Google Inc. v. Traffic Information LLC

Filing 52

Brief Plaintiff's Opening Claim Construction Brief. Filed by Google Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B, # 3 Exhibit C, # 4 Exhibit D, # 5 Exhibit E part1, # 6 Exhibit E part 2, # 7 Exhibit E part 3, # 8 Exhibit E part 4, # 9 Exhibit E part 5, # 10 Exhibit F part 1, # 11 Exhibit F part 2, # 12 Exhibit G, # 13 Exhibit H) (Markley, Julia)

Download PDF
Google Inc. v. Traffic Information LLC Doc. 52 Att. 4 Case 3:09-cv-00642-HU Document 50 Filed A7ft2|fi Page 1 of 2 Page lD#: 662 Julia E. Markley, OSB No. 000791 JMarkley@perkinscoie.com PERKINS COIET-Ip 1120 N.W. Couch Street, Tenth Floor Portland, OR 97209-4128 Telephone: 503.727.2000 Facsimile: 503.727 .2222 Thomas H. Shunk (Ohio BarNo. 0025793) TShunk@.bakerlaw.com (admitted'p ro hac vice) Christina J. Moser (Ohio Bar No. 0074817) cmoser@bakerlaw.com (adm itte-d p r o hac v i c e) BAKER & HOSTETLER LLP 3200 National City Center 1900 East Ninth Street Cleveland, Ohio 441 14-3485 Telephone: 21 6.621 .0200 Facsimile: 21 6.696.07 40 Attornevs for Plaintiff L]NITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF ORECON PORTLAND DIVISION GOOGLE INC., No. CV09-642'HU Plaintifi v. JOINT CLAIM CONSTRUCTION CHART TRAFFIC INFORMATION LLC, Defendant. Pursuant to the Scheduling Order in this case entered April 2 l, 20 I 0 (Docket No. 41); Northern District of California Local Patent Rule 4-3; and this Court's Minute Order of May 4, 14| O JOINT CLAIM CONSTRUCTION CHART 63 -O | 2 4 Perkins Coie llP I120 N.W. Couch Street, Tenth Floor Portland. OR 97209-4128 Phone: 503.727.2000 lt-EG AL 1 86 65 42 5.2 Fax: 503.727.2222 Exhibit D Page 1 of24 Dockets.Justia.com Case 3:09-cv-00642-HU Document 50 Filed A7102110 Page 2 of 2 Page lD#: 663 2010 (Docket No. 43), plaintiff Google Inc. and defendant Traffic Information LLC submit this Joint Claim Construction Chart containing the parties' current constructions of the terms that the parties have identified to be construed in U.S. patent no.6,466,862 and U.S. patent no.6,785,606 as set forth in the attached Exhibit A. Pursuant to Local Rule 1 I -l (d). all parties consent to the electronic signature and filing of this document. DATED: Ju|y 2,2010 /s/ Robert A. Shlachter Robert A. Shlachter. OSB No. 911718 Timothy S. DeJong, OSB No. 940662 Stoll Stoll Berne Lokting & Shlachter P.C. 209 S.W. Oak Street, Fifth Floor Portland, Oregon 97204 Telephone: (503) 227 -l 600 Facsimife: 6A3) 227 -6840 /s/ Julia E. Marklev Julia E. Markley, OSB No. 000791 JMarkl ey@perkinscoie. com Perkins Coier,r,p I 120 N.W. Couch Street, Tenth Floor Portland, OR 97209-4128 Telephone: 503.727 .2000 Facsimile: 503.727 .2222 /s/ Thomas H. Shunk Thomas H. Shunk (Ohio BarNo. 0025793) Christina J. Moser (Ohio Bar No. 0074817) Baker & Hostetler LLP 3200 National City Center 1900 EastNinth Street Cleveland, Ohio 441 14-3485 Telephone: 21 6.621 .0200 Facsimile: 216.696.07 40 /s/ C. Dale Ouisenberry C. Dale Quisenberry John T. Polasek Jeffrey S. David Polasek, Quisenberry & Errington, L.L.P. 6750 West Loop South, Suite 920 Bellaire, Texas 77401 Telephone: (832) 77 8-6000 Facsimile: (832) 77 8-6010 Attorneys for Defendant (admittedpro hac vice) Attorneys for Plaintiff JOINT CLAIM CONSTRUCTION CHART 41 063-01 24 {LEG Perkins Coie llp I120 N.W. Couch Street, Tenth Floor Portland, OR 97 209-4128 Phone: 503.727.2000 ALI 8665425.2 Fax 503.727.2222 Exhibit D Page 2 of 24 *!ii9 .ifr' 1&C qi P^S is f*i Ll S E.tB E5i'i.9 ; ; YA_.OO g-" q U .eqE 3."E 5 eF.? t*i !xE -= ! &ffi] i:;t F- Et* o 3iEE6 F? x* Fqc E ti sEE E >' a HgiE E sil; Eg$EaE (B 3.4, *k \ir (o (o 3$h c. # o o oN N gffi *.1;. # 6 tr ,o =# o o i: o o (5 aE H",gi g sE;sc.n.Y r* (q'= Y tr t .. -r"fi8E11"E 3 = Hi -e E.nIe F: EE a 9t o'tlf, L .O*=d q N F. o ! P tL if."'E *ry, EHET.: F EEdS:I;F ,9Eob.Fb F g'i Eudltrt F E; EE e" Ii:-3i EE E FE S HggE g Fi E sri EgE:I;:FE Ftif T' U ETcgEm SQBs -o t XE= o pL >ooo ? x = i?o ; $F SIloo 8:Ei5 og d .9 HdE:'5e: ; ES g g E F H5'e(ge-CJ.d dE HH HEt g F 6{ :!?oo oxcJ.x;- ;e-b6sgB eEE: F H: o x$sEt FE$fc*E W lf) q) :'.i' t E 3 EF 9.= ii 6 TE Yioi9 st 4; EuF :Yi : 9 ,=ae Y 9*i I "ii5Ea-qEEEga$E o o o o f I X:ii:i oo 3 RO E s o 6 O E: -k c; FEBfi !2 () {) 3P5 F OHi N tif (o <) E EE-q F qcq o 8a$53E o, o o a w ru!"-'1 &:.* ; Sr* O w; ffi'i tr (ffi'r I o 6 X.: w1 E 9.JYEt iY Hdof :F-Id (d. oo 3sb ,1ijjotr Ea boE x @ .;.' .! >,o L4'" o I 4 ,6E9. P9= E J trl V <E E o E . P-i E o HSOoO F&b; i@.a? :F = 9 39 a g Ei.JBE U :oG rE E E ^OO?t Exhibit D Page 3 of 24 :ry.:..:.: :Wilttl e. ${ f,at *:i BI iEEEAEF ffid '; a 8.5:F$g, 9agFgEEtIbst :PgcHge;> E*E:fg' ! Q +d itr e egiTFi0HE.bsa F- ts,E'g y fft.i!; H sii4t jE-}i$* o o E reEE:EgifE tr) (0 F # o o o x o o (L N N o C\I ew 4 o ik, @ ffir s{iq >l do ot) (I IL o ffi; d o N $I ffi Hc9o -.! n :: Eioa -F f - ool E ffii FgSsoj$ tsoE' b : d-sXE *i 9 Y r g, 9t*': h s3 960 6 ,o *..ts E d y E^o E e 4.: OYi k.= ^ Y rO o o E EnE* gE-4, -I+eEfi's* 9.E Y tr- o iI F- o d HTEEE ?;.9 g; * Ei., ;d 9 > v.= =r A t a >rtr L "bo d.= E "*i$aqEg5*r F L # cEf i =d> z ,EEUEEEFEEEE 'alt*sEe?r :EE I 9 .S rffi ri! ?ft g E ro O o itr b0- >l E F 9T o E :t o o :) I Nf ri o * w fgFb"HE: ; iffi! iilti@ igBEs{ f # sgE Ef F F!;5E :'5-Ee.9-ioU g (o o) < I o o) F;*i l) 1 lJ-a k,i$l$ 5:::.':.. o 0) ti.:: d'o !JA :.1 o .= E E ffi a,; ; M b pbi &x e;# ?('"! .xo:f >-t }Y A 5oE hEE . 'E a,Y oi w ffiiri EE.:AI 'O=9e*FH d= h !'= 6 F'E a; 3E g 9 EE :P0'EEH E b ap a i i'= . ; u >,5 E ec E QE fie u x- FEYx x.= TU :3E .dH ?98F9 o o I J i4 o 6 o Exhibit D Page 4of24 :- giE;{ga A FF q E E E:3! gi;J$ Llrdl eE F 3E Ei E (o (o (o # o o oN N (r) o o wo ir!.1* ts w,4 si*i E o) 0fit Q) e r g.eE 6 gi.H E* o o L sfi [q E o ogo .r @ q9;, id.9 HB eb eF o.Y!Ylr a ao" -s N O F. i* :i; F F 9.dE E=33 9.6 d ooo E g o) g3#. iti; >'= Nq dJ gegs; -g; ! frFgEEEE E E g? E SE o rc 3 L '.x t.Y'F'X 4 tr c w Z :- 3 .l:st x E $" "trE3sEg.bs :gE;E FEi () c) ffi F.E ai :tc =*; e 8E " dE *3' E v\r bE o f I N o EiEEE aI E E+E eHiHEHB V/. !d Ao ocOt/ s o I P'f:i 33 c.t G C) o a #r-* f;i'::)ii',U t, ,, $$ Yt4 e4* Slilr,l; o o E Wit"t'i:& S:li:: 'a#," 6. '<a iX (0b0 >:\ :'o w $::* t$ir{# EY o6 aa gd qh 'E= F F .:lx-tr b60g a .o .9) E; ETE6 I. H O.= ; g.EE a,:> X >rd ='v a> O a* J o I ^a gg e,5 Exhibit D Page 5 of 24 i ragc=*e iugs;$" e$fi**ir! EE Br; ris!;s!;:EsEgfig AAiEEE;EEtt'E!FEa FE;SgE"gEEE*E! F W 5HEfiTEgggEEEEg;H ffi fof:i{ i '' HE Ww F- ,9i #g i E lt C) *r (L N N o o, G o ffi W;:e Attt',::; o s o o, o (L N F- f d E.J': ffi W iw U6 ?iE $E=Eftns;ss ! xpi't., *t.,0 g Ee Xd Jao EEe*segc.tif:EEg HiiEE3E;5s;E!E rg:E u; :'Eg E# E! g gE g g'; C HW 5.= ., bt) F KT$E!;gFF;:EHEg nEE trs s Fw ,,,:,:fi I o |r) 0) ;H-q a: t 9@ '-CqY Eg e68.Fi a 65J E = o o l I N :{. .; s& EoE-6uFI o. &i6 -'.=g.aoF g:E ut H q.li E E 'ni:-:* Ya i dF*'-q0 i s O. gE3!EA o.6bI* cd 5 g ,ffi;: i ,M F,= *,;* o o) c.j (t) I 4,1 o tr* &t a?. O .E 9a tr ! g.H a.X FE F -*'l '9ch of.Y= @.irtiB,\ X iE,jr 4 6t EgE6 F qYY o h 9e 6-=' J q J - i;EES llg iE Exhibit D Page 6 of 24 W {sg,: @ (o +i o 0) #i lEs l (L ffi.'..; N N o rO o o- S# :: :'-1 ffi 9;: Hffi1 ,*i oS E9!i;gEi, iE:ausE EF" E E F 6.: E 9d6=.i A:iE FrE 9 trE EA: L ot N (f N *E E* EBrE!Xs o iI 0) sEES'EB imr':':1 e EE 6 t B.a; E E E ti g atri'E E EE I fi6;-;;;g ;EEEE.H iI liE;i s F;E*EE: o..= c !4 x O o E O ro @*& &d E=3o'Ju 3: :k. P :nr'f;a ,or,tla 5.99g E g XE o f I N \f <) O f.fHi :Ee.*6!tFgEi a ' H H& ,, x h-c * s# ]#ff,i? fs i _&,{ e :.gr]. ,i.= EdF5 e o. g b C O. F o {2 g-Eo iEa s dF '.tr s o c"t o (E O 0) $'rli g .l FH., o@ io o o! x6 do I .oox troa J r' ..". =46) r J Y g '{r;::,ffi goo aoo - gE Exhibit D Page 7 of24 J. io ",1 E'l: r EF $eE 3f E+ U 9'E 6 E E g faE;:;1KE*Eg rEE :r s q.lE'I.lot* F Eb --,3s A F,E g{E e4 :.: ru,tffi -o qo o3 Yt:& ad r: !9 UES6.Ei:FE59i q .sE q e e' : E- #SgEEEgE {*EiFE.E6; E ry{ cl) ir o o, (L c\I o o Eq .{0 -E FS i5t* Eg F# 4;ffi I E I fu b0 o 6 Effi E d N q& t4!l}& ok o o_ Hffi la^ re e 6 fi.9c 9 I ol -9 +^6-.q 2 0 aG ll -trEH> k B* .z;* x E c\t o N ffii ffi: *, { iI o) 1r q @ 5E;EEd E a gg E E!;E:FFeEc* 1E= :.! EtirEtei EfisqE F o6Eh!,iF5oEo-c L F93ie s;: H b Es!;H,efrEtE E gE E gE{;E.; '" 9 E E E.9.5 3 3:*'i ffi *Ei; ii o x= o Ejir H r re (c ! o -* hE FE;F6 qEEsEiE;s E:ts. ;E r @ o EE8;t6=ET*bE . sE tu I li 9 #rEFEee.gS od F qx i':fiHEEh'dE; 8f;H.EiEE.Eg E' g q F ,i *E od 6: 5x ; E: xpE - b e E -: g E 8 E 9E: c.Y o ndtr .dh; o E O ;H:E;i5:#*i;rEE Ei g ; g3 * , .ghISdhgEP-e EE g E 3E iEE sE S 5: x =e ; t:d !4 o Rg; d o l I c! \o (r o o o o't g3g:HE3+tEE L# Hffi P...&- !? >d 6: O o Q.F a.d E60 F! d EO o; HO E lt 4l s,e a= d F1ffi o a tr @.: Oq cB (J E gs' 6U d=PA E bI) ,ti g 9'E F *F 9 .= d.E x o @ tsi3 o Fo,g ',5 da o.:5 sh *:'t: fi9sz' :EBg '=i:LG ;;!{)!! .e E n.9 h$ A J q ,eE9;r ;-oJI'E i @= :98 FEBxa P E F 55 E 8; eii ti.g 3 JFEFO: 9 I Exhibit D Page 8 of 24 ,Ef ;3gE E E M 'i9-^*EFE *k $TfiEEE$ ffi E,E !r f E,gs': .bX 6 .E 9, i5 A '>' s oJ g b0 H.ffi lg il# :,: *r*i* r EEigAFiEfiE flfi[gsrHss 6 .vo oo o3 a6 O F(o i.:' o oN N F(tt TL w t::,: ffi"li && O ffi w ,l 6 d 6 g b0 o E X' (', c) t d ;e ,w O o o c-d?aE; a dd5iFo s F o O C\ i# ol o! e ,ti i1ffi i'::'i"1 O -. N g tL z 3:gEE, g E g s q.-e HE k F E; up;rH d= gtr o0c-cq: ,-39!EPE.E 5 +t;t FE IC * E:E-E. bE F#F;F5 gE+gEZEAE B E E F Ee s g F L ig g!issiEF 5 B(2X F an qtE;rsE E EE E. EE g o ro o C. :aa-. EEA 'o.b - ffi1 o () o l I N s (o O <I) x.9 I d Rg,E o; OP 3 j :'io tr;o s o o oE 6C, d60 F d =o i'& is* lti'w trrS 6) Q cf) o o :':: w, e rg i ?g.5 g; -eE , ;E H g; i gE!; gEFg;E;E$E a 3EEE '=vo OtZ I -H ei a .i EIEHEEFFEgB; 6"FE o e.E t d! b 8.9 E-> * Sr J I J -3o 6 Lo 9 .i o + 5'd Exhibit D Page I of 24 J o o H E J)o 6; ad F ,!o q)6 oo O5 N (o # o o_ E a s F r o E N N @ o I do d o o O I'I 6,:: u I 6 hE= ! lrt : .e3 66 oo. I c;o'i x4 I H 6.tr PE: ;' 3.E 5 -.e bt6 9?t'i 3tlg oi -tlEE 5 ol u Fl* 6t F tv oX ol 3 ir- r e E*r c E 15: b Edi l'^o q N o F- o iI I -iBr A OOCO h.5 E Fq -!l o 4"L,= sf; Fbu a::)::ffii F ESBE: liEEPE E ;i Sx .E3E! j- o F. troo . c) :re6 Fti'ii " F 5 iH zl ol ol oH g 5E;EEf EeR EE JOC L c) rr) (D c o F qee E ffi e;EictE=E ffi al,;Sl F ., *E o .!.Y 6 -:Y #*J:eggT*EesTi a I 3[E ;iEE A -d ! o f I N (o gEEIHEEEF EE4tei{H; EiEiaF;* gg:SXEErH;EF EgEEs;gE83 'b1r=3*3q8!E Ei ': i5 :3 eH-= EF E r-si;gEsEsEEF .E O I EeE"vi;Ot>!.9.- yi : :.b C:a E o o, (f) 9 o o o o o s ::w:4 D ::&iaaaaal rl; o 6 trXo @tri i: r o oi tro 9c o < tr d k O I I a 'ffi,|, 6 F! F trg gE g 5.:,= g xE 6 >,": o.5 oCarG alO E'B . o ? o .. (! qo s : 'a'a OH di FX EE TF bx I =' Exhibit D Page 10 of24 ,it'': @ ;-t tS'/i 63 r oo r^= N F- # o o) 6 iry o. -qd o L Nt (\ tr d o) q) doPo q o,= 9= >' .i dJ 'do -e6. IL o 0{ 3# eso :_ r F 'E d 6s o N F(f ! .ri :JqE Y {;.1 'ffi >i6E o bot e 8'E :X F.=.S :E tr c F =;1i E Ij,Yq P tL <;3i eY EE9 ro o -R3.-E *F Ea gr r Eg t gi q Ag 3 tEe5 r EE E', E ,:k.i H EHEE.: F,,et -a ,. Pts 6 - 5 -'E ' -E.E.s e e F: HE U T' Ei E s-B'i qb I -0 g fio10 z o.= .!='= -E a >l u p.pi OG aE Ao trbo - 3- x 0 kr.= _9 9 F E X boE sdO @b aE .= !l YO6 'Xtts tr o tr l:.Ycr '=.Y'F'd ; E E <;.gE 4reY t HX YO6 I t:ll i:68 I e 3E. o E ;qtEEe o ) I N <i u-,:5i s e! E a;f oof g eaido, oExB 5E o g o!\J Fi Y E3 C:.d va 9 E >. E.=-i<6 YloFF e FoY TE H A ?i!EEE EIFA;e Bz ;E a6EHB o # E 5o o O) -<? Q) .n U' fit o o u o q E=d .-Y 'i > h0 tro!l o x a! -o.= F :59D^ HtE9" tb P o o o v 6,ts E EEF 6 >.: hX!?'6 6o 33Y, -Seh X: Et x.;6 E x.eE EFc o o -.: .. o.r -9Hd t*ta=l sF 3s 3':T"EFH og Epii E .H 6.5EgBE -'g0 Fo -o 9i xq q J 9E E; $ E a >rg'; _<!9= fiE - !OOO N Hg oo E}{$gE oi Exhibit D Page 11 of24 a eErlri 6 o o o o o 0 o a o && ry al'. a.i q-o liii&, od a Ft* Ps o o oN N s.C Lffi. FT' Htr Effi E g o o E E o e o o (', (L o r q a L o .-: 0 0 oo c. b> ax @6 :o 96 0i o,i o c{ F- E ( o gd ga bt) atr o i.r- F L o: N z YOG 93 o.H,i X:E: x: x r 9E 9.= 2 ffi qi.isS o) rf c) I w t-: gH {) sri o o l I N s 4E H# iiti.. pffi, !{*, tf.,:::. t o o) <'t () o a (5 .i I J iegsE gE g 3 EaEE Exhibit D Page 12of24 i:l'l:::j sl ? o F E! oi 6 -$)@ a d d G o'. o:i o o o O a 'ai ,ffii .d o EFqb J FO a 6:...Y 6 F .5.= E 5 o oio c .9.g d a>!3 0 =3 O d g :+t o o, fit fL c) ffiE -ss .:t!;r o d n 6 H&ffi g: : 6 c! C\l I !E ffis o o_ *ffiaeii o, (E #l F: ''&ds o, t 6 oo q> R.. r 9,q 5 *'E 5 6 !;j5S-p. 85 . 6t 'oh o ! oh ,g ; ",g e v Ye o I YIF EL EE5I d X'6 i .) a F'3 EEt.i -Y G c 05 o ?T F 69 c I a!q >l 39 I N F- i:q ., 6 6 ,YaF q=x N :Y,9 ffi:: d 60 iI .t o 3 t'o ( z JC TEE:,'l:! E E;fic:!E*EEg F 9o"9 .i: X fi 3,5 Sts 3 g c: [9a : XI : iii br .4 3* A (tx>* F,tr o s 6 -^6. E eExss ts s Fb .",9ts.)trI r i.s.i i6 I oE'! - ox"oo atl a y9 !) 9'- oFly :lFod '1:5c5 tr gE I g'i -a 2 Ha-o;t; EXHfr !){= \| o rr, o E ; F:E fT l:g PE6 6 U i ooi >' i,Ec . gE*" - o f I N !f (0 O O I () t# i::,:.:l: u% E EE:' * *t L o v_.j o E 3:" E; i:-E;EF-93 E 5 >b9 r.9;oii e f gEE E 5 1* i;gia*ce E 3+.; qi : ;a "E e3E;BE*E I d g o, c"i (E I o o o G 'ff:i ffi:t,a 6 o &i ..W,1 i *,,,: o iif&:t; ;H 6 i.: -fY;i eS 6E il :{$,5 g EEE,'. htSEyE* ' .i I J b:Ee{E agEEe! ;TF'{ 3:i:8383 g@:,, *&,! 3 EE: og;tEga Exhibit D Page 13of24 EE r:a:i: q .r.wi s# F'.4 +t 0) FFI o (L N N N 8ffi f,E FE o) (U E F= glt:::::4. o o_ . -?"rE -sEsEn;; &s fqfliw 8#.* Et.EeE:iE; I HE Eer s i ;E. is EJH-* f :. Ef fr.859 .- aE O d* .: Y ^.= a N F- g tL 1r) ffi'a N (o s, EEIf Fsn E gE i sEE;'EbS! EE Ea '!E?9 '56;; * a 3.Fi tH; F 8"8 EE:3EEgi a.=a oa?dLoAAg aE! e:*+t ; Fb E;{gEFEE *g "aE EE 3'g E;SB ;isEsgAEOE A c-t c) ro o = o 9t b F,9 e o l I N v ='e.*ctHE S UE dEeEi H F=. H b x h_d ts o" g;E , i"gE.6F5 9 O, 6C F.= o <"t 0) ya 3 oob a sffi i_: o Effi n-i $iw o o 's .9 o xF h1, =^ f,ffi g :i:i I i.3 xP oo hq W ffis* g EryEEEbg E E ET* m F6h >;; .i o J E J -EE;:IFJg 3q ABgIH P"hiE*i F x l; S hp I3E - i; H I iEi :XEoI o H,H3 Fn3Eg >3 . ";:;Y9o-ts ' EEBr Exhibit D Page 14 of 24 w o F b0 o w k"r ."o oo o! v)B tr # a (L N N c.) o F 5o b0 o o, ulf;, : l s,i i d :q;l L O ot) (I o qa! KX* W i:lw illW = -pE3gr.E EqbEgha;.giH -sePE ebg 9 B E Ei5 i i'i{e li E o 6E .Eo *$ft:$;: ggE E f,EEi o h ol c{ o t\ :{E E.E.E i 9,e; l;[{ Eg g F ,, *! ,4EF;Se : ED6 E 5= ; :zo ! ^o bo s . ios t rb0 bo* ooH g flw lL(o N (o 'tEtH.F5!"=8'-ts i*.EPEu li EIo tr . ilU q " EeggEgEF gr ** g.Egi 5 E*{*:EEH k *c) dE -d9 vd; o riF F L x sg E *Et u ="" i s o' - -o) o) rr o o o f I N $ (o O I O) c", FTI ;.5 5: oxo d.x I 9?6tr eE o ?? o b| -c ; EtEc$a*3sE Ehlt 6ry9 -o _;! X.9 c ffiw ,:.1:i:: E"ES$;qi:E; gFE:s g;$E a vo x =e ; i:-o Mi'e* s 8: a."" aa c t) 2 F.e I .qY, . co 5i;Ji YXs aaaca !.=.: !Jxg o !,o Edo o o o (E I" l,ll#;,,:,,,,: *-o* :,i,*,,.. 1,fffitrri 98 Q.,"o H#3 Kefie q g:t*i"6.*! H6g! ^o 9 E v-.: B+E;aiEb i aU r :E F EEEEf'8; U :T;E E;EE o* H-oS i 9.; a 5 i;g: i; 6' i,i h tHoo c:-o c !) v,^oH f; i e':tr F H.5 -i'5 *'5xihX,9 x o rco:?'E o-:: o,, Y .d o-C F ovx-Y E AUH e *E :>:bE E .:* b9) 6H o6J J 5 ? I :bsE E Eg E Exhibit D Page 15 of 24 *ilirn eg gd;g &'s &E d o o o d xc) od E o v) d) o o a o q)d-d o ; ,it o r 'EE o ([ w) ct& o o ;t g t1f' W o o q N N *: :* o :),l#l:tt:ta F s o o- ot, (I Wl ffi* I 4) o-i 46 ; g 'e@4" ffe i g" sgt*6 rh:. * .:l *:ffi o d :Eo I o g N c) F(> O I .L ffi FK:.ry e o 'Ed .6 !l oo0 t.s O!Q 'E o.k,i ob:s 3QBg a st. xG=o u >ooo I = ; - 6'.= E t? 5 H o+ gF Fa E o ii 9: S av'7i d 9oo 9E 9y> Ec,EEEE" i sE$ $gk E 4 E,E qH ie T r 9 - .9 o 'x.= xa .9 oo z*F*iT3r E=qYhn'"'5:H; I ctr> h 9.E q oG C I.LN I tr) z FH: o dp ffi #s !**,6 o o o -9 90 E E;.9 :gEE E!R o E* e E "e-s q 9s 3oE 38 E ii,5 r. EEf;:fl$E o 6 o F 6 o g g$ E E E.E E F 3'" 3E d I r S Fr H+ !o o'= s o- . ;FE*9H; ...E ri a*; rU- l f I N S., t&* :,::... Tg{=sP 5();0bc;*E'; !2 -q HP5 F O+ \r o o EA$5EE s 3E ; EZspEE lEr6; E9!r:DEHE" Efg d: fi I 5.E:t g gEE g f E fi o e&i'r * m; i:.' '#1.& r=v;a I ? h.FpE F tr != d qd #w i ffi i'.i E::!FEE ;:a* *"&,; e+ii:s f'P J 18H5,"9pE ,9 ii c E E.E r J ,-#.l ,#l I* F,c,g F E IEE 5E Exhibit D Page 16of24 itti! ili iillii i.:,.! o (q o E ,9> os :=o od u) -a q Po oo a3 ?)d +i O c q), E o F o o E !3 (L N N (s tr) o, (L G 0) o N F- 5! "J + a6! Q: o eo ^. 'E ad od t T Eg$ Egtfi i 4 F.E ss ig EcEE" { r 9 or .2 o x.r '=a ii(g e * s' qt .rf.g3, 6 Ap. " g^ x E 9tr io .ooo E(! F h.s iIo . F I 0) ffi G-:. oQ L EY XE a F c9> F Zf9Eo$-;H!E E EF o .' . Eq :o,i dt> g h 9^E giEE tr o rWtt:itt:ii z x:x (o EgeEEB+i o E.gs HE;E ; FXsgR 0.6 :''- oljo o E tr - Eir E !g o'= o oe{ TgHE '= _Y'='*l! 91 '= Fi ::E *cy9 FE ro o o o o i;Es ei E H *.8' W P"E rE'a* 1 -T: f I p'ffi K-g st Hgr*;s E;!HEFEE g 3EfE* #gEE s# g EE*EEEB q+E N v I*iE;6; EiiF a6 E HE oz 5o o o) %ffi If) c O :!?.-*s frq,s t _; o iffi ffi: d O fik$ 'fM tso 9i,.', o M Nx iffi* Le qjtr Figg o AJ o ,- oo 4 FB x!9 ffi:rW FOE -dcE !Y gEa 9 t.9 G ddE I J @ F6I 'FP-b 9 HU!) 3 i-iBt =-6 qY i-o Exhibit D Page 17 of24 @ N o odi o3 7ld .sl > o at +t o c) (E F 0 o E oN N (o o- o, (L O Cd oa oil oN .2 T '9c EcEt": EeEE!! E9 i$9gf! EEE c{ F* s cD LL F- 6.tr,r tr!l> x::x eo fEEp.-;EE f;AF5:sr E: E;fi.nxE E I E q oN Edi F q! F a't : so o 8trq *t 6G= -HE trEs - o 3r >. 6 oao91-. E |.r, c (D :J !6 U i ooX x RI F 9E s E rr"i; H F H e 42, 9tr'ts il-E *-B' o f I N I rs: E' i9 E: X E.i E EE*E F;E el E e$E ez gEEHe oH d a6 5o s O o ("i qgeigE o a o o F3, il * g sE u g8s E i;FEfiEI 6i+'trcz I J ax; E I b 'a' 6 ,;'a'^ L 3 I iFsEg-6 c^t I* 5 J.= tr Exhibit D Page 18of24 l1=? i iKc, ,= -! dsd #.: >t d !! q ffl,it E baj-- fi;E AE x ffi* :.4 :i4 &l.lt oo (od r5 &,t #. w +i o o) (L N c! F. c) ii*F *irq fi fli ffi:.ti.::.t I 6 d o o ff,;l Clrit o, (U o_ o f:fi t w?., .9ioP :q -u o.= >' : 'n = dJ o^ qE x @ F.o yo *o -F9 d *o .cil c (f Kt. ?ii,t:tt:" 3f c{ Itr #rlrrit: s.,,,. O W: F @i{ti SESE q: bol : F.g& '= -Y'='tr O =|| AH sb0 a6 7a .*6 bo X so x,= fioP v: >. e bt D. 6C 3# .d't=99E d 9j;. -6 > -e;< boE 9 X c-o e L sb0 od g o rO c E u-o K.: itw& 11 <;g EE :E *eY FER 3'E g: od {2X 9.gs, iEi *;5 5()'' -vr-i '=.Y F - L ?E ":9{ tr o F =!z) F -s;.ic FE 4 ci ! 3'; Fr o f I N s (o o () I o 3 o w c 3Es e h ?t s+tr H c.Y o rEE o Ei: 9c[i o i;:r *F Eq; x Ye a o,; i:o * :l a;tsa*a eH;HE*e \JZ O.O O'O\J gEiEei? oz F a6 uro 8.P o s >-^ o oC ae) FC9 Id . F gilieExB bft &v& o ai #: iibrr:*+ i. o :::r x;*{ E o o o o c !: ;tq i ris# b& o t ',"' 11..,.,.,W xB '.$ ;'! ( s Xo b 3E I troh '; 3F3 = PSos EfoPF: x 6' lffi !D =d l au i.s= ''ffi 9'r: E '9 e ts8 EFE aP E E FEtsb Qa -a-s oi H @ ,.E 9E F;s ni>5;50 "s F Fi E g lr e.Y= g;i o X ".t HE tr-o i rEE*gE 6 5: tr E.Eg jg U a Y Exhibit D Page 19of24 i'!:..; ! '.;!3 {:a IE 6 F: iE gE a t F o tlG Fnq r.o n-x qo qld ,L-;,* Ps W:94 +L 0) a o, IL GI C\t FT !* ei Eq :: 6 = il.tr E Ra !H 2S I o @ (D o, o_ N F- NE :E } 6 sF"sFEE{ '.cEP 9::F s h"Ets 3 g 6 6fr6. tr ME, F^o-c .v!E.:> +F eS c 9;o ; BF E E bo N C xFg -dEo L Ei E 9.}8r F,"il @ :.lllriK aiuti# ry1.ry 3 gts 3xG= o iEs >ooo i _369 "e3E 'o ;"9 E ^^ bt) L Fr 9y>i g O LL- I Exfrs!: A=s EE.=E532 L F .9tsi; 'A.= 6-e i EXa :I arP s'E E EiBiA.g n ;i ii (o to w& s ""9 6:" 9 --'a .==ii B 2 c c) E.E 9B 6tr .u l !3i ss i Ei BE 8 } E g;f'a#8". <gt3 E?-oo :9 * b 3Fs H ;E} EE9* d 3E oo r'o o o >' o :) I c\l I o o p"i qo;; 16 eEO;Vi J Al <i 3'E:T; oo * 3FE W -3 FE I ;*{ffi E:4 v:: :l UTY cgEtEic xgF*99 H=3 F o= I (d T;E -q s,; q o o FE d x 8E$5EE o o o o <"i u, C) o ffi.\tw FE Ft4 #);iE s s rOS ,se t3'3: E E d o i!& $i oo :=y?^ .F c 6# ?^aA :9 ar *E:;90 E F c o .. \a s.6 ts: lr * * eS:F F w;4 v. <E F E F E NEAE E s0 E; ; E !EOO Jr:4tr E*.: oo; lr CC H U.E "E >\o =" X---O r =votG N I ! w V, =x=x a996 Y Exhibit D Page 20 of 24 q q o F o $ d q E o o o E !? ftru >.i o o # (rd 6 *.ffi t,W oo qJ6 a o o +l G iH gF :lt,'lL a o (L c|l iqr 5C rffi u 0 6 a 'd E o o 5 o o o -5 o N ffi c I (') o (It o_ F'T; .Fts E ;i9t061 s i r !tffi ew 5'i1 do ).2 Ia EN r tr"cF ri O CN F. O 3N I.L O I ke tr, "E E;* Qji ao9 I -: c o -.c H,ot-*d E : X bo# v n d:= Eus da* Xotr r 6 o o al \o q9' + L l Hd Qo9 k troi !26d o o o L 6-C6 fs rEE I hs :-E> 3 $E 5.E g :'fr i ;its3 I L od 5 oE Fr!s6F 33*g,I Fi -dY>T' :' 3'H i 9tsQq :'ff E Ff EH> 6 : - q h.5 il* v o Fi g F H!l>i EE} ok.,- o !q.= @ z ." 3 z (o to - e.,& i]lf*ry E.: .o o gs px EeeEir ggHsf g Ef XET5tr: I o f w s! ifrE ss !l- - tl ;tri. E eod SE r I N (o s @,t &tt&t: 3 tt: ;t f Ets *,E; s E c) [: ry c"j W, t& o o o (E itr ffi "g Fffi > -'= ffii tr H 9-o.:.= 9@ h6 0 h- o>l > --: s{u e b:'tsi p,..# 6! > d-A .'= I E o.: !, !:i= ,Y):4E '- o* o= o '-.d'E -ocdd ; 7 u x o .=t 36 EE g'o Yb s{ N I ...t *; Wl:,# d F'F i; ='= E 9 EE 3E uxi=xi;x v = 5 Ia, 60ts - dd 'o6 i. '.q o cu > o i!,:t& :*'gEg*' d a Exhibit D Page 21 of 24 *8 lii}l !ltg triifl lrl1g !!iG lrtrC iIg d,i;:;i *,ffi fs& :tt o o o (L (\I N N ffi i6 tffi o) i^ffi w ti*; E o (g ,11 (L O N .YGr h i= 'A : o O.F Po o)l E fftio 'aHO Y'EaY ^ aqdo oo >r>| .9 -o -o ots ^, g 3f ot ra; E H=;r^ 8 F5 E.9 o oe fi EEg*FI f oEh ato+(EE ,, ..1 t,g (f) " ooFd .9 >=c d'tr - lfa cF o 5 e > 6 ; E E;; E 3i F L s5 m9,o ii.= L lr o '=,:'F EH} "xtr tr o F 6rH:;D tr !q aE t LX ; i;;1; 5 Q.: ;;gs X J E 9c*Fi H.E5R9 F F* E A 6 E E d.E E E 3 ;EEEEEg.$ Hg8]E'EfiE : o 9 i H F FEEF H E cn t: t* xq ro ? 5,,* q"EE ;s :>, Y- fYr=qO . ,^ o gw q6 6'.b"8: a 9 Us. YL.=9OJ {# :*E-E o f e& tiw ),r:i gigeiig. Iaica'EEg 3s.* !t X E g o .E -\l c I I )* ffi 9= b Hg e u E xE s $ (o x ht - o. ", E.H.F 6 g F.= 6 5 tr O 6 gF-'.:!E.i E tr d o <"i q) o U' :+a Elq O 5r* .(xq i a?i o o ilffi sffi flffi a:,.i6 bo9 >-o hw t&. w ii,rr,,,* tr6 sd 36*.6 !l o.- o 5'vF^ 90 po :-e: *s 2 139 O d J !E .e= ^o I E.{ > o o R )oo6 -c o d ;= =..>i-o ai a9 5 Y Exhibit D Page 22 of 24 '&':::::'& * G I e il o P,8 >. tE d -!1 q :E lsr tr ffi cr6 E1,; @ E ga:: -:. Fd q5 0 2 q Fd q3 o o (r6 sl ry' 4 ,i{ g 6|a d d il o h o o o_ g# affi o) (E N N N 0) E F W 8wr l SJt d (s o_ g& 2;a, -xf- o N F- (4w F 3E eE F.H;r d E s Y o i x,. 6-:E9p9 'g 6'tr uol :HEi h q EtlssE*,gF* E5*EE*F;e3 H: r;:'ir? X e = d a E s-i'8:F sE e sil e ,Y: EtEs s qb T - rtF&# E d >-o 9F' it -. -q o ).! -@ X o d 3 a'oBP >E -ds" c.l re.E o ?ae .x oo-d ..5 j -6 tr r.E o o OC 0): E0E ff o - () k o 6 F o i.t- s @ ffi tgry i&: ff.d !r6 ,G! *,i ! :TiEE;9TEqESEH:, E 'E-: ;YF Hd ;. :E E F EAEEEPEPEOE ,59EE8.s.ESgS3 bE ' BH I P N oto r5Ex>' O ! FE sE r E ro o () = L!;E;seEEg{;qi:fr; g gq a= tr.Y !4E 9 tr o f I N s (o I q.i t![n i s:'! ! cEEH$atrsE .e w. :a; ;:3IX b. qE: I X >\'! 3 E'o U; *: s-: o o- EO ot ,& gpE;gBEi.E uffi* i F.(] E-E 5 (!E O = o, <"i o o fffti fi wl ffi cEl fd o $ ffi '50@ ffiw 9oX ;y*s;s H >p r* iPu i = .i= a o9b'E x tr- q )i3 tr g I'E E9trE 6 effi Fo,9 q= lq L a2 E>\ ,^ t*r* E, s*fss F ^6 OE 6 9 Qa 6 >rG E J WE ea' E U.^ =Pq o >,l; c ts .o t;.O !s ; xEi a4 'iaQ o O= ffiq e. ffi $ EE .6i g5E d.= b E ir'bOd F g.E E a Exhibit D Page 23 of 24 ci' 3 ; =E H s\9!oYar;e > > -E E =? EET"EEE eE Effi a ETEE;: F# IE ::.: ft',,s$i f 6 P s: a.3 F g H bs a o +r o (D d o- o E4H 60 l't . r{fifl a 6f r:1 N AI &; a,A q o N N o_ li oq itllrl o. (', g! !a6 UEE qa .d t!s-oO E -! -6@ g A ov o E >, g.b .E .: oAc N <) F O 3 .6 L !6 EgEPEE ' " F hF d.: Ld C o F -Eioq!q t:=-oq ssdttr.Yo; g I il'; ;E Eb E 6= u- lo o (o s E! HO -9? 6 F 6 sbFEH: H c-l al rO o c) *. -Y6 tr/ q riu A=6 q \il cra,t{ iir- r =*'".tl qrrt:ti t.:l;a::;:: o o :) I N I 9)E uP oz a { E dpG qil-sr '=64 FITH o!ro. ! t=i s o o I I s 3 9I dt, ffi:: ",%t f -r G{$ c"t o o o o .ffi W "O,",,f ij.:; e d ais: ffi ffiIg 9>, d tr;. cka=.:d N o ,l ul ao= ; [i tii xos :. u >, I Exhibit D Page 24 of 24

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?