The Football Association Premier League Limited et al v. Youtube, Inc. et al

Filing 276

DECLARATION of Elizabeth Anne Figueira, Esq. in Opposition re: 167 MOTION for Summary Judgment.. Document filed by The Music Force LLC, Cal IV Entertainment, LLC, Cherry Lane Music Publishing Company, Inc., The Football Association Premier League Limited, Robert Tur, National Music Publishers' Association, The Rodgers & Hammerstein Organization, Edward B. Marks Music Company, Freddy Bienstock Music Company, Alley Music Corporation, X-Ray Dog Music, Inc., Federation Francaise De Tennis, The Scottish Premier League Limited, The Music Force Media Group LLC, Sin-Drome Records, Ltd., Murbo Music Publishing, Inc., Stage Three Music (US), Inc., Bourne Co.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 189, # 2 Exhibit 190, # 3 Exhibit 191, # 4 Exhibit 192, # 5 Exhibit 193, # 6 Exhibit 194, # 7 Exhibit 195, # 8 Exhibit 196, # 9 Exhibit 197, # 10 Exhibit 198, # 11 Exhibit 199, # 12 Exhibit 200, # 13 Exhibit 201, # 14 Exhibit 202, # 15 Exhibit 203, # 16 Exhibit 204, # 17 Exhibit 205, # 18 Exhibit 206, # 19 Exhibit 207, # 20 Exhibit 208, # 21 Exhibit 209, # 22 Exhibit 210, # 23 Exhibit 211, # 24 Exhibit 212, # 25 Exhibit 213, # 26 Exhibit 214, # 27 Exhibit 215, # 28 Exhibit 216, # 29 Exhibit 217, # 30 Exhibit 218, # 31 Exhibit 219, # 32 Exhibit 220, # 33 Exhibit 221, # 34 Exhibit 222, # 35 Exhibit 223, # 36 Exhibit 224 Part 1, # 37 Exhibit 224 Part 2, # 38 Exhibit 225, # 39 Exhibit 226, # 40 Exhibit 227 Part 1, # 41 Exhibit 227 Part 2, # 42 Exhibit 227 Part 3, # 43 Exhibit 227 Part 4, # 44 Exhibit 228, # 45 Exhibit 229, # 46 Exhibit 230, # 47 Exhibit 231, # 48 Exhibit 232, # 49 Exhibit 233, # 50 Exhibit 234, # 51 Exhibit 235, # 52 Exhibit 236, # 53 Exhibit 237, # 54 Exhibit 238, # 55 Exhibit 239, # 56 Exhibit 240, # 57 Exhibit 241, # 58 Exhibit 242, # 59 Exhibit 243, # 60 Exhibit 244, # 61 Exhibit 245, # 62 Exhibit 246, # 63 Exhibit 247, # 64 Exhibit 248, # 65 Exhibit 249, # 66 Exhibit 250, # 67 Exhibit 251, # 68 Exhibit 252, # 69 Exhibit 253, # 70 Exhibit 254, # 71 Exhibit 255, # 72 Exhibit 256, # 73 Exhibit 257, # 74 Exhibit 258, # 75 Exhibit 259, # 76 Exhibit 260, # 77 Exhibit 261, # 78 Exhibit 262, # 79 Exhibit 263, # 80 Exhibit 264, # 81 Exhibit 265, # 82 Exhibit 266, # 83 Exhibit 267, # 84 Exhibit 268, # 85 Exhibit 269, # 86 Exhibit 270, # 87 Exhibit 271, # 88 Exhibit 272 Part 1, # 89 Exhibit 272-2, # 90 Exhibit 272 Part 3, # 91 Exhibit 272 Part 4, # 92 Exhibit 272 Part 5, # 93 Exhibit 272 Part 6, # 94 Exhibit 272 Part 7, # 95 Exhibit 272 Part 8, # 96 Exhibit 272 Part 9, # 97 Exhibit 272 Part 10, # 98 Exhibit 272 Part 11, # 99 Exhibit 272 Part 12, # 100 Exhibit 272 Part 13, # 101 Exhibit 272 Part 14, # 102 Exhibit 272 Part 15, # 103 Exhibit 272 Part 16, # 104 Exhibit 272 Part 17, # 105 Exhibit 272 Part 18, # 106 Exhibit 272 Part 19, # 107 Exhibit 273, # 108 Exhibit 274, # 109 Exhibit 275, # 110 Exhibit 276, # 111 Exhibit 277, # 112 Exhibit 278, # 113 Exhibit 279, # 114 Exhibit 280, # 115 Exhibit 281, # 116 Exhibit 282, # 117 Exhibit 283, # 118 Exhibit 284, # 119 Exhibit 285, # 120 Exhibit 286, # 121 Exhibit 287, # 122 Exhibit 288, # 123 Exhibit 289, # 124 Exhibit 290, # 125 Exhibit 291, # 126 Exhibit 292, # 127 Exhibit 293, # 128 Exhibit 294, # 129 Exhibit 295, # 130 Exhibit 296, # 131 Exhibit 297, # 132 Exhibit 298, # 133 Exhibit 299, # 134 Exhibit 300, # 135 Exhibit 301, # 136 Exhibit 302, # 137 Exhibit 303, # 138 Exhibit 304, # 139 Exhibit 305, # 140 Exhibit 306, # 141 Exhibit 307, # 142 Exhibit 308, # 143 Exhibit 309, # 144 Exhibit 310, # 145 Exhibit 311, # 146 Exhibit 312, # 147 Exhibit 313, # 148 Exhibit 314, # 149 Exhibit 315, # 150 Exhibit 316, # 151 Exhibit 317, # 152 Exhibit 318, # 153 Exhibit 319, # 154 Exhibit 320, # 155 Exhibit 321, # 156 Exhibit 322, # 157 Exhibit 323, # 158 Exhibit 324, # 159 Exhibit 325, # 160 Exhibit 326, # 161 Exhibit 327, # 162 Exhibit 328, # 163 Exhibit 329, # 164 Exhibit 330, # 165 Exhibit 331, # 166 Exhibit 332, # 167 Exhibit 333 Part 1, # 168 Exhibit 333 Part 2, # 169 Exhibit 334, # 170 Exhibit 335, # 171 Exhibit 336, # 172 Exhibit 337, # 173 Exhibit 338)(Figueira, Elizabeth)

Page
UNITED FOR VIACOM THE STATES DISTRICT DISTRICT OF COURT NEW YORK

SOUTHERN

INC. COMEDY COUNTRY MUSIC PARTNERS TELEVISION INC. PARAMOUNT and BLACK PICTURES CORPORATION
ENTERTAINMENT TELEVISION

INTERNATIONAL

LLC

Plaintiffs
vs. NO.

07-CV-2103

YOUTUBE
and

GOOGLE

INC. YOUTUBE INC.

LLC

Defendants.

THE

FOOTBALL

ASSOCIATION

PREMIER

LEAGUE BOURNE LIMITED of themselves on behalf others similarly

CO.
and

et

al

all

situated Plaintiffs

vs.

NO.

07-CV-3582

YOUTUBE GOOGLE

INC. INC.

YOUTUBE

LLC

and

Defendants.

30b

VIDEOTAPED SAN

DEPOSITION

OF

STORM

DUNCAN

CALIFORNIA FRANCISCO WEDNESDAY JULY 16 2008

BY
CSR JOB

ANDREA LICENSE
NO.

M.

IGNACIO
9830

HOWARD

CSR

RPR

CLR

NO.

15373

DAVID
450

Seventh

Avenue

FELDMAN Ste 2803

WORLDWIDE
New

INC. 10123

York

NY

212705-8585

BeflcSO8MaOS-4a77-add7-6ef7c2deaSa6

Page

87

115536 115539 115540 115543 115547 115550 115602 115604 115607 115609 115611 115611 115618 115622 115629 115633 115636 115639 115641 115645 115647 115648 115653 115658 115700
10

MR.

VOLKNER WITNESS
of the
of

And
No.

renew
The

that way the be

objection. read gross 189 than me

THE
63

it

ts
So 424
63.

percent

net the

total
total

not

total.

the

percentage would
MR.

would

over the step of

which

be

smaller

percentage
Okay. Let

HOHENGARTEN
the
is

back.

As

corporate
your

representative
of

Credit

Suisse

what

understanding
to

the

purpose

of

provdng
MR.

ths nformaton
VOLKNER

Credt
to

Suisse
form
of

Objecton

the

the

11

queston.
THE that
--

12

WITNESS
is

This

is

more
to

information
us

13

that

being
we

provided
just

coincident
in

with
11

14

think
help us

with what
facilitate or the

discussed

Exhibit

to

15

doing
financial
of

some

modeling

around

the then

16

valuation
the

performance

first and

17

valuation
MR.

second

YouTube.
Q.

18

HOHENGARTEN
down

And
on

its
YouTube

--

one

way

19

of

breaking

video

content

into

20

categories
Yes.

correct

21

22

And
the be

its
to

relevant

to these

the

valuation

insofar

as

23

ability different
That

monetize

different

categories

may

24

correct
is

25

one

way

they

could

be

differentiated

DAVID
450

Seventh

Avenue

FELDMAN Ste 2803

WORLDWIDE
New

INC. 10123

York

NY

212705-8585

BeflcSO8-0a03-4a77-add7-6ef7c2deaSa6

Page

88

115704 115704 115708 115713 115718 115721 115722 115725 115725 115727 115728 115729 115731 115733 115734 115735 115737 115737 115738 115740 115741 115743 115751 115753 115758
10

yes. Do you

know

whether
get

your but
at

final this

valuation

models fact

which you
to

well

to

point

whether

differentated
the

between monetize
easier
in

these

categories

accordng
It

ability to probably
have that be

them
to answer
of me.

would

that

queston

when
Okay. You want

stuff

front

me

to

guess
you
to

No
Okay. But though you on
--

dont

want

guess.

11

12

but

having
be able

worked
to give now.

on me

this
--

project
an

13

might you

answer

14

based

what Okay.
MR.

know

right

15

Yeah.

16

VOLKNER
--

Im

going

to

object

to

the

form

17

of

this

question
THE
MR.

18

WITNESS VOLKNER

Okay.
--

19

to

the

extent

theres

20

question

pending.
MR.

21

HOHENGARTEN
actually. can

Well
read in but

it

was

my

original

22

question
Do

it.

23

you

know

whether
get

your
at

final this

valuation

24

models
in

which you

well

to

point

whether

25

fact

differentiated

between

these

categories

DAVID
450

Seventh

Avenue

FELDMAN Ste 2803

WORLDWIDE
New

INC. 10123

York

NY

212705-8585

BeflcSO8-0a03-4a77-add7-6ef7c2deaSa6

Page

89

115801 115806 115808 115812 115813 115815 115816 115817 115819 115819 115819 115822 115825 115827 115828 115829 115830 115836 115836 115840 115845 115847 115847 115855 115859
10

according

to MR.

the

ability

to

monetize
to

them
the

VOLKP4ER

Im

going

renew

objection. THE

WITNESS
wait

Thank
until we

you. get to

Lets Ill give you
MR.

those

and

then

better

answer.
Q. --

HOHENGARTEN though

Lets walk through

the

breakdown

here

Sure.
--

still.

11

We to go

started
it

to

talk

about

it

but

want
to

to

try

12

through
that

little the

more niethodically information

make being

13

sure

understand
here.

thats

14

supplied

15

Okay.

16

There
total and
it

is

--

the

first

line

gives

gross

17

says

TT424Ir

correct

18

Thats
In

correct.

19

parenthesis
it

and

you

mentioned
123 that

this

in

20

prior answer

says

Includes

arent valid

21

tJRLs

correct

22

Thats correct
Do My
it

also.

23

you

understand
of the

what
the

the 424

424
is

refers
that

to
--

24

recollection
the top of

its

25

says

at

e-mail

Some

manual

DAVID
450

Seventh

Avenue

FELDMAN Ste 2803

WORLDWIDE
New

INC. 10123

York

NY

212705-8585

BeflcSO8-0a03-4a77-add7-6ef7c2deaSa6

Page

90

115902 115907 115910 115916 115919 115925 115927 115930 115936 115938 115942 115946 115949 115952 115955 115958 115959 120003 120007 120013 120013 120014 120018 120020 120021
10

analyss we
Google number that and folks of 424
--

did
had

was

that

it

was

study you

that

the

performed

studying
or they chosen had

know
and chosen

randomly
is

generated
that

vdeos
randomly
these

the were

number
able to

and

categorize

with

subcategorizations.
Okay.

And
do

the

includes

123

that the

arent
of

valid
that

URLs

you

understand

what

meaning

would technology
assume that put

assume

--

dont
well point of

know

YouTubes
but

11

underpnnings
meant up but
at

enough
there looks on

would
video that
car

12

one
it

was
as

13

had been
click no be on

and

kind

though that

you

14

it

when you
so

click no

it

video
That

is

15

longer my

there

its

longer

valid.

would

16

understanding.

17

And
that gross
is

that

number
URLs

is

subtracted
--

from

--

the from of

123

18

arent
total

valid
to

are

are total

subtracted
of

the

19

provide

net

videos

301

20

that

correct Thats
And
correct. that net
as

21

22

then

total 100

of

301

videos for

thats
of

23

regard the

--

that

treated

percent

purposes

24

analysis

right
correct
yes.

25

Thats

DAVID
450

Seventh

Avenue

FELDMAN Ste 2803

WORLDWIDE
New

INC. 10123

York

NY

212705-8585

BeflcSO8-0a03-4a77-add7-6ef7c2deaSa6

Page

91

120022 120026 120029 120037 120040 120040 120041 120043 120044 120046 120046 120048 120053 120055 120058 120103 120108 120112 120115 120117 120137 120137 120104 120105 120111
10

And
The

then

thats
is

divided

into

two

categories. second means

frst

category
is

called

No

and

the

category

called

rlpram/gemT

which

believe

premium/removed
Yes.
MR.

correct

VOLKNER

Object

to

the

form

of

the

queston.
MR.

HOHENGARTEN

Q.

The

first

category

is

No
11

correct
Yes.

And

the

second

category

is

labeled

here

12

Prem/rem

correct
actually below
just two upon labelings. that to say
So

13

Theres
definition
means down

the
it

14

expands

that

15

premium/removed.
Okay.

16

And

that
is

category
63

of

premium/removed
the net total of

17

under videos

this

analysis

percent

of

18

sampled
MR.

correct
Objection
to the form
of

19

VOLKNER

the

20

question.

21

whereupon
follows
riQuestion

record

read

by

the

Reporter

as

22

23

Okay.

And under

that this total

category analysis
of

of
is

24

premium/removed
63

25

percent

of

the

net

videos

DAVID
450

Seventh

Avenue

FELDMAN Ste 2803

WORLDWIDE
New

INC. 10123

York

NY

212705-8585

BeflcSO8-0a03-4a77-add7-6ef7c2deaSa6