The Football Association Premier League Limited et al v. Youtube, Inc. et al

Filing 276

DECLARATION of Elizabeth Anne Figueira, Esq. in Opposition re: 167 MOTION for Summary Judgment.. Document filed by The Music Force LLC, Cal IV Entertainment, LLC, Cherry Lane Music Publishing Company, Inc., The Football Association Premier League Limited, Robert Tur, National Music Publishers' Association, The Rodgers & Hammerstein Organization, Edward B. Marks Music Company, Freddy Bienstock Music Company, Alley Music Corporation, X-Ray Dog Music, Inc., Federation Francaise De Tennis, The Scottish Premier League Limited, The Music Force Media Group LLC, Sin-Drome Records, Ltd., Murbo Music Publishing, Inc., Stage Three Music (US), Inc., Bourne Co.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 189, # 2 Exhibit 190, # 3 Exhibit 191, # 4 Exhibit 192, # 5 Exhibit 193, # 6 Exhibit 194, # 7 Exhibit 195, # 8 Exhibit 196, # 9 Exhibit 197, # 10 Exhibit 198, # 11 Exhibit 199, # 12 Exhibit 200, # 13 Exhibit 201, # 14 Exhibit 202, # 15 Exhibit 203, # 16 Exhibit 204, # 17 Exhibit 205, # 18 Exhibit 206, # 19 Exhibit 207, # 20 Exhibit 208, # 21 Exhibit 209, # 22 Exhibit 210, # 23 Exhibit 211, # 24 Exhibit 212, # 25 Exhibit 213, # 26 Exhibit 214, # 27 Exhibit 215, # 28 Exhibit 216, # 29 Exhibit 217, # 30 Exhibit 218, # 31 Exhibit 219, # 32 Exhibit 220, # 33 Exhibit 221, # 34 Exhibit 222, # 35 Exhibit 223, # 36 Exhibit 224 Part 1, # 37 Exhibit 224 Part 2, # 38 Exhibit 225, # 39 Exhibit 226, # 40 Exhibit 227 Part 1, # 41 Exhibit 227 Part 2, # 42 Exhibit 227 Part 3, # 43 Exhibit 227 Part 4, # 44 Exhibit 228, # 45 Exhibit 229, # 46 Exhibit 230, # 47 Exhibit 231, # 48 Exhibit 232, # 49 Exhibit 233, # 50 Exhibit 234, # 51 Exhibit 235, # 52 Exhibit 236, # 53 Exhibit 237, # 54 Exhibit 238, # 55 Exhibit 239, # 56 Exhibit 240, # 57 Exhibit 241, # 58 Exhibit 242, # 59 Exhibit 243, # 60 Exhibit 244, # 61 Exhibit 245, # 62 Exhibit 246, # 63 Exhibit 247, # 64 Exhibit 248, # 65 Exhibit 249, # 66 Exhibit 250, # 67 Exhibit 251, # 68 Exhibit 252, # 69 Exhibit 253, # 70 Exhibit 254, # 71 Exhibit 255, # 72 Exhibit 256, # 73 Exhibit 257, # 74 Exhibit 258, # 75 Exhibit 259, # 76 Exhibit 260, # 77 Exhibit 261, # 78 Exhibit 262, # 79 Exhibit 263, # 80 Exhibit 264, # 81 Exhibit 265, # 82 Exhibit 266, # 83 Exhibit 267, # 84 Exhibit 268, # 85 Exhibit 269, # 86 Exhibit 270, # 87 Exhibit 271, # 88 Exhibit 272 Part 1, # 89 Exhibit 272-2, # 90 Exhibit 272 Part 3, # 91 Exhibit 272 Part 4, # 92 Exhibit 272 Part 5, # 93 Exhibit 272 Part 6, # 94 Exhibit 272 Part 7, # 95 Exhibit 272 Part 8, # 96 Exhibit 272 Part 9, # 97 Exhibit 272 Part 10, # 98 Exhibit 272 Part 11, # 99 Exhibit 272 Part 12, # 100 Exhibit 272 Part 13, # 101 Exhibit 272 Part 14, # 102 Exhibit 272 Part 15, # 103 Exhibit 272 Part 16, # 104 Exhibit 272 Part 17, # 105 Exhibit 272 Part 18, # 106 Exhibit 272 Part 19, # 107 Exhibit 273, # 108 Exhibit 274, # 109 Exhibit 275, # 110 Exhibit 276, # 111 Exhibit 277, # 112 Exhibit 278, # 113 Exhibit 279, # 114 Exhibit 280, # 115 Exhibit 281, # 116 Exhibit 282, # 117 Exhibit 283, # 118 Exhibit 284, # 119 Exhibit 285, # 120 Exhibit 286, # 121 Exhibit 287, # 122 Exhibit 288, # 123 Exhibit 289, # 124 Exhibit 290, # 125 Exhibit 291, # 126 Exhibit 292, # 127 Exhibit 293, # 128 Exhibit 294, # 129 Exhibit 295, # 130 Exhibit 296, # 131 Exhibit 297, # 132 Exhibit 298, # 133 Exhibit 299, # 134 Exhibit 300, # 135 Exhibit 301, # 136 Exhibit 302, # 137 Exhibit 303, # 138 Exhibit 304, # 139 Exhibit 305, # 140 Exhibit 306, # 141 Exhibit 307, # 142 Exhibit 308, # 143 Exhibit 309, # 144 Exhibit 310, # 145 Exhibit 311, # 146 Exhibit 312, # 147 Exhibit 313, # 148 Exhibit 314, # 149 Exhibit 315, # 150 Exhibit 316, # 151 Exhibit 317, # 152 Exhibit 318, # 153 Exhibit 319, # 154 Exhibit 320, # 155 Exhibit 321, # 156 Exhibit 322, # 157 Exhibit 323, # 158 Exhibit 324, # 159 Exhibit 325, # 160 Exhibit 326, # 161 Exhibit 327, # 162 Exhibit 328, # 163 Exhibit 329, # 164 Exhibit 330, # 165 Exhibit 331, # 166 Exhibit 332, # 167 Exhibit 333 Part 1, # 168 Exhibit 333 Part 2, # 169 Exhibit 334, # 170 Exhibit 335, # 171 Exhibit 336, # 172 Exhibit 337, # 173 Exhibit 338)(Figueira, Elizabeth)

PETER

CHANE

HIGHLY

CONFIDENTIAL

Page
UNITED SOUTHERN STATES DISTRICT OF COURT NEW YORK

DISTRICT

INTERNATIONAL INC. COMEDY COUNTRY MUSIC PARTNERS PARAMOUNT TELEVISION INC. PICTURES and BLACK CORPORATION ENTERTAINMENT TELEVISION LLC
VIACOM

Plaintiffs
vs. No.

07-CV-2103

YOUTUEE INC. YOUTUEE and GOOGLE INC.
Defendants.

LLC

THE FOOTBALL ASSOCIATION PREMIER BOURNE et LEAGUE LIMITED CO. on behalf of themselves and al others similarly situated

al.

Plaintiffs
vs. No.

07-CV-3582

YOUTUBE INC. YOUTUBE and 0000LE INC.
Defendants.

LLJC

HIGHLY

CONFIDENTIAL CHANE

VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF PETER PALO ALTO CALIFORNIA

WEDNESDAY
JOB
NO.

DECEMBER

2009

18308

Figueir 281

Deci.

Thb

-a

DAVID
450

Seventh

Avenue

FELDMAN WORLDWIDE Ste 2803 New York NY

INC. 10123

212705-8585

elebBO5c-a35a-4be9-ac4B-48248a50ece4

PALO

AJIJTO

CA
One and have

PETER
one

CHANE

DECEMBER

2009

100748 100750 100754 100755 100757 100759 100831 100832
13

A.

half

days.

Q.

And

you

ever

testified before

under

oath
A.

No
Do

have

not. take not

Q.

you of

it

youve

testified

then

in

court have

law

before

A.

not.

Q.

And

youve

never

testified

at

deposition

100834 100835 100837 100839 100811 100815 100817 100819 100821 100824 100832 100833 100837 100847 100852

before
A.

11

have

not

testified at

deposition

12

before.

13

Q.

And why

since

is

there in the the

any

reason
to

youre
give

14

aware

of best

you

are

not

position

15

your

testimony believe

today

to

jury
to

16

A.

Im

in

position

give

my

17

best

best

testimony when
that you was

today.

18

Q.

Now
said

joined
in

Google

seven

years did you

19

ago join

you

2001

2002

When

23

21

A.

joined And
were
at

Google time

in of

January
the

of

2003. of unit

22

Q.

the

creation
the

23

YouTube
known
as

you

involved

with

business

24

Google MR.

Video
INGRER
Objection. lacks foundation.

25

100856

PALO

AIJTO

CA
THE

PETER

CHANE was

DECEMBER
involved.

2009

100858 100931 100934 100935 100939 100910 100914 100915
13

WITNESS
when YouTube

dont

know BY

exactly

started.

MR.

BASKIN
In

Q.

2005

and

2006

were

you

employed

by

Google
A.

Video
was

employed

by

Google

Incorporated

at

that

Lime.

Q.

Axid

were

you

assigned

to

the

business unit

100917 100919 100921 100922 100925 100925 100928 100929 100929 100931 100935

known

as

Google

Video
on

11

A.

worked

project

known

as

Google

12

Video.

13

Q.

And

were

you

senior

management

of

that

14

project
MR. THE BY MR.

15

INGEER WITNESS

Object

to

form. not.

Vague.

16

No

was

17

BASKIN
Who was the senior was

18

Q.

manager
the senior

19

A.

Susan
Video.

Wojcicki

manager

of

23

Google

21

100936
100940 100944 100945 100950
known

Q.

And

how

many

people
in and

worked around

on 2005

this and

project

22

as

Google

Video

2006

23

A.

dont
And
was she

recall. direct not.

24

Q.

your was

report

Miss

Wojcicki

25

A.

No

10

PALO

AJIJTO

CA

PETER
sne

CHANE Enar.

DECEMBER

2009

100951 100952 100954 100955 100957 101031 101032 101034
13

as
Were

srriKe her direct

you

report

A.

Yes

was.

Q.

So

basically
this

you

were
known

the

second Google

person

responsible

for

project

as

Video

MR. THE fideo MR. team.

INGRER WITNESS

Objection. was

Form.

member

of

the

Google

101035 101035 101037 101038 101010 101014 101017 101018 101020 101021 101022 101025

BY

BASKIN
Mid
do you recall

11

Q.

officially

what

your

12

title

was
A.

13

My title
l4rid

was

business people

product

manager.
as

14

Q.

how

many

did you

manage

15

Dusiness

product
Zero.

manager

16

A.

17

Q.

So

it

was

just

you

You

were

the

sole

18

jusinss
A.

project
Yes.

manager

19

23

Q.

Mid
you The

what

was

business

project

manager

21

Vhat

did

do
terra is

22

101026
101028 101034 101041
was

A.

business
the

product
of the

manager
product build

and and

23

responsible
to

for

vision

24

responsible
roduct.

work

with

engineering

to

the

25

48

PALO

AJIJTO

CA
you were

PETER

CRANE about
in

DECEMBER
the

2009

105857 105859 105933 105934 105937 105910 105913 105915
13 10 59 16

time of

that

talking
till

early part
to

the

deposition

now

Were

you

promoted

senior

business product

manager exactly
but guess

A.

dont
changed

recall

was

since

my title.
in your

Q.

Mid

capacity

as

senior to

business

product
A.

manager
No.

did anyone

report

you

then

Q.

Now
the

Im

interested
4.

in the of

email

in

the

11

105921 105931 105937 105944 105951 105957 105958 105958 110030 110033 110037 110038 110010 110013 110024

middle of
that
in

Exhibit

First

all

youll 2006
at

see

12

the

email

dated

January
were

15th

13

229
Mr.

p.m.

on

Sunday
at

you

explaining

to

14

Rosenberg

least
for

Google

Videos

zero

15

tolerance

policy
Do

copyrighted

content.

16

you see he in

see that.

that

17

A.

18

Q.

lAnd

tells the

you

in

the

immediately
above that that

19

preceding
agree

--

e-mail here.

right

23

with

our

policy
see see do

21

Do

you

that
those

sir
words.

22

A.

Yes

23

Q.

Now
recall

you

recall

actually

discus
that

now

24

do

you

discussing had
zero

with Mr. tolerance

Rosenberg policy
for

25

Google

Video

49

PALO

AJIJTO

CA

PETER

CHANE

DECEMBER

2009

110028 110029 110029 110031 110039 110040 110042 110043
13

copyrighted
A.

content

dont
but

recall

specific
sure he Mr.

discussion
was for

with
aware all

Mr. of

Rosenberg
our

Im

Rosenberg

policy
products details

because

was

responsible
of his

Google
to

and
about then

as

matter

work

needed

know

them. in the of that

Q.

Now
at

you

say

course

email

229

p.m.
is

110047 110051 110054 110130 110134 110138 110110 110111 110112 110114 110124 110125 110127 110130 110133 110135
Mr. who that

youtube arent
like

at

an

advantage
that we

because
are of and

they issues

11

the

target They

with
this

12

this.

are on

aware

13

spoke on and

with

them

friday
in order

they get

plan more

14

exploiting
more

this

to

15

traffic.
you see

16

Do

that

Mr.

Chane

17

A.

do

see

that. of

18

Q.

Now

first about

all

in

reporting

to

19

Rosenberg
did you got

YouTubes
on

awareness
at

and

plan
when
--

23

speak this

with

Friday

Youlube

21

you
A.

information
recall. that extent we recall

22

dont
with
So

having

the

one

23

meeting
Q.

YouTube
to

already
you

discussed. were

24

the

that and

accurately
to

25

reporting

Youlubes

policies

practices

50

PALO

AIJTO

CA

PETER
take have
it

CRANE that the

DECEMBER
source Mr. of

2009

110137 110142 110145 110149 110151 110157 110230 110231
13

Mr.

Rosenberg would
this

your or

information
Mr.

been

either

Hurley

Maxcy

at

one

meeting

you

had
lacks

right

sir

MR. calls for

INGRER

Objection

foundation

speculation. THE

WITNESS

Those

are

the

attendees

in

the BY

meeting
MR.

BASKIN
iid
the

110231 110235 110235

Q.

only attendees

in

the

meeting

11

right
A.

12

Thats
Axid

correct.

13

110236
110239 110213 110214

Q.

that

was

your

only meeting
by

with

14

YouTube
A.

prior

to

the

acquisition

Google

correct

15

Thats
l4rid

correct. recall

16

Q.

you

no

phone

call

correct

17

110216
110217 110219 110221

sir
A.

18

recall

no

phone

calls. sit and here

19

Q.

Now

do

you
to

recall you
in

as

you

today
that

23

Chad Hurley
they are

saying
that

nouns an

verbs
as

21

110226
110230 110233 110238 110241

aware

they have
zero

advantage

22

against

Google

Videos
and

tolerance plan
on

policy

for that

23

copyrighted advantage
in

content
order

they

exploiting

24

to

get

more and

more To

traffic
extent
it

25

MR.

INGRER

Objection.

the