2
?
Local Government
Note: this editorial was writlen to expose a local munipality and County in the State of Montana which does nol have the lawful papeMork required by State
Code to exist
Hamilton, MT county seat of Ravalli County
photo courtesy ot goNorthwest.com
This letter will look at how well our governments are working in Ravalli County, without the party spin, but with hard facts, and
hard truths.some might remember the documentary commissioned and filmed in the Bitterroot Valley in 2009 named "Beneath
the Beauty". Within that 2 hr. production the Mayor of Hamilton, Jerry Steele is asked about incorporation documents for his city,
required for public inspection in Montana under MCA 7-24100 and following.
http:/iwww.michaelspreadbury.com/search?updated-min:2012-01-01T00:00:00-08:00&up...
312612012
Michael Spreadbury - Crystal Cox Blog Exposing Montana Comrption.
The public inspection issue is a problem for our local governments.As many people work for these governments, all of a sudden
it has become "all of them" against an individual, or smaller group of people. This newspaper has bravely entered the courts to
attempt to warm the heart of Honorable Langton, personally I tried with Honorable Haynes to plead public disclosure of police
reports which outweigh personal privacy of an individual, even if they work for a local government. The constitutional right to
know is a powerful one in Montana, and our local governments don't have a terribly good track record if you look at the filing
history in the Montana Supreme Court.
In 2006 a person named Prindel sued Ravalli County for not releasing documents, and records the failure to release public
information. In 1992 it appeared that the Hamilton City Judge was sexually harassed by the sitting Mayor Whitlock, and a group
called Citizens to recall \Mtitlock sued the Mayor to release the investigation due to public concern of the document. The
Bitterroot Star, and others sued the County for the release of Geoff Mahar's complaint against the Ravalli County for similar
reasons.
Why do our local governments behave so badly? lt's due to the "all of us" against the individual mindset.The interesting part is
the admission in official meeting of Mayor Steele in August 2009 of no incorporation public documents for the City of Hamilton.
The official plat map indicates the City of Hamilton was annexed to Missoula Co. on September 4, 1890, with no record of
incorporation since. Ravalli County was created by the Montana Legislature on March 3, 1893 except that Hamilton relies upon a
newspaper article from July 21 , 1894 as proof of "incorporation". Neither the cunent city clerk nor county clerk can find required
public documents for Hamilton's lawful incorporation. How can these local governments lawfully collect taxes or have employees,
elections or any function of a government such as courts, law enforcement?
Montana law MCA 7-2-2103 says that a county seat such as Hamilton must be incorporated for a county to laMully exist. Seeing
how the chicken came before the egg for Ravalli County (county created 1893 prior to "incorporation" in 1894 or Marcus Daly
founding in 1895) do we wonder why our local governments are behaving so badly?lt's because they don't laMully exist, and
they don't need to behave or follow the rules.
Official Plat May shows Hamilton, MT is Missoula Co.
cerlified mao of Hamilton MT
on Feb.25,2010 by Ravalli Co. Clerk Regina Pleltenberg
Open meeting laws, public disclosure of information, partisan infighting, potential issues with civil rights; all due to no desire to be
lawful.lf we want less government intrusion, public officials can decide to put their pencils down, and stop collecting our taxes.
Seeley Lake is a wonderful place to live, because Missoula Co. leaves them alone.Wth proof that Missoula Co. owns Hamilton,
and Ravalli County cannot exist without a legitimate county seat, it's time to get out the drawing board and chalk out some laMul
solutions for our local governments to exist in the Bitterroot Valley.
Source of Post: htti]: /lww\ri hem ltonmonlana u$/20 1 Zi02linva lid html
i
Posted by fu1iti)({$i .'jpre;.iii*tiiv at ii }3
li']i:reitliSrl Ravallr
llfl
r:\tu] ., *l
.
1
iqs0(rnneril thr$ r* {)ooijte
fu1oi:1iiia
http://www.michaelspreadbury.com/search?updated-min:2012-01-01T00:00:00-08:00&up,.
.
3/2612012
Michael Spreadbury - Crystal Cox Blog Exposing Montana Corruption.
$aturday, January 28. 20'12
FRAUD at Rocky Mountain Labs
Crystal Cox and I have collected information on the Roc ky Mountain Labs for a few years now.
The entire US Government (federal agencies, legislalure, judiciary) has been closed to making lhe NIH lab in Hamilton, Monlana accountable to ANY standard
From Crystal: a connection to a law firm that Presidenl Obama worked for, Foley & Lardner and has high conneclions lo Chris Bebe (sic?) a high ranking
Republican slrategist.
flickr pholo
Marshall Bloom in bowtie, Dr, Anthony S, Fauci in the blue tie [NlAlD direc'tor since 1980's]
The Vviite House has made one of the Directors, Marshall Bloom (physician license in MT inaclive) a liaison for immunology, and infectious agents. The
problem is the NIH/NlAlD facilily in Hamilton, MT does nol have onsite fire/bio hazmat facility like the Bethesda, Maryland headquarlers of NIH Ia recent
upgrade of the rescue, capabililies took placel.
Here is the $250,000 Aerial Ladder truck NIH bought for
the VOLUNTEERS in Hamilton Montana
[hey seem to have trouble stafiing the lruck-so it is used in paradesl
pfEtiro.com
OK, should volunteer firemen respond to EBOLA and infectious agents
at NIH NIAID Rocky Mounlain Labs Hamillon MT?
(remember, no crew for this truck, and NO bui ldings higher than 3 stoies!)
The other problem is the environmental problems: 1) clean water ac1, 2) Low Frequency Emissions into neighborhoods surrounding the Hamilton, MT facility,
3) safety of Infectious Agents lsuch as Ebolal studied at Rocky Mountain Labs (RML) in Hamilton, MT.
Here is a video showing the sound of silence in Hamilton, MT at RML
http://www.michaelspreadbury.com/search?updated-min=2012-01-01T00:00:00-08:0O&up... 312612012
Michael Spreadbury - Crystal Cox Blog Exposing Montana Comrption.
39 second video with sound meter reading 62 dbc
World Heallh Standards are approx. 44dbc nearly twice as quiet.
Low Frequency Noise has serious effects to Human Health--Ig conseguence for NlH.
The NIH facllity was VERY Interested when I took data: I was watched.
September 25, 201
I
recording of sound
On February 2,2011 a contractor for NIH committed fraud by measuring the sound signature from RML with a sound scale that intentionally DEFLATED the
data. RML worked with the contractor by reducing their signature that day by one order of magnitude (as recorded by me).
The sound fraud is a detilment to the NIH mission which states scientific accountability to the public. The Acoustics contractor for RML was BUSTED (by me)
for using an Engineering License PE on his report, when he did nol have one in Montana. Read more:
i')11p 1/uiww.rnd|i$1rylvhiglle biow*r ?omiz01 1l08lnili-rrnfconlracilor-busled hiftl
The RML facility is willing to stand behind fraudulent data, that which directly harms Americans who pay the NIH bill. To see the memo, and LOTS of photos ot
the facility see:
irttp:liwww.irdiislrywhisllehiowor crrri 2il 1 1i 0$i fiih-fraud-vtori#embarassmeni:.nol"erl$ugh hlml
The RML facility also decided to tell the Montana US represenlative Denny Rehberg that'lhey stand behind the data" lwhich is absolutely fraudulenl,
endangers area residents near RML Hamitlonl.
Here is my request for a Federal Fire Station in August 2009 from Rehberg:
http://www.michaelspreadbury.com/search?updated-min:2012-01-01T00:00:00-08:00&up...
312612012
Michael Spreadbury - Crystal Cox Blog Exposing Montana Comrption.
Members of the Hamilton, MT community have put foMard a letter to the US President in 2009 about lhe RML tab in Hamitton, and civil rights to the first
African American US President.
(we did not get a response lo the lener, and no help with the RML Lab in Hamitton, MT)
read the US Presi dent letler [10 pg] f rom 2009 about the NIH facility in Hamillon MT.
iltl) i/wuJw sDiitlfiijilrj:ilicoli1{.ws 1tir.2i}1 1/orjr'Cl-1en^leil*f-lc-prestrj*it-ilhaJ}a- plsadlnq
l1nl
the letler has had over 10 Million views. Anonymous sent it lo more people via email.
There is a documentary movie named Beneath the Beauly lavailable: www Ben{rathlhe#*arly cofirl where Mr. Bloom is interviewed aboul the history ot Rocky
Mountain Labs (RML) in Hamitton, MT. We look into the safety issues of RML, and explore Hamilton's unincorporated slatus.
I wrole an appeal to lhe gth Circuit for lhe environmental issues at RM L. lt was also swiped away to protect this facilily. The case as not even SERVEO by lhe
US District courl for Montana, and lhe gth circuil issued an "unpublished opinion" lwhich means they can discard itl. W]atever they do at RML Hamillon, the
employeesneedtopgecretclearancas,andnoformofUSGovemmentwill intervene: EPA,OSHA,USSurgeonGeneral. Soall threeformsofgovernmenl
cannot touch Rocky Mountain Labs in Hamillon, MT (which doesn't lawfully exist).
placsstostay-Mohlana.com
Hamilton is counly seat to Ravalli County (Bitterroot Valley)
and does nol lawfully exist as a municipality in Montana.
The Bitterroot Valley that sunounds the facility has 9,000 foot peaks, is isolated in US Foresl Service land and wilderness ('1.6 M acres) and high fire danger
It is silueted in a spot not near popu lation centers, and would only kill 40,000 Americans if lhe infectious agents gol out lif they could isolate the bio-medical
infectious agenl regionallyl.
Aftidavit of Misconducl of Public Healln Service (PHS) Officer
Kelly Hudson, Oflice of Research Facilities (ORF) Hamilton Montana
Fraud by Kelly Hudson endangers Americans health in Hamilton, MT @ RML
http://www.michaelspreadbury.com/search?updated-min:2012-01-01T00:00:00-08:00&up...
312612012
Michael Spreadbury - Crystal Cox Blog Exposing Montana Comrption.
1ii,:!,ili!
L
I
i
i.
j.
ri.
lr
fi
ii
'''
!i.
iil.ll!!!tititi..l., l,!ric..&Iir::,:
r"ltr t:!3, Sidjijltul} ti r I i:ronr ;s i:i ali rl:[ i ierrrr
'{ .
i,r.:\1i(lxri\i.r?irii"niq..i1:tif.rr,aj(.!l\
i.r(;ri;iS: l.J+,!' \uirrlj,:r.,:::r:
\Jrrlrm:r rrt |.^u_
>
>
>
>
Tho Aulhors specifically invokes the First Amendment rights of freedom of
sPeech and ofthe press, without prejudice, on this website, this Blog.
hlarch
l-ebfuar'
'ianrtry
2011 (7)
(1)
(2)
L
ii;rary
The information posted on this website, this btog is pubtished for informational
purposes only under the righls guaranteed by the First Amendmenl of the
Constitution for the united states of America. lmages, texl and logic are
copyrighl prolecled'
Thls ls My Blog, my Oplnlon, My "Pulpit", My "Soapbox"..
2010 (2)
2009
(5)
This Blog is NOT Owned, Controlled or Coniributed to By Michael
Spreadbury, Hamilton Montana.
Awesome Inc. templale. Powered by Rlog(Jer.
http://www.michaelspreadbury.com/search?updated-min:2012-01-01T00:00:00-08:00&up...
312612012
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?